® ATENEO. SURVEY OF CASES FOR KOKOBAR2018 Lae Schoo By: Dean Sedjrey M. Candelaria. SURVEY OF CASES FOR POLITICAL LAW conrenr ouruine CASE TITLE | YEAR Article 1 (Nat Magallona v. Ermita, G.R. No. 187167, 2011 Aupaitis, 2011 1 Article 2, Section 1 (Government) Funa v. MECO, 193462, February 4, 2014 2014 Update of PCA judgment Permanent Court of Arbitration, South 2015 China Sea (SCS) Dispute Between Philippines and People’s Republic of L China, October 29, 2015 and July 12, 2016. | __ Article 2, Section 3 (AFP as Protector) in | First Class Cadet Aldrin Jeff P. Cudia of 2015 Relation to Article 3, Section Land the Philippine Military Academy v. the Article 14, Section 5 (2) (Academic Superintendent of the Philippine Freedom) Military Academy (PMA), G.R. No. 211362, February 24, 2015 Article 2, Section 14 (Equality Between | Garcia v. Hon. Judge Drilon, G.R. No. 2013, Women and Men) in relation to Article 3, Section 1 (Equal Protection) and | Article &, Section 1 (Judicial Power) 179267, June 25,2013 Article 2, Section 12 (Sanctity of Family | Imbong v. Hon. Ochoa, GR.No.204819, | 2014 Life; Right ofthe Unborn) in relation to | April 8, 2014 Article 3, Section 1 (Life, Procedural Due Process, Equal Protection), Article 3, Section 3 (Privacy), Article 3, Section 6 (Freedom of Religion), Article 3, Section 18 (Involuntary Servitude), Article 6, Section 1 (Undue Delegation) and Article 6, Section 26 (One-Subject-One Bill) Article 2, Section 16 (Right to a Balanced | Paje v. Casifia, et al., G.R. No. 207257, 2015 and Healthful Ecology) in relation to February 3, 2015 Article 8, Section 5 (2) (a) (Standing); Article 10, Section 2 (Local Autonomy), and Section 59 of the Indigenous _ a _ |__| Peoples’ Rights Act West Tower Condominium Corporation — | 2015 v.FPIC, et al, GR. No, 194239, June 16,2015 LNL v. Agham Party List, GR No. 209165, | 2015 April 12, 2016 _ International Service for the Acquisition | 2015, ‘of Agri-Blotech Applications v, Green 2016 Peace Southeast Asia, etal, GR. No. 209271, December 8, 2015 and July 26, 2016 (MR reversing previous judgment) Article 2, Section 16 (Right to a Balanced | Pedro Arigo v. Scott Swift,G.R. 206510, | 2014 and Healthful Ecology)in relation to Article 7, Section 21 (Treaties), Article 16, Section 3 (State Immunity) and Article 18, Section 25 (VFA) September 16,2014 appa© ATENEO SURVEY OF CASES FOR KOKOBAR 2018 Law Schoot By: Dean Sedfrey M. Candelaria Article 2, Sections 25 (Local Autonomy) | Belgica v. Hon. Ochoa, et al, G.R. No. 2013 and 26 (Political Dynasty), Article 6, | 208566, Nevember 19, 2013 Sections 1 (Undue Delegation), 25(4) (Special Purpose Fund), 25(6) Discretionary Fund for Public Purpose), 27(2) (Item Veto), 29(1) (Payment Pursuant to an Appropriation), Article 10, Sections 2 and 3 (Local Autonomy) and Article Il, Section 1 (Public Office and Public Trust) “Article 2, Section 28 (Full Public ‘En Bane Resolution, February 14,2012, in | 2012 Disclosure) Re: Production of Court Records and Documents and the Attendance of Court Officials and Employees as Witnesses Under the Subpoena of February 10, 2012 and the ‘Various Letters for the Impeachment Prosecution Panel dated January 19 and 25, 2012 Article 2, Section 28 (Full Public Philippine Savings Bank and Pascual M. | 2012 Disclosure) and Article 3, Section 1 Garcia Ill v, Senate Impeachment Court, (Privacy) GR. No. 200238, February 9, 2012 [Article 3, Section 1 (Right to Life, Liberty | Burgos v. PGMA, et al, GR Nos. 183711- | 2011 and Security; Writ of Amparo; Writof | 13, july 5.2011 Habeas Data) Boac v, Cadapan, G.R. No. 186050, 2011 “Article 3, Section 1 (Substantive Due Process) December 1 “Mison v. Hon. Gallegos, G.R. No. 210759, June 23,2015 ‘Hon. Zarate, etal. v. LE. Aquino IIL, G.R. 220028. November 10, 2015 ‘Valentino L, Legaspi v, Gity af Gebu, et al. / Bienvenido P. Jaban, Sr., et al. v. Court ‘Of Appeals, et al, G.R. No. 1591 10/G.R. No. 159692, December 10, 2013 2015 2013 Article 3, Section 1 (Substantive Due Process; Equal Protection; Police Power) in relation to Article 6, Section 26 (Riders in Bills) Remman Enterprises, Inc. v. Professional Regulatory Board of Real Estate Service, G.R.No. 197676, February 4,2014 2014 Villanueva v. Judicial and Bar Council, G.R. No. 211833, April 7.2015 2015 Ferrer, Jr. v. Mayor Bautista, etal.,G. R. No. 210551, June 30,2015 _| 1-UTAK v. COMELEC. G.R. No. 206020, April 14,2015 2015 [2015 | Article 3, Section 1 (Right to Property: Procedural Due Process; Equal Protection in relation to Article 3, Section 2 (Search and Seizure), Article 3, Section 3 (Privacy); Article 3, Section 4 (Expression), Article 3, Section 21 (Double Jeopardy) and Article 3, Section 22 (Bill of Attainder), and Article 6, Section 1 (Undue Delegation) 2|Page Disini vs. Secretary of Justice, G.R. No. 203335... February 18,2014 2014© ATENEO SURVEY OF CASES FOR KOKOBAR 2018 Law School By: Dean Sedfrey M. Candelaria Article 3, Section 1 (Procedural Due Petition for Radio and Television 2011 Process; Trial by Publicity) in relation to | Coverage of the Multiple Murder Cases Article 3, Section 4 (Freedom of the Against Maguindanao Governor Zaldy Press) and Article 3, Section 14 (Rights | Ampatuan, et al., AM, Nos, 10-11-5-SC and of the Accused; Public Trial) 10-11-6-S¢, June 14,2011 Article 3, Section 2 (Search and Seizure) | Pollo v. Chairperson Constantino-David | 2011 inrelation to Article 3, Section 3 (Right | (Civil Service Commission), G. R. No. to Privacy) Article 2, Section 28 (Full | 181881, October 18, 2011 Public Disclosure) Article 3, Section 2 (Search and Seizure; | Saluday v. People, G.R. No. 215305, April3, | 2018 Standards Applied to Buses) 2018 Article 3, Section 3 (Rightto Privacy) _| Spouses Bill and Victoria Hing v. 2013 ‘Alexander Choachuy, Sr. and Allan Choachuy, G.R. No. 179736, June 26, 2013 al. GR. No. 194192, June 16, 2015 Article 3, Section 3 (Rightto Privacy; _| Rhonda Ave S. Vivares v. St. Theresa's 2014 Writ of Amparo; Writ of Habeas Data) _| College, G.R. No. 202666, September 29, 2014 Dr. Joy Margate Lee v. P/Supt. Neri A. 2014 gan, GR. No. 203254, October 8, 2014 Article 3, Section 4 (Expression) GMA Network, Inc. v. Commission On 2014 Elections, et al., G.R. No. 205357, September 2, 2014 Diocese of Bacolod et al. v. COMELEC, G.R. | 2015 No. 205728, January 24, 2015 ‘SWS and Pulse Asia v.COMELEC.GR.No. | 2015 208062, April 7, 2015 Davao City Water District v. Aranjuez, et | 2015, DO) 17,2018 Article 3, Section 5 (Freedom of ‘erfecto v. Esidera, 763 SCRA 323, july 22, | 2015 | Religion) S Re: Letter of Tony Q. Valenciano, Holding | 2017 of Religious Rituals at the Hall of Justice Building in Quezon City, A.M. No. 10-4-19- SC, March 7, 2017. Article 3, Section 6 (Liberty of Abode _| SPARK, etall. v. Quezon City, G. R.No. 2017 and Freedom to Travel) in relationto | 225442, August 8, 2017 Article 3, Section 1 (Due Process), Article 3, Section 4 (Speech, Expression and Assembly), Article 3, Section 5 (Religion) and Article 2, Section 12 (Primary Right of Parents to Rear their Children) Article 3, Section 6 (Right to Travel and | Genuino v. De Lima, GR.No. 197930, April | 2018 Clause) 195540, March 13, 2013 Article 3, Section 7 (Right to Sereno v, Committee, G.R. No. 175210, Feb. | 2016 Information) in relation to Article 2, 1,2016 Section 28 (Public Disclosure) DFA v. BCA international, GR No. 210856, | 2016 June 29, 2016 Article 3, Section 10 (Non-Impairment — | Goldenway v. Equitable Bank, G.R. No. 2013© ATENEO SURVEY OF CASES FOR KOKOBAR 2038 Law School By: Dean Sedfrey M. Candelaria Article 3, Section 13 (Right to Bail) Enrile v. Sandiganbayan, G.R. No. 213847, | 2015 | eee ae | Mian 1B 20115, 787 SERALZA2 | __ Ls Article 4, Sections 2 and 3 (Citizenship) | Casan Macode Maquiling v. COMELE( 2013 Rommel Arnado Y. Cagoeo, Linog G. Balua, G.R. No. 195649, April 16, 2013 and | July 2, 2013 (MR). Article 4, Sections 2 and 3 (Citizenship) | David v. Editha A. Agbay and People of 2015 in relation to Article 12, Sections 7 and | the Philippines, G.R. No. 19911, March 18, 8 (Acquisition of Private Land 2015 Distinguished from Public Land) Article 4, Sections 1, 2 and3 Poe-Llamanzares v. COMELEC, G.R. No. 2016 (Citizenship) 221697, March 8, 2016. Rizalito Y. David v. Senate Electoral 2016 ‘Tribunal and Poe-Llamanzares, G.R. No. | 221538, September 20,2016 | Article 5, Section 1 (Suffrage) ‘Kabataan Party-List v. COMELEC, G.R.No. | 2015 221318, December 18, 2015, Article? Arroyo v. DOJ, 681 SCRA 181 [2012] [2012 La Suerte v. CA, 739 SCRA 489 [2014] | 2014 ‘Quezon City PTCA v. Department of 2016 Education, G.R. 188720, February 23,2016 | Article 6, Section 1 (Undue Delegation of | Biraogo v. Philippine Truth Commission, | 2010 Legislative Power) in relation to Article | G.R. Nos. 192935, 193036, December 7, 7, Section 17 (Ensure Faithful Execution | 2010 of Laws) and Article 3, Section 1 (Equal | Protection) _ _ Article 6, Section 1 (Undue Delegation) _| Deutsche Bank v. CIR, GR No. 188550, | 2013 in relation to Article 7, Section 21 August 19, 2013 (Treaties) and Article 8, Section 14 ‘ision)_ | 5 (1), (3), (4) ‘Aquino v. COMELEC, GR. No. 189793, April | 2010 (Legislative Districts) 7, 2010 Article 6, Section 5(2) (Party-List) Atong Paglaum v. COMELEC, G.R. No. 2013 203766, April 2, 2013 Article 6, Section 5(2) (Party-List) Lico v. COMELEG, G.R. No. 205505, 2015 September 20, 2015 | Article 6, Section 6 (Qualifications; ‘Tagolino v. HRET, G.R. No. 195540, 2013 Domicile) March 19, 2013, Reyes v, COMELEG, G.R.207264,June | 2013, } 123,2013. Article 6, Section 16 (Officers; Minority) | Baguilat v. Speaker Alvarez,G.R.No. | 2017 227757, July 25, 2017 | Article 6, Section 21 (Legislative Balag v. Senate, G.R. No. 234608, July 3, | 2018 Inquiries) 2018 [ Article 6, Section 23 (2) (State of ‘Ampatuan v. Secretary Puno, GR.No. | 2011 Emergency) in relation to Article 7, 190259, June 7, 2011 Section 17 (Executive Power of Control) and Article 10, Section 16 (Presidential Supervision over Autonomous Regions) 4a| Page© XTENEO SURVEY OF CASES FOR KOKOBAR 2018 By: Dean Sedfrey M. Candelaria Funds) in relation to Article 6, Section 29(1) [2013] 209287, July 1, 2014 and February 3, Araullo v. President Aquino, GR. No. Article 6, Section 23 (2) (State of Lagman v. Executive Secretary 2017, Emergency) in relation to Article 7, Medialdea, G.R. No. 231658, July 4, 2018 Section 18 (Commander-in-Chief 2017 and MR February 6, 2018 | Powers) Article 6, Section 25 (5) (Transfer of | Nazareth v. Villar, 689 SCRA 385, 2013 Months Before Elections) provision read with A8, Sec. 4(1) 2015 (MR) “Article 6, Section 28 (Exemptions) CIR v. St. Lukes Medical Center, G.R.No. | 2012 195960, September 26, 2012 Article 6, Section 29 (3) (Special Fund) | Philippine Coconut v. Republic, 663 | 2012 SCRA S14 [2012] ‘Article 7, Section 4 (PET) Macalintal v. PET, 635 SCRA 783 2010 [2010] Article 7, Section 13 (Other Officers) | Espirituv. Lutgarda, GR.No. 204964, | 2014 relation to AB, Section 1 (Judicial Powers) 8, 2015, 755 SCRA 260 Article 7, Section 16 (Appointments) | Velicaria-Grafel et al. v.0.P.,GR.Nos. | 2010, 203372, 206290 and 209138, June 16, | 2015 2 2015, 758 SCRA 414 - March 10, 2010 Article 7, Section 17 (Control) Boy Scouts v. COA, G.R 177131, G.R.No. | 2011 1771, June 7, 2011 Article 7, Section 17 (Faithful Execution | Ocampo v. Rear Admiral Enriquez, | 2016 of Laws) GR. Nos. 225973, 225984, 226097, 226116, 226117, 226120, and 226294, November 8, 2016 “Article 7, Section 18 (Calling-Out Power; | Fortun v. Arroyo, G.R. No. 190293, March | 2012 Habeas Corpus; Martial Law) in relation | 20,2012 to Article 18, Section 24 (Armed Groups) |_ _ a Jamar M. Kulayan, et al. v. Gov. 2012 Abdusakur M. Tan, etal.,G.R. No. 187298, July 3, 2012 Article 7, Section 18 (Commander-in- | Lagman v. Executive Secretary 2017 Chief Powers) Medialdea, GR. Nos. 231658, 231771, and 231774, july 4,2017 Article 7, Section 19 (Pardon) in relation | Atty. Alicia Risos-Vidal v. Alfredo Lim, GR | 2015 to Article 9-C, and Section 5 (COMELEC | No. 206666, January 21, 2015 | and Recommendation) irticle 7, Section 19 (Pardon) in ‘San Diego v. People, GR. No. 176114, April | 2015© SURVEY OF CASES FOR KOKOBAR 2018 ATENEO Law Shoot By: Dean Sedfrey M. Candelaria Article 7, Section 20 (Loan Agreement) | China National Machinery & Equipment | 2012 Corp. v, Santamaria, 665 SCRA 189, February 7, 2012 Landbank of the Philippines. Atlanta | 2014 Industries, G.R. No. 193796, July 2, 2014 Hontiveros - Baraquelv.TRB,G.R.No. | 2015 181293, February 23, 2015 I DPWH v. CMG, GR 179732, September 13, | 2017 2017 Article 7, Section 21 (Peace Treaties; Vinuya, etal. v. Romulo, GR. No. 162230, | 2010 International Agreements; Foreign Relations Power; Extradition) April 28, 2010 and August 12, 20 Bayan Muna v. Executive Secretary Romulo, GR. Nos. 159618, February 1, 2011 MI Deutsche Bank v, CIR, GR. No, 168550, | 2013 August 19, 2013 | Saguisagv. Executive Secretary Ochoa, | 2016 GR. Nos. 212426 and 212444 January 12, 2016 Ll Government of Hongkong Special 2016 Administrative Region (HKSAR) v. Munoz, GR. No. 207342, August 16,2016 Mitsubishi y, CIR, G.R. No. 213948, April | 2017 25,2017 Article &, Section 1 in relation to A17 Philconsa v, GPH, GR, Nos. 218406, 2016 (Justiciability; Constitutional 218761, 204355, 218407 and 204354, Amendments) November 29,2016 | Article 8, Section 5(2) (a) (Operative Film Development Council v. Colon 2015 Fact) Heritage Realty Corporation, G.R. No. ee 203754, June 16,2015 _ _ | Article 8, Section 5(5) (Rule-Making Estipona Jr. v, Hon, Lobrigo, GR. No, 2017 | Authority of the Supreme Court) 226679, August 15, 2017 Article 8, Section 8 and 9 (JBC; Hon. Aguinaldo v. H.E, President Aquino | 2017 Nominations; Clustering) IIL. GR. Na, 224302, November 29,2016 and August 8, 2017(MR) Article 10, Section 6 (Just Share in Villafuerte v. Robredo, GR No. 195390 | 2014 National Taxes) | December 10, 2014. alt Mandanas v. Executive Secretary Ochoa, | 2018 GR. No. 199802, July 3, 2018 Article 10, Section 6 (Just Share in League of Cities of the Philippines v. 2008. National Taxes) and Article 10,Section | COMELEC, et al., G.R. Nos. 176951, 2009, 10 (Creation of Cities) in relation to 177499, 178056, November 18, 2008; 2010, Article 3 (Equal Protection) March 31, 2009; December 21, 2009; 2011 August 24, 2010; February 15, 2011; Apri 12, 2011; June 28, 2011 Article 10, Sections 8 (Term of Local ‘Abundo v. COMELEC, G.R. No. 201716, 2013 Officials) 2014 2014 6IPATENEO Lan Schoo! SURVEY OF CASES FOR KOKOBAR 2018 By: Dean Sedfrey M. Candelaria | Article 10, Sections 10 (Creation of Province) Navarro v. Ermita, G.R. No. 180050, July 20, 2012 (1st Decision) and April 12, 2011 2011, 2012 Ownership in Public Utility) 176579, June 28, 2011 (1st Decision) and October 9.2012 (MR) _ Roy Ill v. Chairperson Herbosa, G.R. No. 207246, November 22, 2016 (MR) _ a Cagas v. October: Umali vy. COMELEG, GR. No. 203974, April | 2014 22, 2014 Article 10, Sections 14 (Regional Pimentel y, Executive Secretary Ochoa, | 2012 Development Councils) 676 SCRA S51 [2012] Article 10, Sections 15-22 (ARMM), in | Abas Kida.Senate,G.R.Nos.196271, | 2011 relation to Article 6, Section 1 196305, 197221, 197280, 197282, 197392, (Legislative Power), Article 6, Section 16 | 197454, October 18, 2011 (2) (Majority Vote), Article 6, Section 26 (2) (Urgent Bills), Article 7, Section 16 (Appointment), and Article 18, Sections Gutierrez v. House of Representatives, | 2011 GR. No, 193459, February 15,2011 Gonzales III v. Office ofthe President, | 2014 (Independence of the Ombudsman; 714 SGRA 611 Power to Investigate) Article 11, Section 13 (Powers of the Carpio-Morales v. CA, G.R.Nos.217126- | 2015 ‘Ombudsman; Injunctions against 27, November 10, 2015 Investigation Conducted by Ombudsman) inrelation to “Condonation Doctrine” a _ Article 12, Section 2 (Service Contract) | Resident Marine Mammals v.Secretary | 2015 Reyes, GR. Nos. 180771 and 181527, April 21,2015, Article 12, Section 10 (in relation to A14, | Knights of Rizal v. DMCI Homes, G.R.No. | 2017 Section 15 (Historic Sites: Arts and 213948, April 25, 2017 Culture) and A3, Section 9 (Expropriation) Article 12, Seetion 11 (Foreign Gamboa v. Secretary Teves, et al. GR.No, | 2011 Section 28 (3) (Tax Exempting DLSU, G.R. Nos. 196596, 198841, and 198941, Nov.9, 2016 Article 13, Section 4 (Rights of Farmers | Hacienda Luisita Inc. v, Presidential 2011 and Farmworkers) in relation to Article | Agrarian Reform Council, et al., GR. No. 3, Section 1(Due Process) and Article 3, | 171101, July S, 2011 Section 10(Contract Clause) Article 14, Section 4 (3) inrelation to. A6, | Commissioner of Internal Revenue wv. — | 2015 7 Page 000