Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
net/publication/328269133
CITATIONS READS
0 200
1 author:
Aniket Marathe
University at Buffalo, The State University of New York
5 PUBLICATIONS 1 CITATION
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Aniket Marathe on 23 December 2018.
Abstract
In this paper, we will provide an overview of the advancements in IoT, which can be summarized as framing the
network of smart equipment with sensors that will be capable to collect data in real time and communicate with
other elements of the chain. Further, we propose to explore the role of IoT in overcoming the challenges faced by
logistics in pharmaceutical industry and discuss the modern trends in manufacturing and supply chain logistics with
the latest developments in IoT.
At present milieu of globalization, it is necessary that companies frame integrated supply chain networks
and coordinate their processes to stay competitive. Pharmaceutical industries around the globe are striving hard to
reduce the costs of R&D to augment the investments in logistics in order to stay competitive. This study presents a
framework to articulate implementation of IoT to utilize digital advances to accelerate their speed to market while
abiding to the strict regulatory requirements that often limit technological changes. Some of the major problems
faced by pharmaceutical industries are related to lack of coordination between clusters, high dependency on human
resources, temperature control in facilities, supply chain visibility, etc. Our paper will present the modus operandi in
implementing the IoT to overcome those challenges with focus on specific applications such as acquiring accurate
information across the entire chain at any point and at any location, access to real-time updates, visibility of all
handovers in supply chain, personalized high tech care demands for customers and seamless collaboration between
involved companies.
Keywords
Internet of Things (IoT), Supply Chain, Pharmaceutical Industry, RFID, Cold Chain.
Introduction
In recent years, Internet of Things or IoT is emerging as one of the most promising technologies. Extensive research
is being conducted all over the world to realize the potential of this technology. Most of the researchers have
projected that the IoT will be a driver of the next industrial revolution. The “things” which are capable of being
connected to the Internet are more likely the “things” which could be connected to each other. This network of
connected things: vehicles, industrial components, household objects, electrical devices, perishable products and
other utilities with the internet connectivity and with the help of dynamic data analytic capabilities could altogether
alter our lifestyle. Enormous growth potential can be created for businesses by connecting the previously
unconnected entities, to improve on decision making speeds and correctness. Service called ‘Amazon key’ and
recently launched ‘In-car Deliveries’ from Amazon are the great examples of utilizing the network of connected
devices to deliver more efficient and hassle free services to the consumers. Amazon key is a service provided by
Amazon in which they provide a kit comprising of a security camera, cloud cam and a compatible smart lock, which
will enable the delivery service provider to have access into the consumers’ homes while consumers can remotely
monitor and ensure the delivery of shipment inside their homes. Similar set of equipment can be used at more
personal levels to grant easy access to family members or friends into your house, car, etc. while maintaining the
security of your belongings. Many other companies from different sectors are trying hard to utilize the potential of
this network of things for mutual benefit of consumers and firms; companies from pharma sector for example, are
testing and validating similar services to ensure the safe delivery of medical drugs to the consumers.
This paper introduces the Internet of Things with the definition which relates to the current world scenarios
along with the real life applications. There are endless possibilities of implementation of this technology in almost
Internet of Things
The "Internet of Things" term was first was introduced roughly 18 years ago by the founding members of the MIT
Auto-ID Center (Sundmaeker, Guillemin, Friess, & Woelfflé, 2010). There is no unique, universal definition for the
Internet of Things (IoT), the core concept is that everyday utilities can be equipped with identifying, sensing,
networking and processing capabilities that will allow them to communicate with one another and with other devices
and services over the Internet to achieve some useful objective (Cortés, Boza, Pérez, & Cuenca, 2015). Exhibit 1.
shows few of the technologies and devices which constitute the IoT network.
Rose, Eldridge, and Chapin (2015) defined the Internet of Things as “a global infrastructure for the
information society, enabling advanced services by interconnecting (physical and virtual) things based on existing
and evolving interoperable information and communication technologies.” In general terms, IoT is an extended
internet service model to contain every single utility which eventually could make human activities more
convenient. Xu, He, and Li (2014) forecasted that the IoT will reach 26 billion units by 2020, up from 0.9 billion in
2009, and will impact the information available to supply chain partners and how the supply chain operates. Few
surveys correlate the IoT to a point in time when the number of objects connected to the internet exceeded the total
human population connected to internet.
IoT Enablers
RFID tags and devices, sensors, actuators, software, energy harvesting technologies, machine to machine interface,
etc. represent the building blocks of the IoT technological network enablers. In the realm of endless opportunities,
technological advances such as telepresence and adjustable autonomy, geo tagging and geo sensing, robotics,
augmented reality, etc. are the collaborative technologies which add value to the primary network of things.
The inclusion of these identified enablers of IoT depends on the application requirements. For example, in
case of logistics and maintenance services, depending upon the availability of service information data for
transportation services, a network of devices is integrated. Segregation is done for rough and burdensome
environment’s RFID (Radio-frequency Identification) tag sensors. Depending on the need, auto adaptive sensor
2
Copyright, American Society for Engineering Management, 2018
networks with auto track and traceability-enabled tags are used. Innovative, value added software solutions are used
for end to end data security, configuration control and predictive forecasting. End to end service integration can be
applied on the separate/multiple vehicles’ engines, for enhanced traceability and the current status update of engines.
Further, overview of an applications of IoT in different domain are discussed. Also, Exhibit 2. illustrates the IoT
building blocks and cooperative technologies which constitute the IoT enablers.
Layered Architecture
The IoT is framed on three pillars, concerned with the capabilities of smart “things” to be:
1. Capable of being identified
2. Able to communicate
3. Capable of interaction; which could be amongst building blocks of network, or themselves or with consumers,
or with other bodies within the network.
Additionally, IoT consists of layered architecture which is associated with networking, web services,
communications and business structures, data analytics, intelligent interface for objects, etc. It is crucial from the
design perspective that due consideration needs to be given to adaptability, expandability and flexibility amongst the
conglomerate of devices. Based on that IoT is structured into four layers: 1) Interface layer 2) Service layer 3)
Network layer and 4) Sensing layer (Xu et al., 2014). Exhibit 3. briefly describes this layered architecture of IoT
along with its components constituting each individual layers.
3
Copyright, American Society for Engineering Management, 2018
Applications of IoT Solutions in Supply Chain Networks
Exhibit 4. illustrates the main identified domains of IoT applications with their characterization and
inclusive examples. Exhibit 4, though not very comprehensive and detailed but, it is a simple representation of scope
of utilizing IoT in various fields. From the extensive list of applications of IoT in almost every sector, such as:
Aerospace, Automotive, Telecommunications, Intelligent Buildings, Healthcare, Individual Wellness,
Pharmaceuticals, Production Processes, Entertainment Media, Environmental Monitoring, Agriculture and
Sustainable programs, etc. Out of them, few applications are briefly discussed in this section.
Medical Equipment
In the so-called medical internet of things, wireless sensors are embedded in clinical devices, which are connected to
hospitals, patients and medical equipment (Hu, Xie, & Shen, 2013). Using RFID tags to detect the counterfeit of
medical devices and medicines, constant real-time monitoring of medication storage processes, management of
patient’s medical information such as blood information, efficient handling of medical emergency, telemedicine and
mobile medical care (Hu et al., 2013) etc. are the examples of implementing IoT for improved healthcare services.
4
Copyright, American Society for Engineering Management, 2018
Traceability of Food and other Perishable Goods
Traceability of foodstuffs with re-organized supply chains with IoT ensures that food can be recalled if the quality is
compromised. Also, real-time status updates of perishable goods will be very helpful in avoiding goods (during its
transit time or idle time in warehouses) expiring before they reach to the consumers. Accordingly, such updates can
be used to alter the production schedule and supply of materials.
High level of security can be achieved by optimizing and digitizing crucial parameters of manufacturing
and supply chain management. Solutions from IoT can be utilized to tackle the bottleneck issues, maintain the
conformity to the specifications and effective expenditure of the resources. In this work, major challenges faced by
the pharmaceutical industry are discussed and convincing solutions from IoT are proposed.
5
Copyright, American Society for Engineering Management, 2018
with existing systems. Exhibit 6 gives an example of smart warehousing with the help of IoT (Macaulay, Buckalew,
& Chung, 2015). IoT solution strategies to tackle this problem are briefly discussed in further sections of this paper.
Exhibit 6. Example of Smart Warehousing with the help of IoT (Macaulay, Buckalew, & Chung, 2015).
Collaboration Issues
Trust deficit, lack of transparency and reluctance to share data is a huge challenge in the pharma supply chains.
Huge conglomerates are involved in the collaboration of this multi-layer supply chain and invariably there is huge
and complex data flow, which is vulnerable and prone to delays, and in this case unwillingness of partner
organizations to share data is an obstacle in the effective collaboration and resilience of the supply chain network.
Temperature Control
Temperature control is the major factor which distinguishes pharma supply chains from rest of supply chain
networks. For most of the pharmaceutical products, it is necessary to maintain certain temperature range throughout
transit and warehousing periods. During the transportation through air, rail, sea or road; drugs or other products are
exposed to various certain and uncertain temperature conditions, in that case maintaining a specified temperature is a
challenge to ensure the confirmation of the products to the quality and regulatory standards. Special care needs to be
taken in case of the pharmaceuticals which are extra sensitive to exceeding temperatures and which start to
degenerate if not taken care of the specified environmental conditions.
Warehouse Management
Owing to the rapid growth in the sales volumes of pharmaceutical products, the need for the increased warehousing
capacities cannot be overemphasized. But, at present scenario, the logistics companies are not yet ready to handle
the surge in demands from the pharma industries because, most of them do not have sufficient infrastructure to cater
the needs of increased visibility and reduction in overall costs. Huge investments are required for such specialized
warehouses with temperature controlled zones. And there are already big companies with more matured setup in this
sector, which makes entry of new companies very challenging. Reliability and confidentiality of the data, knowledge
shared between the drug manufacturers and the logistic companies are another major challenges.
Regulatory Compliance
There are varying regulatory standards and quality compliance guidelines for the medical drugs across the world.
For pharma manufacturers and supply chain networks it is an absolute necessity to adhere to and comply with the
regulations of the respective markets, which brings more complexity in the supply chain networks. Under these
circumstances, there is added pressure to have the maximum visibility of the supply chain, optimum temperature
control and effective warehousing.
6
Copyright, American Society for Engineering Management, 2018
Data Handling
While almost every sector is getting more and more data intensive and deploying resources to maximize the
utilization of the available data for analyzing the trends and accordingly developing the business models. For
pharma industry as well, this is a great opportunity. But, simultaneously it is an equally big challenge. Two major
challenges are, building data centers capable of handling the data and ensuring the cybersecurity from the attackers
who are chasing all kinds of data breach; from intellectual property, commercially critical data to patient’s private
health data from the research labs. Above mentioned obstacles in the flow of pharmaceutical supply chain are
summarized in Exhibit 7.
After carefully recognizing the major challenges in the pharmaceutical manufacturing and logistics; it is
observed that while some challenges are similar to other industries’, there are few unique challenges faced by the
pharma industries which consequently require the unique solution strategies. This paper presents some prospective
solutions from the technological advances of IoT, to tackle above mentioned challenges. Proposed solutions, their
implementation and the associated limitations are discussed in next section.
7
Copyright, American Society for Engineering Management, 2018
internal information system integration within the Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) and Warehouse Management
System (WMS). In this way even customers can protect themselves even if counterfeit drugs enter inside the supply
chain network.
Smart Warehousing
According to the report by (Madhukar Saboo, 2017), warehouse operations are vital part of the pharmaceutical
operations, which costs about 90% of the logistics costs. With real-time updates on inventory, floor space can be
utilized to its maximum potential. Sensors can be used to track and analyze the inventory flow, in that case
information will be captured by the wireless readers and used for the aggregate planning. Embedded sensors on the
forklifts are used to track the asset movement. RFID tags are used to track location and consumption rate.
Inconsistencies in the processes are captures by these sensors and transmitted for analysis. Data from arriving pallets
is also captured with the help of wireless readers. These solutions altogether contribute towards the higher
productivity and maximum floor space utilization. The data of the inventory flow from warehouses can be fed for
the production planning to optimize the inventory levels, reduction in stock outs and improvement in demand
fulfillment.
8
Copyright, American Society for Engineering Management, 2018
The degree of automation already existing in the company, determines the value addition from the
connected production process and accordingly set of solutions should be recommended for the companies.
Shipment Traceability
According to the report from Freight Watch International Supply Chain Intelligence Center, the pharma companies
have suffered major load loss due to cargo theft. On the other hand, due to the adaption of smart methods of
shipment tracking and data collection, the average loss value of pharma sector in US has dropped by approximately
55% from 2010 to 2012 (Madhukar Saboo, 2017). This clearly signifies the importance of shipment tracking in case
of pharma sector, mainly because of the sensitivity towards the health concerns. Because of the medicines involved,
it becomes even more critical. Bi directional communication and product verification is necessary at every stage of
transit to ensure the integrity and quality of drugs. NFC (Near Field Communication) sensors, 2-D bar codes, RFID
tags with smart labels can be used for packaging. Such IoT enabled packaging continuously tracks the products to
detect counterfeiting or avoid theft as products move through the transportation network. Further, AIDC (Automatic
Information Data Collection) for smart serialization incorporated with electronic chips in packaging help to monitor
the introduction of drugs into the healthcare environments which provides another level of protection to ensure safe
delivery of the drugs. Global positioning system location and condition monitoring also provide real-time, digital
solutions to track the security during transit. Exhibit 9. (Macaulay, Buckalew, & Chung, 2015) illustrates one such
example of real time tracking of the shipments with updates on the temperature and environmental conditions.
Temperature Control
Biologics are the high-ticket drugs which are highly sensitive to storage conditions. In 2016 alone, eight out of the
ten most selling drugs were biologics. Moreover, the estimated growth of the cold chain pharma products is
expected reach more than $361 by 2019 worldwide (Madhukar Saboo, 2017). Threat of drug expiration or
deterioration can get worse if the degraded drugs go unnoticed and travel into the network. (Madhukar Saboo, 2017)
estimates that 20 percent of the goods were wasted during transit out of $260 billion worth of cold chain market.
To maintain desired storage conditions of such sensitive drugs, environmental sensors are used to collect
data from storage areas to track real-time conditions of the drugs. Log data, which could be active or passive is used
to generate alerts in the events of temperature excursions by comparison with the medicinal thermal stability tables.
This will eventually prevent the untimely expiration or degradation of drugs.
Along with managing the temperature spikes during the transportation, maintaining the drug quality during
the transportation is of paramount importance. Temperature of the drugs being transported can be tracked to ensure
they remain within specified stability range. Environmental sensors are embedded and program sensors are
employed to initiate alert if the drug storage conditions deviate from the designated temperature range. Apart from
reducing the wastage of drugs and assuring the efficacy, these solutions also help to ensure compliance with regional
and International target market norms and regulations.
9
Copyright, American Society for Engineering Management, 2018
Telemedicine
Telemedicine monitoring focuses on improving the diagnosis and medications, to reduce healthcare costs and to
build patient focused system by collection of data from past medical programs and patient’s lifestyle habits (Hu,
Xie, & Shen, 2013). Focus of the implementation of IoT in this program is to enable healthcare providers achieve
continuous improvements in the medical care. RFID tags and sensors can be employed to collect data which would
be beneficial in developing new drugs. Telemedicine has promising implementation into the research for pharma
manufacturers, which eventually will help them to develop new drugs within reduced timeframe and at the same
time adhere to the regulations, speed up the production and to make drugs available at reduced costs to the
consumers.
Recommendations
Though solutions from IoT appear very promising, it is essential that before implementation of these network of
devices, companies must acquire the required security and infrastructure in place. For pharmaceutical companies,
IoT offers visibility and access into every area of production and operation, thus generating huge amount of
vulnerable confidential data resource. Typically for pharma industries, privacy of the data is of paramount
importance, hence strong data security must be ensured to avoid any kind of data breach which would affect not
only the firm’s business but the personal data of the consumers. Trusted collaboration within the partner
organizations is crucial for the successful implementation of the IoT. Any production domain contains a wide
spectrum of utilities, equipment, operators and associated software all of which should be compatible with every
element/sector of the supply chain network. Also, the change management is to be considered and optimized before
implementation of the Internet of Things, to develop business in compliance with the major drivers and stakeholders
of the business with successful transition. To conclude, the scope and overall applications of the Internet of things
are very promising, which in future will bring revolutionary benefits for large population; provided necessary
infrastructure will be there in place for the security and assurance of the people and associated firms.
References
Cortés, B., Boza, A., Pérez, D., & Cuenca, L. (2015). Internet of Things Applications on Supply Chain
Management. World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology, International Journal of Computer
and Information Engineering, 2(12).
Hu, F., Xie, D., & Shen, S. (2013). On the Application of the Internet of Things in the Field of Medical and Health
Care. Paper presented at the 2013 IEEE International Conference on Green Computing and
Communications and IEEE Internet of Things and IEEE Cyber, Physical and Social Computing.
Macaulay, J., Buckalew, L., & Chung, G. (2015). Internet of things in logistics: A collaborative report by DHL and
Cisco on implications and use cases for the logistics industry. DHL Trend Research and Cisco Consulting
Services.
Rose, K., Eldridge, S., & Chapin, L. (2015). The internet of things: An overview. The Internet Society (ISOC), 1-50.
Sundmaeker, H., Guillemin, P., Friess, P., & Woelfflé, S. (2010). Vision and challenges for realizing the Internet of
Things. Cluster of European Research Projects on the Internet of Things, European Commission, 3(3), 34-
36.
Turcu, C. E., & Turcu, C. O. (2013). Internet of Things as Key Enabler for Sustainable Healthcare Delivery.
Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences, 73, 251-256. doi:10.1016/j.sbspro.2013.02.049
Xu, L. D., He, W., & Li, S. (2014). Internet of Things in Industries: A Survey. IEEE Transactions on Industrial Inf
ormatics, 10(4), 2233-2243. doi:10.1109/tii.2014.2300753
Hu, F., Xie, D., & Shen, S. (2013). On the Application of the Internet of Things in the Field of Medical and Health
Care. Paper presented at the 2013 IEEE International Conference on Green Computing and
Communications and IEEE Internet of Things and IEEE Cyber, Physical and Social Computing.
Macaulay, J., Buckalew, L., & Chung, G. (2015). Internet of things in logistics: A collaborative report by DHL and
Cisco on implications and use cases for the logistics industry. DHL Trend Research and Cisco Consulting
Services.
Madhukar Saboo, A. C., Mugdha Suranglikar. (2017). The Internet of Things:
The New Rx for Pharmaceuticals Manufacturing & Supply Chains. Cognizant 20-20 Insights, 1-12.
Rose, K., Eldridge, S., & Chapin, L. (2015). The internet of things: An overview. The Internet Society (ISOC), 1-50.
Xu, L. D., He, W., & Li, S. (2014). Internet of Things in Industries: A Survey. IEEE Transactions on Industrial
Informatics, 10(4), 2233-2243. doi:10.1109/tii.2014.2300753
10
Copyright, American Society for Engineering Management, 2018
Yan, B., & Huang, G. (2009). Supply chain information transmission based on RFID and internet of things. Paper
presented at the Computing, Communication, Control, and Management, 2009. CCCM 2009. ISECS
International Colloquium on.
11
Copyright, American Society for Engineering Management, 2018