Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
ISSN : 2599-2031
Abstract
Nurse who is not exceling in giving the service to the patient is also called ''Nursing Error”' as
a failure of the nurse to complete a planned action or use of a misplaced plan to achieve a goal.
Data shows that Indonesian patients seeking treatment at Lam Wah Ee Hospital Malaysia
reached 12,000 per year or about 32 patients per day. Community demand to get professional
nursing service is the most important health service agenda. Nurses need to document all forms
of nursing care provided by recording or documenting.
The purposes of this study are to analyze different strategies in implementating the
comprehensive nursing documentation and the difference of nurse service quality before and
after treatment, to analyze the relationship of the implementation strategy of nurse
documentation on comprehensive nursing care with the improvement of nursing quality service
before and after treatment.
This research using Pre Group One Experiment Pre-post test design, population was 100 people
and the sample was 30 people. Data analysis used Wilcoxon Sign Rank Test, Chi Square and
Fisher Test.
The results showed that documentation before and after treatment using Wilcoxon test p ≤ 0,05
that is p = 0,003, service quality before and after given treatment p ≤ 0,05 ie p = 0,000, and chi
square test that is used to see correlation of documentation strategy with quality of service
before treatment p ≤ 0.05 ie p = 0.000 as well as Fisher test is used to identify relationship of
documentation strategy with service quality after treatment p ≤ 0,05 ie p = 0,000.
The conclusion of this study are, there is a significant different between documentation before
and after treatment; also concerning the service quality, there are significant differences before
and after treatment; as well as the relationship between documentation strategy and service
quality before and after treatment.
Pancaran Kasih Hospital needs to improve a comprehensive documentation system.
225
Proceeding Manado Health Polytechnic 1st International Conference. ISSN : 2599-2031
giving the service to his patient is also called This trend occurs because they were
'' Nursing Error '' as a failure of the nurse to dissatisfied with health services provided
complete a planned action or use of a by hospitals in Aceh and surrounding areas
misplaced plan to achieve a goal, but not (Serambi on line 14 July 2007). High
including deliberate action or interest towards foreign medical providers
indiscriminate acts that could bring harm to such as in Malaysia and Singapore due to
the patient. The nurse considers the factors of facilities and the quality of
documentation as confusing and service provided has met the expectations
inconvenient, with overlapping duties and of the patients. Around year 2012, Pancaran
responsibilities, with no standardized Kasih hospital experienced a period of
assessment forms and no nursing care crisis where patient visits in July was 925,
documented agreement from the hospital. August was 832 and September was 732.
Not all nurses in the hospital provide It happens because since 2008 professional
optimal care towards their patients and it services of the doctors and nurses were not
has resulted complaints that makes paid properly by the hospital management
dissatisfaction of patient in nursing services (manado.tribun.com). This had an impact
even though the nurses feels that they have on patient service and data shows a
given the best services to the patient and decrease in visits for each month.
impacted to the hospital's income as well as Documentation of Nursing System at
the faulty plan to achieve a goal, but not Pancaran Kasih hospital Manado also
including deliberate actions or makes the nurse confuse and the
indiscriminate acts so as to harm the complexity of point by point regarding the
patient. documentation, either the assessment,
People's view on the quality of nursing diagnoses, intervention or
service in Indonesia is decreasing, Patients evaluation. Therefore, nurses have not done
from Indonesia who seek medical treatment the documentation properely.
abroad continue to increase. Data from the Pancaran Kasih hospital is currently
website mentions in Singapore every year trying to improve its service in line with its
about 300,000 International patients come motto "is Called to Serve". Until now the
for treatment and 7200 people are hospital continues evaluating and
Indonesian citizens (Communication improving, although there are still
Doctor Indonesia edition May 13, 2009). complaints made by the patients as users of
Other data mention the number of services.
Indonesian patients seeking treatment at Nursing is a form of professional
Lam Wah Ee Hospital Malaysia reached service that has a paradigm or nursing
12,000 per year or about 32 patients per model that includes four components,
day. Number of visits at Adventist Hospital namely: human, health, environment and
Malaysia have reached 14,000 or about 38 nursing (Marlyn A.R) in Alligood& Tomey
patients per day. Patients from Aceh and (2006). Health workers such as nurses are
surrounding areas reported at least a the key to the successful achievement of
thousand patients seeking treatment to health development goals. Nurses as health
Penang Malaysia for excellent health care. workers who first meet with patients will be
226
Proceeding Manado Health Polytechnic 1st International Conference. ISSN : 2599-2031
the first to know the state of the patient. provided efficiently and effectively in
Patients who come with various complaints accordance with professional standards.
will experience emotional problems. Service standards are implemented
Documentation of the nursing care thoroughly in accordance with the needs of
process is a display of behavior or patients, utilizing appropriate technology
performance of nurses in implementing the and research results in the development of
process of nursing care to patients during health services or nursing to achieve
hospitalized patients. The quality of nursing optimal health.
documentation can be seen from the
completeness and accuracy of writing down Based on the survey and
the nursing care process given to the interviews with the head of nursing division
patient, which includes assessment, nursing and some nurses at Pancaran Kasih hospital
diagnoses, action plans and evaluation Manado, the implementation of the
(Nursalam, 2008). documentation system has not been optimal
The public demand to get because the nurses have not understood the
professional nursing services is the most comprehensive nursing documentation and
important health service agenda. In order to based on that problem, the researchers
achieve an optimal service, it needs a conducted a research on "A Comprehensive
professional nurse staff. The nurse’s Nursing Documentation Implementation
profesionalism at work can be seen from the Strategy with Quality of Nurse Service at
nursing care provided to clients who are Pancaran Kasih hospital Manado”.
being treated. Nurses need to document all
forms of nursing care provided through the RESEARCH METHOD
recording or documentation. This is done as This research design used
a form of professional and legal quantitative method that is pre-
responsibilities towards the client he or she experimental one group pretest post test
cared for. In developed countries, design, which the researcher give pretest to
documenting systems of nursing care are group which will be given treatment to.
made in line with the development of Then the researchers do the treatment, after
science and technology and done the treatment, the researcher gives post test
professionally. But, in some developing (Nursalam, 2008, Arikunto,2010). This
countries, such as in Indonesia, only a few research is in the treatment group to prove
hospitals provide the information system. the relation of training giving in strategy of
Documentation of nursing care is done implementing comprehensive documenting
manually, takes a lot of time, thoroughness system of nursing care with the
and diligence. To build information system improvement of nurse service quality at
based on computer technology, the hospital Pancaran Kasih hospital Manado. Time and
must spend a lot of money. In addition to place of research was conducted from
funds, professional human resources are August until September 2017 at Pancaran
required to operate the system. Kasih hospital Manado. The population of
According to Nursalam (2011), the this study is nurses who served in the
quality of service is the degree of services inpatient care unit of Pancaran Kasih
227
Proceeding Manado Health Polytechnic 1st International Conference. ISSN : 2599-2031
228
Proceeding Manado Health Polytechnic 1st International Conference. ISSN : 2599-2031
Quality Of Pretest
Pre Test Service
Documentation Good 12
(40%)
Good 13
(43.3%) Less 18 (60%)
Less 17
(56.7%)
Figure 6 Distribution of Respondents
based on Documentation of Respondents
Figure 4 Distribution of Respondents before being given treatment, at
based on Documentation of Respondents Pancaran Kasih hospital Manado in
before treatment, at Pancaran Kasih August-September 2017
Hospital Manado August-September
2017 Based on figure 6, 18 (60%) of 30
respondents mostly with less service quality
Based on figure 4, 17 (56.7%) of 30 before the treatment.
respondents mostly with less
documentation. Univariate Analysis of Quality of Service
after Treatment
Univariate Analysis on Documentation
after Treatment
229
Proceeding Manado Health Polytechnic 1st International Conference. ISSN : 2599-2031
BIVARIATE ANALYSIS
n Median Standard P
(Minimum-Maximum) Deviation
Documentation before 30 1 (1-2) 0,579 0.003
treatment
Documentation after 30 2 (1-2) 0,379
treatment
Based on table 1, the data analysis value is 003, which means less than α 0.05.
using Wilcoxon Sign Rank Test shows that Thus, it can be concluded that there are
there are 2 people perform poor meaningfull differences in documentation
documentation, 14 respondents are fair and before and after the treatment.
14 respondents are better. The significance
Table 2 Analysis of Service Quality Differences before and after Treatment at Pancaran
Kasih hospital Manado in August-September 2017.
N Median Standard P
(Minimum-Maximum) Deviation
Quality of Service before 30 1(1-2) 0,498 0.000
Training
Quality of Service after 30 2 (1-2) 0,346
Training
Based on table 2, the data analysis value is 0,003m which means less than α
using Wilcoxon Sign Rank Test indicates 0.05 Thus, it can be concluded that there are
that there is 1 person performs low rating on significant differences in service quality
service quality, 14 Respondents are fair and between before and after the treatment.
15 respondents are better. The significance
230
Proceeding Manado Health Polytechnic 1st International Conference. ISSN : 2599-2031
Quality of Service
Less Good P
n % n %
Documentation Less 15 50 2 6.7 0,000
Good 3 10 10 33.3
Quality of Service
Less Good P
n % n %
Less 4 13.3 1 3.3 0,000
Documentation Good 0 0 25 83.4
231
Proceeding Manado Health Polytechnic 1st International Conference. ISSN : 2599-2031
232
Proceeding Manado Health Polytechnic 1st International Conference. ISSN : 2599-2031
233
Proceeding Manado Health Polytechnic 1st International Conference. ISSN : 2599-2031
strongly determine to make changes within 1991 stated that Nursing Documentation is
hospital where they work in nursing a systematic document that contains
service, the noble task in accordance with complete data, real and recorded not just
the motto of the hospital, to serve with love about the level of morbidity of clients but
does not have a positive impact on the also the type and quality of health services
client's assessment of the service quality of provided. Satrianegara 2012 also said that
the hospital, but with the limitations of its the basic requirement of good health
human resources with 36.7% Ners service is that the service must be available
education, even facilities in the form of a in the community and continuous, meaning
specific nursing assessment form, all types of health services needed by the
establishing nursing nursing diagnoses is community.
still difficult to follow the requirements of This research was conducted during
making a proper nursing diagnosis and the training given to nurses at Pancaran Kasih
unavailability of facilities that can facilitate hospital Manado that the contents of
nurses in documenting diagnose, where the activity in the form of review about nursing
hospital only focused on nursing issues, at process (assessment, nursing diagnoses,
the implementation of nursing activities as intervention and implementation and
the service to the client, which do not evaluation). This activity resulted in nurse
support the continuous implementation of feeling there is something new done, then
this simple documentation program. just update the process of nursing, they
have prepared a nursing assessment form
Comprehensive Document for nursing, prenatal mother, intranatal
Implementation Strategy after mother, postnatal mother, emergency
Treatment Service Quality assessment, client assessment with internal
Analysis of data using Chi Square diseases and surgical diseases, with the
shows there is 75% of the test which is less demand for hospital accreditation, make the
than five of the expected value. Therefore, hospital director in the field of nursing in
it is used an alternative test that is Fisher consultation with the head of the hospital,
test results show the results of good Nursing responds quickly, this makes the
documentation results in client perceptions clients treated feel cared for nurses, clients
on good service quality of 83.4%. The reviewed according to available
statistic test shows that the value of p ≤ 0.05 assessments, served in accordance with
significancy value is 0,000 for Exact sig. (2 nursing problems experienced, often nurses
sided), it can be concluded that there is a do communications both during the
relationship between the Comprehensive morning service, evening service, and night
Documentation Implementation Strategy service because documentation activities,
and after Treatment Service Quality. nurses often make communication and
According to Nursalam, through nursing provide services optimally.
documentation will be seen how far the role
and function of nurses in providing nursing CONCLUSION
care to the client, it is useful for improving There were significant differences in
service quality, also according to Fisbach documentation before and post-treatment.
234
Proceeding Manado Health Polytechnic 1st International Conference. ISSN : 2599-2031
235