Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
DigitalCommons@UNO
Service Learning, General Service Learning
11-1990
Recommended Citation
Berman, Sheldon, "Educating for Social Responsibility" (1990). Service Learning, General. Paper 43.
http://digitalcommons.unomaha.edu/slceslgen/43
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Service
Learning at DigitalCommons@UNO. It has been accepted for inclusion in
Service Learning, General by an authorized administrator of
DigitalCommons@UNO. For more information, please contact
unodigitalcommons@unomaha.edu.
SHELDON BERMAN ------.1 t1
;1
Social Responsibility ·j
I •
Educating for
Social Responsibility
Schools must help students fight their feelings of
powerlessness by developing their sense of
community and their confidence that they can
n1ake a difference in the world.
oday the development of social · drawal from active participation in our srateme:;:, "I feel I can do very little to
responsibility is a renewed con- , society, their declining voting patterns, change :.'r)e way the world is today."
cern of educators, and this has ; and their preoccupation v.im their in- And ap;·roximately 30 percent chose
..,.. ..... '".u a number of innovations. At : dividual desires and needs. For exam- "mostly ::gree" or "agree" in response
these. effons developed in isola- i pie, jerry Bachman, who has surveyed to this s-.:uement: ''When I think about
Different movements addressed I 17,000 high school seniors each year all the :errible things that have been
•;OJilterem aspects of social responsibil- : since 1975, found that since 1978 an happeni."1g, it is hard for me to hold
learning, conflict i average of approximately 45 percent out muC::: hope for the world." 1 Alarm-
multicultural education. : of the students polled chose "mostly ingly, the 18- to 24-year-old voting group
development, global educa- · :tgree" or "agree" in response to the is the c-:Uy category of newly enfran-
environmental education, com- . chised •'C-::ers in our history whose vot-
ty service, and involvement in i ing parre:ns have shown a decline since
and social issues. Now .edu- . they we-e enfranchised. 2 These findings
experiments are emerging'.;. point to :! fundamental lack of cormec-
blend all of these intc:i programs tion anc commitment between self and
make social responsibility a core Social responsibility the large:- community.
of the curriculum and school Soci:J responsibility-that is, a per-
-that
These initiatives are helping is, a personal sonal ir:-.-estment in the well-being of
.....mn""~.··- develop basic social skills. a investment in the others :!.::d of the planet~oesn't just
.of connection with the world happen It takes intention, attention,
: well-being of
them, and the confidence that and time It may even take redesigning
~ey make'a difference in the worl~. others and of the schools .:nd classrooms to embrace a
· Why the concern? Young people m , , culture :.,at values and creates em-
the United . States are expressing a 1 planet--doesn t powerr::::nt, cooperation, compassion,
~se of powerlessness to affect con- just happen. and res:--ect.
~ctive social or political change. To
Young, the odds of success seem Our Relationship with Society
~erwhelming, the personal costs The que:::ion of what motivates panic-
high, the disappointments inevitable. ipation ~ an old one, but researchers
'llie results are seen in their with- l who h:::;e studied political socializa-
1990 75
tion, prosocial behavior development, :-ome::tnes the struggle to reconcile Understmtding Our
psychosocial development, and moral jape .illd pain. The power of this work Interdependence
development give us only glimpses :Cas convinced me that we must help Teachers m~r first help students
into the development of social respon- :'tuder:rs develop a positive relationship velop an ur:dersranding of our
sibility. Their research tells us that -;>.'ith s.xiety by promoting a passionate and ecologid interdependence.
children begin constructing their rela- • md i_lformed engagement with the crises of the L1St decade-nuclear
tionship with the political world early · world around them. destruction of the environment
in life and thai parentS, teachers, and ism, hunger and homelessnes's
other role models are critical for each Educating for the mass scale, md local and inte
child's formation of a positive and Development of Sc:-;:ial violence-r""\·e demonstrated the
empowe:red relationship with society. Consciousness ness of our ;>hnet and our
We also know that the most effective Once the conversation has been connection "-ith others around
means of helping studentS de\·elop openc:D, educating young people for globe. There is no getting ··away"
this relationship is to give them the :he development of social conscious- more. We Juye to understand our
opportunity to enter and engage the Z'!ess means posing a set of questions dependence md Jearn how to get
real world around them. 3 :hat e::nphasizes their social develop- in an interdependent world.
My own research (Berman 1990), mem: What does the way I lead my life Some '·ir::emational studies"
on the development of social con- ' mean for the lives of others? What is schools alre:1dy embody this
sciousness confirms this. Each of us my hope for the future and my vision standing. And 3. number of mr..v..rn-
develops a reb.tionship to society and of wl':.at I would like our world to in educatior. .lre beginning to d
to the world. Furthermore, the way we xcooe? Are my actions consistent our knowledge of how to live in
give meaning w this relationship de- -;>.·ith L.1e way I would like the world to interdependent \\'Orld. The nrrlmin-
termines the nature of our participa- x? \r"nat can we do together as a com- ones induce the global
tion in the world Like a relationship munir:;, as a society, and as a world movement. :he environmental
with another person, our relationship community, that will promote our com-
with society includes such powerful mon good and our common wealth? education rr:o\·emem.
factors as interconnection, emotion, How can I contribute in a meaningful There are :1lso some promising
influence, and vulnerability. "'-ay m creating a more just, peaceful, e.xperiment5 To help students see
I use the term relationship because md e.::ologically sound world? Iems holistiC:llJy, jay Forrester and
people don't make moral decisions in In schools and classrooms, this ers at MIT ruve been working
isolation, especially not decisions that mearu balancing our emphasis on teachers in Brattleboro, Vermont, to
relate to larger social and political ~rsmal self-realization and personal regrate syste:ns d~namics into the
.issues. ·These. deeisions emerge di- · :1chievement with an equal focus on riculum? Sys:erns dynamics nrr1mi~p<;;·
. rectly from people's understanding ~ocial self-realization and collective help students ~ problems uu.u.>u...-.
of the dominant morality in the polit- : :1chie>ement. Bur,· in teaching for so- understand me workings of whole
ical culture and from their sense of ! cial self-realization, the wav we teach terns whether thev are social, ecc1nor~
their personal ability to influence that l md the culture of our classrooms or envirorunenrai, and to see the
culture. :md schools is of even greater impor- connections :1mong these systems.
Although we all exist in relationship : :mce than what we teach. Teachers These effor..s are vitally
to society, I've come to realize that ; :nust model the values and principles help studen:s grasp and work
people seldom talk about the nature of of care, justice, empowerment, com- conceptS of in<erdependence. Yet
this relationship. But helping young muniry-, and social responsibility for are often add-ons, imposed on
people become socially responsibile dleir studentS. that are accountable for a Jmc:>WJletJ!
starts with opening a conversation In particular, teachers must help and skill base that does not give
about this rel:nionship. When it is dif- i:heir srudenrs understand our- global of interdependence top priority.
ficult for people to describe this in interdependence, give them the e."Cpe- truly want w develop socially
words, I:ve asked them first to draw rience of community, encourage them scious young people, we will
the way they see their own relation- co den:lop basic social skills, provide change our priorities so that
ship to society. Tve collected drawings them with opportunities to make con- social skills. appreciation for
from elementary school children, from aibutions to others, strengthen their diversity and ecological balance,
high school and college students, and group problem-solving and organiza- systems analysis are central nn)>11LUo'
from adults '\Vho represent a wide Lional skills, and encourage them to concepts within the curriculum.
range of lifesryles and viewpoints. explore the real political world. In the
These drawings usually reveal complex ~tions that follow, I'll discuss each of Becoming Part of a
feclings towards society-sometimes a r:hese dimensions and dose with ex- Community
rich mosaic of interconnectedness, amples of programs that are trying to Becoming socially conscious
sometimes the painful expression of mcorporate all of them into the lives becoming :m-are of group
alienation and· powerlessness, and of schools (see fig. 1). individual who develops a '
76
NG REAL .WORLD ISSUES . . ESTO BE A RESPONSIBLE
. ;~·.;;t
-inquiry ER OF A COMMUNITY
-critical thinking - :_sharcil goals
-dialogue -Participatory decsioo-making
-negotiation - -collective efforts
-acknowledgement oi community
accomplishment5
of the group" begins to sense the people who acknowledge their inter- oommunity, people be-.:ome rich re-
zmosphere that is present in the group, connectedness, have a sense of their sources to each othe:- Communities
observe how people's interactions common purpose, respect their differ- meed stories, heroes ar:d heroines, rit-
I.J.Ilnue.nce the productivity of the group, ences, share in group decision making u:als, and celebrations These are the
2lld to understarld the impaa his or her as well as in responsibility for the oil that makes a com...-:mnity function
nons have on the group as a whole. actions of the group, and support each smoothly. They demmstrate that its
Becoming socially responsible means other's grov.1h. members are valued ~~d that people
USing this consciousness to intervene to With time. diligent effon, and new care about each other and about the
the group's ability to live and forms of shared leadership, class- group as a whole.
'•ork rogether. rooms and schools can be this kind of Out of the experie::ce of commu-
De\·eloping a "consciousness of the community. Creatinp,a caring commu- nity, young people nc-: only become
8mup" is a skill that can be nunured nity in a classroom or school calls for oonscious of group ne-eds and group
only through experience. But the style developing a shared set of values or process, but theybegi!'. to understand
of instruction in most classrooms is goals and establishing struaures that dbe meaning of the common good,
either individualistic or competitive, allow students and faculty to panici- to appreciate that tl:eir efforts do
and consequently, children do not pate in decision making. It also means make a difference. and to develop a
ha\'e _occasion to develop this skill.
Cooperative learning techniques help,
providing .. community time" for fac- sense of relatedness to the larger
ulty to think and work together and for human community.
I
1·
2S you might expect, but the best way students to panicipate in community i!
!0 te2.ch this consciousness is to create decision making and in collective ef- Developing Basic Social '·L
classrooms and schools that function forts that contribute to the school or Skills I
as caring communities. make a difference in the world. Community building ::.::d developing a l
t
The term communi[)• is often used A sense of community requires affir- sense of social respor;5ibility demand
'-ery loosely; but when-I ask people in mation. Community building means basic social skills such :ts communica-
~y Workshops to think about commu- finding ways in which the community tion, cooperation. conflict manage-
flity in their own lives, a rich definition can affirm its members and acknowl- ment, and perspec-Jw taking. Like
emerges: a community is a group of edge its own accomplishments. In a competency skills in r~ding, writing,
~O\'f:\IBER 1990 77
tasks that compel us to live "'·ith ambi· stories of others. szudems ": ._. have
guity and to be continualh· open tc, reci.Iimecl forests. cleaned up rirers
change. Two useful strategies that em improved their school environmen~
help studentS learn to take another s helped the homeless 6 They need to
Teachers who create perspecth·e and to reflect on their 0\\·n hc:Ir about the .:\!mher Teresas and
environments that thinking 2.re role playing and jounul the .\1anin L.Jther Kings, of course,
writing. .Manin Hoffman's (1984a,b) in- but also about the people who live
model social skills ductive discipline--directing a child' dO\\n the street who are doing what
will succeed in ,lttention :o the feelings of another-i, the\· can to impro .. ·e the ne;g1bor-
another sr.rategv. At the secondal\' len:!. hoocl and about the many on!.:lniza-
teaching them. Peter Elbow ( 1986) and ESR have de- tions that make a difference in our
veloped ::. particularly po,Yerful tool communities. \\"e must put students ,
called me:hodological belief (Bemun in touch with these people and orga-
1987). In this exercise, students go niz:nions so that L~e,· can see how 1
~OI'E.\iBER 1990 70
~~----------------------------------------~
I.
........... ~
r
serY:: to build a cohesive ar1d suppor:t- Each of these efforts is experiment- :;l·hool students and }f/akinB i-:!!sto'}' for
h·e ~=mosphere that nunures moral ing with long-rem1, comprehensive Sc'l.:ondary school students. Tr.::c:<c are avail.
gro-..-:h and social competence. change. As they eYolve, they will offer J.ble from ESR at Sheldon Bc::man·s ad.
A ~-=cond example, the Child Devel- us models of what we can do and dr6s, below.
opn·:::nt Project, promote~ prosocial provide experience, research, and -\'\'rite to ESR for Susan jon~ >··10 Point
~lc~del for Teaching ContrO\e~i:ll Issues."
beh.;:·,iors such as helpfulness, fair- suppon materi:lls to make it easier for
"For more details on te::.~:;ing about
nes~ :md responsibility by integrating other schools md districts to initiate •1.mtroversial issues see: S Berman
five ::leme;its into the regular aca- successful progr-Jins. "Thinking in Context: Teachir.~ :'or Ope0:
den:.:~ curriculum of three San Ramon mindedness and Critical Cnc;e;-s;;1r:ding,"
eler:·.::mary schools. These: five ele- Social Vision and Education in Dez·eloping .Hinds: A Resour:c: Book for
mer.:< include: (1) teaching cooper- As educators, ...-e must inspire young Teaching Tbinking. 2nd ed .. ;:-ji:ed by A
aria:-.. (2) promoting helpin3 skills, (3) people to hold J positive vision of the Costa. Alexandria, Va.: Associ~:ic:.n for Su.
pwding positive role models both future-{O b~lie,·e that we can do bet- ;>enision and Curriculum JJ;e\·~Jopmen~
ficti·: :131 and real, (4) enh:mcing stu- ter, live better. be kinder, and be 1900.
den:' ability to understand another's fairer. Studenrs need our help if they References
feeli:-cgs. customs, and the like. and (5) are to develop confidence to partici- Berman, S. (1990). "The :\d Ropes
de,·:::·)ping self-control and internaliz- pate in creating a more peaceful, just, Course: The Development c: SociJI Con-
ing : xe helping values through "posi- and ecologically sound world. This &."iousness, ESR]ournall-:~
tive Jiscipline." The proiea docu- challenge raises questions about what Berman, S. (1987). "Beyond C:-::ic:;J Think·
mer.:::d increases in studenrs· helping we teach. ho"'· ...-e teach, and how our ing: Teaching for Synthesis ESR Forum
beh.;:·,iors, cooperation, and ability to schools are strucrured. It demands that 6. 1: 1-2. .
deal :-,ith conflicts (see article: by Schaps we find ways to balance personal com- Berman, S., ed. (1983). Pt-ro-;-2ctires: A
and ~olamon, p. 38). petence with social skills and social Teaching Guide to Conce;:..< of Peace;
Cambridge, Mass.: Educate:-! for Social
Fi:-.:llly, the Educating for living in a responsibility. Responsibility. )
.i\'uc::::1r Age Project (ELNAJ (see ani- In spite of irs challenges, this effon Community Board Progr-.:..-::.
de ty Richard Sagar, p. "'fl is a col- can renew our sense of purpose and ' Conflict Resolution: A Sec01:-:fm)'
labo::-~Iive effon of 12 school districts meaning as educators. Most teachers Cum·culum. San Franciscc
in L'-.e Boston area and five school enter the profession because they care munity Board Program.
distr: :rs in Ponland, Oregon, to make about children and care about the Elbow, P. (1986). Embracing (',-,,,,trLlril!jc~l
soci.:i responsibility a core element of world. Teaching is our vehicle for :\ew York: Oxford Universi::-:· ?ress.
the crficulum. The project's four ma- making a difference in the world. This Erikson, E. (1968). Identity. ioutb
jor cbjectives are to help students: (1) vision offers all of us an occasion for · Crisis. New York: W. W. 1\o::-::•n.
und:::-stand the nature of social and seeing our work as pan of the world Hoffman, M. (1984a). "Empa&.:.-. Its
tions. and Its Role in a Cor:- --L---·'· ..."
ecol: gical interdependence through we hope to cre-.:.te.O ~!oral Theory." In Mora/if)
glob.J education, multicultural educa- bat·ior, and Moral Develop•:.mt.
byW. Kunines and]. Gewir:z. ~e.,·
1
tion. ~d environmental education; (2) L. D. johnston.]. G. Bachman, and P.M.·
den·~op cooperation and conflict res- O'Malley (Projec: Directors), (1975-1989), 1 John Wiley and Sons.
oluti:·n skills; (3) understand current The ·'Monitoring r:.l-Je Future Study," Insti- ~
·. :Honman, 4b). "Paren:
~ 1.( 198
soci:;I and political issues by integrat- tute for Social R~e-:;..rch, The University o f ~!oral Internalization, and D=··;e}()pnJef!~l
ing :-eal-world issues throughout the Michigan, Ann .-\roor. :\U 48106. of Prosocial Motivation... 1.1
2
Data are from the Committee for the ment and Maintenance of ""''""-,/11
curn:ulum; and (4) develop the con-
Study of the American Electorate, 421 New baz·ior, edited by E. Staub. D.
fider:·:e that they can make a difference
jersey Ave., S.E.. ~ashington, DC._20_003. Karylowski, and]. Reykowski ~ew-
through panicipatory decision mak- 3For a list of 50me of the leading re· Plenum Press.
ing. -community building, and commu- search anicles and books in the area of Kreidler, w. (1984). CreatiFe Conflict
nity. service. The projea engages social responsibility. write. to ESR at She!- olution. Glenview, Ill.: Sea::. Fo 1:esin~IJI
team~ of teachers in participating don Berman's address, below. .
· schml districts to create programs and
4 See the Brattlel;oro Bulletin: The News- I . and Company. _
1 .Lickona, T. (February 1984). ·:our
initi2ives that promote social respon- letter of the Systems Thinking National : gies for Fostering Characre:-
sibili:y. Although it is in its initial Education Projea Setwork, edited by Pe- mem in Children." Phi Det':a
pha~s, the project has produced a
ter Bunner, South St.. RD 2, Box 9, West 41 9-4 23.
model curriculum assessment on is- Brattleboro,
5
Vf 05301. ~oderick, T. (Dec,1an 1988). ·.iohnnY
See Educational leadership, December Learn to Negotiate," Educat:.onal
sues related to social responsibility 1989/.January 1990 issue for its articles on erbsip 86-90.
and has initiated programs in environ- cooperative learning.
menu! education, global telecommu- ~wo excellent resources on participa- Sheldon Berman is PresidenL
nications, student leadership develop- tion and communi[)· service are ESR's cur- !for Social Responsibility, 23 U<;U.u~····
meaL and conflict resolution. riculum guides Taking Part for elementary Cambridge, MA 02138.
80