Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
com
Implementing Theory of
Constraints in unfamiliar
territory: The Construction
Rental Industry
Name : Albert Van der Wat
Company : PERI Formwork, Scaffold Engineering
Country : Johannesburg, South Africa
Presenter’s
Presenter logo
Content
• Who is PERI?
• Business Scope
• Implementing TOC in:
• Supply Chain
• Sales
• Returns and Maintenance
• Rental
• Current projects running
• Recommendations
Maintenance
When in Doubt…….Go to the problem areas!!
Sales and Maintenance problem areas:
• Always run out of stock!
• Very difficult to plan!
• Have way too much dead stock!
• The market fluctuates too much!
• We never know when maintenance stock is needed!
• Some suppliers are not reliable!
• International supplier lead times fluctuate a lot!
• We forecast, but it is always wrong, so we make a plan…
• Impossible to plan stock!
• Firefighting!
Maintenance
Step 1: Aggregation
Step 1: Aggregation
92% of 8% of Volume
Volume
99% of
Firefighting
Step 1: Aggregation
The Stats:
Articles % Volume % Frequency %
Total 1179 100% 3123103.007 100% 16522 100%
Top 10% 118 10% 2685408.323 86% 12450 75%
Top 20% 236 20% 2866148.287 92% 14106 85%
Bottom 80% 943 80% 256954.72 8% 2416 15%
Johannesburg DC: TRR = Local supplier lead times + Order Lead time (once
a week, now every day)
Cape Town DC (German imports): TRR = Lead time from Germany + Order
lead time (every 2 weeks)
Branches: TRR = 2 weeks
Pol
Nel
Supplier
DWJ
Mid
Up
Rdb
Blm
Dbn
EL
DWC CT
PE
National Replenishment
chain
chain
chain
chain
chain
Growth at DC level
chain
Main
Yard Site
Maintenance Returns
Yard Yard
Where to start?
…When in doubt… go to the problems!
Some rental obstacles:
– Stock is not always available (MAKE A PLAN!)
– Determining what to source takes a long time
– Sourcing from branches takes a long time
– Stock is stuck in maintenance or returns yard (Fire Fighting!)
– Return dates are erratic
– How do we know what stock to keep?
– Someone just poached my stock!
– The other branch does not want to release their stock!
– And....THE CLIENT‘S TRUCK IS HERE! WHERE IS MY STOCK?!
www.tocpractice.com 42 TOCPA International Conference
Presenter’s
20%
SKUs 80% of SKUs
90%
Vol. 10% of Volume
Total Volume % Frequency % Current Avg Util Last Years' Avg Util
Article 685 996856 100% 20859 100% 44% 38%
Top 10% 69 646369 65% 12034 58% 68% 56%
Top 20% 137 809835 81% 15898 76% 64% 52%
Bottom 80% 548 187021 19% 4961 24% 39% 35%
Total Volume % Frequency % Current Avg Util Last Years' Avg Util Total Volume % Frequency % Current Avg Util Last Years' Avg Util
Article 487 868732.4 100% 24004 100% 37% 46% Article 326 438931 100% 11702 100% 31% 47%
Top 10% 49 643298 74% 15165 63% 61% 65% Top 10% 33 229306 52% 5764 49% 42% 64%
Top 20% 97 743238 86% 19615 82% 58% 63% Top 20% 66 351721 80% 8160 70% 44% 61%
Bottom 80% 390 125494.4 14% 4389 18% 31% 42% Bottom 80% 227 87210 20% 3542 30% 28% 44%
Total Volume % Frequency % Current Avg Util Last Years' Avg Util Total Volume % Frequency % Current Avg Util Last Years' Avg Util
Article 410 409508.94 100% 8860 100% 41% 51% Article 348 369015 100% 8536 100% 38% 47%
Top 10% 41 252770.94 62% 4965 56% 48% 63% Top 10% 35 242686 66% 4587 54% 76% 66%
Top 20% 82 311696.94 76% 6801 77% 45% 62% Top 20% 70 309024 84% 6237 73% 62% 62%
Bottom 80% 328 97812 24% 2059 23% 40% 48% Bottom 80% 278 59991 16% 2299 27% 32% 44%
Total Volume % Frequency % Current Avg Util Last Years' Avg Util Total Volume % Frequency % Current Avg Util Last Years' Avg Util
Article 344 342906 100% 7832 100% 41% 47% Article 327 272885.9 100% 6360 100% 22% 50%
Top 10% 34 201511 59% 3772 48% 62% 67% Top 10% 33 146082 54% 2937 46% 39% 64%
Top 20% 69 253772 74% 5451 70% 60% 63% Top 20% 65 191562 70% 4193 66% 35% 63%
Bottom 80% 275 89134 26% 2381 30% 37% 43% Bottom 80% 262 81323.9 30% 2167 34% 19% 47%
Total Volume % Frequency % Current Avg Util Last Years' Avg Util
Article 218 247879 100% 6068 100% 34% 53%
Top 10% 22 159059 64% 3091 51% 55% 67%
Top 20% 44 192603 78% 4310 71% 50% 66%
Bottom 80% 174 55276 22% 1758 29% 31% 50%
Source in Advance
Returns sheet
Stockyard Description PG PG Description Article Description Qty in Return Yard Qty in Maintenance Yard Qty in Main Yard Qty in Sales Stock Buffer in Main Yard Priority Utilisation Peri / Conventional
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 37 PLYWOOD FORMLINING 350740 PLYWOOD BETO 2500X625X21 30 0 -11 0 678 102% 100% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 17 RAPID COLUMN FORMS (ALU) 411964 COLUMN PANEL LICO 700X500 13 0 0 0 36 100% 100% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 60 ZA WALL FORMWORK 660013 EF PANEL 900X100 20 0 0 0 16 100% 100% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 63 ZA SHORING 663008 Q/SHORE LEDGER 600 8 0 0 0 250 100% 100% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 64 ZA SCAFFOLDING SYSTEMS 664045 Q/STAGE LEDGER 1219 1 0 35 0 1838 98% 98% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 63 ZA SHORING 663003 Q/SHORE LEDGER 1200 3 0 9 0 472 98% 97% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 9 ACCESSORIES AND TOOL FOR WALL FORMS 403845 HOOK STRAP UNIVERSAL HBU 1 0 43 0 878 95% 92% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 63 ZA SHORING 663030 Q/SHORE U HEAD JACK 46 0 47 0 744 94% 97% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 63 ZA SHORING 663000 Q/SHORE BASE JACK 45 0 42 0 504 92% 97% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 61 ZA SLAB FORMWORK 661021 AW SLAB STOPEND ANGLE 300 (SA) 107 0 109 0 1182 91% 95% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 24 DOMINO 366067 DOMINO ARTICUL. CORNER DGE 75 1 0 2 0 16 88% 88% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 63 ZA SHORING 663004 Q/SHORE LEDGER 1500 1 0 358 0 2331 85% 92% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 21 SKYDECK 361290 PANEL CLIP SPK 7 0 27 0 144 81% 84% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 17 RAPID COLUMN FORMS (ALU) 411957 COLUMN PANEL LICO 700X1000 15 0 10 0 50 80% 93% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 63 ZA SHORING 663098 Q/SHORE OMEGA CLIP 1 0 40 0 200 80% 86% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 1 GT24 GIRDER 375210 GIRDER GT 24, 210 1 0 127 0 632 80% 86% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 63 ZA SHORING 663036 Q/SHORE VERT BRACE 1500X1500 1 0 188 0 890 79% 77% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 63 ZA SHORING 663001 Q/SHORE BASE SOCKET 18 0 90 0 375 76% 94% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 5 VARIO SYSTEM, STEEL WALES (SRZ) 320330 FOLDING BEARING PLATE 25 1 0 12 0 48 75% 86% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 64 ZA SCAFFOLDING SYSTEMS 664003 Q/STAGE BASE JACK 610 R/O 36 0 324 0 1209 73% 96% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 1 GT24 GIRDER 375390 GIRDER GT 24, 390 21 0 155 0 544 72% 92% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 32 BUILDING EQUIPMENT 426299 PLASTIC SLAB STOPEND ANGLE 15 0 160 0 546 71% 90% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 1 GT24 GIRDER 375510 GIRDER GT 24, 510 1 0 26 0 80 68% 91% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 37 PLYWOOD FORMLINING 637004 PLYWOOD BETO 2500X500X21 28 0 255 0 780 67% 73% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 63 ZA SHORING 663009 Q/SHORE LEDGER 900 13 0 688 0 2000 66% 80% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 17 RAPID COLUMN FORMS (ALU) 411683 COLUMN PANEL LICO 700X3000 32 0 62 0 152 59% 82% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 32 BUILDING EQUIPMENT 415151 GUARDRAIL HOLDER -2 26 1 166 0 392 57% 94% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 36 FORM TIE PROGRAM 330020 TIE ROD DW15 L=1.70M 5 0 40 0 90 56% 77% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 36 FORM TIE PROGRAM 330710 TIE ROD DW15 L=2.50M 75 0 292 0 648 55% 75% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 62 ZA COLUMN FORMWORK 662108 PMI WEDGE ASSEMBLY 101 0 650 0 1440 55% 82% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 9 ACCESSORIES AND TOOL FOR WALL FORMS 401290 HANDRAIL HOLDER GT24/VT20 1 0 75 0 164 54% 73% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 24 DOMINO 410406 STOPEND TIE-2 DSA 2 0 87 0 190 54% 90% Peri
4210 Return Stockyard Midrand 60 ZA WALL FORMWORK 660156 EF PANEL 3000X600 24 0 62 0 134 54% 68% Peri
Maintenance sheet
Stockyard Description PG PG Description Article Description Qty in Maintenance Qty in Main Yard Qty in Sales Stock Buffer in Main Yard Priority Utilisation Peri / Conventional Comments and Reasons for Non-Completion
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 10 ADJUSTABLE BRACES 403800 PUSH-PULL-PROP RS 1400, GALV 3 0 0 12 100% 0% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 32 BUILDING EQUIPMENT 415151 GUARDRAIL HOLDER -2 1 166 0 392 58% 94% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 20 ALUMINIUM SHORING 403062 PROP PEP 30-300 18 731 0 1383 47% 87% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 10 ADJUSTABLE BRACES 417469 PUSH PULL PROP RS650 12 9 0 16 44% 59% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 10 ADJUSTABLE BRACES 417467 PUSH PULL PROP RS300 74 77 0 81 5% 54% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 10 ADJUSTABLE BRACES 406000 BASE PLATE-2 FOR RSS COMPLETE 25 201 0 186 -8% 68% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 21 SKYDECK 361100 MAIN BEAM SLT 225 4 1063 0 875 -21% 81% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 20 ALUMINIUM SHORING 327291 MULTIPROP MP 480 5 2065 0 1483 -39% 21% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 21 SKYDECK 361530 PALLET SD 150 X 225 29 88 0 63 -40% 45% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 10 ADJUSTABLE BRACES 417468 PUSH PULL PROP RS450 36 63 0 34 -85% 52% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 20 ALUMINIUM SHORING 327305 MULTIPROP MP 625 3 2080 0 574 -262% 23% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 32 BUILDING EQUIPMENT 403429 PALLET RP 150/2 28 436 0 77 -466% 40% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 32 BUILDING EQUIPMENT 403434 PALLET RP 120/2 9 311 0 40 -678% 33% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 9 ACCESSORIES AND TOOL FOR WALL FORMS 324070 HOOK STRAP HB 24-100/120 2452 7138 0 782 -813% 16% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 32 BUILDING EQUIPMENT 365016 CRATE PALLET 80 X 120 6 674 0 67 -906% 40% Peri
5210 Repair Stockyard Midrand 9 ACCESSORIES AND TOOL FOR WALL FORMS 404931 UNIVERSAL HOOK STRAP HBU 20 344 3564 0 288 -1138% 13% Peri
Final Steps
Recommendation
“The ability to focus lets you stand out above the noise of
the flood of information in todays world.”
Questions… logo
www.tocpractice.com
?
42 TOCPA International Conference