Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Aimed at helping re~ders prepare and use reliable and valid lUV8V:q llbnl.
Ask Survey Questions, 2nd Edition shows readers how to: h
Ask valid and reliable questions for the context
Determine whether to use open or cloSed questions
Choose the right type of measurement (categOrical, nominal, or ordinal)
for responses to survey questions
Ask questions that get at attitude, behavior, and knOwledge
6'
Develop factorial. conjoint, and Intemet survey questions
~
CJ) II~
New to this edition is coverage of focus group questions, the Characeanatic8 and I as of
factorial questions and conjoint analysis questions, and the princ:iples ~ In :met c
survey questions.
'<
~
oc:
CD
~
o
:J
en
I\)
2
~
g
C'C)ok~? 'r-j The Sur KH:
The Survey Handbook, 2nd How to Conduct In-Person HoIr ... 1IiInIge, AIIIIpa.
Arlene Fink Interviews for Surveys, 2nd and......".. Surnr'"
Volume 1/1SBN 0·7619·2580·51 pb Sabine Mertens Oishi 2nd
Volume 5/1SBH G-7619-257Cl-81 pb ArlIne FInk
~ II. . G-7'II1N57& pb
How to Ask Survey Questions,
2nd
Arlene Fink
How to DesIgn Survey Studies,
2nd
_ ........011....,
Volume 2/1SBN 0·7619·2579·11 pb
~
any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photo
copying, recordin g, or by any information storage and retrieval system,
without permission in writing fro m the publisher.
For information:
Sage Publications, Inc. Content,s
($) 2455 Teller Road
E-mail: order@sagepub.com
6 Bonhill Street
How to Ask Survey Questions: Learning Objectives vii
United Kingdom
1. Asking Questions: A Matter of Context 1
M-32 Market
Guidelines for Asking Survey Questions 22
Greater Kailash I
Guidelines for Using Conventional Language
Printed in the United States of America 2. Keep Questions Closed or Open Them Up? 3S
02 03 04 05 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Categorical Responses and Meaning 49
Ravi Balasuriya
Production Designer: Michelle Lee
4. Knowledge, Attitudes, and Behavior:
Additional Tips for Creating Survey Questions 67 How to Ask Survey Questions:
90 following:
117
123
Question Sequence
- Use time periods that are related to th e impor
123 tan ce of the question
Exercises
125 - Use conventional language
Answers
129
Suggested Readings
Glossary 137 - Are appropriate in length
141
About the Author
143
• Apply special questioning tech niques to survey
- Use loaded words cautiously behaviors, knowledge, attitudes, and demographics
- Avoid biasing words • Describe the characteristics of focus group
questions
- Avoid two-edgers • Identify the characteristics an d uses of fact orial
- Avoid negative phrasing questions
• Identify the characteristics and uses of conjoint
- Are appropriate in light of the characteristics an d analysis questions
uses of closed and open questions • Understand the principles underlyin g questions in
- Distinguish among response formats that use Internet surveys
nominal, ordinal, and numerical measurem ent
Asking questions:
A Matter
ofContext
1
3
2 H OW TO ASK SURVEY Q U ESTIONS Aski/1g Questio /1s: A Matter ofCo ntext
EXAMPLE 1.3
Example 1.2 continlled
Two Surveys
Survey 2
The Children's Clinic is a school-based clinic in a
Effect on
very-low-income area of a large city. The cHnlc intends Survey 1:
Survey 2;
Questions
Interviews About
to conduct a survey in which fa milies an d teachers will A Mailed the Services of a
be asked to identify children's health problems (includ Questionnaire School-Based
Concerning Clinic
ing medical and psychosocial issues) that th e clinic Child Abuse
might address. A sample of parents, teachers, health pro Identify need~ to Survey I :
Identify needs Questiom are
fessionals, an d children will be interviewed in person. l'urposC and solutions to guide focus of about education
gu ide program d inic serv ices
Each interview will take 30 minutes. In terviews will be development Survey 2:
conducted in English or Spanish, depending on the first Que~tions are
about health
language of the respondent. About half the questions
will ask respon dents to give ratings and make rankings; Parents. teachers, Survey 1:
Parents of Qucstions po~ed
the remainder will allow respondents to give answers in Respondents
school-age health arc [or parents
th eir own words. All responses will be confidential. A professionals, and
d Lildren children only
report of the results will be available in 12 months. survey 2:
Questions posed
ate for people of
differing roles
and ages
The two surveys described in Examples 1.2 and 1.3 aim to Survey 1:
guide the development of programs and the focus of services Interviewers ask Questions must
Surveyor Self- questions face-to
to prevent child abuse and family violence and to promote ad ministered, be easily read and
mailed face understood
health. Survey 1 is for parents only; Survey 2 is for parents, questionnaire without ouhide
teachers, health profeSSionals, and children. Because Survey contains the assistance
questions
1 is self-administered, the surveyors must be certain that the S\lrvey 2:
questions can be understood by respondents without assis Questions must
he worded so
tance from . the survey team. The results of Survey 2 will tha t they can be
reqUire the surveyors to have special expertise in interpreta understood orally
tion and classification of the responses that are given in the
participants' own words. Survey l 's team will need resources
for printing and mailing; the Survey 2 researchers wHl need
fu nding for hiring and training interviewers. Because all
answers on Survey 1 are anonymous, the surveyors may be
able to ask questions about topiCS that named respondents
might be reluctant to discuss. Although answers on Survey 2
r-
7
Asking Questions:;\ Ma tter of Context
6 HOW TO ASK SURVEY QUESTIONS
Effect on
Survey 2: Questions
Survey L:
I Survey 1: Survey 2: Effect on A Mailed
Interviews About
I A Mailed interviews About Questions Questionnaire
the Services.of a
QuestiolUlai re the Services of a School-Based
Concerning Clinic
Concerning School-Based Child Abuse
Child Abuse Clinic Survey 1:
n-. All reSponses will
All responses be confidential "Sensitive"
Responses Closed: Ratings Some questions use Survey 1: Privacy questions (e.g.,
will be (codes will replace
made on a scale ratings. and Responses Can be anonymoUS about drug use
from 1 to 4 rankings, the trans\ated on a names) and sexual .
rE'maJnd er rely on scale from 1 to 4 habits) are more .
tile respondent's .likelY to be
own words Survey 2:
answered
I Half the
responses will Survey 2:
come from Must be a little
ra lings and more "careful"
ran kings, the with sensitive
remainder will be questions, as
in participants' respondents can
own words be traced
liming Survey takes 20 Survey takes 30 Survey 1:
minutes minutes Respondents may
not return
question naires,
or they may not
anSWer all
questions
Survey 2:
Time must be
allocated for
reading and
interpreting
respondents'
answers
Resources Need translation Need translation Survev I:
into five into Englbh and Expertise is
languages Spanish needed in five
languages
Survey 2:
Survey must be Interviewers must Expertise is
printed and be hired and needed in two
maiJed trained languages
9
HOW TO ASK SURVEY Q UESTIONS
Asking QlIes Ho/1 s: A Matter ofContex t
8
will be kept confidential, the respondents will not h ave com =-~==
Survey 2 in Example 1.2 is about the h ealth needs of
plete anonymity, and this may reduce their willingness to be
children. Definitions of health are far from uniform and
fran k in their answers. Survey 1 needs to be translated into
vary according to culture. To select appropriate and
five languages; Survey 2 is to be given only in English an d
usable definitions for your survey, you can review what
Spanish .
is known and published about the topiCyou are address
You m ust understand fully your survey's purpose, the
ing. You can also define terms yourself, but this may be
needs of the survey team, and the nature of your respon
p roblematic in that others may not be convinced of
dents (along with other considerations) before you begin to
your definitions' validity. Sometimes, it is best to adopt
write your survey questions. The following checklist will
already respected definitions an d even, if possible, an
help you to iden tify and understand yo ur survey's context .
already tested set of questions.
Your choices regarding the focus of your survey and
the definitions used in survey questions sometimes
Ch ecklist for Deciding the Survey's Context become clear when you know your survey's specific
ob jectives.
,/ Identify the survey's specific purpose. ,/ Be sure to have the specific objectives of the
survey in place.
The purpose of a survey is its hoped-for outcome.
Usually, you have a general purpose in mind- say, to The specific objectives of your survey are the precise
find out about job satisfaction, preferences for certain goals you aim to meet with the infor mation you collect.
products, or voting plans. If you are concerned with job Sometimes, specific ob jectives are expressed as research
satisfaction, for example, your survey should focus on hypotheses or questions; at oth er times, they take th e
that topic. Questions about respondents' previous jobs, form of statements. Consider these sample objectives for
hobbies, personal backgrounds, and so on, may not be Smvey 1 in Exam ple 1.2:
relevant.
1. ldentify the most common needs for edu
,/ Clarify the terms used to state the survey's
cational services
purpose.
SUGGESTED ANSWERS
EXERCISE
The following are four specific objectives for Survey 2 in Two additional objectives:
Example 1.2:
5. Compare the barriers to use of health services
1 . Find out where children usually receive their among older and younger parents whose chil
health care
dren will use the clinic
2. Identify barriers to using preventive health ser 6. Determine if respondents are satisfied with the
vices, such as vaccinations quality of the health services their children cur
=
and behaviors. For example, if you ask relatively healthy
./ Know the respondents. survey respondents about what their h ealth was like
exactly 1 year ago, they may be unable to remember,
Your survey questions should be written so that they
because they have no compellin g reason to dwell on
encompass your needs for da ta, but they m ust also be
their health . Also, if you ask people to tell you wh o they
formulated so that respondents can answer them easily
will elect to the Board of Education in 6 months, they
and accurately. Check the appropriateness of the reading may n ot yet know. Asking respondents to compare their
level of any questions you write. Reading abilities behavior to that of others also sometimes results in con
among respondents may vary considerably, even for the fusion. Asking employees of a particular company to
same survey. For example, a survey of parents in a school compare th e adequacy of child care at that company to
district may include some people who read extremely the care provided by other firms, for example, is likely to
well and oth ers who read poorly. You have to decide prod uce poor results unless you are certain that the
how to state your questions so th at the number of respondents are fam iliar with the child care offered at
respondents who can read and comprehend all ques
tions is maximized. other companies.
Because facing unanswerable questions is extremely ./ Carefully match what you need to know against
frustrating, you need to make sure that your respon the amount of time you have to find out.
dents have sufficient knowledge to answer the questions
you ask. For example, in a survey to find out about the The number of questions you can include in a survey
quality of education, many people may not be able to depends largely on the amount of time available for
answer a question like the following: respondents to answer the questions. You can usually
include more questions in a half-hour interview than in
a 10-minute interview. The number of questions you
What role should the Department of Curriculum should include in a survey also depends on what you
and Instruction play in setting educational stan need to know and how many questions you need to
dards for this community?
attain adequate measurement.
Suppose that in Survey 1 in Example 1.2, the time
allotted for a respondent to fill out the questionnaire is
Unless told, many people might not know about the
department's current authority, how it is administered, 20 min utes. Suppose also that the survey is supposed to
and how it has been designed to fit into the community. cover 10 topiCS: educational n eeds, ethnicity/race, gen
They may not have a clue about th e department's role. der, willingness of respondents to participate in job
In their frustration, they may guess, or they may refuse retraining, satisfaction with current educational status,
to answer that question or any other question on the age of parents, h ow parents manage their h ousehold,
h ow parents can care for their children, level of parents'
survey.
Survey respondents may also have difficulty answer education, and methods for discipliniIlg children fo r
ing questions that concern their past or fu ture actions mild, moderate, and severe infracti ons. The surveyor can
16
HOW TO ASK SURVEY QUESTIONS 4ski17S Questions: A Ma tter ofContext 17
,.--
ask 1 or more questions to Cover each topic or ask 10
questions about any single topic. To decide on which EXAMPLE 1.4
questions to ask, you m ust balance what you need to Topics, Number of Questions,
know (the specific objectives), the number of questions and Information Collected
needed to cover each top ic related to each objective, an d
the amount of time available for the survey.
Number of
A good way to get started in determining the number Topic Que~tions Information Collected
of questions for each topic is to make a chart like t he one
shown in Example 1.4. Educa tional level I I Last year of school completed
Remember that Survey 1 is to last 20 minutes. To Educational needs 10 ---1 Whether had training for specific
jobs (e.g., sales, nurse's aide)
find out if the 35 questions can be answered in the 20
minutes availa ble, the surveyor must tryout the ques Eli1l1iclty/race 1 African American, White but not
Latino, Latino/ Latina, Chinese,
tionn aire with potential respond ents or people just like Southeast ASian, other
them . To determine if the questions cover the topics of
Ge nder 1 Maie/ Female
the survey adequately, the surveyor can ask experts,
search other surveys, and conduct statistical analyses to Satisfaction with I Yes/No
current educational
fi n d out, for example, if paren ts Who are known to cope
status
well answer the questions differently from parents who
EXAMPLE 1.S
./ Standardize the response format.
Standardized Surveyors
A standardized format asks each respondent to select
1. A survey of parents is conducted to find out from a list of preset choices. Example 1.6 distinguishes
jf they are willing to partidpate in a program between standardized formats and other types.
to prevent child abuse and neglect. A 25. Some people may have difficulty with standardjzed
item questionnaire is mailed to 200 parents. question-and-response formats. They may ob ject to the
TIle questionnaire was tried out witll 50 par. structure or be unfamiliar with it. When this happens,
ents before it was considered suitable. The the surveyor should try to find another standardized for
original version had 35 questions, but the mat that is acceptable to the respon dents or look for an
parents who served as test respondents felt alternative way of getting the information. One way
that it took too much time to answer. If 10 some surveyors make the structure of a standardized for
or more of the test respondents either would mat more p alatable for respondents is by offering the
not or could not complete particular ques questions and choices on videotape.
tions, those questions were omitted. All
questions are accompanied by four answer ./ Remember that questions are asked in a social,
choices, and the respondent is asked to circle cultural, and economic context.
t11e one "best" answer.
In the two survey situations described in Example 1.2,
2. Interviews were con ducted to compare the the survey instruments are to be translated from English
views of managers and sales staff regarding into other languages. Whenever you must undertake such
a program to introduce more flexible hours translation for a survey instrument, you need to ensure
fo r employees. The Human Resources that you are asking questions that are meaningful to peo
Department trained five HR staff members ple speaking the languages you are using. You should rely
to conduct the interviews. TIle training on survey experts and potential respondents to help with
took 6 hours, and quality checks of a sam the wording of the questions. Remember also to budget
ple of interviews were made to ensure that time and money for these activities.
each interviewer followed very strict q ues. Another contextual factor to consider is whether the
tion.asking guidelines. answers will be anonymous. If so, you may be posing
dlfferent kinds of questions than you would otherwise.
Surveyors agree generally that respondents are more
willing to answer "sensitive" questions about person al
behaviors and beliefs when surveys are anonymous (that
is, the identities of respondents are not known ) than
when they are simply promised confidentiality or when
respon dents' na mes are common knowledge.
-
~1
To determine 1 2 3 4 5
if any
questions are
misleading
To examine 1 2 3 4 5
whether
surveyors can
appropriately
use the survey
forms
To determine 1 2 3 4 5
if the
information
obtained by
the survey is
reliable
To determine 1 2 3 4
J
if tbe
information
obtained by
the survey is I
vaJid
1
23
ASking Qllestions: A Matter ofContext
22 HOW TO AS K SURVEY QUESTI.ONS
~
instead of asking about usual or typical behavior in a
Guidelines for Asking Survey Questions given period, ask about a specific t ime period, as illus
You may find that in your own survey, some of these trated in Example 1. 7 .
guidelines are more important than others.
lines' fo od, service, on-tim e records, and so on. If you .to Make Questions More Concrete
Make these three questions more concrete and describe how Periods of a year or more can be used for major life
you improved specificity.
events like the purchase of a house, occurrence of serious
1. How sati sfactory was your stay at the hotel? illness, birth of a child, or death of a parent. Periods of a
month or less should be used for questions that are less
2. What is the best way to improve health care? important. Asking people to remember relatively urtim
portant events over long periods of time leads to too much
3. Which restaurants do you eat in most
guessing. You do not want the period to be too short,
frequently?
either, because the event in question may not have
occurred during the interval. Example 1.8 illustrates good
and poor use of time periods in survey questions .
•• • • • • • • • • •• • • • •••• •• • • •
POSSIBLE ANSWERS
1. How satisfactory was room service during your
EXAMPLE 1.8
stay at the hotel?
Use of Time Periods in Survey Questions
The question has been made more specific in that it Poor: How long did it usually take for you to fa ll asleep
now focuses on one aspect of the hotel stay: room during the past 6 months?
service .
Comment: Too much time has probably elapsed for the
2. Wh at is the best way to improve the quality of
respondent to recall accurately. Also, the amount of
preventive health care?
.time to fall asleep may have varied considerably,
making estimation a difficult task.
The question is more specific in that it now concen Better: How long did it usually take for you to fall asleep
trates on a particular area for improvement: the quality during the past 2 weeks?
of preventive care.
Poor: In reference to your car accident of a year ago, how
3. In the past 3 months, which New York restau
many visits have you made to a p hysician in the past
rants did you eat in most frequently?
6 weeks?
Commm t: The number of visits made to the doctor in
A time period and a place have been set: in the past 3 t he past 6 weeks is probably different from the
months and New York.
number made in the first weeks after the accident.
Better: In reference to your car accident of a year ago,
look at the fo llowing list and tell how many visits
you have made to a physician.
26
H OW TO ASK SURVEY QUESTIO NS Asking Questions: A Ma tter o(Context 27
A survey is not a conversation. To get accurate infor When Asking Survey Questions
EXAMPLE 1.9
AVOID ABBREVLAI10NS
same job or profeSSion, people with similar health or
Avoid using abbreviations and acronyms in your social problems, and teenagers.
questions unless you are certain that they are commonly The problem in using slang and colloquialisms is
understood. Most people probably are familia r with USA that if you plan to report the results of the survey to a
and I.'BI, and many would be familiar with the abbrevia general audience, you will need to translate the slang,
tions for th eir own cities, states, provinces, un iversities, and less-than-expert translation may result in loss of
and so on. But don't count on it. If in doubt, spell it out, meaning.
as shown in Example 1.10.
BE CAREFUL OF JARGON
HAVE THE QUESTIONS REVIEWED BY EXPERTS Short: Have you ever traveled to another country? If yes,
how important was the scenery in your decision to
Experts are individuals who are knowledgeable about take a trip?
survey question writing or the subject matter addressed
by a survey. Experts can tell you which survey questions Long: Travel to other countries has become increasingly
appear too complex to be administered easily and which popular amon g Americans. Have you ever traveled
are too long or too difficult to be answered accurately. to another cou ntry? If yes, you might have traveled
to oth er countries to enjoy their scenery. How
HAVE THE QUESTIONS REVIEWED important was the scenery in your decision to take
BY POTENTIAL RESPONDENTS a trip?
Potential respondents are people who are eligible to Long questiOns are useful for getting information on
be part of the survey sample- that is, the kind of people sensitive concerns (e.g., health and sexual habits) and
you want to hear from. For example, if you plan to sur socially controversial issues (e.g., gun control and sub
vey teens in high school to find out about their eating stance abuse). When using longer questiOns in self
habits, then your reviewers should be high school administered questionnaires, you need to consider the
teenagers. A review by potential respondents helps to time they take to read an d answer. Example 1.12 shows
guarantee that the survey's questions are meaningful the use of a longer question.
and inclusive of all important ideas.
A great many survey questions are available to the A Sample Longer Question
dents will fail to read the word not. Others will mistak Keep Questions
enly translate the negative into the positive and believe
the questi on is "Do I think the United Nations should (Jlosed or Open
have more authority to intervene in a nation's military
affairs?" If you do use a negative question, be sure to ThelDUp?
emphasize the negative word: "The United Nations
should not have more authority to intervene in military
affairs."
Open-Ended Questions
Open-ended questions allow respondents to give answers in
their own words. These questions are useful if you are inter
ested in getting unanticipated answers or in learning about
the world as your respondents really see it. Also, some
respondents prefer to state their views in their own words,
and sometimes this results in quotable material that can be
3S
37
36 HOW TO ASK SURVEY QUESTIONS Keep Ques tions Cl osed or Op en Th em Up ?
usefu l for the survey report. The responses to open ques Closed-ended questions produce standardized data that
tions, however, are often difficult to compare and interpret. can be analyzed statistically, an d statistical analysis is essen
Consider the q uestion in Example 2.1. tial for m aking sen se of survey data for groups of people (e. g.,
teams, schools, teens, the elderly, Americans). Also, because
what is expected of the respondent is more clearly spelled
EXAMPLE 2.1
out in such questions, the answers h ave a better chance of
An Open-Ended Question and Three Answers
bein g reliable or consistent over time . Closed questions are
easy to standardize. Example 2.2 shows a closed question.
Question: How often during the past month did you find
yourself having difficulty trying to calm down?
EXAMPLE 2.2
Answer 1: Not often A Closed Question
Answer 2: About loo/b of the time
How often durin g the past month did you find yourself
Answer 3: Much less often than the m onth before baving difficulty trying to calm down?
y If Yes, -J If Yes,
Use Open-Ended Use Closed-Ended
Questions Questions
Purpose Respondents ' own words You want data that are rated
are essential (to please
respondent, to obtain
quotes, to obtain
or ranked (on a scale of very
poor to very good, for
example), and you have a
Responses:
testimony) good idea of how to order
the ratings in advance
Uhoi ces and
Respondent
characteristics
Respondents are capable
of providing answers in
You want respondents
to answer using a
MeasnreDlent
their own words prespecified set of response
choices
Responden ts are willing
to provide answers in
their own words
Asking the You prefer to ask only the You prefer that respondents
question open question because choose among known
the choices are unknown choices
Analyzing the You have the skills to You prefer to count the W hen a respondent is expected to give an
results analyze respondents' number of choices
comments even though answer in his or her own words, the question is open-ended.
answers may vary When a list of the possible answers to a question is provided
considerably
fo r the respondent to choose among, the question is closed.
You can handle responses Items on a survey instrument that use open-ended questions
that appear infrequently
consist of the questions alone. Items that use closed-ended
Reporting the You will provide You will report statistical questions consist of the question and the response choices.
results individual or grouped data
verbal responses
Response Choices
Response choices, or the choices given to respondents fro m
among which they select their answers, take several forms.
Categorical or nominal (the two terms are often used inter
chan geably) response choices involve categories, such as
male and female. These types of responses h ave no numeri
calor preferential values; they are simply correct or incor
rect, true or false.
39
40
H OW TO AS K SURVEY QUESTIONS Responses: Choices and Measurement 41
EXAMPLE 3.1
Three Common Response Choices Which kinds of response choices should you use? To decide,
. Pisces 0
0 Virgo 0 Suppose the obj ectives of the survey in Example 3.2 are
0
Taurus 0 Scorpio 0 • Identify books and plays that are considered important
Gemini 0 Sagittarius ':J reading for graduates.
Cancer 0 Capricorn 0
• Examine the relationship between the books and plays
people read and those they rate as being im port ant.
42
HOWTO ASK SURVEY QUESTIONS Responses: Choices and Measurement 43
Oedipus Rex 1 2 3 4 5
EXAMPLE 3.2
The Bible 1 2 3 4 5
1. Nominal or categorical: Which · of these Mob)' Dick 1 2 3 4 5
books or plays have you read? Circle yes or The Glass i\-1euagerie 2 4
1 3 5
. no for each choice. - -
finding that uses categorical data might take this form: How to Get Them
centages of people who select each point on the scale. Born in France? 20 80 I
1. Yes 2. No
1 2
CATEGORICAL RESPONSES AND WHO IS ELIGIBLE ProfeSSional
1 2
Nominal or categorical responses put respondents in to Registered nurse
categories, such as male or female, Native American or 1 2
Nurse practitioner
African America n. Questions that ask respon dents to catego 1 2
Administrator
rize or name themselves are used t o get demographic infor
1 2
m ation and help decide who should be in cluded in (or Nurse midwife
excluded from) a survey. Suppose you are pla nning to ask
49
48 HOW TO ASK SURV EY Q UESTIONS Bespol1ses: Choices and Measurement
Comment: The categories for the responses are not m utu Better: Which one of the following best describes your
ally exclusive. The choi ce "professional" can include primary exp ertise?
all of the remaining categories; that is, a n urse practi
tioner, a registered n urse, a nurse midwife, and an Lan dlord-tenant problems o
administrator can all be considered professionals. To Consumer problems o
confuse matters even m ore, nurse practition ers, Traffic cases o
administrators, and nurse midwives may all be regis Small claims o
tered nurses. Misdemeanors o
Felony cases o
Better: Which of the following best describes you? Answer Wills o
yes or no for each category. Personal in jury claims o
Domestic relations
o
1. Yes 2. No Adoption
Tax
o
Registered nurse, but n o bachelor's degree 1 2 Real estate
EXAMPLE 3.4
EXAMPLE 3.5
Which best describes your age group'? Circle one choice 1. We conducted a suryey to compare teens
only. and others in their m usic-llstening habits.
We asked this question:
Which best describes your age?'Circle one.
Age Gro up 1. ves T 2. No
1. Yes 2. No
Years of Age
I. . ~
65-74
75-84
85-95 '
.
-~
l' +__
I
I . .
2
2_
2 ,
,
----.
12 or younger ·
.13-14
~-
1
1
2
2
-
~--------~-------. 1 2
l Over 9S I 2 I 15-17 --
1 2
18·21 I
1 2
22-30
1------
31 or older 1 1 2
The aim of Question 2 is to obtain data for comparing Ordina l measures are extremely common in surveys. In
people of differing ages. The groupings are based on the fol fact, typical surveys tend to have more ordinal measures
lowing assumptions: than any oth er kind. When you are asking questions th at
require respondents to order their answers, you need to be
1. Music-listening habits vary accordin g to age decade concerned with the content of the choices, the n umber of
(e.g., 31-40 and 51-60). choices, and whether or not you should include a middle
2. All people un der 20 years of age have similar listening point and a "do not know" response. You also need to be
habits and all those 61 and older have similar listen concerned with grammar and how the question looks on a
ing ha bits. page or sounds when spoken in person or on the telephone.
B: Before I answer, 1 want to raise some issues you Frequency: Always, very often, fairly often, sometimes,
should consider in asking respondent s to order their
responses, such as wheth er to include a middle point almost never, never
("neither agree n or disagree/' fo r example) and Intensity: None, very mild, m ild, moderate, severe
whether to include a "don't know" or "no opinion" Influence: Big problem , moderate problem, small prob
choice. lem , very small problem , no problem
A: Do you know of some guidelines for me to use in ask Comparison: Much more than others, somewhat more
ing these types of questions and de termin ing than others, about the same as others, somewhat
response choices? less than others, much less than others
B: You're in luck. I just came across a set.
tudes, you should consider putting the negative end of KEEP QUESTIONNAIRES UNCLUTTERED
clothes do not
4 3 2 1 0 the responses.
fit. I I I
I am
-
Example 3.7 continucd
E.v.ample 3.7 conal/llcd
. Avoid questions .with skip patterns in self
2. Most of the time I have to force myself
administered questionnaires.
to go to work.
A skip pattern is an instruction used in a o Strongly agree o Undecided
question that you exp ect does not apply to o Agree o Disagree
all participants. If you must use skip pat o Strongly disagree
terns, set them off as clearly as possible, as
shown below. Item 1 is poor because it is unclear whether the respon
dent should mark the line befo re his or her choice or the
Skip Pattern: line following it. For example, the line that precedes
I(Agree" is also right next to "Undecided." Item 2 is p oor
14. Have you had two yeats or m ore in your beca use the ch oices are not aligned, and the logic of the
life when you felt depressed or sad most scale dIsappears.
days, even if you felt OK sometimes?
Cl No ~
GO TO QUESTION 15 Strongly Strongly
D Yes Agn~e
(1)
Ab'Tee
(2)
Undecided
(3)
Disagree
(4)
Disagree
(5)
~
Each day of work ieels as 2 3
if it will never end . 1 4 5
14A. Have you felt depressed or sad much of
the time in the past year? Most of the time I ha ve
to force myself to go to 1 2 3 4 5
work.
DYes D Na - - --_.
ers should use cards that show the scales and the scale rank of students in a college senior class is important to
points' defin itions when respondents are asked to select graduate school admissions committees, for example.
from among five or more choices. Telephone interview The following is typical of questions that ask respon
ers should read th e choices before asking any questions dents to rank their preferences:
respondents will answer by using a scale and then repeat • Using the followin g list, select the three most
the choices fo r each questio n. important books or plays that U.S. college graduates
sh ould have read.
Oedipus Rex
The Bible
Moby Dick
Other (specify) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
Top choice:
Second choice:
--
Stopped and talked when we met 1 2
~~
Had din ner together at their 1
home or ours I In telephone interviews, rankings should be limited to
Had dinner together at a
1 2
two or three alternatives at a time. In self-administered sur
f
restaurant ! veys and face-to-face interviews in which visual aids can be
UI Watched their home when on
vacation , or they watched ours
1 2
used, respondents should not be asked to rank more than
five alternatives. If you insist on having many alternatives,
you should ask respondents to choose the top two or three
and the bottom two or three.
USE RANKINGS ONLY IF RESPONDENTS CAN SEE
OR EASILY REMEMBER ALL CHOICES
Rankings or rank-order scales are a type of ordinal Numerical Measures
measure in which choices are placed in order from the
Numerical measures ask respondents to produce num bers, as
highest to the lowest (or the other way around). The
illustrated in Example 3.9. The first question in the example
64 HOW TO ASK SURVEY QUESTIONS 65
Responses: Choices and lv[easurement
Numerical Measures
Draw a .line through ONE number in each row:'
67
68 HOW TO ASK SURVEY QUESTIONS Kn owledge, A ttitudes, and Behavior: Tips 69
belief, preference, feeling, and vallie. The following are typical n ot in a pOSition to do a scientific experimen t to validat e the
of survey questions about attitudes: questions, you sh ould use already existing and proven ques
• Do you favor gun control? tions. You can find such q uestions through online searches
as well as library searches of books an d journals; by contact
• Should the federal government do more to equalize ing college and university departments of medicine, public
income differences between the rich and the poor? health , sociology, political science, and psych ology; and by
• How satisfied are you with your job? asking colleagues and associates to lend you th eir questions
and measures. Books are available that con tain attitudinal
• Which of the fo llowing are essential goals of a demo questions, but n o central, updated clearinghouse exists. The
cratic society? fact is that findin g attitude questions and scales is hard work.
• Which description comes closest to defining the qual It can be costly in terms of the amount of time you have to
ity of your life? spend to identify the right agency with the right questions.
In some cases, you may need to pay to use particular ques
• How h ealthy do you feel? tions. If you plan to use questions from existing surveys, you
• Which is the best solution to illegal immigration ? must check on who owns the copyrights to those surveys
an d find out whether you need the authors' permission to
• Do you favor an increase in taxes to support educa rep roduce some or all of the questions .
tion al programs for very poor children? Once you have identified existing questions that meet
the needs of your survey, you must check carefully to make
Attitudes are very complex entities, and they are difficult certain that each is suitable for your survey's respon dents. Is
to define and measure. What are the characteristics th at con the language level appropriate? Does it truly ask what you
sistently and accurately distinguish li berals from conserva need to know? You should have any borrowed questions
t ives? Is th ere a universal definition of quality of life? Aspects reviewed and pretested.
of these questions are philosophical, bu t scientific and tech A good way to examine the usefulness of a question is to
nical methods are available for producing attitude scales th at ask your pretest respondents to tell you in their own words
are valid for specific survey needs. Psychometricians use what the question means to them. This is called cognitive
these methods to examin e the stat istical properties of ques pretesting. Tune in on the following dialogue between a sur
tions to find out if they consistently an d accurately distin veyor and two potential survey respondents:
guish people who have particular attitudes from those who
do n ot. Surveyor: We are condu cting a survey to fin d out if
Attitudes are often contrasted with knowledge an d you are satisfied with your h ealth care .
behavior. For example, how a person feels about gun control Question 1 asks you to rate the importance
laws, what that person knows about gun con trol laws, and of accessible care. The scale you will use has
what he or she personally does abou t guns mayor may n ot five response choices: "defin itely impor
be related logically. tant," "important," "probably im portant,"
Most survey experts agree that if you are interested in "probably not im portant, " and "no opin
measuring concepts such as political stance, religiosity, an d ion." Please tell me in your own words what
satisfaction (with job or quality of life or health), and you are this question means.
70
HOW TO ASK SURVEY Q UESTIO NS Knowledge, Attitlldes, and Behavior: Tips 71
natural disasters such as fires, floods, and earthquakes. For Because questions about behavior have a tiIne element,
most other kinds of even ts, you should not expect people to yOU are dependent on your respondents' ability to recalL To
remember past about a year's time. You can, however, use jog respondents' memories, use lists such as th e one sh own
yearly periods primarily for summary information: in Example 4.2. The advantage of using lists is that they can
rem ind respondents of events they may have forgotten. To
• About how much money did you spend on vacations be maximally helpfu l, lists should be as inclusive as possible
away from home in the past year? without being too long; lists th at go on for many pages can
• In th e past 12 months, how often did you go for bicy be confusing and boring for respondents. On e way to get
cle rides of 5 or more miles? around this problem is to divide a question into component
parts, as illustrated in Example 4.3.
Asking respondents to give specific information about
their behaviors over long periods of time leads to omissions:
EXAMPLE 4.2
Poor: In the past year, which of the following items of
ch ildren 's clothing did you buy from Outdoors Using a List to lIelp Respondents
Clothing Company? . Renlember Their Actions
Comment: Unless respondents have bought very few This question is about your leisure activities. Since last
clothes for their children or buy exclusively from January, did you do any of these activities? Check yes or
Outdoors Clothing Company, they might very easily D O for each.
forget.
Better: In the past 3 months, which of the following items Yes (1) No (2)
of children's clothing did you buy from Outdoors
1 2
Clothing Company? Go to a movie
1 2
Eat out for pleasure
Questions concerning very short periods of time can I
1 2
adversely affect the accuracy or validity of answers about Window-shop
behavior: 1. 2
Go to the theater
Poor: In the past week, how often did you buy coffee, tea, 1 2
Read for pleasure
bottled water, diet soda, or regular soda?
1 . 2
Go for a run
Comment: A question like this may produce invalid
1 2
results because respon dents may not have purchased Go for a hike I
f-.
any of the items during the past week. Nevertheless, 1 2
Ride a bicycle
because they do purchase and use such items regu
1 2
larly, they may overreport by in dicating a purchase in Go fishing
the past week that really occurred the week before. 1 2
Do gardening
Better: In the past 3 weeks, how often did you buy coffee,
tea, bottled water, diet soda, or regular soda?
74
HOW TO ASK SURVEY QUESTIONS Kn owledge, Attitudes, and Behavior: Tips 7S
EXAMPLE 4.3 you add this option, however, you are in clu din g an open
Dividing the Question:
ended question, and you must be prepared to interpret and
How to Avoid Long Lists and
catalog the answers.
Still Get the Information on Behaviors You Need
l=
I
~balt 1 2
_ _ ---1 Getting at Kn owledge
Foo tball 1 I 2
Knowledge questions are included in surveys to achieve the
Bowling
---iI
1 2
following objectives:
- ---+ --
Other- please na me: 1 I 2 • Determine if people have enough knowledge about a
Other- please name: ~---2--- topiC to warrant askin g their opinions about it
• Identify gaps in knowledge that warrant education,
advertiSing, p Ublicity, or other kinds of inform ation
Using li sts can also h ave a disadvantage: By presenting cam paigns
lists to respondents, you may encourage them to use only • Help explain attitudes and behavior
the categori es named in the lists, and this m ay result in a loss
of information. To encourage respondents to provide infor Example 4.4 ill ustrates the three m ain uses of knowledge
mation on all their relevant behaviors . you can add an questions .
......
76
HOW TO ASK SURVEY Q UESTIO NS 77
Kn ow/edge, Atti tudes, and fi ehavior: Tips
EXAMPLE 4.4
Example 4.4 COl1til11 ted
Using Knowledge Questions in Surveys
--
79
78 HOW TO ASK SURVEY QUESTIONS KI/ ow/edge, A ttitucles, ancl Behavior: Tips
Knowledge questions are sometimes disguised so as to dents about the physical environment. You might ask a ques
reduce their threatening appearance. Th is is done with tion like the following:
phrases like /lin your opinion ," "using your best guess," and A fossil of an ocean fish was found in a rock outcrop on a
"have you heard or have you read that ... ?" Knowledge mountain. Which of the following best describes the
questions can vary widely in difficulty. The easiest questions mean ing of this find ing? Select one ch oice only.
are relatively general and ask for recall of curren t or signifi
Fish once lived on th e mountain.
cant information. The most difficult questions ask the The relative hu midity was once very high.
respondent to recall, understand, in terpret, and apply infor The mountain was raised up after the fish died.
m ation in innovative ways . Consider this example: Fish used to be amphibians like toads and frogs.
Easier: Have you heard or read about President Kennedy's The fossil fish was probably carried to the m ountain
assassination? by a great flood.
More difficult: From this list, select the name of President 1don't kn ow.
Kennedy's probable assassin. By providing an "I don 't know" category, you give people
who might otherwise just guess a place to put their
Even more difficult: Five cities are circled on this map.
Please pOint to the circle that indicates the city in responses. But beware-sometimes respondents who are just
which President Kennedy was assassinated. lazy or who do n ot want to think about the question will use
the "I don't know" option even when they m ight be able to
The first question is the easiest because the significance come up with th e correct answer.
of the assassination suggests that nearly everyone (not just
Americans) will have heard or read about the assassination. Demographics: Who Are the Respondents?
The second question requires recall of a name. President
Demographic information consists of facts about a respon
Kennedy was assassinated in 1963, and for many, the assas
dent's age, race/ethnicity, education , job, gender, marital sta
sin's name has faded from memory. Others may have never
learned the name. The use of a list may help respondents to tus, geographic place of residence, type of residence, size of
remember the name if they ever learned it. The third ques family, and so on.
Compare the two typical demographiC questions about
tion requires knowledge of the name of the city in which the
assassination took place and its location on a map; because it race and ethnicity in Example 4.5. The aim of these two
involves recall and understanding of geography, it is the questions is to collect a vital statistic: the race or ethnicity of
the respondent. The two questions differ in th e following
hardest of the three questions.
Most surveys of knowledge are not achievement tests in ways:
the classical sense. They are not used to grade or prom ote • Question 1 gives the choice of "Black or Negro,"
students or to find out what they h ave learned. You may be whereas Question 2 gives the choice "Black, African
more interested in finding out how many respondents do not American."
kn ow about something. Many surveys of knowledge include
• Question 1 refers to "Indians (Amer,)" an d asks for the
"do not know" or "no opin ion " response choices. These name of the enrolled or principal tribe, whereas
choices also help rem ove some of the threat associated with Question 2 gives the choice of "Native American
knowledge questions. Suppose you were surveying respon
Knowledge, Attitl.lde.';, and BeiJ avior: Tips 81
80 HOW TO ASK SURVEY QUESTIONS
"Asian Indian/' "Guamanian /, "Eskimo/' and "Aleut/' What is your race/ethnlcity? Check one only.
Que$t;ol'l 1, .
Q Southeast Asian: Vietnamese, Cambodian,
o Eskimo
b· Aleut
on .................._...... --> I I
women who participated in a fede rally fu nded project in
If Other race, ......... --> I
I
I
_ , California to improve maternal and infan t outcomes
print race .------------------------------ - ---~ through pren atal care.
o Other race (Print race) 1
82 HOW TO ASK SURVEY QUESTIONS Knowledge, Attitudes, and Behavior: Tips 83
was no longer favored, and the prenatal study team elected prenatal car'e in Califomia:
to use "African American." At about the same time, ((Native If you are White, Latina (or HIspanic), then what is
American " began to coexist with and even su pplant the- country of your birth? Check one only.
(( Am erican Indian" as a category, and Question 2's response
choices also reflect this. 0 United States
Note also that Question 2 offers as one of its choices
"White, Latino (or Hispanic), " but Question 1 does not 0 Mexico
include a comparable choice. People who might be described
as ((White, Latino" constitute a large segment of the U.S. 0 Central America
population, b ut, at least in 1990, Hispanics (or
Caribbean
Latinos/ Latinas) were not, strictly speaking, considered a
racial or ethnic group by the U.S. Bureau of the Census. The
0 SmIth America
Census Bureau asked about Spanish origin, and the prenata
care study asked about country of birth, as shown in 0 Spain or Portugal
Example 4.6.
An important distinction between the two questions is in 0 Other: - - -
the specificity of the responses. The Census Bureau's ques
84 HOW TO ASK SURVEY QUEST IO NS Knowledge, Attitudes, ami Behavior: Tips 85
the ages on the basis of where the respondents were 12 When you are asking income questions with categOrical
months ago? Do you make any allowances for the fact that choices, make sure the categories are meanin gful. If your
by the time you got aroun d to Respondent C, Respondents A respondents are wealth ier people, you sh ould give t hem
and B h ad aged? If you h ave your respondents' dates of birth, many choices above th e median income fo r the commu nity,
you can much more easily compute exact frequencies and whereas if your respondents are poorer, you should give
averages. You can pick one date-say, 6 months after the them many choices below the median, as illustrated in
start of a I-year survey-and compute everyon e's exact age Example 4.8.
on that date. Wh en ever possible, you should ask for precise informa
In come questions are often ((sensitive. " In the United tion about income. The U.S. Census Bureau's income ques
States, a person's income is considered a private, even per tions are very specific: Respon dents are asked about th eir
sonal matter, and asking respondents about their income total income and are also asked to specify income from
requires special care. One way of protectin g respondents' pri wages, salar ies, commiSSions, and tips; self-employment
vacy and yet getting the data you need is to ask respondents income from farms and other businesses; income from inter
where their income falls in a listing of categories, such as est and dividends; rental income; income from estates and
between $40,000 and $50,000 or between $50,00 1 and trusts; in come from royalties; income from social security or
$60,000. Remember to provide mu tually exclusive cate railroad retirem ent pay; Supplemental Security Income, Aid
gories: to Families with Dependen t Children, or other public assis-
Poor: Which best describes your personal income in
2002? Check one only. EXAMPLE 4.8
$35,000 to $55,000
$55,000 to $ 75,000 o
. Setti,,% 1
$75,000 or more o
A survey is being conducted of all people who used
Comment: These categories overlap, so that a person Travelniore Travel Agen cy for three or m ore trips out of
whose income is at the h igh or low end of a category the country that lasted at least 2 weeks . One question
could correctly choose either one. asks about household income:
Whi ch of the following best describes your income
Better: Which best describes your personal income in this current year? Check one only.
2002? Check one only.
o $50,000 or less
$35,000 or less 0
tJ $50,001 to $100,000
$35,001 to $55,000 0
o $100,001 to $200,000
$55,001 to $75,000
o $200,001 or more
$75,001 or m ore
88 HOWTO ASK SURVEY QUESTTONS Knowledge, Attitudes, (lllcl Beha vior: T ips 89
EXIII1ljJIe 4 B wntillueel
EXAMPLE 4.9
Settillg 2 Two Questions About Education
A survey is being conducted to find out where low Question 1
income families obtain mental health services. People
are approached outside schools, churches, and super A survey of physicians in an academic medical center
markets. One question asks about Illcome: l:S interested in finding out bow many of them have
Which of the following best describes your income obtained academic degrees. The survey asks this question:
this current year? Ched. one only. Do you have any of the following degrees? Circle yes
or no for each degree listed.
o $10,000 or less
Vc, (1)
I
f\jo (2)
o $10.001 to $20,000 Master's dCK''''' in publlC Iwalth I :2
~.
I :l-
o $30,00 l or more
I Ph.D. {speLl!". Held:
i-- ..
Vnc tuf l,f D ent~ 1 surgery
I
1 2
Juri;. [loch)r I ~
-
Doctor of Vcterin~r" Medicine 1 2.
ability pensions; and income from child support payments, Oti1t, (specifv: _ _ I 1 1
(such as 9th grade, 8th grade, 7th grade, 6th grade, or lower);
you may also wish to include "Other" as a category. The fol Use current words and terms. The words that are consid
lowing guidelines will help you to fo rmulate the kinds of ered appropriate for use in describing people and
questions you need to get demographic information. their backgrounds change over time, and respon
dents will sometimes find outmoded words to be
offensive. Th e world's geography changes, and peo
ple's affiliation s an d commitments alter. II you bor
Guidelines for Asking Questions row questi ons from other sources, check to be sure
on Vital Statistics and Demographics that they use words tha t are contemporary and
appro priate. Definitions of terms such as household
Learn the characteristics of the sun1ey's targeted respon and understandings of concepts such as "wealth"
dents, so that the response categories make sense. You and "poverty" also change over time.
can fi nd out about your intended respondents by
checking census data, interviewing some individu Decide if you want comparability. If you want to com
als fro m the targeted group, asking others who pare one group of respondents with anoth er, con
know about the respondent group, and reviewing sider borrowing questions and response choices
recent literature. . from other surveys. For example, if you want to
compare the education of people in your survey
Decide on an appropriate level ofspecificity. An appropri with the education of typical Americans in 2000,
ate level is one th at will meet the needs of the sur th en use the education question that was asked in
vey but not be too cumbersome for the respondent. the 2000 U.S. Census. If you borrow questions,
Remember, questions in a self-administered survey check to b e sure that th e words and terms used are
or a telephon e interview should have no more than still relevant and that the response choices are
four or five response categories. An in-person inter meaningful.
viewer should provide respon dents with visual aids
if questiOns h ave more than five response cate
gories.
Special Survey
Questions:
Factorial~
Conjoint~
and Online
Factorial Survey Questions:
your survey, you need to create vignettes that involve factors Example S2 shows the several levels the surveym has
t hat vary (variables) and that you know are likely to be asso identified for each of the variables that appear in brackets in
ciated with the outcome that interests you. Looking at th e Example 5.1. Several thousand vignettes would be needed to
vignettes in Example 5.1, you can see that the surveyor has cover all the possible combinations of variables and levels; in
determined that eight variables are likely to influence teach the real world, you can probably get respondents to concen
ers' definitions and reporting (the outcomes) : gender of the trate on ] 0 to 30 vignettes. The actual number you can use
parent, gender of the child, age of the child, parent's ethnic will depend on the complexity of the vignettes and the moti
ity, parent's employment status, severity of punishment, vation of the respondents to complete the questions. If th ere
type of punish ment, and child's behavior. are too many questions, people may get bored or confused.
Also, because factorial questions usually require respondents
to read more than do other survey questions, you have to be
EXAMPLE 5. 1
careful that the reading level of yom Vignettes is appropriate
Factorial Survey Question in Use
for your respondents. Finally, if the vignettes deal with situa
tions your respondents are unfamiliar withl or that do not
Teachers in this state are required to report suspected interest them, the respondents may give up after completing
cases of child abuse and neglect. Do the teachers define only two or three questions.
child abuse uniformly? How often would they report To create Vignettes for factmial questions, you should
abuse if lliey saw it'? To find out the answers to these begin by randomly combining the different elements of
question s, the surveyor creates Vignettes to use in a sur interest at their various levels. You mus t ensure that all vari
vey of teachers. Each vignette describes a situation that ables have the same probability of being included in the sur-
some people may consider to be an instance of child
abuse. Certain factors wHhin the Vignettes vary (such as
the parent's gender, the child's age, and the parent's eth EXAMPLE 5.2
nicih'). Two sample vignettes follow. Variables and Levels
Variables L~yels
If you saw till,
wouJd you I Cenclrr of p"r~n l I Ma le remitl..
Vignetle5 Is this cWld ahuse? report it?
~ --- -
Gcrlder of chilli 11.1,11" . ("mail'
The [mother] hi t ~ her [1Z-year
old] [daughter] m ing [a
!
I
\~~ "I ch ild l-I-',--I_",--
woodt n stick]. I h e mot heI is YC$ No Ye:; No [t !Jn ,e"i l)' <1' pare" I I\ nn- i.llsp;,m ic Wl l il~, IU'pJ ilk White,
IWhite] an d [unem ployedl. The I ;\l1f(,n Am.mClln . '(lIllh ,\~'i"I\, EIISI \~lol1.
child lappears sullen1. r:tlh "" ~, Japan e,.
I ~- -------
T
-- ~ - -
~l a t u5
The [father] is rarely at home,
vey, and that the resulting vignettes make sense. The survey
questionn aire itself will con sist of a random selection of variables and thei r associated levels shown in
vignettes from the entire pool of vignettes; each respondent Example 5.2 derived those variables and levels fro m
should receive a different combination of vignettes. If you personal experience gained in caring for abused
have 400 persons who complete 25 vignettes each, you will children and from the literature on child abuse and
have 400 x 25 or 10,000 responses. neglect. For instance, the literature shows that the
The advantage of factorial surveys is that they allow you gender of the perpetrator influences people's opin
to m aximize the internal validity associated with experimen ions on the nature of adu lt behavior toward chil
tal designs and the external validity fe atures of a statistical dren. The surveyor therefore included the gender of
survey (one in which the analytic u nits- the vignettes the parent as a variable.
have been randomly sampled). The following guidelines will
• Assign the variables randomly to the vignettes. Random
help you in for creating factorial survey questions.
assignment helps guarantee that every variable has
an equal chance of inclusion in a Vignette. You
should verify that the Vignettes make sense by try
Guidelines for Creating Factorial Survey
ing th em out. In surveys with many variables, you
Questions
may come up with Vignettes that are implausible
and should be omitted .
• Identify specific survey objectives. Before you begin to • Ensure that the vignettes are readable. Factorial sur
design the survey and its questiOns, you must be veys reqUire respondents to do m ore reading than
Ie ·
able to describe each of the survey's objectives with do other surveys. Try out the vignettes with sample
a simple p hrase begin ning with a verb in infinitive respondents to make certain that they can read and
form (e.g., "to identify/' "to understand/' "to exam interpret each one. Keep the Vignettes short, and
ine"). In Example 5.2, the ob jectives are as follows: limit the number you use with respondents who
read poorly.
- To iden tify the variables that teachers say they
associate with child abuse
ing products or services and are asked to p ick the ones they
prefer. EXAMPLES.3
Conjoint analysis is based on th e premise that any good Partial Basis for Pairwise Questions
analysis. As with factorial questions, respondents may Sample question : How much would you be willing to pay for
become weary or confused if you ask them question after white jeans: $30 or $40?
question about pair after pair of attributes. Yo u can use stan
dard experimental designs, such as random selection, to
reduce the number of pairwise items you give to each Fabric
respondent. De'n im Cotton Blen d
In addition to the pairwise approach, conjOint analysis
can use the full-profile method, also called multiple-factor eval $30
uation. In this approach, full or complete profiles of the good Price $40
or service are constructed for all the attributes (see Example
5.4). In a full profile, the respondent is presented with one $50
complete description of the product. Th e description takes Sample question: Row much would you be willing to pay for
into account all attributes of in terest, so if there are many den im jeans: $30 or $40?
attributes, the description can be quite long. In order to
100 HOW TO ASK S U RV~Y QUE$TlONS Special Survey Questions 101
reduce respondent burden, you can use special methods The evidence suggests that the two approaches produce
(e.g., a special class of fra ctional designs caned orthogonal comparable information. In making your choice between
arrays) to diminish the number of full-profile scenarios that approaches, you should consider the purpose of the conjoint
each respondent is required to address. analysis and your respondents' reading level and motivation.
Once you choose an approach, you can ask respondents
to rank or rate the scenarios. In Example 5.5, a respondent
EXAMPLE 5.4
who has been asked to rank nine possible choices of fabric
Conjoint Analysis Question
and color has marked white linen as the top choice and black
Using a Full-Profile Approach:
cotton as the second choice. The respondent's least-favored
Choosing One of Two Profiles
choice for jeans is a blue blend.
EXAMPLE 5.5
Color · 1 White
. Ranking Color and Fabric in a Pairwise Question
Fabric I Blend - Directions: Please rank each color and fabric combination
Price 1$40 on a scale of 1 to 9. A rank of 1 is your top choice. A rank
of 9 is your bottom choice.
Versus --
White Black Bl~e
Cotton 7 2 4
-
Color Blue
Linen 1 6 3
Fabric I
I
Blend
. Blend 8 5 9 ]
I Price
- - - -
1$60
EXAMPLE 5.6
EXAMPLE 5.7
Please rate each of the following using this scale: Please rate your preference for Option A or B.
5 = Definitely prefer Use this scale:
4 = Probably prefer 5 = Definitely prefer A
3 = No prefeIence 4 = Probably prefer A
2 = Probably do not prefer 3 = No preference
1 = Definitely do not prefer 2= Probably prefer B
1 =Definitely prefer B
White linen at $40 5 4 3 2 1
-
Black linen at $30 5 4 3 2 1 OPTION A OPTION B
Blue linen at $20 5 4 3
-_... 2 1 White OR I Black
Blue cotton at $20 5 4 3 2 1 Linen Linen
Black blend at $20 5 I 4 3 2 1 $40 $30
Etc. 5 4 3 2 1
Online surveys are different from paper-and-pencil an d your company's Intranet), you can easily use color and sim
computer-assisted surveys in that they can provide respon ple graphiCS to make your survey more attractive. The com
dents with sophisticated audio and visual aids to help th em parative effectiveness of color versus th e usual black
better understand terms they cannot read or do not under and-white survey questionnaire is currently unknown, how
stand. However, although technology exists that will allow ever. Remember that if you plan to use graphics in your
you to supplement online surveys with audio and visual online survey, you n eed to make sure that your intended
aids, respondents may not have the equipment (e.g., sound respondents can easily download any necessary files. Do
cards) that will enable them to hear or view these features. they have compatible software? Do they have enough di sk
Even if respondents do have access to the latest technol space to store any files you send them?
ogy, they may not know how to use it appropriately, if at all.
If you are planning to conduct an online survey, you must be
DROPDOWN LISTS
concerned with your respondents' "computer literacy." In
particular, do they have the skills to use a keyboard, a mouse, Although online surveys rely on the same principles of
or both in order to scroll through th e screens that make up question writing as do mail surveys and other self-adminis
the questionnaire, enter the answers, and perform the opera tered surveys, the question and response formats you can use
tions necessary to go from question to question and submit onlin e are more varied. For instance, questions in online sur
the completed questionnaire? Some online surveys require veys can offer responses in dropdown lists, as shown in
respondents to open e-mail attachments or to input particu Example 5.8. The respondent clicks on the down arrow fol
lar Web site addresses (URLs) to get to the questionnaires. lowing a question, and a list of response choices appears. The
Some people may use computers but still have difficulty with respondent then clicks on his or her choice, which immedi
these operatiOns. ately appears in the blank bar.
The levels of computer literacy among potential respon If you use drop down lists, you must be sure that your
dents vary greatly. Some people can use practically any type respondents know how to use a mouse. Such lists are useful
of software, whereas others are mainly fam iliar with sending when you want respondents to provide you with informa
e-mail and shopping on th e Internet. Generally, individuals tion in certain words (e.g., "program," not "intervention";
respond to online surveys on desktop or laptop computers or "interview," not "survey") or when you want information in
on handheld devices. Voice recognition and touch-screen a specified format (e.g., California, not CA or Cal).
technologies are not yet the norm for these surveys. Dropdown lists need to offer a finite number of choices
On the whole, the types of questions that are appropriate (such as the 50 states in the United States, the 6 states of
for online surveys are fa irly similar to those used in other Australia plus the Northern Territories, the 7 days in a week,
self-administered questionnaires. In fact, an important and or the 12 months in a year).
cu rrently unanswered qu estion about online surveys is
whether they are simply a technological advance in self
administered survey design or if th ey are actu ally a different
type of survey altogether.
One major and im portan t difference between the ques
tions you can use in online surveys and those in other types
of surveys is that online, even in small surveys (say, those on
106 HOW TO AS K SURVEY QUT:Sn ONS Specia I Survey Questions 107
""wlPI.:q!9J/lj::
(l .e.b 3UCV'1!7
'.
SELECT ONE
In another fo rm of online question, the respondent
selects one of multiple answers. The response choices may be
ordinal (as in Example S. 9), nominal (Exam ple S.IO), or
nu merical (Example S.I1). An "other, please specify" choice
may also be offered.
108 HOW TO ASK SURVEY Q UESTIONS Special Survey Questions 109
EXAMPLE 5.10
EXAMPLE 5.11
Q.::!m
ht.....,. *'...... "y7 (NuoIoal Roopo. . "S " " " "
-
o o..ipcIWcon._"--Ib_md
. . . t Year
a 0 . dli'f' Ih.. "., eo.pttt....t.ed f'lMY PO O1: AYlllrap Ibccellatt.
- _.....·lfPly·
o 1\1'1'''
"check all that apply" option for responses (see Example o OIM,. plo....pody-_ _ _ __
Ye, No
s...- O 0
One common format used in online surveys to get
OO""p~'" 0 0 answers from several questions with the same response
.poat;- - choices takes the form shown in Example S.lS. Questions
and response choices like these are often used in surveys,
and respondents are familiar with them. Respondent famil
iarity with response scales and how to use them increases
reliability.
If you plan to use questions like these in online surveys,
you should keep each question and its response choices to a
length that fits on one screen, so that the respondent does
One of the advantages of offering yes/no choices is that if not have to scroll up to read the choices. If you cannot
respondents n eglect to answer any questions, the online sur shorten the question, divide it into two questions. If you are
vey software can prompt them to go back and give answers, the first person to divide a particular question into two (that
and prevent them fro m m oving on in the survey until they is, if you have adapted or adopted the longer form of the
do. This feature, which protects against m issing data, is often question from another survey), you will need to ensure that
cited as one of the main advantages th at online surveys h ave you h ave not altered its reliability. You can test this in your
over oth er surveys. Online surveys th at require respondents pretest and pilot test. In large surveys, you can design an
to complete one item before they can move on to th e next experiment to answer the question: Do I collect the same
are called interactive. (equivalent) information when the question is asked in two
Some surveyors object to the idea of forc ing respondents parts as I do when it is in one part?
to provide an answer to one question before they can go on
to the next. They point out that no other type of survey
fo rces answers from respondents. They also say that some
times responde nts have legitimate reasons for ob jecting to
....
114 H O W TO AS K SURVEY QUESTIONS Special Survey Questions 115
~I
. ~•. 4..
I WOUl.d. as ltUdh a.
Li b I ,",auld.
LUte.
bepperut to ~
I Qe t l o~ and a :C tee:&icn 0 0 0 0
ma~t~[';!
OPEN-ENDED QUESTIONS
Most surveyors prefer to minimize the use of open-ended
questions in onlin e surveys, which are design ed to permit
instant data analysis, and so to yield results quickly.
However, in keeping with survey tradition, many surveyors
leave space in their online surveys for respondent com
ments. Example 5.16 shows an open-ended question that is
typical of the kind often foun d in Internet surveys.
User-frien dly software programs are available to guide
you in choosin g and formatting questions for an online sur
vey and arranging them into a questionnaire. To comparison
shop, enter the keywords survey software into practically any
Internet search engine.
5lJ
Survey question
Techniques for
the Survey Teaut:
The Focus Group
117
0..::
11 8 HOW TO ASK SURVEY QUESTIONS The Focus Group 119
education, or any other area of interest. The people in a The purpose of focus groups is not to educate people. For
focus group may be schoolchildren, famlers, consumers, or example, you would not use the fo cus group described in
entrepreneurs, or they may h ave any other kind of character Example 6.1 to teach the participating parents about the use
istic in common. Surveyors typically use focus groups to of seat belts. Nor is the purpose of focus groups to come to
hel p develop t he content and format of surveys. However, if consensus about an issue, such as the appropriate use of seat
you have the resources, you can use focus groups to check on belts. Compare the scenarios in Example 6.2: Scenario 1
the appropriateness of the language and content of a survey describes an appropriate use of a focus group, whereas
that you h ave already developed (see Example 6.1). Scenarios 2 and 3 do not. You should use focus groups when
you are looking for a range of ideas and perspectives and you
want ideas to emerge from the group. If your aim is to estab
EXAMPLE 6.1
lish group consensus or to educate, focus groups are not the
Checking Language and Content
appropria te technique to use.
With a Focus Group
~
120 HOW TO ASK SURVEY QU ESTIONS Th e Focus Group 121
role-playing. At the end of the meeting, they are given a Overall Purpose of Study and Learning Names
.....
HOW TO ASK SURV EY QUESTIONS T he Focus Group 123
122
3. Do you think your class work is affected by ./ Don't let one person dominate the discussion.
4. If you did not h ave access to TechHelp, ./ Keep your opinions to yourself.
sequence that will yield the most complete information. ending questions.
Look at the sequence of the set of questions in Exam ple 6.3,
which is fairly standard in focus groups. It is likely that 2
h ours will be just sufficient to get complete answers to the
eight questions shown in this example.
5f]
Exercises
EXERCISE 1
Read the description of the survey plan
Number of
Topic Questions Information Collected EXERCISE 2
Age 1 Date of birth Write a survey that answers these questions:
Region of the 1 Northeast, Middle Atlantic,
country Southeast, Midwest, Northwest,
Southwest, West 1. Does this book achieve each of its stated objec
tives?
Kitchen goods 5 Type of kitchen goods wou ld
purchase, if any (e .g., furniture,
dishes, linens) 2. On the whole, how helpful were the book's
Household goods 1 Type of household goods would
examples in assisting readers to learn?
purchase, if any (e.g ., furniture,
pictu res) 3. How practical are each of this book's gUidelines
Frequency of past 1 If ever, once before, twice, three or and checklists ?
purchases from more times
Outdoors
4. Do readers usuaUy enjoy reading the text and
Satisfaction 2 Sa tisfied with service, with doing the exercises?
purch ase : ex tremely satisfied to
extremely dissatisfied
I
128 HOW TO ASK SU RVEY Q UESTIONS Exercises 129
thing before we concl ude? It is very important that we come Month Day Year
Middle Atlantic 0
Furniture for the living Toom 1 2 3
Southeast o
Floor coverings 1 2 3
Midwest o
Pictures and photographs 1 2 3
Northwest o
Southwest o
Bedroom furniture 1 2 3
West o
Furniture for a study or den 1 2 3
Floor coverings 1 2 3
3. Types ofData Obtained From Each Question
. -
........
Probably yes 2
Uncertain/
Yes No Don't Know Pro bably no 3
measurement 3 = Practical
Please make one rating for each of the listed guidelines and 2. Do you recommend this book to others who
checklists. have similar responsibilities for asking survey
questions?
Guidelines
Please circle one.
I
Guidelines for Asking 1 2 3 4 0
Survey Questions Definitely yes 1
Probably yes 2
Questions
Uncertain/no opinion 0
Government 0
Bu siness
Did you usually enjoy reading the text and doing the exer Health professiOns
Other: _ _ _ _ _ _ __ o
.oil
136 HOW TO ASK SURVEY QUESTIONS
EXERCISE 3
An overview and good examples of how surveys are used in the United
States; helpful for understanding the context of survey research.
Couper, M. P, Traugott, M . w., & Lamias, M. J. (2001). Web survey design.
Public Opinion Quarterly, 65, 231-253 .
Many examples of questions used in an Internet study to examine the effects
ofquestion format and design on data quality.
Fink, A. (1993). Evaluation fundamentals: Guiding health programs, research, and
policy. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
Gives rules for asking questions and responses, provides a checklist for creat
ing or adapting measures, and discusses the roles of categorical, ordinal, and
numerical data in measurement and data analysis.
137
Suggested Readings 139
138 H OW TO AS K SURVEY Q UESTIONS
Schuman, H., & Presser, S. (1981). Questions and answers in attitude surveys.
Fink, A., & Kosecoff, J. (1998). How to conduct surveys: A step-by-step guide (2nd
ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. New York: Academic Press.
Gives many examples of survey questions and contains rules and guidelines Raises and addresses many important issues regarding how to design ques
for asking questions. tions about attitudes; includes good examples.
Frey, J. H. (1989). Survey research by telephone (2nd ed.). N ewbury Park, CA: Stewart/ A. L., & Ware/ J. E. (1992). Measuring functioning and well-being: The
Sage.
medical outcomes study approach. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Gives excellent examples of questions and how to get needed information Tells of the design and validation of a wide range ofself-reported functioning
through telephone surveys. and well-being measures developed for a large U.S. study of health care; very
good source of questions.
Lavrakas, P. J. (1993). Telephone survey methods: Sampling, selection, and supervi
sion (2nd ed.). Newbury Park, CA: Sage. Sudman, S., & Bradburn, N. M . (1982). Asking questions. San Francisco: Jossey
Bass.
Discusses questions in the context of telephone surveys.
Very good source for examples of how to write questions pertaining to atti
McDowell, 1./ & Newell, C. (1996). Measuring health: A guide to rating scales and tudes, knowledge, behavior, and demographics.
questionnaires (2nd ed.). New York: Oxford University Press.
Contains a very good compendium of scales to use in asking questions per
taining to health.
Miller, D. C. (1991). Handbook of research design and social measurement. N ewbury
Park, CA: Sage.
Glossary
141
142 H O W TO ASK SURVEY QUESTIONS
143