Sunteți pe pagina 1din 9

See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.

net/publication/329799370

IMPACT OF CPEC ENERGY PROJECTS ON SOCIO-ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT OF


PAKISTAN

Conference Paper · November 2018

CITATIONS READS

2 1,611

3 authors, including:

R. M. Ammar Zahid Athar Rashid


Virtual University of Pakistan National University of Modern Languages
10 PUBLICATIONS   3 CITATIONS    4 PUBLICATIONS   6 CITATIONS   

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Determinants of IFRS and SMEs-IFRS adoption View project

Analysis of energy related household consumer preferences, awareness and behaviors in Pakistan View project

All content following this page was uploaded by R. M. Ammar Zahid on 20 December 2018.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


Proceedings of the International Conference on Renewable, Applied and New Energy Technologies
ICRANET-2018, 19-22 November 2018, Air University, Islamabad, Pakistan

ICRANET-180702

IMPACT OF CPEC ENERGY PROJECTS ON SOCIO-ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT


OF PAKISTAN

Dr. Muzammil Khurshid* Athar Rashid**


Assistant Professor, Department of Business and (Ph.D. Scholar), Department of Political Science
Commerce, University of Central Punjab, & International Relations, Izmir University of
Sialkot Campus, Sialkot Economics, Turkey
Email: Email: athar.gs@gmail.com
drmuzammilkhursheed.skt@cps.ucp.edu.pk

R.M. Ammar Zahid***


PhD, Assistant Professor
(Management Sciences), Virtual
University Pakistan
Email: amrzahid@gmail.com

Abstract
China Pakistan Economic Corridor is a leading plan of In the past foreign businesses were set up in the more
China’s One Belt One Road (OBOR) which is going trade-friendly coastal cities in the eastern sea-front of
to rotate the economic powers from advanced China thus leaving the western provinces of the
economies to emerging Asian economies. The primary country underdeveloped. It is also anticipated that
objective of present study is to find out the impact of CPEC would help in enhancement of connectivity of
CPEC Energy projects on the Socio-economic Chinese provinces such as Xinjiang, by attracting
development of Pakistan. Moreover, this research foreign and local investment through companies
article also discusses risks and challenges to the setting up their operations in the region. Moreover,
economy of Pakistan due to CPEC. It is the dire need Pakistan could act as a “transit facility,” connecting
of the hour to highlight the major issues regarding to western provinces of China to Central Asian markets
the CPEC. Data have been gathered through different and the Indian Ocean[1].
books, research articles, journals, magazines, China has developed as the second largest
newspapers, different reports and seminars. Since last economy in the world. Through Innovation and
two decades, Pakistan is facing energy crisis and the technological advancement it has emerged as a global
notable contribution of CPEC is in energy sector by leader in main technologies like electric cars, green
putting $35 billion. CPEC is playing important role in energy, robots, and semiconductors. Being a new
all fields like FDI, Transportation, Infrastructure global power China is taking lead on foreign direct
Development, Regional Integration, Employment investment (FDI) in world markets. Like other
Opportunities, Industrial Parks, exchange of cultures, developed capitalist economies, China is also facing
Tourism etc. Despite of all these positive points, there the problem of market saturation at home. The
are some challenges too as: security, political domestic need of Coal, Cement, Steel and other
consensus, terrorism, fair allocation of funds, industrial goods has minimized and the manufacturing
stabilization of local businesses etc. giants in the country are presently overproducing.
“Going Out,” strategy responds to their need for
Keywords: CPEC, Economic Development, OBOR, growth and accumulation[2]. Irrespective of the
Pakistan intentions behind this mammoth project of Belt and
Road Initiative(BRI), People’s Republic of China has
already invested $300 billion in loans and trade
1- INTRODUCTION financing in the BRI partnering countries[3].

The China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) Furthermore, for China, the world’s second
brings immense benefits for both China and Pakistan. largest importer of oil CPEC carries great potential to
Proceedings of the International Conference on Renewable, Applied and New Energy Technologies
ICRANET-2018, 19-22 November 2018, Air University, Islamabad, Pakistan

make it energy secure [4]. Figure 1 reveals the fact that strategic position of Pakistan as an alternative
presently China imports approximately 54.8% of Oil energy corridor to the Gulf States, Central Asia, and
through a very long route of energy supply. CPEC even Iran invokes China’s energy interest in the
would reduce the distance, time and cost of the oil country[11].
imported from the Persian Gulf and East Africa
considerably [5]. Moreover, with the CPEC, Pakistan is
counting on PRC’s technological as well as
financial cooperation to diversify its energy
resources[12]. Gas accounts for 50% and Oil 30%
of Pakistan’s total energy requirements and export
cost the country a lot of financial burdens. Pakistan
needs to shift to the contribution of other energy
resources to the total energy mix. Cooperation has
already been very strong in the nuclear energy
sector, to a lesser extent in the hydroelectric sector
between China and Pakistan. Pakistan is looking to
China for much-required technology, expertise and
investment to develop the use of renewable energy
technologies like wind and sun[13].
Since its independence in 1947, Pakistan
with a population of 30 million people had per
capita income of 100$. Agriculture was the main
sector as the 50% of the total economy with zero
Figure 1: The Strait of Malacca route compared to the
manufacturing [14]. Presently, Pakistan’s economy
CPEC route to China [6].
is the 26th largest in the world in terms of Purchasing
Pakistan-China enjoys a cordial relationship power parity (PPP). International Monitory Fund
from the very start. CPEC will greatly help Pakistan to (IMF) estimates the current GDP of Pakistan for the
overcome its various challenges including energy FY15 as 271 Billion. The GDP of Pakistan
crisis. The Sino-Pak relationship is based on four represents 0.39 % of the world economy. Per capita
pillars namely shared Economic interest and GDP stands at 1427 USD. The GDP growth rate of
cooperation, shared security concerns, shared energy Pakistan is 4.7 % in 2014. The GDP growth rate of
security and geostrategic interest [7]. It is very Pakistan stands at 4.7% in the year 2014 [15].
interesting to observe that Pakistan and China share
Rest of the paper is structured as follows:
common concerns with regard to their energy security
Literature Review presented in Section II.
challenges as well. Pakistan is suffering from energy
Methodology is discussed in Section III. The detailed
crisis for the last few years. Pakistan is spending 60 %
discussion on challenges are discussed in Section IV.
of its reserves on importing the fossil fuel which is a
Finally, conclusions regarding future
great burden on its crumbling economy [8].
recommendations have been discussed in Section V.
On the other side, China (2000-08)
witnessed growth in the demand of energy so 2- BACKGROUD AND RELEVENT
rapidly that it single-handedly accounted for 51% of LITERATURE
the growth in world demand during that time period
[9]. China was self-sufficient in oil until 1993, with The government of People’s Republic of
rapid growth it became the world’s second largest China (PRC) and Pakistan through a strategic
consumer of oil behind the U.S. in 2003[10]. With partnership are developing the China Pakistan
this, the growing energy needs of China the share of economic corridor (CPEC) as the most important
oil imports is also expected to rise to 60-80% by project of $1.4 trillion USD Belt and Road Initiative
2020. With rising economic growth and energy (BRI)[2]. The Belt and Road Initiative by China
consumption, China naturally requires access to integrates a grand scale of enterprises like energy,
adequate energy supplies which is an increasingly trade and economy, transportation, culture. The BRI’s
significant priority for its future. It is based on these physical section includes to the North is the ‘land
realities that China looks at Pakistan as a potential Route (Belt),’ that cuts across Eurasia and to the South
link in a regional grid of energy suppliers. there is the ‘Maritime Silk Road (Road),’ starting in
Moreover, in the current energy poverty scenario, the Chinese Coast transient through East Asia into the
Pakistan cannot become a net energy exporter, the Indian Ocean touching several ports on the way before
Proceedings of the International Conference on Renewable, Applied and New Energy Technologies
ICRANET-2018, 19-22 November 2018, Air University, Islamabad, Pakistan

dismissing in Europe[16]. The ‘Asian Infrastructure consuming country and losing 2.5% of its annual GDP
Investment Bank’ (AIIB) and ‘New Silk Road Fund’ due to the shortage of energy. This massive shortfall
(NSRF) as new regional economic institutions have has severely hit the industrial sector, services sector
been formed in part to complement and for sustenance and agriculture sector which has been resulted in a
of the BRI[17]. There have been many debates major economic downturn[24]. China has announced
internationally regarding different facets of this mega to invest $33 billion in 22 energy projects in Pakistan
Belt and Road Initiative. According to the view and through CPEC during 2018 to 2020 at fast track
vision articulated in the Chinese white paper on BRI is policy. These energy projects have been financed
that it is primarily economic in nature. There are through Exim Bank of China at a rate of 5-6%.
parallel initiatives in education, technology According to some researchers [25, 26], there is a link
development, culture, healthcare and other areas in the between energy and economic development in
greater BRI scheme. Pakistan. Moreover, the study concludes that energy
CPEC was publicized in July 2013 during the has a positive impact on employment opportunities.
Prime Minister of Pakistan’s visit to PRC. CPEC is a On the other hand, a study by [27] exhibits no
long term initiative having a time frame of 2014 – relationship between energy and economic growth of
2030[18].There are five main constituents of CPEC. the country.
1. Gwadar (socio-economic development of Turning out to the challenges and risks of
Gwadar city as well as the region including the port) CPEC to the Pakistani economy, China has its
2. Energy (hydel, coal, solar, wind, LNG etc.) economic and strategic interests, which are One Belt,
3. Transportation Infrastructure (Rail, Road, One Road, control over Gwadar port and access over
Air) central Asia through sea. According to a study by [28],
4. Industrial and Investment Cooperation (Free the revival of Pakistani economy does not depend on
zone in Gwadar and industrial parks) CPEC but focusing on competitive exports.
5. Other areas of mutually agreed interest[19]. The above literature brings forth multi-faceted
According to Board of Investment (BOI) 74 % of and numerous aspects of the energy projects of CPEC.
the total CPEC projects are energy projects, which Additionally, there are some studies are available that
comprise: hydro, coal, solar and wind. Total Chinese focus on CPEC. But, to the best of author’s
investment in the project is estimated to be $ 46 billion knowledge, no considerable study is available in this
out of which around $ 35 billion have been reserved regard in Pakistan. Thus, the present research is going
for energy[20]. Due to the overwhelming significance to fulfill this gap.
of energy in the CPEC project it is also known as the
Pakistan-China Energy and Economic Corridor 3- METHODOLOGY
(PCEEC)[21]. In the 1993, Zhu Rongi, the Vice This study is based on descriptive research.
Premier of China and Shahid Javed Burki, a Pakistani Therefore, adopted research methodology is
and at that time Director of World Bank in China exploratory review of existing literature on the socio-
shared the idea of PCEEC, as an approach to warm economic benefits of energy projects under the flag of
water through Pakistan’s Gwadar. This notion was to CPEC. The Data have been gathered through official
develop the Western China by developing a transport website of CPEC, different books, research articles,
and communication network, comprising road, rail, oil journals, magazines, newspapers, different reports and
and gas pipeline between the city of Gwadar port in seminars.
Pakistan with Western Chinese city of Kashgar [21].
A number of research articles and books have 4- DISCUSSIONS
been presented on the importance of China- Pakistan
Economic Corridor. No doubt, CPEC is a massive The Pakistan–China Energy and Economic
developmental project that aims to link Gwadar Port Corridor (PCEEC) also termed as China-Pakistan
to China through a network of highways, pipelines and Economic Corridor (CPEC) is a leading plan of BRI
railways. CPEC is being considered a source of job has brought notable socio-economic benefits for
opportunities, to excel the economic activity, Pakistan. The China-Pakistan Economic Corridor
infrastructure, roads and rail networks, establishment (CPEC) whose total cost has gone up to $62 billion
of new industrial estates and cultural activities among from initial $46 billion. It is further expected that
the people of Pakistan and China[22]. $100 billion worth more will be needed for
Energy is the backbone of any country like additional projects in the CPEC by 2030. The CPEC
Pakistan. It is considered a very important factor of is observed to have invested $ 33,793 billion in
socio-economic development of the society [23]. energy projects in Pakistan. The CPEC energy
Recently, Pakistan is facing energy crisis with a projects aim to add some 17,000 megawatts of
shortfall of 5,400 MW. As, Pakistan is an energy electricity generation to the national grid through
Proceedings of the International Conference on Renewable, Applied and New Energy Technologies
ICRANET-2018, 19-22 November 2018, Air University, Islamabad, Pakistan

different sources including coal, wind, solar, and Port Qasim started in May 2015
hydropower to combat the growing and pressing Karachi  Jetty completed
energy needs of Pakistan[29].  Plant 2 months ahead
of schedule
According to studies Pakistan was in the severe
 Energization in
energy crisis of 4000 MW in 2008 and it was
October 2017
expected that energy shortage will increase to 8000
MW till 2010 and this energy shortage will  Ist Unit Inaugurated
continuously grow at the usual yearly pace of in November 2017
5.67%. In 2015 Pakistan faced an energy deficit of  Second Unit
5201 MW and on daily basis, there was load- Commercial
shedding of 14-18hours across the country Operation Date
continuing from 2011. According to the present (COD) 25th April
government prediction, it is expected that the energy 2018
crisis in Pakistan will completely finish in 2019 and  Project completed 67
the country will produce the surplus energy of 2732 days ahead of
MW. According to this study, Pakistan was schedule
generating 553.3 MW of electricity through modern  Current Status:
renewable energy technologies in 2015-16 which is Operational
added to the national grid [30]. Still, Pakistani 2- Suki Kinari  Financial Close
energy scenario heavily depends on oil to produce Hydropower achieved on 31st
electricity until 2013-14 a shift from oil to gas have Station, December 2016
been witnessed in the power sector to produce Naran,Khyber  Land acquisition
energy for industrial, household, commercial and Pukhtunkhwa award announced on
transport sector consumption. As compared to 2008, 17th Nov, 2016
the fossil fuel cost increased in 2009 resulting in a  Construction work
0.6 % decrease in the total energy supplies which under way
badly affected the economy of the country. The  Expected Commercial
contribution of fossil fuel remains the highest in Operation Date
form of oil and gas i.e., 64% resource utilization in (COD) December
order to generate electricity. Despite all these 2022
efforts, Pakistan is unable to fulfill the demands of 3- Sahiwal  Financial Closed (FC)
energy requirement. This situation mainly affected 2x660MW Coal- achieved on
the industrial sector resulting in the export fired Power December 2015
minimization and resulting in adverse effects on the Plant, Punjab  Project Completed in
economic growth of the country. The total installed 28th October 2017
capacity in terms of fossil fuel, hydropower and  Project has been
nuclear power plant to generate electricity in connected to National
Pakistan up to July 2017 reach to 25100 MW and grid
with a generation of 108408 GWh [31].  Current Status:
Like other countries one of the main element Operational
for the Pakistan’s economy is energy. Since the last 4- Engro Thar  Financial Closed
decade Pakistan is faced with severe energy Block II (FC) achieved in
shortages. CPEC energy projects has greatly helped 2×330MW and April, 2016.
Pakistan to mitigate energy poverty in the country. Thal Nova  Construction work in
Following chart shows details of the energy projects 1×330MW Mine progress.
completed, ongoing and the ones in the planning Mouth Lignite  Construction of
stage. Coal fired Power Transmission line-
Plant contract awarded.
CPEC Energy Projects progress update TEL 1×330MW Contractor mobilized
Mine Mouth  Commercial
Project Name Progress Update Lignite Fired Operation Date
1- 2×660MW  Financial Closed (FC) Power Project at (COD) June, 2019
Coal- fired achieved Thar Block-II,
Sindh, Pakistan
Power Plants at  Civil works on site
Proceedings of the International Conference on Renewable, Applied and New Energy Technologies
ICRANET-2018, 19-22 November 2018, Air University, Islamabad, Pakistan

5- Surface mine in  Financial close (Bahawalpur)


block II of Thar attained in April 2016 Quaid-e-Azam
Coal field, 3.8  IA/EA signed 9- UEP Wind Farm  Financial Closed (FC)
million tons/year  Mining work in (Jhimpir, Thatta) achieved on March
progress 30, 2015
 3.8 metric tons per  Commercial
annum (MTPA) Operation Date
 Thar Block II (COD) : 16th June,
Unearths Coal on 2017
10th June 2018  Current Status:
 Commercial Operational
Operation Date 10- Sachal Wind  Financial Closed (FC)
(COD) expected Farm (Jhimpir, achieved
December,2018 Thatta) on December 18,
6- Hydro China  Financial Closed (FC) 2015
Dawood Wind achieved on March  Commercial
Farm(Gharo, 27, 2015 Operation Date
Thatta)  Commercial (COD) attained 11
Operation Date April, 2017
(COD) attained 5th  Current Status:
April, 2017 Operational
 Current Status: 11- SSRL Thar Coal  Financial Close of
Operational Block-I 6.8 mtpa Plant and Mine
7- 300MW  LOI was issued on &SEC Mine second quarter
Imported Coal 26th May 2017 Mouth Power of 2017.
Based Power  PPIB Board in its Plant(2×660MW  Mine Commercial
Project at 117th meeting has ) production is
Gwadar, approved extension in expected by 2019.
Pakistan the validity of the  Plant Expected
LOI up to 25th Commercial
November 2018 Operation Date
LOI extension issued (COD) 2018/2019.
on 20th July 2018 12- Karot  Land acquisition
 Site finalized by Hydropower award done.
CCCC Station  Financial Close
 Section IV for land achieved on 22nd
acquisition February 2017.
reprocessed by  Construction of
Deputy access road/bridge,
Commissioner for concrete batching
200 acres plant, diversion
 Balochistan tunnel and
Environmental spillway, etc. are in
Protection Agency process.
(BEPA) has accorded  Work initiated
its Environmental through equity – 41%
Approval to the civil works
Power Project on 6th completed.
July 2018  Expected Commercial
 NEPRA’s tariff Operation Date
determination is in (COD) December
process 2021.
8- Quaid-e-Azam  COD of 3 x 100 MW 13- Three Gorges  LOS issued in August
1000MW Solar attained in August Second Wind 2016.
Park 2016. Power Project
Proceedings of the International Conference on Renewable, Applied and New Energy Technologies
ICRANET-2018, 19-22 November 2018, Air University, Islamabad, Pakistan

Three Gorges  EPA initialed on 30th  TSA/IA initialed


Third Wind November, 2016. during 6th JCC
Power Project  Financial Close  China Electric Power
March 2017. Equipment and
 COD: Three Gorges Technology
Second Wind Company(CET) /
Farm(TGTWF): 30th State Grid nominated
June, 2018 by Chinese side
 COD: Three Gorges 17- Thar Mine  Feasibility stage tariff
Third Wind Mouth Oracle obtained for coal.
Farm(TGTWF): 9t Power Plant  Shareholding
h July, 2018 (1320MW) & agreement on new
 Current Status: surface mine equity partners in
Operational process.
14- CPHGC  IA/ Power Purchase  Under issuance of
1,320MW Coal- Agreement Signed on NTP/LOI.
fired Power 25th January 2017
Plant,  LOS issued on 12th
Hub,Balochistan April 2016; 1st
extension to LOS 5- CONCLUSION
issued on 24th
January 2017 The main objective of present study is to
 Ground breaking investigate the impact of energy projects of CPEC on
ceremony held on 21 the socio-economic development of Pakistan. The
March 2017 study concludes that energy project regarding CPEC
 Expected Commercial are contributing in all fields like Transportation,
Operation Date Foreign Direct Investment, Employment
(COD) 660 MW Dec Opportunities, Industrial Parks, Infrastructure
2018, 660 MW Aug Development, Regional Integration, Socio-Economic
2019 Cooperation, exchange of cultures, Tourism etc. The
15- Matiari to  Feasibility study study also concludes that CPEC proves a fine medium
Lahore ±660kV completed to bring a positive and bright face of the Pakistani
HVDC  Tariff determined by society at national and international level.
Transmission NEPRA
Line Project  TSA/IA initialed in Despite of positive points, there are some risks
December 2016 and challenges too as: terrorism, security, fair
 Land acquisition for allocation of funds, political consensus, stabilization
converter stations at of local businesses etc.
Lahore and Matiari
completed
 Agreement signed
between PPIB and REFERENCES
State Grid of China [1] Grieger, G., One Belt, One Road (OBOR):
on May 2018 China's regional integration initiative. 2016:
 Expected COD in European Parliament.
March 2021 [2] Harris, J.R., Who Leads Global Capitalism?
The Unlikely Rise of China. Class, Race and
16- Matiari (Port  Feasibility study Corporate Power, 2018. 6(1): p. 8.
Qasim) — completed [3] Casarini, N., When all roads lead to Beijing.
Faisalabad  Decision on tariff Assessing China’s New Silk Road and its
Transmission review petition implications for Europe. The International
Line Project announced by Spectator, 2016. 51(4): p. 95-108.
NEPRA [4] Administration-EIA, U.E.I. China Country
 COD expected in Analysis Brief. 2018; Available from:
2018 / 2019
Proceedings of the International Conference on Renewable, Applied and New Energy Technologies
ICRANET-2018, 19-22 November 2018, Air University, Islamabad, Pakistan

https://www.eia.gov/beta/international/?fips [19] Javaid, U., Assessing CPEC: Potential


=CH. threats and prospects. Journal of the
[5] Zhang, Z., China's energy security, the Research Society of Pakistan, 2016. 53(2).
Malacca dilemma and responses. Energy [20] Zimmerman, T., The New Silk Roads:
policy, 2011. 39(12): p. 7612-7615. China, the US, and the Future of Central
[6] Mushtaq, T. China-Pakistan Economic Asia. 2015: Center on International
Corridor : An insight. 16-02-2018; Cooperation.
Available from: [21] Shaikh, F., Q. Ji, and Y. Fan, Prospects of
https://dailytimes.com.pk/28660/china- Pakistan–China energy and economic
pakistan-economic-corridor-an-insight/. corridor. Renewable and Sustainable
[7] Ali, L., et al., The Potential Socio-Economic Energy Reviews, 2016. 59: p. 253-263.
Impact of China Pakistan Economic [22] Hussain, E.a.G.A. China–Pakistan economic
Corridor. Asian Development Policy relations. . 2015; Available from:
Review, 2017. 5(4): p. 191-198. http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/opinion/28-
[8] Sheikh, M.A., Energy and renewable energy Feb-2015/pakistan-china-economic-
scenario of Pakistan. Renewable and relations. .
Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2010. 14(1): p. [23] Huang, B.-N., M.J. Hwang, and C.W. Yang,
354-363. Causal relationship between energy
[9] Kennedy, A. Rethinking energy security in consumption and GDP growth revisited: a
China. 2016; Available from: dynamic panel data approach. Ecological
http://www.eastasiaforum.org/2010/06/06/re economics, 2008. 67(1): p. 41-54.
thinking-energy-security-in-china/. [24] Ahmed, R. and U. Mustafa, Impact of CPEC
[10] Downs, E., The Energy Security Series: projects on agriculture sector of Pakistan:
China, The Brookings Foreign Policy Infrastructure and agricultural output
Studies. Energy Security Series, Brookings linkages. Pide. Org. Pk, 2014.
Institution Press, 2006. [25] Aqeel, A. and M.S. Butt, The relationship
[11] Garlick, J., Deconstructing the China– between energy consumption and economic
Pakistan Economic Corridor: Pipe Dreams growth in Pakistan. Asia-Pacific
Versus Geopolitical Realities. Journal of Development Journal, 2001. 8(2): p. 101-
Contemporary China, 2018: p. 1-15. 110.
[12] Tiezzi, S., China Powers up Pakistan: The [26] Kakar, Z.K. and B.A. Khilji, Energy
Energy Component of the CPEC. The consumption and economic growth in
Diplomat, 2016. Pakistan. Journal of International Academic
[13] Hussain, M., S. Mehmood, and N. Saeed, Research, 2011. 11(1): p. 33-36.
SWOT Analysis of the China-Pakistan [27] Eden, S. and J.C. Jin, Cointegration tests of
Economic Corridor (CPEC) 1. Quarterly energy consumption, income, and
Journal of Chinese Studies, 2017. 5(2): p. employment. Resources and Energy, 1992.
42-64. 14(3): p. 259-266.
[14] Pasha, H.A., Economy of tomorrow: case [28] Hussain, M., China Pakistan Economic
study of Pakistan. 2014. Corridor (CPEC): Challenges and the way
[15] economies, T. Pakistan economy. 2018; forward. 2017, Monterey, California: Naval
Available from: Postgraduate School.
https://tradingeconomics.com/pakistan/indic [29] Zhang, R., et al., Social impact assessment
ators. of investment activities in the China–
[16] Chung, C.-p., What are the strategic and Pakistan economic corridor. Impact
economic implications for South Asia of Assessment and Project Appraisal, 2018: p.
China's Maritime Silk Road initiative? The 1-17.
Pacific Review, 2018. 31(3): p. 315-332. [30] Kamran, M., Current status and future
[17] Das, K.C., The making of one belt, one road success of renewable energy in Pakistan.
and dilemmas in South Asia. China Report, Renewable and Sustainable Energy
2017. 53(2): p. 125-142. Reviews, 2018. 82: p. 609-617.
[18] Malik, A.R., The China–Pakistan Economic [31] Resources, M.o.P.a.N., Pakistan Energy
Corridor (CPEC): A Game Changer for Year Book. Pakistan Energy Year Book,
Pakistan’s Economy, in China's Global 2009.
Rebalancing and the New Silk Road. 2018,
Springer. p. 69-83.
Proceedings of the International Conference on Renewable, Applied and New Energy Technologies
ICRANET-2018, 19-22 November 2018, Air University, Islamabad, Pakistan

View publication stats

S-ar putea să vă placă și