03/01/2019 Smoke clouds obscure India’s solar revolution | Financial Times

Special Report FT Guide: The Energy Transition
Renewable energy
Smoke clouds obscure India’s solar revolution
Analysts warn that ambitious expansion drive is losing momentum

An Indian solar power installation - Bloomberg © Bloomberg

Simon Mundy in Mumbai DECEMBER 4, 2018

India is targeting an economic expansion of gargantuan scale over the next few decades. The
country, with a population exceeding 1.3bn and annual per capita income below $2,000, has
become the world’s fastest-growing big economy.

But while India’s annual economic growth — about 7 per cent over the past two years — promises
to lift millions out of poverty, environmentalists have warned that unless the country changes its
energy mix dramatically, it could have dire consequences for the global climate. Plentiful domestic
coal reserves has meant India has long relied overwhelmingly on the highly polluting fossil fuel to
power its economy.

Soon after taking office in 2014, the government of Narendra Modi, prime minister, made one of
the most remarkable renewable energy pledges of any government to date. It promised that by
2022, India would create 100,000MW of renewable energy capacity — equivalent to 40 per cent of
the country’s entire installed power generation at the time of the announcement.

Since then, investment in India’s solar sector has boomed and it is now a key market for the global
industry.

Among these investments is world’s largest solar project. Stretching across more than 10,000 acres
of desert in India’s northern state of Rajasthan, at a site where temperatures frequently top 40C,
the Bhadla project is taking shape.

https://www.ft.com/content/d77ed284-e41f-11e8-a8a0-99b2e340ffeb 1/6
03/01/2019 Smoke clouds obscure India’s solar revolution | Financial Times

It is the centrepiece of the government’s ambitious

plans for a rapid acceleration of renewable power. Yet
The government policy has analysts are now warning that the overall pace of
gone from very clear to very expansion appears to be slowing.
confused
“For a while, everything was looking so good,” says
Tim Buckley, Institute for Energy Economics and
Tim Buckley, director at the Institute for Energy
Financial Analysis
Economics and Financial Analysis. “But the
government policy has gone from very clear to very
confused.”

The conditions for Mr Modi’s bold pledge were created in China, where surging production of solar
panels led to dramatic price falls — meaning solar power producers in India could compete on cost
with coal-fired electricity.

Indian government policy further reduced costs for solar investors — notably by establishing huge
solar parks such as the one at Bhadla, where the government promised to take care of supporting
infrastructure such as connections to the national grid.

The sheer size of these projects helped to draw in big investors attracted by the economies of scale,
says Rishab Shrestha, an analyst at Wood Mackenzie. “Other countries have 100MW or 200MW
tenders — so when India has a 1,000MW tender, it attracts a lot of people,” he says.

Among those was Masayoshi Son, the chief executive of Japanese conglomerate SoftBank, who has
promised to lead $20bn of investment in Indian solar projects, in partnership with local group
Bharti Enterprises and Foxconn of Taiwan.

Optimism around India’s solar push has taken a hit over the past year, however.

The government has imposed a two-year “safeguard duty” on solar panel imports, in an effort to
boost local production. But this means potential producers would again face competition from low-
cost imports after just two years — making it unlikely to jump-start domestic solar panel
manufacturing, warns Ankur Agarwal of India Ratings & Research, a credit-rating agency.

In fact, the past year has brought a sudden decline in bids for projects as investors respond to the
higher cost of imported panels.

https://www.ft.com/content/d77ed284-e41f-11e8-a8a0-99b2e340ffeb 2/6
03/01/2019 Smoke clouds obscure India’s solar revolution | Financial Times

Graphic for future of energy report
“It’s really an own goal,” Mr Buckley says, estimating that there will be solar investments worth
$7bn-$9bn in India this year, instead of the $20bn predicted before the safeguard duty was
introduced.

Alongside the development of giant solar parks, India should consider much smaller solar panels
on a more dispersed, local scale, some argue.

BuffaloGrid, a UK-based start-up, is piloting solar-powered communal mobile phone charging

stations in India.

“I believe it makes no economic sense for the Indian government to pursue a traditional grid
expansion model,” says Daniel Fogg, BuffaloGrid’s chief operating officer. “It makes more sense to
look at distributed solar projects,” he adds, insisting that this will be cheaper and more reliable
than a system that relies on a big rollout of substations and power lines.

https://www.ft.com/content/d77ed284-e41f-11e8-a8a0-99b2e340ffeb 3/6
03/01/2019 Smoke clouds obscure India’s solar revolution | Financial Times

Whatever the mix, most analysts agree that further declines in the cost of solar compared with coal
means its share of Indian power generation will continue to grow. However, there is increasing
scepticism about solar’s chances of hitting the 2022 target of 100,000MW, given that installed
capacity is currently only a quarter of this.

“India’s energy transition is well under way,” says Kanika Chawla, at New Delhi’s Council on
Energy, Environment and Water. “But in terms of the government’s priorities, reducing energy
poverty comes above cleaning up the energy system.”

The sheer abundance of domestic coal, she adds — as well as continued limitations on storage of
solar power — mean that coal-fired generation will remain a big part of India’s electricity mix for
the foreseeable future.

Get alerts on Renewable energy when a new story is published Get alerts

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2019. All rights reserved.

https://www.ft.com/content/d77ed284-e41f-11e8-a8a0-99b2e340ffeb 4/6
03/01/2019 Smoke clouds obscure India’s solar revolution | Financial Times

Explore the Special Report

ABOUT THIS SPECIAL REPORT
Part 5/6: Leadership and climate
change policy 
 
The world’s political and economic
leaders are racing against time to modify
energy use and mitigate climate change.
Three years on from commitments given
in Paris to limit carbon emissions, FT
writers and contributors assess whether
enough is being done. 
 
The next instalment, on the challenge of
financing measures to tackle climate
change while delivering energy security
to the world’s population, will appear on
January 23 
 
Supported by Mitsubishi Heavy
Industries Group
Currently reading:
Smoke clouds obscure India’s solar revolution

The answer to climate change lies in technology and engineering

Spain unveils ambitious green energy plan

Europe must grab chance to make up ground lost to China

Businesses push for greener buildings despite Trump rhetoric

Companies take power into their own hands

Miners turn to green power options

See all 30 stories

Follow the topics in this article

Utilities
Renewable energy
India

https://www.ft.com/content/d77ed284-e41f-11e8-a8a0-99b2e340ffeb 5/6
03/01/2019 Smoke clouds obscure India’s solar revolution | Financial Times

Simon Mundy

How easy or hard was it to use FT.com today?

Leave feedback

https://www.ft.com/content/d77ed284-e41f-11e8-a8a0-99b2e340ffeb 6/6