Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
in east Indonesia
2015
Project Proposal
Diabetic Retinopathy Management Programme in East Indonesia
2015
1. Introduction
The estimated number of people visually impaired in the world is 285 million, whom
39 million are blind and 246 million having low vision. 65 % of people visually impaired
and 82 % of all blind are 50 years and older. In recent studies in South Sulawesi, using
RAAB method (RAPID ASSESSMENT OF AVOIDABLE BLINDNESS) The prevalence of
bilateral blindness was quite high compared with other countries (2.6 %). The most
common causes of blindness are cataract (64.3%), non trachomatous corneal opacity
(10.8%) and other posterior segment disease (7.1%). Untreated cataract is the major
cause (54.5%) of severe visual impairment (people with visual acuity >3/60 - ≤ 6/60) while
refractive error is the major cause (52.9%) of moderate visual impairment (visual acuity >
6/60 - 6/18). These problems need a priority in planning and implementation eye
programs.
LCIF First Grant , Sight First Project (1496/307-B2) , Two Year Project For the
Comprehensive Eye Care in Prevention of Avoidable Blindness in Indonesia had been
done with very good results. Training had been done to 79 general practitioners (GPs) ,
163 nurses, 173 cadres, 141 school teacher at 6 different areas (Bantaeng, Palopo, Bone,
Palu, Parigi, Luwuk). Equipment donations such as direct direct ophtalmoscope, cataract
surgery set, trial lens, tonometer,etc had been given to those areas. In addition to that,
indirect fundscopy and laser photocoagulation had also been donated to Palu and Palopo
as part of the step in fighting diabetic retinopathy. Furthermore ,free mass cataract
surgery had been done in Bantaeng and Makassar.
Screening , as the main step for preventing avoidable blindness, had been done
to 3 regency (Bantaeng, Palopo, Bone). More than 6000 in total elementary school
students was screened for refractive errors.
Diabetes mellitus is characterised by chronic hyperglycaemia secondary to insulin
resistence or defects in insulin secretion leading to long-term multi-organ complication.
All individuals with DM will be at risk of developing diabetic retinopathy (DR). DR may be
defined as the presence and characteristic evolution of typical retinal microvascular
lesions in an individual with diabetes. The progressive condition of microvascular
alterations in DR can lead to retinal ischemia, retinal permeability, retinal
neovascularization and macular edema. If left untreated, patients with DR can suffer
severe visual loss. In developed countries DR considered as the leading cause of
blindness in the working age population and has a considerable economic impact. Proper
management for DR can prevent more than 90% of cases of visual loss. A disease like
DM where a multidisciplinary approach is needed, cooperation among colleagues of
different specialties is important. General ophthalmologist, retinal specialties, internists,
endocrinologist and pediatricians can learn to speak same procedures in order to provide
the ideal care for DM and DR patients. According to IDF (International Diabetes
Federation) , the situation in Indonesia are as follow :
2
Total cases of adults (20-70 years) with diabetes = 9.116.000
Cost per person with diabetes = 174.7 USD
Number of cases of diabetes in adults that are undiagnosed = 4.854.300
Indonesia was divided into 3 big area, West Indonesia (Java island, Sumatra, and
surroundings) , Middle Indonesia (Borneo/Kalimantan Island, Bali and surroundings),
and East Indonesia (Celebes/Sulawesi Island, Maluku, Papua, and sorroundings).
Makassar is the gate to the East Indonesia and currently is the biggest and the most
advance city in the area. Makassar has long became reference center in all
ophthalmologic diseases including diabetic retinopathy cases. In year 2014 ,
Hasanuddin University Hospital , one of the biggest hospital in Makassar,South
Sulawesi had perform surgery (vitrectomy) to 148 Patients who got diabetic
retinopathy (most of them already in advance stage). Nevertheless, the long list of
patient’s queue still increasing till now.
The cause of this is mainly from the lack of equipment that necessary needed to
treat the patients (especially when they was still in early stage). Because the lack of
equipment, the local ophthalmologist had no choice but to refer the patient to
Makassar. These situation overwhelmed the ophthalmologist in Makassar which led
to long list of patient’s queue that ultimately delay the treatment to the patients and
reduce the chance of better visual outcome.
3
the province is Central Sulawesi province. The province is divided into five regencies
(Kabupaten) and one city.
Ambon is the main city of seaport of Ambon island, and is the capital of Maluku
province of Indonesia. It is one of the largest cities in eastern part of Indonesia. The
city of Ambon is divided into five district with total population 310,241 (2012 census).
Ambon island has an area of 775 km2 and is mountainous, well watered and fertile.
Luwuk is the capital of Banggai regency, Central Sulawesi province. Banggai
regency is a regency located at the eastern end of the province. Its area is 101.43
km2. Population of this regency was 328,872 based on 2010 census. Luwuk has a
very strategic area between marine and other industries. Currently Luwuk has
become a city that has a relatively complete infrastructure and it can be regarded as
the entrance gate of the east side of Central Sulawesi, while the west side is the city
of Palu.
4
Resource Gorontalo Ambon Ambon Banggai Sayang Rakyat
(Masohi (M.Haulussy Hospital
Hospital) Hospital) (Makassar)
Equipment Snellen Chart , Slit lamp, Slit Lamp, Slit lamp, Slit lamp,
for Slit Lamp, Shiotz tonometer Snellen chart Shiotz
diagnosis Schiotz tonometer, schiotz, Auto projector, Trial tonometer,
Tonometer, Snellen chart refractometer, lens , Fundus Snellen chart
Keratometer , projector, Trial direct Photograph, projector, Trial
Indirect lens, Direct ophtalmoscope, Biometri lens, Direct
Ophtalmoscope ophtalmoscope, snellen chart Machine, Auto ophtalmoscope
Lens 78 D projector, trial Refractometer
lens
4.1. Goal
To set up comprehensive system to reduce blindness and visual impairment
prevalence due to diabetic retinopathy in east part of Indonesia
5. Strategies
5
The strategies for this programme will according to WHO Vision 2020 program
which focusing in 3 strategies that are cost-effective disease intervention, human
resources development and strengthening infrastructure.
6
1. dr.Naning Sulaeman 2016 Gorontalo Medical Retina
Screening and
management for diabetic
retinopathy
7
Care for diabetic retinopathy is relatively expensive and requires properly available
health-care infrastructure. We need to provide adequate treatment for diabetic
retinopathy, with prevention of vision loss as an integral part of the management of
diabetes mellitus and specific treatment for sight-threatening stages of retinopathy.
Effective services for prevention and treatment of diabetic retinopathy can be provided
only if adequate medical services for patients with diabetes mellitus are in place.
Following are our proposed instrument to provide for respective area of programme
implementation.
Table 5.1.
No INSTRUMENTS AREA
1. Laser Photocoagulation Gorontalo
Luwuk Banggai
Ambon
Sayang Rakyat
Hospital
(Makassar)
2. Indirect Ophthalmoscope + Gorontalo
CCTV + Laptop Luwuk Banggai
Ambon
Sayang Rakyat
Hospital
(Makassar)
3. Non Midriatic Fundus Camera Gorontalo
Luwuk Banggai
Ambon
Sayang Rakyat
Hospital
(Makassar)
4. Portable Fundus Camera Gorontalo
Luwuk Banggai
Ambon
Sayang Rakyat
Hospital
(Makassar)
5. A-B Scan USG Gorontalo
Luwuk Banggai
Ambon
Sayang Rakyat
Hospital
(Makassar)
6. 20 D lens Gorontalo
Luwuk Banggai
Ambon
8
Sayang Rakyat
Hospital
(Makassar)
7. 78 D lens Gorontalo
Luwuk Banggai
Ambon
Sayang Rakyat
Hospital
(Makassar)
8. 90 D lens Gorontalo
Luwuk Banggai
Ambon
Sayang Rakyat
Hospital
(Makassar)
9 USG + Biometri Machine Sayang Rakyat
Hospital
(Makassar)
10 Keratometer Sayang Rakyat
Hospital
(Makassar)
6. Work Plan
The work plan for the two year period is shown in a tabular layout (Table 7.1)
Table 7.1
Two Year Work Plan
Detailed Activities 1st 2nd
Year Year
Objective 1
To strengthen primary eye care services for diabetic retinopathy to
prevent blindness in communities where diabetes is a public health
problem
Workshop to orient the stakeholders about the X
Project / Programme (one day workshop)
Training for GPs X X
Training for Nurses X X
Training for cadres X
9
Develop and distribute IEC materials X
Prepare the brochures / leaflet X
Distribute to communities X
(In collaboration with Health Promotion/Health
Education)
Objective 2
To identify person at risk for visual loss due to diabetic retinopathy at
the communities
Seminar on the prevention of retinal diseases at X X
national/local health professional meeting
(internist, and ophthalmic personnel)
Training for ophthalmic team for diabetic X
retinopathy screening in the community
10
Meeting for terminal evaluation X
8. Team Work
9. Budget
Budget matrix for costing training of human resource development and local
procurement
11
Categories of Fellowship Location of Duration Number of Cost per Total Cost
Personnel / Training trainer/ participants (US$)
Training participants (US$)
Event
First Year
Sub Total 1
12
Review existing PEC training manual and modify its as necessary
Sub Total 2
*See Appendix B
Subtotal 3
13
Second Year
Sub total 2
14
Screening for GP, nurse, District Hospital
diabetic voluntary workers
retinopathy
General Ophthalmologist, Primary Health
ophthalmic ophthalmic nurse, Care
screening volunteers
Subtotal 3
Sub total 5
15
10. LOG FRAME
16
OUTPUT 1. Established 1. Increased number 1. quarterly - Professional
Network of of referral of project willingness
diabetic Diabetic patients monitoring and
retinopathy from Internist to reports commitment
managements Ophthalmologist exist
between health and vice versa - Equipment are
care Provider , 2. Increased number fully
local, of referral from functional
government , PHC to - Quality of
and patients Ophthalmologist human
2. Increased to screen for resources are
awareness of retinopathy standardized
Diabetic diabetic
Retinopathy 3. Increased number
3. provide of Newly
proper Diagnosed Cases
management for of Diabetic
diabetic Retinopathy
retinopathy with 4. Increased number
prevention of of Diabetic
visual loss, Retinopathy
treatment for patients that
sight- receive laser
threatening photocoagulation
stage and treatment
follow-up care
for the disease
cost-effectively
17
diabetic Training to GPs,
retinopathy nurses, and
at the cadres about
communities diabetic
3. Prepare a Retinopathy
better quality 4. Sending
of human ophthalmologist
resources for to train in retinal
eye care field , for three
services months in
especially in selected eye
diabetic center
retinopathy 5. Using new
management equipment in eye
4. Provide a care service ,
better especially in
equipment diabetic
for eye care retinopathy
services management
especially in
diabetic
retinopathy
management
APPENDIX A
Duration : 3 months
Location : Jakarta / Bandung
Participant : 6 general ophthalmologists
1st year, from:
Gorontalo, Luwuk Banggai, Ambon
Conditions :
Ophthalmologist whose been assigned to have training.
18
Objectives:
To increase the skill of ophthalmologists in medical retina field, including diagnosis and
non surgical management of retinal diseases.
Duration : 3 months
Location : Jakarta / Bandung
Participant : 2 general ophthalmologists
Conditions :
Ophthalmologist whose been assigned to have training.
Objectives:
To increase the skill of ophthalmologists in cataract surgery, especially in Small Incision
Catarat Surgery tehnique
Duration : 12 months
Location : Jakarta / Bandung
Participant : Staff from Ophthalmology Department of Hasanuddin University
Conditions :
Ophthalmologist whose been assigned to have training.
Objectives:
To increase the skill of ophthalmologists in medical retina field, including diagnosis and
surgical management of retina diseases.
Duration : 3 days
19
Condition :
Selected GP from primary health centre with large number of patients
Objectives:
Increase basic knowledge of GPs in identifying the common retinal eye disease
GPs able to detect and diagnose diabetic retinopathy
The selected GPs (the one who was sent to train) can teach to his/her peers about
early detection and early management of diabetic retinopathy cases
To join the social activity in their district respectively
Training for Nurses
Duration : 3 days
Condition :
Nurses who works with trained GPs
Objectives:
Increase basic knowledge of Nurses common retinal eye disease and diabetic
retinopathy
Nurses able to detect and diagnose diabetes
Nurses able to basic eye examination and refer the patient to GPs /
ophthalmologist to have complete examination
The selected Nurses (the one who was sent to train) can teach to his/her peers
about diabetic retinopathy
To join the social activity in district
Training for Volunteers (Cadres)
Duration : 2 days
20
Target in 1st year: 2x training /year
Gorontalo, Luwuk Banggai
To teach how to detect visual abnormalities by the gesture, habits, complaints, etc
Outreach activities
3rd year:
Ambon, Makassar
APPENDIX B
Diabetic retinopathy screening camp and management protocol
21
will undergo Random Blood Glucose (RBS) tests with the help of a strip and a glucometer.
Patient’s height, weight and hypertension are also measured. The patients are asked
whether he/she is a known diabetic or has come to learn about his/her diabetic status.
This information will also be entered in the card. All the patients will be referred to the
physician for his advice. The physician will see all the patients, gives advice and refer the
diabetic patients for Diabetic Retinopathy screening. The non-diabetic patients will
receive the physician’s advice only. IEC materials will be given to all the outpatients at
registration counter.
22
are applied for all the diabetic patients. Patient’s sit in a darkroom till the eyes are
fully dilated, then are taken for a more thorough Diabetic Retinopathy screening.
5. Diabetic retinopathy screening: Examination takes place in a darkened room
using direct / indirect ophthalmoscope. This provides a wide field of vision but low
magnification and patients who detected with the signs of DiabeticRetinopathy
are referred to the base hospital. Others are given suitable advice.
6. Counselling: All diabetics leave with information concerning the diagnosis of
Diabetes and Diabetic Retinopathy. They are given more detailed information about the
disease, its effects, and the treatment options, including the recommended course of
action and laser treatment. They are informed of the locations where treatment is
available, and encouraged to come to the hospital to receive treatment.
Screening team :
Local Ophthalmologists
Local Ophthalmologists will screen for diabetic retinopathy in all patients that come
to local hospital,
Hasanuddin University’s ophthalmology residents
Residents teach the GPs to properly use ophthalmoscope for early detection and
will periodically visit the primary health care for diabetic retinopathy screening
23
General Practitioners
GPs will screen for un-diagnosed diabetes , learn from the residents to how
properly use ophthalmoscope, and screen all diabetes patients that come to
primary health care facilities
Nurse
Nurse will screen for un-diagnosed diabetes patients that come to primary health
care facilities and together with cadres will do home visit to people (periodically)
who haven’t go to the primary health care facilities yet
Cadres
Cadres will actively do home visit to people who haven’t go to the primary health
care facilities yet and encourage them to have their eyes checked.
24