Sunteți pe pagina 1din 7

76 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. 52, NO.

1, JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2016

Enhancing Traditional Process SCADA and


Historians for Industrial and Commercial Power
Systems With Energy (Via IEC 61850)
David C. Mazur, Member, IEEE, Rob A. Entzminger, Member, IEEE, and John A. Kay, Fellow, IEEE

Abstract—The coordination of large-scale distributed measure- historical data, and sometimes, they still revert to writing down
ment and control systems, such as supervisory control and data when machines malfunction or to transferring data to spread-
acquisition (SCADA) and other process control system implemen- sheets for review. For these data to make sense, strategically,
tations, require reliable and robust networks that can connect
thousands of remote devices from multiple remote locations. Ad- for any business, users must have access to both historical and
ditionally, many heavy industries have ever-increasing demands real-time data through a highly accurate and time-synchronized
for their infrastructure to handle more network services and referenced intelligent automation system. The benefits of the
deliver a full spectrum of the control and monitoring of thousands real-time archiving of process values, process messages, the
and even tens of thousands of points within their global business intelligent electronic device (IED) status, and alarm data, along
operations. This paper will outline a novel method of providing a
convergent use of the International Electrotechnical Commission with process batch data, can be now achieved using an advance-
61850 protocol within process control networks to provide a more ment of traditional historian-based systems.
deterministic type of process control, monitoring, and energy Intelligent automation systems collect the information that
management. The benefits of the real-time archiving of process has the potential to refine and improve business results. For
values, process messages, the intelligent electronic device status, example, production rates and/or production quality can be
and alarm data, along with process batch data, can be achieved in
an advancement of traditional historian-based systems. This new monitored in a real-time environment to reveal the sections
approach provides traditional downtime reports and alarm sum- of production that may be underperforming and deserve the
maries for maintenance purposes and the added benefits of pro- most attention. Machine or production flow characteristics may
viding the opportunity for highly accurate and time-synchronized be continuously refined and monitored to enhance production
energy consumption and energy balance data, along with effi- flows, maximize specific machine outputs, establish overall
ciency reports of various production or process operations.
operational efficiency, and even determine appropriate main-
Index Terms—Historical data trending, intelligent electronic tenance schedules to prolong equipment life. With the ever-
device (IED), International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) present need to reduce costs, there are the added benefits
61850, Object Linking and Embedding Database (OLE DB),
process historian, supervisory control and data acquisition of providing the opportunity for highly accurate and time-
(SCADA). synchronized energy consumption and energy balance data,
along with efficiency reports for various production or process
operations.
I. I NTRODUCTION

C OLLECTING large amounts of data is now less of a


challenge with current information technology and au-
tomation systems. However, it still remains a struggle to turn
II. I NDUSTRIAL AND C OMMERCIAL
P OWER S YSTEMS J USTIFICATION
all the data into actionable information. Many companies still Today, many industrial processes are controlled by a combi-
experience high levels of frustration sorting through all of these nation of systems working together (hopefully in sync) in order
to produce a target yield or product. Examples of these sys-
Manuscript received January 27, 2014; revised September 24, 2014; accepted tems include continuous and discrete process control systems,
November 28, 2014. Date of publication August 3, 2015; date of current version electrical protection, supervisory control and data acquisition
January 18, 2016. Paper 2014-PSPC-0040.R1, presented at the 2014 IEEE
Industrial and Commercial Power Systems Technical Conference, Fort Worth, (SCADA), and a historian for archiving and reporting tools for
TX, USA, May 20–23, and approved for publication in the IEEE T RANS - the trending of data.
ACTIONS ON I NDUSTRY A PPLICATIONS by the Power Systems Protection Previous research and advancements in technology have cre-
Committee of the IEEE Industry Applications Society.
D. C. Mazur is with Rockwell Automation, Inc., Milwaukee, WI 53204 USA ated a society where companies want to collect a large amount
(e-mail: dcmazur@ra.rockwell.com). of real-time data, sort these data, and, with the advent of the
R. A. Entzminger is with Rockwell Automation, Inc., Lenexa, KS 66214 discrete-event data, turn these into actionable information [1],
USA (e-mail: raentzminger@ra.rockwell.com).
J. A. Kay is with Medium Voltage Technologies, Rockwell Automation [2]. Now, there is a push to archive these discrete data so that
Canada, Inc., Cambridge, ON N1R 5X1, Canada (e-mail: jakay@ra.rockwell. they can be trended at a later time and used for the modeling of
com). the overall process.
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org. From an industrial manufacturing standpoint, electrical pro-
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TIA.2015.2463792 tection and SCADA data are very crucial in order to identify
0093-9994 © 2015 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
MAZUR et al.: ENHANCING PROCESS SCADA AND HISTORIANS FOR POWER SYSTEMS WITH ENERGY 77

operating points, create predictive maintenance models, identify


load-shedding opportunities, and manage energy consumption
and root cause analysis. As the information age has evolved,
the technology used to transmit data from a protection sys-
tem to SCADA systems has also evolved. Power-system-based
and industrial-based electrical protection devices have evolved
over the past three decades from electromechanical-based
to microprocessor-based relays. With the advent of sophisti-
cated microprocessor-based relays, more advanced protection Fig. 1. Traditional process historian flow.
schemes that correctly identify and clear faults in acceptable
time frames have been developed [3]. layer that consists of an industrial controller. A historian’s
As microprocessor-based relay technology has evolved, com- contribution is mainly the storage of the event data in a format
munication networks for electrical protection have also evolved that is highly recoverable and indexed on time. The historian
[4]. Electrical protection architectures have developed from data are not relational and are highly scalable [17], [18].
hardwired contacts to communication networks using serial Typically, the event time stamp is applied at the interface
protocols such as Modbus. Serial communication has evolved node. Interface nodes collect, interrogate, and qualify the in-
to communication protocols over the Transmission Control formation provided by the data server [19]. If the data values
Protocol (TCP)/IP stack such as Modbus TCP and DNP3 collected at the interface node exceed predefined deadband
LAN/WAN, which then allowed substation devices to commu- thresholds, a time stamp is applied, and the data are trans-
nicate in a peer-to-peer manner to share data. ferred to the historian repository. If the data do not exceed the
In the past four years, research and application examples with threshold, the data point is disregarded and not archived. This
the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) 61850 process is better known as exception testing and can be seen in
standard have become more prevalent [2], [3], [5]–[7]. These Fig. 1 [17], [18].
examples and applications show that an Ethernet-based stan- This procedure for collecting and time stamping data does
dard such as IEC 61850 can be used for the protection, com- not work well for events that are time stamped at the source
mand and control, and SCADA gathering of data over the same device. In the aforementioned example, the event that is passed
redundant wire pair [8]–[11]. As these “real time” data are to the interface node is value based, not time driven. After it
provided to the central controller or the SCADA master in has been determined that an exception has occurred, a time
the system, graphics can be populated to alert engineers and stamp is generated and applied to the event. For example,
operations of the system status [3], [6]. Additionally, these data if a process engineer is trying to log and store events from
can be used to make command and control decisions in an IEDs, i.e., trips, alarms, etc., the time stamp of these events is
industrial application [5]. generated by the IED. Using value-based exception reporting
Moreover, the data that come from IEDs via IEC 61850 will not suffice in transferring meaningful time stamps from
come with an associated time stamp that is accurate to the the IED to the historian repository. Referring back to Fig. 1,
microsecond level [3], [8]. The time synchronization of automa- the controller does not provide a time stamp to the data server
tion controllers has also evolved in the past decade. Protocols but only provides a process value. For most manufacturing
and standards such as the Global Positioning System, inter- environments, this schema is acceptable as a time-delay error
range instrumentation group time codes (IRIGs), the Network is within the poll rate of the data server.
Time Protocol, and the Precision Time Protocol have become
established in the industrial space [12]–[15]. Previous work
IV. P LACING IED S IN P ROCESS SCADA S YSTEM
has shown that automation controllers can be synchronized to
the same timescale and accuracy of the electrical protection In an IED system with IEC 61850 communications, the event
network [16]. drives both value and time-stamp changes in the data collection
With all system components now time synchronized, the data system. Both the event data and the time stamp are created at
can become more meaningful as all time-stamped data, whether the IED and must travel together from the source of the event
the electrical or mechanical process is referencing to the same to the repository to be meaningful. The previous two statements
reference in time or not. By creating a system that would allow are the root cause of the problem in attempting to store electrical
the aggregation of these time-synchronized data from different distribution values in a process control data historian. The block
sources, more process improvement gains can be realized. diagram that describes the solution to this problem can be seen
The remainder of this paper describes how to provide time- in Fig. 2.
synchronized event data to a traditional industrial process Fig. 2 shows the progression of data through the block
historian. diagram system. Block 1 defines the physical IED. The IED(s)
is (are) connected to the gateway module via an Ethernet con-
nection. Additionally, the gateway module is connected to the
III. T RADITIONAL P ROCESS H ISTORIANS : P ROBLEMS
controller represented by the controller block. The time stamp
A traditional process historian system consists of three major that is generated on the event by the IED is passed through the
components, i.e., a data server, an interface node, and a histo- gateway to the controller, as shown by the progression from
rian repository, respectively. In most systems, there is a control boxes 1–3.
78 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. 52, NO. 1, JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2016

Fig. 2. Progression of data.

Fig. 3. Ladder logic.

Although the controller data table contains both the event


value and the IED time stamp, it is not inherently passed to the
historian repository. In order for an event with a historian tag to
persist, the configuration of a digital alarm (ALMD) instruction
associates the event to the point ID of the historian tag. A
historian point ID is a unique identifier for a tag in the historian
repository. When an alarm occurs, the following parameters are
known: the time stamp of the IED, the unique point ID, the time
stamp of the entering alarm, the value of the alarm, and the event
association ID. An example of this logic is shown in Fig. 3.
Fig. 4 shows the configuration of the ALMD instruction with
the associated IED time stamp (1) and point ID (2). It is impor-
tant to note that the severity is set to 200 (the default is 500) in
order to provide the control system a way to differentiate tags
as electrical distribution tags. The data type of the time stamp is
the long integer (LINT), which is a 64-bit representation of the
number of microseconds from January 1, 1970, which is also
known as the Unix Epoch.
When the alarm is triggered, a message is sent to the alarm and
events (A&E) data server, as depicted in Fig. 2. The data server Fig. 4. Alarm configuration.
then populates the condition event table in the A&E database
(dashed arrow). Fig. 5 shows an example of this table. The
condition event table shows InputValue, EventAssociationID,
Tag1Value (the IED time stamp), and Tag2Value (the point ID). Fig. 5. A&E table example.
Fig. 5 also shows the off/on and on/off transition of an alarm
event, which is represented by the EventAssociationIDs being In Fig. 2, the top path in block 4 represents the traditional
equal. data flow within the process historian system. The solution
MAZUR et al.: ENHANCING PROCESS SCADA AND HISTORIANS FOR POWER SYSTEMS WITH ENERGY 79

Fig. 6. GUI tool.

Fig. 8. Result of the query.

Fig. 9. Historian time stamp.

Note that Active is the input state of the alarm instruction


(ALMD). Tag1Value is the time stamp from the IED, and
Tag2Value is the point ID of the historian tag; FTHTS is the
historian time stamp. FTHInsertTime is the time used in the
insert to the historian. FTHTS and FTHInsertTime can be up
Fig. 7. Database query.
to +/−15 μs as this is the highest resolution that this time-
stamp object can represent. Fig. 9 shows the complete run of
developed for this paper takes an alternative approach to pro- the GUI tool with the FTHTS column populated. The difference
viding data to the historian repository, as represented by the between the IED time and the historian time for the first two
lower path through the RACE SOE/Historian tool. This GUI events are 2 and 7 μs, respectively, which are well within the
tool is shown in Fig. 6. The GUI program was written using error bars of the defined system.
the .NET framework. The results workgroup represents the two This tool, much similar to the hardware, is multithreaded so
collections, i.e., the A&E records and the historian tags. Con- that it does not burden the machine upon which it is installed.
nections to both the A&E database and the process historian are The application has two modes auto and manual, i.e., the A&E
defined in the Object Linking and Embedding Database (OLE that have occurred that have a severity of 200 is collected. Then,
DB) connection strings. if in the auto mode, the items are processed and passed off to a
Now that an event with point ID 297 has been captured in the separate thread that handles the insertion into the historian and
A&E database, the information, including the associated IED the logging of each inserted event. If in the manual mode, the
time stamp, needs to persist to the historian tag. This is accom- operator has the choice to process the events. If the operator
plished by the user with an insert query to the process historian. wants to process the events, the same thread is used to process
After the insert is successful, an artifact record is written to an the events into the historian. After the events are processed and
additional table in the FT A&E database called SOEtoFTH. are in the auto mode, the application will sleep for a default of
Fig. 7 defines the query to display the information in the 10 min, and then, it will reprocess the events that have happened
SOEtoFTH table. The result of this query can be seen in Fig. 8. in the last 10 min. The logic flowchart is shown in Fig. 10.
80 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. 52, NO. 1, JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2016

Fig. 10. Software flowchart.

Fig. 12. Calculation values.

V. T ESTING AND VALIDATION OF T OOL


The enterprise management tool (the historian), which was
used to collect real-time data and events, does not accept for-
eign time stamps due to the way traditional process historians
function. In order to test the functionality of this software tool,
2000 alarms were created and tested on IEDs in a system.
As long as a time stamp inserted into the historian was within
15 μs of the IED published time, the tool was within tolerance,
and no further error propagated throughout the system. The
Fig. 11. Device data flow. ±15-μs specification results from the time-stamp tolerance
within the historian [17]. The time stamps that were compared
Fig. 11 shows the flow of information created by the de- are shown in Fig. 12.
velopment of the software discussed in this paper. As shown, The FTHTS time stamp corresponds to the time stamp
the information moves from the IEDs in the field through the published to the process historian, and the FTHInsert time
gateway module to the controller. From the controller, these stamp corresponds to the time stamp published by the IED
values can be then inserted into the historian and are trended network. As long as the time difference between the FTHTS
in reports on view screens for visualization and reporting. and FTHInsert time stamps is less than or equal to 15 μs, the
MAZUR et al.: ENHANCING PROCESS SCADA AND HISTORIANS FOR POWER SYSTEMS WITH ENERGY 81

TABLE I
R AW D ATA F ROM THE T RIAL

Total
Time Error [us] 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
Number of results 172 176 137 116 97 164 170 152 151 161 115 112 92 85 63 37 2000

Fig. 13. Time variance results.

Fig. 15. Ground current example.

Fig. 14. Relay configuration simulator software.

tool has no added delay outside the tolerance of current process Fig. 16. Analog waveform trending.
historian systems. The results of the testing can be seen in
the ground current (the third trace), exceeds 60 A and resets
Table I and Fig. 13.
when the relay resets. In this example, this occurs when the
Table I and Fig. 13 also show that, after 2000 test trials, all
ground current is less than 60 A.
resulting data points are within the error bars of 15 μs. The
Analog waveforms can be depicted if the IED manufacturer
data suggest that 74.7% of the results are within 9 μs of each
allows this information to be sent over the IEC 61850 standard.
other, which is well within the 15-μs tolerance provided by the
These waveforms can be seen in Fig. 16. Fig. 16 shows the
historian used to store real-time data and events.
waveforms zoomed to approximately eight electrical cycles.
In addition to the testing of the time discrepancy, this test
also checked whether fundamental parameters could be trended
VI. C ONCLUSION
against electrical faults in the system. To check this, a second
vendor’s IED was tested as it had a built-in simulator to test In conclusion, the time stamping of event data can be placed
the relay functionality and trip settings. This software can be in a process historian, although the act of event detection is a
seen in Fig. 14. By adjusting the slider bars in the simulator, the distributed system component. This enables reporting and key
currents, voltages, and harmonics of the corresponding wave- performance indicator calculations based on energy data and
forms were adjusted. The relay tripped when the set thresholds manufacturing processes variables.
of these parameters were exceeded, thus triggering an alarm to The impact of manufacturing intelligence with power system
be logged by the controller and the historian system. data will yield relationships that, to date, have not been avail-
The information for analog parameters can be also logged able in typical reporting environments.
and trended in the historian, as shown in Fig. 15. In this figure, IEDs are critical to the management and control of industrial
the lowest trace represents the trip status of the relay, which, and commercial power systems, and they can provide value in
in this example, was set to trip on a ground current greater an environment with process historians.
than 60 A (the third trace down), regardless of the currents on Highly accurate and time-synchronized energy consumption
phases A and B (first and second traces). As shown in this figure, and energy balance data can be utilized to determine the
the lowest trace is asserted any time the process parameter, i.e., overall process efficiency for various production or process
82 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. 52, NO. 1, JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2016

operations. The data from trip and alarm events can be de- [16] D. C. Mazur, R. D. Quint, and V. A. Centeno, “Time synchronization of
terministically used to establish maintenance schedules to automation controllers for power applications,” in Conf. Rec. IEEE IAS
Annu. Meeting, 2012, pp. 1–8.
prolong equipment life. Additionally, machine or production [17] PI Server Reference Guide, 2nd ed., OSI Soft, San Leandro, CA, USA,
flow characteristics can be continuously refined and monitored 2013.
to enhance production rates and maximize specific machine [18] FactoryTalk Historian SE Reference Guide, 3.0 ed., Rockwell Autom.,
Milwaukee, WI, USA, May 2012.
capabilities. [19] Live Data Interface User Guide, 2.0 ed., Rockwell Autom., Milwaukee,
Understanding the resolution of time accuracy is critical when WI, USA, May 2012.
doing comparisons and aggregating data from various pieces
of a process system. For example, if the data are being logged
with an accuracy of 15 μs, then the system must have time syn-
David C. Mazur (S’07–M’12) received the
chronization to that degree. A time stamp taken as close to the B.S.E.E. (summa cum laude) and M.S.E.E. degrees
electrical event as possible will yield better correlation of the and the Ph.D. degree in mining engineering from
Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University,
root cause when used in a wider view of analysis. These high- Blacksburg, VA, USA, in 2011, 2012, and September
resolution data can be passed to a process historian, which, in 2013, respectively. His M.S.E.E. studies were on the
turn, can be reported via web clients, as described in this paper. rotor angle measurement of synchronous machines,
and his Ph.D. studies were on the automation
This paper has been conducted due to the push of and control of the International Electrotechnical
communications-based protection and SCADA protocols and Commission 61850 standard.
standards. The evolution of hardwired contacts to serial com- He is a Global Technical Consultant with Rock-
well Automation, Inc., Milwaukee, WI, USA, currently focusing on supervi-
munications to Ethernet-based communications has led to sory control and data acquisition (SCADA) communications and substation
the ability to pass large amounts of time-synchronized data automation. His experience includes the development of regenerative variable-
throughout industrial and commercial power systems. Recently, frequency drive technology. He has also helped develop the technology for
time-synchronized continuous casters for the steel industry. He also ran a
standards such as DNP3 LAN/WAN and IEC 61850 have project that aimed to assess the power quality of Asia-Pacific and European
been able provide a time resolution to the millisecond and countries.
microsecond, respectively. Dr. Mazur is an active member of the IEEE Industry Applications Society
(IAS) and serves as the Working Group Chair for the Communication-Based
Protection of Industrial Applications Working Group. He also serves as a
member of the Mining Industry Committee and the Industrial and Commercial
R EFERENCES Power Systems Committee (I&CPS) of the IAS. He is also an active voting
[1] D. C. Mazur, J. A. Kay, and K. D. Mazur, “Intelligent motor control, a member of the IEEE Standards Association.
definition and value add to process control,” in Conf. Rec. IEEE IAS Annu.
Meeting, 2013, pp. 1–7.
[2] D. C. Mazur, “An electrical mine monitoring system utilizing the IEC
61850 standard,” Ph.D. dissertation, Mining Mineral., Virginia Polytech.
Rob A. Entzminger (M’14) received the B.S.E.E.
Inst. State Univ., Blacksburg, VA, USA, 2013.
degree from the University of Wisconsin–Milwaukee,
[3] D. C. Mazur, J. H. Kreiter, M. E. Rourke, and E. Syme, “Protective relay
Milwaukee, WI, USA, in 1981.
faceplate development utilizing the benefits of IEC 61850,” in Conf. Rec.
He is a Commercial Engineer with the Infor-
IEEE IAS Annu. Meeting, 2013, pp. 1–8.
mation Software Team, Rockwell Automation, Inc.,
[4] S. H. Horowitz and A. G. Phadke, Power System Relaying. Hoboken,
Lenexa, KS, USA.
NJ, USA: Wiley, 2008.
Mr. Entzminger is a member of the IEEE Industry
[5] D. C. Mazur, J. Sottile, and T. Novak, “An electrical mine monitoring
Applications Society. He is a Registered Professional
system utilizing the IEC 61850 standard,” in Conf. Rec. IEEE IAS Annu.
Engineer in the State of Wisconsin.
Meeting, 2013, pp. 1–10.
[6] D. C. Mazur, J. A. Kay, and J. H. Kreiter, “Benefits of IEC 61850 stan-
dard for power monitoring and management systems in forest products
industries,” in Conf. Rec. Annu. IEEE PPIC, 2013, pp. 69–75.
[7] D. L. Ransom and C. Chelmecki, “Using GOOSE messages in a main-tie-
main scheme,” in Conf. Rec. IEEE IAS Annu. Meeting, 2012, pp. 1–8.
[8] D. Dolezilek, “IEC 61850: What you need to know about functional- John A. Kay (M’94–SM’98–F’12) received the
ity and practical implementation,” in Proc. PS, Adv. Meter., Protection, B.S. degree in electrical/electronic engineering tech-
Control, Commun., Distrib. Resour., 2006, pp. 1–17. nology from Conestoga College, Kitchener, ON,
[9] V. M. Flores, D. Espinosa, J. Alzate, and D. Dolezilek, “Case study: Canada, in 1977.
Design and implementation of IEC 61850 from multiple vendors at He is currently with Medium Voltage Technolo-
CFE la venta II,” in Proc. 60th Annu. Conf. Protective Relay Eng., 2007, gies, Rockwell Automation Canada, Inc., Cambridge,
pp. 307–320. ON, Canada, as a Senior Product Specialist. He is
[10] T. Zhao, L. Sevov, and C. Wester, “Advanced bus transfer and load shed- the author or coauthor of a wide variety of award-
ding applications with IEC61850,” in Proc. 64th Annu. Conf. Protective winning technical papers and other technical articles
Relay Eng., 2011, pp. 239–245. and manuals related to medium-voltage electrical
[11] L. Sevov, T. Zhao, and I. Voloh, “The power of IEC 61850 for bus transfer control and protection systems, arc-resistant equip-
and load shedding applications,” in Conf. Rec. 58th IEEE IAS Annu. ment, and infrared technologies. Several of his papers have been published in
Meeting, PCIC, 2011, pp. 1–7. the IEEE T RANSACTIONS ON I NDUSTRY A PPLICATIONS and IEEE Industry
[12] L. M. N. M. A. Lombardi, A. N. Novick, and V. S. Zhang, “Time and Applications Magazine.
frequency measurements using the global positioning system,” Cal. Lab. Mr. Kay is a member of the IEEE Industry Applications Society (IAS) and
Int. J. Metrol., vol. 8, no. 3, pp. 26–33, Jul.–Sep. 2001. is actively involved with its Pulp and Paper Industry Committee, serving on its
[13] IRIG Serial Time Code Formats, IRIG Std. 200-04 ed. Range Commanders main executive board, on the conference committee, and on several subcommit-
Council, U.S. Army White Sands Missle Range, NM, USA, Sep. 2004. tees. He is a member of several other technical groups and participated on the
[14] D. L. Mills, “Internet time synchronization: The network time protocol,” local planning committees for the 2011 IEEE Petroleum and Chemical Industry
IEEE Trans. Commun., vol. 39, no. 10, pp. 1482–1493, Oct. 1991. Conference and the 2002 IEEE Pulp and Paper Industry Conference. He was
[15] IEEE Standard for a Precision Clock Synchronization Protocol for the recipient of several IEEE Paper Awards and the Meritorious Service Award
Networked Measurement and Control Systems,” IEEE Std. 1588-2008, from the IAS Pulp and Paper Industry Committee. He is a Certified Engineering
(Revision of IEEE Std 1588-2002), pp. c1-269, Jul. 2008. Technologist in the Province of Ontario, Canada.

S-ar putea să vă placă și