Report of

Two Days Programme on Industrial

Disaster Risk Management
(7th-8th Jan. 2010)

At CII, Sector 31, Chandigarh

1. Executive Summary

CODE AWARE|2009|MIX|74
Title Chandigarh - Industrial Disaster Risk Management
Short title Chandigarh - Industrial Disaster Risk Management
Training Type Training/Awareness on industrial Disaster Risk Management for all
stakeholders of Punjab State
Thrust Area HRDP: Human Resource Development
Targets Industries, Regulators, NGOs, Media, Administrators
Training provider DMI, Industries, NDMA, InWEnt, Director of Factories, etc.
Institutions involved DMI, InWEnt, Government of Punjab
Target group Industries, Regulators, NGOs, Media, Administrators
Workshop objectives A series of the lectures have been organized by distinguished speakers
in two days programme to provide information on:
ƒ access to information provided on www.hrdp-idrm.in web
platform,
ƒ regulatory mechanism available in India and the state of Punjab
ƒ disaster mock drills,
ƒ risk assessment methodologies, computer modelling,
ƒ case studies of emergency preparedness from industries of the
Punjab to show the best practices
Achieved result The participants recommended conducting such workshops twice a
year.
Description of contents Agenda
/agenda • Registration
• Inauguration and key note address
• Guidelines and Action plans etc by Dr. Rakesh Dubey
• Presentation on Present scenario of chemical industrial disaster
management – Dr. Rakesh Dubey
• Presentation on www.hrdp-idrm.in (Capacity building)- Dr.
Florian Bemmerlein-Lux
• Cause for emergency preparedness- Presentations by Bhupesh
H. Upadhyay (M/s Ranbaxy Lab, Mohali),
• Mock drills and their relevance- by Dr.Brg B.K. Khanna,
• Occupational health aspect- by Dr. Paramjit Singh (m/s
Parabolic drugs Ltd),
• Properties and Characteristics of LPG- by Prashant K Shukla,
and Mr Pandey
• Response mechanism in chemical (Industries) disaster
Manager - By Shri G.S. Saini (Nagpur),
• Off site and on site plan based on risk assessment- Dr. Rakesh
Dubey,
• Handling storage and transportation of chlorine-by Sanjeev
Verma (M/s Siel, Rajpura, District Patiala)
• Validictory session by Shri N K Wadhawan, Punjab Labour
Commissioner
Participants number More than 100
Start dd/mm/yy 7th January 2010
End dd/mm/yy 8th January 2010
Duration 2 Days
Venue CII Auditorium, Sector 31, Chandigarh
Contact for more information Dr. Rakesh Dubey (Coordinator)
Dipl.-Biol. Florian Bemmerlein-Lux (Moderator)
Resource persons Shri Hardayal Singh Gill and Sodhi Mall (coordinators)
/Trainers Dr. Brg. B.K. Khanna (Speaker)
Prashant K Shukla
Shri G.S. Saini (Speaker)
1.0 Background

Disaster Management Institute (DMI), Bhopal, in coordination with the Directorate of

Factories, Govt Punjab organised a two day training cum-awareness programme
with the support of InWEnt and GTZ-ASEM under the Indo-German bilateral
cooperation on Industrial Disaster Risk Management (iDRM) with the objective of
disaster risk reduction in the area of industrial (chemical) disasters.

The prime objectives of conducting the programme are to:

• improve the awareness in area of industrial disaster risk management with all
stakeholders,
• promoting the civil administration, industries and communities to develop a
disaster resilience society jointly by establishing the dialogue,
• concept development of hazards identification and risk assessment (HIRA)
and its application in overall emergency development,
• on-site and off-site emergency planning development to reduce the
vulnerability of the industries and society respectively,
• make aware of iDRM web platform www.hrdp-idrm.in and make the wider
utility by involving the various stake holders to it.

Under the Indo-German bilateral programme, in addition to organise the numbers of

training programmes, a web platform www.hrdp-idrm.in has also been developed to
achieve all training related activities. The details of the programme and activities
have been organized at web platform on www.hrdp-idrm.in for view and download of
the relevant information.

2.0 The need of the programme

In the iDRM project operation plan, approved by MoEF, the need for transfer of
knowledge, demonstration of state-of-the-art technologies and processes that can
create multiple effects in the area of industrial disaster risk management was
expressed with organisation of a series of the awareness and training programmes.

To make it more effective, a series training / awareness at the regional level with
various stakeholders have been planned. The programme at Chandigarh in north is
planned to cater India’s Industrialised and rich state Punjab with the following thrust:

• to share experiences in HIRA, off-Site and on-site plans to get a common

understanding and getting ideas about increasing overall emergency
preparedness,
• to discuss about the possibilities of inclusion of Civil Defence, Medical
preparedness, fire fighting effectively in iDRM,
• to identify the existing and relevant databases, review documents and
assessments process and provide direct access to the knowledge amongst
various stakeholders,
 • to exchange experiences about capacity building efforts and constraints in the
area of iDRM,
• to highlight the importance of mock drills in the area of iDRM to target the
overall capacity development in preparedness, response and planning with
the help of NDMA,
• to discuss about the possibilities for a joint use of www.hrdp-idrm.in web
platform for knowledge management and management of training events in
iDRM.

3.0 Overall objectives

The overall objectives of the workshop is to impart awareness and knowledge in the
area of iDRM with all key stakeholders

Awareness: To provide awareness on the following:

All aspects of disaster management e.g. preparedness, prevention, mitigation,
response, rehabilitation and resettlement for Disaster Risk Reduction in future
development with case studies.
Communication with local community for effective preparedness & response.
DMI - Bhopal
Knowledge: To provide knowledge on the following:
Understanding hazards, risk, consequences by making available the posters
and literature for all types of target groups.
Availability of various Indian Standards and regulations on hazardous
chemicals and safety related information.
4.0 Programme details

Dates and Venue:

The programme commenced on Thursday, January 07th, 2010 and concluded on

Friday, January 08th, 2010 successfully at CII Auditorium, Chandigarh with the
support of Directorate of Factories (Under the Department of Labour, Govt of
Punjab).

Registration

The programme started as per schedule on Thursday, January 07th, 2010 with the
registration of the participants. The participants assembled in the Reception Counter
for registration at 9.30 am.

Inauguration

Shri Tiksham Sud, Ho’ble Minister for Forests and Labour, Govt of Punjab,
Chandigarh inaugurated the programme at 10.30 am. In the inaugural speech he
informed that District Crisis Groups (DCGs) have been notified under the
chairmanship of respective Deputy Commissioners in all districts of the Punjab to
monitor and enforce the regulations of chemical/industrial disaster management. He
stressed the need of the training to refresh the reflex action during the emergency
and highlighted the importance of disaster mock drills for improving the response
mechanism of the civil administration.

Shri N K Wadhawan, Punjab Labour Commissioner, appreciated the initiatives

taken by Directorate of Factories and Disaster Management Institute jointly, to link
the capacity building initiatives with the InWEnt-gtz-ASEM under Indo-German
bilateral programme.

Dr Rakesh Dubey, Director, Disaster Management Institute highlighted the

activities of DMI in various states of the country and MAH industries, he also
appreciated that Punjab Govt initiated the preparation of off-site plans of MAH
districts by applying the risk assessment.

Sri Hardayal Singh Gill, Additional Director, Directorate of Factories of Punjab

and Joint Director Sri Sodhi Mall were also present and expressed the vote of
thanks.

Dr Florian Bemmerlein-Lux, Sr Advisor, InWEnt-gtz-ASEM, Nuremberg,

Germany was present as special invitee during inaugural function and highlighted
the ASEM and capacity development programme on iDRM.

The local news papers widely covered the inaugural function, the media coverage by
leading Chandigarh Tribune, Chandigarh of dated January 8th, 2010 is attached
herewith as annexure I.
After inauguration programme was started as per the schedule given in annexure II.
The session by activities is listed below:

Session 1: Dr Rakesh Dubey started the 1st technical session and delivered talk on
“Present Scenarios of Chemical (industrial) Disaster Risk Management in India”. He
highlighted the importance of preparedness and response parts in overall disaster
management. He stressed the application of hazards identification and risk
assessment (HIRA) process in both on-site and off-site emergency planning for
effective emergency planning. The spatial planning at local and regional level can
only be possible when proper simulation of chemical releases is carried out with the
support of reliable software and trained manpower. He was of the view that to control
hazards the following protocol should be applied in national action plan:

o Elimination,
o Substitution,
o Engineering control,
o Administrative control,
o PPEs.

He has shown some of the examples of these controls in his presentation.

Session 2: Dr Florian Bemmerlein-Lux made the second presentation and

highlighted the importance of knowledge and information sharing in the area of iDRM
by explaining the utility of www.hrdp-idrm.in . He also shown the online web platform
to all delegates and urged to share their activities on this platform. He made aware
the whole floor about the web platform by making live demonstrating.

Session 3: The regulatory activities on iDRM was presented by Sri Sodhi Mall,
Joint Director, and Directorate of Factories Punjab and requested to all MAH
industries to follow and take all necessary steps in making compliance of the legal
provisions to reduce the chemical risk at acceptable level. He also highlighted the
off-site emergency plans prepared by DMI in reducing the risk in the districts.

Session 4: Sri Bhupesh H Upadhyaya, General Manager (EHS), M/s Ranbaxy

Labs, Mohali made a presentation in length on “Emergency Preparedness, Planning:
a case study of M/s Ranbaxy Lab”. He highlighted how his unit has prepared plan
and conducting the drills to review the weaknesses of response and preparedness
mechanism of his unit. He stressed that every unit should take action for hazards
identification and risk analysis before making on-site emergency plans and should
share it for making off-site plan with deputy commissioner of the respective district.

Session 5: Brig (Dr) B K Khanna, Sr Specialist, from NDMA made an elaborated

presentation based on the chemical (industrial) drills he did in the country. He
addressed how DMI helped NDMA in making technical scenarios in making drills
successful stories. Through his presentation he requested to state govt Punjab to
take action for strengthening the medical and fire fighting departments on priority.

Session 6: Occupational health aspects were discussed by Dr Paramjeet Singh,

Medical Advisor, M/s Parabolic Drugs Ltd., Derabassi. He is of the view that
occupation health can be improved with disclosure of hazards to workers and also
the local community as workers are the local community after the work hours and
also the spokesperson of the industry. Action plan for medical preparedness is
generally weak in most of the industries so he stressed the proper follow up with
management to meet out the challenges.

Session 7: The second day started at sharp 9.30 am with Dr Rakesh Dubey who
made a presentation of RRPTC Punjab. RRPTC is the data management of various
industries located in the different district. It was appreciated by all participants
because the data is available at one place and can be used by various agencies for
emergency purposes. The RRPTC is prepared by DMI for the state of Punjab and is
available with the Punjab Pollution Control Board.

Session 8: Shri Prasant K Shukla, Dy Manager (operation), M/s Bharat Petroleum

Corp. Ltd., Mohali and Shri Yogesh Pandey, territory Manager M/s Bharat Petroleum
Corp. Ltd., made a detail joint presentation of emergency preparedness of his LPG
bottling plant. He highlighted the properties of LPG and also demonstrated the
importance of MSDS for hazardous chemicals. He has also shown the findings of
Mockdrills of his plant. His presentation was liked by many participants.

Session 9: How we should do the HIRA and how it should be applied in on-site
emergency management plan was discussed in detail. The off-site emergency plans
prepared by DMI were discussed in detail. Certain software were also demonstrated
in this session.

Session 10: Chlor-alkalies plants carry a very high degree of risks within the plant
and outside the plant due production, processing, storing and transportation of
Chlorine gas. How we should minimise the risks was discussed beautifully with
numbers of slides and photographs by Shri Sanjeev Verma, Sr Manager, M/s Seil
Ltd., Rajpura, Patiala.

Session 11: US Communication model for community information was discussed so that
technical information can be disclosed to local community for their preparedness. A film on
Risk assessment was also shown to have better understanding of the risk.

Session 12: After evaluation of the programme was done by participants through a format
the valedictory programme was organized for concluding the programme. Shri N K
Wadhawan, Punjab Labour Commissioner was the Guest of this session.
Participants express their views about the programme and made remarks that such
programmes should be organised at least twice in year to upgrade and refresh their
level of knowledge in the area of industrial disaster management. With the
distribution of certificate of participation the programme was concluded and all
participants dispersed to their respective places after tea.

The recommendations made in this session are present in the conclusion and
recommendation point in the last of the report

The presentations of all above sessions are loaded on web platform for view and
down load. Please see the link http://www.hrdp-idrm.in/e6547/e6546/e15854/e17498
for further reference and reading
5.0 Participants

Altogether more than senior and middle cadre level 100 participants as per the
annexure III, participated in the programme. All participants are responsible for
formulation & implementation of industrial disaster risk reduction programmes in their
respective industries and were present from all MAH industries of the state of
Punjab. Officers from the state of Punjab from Directorate of Factories were also
participated and interacted with MAH industries to review the overall emergency
preparedness for accident reduction. Short Description about participating
Institutions is given in following paragraphs:

¾ National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA)

The National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA), headed by the Prime Minister
of India, is the Apex Body for Disaster Management in India. The setting up of the
NDMA and the creating of an enabling environment for institutional mechanisms at
the State and District levels is mandated by the Disaster Management Act, 2005.

The development and promotion of an ethos of prevention, mitigation and

preparedness Country wide to mitigate the damage and destruction caused by
natural and man-made disasters is main focus of NDMA. NDMA translating its efforts
through sustained and collective efforts of all Government agencies, Non-
Governmental Organisations and people’s participation, by adopting a Technology-
Driven, Pro-Active, Multi-Hazard and Multi-Sectoral Strategy. The building of a Safer,
Disaster Resilient and Dynamic India is the ultimate goal of the NDMA.

Brig. (Dr) B K Khanna, Sr Specialist, NDMA, participated in the programme and

delivered a lecture on Mockdrills and shared his experience of the drills conducted
by NDMA countrywide.

¾ Disaster Management Institute (DMI)

DMI was established in 1987 in the backdrop of world’s worst ever chemical disaster
in Bhopal. The President of the organization is the Chief Minister of MP and the vice-
president is the Minister of Environment of the state. The principal objective of the
institute is to evolve the techniques for and enhance competence in prevention,
mitigation and management of natural as well as industrial disasters in India.

The other objectives includes –

Train government officials, executives of PSUs and private sector firms in
various facets of Disaster Management.

Carry out research on causes, effects etc. of disasters.

Collect, store and effectively disseminate information regarding hazards and
disasters for mitigation and prevention state-of-the-art techniques.
Offer consultancy services to the industries and others.
Institute awards, medals, scholarships and prizes to promote these objectives.
Presently the institute is partner with InWEnt-GTZ-ASEM on capacity development
project on iDRM under Indo-German bilateral programme. Institute is also working
very closely with MOEF, GOI and NDMA to develop national policies and
programmes on disaster management and coordinates with various state
governments.

¾ National Civil Defence College (NCDC), Nagpur

NCDC was founded on 29th April 1957 at Nagpur as Central Emergency Relief
Training Institute (CERTI) to offer advanced and specialist training for efficient
conduct of relief operation after any disaster. The training programmes of CERTI
primarily focused on response mechanism during and after emergency necessary to
be organized for civil protection. CERTI was renamed as National Civil Defence
College in 1968 after the passage of Civil Defence Act, 1968 by the Parliament.

The objectives of NCDC includes –

DMI - Bhopal
To organize scientific and specialized skill oriented training of trainers in order
to enhance capabilities of Emergency Relief officers and personnel for
efficient conduct of Disaster Response and Relief operations during War
Emergencies and Disasters.
To advise Ministry of Home Affairs in technical matters related to Civil
Defence Organisation.
To assist the Ministry of Home Affairs in compilation of handbooks, manuals
and other Civil Defence literature.

Sri G S Saini, Director, NCDC participated in the programme and delivered a lecture
in the programme to improve the civil defence in the area of iDRM.

¾ Directorate of Factories, Punjab

Directorate Industrial Safety and Health is a part of Labour and Employment

Department, Govt. of Punjab, and looks after the industrial health and safety issues
and implements the following:

The Factories Act 1948 and Punjab Factories Rules,

The Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules, 1989,
Chemical Accidents (Emergency Planning, Preparedness and Response )
Rules,1996 of The Environment Protection Act, 1986 to prevent, prepare and
plan for any type of chemical/industrial disasters.

Directorate of Factories, Punjab coordinated and organised the programme.

 ¾ Major Accidents Hazards (MAH) industries

MAH industries from the state of Punjab participated actively and reviewed their
overall emergency preparedness. A few of them presented their preparedness in the
training programme. The following categories of industries were present across the
whole state of Punjab:

ƒ Chemical fertilisers,
ƒ Chlor-alkalies,
ƒ Pharmaceuticals,
ƒ Metallurgical,
ƒ Heavy Engineering,
ƒ LPG,
ƒ Refineries,
ƒ Spinning mills,
ƒ Paper and pulp,
ƒ Etc.
6.0 Conclusions and Recommendations

The second day concluded with valedictory session with the following
recommendations:

1. In the northern region, Punjab Govt will support national efforts in reducing the
industrial accidents by better planning and all participants agreed that such
programmes should be organised twice a year.
2. Participants were of the view that such programmes should also be organised
to RTOs for reducing and controlling the road disasters while transporting the
hazardous chemicals.
3. Since M/s Seil Chemical Ltd., Rajpura has better preparedness plan for
Chlorine disasters hence Seil model can be replicated to other Chlor-alkalies
plants of the country and Directorate of Factories of Punjab will support DMI
and NDMA in this regards. Further action may be finalised at DMI level.
4. M/s Ranbaxy Lab has also good emergency planning procedures for the
pharmacy sectors hence the experience of M/s Ranbaxy can be utilised to
other pharmacy units. Ranbaxy is ready to share their experience for capacity
building measures in the area of chemical emergency planning.
5. Participants were ready to use www.hrdp-idrm.in platform for knowledge
sharing.
6. Participants were happy to know the RRPTC of Punjab and off-site plans
prepared by DMI Bhopal.

Consolidated Summary of Evaluation of the Workshop is attached as annexure IV.

-----------------------
 Annexure I

News Paper Cutting of Daily News Paper “Chandigarh Tribune”, 8th January
2010, Chandigarh
 Annexure II

Training Programme* on Industrial Disaster risk Management (iDRM) at

Chandigarh

7th – 8th January 2009

First day
Time Programme Key Words
9:30-10:00 Registration Registration
10:00-10:30 Programme Inauguration & key note addresses
10:30-10:45 Tea
10:45-11:30 Present Scenario of Chemical (industrial) Disaster Guidelines, Action plan,
Risk Management in India and future strategies : Dr etc.
Rakesh Dubey, Director, DMI

11:30-12:30 Presentation of the www.hrdp-idrm.in platform as a Management, web

possible management tool on iDRM portal,

Discussion about the possibilities for a joint use for Possibilities, joint use
knowledge management and management of
training events in IDRM of www.hrdp-idrm.in by Dr
Florian Bemmerlein-Lux and Dr R Dubey
12.30-13:00 Sharing of experiences on iDRM : Shri Sodhi Mall, Status in the
Joint Director, Directorate of Factories Punjab respective state
13:00-14:00 Lunch Break
14:00-15:15 Emergency Preparedness, Planning – a case Activities of the
study of M/s Ranbaxy Lab : Dr B H respective
Upadhyaya, GM (HSE) M/s Ranbaxy Lab, organisation and their
Mohali role in iDRM
15:15 – 15:30 Tea
15:30-16:15 Mock drills and their relevance: Dr Brg B K Mock drill
Khanna
16:15 – 17:00 Occupational Health Aspects : Dr Paramajit Singh, Occupational health
Medical advisor, M/s Parabolic Drugs, Derabassi
 Second Day
9:30-10:15 RRPTC of Punjab
Modelling for Chemical releases
10:15-10:30 Tea
10:30-11:30 Liquefied Petroleum Ga: Prashant Shukla, Dy Best practice
Manager, Bharat Petroleum Corp Ltd. Distt Mohali
11:30-12:00 Response mechanism in Chemical (industrial) Response
disaster management: Sri G S Saini, Director,
NCDC, Nagpur
12:00-12:30 Risk assessment based On-site and off-site plan: Onsite and off-site
Dr Rakesh Dubey, Director, DMI
12:30 – 13:15 Safety in handling, storage and transportation
of Chlorine: Sanjeev Verma, Sr Manager, M/s
Siel Ltd., Rajpura, Patiala
13:15 – 14:15 Lunch
14:15 – 15:30 Communication model for community
A film on Risk Assessment and open house
Evaluation of the seminar
15:30 – 16:00 Valedictory
16:00 Tea
 Annexure III

List of participants who attended the programme

Name Dept/org. Designation Mobile E-mail

Sandeep Sharma Glaxo Smith Ch. Ltd Process Engineer 9878820603 sandeep.h.sharma@gsk.com
S.K. Singh PACL Asst. Gen. Manager 9815921550 paclngl@sify.com
Senior Chemical
Manmohan Seghal Punjab Alk.& Chem. Ltd Engineer 1887222611 seghal_manmohan@yahoo.com
Devinder Singh Chan. Distiller& Bottlers Ltd Asst. Manager 9872207610 hr@cdblindia.com
Ashwinder Singh BPCL Dy. Manager 9888021599 narulaas@bharatpatroleum.in
Satish Garg Indian Oil Corp. Ltd Dy. Manager Plant 9872969433 satishgarg143@yahoo.com
Nitin Chauhan Godrej & Boyce Mfg. Ex. Utility 9815611222 nitin@godrej.com
J.S. Sohal Nestle India Ltd Prod. Executive 9814481750 jaswant_singh.sohal@in.nestle.com
H.S. Makkar Nestle India Ltd Prod. Executive 9814917564 harpal-singh.makkar@innestle.com
Anil Kumar S.T. Cottex Expo. pvt. Ltd. Safety Officer 9781922483 anil_thakur2000@yahoo.com
Vasakha Singh S.T. Cottex Expo. pvt. Ltd. Asst. Manager 9781922422
Sunny Behl Bonn Nutrients pvt. Ltd Hr Manager 9914195550 sunny.behl@boun.in
Asst. Manager
Ankur Davesar Sangpur-148026 Production 9872988764 ankur.devas@intl.pepsico.com
Ranjit Chatterjee Chemical Lab. Arti Sttel Ltd Sr. Chemist 9257308122
Raj Kumar Chopra Steel Melting Shop Manager Trainee 9915517700 rajkchopra75@yahoo.com
Jagbeer Singh zinc plant Asst. Manager 9988196237
Harbinder S. Gill Pepsico India Production Manager 9872081331 harbinder.gill@inte.pepsico.com
Alok Goyal Indion acrylic ltd CGM (W) 9855630008 alokgoyal@indiconacylic.com
Shahid Shams Executive 9779014646 shahidshan@rediffmail.com
Brijesh K. Mishra Godrej& boyce mfg. Asst. Manager 9988880577 brijeshm@godrej.com
Manager HR &
S.S. Cheema GNA Enterprises ltd Manager 9915014157 pm@gnaent.com
Anil K. Sharma Vardhman yarns Safety Officer 9872873593 mat@vardhaman.com
Umesh Kumar Ambuja cement Officer 9216789077 umesh.verma@ambujacement.com
Vijay Sappo Highway indus. Asst. Manager 9815598116 info@highwayindifyers.com
689. Indu. Area
Shallender Rattao Asst Manager Ludhiana 9915709034 shallender3300@gmail.com
Rakesh K. Bains Pepsico India Quality Executive 9876601978 ramesh.baisns@intt.pepsico.in
Name Dept/org. Designation Mobile E-mail
Col. Jaspal SS Foods Chief Secu. Officer 9781929008 jassie2k2@yahoo.co.in
Manoj Kumar Ranjeev Alloy ESI Clerk 9855589954 bhatiaranjeev@hotmail.com
Bipan Chandev Mehta Engg. Manager 9216612787 bippan@methaenginers.com
En. Subhash Kumar GHTP Asst. Engineer 9646117871 gsubhashk@yahoo.com
Amitabha Roy Technology Sen. Manager 9592675753 info@akmnltimetl.com
Charan Dass Security Officer 9815647216
R.S. Rana Oswal Woolen Mills Manager Utility 9915640712 rajender840@rediffmail.com
Gurbhajan Singh HPCL Sr. Oper. Manager 9815327440 gurubhajansingh@hpcl.co.in
Navpreet Singh Hindustan Unilever ltd Executive 9878937905 navpreet.singh@unilever.com
G.L. Gupta GGSSTP Sn. exe. Engineer 9646110901 glgupta187@gmail.com
Asst. Chief Safety
Satnam Singh GG Singh Termal Plant Officer 9646110907 satnamsingh@gmail.com
P.A. Khan Pulp Mill/Satia Paper Mill Manager 9872253775 satiapaper@gmail.com
Lalit Rana ROCKMAN LTD Manager 9216542827 autochain@rockmanindustries.com
B.S. Sekhen Safety Sn. Exe. Safety 9855186004
Wg. Cdr. H.S. Bakshi Administration Chief Admin. Officer 9357511514
R. Mathur Milk Food Ltd Manager HR 9779750706
M.G. Azad Spinning Mill V.P. (Engineer) 9814900585 mgazad585@yahoo.com
N.K. Zindal Hero cycles DGM 9878622246 nk_jindal@herocycles.com
Mukesh K Sharma Hero cycles G.M. Pers. 9878652003
Abhijeet Singia Etp/Steel Strips Sr. Engineer abhijeet@sswlindia.com
Mandeep Sharma Reliance Ind. Sr. Manager Adm. 9876591603 mandeep.sharma@rediffmail.com
Hirish H. Gandhi Riliance Ind Sr. Manager 9876591608 shirishkumar.gandhi@rediffmail.com
Sukhjinder Singh Rail Coach Fact. Works Manager 97792414315 workmangertransport@yahoo.co.in
Jasbeer Singh NSM ltd Asst. Manager 9814914884 asbirthakur_69@yahoo.com
Subhash Awasthi Ambuja Cement Dy. Manager 9872972358 subhash.awasthi@ambujacement.com
Vijay Dhumal Ambuja Cement Sr. exe. Manager 9878615098 vijay.dhumal@ambujacement.com
Kapil Dar Sharma Asst. Manager 9779906414 sharma.kapilder@swaraj enterprises
Arvind Ghai Federal Mogul 9781922012 arvindghai@fedralmogal.com
K.K. Korla Federal Mogul HR Head 9815550657 kkkorla@fedralmogul.com
Kuldeep Sharma Mahendra & Meh Asst. Manager 9814651049 sharma.kuldeep@swarajenterprises.com
Deepak Rai Health care Dy. Manager 9878685432 singhideepak@yahoo.co.in
K. Shatruanjan Singh Grasim cement Safety Officer 9781298196 kunwar.shatruanjaysingh@adityabirla.com
Name Dept/org. Designation Mobile E-mail
Praveen K. Chopra New Hero Auto G.M. 9988077754 pkchopra@herocycles.com
Baldev Singh Hero Cycles Asst. Manager 9463217881 baldev_singh@yahoo.com
Naresh Midha Anand Nishikawa co. Ltd Dy. Manager 9988508360 naresh mishra.alp@anbross.com
Aasim Sareen Indian Bottling Plant Operation Officer 9914301365 asareen@indanoil.com
Bikram Singh ABC Paper Ltd Aso 9781523266
Manohar Singh Birring PERS Sr.GM (HR) 9781523266 manohar@abc.co.in
Paramjeet Singh Ranbaxy Manager 9915545679 paramjeet.s@ranboxy.com
Vinay Anand Ranbaxy Sr. Prod. Exec. 9815553752
Shashi Gupta Rail coach fact. Sr. Sec. Engineer 9814723929 shashikumargupta16@yahoo.com
Lalit Sharma Overseas Health Care Ch. Prod. Officer 9872019738 production.ohepl@gmail.com
G.D. Tyagi Galvanizing DGM 9815628261
Naresh Midha
Narayan Prasad Shrama Malwa ind ltd Security Officer 9878505278
Satwant Singh Bhushan powers & steels ltd DGM 9815598644 ssb_45in@yahoo.com
Sampurna Nand Singh Malwa Ind Ltd Env. Exe 9878638600 snsingh@malwagroup.com
S S Kandhari Ranbaxy Lab Manager Prod. 9646073009 satinder.kandhari@ranbaxy.com
C.B. Bains NFL Nangal Unit Ch Manager 9417012327 csbains@nfl.co.in
Arvind Kumar C.D.B.L Asst. Manager 9216489016
S.P. Jangra NFL Nangal Unit Sr. Manager 9463288943 spjangra@nfl.co.in
Dinesh Pandey Grasim cement Dy Manager 9914910131 dinesh.pandey@adityabirla.com
Naresh Karwal Nicks India Tools Dy Manager 9815546491 info@nicksindia.com
Anil Kumar Gupta Surya Air Products Manager Operation. 9876043993
Ardeep Madan SIEL Chemical Manager 9815620934 ardeepmadan@sielchemical.com
Bhushan Chauhan SIEL Chemical Manager 9988579142 bhushanchauhan@sielchemical.com
Atul Prakash Verma Vardhman Spinning Asst Manager 9216555352 atulverma@vardhman.com
Jobandeep Singh Power Plant Elect. Engineer 9478149280 jobandeep@gmail.com
Prem Shankar Rawat Parabolic Drugs Sr Manager Safety 9317749916 psrawat@parabolicdrugs.com
Maj. P S Kharwal DCM Ch. Security Officer 9501073336 pskharwal@dcmengg.co.in
Nakul Mahajan Jagat Jeet ind ltd Chem Engineer 9463932147 er_Nakulmahajan@yahoo.com
Deshpal Singh Jagat Jeet ind ltd Safety Officer 9781990041 dpsingh1982@yahoo.co.in
 Annexure IV

Consolidated Summary Evaluation of the Workshop

Meeting / Symposia / Conference / Training Programme on Industrial disaster

Dialogue event - Title Risk Management
Code AWARE|2009|MIX|74
Training Institution DMI, Directorate of Factories Punjab, InWEnt
Duration Two days i.e. January 07-08, 2010
Overall training course and objectives
Number of questions (3) Evaluation Rating* Rating**
where response rounded average is equal to (EI)
Index (EI)*
1 2 3 4 5
1 1 2.5 Very successful
Objectives
6-1-1 on-site and off-site emergency planning development to reduce the vulnerability of
the industries and society respectively
6-1-2 promoting the civil administration, industries and communities to develop a
disaster resilience society jointly by establishing the dialogue
6-1-3 to highlight the importance of mock drills in the area of iDRM to target the overall
capacity development in preparedness, response and planning with the help of
NDMA
6-1-4 to discuss about the possibilities for a joint use of www.hrdp-idrm.in web platform
for knowledge management and management of training events in iDRM
Remarks
9.3 I liked specially
I liked the Present scenarios of Chemical (industrial) Disaster Risk Management in India
and the usability of www.hrdp-idrm.in web platform
9.4 I disliked especially:
Nill
9.5 What kind of awareness did you receive through this event?
Total refresh of knowledge about emergency preparedness and planning
Organisation and venue (Q: 7-1 to 7-10)
Number of questions (10) Evaluation Rating**
where response rounded average is equal to Index (EI)*
1 2 3 4 5
0 9 1 0 0 7.25 Very Good
Follow up
8.1 Which follow-up activities would you recommend? (e.g. further specialist
events,
e-Learning courses, etc.)
Such training should be twice a year
8.2 Further comments and suggestions for improvements suggestions for
improvement:
Nill
The moderator/facilitator and methods (Q: 4-1 to 4-4)
Number of questions (4) Evaluation Rating**
where response rounded average is equal to Index
(EI)*
1 2 3 4 5
0 4 0 0 0 3 Very Good
Participants - How do you assess (Q: 3-1 to 3-5)
Number of questions (5) Evaluation Rating**
where response rounded average is equal to Index
1 2 3 4 5 (EI)*
0 5 0 0 0 3.75 Very Good
Relevance and impact of the work (Q: 2-1 to 2-2)
Number of questions (2) Evaluation Rating**
where response rounded average is equal to Index
1 2 3 4 5 (EI)*
1 1 0 0 0 1.75 Very Good