Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Received: 2 October 2015 Response surface methodology was used to study the effect of process variables on product
Received in revised form: quality of fried maize-based snack (kokoro). The process variables are: African yam bean seed
4 April 2016 flour (AYBSF) (20-40%) inclusion in maize flour, frying temperature (150-170oC) and frying
Accepted: 8 April 2016
time (8-12 min). Product’s protein content, sensory quality and color parameters (L*, a* and
b*) were determined. High quality kokoro characterized by high protein content (>10%), high
sensory quality (>6.5), and acceptable color parameters [(minimum redness (a*), optimum
Keywords yellowness (b*) and lightness (L*)] were obtained by using 30% AYBSF, at frying temperature,
155oC for 11.5 min. Addition of legume (AYBSF) resulted in significant increases in protein
African yam bean seed flour
content and sensory evaluation while increasing frying temperature increased the redness and
Optimization
Fried maize snack yellowness. Based on the lack of fit test and coefficient of determination, R2, quadratic model
Protein content was appropriate for protein content, sensory quality, yellowness (b*) and lightness (L*) while
Color content linear model was appropriate for redness (a*). Statistical analysis with response regression
showed significant (p=0.05) interactions between process variables and quality parameters
measured. The optimal process variables of frying temperature 155oC, frying time 11.5 min
and AYBSF level (30%) would produce AYB-maize kokoro with enhanced nutritive value,
better sensory quality and consistent color parameters.
© All Rights Reserved
*Corresponding author.
Email: gb.tinu04@yahoo.com, aoidowu@mtu.edu.ng
608 Idowu, A.O. and Aworh, O.C./IFRJ 24(2): 607-613
its nutrient contents. Lysine and methionine levels in from a retail market in Ibadan, Oyo State, Nigeria.
the protein are reported to be higher than those of most
of legume crops (Evans and Boulter, 1974). Despite Experimental design
the availability and the nutritional importance of this A Box Behnken design with three variables was
crop, it is still less utilized. AYBS has been processed used to optimize the processing conditions (Box and
into flour and paste used locally for “moinmoin” Behken, 1960). The three independent variables in
(cooked paste) and “akara” (fried bean balls). There this study were frying temperature (X1), frying time
is still limited information on the food uses of AYBS. (X2) and quantity of AYBSF (X3). The variables
Deep fat frying is a heat transfer process combining considered in this study and their levels were chosen
convection within the hot oil and conduction to the based on information from literature and preliminary
surface of the food (Fellows, 1990). All surfaces of laboratory investigation. Protein content, overall
the food receive a similar heat treatment to produce acceptability (sensory quality) and color parameters
a uniform color and appearance. This heat treatment were the main quality parameters evaluated for the
results in modification of physical, chemical and maize snacks.
sensory characteristics of the food. Studies have Frying temperature (X1), frying time (X2) and
shown frying temperature and frying time as major quantity of AYBSF inclusion in the flour blend (X3)
variables controlling deep fat frying operation were considered as independent variables. While
(Sulaeman et al., 2001). Frying has been reported to protein content (Y1), overall acceptability (Y2),
affect product color and sensory quality (Samatcha lightness (Y3), redness (Y4) and yellowness (Y5) as
et al., 2009). Therefore, optimization of the process dependent variables. The three levels of each of the
variables involved in frying is expected to suggest three independent variables were: 150oC, 160oC and
conditions for obtaining products of consistent color 170oC (-1, 0, 1); 8, 10 and 12 min (-1, 0, 1) and 20%,
and consistent sensory quality. 30% and 40% (-1, 0, 1) for frying temperature (X1),
Response surface methodology (RSM) is a frying time (X2) and quantity of AYBSF inclusion
statistical-mathematical method that uses quantitative in the flour blend (X3) respectively. Thirteen
data in an experimental design to determine and combinations and four center points were performed
simultaneously solve multivariate equations to in random order.
optimize processes and the products (Myers and
Montgomery, 1995; Akinoso et al., 2011). Studies Preparation of Maize-AYBS flour samples and the
have been done on optimization of some other food kokoro
products (Olapade, 2010) (Tripathi and Mishra, Maize samples were sorted and milled in a
2009). However, little insight is provided for the hammer mill (model ED-5 Thomas Wiley, England)
optimization of maize snack to improve nutritional and sieved using 750μm mesh size. The African yam
content, sensory quality and physical quality (color). bean seeds were sorted, weighed, washed, soaked
The objective of this study therefore, was to in water, dehulled manually and dried (60oC) in an
optimize the process variables involved in producing oven. The dried seeds were milled in a hammer mill
kokoro from blends of Maize Flour (MF) and African (model ED-5 Thomas Wiley, England) and sieved
Yam Bean Seed Flour (AYBSF) and evaluate the with 500μm mesh size. Parts of the maize flour were
effect of the process variables (frying temperature, substituted with 20, 30 and 40% AYBSF by weight.
frying time and quantity of AYBSF in the flour Each blend was properly mixed thoroughly using
blends) on the protein content, color parameters and a Kenwood mixer (OWHM, England) for 3 min to
the sensory quality of the snack. obtain homogenous samples and packaged separately
in high density (100 µm) polyethylene bags and
Materials and Methods airtight plastic containers prior to further processing.
Kokoro was prepared by using the method of
Materials Uzo-Peters et al. (2008) with slight modifications.
Yellow maize (variety, BR 9928-DMR-SY) was The Maize- AYBS flour blends were divided into two
procured from the International Institute of Tropical equal parts. The first half was mixed with measured
Agriculture (IITA), Ibadan, Oyo State, Nigeria, while quantity of salt and onions while the second half
the African yam bean seeds (Tss-30) were purchased was mixed in hot water to make a paste. The two
from a retail market (Umuaiha), Abia state, Nigeria. halves were pre-gelatinized together by continuous
They were stored at temperature, 4-8oC and relative stirring for about 3 min to form homogenous dough.
humidity, 65-100% prior to further processing. The dough was allowed to cool to a temperature
Refined vegetable oil, salt and onions were obtained of 40oC and kneaded on a chopping board. The
Idowu, A.O. and Aworh, O.C./IFRJ 24(2): 607-613 609
kneaded dough was cold extruded into uniform sizes Statistical analysis
and deep-fried in hot oil (specific gravity 0.918) at A second order polynomial equation was used to
temperature 150oC, 160oC and 170oC for 8, 10 and fit the experimental data given in Table 1. It could be
12 min as reported in our previous work (Idowu and fitted to the following equation:
Aworh, 2014). The fried snacks were drained, left to
cool and packaged in polyethylene bags (100μm) and
stored at ambient conditions (Temperature-24±3oC,
61±3 % Relative humidity).
Where Y is predicted responses for protein content
Deep fat frying operation of the snacks (Y1), overall acceptability (Y2), lightness, l* (Y3),
A deep fat fryer (Model S-516, Hong Kong, redness, a*(Y4) and yellowness, b* (Y5). X1 - X3 are
China) with temperature control of ±1oC was used. coded independent variables and β0, β1- β3, β11- β33
The fryer holds 2.5 L of oil and it is equipped with and β12- β23 are the equation regression coefficients
a 2 kW electric heater. Isothermal conditions were for intercept, linear, quadratic and interaction effects
observed during frying by keeping the snacks-to-oil respectively (Garayo and Moreira, 2002).
weight ratio as low as possible (~0.0035) (Pedreschi
et al., 2005) (Krokida et al., 2001) and the frying Optimization and validation
temperature monitored using a digital thermometer. In order to optimize the processing variables
After each frying test, the oil level was checked and during the frying process whilst retaining high
replenished with oil; and changed after every 2h of quality kokoro snack, the protein content and
frying (Blumenthal, 1991). overall acceptability were maximized, redness was
minimized while lightness and yellowness were
Analysis of quality parameters kept at a recommended acceptable range (Sobukola
Crude protein content, color and overall et al., 2008). Then the coefficients of determination,
acceptability were analyzed as quality parameters of R2 were fitted into the regression Equation 1.
the snacks, using the procedures discussed below. Optimum conditions of process variables for kokoro
preparation was obtained using computer software
Determination of Crude protein content of samples package (design expert version 6.0.6 Stat. Ease
The kokoro snacks were grounded with porcelain Minneapolis, USA). The suitability of the model
mortar and pestle after drying the samples in the developed for predicting the optimum response was
oven for about 2h after each frying operation. Crude tested by comparing the experimental and predicted
protein was determined using Kjeldahl method, values obtained. Standard deviations were calculated
(AACC, 2005) method 46-12.01. for each of the parameters.
Table 1. Process variables and quality parameters (responses) for preparation of kokoro