Sunteți pe pagina 1din 5

CORPORATE GOVERNANCE

CORPORATE GOVERNANCE,
DISCLOSURE AND ITS EVIDENCE
IN INDONESIA
Siddharta Utama

PART 2 date of incorporation, the company’s


Abstract products and main line(s) of business,
personal details of the members of the
One principle of corporate governance is disclosure and transparency. This board of directors and commissioners,
principle stipulates that relevant and reliable disclosure is made on all material and the amount of capital authorized,
matters regarding the corporation. By applying this principle, information placed and paid-in. Unfortunately some
asymmetry can be reduced and thus negative consequences of adverse weaknesses arise in the implementa-
selection and moral hazard problems can be minimized. This paper assesses tion of the law. Among other things, there
the extent of regulation on disclosure in Indonesia and reviews the evidence on is a lack of monitoring and measures
the disclosure level among publicly listed companies in Indonesia. In Indonesia, taken to ensure that companies report
private mechanism to control the negative consequences of information the required information in an appropri-
asymmetry is not effective since the role of board of directors/ commissioners ate and timely manner.
and banks/creditors is minimum in monitoring the firms’ actions. Further, the The government regulation No. 64 of
capital and labor markets are not well developed. Without proper regulation, 1999 expands the base of companies
the amount of information produced by these companies, as expected, is required to submit their financial reports
inadequate. In recent years, there has been significant improvement in the available to the public. In the past only
regulation of disclosure in Indonesia. Badan Pengawas Pasar Modal (Capital listed companies are required to report
Market Monitoring Agency) has issued a number of rules that enforce disclo- their audited financial statements. Un-
sure and that protect the interest of minority shareholders. The accounting der the new regulation, companies re-
standards are harmonized with the International Accounting Standards while quired to file audited financial statements
the due process in preparing the standards has been intensified. Empirical among others include those that issue a
evidences, however, find that in general the disclosure level among publicly debt instrument or that have a total as-
listed companies in Indonesia is low. Even for mandatory disclosure, the sets or net assets in excess of 25 billion
compliance rate is not satisfactory. This low level of disclosure despite the rupiah. This regulation can be consid-
enhancement of disclosure requirement by the regulating bodies suggests that ered as a major step in improving trans-
the enforcement of the regulation needs to be improved. The paper concludes parency and accountability in Indonesia.
with some policy recommendations to improve the disclosure level in Indone- Bapepam has numerous rules re-
sia. lated to financial and non-financial dis-
closure. Some examples are: Planning
Keywords: Corporate Governance, Disclosure, Indonesia, Regulation, Financial and Conducting the General Meeting of
Statements, Annual Report Shareholders (Bapepam Rule IX.1.1),
Disclosure of Information that Must Im-
Regulation on Disclosure Policy in Regulations that govern companies’ mediately be Made Public (Bapepam
Indonesia disclosures in Indonesia includes:1 Rule X.K.1), Report on the Use of Funds
This section reviews and analyzes - Law No. 3 of 1982 regarding Received from Public Offering (Bapepam
the regulation on disclosure policy in Company Registry. Rule X.K.4).
Indonesia with particular emphasis is - Government Regulation No. 64 of Bapepam Rule VIII.G.2 specifies in
given to publicly listed companies. It 1999 regarding annual financial detail materials that must be included in
touches the development of accounting statement. the annual report. These include:
standards in Indonesia and discusses - Badan Pengawas Pasar Modal a. General description
disclosure policy in the banking industry (Bapepam) rules for publicly listed Provide general description of the
as an illustrative case. companies. company, such as products or
services offered, description of
Siddharta Utama, Ph. D, CFA, Under the Company Registry Law, directors and commissioners, the
Department of Accounting, Faculty of companies must provide information
accessible to public which among oth- 1. The following 3 paragraphs are excerpt from
Economics University of Indonesia Ikatan Akuntan Indonesia (2000)
ers include the name of the company, the

USAHAWAN NO. 05 TH XXXII MEI 2003 11


company’s development, and so on. tee, which is a part of IAI. In order to add activities, bank strategies and manage-
b. Special description the credibility of its accounting standards, ment policies, products and services
This section covers stock price in 1994 the committee decided to har- offered, social activities, bank develop-
information, location and type of fixed monize its accounting standards with ment, targets in the future, information
assets, dividend policy, realization the International Accounting Standards technology.
of the use of funds from public issued by the International Accounting
information, other material Standards Committee (IASC). By the end b. Financial statements for the past
information. of 2001, there are more than 60 PSAK two years
c. Summary of important financial data (Statements of Financial Accounting Audit opinion, balance sheet, income
Five year comparison of sales, gross Standards) in effect and they covered statement, retained earnings statement,
profits, operating income, net almost all business transactions and commitments and contingencies, cash
income, outstanding shares, events relevant to companies in Indone- flow statement, notes to financial state-
earnings per share, net working sia. Some of the standards even regu- ment.
capital, total assets, total liabilities, lated transactions or events that have not
return on assets, return on equity, been addressed by the IASC.2 c. Items need attention
current ratio, debt to equity ratio, and To improve the quality of accounting Credit analysis, such as % of credits
other relevant financial information. standards, the Committee enhances the by industry, credits given to related par-
d. Management discussion and due process procedures in developing ties, collectibility of credits, loans that
analysis the standards. The due process for ex- include domestic and overseas loans.
The management should discuss ample includes requiring standards to In general, information required by
and analyze financial and other be exposed to the constituents for com- Bapepam and Bank Indonesia to be
information with the emphasis on ments before they are approved. disclosed is similar. Unlike Bapepam,
material changes that have occurred however, the central bank does not re-
since the last annual report. Annual Report in the Banking Industry3 quire management to discuss and ana-
e. Financial statements Annual report is the primary means lyze the performance of bank in the past
Financial statements should be utilized by the management to commu- two years. On the other hand, the central
prepared to the current accounting nicate financial condition and other infor- bank requires detail information on own-
standards. mation to investors, creditors, and other ership structure that includes directors’
stakeholders. Management’s account- ownership while Bapepam does not.
Herwidiyatmo (2000), the chairman ability is served by the report and further To enforce publication of the annual
of Badan Pengawas Pasar Modal or it indicates the effectiveness of manage- report, the central bank provides a sanc-
Bapepam – the Capital Market Monitor- ment in fulfilling the company’s goal. tion to banks that fail to publish or are late
ing Agency -, suggests that the detail Bank Indonesia and Bapepam regu- in publishing the annual report. In addi-
required in the annual report is claimed late mandatory disclosure requirements tion, the central bank informs the public
to be comparable to the highest interna- in the annual report for publicly listed with the list of banks that have not sub-
tional standards of disclosure. Bapepam banks in Indonesia. Regulation by Bank mitted the annual report.
has also issued several rules to protect Indonesia applies not only to publicly
the interest of minority shareholders. For listed banks but also to all banks oper- Accounting Standard for Banks4
example, it issued rules requiring ap- ated in Indonesia. On the other hand, as On March 2000, IAI issued the new
proval by independent shareholders in described earlier, annual report disclo- accounting standard for Banks, which
the case of conflict of interest transac- sure requirements by Bapepam apply to will be applied to financial statements in
tions. Bapepam Rule IX.E.1 specifies all publicly listed companies and thus year 2000. The old accounting standard
written disclosure documents that must are not industry specific. For publicly (Pernyataan Standar Akuntansi Keuang-
be provided to shareholders prior to the listed banks, this double disclosure re- an (PSAK) No. 31) which was issued on
meeting to approve conflict of interest quirements by Bapepam and the central September 1994 was considered not
transactions. bank can create confusion since the providing adequate disclosure with re-
With support from Bapepam, the requirements are not totally the same. gard to bank’s exposure to various types
Jakarta Stock Exchange, in collabora- Information required by the central of risk.
tion with Ikatan Akuntan Indonesia (IAI) bank to be disclosed at least includes Rossieta conducts a study to inves-
and Asosiasi Emiten Indonesia (AEI) the following information: tigate the adequacy of the old and the
are developing presentation and disclo- a. General information new accounting standards with respect
sure guidelines for publicly listed com- Directors and their vitae, ownership to risks faced by banks. She compares
panies in 22 industries. The guidelines structure, organization structure, main the accounting standards to a guideline
are based on among others, Bapepam
rules, industry regulations, and gener- 2. Examples are accounting standard for mutual funds, for join operating activities other than joint ventures,
ally accepted accounting standards. for real estate, and for Islamic financial institution.
3. This part is excerpt from Irwanto, Evaluasi Pengungkapan Informasi Laporan Tahunan Bank Go Publik
The development of accounting stan- 1998, Thesis, Master in Accounting Program University of Indonesia, 2000.
dards in Indonesia is the responsibility 4. This part is excerpt from Hilda Rossieta, The Role of Accounting Standard in Preventing Risk Shifting
of the Accounting Standards Commit- by Banks, Working Paper, University of Indonesia, 2000.

12 USAHAWAN NO. 05 TH XXXII MEI 2003


Table 1
The Disclosure Score of a Sample of Publicly Listed
developed by Basle Committee on Bank- Companies* agement Discus-
ing Supervision, Bank for International sion and Analysis
Settlements. The type of risks that should Description Actual score / are rather low even
receive adequate disclosure includes maximum score though most of the
Credit Risks, Market Risks, Liquidity disclosure items
1. Background information 44.25%
Risks, and Operational and Legal Risks. are mandatory.
Her analysis indicates that the old 2. Summary of financial performance 84.9% Thus, it can be
accounting standard (PSAK No. 31) had 3. Non-financial information 17.7% concluded that
major limitation in providing qualitative publicly listed com-
information to enhance banks’ transpar- 4. Projected information 4.4% panies in Indone-
ency regarding risks. Of the total 20 dis- 5. Management discussion and analysis 55.7% sia tend to disclose
closure items, only 3 items are required only mandatory in-
Overall score 41.9%
to be disclosed. For liquidity risks, banks formation and even
were not required to provide any qualita- * Processed from J. Gunawan, Table IV.3, page 45-46 for this information,
tive information at all. On the other hand, some items are not disclosed.
only four disclosure items are not re- sold, unit selling price, growths in The study further finds that the level of
quired to be disclosed in the new ac- unit sold disclosure is positively affected by firm
counting standard and three of these d. Projections, such as forecasted size and financial leverage. Larger firms
undisclosed items are related to market market share, sales forecast, profit have higher private incentive to disclose
risks. Thus, the new standard signifi- and cash flow forecast since they make contracts with various
cantly improves the disclosure of banks’ e. Management discussion and parties. In addition, public demand on
exposure to risks. To apply the new stan- analysis such as change in sales, disclosure for large firms tends to be
dard, however, is quite complicated, so change in net income, change in higher than for small firms while the
the next issue is the extent of banks’ expenses, change in market share. relative cost of disclosure is lower. Firms
compliance to the new accounting stan- with higher leverage generate higher
dard. Each part consists of some items agency costs and to control these costs,
which are given a score of zero if it is not they are forced to disclose more.
The Disclosure Level of Publicly disclosed, a score of one if it is dis- The second study conducted by
Listed Companies in Indonesia closed, and a score of two if the disclo- Irwanto (2000) examines the degree of
This section provides some further sure is accompanied by some quantita- compliance to mandatory disclosure
empirical evidence regarding the level of tive information not disclosed in the fi- requirement in the annual reports of
disclosure of publicly listed companies nancial statements. In total there are 35 publicly listed banks.6 He develops two
in Indonesia. First, it reviews a study that disclosure items with the total maximum disclosure lists, one is based on Bank
documents the disclosure level of a score of 75. Indonesia’s rule and the other is based
sample of publicly listed companies in The number of samples is 104 out of on Bapepam’s. The disclosure list based
Indonesia. Then it reviews two studies 274 corporations that were listed in the on Bank Indonesia’s rule consists of
that investigate the disclosure level of Jakarta Stock Exchange in 1998 and the three parts (General Information, Man-
publicly listed banks and insurance com- annual reports examined are those for agement Report, and Items Need Atten-
panies. To measure the disclosure level, year 1998. tion) and the total number of disclosure
these studies develop a score that The following table provides the aver- items is 43 items. For Bapepam rule, the
shows the amount of information dis- age overall disclosure score and the disclosure list consists of four parts (Gen-
closed in the annual report. average disclosure scores for each part eral Description, Special Description,
The first study5 employs a disclosure of disclosure. The score is calculated as Summary of Financial Data, and Man-
score that is developed by Botosan the actual score divided by the maximum agement Discussion and Analysis) and
(1997). The score contains a list of man- score. Overall, the disclosure score is the total number of disclosure items is
datory and voluntary information dis- low, with only 41.9% of disclosure items 49 items. Each item is scored zero if it is
closed in the annual reports of publicly are adequately explained in the annual not disclosed and is scored one if it is
listed companies in the United States. report. This low score is mainly due to disclosed.
The disclosure list consists of five parts extremely low disclosures on Non-finan- He examines the 1998 annual report
as follows: cial and Projected Information, the ma- of all publicly listed banks that published
a. Background information, such as jority of which are voluntary disclosures. their annual report. Out of 32 banks only
general description of the business, The average score for Summary of Fi- 15 banks published annual reports. The
statement of objective, principle nancial Performance is relatively high rest did not publish annual reports since
products and markets, and since Bapepam requires the informa- these banks were either liquidated or
competitive environment tion to be disclosed. However, the scores taken over by the government.
b. Summary of financial performance for Background Information and Man- The following table provides the aver-
c. Non-financial information, such as 5. Juniati Gunawan, Analisis Tingkat Pengungkapan Laporan Tahunan pada Perusahaan yang Terdaftar di
number of employees, average Bursa Efek Jakarta, thesis, Master in Accounting Program University of Indonesia, 2000.
compensation, market share, unit 6. Irwanto, op. cit.

USAHAWAN NO. 05 TH XXXII MEI 2003 13


Table 2
The Mandatory Disclosure Score of Banks - the
Central Bank*
lated as the actual score di- finds that Indonesia ranks very low in the
Description Actual Score / vided by the maximum score. perceived standard of disclosure, con-
Maximum Score Consistent with the previ- sistent with the findings of the studies.
ous results, the overall disclo-
1. General information 76.2%
sure score is low. Information Conclusion and Recommendation
2. Management report 59.2% under Special Description has One principle of corporate gover-
3. Items need attention 50.9% the lowest score. Some items nance is disclosure and transparency.
that are not disclosed at all are: This principle stipulates that relevant
Overall score 58.3% Materials about Investment, and reliable disclosure is made on all
* Processed from Irwanto, Table 4.2 and 4.3, Expansion, Divestment or Ac- material matters regarding the corpora-
page 99-100 quisition. Items that receive the tion. By applying this principle, informa-
most disclosures in- tion asymmetry can be reduced and thus
Table 3 clude: Management Ad- negative consequences of adverse se-
The Mandatory Disclosure Score of Banks - Bapepam* dress, Financial Perfor- lection and moral hazard problems can
Description Actual Score / mance in the Past Five be minimized. As a consequence, the
Years (in term of sales, cost of capital decreases and the value
Maximum Score
gross profit, operating of the firm increases. A credible disclo-
General description 73.3% income and net in- sure may also increase investors’ con-
come), and Business fidence and result in better capital allo-
Special description 34%
Activities. cation in the economy.
Summary of financial data 66.7% In summary, the Due to contracts that firms generate
Management discussion and analysis 54.7% findings suggest that with various parties and due to capital
generally the degree of and labor market pressures, firms actu-
Overall score 58.8% compliance of publicly ally have private incentive to disclose.
* Processed from Irwanto, Table 4.4, 4.5 and 4.6, page 101- listed banks to the cen- However, this private incentive fails to
103 tral bank’s rule and generate optimal information because
Bapepam is rather low. information has a characteristic of public
age overall disclosure score and the Fitriany conducts a study to investi- goods and because there is market fail-
average disclosure scores for each part gate the disclosure level of financial state- ure. This justifies central authority’s in-
of disclosure where the disclosure list is ments of fire and loss insurance compa- tervention to regulate the required amount
based on the central bank. The score is nies which are publicly listed in the Jakarta of information produced by these firms.
calculated as the actual score divided by Stock Exchange.7 The findings also show For publicly listed companies the
the maximum score. that the overall disclosure score of these extent of information asymmetry is sub-
The results indicate that overall only companies is relatively low (less than stantial between majority shareholders
58.3% of the required information is dis- 60%). Interestingly, the study finds that who have access to private information
closed. The score ranges from as high auditors play a role in determining the and minority shareholders who have no
as 81.4% (Bank BNI) to as low as 25.6% disclosure level. In one case, the disclo- access to such information. Private
(Bank Interpacific and Bank Global sure score of one insurance company mechanism to control the negative con-
Internasional). Information under Items dropped after it switched auditor. Further sequences of information asymmetry is
Need Attention has the lowest score investigation revealed that the former not effective since the role of board of
(50.9%). This includes disclosure on auditor participated in the development directors/ commissioners and banks/
derivative transactions (reported only by of accounting standard for insurance creditors is minimum in monitoring the
20% banks) and disclosure on the companies and therefore completely un- firms’ actions. Further, the capital and
amount collected from written-off credits derstood the standard. This suggests labor markets are not well developed.
(20%). Information under Management that comprehension of disclosure re- Without proper regulation, the amount of
Report that receives low scores among quirements plays a major factor in deter- information produced by these compa-
others are: cost of fund (reported only by mining the extent of disclosure. nies, as expected, is inadequate.
1 bank) and ownership of the manage- The foregoing studies directly com- In recent years, there has been sig-
ment, commissioners, and stockhold- puted the disclosure level of publicly nificant improvement in the regulation of
ers in affiliated companies (4 banks). listed companies in Indonesia. disclosure in Indonesia. Bapepam has
The following table presents the av- Pricewaterhouse did a survey to institu- issued a number of rules that enforce
erage overall disclosure score and the tional investors in Singapore, asking their disclosure and that protect the interest of
average disclosure scores for each part perception on the standard of disclosure minority shareholders. The accounting
of disclosure where the disclosure list is and transparency in a dozen countries in standards are harmonized with the Inter-
based on Bapepam. The score is calcu- the Asia-Australia region.8 The survey national Accounting Standards while the
due process in preparing the standards
7. Fitriany, Analisis Kecukupan Pengungkapan Informasi pada Laporan Keuangan Perusahaan Asuransi has been intensified.
Kerugian Go Public, Thesis, Master in Accounting Program University of Indonesia, 2000.
8. Pricewaterhouse Coopers (in collaboration with the Singapore Exchange), 1999 Survey of Institutional Empirical evidences, however, find
Investors. that in general the disclosure level among

14 USAHAWAN NO. 05 TH XXXII MEI 2003


publicly listed companies in Indonesia mendous improvement in the disclo- and Portfolio Composition in the Presence of
is low. Even for mandatory disclosure, sure regulation for public companies; Uncertain Parameters, Journal of Financial
the compliance rate is not satisfactory. however, it appears that the enforce- Economics 19, 1988, p. 279-303,
Coles, J., U. Loewenstein, and J. Suay, On
This low level of disclosure despite the ment of those rules lacks behind. A re- Equilibrium Pricing under Parameter
enhancement of disclosure requirement cent effort by Bapepam, the Jakarta Stock Uncertainty, Journal of Financial and
Quantitative Analysis, September 1995, p.
by the regulating bodies suggest that the Exchange, IAI and AEI to develop presen- 347-364.
enforcement of the regulation needs to tation and disclosures guidelines for Diamond D., and R. Verrecchia, Disclosure,
Liquidity and the Cost of Equity Capital, The
be improved. public companies in 22 industries Journal of Finance, September 1991, p. 1325-
should be applauded, but it is necessary 1360.
Fitriany, Analisis Kecukupan Pengungkapan
Recommendation that Bapepam ensure that firms utilize Informasi pada Laporan Keuangan
The followings are some programs the guidelines. Thus, Bapepam or other Perusahaan Asuransi Kerugian Go Public,
Thesis , Master in Accounting Program
that need to be done to enhance the level regulating bodies (such as the central University of Indonesia, 2000.
of disclosure and transparency among bank) should enforce its mandatory dis- Fujinuma, Tsuguoki, (President of International
Federation of Accountants), Enhancing
publicly listed companies in Indonesia. closure regulation and monitor whether Corporate Governance - IFAC’s initiatives
The environment under which com- companies comply with the regulation. A and the role of the accountancy profession,
panies operate should be supportive in sanction might even be given to compa- Luncheon address to Konvensi Nasional
Akuntansi IV Ikatan Akuntan Indonesia,
motivating these firms to be transparent nies that fail to follow the requirement. September 7 2000, Jakarta.
and to apply the full-disclosure principle. Financial Statements is the primary Gunawan, Juniati, Analisis Tingkat Pengungkapan
Laporan Tahunan pada Perusahaan yang
The monitoring role of board of commis- mean on which investors rely to assess Terdaftar di Bursa Efek Jakarta, Thesis,
sioners, including minority sharehold- financial performance of a company. Master in Accounting Program University of
Indonesia, 2000.
ers, needs to be strengthened. Minority However, they can only be useful if they Glosten, L., and P. Milgrom, Bid Ask and
shareholders legal rights and their pro- are relevant and reliable. The integrity of Transaction Prices in a Specialist Market with
Heterogeneously Informed Traders, Journal
tection also need to be improved. Major- external auditors is very crucial in en- of Financial Economics 16, 1985, p. 71-100.
ity shareholders (which mostly consist hancing the credibility of financial state- Handa, P., and S. Linn, Arbitrage Pricing with
Estimation Risk, Journal of Financial
of family-based controlling sharehold- ments. Auditors also play an important Economics, March 1993, p. 81-100.
ers) should be encouraged to diffuse role in ensuring firms’ compliance to Herwidayatmo (Chairman, Bapepam),
Shareholder Meetings and Communication at
their ownership. To broaden share own- accounting standards. In Indonesia, the Shareholder Meetings , the OECD Second Asian
ership, participation by large domestic auditing standards and the code of eth- Roundtable on Corporate Governance, Hong
Kong, May 31, 2000.
as well as foreign institutional investors ics have been harmonized with interna- Ikatan Akuntan Indonesia, Corporate Governance
such as pension funds and mutual funds tional-level standards. The due-process in Indonesia, The Second Asian Roundtable on
should be encouraged. These institu- procedures in standards setting have Corporate Governance, Hong Kong, May 31-
June 2, 2000.
tions may insist on higher standards of also been refined. These standards and The Indonesian Institute for Corporate
disclosure in general. Thus, develop- codes have to be understood by audi- Governance, Vision, Jakarta, 2000.
Irwanto, Evaluasi Pengungkapan Informasi
ment of an institutional investor commu- tors; therefore it is imperative that IAI or Laporan Tahunan Bank Go Publik 1998, Thesis,
nity is crucial to the promotion of the role other regulating bodies to formulate a Master in Accounting Program University of
Indonesia, 2000.
of outside shareholders in monitoring policy aiming to improving the auditors’ OECD, A Consolidated Report on Corporate
firms. Further reforms in bankruptcy pro- competence. Monitoring on the compli- Governance and Financing in East Asia, The
Second Asian Roundtable on Corporate
cedures and laws are required to ance or violation of standards or codes Governance, Hong Kong, May 31- June 2,
strengthen the role of creditors in advis- needs to be strengthened while sanc- 2000.
Pricewaterhouse Coopers (in collaboration with
ing, monitoring, and supervising com- tions should be clearly formulated to the Singapore Exchange), 1999 Survey of
panies and managers and to protect punish violation. U Institutional Investors.
Rosieta, Hilda, The Role of Accounting Standard
creditors’ rights. The investment com- in Preventing Risk Shifting by Banks, Working
munity should also create a condition Reference Paper, University of Indonesia, 2000.
Rahman, M. Z., The Role of Accounting Disclosure
whereby transparent and fully disclosed in the East Asian Financial Crisis: Lessons
Ad Hoc Task Force on Corporate Governance
companies are rewarded. For example, (OECD), OECD Principles of Corporate Learned?, The Second Asian Roundtable on
a survey can be conducted regularly to Governance, April 19 1999. Corporate Governance, Hong Kong, May 31-
Amihud, Y., and H. Mendelson, Asset Pricing June 2, 2000.
evaluate companies in term of their dis- and the Bid-Ask Spread, Journal of Financial Saudagaran, S. M. and J. G. Diga, Financial
closure level and high-ranked compa- Economics 17, 1986, p. 223-249. Reporting in Emerging Capital Markets:
Botosan, Christine A., Disclosure Level and the Characteristics and Policy Issues, Accounting
nies are rewarded accordingly. Cost of Equity Capital, Accounting Review , Horizons , June 1997, p. 41-64.
The government should continue or July 1997, p. 323-349. Scott, William R., Financial Accounting Theory,
Claessens, Djankov and Lang, Who Controls Prentice-Hall International, 1997.
even accelerates the development of East Asian Corporation?, World Bank Working Sengupta, Partha, Corporate Disclosure Quality
equity as well as debt markets. It should Paper, as quoted from Ramsay and Stapledon, and the Cost of Debt, Accounting Review ,
Corporate Governance: An Overview of the October 1998, p. 459-474.
also review public listing, trading rules Sheng, Andrew (Chairman, Securities and Futures
Key Issues and Debates, AISC Corporate
and supervision systems to improve the Governance Training Program, Sydney, March Commission Hong Kong), Transparency,
20 2000. Accountability and Standards in Global
efficient operation of capital markets. Markets, Luncheon Address to the OECD
Clarkson, P., J. Guedes, and R. Thompson, On
Those related to disclosure, insider trad- the Diversification, Observability, and Second Asian Roundtable on Corporate
Measurement of Estimation Risk, Journal of Governance, Hong Kong, June 1, 2000.
ing, and listing rules are of special im- Utama, S. and U. Afandi, Uji efisiensi bentuk
Financial and Quantitative Analysis, March
portance. 1996, p. 69-84. setengah kuat pada Bursa Efek Jakarta,
Coles, J., and U. Loewenstein, Equilibrium Pricing Manajemen Usahawan Indonesia, Maret 1998.
In recent years, there has been tre-

USAHAWAN NO. 05 TH XXXII MEI 2003 15

S-ar putea să vă placă și