Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
AIDS Care
Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information:
http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/title~content=t713403300
To cite this Article Kiš, Adam Daniel(2010) 'ABC for AIDS prevention in Guinea: migrant gold mining communities
address their risks', AIDS Care, 22: 4, 520 — 525, First published on: 03 February 2010 (iFirst)
To link to this Article: DOI: 10.1080/09540120903253965
URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/09540120903253965
This article may be used for research, teaching and private study purposes. Any substantial or
systematic reproduction, re-distribution, re-selling, loan or sub-licensing, systematic supply or
distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden.
The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents
will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae and drug doses
should be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss,
actions, claims, proceedings, demand or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly
or indirectly in connection with or arising out of the use of this material.
AIDS Care
Vol. 22, No. 4, April 2010, 520525
ABC for AIDS prevention in Guinea: migrant gold mining communities address their risks
Adam Daniel Kiš*
Adventist Development and Relief Agency, São Tome´ e Prı´ncipe Country Office, ADRA-STP, Caixa Postal 161, São Tome´,
Sao Tome e Principe
(Received 8 March 2009; final version received 10 August 2009)
Contrary to expectation when compared with other migrant mining zones of sub-Saharan Africa, the nation of
Guinea has a comparatively low and stable HIV rate. In addition, the regions with the largest gold, diamond, and
bauxite mining operations report the lowest HIV rates within the country. This research set out to explain
practices and beliefs within gold mining communities near Siguiri, Guinea the highest-producing gold mining
zone in the country that may contribute to this phenomenon, particularly as they relate to the Abstinence, Be
faithful, use a Condom approach to AIDS prevention. Structured interviews on a randomly selected sample of
460 adults and regular visitation to 16 pharmacies and health clinics within the mining zone yielded data showing
that abstinence and condom use are minimally practiced for AIDS prevention. Instead, faithfulness to partners
was overwhelmingly reported as the method of choice for AIDS avoidance. In addition, this research explored
Downloaded By: [Swets Content Distribution] At: 05:34 9 June 2010
ways in which local conceptions of fidelity differed from those generally understood in other contexts, including
engagement in short-term marriages at the gold mining sites.
Keywords: Guinea; HIV/AIDS; labor migration; ABC; gold mining; Islam
Introduction
The Republic of Guinea, West Africa (Guinea- lowest HIV rates in Guinea are found in the principal
Conakry, for short), has an adult national HIV mining regions is counterintuitive, as longstanding
prevalence of 1.5% (Direction Nationale de la Statis- theories about labor migration predict that migrant
tique, 2005a; Joint United Nations Programme on workers will engage in unprotected multi-partner sex,
HIV/AIDS [UNAIDS], 2007). This is lower than all particularly with prostitutes (Hunt, 1989).
neighboring countries for which there are data except This study investigated the ways in which labor
Senegal (0.9%); Guinea’s rate is also substantially migrants and their potential partners in Guinea’s
lower than that of Côte d’Ivoire (7.1%) (UNAIDS, principal gold-mining region protect themselves from
2007). Two surveys by UNAIDS taken six years apart HIV. The largest gold mine in the country is located
indicate that Guinea’s HIV rates are stable, neither 30 minutes down a dusty track from the city of
rising nor falling (UNAIDS, 2001, 2007). Siguiri. The industrial mine, Société Ashanti Gold-
Though HIV rates measured within country vary fields (SAG), is 85% owned by the South African
significantly between surveys, there is consensus that company AngloGold Ashanti. Clustered around the
the highest rates are found in the capital, Conakry, periphery of the fenced-in industrial mine are four
and the Forest Region. By contrast, some of the main villages: Fatoya, Boukariah, Balato, and Kinti-
lowest rates are found in the two regions containing nian. These villages are the locations of extensive
the largest mining operations in the country Haute artisanal mining operations, which attract prospec-
Guinée (gold and diamonds) and Basse Côte (baux- tors from around the country and abroad to try
ite) (Direction Nationale de la Statistique & ORC their hand at digging, sifting, and panning for gold.
Macro, 2006; Lartigue, 2001). These mines attract SAG produces far more gold than the villages, but
thousands of labor migrants both from other regions this is as much due to the use of colossal extraction
within Guinea (all with higher HIV rates) and equipment as it is to owning prime gold-producing
neighboring countries (with comparable or higher land. Some labor migrants work for SAG, but many
HIV rates). Mining accounted for over 70% of more are self-employed prospectors testing their luck
Guinea’s exports in 2004 (Central Intelligence Agency in the hardscrabble artisanal mining pits. Collec-
[CIA], 2006), indicating that it is a dominant industry tively, the industrial mine and peripheral villages are
with significant influence over the nation. That the called the Boure´.
*Email: adamkis@gmail.com
Condoms
Of the 429 respondents listing correct answers for
AIDS prevention, 309 listed condoms (72.0%) (see
Figure 1). Of the 359 respondents identifying meth-
ods they practice, 94 reported condoms (26.2%) (see
Figure 2). However, when a subset (n 54) of those
reporting condom use as the strategy they actually
practice was asked about condom use during the last
time they had sex, 28 respondents (51.9%) reported
that they had not used a condom.
The contribution of condoms to low and stable
Figure 1. Breakdown of correct responses. HIV rates depends partly upon availability, knowl-
edge of proper use, and women’s ability to enforce
Downloaded By: [Swets Content Distribution] At: 05:34 9 June 2010
gender clarifies things, however; 128 of 178 respon- condom use: 164 respondents (35.7%) listed at least
dents who answered no were women (71.9%), and 145 one correct step from the list; 163 (35.4%) listed at
of 210 respondents who answered yes were men least one correct step not from the list; and nine
(69.0%). As neither 95% confidence interval includes (1.96%) listed at least one incorrect step. Of the 164
50% (the interval for no is [65.3%, 78.5%], and the listing at least one correct step, 98 (59.8%) knew only
interval for yes is [62.7%, 75.3%]) these differences one step, 51 (31.1%) knew only two steps, 11 (6.71%)
are statistically significant. A Chi-square test of knew three steps, and four (2.44%) knew four steps.
independence yields a p-value of B0.001. This means No respondent knew more than four out of 10 steps
that women perceive inability to enforce condom use for proper condom use.
whether or not it is actually so, and thus may be
reluctant to try. Many women indicated fear of
Abstinence, Be faithful, use a Condom (ABC)
retribution if they required condom use of their
partners. Thus, women’s agency to enforce condom The components of ABC were the most frequently
use is also inconclusive. mentioned AIDS prevention methods. Only 12 of 359
Knowledge of proper condom use was measured respondents reporting methods personally used listed
by asking respondents, ‘‘How should one use a something other than an ABC component (3.34%)
condom? What are the steps to use a condom (see Figure 2). In addition, 127 of 429 respondents
properly?’’ The benchmark used to evaluate re- listing correct answers for prevention mentioned all
Downloaded By: [Swets Content Distribution] At: 05:34 9 June 2010
sponses was based on Legrain and Delvoye’s (1994) three components (29.6%) (see Figure 1).
condom education curriculum that is widely used for To find out who is using which components, self-
public health training by various agencies in the reported prevention methods were broken down by
Bouré. The list enumerates the following steps: three binary categories. A Chi-square test at the 0.05
level flagged all differences between married and
1. use a condom for each sexual encounter; single respondents as statistically significant: singles
2. unroll the condom onto the erect penis before reported abstinence and condom use significantly
beginning intercourse; more often than married respondents, and married
3. don’t put the condom directly onto the tip of respondents reported faithfulness significantly more
the penis: leave a little space (one to two often than singles (see Table 1). Sorting by sex, there
centimeters) to gather the semen (certain con- is no statistically significant difference for abstinence.
doms have a nipple that serves to gather However, 22.5% more women than men report
semen); faithfulness, while 21.6% more men than women
4. unroll the condom all the way to the base of the report condom use; both are statistically significant at
penis; the 0.05 level. Further research could establish
5. after ejaculation, withdraw the still-erect penis whether the unfaithful husbands of faithful wives
while firmly holding the base of the condom, to are the ones using condoms, given that their percen-
avoid any leakage of semen; tages so closely match (see Table 2). Sorting by place
6. use a new condom for every encounter; of origin (local or out of town) yields no statistically
7. throw condoms away after use (out of reach of significant differences on any components of ABC
children); (see Table 3).
8. if one wishes to use a lubricant, choose one that
is water-based, such as contraceptive jelly.
Lubricants that are petroleum or Vaseline- Discussion and conclusions
based can damage condoms; Despite the use of Legrain and Delvoye’s (1994)
9. store condoms in a dry, cool place; and condom education curriculum in the Bouré, knowl-
10. don’t use sticky, broken, or damaged condoms. edge of proper condom use was low in the interview
setting. Unless steps for proper condom use are
Each respondent listed all steps for proper condom internalized in calmer moments, it’s unlikely they
use they could remember, and answers were categor-
ized as: correct answers from the Legrain and Table 1. Marital status and practice of ABC behaviors.
Delvoye (1994) list, correct answers not on the
Legrain and Delvoye (1994) list, incorrect answers, A (%) B (%) C (%) Total (%)
and null. Null comprised 54.6% of the sample (251 of
Unmarried 30.5* 6.8* 62.7* 100.0
460), and as the 95% confidence interval (50.1%,
Married 6.5* 76.7* 18.8* 102.0
59.1%) does not include 50%, a small majority of the
population is unable or unwilling to describe proper *Statistically significant differences.
524 A.D. Kisˇ
Table 2. Gender and practice of ABC behaviors. beliefs. This study shows that other methods beyond
A (%) B (%) C (%) Total (%) polarized approaches are valid, and can provide
significant explanations for low HIV rates in certain
Female 8.3 76.2* 15.5* 100.0 contexts.
Male 12.6 53.7* 37.1* 103.4 Explaining why B is more popular than A or C in
*Statistically significant differences. the Bouré requires further study. However, some
possible explanations can be suggested. The Direction
will be recalled in a sexual frenzy. More thorough Nationale de la Statistique (2005b) reported a na-
instruction in the use of condoms is needed to tional survey in which 99.5% of urban men and
maximize their contribution to AIDS prevention. 99.0% of rural men say that married men should have
Low knowledge of proper condom use may also sex only with spouses. In addition, 75.4% of urban
reflect reluctance to discuss them, specifically for women and 91.9% of rural women agree. Societal
women. Just as women’s hesitancy to insist upon norms can be a powerful deterrent for ‘‘abnormal’’
condom use is tied to issues of power, fear, and social behavior, especially if normal behavior is a condition
for advancement and social participation (Bandura,
norms discouraging active sexual negotiation, this
1977).
likely affected other interview responses, as well.
Religious prohibition can also influence sexual
These issues must be addressed to avoid compromis-
behavior; Islam promotes strict rules governing sex
Downloaded By: [Swets Content Distribution] At: 05:34 9 June 2010
enqueˆte démographique et de sante´ 2005: Rapport expected rates of HIV. Retrieved September 24, 2004,
pre´liminaire [Guinea demographic and health survey from http://www.usaid.gov/gn/health/news/021011_
2005: Preliminary report]. Conakry, Guinea: Ministère hivsurvey/
du Plan, Direction Nationale de la Statistique. Legrain, G., & Delvoye, P. (1994). La planification famil-
Direction Nationale de la Statistique (2005b). Population, iale: Pratique et operationnelle [Family planning:
pauvrete´ et VIH SIDA en Haute Guine´e: Le cas de la Practical and operational]. Paris: Hatier.
prefecture de Siguiri [Population, poverty and HIV/ Mukhopadhyay, N. (1999). Comment on Duranleau. Field
AIDS in upper Guinea: The case of the Siguiri Methods, 11(1), 68.
prefecture]. Conakry, Guinea: Ministère du Plan, Roehr, B. (2005). Abstinence programmes do not reduce
Direction Nationale de la Statistique. HIV prevalence in Uganda. British Medical Journal,
Direction Nationale de la Statistique & ORC Macro (2006). 330, 496.
Enqueˆte démographique et de sante´, Guine´e 2005 Stoneburner, R., & Low-Beer, D. (2004). Population-level
[Demographic and health survey, Guinea 2005]. HIV declines and behavioural risk avoidance in
Calverton, MD: Author.
Uganda. Science, 304, 714718.
Duranleau, D.L. (1999). Random sampling of regional
Tobias, R.L. (2005). Guidance to United States government
populations: A field test. Field Methods, 11(1), 6167.
in-country staff and implementing partners applying the
Feldman, D.A. (2003). Reassessing AIDS priorities and
ABC approach to preventing sexually-transmitted HIV
strategies for Africa: ABC vs. ACCDGLMT. AIDS
infections within the President’s Emergency Plan for
and Anthropology Bulletin, 15(2), 58.
Gray, P.B. (2004). HIV and Islam: Is HIV prevalence lower AIDS Relief. Washington, DC: Office of the US
among Muslims? Social Science and Medicine, 58(9), Global AIDS Coordinator.
17511756. UNAIDS (2001). HIV prevalence in Africa. Africa Recov-
Green, E.C. (2003). Rethinking AIDS prevention. Westport, ery, June 2001.
CT: Praeger. UNAIDS (2007). Adult HIV rates in Africa. Africa
Haeri, S. (1989). Law of desire: Temporary marriage in Shi’i Renewal, October 2007.
Iran. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press. Williams, T. (1900). The historical and ethical basis of
Halperin, D.T., Steiner, M.J., Cassell, M.M., Green, E.C., monogamy. International Journal of Ethics, 10(2), 156
Hearst, N., Kirby, D., et al. (2004). The time has come 173.
for common ground on preventing sexual transmission Wilson, D. (2004). Partner reduction and the prevention of
of HIV. The Lancet, 364, 19131915. HIV/AIDS. British Medical Journal, 328, 848849.