Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
net/publication/228404924
Financial behavior and problems among university students: Need for financial
education
CITATIO READS
NS
104,495
33
1 author:
Jariah Masud
Universiti Putra Malaysia
44 PUBLICATIONS 409 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Jariah Masud on 24 January 2014.
ABSTRACT
Introduction
Review of Literature
focused on credit use while none of them focused on financial problems and
constraints faced by college students. In contrast, this study focuses on
financial behavior and problems of college students and discusses the need
for financial education.
Within the context of Malaysia, research on financial management
is lacking particularly with young consumers, including college students.
Increased average monthly income from US$532 (RM2020.00) in 1995 to
US$650 (RM2472.00) in 1999 (Government of Malaysia, 2000) reflects the
increase of purchasing power for the overall population. The household
expenditure survey in 1998-1999 indicated that Malaysians spent US$25
(RM96.00) (6%) per month on recreation, entertainment, education and
cultural services. This figure doubled in comparison to the mean expenditure
in 1980 (Department of Statistics, 2000).
Methodology
Findings
60% were females. More than 70% of the respondents were Malays followed
by Chinese, Indian and others. Respondents were asked to indicate their place
of origin; rural/ village, small town, or urban/ city. Larger proportions of the
respondents (46%) were from rural areas and 31% from urban areas. Those
brought up in urban areas may have more exposure to goods and services
compared to those brought up in rural areas. On the other hand, those from
rural areas can also be expected to face drastic changes in their spending
environment when entering college.
Fourteen percent of the respondents depend solely on educational
loans to support themselves. Other forms of monetary support came from one
to eight different sources. One third of the respondents received the majority
of their money from their father. Less than 40% of the respondents received
money from their mother. This is likely due to the fact that more than half of
the respondent’s mothers were full time housewives. The source of money
influences the purchasing power of the respondents and may influence the
financial problems they face. The average amount of money received by
respondents was US$71.74 (RM272.60) with males receiving slightly more
(US$77.85 or RM295.82) compared to females (US$67.62 or RM256.97).
The Chinese students received slightly more than others.
Table 1
Profile of the Respondent by Gender
Male Female
N % N %
Ethnicity Malay 413 70.5 656
73.1
Chinese 116 19.8 151 16.8
Indian 37 6.3 53 5.9
Others 20 3.4 37 4.1
Theory
Research &
Place of origin Village 275 46.6 422 46.9
Small town 118 20.0 191 21.2
Urban 197 33.4 287 31.9
Sibling ranking Eldest 172 29.2 248 27.5
Middle 303 51.4 486 53.8
Youngest 109 18.5 160 17.7
Only child 6 1.0 9 1.0
Boarding school Yes 311 52.7 398 43.9
No 279 47.3 509 56.1
College GPA <2 35 6.0 38 4.4
2-2.49 160 27.5 210 24.1
2.5-2.99 206 35.4 329 37.8
3-3.74 161 27.7 262 30.1
3.75-4 20 3.4 31 3.6
88 Volume 3, Issue 1 Journal of Personal 88
Finance
Family Background
Financial Behavior
Urban
Small Tow n
Rural
Others
Indian
Chines e
Malay
3.75-4
3-3.74
2.5-2.99
2-2.49
<2
Female
Male
Theory
Research &
H ide s pe nding ha bit s f ro m f a m ily
M a in ho bby is s ho pping
B uy as o fte n a s I ca n
A ttra c te d to buy things o n s a le
T e m pte d to buy e v e n la ck o f tim e
B uy t hings never us ed
B uy t hings no t ne e de d
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
Male Female
90 Volume 3, Issue 1 Journal of Personal 90
Finance
Financial Problems
Gambling
Too much debt
No spending plan
Insufficient money until end of semester
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Female
Male
Theory
Research &
Chart 4 shows the average number of problems reported by gender,
college grade point average, and ethnicity. A total of 43 males (7.3%) and 77
(8.5%) females testified to never experiencing the 16 problems listed. When
the problems experienced by the respondents were counted, females reported
fewer problems compared to males. More than half of the females reported
experiencing one to four problems while males reported more than three
problems.
Problems faced by college students were significantly different
when the academic achievement was compared. Those with a higher grade
point average reported fewer problems compared to those with a lower grade
point average. Therefore, a lack of financial management skills may also
translate into a lack of academic management skills. There is also a
significant differ- ence in financial problems by ethnicity. Ethnic groups from
Sabah and Sarawak (indicated by “Others” on Chart 4) reported higher means
followed
by Malays. Students coming from Sabah and Sarawak reported more financial
problems since the demand for money is higher for them and amount of loans
received was the same as those from Peninsular Malaysia.
92 Volume 3, Issue 1 Journal of Personal 92
Finance
Indian 4.2
Chinese 3.87
Malay 4.72
3.76
3.75-4
4.08
3.00-3.74
2.5-2.99 4.46
5.12
2.2-2.49
<2 5.6
Female 4.2
Male 5.08
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
The data presented indicates that respondents in this study lack the
skills necessary in order to manage their financial resources. The result of this
study is similar to the result of a previous study (Hira, 1997). Respondents
were asked to indicate whether they needed any help on how to manage their
financial matters. Ninety percent reported that they were interested in
learning about financial management. Chart 5 shows the percentage of
respondents who are interested in learning about specific topics. The highest
percentage
of respondents reported they would like to have counseling services followed
by learning about savings and investment, budgeting, how to increase their
income, and financial management. More than half of the respondents
reported that they would like to learn about personal management, how to
reduce spending, insurance protection, and wise spending.
Counseling services
Personal management
Financial management
How to cut spending
Insurance protection
0 20 40 60 80 100
Theory
Research &
example, 46% had cell phones and 5% plan to buy a cell phone with the loan
money they receive. In fact, during the data collection period, there was one
sales agent outside the Grand Hall promoting the purchase of cell phones
among the students. Those with a higher grade point average tend to report
fewer problems compared to those with a lower grade point average and
males tend to have more financial problems than females. With increased cost
of living, students need more money to meet their daily needs.
University education can be regarded as a ticket for a better-paid job.
With the present curriculum at most of the universities in Malaysia, students
are given the knowledge and skills which can be used for job seeking, but
they lack the knowledge and skills necessary to manage their personal or
family matters. Graduates need to be equipped with basic financial
knowledge and skills that will enable them to manage their income
efficiently and effec- tively when they enter the labor force. Although all
students in this study receive educational loans, only a small percentage
expressed a need to learn about credit.
The expansion of the financial market will require consumers to
have information and the ability to choose the services that meet their needs.
Individuals are confronted by a new demand for their money in addition to
meeting basic needs. Medical cost, children’s educational expenditure, and
saving for retirement can be a few of the new financial demands for
individu- als and families. Skills in credit, risk, and investment management
are neces- sary to enable consumers to manage their finances effectively to
meet their goals. Various sources can be tapped to acquire this knowledge.
Neverthe- less, since those providing the financial services are selling
financial prod- ucts, consumers need to be knowledgeable about which
products actually meet their needs. Providing basic financial management
knowledge and skills before graduates enter the job market can be beneficial
so they are equipped with the skills necessary to manage their income
effectively.
In conclusion, the data revealed that respondents did not have
sufficient knowledge and skills about managing their financial affairs.
Finan- cial education should be introduced at the college level or earlier to
prepare students to manage their finances effectively. Various approaches
and learning channels can be utilized to achieve this objective. The
availability of online materials can complement and supplement the
educational activities. Effective financial management will contribute to
improving the quality of life and sustainable consumption.
References
Bandura, A.J. (1977). Social learning theory. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice
Hall.
Carlston, L., Grossbalt, S., & Stuenkel, J.K. (1992). The role of parental
socialization types on differential family communication patterns
regarding consumption. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 1, 31-
52.
d’Astous, A., Maltais, J., & Rohberge, C. (1990). Compulsive Buying
Tendencies Of Adolescent Consumers. In M.E. Goldberg, G. Gorn
& R.W. Pollay (eds). Advances in Consumer Research. Provo,
UT: Association of Consumer Research, 17, 306-312.
Department of Statistics (2000). Report on Household Expenditure Survey
1998/99.
Department of Statistics (2000). Social Statistic Bulletin Malaysia.
Evangelauf, J. (1987). Students’ Borrowing Quintuples In Decade, Raising
The
Spectre Of “Debtor Generation.” The Chronicle of Higher
Educa tion, 33(17), p. 1, 18.
Friese, S. & Koenig, H. (1993). Shopping For Trouble, Advancing the
Con sumer Interest, Spring, Vol. 5, No 1, 24-29.
Gladieux, L.E. (1997). Trends In Students Aid: 1987-1997, Washington D.C.
The College Board, Summer.
Government of Malaysia (2001). Third Outline Perspective Plan 2000-2010.
Government Printing.
Greiner, K. (1996). How much student’s debt is too much? Journal of Student
Financial Aid, 26, 7-16.
Hira, T.K. & Brinkman, C.S. (1992). Factors influencing student debt.
Theory
Research &
Journal of Student Financial Aid, 22, 33-50.
Hira, T.K. (1997). Financial attitudes, beliefs and behaviors: Differences
by age. Journal of Consumer Studies and Home Economics, 21,
271-
290.
Holland, A., & Healy, M.A. (1989). Student loan recipients: Who are
they, what is their total debt level, and what do they know about
loan repayment? Journal of Students Financial Aid, 19, 17-25.
Marchese, T.J. (1986). Fulfilling The Institution Responsibilities To
Student Borrowers. In proceedings of the College Scholarship
Service Colloquium On Student Loan Counseling And Debt
Management,
1-31. NewYork: College Entrance Examination Board.
McCormick, J. (1987). The default rate factor: Who is really at fault? Journal of
Student Financial Aid, 17, 31-36.
Moore, R. L., & Moschis G.P. (1981). The effects of family communication
and mass media use on adolescent consumer learning. Journal of
Communication, 31, 42-51.
96 Journal of Personal
Finance