Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Abstract
The selection of a PCC does not only depend on the voltage level alone but also on the grid strength at any
particular point. This grid strength is usually represented as short circuit ratio (SCR). Nowadays, tendency
of low SCR grid connections has become an important consideration when it comes to integrating wind
power plants (WPP). Since quality of wind resources is an important factor, therefore these plants are
generally located in remote areas with high wind potential. These remote areas are usually less populated
where the grid does not always have to be strong. Furthermore, high wind penetration and exceeded
loading affect the utility and equipment by allowing the flow of unbalanced currents and voltages.
Consequently, power quality is becoming an important aspect of distributed energy generation that needs
to be taken care of by consumers as well as distributors. In this research paper a permanent magnet
synchronous generator (PMSG) based wind energy conversion system (WECS) integrated is presented. It
discusses a solution to provide low voltage ride through (LVRT) support by the suppression of DC link
overvoltage and active power limitation during asymmetrical grid faults. With an improved back to back
converters control, the machine side converter (MSC) was used to regulate the DC link voltage and the
grid side converter (GSC) was implement the active/reactive current injection according to the grid code.
By implementing this solution, the need of external hardware can be avoided which is usually needed to
dissipate the extra energy generated during a grid fault. Hence, proves it to be an inexpensive solution.
Simulations were performed for the entire system to show the validity and efficiency of the proposed control
approach.
Index Terms— Weak AC grid, LVRT support, symmetrical and asymmetrical faults, suppression of DC-
link voltages. Active / reactive current injection, Positive and negative sequence current control.
INTRODUCTION
Greenhouse emission commencing from the ignition of fossil fuels to harvest electrical energy
contributes a foremost factor in global warming and climate change. In the new era of consumers
and power quality, there is a need to install renewable energy resources based power plants.
I qs ref Vq s
2m
4
P I qs
k o p tim a l 3 p
I qs
ds
i re f Vd s e Ls id s
PI ds
i ds e Ls iq s
consists of additional external devices (e.g. STATCAOM, reactive power compensator, Crowbar,
ESS and SDBR). Which increases the initial installation cost of WPP. [4].
In this thesis, the main focus is on advanced control of back to back converters avoiding additional
external devices attached to transmission/distribution systems to maintain constant DC link
voltages. In this technique, the DC link voltages are controlled directly through MSC. During
unbalanced conditions (symmetrical and asymmetrical faults) positive and negative sequence
fluxes are created in PMSG which will be controlled by pitch angle control with the help of suitable
optimal controller. This method is a substitution to controlling DC link voltages with the help of
GSC as in conventional techniques using an external device to trigger the VDC link [6-7].
The proposed technique is valid for symmetrical fault and also valid for asymmetrical faults using
proportional-integral controller. In this research main focus is on improving the control strategy
using suitable optimal controller on MSC to work under symmetrical and asymmetrical faults. In
this research, a weak AC grid is observed connected with wind energy system. Suitable control
algorithms are designed for both MSC and GSC to support LVRT during grid faults (symmetrical
and asymmetrical faults). Moreover, in this research coupling phenomenon is observed between
positive and negative sequence currents, where-as boosting the positive sequence voltages the
negative sequence voltages are also boosted.
w
Ls
X
Iq
d
I ref 0 PI
Vd
Controller Vdq to
Vαb
d
I Grid
PWM
ref
V
dc link PI
Controller
Vq
G MSC
dc w
q
V
converted I Grid Ls
X
Id
M P P T C o n tro l
d axis controller Vd f
I ds ref
2m Ed f
2
k o p tim a l PI df
3Vd f
P lo s s I df
f L f iq s
Vd f i q s re f
PI ds P I qf
Vq f
i qf f Lf id s
q a x is c o n tr o lle r
Fig. 3. Proposed grid side controller
In “fig. 3”, a new control is designed for grid side controller for maximum power point tracking
and for to balance grid voltages during grid faults.
Due to different environmental operating conditions in WECS and several properties different
type of generators are installed in WECS to harvest electrical energy from wind energy. Most four
frequently used wind turbines generators are
• Squirrel cage induction generator
• Wound rotor induction generator
• Double fed induction generator
• Permanent magnet synchronous generator
Since quality of wind resources is an important factor, therefore these plants are generally
located in remote areas with high wind potential. These remote areas are usually less populated
where the grid does not always have to be strong. Furthermore, high wind penetration and exceeded
loading affect the utility and equipment by allowing the flow of unbalanced currents and voltages.
So the selection of power generator would be a difficult task. In table 1, comparison between
different generators are given for suitable selection for wind turbine.
According to table 1 Most efficient and appropriate generator attached with wind turbine is
permanent magnet synchronous generator. PMSG has many benefits over other type of generators
such as it is gearbox free, having high power density, better precision and modest control
techniques are required.
Wind Turbine
Emulator
MSC GSC
Weak Grid Emulator
In fig. 4, permanent magnet synchronous based wind farm configuration is shown. This
configuration has four major parts.
a. PMSG
b. Back to back converters
c. AC grid
A generator in which the excitation field is allotted by the permanent magnet. The magnetic field
of rotor is produced by permanent magnets and hence the name is satisfied. The design of such
generators is very simple. The speed of rotor is nearly same as the frequency of the supply.
As compared to conventional generators permanent magnet can have more number of poles, less
cost and high efficiency. This gives it a suitable application in wind turbines. Reduction of
maintenance makes PMSG a best choice in application of wind turbines. As there is less facilitation
at sites of wind turbines.
Rs l sd is
Vsd e q
Vs
q
e d
Total flux linkage for D_axis PMSG model is expressed in equation (1)
d Lsd ids (1)
Total flux linkage for Q_axis PMSG model is expressed in equation (2)
q Lsqiqs pm
(2)
In DQ axis coil, two types of voltage component are induced. Transformer emfs and rotational
emfs respectively. The transformer emfs is induced due to the rate of change of the total flux
linkage in their respective coils. The d and q axis circuit transformer emfs are in equation (3), (4).
d
daxis
t (3)
q
qaxis
t (4)
Vsq , isd and isq are the dq components of stator voltage and currents respectively. is the magnetic
flux and we is the electrical angular speed. The power output of the PMSG is given by equation
(12).
3p 3 2
PMSC isq m Rs (isd isq )
2
22 2 (12)
MSC
Encoder
ω ɵ PWM
I abc V* dq
Idq V* ? ß
VDC
Control
Two back to back convertor (machine side and grid side converters) are used in PMSG based wind
farm configuration as shown in fig. 4.
In “fig. 7”, machine side controller is proposed for machine side converter. In this technique “ɵ”
1. Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Minhaj University, Lahore, Pakistan, (e-mail:
akrama.khan@hotmail.com)*.
2. Faculty of Electrical Engineering, University of Central Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan (e-mail:
majidguzar3@gmail.com)
3. Faculty of Computer Science, Qarshi University, Lahore, Pakistan (e-mail: Hasnain.ahmad@qu.edu.pk).
is feed for conversion of generated currents in to their direct and quadrature axis currents. These
currents are feed to controller for to obtain optimized Vdq. Then this optimized / compensated
Vdq is converted into V_alpha and V_beta, because these two parameters are required to produce
PWM. Which will further feed to controller gate for controlling the DC link voltages
In this research, dual current controller is used to eliminate second order components fluctuations
of grid active power and to decrease over DC link voltages for positive and negative sequences.
Two components Ps2 and Pc2 are set to zero for elimination of second order component fluctuation
of grid active power. in order to determine q and d axis components of negative and positive
sequence of current references solving the matrix in equation (14) [4]. In fig. 8, block diagram of
proposed grid side controller is illustrated. During grid faults grid side controller is compensating
the grid voltages with the help of power reactive power injection. With the help of Eq. (14) positive
and negative current sequences references are obtained for GSC.
grid requirements the reactive power reference Q 0 ref is set according by requirement of grid. the
Weak Grid
Any significant change in operation of power system which lead to deviation in frequency and
changes in voltages consistency. Strong AC grids have high short circuit ratio (SCR) which is low
in weak AC grids. The short circuit ratio is invers in relation to the impedance of the system, and
it is a complex number which accounts the reactive power generations. The ratio of short circuit
1. Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Minhaj University, Lahore, Pakistan, (e-mail:
akrama.khan@hotmail.com)*.
2. Faculty of Electrical Engineering, University of Central Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan (e-mail:
majidguzar3@gmail.com)
3. Faculty of Computer Science, Qarshi University, Lahore, Pakistan (e-mail: Hasnain.ahmad@qu.edu.pk).
MVA of AC grid to the rated DC power is defined as short circuit ratio. Power consumer are
normally a highly inductive so the short circuit ratio is inverse in relation to the inductive
impedances. According to standard values if the value of SCR is less than two, it is considered to
be very weak AC grid in High voltage direct current configuration. If the value of SCR is greater
than three, it is known as strong and healthy AC grid. While if the value of SCR lies in between
two and three it is considering as weak AC grid [17]. The value of short circuit ratio above 20 in
medium voltages case is considered strong AC grid and if the value of SCR is less or equal to 10
its will consider as weak grid [18] - [19].
In fig. 9 grid side controller is implemented for to balance grid voltages during symmetrical and
asymmetrical faults. The extraction of positive and negative sequence direct axis and quadrature
axis current are extracted with the help of equation (16), (17), (18) and (19) [4] [12].
2 2
2[( Vdqf Vdqf ) PlimVdf ( Vdqf
2 2
Vdqf )Qref
0
Vqf ]
I 2 2 2 2
3( Vdqf Vdqf )( Vdqf Vdqf )
d
(16)
2 2
2[( Vdqf Vdqf ) PlimVqf ( Vdqf
2 2
Vdqf )Qref
0
Vdf ]
I 2 2 2 2
3( Vdqf Vdqf )( Vdqf Vdqf )
q
(17)
2 2
2[( Vdqf Vdqf ) PlimVdf ( Vdqf
2 2
Vdqf )Qref
0
Vqf ]
I 2 2 2 2
3( Vdqf Vdqf )( Vdqf Vdqf )
d
(18)
3 1 k 22
Plim I max Vdqf [1 ( dq dq 2 ]
2 [1 ( dq dq ]2 [1 ( dq dq 2 ]
(21)
Where is taken as equation (22)
0
I q
2.5Vdq pu 2.25
dq dq
1 (22)
1
K 1 ( dq dq ) 2 (23)
1 ( dq dq )
Whereas the values of direct axis current and voltages are
dq d 2 q 2
(24)
dq d 2 q 2
(25)
Vdqf Vdf 2 Vqf 2
(26)
Vdqf Vdf 2 Vqf 2
(27)
Matlab 2018a based Simulink model for MSC control code is shown in fig. 10. Where the
control code is according to fig. 7. Expended view of controller box and code is shown in fig. 11.
Results
in fig. 12 with the help of crowbar a technique is implemented in [21] to regulated DC link voltage. Where-as in figure
compensated GSC output voltages are shown in part (A) and the unbalances during single line to ground fault are also
showed in zoom section. in part (b) zoom section the compensated GSC current unbalances are shown. It is clearly
observed that the current is reducing during unbalance condition. after removal of asymmetrical fault then it is taking
time to reaches it nominal value. In zoom section (C) of fig. 12 harmonics are shown in direct and quadrature axis
voltages. regulation of DC link voltage is shown in zoom section (D).
proposed technique simulation based results are shown in fig. 13. Where are the proposed technique results are similar
to results shown in fig. 12 which are achieved with the help of crow bar. the crow bar is expensive device which makes
the system more expensive and also the crow requires and additional controller to regulated the DC link voltages
during any of unbalanced condition. more-over the compensated current regulation is better than the conventional
technique in research paper [21]. Where the current is reducing during asymmetrical fault but in the proposed
technique current were remained in safety limits. Comparing DC link voltage of both techniques both results are good
enough to regulate the voltage in safety limits. Hence the proposed technique makes the system more stable and cost
efficient without using any of installing the additional hardware to regulated the DC link voltage.
C D
CONCLUSIONS
In this research, a new technique was implemented to enhance capability of low voltage ride
through for permanent magnet synchronous generator based WPP integrated to a weak AC grid.
Bundle of control techniques were implemented in literature survey. In conventional techniques
GSC was implemented to regulate DC link over voltages and MSC was implemented to achieve
MPPT in PMSG based WPP. There were many challenges to deals with these conventional
techniques. By swapping the MSC and GSC control functions in this technique, now MSC is
implemented to regulate DC link over voltages without any external hardware support and GSC is
implemented to control balanced power supply to a weak AC grid. Three major contributions of
this research are: DC link over voltage was regulated without any additional hardware.
Active/reactive power limitations were implemented during grid faults. Grid current magnitudes
were also kept in the safety limits.
The enhanced back to back converter controllers and reactive / active power limiter allowing the
1. Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Minhaj University, Lahore, Pakistan, (e-mail:
akrama.khan@hotmail.com)*.
2. Faculty of Electrical Engineering, University of Central Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan (e-mail:
majidguzar3@gmail.com)
3. Faculty of Computer Science, Qarshi University, Lahore, Pakistan (e-mail: Hasnain.ahmad@qu.edu.pk).
negative sequence currents can be injected to weak AC grid during unbalanced conditions.
Moreover, there were no need to install an additional external hardware to dissipate extra electrical
energy coming from wind turbine. Requirements of grid code reference to current injection was
also performed in this thesis. An LCL filter is analyzed to eliminate 2nd order harmonics and
switching frequency current harmonics.
FUTURE WORK
In this thesis wind scenario was taken constant. In future this control technique could be applied
on nonlinear wind scenarios. Same method could be updated by having information of actual grid
and weak AC grid impedances then the currents could be injected with certain angles to increase
efficiency. More-over with upgradation in proposed technique MPPT and balance power supply
could be ensured during unbalanced conditions simultaneously. Major concern was with
symmetrical and asymmetrical faults in this research so in future loss of synchronous could be
analyzed during phase shifts and frequency disturbances.
REFERENCES
1 Grainger, C., & Zhang, F. (2017). The Impact of Electricity Shortages on Firm Productivity: Evidence from
Pakistan. Policy Research Working Papers. doi: 10.1596/1813-9450-8130
2 Aslam Bhutta, M., Hayat, N., Farooq, A., Ali, Z., Jamil, S., & Hussain, Z. (2012). Vertical axis wind turbine – A
review of various configurations and design techniques. Renewable And Sustainable Energy Reviews, 16(4),
1926-1939. doi: 10.1016/j.rser.2011.12.004
3 Gerard de la Bat, J. (2011). Development of a System for Testing Grid-Connected Permanent Magnet Wind
Generators [Ebook].
4 Nasiri, M., & Mohammadi, R. (2017). Peak Current Limitation for Grid Side Converter by Limited Active Power
in PMSG-Based Wind Turbines During Different Grid Faults. IEEE Transactions On Sustainable Energy, 8(1),
3-12. doi: 10.1109/tste.2016.2578042
5 Dey, P., Datta, M., Fernando, N., & Senjyu, T. (2018). Coordinated control technique of PMSG based wind
energy conversion system during repetitive grid fault. 2018 IEEE International Conference On Industrial
Technology (ICIT). doi: 10.1109/icit.2018.8352300
6 Geng, H., Liu, L., & Li, R. (2018). Synchronization and Reactive Current Support of PMSG-Based Wind Farm
During Severe Grid Fault. IEEE Transactions On Sustainable Energy, 9(4), 1596-1604. doi:
10.1109/tste.2018.2799197
7 Kim, K., Jeung, Y., Lee, D., & Kim, H. (2012). LVRT Scheme of PMSG Wind Power Systems Based on
Feedback Linearization. IEEE Transactions On Power Electronics, 27(5), 2376-2384. doi:
10.1109/tpel.2011.2171999
1. Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Minhaj University, Lahore, Pakistan, (e-mail:
akrama.khan@hotmail.com)*.
2. Faculty of Electrical Engineering, University of Central Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan (e-mail:
majidguzar3@gmail.com)
3. Faculty of Computer Science, Qarshi University, Lahore, Pakistan (e-mail: Hasnain.ahmad@qu.edu.pk).
8 Syed Islam Kelvin Tan, "Optimum Control Strategies in Energy Conversion of PMSG Wind Turbine System
without Mechanical Sensors," IEEE Transactions on Energy Conversion, vol. 19, no. 2, pp. 392 - 399 , 2004.
9 Gijs A.M. van Kuik. (2007) The Lanchester–Betz–Joukowsky Limit. [Online].
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/we.218/pdf
10 S. Hari, S. Islam, and C. V. Nayar, “Power Quality Simulation of a Variable Speed Wind Generator Connected
to a Weak Grid,” Proc. Int. Conf. Harmon. Qual. Power, ICHQP, vol. 3, pp. 988–993, 2000.
11 (2019). Retrieved from
https://www.entsoe.eu/fileadmin/user_upload/_library/resources/RfG/130308_Final_Version_NC_RfG.pdf
12 (2019). Retrieved from
https://open.uct.ac.za/bitstream/item/10533/thesis_ebe_2011_de_la_bat_j.pdf?sequence=1
13 Electrical grid. (2019). Retrieved from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electrical_grid
14 Sager, S. (2019). Design and implementation of a grid-connected variable-speed PM WECS. Retrieved from
http://hdl.handle.net/11427/13392
15 J. Schmall, S. H. Huang, Y. Li, J. Billo, J. Conto, and Z. Yang, “Voltage stability of large-scale wind plants
integrated in weak networks: An ERCOT case study,” Power Energy Soc. Gen. Meet. IEEE., 2015.
16 J. Z. Zhou and A. M. Gole, “VSC transmission limitations imposed by AC system strength and AC impedance
characteristics,” 10th IET Int. Conf. AC DC Power Transm., no. 2, 2012.
17 M. F. Farias, P. E. Battaiotto, and M. G. Cendoya, “Wind Farm to Weak-Grid Connection using UPQC custom
power device,” IEEE Int. Conf. Ind. Technol., pp. 1745–1750, 2010.
18 J. O. Tande, G. Di Marzio, and K. Uhlen, “System Requirements for Wind Power Plants,” 2007.
19 N. P. W. Strachan and D. Jovcic, “Stability of a variable-speed permanent magnet wind generator with weak AC
grids,” IEEE Trans. Power Deliv., vol. 25, no. 4, pp. 2779–2788, 2010.
20 Xing, P., Fu, L., Wang, G., Wang, Y., & Zhang, Y. A compositive control method of low-voltage ride through
for PMSG-based wind turbine generator system. IET Generation, Transmission & Distribution, 12(1), 117-125.
doi: 10.1049/iet-gtd.2017.0270, 2018