7/31/2019 Breaking the NFC deadlock - Newspaper - DAWN.

COM

TODAY'S PAPER | JULY 31, 2019

Breaking the NFC deadlock

From the Newspaper | Updated August 13, 2018

THE PML-N government could not break the enduring deadlock at the National
Finance Commission (NFC) to finalise the 9th NFC award during the party’s five-
year tenure.

Will the incoming PTI government succeed where its predecessor failed? For the next five-year
tenure of the new award, the NFC will have to include issues such as the new population census,
the merger of Fata with Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, and possibly the creation of a South Punjab
province — which is on the PTI’s 100-day agenda.

https://www.dawn.com/news/1426751 1/3
7/31/2019 Breaking the NFC deadlock - Newspaper - DAWN.COM

Meanwhile, the voices for fiscal re-centralisation to remove a “vertical fiscal imbalance” are
growing louder. In recent public debate, issues in horizontal distribution of resources that have
cropped up and may not be prudent to ignore are: undue weightage given to population, and an
absence of impetus for boosting the provinces’ own tax collection and generation.

The PTI has yet to make up its mind on how to go about tackling divergent views. In an
interview on July 30 with Business Recorder, Mr Asad Umar, tipped as the next finance
minister, said the NFC award is “long overdue”. He however, added: “at this stage, it is too early
to provide specifics”.

Voices for fiscal re-centralisation to remove

a “vertical fiscal imbalance” are growing
louder with views that population should
cease to be a consideration in resource
distribution

Three days later, addressing a workshop on ‘Sustainable Development Goals—Baseline on

Target Setting’ Finance Minister Dr Shamshad Akhtar stressed that the finalisation of the NFC
award was “crucial” for the next financial year to promote social development; align federal and
provincial budgets; take onboard provincial and local governments to pursue SDG goals; and
play an effective role in policy implementation.

Under constitutional mandate, the current resource distribution arrangement, based on

expenditures and needs of the stakeholders, has to be revised every five years. After Fata’s
merger with Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, the province, with increased population and much larger
territory, will qualify for a bigger share in the Divisible Pool.

The changes in the horizontal distribution criteria may be easier than the vertical distribution of
resources. To amend the NFC formula for sharing of resources between the federation and all
the provinces combined, a two-third majority is required in the parliament which the PTI will
not command. A change of heart in major opposition parties, which managed the 18th
Amendment, is unlikely to occur.

The PTI Chairman Imran Khan has set his sight on reforming the Federal Board of Revenue and
incentivising the informal sector to pay taxes and raise tax revenue with a mind-boggling target
of Rs8 trillion.

A peep in party’s posture in the NFC proceedings would show that resource-poor KP
government was comfortable with horizontal distribution of resources under the 7th NFC award
as the province shared the revenues raised by Sindh and Punjab. On the other hand, the KP
https://www.dawn.com/news/1426751 2/3
7/31/2019 Breaking the NFC deadlock - Newspaper - DAWN.COM

government’s representatives in the NFC had sought to increase the share of the provinces from
57.5 per cent to 75pc; something beyond the realm of possibility.

The PTI provincial government had reservations about transferring collection of sales tax on
goods to the federating units as provided under the 1973 Constitution (and proposed by Sindh),
fearing that the province’s share in the divisible pool would be reduced.

On the political level in the two smaller provinces, there are views that population should cease
to be a consideration in resource distribution; as suggested by Senator Usman Khan Kakar from
Balochistan and Senator Shibli Faraz from KP in a meeting of Senate Standing Committee on
Planning and Development held in May. They said that the NFC Award should be based on only
poverty/ backwardness and social and economic development of the federating units.

The multiple indicators and their respective weights in the 7th NFC award are as follows:
population 82pc, poverty/backwardness 10.3pc, revenue collection/generation 5pc, and inverse
population ratio 2.7pc.

On the technical level too, views differ sharply. In an article published in this newspaper on July
9, titled ‘Federation’s fiscal dismemberment’, political economist Mohammad Zubair Khan was
highly critical of the 7th NFC award. He argued that the progress in improving basic social
service delivery — one of the key economic justifications for fiscal decentralisation — has been
mixed.

The International Monetary Fund holds similar views. The Fund says the 7th NFC award has
created “a vertical fiscal imbalance” but sees no easy solutions. It has advised Pakistan to create
a contingency fund to be financed jointly by the federal government and the provinces.

However, there is also a view that federal spending can be significantly cut by administrative
reforms. The number of federal ministries can be reduced from 27 to 18 and divisions from 35 to
23 through mergers, creation of new entities and transfer to the provinces as provided by the
18th Amendment.

Some even see room for reducing spending on national security. And the two bigger provinces
are convinced that more revenues can be generated by transfer of collection of sub-national
taxes to the federating units, still retained by the federation.

The issues involved in hammering out the new NFC award are complex, diverse and difficult to
resolve. All stakeholders have to demonstrate flexibility and mutual accommodation for arriving
at a decision to strengthen fiscal federalism and not weaken it.

jawaidbokhari2016@gmail.com

Published in Dawn, The Business and Finance Weekly, August 13th, 2018

https://www.dawn.com/news/1426751 3/3