Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
ESDA2014
June 25-27, 2014, Copenhagen, Denmark
ESDA2014-20549
1. the ASME HPV Student Challenge, with both East and West
coast events and recently also a South-America edition;
2. the Australian HPV Super Series, a true multi-event cham-
pionship organized by the University of South Australia.
In both cases, technical and safety requirements for the vehi- FIGURE 2. EXTERNAL AND CUTTED VIEW OF TWO COM-
cles are defined with a strict and very detailed approach. The first MERCIAL VELOMOBILES.
challenge also consists of some technical tests in order to assess
the characteristics of each prototype such as braking and stabil-
ity, while in the Australian competition a vehicle scrutineering
is mandatory before racing. Rollover and crash protections are
mandatory and technically defined with specific standards in the
rules. The HPV Super Series also impose recumbent position, THE EU-HPV STUDENT CHALLENGE
a minimum of three wheels and some limitations in size, track A first European educational activity in the field of HPVs
width and wheelbase for the vehicles. From a general overview, was developed between 2011 and 1013 as an Erasmus Intensive
also referring to pictures of the participating vehicles, the Pedal- Program called ”Powering the Future with Zero Emission and
Prix seems to be more oriented toward standardization of vehi- Human Powered Vehicles”, involving about ten Institutes from
cles, giving a strong margin on safety at the expense of innova- all over the Europe. Each of the three years an Intensive Program
tion, while the ASME competition give relatively more freedom of a couple of weeks was hosted in a different place (Terrassa, SP
and has a strong educational focus thanks to the testing chal- 2011 - Bradford, UK 2012 - Antwerp, BE 2013) with students
lenges. In both cases, the approach is very different to the one and teachers from the participant Institutions. Besides lectures,
adopted by the WHPVA, where few technical requirements are also practical workshops were organized. For the last edition,
imposed and the maximum freedom is given to the participants. some student groups were in the condition of realizing a proto-
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
08
09
10
11
12
13
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
Year Taking advantage from the context
From the first approach to the organization, it was clear that
FIGURE 3. 2000-2013 YEARLY PRODUCTION BY A DUTCH the effort required to create a competition from zero was far
VELOMOBILE MANUFACTURER [2]. bigger than setting-up a new special category inside an existing
event. Then, an analysis of pros and cons of the two approaches
was conducted and a first informal opinion of the WHPVA was
type of electrically assisted HPV. Thus, a small informal compe- acquired during the World Championship 2013 in Leer (DE). In
tition was organized while the remaining students proposed and fact, the WHPVA framework resulted to be the best option for
discussed some vehicle assessment principles. Even if not in- many reasons:
volved from the beginning, Politecnico di Torino participated in - an international expert jury for student project evaluation
the last edition of the IP with two students and one of the authors can be easily formed within the WHPVA members which
as teachers. In fact, from 2009, a student team named Policum- are attending the event;
bent was active at the Politecnico di Torino under the guidance - design and manufacturing experience developed by individ-
of the authors. Starting from 2010, every year the team has de- ual participants is a good state of the art to be mixed together
signed and realized a new HPV prototype and participated to the with student innovative inclination;
WHPVA World Championship as the only student team among - racing and event logistic is demanded to the national mem-
many non-educational single participants. ber hosting the World Championship;
From the positive mood generated during the IP 2013 in - the WHPVA itself could take advantage of new young peo-
Antwerp, the idea of a European HPV Student Challenge was ple being involved in his main event.
born and some of the participants decided to work together in the
creation of the event [3]. It was then decided to organize the 1st edition of the EU-
HPV Student Challenge as a special EDU (educational) category
inside the next HPV World Championship that will be held in
A multi-disciplinary challenge Saône (FR) from 8th to 10th of August 2014.
Land HPVs represents an exciting challenge for engineer-
ing students and researchers independently from their passion
for sport: the challenge to design and build a lightweight, aero- A soft approach to technical requirements
dynamic and efficient vehicle able to go up to 70-80 km/h with Starting within an existing event, the EU-HPV-SC was based
only few hundred Watts of power. on the same soft approach to vehicle technical requirements
There is enough place for many scientific and technical dis- adopted by the WHPVA. The purpose is to guarantee the max-
ciplines in HPV design: structural mechanics for the frame (al- imum freedom for innovative solutions by defining only basic
loys or composites) or for monocoque fairing [4–7], aerodynam- safety requirements. If this can be perceived as a risk, the over
ics [8–10], drivetrain optimization as well as ergonomics and 20 years experience coming from the WHPVA (and also IHPVA)
biomechanics [11,12]. Riders training program management can events confirms that accidents and injuries in HPV racing (even
be learned by students as well as design and testing methodolo- in their most extreme form) are no more dangerous and no more
gies under a variety of point of view: frequent than in indoor cycling or any other sport.
Teams will have to deal with three documents concerning
- CAD design; vehicle technical requirements: the general one from WHPVA,
- FEM and CFD analysis; the World Championship specific edition requirements from the
1. a mandatory helmet complying with a national standard also From the 1st principle it follows that no limitations were im-
in case of fully faired vehicle - case (A), only required by posed to vehicle size, number of wheels and their configuration,
the EU-HPV-SC rules; rider position or drivetrain system (as long as human powered
2. the ability to stop the vehicle within a distance of 6 m with only). The organizers simply suggest the teams to focus on the
a starting speed of 25 km/h (as required in EN 14781 for velomobile class, as it is one of the most interesting category for
standard bicycles) and without any loss of control - case (A), green mobility development, but complete freedom is left to the
only required by the EU-HPV-SC rules; young designers in case they have good innovative ideas for other
3. the vehicle-driver combination must show a good control vehicle classes.
and steering behaviour: at any time during a race the racing From the 2nd principle, a ranking score system was defined
committee can stop a vehicle if it is clearly showing unsafe with a maximum of 100 points, composed by a maximum of 45
control - common requirement; points for racing and 55 points for project evaluation.
4. in any weather condition, front, lateral and rear visibility The project evaluation was divided into five sections: inno-
from inside the vehicles must guarantee the safety of the vation, safety, style, engineering and presentation. The first four
rider and of all other participants - common requirement; sections will be evaluated through a jury with a maximum of 10
5. dangerous protrusions, sharp edges or other unsafe design points each by means of a team ranking (Tab. 1). Each team
features are not allowed for racing - common requirement. will be asked to present the prototype(s) with a short technical
report (for engineering section evaluation) and with an oral pre-
In fact, case (B) is not happening with the present version sentation. The ranking of the oral presentation will be defined
of all the rules, but it was included as an indication for future through a peer assessment procedure, where each team has to
modification of the technical requirements. evaluate all the others. Up to 5 additional points can be added to
Even if some of the requirements are proposed in a generic each team by a Special Guest, with experience in cycling engi-
way, they proved to be effective over the years in WHPVA racing neering and/or in racing.
and registered teams will be pressed to ask the committee for By following the 3rd principle, a single category was de-
clarification of any doubt before attending the event, as they risk fined, so that teams will be pushed to have their prototypes fully
to be excluded from racing. In the end, starting from the imposed faired in order to compete at high level. In addition, in order to
condition of adult only riders (≥ 18 years old) and designating overcome the rider separation by gender, a multiplication factor
each participant Institution as responsible for the safety of their of 1.5 was provided for racing points given to female riders. The
own prototypes, it was easy to find an insurance coverage for the factor was based on the ratio of power output between male and
Student Challenge which is added to the main event one. female professional cyclists reported in [13] for different races
Of course, a pre-race vehicle check is mandatory in order to and rounded up to 1.5 for both simplifying the calculation and
verify the given basic safety requirements for the admission to incentivize the participation of female riders. The overall racing
the race track, as it usually happens for the World Championship points given in case of male and female riders are summarized in
individual participants. Tab. 2 and they will be equally divided by the number of races
organized for each edition.
Competition rules Moreover, teams are free to decide their racing target: they
Competition rules were inspired to the following principles: can change the rider between races in order to optimize their
strategy to win the EDU category or they can participate with
1. leave the maximum freedom for innovation on any kind of the same rider to all races in order to compete also for the overall
individual land HPV; title of World Champion.