Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
University Of Zimbabwe
Relationship Management
CCL 2007
CONTENTS
_____________________________
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
1.0 Introduction 3
Defining Relationships 4
New Generation Organisation 4
2.0 Understanding Relationships 5
Fundamentals of Relationships
5 Internal Relationship Management
7
Organizational culture 7
Strive for Win Results 9
3.0 Relationship Development 10
Institutional Relationship Management 11
4.0 Customer relationship management 13
Core Values and beliefs 14
Customer Profitability 15
Customer Acquisition 15
Customer Retention 16
Customer Growth 18
5.0 Making Relationships Work 19
6.0 References 22
2
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
INTRODUCTION
1.0
_____________________________
The main aim of this module is to enable students to identify key customer
relationships, internally and externally and develop strategies for improving them.
Essentially there are 4 key objectives to be achieved. By the end students will be
able to:
3
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
Customers
Suppliers
Employees
Financiers
Regulatory authorities, etc
RBZ
International banks
Other local banks
Recruitment agencies
Financiers
Customers
Government
All these relationships are created and managed so that the customers,
management and eventually shareholders are satisfied. The customer is
central in this relationship network.
The old viewpoint in industry was: 'Here's what we can make - who wants to buy
our product?' or we can make a Ford for you in any colour for as long as it is
black!
4
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
2.0 _____________________________
It is any connection between two or more parties in view of drawing from each
other and mutually benefiting from the association. According to Christopher
Lovelock (1996), it is one in which the customer finds value because the benefits
received from the service delivery or product significantly outweighs the
associated costs of obtaining them. From the company’s point of view it is that
which is financially profitable over time and in which the benefits of serving the
customer may extend beyond revenues to include such intangibles as the
learning obtained from working with that customer.
5
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
* Focus on services
* Globalisation
2.2.2 Understanding
Partners to a relationship are appreciative, sympathetic, empathetic and
considerate of one another. Understanding relates to the genuine interest to
know each other’s situation and accept it with its shortcomings. The service
provider or manufacturer must understand the customer’s needs and
requirements so that they do not force their product on to the customer but
should structure a tailored financial solution for specific financial need.
Equally important, the customer must also develop interest to understand the
supplier’s situation and limitations. It makes the relationship relevant.
6
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
regarded as an adversary. They must be credible and not self centred but close
to each other. The warmth of the relationship is apparent. The following equation
developed by Don Peppers and Martha Rodgers completes the puzzle.
A B
In the same vein the smaller the shared interest level and mutual benefit the
weaker the relationship. It calls for honesty and selflessness and commitment to
a win-win result. No unjust profiteering, Employees are equitably rewarded.
Customers are satisfied and the company makes a profit.
The idea is to ensure that the organisation does not suffer from internal
counterproductive discord. Employees and management must be pulling in one
direction avoiding the “us and them” syndrome. Unity of purpose (direction) is
achievable if people operate in teams and not groups.
7
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
Discussion
What are the key deliverables of internal relationship management?
Here are a few techniques you can use to increase the effectiveness of your
internal marketing efforts:
i. Begin with new employee orientation
Rather than thinking about internal marketing or cross selling, encourage cross
eating. Food is the best icebreaker among people. Encourage interdepartmental
lunches. Consider organizing lunches or providing food. Follow up regularly to
8
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
Of course, conduct regular internal training sessions on all your services. The
important thing is to have your very best presenter do the training. Too often,
internal training is relegated to either a department head or the most technically
astute employee. An accurate-but-dull presenter will hinder your internal
marketing effort. An energetic, likable, enthusiastic team member will help
capture the attention of others, and generate excitement about the service.
Reward and recognize the people who let clients know about new services. It
doesn’t necessarily have to be a financial reward. Sometimes a simple thank-you
note or e-mail does the trick.
Ask each department to submit information current activities and to provide good
news about business development efforts. Remember that the goal in these
venues is to inform and uplift.
This is the time for discussions about which internal marketing efforts are working
and which aren’t. It’s absolutely not the time for displays of hot air. Trust builds
when people are honest with each other. Sharing both successes and failures
(call them learning experiences if you want) enables people to understand the
complexities of the firm’s different services, what makes them useful, and what
services clients are and aren’t accepting. It is also a unique opportunity for
problem solving.
9
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
a. Win – win scenario where both parties walk away feeling satisfied
knowing that neither parties has taken advantage of the other.
b. Win – lose scenario where the seller (employer) wins at the expense of
the buyer (employee). The seller may feel good but the buyer feels
cheated and looks forward to revenge.
c. Lose – win scenario where the seller (employer) loses and the buyer
(employee) wins. Usually the seller expects to make up in future but the
opportunity never comes.
d. Lose – lose scenario where both parties lose and neither feels good
coming out of the transaction.
Discussion
10
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
3.0 _____________________________
11
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
12
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
3.2.1 User buying Influence – the role of the user buying influence is to make
judgements about potential impact of your augmented product on their
performance. User buyers will supervise or use the product and so their personal
success is directly tied to the success of your solution. The user buying influence
is concerned about the job to be done (how does this impact my job
responsibilities).
You cannot afford to ignore this buying influence even if you are connected to the
big guns. Management can and sometimes does approve orders for products
that user departments just as soon would not buy but the eventual outcome of
these is generally bad for everyone concerned. Resentment, lack of co-
operation or outright sabotage from user buying influences can affect future
potential sales.
3.2.2 Economic buying influence – this gives final approval to buy. The role is
to release the money to buy or invest. There is always one person or a set of
people playing this role for any given proposal. The economic buying influence
can say YES when everybody else has said NO, as well as veto a deal that
everybody else has approved. He or she exercises the golden rule: whoever has
gold makes the rules! His or her focus is on the bottom line and effect on the
organization (what return will we get on this investment?).
3.2.3 Technical buying Influence – the role of the technical buyer is to screen
out possible suppliers. Their focus is on the augmented product itself, and they
make recommendations based on how well (measurable and quantifiable
aspects) the proposal meets a variety of objective specifications. Technical
buyers cannot give a final YES but they can give a final NO. The technical
gatekeepers do not decide who wins, but they decide who can play the game
(does this meet the specified criteria?). There are usually several people playing
this role. Technical buyers are often difficult to identify but you can only
underestimate their power at your own peril.
3.2.4 Advisor – the unique and very special role of an advisor is to guide you to
your particular sales objective by leading you to the buyers and by giving you
information that you need to position yourself effectively with each one of them.
Advisors may be found in your organization, in the buying organization or both.
Their focus is on helping you make this sale (how can we make this relationship
happen?). You do not want to give away a hamper containing wine for Christmas
to a client who returns it saying they do not drink alcohol!
Understanding these four buying influence roles and identifying all the people
playing them with regard to your sales goal is the foundation of cutting edge
selling. Selling to the economic buying influence alone can be as disastrous as
only selling to someone who doesn’t give the final “yes”. Stay out of that comfort
zone and sell to all the buying influences.
13
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
Discussion
How do we deal with customer relationships that are so personal that the
relationship manager may leave the organisation with the customer or business
relationships that are too personal? In other words how do we avoid losing
customers with staff turnover?
4.0 _____________________________
“In the new economy of intense, global competition and constant change, a
golden business rule from yesterday remains constant: the customer reigns
supreme. Today, successful businesses must excel in all areas of customer
intimacy, product leadership and operational excellence. Winning companies
never lose site of constantly evolving customer demands and strive to exceed
customer expectations.” SAP
Abundance of choice
Availability of information
Commoditisation
Time scarcity
4.3 Outcomes
14
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
Customer defections
Customer attrition
Complaints
Price sensitivity
15
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
- Joint value creation compared to the traditional value chain (as popularised by
M Porter).
Discussion
1. About 20% of each business’ customers account for nearly 100% of its profits.
2. This top 20% group of customers poses both a threat and an opportunity to
your business. The opportunity is in that once you have identified them you
can easily target them for retention and cross-sell programs. The threat is that
most businesses have traditionally over-charged their best customers to
subsidise other loss inducing customers. This has normally resulted in the
top clients being dissatisfied and thus being highly targeted by competition.
The strategy therefore is for the business to identify its top 20% customers
and seeking to grow them.
3. If you have not been using the Pareto rule then you were having it wrong
throughout!
Businesses that are not profitable always go under in the long run.
It enables the business to identify short-term profit improvement strategies
that can be immediately implemented.
It can assist the organisation to nurture currently unprofitable customers
towards profitability.
Analysing the relevant profit drivers can help a business to achieve that
higher level of profitability faster by focusing the right tactics on the right
customers.
16
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
The analysis also helps to identify unprofitable customers who are unlikely to
ever become profitable and need sacking.
Profitability analysis helps the business to anticipate the profit potential of
customers and thus enabling it to focus more on the highest profit potentials.
Marketing companies should worry over three key performance indicators for
their customer acquisition programs namely,
The ideal combination is a low cost acquisition program that generates high
customer equity. It must be remembered that safety in big numbers is not always
profitable. Some customers cost more than what they are worth./
o Personal selling
o Under- serviced accounts
o Satisfied customers – referral customers
o Networking – personal contacts with the well connected
o Promotional Activities
Exhibitions, seminars, trade shows and conferences
Sales promotions, advertising,
Publicity,
o Websites - interactive
o Lists and Directories
Attendee lists, telephone directories
o Canvassing and pitching
o Telemarketing
The decision on which customers to acquire must rest on customer value
estimates. All other things being equal, a customer that shows a higher value
estimate is a better prospect for acquisition. It is a core principle of CRM to use
customer knowledge to target acquisition efforts accurately and cost effectively.
In a CRM environment it is often possible to query the current and prospective
customer databases for clues to guide customer acquisition.
17
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
Know whom you are targeting. Whilst some target the high net worth, others
target every one. Establish your ideal customer profile. Then define your unique
selling proposition or extra value proposition enough to separate your product
from competition. Differentiate and sell. But do not end there.
Given the cost of acquiring customers, businesses can’t expect to grow customer
business simply by attracting more new customers. They must retain
existing customers longer and build the customer base by looking more
closely at the other end of the customer lifecycle — attrition.
Rule No 1 - You cannot assume that you know what a customer's expectations
are ... You must ask.
18
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
You may consider; access to members-only products and services, prompt alerts
on upcoming and improved products, discounts, electronic newsletters etc.
iv. Bonding
Aim to create social and structural bonds with customers to raise switching costs
such as,
Multi product bonding – there are economies for customers dealing with a few
suppliers. When the relationship breaks the customer incurs significant costs,
financial, psychic and physical.
Financial such as offering discounts (higher rates) with product bundling
Legal contracts
Technological where the customer invests in technology tying them down to
you.
Learning relationships get smarter with each interaction. Every interaction and
modification improves your ability to fit your products to particular customers.
This raises customer” switching costs and acts as a barrier against competitor
invasion.
v. Build Commitment
Several authorities have urged companies to work on developing customer
commitment. Committed customers are more than satisfied, they believe your
company is superior to other competitors, they are involved in your brand, offer
or company, they have a strong intention to buy that overrides promotional offers
from competitors.
19
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
5.0 20
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
_____________________________
The treasury (in banks) needs to be equipped with a robust information system
such as the Reuters to deal with global banks.
Discussion
21
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
1. Give more attention to your most profitable customers. Use the Pareto rule.
2. Take ownership of your customer’s problem, even if you are not the cause of
it. This means acting like you were the cause of the problem by apologizing,
empathizing and putting in 100% effort to get it fixed.
3. Follow up with every customer who was upset or had a difficult problem. Make
sure the problem was resolved to their satisfaction.
4. With every customer interaction, ask yourself: If this were me, what would I
want? In other words, are you following the Golden Rule and treating your
customers the way you would want to be treated in a similar situation?
5. Thank your customers and co-workers every chance you get. Why your co-
workers? Because it will make them feel appreciated and help give them a sense
of well being, which in turn will trickle down to your customers.
6. Fax, mail or email articles or other materials to your customers if you think they
can benefit from the information. In fact keep your communication lines open and
open. Be there for the customer.
8. Look for ways to bend the rules and remove service obstacles.
9. Never forget that time is a person’s most precious commodity. Respect your
customers’ time and schedule. This means being on time – or early – to
appointments, wrapping up your presentation in the allotted time and leaving
succinct voice mail messages.
10. Provide your customers with respect, friendliness, knowledge and concern for
their needs first, and with the products and services you sell second.
11. Remember all the fundamentals about relationships. Be committed and not
involved.
12. Smile every time you talk on the telephone. It will come through in your voice.
22
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
Organizations need to listen to their customers in a way that shows that those
customers are valued. This is especially important because customers'
expectations are constantly changing -- moment-by-moment.
It's imperative that companies include customers in such a way that they feel like
partners. One-way to do so: feedback. Companies should beg for feedback and
celebrate it like the gift that it is.
Customers are devoted to companies that help them learn and make them
smarter. It's very powerful. It says, 'We care about your growth.’
"All trust begins with a leap of faith," Bell said. "If you trust customers first they
will respond to you in kind." Something in the relationship fundamentally changes
when you show trust. Service recovery is about managing betrayal. It's not about
fixing the problem only, it's about how you communicate empathy.
Customers like dealing with employees who are committed, but they love dealing
with employees who are passionate. Do not to put all their effort into
transactional costs and miss the relationship value.
23
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
Follow-up after the resolution - remember you still need the client
REFERENCES
_____________________________
6.0
1. Paul R Gamble, Merlin Stone, Neil Woodcock and Bryan Foss, Up Close
and Personal, Customer Relationship Marketing at Work 2nd Ed (2001)
Kogan Page Limited.
2. Francis Buttle, Customer Relationship Management Concepts and Tools,
(2004), Elsevier Butterworth- Heinemann.
3. Don Peppers, Martha Rodgers and Bob Dorf, Is Your Company Ready For
One To One Marketing, Harvard Business Review Jan 1999.
4. Christopher Lovelock, Services Marketing, Butterworth, 1996.
5. Susan Fournier etal, Preventing the Premature Death of Relationship
Marketing, Harvard Business Review Jan 1998.
6. Robert C. Blattberg etal, Interactive Marketing: Exploiting the Age of
Addressability, Sloan Management Review Jan 1991.
7. Leyland Pitt etal, Managing the Process of Competitive Advantage with
Customer Equity as the Outcome, Cardiff Business School Jan 1991.
8. Robert C. Blattberg and John Deighton, Manage Marketing By The Equity
Test, Sloan Management Review Jan 1991.
24
Relationship Management Study Guide - Executive Certificate In Treasury Management
University Of Zimbabwe / CCL Business Training
9. http://www.1to1.com
10. http://www.sellingpower.com
11. http://www.carlsonmarketing.com
12. http://www.relationshipmarketing.com
13. http://www.gsb.stanford.edu/eep
25