Sunteți pe pagina 1din 100

The Journal Published on 15th February, 2018

of Insurance Institute of India


VOLUME NO. V ISSUE NO. III MUMBAI JANUARY-MARCH - 2018

AwA r d w i n n i n g
Articles 2017

Service
Excellence
In Insurance
e-learning
The emblem of III speaks about “Achievement through application of knowledge”. III as a pioneer educational
institute in Insurance Domain is always endeavor to use the latest technology in order to impart, promote systematic
insurance education and training as well as spread insurance awareness in our country.

e-Learning stands for electronic learning system which allows candidates to learn a particular subject directly from
the internet enabled computer on web based platform.

This mode of learning been developed & started by III to enable the candidates to take the advantage of such facility
and to get success in the professional examination conducted by III at various centres all over the country. The
modules of e-Learning provides much beyond the course material in terms of web-links, selflearning questions,
mock tests, blogs to communicate within the circle of tutors and candidates etc.

How to apply?
1. Visit website www.insuranceinstituteofindia.com
2. Go to menu “Study Material” --> “Apply for eLearning”.
3. Fill the details, select subjects and pay required fees.

How to use?
After successful completion of online transaction for e-Learning, Candidate will receive the login credentials on
email address provided at the time of registration to access the e-learning module. The email contains the URL
along with user id and password to access the e-Learning program. The e-Learning program is web based,
internet connection is required to access the e-Learning module online.

INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA


Plot No. C-46, G Block, Bandra-Kurla Complex, Bandra (East), Mumbai 400 051.

For queries please mail at elp@iii.org.in


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA CONTENTS
02 Editorial 56 A Comprehensive Study on
03 Turbocharging Growth of Working and Challenges in the
Insurance Business through Functioning of Pradhan Mantri
Service Excellence: Going Fasal Bima Yojana
Beyond what Regulation Anusha Iyer
Demands Nishtha Dahiya The Journal
Venkatesh Ganapathy Vatsala Tiwari of Insurance
Institute of India
62 Travel Insurance: Do Travellers’
Attitudes Shape Their Purchase Established in 1974
Intention? Volume XXXVV

Anicar D. Manavi January-March 2018


Bimal Thapa
D.H. Malini Srinivasa Rao
Editorial Team
70 Building Loss Assessors Cadre
for Crop Insurance in India Arindam Mukherjee

Shuvajit Chakraborty Shashidharan Kutty


11 Technology: A Game Changer George E. Thomas
for Insurance Industry 74 Customer’s Preference for
Micro Insurance: A Study with Archana Vaze
Sheetal Gawde Reference to Kollam District,
15 Service Excellence in Insurance Kerala Editorial Associate
G. N. Bhaskar Rau R. Neelamegam Manisha Sutar
21 Protecting Life Insurance Email: journal@iii.org.in
Moneys for the Beneficiaries –
Section 6 (1) of the MWP Act,
Printed and Published by
1874
P. VENUGOPAL on behalf of
V.N.S. Pillai INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA,
28 Using Blockchain Smart Printed at SAP PRINT SOLUTIONS PVT.
Contracts to Drive Service LTD., 28, Laxmi Industrial Estate, S.N.
Excellence in Insurance Sector
Path, Lower Parel, Mumbai - 400 013 and
Monica Mittal Published from INSURANCE INSTITUTE
Anina Bhattacharjee 80 Impact on Motor Insurance OF INDIA, Plot No. C-46, G Block, Near
31 New Corporate Governance Business & General Insurance American Consulate, Bandra-Kurla
Rules will Improve Service Industry With Regard To Complex, Bandra (East), Mumbai 400 051.
Excellence in Insurance Autonomous Car Editor : Arindam Mukherjee
Jagendra Kumar Roopesh Janmanchi
41 Service Excellence in Insurance 83 Tasar Silkworm and Sericulture Editorial Support, Design and

Shirmila Sudhakaran Insurance Printing by


Rathindranath Banerjee SAP PRINT SOLUTIONS PVT. LTD.
44 Measuring Customer Loyalty
Website: www.sapprints.com
with Service Quality and 87 Call for Papers
Customer Satisfaction in Life Email: design.sapprints@gmail.com
88 Guidelines for Contributors
Insurance
91 Program Calendar Notice to Readers
R. Venkatesan
Publication of papers and other
50 Expeditous Claim Settlement as
the Best Market Differentiator contribution in this Journal does not
necessarily imply agreement with
Shashi Kant Dahuja
statements made or opinions expressed;
This journal is for distribution among members only and not for sale at any retail for which the respective writers alone
outlets or bookstores. are responsible.

Follows us on facebook f www.facebook.com/#!/pages/Insurance-Institute-of-India/164203300299381

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 1


TRAVEL INSURANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

I
nformation Technology and Communication coupled with the ubiquity
of social media has completely transformed the external environment of
insurance. On the one hand it creates possibilities for insurers to deep
dive into their customer environment and be a part of their experience in multiple
ways. On the other hand, customers who are today empowered by all the forces
of their disposal, have become extremely demanding about how they look at
customer value.
The concept of service has been considerably changed. A new term ‘Servitaization’
is used increasingly today to describe the tendency of the firms to offer a fuller
value proposition that combines products, services, support systems, self
edITorIal

service, knowledge and more. More and more companies are today focused less
on providing products and more on creating eco systems which enable customers
to not only address their needs but also have a great experience.
In this issue we invite you to look at service in a much larger sense and explore
the new frontiers that are opening up. It would of course mean a lot of unlearning
- cleaning up the cobwebs that have covered our minds in the insurance industry
for the last two centuries. We feel it may be worthwhile.
The next issue i.e. April – June 2018 issue is on open theme. Articles on any topic
on insurance or allied areas are invited. The articles should reach us on or before
28th February, 2018.
The July – September 2018 issue shall be on ‘Insurance: Learning
from Global Best Practices’. The articles should reach us on or before
31st May, 2018.

2 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA TURBOCHARGING

Turbocharging Growth of Insurance Business


through Service Excellence: Going Beyond what
Regulation Demands

Abstract the only means to grow the business


in an insurance market that resembles
In a world that is increasingly
a red ocean characterized by intense
dominated by technology, sustaining
competition between public sector
a business has become more
and private sector. This essay talks
challenging than before. Insurance
about why service excellence is so
business is no exception. Being a
crucial for the insurance business and
service industry, insurance has to
also discusses the various business
constantly strive to raise the bar and
excellence models from which the
deliver service that is way beyond
insurance industry can get inspired to
customer expectations. Services
excel in service delivery.
are not only process-dependent but
also people-dependent. The role of Keywords: Service excellence,
employees who face customers at the insurance, regulation, Kano model,
front end, in ensuring a satisfactory customer focus, Net promoter score,
Venkatesh Ganapathy service experience for the customer has sustainability
Associate Professor, become important. Service excellence
Introduction
Presidency School of Business, has therefore become a differentiator in
Flat no. 102, Jeevanadi Samskruti, a market where online and traditional Service excellence is the process
BMP No. 12, 3rd main, 3rd Cross, modes of service delivery compete for of consistently communicating to
HAL 3rd Stage, both market share and mind share. every customer – whether internal or
Bangalore - 560 075. With the risks of services becoming external – that they are valued and
gvenkatesh69@gmail.com commoditized, service excellence is that their satisfaction is paramount

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 3


TURBOCHARGING THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

to an organization. Consistent service a clear strategy in place to meet the Through the adoption of lean model,
excellence can lead to competitive requirements of customers. the company can increase productivity,
advantage for an insurance firm. reduce costs, increase profits and boost
Every organisation across the globe
Customers are well informed, more employee morale. Lean implementation
is now realizing the value of having a
techno-savvy, less loyal and more in services can lead to service
strategic management process in place.
demanding. In a buyer’s market, excellence and customer satisfaction.
So, it is high time the insurance sector
the customer has a wide choice of
uses strategic management to grow The interesting aspect of services is
insurance covers to choose from.
the business. Way back in the 80’s, that it is possible for an insurance
Clients expect that service standards
Michael Porter spoke about the five firm to benchmark its services against
are not only best but also maintained
forces model that shaped competition services of a successful service
by the firm. The customer experience
in the market. These five forces are – provider – though the latter may not
management principle has superseded
bargaining power of buyers, bargaining necessarily be part of the insurance
that of customer relationship ecosystem. Best quality practices that
power of suppliers and intense rivalry
management. deliver customer value can always be
between existing players in the market,
Exceptional client service is about threat of new entrants and threat of imbibed.
going beyond what is expected by the substitutes. Customers are spoilt for In a study to understand diners’
customer. A delighted customer will choice today as insurance can even behavior, Chen etc al (2017) talk about
give positive word of mouth referrals be bought online and customers can creating customer segments based on
about his experience with the insurance compare the prices of covers from customer participation in hospitality
company. Service excellence is a different insurers. Insurance agents are service encounters. The identified
result of emotional connection with being wooed by both national insurers customer segments can be profiled in
customers. Often it has been found and private insurance companies. The terms of demographics, attitudes and
that emotion takes over rationale when insurance market resembles a red behaviors. The next step is to evaluate
it comes to purchasing decisions. ocean where sharks fight with one the relationship between customer
This behavior of consumers must be another and there is a bloody battle. participation segments and service
effectively leveraged by the insurance After dismantling of the TAC, price outcomes. The results revealed that
industry. In a market characterized by undercutting has become a common the level of customer participation is
intense rivalry between players, service feature of insurance markets. For an related to service outcomes. Thus,
is going to be the key differentiator. insurance firm to succeed in the long service providers can use customer
Service excellence is not the forte run, it has to work towards creating an participation segments to understand
of the sales or marketing functions. uncontested market space – something customers’ service needs and wants.
Back end functions in insurance that resembles a blue ocean. There is The service strategies can then be
must complement the front line sales an urgent need to develop innovative appropriately designed to meet the
force. So, unless service excellence is service propositions that can add needs of target customer groups. The
immense value to customers. insurance sector can explore such
underscored as an essential component
possibilities.
of strategic management, insurance
Review of Literature
firms will find it difficult to sustain Word-of-mouth publicity is always
in the long run. Employees need to Service organisations can learn about considered a good promotional tool to
be trained, engaged and empowered excellence from their manufacturing market a firm’s products and services.
so that they understand the meaning counterparts. In their book – ‘The The customers’ interactions with each
of delivering a service that moves Toyota Way to Service Excellence’ other can also affect service quality
beyond what the customer expects. (2017), Ross and Liker show that outcomes. These interactions can be
Insurers often feel that they are bound service organisations can adopt the characterized along two dimensions
by the dictates of the regulator - lean approach to reduce waste and – design of service operations and
IRDA. However in their own interest gain value. The authors demonstrate delivery. The positive effects of
it will be prudent if they can think the development of a lean model that customer to customer interactions can
beyond regulatory norms and have can lead to superior quality of service. be leveraged to reduce costs, add value

4 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA TURBOCHARGING
and deliver a unique service proposition Dealing with Customer Role of People in Insurance
(Moura & Amorim, 2017). Use of Expectations Services
existing customers to act as de-facto
A survey of more than 500 high net The American National Insurance
brand ambassadors to propagate the
worth individuals across the UK, Company believes that agents need to
benefits of insurance products and
Ireland and France was conducted. be supported and mobile technologies
services is not a bad idea at all.
The objective was to gauge their can at best be a great value addition.
People aspects play an important feedback about the level of service People skills and their role in value
role in service excellence. Softer that they received from their insurance creation for customers should never
dimensions of quality management provider and to obtain their suggestions be underestimated. Some insurers are
are essential too (Escrig et al, 2015). about whether the industry could enabling brokers to work with tablets to
Psychological contracts can shape do better. These individuals felt that service customers better. If customers
organizational identification and their insurance provider gave them are assisted by employees who possess
influencing service-oriented behaviors a personalized service. The survey high degree of knowledge coupled
of frontline employees. Employees are also revealed that these individuals with superlative interpersonal skills it
influenced both by their co-workers purchased personal insurance cover increases the chances of making a sale.
and supervisors (Lu et al, 2016). using a comparison website. 60% Whether it is brokers or agents – if
Frontline employees in insurance like high net worth individuals look for an they have a sophisticated web portal
advisors, brokers, agents, surveyors, insurance service provider who has technology to service customers better,
development officers and other a strong reputation for handling and it leads to better decision making and
customer facing staff must be trained settling claims within a reasonable time ensures growth of business. Thus
well so that they can demonstrate frame. service excellence means walking
exemplary behavior. It is imperative that insurance firms along with the customer to create an
in India take regular feedback from experience of an exemplary service.
There are a plethora of service
excellence models. These models customers to understand their Likeonomics
of service excellence are still being expectations better. The insurance
People do business with people they
developed despite the fact that service sector must expand its market
like. This is the basic principle of
excellence is being recognized as a segmentation by including college
“Likeonomics”. Businesses tend to
critical factor for success of business. students (students nowadays ride a
believe that delivering exceptional service
vehicle and must therefore buy motor
Absence of a comprehensive approach will cost them too much in staff time,
insurance cover). The industry must
to systematic implementation and training or developing service standards
also include the poorest of the poor
management of service excellence and procedures. These organisations lose
(the bottom of the pyramid segment)
models is a cause of concern. There customers when they start cutting costs
as part of “inclusive” insurance. This
is a need for an integrated approach under the garb of operational efficiency.
will support Prime Minister Narendra
to develop an overarching system for Employees need to be recognized and
Modi’s vision of “financial inclusion”
service excellence that can invariably rewarded failing which employee turnover
as part of developmental agenda. In
lead to customer delight (Asif, 2015). may rise. Training employees in delivering
fact, micro insurance segment itself
Such models need to be customized to excellent service must be considered as an
can be split into two – one for the poor
suit the sensibilities of the insured. investment for future growth of business.
and the other for the marginalized and
Innovation has the greatest impact on underprivileged communities in India. Some people and companies are more
service excellence as far as customers IRDA can also request corporates to join believable than others. Likeability is the
are concerned (Sekhon et al, 2015). hands with the insurance community as secret to being more trusted and getting
So, insurance firms have to brainstorm part of corporate social responsibility more customers. Businesses need to
innovative methods to capture and trigger an “insurance” revolution know how to build and develop deeper and
customer attention, lure them into in India. But all these efforts will need more trusted personal relationships. The
buying insurance covers and match that a clear understanding of customer concept of likeonomics was put forward by
with impeccable service. expectations. Professor Rohit Bhargava of Georgetown

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 5


TURBOCHARGING THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

University. He uncovers five principles of The Six Principles of Service Excellence


the TRUST formula – Truth, Relevance,
Unselfishness, Simplicity and Timing. The
principles of Likeonomics are relevant for
the insurance sector as well.

Consequences of Poor Service


Poor service can be costly to an insurance
firm. Undoing the damage done can be a
costly affair. Negative customer experiences
reduce revenue and drive up costs. The
credibility of the firm suffers and market
reputation dips. A client who is dissatisfied
is more likely to spread the word about poor
service experience than a satisfied client. It
is not uncommon to find unhappy clients
take to social media platforms to broadcast
their disillusionment with services. Even a
small thing like returning a phone call or
providing information or simply getting
to know the customer better can make a
http://www.psbydesign.com/the-six-principles-model/
large difference in terms of enhancing the
satisfaction levels of clients. Leaders have Principle 1 – Vision & Mission World class organizations that sustain a
to communicate to employees the need culture of service excellence have a sound
for customer focus. Employees must be vision and mission.
told that by delivering excellent service, the Principle 2 – Business Objectives Simple, quantifiable organizational goals
resulting personal satisfaction can make are essential; these need to be socialized
one feel valued. with employees
Principle 3 – Service Standards Employees need clarity on actions
Responsiveness to customers, listening
and behaviors that can drive service
to customers, fulfilling the promises and excellence and create customer loyalty;
having cutting edge knowledge in the field communication of standards of excellence
will build bridges with discerning customers to employees is vital.
today. Insurance advisors must take good Principle 4 – Intervention and Learning There is a need for systems and
care of their client. Developing long lasting strategy processes to ensure that service
personal relationships with customers is philosophy is interwoven into every
very important for sustainability of business. aspect of the organizational culture.
Service philosophy has to be integrated in
each and every aspect of the recruitment
and selection process.
Principle 5 – Organizational alignment The service philosophy has to be
constantly reinforced. Leaders must
be accountable for discussing the
organizational vision, mission, business
objectives and service standards.
Principle 6 – Measurement & Use of simple scorecards can
Leadership accountability help employees keep track of the
organization’s success or failure in
driving excellence.

6 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA TURBOCHARGING
Commitment of the top management Engaging new customers is critical for the channels are ably supported by
is essential for driving the service insurance – it is not about selling more productive employees.
excellence agenda. These principles to existing customers but diversifying
Insured who is seeking a cover will
of service excellence are more than into new markets and convincing
primarily expect that the quality
just a business model. The customer new buyers and segments to become
of service is outstanding and that
experience needs to be elevated from insurance clients. The best way to
service is delivered in a time bound
average to extraordinary. This can engage Gen Y customers is through
fashion. Accurate information must be
eventually lead to a service organisation mobile and digital technologies.
available and accessible. Staff needs
achieve and sustain a work environment
Enhancing customer experience to demonstrate high standards of
that can drive superior employee
through service excellence can ensure professional excellence.
performance and service excellence.
competitive advantage for insurance Steps for Achieving Service
Customer Service & Service business. This will increase market Excellence
Excellence share and profitability and reduce costs.
The essential elements in service
The role of customer service in growing The convergence of social, mobile,
excellence can be classified as
a business and sustaining it can never digital and analytics will provide new
positioning, proficiency, partners and
be ignored. Customer service excellence ways of interacting with new buyers.
process. The role of service in the
is no longer an option. In the era Despite these technological advances,
insurance company’s positioning and
of globalisation, culturally sensitive client-facing persons be it the insurance
competitive differentiation needs to be
approaches to customer service are agent, broker or call center employee
understood. Service excellence has to
essential. Essential strategies for who directly interact with the customer,
be an integral part of an organisation’s
customer service excellence need to be can make or break a current or future
identified. sale.

Customer Service Service Excellence


Poor service can be
costly to an insurance Meeting expectations Exceeding expectations
Compliance with needs Compliance and anticipation
firm. Undoing the Meeting standards Exceeding standards
damage done can be a Warm and friendly Accommodating and Flexible
costly affair. Negative Competent/ Knowledgeable Subject matter expert
customer experiences Focus on function Focus on purpose
reduce revenue and drive Customer satisfaction Customer Loyalty

up costs. The credibility One of the fundamental philosophies strategy. Mystery shopping is a
of the firm suffers and of TQM is doing things right the first technique in service marketing whereby
market reputation dips. A time. The insurance industry must an organisation shops for its own
client who is dissatisfied absorb this tenet in all earnestness. services by using in-house teams or
This will enhance productivity and drive trusted third party consultants. These
is more likely to spread
cost savings. Dealing with customer people pose as buyers and seek service
the word about poor complaints effectively and efficiently is from the business.
service experience than the main requirement to drive service
a satisfied client. It is excellence. But this alone is not enough The insurers can appoint trusted teams
to pose as customers and seek the
not uncommon to find to earn loyal customers. Delivering
services of an insurance agent or a
unhappy clients take to outstanding service consistently at
all times is vital. Employees must be broker or a development officer. This
social media platforms will help the insurance firm to assess its
skilled and highly engaged. It needs to
to broadcast their be reiterated that digital channels may proficiency in terms of speed, quality,
disillusionment with be unsuccessful in demonstration of consistency and continuity of service
services. empathy towards customers unless across various interaction channels like

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 7


TURBOCHARGING THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

online, social media and phone. The Net Promoter Score organisations to earn customer
insurance firm must treat agents and advocacy. The Net Promoter score is an
This score is a customer loyalty metric
brokers and external stakeholders like index that measures the willingness of
that can be used to gauge the loyalty of
marketing and sales head of institutions customers to recommend a company’s
a firm’s customer relationships. The UK
as partners in progress. Customer products or services to others. It is a
service must not begin only after sale Customer Satisfaction Index (UKCSI)
proxy for gauging the customer’s overall
– it should commence even before the highlighted that the insurance sector satisfaction with a company’s product
sale. Every purchase of an insurance in the UK has enjoyed an increase in or service and customer’s loyalty to the
policy must be a moment of truth for the overall customer satisfaction over brand. If customers have a hard time
policyholder. the past year. But there is a drop in in getting their problems resolved by
Net Promoter Score. This means that the insurer it could have a deleterious
Optimizing the way a customer service
it is becoming difficult for insurance impact on customer satisfaction.
query is routed and processed is crucial
to service excellence. Gaps in service ·
quality delivery need to be identified so
that corrective actions can be taken.

The different ways in which service


excellence can be achieved are
enumerated below:
• Focus on customer
• Training frontline employees who
have regular interactions with
customers
• Updating policies and procedures
Source: https://www.checkmarket.com/blog/net-promoter-score/
• Ensuring that controls are in place
The Kano Model can help any think about how products relate
• Continuous assessment of business
team or organization get a better to customer’s needs. Rather than
practices
understanding of customer constantly introduce new features to
• Explore additional tools and requirements and their impact on a product, it will be better to add one
techniques to deliver continued customer satisfaction. The Kano attractive feature that could delight
service excellence
model of product development and customers and increase sales.
Service Excellence Models customer satisfaction was published
in 1984 by Dr Noriaki Kano, professor
The EFQM excellence model provides a of quality management at the Tokyo
framework that encourages cooperation, University of Science. According to
collaboration and innovation. This
Kano, a product or service is about
model provides a holistic view of
much more than just functionality.
the organisation. It tells us how the
Consumer emotions are important.
different tools can complement each
The model encourages a firm to
other. The model can thus be used to
deliver sustainable excellence. Service The Net Promoter Score
excellence is all about exceeding the is an index that measures
expectations of customers. Using the
the willingness of
EFQM model people can understand the
cause and effect relationships between
customers to recommend Fig: Kano Model [https://www.
what their organisation does and the a company’s products or mindtools.com/pages/article/
results achieved. services to others. newCT_97.htm]

8 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA TURBOCHARGING
14. Positioning aimed at increasing
mind share

15. Mobile apps for greater customer


engagement

16. Compulsory life insurance for all

17. Premium payback after every 5


years

18. Include calamitous events as part


of insurance covers

19. An insurance cess by government


that can help crop insurance / micro
insurance

Conclusion
Customer service is a critical
differentiator for businesses. The ability
https://www.slideshare.net/oeconsulting/service-excellence-models-by- to have effective customer interactions
operational-excellence-consulting can lead to distinctive competence.
In Kaufman’s service excellence 3. The government can create an app so Service excellence is closely linked
model, there are 6 steps. Criminal that pricing strategies of different insurers to customer loyalty. It is not a good
service is something that violates even is known to the insured public. idea to cut corners when it comes to
minimum expectations of customers. delivering impeccable service quality.
4. Insurers must provide subsidized
Today’s internet savvy customer will not
Basic service is disappointing that can health insurance cover for the needy
leave any stone unturned to bash up an
frustrate customers. Expected service
5. Introduction of wide variety of policies egregious service experience.
is an average service that just about
(different types of covers including cyber
satisfies customers. Desired service is It is a system of processes that leads
insurance cover) and innovative value
what customers hope for and prefer. to great service as exceptional service.
propositions
Surprising service is something that The service DNA consists of values
is special like an unexpected gift. 6. Use social media marketing to and capabilities that lead the frontline
The service more than meets their popularize insurance schemes workers to be so motivated as to raise
expectations. 7. Transparent clauses in policy contracts above the call of duty and deliver
superior service to customers.
Brainstorming Exercise 8. A feedback mechanism that is used for
continuous improvement in services Companies with a service DNA must
To know the views of younger ensure that customer needs are part
9. Equated monthly instalments for
generation about service excellence of everyday decision making. Well-
paying insurance premium
in insurance, a brainstorming session orchestrated service processes are
was conducted among post graduate 10. Strategic alliances between insurers crucial for success. But a service DNA
students of management. The sample and educational institutions and that consists of customer-focused
size was 60. The views that emerged universities values is more important. Customer
from the session are as below. 11. Loyalty bonuses in motor insurance defection happens because they are
not properly treated and often they
1. Insurance premium pricing must be 12. Service quality assurance
do not feel valued enough. Insurance
competitive.
13. Monthly insurance plan for education organisations must walk the talk
2. Less paper work and faster and hospitality sector (` 10 as premium) when it comes to rendering service
processing of claims (this should be made mandatory) of exceptional quality. The company

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 9


TURBOCHARGING THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

strategy must ensure that structure and organisations like insurance must use to the idea of “self-insurance” which
processes in the organisation match the strategic management to drive service companies like British Petroleum
needs of the customers. This will lead excellence so that existing customers promoted and eulogized many years
to a seamless customer experience. can be retained and new customers ago. If policyholders do not get good
Policies and metrics must be aligned can be acquired. The different business service from insurers, then they may
excellence models give an idea of what as well create their own reserve and
with customer needs. A service DNA
service excellence entails but what is build the reserve to meet their future
requires a commitment to generating
needed is an integrated framework that requirements. If this idea gains ground
and sharing consumer insights to
can suit the needs of the insurance it might be inimical to the prospects of
improve customer service excellence
sector better. the insurance sector in the long run.
over time. This is all the more reason service
Today the customer is aware about his excellence has to become part of the
The brainstorming session with rights. Customers cannot be taken for DNA of every insurance organisation.
students gave a clear idea of what a ride. There is an emerging school
the younger generation expects of thought that can be a real threat The truth is that there can never be any
from insurance industry. Service to the insurance sector. This pertains substitute for service excellence.

References Sekhon, H. S., Al-Eisawi, D., Roy, S. https://www2.chubb.com/uk-en/insight/


K., & Pritchard, A. (2015). Service the-three-pillars-of-service-excellence.
http://flevy.com/browse/business-
excellence in UK retail banking: aspx
document/delivering-service-
customers’ perspectives of the important
excellence-159
antecedents. International Journal of https://www.ibm.com/blogs/insights-
https://www.slideshare.net/theojamison/ Bank Marketing, 33(7), 904-921. on-business/insurance/customer-
creating-a-culture-of-service-excellence engagement-service-excellence-in-
Asif, M. (2015). A critical review
Liker, J. K., & Ross, K. (2017).The insurance/
of service excellence models:
Toyota Way to Service Excellence. towards developing an integrated https://www.ahip.org/events/
Chen, S. C., Chen, S. C., Raab, C., framework. Quality & Quantity, 49(2), insurance-032116/
Raab, C., Tanford, S., &Tanford, S. 763-783.
(2017).Segmenting customers by http://www.destinationcrm.com/Articles/
Escrig, A. B., & de Menezes, L. M.
participation: An innovative path Web-Exclusives/Viewpoints/4-Keys-to-
(2015). What characterizes leading
to service excellence. International Customer-Service-Excellence-82539.
companies within business excellence
Journal of Contemporary Hospitality aspx
models? An analysis of “EFQM
Management, 29(5), 1468-1485.
Recognized for Excellence” recipients
http://www.customernet.com/customer-
Moura e Sá, P., & Amorim, M. (2017).A in Spain. International Journal of
satisfaction-in-insurance-good-but-not-
typology of customer-to-customer Production Economics, 169, 362-375.
good-enough/
interaction and its implications for
excellence in service provision. Total https://www.slideshare.net/theojamison/
http://www.freepatentsonline.com/
Quality Management & Business creating-a-culture-of-service-excellence
article/Paradigm/297309483.html
Excellence, 1-11.
https://www.slideshare.net/oeconsulting/
Lu, V. N., Capezio, A., Restubog, S. L. service-excellence-models-by- https://www.islands.insure/about-us/
D., Garcia, P. R., & Wang, L. (2016). operational-excellence-consulting customer-service-excellence.html
In pursuit of service excellence:
http://www.efqm.org/the-efqm- https://www.futurelab.net/blog/2016/11/
Investigating the role of psychological
excellence-model service-dna-%E2%80%93-creating-
contracts and organizational
customer-service-excellence
identification of frontline hotel http://www.insurancebusinessmag.com/
employees. Tourism Management, 56, ca/news/risk/client-service-excellence-- http://likeonomics.com/likeonomics-
8-19. with-more-than-a-smile-48394.aspx about-the-book

10 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA TECHNOLOGY - A GAME CHANGER

Technology: A Game Changer for Insurance Industry

Aegis was a magical protective cloak, Individuals in due course began to


made from the goat skin that had realize the importance of mitigation of
suckled Zeus as an infant. It is a brilliant risks either associated with an asset
metaphor for shield or protection, the they possess or their own existence.
one which is sought against perils and Since the risk associated with each
be protected from menace. person cannot be freely exchanged or
replaced, people with exposure to risks
Since aeon of human history, the
of the same kind, naturally, formed
kindred who lived in groups relied
groups to assess those risks, evaluate
on the kin relatedness as their only
and price them and eventually pay a
palisade against the wrath of nature,
quantum to transfer them.
unknown diseases, injuries and famine.
As we proceeded to later stages of The early risk instruments with circa
development, the dawn of agrarian 2250 BC when the Babylonians
revolution made it possible to curb developed a loan instrument for the
the dearth of food and its storage. The marine business, the innovation in
barter system and later with instigation terms of policies, terms and conditions
of pecuniary measures, enabled spread through other countries.
Sheetal Gawde monetary gains and creation of social Eventually, England adopted the
Assistant Manager structures at various levels including practice of protecting the merchants
(International Operations) merchants, labourers, blacksmiths, and ship owners by insuring their
General Insurance Corporation of India goldsmiths, sailors etc. With the advent voyages. Corresponding to that the
“Suraksha”, 170, Jamshedji Tata Road,  of the mercantile generation, the focus underwriters would meet at Lloyd’s
Churchgate, Mumbai - 400020. was amicably shifted from the collective coffee house wherein each of them
sheetalg@gicofindia.com approach to individual approach. would write their name and the amount

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 11


TECHNOLOGY - A GAME CHANGER THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

of risk he was assuming underneath the customer experience at a broader easier data processing solutions, a
insurance proposal. This gave birth to sense. These technologies are also substantial rise in the computing power
the term “underwriting” which is today enabling the insurers to come up with (from 1956 to 2015, there has been 1
associated so closely with the Lloyd’s. a robust business model to discover trillion-fold increase in performance),
the challenges and opportunities to reduction of cost, optimization of
In modern world, the prolificity of
increase the insurance penetration by resources, omnipresence of internet and
insurance, contributes to overall growth
focusing on the market trend to meet proliferation of smart gadgets. Insurers
and advance of the financial sector of
the demands. are increasingly relying on the business
each country. At the grassroot level,
models and advance analytical tools to
the industry has helped to strengthen The Paradigm Shifts
study to leverage the surge in data and
the robustness of the economy by
Until recently India had a low insurance curtail the number of unknown risks,
facilitating the transfer of risk. Every
penetration market in rural areas. reduce the threats, mitigate the peril,
sector in the global economy has
However, with the introduction of smart study the historical patterns, decrease
been touched by technology now.
phones and internet at affordable rates the underwriting risk, offer affordable
The world has crunched into palms
and major shifts in client demographics, premium, expand insurability which
of every individual who has access to
access to web applications which shall lead to delivery of significantly
internet, smart phones and tablets.
created financial transactions accepted insurance products.
The data procured each day is closed
to 20 zettabytes per day and shall be awareness, the insurance widespread Access to Real Time Data
close to 44 zeta bytes by the end pf has evolved radically. There has been a
Real time data is often based on
2020. To give a close perspective, one smooth transition from the agent driven
preliminary estimates and there is
zettabyte is equivalent to 44 trillion market to the digitally driven market.
gigabytes. The data produced each day Technology has been the game changer Prudent understanding
is a combination of text, images, videos, in the very terms of transforming the
GIFs, live streaming which comprises of
of the technology
nature of risk which is regarded as
the digital technology. the core element of insurance sector available, the expectations
Digital technology is the advancement by enabling avant-garde methods of
creating, capturing and analyzing data
of the consumer
which led to the spur of transformation
in the insurance industry including important to insurance companies. market, transparency
cloud computing, advanced analytics, Today, gaining customer insights
mobile phones, web applications, digital have becomes favorable as interaction of regulation, coherent
with customers has become possible
platforms and artificial intelligence. services and personalized
This emergence from the fundamental effortlessly. The growing prevalence of
technology, will help the insurers in mobile phones provide new methods experience should
studying the preference patterns and to communicate with customers and
engaging the existing and potential
define the insurance
provide undisrupted services at all
customers with lowered costs, hours encouraging brand allegiance. products and accordingly
increased efficiency and expanded
Technologies Available Today the services shall
insurability.
and Future Implementations
Prudent understanding of the Suggested to Increase be rendered. Digital
technology available, the expectations Insurance Penetration
of the consumer market, transparency
technology is enabling
Big Data and Cloud Computing
of regulation, coherent services insurance companies to
and personalized experience should The digital data glob is doubling in
define the insurance products and size every alternate year. This gigantic enhance the customer
accordingly the services shall be growth is attributed by various factors
experience at a broader
rendered. Digital technology is enabling including cheap solutions for data
insurance companies to enhance the storage, higher storage capacity, sense.

12 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA TECHNOLOGY - A GAME CHANGER
no delay in the timeliness of the concert was an undisputable proof and the smart phone can help to control the
information provided. The data on that grounds, the claim was declined. temperature at a furnacing unit, averting
pertaining to insureds shall be available The insurance companies could also get the risk of a possible fire breakout.
immediately to insurance companies to know the social habits of the insured Sensors at home enable the homes to
and help them to provide better in case anyone has hid any information be known as smart phones. A camera
services. Also, insurers can make in the policy. At a positive note, social fitted on the door can be monitored
available any vital information or alert to media shall serve as an excellent through smart phone enabling the users
insureds via real time mobile technology distribution channel and almost every to have a view at the visitors. This shall
to avert them of any unpleasant millennial is tech savvy and liberal definitely help to curb the possible
instance. For example, any storm which towards it. house breaking incidents. Biometrics
is slated to occur or timely alerts for and retina scanners have evolved to
Internet and Evolving Data Sources
premium payment to avoid disruption identify each person and thus help in
of policy continuity. This results in The rate of data transmission is maintaining a centralized record of each
fewer claim occurrences and in turn available at unprecedented speed and as person in a country. Certain wearables
contributes to increased customer time shall pass, the cost of producing like Fitbit; provide the insurance
satisfaction. Real time data access ultra-high-speed network shall decrease companies with information pertaining
shall help actuaries build robust data considerably. The data sources available to the health of its clients. The constant
assessment model which shall be able now and in future could be anything tracking of calories intake, miles walked,
to price an insurance product at more from cosmic satellite to home security water consumed, heart rate, pulse rate
basic level and offer effectual coverage system, from health monitoring units etc. help the users to monitor their
at optimized premium. In future, to automobile manufacturing factories, health. This results in a better and
real time data could also provide the from GPS (Global Positioning System) healthy life and contributes to lesser
current location of an insurer enabling to government databases. The wide health insurance related claims thus
the insurance companies to pitch for ambit of the information type, demands increasing customer reliability. Token, a
certain insurance coverages like travel, that robust information systems shall be biometric identity ring that streamlines
baggage, household, burglary, health available which shall help to fetch data the process of payment authentication
etc. in an astute pattern for further analysis has officially launched. “Swiss startup
and decision making. To fetch the data Biowatch SA has invented the world’s
Social Media
and make it available to end users the first fully functioning prototype for
Social media these days have become internet should be of high speed without a wearable device secured by wrist
a powerful tool to reach out to masses. any connectivity issues as billions of vein patterns that can be used for
This in turn has also given rise to users are getting to the internet on daily payments, access control, ticketing,
social marketing and brand building. basis. This trend shall continue at an ID management, environment
Interestingly, social media could also increasing speed and apprehend various personalization and more”. University of
be used as an effective platform to curb classes of business globally. Surrey has developed three blockchain
fraudulent claims. Max Drucker, CEO initiatives which shall be focused on
Sensors, Wearables and Telematics
and President of Social Intelligence health care, voting and digital archives
Corp., cited an example wherein a Sensors which are present in home, that will store and analyze wearable
worker’s compensation insurance offices, automobiles, manufacturing biometric data, according to a report
company used the platform of social units which help to reduce the by V3. Insurance companies can come
media to discover an illicit claim. A incidences of accidents by alerting up with health web applications which
warehouse worker who claimed to people. Insurance companies could use shall be developed keeping in view
have an injured arm also played guitar the data collated from these sensors to the risk profiling of an individual and
in a bar band. After coming across send alert messages to insureds. These constantly monitor the life style of the
an advertisement for his performance days smart phones are aligned with insured. It shall provide alerts to enable
show on a social media site, the insurer these sensors to control the operation the insured to be cautious within time
sent an investigator to further probe of the devices on which they are fit. For as it shall capture data like daily calorie
the matter. The photograph took at the example, the software downloaded in intake, workout done etc. against ideal

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 13


TECHNOLOGY - A GAME CHANGER THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

parametric values. Telematics can that they are user friendly and could be should influence on the extent of data
give an altogether different dimension easily accessed even by the consumers availability and storage so that there
to motor insurance by securing and who are less tech savvy. Insurers are is no breach of information security
providing real time data related to realizing the importance of the growing and cyber fraud instances. Regulators
driving habits, the speed at which the trend of the smart phones, faster data should leverage the impact of regulatory
car is driven, the history of accidents, connectivity and taking advantage of policy in such a manner that no
any offenses if done by the insureds. the emerging technology to tap in the interests are favored biasedly neither
The technology of telematics could also growth potential. are obstructed with adjuring hostility.
provide alerts to the drivers informing Advent of technology will definitely
Technology of the Future:
them of any hurdles or mishaps if shall help regulators to be stringent on
Automation due to Artificial
be encountered ahead. The technology noncompliance issues.
Intelligence (AI)
of telematics could also be utilized to
capture real time data of the driver AI shall be utilized to exhibit cognitive Towards Closure…...
if met with an accident by providing behavior by computers for decision Innovative technology solutions are
instant medical help as it shall capture making and problem solving. AI will major game changers in the way
the coordinates of the location of the enable insurance firms to do optimized insurance industry will evolve in the
car and give information of the driver as pricing, better decision making on coming years. It shall contribute
age, gender, any prior medical history underwriting risks, highly proficient immensely in elevating the insurance
which shall help the paramedics to study of archaic data to understand growth, reduce operational costs,
decide the course of medical treatment. the demographics better and study the entice customers, increase productivity
Custom Made Web Applications by claims / loss history, efficient business and provide a modern approach to
Insurance Companies planning and marketing by adopting the overall functioning of the industry.
approaches of statistical methods, Currently, it has led to increased market
The insurance products available computation intelligence and traditional penetration by spreading its wings
with the insurance companies can be symbolic AI. AI technology in future will enormously over regions of all the
accessed at one single touch point also help to study and predict weather nations by providing brilliant insights in
by the users. This help to create a
forecasts more accurately as the wrath people’s lives.
customer database and study the
of nature and its unpredictability is
preference patterns of the users by
something humans have not been able References:
analyzing the products searched by an
to gauge perfectly till date. The research Wikipedia: Real time data
existing / potential customer. Today,
is ongoing on making the machines
with a single swipe on the screen of http://www.biometricupdate.com/
more “human-like” for better knowledge
a smart phone, an insured can buy biometric-news/wearables-biometric-
representation, default reasoning and
a policy. Facilities like net banking news
qualification problem. With cognitive
helps to transfer the premium amount http://www.livemint.com/Home-Page/
efficiency, the insures shall be able
instantly and policy could incept
to gain insights into each clients’ ZSDoTO4TMeAOfs2Bn2U7BP/How-
from the very single day. The web
needs thus contributing to fasters fintech-can-lift-the-insurance-sector.
applications are designed in such a way
customer responses and increasing the html
processing capacity. http://www.businesstoday.in/union-
Technology Implications on budget-2017-18/ceo-expectations/
Regulatory Framework budget-2017-can-help-increase-
insurance-penetration/story/244880.
Regulators around the world wherein
html
there is profound use of technology in
the insurance sector should come up http://cafemutual.com/news/
with robust and resilient regulations insurance/6283-ey-recommends-
to monitor insurance companies and leveraging-digital-technology-to-
insureds. Regulatory implications increase-insurance-penetration

14 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA SERVICE EXCELLENCE CONCEPT

Service Excellence in Insurance

Excellence is a word that may mean In other words, this Paper suggests that
differently to different persons. It is so such excellence in insurance service
because persons ate not mere human can be achieved on a long lasting basis
beings but bundles of many emotive by putting efforts from the theoretical
characteristics. These characteristics side of insurance – by improvising in
are also transient in nature and with packaging and presenting and selling
differently responsive emotes to the theory of insurance – differently.
different situations or to the same
In a way, excellence is a view held by
situation at different times.
people, bound by more of psychological
There could be many practical ways conditions rather than physical
and means by which service excellence conditions or experiences. It is more
can be brought into insurance. These of emotional shades than experiential
practical marketing efforts could ones.
be like, improvisation in packaging,
While it is conceptually so, presence
presenting or selling the service or in
of excellence in marketing parlance
the after-sales service. Instead this
is always targeted by marketers, in a
Paper has taken a different perspective.
physical sense – may be, because it is
Most of the practical applications to
more possible and easier.
augment service, with excellence, are
G. N. Bhaskar Rau all in the sale or the after sale scenario Here again, targeting by marketers takes
Former Research Associate & of insurance service. This Paper different views and approaches given by
Faculty NIA – Pune suggests that infusion of excellence in the two types of markets – the tangible
301, Shanti Nivas Apts. 6 – 3 – 609/1, the insurance service should be at the or product market and the intangible
Anand Nagar Colony, Khairatabad, primary stage of prospecting, pre- or service market. In several instances
Hyderabad - 500004. approach, approach and discussion the tangibility or various features that
gnb_sri@yahoo.com stages itself. make up the tangibility of a product,

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 15


SERVICE EXCELLENCE CONCEPT THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

itself defines and sets the levels of product is not so distinctly available are a few very important and highly
excellence measurable by various for a service marketer. The reason popular ‘services’, which are difficult
degrees of satisfaction, derived by the is obvious. No service has ‘physical to improvise for higher excellence with
consumer from the use of the product. features’ to tinker with. augmented features of physicality.
By benchmarking these various degrees The most relevant of such services
However, there are a few services where
of satisfaction, on each of the various are financial services – banking and
the end-utility of the service is provided
features of the physical product - from insurance.
by the said service marketer using
the initial looks of the packaging to the
certain physical ‘articles’ or ‘goods’ Banking and Insurance Services
final yield or utility value of the product
or ‘accessories’ or ‘peripherals’. In
- the sum total of such measurements
such case the marketer will have the Though both are financial services
can be summarized into certain levels of
advantage of ‘augmenting’ his service to there are many differences in their
excellence of the product, as seen and
achieve a certain degree of excellence, service provisions mainly in their
felt by the consumer.
by enhancing the features of relevant financial transactions, with most of the
However these measurements, as given ‘articles’ or ‘accessories’ etc. A few banking financial transactions having
by the customer may eventually change examples are given below. visibility and palpability of physicality
and downsize the earlier given levels of – in the shape of cash and bills. Such
Travel Services
excellence. When these are recognized physicality is absent in insurance
or realized by the marketer, he can raise Theatre Services financial transactions. This feature of
the level perceived by the customer by physicality brings banking services
Clinical Services
changing or altering or enhancing the closer to acceptability by people while
various features of the product and, Many services such as mentioned
its absence leads to preference or
or repair the benchmarking process to above, supply certain promises which
priority to insurance being ‘in waiting’ or
achieve his targeted level of excellence are fulfilled by conveying them to the
postponed. This is so because insurance
from his customer. customers through the use of certain
is in reality only a promise. No promise
relevant physical ‘properties’ – the
In contrast, even this slight advantage carries any features or similitude of
Travel Agent providing his service by
of achieving a certain level of excellence physicality, which can enable the
using a motor vehicle or train or aircraft
or satisfaction of the customer in his and the like. The marketer can improve customer to comprehend the nature
his service excellence by enhancing of the service offered. This makes him
There could be many the features of the ‘goods’ he uses think and rethink several times before
practical ways and to convey his service – the better the accepting it. In most cases personal
motivation and persuasion by the
means by which service features of the goods the higher the
intermediaries are effectively required
degree of service excellence.
excellence can be brought for the customer to accept the service –
In other words, in the type of service
into insurance. These providers like the above – certain
which again has its own problems and
issues.
practical marketing ‘tangibility’ can be brought in and
improvisation provided by the marketer Some More Difficulties with Insurance
efforts could be like,
to make his customers enjoy better Services which Deter its Purchase are
improvisation in and higher degree of excellence in the
(i) the promise is not a simple and
packaging, presenting or service.
unconditional one; it is ‘contingent’
selling the service or in A little intense observation tells us that
in nature;
in most cases of ‘services’ which are
the after-sales service. aimed at providing appeal to the eye, (ii) the duration for the performance of
Instead this Paper ear, smell, taste or touch, an opportunity the promise by the insurer is not
is given to the marketer to bring in and short but its mostly long-termed
has taken a different
improvise certain ‘physicality’ to the – especially in the case of life
perspective. service – as described above. There insurance promises;

16 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA SERVICE EXCELLENCE CONCEPT
(iii) Given the long term for the promise occurrence – contingent on an ‘external It appears that a time has come for
to be performed by the insurer, the factor’, which is not in the control of insurance marketers to revise their
value of the benefits of the promise either the beneficiary or the insurer – selling aspects – especially in the
may, sometimes, vary from the like fire, accident or death. light of the increased and faster
expectations of the beneficiary, dissemination of awareness among all
Thus, we may safely presume that
due to the various changes that strata of customers and consumers and
what is marketed as ‘insurance’ is
may occur in the socio-economic also in their capacity to see through the
neither a ‘product’ nor a ‘service’ but
and financial conditions of the strategies of the marketers.
it is essentially only a ‘contingent idea’
beneficiary and also in the macro that is sold. It is so because it is in Therefore, it is all the more important
factors that may affect the overall essence a ‘guard’ against ‘risk’, which to take a different view or strategy
economy of the nation; is again an idea – incomprehensible and in selling insurance - because it is
(iv) the service is formulated with many indefinable. difficult to compete with the other
legal and technical aspects which But, the present question is: will all this existing financial services which offer
are all totally unknown and not theory make the customer compromise definite physical returns that are almost
easily knowable by the customer; to accept service as it is and buy it? immediate or at least in very short time
intervals.
(v) in case of exiting from the service Can the insurer make the prospect
‘perceive’ excellence in the service – To make the current point clear, let us
it is with heavy monetary penalties
and, also throughout all the years of the take the example of a fire risk cover.
and, orlosses;
long term of the service? When a fire breaks and a claim arises,
(vi) the service seems to be in nine out of ten cases, the insured is
monotonous and uneventful to the It is human nature to expect some
not satisfied with the ‘service’ offered,
customer as he goes on paying reasonable and satisfactory ‘return’ (or
as he always sees that the ‘return’ (or
premiums for decades for the benefit) and within reasonable time,
benefit) is much below his expectations
for every effort or rupee spent by an
insurer to react after a great length and less said when compared with
individual. The ‘value’ of this return need
of time. Such monotony creates the original sum insured. In fact, in
not be in monetary terms or physical
mental and psychological ennui to most of the cases the indemnification
terms; it can also be based on emotional
the customer. This may result in might have been perfect in technical,
terms. The element of excellence in
middle exit. legal and contractual terms. But, what
this return will be the highest, in the
we – the insurers – miss actually is to
May be this list is not complete but only perception of the customer, if the
create the perception in the mind of the
suggests that it is a mountainous task time element is the shortest or near
insured, that the value of his original
for the marketer to infuse the element immediate – and where the satisfaction
bondage and affinity with the value of
of excellence in his service to attract the derived from the return is the highest or
the subject matter of insurance – be
customer, either at the beginning of the the quantum of the return is high and
contract or during its currency. over and above the original expectation.

The list also suggests that these not so If we now look at insurance service
favourable features mentioned above are against the background described
in the nature of the service (insurance above, we can see that insurance
service) itself and are inseparable and service does not provide either a
in-built features of the service. physical or monetary return during the
entire term of the service. At best, it
This Paper believes that there should be
can provide a return in emotional terms
some way out and suggests.
only, that the worth of his asset is
Insurance is sold as a promise of a covered and taken care of by the insurer
benefit which may materialize to the – but, unfortunately, it is not described
beneficiary or not because the material so or sold so on emotional parlance in
benefit is based on a contingent the market.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 17


SERVICE EXCELLENCE CONCEPT THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

it his house or mill or factory – is around it, as a background while selling he CAN call his, not only his body and
sustained and maintained by the insurance. his psychic powers, but his cloths and
insurer in emotional terms. It is the his house, his wife and children, his
Thus, focus is on the value of the ‘emotional
financial equilibrium maintained that ancestors and friends, his reputation
worth of the asset’ and not merely its
is the benefit of insurance and not the and works, his land, and yacht and
monetary value, as is usually mentioned
claim money paid. The insured must bank account. All these things give
only to calculate the service ‘cost’.
be made to realize that what was being the same emotions. If they wax and
indemnified by the insurer is neither the In his article (“Insurance as a prosper, he feels triumphant; if they
partial loss of the physical asset nor the commodity? Addressing our Industry’s dwindle and die, he feels cast down.
partial loss in value of the lost physical Biggest Challenge”, Tinothy P. O’brien,
asset in monetary terms, but it is the opines that though the concept of cost We, insurers, must adopt his last
indemnification of the partial loss of his requires no explanation, understanding, two sentences and use them in
emotional association and attachment the worth of a product is quite the right way to sell a cover on the
to his asset. He must be made to challenging. A quick search for a psychological ownership of the
understand what would have been the practical definition of worth yields these individual on his asset and not on
worth of his asset in the case of a fire two offerings: “the quality that renders his legal ownership or the physical
and in the absence of insurance. It is something valuable or useful” and “the asset: “All these things give the same
certainly not difficult to do this. value of an object in relationship to a emotions. If they wax and prosper, he
purpose”. feels triumphant; if they dwindle and
The customer would have certainly die, he feels cast down”
understood this emotional aspect had Sadly, our industry appears to have
the service been described and sold to little interest in helping consumers to Cram, F., & Paton, H made a study
him so at the beginning of the sale talk examine the actual worth of the coverage of elderly women who have moved
and discussions. being offered.(Timothy P. O’BrienI) from their residential dwellings to
Understanding the true worth of most hospices. They report that they (the
After all, any kind of ‘ownership’ is an
products requires an inside perspective elderly women) “in their discussion of
attachment and affinity, with certain
that is often beyond most consumers. possessions as part of the extended
emotional threads woven around it,
(Timothy P. O’BrienI) self, note that it is common to witness
nurtured and protected over years of
In other words, what is being suggested the debilitating effects associated
investment of time, labour and efforts
here is that the insurer must play with the movement of the elderly
and money. The owner always takes
upon the emotional attachment of the from their homes to nursing facilities.
more pride in the time and efforts spent,
individual on the asset – that is upon his They attribute these effects to the
rather than the money part – and, this
psychological ownership and not on his separation of the individual from their
positive feeling only lasts long to him.
mere physical or legal ownership of the possessions, in which much of the self
Scott Cavanaugh quotes Martin has become interwoven.”
asset insured.
Seligman of the University of
Pennsylvania, the father of Positive Many psychological studies have Knowingly or unknowingly, every
Psychology, in his article “Psych proved that it is human nature for every individual carries an affinity with what
of Satisfaction”, that “we can make individual to develop an ownership of he has created as an asset “in which
positive feelings last longer when we his possessions apart from his legal much of the self (his own self) has
deliberately take a “mental picture” of ownership and rights. In fact, every become interwoven.”
pleasurable events to share with others individual identifies ‘himself’ personally
Therefore, an insurer must sell
or recall later. in all that he possesses – but latently.
insurance to appeal and to appease
It is for the insurance marketer to bring
An insurer can easily and deliberately to these parts of time and efforts of
it out patently for the customer to
create such a mental picture of pride this pride of psychological ownership
perceive.
and belonging to his customer in which is the real ‘worth’ of the asset
respect of his ‘asset’ which is his In the words of William James, –– “a that is being insured and not its
creation with pleasurable events man’s Self is the sum total of all that nominal monetary value. Monetary

18 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA SERVICE EXCELLENCE CONCEPT
terms are only indirect means of Of course, it is difficult to propose to However these
expressing the elements of time and sell insurance on a premise that is more
efforts of his pride of psychological abstract than the product itself. But,
measurements, as given
ownership. still, it is the suggestion that at least this by the customer may
It is also interesting to note that many
abstract thought of the actual emotional eventually change and
worth of the asset should always linger
tangible physical products are not downsize the earlier given
sold on the point of ‘worth’ of the around the entire sale-talk till it is
realized by the buyer to buy insurance. levels of excellence. When
commodity which is more realized
mentally rather than physically, but This concept should serve as a
these are recognized
on the cost, which is purely monetary background score for the scene of or realized by the
and physically understood. Even this the sale-talk to become effective and marketer, he can raise
commonly used concept is also getting yielding.
revised differently.
the level perceived by the
In analogy, this is a simple change in the
customer by changing or
In one of the IRMI articles, it is presentation or packing of the insurance
reported that, “years ago, a memorable service to dress it anew – just in the altering or enhancing the
Mercedes Benz advertisement manner in which product marketers do. various features of the
reminded readers that, in order to
The actual selling of insurance lies in the product and, or repair the
determine the true value of a car,
consumers should focus not on what a
fact that the value of the return or benefit benchmarking process to
is interwoven with the value of the
car costs but on what the car is worth.” achieve his targeted level
emotional affinity of the ownership. With
Unfortunately, insurance industry is no risk occurrence, the customer will of excellence from his
yet to show interest in making their continue his earlier ‘happy’ association customer.
customers realize that the cover and affinity with his asset intact, and
bought by them is on the actual and in the case of a risk occurrence his insurer to inject a dose of excellence
real worth of the asset covered and affinity with his asset is restored back – by show of care and concern in the
not the cost paid by them. The insurer to him in tact by the insurance service service – till the end of the contract
should first start calculating the actual – or, in other words, his marred happy which would normally be decades away
worth of the asset (be it non-life or life) association is restored back to his in time.
– which calculation should not only original happy state. Customers, normally, want shorter
include the physical worth but also the
The service excellence in insurance lies experiences of excellence in any service.
mental worth the customer carries in
his mind. The calculation of the cost more in the care and concern, than the This trend is not new. It was there in the
must come later only. speed and accuracy, with which the past years of life insurance business also.
above said restoration is effected by
Customers must be made to think A review of past business records
the insurer. Excellence really lies in the
what would be the total cost of the will reveal the statistical history of life
sincere care and concern expressed in
risk upon the asset in the absence of insurance service, that customers always
the service, and where they are, speed
insurance. We must all understand that preferred such insurance schemes more,
and accuracy will automatically follow.
this particular thought or idea is what where there were shorter-timed and
we should sell as ‘insurance’ – and not The customer must feel that he is owned
intermediate returns, to the schemes
insurance. by his insurer.
where the returns were at the end of long
A reputed Broker, Craig Rowe, Further, in the case of life insurance terms. The latter were preferred least.
commented that, as an insurance service, there is no immediacy for the Money Back life policies were always the
broker, it is necessary to make price as insured to perceive the value of the major part of the life insurer’s portfolio.
irrelevant as possible. Clients should return (benefit) which may make him Stock linked insurance schemes were
start thinking not only of price, but of uncomfortable and unsympathetic. It preferred. Jeevan Dhara schemes had
the “total cost of risk” is also well neigh impossible for the record sales which also had life cover.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 19


SERVICE EXCELLENCE CONCEPT THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Even today such a trend may be


preferred for customers to own
insurance by volition, if the required care
and concern is shown by the insurer and
also if the service is offered as cover
to the love and happiness the buyer
owes to his family. Such a sale is the
excellence augmented in the service of
life insurance.
It is indeed wrong to encourage such
singularly motivated sales of short-term
benefit policies and it is much against
the very basic principle and primary
need of life insurance – in the sense
that life insurance is service given to a long years – with benefits at a far and all, across the populations, in
person when he needs it most – that is distant date – and a satisfaction that present day and future years of
in his advanced ages. the premiums have given monetary India.
These two individual interests of the (physical) returns intermediate.
Bibliography
buyer and the seller – short term returns • This also may help the insurer to
1. Cram, F., & Paton, H, “ Personal
or benefits and long term insurance – have a live-link and contact with the
are both juxtaposed. possessions and self -identity: The
customer once in certain short
The Principles of Psychology”, Holt,
However, this Paper suggests a way to durations – more or less a physical
feature introduced in his service New York, 1890, Australian Journal
meet both these divergent ends.
to augment it emotionally. The on Aging 12(1), 19-24
Life insurance service may be offered as
long-term feature and contact is 2. Craig Rowe. On Risk Management
long term policies (with profit sharing
minimized. Blog of ClearRisk (http://www.
provisions) to make the cover available
even in advanced ages of the customer, • This also may give an opportunity clearrisk.com/risk-management-
when it is most needed – and in to the insurer to serve the blog/bid/47402/Insurance-is-a-
addition the service should also give the customer with certain a high Commodity- Or-is-it)
customer an option to reap the partial degree of excellence if he could 3. Scott-Cavanaugh“Psychology of
returns whenever he desires – as under: serve him with speed and a tinge of Satisfaction”, (http://poeticsofaging.
• Such an option can be the option to immediacy – and with promptness. org/wordpress/wp-content/
surrender his accrued reversionary • These transactions can very easily uploads/2011/11/Scott-Cavanaugh_
bonuses to avail in cash and such be done with no paper work and via Psych-of-Satisfaction-Poetics-of-
an option being made available at well designed digital portals. Aging-.pdf)
specified frequencies – say every 5
What is being suggested is, in short, 4. Tinothy P.O’brien, “Insurance as
years.
that the insurance marketer should a commodity? Addressing our
• Such cash options of the accrued redefine his service on emotional and Industry’s Biggest Challenge”,
reversionary bonuses may be psychological terms and sell it on a (https://www.irmi.com/articles/
restricted to a specified percentage newer footing and platform, with a new expert-commentary/insurance-as-a-
also – say not more than 75% of the packing and delivery model. commodity/
total accrued amount available under
This Paper believes that the suggested 5. William Jones,“The Principles of
the policy.
scheme of service should succeed in Psychology, Vol.I.”,1890 (http://
• This may give a feeling of relief to providing sufficient levels of excellence library.manipaldubai.com/DL/the_
the customer that his contributions in the wake of expanding avenues of principles_of_psychology_vol_I.pdf)
as premiums are not locked in for digitalization and its acceptance by one p. 291-292.

20 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA PROTECTING MONEY

Protecting Life Insurance Moneys for the


Beneficiaries – Section 6 (1) of the MWP Act, 1874

“It is obvious that Section 6 avoids these difficulties


to a large extent by bringing into existence what is
conveniently described as a “statutory trust”. The
significance of Section 6 lies in the fact that it renders
unnecessary a compliance with formalities required- For
an assignment, by Section 38 of the Insurance Act, or for
the creation of a trust, by the Indian Trusts Act, 1882”.

I. Introduction damaged in a boat by the fault of the


Complexities of modern economic boatmen, that shall be made good by
life of people have motivated men to the boatmen collectively, (each paying)
search for various methods to save his share1. This decision in suits
V.N.S. Pillai and protect incomes and wealth for (brought) by passengers (holds good
Vilackattu House, themselves and/or for their families. only) in case the boatmen are culpably
Kaippattoor Post Office, Insurance is one such method. In fact negligent on the water; in the case of
District Pathanmthitta, the earliest kind of any operational (an accident) caused by (the will of)
Kerala - 689648. insurance cover may be found in the gods, no fine can be (inflicted on
pillaivnsreekaran@gmail.com the Manu Smriti: Whatever may be them)ii.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 21


PROTECTING MONEY THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

There are many legal provisions that any of those religions. And the  State property. This Section is reproduced
protect life insurance moneys. In this Government may from time to time, by here: Married women’s earnings
brief article we limit our discussion order, either retrospectively from the to be their separate property: The
to life insurance purchased through passing of this Act or prospectively, wages and earnings of any married
protection offered under Section 6(1) exempt from the operation of all or woman acquired or gained by her
of Married Women’s Property Act, any of the provisions of this Act the after the passing of this Act, in any
1874, which is rarely discussed in members of any race, sect or tribe, employment, occupation or trade
life insurance marketing seminars or part of a race, sect or tribe, to carried on by her and not by her
and symposia and seldom acted whom it may consider it impossible or husband, and also any money or other
upon by marketing personnel. Sound inexpedient to apply such provisions. property so acquired by her through
knowledge and broad understanding The State Government may also the exercise of any literary, artistic
of the subject is the sine qua non revoke any such order, but not so or scientific skill, and all savings
of any marketing activity, more so that the revocation shall have any from and investments of such wages,
with services-marketing. This paper retrospective effect. All orders and earnings and property, shall be
progresses into five parts, namely, revocations under this section shall be deemed to be her separate property,
I. Introduction, II. Married Women’s published in the official Gazette’iii.  and her receipts alone shall be good
Property Act, 1874, III. Section 6, discharges for such wages, earnings
What is the rationale for non-
MWP Act. IV. Discussion on Section and propertyv.
application of this Act to married
6(1), and V. Conclusion. women who at the time of their Section 5 deals with insurance
II. Married Women’s Property marriage belonged to Hindus, purchased by the wife for her own
Act, 1874 Muhammedans, Buddhists and benefit and Section 6 deals with
Jains? The answer to this could be insurance purchased by a married
Married women’s earnings to be their found in the 66th Report of the Law man for the benefit of his wife. Section
separate property - Married woman Commission of India. ‘Prior to January 5 is quoted here and Section 6 will
mayeffect policy of insurance on her 1866, the law applicable in India, be dealt with as a separate topic as it
own behalf and independently of her to persons who were not Hindus, forms the main content of this article.
husband; and the same and all benefit Muslims, Buddhists, Sikhs or Jains, ‘Married woman may effect policy of
thereof, if expressed on the face was in general, the English common insurance: - Any married woman may
of it to be so effected, shall ensure law as regards matters concerning effect a policy of insurance on her
as her separate property - Married personal status. Hindus, Muslims, own behalf and independently of her
women may take legal proceedings - Buddhists, Sikhs and Jains were husband; and the same and all benefit
Wife’s liability for postnuptial debts governed by their personal law. The thereof, if expressed on the face of it
- Husband not liable for wife’s ante persons to whom the English common to be so effected, shall ensure as her
nuptial debts - Extent of husband’s law was thus applicable for want separate property, and the contract
liability for wife’s breach of trust or of their own personal law, included evidenced by such policy shall be as
devastation Europeans and Indian Christians, valid as if made with an unmarried
This is a small Act (referred as MWP Jews, Armenians and Parsis – to womanvi. ‘As the law stood then, if a
Act in the article hereafter) containing mention some of the most important wife effected such a policy otherwise
ten Sections and applies to the whole communities. Accordingly, the than out of her separate estate and
of India except Jammu and Kashmir. restrictions as regards possession and died in the husband’s life time, then
Its further applicability is discussed alienation of property of an English the husband became the owner of
here. ‘But nothing herein contained woman generally applied to women the policy in the capacity of her
applies to any married woman who at belonging to these communitiesiv. administrator. Hence a need for this
the time of her marriage professed the provisionvii.
Section 3 of the Act stands repealed
Hindu, Muhammadan, Buddhist, Sikh through the Repealing Act of 1876. ‘Married Women may take Legal
or Jain religion, or whose husband, at Section 4 states that married women’s Proceedings :- A married woman
the time of such marriage, professed earnings will be their separate may maintain a suit in her own name

22 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA PROTECTING MONEY
for the recovery of property of any 1865 shall not by reason only of such and expressed on the face of it to
description which, by force of the said marriage be liable to the debts of his be for the benefit of his wife, or
Indian Succession Act, 1865, (10 of wife contracted before marriage, but of his wife and children, or any of
1865) or of this Act, is her separate the wife shall be liable to be sued them, shall endure and be deemed
property; and she shall have, in her for, and shall, to the extent of her to be a trust for the benefit of his
own name, the same remedies, both separate property, be liable to satisfy wife, or of his wife and children,
civil and criminal, against all persons, such debts as if she had continued or any of them, according to the
for the protection and security of such unmarried: Proviso.- Provided that interest so expressed, and shall
property, as if she were unmarried, nothing contained in this section shall  not, so long as any object of the
and she shall be liable to such suits, trust remains, be subject to the
invalidate any contract into which a
processes and orders in respect of control of the husband., or to his
husband may, before the passing of
such property as she would be liable creditors, or form part of his estate.
this Act, have entered in consideration
to if she were unmarriedviii. of his wife’s ante nuptial debtsx. When the sum secured by the
policy becomes payable, it shall,
Wife’s Liability for Postnuptial ‘Extent of husband’s liability for
unless special trustees are duly
Debts:- If a married woman (whether wife’s breach of trust or devastation:
appointed to receive and hold
married before or after the first day Where a woman is a trustee, executrix
the same, be paid to the Official
of January, 1866) possesses separate or, either before or after marriage, Trustee of the State in which the
property, and if any person enters into her husband shall not, unless he office at which the insurance was
a contract with her with reference to acts or intermeddles in the trust effected is situate, and shall be
such property, or on the faith that her or administration, be liable for any received and held by him upon the
obligation arising out of such contract breach of trust committed by her, trusts expressed in the policy, or
will be satisfied out of her separate or for any misapplication, loss or such of them as are then existing.
property, such person shall be entitled damage to the estate of the deceased And in reference to such sum he
to sue her, and, to the extent of her caused or made by her, or for any loss shall stand in the same position in
separate property, to recover against
to such estate arising from her neglect all respects as if he had been duly
her whatever he might have recovered
to get in any part of the property of appointed trustee thereof by a High
in such suit had she been unmarried
the deceasedxi. Court, under Act No. XVII of 1864,
at the date of the contract and
These Sections were quoted to give to constitute an office of Official
continued unmarried at the execution
the reader a clear picture of the Trustee, section 10.
of the decree:  Provided that nothing
herein contained shall- scheme of the legislation. Nothing herein contained shall
operate to destroy or impede the
(a) entitle such person to recover III. Section 6, MWP Act. right of any creditor to be paid out
anything by attachment and sale or A policy of insurance effected by any of the proceeds of any policy of
otherwise out of any property which married man on his own life, and assurance which may have been
has been transferred to a woman effected with intent to defraud
expressed on the face of it to be for
or for her benefit on condition that creditors.
the benefit of his wife, or of his wife
she shall have no power during her
and children, or any of them, shall (2) Notwithstanding anything
marriage to transfer or charge the
endure and be deemed to be a trust contained in section 2, the
same or her beneficial interest therein,
for the benefit of his wife, or of his provisions of sub-section (1) shall
as
apply in the case of any policy of
wife and children, or any of them
(b) affect the liability of a husband for insurance such as is referred to
debts contracted by his wife’s agency Section Reproduced: therein which is effected-
expressed or impliedix. Insurance by Husband for Benefit of (a) by any Hindu, Muhammadan, Sikh
Wife:-  or Jain-
‘Husband not Liable for Wife’s Ante
Nuptial Debts :- A husband married (1)  A policy of insurance effected by (i) in Madras, after the thirty-first day
after the thirty-first day of December, any married man on his own life, of December, 1913, or

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 23


PROTECTING MONEY THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

(ii) in any other territory to which this (iii) The policy must be effected for IV. Discussion on Section 6(1)
Act extended immediately before the benefit of his wife, wife and
Section 6 enacts that the trust should
the commencement of the Married children or any of them
appear “expressed on the face” of
Women’s Property (Extension) Act
(iv) This intention must be expressed the document, that is to say, that
1959, after the first day of April,
on the face of the policy the words used should be plain and
1923, or
unambiguous. For whatever purpose
(v) The said policy will be deemed to
(iii)in any territory to which this the policy may be governed by the
be a Trust for the benefit of the
Act extends on and from the terms of the application that preceded
said beneficiaries
commencement of the Married it, for the purpose of the Married
Women’s Property (Extension) (vi) As long as the object of the policy Women’s Property Act the only
Act, 1959, on or after such remains: document that can be looked into is
commencement; the policy - On a careful consideration
(a) It shall not be subject to any
of all aspects of the matter, we have
(b) by a Buddhist in any territory to control of the policyholder
come to the conclusion that while
which this Act extends, on or after
(b) It shall not be subject to any the present statutory scheme as
the commencement of the Married
control of policyholder’s contained in the various provisions
Women’s Property (Extension)
creditors, and mentioned above, may be complex,
Act, 1959:
the complexity is primarily due to
(c) It shall not form part of the
Provided that nothing herein contained legislative anxiety to provide for the
estate of the policyholder
shall affect any right or liability which variety of results which in actual life,
has accrued or been incurred under (vii) When policy moneys become persons taking out life insurance may
any decree of a competent court payable it shall be paid to the desire to achieve
passed- special trustees appointed by the
Section 6 offers unique rights for
policyholder
(i) before the first day of April, 1923, beneficiaries of a policy of life assurance
in any case to which sub-clause (viii) If special trustees are not purchased for their benefit, which is
(i) or sub-clause (ii) of clause (a) appointed, the policy moneys expressed on the face of the policy.
applies; or shall be paid to the official trustee
The Section expects meaningful
of the State where the insurer’s
(ii) before the commencement of consequences. ‘This provision was
policy-effecting-office is situated
the Married Women’s Property thought necessary because it was
and he shall be deemed to be a
(Extension) Act, 1959 (61 of thought that in the absence of such
1959), in any case to which sub- trustee appointed by the High
a provision, the transaction would be
clause (iii) of clause (a) or clause Court as per relevant provision of
considered a “voluntary settlement”
(b) applies. law
on the lines of English law as modified
Sub-section 2 expands the (ix) The trustees, whether special or by statutexii. Regarding voluntary
applicability of sub-section 6(1) official, shall receive and hold the settlements, i.e. settlements made
to practically all people of all policy moneys for the benefit of without consideration, there are certain
communities by negating the the beneficiaries
special rules applicable in equity.
restriction put by Section 2 of (x) Nothing herein contained shall
Transfer of life insurance money
the MWP Act. We can analyse the operate to destroy or impede
conditionality of application of the through Section 6 is an assignment of
the right of any creditor to be
benefit as follows: a ‘chose in action’ or actionable claim.
paid out of the proceeds of any
An assignment may be absolute or
(i) The policy must be effected by a policy of assurance which may
conditional. Under the rules of Muslim
married man have been effected with intent to
law, conditions attached to a gift
defraud creditors. The Law does
(ii) The insurance coverage must be were generally void, except where the
not support fraud
on his own life

24 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA PROTECTING MONEY
assignment of the policy is made to the C, is born to the father. It will not must ensure that his intention appears
wife by way of dower. The gift was valid, be a beneficiary for the policy. But if on the policy document. So when the
but the condition void . But amendment
xiii beneficiaries are mentioned as ‘children’ policy bond reaches him he should
to the Insurance Act 1938, Section 38 (as a class) a child born subsequent confirm that his intention is ‘expressed
has changed the situation by adding to purchase of the policy automatically on the face of the policy’.
“notwithstanding any law or custom becomes a beneficiary. The policy earmarked for the benefit
having the force of law to the contrary” ‘Expressed on the face of the policy’ of wife and children and this intention
conditional assignments are valid . xiv is a direction of wider application. expressed on the face of the policy
The Law Commission has dealt with will be deemed to be a trust. Trust is
We may ask as to what is the real
the subject and elaborated the same: generally governed by the Indian Trusts
significance of Section 6 of the MWP Act 1882. ‘A “trust” is an obligation
“It would appear that the intention to
Act. It is obvious that Section 6 avoids benefit the wife and children must be annexed to the ownership of property,
these difficulties to a large extent expressed in the policy and not in the and arising out of a confidence reposed
by bringing into existence what is proposal. In one Madras case xvii
in the in and accepted by the owner, or
conveniently described as a “statutory insurance policy, against the column declared and accepted by him, for the
trust”. The significance of Section 6 lies “to whom payable” appeared the words benefit of another, or of another and the
in the fact that it renders unnecessary a “to the person or persons legally owner:
compliance with formalities required- entitled thereto”. It was contended by “author of the trust”: “trustee”:
the defendants that a trust arose under “beneficiary”: “trust property”:
(i) For an assignment, by Section
section 6 of the MWP Act. It was, “beneficial interest”: “instrument of
38 of the Insurance Act, or
however, held by the High Court that trust”:
(ii) For the creation of a trust, by the requirements of Section 6 had not
the Indian Trusts Act, 1882xv. The person who reposes or declares
been fulfilled. There was no mention in
the confidence is called the “author of
The policy to be effected under MWP the policy of the wife and children but
the trust”: the person who accepts the
Act shall be on the life of a married there was a statement in the proposal
confidence is called the “trustee”: the
man and the policy shall be purchased form that the object of the policy was
person for whose benefit the confidence
“for the maintenance of the family”. It
by him. That means a married man is accepted is called the “beneficiary”:
was held: Although, where the intention
purchasing a policy on his spouse’s the subject-matter of the trust is called
already appears that a trust is to be
life or daughter’s life cannot mark that “trust-property” or “trust-money”: the
created, the law does not require that
policy under Section 6(1) of MWP Act. “beneficial interest” or “interest” of
the words used should be identical
Also a policy which a married man got the beneficiary is his right against the
with those occurring in the statute, it is
by way of absolute assignment cannot trustee as owner of the trust-property;
impossible to hold in the present case
be marked under MWP Act for he did and the instrument, if any, by which
that the requirements of Section have
not effect it although legally he becomes the trust is declared is called the
been fulfilled….Section 6 enacts that
the policyholderxvi. “instrument of trust…”xix ‘The subject-
the trust should appear “expressed on
The policy shall be effected for the matter of a trust must be property
the face” of the document, that is to say,
benefit of wife and /or children or any transferable to the beneficiary. It must
that the words used should be plain and
of them, individually or collectively. So not be merely beneficial interest under a
unambiguous. For whatever purpose the
policy beneficiary may be wife alone subsisting trustxx. The Trusts Act deals
policy may be governed by the terms
or any child or all children or wife and with all aspects of trusts, their creation,
of the application that preceded it, for
children. Beneficiaries may be named rights and duties of various parties to
the purpose of the Married Women’s
in the policy or they may be named as the trusts etc.
Property Act the only document that can
a class. If beneficiaries are children, be looked into is the policyxviii.” In other It may well be asked whether a
A and B, the policy money will go for words even if the proposer has stated nomination u/s 39 of the Insurance Act,
their benefit. Assume that a third child, his intention in the proposal form he 1938 creates a trust for the benefit of

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 25


PROTECTING MONEY THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

wife (nominee). The Allahabad High Laws (Amendment) Act 2015 has policies to be covered under Section
Court in Shanti Devi v Shri Ram Lal become very vital in nomination vis-à- 6(1) of the MWP Act provides the
observedxxi ‘It seems to us clear that vis operation of Section 6 of MWP Act customer with the necessary forms
Section 39 of the Insurance Act and to which all insurance professionals that helps the policyholder in setting
Section 6(1) of the Married Women’s shall give their attention to. “The up the trust formally and in appointing
Property Act are not complimentary provisions of this section shall not trustees and in defining trust rules. This
and the right of nomination which is apply to any policy of life insurance customer orientation in selling must
bestowed on a policyholder under
to which section 6 of the Married continue till the end of the policy.
Section 39 of the Insurance Act cannot
Women’s Property Act, 1874, applies
be read into Section 6(1) of the MWP Questions on the revocation of a
or has at any time applied: Provided
Act so as to vary the clear intention trust created, if appropriate situation
that where a nomination made whether
of the latter Act’. On the question of develops, by a policyholder may be
before or after the commencement
transfer of property through nomination lurking in his mind. Law on the subject
of the Insurance Laws (Amendment)
(section 39, Insurance Act), assignment answers it thus: ‘A trust created by
Act, 2015, in favour of the wife of the
(Section 38, Insurance Act) and trust will may be revoked at the pleasure of
person who has insured his life or of
(Section 6(1) MWP Act) the Law the testator. A trust otherwise created
his wife and children or any of them is
Commission has given this observation: can be revoked only- (a) where all
expressed, whether or not on the face
the beneficiaries are competent to
‘On a careful consideration of all of the policy, as being made under
contract-by their consent; (b) where
aspects of the matter, we have come to this section, the said section 6 shall
the trust has been declared by a non-
the conclusion that while the present be deemed not to apply or not to have
testamentary instrument or by word
statutory scheme as contained in the
applied to the policy’xxiii.
various provisions mentioned above, of mouth-in exercise of a power of

may be complex, the complexity is The trust created by Section 6(1) is a revocation expressly reserved to the

primarily due to legislative anxiety to statutory trust. Simple understanding author of the trust; or (c) where the
provide for the variety of results which of the trust created is that the trust trust is for the payment of the debts
in actual life, persons taking out life moneys must be out of control of the of the author of the trust, and has not
insurance may desire to achieve. The policyholder, it must be earmarked for been communicated to the creditors at
insured may wish merely to avoid a the benefit of beneficiaries only and the pleasure of the author of the trust.
controversy as between his heirs and this will be ensured by the trustees. Illustration: A conveys property to B in
the insurer, without more. For him, Life insurance companies while selling trust to sell the same and pay out of the
nomination is a suitable choice. He
may desire to go further, and decide to
transfer all rights under the policy. He
can then resort to assignment. Or he
may prefer the less elaborate machinery
of Section 6, if he wishes to create a
trust governed by the legislation. The
statutory provisions are, thus as varied
as the intentions of the insured. Hence
the apparent complexity’xxii

The amendment to the Section 39


by substituting the new Section and
introducing sub-section 12 with a
proviso thereto through the Insurance

26 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA PROTECTING MONEY
proceeds the claims of A’s creditors. rights and protection cannot emanate
A reserves no power of revocation. from an illegal act.
If no communication has been made
to the creditors, A may revoke the V. Conclusion
trust. But if the creditors are parties to These situations make one need
the arrangement, the trust cannot be more of life insurance cover and
revoked without their consentxxiv. protection for the cover itself. For
life insurance professionals this
It may happen many a time that trustees
is a situation of opportunities
appointed by a policyholder may not be
if they are equipped with
able to act when the time comes – may
knowledge, which is a sine qua
be due to reasons beyond their control
non for service excellence.
like feebleness in old age, illness,
inability to arrive at rational decisions, Economic development and growth
trustee moved to another country to live automatically enhances insurance
that brings in two types of problems,
with sons and daughters, trustee is in business – life, nonlife, health, deposit,
viz., stoppage of income to the family
jail, death of the trustee etc. Anticipating agriculture, export, reinsurance etc. in
(hence need for an alternate source of
all such situations the policyholder or an economy. As incomes and wealth
income) and probability of assets being
rather creator of trust must retain the grow people desire to protect sources
taken away or attached for repayment
power to appoint alternate trustees in of income (individuals who are cause
case the existing trustees are unable to of liabilities (hence need for protecting
of the income). Individuals tend to
act. In the enthusiasm of new business take more and more bank credit for assets for the family from the demands
selling marketing officials and salesmen industrial, agricultural, trade and export of creditors). These situations make
of life insurers should take special care and housing purposes. Rise in credit one need more of life insurance cover
of this. and liabilities promotes the tendency to and protection for the cover itself. For

If policy is purchased and attempted to protect income from sudden withdrawal life insurance professionals this is a
be covered under Section 6 of the MWP of earning individuals from the scene. situation of opportunities if they are
Act as part of fraud played on creditors Sudden withdrawal from scene is in the equipped with knowledge, which is a
Section 6 becomes ineffective. Legal form of death, an irreplaceable situation sine qua non for service excellence.

Reference xv 66th Report of the Law xviii Para 8.24 66th Report of the Law
i Manu Smriti 8.408 Commission of India, Para 8.5 Commission of India Pp46
ii Manu Smriti 8.409 Pp36-37 xix Section 3, Indian Trusts Act, 1882
iii Section 2 of MWP Act xiii Sadiq Ali v Zahida Begum AIR xx Section 8, ibid
1939 All744 xxi S
 hanti Devi v Shri Ram Lal AIR
iv Para 1.7A, 66 Report of the Law
th

Commission of India. xiv Section 38(10), The Insurance 1958 All 569 (quoted by Law
Act, 1938 Commission)
v Section 4, MWP Act, 1874
xv 66th Report of the Law xxii 6 6th Report of the Law
vi Section 5, ibid
Commission of India, Para 8.17 Commission of India, Para 8.42,
vii Para 4.2., 66 th Report of the Law Page 42 Pp53
Commission of India,Pp27
xvi Section 2(2), Insurance Act, 1938 xxiii Section 39(12) The Insurance Act,
viii Section 7, ibid
xvii  Krishnamurthy v Anjayya AIR1936 1938
ix Section 8, ibid Mad 635 quoted by the Law xxiv Section 78, Indian Trusts Act,
x Section 9, ibid Commission of India in its 66th 1882.
xi Section 10, ibid Report

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 27


ACHIEVING EXCELLENCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Using Blockchain Smart Contracts to Drive


Service Excellence in Insurance Sector

The biggest challenge that is being it is not only very secure but also
faced by the insurance industry is to has the ability to provide efficient
engage new customers i.e. shifting and intangible technological benefits.
their target audience from traditional Its application is not just limited to
customers to newer segments. The public crypto currencies rather it can
millenniums or the generation Y be used to perform a wide variety
happen to be one of the most desired of other complex operations. This is
Monica Mittal segments and the best way to capture how the concept of smart contracts
Assistant Professor  this segment is by incorporating has emerged. Smart contract are
Birla Institute of Management mobile and digital technologies. computer programs where the terms
Technology (BIMTECH) Insurance companies have realised of the contract are computer coded
Plot Number 5, Knowledge Park 2, that to entice this segment their focus and have the ability to self-execute
NCR,  Gr. Noida - 201306. should be on driving service excellence and enforce itself when an encoded
monika.jain@bimtech.ac.in by incorporating newer technologies condition is satisfied. The entire
that are capable of providing faster process is automated and can work
Anina Bhattacharjee and flawless service to the customers. as a substitute for conventional legal
Student (PGDM-IBM), 2nd year student The blockchain technology is one contracts. The smart contract operates
Birla Institute of Management such medium which is capable of on the concept of If- Then, whereby
Technology (BIMTECH) performing wide variety of operations. the terms of the smart contract are
Plot Number 5, Knowledge Park 2, Its application in the public crypto recorded in a computer language as
NCR,  Gr. Noida - 201306. currencies has shown the world that a set of instructions. Such a concept

28 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA ACHIEVING EXCELLENCE
will reduce the need of an intermediary the customer satisfaction levels and Based on the following
while doing business. According to a see how blockchain technology can
report by (Goldman & Sachs, 2016) be utilised to improve the overall capabilities we can see
it has been estimated that consistent process thereby improving customer
that blockchain in an
use of blockchain in KYC/AML checks satisfaction.
alone could save $2.5bn of the
Defining Blockchain organization will be
estimated $10bn global processing
costs in the sector. Apart from that Before starting to explain the very useful to create a
a report published by (Mainelli & applications of the blockchain let
us first understand what blockchain
successful audit trail
Manson, July 2016) they could identify
the key segments where the concept technology is? It is basically a that is tamperproof and
of smart contract can find practical Mutually Distributed Ledger and
use. According to the report the key technically speaking is a computer which can be reviewed
data structure capable of storing large
performance areas are:
chunk of data in a secured way. Block
externally. Apart from
• Placement and contract lifecycle:
documentation.
chain has the following capabilities: that the success of public
• Block-chain is shared across many
• Claims management. crypto-currencies has
organizations. However no single
• KYC/AML. organisation owns it. shown that blockchain
The objective of this paper is to • Blockchain data is not restricted to technology can be
explore in detail how smart contracts one single location as it a multi-
can be incorporated to improve the locational data structure. Thus highly secured and well
performance in the above mentioned users can store copies locally
areas. which provide greater robustness
equipped to handle huge
Literature Review and security. chunks of data quite
• Once a transactional detail is
(Mainelli & Manson, July 2016) In efficiently. Thus for an
entered into the block-chain it
their paper titled Chain Reaction:
How Blockchain technology might
cannot be erased moreover the insurance company which
availability of local copies across
transform the wholesale insurance
several locations helps in proving is entirely data driven it
market, talked about how blockchain
the integrity of the ledger.
enabled solutions can be helpful becomes very important
in providing efficient and secured Based on the following capabilities
services to the customers. The we can see that blockchain in an
to leverage the power of
paper also touched upon the various organization will be very useful to blockchain technology.
use cases whereby the blockchain create a successful audit trail that
technology can be utilised. The is tamperproof and which can be Blockchain smart contract is one of
biggest issues highlighted in the paper reviewed externally. Apart from the ways by which the amazing power
were KYC/AML, problems in claim that the success of public crypto- of blockchain can be leveraged. Smart
processing and proper documentation. currencies has shown that blockchain contracts are basically computer
It could be understood that these technology can be highly secured and
programs where the terms of the
problems had direct impact on the TAT well equipped to handle huge chunks
contract are encoded as triggers.
(Turn Around Time) of the process of data quite efficiently. Thus for an
The contract gets executed when one
and the companies had to bear extra insurance company which is entirely
expenses also. In the following paper data driven it becomes very important of the conditions is triggered. The
we are going to explore some of the to leverage the power of blockchain entire process is automated and the
use cases which can directly impact technology. contracts are self-executing in nature.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 29


ACHIEVING EXCELLENCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Key Areas where Blockchain that the documents can be accessed transaction might involve a great many
Smart Contract can be Used by multiple participants and as the participants. In such cases performing
blockchain system is very secure KYC/AML on multiple partners
1. To Properly Document
hence there is no fear of damage to becomes a cumbersome task. It is
Placement and Contract Lifecycle
the files due to accidental change or expensive as well as time consuming
In order to obtain a quote from an corruption. The added advantage of activity which is responsible for the
underwriter a broker must submit a this concept is that the files stored delay of the overall process.
“head of terms” of the overall contract in blockchain can be accessed by
One solution is to use an external
along with some supplementary the regulators and Tax authorities,
agency which is specifically entrusted
documents that is submitted in both which will greatly simplify the overall
process of reporting and checking the with the task of KYC/AML. Such an
paper and electronic format. These
documents describe the risk of the documents. agency can utilize blockchain to store
insured and thus are highly detailed. the information of all the clients and
2. Claims Management as blockchain is immutable hence data
The issue with the Insurance Contracts
Whenever a claim is made on a policy once entered cannot be changed. Thus
is that it comprises of large number
the underwriters, insured, insurer and there is no need for validation of the
of files both in electronic and paper
all the concerned parties generally client over and over again. This will
format. Moreover new files get added
want to be kept abreast of the save precious time and effort on the
to the original file throughout the
proceedings. There might be multiple part of companies and thus will help in
lifetime of the contract. The problem
underwriters who are busy pursuing servicing the client faster.
is that there is a heavy processing
their own process and this might
overhead as many personals can Conclusion
generate extra overhead expense.
check these files at various stages
Blockchain technology can be used The need of the hour is to drive
of the contracts lifecycle. Apart from
here to create a chain of all the customer satisfaction by utilizing
that there is operational inefficiency
documents created in the claim technology enabled solution that can
that is associated with preparation
process and which is available to all give faster, efficient as well as secured
of any paper document; even files in
the underwriters apart from client service to the customers. By utilizing
electronic format fall short when it
comes to create a tamperproof and broker and claims brokers. This will blockchain smart contract the various
accurate audit report which shows the reduce the administrative cost and problems in insurance industry that
exact documents and versions that are fasten the overall process. affect the service rendering capabilities
of the industry can be addressed.
included. Moreover the presence of 3. Know Your Customer (KYC)/
This technology is not only secured
multiple personals that have access to Anti-Money Laundering (AML)
the files also increases the chance of but also robust and can work with
Brokers, insurers as well as reinsurers huge chunk of data. Thus blockchain
the file getting corrupted or changed.
have to perform KYC/AML on all the
smart contracts are totally going to
Blockchain smart contracts can be parties which can be legal entities
revolutionise the insurance industry in
very helpful to solve this problem as or individual. More than often one
the years to come.
by storing all the important documents broker can be associated with
in a distributed ledger we can ensure multiple underwriters and a single
Bibliography
1. Goldman, & Sachs. (2016). Profiles
in Innovation blockchain. Goldman
Sachs.
2. Mainelli, M., & Manson, B.
(July 2016). Chain Reaction: How
Blockchain Technology might
transform wholesale insurance. Z/Yen
Group.

30 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA CORPORATE GOVERNANCE

New Corporate Governance Rules will Improve


Service Excellence in Insurance

Insurance business is the art of selling it’s solved as quickly and painlessly
promise and providing financial security. as possible. If senior managers start
Consumers, too, have recognized the taking an interest in tracking complaints
need for such products, especially in and how they’re fixed – this should be
urban cities where the impact of risk fairly easy to do. While attracting new
is more pronounced. The strategy of customers is as important as ever,
an insurance company requires that a smart executives are also examining
bold, new culture of service excellence their internal operations, looking for
be embraced across all aspects of its ways to lower servicing costs and
operations. If successful, the culture deepen customer relationships. In
would increase customer loyalty and today’s challenging environment,
allow the Company to advance its insurance executives are searching
market share over its competitors. hard for ways to grow the top line and
User experience and customer improve profits. Some use reduced
experience are inextricably linked and prices to lure valuable customers
while UX is a vital component of CX; from competitors. Others attempt to
it’s not the only factor that leads to convince a skeptical generation to buy
long-term satisfaction with a brand and their first policy. And everyone is trying
its products. There are many ways to to hang onto the business they already
deliver better customer experiences but have. While revenue growth seems
Jagendra Kumar
a few keys will help shape a memorable elusive, some insurance leaders are
Pearl Insurance Brokers
and valuable customer experience into directing their focus to the loss and
71/143, “Ramashram”
the future for a long time to come. expense side of the profit equation.
Paramhans Marg,
The best businesses take ownership But slashing operating costs is easier
Mansarovar,
of the customer experience across said than done, especially when today’s
Jaipur - 302020. the board; it doesn’t matter where a customers demand quality service
kumarjagendra23@gmail.com complaint originates – it matters that anytime, anywhere.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 31


CORPORATE GOVERNANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

The Indian insurance sector is What is Service Excellence? So, what is service
conceivably as longstanding as the
banking industry, but it has seen a
So, what is service excellence? excellence? Exceptional
Exceptional client service is about going
sea change in business expansion client service is about
beyond what is realistically expected.
and disclosure standards over the
past 10-15 years. The Insurance It’s about surprising – and often going beyond what is
Regulatory and Development Authority delighting the clients, turning them
into enthusiastic referral sources who realistically expected.
of India (IRDAI), which was instituted
in 2000, opened the insurance sector will stick with you not only because It’s about surprising –
to private enterprises allowing Indian you do great work, but because of
companies to partner with foreign the value you bring. Unfortunately, and often delighting the
establishments. This has redefined the many insurance companies believe clients, turning them
insurance sector, allowing common that delivering exceptional service
people to have adequate financial will cost them too much in staff time, into enthusiastic referral
cover at reasonable cost. A developed training or developing service standards sources who will stick
and evolved insurance sector is a and procedures. These in-focused
catalyst for economic development of organizations are only concerned with you not only because
a country. It provides long-term funds with company profit and cutting you do great work, but
for various developmental activities costs, and give little thought to how
and simultaneously strengthens the to keep clients happy. Realistically, because of the value you
risk-taking ability of the country. bad service is actually more costly bring.
Indian insurance sector consists of 57 to an insurance firm than the time
perspective, it’s the little promises
companies, out of which 24 are life taken to provide great service. Poor
insurance, 31 general insurance, and you keep that matter most. Returning
service influences more than just a
two are re-insurance companies. The a phone call, providing information
negative customer experience – it
public listing initiative by insurance or simply getting to know them on a
reduces revenue and drives up costs. It
companies has gained tremendous damages public perception, credibility personal basis can significantly impact
momentum this year, with growth and market reputation. As we all the relationship. Providing great
potential in the sector and acceptability know, a dis-satisfied client is more service is really about consistency,
among institutional and retail investors. likely to spread the word about a poor and realistically, that’s not too difficult
This signifies increasing traction in the service experience than a positive one. for an insurance company to achieve.
sector on the IPO front. Listing is also Nowadays, unhappy clients will take For leaders, it is vital to communicate
a step towards improving disclosure to social media platforms to broadcast clearly to their employees the service
standards and their periodicity, which their disappointment. From a client’s behaviours that are expected with both
will make businesses answerable to
investors and society in general. Till a
decade ago, there was little transparency
in terms of policy details, claims and
surrender rates. The insurance regulator
changed the landscape by bringing in
more disclosures. Price competition
is accelerating as customers turn to
Internet data aggregators to shop for the
best deal on many types of insurance.
Insurers that define and implement
solutions to these challenges are those
that will successfully compete and thrive
into the future.

32 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
internal and external clients. Explain independent directors, corporate social The revised guidelines
to the team why service excellence responsibility obligations, etc. The
matters, not only for the company guidelines have closely aligned the
combine the stipulations
or client, but also for the personal stipulations for insurance companies regarding the Corporate
satisfaction experienced in making with the provisions of the Companies
Governance practices,
others feel valued. Act, 2013. The appointment and
reporting of the Key Management appointment of MD/
Corporate Governance
Framework
Persons (KMPs) and members of the CEO/WTD and other Key
Board of directors has been integrated
The Insurance Regulatory & into the Corporate Governance Management Persons
Development Authority, after Guidelines. Insurance companies (KMPs) as well as the
interactions with all the stakeholders, need to ensure proper procedure of
issued the revised Corporate recommendation by the Nomination
appointment of statutory
Governance Guidelines for insurance and Remuneration Committee for the auditors of insurers.
companies on 18th May, 2016. appointment of KMPs by the Board
The revised guidelines combine the
The guidelines require
and would need to maintain proper
stipulations regarding the Corporate records of due diligence in respect of all insurers to furnish a
Governance practices, appointment such appointments. The guidelines checklist to the Authority
of MD/CEO/WTD and other Key also provide for various kinds of
Management Persons (KMPs) as well disclosures in the Annual Reports by
on an annual basis
indicating the compliance
Audit Committee
position with regard to
Investment Committee
Nomination and
remuneration Commitl BOARD OF DIRECTORS corporate governance
• Constitution procedure Risk Management Committee
includes independent
director and women
stipulations.
Policyholder’s protection
Committee director. CSR Committee
• Conduct of meeting and compensation policy and the
as per ICSI secretariat
payment of incentives should be under
a Board approved policy and should
• Outsourcing policy be uniformly implemented across the
• whistle blowing policy
• Disclosure policy organization. The following pictorial
• Evaluation of Directors
• Keeping control function independent of business gives an overall picture of the corporate
• Role of external audit & actuary defined
• Role of CEO and other senior management defined
governance in action as envisaged by
IRDAI policy:

Ease of Doing Business


as the appointment of statutory auditors insurance companies. The guidelines
of insurers. The guidelines require all seek to benchmark the governance By offering a transparent, easy
insurers to furnish a checklist to the standards and practices as well as experience where customers can
Authority on an annual basis indicating the disclosure requirements of the interact with your business in the
the compliance position with regard insurance companies with that of way they have grown accustomed
to corporate governance stipulations. listed entities. The Authority has to, insurers will gain a competitive
These are applicable from FY 2016- also issued guidelines regarding the advantage that will increase market
17 onwards. Considering the peculiar remuneration of the MD & CEO and share, profitability and reduce costs.
nature of the insurance industry, the Non-Executive Directors. The Those carriers willing to adapt to
the guidelines incorporate special guidance mainly relates to the various these customer expectations should
provisions relating to the Committees components of the remuneration, both be well rewarded for their efforts with
of the Board, the qualifications and fixed and variable, and the manner of all their customers, especially in this
experience criteria for auditors, payment of the same. The remuneration increasingly lucrative market segment.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 33


CORPORATE GOVERNANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

investments. With focus on four key


components – workflow automation,
electronic content management, system
integration, and information channel
management – The New Business
Excellence offering helps insurers
innovate around processes automation.
This, in turn, helps generate increased
capacity within underwriting function.
It helps you systematically analyze your
needs and recommend build, buy, or
reuse solutions for your existing new
The customer-facing insurance Robust Performance business system. Now, becoming an
expert sits at the nexus of trends Management intermediary and then retaining one’s
in hiring, customer expectations, license has become more difficult.
This market also presents a need
digital reinvention and integration of So distribution channels have begun
for greater financial, operational and
mobile, social, analytics and cloud to shrink. But customers do benefit
technical investment. A differentiated
technologies. The implications are because better qualified, trained and
operational strategy backed by
wide and can be seen already in long-term operators sell insurance to
a dedicated organization, skilled
other industries, where they are them.
manpower and robust performance
more likely to make the difference Customer Service-A Critical
management systems is critical for
and help more customers. Real-time Differentiator
insurers to succeed. To fulfil the new
continuous quality assurance, with the
strategy, every employee needs to be Customer service is emerging as a
flexibility to enable specific processes, trained to understand what service critical differentiator for insurance
individuals or transaction types should excellence means to his or her role – as businesses. The ability to have more
be monitored in more detail.  This is well as have the skills to fulfil it. Using effective customer interactions is hard
effectively a risk-based approach to an innovative IP conferencing and to replicate and can produce lasting
quality assurance, enabling managers virtual classroom system, the company competitive advantage. Although
to focus more on higher exposure should deliver a global communication customer service is clearly very
transactions and use the learning’s and education program that can important for winning new customers
from these to refine both processes and embrace every employee. Businesses and retaining existing ones, insurance
work distribution. Beyond just a safety can assess their service proficiency in companies struggle to achieve
net, insurance is an enabler for such comparison to that of their peers by acceptable customer satisfaction
consumers, allowing them to take risks “eating their own service dog food.” levels in their call centres. Cutting
and invest in business opportunities An effective method is the “mystery corners in service is no longer an
without worries of losing their earnings shopping” approaches, where analysts option. Before insurance companies
to an unforeseen event. Insurance for pose as buyers and seek customer strategize in customer service, they
such emerging consumers is growing service from your business. They can need to know the role of service in their
in global importance as various entities assess the speed, quality, consistency, company’s positioning and competitive
from state-backed public sectors and continuity of service across differentiation. Is their company
and mutual companies to large-scale interaction channels—online, social, emphasizing service excellence in its
commercial insurers focus on this and phone, for example. They can then annual reports, sales presentations,
market. These three challenges can be determine your market standing in and employee communications? Once
mapped to the following external and service by repeating the same exercise they have this understanding, they
internal success factors that will play with your competitors. This approach could use a simplified framework like
an important role in developing this can help make a compelling business the following, which includes four
market. case to your Company for service scenarios, to formulate a service

34 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
strategy aligned with your strategic to address the complaints. Rejection of low without negatively impacting
intent for service and the competitive the claims on purely technical grounds customer service. This tough task
service parity in the market space. in a mechanical manner will result in a includes employing techniques that
Optimizing how a customer service “loss of confidence” of policy-holders minimize contact center costs, such as
query is routed and processed is in insurance industry. If the reason for decreasing call volume and handling
critical to service excellence. A great delay in making a claim is satisfactorily times, and reducing workforce and
way to uncover process gaps is to explained, such a claim cannot be overhead expenses.
staple yourself to a customer service rejected on the ground of delay. It is
New Ways to Interact
query, along the lines of the grievance also necessary to state that it would
redressal mechanism to identify gaps not be fair and reasonable to reject We are living in a world, which is
in the customer order management genuine claims which had already been getting digitized at a fast pace. In the
cycle. Lack of customer interaction verified and found to be correct by the financial world, too, digitization has
is one of many factors that limit Investigator. The Consumer Protection been embraced in a big way leading
selling opportunities in the insurance Act aims at providing better protection to considerable savings in operational
industry. Consumers are increasingly of the interest of consumers. It is a and transactional costs. The technology
bypassing distributors and using the beneficial legislation that deserves allows easy education of employees
Web to research products and prices. liberal construction. This laudable all over the world, without requiring
Insurance sales occur mainly by object should not be forgotten while anyone to travel. So the convergence
product silos, further limiting cross-sell considering the claims made under the of social, mobile, digital, analytics
and up-sell opportunities and making it Act. The complaints can relate to any and self-service smarter commerce
difficult to differentiate products. But, grievance against the insurer, including technologies offer new ways to interact
to capture the full lifetime value of the those on claims and dispute with regard and convince this desirable segment
customer, insurance companies should to: premium paid or payable, legal and others of becoming new buyers.
anticipate the needs of the customer construction of the policy wordings, The value of these technologies to
as they move through life stages and delays in settlement of claims and non- insurance is fairly well accepted, but
strive to understand which channels issuance of any insurance document where to start is often a more near-
their customers feel most comfortable to customers after receipt of premium. term challenge. The technologies have
interacting with. There is a big opportunity for the implications for how insurance will
operate, as well as who might be the
unexpected emerging competitors
within the insurance industry of the
near future. However, the perspectives
might just hurry past a critical link in
the value chain, which is the value of
the actual client-facing person using
any new technology to serve – often
the weakest link in deployment plans
- when focus tends toward achieving
value from the capital expenditure.
Yet the customer still deals with a
person in many transactions with
insurance, so customer facing people
industry to step up its claim handling. offer actual differentiation potential
Building Confidence of The industry bodies should set up a – the agent, the broker or even the
Policyholders neutral, professionally run grievance call-centre person that deals directly
There could be several grievances that handling cell rather than depend upon with the customer can make or break
an insurance consumer has with the the ombudsman or regulator. Insurance a current or future sale. So why do
insurer. And there is a system in place companies are trying to keep costs most discussions of these technologies

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 35


CORPORATE GOVERNANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

focus on the automation, self-service frequent communications leading may include multiple contacts with
and disaggregation effect with agents up to the renewal event, and that customers, service providers and other
and service people, rather than the number of products sold per third parties. Today, customers are
empowering them and increasing their customer also increases. Within getting more sophisticated and more
value? The point is the vigilant focus the life insurance industry, advisors demanding. Also, the competitors are
on the shiny new technology sometime really should view their book of upgrading their systems, becoming
underestimates the value of the people clients as their most valuable asset more productive and improving.
skills required to use it and achieve that and develop a plan around taking Insurance companies can implement
value. Very soon, insurance policies good care of them. Most important, cross-sell and up-sell strategies based
would also be available in demat form they need to develop long-lasting on customer relationships, promote
as the IRDAI has already initiated personal relationships by keeping in agent productivity and satisfaction and
the process to this end. The process touch regularly, both in good times strive to transform their operations into
would be successful only if it benefits and in bad. Insurers are leveraging dynamic contact centres that ensure an
the key stakeholders. For insurance various technology-enabled channels, excellent customer experience across
companies, the process assures to be such as mobile phones, to sell these channels and increase customer loyalty.
a paperless transaction and eliminates insurance services, thereby reducing
Matrics that Matter
the cumbersome procedure of printing distributor and operating expenses.
or issuance of duplicate documents, Insurance interactions usually involve Emerging markets are unique in
besides reduction in grievances for multi-step business processes that terms of demographic and economic
non-receipt of policy bonds. Providing segmentation. Countries such as
customers with a seamless experience All insurers are within the India have a more standard income-
across all channels ensures that based segmentation. Insurers need to
interactions are as consistent and
jurisdiction of consumer develop metrics that matter for a great
customer experience; they should be
efficient as possible, which will help fora in terms of Consumer
to build a solid relationship with the able to see how focusing on a specific
customer. Protection Act, 1986. issue will impact not just satisfaction
figures but also the bottom line. The
Need Based Service The government has also budget for customer experience will
The Protection of Policyholders’ put in place grievance never be an unlimited one and that
Interests Regulations are not an end means companies have to be able to
in itself. All the regulations made by redressal portals such as determine their priorities in line with
the Authority keep this objective as the CPGRAMS, DARPG and their customer needs and their business
centre point. Insurers need to define needs. What information would help
their model customers. What services PIMO portal, consumer them identify customers who are at
do they need? How do they want to risk of dropping their coverage or
councils, and dedicated
communicate? Which prospective moving to a competitor? What would
customers do they want to avoid? consumer affairs help them control claims costs or
Align underwriting practices with the offer more competitive pricing to
targets to make sure that company
departments in various prospects? Setting tight objectives for
is offering the applicable coverage government organisations research and analysis will help them
at an appropriate price to the right avoid drowning in interesting, but
customers. Because customers don’t and establishment of the not actionable, information. Insurers
interact with the contact centre on a institution of Insurance and intermediaries are expanding
frequent basis, insurance companies their sales focus down the pyramid
should consider initiating proactive Ombudsman. Then there’s to reach the emerging consumer.
contact to stay in touch with the Depending on the specific market, some
the need to care about
customer. Insurance companies find players are servicing the low-income
that policy renewals increase with customers. customer segment through simple

36 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
insurance offerings and third-party their organizations to support the Transformational
distribution. Nevertheless, the vast business transformations required
majority are conventional insurers to reach emerging consumers and programs are required
targeting the current “top” of the achieve sustainable value. Operational to achieve operational
pyramid. All insurers are within the excellence has its origins in markets
jurisdiction of consumer fora in terms such as the automotive industry where excellence. This is where
of Consumer Protection Act, 1986. price and cost competition have led to investment from insurers
The government has also put in place greater customer-centricity, process
grievance redressal portals such as efficiency and to various process or private equity investors
CPGRAMS, DARPG and PIMO portal, improvement approaches. These can bring true value —
consumer councils, and dedicated are extremely critical in low-margin
consumer affairs departments in businesses. Insurers have used smart not just in the form of
various government organisations cards for enrolments, paperless capital, but also technical
and establishment of the institution of insurance policies and straight-through
Insurance Ombudsman. Then there’s underwriting processes to streamline knowledge and expertise
the need to care about customers. their operations to serve low-income to develop cost-efficient
It’s truly frightening how many senior customers.
executives never, ever come into distribution channels and
Regulatory Environment
contact with a customer unless there’s
There have been scores of regulatory
well-designed products,
a huge complaint. How can they
respond effectively to customer needs guidelines, notifications and orders and to drive organizational
if they don’t talk to customers? The issued by the IRDAI. Each change
people who influence the customer is widely reported in the media and
change for profitability.
experience need to be brought into discussed and debated within the financial products such as insurance
contact with customers and customer industry. The first trend is that insurers have been frequently mis-sold.
data and taught to understand are being forced to focus on the Regulations are now forcing insurers
them. It is important for insurers, customer. The use of the word “forced” and distributors to respect the rights
investors and other stakeholders to is deliberate. Given that financial literacy of customers. There have been over 10
invest in building this framework in in the country is extremely poor, fundamental regulatory interventions
that significantly improve the value
proposition of insurance for the
customers. The second trend has been
to ensure better quality of distribution.
The third trend of the regulations has
been to establish strong financial
practices that ensure solvency of the
insurers. Many surveys indicate that
customers do not trust private sector
companies as much as government-
owned insurance companies. This
does not mean that there have not
been misses in regulations. The most
notable has been the delay in raising
foreign direct investment (FDI) from
26% to 49%. Attracting FDI into the
country can significantly improve
the quality of products and customer

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 37


CORPORATE GOVERNANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

experience.  Though the number of the appropriate operating model to dissatisfied with what insurers do.
insurance companies operating in ensure lean and straight-through Increasing downward pressure on
India has increased significantly, processing of insurance policies. Map costs, combined with more demanding
hundreds of millions of people have the organization and activity of the regulatory requirements and increasing
limited awareness about the benefits target operating model and governance customer awareness – leading to
of insurance protection and/or access structure. However, the more the higher levels of interaction for each
to insurance services. India as a market develops, the more it will customer, has meant that a further
country still faces the challenge of merge structurally with the traditional step-change is needed. Insurance has
‘under-insurance’ in terms of insurance insurance business in emerging
a clear social value for the emerging
penetration and density. To address the markets and be enriched by new
consumer. Low-income consumers
challenge, it is imperative for IRDAI to services and solutions.
need to be insulated from risk since
maintain a delicate balance between the
An effective customer management they lack the accumulated capital to
growth and sustainability of insurance
strategy requires the development of withstand adverse events. Apart from
business with focus on protection of
a customer service ethos within the its advantages as a risk management
interests of the policyholders as the
organisations. Therefore, the approach tool, insurance enables low-income
central point. While technology is an
to customer management identifies consumers to take calculated risks
important enabler for good customer
the elements that need to be blended
management, it should not drive the to emerge from poverty, make wise
together to deliver the service. The
business. investments or assure their families
foremost challenge for insurers in
will be provided for in case of an
Transformational programs are required this market is the lack of systems and
unforeseen event. Insurers need to
to achieve operational excellence. dedicated performance management
develop a customer focused service
This is where investment from tools to track profitability. India’s
culture such that it recognises the
insurers or private equity investors insurable population is anticipated
importance of contact management and
can bring true value — not just in to touch 750 million by 2020, with
the form of capital, but also technical life expectancy reaching 74 years. In this is reflected in its core operational
knowledge and expertise to develop addition, life insurance is projected priority and the behaviour of its
cost-efficient distribution channels to comprise 35% of total savings by personnel.
and well-designed products, and end of this decade, as against 26%
to drive organizational change for in 2009-10. The country is the 15th
profitability. Providing insurance at largest insurance market in the world
References
an affordable price and benefits that in terms of premium volume, and has 1. https://www.ibm.com/blogs/
the end customer values - this places the potential to grow exponentially. insights-on-business/insurance/
high importance on product design. This certainly makes a strong case customer-engagement
Many insurers have used existing for insurance companies to unlock 2. https://www.interaction-design.org/
operating models in innovative ways value and tap stock markets for literature
to reach the low-income consumer. future expansion plans. But in the 3. https://www2.deloitte.com/content/
A large private sector life insurer in insurance industry, this is possible dam/Deloitte/mx/Documents/strategy/
India, for example, created a “top-up” only with excellence in service. This servicios
life insurance product in 2008, offering is often missing because of a lack of 4. http://www.ey.com/Publication/
low-income consumers pay-as-you- investment or simply, a lack of focus vwLUAssets/EY Operational excellence
go options. This eliminated scheduled by senior management. The truly
5. http://www.genesys.com/resources/
premiums for consumers that typically exceptional organizations create a brochures/customer-service-strategies
do not have a steady stream of income. customer experience by anticipating
6. https://customer-service-
Insurance market require holistic its customer’s problems and solving
experience.blogspot.in/
and sustainable solutions which are them before they arise. If customers
customer-driven, end-to-end focused don’t encounter problems, it’s 7. IRDAI Annual Report:2015-16
and support innovation. Determine much harder for them to become 8. Newspapers & Journals.

38 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE Journal
The JOURNAL of
OF Insurance
Insurance InstItute
INSURANCE InsTITuTe
INSTITUTE of
OF IndIa
INDIA
of GOVERNANCE
CORPORATE IndIa
YeejleerÙe yeercee mebmLeeve
"
G-Block, Plot No. C-46, Bandra Kurla Complex,
Mumbai – 400 051.
www.insuranceinstituteofindia.com

request for ‘The Journal’


Complete all the details in Capital letters and return to the address below.

Do you work in the Insurance Industry? If yes, please state the name of the Company

Yes No

Your Details

Email _________________________________________________________________________

Mr/Mrs./Ms./Miss/Other First Name _____________________ Surname ____________________

Designation ____________________________________________________________________

Correspondence Address

Address 1 _____________________________________________________________________

Address 2 _____________________________________________________________________

Address 3 _____________________________________________________________________

City ______________ State _________________ Country ________________ Pin ____________

or
You can subscribe ‘The Journal’ through our website www.insuranceinstituteofindia.com or can send a
mail to journal@iii.org.in.

return the duly filled form at the below address.


Knowledge Management Center, Insurance Institute of India
G-Block, Plot No. C-46, Bandra-Kurla Complex,
"

Mumbai – 400 051.


JANUARY - MARCH - 2018
october-december 2017 3967
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

40 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA INSURANCE SERVICE

Service Excellence in Insurance

Abstract the insurer’s responsibility should be


considered from two angles. Preserving,
This article aims at providing an
protecting and up keeping the interest
outlook of the requirement of service in
and standard of the company on one
the insurance industry and some of the
side and to satisfy the customers in
ways to improve the service excellence
order to cater their changing needs on
in insurance industry. Among the
the other side. At this Point, the role of
various methods, it can be concluded
service excellence comes into picture
that the requirement of technical
and this plays an important role in the
advancement in insurance industry is to
Insurance Industry.
be given the prime consideration.
1
Customer service in this industry is at
Introduction
a turning point and those organizations
In the modern era, insurance industry is that embrace this will be the ones to
Shirmila Sudhakaran one of the sectors which is facing heavy sustain growth.
Senior Associate competition in the market. This is a
While considering the requirement of
Kuwait Insurance Company SAK widespread phenomenon which is being
the customers, the insurer will have to
Karuna, Near Govt LPS, experienced throughout the world. In
think within the ambit of the following:
Eanikkara, Karakulam PO, Insurance Industry, the prime concern
Thiruvananthapuram - 695564. of any insurer should be the satisfaction 1. Maintain and act within the purview
preethapadmadas@yahoo.com of the customer. In this perspective, of the regulatory guidelines

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 41


INSURANCE SERVICE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

2. Up keeping and preserving the 2. Speed and Accuracy used such as media advertisement,
goodwill, reputation and rating of This is essential to retain the existing opening new branches, enhancing and
the company customer as well as the new customers improving the service of the agents,
and to upkeep the excellent service call centers etc. Call center executives
3. A
 menable to the changing and
rendered by an entity. should be able to give a proper answer
emerging trends in Insurance
to the customers. For this, they should
Industry Customers expect the response and
be well educated and trained on the
The following methods will help an /or documentations in their hand
different insurance products and their
insurance company to keep up the immediately after their submission of
response should never leave a room for
excellent service in insurance industry. request or acceptance of the offer as
unsatisfied customer.
the case may be. This must be handled
1. Keeping Good and Healthy carefully with immediate responses 5. Social Media
Relation with the Existing without any delays which help the Social Media is fast growing and the
Customers company to provide excellent services. general public are more active in
Healthy customer relationship is very 3. Importance of Proactive the usage of web services and social
important since the price competitions Contacts and Actions medias. This should be used wisely and
are accelerating so fast in Insurance effectively by the insurance companies
While considering the policy expiry
industry. It is human nature that for getting more closer with the people.
and renewals, the insurers should
most of the people would go for a This can be considered as one of most
act proactively that is at least two
comparatively lesser price and when effective mode of communication at
months prior to the expiry of the policy
there is a difference in the price offered the present age which bring the people
(subject to statutory requirement on
from different companies, naturally more closer. The company should utilize
each country). Each company have to
they may opt for the lowest. In this the web services such as whatsup and
ensure that almost 95% or more of the
scenario, the role of good relationship other applications for communicating
expiring policies are renewed and for
with the customers will trigger. Good with their customers.
the policies which are not renewed,
relation with the existing customers
the reason for non renewal is obtained In this scenario, the role
will help us to convince and educate
from the Customer on a monthly basis.
them more easily for not opting for
At this juncture, while analyzing the of good relationship
cheaper price and thereby ending up
reason for non renewal, the company
with the poor services in return. The with the customers will
will be able to know the stand of each
Insurers have to consider the changing
customer and thereby analyse the trigger. Good relation with
needs of the customers as well and
standard of service which is provided
act in a timely manner. Previous the existing customers
by the company to the customers. For
experience of the customer with an
this, there should be proper tracking will help us to convince
insurance company plays an important
and system generated reports. Also the
role in maintaining the existing
company should always ensure that the
and educate them more
business with that customer and the
customers are kept updated about the easily for not opting for
likelihood and chances of the future
status of their existing policy and the
buying will depend on the previous new implementations in the company.
cheaper price and thereby
experience. Call center executives
4. Procuring New Business ending up with the poor
can play an important role in getting
the feedback from the customers and Business Development is one of the services in return. The
upon the feedback, they can very well main criteria in insurance industry
Insurers have to consider
identify the angry customers and can The Company must use the different
analyze and recommend suggestion possibilities for procuring new business the changing needs of the
for improvements. Not only that, the as well, along with the existing
customers as well and act
challenging calls should be handled business. In order to get the new
carefully. business, different methods are to be in a timely manner.

42 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA INSURANCE SERVICE
6. Online Purchase 7. Maintaining Confidentiality the valuable time. Outdated systems
are to be updated to impart speed
Certain products such as travel As in all other sectors, insurance
service.
insurance, Motor Insurance, industry also should maintain the
Personal Accidents, other life client confidentiality and is to be Souces says that 3 “Digitilisation can
Insurance products should be made careful for not passing on any vital lead to more engagement with the
available through online which is client information outside their customer. PwC research found that
business circle. 68 per cent of consumers would be
just a few clicks away from the
willing to download and use an app
customer. Earlier, the company 8. Impart Training to the
from their insurance provider; two-
used to sell these products by Employees and Conducting
thirds (67 per cent) would be willing
conservative methods such as Meeting
to have a sensor attached to their
through intermediaries like agents, Training of Employees within the car or home, if it meant a reduction
brokers, through direct selling for department and department wise in premiums.”
those who directly approaches meeting are vital factor to excel the
Insurance company. By introducing service. This must be an ongoing Conclusion: In brief, technology plays
many products which can be made bimonthly or quarterly process to an important role in the insurance
available for buying through online, be compulsorily complied with by sector both in imparting excellent
each company. Training is one of service to the customers as well as in
there will be uniqueness in prices
the most important step which is to maintaining the company’s reputation.
and the product features.
be initiated by the companies since The company should ensure the best
While the customers decide to buy to the Customers since the Insurance
this helps to improve the technical
online Products, they will take in knowledge of the employees which industry is a service oriented
to consideration the history of the in turn will help much in upkeeping industry. At this point, the words of
company, the quality of the services the standard of the company. This Albert Einstein that “Strive not to be a
rendered by the company and the will also ensure the improved level of success, but rather to be of value”, is
Price comparison among the various confidence among the employees for to be remembered. Excellent service
insurance companies. dealing with the clients. When new keeps customers cheerful. In order
products are introduced like tailor to maintain a healthy relation, the
2
According to a report by McKinsey,
made policies or comprehensive Insurance companies should act
when it comes to dealing with
covers or new products which with utmost good faith on the one
insurers, customers expect the
are available in the markets, the side whilst the Insured should not
following service: simplicity; 24
employees should be aware of the suppress any material facts known
hour access across every channel;
products. Introduction of new IP to them and should not misrepresent
be able to quickly find relevant portal by international markets are facts. Only when the Insurers and the
information, particularly in relation now becoming very common. For the Insured start having more meaningful
to policy details and premiums; and employees to be user friendly with and closer interactions, better service
innovative services tailored to the this portals and their updates if any, can be expected in the insurance
digital age. they should be given proper training. sector.
2
Today’s consumers expect more 9. Upto Date Data Base and References
than just competitive prices and Sophisticated IT System
1. By Sunil Dhawan May 21, 2016
good quality products. Being In the modern era, books for different Economic times
task-rich and time-poor, today’s portfolios are maintained by the
customers are putting more value in 2. Sourced by Peter Goodman,
insurance industry in the system data
companies that are able to provide founder and CEO of Homelyfe http://
base. Some companies may be still
them with a quick and convenient www.information-age.com
using the outdated systems which
service that fits perfectly into their consumes more time in generating 3. By Clare Gascoine October 12
busy day-to-day lives. policies which will take out most of 2016 https://www.raconteur.net

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 43


CUSTOMER LOYALTY THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Measuring Customer Loyalty with Service Quality


and Customer Satisfaction in Life Insurance

Abstract of policyholders about service quality


and satisfaction. The results of the
Life insurance is a contract between
quantitative assessment of customer
policyholders and an insurance firm.
loyalty may offer some insights on
The purpose of the study is to examine
how customers rate the service and
customers’ loyalty in the insurance
satisfaction of an exacting insurance
industry. The aim is to assess customer firm. Thus, the findings may be used
loyalty of insurance attributes and to as a guide for insurance employees,
determine the factor structure of service legislators and agents to improve the
quality and customer satisfaction. A key quality attributes and enhance
modified SERVQUAL scale was used to customer satisfaction and business
evaluate service quality of perceptions performance to keep customers loyal.
and expectations, including four items
Keywords: loyalty, satisfaction, service
for customer satisfaction and five
quality, life insurance
R. Venkatesan items for customer loyalty from the
Assistant Professor and Head, life insurance policy holders. Data was 1. Introduction
Department of Business Administration, collected for three insurance companies’ Service quality, customer satisfaction,
Shanmuga Industries Arts and Science policyholders (India), using a self- and customer loyalty has lately been
College, Tiruvannamalai - 606601. administered questionnaire. The study emerging as key constraints for both
venkat7pub@gmail.com results indicate rather high expectations researchers and practitioners. Life

44 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA CUSTOMER LOYALTY
insurance is a contract that pledges delivered to retain customer. Moreover, and Zeithaml, 1988) is a widely used
payment of an amount to the person this writing will try to highlight the and accepted gap analysis model.
assured (or his nominee) on the underlying causes behind customer Deng, Lu, Wei, and Zhang (2010)
happening of the event insured against. satisfaction of the insurance companies identify customer satisfaction and
The contract is valid for payment of in India. loyalty through trust, service quality,
an amount on the date of maturity or monetary, functional, emotional and
There are many studies that have
specified dates at periodic intervals or social values. Customer perceived value
focused on analyzing service quality in
unfortunate death, if it occurs earlier is a supplement and not a substitute for
life insurance sector, there have been
. Better service quality is a significant customer satisfaction (Eggert and Ulaga,
few studies that have focused on factors
contributor of customer satisfaction. 2002). Olorunniwo and Hsu (2006)
liable for making loyal customers of
Loyalty makes customer ready for found a need for service managers to
existing policy holders. The current
long-term business relationship. develop approaches and procedures
study addresses this research gap by
Carman (1990) suggests to discuss this focusing on service quality factors, that
incorporating service quality, customer
subject of perception-minus-expectation can lead to enhance satisfaction, which
satisfaction, and customer loyalty into
gap scores and makes several useful in turn can lead to favorable behavioral
one conceptual model.
suggestions that are worthy of intention.
additional research. Satisfied customers This research results can be used as a
Research Framework
maintain continuous business with guide for life insurance agent, insurance
the particular firm and also encourage official and policymakers to improve the
Service Quality
their friends and family members to do key quality trait and enhance customer
business in the existing firm. The firm satisfaction and business performance H1

retains its existing customers through for making the customer loyal. H2 Loyalty

delivery of quality service that the This paper is organized as follows. The H3

customer expects of them. First section, which has been already Satisfaction

Research Objectives: The current discussed, gives an introduction of


Proposed Research Model
research study attempts to find the the study, its objectives, and research
impact of service quality, customer question. The second section considers
Hypotheses: A total of six hypotheses
satisfaction and customer loyalty. The the literature review part of service
were developed to evaluate the
study has several objectives. The first quality, customer satisfaction and
proposed model.
objective is to measure the factors customer loyalty. In section three,
the research frame work is laid out, H10: There is no relationship between
influencing policyholders loyalty in
which deals with questionnaire and service quality and customer loyalty.
life insurance. The second aim is to
establish the number of dimensions of measurement, sample selection, data H1a: There is a relationship between
collection, reliability and validity. The service quality and customer loyalty.
service quality in life insurance, using
fourth section considers the results and
a modified SERVQUAL model. Finally, H20: There is no relationship between
discussion. The fifth and final discusses
the third objective is to evaluate the service quality and customer
the limitations of the study and future
most important factors determining satisfaction.
directions.
policyholder’s satisfaction of the life
H2a: There is a relationship between
insurance firm. 2. Review of Literature
service quality and customer
Research Questions: The following Brown and Swartz (1989) measure satisfaction.
research questions were addressed: service quality through expectation
H30: There is no relationship between
What levels of service provision are and experience with physician
customer satisfaction and customer
needed to retain customers and create services. Service quality is given as the
loyalty.
loyalty? What aspects of service are comparison of service expectations
most important for customer retention? with actual performance perceptions H3a: There is a relationship between
(V. A. Zeithaml, 2000). What level (Bloemer, De Ruyter, and Wetzels, customer satisfaction and customer
of service quality is required to be 1999). SERVQUAL (Berry, Parasuraman, loyalty.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 45


CUSTOMER LOYALTY THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

3. Data and Methodology


A modified SERVQUAL scale was
used to measure service quality of
perceptions and expectation, four
items for customer satisfaction and
five items for customer loyalty are
used to measure the loyalty potential
of life insurance policy holders. Data
was collected from policy holders of
three life insurance companies, using a
self-administered questionnaire.

The dependent variable in this study


was taken as customer loyalty. One
Previous research considered three through using both physical form of
of the key research instruments for
geographical areas of survey as being questionnaire and online questionnaire
measuring quality in service industries
more reliable (Bala, 2011; Rand, was used in this study, in physical
is the servqual model, developed
2004; Siami and Gorji, 2011). The form, 148 responses were obtained.
by (Berry et al., 1988). The model
snowball sampling procedure was One hundred and fifty nine online
contains 22 items for assessing
followed to select the sample. The responses for the questionnaire
customer perceptions and expectations
questionnaires were sent to qualified were collected. The total sample size
regarding the quality of service. A
policyholders via friends and family as 307. Online questionnaire was
level of agreement or disagreement
members through email and other designed using Google docs, and the
with a given item is rated on a seven
electronic channels. Data collection
point Likert-type scale. The level of links were sent to insurance agents,
friends and relatives. To identify the
service quality is represented by the The dependent variable
gap between perceived and expected customers of life insurance company
in this study was policy holders through the referral
service. The servqual model is based
on five service quality dimensions,
taken as customer chain (Biernacki and Waldorf, 1981),
namely Tangible (4), Reliability (5), loyalty. One of the key request for participating in the survey
Responsiveness (4), Assurance (4), research instruments were sent through email and mobile.
Empathy (5), Social Responsibility (5). The collected data were analyzed using
for measuring quality
the SmartPLS 3 (Ringle, Wende, and
Customer loyalty used the five item in service industries Becker, 2015). Descriptive statistical
scale proposed by (Valarie A Zeithaml,
Berry, and Parasuraman, 1996) which
is the servqual model, analysis, exploratory factor analysis

demonstrated a reliability of α = 0.930. developed by (Berry et and confirmatory factor analysis were
carried out in this study.
Customer satisfaction used a four al., 1988). The model
item, scale prescribed by Olorunniwo contains 22 items for The assessment of questionnaire
and Hsu (2006) which demonstrated reliability-internal consistency is
a high reliability of α = 0.938. All
assessing customer
feasible by Cronbach’s α (Cronbach,
multiple-item scales in this study were perceptions and 1951), which is measured as the most
measured on a seven-point Likert-type expectations regarding significant reliability index and is
scale.
the quality of service. based on a number of variables/items
The insurance policy holders A level of agreement or of the questionnaire. In all cases, the
were residents of Tiruvannamalai, values obtained are acceptable, the
disagreement with a given reference value of 0.80 for composite
Villupuram and Vellore1 who held
insurance policies in ICICI life, LIC item is rated on a seven reliability (Hair, Black, Babin, and
and SBI Life2 insurance companies. point Likert-type scale. Anderson, 2010, pp. 649-651).
1. These three districts are progressive area of southern part of India.
2. LIC is public sector and remaining are private insurance company, IRDA annual report 2013 -2014

46 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA CUSTOMER LOYALTY
4. Discussion
The details of demographic profile of the respondents are depicted on Table 1.

Table 1 - Basis Data of the Research Sample (N=307)

Population Characteristics N % Population Characteristics N %


Gender Male 194 63 Geographical Tiruvannamalai 122 39.7
  Female 113 37   Villupuram 93 30.3
Marital Married 186 61   Vellore 92 30
Unmarried 121 39   Profession Salaried 200 65.1
Age (Years) 18 to 25 53 17.3   Own Business 62 20.2
26 to 35 130 42.3   Unemployment 44 14.3
36 to 45 92 30 Life Insurance Company ICICI Life 56 18.1
46 to 55 23 7.5 LIC 144 47.2
Above 56 9 2.9   SBI Life 45 14.7
Education School 12 3.9 More than One 61 20
UG 55 17.9 Income INR = (`) Less than ` 7000 51 16.6
PG 207 67.4 ` 7001 to 103 33.6
` 15000
Technical 28 9.1 ` 15001 to ` 83 27
25000
  Others 5 1.6   ` 25001 to ` 54 17.6
40000
Residential Rural 123 40.1 Above ` 40001 16 5.2
Urban 184 59.9      
The indicators of the measurement this value, thereby assuring reliability variable’s Average Variance Extracted
model must also show reliability; their and validity of the measurement (AVE) is evaluated. Again from Table-2,
standardized loads, according to Hair et instruments. it is found that all of the AVE values are
al. (2010) must have values greater than greater than the acceptable threshold of
Convergent Validity: To check
0.70. In Table 2, it is seen that most 0.5, so convergent validity is confirmed.
convergent validity, each latent
of the loads of the indicators exceed

Table 2: Results Summary for Reflective Outer Models

Latent Variable Indicators Loadings Indicator Cronbach’s Composite AVE


Reliability (i.e., Alpha Reliability
loadings2)
Service Quality P_Tangible 0.929 0.863 0.959 0.968 0.859
P_Reliable 0.952 0.906
P_Responsive 0.916 0.839
P_Assurance 0.950 0.903
P_Emapthy 0.884 0.781

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 47


CUSTOMER LOYALTY THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Latent Variable Indicators Loadings Indicator Cronbach’s Composite AVE


Reliability (i.e., Alpha Reliability
loadings2)
Satisfaction SAT1_1 0.921 0.848 0.929 0.950 0.825
SAT2_1 0.909 0.826
SAT3_1 0.908 0.824
SAT4_1 0.894 0.799
Loyalty LOY1_1 0.910 0.828 0.943 0.957 0.815
LOY2_1 0.900 0.810
LOY3_1 0.915 0.837
LOY4_1 0.909 0.826
LOY5_1 0.879 0.773

Discriminant Validity: Fornell and are larger than 0.2, so there is no Among the factors shown in Table
Larcker (1981) suggest that the square collinearity problem(Kline, 2005). The 4, the perceived service quality and
root of AVE in each latent variable variance of the estimated coefficient satisfaction significantly affect customer
can be used to establish discriminant of P_Assurance (5.845), P_Empathy loyalty.
validity, if this value is larger than other (7.961) and P_Responsibility (9.040) 5. Conclusion
correlation values among the latent is highly correlated with at least one of
variables. The empirical study and the results
the other predictors in the model.
offer important evidence for managers
Table 3: Fornell-Larcker Criterion Model Fit: SRMR is defined as the and agents, specifically, the delivery
Analysis for Checking Discriminant difference between the observed of quality service to the customer;
Validity
customer’s level of satisfaction and
  Loyalty Service Quality Satisfaction achievement of final loyalty. This is
Loyalty 0.903 of importance to the life insurance
Service Quality 0.750 0.927 industry. Service quality and satisfaction
Satisfaction 0.818 0.788 0.908 positively influences customer loyalty of
The latent variable loyalty AVE is seen correlation and the model implied life insurance.
to be 0.815 (from Table-2) and hence correlation matrix. A value less than
6. Limitation and Extension
its square root is 0.903. Similar 0.10 or of 0.08 (Hu and Bentler, 1998)
observation is also made for the is considered a good fit. The present This study is subject to many
latent variables service quality and model SRMR value is 0.035. limitations. First, there are uncertainties
Satisfaction. The result indicates The Chi-square value is 403.35. The in the definition of service quality,
that discriminant validity is well NFI results in values between 0 and customer satisfaction and customer
established. 1. The closer the NFI to 1 is the better loyalty. Second, sample areas are
the fit. NFI values above 0.9 usually restricted to three insurance companies
R Square: The R2 values of 0.25, 0.50
represent acceptable fit. The present out of twenty four and cover only three
and 0.75 represent explanatory power
study NFI value is 0.920 is acceptable districts. Identification of respondents
of the latent variables as low, medium,
good fit. in each category is difficult. Finally,
and significant, respectively. The
Table 4 - Results of Hypotheses Test the study focused on existing policy
present research, R2 value of loyalty is
0.698 and satisfaction is 0.621. Both Hypothesis Path Coefficients Standard T Value P Values Remarks
are significant. Deviation
Collinearity Statistics (VIF): The H1 SQ -> Loy 0.278 0.054 5.135 0.000 support
indicators VIF values are lower H2 SQ -> Sat 0.788 0.026 29.771 0.000 support
than 10 and their tolerance values H3 Sat -> Loy 0.599 0.052 11.540 0.000 support

48 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA CUSTOMER LOYALTY
analysis: A global perspective: New
Jersey: Pearson Prentice Hall.
Hu, Li-tze, & Bentler, Peter M.
(1998). Fit indices in covariance
structure modeling: Sensitivity
to underparameterized model
misspecification. Psychological
methods, 3(4), 424.
Kline, Rex B. (2005). Principles and
Practice of Structural Equation Modeling,
2e éd., New York: Guilford Press.
Olorunniwo, Festus, & Hsu, Maxwell
K. (2006). A typology analysis of
service quality, customer satisfaction
and behavioral intentions in mass
services. Managing Service Quality: An
International Journal, 16(2), 106-123.
Rand, Graham K. (2004). Diagnosis
and Improvement of Service Quality
holders of life insurance only and it is service quality. The Journal of in the Insurance Industries of Greece
not concentrating on lapsed or switched Marketing, 92-98. and Kenya. Lancaster University
policy holders, agents, and insurance Carman, James M. (1990). Consumer Management School Working Paper, 46.
employees. perceptions of service quality: an Ringle, Christian M, Wende, Sven, &
assessment of the SERVQUAL Becker, Jan-Michael. (2015). SmartPLS
7. Reference dimensions. Journal of retailing, 3. Boenningstedt: SmartPLS GmbH,
Bala, HS Sandhu Neetu. (2011). 66(1), 33. http://www. smartpls. com.
Customers’ perception towards service Cronbach, Lee J. (1951). Coefficient Siami, Sahar, & Gorji,
quality of life insurance corporation alpha and the internal structure of tests. Mohammadbagher (2011). Service
of India: A Factor Analytic Approach. psychometrika, 16(3), 297-334. Quality Management in the Insurance
International Journal of Business and Industry on the Basis of Service Gap
Deng, Zhaohua, Lu, Yaobin, Wei,
Social Science, 2(18). Model Australian Journal of Basic and
Kwok Kee, & Zhang, Jinlong. (2010).
Berry, Leonard L, Parasuraman, A, & Understanding customer satisfaction Applied Sciences, 5(11).
Zeithaml, Valarie A. (1988). SERVQUAL: and loyalty: An empirical study of Zeithaml, V. A. (2000). Service Quality,
A multiple-item scale for measuring mobile instant messages in China. Profitability, and the Economic Worth
consumer perceptions of service quality. International journal of information of Customers: What We Know and
Journal of retailing, 64(1), 12-40. management, 30(4), 289-300. What We Need to Learn. Journal of the
Biernacki, Patrick, & Waldorf, Dan. Eggert, Andreas, & Ulaga, Wolfgang. Academy of Marketing Science, 28(1),
(1981). Snowball sampling: Problems (2002). Customer perceived value: 67-85. doi: 7/0092070300281007
and techniques of chain referral a substitute for satisfaction in Zeithaml, Valarie A, Berry, Leonard L,
sampling. Sociological methods & business markets? Journal of Business & Parasuraman, Ananthanarayanan.
research, 10(2), 141-163. & industrial marketing, 17(2/3), (1996). The behavioral consequences
107-118. of service quality. the Journal of
Bloemer, Josee, De Ruyter, KO, &
Wetzels, Martin. (1999). Linking Marketing, 31-46.
Fornell, Claes, & Larcker, David F.
perceived service quality and service (1981). Evaluating structural equation (Endnotes)
loyalty: a multi-dimensional perspective. models with unobservable variables 1
BIMA SAMADHAN education series by
European Journal of Marketing, and measurement error. Journal of
LIC of India advertisement published
33(11/12), 1082-1106. marketing research, 39-50.
on Newspaper Indian Express, Mumbai
Brown, Stephen W, & Swartz, Teresa A. Hair, JF, Black, WC, Babin, BJ, & publication dt on 2.5.15 Saturday
(1989). A gap analysis of professional Anderson, RE. (2010). Multirative data page no.3

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 49


CLAIM SETTLEMENT THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Expeditous Claim Settlement as the Best Market


Differentiator

Underwriting and claims settlement are to improve the operational efficiency


the two most important aspects in the of their claim organisations and build
functioning of an insurance company. an operating model that can minimise
In the present highly competitive and claim costs as well as eliminate the
economically challenging environment, unnecessary expenses associated
claims settlement can serve as a market with claims handling. Implementing
differentiator that puts insurance effective supporting technology to
companies at the forefront of industry improve claims management across
leadership and innovation. Claim the organisation is an important step
is a moment of truth as far as an in this direction. However, supporting
Insurance policy is concerned. It is the technology is only one part of a
culmination of the insurance contract. total claim improvement initiative.
The expectation of the policyholder Often overlooked are the people and
is whenever the claim amount has process components of a more holistic
fallen due; the insurer honours the improvement initiative, something that
Shashi Kant Dahuja claim and makes the payment of the packaged solutions are not necessarily
Head- Motor and Liability Underwriting insured amount at the earliest and positioned to address. Claim has a
Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd. with least possible inconvenience. The different impact on the policyholder/
E-8, EPIP, RIICO Industrial Area, efficiency of claim handling is a test of claimant and the insurer. In case of a
Sitapura, Jaipur - 302022. the customer service orientation of an claimant, the claim amount is the benefit
Shashi.kant@shriramgi.com insurer. To be successful, insurers need whereas for an insurer it is expenditure.

50 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA CLAIM SETTLEMENT
A claimant would expect the payment a dispute. Once a dispute is raised and at enhancing the level of insurance
of the due amount in time without the same is not resolved or explained inclusion as measured by indicators
facing any hardship whereas the insurer with reasons, the policyholder/claimant such as insurance penetration and
would want to pay the claims only after loses trust in the insurer. Thus, there insurance density. Increased incidence
due satisfactory compliance of all the is little possibility that the claimant of mis-selling can adversely impact
requirements for making the payment would take/ renew insurance with the growth in the insurance industry which
in accordance with the policy terms and insurer, thereby affecting new business in turn would impact the availability
conditions. or persistency. Further, the negative of long-term funds for economic
publicity about the unreasonable development from the insurance
Claim Handling is a Critical
rejection of claims also can affect the sector. Hence, while there is a need
Function
potential of sourcing of new business to assess and eradicate mis-selling
Claim best practices look fantastic or renewals by the insurer. On the part from insurance industry, there is also
when they are mapped on whiteboards, of insurer, paying of all claims without a need to reassure the general public
but often fall short when insurers do proper examination can result in a that the regulatory framework of life
not have the ability to execute them. situation where fraudulent claims also insurance business is sound enough
Moreover, each claim settlement get entertained and paid. This would to protect policyholders’ interests
process requires a customised severely impact the financials of the and grievances, if any, are capable of
approach that takes into consideration company putting in jeopardy the very being resolved by insurers or settled/
the specific characteristics of the solvency of the insurance company. adjudicated by insurance ombudsmen
claim. A strong case management Therefore, the claim handling is a critical or consumer fora. Insurers have also
platform helps insurers integrate function of an insurer, which has to be been taking the issue of misspelling
legacy improvement assets into claim carried out with diligence and prudence seriously by doing a root cause analysis
improvement strategies. Insurers can without adversely affecting the customer of mis-selling complaints to identify the
use latest technology to unlock these service.
static tools and achieve functionality Delay in the settlement
Impact of Mis-Selling on
that previously was not possible.
Claims of claims creates undue
The information asymmetry in so far
as the understanding of the insurer The right case management solution hardship to the claimants
and the policyholder/ claimant and can break down claim processes into an who are already reeling
the interpretation of clauses of the infinite number of sub-claim units, each
insurance contract is one of the main of which is able to be routed, managed
under the impact of
reasons for disputes relating to claims. and monitored individually, while still the loss caused to
Delay in the settlement of claims creates providing insight and control. Adjusters
undue hardship to the claimants who and managers can leverage real-time
the subject matter of
are already reeling under the impact of analytics to get comprehensive views insurance. Repudiation
the loss caused to the subject matter of of claim operations any time. They
of claims either fully
insurance. Repudiation of claims either have the ability to view and re-route
fully or partially makes the claimant work as needed, enabling a dynamic or partially makes the
feel that the entire exercise of taking response to complex claims or shifts claimant feel that the
an insurance policy was futile and the in work volume. Insurers can use
premium paid was only an item of this insight to drill down into specific entire exercise of taking
expenditure without any commensurate tasks to understand which processes an insurance policy was
benefit. If the reasons for delay in are working well, and which are not.
settlement of claims and the reasons Complaints on unfair business practices
futile and the premium
for partial or complete repudiation of affect the sentiment about the insurance paid was only an item of
claims are not informed to the claimant sector in general and life insurance
with clarity by the insurer, the claimant sector in particular. This would
expenditure without any
is left with no other option but to raise significantly impact the initiatives aimed commensurate benefit.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 51


CLAIM SETTLEMENT THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

major causes and have taken steps to also take up action against the agents servicing issues. Providing of cashless
prevent or reduce mis-selling through or intermediaries in the form of issuing facility and settlement of reimbursement
steps to ascertain suitability of product, warning letters, terminating employees, claims is facilitated by TPAs. The
place controls on the various channels, filing police complaints and most professionalism in conducting both
tuning it based on the vulnerability of commonly resorting to claw-back of these functions determines the
the channel and have a strategy on commission wherever the policies have smoothness of claim handling by
dealing with complaints of mis-selling. been cancelled as a consequence of insurers.
Insurers are now conducting sales audit proven mis-selling.
Redressal of Claims Related
of the proposals that satisfy certain
Intermediaries in Handling of Grivances
vulnerability criteria like Proposals from
Claims General insurers rely heavily on claim
Senior Citizens, Premium payable not
commensurate to the declared sources Insurers can apply precautionary organisations to maintain high customer
of income etc. to ensure right selling. concepts to track, measure, and report satisfaction, minimise risk and loss
Further, every insurer has a Board on an infinite number of sub-units exposure, as well as delivering strong
approved insurance awareness policy under the primary claim event. This operating results. These are no small
containing the strategy and efforts to drives best practice processes and can tasks, especially when one considers
build awareness among customers. be extended to other lines of business; the unique challenge that a claim
In addition to the action taken by it also gives insurers the flexibility to organisation faces: when customers
IRDAI based on the examination of systematically integrate claim processes need its services, the organisation has
complaints by the insurers, Insurers that are historically segregated or only one chance to deliver. One negative
require manual intervention - a must for experience reaches well beyond a
Claim related complaints insurers trying to contain overall claim complaint to a neighbour nowadays.
costs or bundle new product offerings. Once a claim has been unduly delayed
constitute nearly 43-53% Surveyors and loss assessors in non- or repudiated by the insurer, there is
of general Insurance life and third party administrators in a cause of complaint. The claimant
health insurance are the most important takes up the matter first with the
complaints. This clearly intermediaries who have a significant insurer. All the insurers have put in
shows that claim role in claim handling. Ensuring that place internal mechanism to deal with
these intermediaries function properly such grievances and resolve them. The
handling is a serious is the most critical to the discharge of resolution of claim related complaints
customer service issue claim related functions by insurers. also generally includes review of the
Surveyors and loss assessors are decision on claims by a Committee.
in the general insurance appointed by the insurer for surveying After review, the decision on the
industry, which needs and assessing the loss caused when a claim is conveyed to the complainant.
claim is reported. The report is required Once the complaint is not internally
immediate attention. to be furnished to the insurer. The redressed, the claimant is forced to
There has been a general insurer decides upon the claim and seek adjudication of the dispute. For
may use the report of the surveyors this purpose, he may approach an
reduction of claim related and loss assessors but is not bound insurance ombudsman, consumer
by it. The timeliness in appointment forum or a civil court and later take
complaints life insurance
and conduct of survey and furnishing a it through the appellate channels if
claims and in respect of report, the professionalism displayed in redress is not to his satisfaction. The
their functioning and the quality of the statistics on claim related grievances
general Insurance, there
report determines the speed and quality indicate that in the Non-Life Sector,
is an increase of about of settlement of claims by insurers. In claim related complaints constitute a
case of health insurance, Third Party major proportion to the total complaints
4% compared to the
Administrators are the most important as compared to the life insurance
previous year. intermediaries handling policyholder sector. The data relating to claim

52 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA CLAIM SETTLEMENT
related complaints as obtained from Increasingly, insurers are striving to to address complaints and grievances
the Integrated Grievance Management achieve better operational efficiencies of policyholders efficiently and
System, is as follows while simultaneously maintaining speedily. Regulations 8 and 9 deal
with claims procedure in respect of life
Year No. of Claim % increase / Total % of Claim related
insurance and general insurance policy
complaints decrease compared complaints complaints to total
respectively. IGMS is the regulatory
to last year complaints
framework and institutional arrangement
NON-LIFE COMPLAINTS for processing claims expeditiously and
2013-14 27409 (-) 8.77 63335 43.28 resolving grievances relating to claims.
2014-15 26467 (-) 3.43 60688 43.61 The major claim related complaints as
per IGMS are as follows:
2015-16 26480 0.05 59083 44.82
1. Insurer not disposing of the claim.
2016-17 27637 4.37 52104 53.04
2. Difference between the amount
Source: https://www.irdai.gov.in and IRDAI Annual Reports claimed and the amount settled by the
Insurer
Claim related complaints constitute or improving claimants’ experience. 3. Insurer reduced the quantum of claim
nearly 43-53% of general Insurance While this tenet holds true for most without providing proper reasons.
complaints. This clearly shows that insurers, back-office claim units are
claim handling is a serious customer 4. Insurer failing to offer settlement of
not necessarily equipped with systems
service issue in the general insurance claim after receipt of survey report.
they need to ensure satisfaction. Claim
industry, which needs immediate
management functions have a direct 5. Delay on part of the TPA to arrange
attention. There has been a general
impact on an insurer’s expense and claim Reimbursement
reduction of claim related complaints
combined ratio; they must balance
life insurance claims and in respect of Insurers can eliminate misinterpretation
costs against service carefully and and manual workarounds by using
general Insurance, there is an increase
still deliver every time. More and intent-driven service experience that
of about 4% compared to the previous
more, the strategy to attract and retain dynamically applies best practices at
year. While the volume of complaints
customers includes tactical plans for each interaction. This approach can be
in relation to total number of claims is
tailoring the claimant’s experience. leveraged to anticipate a policyholder’s
very small, the problems faced by the
IRDAI (Protection of Policyholders’ needs, while addressing concerns
complainants cannot be wished away
Interest) Regulations, 2002 constitutes rose via web, phone or email. Imagine
given the inconvenience caused to them.
the regulatory framework for the the power of being able to anticipate
Framework for Expeditious protection of policyholders’ interests. and respond to a claimant’s needs
Claim Disposal In terms of Regulation 5, every before they ask the question (or to
An insurer can now face scrutiny insurer should have in place proper dynamically assign work to a glazier
from an entire social network. procedures and an effective mechanism when the customer provides notice
of loss). Insurers themselves also
take several steps for better claims
handling. The steps include giving the
claim related documents and the list
of documents to be submitted along
with the policy document itself, having
a claim review committee headed by
independent persons of repute from
the industry / judiciary. The monitoring,
supervision and constant interaction
with the intermediaries like surveyors/

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 53


CLAIM SETTLEMENT THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

loss assessors, TPAs etc. also enables emptor’ or ‘buyer beware’ applies to In order to provide a
these intermediaries to perform their insurance as well. However, considering
responsibilities in accordance with
separate forum for dealing
the several terms and conditions in the
regulations issued by IRDAI and the insurance contract which are presented with cases relating to
Code of Conduct specified for them. in highly technical legal terms, literal third party claims in case
Insurers have to strictly follow the application of the principle to largely of motor accidents, the
Turnaround Time (TAT) for claims financially illiterate insured persons
related services as per the Regulations, would shift the balance heavily in the
Motor Accident Claims
which is as follow: insurer’s favour in case of any dispute Tribunals have been
NON-LIFE INSURANCE CLAIMS
set up under the Motor
S.N. CLAIM SERVICE TURN AROUND TIME Vehicles Act. Several
1. Surveyor appointment 72 hours of these Tribunals are
2. Survey report submission 30 days in operation across the
3. Insurer seeking addendum report 15 days
country. The number of
4. Additional report submission 3 weeks
5. Offer of settlement/Rejection of claim after 30 days cases pending before
receiving 1st/addendum survey report these Tribunals is huge
6. Payment after acceptance of offer of settlement 7 days and the time taken for
Source: https://www.irdai.gov.in and IRDAI Annual Reports disposal owing to the
Claims and Litigation in enforcing the obligations under the involved processes is
insurance contract. As the decision to substantial.
The basic principle on which insurance
underwrite a policy is supposed to be
operates is ‘uberrima fides’ i.e. principle ordered is too low, they go for Appeal
taken by the insurer after obtaining all
of utmost good faith. The good faith is to the High Court and where the insurer
information necessary for understanding
applicable equally to insured as well as feels that the compensation ordered
the risk and the policy terms and
the insurer. The insured gives all the is too high, the insurer goes on an
conditions being standard forms drafted
information required in the proposal Appeal leading to increased number of
by the insurer, while interpreting the
form and the insurer has to give the appeals before High Court and if further
clauses of contract, any unclear term
information about the products like appealed against, before the Supreme
is interpreted in favour of the insured
terms, conditions, warranties and Court. The difficulty in resolving
and against the insurer. The interplay
exclusions in documents of offer like disputes about motor accidents arise
of these principles provides reason for
prospectus, brochure, advertisement of the onerous task of assessing the
disputes in insurance.
etc. and also make them part of the value of human life lost in the accident
policy document. The fine print of In order to provide a separate forum and there can always be divergence of
insurance policy and the legalese in the for dealing with cases relating to third views of either party leading to litigation
wording of policy terms and conditions party claims in case of motor accidents, and escalations in the form of appeals.
makes it an unequal bargain from the the Motor Accident Claims Tribunals In addition to these, disputes regarding
customer’s point of view. Since the have been set up under the Motor claims in other non-life insurance
insurer knows only those things about Vehicles Act. Several of these Tribunals policies, which are not on personal
the insured and the risk as is disclosed are in operation across the country. lines, are taken up before Civil Courts,
by him in the proposal, any failure to The number of cases pending before where long time is taken in deciding
disclose renders the position of insurer these Tribunals is huge and the time the matter, owing to the involved
difficult. The insured has chosen to buy taken for disposal owing to the involved processes. Even after decision of the
the insurance product and is presumed processes is substantial. There is no Court is received, there is the option of
to have satisfied himself about the finality to the decisions as cases where Appeal leading to delay in finality of the
product as the principle of ‘caveat the claimants feel that the compensation decision.

54 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA CLAIM SETTLEMENT
created by Government of India under
LIFE NON-LIFE
COURT / FORUM the Redressal of Public Grievances
No.of Cases No. of Cases
Rules, 1998. However, only disputes
District Level 15270 50723 on personal lines of insurance on only
Consumer
State Lever 5088 19684 5 grounds of complaint and where
Forum
National Level 299 2352 compensation sought is less than
` 20 lakhs can be taken up with the
Civil Court 8874 6933
Insurance Ombudsman. Absence of
High Court 156 2770 mechanisms of appeal against Awards
Supreme Court 8 983 or for enforcement of Awards make
the legal recourse the only alternative
MACT NA 889239
for persons or insurers aggrieved
MACT Related State Level NA 180400 by unsatisfactory Awards. In case
National Level NA 557 of commercial lines of insurance,
while resolution through Arbitration
Source: https://www.irdai.gov.in and IRDAI Annual Reports
and Conciliation is provided for, the
Procedural Awareness conditions through simplification of Arbitration Awards do not provide
language can help in interpretational finality leaving room for litigation even
Most claimants are not aware of the
problems in claim handling, avoiding an after arbitration. Further arbitration
claim procedure. A positive approach
important reason for a lot of litigation clause is provided in general for partial
to claim management provides insurers
in claims. Insurers should have repudiation cases of claim and not in
with the flexibility to offer tailored
proper systems in place for quick and cases of denial of claim. The delay in
solutions to their customers and better
proper handling of claims. Providing resolving a case before the District
align customer needs with business
a reasoned and timely decision about Forum and the several years taken in
objectives. This improvement ultimately
the claim can help mitigate the agony disposal of appeals by the State Forums
boosts key performance indicators,
of the claimant in approaching various and National Forum because of the
which will undoubtedly impact operating
channels only to understand why there huge volume of cases pending before
results in a positive way. Insurance
is a delay and what is the reason for these Fora have rendered the recourse
awareness can help persons taking
repudiation of claim in full or in part. to Consumer Fora ineffective in the
insurance to be more aware about
A suitable mechanism at the insurer’s expeditious resolution of insurance
the nuances of insurance, what to
level to ensure that this information related disputes. Therefore, over the
disclose and what to look for in an
would be provided promptly would years, insurance has grown to be not
insurance product, how to understand
reduce the number of complaints only a subject matter of solicitation
the insurance product and comprehend
relating to claims. but also a fertile ground for litigation.
the terms, conditions, exclusions and
A straitjacketed formula is difficult to
warranties in the insurance policy. When Efficiency is much higher in in-house
implement. However, there is sufficient
this meeting of minds of insurer and settlement of claims—cashless or
scope of settlement of disputes at the
the policyholder/claimant about mutual reimbursement. Dealing directly with
earliest to save the financial burden.
rights and obligations is there, disputes the insurer and its direct control over
After all claim settlement is the reason
warranting litigation would not arise. the service level and settlement gives
of existence of insurers and better
In non-life insurance, underwriting customers a much higher comfort
settlement record puts insurance
includes risk assessment. Therefore, level. Disputes in insurance are
companies at the forefront of industry
suggesting the suitable insurance policy basically disputes in contract and have
leadership and innovation.
and also mechanisms of mitigating risks to be taken up with the civil court. To
can be an important service provided by provide adequate scope for settling References
the insurer to the policyholder. Building the disputes through alternate dispute http://www.policyholder.gov.in/
insurance awareness and bringing in resolution mechanisms, the institution https://www.irdai.gov.in and IRDAI
more transparency in policy terms and of Insurance Ombudsmen has been Annual Reports

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 55


PMFBY THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

A Comprehensive Study on Working and Challenges in


the Functioning of Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana

Abstract the structure and working of the


Yojana. The study is an exhaustive
In the wake of reports regarding the
examination of the plan of Government
distress in the agricultural sector
of India to fathom Agrarian Insurance.
Anusha Iyer and the plight of farmers, the need
The findings highlight the potential of
Assistant professor for a structured scheme made the
the yojana to grow in the upcoming
Christ University, Government to initiate the Pradhan
time, provided the challenges are
Main Campus, Hosur Road, Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY)
addressed in a functional manner.
Bengaluru, Karnataka - 560029. concerning almost all aspects of
anusha.iyer@christuniversity.in Agriculture Insurance in Public Private Keywords
Partnership (PPP) Model. This study Agricultural Insurance, Crop Insurance,
Nishtha Dahiya based in Karnataka, India lays focus Farmers, NAIS, Pradhan Mantri Fasal
Research Scholar on understanding the modus operandi Bima Yojana (PMFBY)
Christ University, and the challenges of the said Yojana.
Main Campus, Hosur Road, Considering the nature and intensity
Introduction
Bengaluru, Karnataka - 560029. of the topic, primary method of data India is primarily an agrarian economy,
dahiya.nishtha@gmail.com collection, particularly interview method where a large section of population
has been adapted. Government officials, relies on the income generated
Vatsala Tiwari Insurance company representatives, by agriculture. Agriculture is very
Research Scholar Bank managers and Farmers were vulnerable to dangers like dry seasons
Christ University, interviewed. Department of Agriculture and surges. It is important to shield the
Main Campus, Hosur Road, was one amongst the respondents farmers from characteristic cataclysms
Bengaluru, Karnataka - 560029. contributing to the findings. The paper and guarantee their credit qualification
vatsala1208@gmail.com contributes a framework depicting for all seasons. Prime Minister

56 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA PMFBY
Shri Narendra Modi introduced Pradhan The likelihood of the Government being 1976). (Ramachandran, 1986) in
Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY) on troubled with immense misfortunes his paper discussed about the new
13 January 2016. The nation couldn’t in in a single year is very unlikely. Comprehensive Crop Insurance Scheme
any way shape or form a superior rural Circumstances of extraordinary 1985 based on the range approach and
yield protection plan than the PMFBY. misfortune like the one affecting the covered five crops, rice, wheat, millets,
Rabi crop in Tamil Nadu in 2017 due oilseeds and pulses. The scheme
This plan helps in diminishing the
to a drought, untimely rainfall and holds a drawback as it is confined
weight of premiums on agriculturists
hailstorm are uncommon. It is known to to borrowers of crop advances from
who take credits for their development,
be the most terrible misfortune in 140 co-agent credit social orders, business
thus protecting them against the nasty
years. banks and Regional Rural Banks. (Nair,
climate. It has also been decided to
2010) Further an assessment of National
make the settlement process of the The hazards are spread topographically
Agriculture Insurance Scheme (NAIS)
insurance claim, fast and easy so that and among various yields and seasons,
was carried. The study uncovered the
the farmers do not face any trouble thus misfortune in a particular season
facts that the scheme had done well on
regarding the crop insurance plan. is carried forward. An Insurance
the peripheral level. At the same time
company’s risks are diversified. As a
This scheme is implemented in every there were delays in the settlement
result, an insurance company does not
state of India, in association with of cases which bring forward another
bear huge losses. Nevertheless, for the
respective State Governments. The drawback of agriculture insurance in
smooth functioning and better efficiency
scheme is administered under the our country. On similar grounds (Singh,
of the plan, Center should set rigorous
Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers 2006) threw light on the fact that
criteria for selection of Insurance
Welfare, Government of India. Prior there is a requirement for appropriate
providers with a sound asset report and
to the introduction of the structured coordination by all the players at the
solid reputation of claim settlement.
scheme, the National Agriculture states level. Without including states in
Insurance Scheme (NAIS) and Modified The motivation for this study comes a more dynamic form crop insurance
NAIS (MNAIS) did not serve the from a rising number of farm agitations cannot be executed successfully.
farmers’ needs. The whole protection and the unassessed benefits of the crop Beside the depiction of the states at the
plan under MNAIS, especially for insurance models that the government broad level, there is a necessity for a
dangerous crops and locale, was small. has been coming up with from time to dynamic state level consultative body,
NAIS and MNAIS both put together time. involving state government agents, rural
specialists and illustrative of the lead
safeguarded only 25.4 million in Kharif Literature Review
season in the year 2015 compared to bank of the state together with delegates
(Chand, 2007) Agricultural business and of AIC.
35.5 million safeguarded by PMFBY.
the farm income in India is extremely
According to the Press Information All the study done so far talks about the
and most of the time influenced by
Bureau, the quantity of non-loanee drawbacks of the insurance sector in
catastrophic events, for example,
agriculturists increased by more than addressing the farmer’s needs, however
dry seasons, surges, violent winds,
six times. Nevertheless, these figures no study is done so far to understand
tempests, avalanches and seismic
should be tested further before we the challenges in the functioning of the
tremors. Vulnerability of agriculture
praise the plan’s prosperity. PMFBY. We aim to build this research gap.
to these disasters is exacerbated by
One main characteristic of this Yojana the erupt of epidemics and man-made Objectives of the Study
is that the premiums are paid by State catastrophes, for example, fire, offer The study focuses on two main
and Central Governments. This has dual of spurious seeds, composts and objectives-
advantages; on one side farmers are pesticides, value crashes, and so
benefitted as their losses are covered 1. To understand the modus operandi
forth. A similar thought was put forth
and on the other side, Government of Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima
by Dandekar in the year 1976 as in a
Yojana (PMFBY).
does not have to shed huge amount nation where these events cannot be
of money during times of catastrophic controlled by the farmers and hence a 2. To identify the challenges in the
events. need for insurance was felt. (Dandekar, functioning of the Yojana.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 57


PMFBY THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

India is primarily an Objective 2 achieving each objective (presented


objective wise)
agrarian economy, To identify the challenges in the
functioning of the yojana. Objective 1. To understand the modus
where a large section of
operandi of Pradhan Mantri Fasal
population relies on the A Qualitative approach was used
Bima Yojana (PMFBY).
in the process of understanding
income generated by the execution of the yojana. Face In order to understand the operational
agriculture. Agriculture is to face interviews were conducted structure of the PMFBY, a thorough
very vulnerable to dangers with managers and officers of seven study of the rules, roles, and
like dry seasons and banks, department of agriculture and regulations stated in the operational
insurance companies (both private guidelines of PMFBY was done.
surges. It is important and public-sector companies) in While doing so, we realized that
to shield the farmers the state of Karnataka. In all the certain aspects were not clear from
from characteristic interviews, the interviewer clearly a layman’s perspective and hence
explained the motive of asking
cataclysms and guarantee interviews of various officials from
questions. They were told in advance Banks, Government and Insurance
their credit qualification that these interviews are conducted
Companies were conducted to get a
for all seasons. Prime for research purposes and their
clear picture of the actual procedure
Minister Shri Narendra identity will be kept confidential.
followed in the implementation of the
Modi introduced Pradhan Discussion, Analysis and said Yojana.
Interpretation -
Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana Based on the study and the interviews
(PMFBY) on 13 January Below is the analysis and conducted, a simple framework has
interpretation of the data gathered for been presented below.
2016.
Chart 1: Structural Model of PMFBY
Methodology
A Qualtiative approach has been used
to achieve our objectives. Stated below
Central
are methodologies used for each of the Government
Premium
objectives. Government

State
Objective 1 Government

To understand the modus operandi


of Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana Insurance
Loanee Company
(PMFBY). Farmer Farmer (Insurer)
(Main
For getting a thorough understanding Beneficiary)
of the procedure, which government Non-Loanee
Farmer
has laid down, information has been
gathered from mainly two sources:
Channel Partners, Premium
Premium
• The Operational Guidelines of the Insurance intermediary or directly

Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana.

• Interview of various officials from OR


Banks, Government and Insurance
Premium Premium
Companies to get a clear picture
Banks
of the actual procedure followed
Claim Amount Claim Amount
for the implementation of the said
Yojana.

58 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA PMFBY
Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana is a amount directly to the insurance  Concerned Bank and its branches
government scheme with an objective company whereas in case of farmers should ensure submission to
to provide insurance cover to the the premium amount is paid to the insurance companies within
farmers at a subsidized premium rate, insurance company through Banks, stipulated in prescribed format,
where the premium is paid by two along with consolidated Premium
Insurance intermediary, channel
parties: payable separately for both loanee
partner or directly.
farmers and non-loanee farmers. If
• Firstly, Farmers
As per the guidelines, banks not only Concerned Bank and its branches
S. Season Crops Maximum Insurance keep the amount of premium
charges payable by farmer collected beyond the defined
No. timelines, then they will be liable
(% of Sum Insured)
to pay interest (at prevailing rate
1 Kharif All foodgrain and Oilseeds 2.0% of SI or Actuarial
of interest for saving account) for
crops (all Cereals, Millets, rate, whichever is less
the delay period to the insurance
Pulses and Oilseeds crops)
company.
2 Rabi All foodgrain and Oilseeds 1.5% of SI or Actuarial
 Lending Banks to educate the
crops (all Cereals, Millets, rate, whichever is less
cultivators on the scheme features.
Pulses And Oilseeds crops)
 Banks should ensure that cultivator
3 Kharif and Rabi Annual Commercial/ Annual 5% of SI or Actuarial rate,
should not be deprived of any
Horticultural crops whichever is less
benefit under the Scheme due to
Source: Operational Guidelines of Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana errors/ omissions/ commissions
perform the function of collecting and of the concerned branch, and in
• Secondly by State and Central
debiting the premium amount but also case of such errors, the concerned
Government who share the
institutions shall only make good
remaining amount of premium in caters to below mentioned functions:
all such losses.
equal proportions (50% each).  Communicate Notification, as well
 Soft copy of the beneficiary’
It can be clearly seen in the as other directives, guidelines,
farmers may also be uploaded
above flowchart (Chart 1) that the etc. to all agencies within their
directly on Crop Insurance portal
government pays the premium jurisdictional area.
(Samrakshana Portal) by bank

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 59


PMFBY THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

branch to concerned Insurance making themselves aware, updated One thing that is clear
companies for uploading the same and responsible towards the
through the study is that
in their web-site. In the process of provided information by the banks
settling the claim, the insurance and are often found consulting
the yojana has a potential
company directly debits the bank banks about the claim amount to flourish and grow in
account of the farmers and in this rather than the concerned authority future. With consecutive
entire process no intermediary which may be insurance company/ dry spells, and unseasonal
is involved and hence the farmer agent.
rain and hail in specific
receives the direct benefit.
Government officials also threw stashes, it turned out
Objective 2. To identify the challenges light on the fact that at the time of to be certain that the
in the functioning of the yojana. Crop Cutting Experiments (CCE),
dangers in cultivating are
farmers are least participative
• Non-proactive Attitude of Farmers
because of which a delay in the
on the ascent, and the
As per Insurers and banks, farmers completion of process is seen. current arrangement of
have a spoon-feeding attitude and
This non-participative attitude
harvest protection was no
give an excuse of being illiterate,
of farmers acts as one of the place close to addressing
unaware and less privileged. At
constraints for the intermediaries the requirements of
the time when premium is being
debited to the insurer, banks give
to effectively execute the yojana. the lower class. In this
a computer-generated receipt • Lack of Awareness Among specific situation, the new
containing information regarding Farmers about the Nitty Gritty of plan is without a doubt
the insurance company, contact the Yojana. a positive development
person and amount debited to the
Various initiatives have been taken and convenience, which
farmers.
to create awareness regarding will help in sparing Indian
Despite being provided with all the yojana, in the sense that
agribusiness from the
necessary information, farmers farmers come forward and take the
have a negligent attitude regarding particular policy or have knowledge
expanding dangers of
nature.
about the same. But the flip side
of the coin is that there is lack of
understanding of the functionality
of the yojana as the focus is
more on publicizing about the
introduction of new yojana rather
than the procedure to be adopted
by the farmers.

• Limited Reach of Insurance


Company to the Rural Areas

One of the major challenges faced


by insurance company is that
most of the private players lack
the availability of infrastructural

60 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA PMFBY
facilities in the rural areas,
therefore, a communication gap
exists between the farmers and the
insurer. This concern of limited
reach and lack of infrastructural
facilities is not being considered by
the government also while giving
tenders to the companies as the
tender process is purely based
on the bidding. In the process of
bidding, the company that quotes
the lowest premium rates wins the
tender in that particular state.

• Lack of Training for the Novice

The major functions of the


bank for executing the yojana
revolves around using advance
technologies like the Samrakshana
portal. It was found out that most there is limited availability of staff unclear about the Yojana. There is
of the banks receive training for doing office related works like no proper supervision or control
through video conferencing or by maintaining records and data entry. checks whilst executing the Yojana.
written guidelines or telephonic Also training needs are not getting
The next major challenge faced
conversation from their head met.
by the government is availability
offices, which are not good
of funds with state. It has been 2. In the eyes of a farmer ‘Water’ is
enough in providing the complete
observed that in the past three the most important requirement.
knowledge regarding the usage
crop seasons, the actuals have They believe that any monetary
of the technology (portal) to the
always exceeded the estimates, help or crop protection plan is
novice and hence they find it
thus, making it difficult for insignificant compared to solving
difficult to operate. Also, these
the government to meet the the problem of basic necessity
training were not mandatory for all
requirement of timely and full such as ‘Water’.
the banks.
payment of the due amount
3. For any insurance product to
• Staff and Fund Constraints faced (premium). It further leads to the
flourish, the insurer plays a critical
by the Government delay in the entire process of claim
role as they are the ones who
settlement for a season.
In the execution of the yojana, very well understand the concept
state government faces lack of staff Findings of insurance and can deliver the
in both off field and on field jobs. same to the insured. In the case of
The following are the findings of the
The number of personnel available PMFBY, we see that a limited role
study.
for conducting crop cutting is being played by the insurance
experiments are less compared 1. The PMFBY is a far superior plan companies as they are mostly at
to the quantum of work as crop than the other agrarian protection the back end in the sense that
cutting experiments (CCE) need plans. But at the locale level, its they are not in direct contact with
to be conducted in each district/ execution is genuinely bargained. the farmers mainly due to lack of
taluka for every season. Also, The local level authorities are infrastructure in rural areas. This

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 61


PMFBY THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

has led to a gap between insured Conclusion tables for the Public Sector General
and insurer which eventually leads Insurance Companies- National,
One thing that is clear through
to the improper understanding New India, Oriental and the United
the study is that the yojana has
of the procedural aspects of the India- and also for the National Re-
a potential to flourish and grow
yojana. Insurer GIC Re- in view of the huge
in future. With consecutive dry
4. One of the unique feature of the surge in premium from 2016-17.
spells, and unseasonal rain and hail
yojana is to expand the unwavering This is possible due to the Central
in specific stashes, it turned out
quality, precision and speed of CCE Government persuasion and the keen
to be certain that the dangers in
information, required utilization cultivating are on the ascent, and interest of the State Governments.
of advanced mobile phones/hand the current arrangement of harvest This premium is next only to the
held gadgets, Drones, Remote protection was no place close to premium gathered by the Motor and
Sensing Technology, etc. But in addressing the requirements of the Health Insurance portfolios. Also,
the current scenario only smart the lower class. In this specific if the current challenges and issues
phones and mobile applications are situation, the new plan is without a of the Yojana as per the findings
used. Research is being conducted doubt a positive development and are addressed it can help break the
on other advanced technologies convenience, which will help in preconceived notion of the society
and hence in the near future we sparing Indian agribusiness from regarding the lethargic attitude
can expect more use of advance the expanding dangers of nature. of the functioning of most of the
technology. Not only that, PMFBY has turned government driven Yojanas.

References Ramachandran, K. S. (1986). Crop- Insights into Issues: Pradhan Mantri


Credit Insurance: Some Disturbing Fasal Bima Yojana – How Different
Chand, S. S. (2007). Progress and
Features. Economic and Political is it from Earlier Agri Insurance
Problems in Agricultural Insurance.
Weekly, Vol. 21, No. 42, 1866-1869. Schemes? (2016, November
Economic and Political weekly, 1905-
30). Retrieved from http://www.
1908. Singh, G. (2010). Crop Insurance insightsonindia.com/2016/11/30/
in India. Indian Institute of insights-issues-pradhan-mantri-fasal-
Dandekar, V. M. (1976). Crop
Management, 1-27. bima-yojana-different-earlier-agri-
Insurance In India. Economic and
Political weekly Vol. 11, No. 26, Singh, V. S. (2006). Crop Insurance insurance-schemes/
A61-A80. in India: Scope for Improvement.
Gulati, A. (2017, April 24). From
Economic and Political Weekly, Vol.
plate to plough: The faraway fields.
Hardaker, J. B. (1997). Coping With 41, No. 43/44 (Nov. 4-10, 2006),
Retrieved from http://indianexpress.
Risk in Agriculture. CAB International. 4585-4594.
com/article/opinion/columns/
India, G. o. (2012). Report of the Sinha, S. (2004). Agriculture farmer-subsidies-modi-government-
Working Group on Risk Management Insurance in India Scope for agriculture-policies-growth-farmer-
in Agriculture for 11th 5 year plan Participation of Private Insurers. protest-4625288/
(2007-12). New Delhi: Planning Economic and Political Weekly; Vol.
Mukherjee, S. (2017, September 02).
Commission. 39, No. 25, 2605-2612.
Impediments to the Spread of Crop
Jain. (2004). : Challenges in T. S. Walker, R. P. (1986). Risk Insurance in India. Retrieved from
Implementing Agriculture Insurance Benefits, Crop Insurance, and Dryland http://www.epw.in/journal/2017/35/
and Re-insurance in Developing Agriculture. Economic and Political commentary/impediments-spread-
Countri. The Journal, 14-23. Weekly, Vol. 21, No. 25/26, A81-A88. crop-insurance-india.html

Nair, R. (2010). Crop Insurance Venkatesh, S. G. (2008). Crop Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana
in India: Changes and Challenges. Insurance in India – A study. (PMFBY). (n.d.). Retrieved from Crop
Economic and Political Weekly, Economic and Political Weekly, Vol. Insurance: http://agri-insurance.gov.
Vol. 45, No. 34, 73-81. 26, No. 11, 16-18. in/pmfby.aspx

62 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA TRAVEL INSURANCE

Travel Insurance: Do Travellers’ Attitudes Shape


Their Purchase Intention?

Abstract to the limited literature on travel


insurance management, and it will have
Travel Insurance in India has been an
implication on insurance sector for
evolving concept in the last decade. It
further diversification of their products
was observed from the news reports
to reach the customers of travel
that there is less interest among Indian
industry.
Anicar D. Manavi travelers in buying travel insurance
Research Scholar policies. Even though many previous
1. Introduction
Department of Management research studies on insurance are
Pondicherry University available, travel insurance in the Indian “All journeys have secret destinations of
Karaikal Campus - 609605. context has grabbed the attention which the traveller is unaware” Martin
anikarmd@gmail.com of very few researchers. Authors of Buber (2002). This can be interpreted in
this paper have made an attempt terms of both favorable and unfavorable
Bimal Thapa
to understand the attitude of Indian situations a traveller may face during
Research Scholar
travellers towards Travel Insurance. the travel. There are external factors
Department of Management
The paper is exploratory in nature. beyond the control of a traveller which
Pondicherry University
Major statistical tools used in the study may lead to some unfortunate situations
Karaikal Campus - 609605.
are Exploratory Factor analysis and even though the trip is well planned by a
bimalgangtok@gmail.com
Multiple Linear Regression. Results traveller. Thus to reduce the risks faced
D.H. Malini Srinivasa Rao indicate three significant aspects of due to these unexpected happenings,
Assistant Professor travel insurance namely assurance, holding a travel insurance becomes
Department of Management availability and risk reductions largely handy. To strengthen the argument on
Pondicherry University influence the purchase intention of need of study, records on accidents
Karaikal Campus - 609605. travellers towards travel insurance. is presented below. As per National
malini_dh@yahoo.co.in This study will significantly contribute Crime Records Bureau (2014), Traffic

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 63


TRAVEL INSURANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Accidents include (i) Road Accidents The ICAO Annual Report of the Council waitlist and were not confirmed (Roy,
(ii) Railway Accidents and (iii) Railway shows the accident rate trend (per 2016). Only 11% of (77 out of 695)
Crossing Accidents. These were the million departures) over the previous passengers were actually travelling
major cause of accidental deaths owing five years, with 2013 having an accident with Railway Travel insurance policy on
to unnatural factors. A rising trend is rate of 2.8 accidents per million the day of accident. IRCTC, it is to be
seen in the absolute number of deaths departures, the lowest recorded since noted, had started offering Rail Travel
in ‘Traffic Accidents’ during five years ICAO began tracking the global accident Insurance from 1st September 2016
2010 – 2014 as presented in (Table 1). rate. (Times of India, 2016). Only 30% of
passengers were seen to be buying
Table-1: Incidence and Share of Deaths due to Traffic Accidents during 2010-2014
tickets from IRCTC were found to be
Sl. Year Road Railway Railway Total Total Un- Percentage opting for Travel Insurance even when
No. Accidents Accidents Crossing Traffic Natural share of ‘Traffic the premium was priced at 92 Paisa
Natural Accidents Accidents Accidents Accident Deaths’ (India Today, 2016) till the time the
in Un-Natural policy was optional.
Accidental
This created an interest in authors to
Deaths
study about awareness and popularity
1 2010 1,33,938 24,451 3,347 1,61,736 3,59,583 45.0 of travel Insurance among Indian
2 2011 1,36,834 25,872 2,366 1,65,072 3,67,194 45.0 travellers. This paper is an attempt to
study travelers’ attitude towards various
3 2012 1,39,091 27,402 1,808 1,68,301 3,72,022 45.2
aspects of travel insurance such as
4 2013 1,37,423 27,765 1,318 1,66,506 3,77,758 44.1 their accessibility, supporting feature,
5 2014 1,41,526 25,006 2,575 1,69,107 4,31,556 39.2 confidence building etc., and its impact
on their purchase intention of Travel
Source: Accidental Deaths & Suicides in India (ADSI) 2014 Insurance.

In Case of Commercial Air Transport Graph 1


as per the International Air Transport
Global Accident Rate (accidents per million departures)
Association’s Safety Report 2015,
trend of the accident rate continues to
be downward, not only with regard to 2009 4.1
overall accidents, but also with regard
to hull losses and accidents which are 2010 4.2
fatal (IATA, 2016). In 2015, the rate for
accidents was at its lowest as compared 2011 4.2
to all previous rates:
2012 3.2
• Overall : 1.81 accidents per 1
Accidents million sectors 2013 2.8
• Hull Losses : 0.48 hull losses per 1
million sectors On 20th November 2016 the Indore- 2. Literature Review
• Fatal : 0.11 accidents per 1 Patna Express met with an accident in
2.1 History of Travel
Accidents million sectors. which 149 passengers died and more
However, “the overall accident rate” than 200 were injured (Hindusthan Travel has been the part of human life
in Asia-Pacific (ASPAC) has been Times, 2016). Out of 695 reserved since its evolution. In primitive times,
displaying an upward trend since passengers, only 128 had bought survival was the prime reason for
2011, after a period of consistent optional travel insurance offered by which people travelled from one place
improvement between 2007 and 2011 IRCTC. Out of 128 tickets, 51 were to another. People were nomads till
(IATA, 2016). automatically cancelled as they were on the time agriculture was discovered

64 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA TRAVEL INSURANCE
(Andrews, 2008). Previous researches country. People have to incur extremely
have indicated that other forms of
Travel Insurance is a
high medical cost while one is outside
travelling started from as early as one’s own country. Travel Insurance policy that provides
4000 BC, the time when currency first is the most important safety net for
originated (Puri, 1995). India was the
coverage to losses
travellers in the event of misfortune
leader of travel among Asian countries (Allingham, 2013). The risks which that may be incurred
and was the most developed. People are generally covered under Travel
started traveling as Pilgrims during
while travelling such as
Insurance is listed below though the
6th century, the time when religion combination may vary, however, it is medical expenses, flight
was born. During the period of Great
Dynasties, Muslim Evasions, British
not exhaustive. cancellations, lost luggage
rule and Pre independence period, • Medical Expenses with or without etc (Travel insurance
military and trade continued to be in cashless facility (most travel insurance
the list of reasons to travel (Tourism of products offer cashless facility) definition and meaning |
India). Leisure travel gradually gained • Personal Accident Collins English Dictionary).
its popularity and showed phenomenal
growth during 1990s due to gradual
• Loss of Baggage Travel Insurance is
progresses in political and economic • Delay in Baggage arrival dominantly a travel health
scenario post-independence and the
efforts made by Government (Sinha).
• Loss of Passport insurance specially while
2.2. Meaning of Travel
• Travel Delay visiting a foreign country.
• Repatriation of subjective perceived risk than the
According to the Oxford dictionary,
• Transportation of dead body etc. calculated true risk (Thurston, 2000).
traveling is to make a journey of some
(IRDA) The presumed gap between a favorable
length. Travel as defined by Cambridge
attitude towards product as such
Dictionary is going from one usual
2.4. Consumer Attitude towards Travel and behavioral intention to purchase
place to a new place over a long
Insurance those products explains the critical
distance by some means such as Plane,
Train, and Car etc. Modern definition According to Kotler (2000), “an attitude role of other aspects of product like
of travel calls it as a regular event in is a person’s enduring favorable or availability, social norms, perceived
one’s life for some adventure or to unfavorable evaluations, emotional certainty (Vermeir & Verbeke, 2006).
spend some time together with family feelings, and action tendencies Thus based on these studies a study
(Travel Insurance).UNWTO defines toward some object or idea”. Fishbein hypothesis is framed as follows.
travel as an activity made by traveller (1967) defined attitude as “a learned H1: Travellers’ Positive attitude on
who in turn is defined as a person who predisposition of human beings.” various attributes of travel insurance
moves between different geographic Thus consumer attitude towards has a positive impact on their purchase
locations, for any purpose and any travel insurance can be defined as Intention of travel insurance.
duration(United Nations, 2010). predisposition of consumer, their
evaluations, emotional feelings and
3. Methodology:
2.3. Travel Insurance
action tendencies towards travel Causal research design is adopted to
Travel Insurance is a policy that insurance. Previous studies such as investigate the attitude of travellers
provides coverage to losses that may the study by Hung (2009) have found towards factors which influence their
be incurred while travelling such as that consumers have a difficulty purchase intention of Travel Insurance
medical expenses, flight cancellations, determining whether to buy insurance products. An Exploratory method
lost luggage etc (Travel insurance or not, especially when they have little is used to generate the items which
definition and meaning | Collins knowledge about the quantum of loss reflect the attitude of the traveller
English Dictionary). Travel Insurance that may occur because of a particular towards travel insurance. Fifteen
is dominantly a travel health insurance risk. The requirement of buying an statements were finalized under the
specially while visiting a foreign insurance policy depends on level guidance of an industrial expert and

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 65


TRAVEL INSURANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

an academician in the field and the A9. The claims settlement procedure Initially four factors were retained
face validity approach is adapted of Travel Insurance is clearly based on the criterion of retaining
to validate the questionnaire. understood or well understandable factors with eigenvalues of 1 or greater.
Respondents were asked to rate each A10. The process of buying Travel The scree plot also suggested a four-
statement on a 5-point scale, with Insurance is very simple factor solution. But the first run factor
high scores stipulating strong positive analysis output contained attributes
A11. Buying Travel Insurance will have
attitude for that particular aspect of that do not go along conceptually,
psychological impact in handling
Travel insurance. Purchase intention the similarity in meaning of two
the misfortune situations
statement i.e. traveller’s intention to factors advocated to combine them.
buy travel insurance policy in the near A12. Passengers are well informed To overcome the subjective nature of
future (within a year) is also rated on about Travel Insurance these decisions, the factor analysis
a 5-point scale (5 = Definitely buy, 4 A13. Buying Travel Insurance does not was decided to rerun. In the second
= May buy, 3 = Cannot say, 2 = May increases the travelling cost run, the Total Variance Explained part
not buy, and 1 = Definitely not buy). of the output was the same as that of
A14. Travel Insurance has the potential
Travellers who travel by train and Air the first run. Thus the four factors were
of reducing medical expenses
are considered as subjects for the extracted, accounting for a combined
study. A total of 148 subjects provided A15. The coverage amount can support 61.495% of total variance. The Rotated
responses to these fifteen items. Using the victim and his family to a large Component Matrix (Varimax with
the SPSS 16.0 version, Factor analysis extent Kaiser Normalization) presents only
with principal component extraction three rotated factors. All items were
4. Results:
method, was applied to identify the loaded above 0.50(Table-4) and factor
The Correlation Matrix revealed
factors represented by these fifteen loadings ranged between 0.505 and
fairly high correlations between the
statements. The statements are listed 0.848 (Hair, Anderson, Tatham, &
fifteen items written to measure the
in Table-2. Multiple linear Regression Black, 1998). Factor-1 contains seven
travellers’ attitude towards different
was applied to analyse the relationship items that clearly reflect monetary
attributes of Travel Insurance. Given
between traveller’s attitude towards or psychological strength or support
the number of high intercorrelations
travel insurance and their purchase provided by the travel insurance for
between the attributes of Travel
intention. the policy holder and his/her family to
Insurance, the hypothesized factor
meet the expenses without compromise
Table-2 : Attributes of Travel model is appropriate (Ho, 2006). The
in unforeseen disrupt situations
Insurance Bartlett’s Test of Sphericity (Table-3)
in travelling, and thus was named
A1. Travel insurance is affordable produced Chi-Square value of 794.882
‘Assurance’. Factor 2 consists of four
and the associated significance level
A2. Travel Insurance is not complicated items that reflect the easy accessibility
was less than 0.001. Thus it can be
and simplicity of travel insurance
A3. Travel Insurance becoming more concluded that data were approximately
products, and was named ‘Availability’.
available multivariate normal data. Further,
Factor 3 includes four items that reflect
A4. Travel Insurance ensures a risk sufficient covariance was contained by
reduction of the risk of travel insurance;
free journey correlation matrix for factoring (Kim,
thus it was named ‘Risk reduction’.
Wang, Shin, & Kim, 2010).
A5. Travel Insurance is lot like packing This three-factor model represents the
A6. Travel Insurance reduces the risk Table-3 : KMO and Bartlett’s Test combination of the four original factors,
of delay and appears to reflect adequately the
Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin .841
underlying factor structure of the
A7. Travel Insurance reduces the Measure of Sampling
Adequacy. 15-item Travel Insurance attributes.
accident risk
Bartlett’s Test of Sphericity 794.882 As presented in Table-4, the reliability
A8. Having Travel Insurance gives Approx. Chi-Square scores of all the factors were above
scope for better medical Df 105 the threshold score 0.60(Nunnally,
treatment in the case of 1978). The sustainability scale achieved
Sig. .000
accidents highest reliability of 0.836.

66 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA TRAVEL INSURANCE
2.279), as minimum is not less than
Table-4 : Rotated Component Matrix and Reliability statistics
-3.29 and maximum values is not
Component Cronbach’s
greater than 3.29. The histogram of
1 2 3 Alpha
standardised residuals showed that the
A14 0.734 data contained approximately normally
A9 0.726 distributed errors, same with the normal
A15 0.694 P-P plot of standardised residuals,
0.836 which showed points that were not
A11 0.648
completely on the line, but close. The
A12 0.622 scatterplot of standardised predicted
A13 0.615 values showed that the data met the
A8 0.590 assumptions of homogeneity of variance
and linearity (L.Bresgi, D.L.M.Alexander,
A1 0.848
& J.Seabi, 2017). Thus the results of
A3 0.627
.708 regression model stand explained.
A2 0.626
An assessment of the table-5 exhibits
A10 0.505 that all three factors namely, Assurance,
A4 0.793 availability and risk reduction which
A6 0.617 are representing various attributes of
A5 0.615 travel insurance are entered in to the
0.678 prediction equation (Model 1). The
A7 0.525
level of travellers’ purchase intention,
Extraction Method: Principal Component Analysis. out of these three factors is predicted
using the values displayed in the
4.1. Multiple Regression: Factor-1 contains unstandardized coefficients column for
All required assumptions of multiple seven items that clearly Model-1. The prediction equation based
regression are met. For current model, reflect monetary or on the constant and B values would be:
both the “tolerance” values (greater psychological strength PI = 3.486 + (0.437) AS + (0.305) AV +
than 0.10) and the “VIF” values (less
or support provided (0.266) R
than 10) are all quite acceptable (see
Coefficients table-5) (Ho, 2006). Thus,
by the travel insurance Where PI = Purchase Intention (the
multicollinearity is not a problem. An for the policy holder predicted dependent variable), Constant
analysis of standard residuals was and his/her family to (a) = 3.486, AS = Assurance, A =
Availability and R = Risk Reduction
carried out, which showed that the data meet the expenses
contained no outliers (Std. Residual 4.1.1. Prediction Equation’s Strength
without compromise
Min = -1.680, Std. Residual Max = (Model Fit):
in unforeseen disrupt
The coefficient of determination,
situations in travelling,
R-square is a measure of the computed
and thus was named prediction equation’s strength. The
‘Assurance’. Factor coefficient of determination R2 is a
2 consists of four value between 0 and 1 that measures
items that reflect the how well a regression model predicts
the data(Ho, 2006). From the Model
easy accessibility and
Summary table-6 where R – square
simplicity of travel = 0.735, it can be interpreted as in
insurance products, and proposed attitude – purchase intention
was named ‘Availability’. regression model, 73.5% of variance in

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 67


TRAVEL INSURANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Table-5: Coefficientsa

Standardized
Unstandardized Coefficients Coefficients Collinearity Statistics
Model B Std. Error Beta t Sig. Tolerance VIF
1 (Constant) 3.486 .030 117.260 .000
Sustainability .437 .030 .629 14.645 .000 1.000 1.000
Availability .305 .030 .439 10.225 .000 1.000 1.000
Risk Reduction .266 .030 .383 8.912 .000 1.000 1.000
a. Dependent Variable: Purchase_Intention
purchase intention is explained by the = 0 is tested by using the Analysis 5. Discussion and Conclusion:
three predictor variables. of Variance (ANOVA) model. The The study shows that major aspects of
Table-6 : Model Summary travel insurance product are assurance,
availability and risk reduction.
Adjusted R Std. Error of the Durbin-
Assurance factor covers travel
Model R R Square Square Estimate Watson
insurance’s potential to ‘assure’ both
1 .857a .735 .729 .36172 1.811
monetary and mental support during
a. Predictors: (Constant), Availability, Risk reduction, Sustainability disruptions in traveling plan which
b. Dependent Variable: Purchase_Intention would have otherwise led to financial
4.1.2. Testing the Hypothesis: computed F statistic is 132.816, with setbacks. Availability factor explains the
an observed significance level of less easy access to and understanding of the
The status of relationship between
than 0.05 i.e. p-value = 0. Thus, the null travel insurance policy. Lastly the risk
each predictor and purchase intention
hypothesis is rejected. It can be claimed reduction factor explains more about
variables can be drawn from the
that the travellers’ attitude towards precaution to reduce different types
coefficient table, the p-value for beta
of risk involved in traveling. Among
coefficient for all three factors is 0.000. the travel insurance policy and their
these, regression model shows that
All these values are significant at the purchase intentions are related.
assurance factor has more impact on
5% significance level. Thus we can A multiple regression has been run to the travel insurance purchase intention
claim that the purchase intention of predict the purchase intention from of travellers compared to other two
travellers is positively related to their the travellers’ attitude on Assurance, factors. However the current model
attitude towards assurance, availability
availability, and Risk reduction explains only 73.5% of variance, hence
and risk reduction aspects of travel
factors. These variables statistically there is a further scope for studying
insurance.
significantly predicted
However in the context of travellers’ purchase intention, F (3, 144)
attitude – purchase intention model, = 132.816, p <.05, R2 =.735.
the null hypothesis of no linear All three factors contributed
relationship between the independent statistically significantly to
and dependent variables, i.e R-square the prediction, p <.05. Thus
rejecting the null hypothesis,
Assurance
0.437
the alternative hypothesis H1
i.e. that Travellers’ Positive
0.305
Availability
Purchase Intention attitude on various attributes
of travel insurance has a
0.266 positive impact on their
Risk Reduction
purchase Intention of travel
Travel Insurance attributes
insurance can be considered
Figure-1: Travelers’ Attitude – Purchase Intention towards Travel
Insurance
to be true.

68 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA TRAVEL INSURANCE
other factors which are influencing of premium is very low i.e. ` 0.92, an impact on the attitude and behavior
their purchase intention. The insurance the number of train passengers who of travellers on travel insurance. It is
companies and the government of purchase it is abysmally low. As the also essential to bring in a perceptional
India can concentrate on projecting sustainability aspect of travel insurance change on the availability aspect of
purchasing Travel insurance as not has more impact on the purchase travel insurance by making the process
an additional expense but a financial intention of travellers, it is essential to of buying and claiming, simple and
security measure to face any unfortunate invest more time, men and material to accessible. Travellers must also
disruption in travel plans. Though bring awareness about the advantages understand the risk reduction aspect of
railway travel insurance currently in of holding travel insurance. This will travel insurance and require accepting it
India covers life insurance and its rate work at the cognitive level and can have as an intrinsic part of their travel.

Works Cited Kim, C., W. T., Shin, N., & Kim, K.- Times of India. (2016, November 23).
S. (2010). An empirical study of Kanpur Rail Crash. Retrieved December
Allingham, J. D. (2013). Travel Medical customers’ perceptions of security and 8, 2016, from Times of India: www.
Insurance. Can Farm Physician, trust in e-payment systems. Electronic tomesofindia.indiatimes.com
819-822. commerce research and applications, 9
Tourism of India. (n.d.). History.
Andrews, S. (2008). Tourism & (1), 84-95.
Retrieved November 23, 2016,
Hospitality Industry. Kotler, P. (2000). Marketing from Tourism of India: http://www.
New Delhi: Tata McGraw-Hill. Management. Prentice Hall. tourismofindia.com/
Buber, M. (2002). The Legend of the
L.Bresgi, D.L.M.Alexander, & J.Seabi. Travel Insurance. (n.d.). Retrieved
BAAL-SHEM. (M. Friedman, Trans.)
(2017). The predictive relationships
LONDON AND NEW YORK: Routledge. August 10, 2017, from policybazar:
between working memory skills within
https://www.policybazaar.com/travel-
Fishbein, M. (1967). Readings in the spatial and verbal domains and
insurance/
attitude theory and measurement. Wiley. mathematical performance of Grade 2
Hair, J., Anderson, R., Tatham, South African learners. International Travel insurance definition and meaning
R., & Black, W. (1998). Multivariate Journal of Educational Research, 81, | Collins English Dictionary. (n.d.).
Data Analysis. Upper Sandle River, 1-10. Retrieved from Collinsdictionary.com:
NJ: Prentice-Hall. https://www.collinsdictionary.com/
National Crime Records Bureau. (2014).
dictionary/english/travel-insurance
Hindusthan Times. (2016, November Accidental Deaths & Suicides in India
22). India. Retrieved December 8, (ADSI) 2014. New Delhi: Ministry of
Understanding Travel Insurance
2016, from Hindusthan Times: www. Home Affairs, Government of India.
Benefits. (n.d.). Retrieved August 12,
hindusthantimes.com
Nunnally, J. C. (1978). Psychometric 2017, from Insurance Explained: https://
Ho, R. (2006). Handbook of univariate Theory. New York: McGraw-Hill. www.internationalstudentinsurance.
and multivariate data analysis and com/explained/understanding-travel-
Puri, U. (1995). Paryatan ra Vikas.
interpretation with SPSS. CRC Press. insurance-benefits.php
Kathmandu: Taleju Pustak Bitarak.
Hung, H.-C. (2009). The attitude
towards flood insurance purchase when Roy, D. (2016, November 21). India. United Nations. (2010). International
respondents’ preferences are uncertain: Retrieved December 08, 2016, from Recommendations for Tourism
a fuzzy approach. Journal of Risk News 18: www.news18.com Statistics. New York: United Nations
Research, 239-258. Sinha, A. (n.d.). Tourism Development Publication.

IATA. (2016). IATA SAFETY REPORT in India. Retrieved November 23, 2016,
Vermeir, I., & Verbeke, W. (2006).
2015. Canada: International Air from Press Information Bureau: pib.nic.in
Sustainable food consumption:
Transport Association. All rights. Thurston, P. T. (2000). Buying Insurance Exploring the consumer “attitude–
India Today. (2016, November 25). PTI for Disaster-Type Risks: Experimental behavioral intention” gap. Journal of
feed. Retrieved December 8, 2016, from Evidence. Journal of Risk and Agricultural and Environmental ethics,
India Today: indiatoday.indiatoday.in Uncertainty, 271-289. 19 (2), 169-194.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 69


CROP INSURANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Building Loss Assessors Cadre for Crop Insurance


in India

Introduction state government.

Crop insurance refers to an insurance The scenario has changed with launch
which insures farmers and crop of Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana
producers against the loss of crops due (PMFBY). The crop insurance Business
to natural disasters, such as floods, is now being run in complete market
drought, and hail etc. driven model. From sole monopoly of

In India before 2016 crop insurance the Agriculture Insurance Company


functioned mostly as government of India, the market has been opened
schemes. The crop insurance scenario to four PSU non-life insurers and
was dominated by the National as many as thirteen private non-life
Agriculture Insurance Scheme (NAIS) insurers. From nowhere, crop insurance
implemented by Agriculture insurance has emerged the third largest line of
Company of India. This scheme was business after motor insurance and
Shuvajit Chakraborty heavily subsidized by government of health insurance following the launch
Deputy Manager India both in premium and claim. It of the Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima
Agriculture Insurance Company of India operated solely on area approach. The Yojana (PMFBY). Crop insurance has
13th Floor, Ambadeep Building, claims were automatically calculated helped the non-life industry record 32%
14 KG Marg, New Delhi - 110001. based on yield reports received by the growth the last fiscal and cross the
shuvojit.chakraborty@gmail.com implementing agency from the relevant ` 1-lakh-crore mark for the first time.1

70 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA CROP INSURANCE
Challenges in the Crop • Retired Bank officials with From nowhere, crop
Insurance Loss Assessment experience of crop loaning or KCC.
For compliance under the above
insurance has emerged
With the opening of new vistas and
growth in crop insurance, there have
provisions the insurance companies the third largest line of
would empanel the suitable loss
come new challenges for the companies business after motor
assessors for using their services as
who seek to operate in the field. One of
the greatest challenges is assessment and when required. insurance and health
of losses at the individual level. There is a dearth of people who satisfy insurance following the
aforementioned criterion in education
The earlier crop insurance schemes launch of the Pradhan
had only area approach towards loss and experience. The crop insurance
assessment and settlement of claims. in its previous avatars as CCIS, PCIS, Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana
NAIS etc had no provision for individual
The Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana (PMFBY). Crop insurance
has for first time included covers under loss assessors.
individual approach. These are:
has helped the non-life
The supply of people with desired
• Post-Harvest Losses: coverage is educational qualification of B.Sc (Ag) industry record 32%
is not much. The pool of available
available only up to a maximum growth the last fiscal and
period of two weeks from harvesting manpower is also utilized by other more
for those crops which are allowed paying industries especially agro- cross the ` 1-lakh-crore
to dry in cut and spread condition industry, banking, seed companies, mark for the first time.
in the field after harvesting against development sector etc. In this
specific perils of cyclone and scenario, being a crop loss assessor Present Response
cyclonic rains and unseasonal rains. is the lowest priority for an agriculture
IRDA has devised a syllabus for
graduate.
• Localized Calamities: Loss/ preparing the cadre of crop loss
damage resulting from occurrence Retired officers from bank and assessors and Insurance Institute
of identified localized risks of government with adequate experience of India has devised the exams for
hailstorm, landslide, and inundation are old and financially stable. same. These are preliminary steps but
affecting isolated farms in the They are less likely to undertake the efforts have to go further. Of the
notified area.2 physical ardor associated with crop loss thirteen topics only last four deals with
The guidelines issued by the Ministry assessment.
crop loss assessment. These are3:
of Agriculture, Cooperation and The present cadre of loss assessors
• Chapter 10: Production Risk
Farmers Welfare, Government of India working in motor, fire or marine lines
Perils &Manifestation of Perils
require appointment of loss assessors of insurance is of no help as crop
on Crops – Major climatic risks
within 48 hours of receipt of loss insurance is totally different.
and its manifestation on different
intimation. These guidelines also set
Again as of now the sum insured crops and various stages of crop
the qualification of loss assessors as
level for individual asset (farm) growth – Major pests & diseases
follows:
covered is very low, which means and its manifestations on crops and
• Any Graduate (preferably Agriculture the remuneration available to loss resultant losses
i.e. B. Sc. (Ag.)) with minimum 2 assessors for individual survey is
years’ relevant experience. • Chapter 11: Crop Loss Assessment
not very attractive. Whereas, if large
– Principles and Objectives –
• Retired Government officials of number of losses occur, then they will
approach – expectation – fairness
Agriculture/ Horticulture/ Extension be covered under widespread category
–indemnity principle etc.
Department having B. Sc. (Ag.) for which individual loss assessor will
degree. not be preferred. • Chapter 12: Planning Crop Loss

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 71


CROP INSURANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Assessment – understanding – loss assessment in crop insurance • The courses must have 50% or
planning – execution – reporting business could thus be a very more as practical component with
– loss adjustment, etc. subjective assessment. frequent field visits.

• Chapter 13: Crop Loss assessment Way Forward • These courses may be also
and Use of Modern Technologies– conducted at the institutes
The solution may be sought by
satellite imagery, unmanned aerial conducting training on insurance.
adopting following measures:
vehicles, real-time digital pictures In such event the retired officers
& videos, interpretation, etc. • Widening educational requirement from agriculture department/
by including graduates from B.Sc banks/ insurance companies having
IRDA admits that “there are no
in agriculture or allied sciences, B. adequate experience must be
surveyors available to train the new
Sc. in biological sciences, Diploma appointed as trainers.
entrants to carry out loss assessment
in agriculture sciences, senior
in crop insurance.” It has therefore
secondary pass in agriculture (Endnotes)
waived off training requirement.
vocational stream. 1 https://economictimes.indiatimes.
This is a half measure solution to the
• Conducting of short term (3 com/industry/banking/finance/crop-
problem of dearth of loss assessors.
months – 1 year duration) regular insurance-drives-non-life-business/
The assessors are not trained in
courses of crop loss assessment articleshow/58177694.cms
objectively assessing the loss, which
at agriculture universities and 2 http://www.aicofindia.com/AICEng/
farmers would suffer due to a peril, in
agriculture colleges. General_Documents/Product_Profiles/
monetary terms. They may either err
on the positive side writing down more • Inclusion of crop economics and PMFBYOperationalGuidelines.pdf

loss than those actually suffered or crop pathology of major crops 3 IRDA circular number IRDA/SUR/
they may err on negative side deciding in the region should form part of MISC/CIR/71/03/2017 dated 30th
on inadequate compensations. The syllabus in the training courses. March, 2017

72 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA CROP INSURANCE

Non Theme - Based Articles

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 73


MICRO INSURANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Customer’s Preference for Micro Insurance: A


Study with Reference to Kollam District, Kerala

Abstract understand the preferences of the low


income community for the promotion
Insurance underlies a collective
of insurance policies. This paper
bearing of risks. It affords the benefit
brings to light the preference of low
of security, peace of mind, protection
income customers for micro insurance
of property and fulfilment of needs of
policies in Kollam district, Kerala.
insured. In the recent past, insurance
Keywords: Insurance, Micro insurance,
companies in India have embarked
Preference
on the promotion of micro insurance
products for the underprivileged Introduction
R. Neelamegam communities. Though risk is common Insurance (life and general) was earlier
Senior professor to every one, the economic loss affects sold by state owned companies. The
ICSSR Research Centre in Business the lower income group more severely. opening up of the insurance sector
Administration The outreach of micro insurance for private investment has made it
V.H.N.S.N. College (Autonomous) product is severely hampered by the necessary for the government to move
Virudhunagar - 626001. uncertain and low income of the poor. away from control of the sector into
rneelamegam.phd@rediffmail.com So, the insurance companies have to regulation. The Insurance Regulatory

74 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA MICRO INSURANCE
and Development Authority of India
(IRDAI) was set up to regulate,
promote and ensure an orderly growth
of insurance industry. The opening
up of the sector has provided a fillip
to product innovation and sustained
dissemination campaign to educate
the customers about the need for
insurance.

After 2005, IRDA made regulations


on micro insurance. Micro insurance
is insurance for the protection of low
income households against specific
perils in exchange for premium
payment. There are several types of
micro insurance such as life insurance,
health insurance, crop insurance,
property insurance and so forth.

A majority of India’s population through a variety of institutional Hypothesis


lives in poverty. Micro insurance is arrangement and examines these
Ho: There is no difference in
a necessary step to enable the poor arrangements under the conditions in
policyholder’s rating to the variable
people to avail of the benefits of which one might be preferable to other
future saving as their preference for
an inclusive policy. The emerging Ganesan and Jayaprakash(2007) taking policy for factor different areas
opportunity of micro insurance is not infer that getting rural through of residence.
only to promote business perspective micro insurance is nothing but the
but also social development and consolidation of the roots of insurance Ho: There is no difference in six
protection to the poor people. different preferences of buying
business.
Review of Literature policy for the factor different areas of
Research Problem
residence.
Amitab Verma(2008)reports that high
Spreading the idea of insurance
business retention ratios indicate the Data & Methodology
among the poor, illiterate or
health of an insurance company. The study mainly depended on
semilliterate community is not easy.
Anuradha Sharma(2008) observes that It requires a great deal of sustained primary data which was collected
the demand for life insurance is driven effort. A micro insurance company/ with the sample survey by contacting
by several economic factors like price agent is required to know the 400 sample policyholders in Kollam
of insurance, government tax, income, preferences of prospective buyers district. Stratified random sampling
and interest rate. of the policy. With this end in view, method was applied for the selection
it is thought fit to undertake a study of samples. The survey was conducted
Ayemperumal(2010) explains that
on customer’s preference for micro
the business environment for the for nine months during 2016.
insurance in Kollam district, Kerala.
insurance sector has been fast Relevant statistical tools such as
changing, bringing new opportunities Objective of the Study percentage calculation, standard
and posing new challenges. deviation, t-test, ANOVA (one way)
To find out customer’s preference for
Craig Churchill(2006) reports that investing in a micro insurance policy and MANOVA were applied for data
micro insurance can be delivered in Kollam district. analysis.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 75


MICRO INSURANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Result & Discussion The study mainly


Table 1 shows the frequency distribution of demographic profile of 400 micro depended on primary
insurance policyholders.
data which was collected
Characteristic F % to total
with the sample survey
Area of residence Urban 61 15.25
Semi urban 61 15.25 by contacting 400 sample
Rural 278 69.50 policyholders in Kollam
Age (years) 25-35 63 15.75
district. Stratified random
36-45 128 32.00
46-55 146 36.50
sampling method was
56 & above 63 15.75 applied for the selection
Gender Male 151 37.75 of samples.
Female 249 62.25
investing in micro insurance policy
Education Primary level 92 23.00
Secondary level 167 41.75 After economic reforms in 1991 in
Diploma 29 India, several changes took place in the
7.25
insurance sector. Insurance companies
Graduate 112 28.00
have started paying attention to micro
Annual income (`) Below 50,000 42 10.50
insurance schemes meant for the
51,000-70,000 85 21.30 low income group. Preferences of
70001-90,000 101 25.30 respondents for taking a policy may
90001&above 172 43.00 differ. These preferences may be for
instance, future saving, risk coverage,
Source: Primary data
tax benefit, etc. The respondent’s
preference for investing in a micro
Mode of Payment Amount of Premium Payment insurance policy was subjected to a
Policyholder’s mode of premium Income earned by the policyholders detailed analysis. Their responses
payment may vary. Table 2 shows determines the amount of their premium on this point were collected on a five
policyholder’s preferred mode of payment per year. Table 3 presents point numerical scale. Table 4 presents
payment of premium. these details the distribution of policyholders by
their agreement level for six different
Preferred mode of F %to total Amount of Premium F %
preferences (purposes) for holding
Premium Payment Per Year (`) total
the policy with mean score, and test
Salary saving 29 7.25 Less than 50,00 305 76.25
of significance for the following null
Monthly premium 178 44.50 50,00-10,000 80 20.00
hypothesis.
Quarterly Premium 71 17.75 10,000-15,000 3 0.75
Ho: There is no difference in
Half yearly Premium 53 13.25 15,001& above 12 3.00
policyholder’s mean score/rating for
Annual Premium 69 17.25 Source: Primary data future saving as the preference for
Source: Primary data The above analysis discloses that a taking the policy.

It is clear from the above table that great majority of 76.25 per cent of the Similarly, the null hypothesis for
policyholders selected policy premium preference rating of policyholders for
monthly premium is the most prevalent
amount of less than ` 5,000 per annum. the remaining other five preference for
mode of payment of premium, followed
by quarterly premium. Customer’s preference for or purpose of holding the policy was tested by t-test.

76 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA MICRO INSURANCE
Table 4 Preference for Holding Micro Insurance Policy

Response

Preference for Strongly Agree Neutral Disagree Strongly Mean SD T Sig.


taking policy Age Disagree

Future saving F 27 85 21 12 4 4.55 0.81 38.398 0.000


% 69.50 21.25 5.25 3.00 1.00

Growth F 79 215 51 25 30 3.72 1.08 13.289 0.000


% 19.75 53.75 12.75 6.25 7.50

Life risk F 132 153 82 26 7 3.94 0.98 19.324 0.000


cover % 33.00 38.25 20.50 6.50 1.75

Children’s F 21 147 114 84 34 3.09 1.06 1.747 0.081


future % 5.25 36.75 28.50 21.00 8.50

Income Tax F 33 125 78 68 96 2.83 1.32 1.610 0.069


benefit % 8.25 31.25 19.50 17.00 24.00

Other F 64 103 59 58 116 2.85 1.48 -1.995 0.056


preference % 16.00 25.75 14.75 14.50 29.00

Source: Primary data, result calculated


The above table shows that the mean 3.00, and its p-value is higher than the future saving for the factor area of
opinion score is 4.55, which is higher significance level of 0.05, and so it is residence at three different levels.
than the mean of the response scale, not an important preference for taking
Similar null hypothesis was tested
namely 3.00, and the significance level the policy. for the other five preferences of
of one sample t-test is less than 0.05. Relationship of Respondent’s policyholders for the factor areas of
The result indicates that future saving Preference and Demographic residence. Table 5 shows the mean
is one of the important purposes of Variables. opinion score about preference for
holding the micro insurance policy taking policy by area of residence
In several cases, demographic
by the respondents. The same result with test of significance by ANOVA
variables such as area of residence,
has been obtained for the second (one way) and MANOVA.
age, gender, education, marital status
preference, i.e., growth of money and
and annual income of policyholders
the third preference, i.e., life risk cover; In several cases,
would impact their preference for
it means growth and risk coverage
buying the micro insurance policy. demographic variables
are also the important preferences for
During the study, an attempt was
taking the policy. made to find the effect of the such as area of residence,
But in respect of the last three demographic variables on the age, gender, education,
preferences, namely, future of children, policyholder’s preferences for the
tax benefit and other preference, the holding the policy. For this purpose, marital status and annual
reverse is true. It means they are found one way ANOVA and multivariate
analysis of variance MANOVA were
income of policyholders
to be not the important preferences of
policy holders for holding the policy. performed. The null hypothesis to be would impact their
For example, one could see that the tested for ANOVA:
preference for buying the
mean score for children’s future is Ho: There is no difference in
just nearer to mean of the scale of policyholder’s preference rating of micro insurance policy.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 77


MICRO INSURANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Preference Urban Semi Urban Rural ANOVA MANOVA


Mean SD Mean SD Mean SD F Sig. F Sig.
Future savings 4.54 0.81 4.70 0.64 4.52 o.84 1.295 0.275
Growth 3.54 1.03 3.87 0.97 3.73 1.12 1.416 0.244
Life risk cover 3.75 1.18 4.16 0.86 3.94 0.94 2.741 0.066
Future of children 3.43 0.96 2.74 1.11 3.10 1.05 6.636 0.001 2.474 0.004
Income tax benefit 2.66 1.12 3.18 1.26 2.79 1.37 2.840 0.060
Other 2.72 1.40 3.00 1.48 2.85 1.50 0.543 0.581
Source: Primary data. Result calculated

From the above table it is clear that level, annual income and gender. The test of significance of ANOVA and
the significance level of ANOVA is following summarised table 6 exhibits MANOVA factor rise.
less than 0.05 for the purpose of
children’s future. It means that taking
policy for the purpose of children’s Factor Preference ANOVA MANOVA
future varies significantly in regard to F Sig. F Sig.
area of residence. It can be seen that
the preferences of taking policy for Age (at 4 levels) Future Saving 1.638 0.180
the future savings, growth, coverage Growth 2.625 0.045
of risk, income tax benefit and other Life risk cover 1.620 0.184 2.846 0.000
do not significantly vary in respect Children’s future 7.299 0.000
of area of residence at three different Tax benefit 2.777 0.041
levels(p>0.05). Other 2.699 0.045
MANOVA is similar to ANOVA except
that instead of one metric dependent Education (at 4 levels) Future Saving 1.457 0.226
variable, one has two or more. Here, Growth 2.442 0.064
MANOVA is performed to test the Risk cover 4.625 0.003 3.837 0.000
null hypothesis that the different Children’s future 1.317 0.268
levels of area of residence have an Tax benefit 7.699 0.000
impact on the six different preferences Other 5.829 0.001
(dependent variables) as shown in
table 5. The p value is less than 0.05
which indicates that when all the six Gender Future Saving 6.989 0.009
different preferences for the taking Growth 16.834 0.000
policy are taken together, there is Risk cover 9.391 0.002 6.225 0.000
significant difference for areas of Children’s future 0.154 0.695
residence at three levels. Further, it is Tax benefit 20.800 0.000
understood that all preferences except Other 22.526 0.000
children’s future are found to be higher
in semi urban area as against urban Annual income Future Saving 2.553 0.055
and rural areas. Growth 2.890 0.035
Akin to the above preference of Risk cover 2.960 0.032 3.374 0.000
ANOVA and MANOVA for all the six Children’s future 0.944 0.419
preferences at the three levels of Tax benefit 10.740 0.000
residence, such analyses were made Other 10.529 0.000
for the rest of the demographic
Source: Primary data, Result calculated
factors, namely, age, educational

78 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA MICRO INSURANCE
From the above analysis, it can be insurance vary significantly with regard significantly for the factor gender of
seen that the significance value for to policyholder’s educational level as policyholders. The result of MANOVA
the purpose of taking policy for future the F value is less than 0.05. indicates that for all six different
savings, life risk cover, growth and ANOVA in table 6 shows the value of F preferences together for taking policy
other do not vary with regard to age for purpose of investing for growth of there is significant difference for the
of policyholders as this value is higher money, and for risk cover, tax benefit factor respondent’s gender.
than or equal to 0.05. However, from and others is less than the significance Suggestion & Conclusion
the result of MANOVA, it is clear level of 0.05 in respect of annual
that, the preferences for investing in As there is a considerable female labour
income. It means these purposes vary
the policy with reference to age of in the unorganised sector, measures
significantly in respect of four levels of
policyholders vary significantly as the may be taken to attract more females,
annual income of policyholders. The
significance level is less than 0.05. result of MANOVA indicates that for the lesser educated and people from
all the six different preferences for the the lower income groups to micro
Further, concerning education level
tacking policy taken together, there insurance.
the F value for preferences of taking
policy for future savings, growth of is significant difference in regard to The analysis has brought to light
money, children’s future is higher annual income. that the preference for holding micro
than 0.05; hence these preferences For the factor gender, ANOVA indicates insurance policy varies significantly
for taking policy do not vary for the F value for all the purposes of investing in respect of area of residence, age,
factor education at four different levels. in micro insurance policy excepting gender, educational level and annual
However, from the result of MANOVA children’s future is less than the income of policyholders as the
it is clear that, the preferences taken significance level of 0.05. It means significance levels of MANOVA are less
together for investing in micro these purposes/ preferences vary than 0.05, as described above.

References
Amitab Verma. (2008). Retention of
life insurance business _ Need for
improvement. IRDA Journal,
August, p. 23.

Anuradha Sharma. (2008). Life


insurance evaluation _ Current
perspective. IRAD Journal, April, p.22.

Ayemperumal, S. (2010). Impact of


economic globalisation and consumer
expectations in life insurance.
Southern Economist, March, p.8.

Balachandran, S. (2010). Customer


driver services management. Response
Book, New Delhi.

Ganesan, S., and Jayaprakash, S.


(2007). Micro bancassurance model
in India. Paper for 11th Annual
APRIA Conference, National Chengchi
University Taipei, Taiwan, July.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 79


MOTOR INSURANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Impact on Motor Insurance Business & General


Insurance Industry With Regard To Autonomous Car

Introduction: benefits. Through this Article, we will


try to highlight the issues that Motor
We have heard a lot on news channel
Insurance as a segment and General
on new innovations or technological
Insurance Industry may face due to
advancement made each passing day.
Autonomous Cars.
One such technological advancement
is Autonomous Cars commonly known Meaning of Autonomous Car
as driverless car being developed by Before we move ahead on impact on
manufacturing Company. To name a Motor Insurance and General Insurance
few Tesla, Google Self-Driving Cars and Industry as a whole, let us try to
Uber etc. are at various stages of trails understand what exactly we mean by
being made on this Self Driving Cars. Autonomous Car. An autonomous
Well on technological front it is a giant car also known as a driverless car is
Roopesh Janmanchi leap for consumers as it is assumed a vehicle that is capable of sensing
A7-203, Shankeshwar Nagar, driver less cars will be less pronged to its environment and navigating
Manpada Road, Dombivili-East, accidents and may be Zero Accident without human input. Ideally, the only
Thane - 421201. case with more advanced technology role of a human in such a vehicle would
rj_janmanchi@rediffmail.com that may take place along with other be indicating the destination.

80 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA MOTOR INSURANCE
A formal classification1 system for Snap of Motor Insurance and 3) Quest for better life Style and
automated cars has been proposed by General Insurance Business better Purchasing power driving
the National Highway Traffic Safety motor sales thereby increasing
Gross Premium underwritten by
Administration: insurance business leading
Non-Life Insurers within India upto
to growth in Motor Insurance
Level 0: Driver has complete control 31st March 2017 stands at 1, 27,631
business
of vehicle at all times. Crores. Out of these, Motor Segment
Level 1: Some vehicle controls are contributes 39% of the Gross Premium Advantage to Autonomous Car:
automated, e.g. automatic braking. Underwritten which is 50,245.19  There would be no driver and less
Crores. (Source: IRDA Web Site) mistakes on the road
Level 2: Two or more controls can
be automated at the same time, e.g. One can easily say that Motor Insurance  Accident caused by drunk and
cruise control and lane keeping. is the largest contributor for General drugged drivers would be thing of
Insurance Company in terms of past
Level 3: The driver can cede control in
Premium. With increase in new players
certain circumstances.  There would be no need for driver’s
coming into foray we can expect
licenses or driving test
Level 4: Driver not expected to play this segment to grow substantially
any part in the driving process at all. continuously beating other line of  Self-aware cars would lead to a
business. reduction in car theft
Gross Premium
Why Motor Insurance Segment  Sensor technology could potentially
underwritten by Non-Life perceive the environment better
Contributes so much:
Insurers within India upto than human senses far ahead,
Let’s try to understand why Motor
31st March 2017 stands insurance beat almost every other Line
better visibility, early and easy
detection of obstacles thereby
at 1, 27,631 Crores. Out of Business in terms of premium.
leading to less accident
of these, Motor Segment 1) Motor Vehicles Act 1988 makes
All these points will lead to less or no
contributes 39% of it mandatory for all vehicle to be
accident and absence of drivers totally
covered under an appropriate
the Gross Premium over a period of time as technology
insurance policy before they evolves more rapidly.
Underwritten which can ply on road. The minimum
is 50,245.19 Crores. requirement in terms of insurance Here all stakeholders may have to
revisit list of covers that are currently
(Source: IRDA Web Site) is that a vehicle must at least
being offered be it under Package
have a Third Party legal Liability
One can easily say that insurance before it can driven on a
Policy or Liability only Policy. Though
Motor Insurance is public road.
Liability policy may hold good for more
time with a catch explained later.
the largest contributor A third-party insurance policy for
Below covers will definitely be
for General Insurance motor vehicle provides coverage
redundant since Vehicles won’t require
against certain unfortunate events
Company in terms of Drivers.
that lead to heavy expenses
Premium. With increase arising from an accident that led 1) PA to Owner Driver
in new players coming to injuries, damages, or death of a 2) PA to Paid Driver
into foray we can third party. In such a case, insurer
3) Additional PA Cover to Owner
is liable to pay for the expenses
expect this segment Driver
incurred due to that incident.
to grow substantially 4) Additional PA Cover to Paid Driver
2) Fear of bearing huge Litigation cost
continuously beating and damage to Vehicle leads to Once fear of accident vanishes
other line of business. purchase of Motor Insurance from customer’s mind, people may

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 81


MOTOR INSURANCE THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

not purchase Motor Insurance. Above two scenarios will be bigger Motor Vehicles Act 1988
Even government or IRDA may be problem than human caused accidents.
forced to have a relook on Motor
makes it mandatory for
One questions that arises in mind is
Vehicle act wherein Liability Policy that in the age of driverless car, if due
all vehicle to be covered
is compulsory. Upto 31st March to technical glitches, if there is an under an appropriate
2017, Gross Premium Written for accident, damage to Car, Third Party insurance policy before
Motor OD and Motor TP stands at Property, TP Death etc. who will be held
23,724.89 crores & 26,520.30 crores accountable since there is no human
they can ply on road. The
respectively. (As per IRDA Website) to drive car. Whether Manufacturing minimum requirement in
It would not be incorrect to say that Company will be held accountable for terms of insurance is that
said figures would be in danger if in liability that may arise due to same
and whether they will be ready to bear
a vehicle must at least
future autonomous car becomes a
reality in near future. Reduction in same. have a Third Party legal
Premium may definitely have an impact It may lead to addition of new covers Liability insurance before
on profitability in Insurance sector and that insurance company will have to it can driven on a public
capability to Invest in market. There rethink. Rating parameters may be
by impacting health of overall Industry changed thereby having direct link on
road.
growth. This in turn may to Job Loss premium. Will these lead to increase/ A third-party insurance
across industry especially in Motor decrease in Premium drastically time
Segment. will tell since premium is directly
policy for motor vehicle
related to claim cost. Claim cost may be provides coverage against
One important point I would like to
draw attention is that, when technology
higher since more complex machines certain unfortunate
will be used to ensure accident free. But
comes into picture, it has its own
will it offset lesser frequency of claims
events that lead to heavy
disadvantages.
that will arise?? expenses arising from
1) There is every possibility that
One may argue such cars will be a an accident that led to
technical glitches will be very
common feature once autonomous
distant dream especially in a country like injuries, damages, or
India where Infrastructure is not upto the
cars kicks in.
mark. Cost of such cars would be very
death of a third party.
2) Security of Autonomous Car i.e. high thereby skipping mass population In such a case, insurer
hacking of such cars may be where budget cars are more popular and is liable to pay for the
possible and create a havoc on road. high end car for a select few.
expenses incurred due to
that incident.
With rapid advancement of technology,
that day may not be far when we may
see driverless cars on road with no
accidents.

References:
1
https://axleaddict.com/safety/
Advantages-and-Disadvantages-of-
Driverless-Cars

IRDA Website

82 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA SILKWORM

Tasar Silkworm and Sericulture Insurance

Keywords from central and state government.


Central Silk Board closely monitors
Sericulture, silkworms, tasar food
the implementation. The purpose of
plants, cocoons, grainage house,
sericulture insurance is to indemnify
rearing activity, rearers, disease free
the beneficiaries against death of
layings, clandestine sale, pebrine,
silkworms due to accident or diseases
proposal form.
during the policy period.
Abstract Introduction
India is the only country producing all Where villages are affected with poor
the four known commercial varieties health, ignorance, illiteracy, domestic
of silks in the world namely, mulberry, violence, child labour, ill mentality,
tasar, eri and muga. Sericulture is a child marriage and dowry, a step
labour intensive industry in India with towards silkworms raising may force
Rathindranath Banerjee
Administrative Officer employment generation of about 8 them to utilize their qualitative time in
The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., million people per annum. A special income generating activities to support
Bankura Branch, Vidya Bhawan, project for development of tasar the ailing children, poor peasant
Machantola, Bankura - 722101. culture started in different districts of parents, old people, widow, separated
rathindra.nath@orientalinsurance.co.in West Bengal with financial assistance and deserted women.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 83


SILKWORM THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

Tasar culture is one of the primary the most important thing is the leaf so Sericulture Insurance
occupations among the tribals in and the trees are reared in such a way that
The insurance covers death of
around the forest. Rearing of tasar they should produce more of quality
silkworms due to accident or diseases
silkworms is conducted in the forest. leaf. Yellow, brownish, dry, brittle,
during the policy period subject to
In India there are about 11 million fungal affected leaves are unsuitable for
the terms, conditions, warranties,
hectre of tasar food plants in dense rearing. So they are removed from the
endorsements and exclusions of the
tropical forest in Madhya Pradesh, trees. The total cost of plantation and
policy. The insurance coverage is
Andhra Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Bihar, maintenance is very less. Tasar culture
provided to disease free laying (DFLs)
Jharkhand, West Bengal, Orissa and is managed by labourer family as
supplied by the Central or State
out of them only 5% are utilised for this is considered as an employment.
Leaf loss may be considered as a big Government silk board. The policy starts
tasar culture. The main tasar food
problem as this means less amount of from the date the farmers purchase
plants include Terminalia arjuna (Arjun)
food for the larva. eggs and upto the period of disposing of
and Terminalia tomentosa (Asan). To
cocoons in the market.
develop the tasar silk industry tasar The process of rearing comprises of
culture is to be utilised vastly and four production stages. These are: (The following is a report received from
systematically. Rapid and continuous seed, cocoon, yarn and fabric. The the Centre for Women’s Development
destruction of tropical forest is a rearing process includes: (i) incubation Studies, Head Office at New Delhi, Field
big challenge in this industry. Tasar care to eggs, (ii) transferring neonate Office at Khatra, Bankura, West Bengal)
culture is being practiced by tribals larvae, (iii) feeding and protection As of June 2017, more than 50 village
in the natural forest areas near to the of young larvae, (iv) harvesting of level groups, “Nari Vikash Sangha” and
dwellings. Enough density of Terminalia cocoons and handling of spinning “Nari Kalyan Samitis” with membership
arjuna (Arjun) and Terminalia worms. of around 5000 women exist in various
tomentosa (Asan) trees are not
The process of transportation & parts of Bankura, Purulia and Paschim
available in the deep forest. So tasar
hatching of eggs is done very carefully. Medinipur districts of West Bengal. They
silk worms may not be reared there
The eggs are saved from direct own nearly 700 acres of wasteland on
profitably. It is necessary to improve
sunlight, water, fumes and severity which more than 1.6 million trees have
the quality and quantity of tasar food
of climate. Humidity associated with been planted for tasar silk rearing which
plants. Quality of leaves is also very
high temperature increases the chance provides them employment for nearly 5
important here. So a full green tree
of disease. The infected larvae losses months per year.
in the natural forest is most suitable.
its brightness and becomes sluggish
Now a days with the improvement of Information Required in the
with reduced feeding. The infected one
science and technology and by taking Proposal Form
becomes long, soft and thin and it does
previous experience tasar culture Before considering the proposal the
not respond to external stimuli.
has become simple but yet to take an insurer needs to have the following
impression among all. It is the duty of Cocoons serve as the basic material
information from the insured:
the concerned government and private for tasar industry and hence the
importance of rearing. Good cocoons 1. Name and address of the rearer
sector employees related with the
industry to make the concerned primary are taken to the grainage house for 2. Location of the rearing house and
participants in tasar silk production to seed rising and sun dried if it is used the area of plantation
update with the new technology and commercially. Care should be taken 3. Breed of silk worm
educate them. not to make any defective and un- 4. Identification of silk worm
reelable cocoons. Tasar rearing activity
Tasar Rearing Process 5. Total no. of layings
also provides household fuel and the
6. Date of purchase and source of
Tasar silk rearing process is on the grass underneath provide enough
purchase of DFLs
trees grown on uncultivated wasteland. fodder to the livestock. This activity
In tasar culture the silkworms are 7. Date of hatching
also helps indirectly to conserve the
reared outdoors on the trees of proper soil and control water level underneath 8. Expected date of cocoon disposal
height and shape. As in rearing of larva the soil. 9. Price of DFLs

84 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA SILKWORM
10. Arrangement of security 13. Larvae should be examined during be extended to the beneficiaries upon
11. Loss history during the past three different stages. specific demand. Beneficiaries are the
years 14. The rearer has to follow all farmers who are rearing silkworms,
12. What precautions are taken against the instructions given by the they are called sericulturists. It can be
pests and diseases department from time to time. extended to the family members of the
13. Whether the project is from central/ 15. On occurrence of any disease beneficiaries. The beneficiaries may
state subsidiary scheme or not. immediate steps shall be taken opt for family package policy (when
to avoid further spreading of the policy comprises the insured
14. If bank and any financing agency is
diseases.
interested in the project. and spouse, dependent children
16. Weekly/fortnightly silkworm crop and dependent parents) or long
Care & Maintenance progress report to be submitted term policy (which may be extended
regularly to ascertain the stage of
1. The beneficiary shall at all times beyond 12 months and upto 5 years).
the worms, health of the larvae,
exercise reasonable care and Family package discount or long term
survival percentage. Proper
diligence in the selection of labour discount may be available at that time.
remarks should be mentioned
to maintain silkworms. The insured has to select an agreed
against reasons for mortality.
2. The waste leaf, dead worms, waste sum insured limit and which cannot
17. The beneficiaries shall maintain the
materials should be removed from be altered during the currency of the
rearing card, log sheet, rearer pass
the premises. policy.
book.
3. All required management practices 18. The insured should preserve all Exceptions
should be followed in respect of records regarding distribution of
rearing premises, equipments, and 1. Malicious, willful, negligent act
DFLs.
accessories.
19. In the event of any attack of 2. Theft, clandestine sale
4. Appropriate rearing method to disease or pests or calamities 3. Loss due to pebrine (a disease of
be adopted during the rearing of which may cause loss, the insurer
young silkworms. silkworms caused by protozoan)
should be intimated immediately.
5. Proper precaution is taken during 4. War, nuclear perils
PA Coverage
spinning cocoon to pick the larvae 5. Loss due to ants, rodents, lizards,
in correct time. The Tasar silk worm rearers / farmers
birds, squirrels, beetles
are prone to different accidental
6. It is to be checked regularly 6. Diseases contracted by the
hazards due to their working culture
whether silk worms are free from
in the remote forest areas. Many silkworms prior to commencement
diseases, defects, epidemics,
incidences of snake bite, falling from of risk.
parasitical attacks or not.
trees, strike by lightning during the 7. Consequential loss of any kind
7. Adequate hygienic condition
rearing process or allied activities are
in the rearing place should be 8. Transferring by any media
reported in the past. So they need to
maintained.
be protected through personal lines 9. Timely preventive and control
8. Proper atmospheric conditions to accident insurance coverage. measures are not taken
be maintained.
Personal accident policy covers 10. Rearing of eggs which are not free
9. Handling of worms to be done accidental death, accidental from diseases.
effectively. bodily injuries, permanent partial 11. Claims can be entertained only
10. Adequate space/ rearing material disablement, permanent total once for a particular crop.
should be maintained. disablement or temporary disablement,
12. Partial loss can be determined only
11. Cross contamination of disease loss of limbs, loss of eyes. Accidental
after sale of cocoons.
should be avoided. bodily injury is solely and directly
caused by external, violent and 13. Loss due to terrorism act
12. The silkworms should be reared
visible means. The reimbursement 14. PA coverage to drug addicts or
with all specific techniques.
of hospitalization expenses may also alcoholics.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 85


SILKWORM THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

State Wise Silk Production during 2014-15 Conclusion:

Tasar culture is related to textile


State Mulberry (MT) Tasar (MT) Eri (MT) Muga (MT) Total (MT)
industry. The main purpose of tasar
Andhra Pradesh 6485 6485
culture is to produce textile fabrics
Arunachal 1 10 1 12
from the cocoons produced by the
Pradesh
tasar silkworms with the use of latest
Assam 31 3055 136 3222
technological operations. The quality
Bihar 12 33 8 53
of the silk depends on the quality
Chattisgarh 8 225 234
of the cocoons. Tasar rearers have
Haryana 0.3 0.3
to take a lot of difficulties regarding
Himachal 30 30
tasar silkworm seed rearing,
Pradesh
arrangement of their proper feeding,
Jammu & 138 138
and prevention against different
Kashmir
diseases, pests and predators.
Jharkhand 3 1943 1946
Karnataka 9645 9645 This is a field based project activity.
Kerala 7 7 Women’s groups where every
Madhya Pradesh 187 59 1.5 248 members are inclined towards both
Maharashtra 202 19 221 traditional and non traditional
Manipur 150 4 361 1 516 economic activities are founded
Meghalaya 17 622 16 656 in remote pockets to promote
Mizoram 40 0.02 10 0.1 50 the concept of sericulture. Now
Nagaland 6 0.1 610 3 619 a days different non government
Odisha 3 88 7 98 organizations, members of Indian
Council of Social Science Research
Punjab 4 4
and women self help groups at
Sikkim 5 3 0.17 8
regional level are taking interest
Tamil Nadu 1602 1602
in sericulture and sericulture
Telangana 100 0.26 101
insurance. Help from different
Tripura 48 48
labour organizations makes the
Uttar Pradesh 186 18 32 236
project fruitful. A major programme
Uttarakhand 29 0.02 0.23 29
of development of Tasar culture
West Bengal 2450 43 6 0.27 2499
through these women groups are
Grand Total 21389 2434 4726 158 28708
implemented with the technical
The Organizational Offices of Central Silk Board is given below: and financial support of the United
Nations Development Programme and
Zone Regional cum Zonal Office States Covered the Central Silk Board. The project
RO Delhi Northern Zone Punjab, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, becomes internationally familiar with
Rajasthan, Uttarakhand, Jammu and the assistance of World Bank, IMF,
Kashmir, Uttar Pradesh European Union. With the increase of
the concept of sericulture the need
RO Kolkata Eastern Zone West Bengal, Odisha, Madhya Pradesh,
for insurance will be raised.
Chhattisgarh, Bihar, Jharkhand
RO Chennai Southern Zone Tamil Nadu, Maharashtra, Gujarat, References
Karnataka, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh,
Study material from Central Tasar
Telangana
Research and Training Institute (Govt.
RO North Eastern Zone Eight North Eastern States of India, Ministry of textiles), Annual
Guwahati report of Central Silk Board

86 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA SILKWORM

S
THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

L F O R PA PER
CAL
We invite articles/papers for the issues October – December 2018
of ‘The Journal’ of Insurance Institute of Award Winning Articles of Essay Writing
India for the year 2018. Competition 2018.

We request you to send your articles/


April – June 2018
papers to journal@iii.org.in on or before the
Any topic on insurance or allied areas. due dates.
Last date of submission of papers/articles
No enquiries will be entertained post
will be 28th February, 2018.
submission of articles.

July – September 2018 Knowledge Management Center


Theme for July-September 2018 issue Insurance Institute of India
of ‘The Journal’ is ‘Insurance : Learning Plot No. C-46, G Block,
from Global Best Practices’. Bandra-Kurla Complex,
Bandra (East),
Last date of submission of papers/articles
Mumbai - 400051.
will be 31st May, 2018.
www.insuranceinstituteofindia.com

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 87


OCTOBER-DECEM BER 2017 111
The
THE Journal
JOURNAL of
OF Insurance InsTITuTe of
INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF IndIa
INDIA

Guidelines for contributors of the Journal


note to the contributors: such as full postal address, to follow American Psychological
telephone and fax number of the Association (APA) style in
“The Journal” is quarterly publication of
corresponding author must be referencing.
Insurance Institute of India, Mumbai. It
clearly indicated. The category of
is published in the month of Jan/April/
submission should be specified reference to a Book: Author. (Year).
July/Oct every year. “The Journal”
either as a research paper, article, Title of book. Location: Publisher.
covers wide range of issues related to
review, case study etc.
insurance and allied areas. The Journal
Example: Rogers, C. R. (1961).
welcomes original contributions from Point no. 4, 5, 6 and 7 are On becoming a person. Boston:
both academicians and practitioners in applicable only for articles, case Houghton Mifflin.
the form of articles, research papers, studies and research papers.
case studies, special commentary and reference to a Journal Publication:
book reviews. Authors whose papers are 4. abstract: A concise abstract of
Author(s). (Year). Title of the article/
published will be given honorarium and maximum 150 words is required.
paper. Journal name, volume
two copies of the Journal. The abstract should adequately
(issue), page number(s).
highlight the key aspects or state the
Guidelines to the contributors: objectives, methodology and the Example: Smith, L. V. (2000).
results/major conclusions of Referencing articles in APA format.
1. Manuscript submitted to the Editor
analysis. The abstract should APA Format Weekly, 34(1), 4-10.
must be typed in MS-Word. The
include only text.
Length of the articles and case
studies should not exceed 5000 reference to a Web source: Author.
5. Keywords: Immediately after the
words. Research papers length can (Date published if available; n.d.--no
abstract, provide around 3-6
be upto 10,000 words. For book date-- if not). Title of article. Title of
keywords or phrases.
reviews and commentaries the word web site. Retrieved date. From URL.
limit may be upto 1500-2000 words. 6. Tables and figures: Diagrams,
Tables and Charts cited in the text Example: Landsberger, J. (n.d.).
2. General rules for formatting text: must be serially numbered and Citing Websites. In Study Guides
source of the same should be and Strategies. Retrieved May 13,
i. Page size : A4 (8.27” X 11.69”) 2005, from http://www.studygs.net/
mentioned clearly wherever
ii. Font: Times New Roman necessary. All such tables and citation.htm.
– Normal, black figures should be titled accurately
and all titles should be placed on the 8. Usage of abbreviations in the text
iii. Line spacing: Double
top after the number. Example: Table should be avoided as far as possible
iv. Font size: Title-14, Sub-titles– 1: Growth Rate of Insurance and if used should be appropriately
12, Body- 11 Normal, Diagrams/ Premium in India (1997-2010). expanded.
Tables/Charts– 11 or 10.
7. references: all the referred material 9. The papers and articles submitted
3. The first page of the Manuscript (including those from authors own must be original work and it should
should contain the following publication) in the text must be not have been published or
information: (i) Title of the paper; appropriately cited. All references submitted for publication elsewhere.
(ii) The name(s) and institutional must be listed in alphabetical order The author(s) are required to submit
affiliation(s) of the Author(s); (iii) and sorted chronologically and a declaration to this extent in the
email address for correspondence. must be placed at the end of the format specified in Appendix 1,
Other details for correspondence manuscript. The authors are advised while submitting their articles.

112
88 october-december
JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 2017
The
THEJournal
JOURNALof
OFInsurance
INSURANCEInsTITuTe
INSTITUTEof
OFIndIa
INDIA

10. All the submissions would be first 15. Copyright of the published articles weaknesses. The review should be
evaluated by the editor and then by and papers would rest with “The about the books contribution to the
the editorial Committee. Editorial Journal of Insurance Institute of subject rather than what the
committee may require the author to India” and any further reproduction reviewer feels about the book.
revise the manuscript as per the would require prior and written
7. The reviewer should try to make the
guidelines and policy of the Journal. permission of the Editor.
review insightful and informative.
The final draft is subject to editorial
changes to suit the journals specific Guidelines for Book specific Guidelines for case
requirements. Editorial Committee reviews: studies:
also reserves its right to refer the 1. The book review should be of a 1. Cases usually describe complex
article for review/ delete book published in recent years issues and readers are forced to
objectionable content/ edit without (current year or previous year). take optimum decisions/action in a
changing the main idea/ make dilemmatic situation. Cases are
2. The review should not be more than
language corrections/ not to meant to create challenges of
2000 words; word limit can be
publish/ publish with caveats as per decision making in the mind of
more/less depending on the scope
its discretion. The Author would be readers regarding conflicting
of the book.
duly communicated with such situations, insufficient information,
decisions. 3. The reviewer should clearly mention dynamic environment and the like.
11. Contribution(s) should reach the the details of the book reviewed
2. The authors of the case studies can
designated email address at III on or such as Title, Author(s) name,
take organization specific or
before 30th November (January publishers detail, year of
industry specific issues and present
issue), 28th February (April issue), publication, place of publication,
the facts of the case in a logical way.
31st May (July issue) and number of pages and listed price as
mentioned on the cover page of the 3. The case study should be well
31st August (October issue).
book. If the ISBN number is documented and well researched
12. Please send your manuscripts to provided, it should be specified. and must be realistic in its context
Beside the above, the components and relevance.
The Editor, The Journal of Insurance
Institute of India, Insurance Institute of the book review should be brief
4. Sufficient data (primary or
of India Plot no. C-46, G-Block, Near summary of the intended objective/
secondary) should be incorporated
Dhirubhai Ambani International purpose, description of the
within a case study for discussion
school, Bandra-Kurla Complex, approach, logical and objective
and generating alternative solutions
Bandra (East), Mumbai-400051. evaluation.
and identifying the best possible
or 4. The references should be kept to the alternative. Prior approval for
minimum or completely avoided in a disclosure of information (company
Electronically Mail to <journal@iii.
book review. specific) must be taken by the
org.in> with subject line as
author wherever applicable.
“Contribution for “The Journal” – 5. Avoid replicating tables and figures
January/April/July/October (Mention from the book, or directly quoting 5. The issues that are raised in the
Year) issue. from the book. case should be focused and must be
effectively presented without any
13. In case the author has submitted
6. The review should not be just a ambiguity or contradictions.
only the hard copy, an electronic
summary of the book, but it should
version of the manuscript would be 6. All the referenced material should be
bring out the essence of the book
required once the paper is accepted adequately and accurately cited at
and focus on the objective, theme,
for publication. the end of the case.
scope of coverage, etc. The book
14. All enquiries related to the review should put forward an 7. Discussion questions can be
submissions should be addressed objective and fair opinion about the provided at the end of case
only to the Editor. significance, strengths and (optional).

october-december 2017
JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 89
113
THE Journal
The JOURNAL of
OF Insurance
INSURANCE InsTITuTe
INSTITUTE of
OF IndIa
INDIA

appendix I

declaration by the authors

I/We (full name of the author(s))..................................................................................

…………………...…….....…....……, hereby declare that I/We are the author(s) of the paper titled

“……..........………………...………………………………………………………………………..”

(Title of the paper), which is our original work and not the intellectual property of any one else. I/we

further declare that this paper has been submitted only to the Journal of the Insurance Institute of India

and that it has not been previously published nor submitted for publication elsewhere. I/we have duly

acknowledged and referenced all the sources used for this paper. I/we further authorize the editors to

make necessary changes in this paper to make it suitable for publication.

I/we undertake to accept full responsibility for any misstatement regarding ownership of this article.

……………………… ………………………..

(signature author I) (signature author II)

name: name:

date:

Place:

90
114 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 2017
october-december
THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

TRAINING PROGRAMS
SR No CODE SUB PROGRAM DATE FROM-TO FEES FOR FEES FOR NON- DESIGNED FOR
CODE RESIDENTS RESIDENTS
April 2018
1 CP C1 Compliance 16-18 April, 2018 ` 12900 + G.S.T. ` 9300 + G.S.T. Exclusive Program for
Governance and those registered for the
Risk Management Insurance Regulatory
in Insurance Compliance Governance
Course.
2 CP L1 Onward to MDRT 23-24 April, 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. High performing agents of
- Building Sales Life Insurance Companies
Champions being groomed for
membership to the MDRT
3 CP B1 Bancassurance 23-24 April, 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Managers / Executives
dealing with
Bancassurance in
insurance companies and
banks.
May 2018
4 CP L2 Underwriting 2-3 May, 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Underwriting Managers
Management : Life and Executives in Life
Insurance Companies
5 CP L3 Business 7-8 May, 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Business Development
Development Managers of Life insurance
Managers : Life Companies.
6 CP G1 Motor Insurance 14-15 May, 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Insurance officials working
Fraud in Motor, Audit, Fraud
control departments,
Brokers, Surveyors or
Investigator are also
welcome.
7 CP G2 Agriculture 21-22 May, 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Professionals in insurance
Insurance companies, Brokers /
Surveyors having 2 years
exposure to agriculture /
rural insurance

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 91


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

SR No CODE SUB PROGRAM DATE FROM-TO FEES FOR FEES FOR NON- DESIGNED FOR
CODE RESIDENTS RESIDENTS
8 CP G3 Health Medical 21-23 May, 2018 ` 12900 + G.S.T. ` 9300 + G.S.T. Executives working in the
Management claims departments of
including Fraud health insurers and TPA.
Control Also Associates / Fellows
and others having a fair
awareness about health
insurance.
June 2018
9 CP G4 Aviation Insurance 4-6 June, 2018 ` 12900 + G.S.T. ` 9300 + G.S.T. Executives working in
the Aviation department
of General Insurance
Companies / Brokers /
Surveyors.
10 CP G5 Engineering 11-12 June, 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Insurance officials / Brokers
Project Claims / Surveyors / Customers
having awareness about
Project Insurance basics.
11 IP G6 International 18-23 June, 2018 $ 600 USD International Participants-
Program Executives working
-Reinsurance in General Insurance
Management Companies in Re-
insurance, Underwriting
and claims
12 CP G7 Appreciation 25-26 June, 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Junior and Middle Level
Program on Executives dealing with
Liability Lines Liability Insurance
July 2018
13 CP G8 Motor Insurance 2- 3 July, 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Junior and Middle
Liability Executives working for
Workshop Insurance companies,
Broking firms and
Surveyors.
14 CP L4 Marketing 2-3 July, 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Branch Managers /
Strategies – for Marketing Unit heads with
Branch and other 2-3 years experience
Marketing Unit
Heads : Life
15 CP B2 Bancassurance for 9-10 July, 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Managers / Executives
Bankers : Life dealing with
Bancassurance in Banks
16 CP G9 Health Insurance 9-11 July, 2018 ` 12900 + G.S.T. ` 9300 + G.S.T. Middle Level Executives of
Third Party Administrators,
Insurance Companies,
Broking Firms and
Hospitals.

92 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

SR No CODE SUB PROGRAM DATE FROM-TO FEES FOR FEES FOR NON- DESIGNED FOR
CODE RESIDENTS RESIDENTS
17 CP G10 Marine Cargo 16-19 July, 2018 ` 17200 + G.S.T. ` 12400 + G.S.T. Junior and middle level
Insurance Executives dealing with
Marine Cargo from
Insurance Companies,
Brokers, Surveyors and
Customers
18 CP C2 Certified 19-21 July, 2018 ` 12900 + G.S.T. ` 9300 + G.S.T. Exclusive program
Insurance for those registered
Anti Fraud for certified Insurance
Professionals Anti-Fruad professionals
course.
19 CP G11 Claims 23-24 July, 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Middle Level Executives
Management of General Insurance
of Property Companies
Insurance
20 CP G12 Rural and Micro 30 July - ` 12900 + G.S.T. ` 9300 + G.S.T. Insurance Executives
Insurance 01 Aug., 2018 looking after Rural and
Micro Insurance in General
Insurance Companies,
Brokers, communities,
reinsurers and banks.
August 2018
21 IP G13 Excellence in 30 Jul - $ 1200 USD - Junior and Middle
Insurance - 11 Aug, 2018 level executives of the
Technical International Insurance
Industry
22 CP G14 Liability Insurance 20-21 Aug., 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Practitioners from
Focus - Cyber Insurance Companies,
Crime Brokers, Customers, the
Information Technology
industry and related areas.
23 CP S1 Technical Aspects 20-21 Aug., 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Insurance officials working
of Various Fire in risk management
Protection inspection as Underwriting
Systems / Brokers, Surveyors and
Customers.
24 CP G15 Mega Risk 27-29 Aug., 2018 ` 12900 + G.S.T. ` 9300 + G.S.T. Insurance Executives
Insurance looking after Property /
Engineering in Insurance
Companies, Brokers,
reinsurers, Surveyors and
Customers.
September 2018
25 CP G16 Motor Insurance 4-5 Sept., 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Insurance officials working
Fraud in Motor, Audit and Fraud
control departments with
a fair awareness of motor
insurance.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 93


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

SR No CODE SUB PROGRAM DATE FROM-TO FEES FOR FEES FOR NON- DESIGNED FOR
CODE RESIDENTS RESIDENTS
26 CP G17 Actuarial Science 4-6 Sept., 2018 ` 12900 + G.S.T. ` 9300 + G.S.T. Middle Level Executives
for Non-Life of General Insurance
Insurance Companies, Broking firms,
III Associates / Fellows.

27 CP S2 One Day Technical 08 Sept., 2018 ` 4300+ G.S.T. ` 3100+ G.S.T. Executives in General
Worksop On Insurance companies /
The Subject Of Brokers / Customers having
Renewable Energy some awareness about the
subject.

28 CP G18 Management 10-11 Sept., 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Middle Level Executives
of Property from the underwriting
Insurance - Fire department of Insurance
(Underwriting) Companies

29 CP G19 Marine Hull 24-27 Sept., 2018 ` 17200 + G.S.T. ` 12400 + G.S.T. Middle Level Executives
Insurance working in the marine hull
departments of Insurance
companies / Brokers / Loss
Adjuster / Customers.

October 2018

30 CP B3 Bancassurance for 3-4 Oct., 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Managers/ Executives
Life Insurers dealing with Bancassurance
in Life insurance companies
and banks

31 CP G20 Reinsurance 08-10 Oct., 2018 ` 12900 + G.S.T. ` 9300 + G.S.T. Participants are expected
Treaty issues and to have exposure to
Challenges (Focus Reinsurance related areas
- Reinsurance
treaty designing)

32 CP G21 Liability Insurance 15-16 Oct., 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Junior Middle Level
Focus - Financial executives of Insurance
Lines Companies, Brokers,
Surveyors, Customers.

33 CP S3 Advanced 22-24 Oct., 2018 ` 12900 + G.S.T. ` 9300 + G.S.T. Insurance buyers, Risk
Workshop on Oil Managers, Agents, Brokers,
and Energy Underwriters, Adjusters,
Attorneys, and professionals
from the oil and gas
sector, drilling contractors/
companies.

34 IP L5 International 22-27 Oct., 2018 $ 600 USD - Middle Level officials of


Life Insurance Life Insurance Companies
Program / Brokers. 

94 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

SR No CODE SUB PROGRAM DATE FROM-TO FEES FOR FEES FOR NON- DESIGNED FOR
CODE RESIDENTS RESIDENTS
35 CP S4 Risk Assessment 29-30 Oct., 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Insurance buyers, Risk
in Chemical Managers, Agents,
Industries Brokers, Underwriters,
Adjusters and
Professionals from
Chemical Manufacturing
Industry
November 2018
36 CP G22 Risk Management 12-14 Nov., 2018 ` 12900 + G.S.T. ` 9300 + G.S.T. Managers working
and PML - for General Insurance
Significance Companies and Brokers
in U/W and Risk
Assessment
37 CP C3 Compliance 12-14 Nov., 2018 ` 12900 + G.S.T. ` 9300 + G.S.T. Exclusive Program for
Governance and those registered for the
Risk Management Insurance Regulatory
in Insurance Compliance Governance
course.

38 CP G23 Handling of 19- 20 Nov., 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Junior & Middle
Marine Cargo Level Executives from
Claims Insurance Companies,
Brokers, Surveyors and
Customers.
39 CP G24 Management 26-28 Nov., 2018 ` 12900 + G.S.T. ` 9300 + G.S.T. Middle Level Executives
of Property from the underwriting
Insurance - department of Insurance
Engineering Companies Brokers /
Project Customers.
(Underwriting)

40 CP G25 Motor Insurance 26-29 Nov., 2018 ` 17200 + G.S.T. ` 12400 + G.S.T. Executives from
(Own Damage) Insurance Companies,
Workshop Broking firms and
Surveyors dealing with
Motor Insurance.
41 IP G26 International 26 Nov. - $ 1200 USD - Middle level officials
General Insurance 08 Dec., 2018 of General Insurance
Program Companies / Broking
firms.

42 CP S5 Two Days 30 Nov. - ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Officials working in


Workshop On The 01 Dec., 2018 General Insurance
Insurance Needs company, intermediaries
Of Construction Bankers & Professionals
Industry from construction
industry.

JANUARY - MARCH - 2018 95


THE JOURNAL OF INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

SR No CODE SUB PROGRAM DATE FROM-TO FEES FOR FEES FOR NON- DESIGNED FOR
CODE RESIDENTS RESIDENTS
December 2018
43 CP G27 Engineering 3-4 Dec., 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Junior / Middle Level
Claims (Non- Executives of General
Project) Insurance Companies
/ Brokers / Surveyors /
Customers.
44 CP G28 Business 10-11 Dec., 2018 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Junior Middle Level
Interruption Executives of General
Insurance Companies
/ Brokers / Surveyors /
Customers and Buyers
of Business interruption
policies.
45 CP L6 Advanced 17-21 Dec., 2018 ` 21500 + G.S.T. ` 15500 + G.S.T. Young Managers /
Program for Executives Life Insurance
Young Companies.
Leaders : Life
46 CP C4 Certified 20-22 Dec., 2018 ` 12900 + G.S.T. ` 9300 + G.S.T. Exclusive program for
Insurance those registered for
Anti Fraud Certified Insurance
Professionals Anti-Fruad professionals
course.
January 2019
47 CP G29 Marine Cargo 7-10 Jan., 2019 ` 17200 + G.S.T. ` 12400 + G.S.T. Junior and Middle Level
Insurance Executives dealing with
Marine Cargo Insurance
Companies, Brokers and
Surveyors.
48 CP G30 Claims 14-15 Jan., 2019 ` 8600 + G.S.T. ` 6200 + G.S.T. Junior Middle Level
Management Executives of General
of Property Insurance Companies
Insurance / Brokers / Surveyors /
Customers
February 2019
49 IP G31 Excellence in 04-16 Feb, 2019 $ 1200 USD - Junior and Middle
Insurance - level executives of the
Technical International Insurance
Industry
NB :- Fees quoted are exclusive of mandatory Goods Services Taxes, which will be payble over and above Tuition Fees mentioned in
each Program.

96 JANUARY - MARCH - 2018


Online Lending Library
INSURANCE INSTITUTE OF INDIA

GROUp CORpORATE
MEMbERShIp
Insurance Institute of India has introduced a new segment in Online Lending Library named Group Corporate
Membership (GCM) especially for corporates. In GCM, various branches/depts. of a Company can enjoy library
facility. Corporates can enjoy a rich collection of books on Insurance, Risk, Reinsurance, Liability insurance,
Finance, Tax, Law, Management & many more.

GCM MEMbERShIp GCM SERvICES


pARTICULARS pLAN 1 pLAN 2 pLAN 3 More than 5000 books to choose from
NO. OF bRANChES/DEpT. 5 10 15
Free office delivery & pick up of books
REFUNDAbLE SECURITY 100000 200000 300000
DEpOSIT
Delivery within 48 hours from order
ANNUAL FEE 75000 125000 175000
GST 18% GST ON 18% GST ON 18% GST ON Multiple logins for each Company
ANNUAL FEE ANNUAL FEE ANNUAL FEE
NO. OF LOGIN 5 10 15 Back issues of last 6 months of National/International
Journals on Insurance/Finance/Management will be issued
NO. OF bOOKS pER LOGIN 5 5 5
ISSUE pERIOD 1 MONTH 1 MONTH 1 MONTH Maximum 20 books in total will be issued to Cos.
RENEW pERIOD 1 MONTH 1 MONTH 1 MONTH against GCM

CONTACT DETAILS
Library, Knowledge Management Center, Insurance Institute of India, Plot No. C-46, G Block,
Bandra-Kurla Complex, Bandra (E), Mumbai – 400 051. Phone: 022-26544290
Email: library@iii.org.in l Website: www.insuranceinstituteofindia.com
RNI No. MAHENG/2013/50733 ISSN No. 2278-6759

Insurance InstItute of IndIa


YeejleerÙe yeercee mebmLeeve
ESTABLISHED IN 1955

InsuNews
Weekly e-Newsletter

Subscribe to InsuNews of
Insurance Institute of India,
which gives news about Indian
Insurance Industry, Insurance
Regulations, Reinsurance, Life
& General Insurance & Global
Insurance Industry

Feedback

We will be happy to receive


feedback, suggestions,
opinions, views and queries at
newsletter@iii.org.in

Follow us on Facebook f http://www.facebook.com/#!/pages/Insurance-Institute-of-India/164203300299381

Insurance InstItute of IndIa


YeejleerÙe yeercee mebmLeeve

G-Block, Plot No.C-46, Opp. American Consulate, Bandra Kurla Complex, Mumbai – 400 051.

S-ar putea să vă placă și