Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Third Edition
NEW!
Online Course
Portal with
Course Enrollment.
See inside for details.
Insurance Company Operations
Third Edition
20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
This text, or any part thereof, may not be reproduced or transmitted in any form
or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording,
storage in an information retrieval system, or otherwise, without the prior written
permission of the publisher.
While a great deal of care has been taken to provide accurate, current, and authori-
tative information in regard to the subject matter covered in this book, the ideas,
suggestions, general principles, conclusions, and any other information presented
here are for general educational purposes only. This text is sold with the under-
standing that it is neither designed nor intended to provide the reader with legal,
accounting, investment, marketing, or any other types of professional business
management advice. If legal advice or other expert assistance is required, the ser-
vices of a competent professional should be sought.
ISBN 978-1-57974-381-9
Contents
Preface.................................................................................................PREF.1
Acknowledgments.............................................................................. PREF.13
Introduction.........................................................................................INTRO.1
Using the Test Preparation Guide........................................................INTRO.3
Glossary............................................................................................. GLOS.1
Index.................................................................................................INDEX.1
Preface
Insurance Company Operations, Third Edition describes how life companies
operate: how they are organized, how they are managed, and the roles of func-
tional units in developing, distributing, issuing, and administering life insurance
and annuity products. Readers will learn how an individual job fits into the entire
scope of an insurance company, as well as the importance of each employee’s con-
tribution to overall organizational success. The text is divided into five modules:
Module 1: Company Organization and Governance (Chapters 1-2)
Module 2: Support Functions (Chapters 3-5)
Module 3: Financial Functions (Chapters 6-8)
Module 4: Marketing, Product Development, and Distribution
(Chapters 9-11)
Module 5: Product Administration Functions (Chapters 12-14)
Acknowledgments
Insurance Company Operations, Third Edition is the result of the combined efforts
of industry experts who served on a textbook development panel, LIMRA staff,
and LOMA staff and consultants. The LOMA 290 authors are extremely grateful
for the dedication, knowledge, expertise, and guidance provided by all of these
individuals throughout the writing of this textbook.
LIMRA
We thank the following LIMRA colleagues who provided expert guidance, sub-
mitted relevant research materials, and answered numerous questions during this
text’s development:
Thomas P. Caraher
Vice President, Compliance and Regulatory Services
Andy Khoo, MBA, CFP, FLMI, AIAA, ACS
Managing Director, The Centre for Professional Development
Patrick T. Leary
Assistant Vice President, Distribution Research
Lucian Lombardi
Vice President, Distribution Research
Laurence J. Niland, CLU
Senior Regulatory Advisor
LOMA Staff/Consultants
The authors wish to thank the LOMA 290 Course project team members for all
of their hard work. We also want to thank Gene Stone, FLMI, ACS, CLU, and
Miriam A. Orsina, FLMI, PCS, ARA, PAHM, who wrote the previous edition of
Insurance Company Operations, and upon which much of this edition is based. In
addition, we would be remiss if we didn’t thank other LOMA staff members who
graciously provided expert advice on a variety of topics: Susan Conant, FLMI,
HIA, CEBS; Harriett E. Jones, J.D., FLMI, ACS, AIRC; and Lisa M. Kozlowski,
FLMI, FFSI, CLU, ChFC, AIAA, AIRC, ARA, FLHC, AAPA, ACS.
And, finally, we extend a very special thank you to Julia K. Wooley, FLMI,
ACS, ALHC, HIA, MHP, Assistant Vice President, Learning Content Develop-
ment, who served as Project Manager and provided guidance and support through-
out the project; and Katherine C. Milligan, FLMI, ACS, ALHC, Vice President,
Education and Training Division, who provided leadership, guidance, resources,
and support for this project.
Introduction
The purpose of Insurance Company Operations, Third Edition is to provide indus-
try employees with an overview of how insurance companies operate within
today’s global environment. To enhance your learning experience, LOMA makes
available for this course a Course Portal that is accessible upon course enrollment
in LOMANET. A LOMA Course Portal is an online resource from which learners
access everything they need to study and prepare for the course examination. The
Course Portal organizes the assigned text material into convenient Modules—
chapter clusters that help to focus the learning process by breaking up the course
content into meaningful sections. In addition to the assigned study materials, the
Course Portal provides access to an array of blended learning resources, including
multimedia features designed to enhance the learning experience. The LOMA 290
Course Portal provides access to
An introductory course video
Protected PDFs of the assigned text and Test Preparation Guide, which can be
printed or read online
The interactive version of the Test Preparation Guide’s Practice Questions and
Sample Exam
Review tools, including Learning Aids—animations of important concepts—
and a “Top Ten Tough Topics” tutorial
Recommended study plans to help you set goals and manage your learning
experience
Related links which help you apply the course instruction to the real world
LOMA 290 is part of the Associate, Life Management Institute (ALMI) and Fel-
low, Life Management Institute (FLMI) program. Students preparing to take
the examination for LOMA 290 will find that the assigned study materials—the
protected PDFs of the text and Test Preparation Guide—include many features
designed to help learners more easily understand the course content, organize
their study, and prepare for the examination. These features include lists of Learn-
ing Aid topics available on the Course Portal, chapter outlines, chapter learning
objectives, key terms, figures containing real-world examples of course content,
and a comprehensive glossary. As we describe each of these features, we give you
suggestions for studying the material.
Learning Aids and Top Ten Tough Topics. A list of Learning Aids is provided
in the protected PDF for the entire text as well as for each Module. Review
this list to become familiar with topics for which an animated learning aid is
available on the Course Portal. Viewing these Learning Aids allows you to see
topics in action or to view topics from a different perspective than from simply
reading about them in the text. Also included is a Top Ten Tough Topics tuto-
rial. This tutorial contains animations and study tips for topics that learners
often find difficult when answering questions on the examination. Both the
Learning Aids and the Top Ten Tough Topics tutorial enhance the learning
experience, appeal to a variety of learning styles, and offer a great way for
learners to advance their understanding and retention of course content.
Learning Objectives. The first page of each chapter contains a list of learning
objectives to help you focus your studies. Before reading each chapter, review
these learning objectives. Then, as you read the chapter, look for material that
will help you meet the learning objectives. The interactive version of the Test
Preparation Guide’s Practice Questions and Sample Exam questions (acces-
sible from the Course Portal) are linked to the learning objectives to give you
an idea of how the learning objective might be measured on an examination, as
well as to help you assess your mastery of the learning objectives.
Chapter Outline. Each chapter contains an outline of the chapter. Review this
outline to gain an overview of the major topics that will be covered; then scan
through the chapter to become familiar with how the information is presented.
By looking at the headings, you can gain a preview of how various subjects in
each chapter relate to each other.
Key Terms. This text explains key terms that apply to the text material and,
where appropriate, reviews key terms previously presented in LOMA courses.
Each key term is highlighted with bold italic type when the term is defined and
is included in a list of key terms at the end of each chapter. All key terms also
appear in a comprehensive glossary at the end of the protected PDF of the text.
As you read each chapter, pay special attention to the key terms.
Figures and Insights. We include figures and insights throughout the text to
illustrate and bring a real-world perspective to the text’s discussion of selected
topics. Information contained in figures and insights may be tested on the ex-
amination for the course.
Glossary. A comprehensive glossary that contains definitions of all key terms
appears at the end of the protected PDF of the text. Following each glossary
entry is a number in brackets that indicates the chapter in which the key term
is defined. The glossary also references important equivalent terms, acronyms,
and contrasting terms.
LOMA may periodically revise the assigned study materials for this course.
To ensure that you are studying from the correct materials, check the current
LOMA Education and Training Catalog available at www.loma.org or on the
Course Portal. Also be sure to visit the Announcements page on the Course
Portal to learn about important updates or corrections to the assigned study
materials.
Learning Aids
The LOMA 290 Course Portal, available online at www.LOMANET.org, includes
several Learning Aids designed to reinforce concepts covered in the assigned
text. If you are not already using the online Course Portal but would like access to
the Learning Aids for this course, please follow the log-in instructions provided
in your enrollment confirmation email, or call 1-800-ASK-LOMA or email edu-
cation@loma.org for assistance. PLEASE NOTE: Examination questions will be
based only on content presented in the assigned text.
Chapter 1
Objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to
Identify and describe stakeholder groups associated with an insurance
company
Distinguish between external and internal customers
Distinguish between solvency laws and market conduct laws
Describe the basic levels of management and list the four functions of
management
Describe organizational concepts such as authority, responsibility,
accountability, chain of command, delegation, centralized organizations,
and decentralized organizations
Recognize typical functional areas for insurance operations and classify
functional units as line functions or support functions
Explain how companies can use a value chain to identify competitive
advantages in operations
Describe traditional ways that insurers organize operations
Identify the primary characteristics of a profit center and a strategic
business unit (SBU)
Identify different types of committees and describe the role that
committees play in a company’s operations
Explain the holding company structure and list four advantages to
insurers of creating such structures
Outline
Stakeholders in an Insurance Management Functions
Company Planning
Owners Organizing
Customers
Organizing Insurance Operations
Producers
Introduction to the Value Chain
Employees
Traditional Ways Insurers Organize
Regulators
Work Activities
Rating Agencies
Profit Centers / Strategic Business
Reinsurers
Units (SBUs)
Other Stakeholders
Committees
Balancing Stakeholder Interests
Holding Company Systems
Levels of Management
Board of Directors Downstream and Upstream Holding
Companies
Senior-Level Managers
Lower-Level Managers
I
f you are new to the workplace or new to the insurance industry, you might
not fully understand how an insurance company operates. You may have heard
about underwriters or actuaries, but don’t understand what they do. You might
be uncertain about how all of the different areas in your company work together.
This course explains how life insurance companies operate. You will learn what
insurers do and how they do it. You’ll also see more clearly how your individual
efforts affect your company’s overall performance.
them from financial losses associated with certain risks. Three broad categories of
insurance companies include: life insurance companies, health insurance compa-
nies, and property and casualty insurance companies. Life insurance companies
primarily issue and sell products that insure against financial losses associated
with the risk of death. A family or business with adequate life insurance coverage
may have less of a financial burden if the person whose life is covered under the
policy, the insured, was to die. Common uses for life insurance benefits include
Paying final expenses or debts after an insured’s death
Establishing a cash reserve for an insured’s survivors
and satisfy the various needs and requirements of the company’s stakeholders. A
stakeholder, also known as a constituent, is a party that has an interest in how a
company conducts its business. Lots of individuals and entities have an interest in
how an insurer conducts its business. Some of the most important stakeholders in
an insurance company are shown in Figure 1.1.
Rating Employees
Agencies
Producers
Regulators
Trade
Reinsurers Organizations
Suppliers
Creditors
Owners
The owners of an insurance company expect the company to earn a profit. If the
company earns a profit, its value increases and it can return a portion of those
profits to the owners of the company.
Customers
The most obvious customers of an insurance company are its policyowners. How-
ever, insureds, beneficiaries, and applicants are also customers of an insurer. All of
these individuals are external customers. An external customer is any person or
organization in a position to (1) buy or use the company’s products or (2) advise or
influence others to buy or use the company’s products. External customers expect
an insurer to be financially stable and pay financial obligations when required.
A good reputation and strong financials are good indicators that an insurer is
financially stable. However, customers require much more from insurers than just
financial stability. For many customers, insurance products look the same from
one insurer to the next. To attract and satisfy customers, insurers must provide
insurance products that satisfy customers’ needs at reasonable prices. Customers
also expect customer service that is convenient, easily accessible, reliable, accu-
rate, and courteous.
Producers
Because life insurance and annuity products typically are quite complex, they
are often sold by insurance producers. An insurance producer is any individual
who is licensed to sell insurance products, solicit sales, or negotiate insurance
contracts. Producers know that they are more likely to generate sales when they
work for companies with good reputations that offer a broad range of products to
satisfy customer needs.
Producers are external customers of an insurer because they advise customers
and organizational buyers regarding insurance product purchases. Many producers
operate largely independently of an insurer’s control and can take a client’s busi-
ness to the insurance company that best meets that client’s particular needs. As
external customers, producers expect insurers to respond to their needs promptly
and provide them with the best possible customer service, so that they, in turn, can
better serve their own clients.
Sometimes producers are internal customers of an insurer. An internal
customer is an employee or department that receives support from another
employee or department within the organization. Producers who are considered to
be internal customers receive a substantial amount of financial and other types of
organizational support from the insurer.
All types of producers expect insurance companies to pay them a competitive
commission—an amount of money, typically a percentage of the premiums paid
for the sale of an insurance policy. In addition, producers often expect other forms
of compensation such as incentive bonuses and insurance benefits.
Employees
Employees are also stakeholders of an insurer. In fact, they’re very important
stakeholders. The combined efforts of an insurance company’s employees have a
significant impact on the success of an insurance company’s operations and profit-
ability. Insurance company employees expect the insurer to operate in a reputable
and ethical manner so that the company will be able to remain in business. A
company that engages in unfair or illegal practices may be subject to government
actions that, at a minimum, will hurt profitability or possibly result in the loss of
the company’s right to remain in business.
Employees also expect fair and adequate compensation for their work as well as
a safe and comfortable environment in which to work. Governments regulate com-
pensation, employee benefits, and workplace safety in most industrialized coun-
tries. Still, it is in an insurer’s best interests to go beyond the minimum govern-
ment requirements in these areas to attract and retain highly qualified employees.
Regulators
Life insurance companies are subject to extensive government regulation designed
to protect customers and preserve an insurer’s long-term financial stability. Insur-
ers invest huge amounts of money into economies around the world and, as the
2008 global financial crisis illustrated, are vital to the world’s economy. Local,
national, and international laws all impact how insurers operate.
Essentially, the laws regulating insurance companies are designed to make sure
that insurers remain financially sound and uphold customers’ trust. Two broad
categories of insurance regulations throughout the world include solvency laws
and market conduct laws.
In general terms, solvency is the ability of a company to pay its debts, contrac-
tual obligations, and operating expenses on time. In most countries, solvency
regulation, which is referred to as prudential regulation in some countries,
focuses on making sure that insurance companies remain solvent.
Market conduct laws, known as marketplace regulation in some countries,
are designed to ensure that life insurance companies conduct their businesses
fairly and ethically. Market conduct laws focus on nonfinancial operations,
such as marketing and sales practices, policyowner service, underwriting
activities, claim administration practices, and complaint handling.
In addition to insurance regulations, insurance companies must comply with
the laws that govern all businesses—for example, taxation laws, employment laws,
and laws affecting investment transactions.
Rating Agencies
Private organizations known as rating agencies evaluate the financial condition
of insurers and provide that information to potential customers and investors. A
rating agency is an organization, owned independently of any insurer or govern-
ment body, that evaluates the financial condition of insurers and provides informa-
tion to potential customers of and investors in insurance companies. A.M. Best,
Fitch, Moody’s, Standard & Poor’s, and Weiss Ratings are examples of major
insurance rating agencies. Each rating agency has its own rating method for rank-
ing insurance companies. Figure 1.2 presents a portion of the favorable rating
categories A.M. Best, Weiss, and Standard & Poor’s use. To receive a favorable
quality rating from a rating agency, an insurer must satisfy that agency’s internally
developed minimum standards relating to solvency and profitability. The fact that
the company being rated typically pays a fee to the rating agency has brought into
question the validity of some rating agencies’ decisions.1 Still, customers, produc-
ers, and investors generally prefer to do business with insurers that receive top
evaluations from rating agencies.
Reinsurers
Although insurers can predict with a good deal of accuracy the number of claims
they will receive, the dollar amount of those claims can fluctuate significantly. If
an insurer has to pay a series of large claims unexpectedly, the insurer’s financial
solvency might be negatively affected. To safeguard their financial stability and
maximize the amount of insurance they can safely issue, insurers use reinsurance.
To state it simply, reinsurance is insurance for insurance companies. In a rein-
surance transaction, the insurer that transfers all or part of an insurance risk is
known as the direct writer, or ceding company. The company that assumes the risk
from the direct writer is known as the reinsurer, or assuming company.
The relationship between a direct writer and a reinsurer is complicated. When a
direct writer purchases reinsurance, it becomes a customer of the reinsurer. How-
ever, in many ways, the direct writer and the reinsurer are each stakeholders in
the other company. The direct writer pays a premium to the reinsurer as well as
other agreed-upon expenses. The reinsurer might pay the direct writer an allow-
ance on the reinsured business or a portion of the claims on the reinsured business.
In addition, the reinsurer often provides the direct writer with expertise in many
areas, such as underwriting, reinsurance administration, or claim administration.
Both the direct writer and the reinsurer expect timely, accurate, and professional
customer service from each other and that the other will conduct its business in a
fair and equitable manner.
Other Stakeholders
Many other groups may have an interest in how an insurer operates its business
and could be stakeholders in the company depending on the circumstances. When
an insurer borrows money, banks and creditors become stakeholders in the insur-
ance company. Suppliers, industry trade associations, the media, nongovernmental
organizations, and public, social, or environmental groups may all be stakeholders
in an insurance company at various times.
Levels of Management
In a broad sense, there are four distinct levels of management: the board of direc-
tors, senior-level managers, middle-level managers, and first-level or supervisory
managers. Not every company has all of these levels of management. As a com-
pany’s size increases, so does the number of management levels.
Each level of management has varying degrees of authority, responsibility, and
accountability for work activities. Authority is an employee’s right to make deci-
sions, take action, and direct others to fulfill responsibilities. A responsibility is a
duty or a task that has been assigned to an employee. Accountability means that an
employee is answerable for how well he carries out his responsibilities. The board
of directors and senior-level managers have the authority and are responsible for
balancing stakeholder interests. They are also accountable to stakeholders for how
well they carry out these responsibilities.
Board of Directors
The top level of management in a company is the board of directors. The owners
of a company elect the board of directors, which meets regularly to review the
company’s activities and finances and to set broad company policies. The board of
directors appoints a chief executive officer (CEO) to be the head of the company,
as well as other executives, and holds these executives responsible for the com-
pany’s overall operations. Usually, the CEO and other principal executives serve
as members of the board.
Board members—such as the CEO and other principal executives—who hold
positions within the company in addition to their positions on the board are known
as inside directors. Inside directors are knowledgeable about the company’s oper-
ations. Board members who do not hold positions within the company are known
as outside directors or independent directors. Outside directors are usually busi-
nesspeople, professionals in academia, community leaders, or retired executives
of the company. Because of their experiences outside the company, outside direc-
tors often provide a broader, less biased perspective than inside directors. Some of
the duties that board members perform include
Setting major company policies
Evaluating the results of operations
Setting compensation for the CEO and some of the other top-level executives
Senior-Level Managers
The most senior member of management is the CEO. In many companies, the
CEO is also the company president. The board of directors entrusts the CEO with
broad authority to oversee the administration of the company. Some companies
also appoint a chief operating officer (COO), who manages the day-to-day opera-
tions of a company, and a chief financial officer (CFO), who oversees an insurer’s
financial management policies and functions. Other typical senior-level managers
are a chief information officer (CIO) and a chief marketing officer (CMO). All of
these positions report to the CEO, as do other executives known as vice presidents.
Each vice president supervises and coordinates the work activities of a major divi-
sion of the company. These positions are known collectively as the company’s
executives or officers.
Lower-Level Managers
Below vice presidents are the company’s middle-level managers. Managers are
generally in charge of smaller units within a company division, known as depart-
ments. Middle-level managers are typically functional experts for the area they
manage. For example, the claim department manager will have a high degree of
expertise in claim administration.
First-level managers, or supervisors, are managers in charge of subunits of
departments. Supervisors have less latitude in interpreting the directives of top
management and spend more time in the direct supervision of nonmanagement
employees than do middle managers.
Management Functions
To a certain extent, all managers are supervisors. The board of directors supervises
senior-level management, and senior-level management supervises middle-level
management, and so on. However, supervision is just one aspect of a manager’s
job. The management process involves many interrelated organizational activities.
Traditionally, these activities have been divided into four management functions:
planning, organizing, directing, and controlling, as shown in Figure 1.3. Supervi-
sion corresponds to the formal functions of directing and controlling, which we
describe in Chapter 2. In this chapter, we focus on planning and organizing. Typi-
cally, the higher the level of management, the more the manager engages in plan-
ning and organizing activities.
Planning: Organizing:
Sets goals and Coordinates resources
strategies to accomplish goals
Controlling: Directing:
Monitors and Leads, influences, and
corrects motivates
Planning
Planning is the process of preparing for the future by establishing appropriate
goals and formulating strategies and activities for achieving those goals. A goal is
a desired future outcome and is sometimes called an objective. A strategy is a plan
for achieving goals and outlines the tactics—required tasks and activities. Plan-
ning involves determining which strategy is most appropriate for accomplishing a
goal, taking into consideration company resources, strengths, weaknesses, and the
environment in which the company operates.
Under the direction of the board of directors, a company’s officers perform
strategic planning. Strategic planning is the process of determining an organiza-
tion’s major long-term corporate goals and the broad, overall courses of action or
strategies that the company will follow to achieve these goals. Insurers conduct
strategic planning for the company as a whole as well as for each operational area.
Strategic planning answers questions such as
Should we expand our current product line by selling a new type of product?
Organizing
Organizing is the process of assembling and coordinating required resources in
the most efficient and effective manner to attain organizational goals. Organiz-
ing enables a company to (1) assign job responsibilities to employees, (2) provide
employees with the proper authority to meet their responsibilities, and (3) provide
a process for holding employees accountable for their job performance.
Organizing involves dividing large work tasks into smaller activities through
a process known as division of labor. For example, the task of processing a life
insurance application can be broken down into underwriting activities and pol-
icy issue activities. Ideally, a company organizes all jobs so that employees can
develop expertise in the specific tasks associated with their job through training
and clearly communicated expectations.
The process of grouping similar or related work activities—jobs or processes—
into units is called departmentalization. Departmentalization makes it easier for
a company to
Establish and maintain a system of supervision
Create standardized measures for employee performance
Board of Directors
Manager Manager Manager Manager Manager Manager Manager Manager Manager Manager
New business administration: Oversees the policy issue process from application
receipt through issuance of the insurance policy
Underwriting: Ensures that the company classifies proposed life insureds so that
their mortality experience, as a group, falls within the range of the mortality rates
assumed at the time of the product’s financial design
Claim administration: Assesses life insurance claims and processes claim benefit
payments
Treasury operations: Manages and invests the cash coming into and out of a
company
Legal: Represents the company in all legal matters, reviews and approves life insurance
and annuity policy forms, and drafts other contracts that insurers use in the course
of business
Compliance: Ensures that the company's operations comply with general business
laws, financial services laws, insurance laws, and insurance department regulations
that apply in each jurisdiction in which the company operates
{
Legal/Compliance
Human Resources
Support
Functions Information/Technology
Investments
Accounting
owners will not realize profits.2 Figure 1.6 shows a simplified value chain for life
insurers. Each of the five links in the figure—marketing/sales, new business admin-
istration, underwriting, customer service, and claim administration—represent
activities that offer customer value. These activities are labeled value-added
activities. By optimizing customer value at each link and better coordinating
operations between links, insurers can develop competitive advantages that
increase company profits. For example, providing excellent customer service can
be a competitive advantage for an insurer. Although support activities are vital to
the operation of the value chain, they alone cannot create value for the customer.
Analyzing the value chain identifies existing or potential sources of competitive
advantages and is useful for both strategic and operational planning.
An insurer that successfully manages its support activities like accounting can
create cost-savings or other competitive advantages. For example, a company that
implements new information technology may see process improvements as well
as cost savings in how the insurer markets, underwrites, administers, and services
its products.
Organization by Function
An insurance company that is organized by function divides its operations accord-
ing to the work that each division performs. Each area is a separate unit or division
that performs its function for all of a company’s products. You can see in Figure
1.7 how the claim administration function handles claims for the company’s indi-
vidual life and group life insurance products.
The major advantages of organizing operations by function are its simplic-
ity and its focus on the development of managerial and technical skills in each
functional area. Organization by function usually works well in small companies
with centralized operations and in large centralized companies that offer only a
few product lines to fairly well-defined customer groups. As the number of differ-
ent products a company offers and the size and diversity of the company’s mar-
kets increase, organization by function alone becomes less effective. For example,
new specialty products and new markets might be neglected because of competing
demands for resources from larger product lines or markets.
CEO
Investments Legal/Compliance
New Business
Marketing/Sales Underwriting Customer Service
Administration
Claim Administration
Organization by Product
A life insurance company that organizes its operations by product distributes work
according to the company’s lines of insurance products. Such a structure allows the
company to compare different product lines more easily. Looking at Figure 1.8, you
can see that each line of business—individual life insurance, group life insurance,
and individual annuities—is responsible for performing actuarial, marketing, or
other administration activities for that product line. However, a few functions—
such as information technology, legal/compliance, and human resources—may be
handled through centrally administered units. Despite these few centralized areas,
organization by product tends to decentralize an organization because it allows
decisions related to particular products to be made by those most closely involved
with the product line.
CEO
New Business
Claim Administration Customer Service
Administration
Organization by Territory
A life insurance company may organize its operations by territory. For example,
an insurer that operates in several countries may have a separate division for each
country. Within one country, an insurer may divide its operations into regions
or districts. This type of organizational structure makes sense when regulatory
or language differences exist among the various regions in which the company
operates. When an insurer uses this structure, each division typically handles
the majority of its own actuarial, marketing, and other administrative functions.
Figure 1.9 illustrates organization by territory.
Organization by Customer
Another type of organizational structure that insurers sometimes use is organiza-
tion by customer type. When an insurer organizes by customer type, the insurer
creates divisions based on particular customer groups such as household markets,
corporate markets, or small business markets. In this type of structure, all of the
marketing, actuarial, and other administrative functions are performed within the
division for each specific type of customer group.
CEO
North American
Division Asian Division
New Business
Claim Administration Customer Service
Administration
Committees
Some aspects of a company’s operations fall outside of a single division or depart-
ment and require the expertise of different members of the company. To address
these needs, most companies establish special committees to bring together a
number of people from various areas, each of whom has other responsibilities
within the company. A committee is a group of people chosen to consider, inves-
tigate, or act on matters of a specific type. Committees exist at all levels of an
organization. A permanent committee that company executives use as a source of
continuing advice is called a standing committee. A company’s officers and mem-
bers of its board of directors make up several of the most important standing com-
mittees of any business. Figure 1.10 describes common standing committees that
are composed of board members. By participating on standing committees, board
members stay informed of the company’s activities during the intervals between
regular board meetings and can report on these activities at board meetings.
Best Life
Insurance
Company
Owns subsidiaries
President reports to Best Life CEO
Key Terms
mission statement solvency
insured rating agency
stakeholder reinsurance
stockholder direct writer
stock reinsurer
security authority
board of directors responsibility
stockholder dividend accountability
policyowner chief executive officer (CEO)
policy dividend inside director
external customer outside director
insurance producer chief operating officer (COO)
internal customer chief financial officer (CFO)
commission planning
Additional Activities
If you want to relate the information in this chapter to your company, try these
activities:
Think about your company’s customers and your job. Who do you primarily
serve in your job? Internal customers, external customers, or both?
On your company’s website, find your company’s ratings and identify which
rating agencies evaluate your company.
On your company’s website, find the list of your company’s board of directors
(usually under Investor Relations or Governance) and read about the com-
pany’s officers and the standing committees of the board.
How is your company organized? Find a copy of your company’s organization
chart. Can you find your own position on the chart?
Endnotes
1. David Serchuk, “Playing the Ratings Game,” Forbes, 10 August 2009, http://www.forbes.
com/2009/08/10/ratings-agencies-conflict-intelligent-investing-interest.html (24 March 2011).
2. “The Value Chain,” NetMBA.com, http://www.netmba.com/strategy/value-chain (24 March 2011).
3. Christian J. DesRochers, “Mutual Insurance Holding Companies: An Update,” Small Talk, May 1998, http://
www.soa.org/library/newsletters/small-talk/1998/may/stn-1998-iss11-desrochers.pdf (24 March 2011).
Chapter 2
Corporate Governance,
Ethics, and Control
Objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to
Define corporate governance and identify the elements necessary for
good governance
Describe the importance of directing as a management function and
identify the managerial activities associated with directing
Define ethics and identify ways in which insurers foster a culture of
ethical behavior
Describe insider trading and recognize examples of inside information
Describe types of customer-related confidential information and how
insurance company employees should handle such information to comply
with privacy and confidentiality requirements
Identify education programs and professional associations affiliated with
the life insurance industry
Describe control as a management function and the circular nature of the
control cycle
Describe the three primary types of control mechanisms in an insurance
company and identify examples of each type
Outline
Corporate Governance Controlling
Directing Types of Controls
Establishing Performance Standards
Ethics and Ethical Conduct Measuring Performance
A Code of Conduct
An Ethics Office
Education
Training
Membership in Associations
U
nfortunately people sometimes act in dishonest ways, whether in their per-
sonal lives or in the workplace. You’ve probably come across instances in
your workplace where someone has acted in a way that made you uncom-
fortable. Highly publicized examples of corporate misconduct also illustrate that
dishonest behavior can occur at all levels of a company, from the board of directors
on down.
As we described in Chapter 1, a corporation has many responsibilities to its
stakeholders, and perhaps the most important is to increase the company’s value.
However, a company’s efforts to satisfy that responsibility should not ignore its
other responsibilities to operate ethically and establish a work environment that
encourages employees to behave ethically. Companies that do so risk significant
adverse legal and monetary consequences. A system of good corporate gover-
nance that promotes transparency within a company’s operations, and control pro-
cedures that establish accountability, can help a company operate ethically and
better satisfy all of its stakeholder responsibilities.
Corporate Governance
Corporate governance refers to a system of policies and processes for directing
and controlling a corporation’s activities that emphasizes accountability and integ-
rity in how the company fulfills its mission on behalf of all of its stakeholders.1 A
good system of corporate governance should keep the organization from engaging
in behaviors that might harm the stakeholders.
The increased emphasis on corporate governance in recent years can be attrib-
uted in part to regulations enacted in many countries. In the United States, the
federal Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002, also known as Sarb-Ox or SOX, sets new
or enhanced standards for corporate controls and increases regulatory oversight.
Figure 2.1 explains how some other countries have addressed corporate gover-
nance. In addition, well-publicized cases of corporate mismanagement have made
companies that can demonstrate good corporate governance much more valuable
to their stakeholders, and to those interested in becoming stakeholders.
Remember the four functions of management—planning, organizing, direct-
ing, and controlling—introduced in Chapter 1. Although governance is most
closely associated with the functions of directing and controlling, management
planning and organizing are also important components. Good corporate gover-
nance requires
Strategic plans that focus on balancing the needs of all stakeholders
Organizational structures and processes that are efficient and work together
effectively to create value for stakeholders
An ethical organizational culture and leadership that balances risk and rewards
Control systems at all levels of the company that provide transparency and
accountability to stakeholders
Throughout the text, we describe the processes insurers use to achieve strategic
and operational goals effectively and efficiently. We also look at how companies
allocate resources within functional areas for their optimum use. In this chapter,
we focus on the two traditional functions of management known as directing and
controlling and how an ethical culture, ethical leadership, and good control sys-
tems contribute to good corporate governance.
Directing
Mary Parker Follett, a management theorist, defined management as “the art of
getting things done through others.”2 Organizational plans and organizational
structures mean very little without people to carry out the plans and work in the
structures. To execute the management function known as directing, managers
must ensure that employees perform appropriate activities in the appropriate way
to achieve company objectives. The managerial activities of directing include
(1) leading, (2) motivating, (3) supervising, (4) communicating, and (5) facilitating.
How well managers direct their employees determines, to a large extent, how suc-
cessful the company will be. Activities that impact how well managers are able to
direct employees include
Recruiting and hiring qualified individuals
Providing employees with opportunities for training and education
A Code of Conduct
A code of conduct, also known as a code of business conduct or a code of ethics, is
a formal statement of a company’s values and its expectations for how its employees
should behave in the course of business. A code of conduct helps employees evalu-
ate the appropriateness of various responses to a given situation. To be most effec-
tive, a code of conduct should refer to specific practices that may be encountered in
the course of the company’s work, followed by explanations of what the company
believes would be the proper response.
An Ethics Office
Another way insurers can make ethics an integral part of operations is to establish
an ethics office, a department in which employees can receive advice or counsel
from qualified professionals about how to handle ethical issues and also report
ethical misconduct. An employee who seeks advice about an ethical matter some-
times wishes to remain anonymous. For example, you might have witnessed mis-
conduct in the workplace but are afraid to report it to your supervisor because you
are unsure how the supervisor might react. A corporate ethics office can provide
anonymity while still bringing the matter to management’s attention. Some com-
panies maintain an ethics hotline or website that allows employees to anonymously
report suspected violations of the code of conduct or other unethical activity.
Some companies have gone further by establishing an organizational
ombudsman—an independent, impartial, and confidential professional who pro-
vides assistance to a company’s stakeholders. For example, an employee may feel
harassed by a manager or a customer may believe that she was treated unfairly
by a company employee. An organizational ombudsman may be able to address a
minor problem in the workplace or in a company’s processes before the problem
escalates or becomes systemic. To maintain neutrality, the ombudsman typically
reports directly to the board of directors or CEO. In addition to acting as a facilita-
tor among stakeholders, an ombudsman coordinates the development of policies
and procedures in the workplace that promote ethical behavior. The ombudsman
also acts as a companywide resource for improving business conduct by sharing
best practices and addressing any systemic organizational problems.3
Education
Encouraging employees and producers to pursue further education is another way
to promote ethical behavior and professionalism. Courses in ethics, insurance, and
general business are often available through local colleges and continuing edu-
cation organizations. Figure 2.2 lists education programs that are designed spe-
cifically for the insurance industry. Education programs specific to an employee’s
particular field can increase job knowledge while reinforcing proper business
behaviors.
Training
Ethics training should be an ongoing process that begins with new employee ori-
entation and continues regularly throughout an employee’s career. Companies
provide this training either online or in-person. Often ethics training focuses on
ensuring employee compliance with certain key laws. Two important areas of
compliance that insurers often address during ethics training are insider trading
and privacy and confidentiality requirements.
Insider Trading
Insider trading is buying or selling a company’s securities (stocks or bonds) based
upon inside information. Inside information is a company’s nonpublic, material
information that employees and other individuals associated with the company
are restricted from disclosing to third parties or using for their individual benefit.
Nonpublic information is any company information that has not been disclosed to
the public. Material information is any company information that might influence
the market price of a company’s securities. Examples of inside information include
nonpublic information about the company’s
Financial performance
Marketing strategies
Arbitration results
Membership in Associations
Industry associations typically have a strong influence on the ethics and profes-
sionalism a particular industry exhibits. Associations influence industry profes-
sionalism by promoting high standards of ethical conduct in their chosen field.
Professional associations give individuals with similar interests, training, and cre-
dentials the opportunity to meet, exchange information, increase their knowledge,
and express their views about developments in their professions. Some of the pro-
fessional associations that are important to the life insurance industry include
Actuarial associations, such as the Society of Actuaries (SOA) in the United
States, the Singapore Society of Actuaries, the Actuarial Society of India, and
the Canadian Institute of Actuaries
Producer associations, such as the U.S. National Association of Insurance
and Financial Advisors (NAIFA) and the Life Underwriters Association of
Canada
Associations of legal professionals, such as the Association of Life Insurance
Counsel (ALIC) in the United States
The Society of Financial Service Professionals, which is an organization for
members of the financial services industry in the United States who hold or
are pursuing Chartered Life Underwriter (CLU) or Chartered Financial Con-
sultant (ChFC) designations or other specified financial services designations
LOMA Societies, which provide Society members, LOMA students, and other
financial services professionals with opportunities for networking, continuing
education, and professional development
Professional associations often have codes of conduct or codes of ethics for
their members. LOMA’s Code of Ethics, for those people who have earned a fel-
lowship designation, is reprinted in Figure 2.3.
The Designee shall continually strive to master all aspects of his or her business and
to improve his or her professional knowledge and skills.
The Designee shall diligently strive to ascertain clients’ best interests and seek to
ensure that these interests are met.
The Designee shall respect clients’ privacy and the confidentiality of information they
provide, within the constraints of the law.
The Designee shall comply with the spirit and letter of the law in all his or her
activities.
The Designee shall hold his or her professional designation proudly and seek to
enhance the reputation of the designation, as well as the financial services industry,
in every way.
Controlling
Consider the work activities of a customer service representative (CSR). A CSR
provides customers with information. What if that information changes and the
CSR continues to provide the old information? What if a procedure changes and
the CSR continues to use the old procedure? If the information a company pro-
vides to customers is wrong, or if the procedures for handling customers are inap-
propriate, customers will have a negative experience. If these negative customer
service experiences persist, eventually they will impact the insurer’s profits. One
of management’s most basic responsibilities is to monitor employee performance,
recognize problems in performance as soon as they occur, and take steps to correct
those problems.
Types of Controls
Insurance companies use three primary types of control mechanisms: steering
controls, concurrent controls, and feedback controls. Companies apply these con-
trols at the division, department, and individual levels.
Steering Controls
A company applies steering controls before a business process is begun. A steering
control, also known as a feedforward control, describes how a company intends to
implement a process. Steering controls seek to establish the most efficient method
for using a company’s resources, such as people, materials, or money. Steering
controls anticipate problems in advance so that hopefully the problems can be
avoided. Policies, procedures, a code of conduct, and operating manuals are all
examples of steering controls. For example, every claim department maintains
claim procedures that describe how claims are to be processed. One typical proce-
dure is to route simpler claims with lower face amounts to less experienced claim
analysts, and to route more complicated claims with higher face amounts to more
experienced claim analysts. In this way, the company reduces the potential for
processing problems with the more complex claims.
Concurrent Controls
Unfortunately, an insurance company cannot account for every contingency
before a process begins so companies also maintain concurrent controls, which are
applied during the business process. Concurrent controls are checks built into and
applied during a process. Concurrent controls determine whether a process should
proceed, requires corrective action, or must be stopped. Examples of concurrent
controls used in insurance companies include
Activity logs or transaction logs that monitor company activities
Error logs
Feedback Controls
Feedback controls gather information about completed processes and evaluate
that information to improve similar activities in the future. Feedback controls are
checks and corrections applied to a process at the end of the process cycle. Feed-
back controls compare the actual performance or output with established stan-
dards. Examples of feedback controls commonly used in insurance companies
include
Audits
Account reconciliations
Performance appraisals
Budget analyses
Feedback control provides managers with valuable information about the effec-
tiveness of planning and operational processes. If the obtained results are in line
with management expectations, then the planning and operational processes are
on target. However, if the results obtained are not in line with expectations, man-
agement can use this information about past performance to make changes that
will bring future performance in line with planned objectives. For example, if the
error rate for processing life insurance claims is too high, management may need
to revise procedures or identify employees who require additional training in the
procedures. Or, if one CSR consistently has superior quality service ratings, then
management should review that CSR’s methods to try and replicate the success
throughout the department. Feedback control is used in planning throughout all
levels of the organization, in the training of employees, and in quality control. The
major disadvantage associated with feedback control is that, by the time a manager
receives the information, a problem may have already occurred.
Steering Controls
Time (e.g., average length of calls, amount of time on hold, number of days
until completion, amount of time website is accessible to customers)
Measuring Performance
Once a company sets its performance standards, it needs a system to measure
performance. Companies routinely monitor performance that can be quantified
numerically using computerized systems. For example, a computer system can
easily track whether a CSR is answering each call within 15 seconds. Technology
also can be used to measure less quantifiable processes. For example, technology
can record customer conversations so that managers can later review the calls and
rate the level of courtesy an employee exhibits. However, performance measure-
ment does not always involve technology. Surveys, visual inspections, and tests
are frequently used tools in performance measurement.
Later, we describe tools that insurance companies use to measure performance
in various areas of insurance company operations. For now, let’s look at three con-
trol tools used throughout an insurance company.
Budgets
A budget is a financial plan of action, expressed in monetary terms, that cov-
ers a specified period, such as one year. Through budgeting, a company affirms
the goals that management established during the planning process. Budgets also
contain performance standards: estimates that reflect management’s expectations
of a company’s future performance. For example, the budget will show both an
expected level of sales for each product and an expected level of expenses. Man-
agement can compare actual results to budgeted expectations, and gain insights
that help them develop new or improved courses of action. The budgeting process
enables a company to
Monitor and evaluate ongoing operations
Allocate scarce resources efficiently
Motivate employees
A budget can act as a steering control by setting financial limits on company
activities. For example, a company with a $50,000 training budget is constrained
from spending $100,000 on training. A budget also serves as a concurrent control.
For example, managers often receive monthly or quarterly reports that compare
current expenses to budgeted expenses for the year to date. If expenses are too
high, managers can take steps to cut spending in the next period, and hopefully
remain within the overall budget’s limits. Budgets are also useful as feedback
controls. The difference between an actual result and an expected result is called
a variance. At the end of an evaluation period, which could be monthly, quarterly,
or annually, management looks for budget variances—differences between bud-
geted and actual expenses and revenues. Large variances are of particular concern
to management and may result in operational changes.
The budgeting process requires a great deal of cooperation throughout the com-
pany. A budget committee comprising top-level management usually oversees the
budgeting process. However, each department and division within an insurer pro-
vides input to the budget committee and usually drafts its own budget within the
guidelines that the budget committee sets out.
Audits
An audit is a systematic examination and evaluation of a company’s records,
procedures, and controls. An audit is an example of a feedback control in that
a company ensures that its company records are accurate or its operational
procedures and policies are effective for the previous period being examined.
Companies commonly use audits to ensure that their financial information and
financial statements provide a fair and consistent depiction of their financial condi-
tion and performance. Audits also can cover nonfinancial conditions such as man-
agement efficiency, market conduct, and regulatory compliance. Auditing is vital
to demonstrating good governance and is described in greater detail in Chapter 7.
Exception Reports
A commonly used control tool is the exception report—a report that is generated
automatically when results deviate from an established performance standard.
Exception reports can be concurrent controls and feedback controls. An excep-
tion report provides information about a company’s operations that can be used to
modify ongoing operations or as feedback for already completed operations.
Let’s refer back to our earlier customer service example in which customer
calls are to be answered within 15 seconds. Assume that, after three hours of
business, the customer service manager receives information that calls are being
answered within 15 seconds only 85 percent of the time. At this point, the manager
can take immediate action to bring performance levels back in line with the goal.
The manager might assign supervisors to answer the phones or eliminate nones-
sential activities.
At the end of a designated period, such as a month, that same customer service
manager might receive an exception report indicating that, in the previous month,
the percentage of calls answered within 15 seconds was only 90 percent rather than
95 percent. The customer service manager would then look for what caused the
deviation from the performance standard. For example, were several people unable
to work due to illness? If so, the deviation is explainable. A manager should deter-
mine the cause of an exception report, and take corrective action if necessary.
Recognizing that performance can fluctuate, management typically establishes
a range of acceptable performance rather than a specific performance level for a
performance standard. For example, management might set a goal of generating
$1 million in first-year premiums. However, management would be satisfied with
a plus or minus 10 percent premium variance (from $900,000 to $1.1 million)
in first-year premiums. Amounts outside of the established range usually require
investigation.
You can support the control function in your company by understanding the
controls related to your job, by suggesting ways to strengthen those controls, and
by encouraging your colleagues to respect controls.
In the next chapter, we begin looking at the various functional areas within an
insurance company. Before you read each chapter, consider ways in which that
functional area interacts with the area in which you work. Understanding how all
of the different functional areas operate and interact can help you better under-
stand how your job contributes to your company’s success.
Copyright © 2012 LL Global, Inc. All rights reserved. www.loma.org
2.16 Chapter 2: Corporate Governance, Ethics, and Control Insurance Company Operations
Key Terms
corporate governance steering control
Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 concurrent control
directing feedback control
ethics control cycle
code of conduct performance standard
ethics office benchmarking
ombudsman budget
insider trading variance
inside information audit
nonpublic information exception report
material information
Additional Activities
If you want to relate the information in this chapter to your company, try these
activities:
Identify characteristics of an ethical culture in your company. Look for exam-
ples of controls that contribute to good governance.
Read your company’s code of conduct (also known as a code of ethics or code
of business conduct). Other than your manager, to whom would you go if you
wanted to report an ethics code violation? Does your company have an ethics
hotline?
Find an example of a steering control, a concurrent control, and a feedback
control in your department. Which do you consider to be the most important
to you in your day-to-day work activities, and why?
Endnotes
1. Gabrielle O’Donovan, “A Board Culture of Corporate Governance,” Corporate Governance Interna-
tional Journal 6, no. 3 (2003).
2. James A. F. Stoner and R. Edward Freeman, Management of Organizations and Human Resources
(Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1989), 3.
3. Mary Rowe, “Identifying and Communicating the Usefulness of Organizational Ombuds with
Ideas about OO Effectiveness and Cost-Effectiveness,” Journal of the International Ombundsman
Association 3, no. 1 (2010), http://web.mit.edu/ombud/publications/usefulness.pdf (11 February 2011).
Chapter 3
Objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to
Distinguish an insurer’s legal function from its compliance function
Describe typical ways in which insurers organize the legal and
compliance departments
List the characteristics of a corporation and describe how these
characteristics may differ in various jurisdictions throughout the world
Define a multinational corporation and identify three ways an insurer
may enter a foreign market
Describe the litigation process and the legal department’s responsibilities
during litigation
Explain two alternative dispute resolution (ADR) methods the legal
department uses to settle legal disputes
Describe typical compliance activities and the three components of a
regulatory compliance management program
Describe the purpose for and activities involved in a market conduct
examination in the United States
Outline
Organization of Legal and Responsibilities of the Compliance
Compliance Functions Department
Responsibilities of the Legal Prevention
Department Education and Training
T
he area of an insurer’s operations that handles legal matters—such as con-
tracts and legal disputes—is known as the legal function. The compliance
function has a different purpose. The compliance function performs a wide
range of tasks to make sure that company operations follow policies and proce-
dures, as well as the laws and regulations of all jurisdictions in which the com-
pany does business. Legal and compliance functions are very important to insur-
ance companies’ operations because of the many laws and regulations that apply
to insurance companies. Sometimes companies combine both functions within
the same department, but some companies separate the two functions. Let’s take
a look at how insurers typically organize these functions and why they are so
important.
Although jurisdictions around the world allow for the creation and operation of
business organizations that have many of the same features of U.S. and Canadian
corporations, some differences are worth noting:
Opening a branch office in the foreign country that is properly registered with
the foreign government
Entering into a joint venture with a local insurer in the foreign country. A joint
venture is an arrangement between two otherwise independent businesses that
agree to undertake a specific project together for a specified time period. The
joint venture arrangement has become quite popular in some countries, such
as in India, where many insurance companies operate as a joint venture with
foreign insurance companies.
The legal department handles many aspects involved in changing the corporate
form of business. For example, sometimes a mutual insurer may consider chang-
ing to a stock form of ownership through a process called demutualization, or a
Canada:
Office of the Superintendent of Financial
Institutions and provincial Insurance
Departments
China:
China Insurance
Regulatory Commission
United States:
State Insurance Departments South Korea:
Financial
Supervisory
Bermuda: Commission
Minister of
Finance Philippines:
Mexico: Insurance
National Commis- Commission
sion of Insurance
and Finances India:
Insurance
Regulatory and
Brazil: Development
Superintendency Authority
of Insurance
Singapore:
Monetary Authority
Argentina: of Singapore
Superintendency
of Insurance
Source: Adapted from Harriett Jones, Business Law for Financial Services Professionals [Atlanta: LOMA (Life Office
Management Association, Inc.), © 2004], 180. Used with permission; all rights reserved.
stock insurer may wish to convert to a mutual company through a process called
mutualization. In such cases, the legal department advises the company’s board
of directors on (1) the differences in the regulation of stock companies and mutual
companies, (2) the legal issues involved in changing the company’s corporate
form, (3) the structure that would be most beneficial to the insurer, and (4) the best
way to accomplish a change in corporate form.
In addition, the legal department is available to advise the board of directors
on any number of issues that arise during the course of the company’s operations.
For example, the board may want the legal department to review a contract with a
foreign company to ensure that it doesn’t violate any trade agreements before the
contract is signed.
Law Firms
At times a person or organization may initiate a legal proceeding, known as a
lawsuit, against a life insurance company, or an insurer may institute a lawsuit
against another person or organization. A lawsuit is an action brought before a
court of law by a party claiming that they have been harmed in some way by
another party. The process or act of presenting the dispute to a court of law for a
resolution is known as litigation. In such situations, the legal department repre-
sents the insurer, or arranges for an independent law firm, often known as outside
counsel, to represent the insurer in the litigation process. If the company chooses
Representing the insurer in all aspects of the litigation process, including cor-
respondence and court appearances
Litigation can be time consuming and costly. Additionally, a public trial can
result in negative publicity that may harm the company’s image. For all of these
reasons, the legal department typically tries to settle legal disputes without going
to court if at all possible. Formal or informal negotiations to resolve the dispute
are known as alternative dispute resolution (ADR) methods. ADR methods are
available in most countries, although the terminology varies and the specific oper-
ation of the procedure also varies. In some countries, such as China, ADR is the
preferred method for resolving disputes, and the disputing parties only turn to the
court system when such efforts fail. Two common methods of ADR are (1) medi-
ation, sometimes called conciliation in countries outside the United States, and
(2) arbitration.
Mediation is a process in which an impartial third party, known as a
mediator, facilitates negotiations between the parties in an effort to create
a mutually agreeable resolution of the dispute. If the parties cannot resolve
their dispute through mediation, they typically have the right to go to arbitra-
tion or to continue with litigation.
Arbitration is a process in which impartial third parties, known as arbitrators,
evaluate the facts in the dispute and render a decision that usually is binding on
the parties. Appeals of arbitrators’ decisions are generally possible only if the
arbitration was done improperly.
Policyowners/Beneficiaries
Insurers deny a small percentage of life insurance claims for reasons such as the
policy was not in force at the time of the insured’s death, the deceased was not
covered under the policy, or the cause of death was excluded from the insurance
coverage. If a policyowner or beneficiary disputes an insurer’s decision to deny a
claim for benefits, the insurer’s claim department, in conjunction with the legal
department, works with the claimant to settle the dispute. If the dispute cannot be
settled, and a lawsuit is filed, the legal department oversees the litigation process.
In some cases, insurers acknowledge that life insurance benefits are payable
but are unable to determine to whom payment should be made. Often in these
cases, there are conflicting or adverse claimants for the policy’s proceeds. The
legal department works with adverse claimants to resolve the matter or oversees
legal proceedings designed to ensure that the policy’s proceeds are paid to the
rightful party.
Employees/Former Employees
Employees or former employees may occasionally bring lawsuits against an insurer
for a variety of reasons. Sometimes they believe they have been treated unfairly or
that their employment was terminated in an unfair or illegal manner. In general,
management has an ethical obligation in all of its dealings with employees to act
in a manner that is fair, consistent, and equitable and also to provide a safe work
environment.
Many countries have formal legislation in place that prohibits employment dis-
crimination on the basis of a number of factors, including race, religion, color,
sex, national origin, sexual orientation, disability, or age. Also, legislation in many
jurisdictions forbids termination of employment without just cause or without fol-
lowing a prescribed termination process. Countries may also require companies to
comply with certain workplace safety rules.
When an employee or former employee brings a lawsuit against an insurer
because of an issue relating to the worker’s employment, the legal department is in
charge of attempting to settle the dispute through ADR methods or defending the
company against the complaint in a court of law.
Responsibilities of the
Compliance Department
An insurer that fails to comply with a law or regulation may suffer significant
financial consequences. The insurer may incur large government fines or amounts
that must be paid in connection with lawsuits. The insurer’s image, and as a result,
its sales may suffer from negative publicity. In extreme cases, an insurer may lose
its license and no longer be able to conduct business in a jurisdiction.
The compliance department, in conjunction with the legal department, moni-
tors all applicable laws and regulations, communicates compliance requirements
to employees through policies and procedures, and makes sure that company
employees are following the company’s established policies and procedures.
In Chapter 1 we described how insurance legislation can be divided into market
conduct laws and solvency laws. Compliance department employees generally are
responsible for ensuring that the company complies with market conduct laws.
Prevention
To have a successful regulatory compliance management program, management
must commit to an ethical work environment. Compliance and ethics are related
concepts. A company that operates within a framework of integrity and ethical
values also maintains a culture of compliance. The company has in place hir-
ing practices that reinforce the company’s commitment to compliance. Employee
incentives do not encourage employees to ignore compliance policies. Compliance
policies and procedures are integrated into the design of work processes so that
employees view compliance procedures as an integral part of their jobs and not as
something that interferes with their ability to do their jobs. In addition, corporate
communication processes clearly define what is acceptable and unacceptable in
the workplace. In a culture of organizational compliance, every employee views
compliance as his own responsibility.
Monitoring
An insurer’s regulatory compliance management program must include moni-
toring. Why? To ensure that the company (1) responds quickly to issues before
they become bigger problems, (2) identifies training needs of employees, and
(3) improves the quality of compliance procedures.
A common way to monitor compliance is through auditing. An internal audit
is an examination of a company’s records, policies, and procedures that is con-
ducted by a person who works for the insurer, typically in the compliance area. An
internal audit examines a specified area of a company’s operations rather than the
entire company. The results of an internal audit are reported directly to the audit
committee of the insurer’s board of directors.
Audits conducted by parties not associated with the insurance company are
called external audits or independent audits. Insurance laws in many countries
require external audits of an insurer’s market conduct. However, such laws typi-
cally are not nearly as extensive as are the market conduct laws in the United
States.
Figure 3.3. Two Types of Market Conduct Examinations in the United States
and (3) the activity being examined is carried out according to established stan-
dards. State laws require that insurers maintain various business records for a
specified time and allow examiners to review these business records as well as
other documents.
Market conduct examiners also want to know whether an insurer has estab-
lished an internal audit plan by which it can detect and correct compliance prob-
lems. Market conduct examiners review the insurer’s audit plan and audit reports,
as well as all accompanying procedures manuals. Market conduct examiners
review how management uses the information in an audit report. For example,
does management respond to recommendations in an audit report by adopting new
procedures or modifying existing procedures?
Most market conduct examinations today are target examinations that exam-
ine one or more lines of business or specific areas of an insurer’s nonfinancial
operations, such as its advertising materials. Target examinations are conducted
whenever an insurance department thinks them necessary, and often result from
customer complaints or recent changes in applicable regulations. Figure 3.4 pres-
ents an overview of the market conduct examination process in the United States.
The more you understand what legal and compliance do, the better you’ll be at
avoiding potential legal liability for your company. Remember, compliance isn’t
just a function within your company; it’s every employee’s responsibility.
Workspace and equipment are arranged for state examiners to use upon their arrival
at the insurer’s offices
Once state examiners arrive, team leader orients them to the company, presents
requested materials, discusses a timeline for completion, and discusses a process
for requesting additional information or interviews with employees
At the completion of the on-site examination, the examiners provide a preliminary
report and discuss outstanding issues with the team leader and company officers
The examiners return to the state insurance department to prepare a draft report to
send to the company
Team meets to analyze draft report and respond in writing to the contents; team
suggests actions the insurer should take based on the examiners’ findings
Examiners file the final report with the insurance department of the applicable state
and schedule any necessary follow-up activities
Key Terms
general counsel litigation
chief compliance officer (CCO) outside counsel
corporation alternative dispute resolution (ADR)
capital method
company limited by shares mediation
company limited by guarantee mediator
domestic corporation arbitration
certificate of authority arbitrator
multinational corporation (MNC) internal audit
joint venture external audit
demutualization market conduct examination
mutualization National Association of Insurance
lawsuit Commissioners (NAIC)
Additional Activities
If you want to relate the information in this chapter to your company, try these
activities:
Do you know in which jurisdiction your company is incorporated? Insurers
often locate their home office in that jurisdiction. Is this true for your com-
pany?
If your company is a multinational corporation, determine in which countries
it operates. Does your company offer all product lines in each jurisdiction?
Why or why not?
Endnotes
1. Portions of this section are adapted from Harriett E. Jones, Business Law for Financial Services
Professionals [Atlanta: LOMA (Life Office Management Association, Inc.), © 2004]. Used with per-
mission; all rights reserved.
2. Companies Act, 2006, c. 46, http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2006/46/section/3 (27 June 2011).
Chapter 4
Objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to
Describe how human resources (HR) departments are typically
organized and their primary responsibilities
Describe HR planning and how multinational staffing and outsourcing
impact the planning process
Describe the steps involved in employee selection
Identify several different types of pre-employment tests
Describe the advantages and disadvantages of different types of
employee training programs
Describe the performance evaluation process and identify different types
of performance evaluation tools used in performance evaluation
Explain HR’s role in compensation and benefits programs
Identify specific compliance concerns for HR activities
Outline
Organization of the Human Training and Development
Resources Department
Performance Evaluation
Human Resources Planning Establishing Performance Goals
Projecting Staffing Needs Monitoring and Reviewing
Estimating the Labor Supply Employee Performance
Recruitment Performance Evaluation Programs
A
resource is an asset or something of value. The use of the term human
resources to refer to the people who work in a company actually indicates
a heightened awareness among companies about the importance of people
to a company’s success. An organization typically divides its resources into four
categories: human, technological, financial, and physical (buildings and machin-
ery). Although a company’s success depends on having all of the right resources in
place, a company typically views its human resources as the most valuable of these
assets. The difference between a highly successful company and a mediocre com-
pany is likely the difference in the talent level, education level, and training of the
people working in each company. Human resources management is the function
within an insurance company that oversees corporate hiring, training, developing,
and retaining of valued employees.
in that new market. If not, what additional human resources will it need, are those
resources readily available, and at what costs? In addition, in today’s business
environment, an insurer’s staffing needs may change rapidly because of increased
regulations or changes in the competitive environment. To successfully address
such needs quickly and effectively, HR’s management must be in close communi-
cation with the company’s management.
The individual who leads the HR department is typically a vice president. If
a company has a chief operating officer (COO), the HR vice president typically
reports to the COO. If there is no COO, the HR vice president reports directly
to the CEO. Large HR departments have managers who are in charge of one HR
operation, such as training and development, and who oversee other HR staff
members. Smaller departments may have no managers. In such departments, HR
staff members report directly to the vice president. The organizational structure
of HR departments varies significantly from company to company, but HR is typi-
cally responsible for
Planning
Recruitment and selection
Performance evaluation
Compliance activities
In small or medium-sized companies, one HR employee may perform two or
more of these activities. In larger companies, the members of the HR staff may
specialize in only one of these activities. Note that an insurance company’s HR
department doesn’t usually provide direct HR support to the company’s producers
and agency personnel. Instead, members of the marketing department usually are
responsible for providing HR support to producers. Finally, in many organiza-
tions, HR organizes employee participation in community activities and charity
events on behalf of the company.
As you read this chapter, remember that a company’s HR practices vary
depending upon the legal requirements, culture, and traditional HR practices
of the country in which the company operates. For example, in some cultures,
employee rewards are based more on department or group accomplishments than
on individual accomplishments.
Internal Factors
Employee turnover rate (number of resignations, retirements, or other voluntary
or involuntary employee terminations)
Skills, abilities, and performance levels of current employees
Current and projected financial condition of the insurer
New products or company initiatives that require changes in or additions to cur-
rent staffing
New technology that affects how jobs are performed
Changes in organizational structure that increase or decrease staffing needs
External Factors
State of the economy (changes in a country’s unemployment rate can cause the
labor pool to increase or decrease)
Political environment (stable or unstable)
Laws and regulations
Demographics (aging populations, ethnic diversity within populations)
Demand for products and services (increasing or decreasing)
As part of the HR planning process, insurers also consider staffing needs for
international operations and whether outsourcing can satisfy some of the insurer’s
staffing needs.
Outsourcing
Another important consideration in HR planning is whether certain organizational
activities should be outsourced. Outsourcing is the process of paying external
specialists to handle specified business activities instead of using an organization’s
own employees or processes to perform those activities. The external specialist
in an outsourcing arrangement is known as a service provider or vendor. An out-
sourcing arrangement may cover all or only part of the functions for an opera-
tional area. For example, an insurer might outsource its entire life insurance claim
administration operation, or the company might outsource only claim investiga-
tion and perform all other claim-related processing activities within the company.
Example: The Tolkien Life Insurance Company acquired the Greene Life
Insurance Company. Tolkien contracted with a service provider to handle
the policyowner service functions associated with Greene’s life insurance
policies. Subject to Tolkien’s overall management, the day-to-day
responsibility for the administration of Greene’s life insurance policies and
IT support was transferred to the service provider. The service provider,
who had in place state-of-the-art policy support systems, hired almost all
of Greene’s former employees, who provided policy support tasks, such
as customer service, billing, and claims processing. Through the use of a
high-quality service provider, Tolkien provided Greene’s customers with
the customer service they expected, at a cost lower than Tolkien could
have provided using Greene’s older, dated systems.
Skills inventories are also useful for talent development and management. Some
HR departments use the information in skills inventories to identify employees
who, with additional cross-training or education, might qualify for higher-level
jobs within the company.
HR can use the information it obtains from a skills inventory to perform suc-
cession planning. Succession planning is the process of identifying possible
replacements within a company for important jobs. Succession planning involves
assessing employees’ current performance levels and promotion potential. Typi-
cally, most companies use succession planning only for management positions.
Companies perform succession planning because it allows the company to plan in
advance for replacing a key employee.
Recruitment
Recruitment is the process of identifying and attracting job applicants who are
capable of performing the duties of a particular position. Insurers recruit job can-
didates by looking inside and outside the company for the best-qualified people.
Internal Recruitment
To the extent possible, most insurers try to fill job positions above entry-level posi-
tions with employees from within the organization. Internal recruitment offers
several benefits to an insurer.
Current employees have an employment history with the insurer. Unlike
a person hired from outside the company, an insurer knows the performance
level of current employees.
Internal recruitment is less expensive than external recruitment. Hiring
from within the company does not require purchasing help-wanted advertise-
ments or the services of employment agencies.
External Recruitment
When no current employees with the required qualifications are available, insur-
ers use external recruitment. Hiring a job candidate from outside the company can
bring fresh energy, perspective, and ideas to the company and stimulate creativity.
The most common methods for external recruiting are (1) placing help-wanted
advertisements in newspapers, (2) listing open positions on the company’s exter-
nal website or on job placement websites, (3) contracting with private employment
agencies, (4) conducting job fairs and searches at educational institutions, and (5)
following up on referrals of potential job candidates made by current employees.
Because of the growing popularity of social media, such as Facebook and Linked-In,
companies are also exploring ways to use social media in their recruitment efforts.
Employee Selection
An insurer’s primary goal when selecting an employee is to determine if a job
candidate’s education, skills, experience, and—for some jobs—personality are
suited to the requirements of a particular position. Traditionally, hiring systems
have focused on current or specific knowledge and skills. In today’s changing work
environment, a candidate’s trainability, problem-solving ability, adaptability, initia-
tive, and ability to work autonomously are increasingly important characteristics.
The number of candidates for a job may be initially quite large. The employee
selection process narrows down the number of candidates until, hopefully, the
company hires the best candidate for the job. The primary steps in the selection
process are shown in Figure 4.4.
Work history
Personal references
The applicant must sign the employment application to certify that the informa-
tion on the form is correct. In addition, the applicant’s signature usually authorizes
the potential employer to conduct background checks or drug tests or both.
Employment Applications
Applications that satisfy minimum job qualifications are selected
for screening interviews
Screening Interviews
Applicants who are obviously not candidates for the job
are eliminated; others proceed to pre-employment
tests or interviews
Pre-Employment Tests
Applicants who fail to meet minimum required
standards on performance tests are eliminated;
others proceed to interviews
Employment Interviews
In-depth interviews of remaining
applicants result in selection
of a candidate for job
Applicant
Hired
Pre-Employment Testing
Sometimes companies require job applicants to take tests that measure their job-
related abilities, aptitude, knowledge, or skill. For a pre-employment test to be of
value to an employer, the test should be valid and reliable. Validity refers to the
degree to which a test is correlated with job-related skills or behaviors. When a
test is valid, a person who scores well on the test is likely to do well in the job.
The reliability of a pre-employment test refers to the likelihood that an appli-
cant would achieve similar results on repeated administrations of the same or an
equivalent test. For example, if a test is reliable, an applicant who scores a 90 on a
test on Monday should score at about the same level on the same or a similar test
on Tuesday.
Pre-employment tests can generally be categorized as aptitude tests, perfor-
mance tests, or behavioral tendencies tests. An aptitude test, also known as a
cognitive abilities test, attempts to determine a job candidate’s intelligence level
and reasoning ability by evaluating how well the candidate can do such things
as remembering details, solving problems, and understanding and using words
correctly. According to research on many different financial services jobs, apti-
tude tests can reasonably predict how successful new hires will be in completing
training, passing professional licensing exams, and general work performance.1
To evaluate how well an applicant has mastered the specific skills needed to
perform well in a particular position, a company may administer a performance
test, also known as a job skills test or a work sample test. For example, a test mea-
suring a clerical applicant’s ability to use spreadsheet software or word processing
software is a performance test. A behavioral tendencies test, also known as a
personality test, attempts to discover a job applicant’s typical job behaviors, such
as: Is the person a team player? Can the person remain calm under pressure? Is the
person honest?
Employment Interviews
Ultimately, the question an insurer wants answered is: Can an applicant do the
job? On the other side, applicants want to know if a job is right for them. An
employment interview, which is often a series of interviews, provides a manager
with the opportunity to decide whether the candidate is qualified for and suited
to do the job. An employment interview also allows a job candidate to assess
the company and the job position. Ideally, an employment interview realistically
presents the positive and negative aspects of a job. Job applicants who have a real-
istic preview of the work adjust better to the position after hire. For example, if
an insurance company expects a claim department employee to work overtime if
claim volume exceeds a certain level, then this expectation should be communi-
cated during the employment interview.
Sometimes the manager or supervisor for the position being filled conducts an
employment interview. Sometimes the employment interview is conducted by a
group of individuals. The group typically consists of the manager and two or three
other employees who will work with the applicant if hired. Having three or four
individuals evaluate the applicant rather than just one lessens the likelihood of
individual bias. Using the same set of job-related questions for all applicants also
lessens the likelihood of bias and promotes consistency in the evaluation process.
Performance Evaluation
Performance evaluation, also known as performance appraisal, is a formal
process of reviewing and documenting an employee’s job performance with the
primary goals of (1) ensuring adequate performance, (2) continually improving
performance, and (3) determining whether the employee qualifies for an increase
in compensation or a promotion. The HR department typically helps develop per-
formance evaluation systems and oversees the performance evaluation process.
Performance evaluations measure employees’ actions against performance
standards and are part of an insurer’s control process. To be of the most value, per-
formance standards must relate to specified goals for each employee. The speci-
fied goals are actions, achievements, or competencies that the employee needs to
attain or complete to successfully perform the job. In general, the performance
evaluation process consists of (1) establishing performance goals, (2) monitoring
employee performance, and (3) reviewing employee performance.
Managers must make sure that employees know and understand what is
expected of them in a job. Managers typically meet with employees at the begin-
ning of an evaluation period and discuss performance goals—standards against
which the employee’s work are evaluated. This initial goal setting is a type of
steering control. Employee goals may also include non-work-specific objectives
such as completing additional training or education courses.
Employees are more likely to be committed to achieving performance goals
when they believe that the goals are fair and attainable. If no claim analyst has
ever processed 35 claims in one day with a 98 percent accuracy rating, then this
performance goal is unrealistic and has little value. Also of little value is a per-
formance goal that only one or two exceptional employees are able to reach. If the
majority of the employees in a department are not reaching performance goals, the
manager needs to carefully assess why. Perhaps the one or two employees reach-
ing the goals have qualifications that the other employees don’t have. Perhaps the
underachieving employees need additional training. Or perhaps the performance
goal needs to be adjusted. In any event, investigation is required. When managers
include employees in establishing performance goals, employees are also more
likely to understand and be motivated to attain those goals.
Performance Tools
HR can choose from a wide array of performance tools to use in the company’s
performance evaluation system. Performance tools measure an employee’s behav-
ior and accomplishment of objectives. Insurers typically use one or more of the
performance evaluation methods shown in Figure 4.6.
Compliance
Many of an HR department’s actions, as described throughout this chapter, must
comply with government regulations. Two other heavily regulated areas are work-
place safety and the manner in which HR manages employee separations from the
company.
Many countries regulate the safety of the work environment. In the United
States, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) develops
and enforces mandatory job safety and health standards to reduce safety hazards
and health hazards in the workplace. The HR department seeks to ensure that the
company obeys all specified standards and maintains a work environment that is
free from recognized hazards. If an employee in the United States files a complaint
with OSHA claiming that unsafe conditions exist, an OSHA representative visits
the workplace and investigates the complaint. The HR department typically over-
sees the OSHA representative’s visit.
However, some countries, such as India, rely on employers’ voluntary efforts to
maintain workplace safety. In India, the National Safety Council conducts safety
training for and provides promotional materials to the HR departments of employ-
ers to encourage workplace safety.
The governments in many countries have in place laws that regulate the separa-
tion of employees from an employer. Separation occurs when an employee leaves a
company as a result of resignation, layoff, retirement, or discharge. A layoff results
when a company has no work for an employee to perform because the employee’s
position has been eliminated or the company is not operating at full capacity. In
the second situation, the layoff may be temporary and the worker will be recalled
if work becomes available. A discharge occurs when an employer permanently
terminates the employment relationship for cause, including the employee’s poor
performance or the employee’s failure to follow company policies or procedures.
The HR area handles the paperwork associated with ending the employment rela-
tionship in compliance with all applicable laws. Typically, HR personnel explain to
departing employees their rights and options, if any, to elements of the company’s
benefit plan. When an employee separates because of layoff, HR may provide or
coordinate the delivery of outplacement counseling or career counseling services
to help such employees in their search for a new job.
Key Terms
human resources planning employee development
home country staffing orientation
host country staffing on-the-job training
third-country nationals mentoring
outsourcing job rotation
skills inventory classroom training
succession planning self-study training
recruitment performance evaluation
groupthink compensation
job posting employee benefits
job description Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA)
screening interview Employee Retirement Income Security
validity Act (ERISA)
reliability Occupational Safety and Health
aptitude test Administration (OSHA)
performance test separation
behavioral tendencies test layoff
employment interview discharge
employee training
Additional Activities
If you want to relate the information in this chapter to your company, try these
activities:
Review the job descriptions in your company’s job postings. Do you need
additional skills or training to apply for one of the jobs that interests you? If so,
contact your HR department to discuss the best way to obtain that training.
Look at one of your previous performance evaluation forms. What type of
performance evaluation tool does your company use?
Endnote
1. Malcolm McCulloch, “Work Changes and Hiring Practices for the Recovering Economy,” Resource,
July 2010, 21.
Chapter 5
Objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to
Recognize and use information and technology terminology
Describe the key job positions in an information technology
(IT) department
Describe the main elements in information management, including a
database, a database management system, a data warehouse, a document
management system, and a workflow management system
Explain the purpose of a transaction processing system and the benefits
and costs involved with legacy systems
Describe how business intelligence, business analytics, and expert
systems are used in insurance companies
Define software as a service (SaaS) and cloud computing and explain
how each is used to expand IT capacity
Describe intranets, extranets, and the Internet, and ways in which
insurers use each type of network
Explain how insurers use different types of computer telephony
integration (CTI)
Define data governance and identify several actions insurers should take
to maximize IT security and improve disaster recovery
Outline
Responsibilities of the Telecommunications
IT Department Networks
Organization of the IT Department Computer Telephony Integration
Other Telecommunications
Information Management Technology
Databases IT Security and Disaster Recovery
Database Management Systems
Document Management Systems
Workflow Management Systems
Business Process Technology
Transaction Processing Systems
Business Intelligence
Outsourcing IT Operations
T
he insurance industry is an information-driven business. Insurers use
information about customers, products, producers, investments, regulatory
requirements, employees, and many other factors in their operations. Infor-
mation must be managed like any other valuable asset in order to create competi-
tive advantages and increase stakeholder value. Information management refers
to all of the people, processes, and technology that companies use to create and
manage corporate information. Specifically, information management addresses
how companies capture, manage, use, preserve, and store physical and electronic
information so that they can deliver the right information to the right people at the
right time.
The insurance industry is also a technology-driven business. Technology
provides ways for insurers to manage business processes more efficiently, reach
customers more effectively, and distinguish themselves from competitors. Tech-
nology management refers to using technology to maximize company resources
and conduct business operations more effectively and efficiently. Within an insur-
ance company, the functional area responsible for information and technology
management is commonly known as information technology (IT). However, the
department may also be called information technology management, information
management, information services, information resources, or a variety of other
names.
that understands how a company’s work processes are done today and can also
envision what the work processes should look like in the future can provide stra-
tegic value that far exceeds just cost efficiencies.
The IT department is usually responsible for all of the technology within an
insurance company, including hardware, software, networks, or any other related
processes. The IT department also supports the management and delivery of voice,
data, or video information. Figure 5.1 provides descriptions of common types
of technology and other terminology important for understanding how the IT
department operates.
today’s uncertain and fiercely competitive marketplace, the CIO’s role in aligning
information technology goals and strategies with corporate goals and strategies is
more important than ever. The CIO normally reports to the chief executive officer
(CEO). If the insurance company has a chief operations officer (COO), the CIO
may report to the COO.
Some large companies may also have a chief technology officer (CTO), also
known as a chief architect or enterprise architect, who reports to the CIO and is
responsible for developing and implementing a technology strategy for the entire
organization, including its processes, information, and information technology
assets. For example, the CTO might be involved in researching and determining
whether to purchase or develop in-house a new type of technology. Figure 5.2
describes key job positions in an IT department.
Source: Adapted from Ferny Espinoza (Transamerica Life Insurance Company), note to author, 2011. Used with permission.
Information Management
Insurers gather incredible amounts of data from policy applications, policyown-
ers, insureds, claimants, employees, producers, products, and competitors. Data
are unprocessed facts, such as a policyowner’s name, address, date of birth, or the
policy’s face amount or policy number. Insurers can combine, manipulate, and
analyze data to create information. Information is a collection of data that has
been converted into a form that is meaningful or can be used to accomplish some
objective. For example, an insurer combines the face amount of one sold policy
with the face amount of all of the other policies sold during a specified period to
obtain information about total sales during that period.
To operate effectively, all areas of a life insurance company need informa-
tion that is accurate, complete, concise, relevant, clear, timely, accessible, usable,
economical, and secure. One important goal for information management is to
ensure that the company’s information possesses these characteristics, which are
described in Figure 5.3.
If an insurer’s information does not have these characteristics, the insurer is
going to be operating below its capabilities. For example, if customer satisfaction
surveys do not collect accurate information or if they are administered too infre-
quently, an insurer’s understanding of its customers’ needs might be inaccurate or
outdated. An important component in how well a company manages its informa-
tion is effective database management.
Databases
A database is an organized collection of data and information. An insurer devel-
ops some databases internally and maintains them for the insurer’s own needs and
uses. For example, an insurer’s life insurance customer database would store con-
tact information and demographic information about the company’s life insurance
customers. Alternatively, an insurer’s personnel database would store information
about the company’s employees, such as salaries, benefits, or skills. Such inter-
nal databases are designed to record business transactions quickly and preserve a
record of these transactions for internal use.
Insurers also use external databases developed by governments and govern-
ment agencies, industry associations, and other information providers. External
databases provide information such as regulatory updates, market demographics,
economic information, actuarial studies, and consumer information. Figure 5.4
lists a few of the many external databases that life insurance companies use.
screened for duplications and edited into a standard format—and then stored. The
data warehousing system provides management with a means of retrieving and
analyzing data for decision making. For example, if a manager wants to know what
percentage of an insurer’s life insurance business comes from a specified region
or country, an analyst can easily pull such information from the data warehouse.
Traditionally, insurers’ data warehouses were specific to one line of business or
one operation. For example, an insurer might have an individual data warehouse
that captures and maintains individual life, individual disability, and individual
annuity data.
But, what if an insurer needs to access information about its customers’ demo-
graphics and stated preferred method of contact across all of its lines of business?
To meet such a need, insurers are increasingly creating enterprise data ware-
houses, also known as integrated data warehouses, which consolidate data from
data warehouses and operational systems across lines of business, geographies, or
operations. The advantage of an enterprise data warehouse is that it can provide
Database Users
Customer File
New Business
Name
Address
Phone
Age
Policy File Marketing
Policy Number
Anniversary Date
Database
Servicing Producer Management
Beneficiaries System Claim Administration
Policyowner
Producer File
Name
Address
Agency Management
Sales
Commissions
Claims File
Claimant
Underwriting
Policy Number
Claim Number
Policyowner
An insurer can analyze the data in a data warehouse through data mining,
which is the analysis of large amounts of data to discover previously unknown
trends, patterns, and relationships. For example, data mining is often used to
detect a pattern of claim fraud or to help identify who among a company’s current
customers are most likely to purchase additional products. Data mining allows
insurers to make proactive, knowledge-driven decisions.
An insurer’s ability to scan new business applications and required forms either
from a centralized location or from a producer’s office has eliminated much of the
need for paper documents and also the associated time and costs of transporting,
processing, and storing paper documents. A DMS offers three primary benefits to
insurers. First, insurers realize a reduction in costs. Second, operational efficiency
increases because employees can access documents quickly through the comput-
erized system and several employees can view the same document simultaneously.
A DMS also aids insurers in satisfying compliance requirements because only
certain people or certain groups of people are permitted access to the electronic
documents.
Documents that request payment or other action from the recipient, such as a
premium due notice or a purchase order
Many of the transaction processing systems insurers use are known as legacy
systems—older systems developed by and customized for an insurer to perform
a specific task. Legacy systems are no longer the best or most modern systems.
However, legacy systems still may efficiently handle processing for very large
blocks of business, and their replacement may present unacceptably high costs and
risks to an insurer. The costs and risks of retaining legacy systems, however, are
growing. Because insurance contracts often stay in force for long periods of time,
a policy administration system may have data going back close to a hundred years.
Transforming this data to work with more contemporary systems can be diffi-
cult, but not doing so means that the data in the legacy system isn’t easily acces-
sible, which may hinder marketing or other essential company efforts. In addition,
because of the system’s age, finding IT staff with the skills necessary to maintain
the legacy system is often difficult. For all of these reasons, many insurers are
being forced to replace legacy systems. Some insurers have found that outsourcing
legacy system operations, such as policy administration, is more economical than
rebuilding these systems internally.
Business Intelligence
Business intelligence (BI), formerly known as a decision support system (DSS), is
an organized collection of hardware, software, databases, and procedures that uses
information taken from a company’s transaction processing systems and databases
to support decision making. Basic BI systems retrieve information, analyze it,
and prepare reports from multiple sources to allow managers to make day-to-day
decisions and control routine activities. Such BI systems typically provide insurers
with automatically scheduled reports on sales, budgets, benefit payments, lapses,
commissions, and many other financial aspects of insurance operations. They also
provide exception reports when an established performance standard is not met.
Some insurers are beginning to use information dashboards rather than printed
or electronic reports to access and monitor information about critical elements
pertaining to company performance. A dashboard, sometimes known as a
performance dashboard or readerboard, is an information system application
that combines information from multiple BI sources into a single, easy-to-read
electronic format that identifies positive and negative trends. A dashboard puts
all of the information needed to evaluate the performance of the company or an
individual business process in one place. A dashboard provides management with
key performance indicators, such as customer service accessibility or sales by line
of business, and allows management to constantly monitor these indicators on a
daily or sometimes real-time basis and proactively manage the processes associ-
ated with the indicators.
More sophisticated BI systems contain business analytics and expert systems.
Business analytics are business intelligence tools that combine technologies,
applications, and processes as well as statistical and quantitative analysis to help
management make decisions or solve problems.3 One of the most important con-
siderations for an insurer when developing business analytics is focusing on key
work processes or aspects of the business that will help the insurer attain some
strategic goal. For example, the new business department might track new appli-
cations coming in according to product type, face amount, premium size, or dis-
tribution channel. Using this information, business analytics can gauge whether a
new product is performing as expected or whether a new marketing campaign is
effective. Insurers increasingly want business analytics that not only identify cur-
rent realities, but also predict future customer patterns and business opportunities.
For example, knowing what products are purchased most often by a particular seg-
ment of the population is good information; knowing whether this pattern is likely
to continue in the future is invaluable information.
An expert system is a knowledge-based computer system designed to provide
expert consultation to information users for solving specialized and complex prob-
lems, which means that the computer system actually suggests a course of action
or helps solve problems. An insurance company can use expert systems for opera-
tional purposes such as assisting in underwriting and claim processing. Expert
systems can also use information gathered through business analytics to suggest
methods for cutting costs, expanding capacity with existing resources, and creating
operational efficiencies.
Outsourcing IT Operations
Until fairly recently, the hardware and software an insurer used for its business
processes and business intelligence was either developed in-house and operated
by an insurer’s IT staff or purchased from vendors and operated in-house either
entirely by the IT staff or by the IT staff in consultation with the vendor. Because
of competitive and economic pressures, insurers are looking for ways to decrease
IT costs and also for ways that IT can modify business processes to react faster to
changing market conditions. Outsourcing, which we described in Chapter 4, is one
way insurers have sought to accomplish these objectives. The outsourcing of IT
operations often involves software as a service (SaaS) and cloud computing.
Software as a service (SaaS), also known as hosted applications, is a software
delivery method for accessing software from a vendor remotely over a web-based
network. Instead of developing an application or purchasing a licensed application
that the insurer will own, the insurer pays a fee to the vendor for the use of the
software. By using SaaS, insurers avoid development or purchase costs, installa-
tion costs, and maintenance costs. However, the use of SaaS requires careful con-
sideration. Poor integration between SaaS and other company systems and a lack
of policies governing the evaluation and use of SaaS can create costly operational
and legal issues for an insurer.
Cloud computing is a subscription-based or pay-per-use service that, in real
time over the Internet, provides an insurer with access to networks, platforms,
applications, or other IT elements that can extend the IT department’s existing
capabilities. To differentiate, SaaS provides software, whereas in cloud comput-
ing, the insurer “plugs in” to the provider to obtain the infrastructure or software
needed.4 For example, actuarial computations that can occupy an insurer’s IT sys-
tems for many hours can be run for a fee on a provider’s system over the Internet.
In this way, insurers can add IT capacity without investing in new infrastructure,
hiring or training new personnel, or purchasing new software. Because of data
security risks, legal compliance requirements, and other issues involving cloud
computing, insurers do not commonly use it for critical business applications. For
example, what would happen to an insurer’s data if a vendor supplying cloud com-
puting were to exit the business suddenly? However, as insurers develop contin-
gency plans and better control mechanisms, cloud computing is likely to become a
more viable alternative for many of an insurer’s business processes.
Telecommunications
Telecommunications is the electronic transmission of communication signals. In
a general sense, telecommunications is a term for a vast array of technologies that
send information over distances. Telephones—land lines and mobile phones—
radios, televisions, and computers that communicate through networks are all
examples of telecommunication devices.
Telecommunications have revolutionized insurers’ business operations. Compa-
nies use telecommunications to communicate more effectively and faster than ever
before with customers, vendors, business partners, and other external stakeholders.
Today, companies compete in a global economy through telecommunications. Tele-
communications provide a variety of tools that allow managers, employees, teams,
Networks
Computer networks have created a world of possibilities for ways in which com-
panies can improve their operations. Networks are used for such simple tasks as
sending a document from a computer to a printer for printing. Networks are also
used for complex tasks such as connecting hundreds of an insurer’s employees
located around the world to the company’s intranet. An intranet is a company’s
internal computer network that uses Internet technology (such as web browsers)
but is accessible only to people within the organization. Intranets are used for a
wide range of work activities including e-mail, collaborative information sharing,
training, and employee access to company databases and computer applications.
E-mail, or electronic mail, is the transmission of electronic messages over com-
munications networks. Employees can send e-mails to other employees through
the company’s intranet or to anyone in the world when the company’s intranet is
connected to the Internet. E-mail has become an important way for insurers to
communicate with customers. Some insurers also provide employees with inter-
nal instant messaging. Instant messaging is the direct transmission of text-based
communication in real time over communication networks. When used by a com-
pany’s employees, instant messaging is faster than e-mail and doesn’t clog the
company’s e-mail system. Instant messaging can also be used to enable text-based
conversations with customers. In such cases, it is often referred to as web chat, text
chat, or Internet chat.
An extranet is a portion of a company’s intranet that is accessible to people
within the organization and to select external stakeholders. For example, insur-
ers often use an extranet to connect with their producers. As an additional secu-
rity measure, insurers can create a virtual private network (VPN), which is a
secured computer network that uses hardware, software, or a combination of both
to act as a “tunnel” through the Internet so that only people in possession of the
required technology have access to data traveling through the network. Extranets
and VPNs allow insurers to securely distribute information—such as forms, sales
illustrations, policy transaction information, or other data—to customers, suppli-
ers, or other business partners.
The Internet is a network of computer networks that can be accessed by any-
one with a device that supports such access, such as a computer or mobile phone.
Figure 5.6 illustrates how insurers use these three networks.
In Figure 5.6, you can see how Internet users are restricted from accessing a
company’s extranet or intranet by a firewall. A firewall—a combination of hard-
ware and software—creates an electronic barrier between the public and private
areas of an insurer’s systems and protects internal company networks. Only autho-
rized users can access the areas beyond the firewall. Life insurance companies
maintain a large amount of sensitive financial, medical, and personal information
about their customers. An insurer’s information systems also contain proprietary
information about the company itself. To protect the insurer’s information and
User
accountability for data so that business processes are optimized and data is secure
and protected, and in compliance with government regulations. Proper data gov-
ernance should ensure that an organization’s data can be trusted; this should, in
turn, instill greater confidence in management’s decision making. Although data
governance policies differ depending upon a company’s needs, data governance
has the following primary objectives:
To establish organizational data priorities to accomplish desired business
results, such as maximizing income or minimizing risk
Key Terms
information management expert system
technology management software as a service (SaaS)
hardware cloud computing
software telecommunications
systems software intranet
application software e-mail
network instant messaging
server extranet
Internet virtual private network (VPN)
web browser firewall
World Wide Web (the web) encryption
Chief Technology Officer (CTO) intrusion detection software
data electronic data interchange (EDI)
information e-commerce
database collaborative software
database management system telecommuting
(DBMS) computer telephony integration (CTI)
data warehouse automatic call distributor (ACD)
enterprise data warehouse screen pop
data mining interactive voice recognition (IVR)
document management system system
(DMS) customer relationship management
imaging (CRM)
content management system (CMS) teleconferencing
workflow management system videoconferencing
transaction smart phone
transaction processing system fax machine
legacy system IT security
business intelligence (BI) antivirus software
dashboard data governance
business analytics
Additional Activities
If you want to relate the information in this chapter to your company, try these
activities:
Locate the contact information for your company’s help desk technician. Then,
when you need it, you will be ready.
Think about your work duties. What types of technology are you using in your
work? How would you do your work without those automated systems?
Consider why data governance policies are important. What types of data gov-
ernance policies does your company have in place? Find out about a few of
them and what caused the policies to be implemented.
Endnotes
1. Webopedia, s.v. “server,” http://www.webopedia.com/TERM/S/server.html (4 October 2010).
2. “Business Intelligence: Key to Surviving Meltdown, Consolidation and Cost Cutting,” Resource,
March 2009, 26–27.
3. Webopedia, s.v. “business analytics,” http://www.webopedia.com/TERM/B/business_analytics.html
(4 October 2010).
4. Kevin Fogarty, “Cloud Computing Definitions and Solutions,” CIO.com, 10 September 2009,
http://www.cio.com/article/501814/Cloud_Computing_Definitions_and_Solutions (31 May 2011).
5. Carrie Burns, “Data Becomes Most Common Fraud Target: Kroll Report States Information Theft
Tops Physical Losses in Increasingly Expensive Concern,” Information Management Online,
20 October 2010, http://www.information-management.com/news/data_security_governance_ROI_
Kroll-10018961-1.html (27 May 2011).
Chapter 6
Financial Management
Objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to
Describe how insurers organize their financial operations
Describe the core functions involved in financial management in a life
insurance company
Distinguish among basic types of financial strategies
Identify and describe common risks that life insurance companies face
Describe risk management techniques: diversification, hedging, and
expense management
Explain the role of enterprise risk management (ERM) in life insurance
companies
Differentiate between profit and profitability
Explain the importance of capital management and list ways an insurer
raises and uses capital
Identify the basic cash inflows and cash outflows for an insurance
company, and describe how cash flow affects solvency and profitability
Identify the primary sources of financial information for stakeholders
Describe an income statement and balance sheet and show how the
balance sheet relates to the basic accounting equation
Describe financial reporting requirements and tools used to monitor
insurer solvency
Outline
Organization of Financial Financial Compliance
Management
Tools to Monitor Solvency
Accounting and Financial
Reporting
Treasury Operations
Investment Operations
Audit and Internal Control
Interdepartmental Responsibilities
Responsibilities of Financial
Management
Setting Financial Strategy
Managing Risk
Managing Solvency and Profitability
Managing Capital
Managing Cash Flows
Providing Information to
Stakeholders
A
ccounting focuses primarily on the recording and reporting of a com-
pany’s financial transactions. Financial management, sometimes called
financial operations or finance, is how an insurance company manages
its resources to meet the company’s financial goals, especially the overall goals
of solvency and profitability. Financial management uses a company’s accounting
records and reports to
Generate information that stakeholders, such as customers, investors, regula-
tors, rating agencies, securities analysts, investment bankers, and the general
business community need
Ensure that the company meets all of its financial obligations and complies
with complex financial regulations
Assist in generating adequate returns for the company’s owners and customers
The investment committee sets the company’s investment policy and oversees
investment operations.
The audit committee, sometimes called the audit/risk committee, directs the
company’s internal audit and control function.
Typically, a company’s chief executive officer (CEO) delegates most financial
and budget responsibilities to senior financial officers. In many life insurance
companies, the chief financial officer (CFO) oversees all the company’s finances
and financial policies. The CFO reports directly to the company’s CEO and works
closely with company directors to develop corporate goals and strategies. Figure
6.1 lists some of the duties of the CFO.
Although many insurance companies have a unit or department called finance
or financial management, many others do not. In either case, people from several
areas, such as investments, accounting, treasury operations, and auditing, typically
contribute to an insurance company’s financial management. Figure 6.2 shows a
simplified illustration of core financial management functions.
Source: Adapted from Miriam A. Orsina and Gene Stone, Insurance Company Operations, 2nd ed., [Atlanta: LOMA (Life
Office Management Association, Inc.), © 2005], 335. Used with permission; all rights reserved.
Audit Committee
Board of Directors
Controller
Treasury Operations
Treasury operations, sometimes called cash management or cash accounting,
manages the cash coming into and out of a company. In most insurance com-
panies, the person who directs treasury operations is called the treasurer, who
usually reports to the CFO. The treasurer oversees the maintenance and manage-
ment of records and reports for all of an insurer’s cash transactions, specifically
money deposited or withdrawn from the insurer’s accounts at a bank or other
financial institution. Within treasury operations, managers and supervisors over-
see departmental activities. Treasury associates, analysts, assistants, coordinators,
and clerks are some of the job positions in treasury operations. Figure 6.4 shows
the organization of the treasury operations function.
Treasury operations include the following activities:
Cash management—Oversees cash receipts and approves cash disburse-
ments. In many multinational companies, cash management is centralized in
the country of domicile, although it may be decentralized in each separate
country in which the company conducts business. Some multinational insur-
ance companies outsource the management of foreign currency exchange in
specific countries to increase transaction accuracy and speed.
Bank relations and account administration—Sets up bank accounts, recon-
ciles bank statements, manages lockboxes for collecting premium payments,
and earns returns on cash.
Bank reconciliation—Records cash transactions and charges them to the
proper accounts.
Treasurer
Investment Operations
Investments are a core insurance company operation. Without careful manage-
ment of its investments, an insurance company would not be able to meet its
obligations over time. An insurer can organize investment operations, as a sepa-
rate department, a subsidiary corporation, or as a major division within a large
corporation, serving the life insurance area and other business units.
Sometimes insurers outsource their investment operations to an investment
company. Although outsourcing investment operations provides insurers with
expert investment experience and can sometimes result in significant cost savings,
Communicating to the accounting and actuarial areas the current and expected
rates of return on the company’s investments
The CIO directs a team of portfolio managers and asset/liability managers
who coordinate investment strategies for specific types of invested assets such
as stocks, bonds, mortgages, and real estate. A portfolio is a collection of assets
assembled to meet a defined set of financial goals. Each portfolio manager makes
investment decisions for their portfolio according to the company’s general invest-
ment guidelines.
Asset/liability management (ALM) is the practice of coordinating the admin-
istration of an insurer’s asset portfolio (its investments) with the administration
of its liability portfolio (its obligations to customers) so as to manage risk and
still earn an adequate level of return. An asset/liability manager, called an asset
manager in some companies, monitors the investments for a specific line of the
insurer’s business and makes sure funds are available when needed to support
that line. Note that actuaries are responsible for determining the financial resources
needed to support an insurer’s obligations to customers for each insurance product.
A simple example of an investment department organizational structure is
shown in Figure 6.5. Recall that some companies outsource all or part of invest-
ment operations activities. In addition to the CIO, portfolio managers, and asset/
liability managers, other employees in the investment department may include
Investment analysts, who research specific investment opportunities and make
recommendations regarding those opportunities
Traders, who buy and sell assets for the insurer’s portfolios
Investment Committee
Board of Directors
Audit Committee
CEO
Board of Directors
Chief Auditor
Interdepartmental Responsibilities
Because financial management involves tracking, approving, and reporting the
insurer’s receipts and disbursements of money, it has an impact on nearly all other
insurance company operations. Various departments within financial management
work with other insurance company departments, including
Actuarial. Financial managers work with actuaries in designing new products.
Actuaries project cash flows from premium payments, investment income, and
benefit payments, and coordinate these projections with treasury operations.
Investment operations works closely with actuaries in coordinating income
from investments with contractual obligations. Actuaries also work with
accounting and financial reporting staff on financial reporting activities.
Information technology (IT). Most of the processes for managing, record-
ing, and reporting financial transactions are automated. Financial management
works closely with IT to ensure data quality and to ensure that decision makers
receive the information they need when they need it to make decisions.
Managing Risk
Life insurance companies face many types of risk. What is risk? Risk is the pos-
sibility that an investment or other venture might have an unexpected result. An
investment is any use of resources with the aim of earning a profit or a positive
return. However, investments sometimes result in a loss to the investor or an inad-
equate gain. Therefore, returns on investments can be positive or negative.
When you hear the term investment, you may think of purchasing assets such
as stocks, bonds, mutual funds, or real estate, yet there are many other types of
investments. Examples of insurance company investments include
Buying stocks or bonds
Launching a new product
Hiring an employee
Issuing a policy
Opening a branch office
Some of the items on this list may not fit your idea of an investment. However,
remember that an investment is any use of resources with the aim of earning a
profit. An insurance company cannot earn a profit without a quality workforce or
an adequate information system.
Which investments on this list involve risk? Every one of them. Insurers
encounter risks in every aspect of conducting business. Figure 6.7 lists common
types of risks that insurance companies face.
Risk Management
Risk management is the process of systematically identifying, assessing, and
minimizing the negative impact of risk. An important risk management tool is
diversification, spreading a portfolio of risks across many risk characteristics to
reduce the effect of any one risk. Insurers may diversify risks by
Purchasing assets in a variety of asset classes, such as stocks, bonds, mort-
gages, and real estate
Investment risk is the possibility that an investor will fail to earn some or all of an expected
return or will lose all or part of the original investment, or principal. Some important risks
associated with investing are
Market risk: The risk arising from unexpected movements in the value of an entire
market for assets, such as the stock market, bond market, currency markets, or real
estate market. For example, real estate investments may lose value if the real estate
market as a whole declines.
Interest-rate risk: The uncertainty arising from fluctuations in market interest rates.
For example, if interest rates increase, bonds tend to lose market value.
Default risk: The risk that a borrower will fail to repay a debt. For example, a mortgage
owner may fail to make scheduled mortgage payments to a bank.
Liquidity risk: The risk of being unable to quickly convert an asset to cash at its true
value. For example, if the owner of property, such as a shopping mall, should suddenly
need cash quickly, the property may have to be sold for a price less than its true
value.
Currency risk: The risk arising from changes in currency exchange rates. For example,
the value of an insurer’s investments in a foreign country fluctuates with the value of
that country’s currency.
Operational risk is a broad category of risks originating from inadequacies in an insurer’s
operational areas or from external events affecting an insurer’s operational areas. Two
major types of operational risk are business process risk and event risk.
Business process risk: The risk of inadequate or failed internal processes and controls,
people, or systems. For example, inefficient customer service processes might create
long turnaround times, which results in a loss of business.
Event risk: The risk that external events, such as earthquakes, hurricanes, or political
unrest, will negatively impact operations. For example, an earthquake might result in
technology failures and an inability to run the business.
Product risk is the risk that a company’s products might not sell as well or be as profitable
as expected. Insurers face the following unique risks associated with their products:
Pricing risk: The risk that an insurer’s actual experience with an insurance product will
be significantly worse than expected when the product was priced, causing the insurer
to lose money on the product. For example, more insureds might die than an insurer
anticipated when pricing a life insurance product, so claims for life insurance benefits
will be higher than expected.
Policyholder behavior risk , also known as customer behavior risk: The risk that
insurers face as a result of the choices that policyholders make. For example, customers’
surrender patterns may be higher than an insurer anticipated.
Insurers face many other types of risks, in fact, too many to list them all. A few of these
risks include
Regulatory risk—The risk of changes in insurance regulations
Pay cash dividends to stockholders and increase the attractiveness of the com-
pany’s stock to investors
Managing Capital
Financial managers attempt to increase the probability that the company will remain
financially healthy by using the company’s capital appropriately. Capital can be cal-
culated as the amount by which a company’s assets—all the things of value owned
by a company, such as cash, financial investments, buildings, and land—exceed its
liabilities—the company’s debts and future obligations. In other words,
If a company’s assets increase or its liabilities decrease, then the company’s cap-
ital increases. Conversely, if a company’s assets decrease or its liabilities increase,
then the company’s capital decreases. Managing capital is a critical component of
a company’s financial success. Capital management consists of all the activities
a company undertakes to use its capital to generate profits while managing risk.
In general, an insurer can reduce its risk of insolvency by holding a large amount
of capital relative to its financial obligations. However, holding too large of an
amount of capital reduces an insurer’s potential profitability because the company
is not using its capital to generate profits and contribute to the company’s growth.
Benefits to an insurer of maintaining a strong capital position—in other words,
holding a large amount of capital—include
Greater ability to withstand difficult conditions such as a bad economy
Better ratings from rating agencies
$ $ $ $
$ $
$ $
cash shortfalls by having sufficient, but not excessive, liquid assets available. In
this way, the company can invest those funds not needed to meet obligations and
earn investment returns that will achieve the insurer’s financial goals. Cash-flow
management is a critical financial management responsibility because the timing
and the amount of cash flows into and out of the company directly affect company
solvency and profitability.
Financial Statements
A financial statement is a summary of a company’s financial condition on a speci-
fied date or its performance during a specified period. Financial statements help
interested parties assess the company’s profitability as well as its financial strength.
Every financial transaction feeds into the company’s accounting system, which
records the flow of funds into and out of the company. The accounting system
categorizes the information, summarizes it, and creates financial statements and
other documents. Two key financial statements are the income statement and the
balance sheet, which we introduce here and discuss in more detail in Chapter 7.
The income statement shows a company’s revenues and expenses during a
defined period, such as one quarter or one year, and shows whether the company
experienced a profit or loss during that period. Revenues are amounts that a com-
pany earns from its business operations—typically premium income and invest-
ment income for life insurance companies. Premium income from product sales is
the most important source of funds for most insurers. Typically, about two-thirds
of cash comes from product sales and one-third from investment earnings. How-
ever, in some insurance companies, investment earnings are higher than product
revenues. The percentage of income can vary from year to year and from one
company to another. Expenses are amounts that a company spends to support its
business operations.
The income statement also shows net income, which is calculated by subtract-
ing expenses from revenues. If a company’s revenues are greater than its expenses,
the company earns a profit. Recall that profit is a short-term measure of the com-
pany’s financial success. If the company’s revenues are less than its expenses, the
company incurs a loss. Figure 6.9 shows how you can tell if a company earned a
profit or a loss, given a simplified income statement that contains only revenues
and expenses.
The other major financial statement is the balance sheet, which lists the value
of an insurer’s assets, liabilities, and capital and surplus as of a specified date.
Surplus represents the cumulative amount of money—calculated as an insurance
company’s assets minus its liabilities and capital—that remains in the company
to accumulate. The relationship of assets, liabilities, and capital and surplus is
expressed in the basic accounting equation, which states that assets equal the
sum of liabilities, capital, and surplus. The basic accounting equation is typically
presented as follows:
Assets = Liabilities + Capital and surplus
Figure 6.10 shows how the basic accounting equation relates to a simplified
balance sheet.
Figure 6.10. Simplified Balance Sheet
On December 31, the AllTrue Life Insurance Company had $25 billion in assets
and $20 billion in liabilities. According to the basic accounting equation,
AllTrue’s capital and surplus as of December 31 was $5 billion ($25 billion –
$20 billion).
AllTrue’s Balance Sheet
Assets $ 25 billion
Liabilities –20 billion
Capital and surplus $ 5 billion
Rating Agencies
The rating an insurer receives from a rating agency affects the company’s ability
to attract new business. For example, customers may choose to do business only
with companies that have the highest rating. Ratings may also impact what stra-
tegic objectives and strategies the company follows. For example, an insurer may
have to sell off its riskier investments in favor of more conservative investments
in order to improve its ratings. The formulas most rating agencies use emphasize
solvency and reflect the adequacy of an insurer’s capital as well as the insurer’s
ability to pay its obligations to customers and creditors. The rating assigned to a
company allows external stakeholders to compare different insurers on a standard
basis. Figure 6.11 lists questions that external stakeholders often ask which insur-
ance company ratings may help answer.
Creditors
Is this company’s
stock a good value? Should we
do business
with this
insurer?
Financial Compliance
Insurance companies protect millions of customers against economic loss and
play a vital role in the continued health of global economies. Because of this criti-
cal role and its position of public trust, the insurance industry is subject to intense
government regulation. Regulators want to ensure that insurance companies
avoid insolvency, a situation in which a company is unable to meet its financial
obligations. Regulators use the information in an insurer’s financial statements
to evaluate the insurer’s financial strength and flexibility and compliance with
insurance laws and regulations. When insurance regulators look at an insurer’s
financial situation, they want to know that the insurer has enough assets to cover
financial obligations, over both the short term and the long term.
Does the insurer have enough current assets to satisfy current liabilities with-
out borrowing money or selling long-term investments?
Does the insurer have enough capital and surplus relative to its long-term
liabilities to remain solvent?
The capital and surplus ratio, also known as a capital ratio, can be used
to measure an insurer’s long-term solvency, and is calculated as
In general, the greater the capital and surplus ratio, the stronger a
company’s financial position. For example, an insurer with a 15 percent
capital and surplus ratio would have a stronger financial position than an
insurer with a 10 percent capital and surplus ratio. To account for risks to
which a particular insurer is exposed, regulators and rating agencies often
require insurers to use weight-adjusted, or risk-based, capital and surplus
ratios in their financial reports.
of business the insurer sells. An insurer that holds more risky investments has a
higher legal minimum standard of capital and surplus than does a comparable
insurer that holds less risky investments. By establishing risk-based minimum
standards of capital and surplus, along with other minimum requirements on the
company’s reserves and other aspects of operations, insurance regulators attempt
to ensure that each insurer has sufficient resources to pay policy benefits and other
financial obligations on time. Failure to satisfy these requirements could result in
insurance regulators’ taking control of the insurer. Regulators generally require
insurers to invest the majority of the assets that back their contractual obligations
in relatively safe, reliable investments. Insurers also must use specific rules when
reporting the value of these investments. Figure 6.12 addresses financial regula-
tory oversight in the United States and Canada.
United States
Federal Government
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) — A federal government agency
that regulates the investment industry.
Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) — A self-regulatory
organization that protects and educates investors.
Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank Act)
Canada
Each province and territory has its own securities regulator.
Annual Statement
Insurance regulators use many tools to monitor insurer solvency, including reviews
of industry-specific financial reports and financial condition examinations. In
the United States, an insurer must file a financial report known as an Annual
Statement with the insurance department in each state in which it does business
as well as with the NAIC. In Canada, every life insurer must file the Life-1, an
accounting report that presents information about an insurer’s operations and
financial performance, with the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institu-
tions (OSFI) and with the regulators of every province in which the insurer does
business.
Recall that a company’s annual report provides company investors and other
interested parties with general information about the company’s financial perfor-
mance during the past year. Industry-specific financial reports such as the Annual
Statement and the Life-1 are designed to meet the specific requirements of insur-
ance regulators, whose primary purpose is to safeguard insurer solvency and ensure
that the company can take care of its obligations to customers, even if it stops
doing business tomorrow. The Annual Statement must satisfy stricter accounting
requirements than the accounting requirements for preparing the annual report.
Investigating the insurer’s financial and business activities to ensure that they
do not present any hazards to the insurer’s solvency
External Audits
In the United States, federal securities laws require publicly traded companies,
including stock insurance companies, to undergo annual external audits of their
financial statements. An external audit, also called an independent audit, is an
examination and evaluation of a company’s records and procedures conducted by
public accountants—employees of a public accounting company who are not asso-
ciated with the company being audited.
External audits are performed primarily for the benefit of interested third par-
ties such as stockholders, creditors, policyowners, regulators, and government
authorities, who may rely on the information in a company’s annual report. An
external audit provides
An independent professional opinion as to whether a company’s financial state-
ments fairly present the company’s operations and that the statements were
prepared according to a given set of accounting principles and standards
Suggestions for changes to the company’s system of internal control
A report of audit findings
Although an external audit confirms whether a company’s annual report is a
fair representation of the company’s results, it does not guarantee the accuracy of
the company’s financial statements.
Comply with requirements for the use of independent external auditors to help
avoid any potential conflict of interest
CEOs and CFOs in Canada must also sign their companies’ financial state-
ments to attest to their accuracy.
Key Terms
financial management liabilities
accounting cash flow
financial reporting cash inflow
controller cash outflow
treasury operations financial statement
treasurer income statement
liquidity revenue
liquid assets expense
investment policies net income
investment objectives balance sheet
investment strategies surplus
portfolio basic accounting equation
asset/liability management (ALM) annual report
asset/liability manager insolvency
chief auditor current assets
aggressive financial strategy current liabilities
conservative financial strategy current ratio
risk capital and surplus ratio
investment Securities and Exchange Commission
investment risk (SEC)
operational risk Financial Industry Regulatory
product risk Authority (FINRA)
risk management Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and
diversification Consumer Protection Act
hedging Canadian Securities Association
enterprise risk management (ERM) (CSA)
profit Annual Statement
profitability Life-1
assets financial condition examination
Additional Activities
Look at your company’s organization chart. How do the areas of financial man-
agement in your company compare to the examples provided in this chapter?
Can you identify types of operational risk in your job? Have you ever experi-
enced event risk?
What are the differences between the annual report and the Annual State-
ment? For example, what is the audience or the purpose?
Endnotes
1. Stephen G. Harvey, Frank A. Mayer III, and Audrey D. Wisotsky, Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and
Consumer Protection Act: The Overhaul of the U.S. Financial System, Webinar Manual (Eau Claire,
WI: Lorman Education Services, 2010), http://www.bankerresource.com/ondemand/386639EAU
(19 Aug 2010).
Chapter 7
Accounting, Treasury
Operations, and Auditing
Objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to
Explain how the organization of accounting, treasury operations, and
auditing is based on the principle of segregation of duties
Give examples of how internal and external stakeholders use an insurer’s
financial information
Distinguish between financial accounting and management accounting
Describe the different types of financial accounting: premium
accounting, investment accounting, general accounting, and tax
accounting
Distinguish among accounting standards: generally accepted accounting
principles (GAAP), statutory accounting practices, and International
Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS)
Describe the primary components of an insurance company’s balance
sheet and income statement
Describe the categories of assets in the U.S. Annual Statement
Explain how insurance companies use management accounting tools
such as budgeting and cost accounting as control mechanisms
Describe the treasury operations activities of cash management and
liquidity management
Describe internal controls that life insurance companies use
Outline
Organization of Accounting, Treasury Operations
Treasury Operations, and Auditing Cash Management
Accounting Liquidity Management
Financial Accounting
Management Accounting
W
hat if a customer calls and wants information about your company’s
third-quarter financial results? Would you know where to direct that
customer to get this information? What if your company’s agency rat-
ing was recently downgraded and your customer read about it in the newspaper?
Would you have enough knowledge to describe in basic terms the reasons for the
downgrade? Understanding how your company, its customers, and other stake-
holders may use such information and being able to communicate basic financial
information to customers makes you a more valuable employee to your company.
The more you know about the potential impact a particular decision may have
on the company’s financial position, the better you understand the relationship
between your job and your company’s ultimate success.
Organization of Accounting,
Treasury Operations, and Auditing
As described in Chapter 6, accounting, treasury operations, and auditing are
closely related, but they are typically managed separately as a method of internal
control. The principle of segregation of duties, also called dual control, requires
an employer to design jobs so that job tasks do not place an employee in a posi-
tion to conceal errors or irregularities in the normal course of his employment.
For example, employees in treasury operations receive cash, and employees in
accounting record the receipt of that cash. Similarly, employees in accounting
approve payments for expenses and contractual benefits, and employees in trea-
sury operations disburse those payments. When a company designs jobs using this
principle to separate conflicting job functions, employees are not presented with
ethical challenges in their day-to-day work activities. We discuss other internal
controls throughout this chapter.
Accounting
Accounting is more than just counting money or keeping records. Generally,
accounting staff in a life insurance company gather, record, analyze, and distrib-
ute information about the company’s financial operations. The accounting depart-
ment performs the following specific activities:
Establishes a system of accounts, which is a systematic way for a company to
record, group, and summarize similar types of financial transactions
Maintains the company’s accounting records and investigates any discrepan-
cies in those records
Analyzes the company’s operating costs and allocates costs to the areas that
incur them
Prepares tax returns (some insurers establish a separate tax department for
this responsibility)
Accounting Systems
As you saw in Figure 7.1, external stakeholders have different needs for account-
ing information than do internal stakeholders. As a result, two general types of
accounting have been developed to meet the diverse needs of a company’s users of
accounting information.
Financial accounting is the process of reporting a company’s financial account-
ing information to meet the needs of the company’s external stakeholders.
Management accounting is the process of identifying, measuring, analyzing,
and communicating financial information to a company’s internal stakehold-
ers, particularly company managers, so they can decide how best to use the
company’s resources.
Note that one type of accounting is not a substitute for the other. Although both
types of accounting may use the same sources of financial information, sometimes
different accounting principles or financial reporting standards are used, as we
discuss later. The two types of accounting differ in several important ways, which
we summarize in Figure 7.2.
Financial Accounting
Financial accounting starts with recording all business transactions to which a
company must assign an objective monetary value. The end goal is to produce
the company’s financial statements, the standardized summary reports of a com-
pany’s major monetary events and transactions. Financial accounting is historical
because it is most concerned with events that have already taken place. Accoun-
tants use financial accounting to organize and summarize a company’s business
transactions so that the company can satisfy financial reporting requirements. The
basic financial accounting operations in life insurance companies are shown in
Figure 7.3.
Accounting Standards
Insurers are required by law to conduct their financial accounting activities in
accordance with specified accounting standards. Each country has its own set of
accounting standards with which insurers must comply for financial reporting
Premium accounting, also called policy accounting, is the accounting operation that
maintains detailed accounting records of all financial transactions related to the policies
an insurer has issued (sold). Premium accounting includes accounting for premiums,
commissions, claim payments, policy loans, and policy dividends. An insurer’s premium
accounting system bills policyowners, records premium payments, calculates producer
commissions, generates management reports and financial statements, and so on.
Investment accounting records transactions related to the assets in an insurer’s
investment portfolios. Because of the volume and monetary amount of investment
transactions, investment accounting is mostly automated. The investment accounting
system tracks and records cash inflows and cash outflows of the insurer’s investments
and investment valuations that will be included in the insurer’s financial statements.
General accounting includes the basic accounting operations that all businesses
undertake. One example is payroll accounting. Payroll accounting involves calculating
employees’ wages, preparing paychecks, maintaining payroll records, and producing
payroll reports for internal management and government agencies. Another type
of general accounting is disbursement accounting. The objectives of disbursement
accounting are to (1) provide a permanent record of all cash disbursed or paid out,
(2) confirm that all cash disbursements are properly authorized, and (3) ensure that all
disbursements are charged to the proper account. Disbursement accounting is usually
performed by a company’s accounts payable department.
Tax accounting keeps records related to all the company’s taxes and prepares tax
returns and filings such as tax forms for employee wages, producer commissions,
and policyowner benefit payments and withdrawals. Insurance companies also pay
premium taxes, which are taxes calculated on premium income an insurer earns within
a particular jurisdiction. Many large insurance companies have a separate function
devoted to tax accounting, which has its own set of reporting rules. In smaller insurance
companies, tax accountants are typically part of the accounting department.
purposes. For example, most countries require insurers to submit detailed finan-
cial statements—balance sheet, income statement, cash flow statement, and state-
ment of owners’ equity—to insurance regulators at least annually. Accounting
standards also advise how and when accountants recognize revenues and expenses
and how they value assets, liabilities, and capital.
Recognition is the process of (1) classifying items in a transaction as assets,
liabilities, capital, surplus, revenues, or expenses, and (2) recording the trans-
action in the company’s accounting records.
Valuation is the process of calculating the monetary value of a company’s
assets, liabilities, and capital for accounting and financial reporting purposes.
Accounting standards—such as standards for recognition, valuation, and for
the types of information to include in financial statements—vary significantly
across countries. In addition, countries that adopt the same standards may vary
widely in the method they use to determine how assets are valued, or how they
recognize certain revenues. What does this mean for an external stakeholder? It
may be difficult to compare insurers in different countries or to assess a foreign
insurer’s financial performance or condition. Having separate, sometimes conflict-
ing, accounting standards and reporting requirements also greatly complicates the
financial reporting process for insurers that do business in more than one country.
For example, many insurance companies in the United States routinely prepare
two sets of financial statements based on different sets of required standards in the
United States. In the near future, these companies face a unique challenge: two
sets of accounting standards, accompanied by increasing pressure to comply with
international standards, which have not yet been implemented.
Generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) are a set of financial
accounting standards, conventions, and rules that U.S. stock insurers follow when
summarizing transactions and preparing financial statements. Mutual and frater-
nal insurers in the United States currently also must comply with GAAP if they
sell variable insurance products or variable annuities. The underlying premise
of GAAP is the going-concern concept, which means that accounting records
are based on the assumption that a company will continue to operate indefinitely.
GAAP-based financial statements focus on profitability and use standardized defi-
nitions, valuation methods, and formats. Interested stakeholders can evaluate the
financial performance of one company from year to year and can compare the
financial performance of several companies that use U.S. GAAP.
Statutory accounting practices are the accounting standards that all life
insurers in the United States must follow when preparing the Annual Statement
and other financial reports that they must submit to state regulators. Statutory-
based financial statements focus on solvency. Insurance companies must satisfy
the statutory accounting requirements for each state in which they conduct busi-
ness. The NAIC approved the Codification of Statutory Accounting Principles,
which created a single, basic set of written standards for statutory accounting, to
help minimize the differences in standards among the states. Each state may adopt
the Codification or may elect to maintain its unique set of standards.
Generally, financial reports based on statutory accounting practices follow
accounting conservatism. Accounting conservatism typically understates the
values for a company’s assets, overstates the value of a company’s liabilities and
expenses, and projects a lower level of net income than would be the case if the
company used a less conservative reporting method, such as GAAP. Conservatism
Financial Reporting
The culmination of financial accounting is financial reporting—the preparation
and filing of required financial statements that summarize a company’s finan-
cial transactions and indicate the company’s financial health. The accounting
standards used to prepare these financial statements depend on the purpose of
the statements, the stakeholders for whom the statements are intended, and the
applicable laws.
To understand the financial management of a life insurance company, you need
to be familiar with certain financial statements. The two primary financial state-
ments that all types of businesses prepare are the balance sheet and the income
statement. In Chapter 6 we presented the major components of the balance sheet:
assets, liabilities, and capital. Figure 7.4 shows a simple balance sheet for an insur-
ance company.
Revenues
Premium Income $1,800,000
Net Investment Income 300,000
Total Revenues $ 2,100,000
asset amounts are permitted to be listed on the Assets page of the Annual State-
ment balance sheet. Assets not reported on the Assets page are reported elsewhere
in the Annual Statement. For purposes of reporting assets on the Annual State-
ment, life insurers divide their assets into three categories:
Admitted assets are those whose full value can be reported on the Assets
page of the Annual Statement. Typical admitted assets include cash and other
high-quality assets such as investment-grade securities and amounts due to
the insurer within 90 days.
Partially admitted assets are those for which only a portion of their mon-
etary value is reported on the Assets page of the Annual Statement. Partially
admitted assets include invested assets that are decreased by any amount that
exceeds the statutory investment limitations.
Nonadmitted assets are those that are not listed or valued on the Assets page
of the Annual Statement. These assets, which are presumed not to affect an
insurer’s ability to pay its future obligations, include furniture, office supplies,
advances to producers, speculative or low-quality investments, and amounts
due the insurer in 90 or more days. Requiring these assets to be reported
elsewhere in the Annual Statement is one way regulators ensure accounting
conservatism in an insurer’s accounting operations.
Other countries also require insurers to submit periodic financial reports to
appropriate regulatory authorities. However, the required format and the ele-
ments that must be included vary from those in the U.S. Annual Statement. Figure
7.6 illustrates how financial reporting requirements differ among jurisdictions.
Despite these differences, most jurisdictions are moving toward stricter solvency,
risk management, and capital management requirements.
Management Accounting
We’ve learned that financial accounting focuses on financial reporting require-
ments for external stakeholders. Management accounting, however, focuses on
financial information for internal stakeholders. Because management accounting
is for internal users only, no specific laws govern management accounting. Insurers
are free to design any type of management accounting reports they choose. Man-
agement accounting is future-focused in that it helps managers plan and implement
business strategies. However, management accounting also plays an important role
in controlling and evaluating existing operations.
Management accounting helps to identify areas of an insurer’s business, such
as product lines or operating units, that are not performing as planned. Manage-
ment accounting tools can be used to
Measure the profitability of products and services
Analyze operating costs and manage expenses
Canada
Effective January 1, 2011:
All companies must prepare financial statements and interim financial reports in
accordance with international financial reporting standards (IFRS).
All financial statements must be in compliance with international standards on
auditing.2
Budgeting
Budgeting is a management accounting process that creates a financial plan of
action designed to help an organization achieve its goals. Budgeting typically
projects revenues and expenses for a company as a whole as well as for indi-
vidual departments, products, lines of business, and profit centers. Typically, the
individual budgets for each department or area are combined into the company’s
master budget, which shows the overall operating and financing plans for the
company during a specified accounting period. A master budget includes budgets
for the company’s core business operations, cash, and capital budgeting for long-
term projects. A company’s master budget can also be thought of as a profit plan,
because achieving the goals in the master budget should result in profit for the
company. Most companies compile the master budget annually and update it semi-
annually to ensure that it provides reliable estimates of revenues and expenses.
Budgeting can also serve as an important control tool. At the end of a specified
accounting period, managers perform a variance analysis, in which they compare
actual results to budgeted amounts. Any discrepancy between the two amounts
requires investigation. A favorable variance occurs when actual revenues are
greater than expected revenues or actual expenses are less than expected expenses.
An unfavorable variance occurs when actual revenues are less than expected rev-
enues or actual expenses are greater than expected expenses.
Cost Accounting
One way to improve the solvency and profitability of an insurer’s operations
is to understand and control the company’s costs, another word for expenses.
Cost accounting is a system for accumulating and categorizing expense data.
The objectives of cost accounting are to (1) establish effective cost controls and
(2) generate accurate estimates of future costs for use in pricing a company’s
products. Insurers may use various terms for cost accounting such as expense
analysis, expense accounting, or cost allocation. Cost accounting enables a com-
pany’s managers to plan operations, organize employee workloads, and evaluate
current financial performance so that the company can make appropriate finan-
cial management decisions. Cost accounting helps an insurer answer questions
such as
What are our costs for a specific line of business?
What are the estimated future costs for a particular product?
Treasury Operations
Staff in treasury operations perform a variety of activities that may range from
processing check deposits to forecasting cash flows to serving as the insurer’s
liaison in banking relationships. Treasury operations staff in some insurance
companies also manage short-term invested assets because these assets can be
readily converted to cash. Most insurance companies administer treasury opera-
tions separately from investment transactions, so they must carefully coordinate
the activities of the two systems. For example, when the investment operations
staff purchases or sells a bond and the system records the transaction, authorized
employees in the treasury operations department can access the relevant informa-
tion. Ultimately, the timely communication of information, such as the amount of
available cash, is critical to effective management of an insurer’s cash and invest-
ments.
The control function for treasury operations focuses on key activities to ensure
that
Job duties for cash receipts, cash disbursements, and bank reconciliation are
segregated
Controls for authorization, check security, and accounting records for cash
disbursements are maintained
Advances in technology and economic treaties have streamlined treasury oper-
ations in some cases for multinational insurance companies. For example, some
European Union (EU) member countries have moved toward a Single Euro Pay-
ments Area (SEPA), which has reduced the labor and transactions costs associated
with cash receipts and cash disbursements within and among EU countries.4
Cash Management
In simple terms, when a policyowner remits a premium payment, it may come
through a wire transfer or lockbox—a post office box that policyowners use to
remit payments. The insurer’s automated accounting system records the cash
receipt. Staff in treasury operations who do not handle cash are assigned to rec-
oncile the deposit with the insurer’s bank statement, which is typically available
Liquidity Management
Most activities within treasury operations focus on managing the company’s liquid-
ity, which is closely related to solvency. If liquidity is not managed carefully, the
company may not have enough cash available to meet obligations as they come due.
Why? A sudden increase in cash surrenders as a result of declining economic con-
ditions could challenge an insurance company that did not plan for this possibility.
Insurance company employees who focus on liquidity also must work closely
with the insurer’s risk management team to ensure that the insurer is minimizing
specific risks, including interest-rate risk. Other treasury operation activities per-
formed in liquidity management include
Managing daily cash balances to determine the amount of cash to invest or to
borrow overnight (if the cash balance is below the minimum cash balance the
company requires)
Anticipating and coordinating short-term and long-term obligations to ensure
that cash is available to pay obligations on time
Auditing
In Chapter 6 we introduced auditing as an integral part of financial management.
Insurance companies routinely conduct audits to ensure that operations proceed as
efficiently as possible and as part of the control function to prevent anything from
going wrong. Recall that auditing is the process of examining and evaluating com-
pany records and procedures to ensure that (1) the company’s accounting records
and financial statements are presented fairly and reasonably, (2) quality assurance
is maintained, and (3) operational procedures and policies are effective.
One of the primary responsibilities of auditing is to conduct internal audits of
company operations—an essential part of a company’s risk management efforts.
An internal audit can focus on any area within the company and serves as an
internal control in various areas, including underwriting, customer service, and
claims.
An internal financial audit is a type of internal audit in which auditors evaluate
the accuracy of accounting and financial reporting, and the adequacy of controls
over cash and other assets. In particular, auditors attempt to determine whether
the company’s
Financial records are fair and accurate
Control procedures are adequate and are being followed
Auditing has traditionally been associated with the accounting function. How-
ever, auditing extends well beyond the accounting area. Any investigation of
records, policies, or procedures to ensure that they conform to established poli-
cies can be considered an audit. For example, insurance companies use audits to
evaluate their operating procedures, management efficiency, and compliance with
specified rules and regulations.
Internal Controls
Recall that an insurer’s internal controls are the steps the insurer takes to protect
its assets, monitor the accuracy of its accounting records, and encourage operat-
ing efficiency and adherence to management policies. Insurance companies have
many internal controls that may vary across companies. However, most insurers
have internal controls similar to those listed in Figure 7.7.
Claim examiners verify policy beneficiaries before proceeds are approved for
disbursement.
CSRs compare the monetary amounts of policy loan requests with amounts on
loan checks.
Investment purchases and sales are performed by different employees from
those who record and report the purchases and sales.
Senior management approves all claim payments over a specified monetary
amount.
Two senior managers must sign all disbursement checks over a specified
monetary amount.
Compliance employees review a random number of transactions to ensure that
regulations are being followed.
Employees in two different departments must handle receipt of cash and
recording the receipt of that cash.
Internal auditors review a random number of insurance applications to ensure
underwriters have assigned correct risk classes to prospective insureds, based
on given risk factors.
Internal auditors review all identified procedure variances.
Key Terms
segregation of duties International Financial Reporting
account Standards (IFRS)
financial accounting cash flow statement
management accounting statement of owners’ equity
premium accounting asset valuation
investment accounting admitted assets
general accounting partially admitted assets
tax accounting nonadmitted assets
recognition budgeting
valuation master budget
generally accepted accounting favorable variance
principles (GAAP) unfavorable variance
going-concern concept cost accounting
statutory accounting practices lockbox
accounting conservatism internal financial audit
Additional Activities
Find out how accounting, treasury operations, and auditing are organized at
your company.
Endnotes
1. “Revenue Recognition—Joint Project of the FASB and IASB,” Financial Accounting Standards Board,
last modified 3 May 2011, http://www.fasb.org/cs/ContentServer?c=FASBContent_C&pagename=
FASB%2FFASBContent_C%2FProjectUpdatePage&cid=900000011146 (10 May 2011).
2. Shevaun McGrath, “Canada: CSA Approves Amendments Related to Implementation of International
Finance Reporting Standards,” Mondaq, 1 November 2010, http://www.mondaq.com/canada/article.
asp?articleid=114054&tw=0 (10 May 2011)
3. Steve Foster et al., “Solvency II: What Will the Likely Impacts Be for Insurers?” (presentation
notes, Deloitte Dbrief Webcast, 18 August 2010), http://www.deloitte.com/view/en_US/us/Insights/
Browse-by-Content-Type/dbriefs-webcasts/230b4b30fc249210VgnVCM100000ba42f00aRCRD.htm
(18 August 2010).
4. Todd Rizzieri, “Managing Global Growth & Resources in Treasury” (presentation notes, 2008 LOMA
Financial Inforum, Hyatt Regency Coconut Point, Bonita Springs, Florida, May 2008).
Chapter 8
Investment Management
Objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to
Describe necessary elements in an insurer’s investment policy
Explain the risk-return trade-off and how an investor determines the
required rate of return on an investment
Describe how diversification decreases investment risk
Explain asset-liability management (ALM) and the differences between
a buy-and-hold strategy and an active management strategy
Distinguish between debt securities and equity securities and explain
how securities are bought and sold
Distinguish between an insurer’s general account and separate account
portfolios
List and describe the types of investments in which insurance companies
typically invest
Describe the characteristics that determine the degree of risk associated
with a bond
Describe the differences between policy loans and other insurance
company investments
Outline
Investment Policy Investment Portfolios
Investment Risk The General Account
I
nstitutional investing is the professional management of money that belongs
to others—individuals, corporations, and governments. The ways insurance
companies manage their own and others’ investments affect not only their
policyowners and stockholders, but also many others throughout the markets in
which the companies do business. By investing in a wide range of businesses and
industries, insurance companies help promote economic growth throughout the
world.
Staff in investment operations conduct investment management. Investment
management consists of all the activities performed to invest a company’s excess
cash, generally in long-term investments. Recall that short-term investments are
often the responsibility of treasury operations.
Investment Policy
As we described in Chapter 6, an insurer’s board of directors establishes invest-
ment policy and also supervises and directs the management of an insurer’s invest-
ments. When setting investment policy, the investment committee, or sometimes
the finance committee, researches the company’s financial position, its current
investments, and any conditions—such as the economic environment—that can
influence investment operations. The investment policy includes the
Types of risks that investment staff can and cannot take in making
investments
Maximum amount of money that each level of investment staff can autho-
rize for an investment without having to seek approval from a higher level of
authority within the company
Regulatory constraints on the insurer’s investment activities
Investment Risk
Within regulatory limitations, life insurers choose whether to pursue an aggres-
sive investment strategy, a conservative investment strategy, or a strategy that falls
somewhere in between. Recall that a conservative investment strategy focuses on
safeguarding the company’s capital rather than on earning high returns. Although
earning adequate returns is important for an insurer following a conservative
strategy, the insurer is willing to give up some potential returns in exchange for
reducing the risk of significant investment losses.
Diversification
To manage the overall risk levels in their investment portfolios, insurance com-
panies diversify their investments by investing in different types of assets. Diver-
sification helps an insurer achieve expected overall investment returns that are
consistent with the level of its tolerance for risk.
Suppose that an insurer invested all of its money in one type of asset and that
returns were much less than the insurer anticipated. The negative impact on the
insurer’s investment portfolio would be significant. However, if the insurer held
many types of assets in its portfolio, the lower return from one type of investment
would have only a minimal effect on the return of the entire portfolio. Insurers
pursue diversification by holding different types of investments, such as bonds,
stocks, mortgages, and real estate, and also by holding many different investments
within each category. Many insurers further diversify by holding investments in
different countries or different types of industries.
Investment Operations
Recall from Chapter 6 that an insurer’s asset/liability managers generally take
a portfolio approach to managing a company’s investments. For example, an
insurer may assign the earnings from a portfolio of bonds to support one of its
term life insurance products. In this way, investment managers can match spe-
cific assets with specific liabilities and can monitor and manage the cash flows of
each product line.
Another way to categorize an insurer’s investment strategy is by the amount
of trading done in the portfolio. Under a buy-and-hold strategy, investment staff
carefully select securities and expect to hold them for long periods, or until they
mature, are prepaid, or default. The total mix of the asset portfolio remains fairly
constant. Choosing appropriate securities is crucial for this strategy to succeed,
because the asset/liability manager bases investment success largely on the origi-
nal portfolio selections. Under an active management strategy, investment staff
view any investment in a portfolio as potentially tradable, if trading the invest-
ment would improve the portfolio’s performance. Theoretically, the entire mix of
assets in the portfolio can be changed at any time.
In reality, most insurers’ investment strategies fall somewhere between the two
extremes of buy-and-hold and active management. A strict buy-and-hold strat-
egy is generally too inflexible because asset/liability managers may need to make
changes in the portfolio depending upon changes in economic conditions, invest-
ment performance, policyowner needs, or asset/liability management require-
ments. Similarly, a strict active management strategy is generally undesirable
because selling a large portion of the company’s assets at any one time is risky.
In addition, a high rate of asset turnover can produce high brokerage commission
expenses and potentially unfavorable tax consequences. Active management also
requires more management time than a buy-and-hold strategy. Most insurance
companies aim for a balance between the two investment strategies.
Evaluating an Investment
Investment analysts conduct research into specific investment opportunities. For
example, investment analysts evaluate annual reports of companies issuing stocks
and bonds, interview the management of such companies, read financial publica-
tions, and screen potential investments using specialized investment management
software. Analysts also collect information about promising mortgage loan and
real estate investment opportunities. The portfolio managers and other members
of the investment staff examine this research and evaluate the various investments
and investment strategies needed to achieve the company’s investment goals.
Investment Portfolios
Unlike most investors, insurers must comply with regulatory requirements that
impose limits on the types and amounts of investments they make in their invest-
ment portfolios. These regulatory requirements are designed to
Require insurers to exhibit reasonable behavior with respect to prudent diver-
sification of their investment portfolios
Separate Accounts
Insurers that offer variable products maintain one or more separate account port-
folios. A separate account, also called a segregated fund or segregated account in
some countries, is one or more asset portfolios that support an insurer’s variable
products, such as variable life insurance policies and variable annuities.
The separate account is divided into various subaccounts, which consist of
pools of investments with distinct investment strategies. Based on their investment
goals and tolerance for risk, variable policyowners choose how their premiums,
and the cash values that accumulate under their policies, will be allocated to sub-
accounts. The insurer manages the purchase and sale of assets in the subaccounts
according to the customer’s allocation decisions. Therefore, investment gains and
losses are based on the customer’s own decisions. An insurer’s separate account
operates in much the same way as a mutual fund, an investment company that
pools the funds of customers and usually invests in a certain type of investment,
such as stocks, bonds, or other securities.
Investments held in an insurer’s separate account are not subject to the same
regulatory restrictions as the investments in the general account. European regu-
lations concerning the types of investments and the amounts of each investment
type that an insurer may hold in its general account and in separate accounts
are typically less restrictive than are those in the United States and Canada. For
example, the general account assets of European insurers typically include a larger
proportion of stocks than do the general account assets of U.S. insurers. However,
investment regulations governing the general account in some emerging insurance
markets are more stringent than are those in the United States.
Types of Investments
As mentioned earlier, the assets in an insurer’s investment portfolios can be clas-
sified generally according to whether the assets represent equity (an ownership
interest) or debt (a liability). Insurance companies primarily invest in (1) bonds,
(2) mortgages, (3) stocks, (4) real estate, and (5) policy loans.
Bonds
Bonds are one way that businesses and government entities raise money. A bond
represents a debt that the bond issuer—the borrower—owes to the bondholder,
the investor who owns the bond. The amount owed is specified on the bond and
is called the bond’s par value, face value, or maturity value. Typically, bonds are
issued with par values of $1,000, $10,000, or $100,000. The bond issuer is legally
obligated to pay the bondholder the par value of the bond on the maturity date.
In addition to repaying a bond’s par value, the bond issuer must usually make
periodic—typically semiannual—interest payments to the bondholder. Such inter-
est payments are called coupon payments because the amount of the interest pay-
ments is based on an interest rate, known as the coupon rate, specified on the
bond. Because the coupon rate is generally fixed for the life of the bond, bonds are
a type of fixed-income investment. If the bond issuer does not meet the repayment
terms of the bond, the bondholder has a legal claim on the assets of the issuer.
A bondholder can earn a return from (1) the receipt of coupon payments and
(2) a capital gain upon the sale of the bond before it matures. A capital gain is the
amount by which an investment is sold for more than its purchase price. A capital
loss is the amount by which an investment is sold for less than its purchase price.
A bond’s market price—that is, the price at which the bond can be traded in the
open market—is not necessarily the same as its par value because the price of a
bond changes as market interest rates change. In fact, during much of a bond’s life,
the market price differs from the par value. As interest rates rise, bond prices fall,
and as interest rates fall, bond prices rise. For this reason, bond prices and interest
rates are said to be inversely related.
Example:
The Glacier Insurance Company purchased a bond with a 6 percent coupon
rate that matures in 10 years. The insurer purchased the bond when it
was issued and paid the par value of $1,000. This bond provides annual
income of $60 ($1,000 par value × .06 coupon rate = $60), which is paid in
$30 semiannual interest payments.
One year later, market interest rates rose, and new bonds were being issued
with coupon rates of 7 percent. Because of this change in interest rates,
Glacier’s bond became less valuable in the marketplace. That is, if Glacier
tried to sell its bond for $1,000, it would have trouble finding a buyer;
buyers would instead purchase newly issued 7 percent bonds because
they provide $70 in annual income ($1,000 par value × .07 coupon rate =
$70), rather than the $60 that Glacier’s bond pays. To find a buyer for its 6
percent bond, Glacier would have to reduce the price below $1,000, or sell
the bond at a discount.
The same principle works in reverse. If interest rates had fallen to 4 percent
one year after Glacier purchased its 6 percent bond, the insurer’s bond,
which pays $60 in annual income, would be more valuable than a newly
issued bond that pays only $40 in annual income. Therefore, if Glacier
wished to sell its 6 percent bond, it could demand a price above the $1,000
par value, in which case the bond would sell at a premium.
Note that a bond is always worth its par value on the bond’s maturity date,
and the bond always pays the same coupon payment, regardless of how
much an investor pays to purchase the bond.
In many countries, bonds are the largest investment holding in the general
accounts of insurance companies. They are relatively safe investments that have
extremely predictable cash flows from the periodic coupon payments and the lump-
sum payment of principal at maturity. Bonds also can help with asset/liability man-
agement because an insurer can match the cash flows of various bonds with specific
liability cash flows such as expected policy and annuity benefit payments.
Insurance companies hold many bonds until their maturity date and use the
cash proceeds to pay benefits under insurance and annuity contracts and to pro-
vide guaranteed rates of return on whole life policies. Some insurers actively trade
bonds to take advantage of bond market segments that increase or decrease in
value.
Moody’s Investors Service and Standard and Poor’s Corporation assign a letter grade to a bond
issue. Bonds that are rated in the higher categories—at least Baa (Moody’s) or BBB (Standard &
Poor’s)—and that have the lowest risk of default are known as investment-grade bonds. Bonds
that are rated in the categories below investment grade are known as high-yield bonds or junk
bonds. Almost all of the bonds held in the general accounts of life insurance companies are invest-
ment grade.
Moody’s Standard & Poor’s Description
Aaa AAA Highest quality (lowest default risk)
Aa AA High quality
A A Upper medium grade
Baa BBB Medium grade
Ba BB Lower medium grade
B B Speculative
Caa CCC, CC Poor
Ca C Highly speculative
C D Lowest grade (highest default risk)
Types of Bonds
Bonds are often categorized by the type of entity or organization that issues them.
Two categories of bonds in which insurers invest are corporate bonds and govern-
ment bonds.
Corporate bonds are issued by corporations, typically very large corpora-
tions. Corporate bonds may be secured or unsecured, and many are callable.
Life insurance companies have been the largest institutional investors in the
U.S. corporate bond markets since the 1930s.
Government bonds are issued by national, state, provincial, or city govern-
ments to generate funds for government expenses, loan programs, or speci-
fied large projects. In the United States, three common types of government
bonds are federal government bonds, agency bonds, and municipal bonds.
Figure 8.3 describes these types of bonds. Most countries issue similar types
of government bonds.
www.loma.org Copyright © 2012 LL Global, Inc. All rights reserved.
Insurance Company Operations Chapter 8: Investment Management 8.13
Mortgages
People and businesses use mortgages to finance the purchase of real estate. A
mortgage is a long-term loan, secured by a pledge of specified property, that
the borrower agrees to pay off with regular payments of principal and interest.
Mortgages are debt securities and are used primarily for commercial property—
office buildings, shopping centers, and so on, or for residential properties such as
houses or condominiums. The borrower pays off the loan through the process of
amortization, which is the reduction of a debt by regular payments of principal and
interest that result in full payment of the debt by the maturity date. If the borrower
does not make the mortgage payments as they come due, the lender has the right to
seize the property pledged for the loan and sell the property to satisfy the loan.
Life insurance companies have always been an important source of mortgage
loans in the United States. Most of the mortgages held by insurers are commercial
mortgages that finance retail stores, shopping centers, office buildings, factories,
hospitals, and apartment buildings. Many of the mortgages that insurers originate
are used to pay off short-term, bank-financed construction loans that come due
when the construction is completed. The insurer and the borrower of a commercial
loan negotiate the terms of the loan. These terms include the loan amount, dura-
tion, and interest rate. By negotiating the loan terms, an insurer can match asset
cash flows with expected liability cash flows, such as benefit payments to policy-
owners and beneficiaries.
Changing market interest rates present significant risks to insurers that hold
mortgages with fixed interest rates. If interest rates rise considerably, the inter-
est an insurer earns from its mortgage investments will lag behind the interest
the insurer could earn on new investments. If interest rates fall considerably,
borrowers are likely to refinance their mortgage loans by paying off their exist-
ing loans and taking out new loans at lower interest rates. When a borrower
refinances, the insurer loses the income stream it had planned to receive from
the investment.
Mortgages, like bonds, are subject to the risk that the debtor may default
and not repay the loan. Unlike bonds that are rated by bond rating agencies,
mortgage loans do not have such a rating. As a result, evaluating the default
risk a mortgage presents is more difficult than evaluating the default risk a
bond presents.
Insurers that invest in residential mortgages do not usually hold individual
mortgage loans. Instead, these insurers typically participate in the residential mort-
gage market by buying mortgage-backed bonds. Such mortgage-backed bonds are
known as collateralized mortgage obligations (CMOs), which are bonds secured
by a pool of residential mortgage loans. Until recently, insurers preferred to invest
in CMOs because they could be bought and sold like bonds and were relatively
liquid. However, after these residential mortgage pools lost significant value as
a result of the worldwide financial crisis that began in 2007–2008, insurance
companies are now less likely to invest in CMOs.
Stocks
During the organization of many companies, the company issues stock to raise
cash in order to begin operations. Other companies operate as privately owned
organizations for a period of time before deciding to offer ownership shares
to the public. Common stock is a type of stock that entitles its owners to share
in the company’s dividend payments. Dividends may be paid in cash—cash
dividends—or in additional shares of stock—stock dividends. A stockholder may
also earn a capital gain upon the sale of the stock.
Generally, stocks are riskier than bonds. First, the cash flows associated with
stocks vary more than the cash flows of bonds. For most stocks, the amount of
a dividend can be changed over time and the dividend may not be paid at all. In
contrast, bond coupon payments are contractually fixed in amount and timing.
Second, stock prices tend to fluctuate much more than bond prices because stocks
have no maturity date and no maturity value. Third, stockholders have a lower
priority claim than do bondholders on the issuing company’s assets if the company
goes out of business. Stockholders are paid only if funds remain after bondholders
and other company creditors have been paid.
Because of the higher risks and irregular cash flows associated with stocks,
insurance regulations place limits on how much of an insurer’s general account
can be invested in stocks. Despite the risks associated with stocks, insurers in
most countries do hold a portion of their general account assets—and a large por-
tion of their separate account portfolios—in stocks.
Real Estate
In addition to financing other people’s purchases of real estate through investing
in mortgage loans, life insurance companies directly purchase real estate. Because
ownership is involved, real estate is classified as an equity investment. Most insur-
ers’ real estate holdings are investment properties, such as office buildings, apart-
ment complexes, and shopping centers in which available space is rented to gen-
erate income for the insurer. The remainder of an insurer’s real estate holdings
typically consist of land and buildings that the company uses for its home office
and regional offices.
Real estate investments provide insurers with a return in the form of rental
income and the opportunity for appreciation in the value of the investments. The
rate of current income received on real estate generally exceeds the rates of div-
idends paid on common stock. However, the income stream from a real estate
investment is unpredictable because of the possibility of vacancies in the proper-
ties. The unpredictable nature of real estate cash flows makes real estate invest-
ments less suited than bonds to meeting an insurer’s asset/liability management
needs. Also, real estate has less liquidity than do stocks and bonds, and the value
of a piece of real estate can fluctuate considerably over time. As a result, real estate
typically represents only a small portion of life insurers’ general account assets.
Insurers can acquire real estate through several methods. The simplest method
of acquiring real estate is outright purchase. The insurer may make the purchase
directly, or it may form a subsidiary company that specializes in real estate invest-
ments. Another option is for the insurer to join with other companies—insurers or
noninsurers—in purchasing a property. The partnering companies then share the
rental income from the property.
Another way for an insurer to invest in real estate is to participate in a sale-
and-leaseback transaction, under which the owner of a building sells the building
to an investor—in this case an insurance company—but immediately leases back
the building from the investor. The individual or organization that leases the build-
ing from the insurer is known as the lessee and is responsible for the maintenance
and operation of the building. The insurer, as lessor, is freed from maintenance
and other property administration responsibilities. However, the insurer receives
regular income in the form of lease payments from the lessee.
Figure 8.4 compares the characteristics of bonds with mortgages, stocks, and
real estate.
Less so than
Predictability Predictable,
bonds and Less so than
of Income Predictable but less so
sometimes very bonds
Stream than bonds
unpredictable
Provides
Some issues Yes No Yes
Collateral
Policy Loans
A policy loan is a loan a life insurance company makes to the owner of a life
insurance policy that has a cash value. When a life insurance policyowner borrows
against a policy’s cash value, the insurer classifies the loan to the policyowner as
an investment in the insurer’s accounting records. Although insurers charge cus-
tomers interest on policy loans, the interest rate is relatively low compared to the
rates of interest insurers earn on their other investments. Policy loans make up a
relatively small portion of the assets that life insurance companies hold. A high-
er-than-expected level of policy loans can limit the insurance company’s overall
portfolio investment returns because, by lending money to policyowners, the
insurer can’t invest it elsewhere for higher returns.
Life insurance policy loans differ in several ways from other insurance com-
pany investments.
An insurer can’t control the timing of a policy loan; the policyowner makes
the decision to take out a policy loan.
Policy loans, unlike other loans, do not require the borrower to make system-
atic payments to repay the loan. As a result, an insurer can’t count on a steady
stream of cash inflows from its outstanding policy loans.
In contrast to other debt instruments, policy loans do not have contractual
maturity dates. A customer does not have to pay back the policy loan or the
loan interest as long as the policy has enough cash value to secure the loan
plus any accrued interest. However, the insurer does deduct any outstanding
policy loan and accrued interest from the benefit payable when the insured
person dies.
Key Terms
institutional investing subaccount
investment management mutual fund
interest spread par value
risk-return trade-off maturity date
principal coupon rate
required rate of return capital gain
risk-free rate of return capital loss
risk premium bond rating
buy-and-hold strategy investment-grade bond
active management strategy call provision
investment activity report convertible bond
investment portfolio performance collateral
review debenture
debt security mortgage
bond amortization
equity security collateralized mortgage obligation
public offering (CMO)
private placement common stock
securities exchange sale-and-leaseback transaction
over-the-counter (OTC) market lessee
general account lessor
fixed-income investment policy loan
separate account
Additional Activities
If you want to relate the information in this chapter to your company, try these
activities:
Think about the organization of your company’s investment management
function. Is it decentralized or centralized? What are some advantages gained
from each form of organization?
Look at the breakdown of assets in your company’s annual report. What per-
centage of assets does your company hold in bonds, stocks, mortgages, and
policy loans? Why do you think the company has more of one investment than
another?
If possible, look at your company’s annual reports for the previous three or four
years. How has the percentage of assets held in various asset classes changed
over this period? If it has changed, can you think of reasons why?
Endnotes
1. Bond issuers typically call bonds when market interest rates drop. Then issuers can issue new bonds
with lower coupon rates. If a bond that an insurer is holding is called, and the insurer wishes to reinvest
the proceeds in another bond, it will probably have to purchase a bond with a coupon rate that is lower
than the original bond’s coupon rate.
Chapter 9
Marketing
Objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to
Describe how insurers organize their home office and agency marketing
operations
Identify and describe the essential elements of a marketing plan
Identify and describe the four variables that make up the marketing mix
Distinguish among four promotional tools insurers use to help them
convey their messages to customers
Define positioning and identify the bases on which insurers position
themselves in the marketplace
Describe how insurers use market segmentation and target marketing to
identify the customers most likely to buy their products
Distinguish among three primary types of target marketing strategies
Describe different sources that insurers use for obtaining marketing
information
Identify elements in the internal and external marketing environments
Describe marketing control mechanisms
Outline
Organization of Marketing Identifying Markets
The Marketing Plan Segmenting Markets
A
dvertising and selling are only two parts of a much larger and broader
marketing process. Marketing is the activity, set of institutions, and pro-
cesses for creating, communicating, delivering, and exchanging offerings
that have value for customers, clients, business partners, and society at large.1
Marketing begins long before a product is offered for sale. The process begins
when a company learns about its customers and their needs in order to develop
products to satisfy those needs. The marketing process continues as the developed
products and services are promoted and distributed to prospective customers.
Finally, the marketing process includes tracking how the products perform in the
marketplace and how customers respond to various marketing efforts.
Through the process of marketing, insurers identify customers’ needs for finan-
cial security and develop insurance and annuity products they believe will best
satisfy those needs. Insurers sell or distribute their products to customers through
a variety of methods, including using producers to personally sell their products.
Insurers also use a variety of promotions, often aiming those promotional efforts
at customers as well as producers.
Organization of Marketing
Insurance companies typically structure their marketing operations so that a vice
president or an executive vice president is in charge of marketing. How companies
structure the remainder of their marketing activities varies greatly depending upon
the size of the company and how products are distributed. Insurers that distribute
their products primarily through producers may separate those operations into an
area commonly known as agency operations. In such cases, agency operations and
marketing would both be headed by an executive at the vice president level who
reports to the president or CEO of the company. In such companies, marketing
activities are divided between corporate and agency operations as follows:
Corporate marketing oversees, among other things, companywide marketing
campaigns directed primarily to external customers.
CEO
Executive VP,
Executive VP,
Agency
Marketing
Operations
Customer Agency
Marketing Marketing
Other insurers combine their marketing operations. In this case, if the insurer
has agency operations, one vice president or manager oversees marketing activi-
ties for both corporate and agency operations. For example, the vice president of
advertising may oversee the development of advertising campaigns for customers
and producers. Figure 9.2 shows a simplified marketing structure for this type of
insurance company.
Regardless of organizational structure, marketing staff work with many other
areas of the company. For example, product development teams include representa-
tives from marketing. In some small companies, the vice president of marketing is
also the head of product development. In addition, home office support for product
distribution activities generally flows through an insurer’s marketing department.
We’ll take a look at some of these home office support activities when we describe
distribution in Chapter 11.
CEO
Customer Agency
Marketing Marketing
Product
Product refers to the goods, services, or ideas that a seller offers to customers to
satisfy a need. For example, life insurers sell life insurance products to satisfy
customers’ needs for protection against financial loss in the event of death. Life
insurers sell many types of life insurance, including individual and group life
insurance, cash value life insurance, term life insurance, variable life insurance,
and variable universal life insurance. In addition, life insurers sell an assortment
of immediate, deferred, fixed, and variable annuities. A product mix, also called a
product portfolio, is the total assortment of products available from a company.
High-level members of a company’s management team set corporate market-
ing strategies that determine the products in an insurer’s product mix. Typically,
an insurer bases its product mix decisions on its particular expertise, its current
resources, its licenses, its overall marketing objectives and strategies, and its com-
petitors’ product mixes.
Example: The Bountiful Life Insurance Company develops and sells fixed
annuities. Bountiful’s marketing department recognizes that there is
a market for variable annuities. However, Bountiful has decided not to
enter into the variable annuity market because a variable annuity product
would not fit well with its conservative product mix strategy. In addition,
the company cannot pursue that opportunity without a significant initial
investment of resources.
Price
Price is the monetary value of whatever a customer gives in exchange for a product.
The price of an insurance product is based on a combination of financial features
that are known as the financial design of the insurance product. From a marketing
perspective, the financial design of a product should consider
Competition. Competitors’ pricing strategies and their prices for similar
products can strongly affect the latitude a company has in pricing its own
products.
Promotion
Promotion is the collection of activities that companies use to make customers
aware of their offerings and to influence customers to purchase, and distributors
to sell, a product. Promotion may include anything from one-on-one conversations
with potential customers to television advertising. An insurer wants to maximize
the impact of the company’s message while controlling overall promotion costs.
Insurers use four promotion tools to help them convey their messages to custom-
ers: personal selling, sales promotion, advertising, and publicity.
Personal selling is a promotion activity that relies on a company’s producers
presenting information to one or more prospective customers. Personal selling
allows a company to (1) communicate information about complex financial
products, (2) provide immediate responses to customer questions, and (3) tai-
lor the sales presentation to potential customers’ needs. The major disadvan-
tage of personal selling is that it costs more to reach each potential customer
than using other promotion tools such as advertising, sales promotion, or pub-
licity. We describe how insurers use personal selling as a distribution method
in Chapter 11.
Sales promotion includes incentive programs, usually monetary, designed to
encourage producers to sell a product or customers to purchase a product.
In insurance, sales promotions are typically aimed at producers rather than
customers because regulations often prohibit offering gifts or prizes as an
inducement to buy a particular insurer’s product unless such inducements are
offered to everyone.
Distribution
Distribution is the collection of activities and resources involved in making prod-
ucts available for customers to buy. Insurers currently use three primary types of
systems to distribute insurance products.
Personal selling distribution systems. Producers who either receive com-
missions or salaries from insurance companies sell products through oral and
written presentations.
Third-party-institution distribution systems. Banks or other financial
institutions sell insurance products to their own customers but do not issue the
insurance products.
Direct response distribution systems. Insurers initiate or conduct the sales
process by communicating directly with customers through direct mail, tele-
marketing, or the Internet.
Positioning
Insurers develop marketing mix strategies in order to achieve a desired position
in the marketplace. Positioning is the process by which a company establishes
and maintains in customers’ minds a distinct place, or position, for itself and its
products. Through positioning, an insurer attempts to distinguish itself from other
insurers by building a company image or product image that contrasts with the
images that competitors offer. Positioning is particularly important in the insur-
ance industry, where a large number of competitors offer similar products. In other
words, to the average insurance customer, all insurance products are the same. An
insurer may position itself on the basis of
Company or product attributes
Types of products offered
Markets served
Distribution characteristics
For example, an insurer might attempt to position itself as “the most financially
stable company” or “the highest-rated company in customer service.” Other insur-
ers may position themselves to appeal to customers who want to purchase insur-
ance products using the Internet or to customers who want to develop a long-term
relationship with a producer. The insurer develops its marketing campaign and
promotional materials to support its intended position.
Marketing goals should always align with the overall strategic (long-term)
goals of the company. For example, suppose a company’s strategic goal is to be
an industry leader in sales of term life insurance. What would this company’s
marketing mix look like? It should contain specific product, price, promotion, and
distribution strategies that will help the company sell term life insurance policies
to customers who have a need for such insurance.
Identifying Markets
No life insurance company can profitably serve the needs of every possible cus-
tomer. Instead, insurers direct their marketing efforts toward people whose needs
the company can feasibly meet and whose business will contribute to the compa-
ny’s earnings, growth, and overall financial strength. Before beginning to develop
and market its products, a life insurance company typically (1) identifies and evalu-
ates the total market for the products the company is positioned to offer, (2) selects
the segments of the total market on which the company will focus its marketing
efforts, and (3) develops and implements a marketing mix strategy to satisfy the
needs of the chosen market segments. To accomplish these tasks, marketers target
specific segments of the market.
Segmenting Markets
Market segmentation is the process of dividing large, diverse markets into smaller
submarkets that are more alike and need similar products or marketing mixes.
Each submarket, or group of customers with similar needs, is known as a market
Identifying markets. Marketers examine and select potential markets for the
company's products. Market identification typically involves segmenting the total
market into smaller submarkets and determining which market segments to target.
Collecting and evaluating marketing information. Marketing research analysts
gather and evaluate information about the company's internal and external
environments to develop sound marketing strategies.
Planning and controlling. Insurance marketers must have a plan for achieving their
marketing goals and ways to assess how well their plan is working. Insurers develop
marketing plans and then compare marketing results to the marketing plan. Insurers
then modify their marketing activities as needed to meet the plan's objectives.
Product development. Marketers participate in many of the activities needed to
manufacture or revise products to meet the needs of a particular market.
Product pricing. Marketers contribute to the financial design of an insurance
product by providing information about the prices of similar insurance products
available in the market.
Promotion. Marketers manage the various activities—personal selling, advertising,
sales promotion, and publicity—that the insurer uses to influence customers to
purchase its products.
Distribution. Marketers help coordinate the activities and resources needed to
make products available to customers. Producer and customer communications are
critical to the success of any distribution plan. Thus, the head of distribution relies
on strong communication support from marketing.
The more narrowly defined each market segment is, the more precisely the
insurer can identify the needs of that segment and focus its marketing efforts on
those needs.
Target Marketing
Once a company has subdivided the total market into clearly defined market
segments, the company can conduct target marketing. Target marketing is the
process of evaluating the attractiveness of each market segment to the company
and selecting one or more of the segments—the target markets—on which to
focus the company’s marketing efforts. Because each target market requires its
own marketing mix, a life insurance company’s choice of target markets helps
determine which products the company develops, the financial design of those
products, how the company distributes those products, and the advertising and
promotion techniques the company uses.
Marketing Information
At the heart of insurance company marketing activities is information—information
about market segments, the company itself, its competitors, the regulatory environ-
ment, and many other factors. Marketing information helps an insurer identify and
define marketing opportunities and threats; determine which customers to pursue,
what products these customers need and are most likely to purchase, and the most
effective ways to promote products to these customers; monitor marketing perfor-
mance; and improve the marketing process. Specifically, marketing information
provides answers to the following types of questions:
What are the general economic and business trends in the industry?
What are the demographic trends in our target markets?
What differentiates our products and services from those of our competitors?
What changes might we make to the financial design of our products to give
ourselves a competitive advantage?
sources such as databases and website traffic analysis, existing external sources of
information about competitors and markets, and industry research studies. Some-
times insurers need information that is not readily available through the marketing
information system. In such cases, insurers conduct research to identify marketing
opportunities or solve a specific marketing challenge.
Internal Databases
Insurers store considerable amounts of product data, sales data, and other types of
data in extensive internal databases. These internal databases can provide detailed
information about a wide variety of topics, including products, promotions, distri-
bution, customers, customer interactions, and markets.
Insurers obtain most of their competitive and market intelligence from publicly
available sources. Figure 9.6 lists some of the most common sources of these
types of marketing intelligence.
Competitors’ websites
Competitors’ advertisements
Competitors’ publications that are available to the general public, such as their
annual reports or annual employee benefits’ surveys
Competitors’ financial reports to regulatory agencies
Marketing Research
When required information is unavailable from existing sources, insurers may
engage in marketing research—a process of collecting, analyzing, interpreting,
and reporting information in order to identify marketing opportunities and solve
marketing problems. Marketing research is often done on an as-needed or onetime
basis and can provide information that is specifically tailored to an insurer’s needs.
The major disadvantage of marketing research is the high cost. Marketing research
projects often gather information about customers’ needs, motivations, preferences
for products and distribution channels, and satisfaction with current products
and services. Some insurance companies outsource part or all of their market-
ing research activities to research providers because they find it more economical
Marketing Environment
Marketing information is invaluable but cannot be the sole basis for marketing
decisions. For example, marketing research may uncover an underserved target
market. However, if the economy is in an economic downturn, the marketing deci-
sion may be to wait on pursuing this new target market until a later time.
Insurers analyze marketing information within the context of the company’s
current marketing environment. The marketing environment consists of all of
the elements in the company’s internal and external environments that directly or
indirectly affect the company’s ability to carry out its marketing activities. A com-
pany’s internal environment consists of those elements within the company that
affect the company’s business functions and over which the company has control,
including financial, physical, technological, and human resources; internal organi-
zational structure; and the marketing mix. The external environment consists of
elements that are outside the company and over which the company has little or no
control, including economic, competitive, regulatory, taxation, and social factors.
Marketing Controls
After a marketing plan has been in effect for a specified period of time, market-
ing managers attempt to determine if they are achieving the goals set out in the
marketing plan. For example, did sales of variable annuities increase as a result
of an advertisement targeted to high-wage earners? Companies typically state
performance standards in their marketing plan goals. Companies gauge whether
they achieve their goals by comparing actual performance with the performance
standard. Insurers use control tools such as sales analysis, expense analysis, and
profitability analysis to measure marketing performance. In a sales analysis, a
company examines its sales numbers to evaluate current performance. Current
actual sales are often compared to forecasted sales, sales in previous years, com-
petitors’ sales, or other performance standards. Expense analysis ties marketing
costs to particular marketing activities to help marketing managers decide if a
cost is worth the value of the activity. Profitability analysis compares the sales
an activity generates with the expenses incurred to make those sales to determine
profitability.
If performance does not match the standard, then the insurer investigates to
determine the reasons for the discrepancy. Sometimes the performance standard
was unrealistic because of inaccurate projections, stronger than expected competi-
tion, or unexpected changes in the external environment. If a company can iden-
tify a problem, the company typically attempts to correct the problem by taking
one or more of the following actions:
Changing tactical/action programs or implementation strategies
Reviewing performance standards to make sure that the standards are valid
and realistic
Insurers may conduct a marketing audit to examine marketing goals, strate-
gies, tactical/action programs, organizational structure, and personnel on a very
broad basis. Alternatively, a marketing audit may look at one aspect of marketing
operations. Regardless of type, the audit should include a review of the interaction
of other functional units with the marketing department. Independent vendors are
often hired to perform marketing audits.
Key Terms
marketing consumer market
marketing plan organizational market
marketing mix multivariable segmentation
product target marketing
product mix target market
price undifferentiated marketing
financial design concentrated marketing
purchasing power differentiated marketing
promotion marketing information system
personal selling unique visitors
sales promotion page views
advertising marketing research
institutional advertising marketing environment
product advertising internal environment
publicity external environment
distribution sales analysis
positioning expense analysis
market segmentation profitability analysis
market segment marketing audit
single-variable segmentation
Additional Activities
If you want to relate the information in this chapter to your company, try these
activities:
Look at your company’s most recent advertisements. Are these examples of
institutional or product advertising?
Endnotes
1. American Marketing Association, “The American Marketing Association Releases New Defini-
tion for Marketing,” press release, 14 January 2008, http://www.marketingpower.com/AboutAMA/
Documents/American%20Marketing%20Association%20Releases%20New%20Definition%20
for%20Marketing.PDF (27 May 2011).
2. “Dictionary,” s.v. “marketing information system,” Marketing Power, http://www.marketingpower.
com/_layouts/Dictionary.aspx?dLetter=M (27 May 2011).
3. “Dictionary,” s.v. “unique visitors,” Marketing Power, http://www.marketingpower.com/_layouts/Dic-
tionary.aspx?dLetter=U (27 May 2011).
4. “Dictionary,” s.v. “page view,” Marketing Power, “http://www.marketingpower.com/_layouts/Diction-
ary.aspx?dLetter=P (27 May 2011).
Chapter 10
Product Development
Objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to
Describe three types of new insurance products
Describe the steps in the product development process
Explain how insurers generate and screen ideas for new products and use
concept testing to evaluate new products
Describe the five elements of comprehensive business analysis and
identify the responsibilities of an insurer’s functional areas in this
process
Explain the technical design stage of product development
Describe the actions insurers take during the product implementation
stage of product development
Describe Day 1 and Day 2 functionalities that must be put into place
during product implementation
Describe how insurers monitor, evaluate, and use feedback to improve
their product offerings as well as their product development process
Outline
The Product Development Process
Product Planning
Comprehensive Business Analysis
Technical Design
Product Implementation
Performance Monitoring and
Review
P
roduct development—the process of creating or modifying a product—is
one of an insurer’s essential marketing and profit-generating activities. Why
is product development so important? The majority of an insurer’s revenues
typically come from product sales. As a product ages and competitors develop new
products, the older product becomes less attractive to producers and customers,
and eventually becomes obsolete. In addition, regulatory changes sometimes make
products obsolete and new ones possible. Thus, insurers are continually creating
new or modified products in order to stay competitive, satisfy customer needs, and
meet regulatory requirements. Yet product development is an expensive process that
requires a lot of human, technological, and financial resources. Too, there is always
the risk that the new product won’t perform as expected, causing the insurer to lose
revenues and market share, and experience lower customer satisfaction. Effective and
efficient product development helps ensure that
New products are consistent with an insurer’s overall strategic marketing
objectives for the company’s product mix
New products generate enough revenue to pay associated benefits and expenses
as well as return a modest profit to the company’s owners
Because product development is so important to insurance companies, most
companies have a dedicated product development team. At some companies, the
team members work exclusively on product development. An actuary often leads a
company’s product development team, and the team includes members from virtu-
ally every operational area, including agency operations.
Many insurance companies follow the five basic product development steps
shown in Figure 10.2. At the end of the first three steps, senior management deter-
mines whether to (1) continue development of the new product idea, (2) request
additional information or a revision to the product idea, or (3) drop the new
product idea.
Product Planning
Comprehensive
Business Analysis
Product
Implementation
Performance
Monitoring and
Review
Product Planning
Product planning consists of three basic activities: idea generation, screening, and
concept development and testing.
Idea generation involves searching for new product ideas that are consis-
tent with the company’s overall product development strategy and the needs
of its target markets. Ideas for new products come from a wide variety of
sources inside and outside the insurance company. Many of these ideas come
from marketing, either from the sales force or from marketing intelligence
and research. Company managers and employees, customers, consultants, and
consumer groups also contribute ideas. Companies that are the most success-
ful at generating new product ideas have an ongoing, formal identification pro-
cess and procedures that encourage employees and others to submit product
ideas. Generally, companies stress creativity more than the technical details of
a new product idea during idea generation.
Screening is a weeding-out process designed to evaluate each new product
idea quickly and inexpensively and to select those ideas that warrant further
investigation. Idea screening involves only a limited evaluation of each prod-
uct idea. For example, the project team looks at such things as whether the new
product (1) is compatible with the company’s corporate goals and existing sys-
tems and distribution channels, (2) satisfies a real need in the target markets in
which the company operates, or (3) replaces sales of existing products instead
of generating new sales. Companies reject more new product ideas during the
screening phase than during any other phase of the development process.
Concept testing is a marketing research technique designed to measure the
acceptability of new product ideas, new promotion campaigns, or other new
marketing elements before entering production. Concept testing for new prod-
uct ideas involves describing the ideas to producers or potential purchasers
and then obtaining their feedback to determine which product ideas have the
greatest appeal. Focus groups—small group interviews, led by a moderator,
in which participants discuss their opinions or feelings about a given topic—
can be used for concept testing. Concept testing might also involve an online
survey where a model of the product is described to survey participants who
then give an opinion as to whether the idea seems interesting to them and
whether they would want to learn more or consider buying it. By gathering the
opinions of the people who will be selling and buying the potential product,
concept testing can provide valuable information about the product idea before
the company incurs the expenses of actually designing and implementing the
ideas. Typically, the more innovative a new product idea is, the greater the
emphasis a company will place on concept testing.
extensive research into all the factors likely to affect the design, production, pricing,
marketing, and sales potential of the new product. Companies typically conduct a
more extensive analysis for completely new products than for modified products. A
comprehensive business analysis typically includes the following five elements:
A market analysis, which is an evaluation of all of the environmental factors
that might affect product sales, including target market characteristics, eco-
nomic conditions, legal or regulatory requirements, and tax considerations.
For example, factors such as customer needs and similar products that com-
petitors offer may affect a product’s performance.
Product design objectives, which specify an insurance product’s basic charac-
teristics, features, benefits, issue limits, age limits, commission and premium
structure, and operational and administrative requirements. Product design
objectives serve as guidelines for the technical design step of the product
development process.
A feasibility study, which is research designed to determine, from an opera-
tional and technical viewpoint, (1) how viable it would be for the company
to produce and offer the product and (2) how the new product would impact
the company’s existing products. A feasibility study often involves a review
of other companies’ sales of similar products or discussions with key product
distributors.
A marketing plan, which describes the marketing goals and strategies for a
product or product line and includes specific, detailed activities for how a pro-
posed product will be priced, promoted, and distributed. A marketing plan
may also include an exit strategy to determine what to do if a new product is
unsuccessful.
Marketing projections, which are preliminary sales and financial forecasts
that include estimates of potential unit sales, revenues, costs, and profits for a
proposed product. These projections, which specify an expected or most likely
value—rather than the best-case or worst-case value—help determine how
financially viable a new product will be. Early estimates are modified as the
product development process continues and additional information becomes
available.
If the comprehensive business analysis indicates a product has good potential,
the product development team incorporates these results into a formal product
proposal and presents it to top management for approval. If approved, the com-
prehensive business analysis serves as the overall guide for product design and
development, testing, and introduction. Figure 10.3 describes the responsibilities
of staff in various functional areas during a comprehensive business analysis.
Technical Design
After management approves a new product proposal, the development team for-
mulates the detailed product design that expands upon the research and other pre-
liminary work done during the comprehensive business analysis. Actuaries create
the financial design of the new product using computer models. These models
Marketing
Conducts a market analysis to determine whether customers want the new product
Prepares a marketing plan and marketing projections
Gathers and analyzes information about potential target markets and competitors’ products
Evaluates how the new product might affect in-force business and sales of the insurer’s current
products
Determines the most appropriate distribution channels and advertising and sales strategies
Works with the compliance area to determine the best test markets in terms of legal requirements
and prohibitions
Agency Operations
Determines if changes are necessary for the current sales force to sell the new product
effectively
Helps determine the proper training materials for producers
Must be very responsive to the communications that the marketing department sends out for
both test phase and ultimate launch
Actuarial
Develops product design objectives with advice from other functional areas, including market-
ing, underwriting, and compliance
Performs preliminary calculations to determine if the new product can be priced to be competi-
tive and profitable within a reasonable time frame
Underwriting
With advice from actuarial, establishes initial underwriting guidelines
Investments
With advice from actuarial, determines what types of investments are needed to support the
expected payment of benefits under the new product and also to add to the company’s profits
Claim Administration
Examines claim assumptions made by actuarial staff in product design
Determines whether current claim systems and staff can adequately administer new product
Customer Service
Considers whether current staff and procedures are adequate to support new product
Estimates any additional staffing costs for new product
Information Technology
Assesses whether the current information systems can support the new product
Estimates any costs necessary to upgrade or outsource systems
Accounting
Reviews financial reporting requirements that the insurer must meet in developing and selling
the new product
Evaluates how the new business will be reflected in the company’s financial statements
Legal/Compliance
Assists in developing the product design objectives
Reviews the product to ensure that it complies with all legal and regulatory requirements in the
jurisdictions in which it will be sold
Determines policy filing requirements and whether the product will be prohibited in any
jurisdictions
Advises marketing during the development of product advertisements
Product Implementation
After the company finalizes the new product’s design and other details, the com-
pany must take various steps before it can begin selling the product. Product
implementation involves establishing the administrative structures and processes
needed to introduce a product into the marketplace. Implementation consists of
three concurrent activities:
Obtaining necessary regulatory approvals
Designing promotion and training materials
Developing and putting into place all information systems and procedures
necessary to market and administer the product
Regulatory Approval
Staff members in an insurer’s legal or compliance area obtain legal approval for
a new or modified product according to the requirements of the jurisdiction in
which the product will be sold. Policy filing is the act of submitting a policy con-
tract form and any other legally required forms and documents to the appropriate
regulatory authority for approval. Among other things, regulators check that man-
datory provisions are included in a policy and that policy provisions prohibited by
law are excluded. The requirements may vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction.
Figure 10.4 describes policy filing requirements in several countries.
insurance policies, and educates customers about how to compare the costs of
similar types of policies. A policy summary is another document that insurers
in the United States must provide to all potential insurance purchasers. A policy
summary provides the customer with information specific to the policy being pur-
chased, including premium and benefit data for the first five policy years. For
annuity products, the policy summary is called a disclosure document. For vari-
able products, insurers in the United States must provide prospective purchasers
with a prospectus—a written document describing specific aspects of the security
being offered for sale such as the insurer’s investment philosophy and objectives,
fund expenses and fees, and past product performance. Generally, promotion and
sales materials must accurately represent the terms of the policy and not be untrue,
deceptive, or misleading.
Because systems activities often require the greatest amount of time in the prod-
uct development process, they should be started as early as possible. To speed up
the implementation process, a growing number of companies are dividing imple-
mentation activities into two categories: Day 1 functionality, which represents
the administrative and systems processes that must be in place and functioning
when the first contract is sold, and Day 2 functionality, which represents the pro-
cesses that are necessary at some future date to service and administer the prod-
uct, but which can be implemented after the product has been launched. Allowing
a product to be introduced to the market before all implementation processes have
been completed can shorten the time it takes insurers to get a product to market.
However, if the company experiences unexpected delays in implementing the later
processes, the company may suffer additional expenses, customer dissatisfaction,
and loss of business.
grow slowly at first. Producers need time to understand the product and feel com-
fortable selling it. However, if sales are significantly below expectations, inves-
tigation is necessary to determine possible reasons for the poor sales. Perhaps a
competitor has introduced a similar product with more competitive premiums or
benefits. Perhaps promotion and training activities were inadequate, so producers
are unaware of the product or feel insufficiently trained in how to sell the product.
Perhaps the compensation structure for producers is inadequate.
If the product fails to meet projections because of weaknesses in the product
itself or in the way it is marketed, the insurer often takes steps to modify the
design of the product. If the product is not profitable enough, the insurer may
need to tighten its underwriting requirements or reduce the costs of administer-
ing and marketing the product. The company may need to revise the commission
or incentive structure of the product to encourage producers to sell the product or
reduce its price to make it more competitive. If the problem seems to be with the
distribution, the insurer may need to advertise the product more or consider other
distribution methods.
A company that can’t effectively or efficiently modify a poorly performing
product may withdraw the product from the market. In general, withdrawal means
no longer soliciting new product sales. However, existing insurance contracts often
remain in force and must continue to be serviced, in some cases for decades after
the product is withdrawn from the market.
Key Terms
product development field advisory council
idea generation product implementation
screening policy filing
concept testing readability requirements
focus groups issue instructions
comprehensive business analysis Buyer’s Guide
market analysis policy summary
product design objective prospectus
feasibility study Day 1 functionality
marketing projections Day 2 functionality
Additional Activities
If you want to relate the information in this chapter to your company, try these
activities:
Think about how your company’s introduction of a new product impacts your
job. Do you have to attend training and learn new procedures, or will it have
little or no impact upon your current job?
Determine whether members of your company’s product development team
have other job responsibilities in addition to their duties on the product devel-
opment team. Larger companies usually have ongoing product development
teams whose members have no other job responsibilities.
Obtain a copy of a Buyer’s Guide, if one is required in your jurisdiction, and
see if you can compare the costs of the various policies your company offers.
Endnotes
1. “Regulatory Measures of the CIRC,” China Insurance Regulatory Commission, http://www.circ.gov.
cn/web/site45/tab2744/i24832.htm (27 May 2011).
2. “Life Insurance Products—File & Use Procedure | Irda,” Bimadeals, http://www.bimadeals.com/
insurance/insurance-info/life-insurance-products-%E2%80%93-file-use-procedure-irda/ (27 May
2011).
Chapter 11
Product Distribution
Objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to
Distinguish between product distribution systems and channels
Distinguish between an employee and an independent contractor
Describe the characteristics of career agents, multiple-line agents,
independent agents, salaried sales representatives, and financial advisors
and how they operate in personal selling distribution systems
Explain how insurers provide sales support such as recruiting, licensing,
and training to different types of agents
List three unfair sales practices and describe the activities that insurers
undertake to monitor the market conduct of their agents and list three
unfair sales practices
Explain the role of broker-dealers, banks and other depository
institutions, and insurance companies in third-party distribution systems
Describe a direct response distribution system and identify the primary
types of direct response distribution channels
Identify and describe the factors an insurer considers when making
decisions about which distribution systems and channels to use
Outline
Personal Selling Direct Response Distribution Systems
Distribution Systems
Distribution Decisions
Agents
Costs
Agent Channel Support
Control
Methods of Personal Selling
Expertise
Salaried Sales Representatives
Customers’ Characteristics
Financial Advisors
Product Characteristics
Third-Party-Institution External Marketing Environment
Distribution Systems
Broker-Dealers
Banks and Other Depository
Institutions
Insurance Companies
A
n insurer can have the best products in the world, but without a way to
get those products to potential customers, the company will never make
any money. A distribution system is the method a company uses to make
its products available for sale to the public. An insurance company’s profitability
depends, to a large extent, on how effectively it selects, manages, and integrates
its distribution systems. An insurer’s choice of distribution systems affects and is
affected by the insurer’s target markets, the products the insurer sells, as well as
many other factors. In Chapter 9 we introduced the three major types of distribu-
tion systems insurers use: personal selling distribution systems, third-party-insti-
tution distribution systems, and direct response distribution systems. Within each
of these broad distribution systems, are distribution channels—specific people,
institutions, or communication methods that companies use to connect with their
customers. Figure 11.1 shows a simplified illustration of insurance distribution sys-
tems and channels. Note that the distinctions shown in this figure are not always so
clear. For example, a financial advisor might primarily sell investment securities
and work out of the office of a broker-dealer.
Distribution Channels
Agents
Financial Advisors*
Broker-Dealers**
Insurance Companies
Direct Mail
Print Media
Direct Response
Distribution Systems Broadcast Media
Telemarketing
Internet Sales
Agents
All agents are producers because they are all licensed to sell insurance contracts.
But not all producers are considered to be insurance company agents. A bank
employee who is licensed to sell insurance is a producer but is not considered to be
an insurance company agent.
We use career agents, but I know some other
insurers use independent agents. What are
the differences between career agents and
independent agents?
Expense provisions covering the types of expenses, if any, that an insurance agent may
incur and be reimbursed for by the company.
A list of the circumstances under which the insurance agent is permitted to submit life
insurance applications to another insurance company.
An insurer is likely to have an employee relationship with its agents when the
insurer exercises considerable control over how the work is conducted and also
when the insurer contributes significant financial support in addition to com-
mission payments. Agents such as (1) career agents, (2) multiple-line agents, or
(3) home service agents are sometimes, but not always, considered employees of
an insurer.
Career agents are under a full-time contract with one insurance company and
sell primarily that company’s life insurance products.
Multiple-line agents sell life insurance, health insurance, annuities, and prop-
erty-casualty products for one insurance company, with the preponderance of
sales being property-casualty products. Multiple-line agents often can sell a
larger number of products to customers than can career agents because they
learn about a customer’s needs for other insurance products from an initial
insurance transaction. For example, a multiple-line agent may recognize that a
person who purchases automobile insurance and has just had a baby may also
be in need of life insurance. The more products a customer purchases from an
agent, the more likely the agent will retain that customer’s business.
Home service agents, sometimes known as debit agents, sell specified prod-
ucts, typically low-face-amount cash value life insurance with monthly pre-
miums. Home service agents provide policyowner service within a specified
geographical area, and often are authorized to collect renewal premiums from
customers. Home service agents are supervised by a district manager. Presently,
only a few companies use home service agents to distribute their products.
Career agents and multiple-line agents are known as affiliated agents, or
agency-building agents, because they sell primarily the products of a single insur-
ance company. Independent agents may also be affiliated agents if they sell one
insurance company’s products exclusively. Many multiple-line insurers have an
affiliated agency arrangement with their independent agents. Insurers generally
invest considerable time and money in establishing and maintaining an affiliated
agent system.
An insurer’s affiliated agents are collectively known as its field force, and the
offices in which they work are usually known as field offices. Typically, insurers
provide financial assistance for some of a field office’s expenses. If an agent estab-
lishes and finances a field office, this agent is often referred to as a general agent
and the office is referred to as a general agency. The people who work in a general
agency are typically considered to be employees of the general agent.
In certain circumstances, affiliated agents may be allowed to sell another com-
pany’s products. For example, when an agent’s primary company declines to insure
an applicant, then the agent might be allowed to place the business with another
insurer. The contract will specify the circumstances under which an agent may
place business with another insurance company.
Commission rates for agents who are not affiliated with one insurance com-
pany are typically higher than the commission rates for affiliated agents. Affiliated
agents receive lower commissions because, typically, they receive some financial
benefits that are not provided to the other types of agents. For example, insurers
may provide their affiliated agents with security benefits such as health insurance,
disability income insurance, or retirement plans. Insurers may also provide their
affiliated agents with an expense allowance for certain business or office expenses,
as well as incentive bonuses, such as cash, trips, or merchandise, as a reward for
sales, persistency, or both. Note that incentive bonuses for sales are often available
to an insurer’s nonaffiliated agents as well.
Example: The Blue Sky Life Insurance Company requires that its career
agents sell at least 50 life insurance policies or a minimum of $500,000
in face amount of life insurance each year in order to maintain a full-time
agency contract with Blue Sky.
Sometimes independent agents—who are not affiliated agents, but who place
a substantial amount of business with one insurance company—may enter into
a special arrangement with that company. The agent, known as a personal-
producing general agent (PPGA), is an independent agent who receives special
consideration for satisfying minimum sales production requirements. For exam-
ple, insurers typically give their PPGAs the option of recruiting and training
full-time subagents. A PPGA receives additional commissions, called overriding
commissions, on the new or renewal business that these subagents sell.
However, most insurers who currently use independent agents market their
products through a wide network of independent agents known as brokers. A
broker, also sometimes known as an agent-broker, is an independent agent who
does not have an exclusive contract with any single insurer or specific obligations
to sell a single insurer’s products. Although brokers may have a primary insurance
company with which they place business, they are under no obligation to place
a certain amount of business with that insurer. They usually enter into separate
agency contracts with each insurer with whom they place business.
Brokers are responsible for all of their own business expenses, including office
expenses, training expenses, marketing expenses, and security benefits. As a
result, insurers incur few, if any costs, in connection with brokers until commis-
sions are due. When an insurer adds brokers to its distribution system, the insurer
instantly adds fully trained, experienced sales agents to its sales force with few, if
any, initial costs to the insurer.
Some independent agents, brokers, and PPGAs have created producer
groups—organizations of producers that negotiate compensation, product, and
service agreements with insurance companies. Producer groups, as well as other
organizations such as independent marketing organizations or brokerage general
agencies, often serve as intermediaries for independent agents, brokers, PPGAs
and insurance companies. By affiliating with an intermediary, an agent has access
to multiple insurers’ products and support services, such as point of sales assis-
tance, underwriting expertise in specialty lines of coverage, business development
services, and management support.
agency operations, that handles all supervisory and support activities for the
company’s agents. Other insurance companies divide supervisory and support
duties between an agency operations unit and an agency services unit. However,
regardless of how a company organizes the home office support activities for its
agents, the head of that unit or units usually reports to the company’s chief mar-
keting officer. The head of the insurer’s marketing operations must ensure that
Strategic goals and objectives for the company’s agency operations are consis-
tent with the insurer’s overall goals and objectives
Policies and procedures for agency operations are in compliance with all regu-
latory requirements
Recruiting
Insurers that use the personal selling distribution system know that the success of
their company depends largely on the success of their producers. Insurers spend
a lot of money hiring, training, and hopefully retaining their affiliated agents. If
an affiliated agent leaves an insurance company shortly after completing training,
the insurer will not recover its initial investment in that agent and must incur addi-
tional expenses to hire and train replacement agents. As a result, insurers want to
recruit agents who are likely to be successful in selling insurance products and are
likely to stay with the company for a long time.
The home office typically helps agency managers with recruitment by provid-
ing formal screening guidelines or tests for use in recruitment. Larger agencies
may receive assistance from a dedicated recruiting specialist. One screening test
that helps an agency manager determine whether to actively recruit a job candidate
is Career Choice developed by LIMRA. Career Choice uses a questionnaire to
gather information from a job candidate and uses that information to predict the
candidate’s likely success as an insurance producer.
Candidates who successfully complete the screening phase are then eligible
for pre-contract training, a trial program that permits the candidate to become a
producer while continuing to work at a current job. During pre-contract training,
the candidate learns (1) the principles of life insurance and annuities, (2) the prod-
ucts and practices of the hiring company, and (3) sales techniques for insurance
products. Typically, the home office prepares the pre-contract training program for
agency managers to use. Candidates who perform well during pre-contract train-
ing are offered contracts by the insurance company.
Some insurance companies provide financial support to their newly hired affili-
ated agents. For example, a company might provide new agents with an income
for the first six months while they complete licensing and training requirements.
In addition, some companies provide longer financing for affiliated agents who
have difficulty earning enough commissions to maintain an adequate standard of
living during their first years in the insurance business. This financing may be an
advance against future commissions, a higher-than-normal commission rate for
new sales, or a monthly supplement payment. Typically, all financial supports end
by a producer’s third or fourth year of employment.
Insurers that use the broker distribution channel must establish and maintain
good relationships with top producers. Such insurers know that brokers are more
likely to place business with insurers that communicate effectively with them,
provide high-quality customer service to them and to their clients, and pay com-
petitive commissions.
Licensing
Home offices play a significant role in the licensing of all producers. Generally, all
insurance producers must be licensed by each jurisdiction in which they sell insur-
ance products. These requirements apply to all types of insurance agents as well
as to people soliciting insurance product sales on behalf of banks and other orga-
nizations. Insurance producers in the United States must be licensed in each state
in which they sell insurance products. To obtain a license in the United States, the
applicant typically must (1) pay a licensing fee, (2) pass a written examination in
each line of insurance that he plans to sell, and (3) provide assurance that he is of
reputable character. Other countries have requirements that are similar to those in
the United States. Insight 11.1 describes the licensing requirements in India.
Many jurisdictions require that, before an insurance producer begins to solicit
insurance product sales on behalf of an insurer, the insurer must appoint, or
officially notify, regulators that it is authorizing that person to sell insurance on
its behalf. In some jurisdictions, the notice of appointment must be filed with the
application for the producer’s license.
Licensing specialists in an insurer’s home office oversee producer licensing
to ensure that all producers are qualified to sell the company’s products and are
appropriately licensed and appointed for the jurisdictions in which they are to
sell products. Licensing specialists maintain databases to ensure that producer
licenses are renewed on a timely basis, that correct licensing forms are on file, and
that licensing fees are paid in each jurisdiction as required. If an insurer termi-
nates an agent’s contract, the home office must notify insurance regulators of the
date of, and reason for, the termination.
Training
The level of training provided to agents varies depending upon the agent’s rela-
tionship with the insurance company. New affiliated agents typically go through
an initial period of sales, product, and on-the-job training. Brokers and more expe-
rienced agents receive mostly product training because they do not need general
sales training. However, insurers are required by law to ensure that all of its pro-
ducers are trained in market conduct laws and acceptable sales practices. Agent
training can be provided in formal classes at the home office, regional sales offices,
or the agency office. Virtual training through webinars and online courses is also
becoming much more common.
Sales Support
An insurer’s home office provides many types of sales support to agents. Again,
the amount of sales support an insurer provides to an agent depends upon the
agency relationship. Brokers and independent agents who do not have an exclusive
contract with one insurance company are likely to receive the least amount of sales
support.
Business development support. One of the most difficult tasks for any insur-
ance producer is locating qualified customers for insurance products. Insurers
may assist agents by providing them with lead generation support. For exam-
ple, an insurer may obtain sales leads from direct response advertisements or
from its website and forward these to the agents. In some cases, the address
and telephone number of an agent are provided at the insurer’s website. In
other cases, the website may allow the customer to send an e-mail directly
to the agent or link to the producer’s own website from the insurer’s web-
site. Insurers sometimes provide agents with contact management software or
systems to promote sales lead generation.
The monitoring system that an insurer establishes for its producers should
include a method for identifying and reporting producers who are found to be
unsuitable to sell insurance products. Although some producer infractions are
unintentional and merely indicate a need for additional training, some serious
infractions, or a pattern of minor infractions, require that an insurer provide ade-
quate disciplinary action, up to and including a termination of the producer’s con-
tract with the insurer. Figure 11.4 lists certain sales practices that are prohibited in
most jurisdictions.
Twisting occurs when a producer misrepresents the features of a policy to induce the
customer to replace an existing policy.
prospect and, hopefully, completes a sale. Once the prospect agrees to purchase
the insurance product, the agent assists the customer in applying for the product,
submits the application to the insurer, and, in some instances, delivers the policy
to the customer.
The amount of time spent locating new prospects depends on a number of
factors. Until fairly recently, the most important factor was how long the agent
had been in the insurance business. Experienced agents had current clients who
could provide additional sales leads and word-of-mouth referrals. Newer agents,
on the other hand, were forced to rely heavily on cold calling, which is the process
of telephoning or visiting prospects with whom the producer has had no prior
contact. However, the advent of the Internet and social networking websites is rev-
olutionizing the process of prospecting. Studies show that consumers trust Inter-
net peer-review ratings as valued sources of information for product purchases.1
Today, a positive recommendation posted on a social networking site can provide
a producer with many more sales leads than can a word-of-mouth recommendation
by one client.
Agents sometimes engage in methods of personal selling other than one-to-one
selling. Worksite marketing is a method for distributing insurance products to
people at their place of work. Under a typical worksite marketing arrangement,
an employer allows an insurer to offer the employer’s employees the opportunity
to buy insurance or annuity products. The employer deducts employees’ premium
payments from their paychecks through a payroll-deduction plan, and submits
the premium payments to the insurance company. The employee owns the insur-
ance policy and can continue the coverage even if his employment terminates. As
shown in Figure 11.5, worksite marketing offers advantages to insurers, employers,
and employees.
Some agents also sell insurance products through a method known as location-
selling. A location-selling system is designed to generate customer-initiated sales
at an office or information kiosk in a store, shopping mall, or other noninsurance
business establishment. For example, location-selling systems that offer insurance
product information and applications are sometimes located in businesses such as
department stores, grocery stores, and funeral homes.
Advantages to Insurers
Can be cost effective —Cost of insurance distribution and administration can
be lower than for individually-sold plans of insurance
Serves as a door opener —Can be used as a gateway to sell other products
offered by the insurer
Meets customer needs —Is particularly appropriate for middle- and lower-
income markets
Increases insurer’s name recognition —Puts insurer’s name before large
groups of potential customers
Advantages to Employers
Is cost effective —Few, if any, direct costs or fees to employers; can help manage
rising costs of employee benefits by shifting some costs to employees
Enhances employee goodwill —Allows employers to complement already
existing employer-provided benefits in a way that is valued by employees
Is nonintrusive —Does not interfere with existing employee benefit program
Source: Adapted from Conning & Company, Life Insurers’ Distribution Strategies: Testing the Waters (Hartford, CT: Conning &
Company, 1999), 37. Used with permission.
Financial Advisors
In the personal selling distribution system, many independent financial advisors
analyze a customer’s personal financial circumstances and goals and prepare a plan
to meet the customer’s financial goals, which often involve retirement or college
savings. Sometimes financial advisors suggest that a customer purchase an insur-
ance or investment product as part of a financial plan. If registered and licensed
appropriately, a financial advisor can assist customers with purchases of insurance
or investment products. In the United States, an independent financial advisor,
also known as a registered investment advisor (RIA), is an individual registered
with the Securities and Exchange Commission to give advice about investment
securities. An independent financial advisor who also sells insurance or annuity
products must comply with all relevant insurance laws. This includes licensing or
registration requirements, as well as regulations regarding advertising and pro-
motional materials. Independent financial advisors typically earn commissions on
their insurance sales, and these commissions are usually higher than commissions
earned by agents.
Broker-Dealers
In the personal selling distribution system, a broker is a type of insurance agent.
A broker-dealer is a financial institution that buys and sells securities either
for itself or for its customers and provides information and advice to customers
regarding the purchase and sale of securities. In the United States, variable life
insurance and annuity products—in which the value of the product is linked to
market performance and the owner assumes some or all of the product’s invest-
ment risk—are classified as securities as well as insurance products. In the United
States, securities can only be distributed through broker-dealers that are regis-
tered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and are members of
the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority. The Financial Industry Regulatory
Authority (FINRA) is a nongovernmental self-regulatory organization empowered
by the SEC to license, investigate, and regulate securities dealers and their repre-
sentatives. Individuals who sell securities must also register with FINRA, and the
broker-dealer is responsible for overseeing this process.
Some insurers enter into third-party distribution agreements with existing
broker-dealers to market their variable products. However, life insurers sometimes
establish a broker-dealer subsidiary. An insurance broker-dealer, sometimes
referred to as an insurance brokerage or insurance-owned broker-dealer, is a reg-
istered subsidiary of an insurance company that primarily or exclusively sells that
insurer’s variable insurance products and also provides specialized financial plan-
ning and investment services.
Banks typically use two types of producers, platform employees and financial
consultants, to distribute insurance and annuity products. A platform employee
is a bank employee whose primary function is to handle customer service issues
and sell traditional bank products such as checking and savings accounts, but who
is also licensed to sell insurance. In Asia and Latin America, platform employees
are the primary distributors of bancassurance. In the United States, financial con-
sultants are used more often. A financial consultant is a full-time bank employee
whose primary function is to sell investment products to bank customers. Financial
consultants are licensed to sell securities as well as life insurance and annuities.
Platform employees usually sell simple life insurance products such as term life
and refer customers with more complex financial needs to financial consultants.
The amount and type of sales support that an insurance company provides
for the bank distribution channel can vary considerably and is often provided to
the banks by wholesalers. Insurance companies typically pay banks commissions,
and the banks decide how to compensate their employees for the sales. Only bank
employees who are licensed producers may receive commissions for the sale of
insurance. However, unlicensed bank employees who refer customers to licensed
bank employees sometimes receive a nominal referral fee.
Insurance Companies
An insurance company can act as a distribution channel by selling nonproprietary
products, which are products developed by another insurance company. By distrib-
uting nonproprietary products, an insurer can provide its sales force and customers
Distribution Decisions
No insurance company can use all of the distribution systems or all of the channel
options available. An insurer is limited by its available resources and also by how
each option fits with its business goals and objectives. The insurer must carefully
weigh the strengths and weaknesses of each distribution option within this con-
text. Insurers consider several factors when making distribution decisions.
Costs
Some insurance distribution systems are more expensive than others. A personal
selling distribution system using a career agent channel is the most expensive
to establish and maintain. In addition to paying commissions for sales, insurers
usually provide for field office expenses, such as rent, technology support, and
utilities. In addition, insurers pay for the recruiting, training, and licensing of
career agents. Newer or smaller insurance companies that wish to use personal
Print media. When an insurer uses print media, the insurer uses printed
publications, such as magazines or newspapers, to describe a particular
product and generate interest in that product. The advertisement
typically contains a telephone number for a customer to call to obtain
further information. When using print media, insurers can try to reach
a particular target market by printing advertisements in newspapers
in certain geographical areas or in magazines that appeal to certain
demographics. For example, an advertisement for an annuity product
designed for people age 62 or older might appear in a magazine for
retired people.
selling distribution may not have adequate financial resources to establish a career
agent sales force and may choose to use a less expensive system of brokers. Other
insurers may choose to distribute their products through a third-party institution to
reduce costs. Direct response channels often require a substantial up-front invest-
ment before any income is received. Direct response insurers must set up facilities
and technology, hire and train staff, and develop sales materials. However, direct
response insurers usually can recover this investment fairly quickly because they
do not rely on commissioned sales personnel with their higher staffing and training
costs. Staffing and training costs are typically lower for direct response distribution
than for other distribution channels.
Control
An insurer that wishes to exercise a great deal of control over distribution activi-
ties typically develops either an affiliated agent system or a direct response dis-
tribution system. An insurer using an affiliated agent system can maintain almost
total control of its distribution system. Agents are required to undergo training and
must sell an insurer’s products. Insurers can also fully control the products and
messages they deliver to customers in the direct response distribution system.
Insurers have less control over other personal selling channels and third-party-
institution distribution channels. Insurers cannot control the types of products on
which brokers and financial advisors focus their sales efforts. However, insurers
may be able to include some controls in these producers’ contracts, such as that the
producers must attend periodic compliance and product training sessions. Insurers
can also run promotions from time to time that reward agents if they reach a cer-
tain sales volume in products that the company wants to promote in a given region,
specific product line, or market situation.
Expertise
Insurers want their producers to have a high degree of sales experience and to be
knowledgeable about the insurer and the insurer’s products. Not only will these
producers be able to sell a primary product, but they can also engage in identifying
an existing customer’s needs for additional products while selling, or after selling,
the primary product.
Career agents, multiple-line agents, and brokers have a high degree of sales
experience and general knowledge about insurance products, and they recognize
the importance of additional sales to increase their earnings. However, career agents
and multiple-line agents are more familiar with their primary insurer’s product
portfolio than are brokers who sell the products of many insurance companies. In
addition, brokers are under no obligation to sell a particular insurer’s products.
Financial advisors often have extensive knowledge about their customers but
may lack expertise about particular insurance products or companies. In some
cases, financial advisors may lack extensive sales experience, as their primary
concern is usually helping their customers achieve overall financial goals. Produc-
ers at third-party institutions also vary widely in terms of sales experience, prod-
uct knowledge, and company knowledge. For example, unless bank employees are
adequately trained, they will not have the knowledge or skills necessary to sell
Customers’ Characteristics
The distribution system through which a product is sold should meet the needs of
the customers in the insurer’s target market. For example, if an insurer has identi-
fied as a target market older, wealthier individuals who expect personalized ser-
vice, then a distribution system that can provide personalized service is probably
best. Customers who prefer to compare products and prices over the Internet at
their own convenience would prefer a direct response distribution system. Rarely
can an insurer satisfy the needs of all of its customers with a single distribution
system or channel. More often, insurers provide multiple options to satisfy various
customer buying preferences.
Product Characteristics
Some products are more effectively and efficiently sold through one distribu-
tion system than another. A complex product such as universal life insurance
typically requires a personal selling distribution system. Simpler products, such as
term life insurance or fixed annuities, can be distributed through a direct
response system or third-party-institution system. Some products, such as vari-
able life insurance or variable annuities in the United States, must be sold through
licensed broker-dealers. Group insurance products are often best sold through
group representatives.
Key Terms
distribution system pre-contract training
distribution channel appoint
agent advanced underwriting
agency contract estate planning
persistency segmented service
employee churning
independent contractor twisting
independent agent rebating
career agent prospect
multiple-line agent cold calling
home service agent worksite marketing
affiliated agent location-selling system
field force salaried sales representative
field office independent financial advisor
general agent wholesaler
general agency broker-dealer
first-year commission insurance broker-dealer
renewal commission bancassurance
service fee platform employee
personal producing general agent financial consultant
(PPGA) nonproprietary product
overriding commission targeted email marketing
broker web advertising
producer group
Additional Activities
If you want to relate the information in this chapter to your company, try these
activities:
Identify all of the distribution channels your company uses. Based on this
information, does your company primarily use a personal selling distribution
system, a third-party-institution distribution system, or a direct response dis-
tribution system?
If your company uses a personal selling distribution channel, look on your com-
pany’s organization chart and determine how the home office and field office
operations connect. Typically, the head of agency operations reports to market-
ing. Is this true for your company? If not, how are these areas connected?
Insurers often use online newsletters that provide readers with helpful advice
or information as part of their direct response distribution system. If your
company distributes such a newsletter, read through it. Identify ways in
which insurance products are promoted in the newsletter and offered for sale
to customers.
Endnotes
1. LIMRA International and Society of Actuaries, Guaranteed Uncertainty: Socioeconomic Influences
on Product Development and Distribution in the Life Insurance Industry (Windsor, CT: LL Global,
Inc., © 2011). Used with permission; all rights reserved.
2. In general, laws in the United States prohibit banks from issuing insurance products. However, laws in
Connecticut, Massachusetts, and New York allow mutual savings banks to issue life insurance policies
to residents of those states.
Chapter 12
Underwriting
Objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to
Define underwriting and explain the relationship between new business
processing and underwriting
Describe the role that technology plays in new business processing
List and describe the basic steps for processing an annuity application
Identify and describe key underwriting job positions
Distinguish between an insurer’s underwriting philosophy and
underwriting guidelines
Describe the underwriting process and the primary sources of medical
information underwriters use in underwriting individual coverages
Define financial underwriting and personal underwriting
Explain how underwriters use the numerical rating system to assign
proposed insureds to four general risk classes
Describe how underwriters use the numerical rating in applying the
premium rate charged for insurance coverage
Explain the relationships between underwriting and other organizational
functions
Describe the group insurance underwriting process and recognize risk
factors that pertain to group coverage
Identify and describe laws and regulations that affect the life insurance
underwriting process
Outline
New Business Processing Control Mechanisms for
Processing Life Insurance Underwriting Operations
Applications Authority Levels
Processing Annuity New Business Other Underwriting Controls
Organization of New Business and Company Interrelationships and
Underwriting Operations Underwriting
Purpose of Underwriting Group Underwriting
Underwriting Philosophy and The Group Underwriting Process
Guidelines Risk Factors for Group Life Insurance
The Underwriting Process Regulatory Requirements
Field Underwriting and
Teleunderwriting
Medical, Financial, and Personal
Underwriting
The Underwriting Decision
Applying the Premium Rate
Y
ou also may wonder about the role of underwriting with respect to evalu-
ating risks and determining the premiums to charge for each proposed
insured. Remember from Chapter 10 that when a new insurance product
is designed, actuaries make estimates about a product’s inflows, such as premi-
ums paid and investment income earned, and outflows, such as benefits paid and
expenses incurred, to determine the financial design of the product. For life insur-
ance, an important element in determining these inflows and outflows is mortality
risk—the likelihood that a person will die sooner than statistically expected. If
the mortality experience for a particular life insurance product is higher—that is,
if more people die—than the insurer anticipated when the product was designed,
then the inflows will be lower and the outflows will be higher than expected. In
other words, the premium rate the actuaries established would not be sufficient to
cover the benefits and expenses that must be paid and earn a profit for the insurer’s
stakeholders. For annuity products, mortality risk is the likelihood that a proposed
insured will live longer than statistically expected.
When an insurance company receives an application for insurance, the com-
pany must assess the degree of risk associated with the application. Underwriting,
also called selection of risks, is the process of (1) assessing and classifying the
degree of risk a proposed insured or group represents and (2) making a decision
to accept or decline that risk. An underwriter is an insurance company employee
who evaluates risks, accepts or declines insurance applications, and determines
the appropriate premium rate to charge acceptable risks.
Once a proposed insured is determined to be an acceptable risk, the under-
writer must determine an appropriate premium rate to charge for the insurance
coverage. The decision regarding the classification of a risk and the premium rate
to charge is called the underwriting decision. Insurers don’t charge all applicants
for the same insurance product the same premium rate because not all proposed
insureds represent the same amount of risk to the insurer. Some proposed insureds
are older, in poorer health, or have other risk factors that make them more likely to
die than other people who are younger or who are in better health. One purpose of
underwriting is to place each proposed insured in the correct risk class according
to the level of risk that the proposed insured represents. A risk class is a group of
insureds who represent a similar level of risk to an insurance company. Insurers
charge different premium rates depending upon the risk class of the proposed
insured.
An insurance company’s success or failure is greatly affected by its under-
writing decisions. Why? Because every person or group to which an insurance
company issues insurance represents a risk to the company. If an insurer does not
properly assess risks, over time the insurer’s profits will suffer, and in the worst
case, the insurer could become insolvent.
What happens if
underwriting accepts
a risk, but charges a What happens if
premium that is too underwriting accepts
high for that risk? a risk, but charges a
premium that isn’t high
enough to compensate
for that risk?
Purpose of Underwriting
The ultimate goal of underwriting is to accept the greatest number of qualified
proposed insureds or groups while keeping the insurer financially sound—a deli-
cate balancing act. Suppose an insurer’s underwriting standards are too strict or
its premiums are not competitive. In this case, producers are less likely to submit
applications to the insurer. The result is a potential decrease in premium income,
which could reduce the insurer’s profitability. What if an insurer’s underwriting
standards are too relaxed? For example, the insurer accepts too many high-risk
applications or its premiums are too low in relation to the risk the insurer accepted.
In this situation, the insurer might not have enough money to pay benefits when
they come due. Either situation could threaten the insurer’s solvency and result in
disciplinary action from insurance regulators. Sound underwriting ensures that
each person pays a premium for insurance that is proportionate to the risk that the
insured represents. Underwriting is considered to be sound if each risk is evalu-
ated accurately, classified properly, and either approved for an appropriate pre-
mium rate or denied according to the insurer’s procedures.
Source: Adapted from Miriam A. Orsina and Gene Stone, Insurance Company Operations, 2nd ed. [Atlanta: LOMA (Life Office
Management Association, Inc.), © 2005], 232. Used with permission; all rights reserved.
Receive application, create a Search the insurer’s records for information about the
case file, and assign a code or applicant—e.g., other coverage, prior claims or complaints,
number for tracking purposes other pending or denied applications with the insurer
Insurable
Yes as a preferred or
a standard risk?
No
Approve application
Insurable
Yes
as a substandard
risk?
Send application to Send application to
policy issue policy issue No
Producer offers
substandard-rated
policy to applicant
Applicant
Yes accepts policy? No
Source: Adapted from Miriam A. Orsina and Gene Stone, Insurance Company Operations, 2nd ed. [Atlanta: LOMA (Life Office
Managment Association, Inc.),© 2005], 243. Used with permission; all rights reserved.
When a policy is rated, new business processing contacts the producer who
submitted the application and explains why the policy was rated. If the applicant
accepts the rated policy when the producer presents the policy to the applicant,
then the policy is in force. If the applicant does not accept the rated policy, then no
policy is in force.
Insurers find that teleunderwriting often provides more complete and thorough
information than does field underwriting because applicants feel more comfort-
able providing personal information to a stranger over the telephone or the Inter-
net. Producers also benefit from having more time to spend on marketing and sales
activities. In addition, telephone conversations can be recorded and reviewed for
quality assurance and to enhance an insurer’s compliance activities.5
How can underwriters find out if a proposed
insured is telling the truth about his lifestyle or
finances on the application?
Assign a debit—a positive number—for each risk factor that has an unfavorable effect
on mortality.
Assign a credit—a negative number—for each risk factor that has a favorable effect on
mortality.
Add the debits to, and subtract the credits from, the base number to obtain the
numerical rating.
Example: Lora Gentry’s medical records indicate that she has a slightly enlarged heart. The
insurer from which Ms. Gentry is requesting coverage typically assigns a debit of +50 to
this impairment. The insurer assigns a credit of –10 because both of Ms. Gentry’s parents
are alive, healthy, and in their 80s. If Ms. Gentry has no other impairments or medical
or personal risk factors that affect mortality, then the total numerical rating Ms. Gentry
represents is 140 (100 + 50 – 10).
150
140
+50 -10
Enlarged Parents’
100 Heart Health
+100
Standard
Mortality
Because positive numbers are assigned to factors that have been determined sta-
tistically to increase a proposed insured’s mortality risk, a lower numerical rating
is better than a higher numerical rating. Generally, the higher the numerical rating,
the higher the premium charged for the same type and amount of insurance cover-
age. The lower the numerical rating, the lower the premium charged for the same
type and amount of coverage.
The total numerical rating determines which risk class is most appropriate
for the proposed insured—the preferred, standard, substandard, or declined risk
class, each of which we described earlier in this chapter. The numerical rating
corresponds to a specific acceptable range for a risk class. For example, a numeri-
cal rating from 100 to 125 may be classified as a standard risk and charged the
standard premium rate. Using this range, Ms. Gentry from our example in Figure
12.4 would not be a standard risk. The underwriter evaluating Ms. Gentry’s appli-
cation would have to determine the extra premium necessary to compensate for
her extra mortality. However, if Ms. Gentry had been a preferred risk, she would
pay a lower premium than the premium charged for a standard risk on the same
amount and type of coverage.
So . . . how does the underwriter get from the
numerical rating to the premium rate?
Should someone who represents a higher risk of loss to the insurer pay the same
premium on the same coverage as someone who represents a lower risk of loss?
No. That wouldn’t be equitable to the person who represents a lower risk to the
insurer. For individual life insurance underwriting, insurers charge premiums that
are proportionate to the risk that each proposed insured represents.
Underwriters may use various methods to determine premium rates for pro-
posed insureds classified as substandard risks. Under the table rating method,
premium charges are determined by dividing substandard risks into broad groups
or tables according to their numerical ratings. The extra mortality for each sub-
standard group is expressed as a percentage added to standard mortality as has
been shown by the insurer’s actual mortality experience. Based on the proposed
insured’s numerical rating, a table rating is assigned that generally reflects a mul-
tiple of the insurer’s mortality rates for standard risks. The table rating method is
appropriate when a risk shows a pattern of extra mortality that increases with age,
as is found in diabetic or overweight people.
Example: Assume that the life insurance company uses the flat extra
premium method for substandard risks. Life insurance applicant Leila
Appelbaum will be charged an extra $3.00 per $1,000 of life insurance
coverage over the standard premium rate. In this case, Ms. Appelbaum’s
premium will be $750 ($4.50 standard premium per coverage unit + $3.00
extra premium per coverage unit × 100 coverage units).
Authority Levels
Not every underwriter has the same level of authority to approve, rate, or decline
an insurance application. An underwriter’s level of authority is specified by (1) the
maximum coverage amount that the underwriter can approve and (2) the degree
to which the underwriter may rate or decline an insurance application without the
approval or review of a more experienced underwriter.
Most individual life insurers develop charts or schedules of underwriting
authority that serve as steering controls. Each chart indicates the highest amount
of coverage that can be approved at each authority level. Generally, an underwriter
one level higher than the original underwriter reviews all rated and declined appli-
cations and all applications that have exclusions.
Company Interrelationships
and Underwriting
Underwriters frequently interact with external and internal customers. External
customers of the underwriting function include producers, vendors, and reinsurers.
An insurance company typically contracts with vendors to perform one or more
services. For example, vendors may conduct medical exams, provide financial
analyses, or perform criminal background checks on proposed insureds. Insurers
contract with reinsurers when the insurer needs to transfer some or all of the risk
it assumed in underwriting.
Underwriters also collaborate with many internal customers, as shown in the
following examples:
Actuaries set actuarial assumptions for insurance products based on average
risks presented by proposed insureds and share findings with underwriters.
Marketing staff share information with underwriters about customer needs
and wants, competitive products, and sales results.
Compliance staff ensure that underwriters follow all applicable laws and
regulations.
Legal staff ensure that underwriters fulfill the insurer’s legal obligations with
respect to insurance contracts.
Claim staff obtain assistance from underwriters, particularly when claims are
filed during the contestable period.
Group Underwriting
Underwriting for group life insurance follows essentially the same principles
and procedures that are used in individual life insurance underwriting, with
one key difference. Except for very small groups, group underwriting evaluates
information about the composition of and the risk presented by the group as a
whole, rather than evaluating information about individual group members. How-
ever, underwriters may require evidence of insurability from individual group
members when the group is very small or when new group members enroll in a
plan after the enrollment deadline. In group insurance, the individual members of
a group are called group members.
The goals of group underwriting are similar to the goals of individual under-
writing: (1) to determine the level of risk a group of people represents and (2) to
charge a premium for group coverage that is appropriate to that level of risk. A
large group normally includes people with medical impairments that would make
them substandard or declined risks if the underwriter evaluated them using indi-
vidual underwriting guidelines. The group underwriter is not concerned with the
high risks presented by a few group members. Rather, the group underwriter is
interested in whether the group as a whole is an acceptable risk.
Group insurance contracts in the United States are subject to state laws that may
be based on the NAIC Group Life Insurance Model Act, which defines the types
of groups eligible for group life insurance and sets forth provisions that group
insurance policies must contain. Underwriters also must ensure that groups apply-
ing for insurance coverage are eligible to do so under the applicable state laws.
1 A group
prospect—for
2 If the
underwriter
decides that
3 If
the group
prospect
4 If the
underwriter
approves the
5 Each
group insured
is provided
example, an
employer, the group approves the coverage after with a
submits a prospect proposal, assessing certificate of
request for represents an the group the master insurance.
proposal. acceptable prospect application,
risk, he submits the insurer
develops a a master uses the
proposal for application to master
insurance. the insurer. application to
develop the
master group
insurance
contract.
1. request for proposal (RFP): A document that provides detailed information about the
group and the requested coverage, and which solicits a bid from an insurer to provide that
coverage
2. proposal for insurance: A document that details the specifications of a group insurance
plan proposed by an insurer for a group prospect
3. master application: An application for group insurance that contains the specific
provisions of the requested plan of insurance and is signed by an authorized officer of the
proposed policyholder
4. master group insurance contract: A legal document that certifies the relationship
between the insurer and the group policyholder and specifies the contract’s benefits,
typically referred to as the group insurance policy or group plan. Only the insurer and the
group policyholder, and not the group insureds, are parties to the master group insurance
contract.
5. certificate of insurance: A document that describes (1) the coverage that the master
group insurance contract provides to the group insureds and (2) the group insureds’ rights
under the contract
Group members who are covered by the insurance contract are called group
insureds. In many cases, group members and group insureds are one and the
same. However, under some master group insurance contracts, group members
must elect coverage under the contract. In such situations, only those group mem-
bers who choose the coverage become group insureds.
Regulatory Requirements
The underwriting decision relies on personal and confidential information
obtained from the insurance application and supporting documents such as
reports on the proposed insured’s health and finances. Many countries have laws
and regulations that govern the privacy of the personal and confidential informa-
tion an insurer obtains to make underwriting decisions. Because of such legal
requirements, insurers have incorporated certain forms and procedures into the
application process. For example, a producer must obtain the applicant’s signa-
ture authorizing the insurer to conduct a credit check, to contact the proposed
insured’s physicians on matters that relate to the proposed coverage, and so
on. In addition, the insurer’s automated systems include features that require
passwords and other authentication methods to ensure that only authorized
employees can access the proposed insured’s nonpublic personal information.
Figure 12.6 describes several laws that affect life insurance underwriting.
Unfair Discrimination
An underwriter’s responsibility is to distinguish risks that are acceptable from risks that are unacceptable by
carefully examining facts about the proposed insured. Laws generally permit insurers to discriminate among
risks as long as they base their decisions on (1) recognized actuarial principles or (2) the insurer’s own actual or
reasonably anticipated experience. However, many jurisdictions have enacted laws to protect customers against
unfair discrimination in underwriting. Generally, insurers are prohibited from basing underwriting decisions on
factors such as the proposed insured’s sex, race, marital status, national origin, or religion. Some jurisdictions
also prohibit insurers from unfairly discriminating against proposed insureds on the basis of certain mental or
physical impairments, such as blindness or deafness.
Example: Underwriters in Canada generally may not discriminate among proposed insureds for life
insurance coverage on the basis of whether a person is male or female. In addition, some provinces
specifically prohibit discrimination on the basis of physical and mental impairments, marital status, and
sexual orientation.
Example: New Zealand’s Human Rights Act of 1993 prohibits discrimination on the basis of age, sex, and
disability. However, the act permits an insurer to base the terms and conditions of insurance coverage
on supporting actuarial or statistical data. An insurer can impose an additional premium or reduce the
amount of insurance coverage if the insurer has actuarial data to support its decision.
Privacy Legislation
The Gramm-Leach-Bliley (GLB) Act is a U.S. federal law that requires insurance companies to respect
customers’ privacy and to protect the security and confidentiality of those customers’ nonpublic per-
sonal information. Nonpublic personal information is personally identifiable information about a con-
sumer that is not publicly available.
Many states in the United States have passed insurance privacy laws based on the NAIC Model Pri-
vacy Act, a model law that establishes standards for the collection, use, and disclosure of information
gathered in connection with insurance transactions. The model act applies only to personal insurance,
and primarily governs underwriting and claim administration.
In Canada, the federal Personal Information Protection and Electronics Document Act (PIPEDA)
governs the collection, use, and disclosure of personal information by organizations in the private sec-
tor. Insurance companies are governed by PIPEDA, except in Quebec, British Columbia, and Alberta,
where substantially similar provincial privacy laws apply. In addition, on the provincial level, the Cana-
dian Life and Health Insurance Association (CLHIA) has issued Right to Privacy Guidelines. Insurers may
either adopt these guidelines or develop their own stricter guidelines.
Key Terms
mortality risk paramedical report
underwriting medical report
underwriter MIB Group Inc. (MIB)
underwriting decision attending physician’s statement
risk class (APS)
new business processing specialized medical questionnaire
electronic insurance application pharmaceutical database
e-signature financial underwriting
click-wrap personal underwriting
exception-based underwriting numerical rating system
straight through processing (STP) debits
suitability credits
jet unit table rating method
antiselection flat extra premium method
underwriting philosophy audit log
underwriting guidelines group member
preferred class NAIC Group Life Insurance
standard class Model Act
substandard class group representative
declined class request for proposal (RFP)
rating proposal for insurance
field underwriting master application
field underwriting manual master group insurance contract
evidence of insurability certificate of insurance
table of underwriting requirements group insured
agent’s statement Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA)
teleunderwriting consumer reporting agency
nonmedical supplement
Additional Activities
If you want to relate the information in this chapter to your company, try these
activities:
Compare how your company organizes the underwriting function with the
descriptions in this chapter. Do you have a new business department or just an
underwriting department?
The MIB Group Inc. (MIB) is a source of medical information for insurers.
Read about MIB at http://www.mib.com/html/consumer_protection.html. If
you wish, obtain information from MIB about the contents of any consumer
file that it has on you. Consumers have the right to request one free copy of an
MIB Consumer File per year.
If you are insured by your employer’s group life insurance policy, locate the
certificate of insurance for your coverage. Note that it is likely located online
at your employer’s website.
Copyright © 2012 LL Global, Inc. All rights reserved. www.loma.org
12.24 Chapter 12: Underwriting Insurance Company Operations
Endnotes
1. Tammy J. McInturff, “E-signatures Revisited,” Resource, February 2009.
2. Dan Woodman, “New Business Origination for Annuities,” MSDN Architecture Center, May 2007,
http://msdn2.microsoft.com/en-us/architecture/bb419309.aspx#nbann_topic (16 May 2011).
3. LOMA, New Business and Underwriting Structure, Information Center Brief (Atlanta: LL Global,
Inc., © 2010). Used with permission; all rights reserved.
4. LOMA, Teleunderwriting and Tele-interviewing, Information Center Brief (Atlanta: LL Global, Inc.,
© 2010). Used with permission; all rights reserved.
5. Ibid.
6. LOMA, Measuring Processing Productivity, Information Center Brief [Atlanta: LOMA (Life Office
Management Association, Inc.), © 2009]. Used with permission; all rights reserved.
Chapter 13
Objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to
Explain why effective claim administration is essential to the success of
an insurance company
Describe the organization of the claim department and the various levels
of authority for claim department staff
List and describe the basic steps in the life insurance claim decision
process
Define material misrepresentation and explain the process for handling
material misrepresentations in a life insurance policy
Identify documents commonly accepted as proof of an insured’s death
and describe types of deaths that might require additional investigation
Describe the suicide exclusion and how exclusions in a life insurance
policy can affect a claim decision
Describe the process for calculating and paying the policy benefit
Describe the claim process for reinsured life insurance policies
Explain the importance of claim investigation in uncovering claim fraud
Describe the laws and regulations that affect claim administration
Describe how an insurer administers annuity death benefits and
scheduled periodic payments
Outline
Organization of the Claim Quality Control in
Department Claim Processing
Claim Philosophy and Regulatory Requirements
Claim Practices Model Unfair Claims Settlement
Practices Act
Life Insurance Claim Process
Determining If Benefits International Laws
Are Payable Annuity Administration
Calculating the Amount Payable Annuity Death Benefit
Paying the Proceeds Administration
Identifying the Proper Payee Annuity Payout Administration
Claim Investigation
Claim Fraud
C
laim administration is the insurance function that is responsible for
evaluating, processing, and paying valid claims for contractual benefits
that policyowners or beneficiaries present. Claim administration, which is
sometimes called claim adjudication, claim handling, claim processing, or claim
servicing, is one of the most significant and often complex processes that life
insurance companies perform. Effective claim administration is important to the
success of an insurance company for several reasons:
Claim administration fulfills the insurer’s primary responsibility to its
policyowners—prompt payment of policy benefits when an insured event
occurs.
As a primary contact point with customers, claim administration greatly
impacts customer loyalty and retention, as well as the company’s reputation.
The data obtained from claim administration is used in determining the accu-
racy of underwriting decisions and in designing new insurance products.
not pay a claim within a certain number of days after receiving sufficient proof of
loss. However, processing claims too quickly can result in the payment of claims
that are not valid. A small number of life insurance claims are submitted under
erroneous interpretations of policy provisions. An even smaller number of claims
are submitted fraudulently. By denying these invalid claims, the insurer controls
costs and protects the insurance-buying public from unnecessary increases in
insurance costs. Thus, effective claim administration balances the need for prompt
claim decisions with the need for accuracy—the right beneficiary and the right
amount—and completeness in claim processing.
Obtain medical and legal advice when necessary to make a claim decision
Y
E
S
Was the
Deceased the No Claim Denied
Insured?*
Y
E
S
Is the Policy
Contestable?
Y
E N
S O
No
Did the Loss Claim Denied
No
Occur?
Y
E
S
Pay Claim
* For a dependent covered under group life insurance, the insured is the employee, who purchases dependent
spouse or child coverage. The claim for a deceased dependent of the insured is typically processed under the
insured’s name, rather than the name of the deceased dependent. In this case, the deceased is not the insured,
but is the insured’s dependent spouse or child.
** Insurer returns premiums paid by the policyowner.
insurance that is not true and that caused the insurer to enter into a contract it
would not have agreed to if it had known the truth. When an insurer learns that
important information in a policy application is untrue, the insurer may have a
right to cancel the policy on the legal grounds that no valid contract ever existed.
Inaccurate information in an application that would not have affected the under-
writing decision is not a material misrepresentation. For example, the fact that a
proposed insured stated in an insurance application that he broke his left arm in
a car accident when it was in fact his right arm isn’t material to the underwriter.
Figure 13.3 shows examples of misrepresentations that are material to an insurer’s
acceptance of a risk.
Source: Adapted from Miriam A. Orsina and Gene Stone, Insurance Company Operations, 2nd ed. [Atlanta: LOMA (Life Office
Management Association, Inc.), © 2005], 295. Used with permission; all rights reserved.
Once the contestable period has expired, an insurer generally cannot contest
the validity of an insurance policy because of a material misrepresentation. In
some jurisdictions, however, if an insurer can prove that the policy was taken out
with the intention of defrauding the insurer, then the insurer can rescind the policy.
When a policy is rescinded, the insurer refunds the premiums paid on the policy,
minus any outstanding policy loan amounts.
Two specific situations require the claim analyst to conduct further investigation.
If the insurer is unable to obtain acceptable proof of death, then the insurer would
seek legal advice on how to proceed.
1. The insured dies outside the country of policy issue. The formalities and
procedures for registration of death in some countries are not as rigorous as
life insurers might desire. As a result, documents offered as proof of death may
be difficult to obtain, authenticate, or translate. Such situations may increase
the likelihood of fraud. Benefits would be payable upon receipt of acceptable
proof of death. Most insurance companies have established procedures for
processing these types of death claims.
2. The insured disappears. When an insured disappears, the claimant is unable
to present proof of the insured’s death to the insurer. Whether the insured’s
disappearance can be reasonably explained generally determines how the claim
analyst proceeds.
a. Explainable disappearance. If the insured disappeared as a result of a
specific peril that can reasonably account for the disappearance, the
insured may be presumed dead. Suppose a commercial airplane on which
the insured was a passenger crashed into the ocean and no bodies were
recovered. In this case, the claim analyst would probably accept the claim
form and attached reports of the peril as proof of loss. The claim analyst
would then process the remaining aspects of the claim.
b. Unexplainable disappearance. If a specific peril cannot explain the
insured’s disappearance, the claim analyst would probably close the claim
file after the disappearance pending acceptable proof of loss. In many
jurisdictions, if the insured hasn’t reappeared within a certain period—five
or seven years in the United States—the claimant can petition a court for
an order presuming the insured’s death. If the policy has been kept in force
during the insured’s disappearance, the claim analyst typically accepts the
court order as proof of loss and proceeds with processing the claim.
that an insured committed suicide. If the insurer proves that the insured died by
suicide, the insurer’s payment is limited to the amount of the premiums that were
paid for the insurance coverage, minus the amount of any outstanding policy
loans. If the insured’s death occurs by suicide after the exclusion period expires,
the insurer pays the full policy proceeds. In some group term life insurance poli-
cies, the suicide exclusion period does not expire.
Claim denial. If the decision is made to deny a claim, typically a claim man-
ager or a member of the legal department reviews and approves the denial.
Next, the claimant is notified in writing of the reasons for the claim denial.
The claimant is also informed that the insurer will reexamine the claim if
the claimant can provide additional facts that might refute the information on
which the denial was based.
Additions Subtractions
Premiums that the policyowner paid in Outstanding policy loans
advance
Accumulated policy dividends Accrued policy loan interest
Policy dividends that the insurer declared Premiums due and unpaid
but that remain unpaid
Paid-up additional coverage that the
policyowner purchased
Accidental death benefits that may be
payable
Example: The life insurance policy insuring Vinny Acworth’s life included
an accidental death benefit. Mr. Acworth was hiking in the mountains
along a high ledge and fell to his death. If Mr. Acworth slipped and fell,
his death would be accidental and policy proceeds would include the
accidental death benefit. However, if Mr. Acworth’s death was the result of
a suicide (he jumped), no accidental death benefit is payable.
When evaluating a claim involving an accidental death benefit, all facts of the
case are taken into consideration. The claim analyst may order autopsy reports,
medical records, and police reports to gather enough information to determine
whether the insurer is liable to pay accidental death benefits. If the benefits are
payable, the insurer adds that amount to the policy’s face amount.
Example: Assume that Mr. Acworth’s death was ruled accidental and that
the following information applies in his situation:
$100,000 face amount of policy
$50,000 accidental death benefit
$1,000 policy loan outstanding
$50 accrued policy loan interest
$500 accumulated policy dividends
The correct benefit amount payable for this policy would be $149,450.
$100,000 + $50,000 + $500 – $1,000 – $50 = $149,450
Interest option. When the insured died, the beneficiary, Sammy Duffly, chose
to leave the policy proceeds on deposit with the insurer. The insurer periodically
sends interest payments on the deposited amount to Mr. Duffly. When Mr. Duffly
dies, the insurer will pay the remaining proceeds to Mr. Duffly’s beneficiary.
Fixed-period option. At the insured’s death, Tonya Snellville, the policy beneficiary,
elected to leave the policy proceeds on deposit with the insurer and receive equal
monthly payments of principal and interest for the next 10 years.
Fixed-amount option. As the beneficiary of a life insurance policy, Polly Winder
elected to leave the policy proceeds on deposit with the insurer and receive a
specified payment of principal and interest for as long as the proceeds last.
Life income option. After the insured died, Damian Barrow, the policy beneficiary,
elected to have the policy proceeds used to purchase an annuity that will provide
him with a series of periodic payments of a specified amount for the remainder of
his lifetime.
Claim Investigation
Most life insurance claims require only routine handling and can be paid after
an analysis of the claimant’s statement and proof-of-loss documents. However,
unusual claim situations do occur, as we mentioned in our discussion of claim
processing. For example, if the insured’s death occurred under mysterious circum-
stances or during the suicide exclusion period or the contestable period, an insurer
might need to obtain more information in order to process a claim.
Additional information can be obtained from law enforcement agencies, motor
vehicle records, medical records, criminal court records, credit bureaus, employ-
ers, autopsy reports, investigative consumer reports, and from the producer who
submitted the insurance application. An investigative consumer report contains
information obtained through personal interviews with an individual’s neighbors,
friends, associates, or others who may have information about the individual. To
handle claim investigations, particularly those that might involve fraud, some
companies establish a special investigative unit (SIU), a group of individuals who
are responsible for detecting, investigating, and resolving claims. The SIU is often
composed of representatives of the claim, legal, and internal audit functions, as
well as independent investigators.
Claim Fraud
Anyone who can influence a claim decision or benefit from an approved claim can
commit claim fraud. Such a person can be an insured, a beneficiary, a medical
provider, an insurance producer, or an employee of the insurance company. For
example, claim fraud occurs when
An attorney signs a deceased client’s name to the back of the monthly annuity
benefit checks after the client’s death and keeps the money.
A life insurance applicant pays a healthier person to take his medical examina-
tion so the applicant will be accepted by the insurer.
Fraud Prevention
Many jurisdictions require insurers to take certain measures to prevent, detect,
investigate, and prosecute claim fraud. For example, in most states in the United
States, insurers must report cases of alleged fraud to the state insurance depart-
ment for further investigation and prosecution.
Some states require insurers to form SIUs to investigate suspected cases of
fraud. Claim analysts and SIU staff members receive training in detecting and
investigating insurance claim fraud and in applying the provisions of unfair claim
practices statutes. In addition, many state insurance departments have established
their own fraud investigation units. Insurers also establish continuous education
programs so employees can maintain awareness of existing and new fraudulent
activities to minimize their impact on insurance operations.
Steering Controls
Regulatory Requirements
Claim administration staff must comply with many laws and regulations during
claim processing. The laws that govern a person’s right to privacy, which we’ve
described throughout the text, are of particular importance in claim processing.
For example, privacy laws in many jurisdictions require that claim forms request
only information that an insurer reasonably needs to make a claim decision.
Claim analysts must also protect the confidentiality of information gathered dur-
ing a claim investigation. Insurers may use only lawful, reasonable, and ethical
means of obtaining information when investigating claims. Many jurisdictions
prohibit insurers from conducting a claim investigation under a false pretext in
most circumstances.
Copyright © 2012 LL Global, Inc. All rights reserved. www.loma.org
13.18 Chapter 13: Claim and Annuity Benefit Administration Insurance Company Operations
Failing to affirm or deny coverage of claims within a reasonable time after the
claim investigation is completed
International Laws
Many other countries have laws, regulations, and recent court decisions that affect
claim administration. For example, in Australia, a 2005 High Court decision
resulted in clearer definitions of policy terms used to describe insurance coverage.
In Canada, provincial laws and guidelines for members of the Canadian Life and
Health Insurance Association (CLHIA) provide protection against unfair claim
practices. In Chile, General Regulation 250 oversees exclusions or other restric-
tions on coverage for preexisting conditions for life, disability, and health insur-
ance policies.
Annuity Administration
Annuity administration consists of all of the work an insurer must do between the
time the insurer receives an annuity application until the time the annuity contract
ceases to be in force. For our purposes, we examine two areas of annuity adminis-
tration: (1) processing annuity death benefit claims and (2) handling the scheduled
periodic payments during the payout period.
The claim form for an annuity death benefit identifies the deceased, lists all
contracts for which the death benefit is claimed, and indicates how the beneficiary
wants to receive the proceeds. Once the insurer receives the claim form, claim
processing can begin. Claim processing for annuity death benefit claims is similar
to that for life insurance claims and includes the following activities:
Authenticating and documenting the claim. To administer an annuity death
benefit, insurers require certain documentation, including a claim form and an
official death certificate.
Determining the amount of the death benefit. Most deferred annuities pay a
death benefit equal to the greater of (1) the amount paid into the annuity con-
tract or (2) the annuity contract’s accumulation value on the day the insurer
receives the required proof-of-loss documents.
Paying the death benefit. The insurer pays the annuity death benefit as a
lump sum or according to a settlement option chosen by the contract owner or
beneficiary. Annuity settlement options generally are the same as the settle-
ment options for life insurance policies.
Addressing applicable tax issues. Unlike life insurance death benefits, annu-
ity death benefits typically result in taxable income to the beneficiary. For
this reason, the insurer typically obtains the beneficiary’s tax identification
number. The insurer reports to the beneficiary and to tax authorities the total
death benefit payment, the taxable portion of the payment, and any taxes the
beneficiary elected to have the insurer withhold from the payment.
Nonannuitized options, which are not linked to the life expectancy of any person,
such as (1) lump-sum distributions, (2) fixed-period distributions, and (3) fixed-
amount distributions. These options are similar to corresponding life insurance policy
settlement options.
Annuitized options tie annuity payments to the life expectancy of the annuitant. To
simplify, assume that the annuitant—the person whose lifetime is used to measure the
length of time that lifetime payments are payable under an annuity policy—and the
payee—the person who receives the annuity payments—are the same person.
A life annuity, also called a life only annuity, provides periodic payments only for
as long as the annuitant lives.
A joint and survivor life annuity is a life annuity that provides a series of periodic
payments based on the life expectancies of two or more annuitants. Payments
continue until the last annuitant dies.
A life income with period certain annuity guarantees that annuity payments
will be made throughout the annuitant’s lifetime and that payments will continue
for at least a specified period, even if the annuitant dies before the end of that
period. If the annuitant dies before the specified period expires, a contingent
payee designated by the policyowner will receive annuity payments throughout
the remainder of the specified period.
A life income with refund annuity, also called a refund annuity, provides
annuity payments throughout the lifetime of the annuitant. This annuity provides
a guarantee that at least the purchase price of the annuity will be paid out.
Suppose the annuitant dies before the total purchase price of the annuity has
been paid in benefits. In this case, the insurer issues a refund to the contingent
payee equal to the difference between the purchase price and the amount that
has been paid out.
Source: Adapted from Miriam A. Orsina and Gene Stone, Insurance Company Operations, 2nd ed. [Atlanta: LOMA (Life Office
Management Association, Inc.), © 2005], 306. Used with permission; all rights reserved.
Key Terms
claim administration claim investigation
claim analyst death certificate
claimant exclusion
claim philosophy suicide exclusion
claim practices accidental death benefit
claim form retained asset account (RAA) option
third-party administrator (TPA) interpleader
claim fraud investigative consumer report
mistaken claim special investigative unit (SIU)
material misrepresentation Unfair Claims Settlement
rescission Practices Act
contestable period annuity date
Additional Activities
If you want to relate the information in this chapter to your company, try these
activities:
Look at your company’s website. Click on the tab for the Claims page and
review the ways in which a claimant can submit an individual life insurance
claim to your company.
Obtain a copy of your company’s claim form. This form is also likely to be
found on your company’s website, on the Claims page. What proof of death
does your company require?
If your company offers annuities, compare how the claim form for annuity
death benefits differs from the claim form for life insurance benefits.
Endnotes
1. LOMA, Death Claim Processing (Individual Products), Information Center Brief [Atlanta: LOMA
(Life Office Management Association, Inc.), © 2009)]. Used with permission; all rights reserved.
Chapter 14
Customer Service
Objectives
After studying this chapter, you should be able to
Explain why providing exceptional customer service is important to
insurance companies
Define work team and explain the purpose of a customer contact center
Identify customer service job positions and explain the relationships
between customer service and other organizational functions
List the characteristics of effective customer service and explain how
providing effective customer service contributes to customer loyalty and
customer relationship management
Define a seamless process and describe the role that technology plays in
providing seamless and personalized customer service
Describe the customer service processes for fulfilling customer requests,
handling complaints, and conserving, up-selling, and cross-selling
insurance and annuity products
Describe the differences between customer service processes for group
products and those for individual products
Identify and describe common controls used in customer service to
enhance the customer experience
Outline
Organization of the Customer Customer Service Processes
Service Department Fulfilling Customer Requests
Typical Customer Service Job Handling Customer Complaints
Positions Conserving, Up-Selling,
Customer Service Department and Cross-Selling
Relationships Customer Service Processes for
Group Products
Effective Customer Service
Education and Training Control Mechanisms for
Technology Customer Service
Customer Relationship Qualitative Performance
Management Measurements
Quantitative Performance
Measurements
E
mployees who interact directly with customers clearly play a role in customer
satisfaction. However, do employees in support functions, like accounting,
who seem far removed from external customers, have an impact, too? What
if accounting doesn’t promptly process a customer’s benefit payment? What if an
IT technician is slow in repairing or replacing a CSR’s computer so that fewer CSRs
are available to answer customers’ questions than are needed? Employees in sup-
port functions provide services to employees who interact directly with external
customers. Without those support services, employees who interact with external
customers couldn’t satisfy customer needs. In one way or another, customer ser-
vice is the responsibility of every insurance company employee. Customer service
consists of a broad range of activities that an insurer and its employees perform to
keep customers satisfied so that they continue doing business with the company
and speak positively about it to other potential customers.
Insurance companies that commit to delivering exceptional customer service
encourage each employee to think of himself as a customer service provider by
focusing on how the work he performs affects customers. Why is exceptional cus-
tomer service important? Exceptional customer service (1) enhances a company’s
image, (2) attracts new customers, (3) helps companies retain existing customers,
(4) makes it easier to recruit new employees and producers, (5) reduces the amount
of time employees spend correcting problems, and (6) potentially increases a com-
pany’s profitability.
According to a 2009 Accenture study of 4,100 consumers in eight countries
across five continents, two-thirds (67 percent) of respondents reported moving
their business to other companies because of poor service. The study also found
that “the number who left because of a poor customer experience was significantly
higher than the number of those who left a business because they found a lower
price elsewhere.”1 What this means for insurers is that customer service is a great
way for an insurer to differentiate itself from its competitors in the marketplace
and increase profitability.
Organization of the
Customer Service Department
Although customer service is every employee’s job, for purposes of this chapter,
we now focus on the customer service activities that the “customer service” unit
within an insurance company provides. The department within an insurance com-
pany whose primary responsibility is performing customer service activities can go
by many names, such as customer service, policyowner service, or client services.
Customer service for group insurance products is often called member services.
The management structure of the customer service department is similar to that
of other departments. An executive such as a vice president or senior vice presi-
dent oversees the department. Some insurers establish one department or area to
deal with every kind of customer service activity. Other insurers divide customer
service activities by product, territory, distribution system, customer, method of
communication, or service request, for example.
Some insurers further assign customer service employees to separate work
teams, two or more people who work together on a regular basis and coordinate
their activities to accomplish common goals. The work teams report to a super-
visor. The supervisor reports to the department manager, who generally reports
to a member of the insurer’s senior management. In some companies, customer
service work teams are employees in processing centers, which handle all cus-
tomer contacts related to a particular process. For example, customers might
contact the claim processing center for claim inquiries or the billing service cen-
ter for billing inquiries. Typical employees in a processing center have greater
knowledge and experience about a particular process than do employees in a
general customer service department.
Most insurance companies have specialized customer service units that serve
as a customer’s first contact with the insurer. Because these organizational units
initially relied primarily upon telephone technology, they were known as call cen-
ters. However, advances in communications technology now provide customers
with a variety of channels for receiving customer service. A customer contact
center, also called a customer care center, provides customers with a variety of
channels, such as telephone, fax, e-mail, Internet chat, and traditional mail, for
communicating with a company. Some customer contact centers handle only rou-
tine customer requests for information and forward other customer requests to
processing centers. Other customer contact centers directly handle a relatively
high percentage of the customer processing requests, while transferring relatively
few requests to processing centers for handling. Customer contact centers rely
heavily on technology, such as customer databases and document management
systems, to provide needed customer service.
Example: Josie Rodriguez has been a CSR at the Rightful Life Insurance
Company for less than two years. She processes routine customer
requests, which include making changes to a policyowner’s name,
address, and contact preferences. Hank Aspinall, a senior CSR at Rightful,
has nine years of experience in customer service. He typically handles
more complex customer service requests and transactions such as policy
surrenders and reinstatements.
Lapse and
replacement Lapse and replacement
statistics Customer Service statistics
Department
Training
updates
Actuarial
Marketing
Service
Requests for
information
Producers
Source: Adapted from Miriam A. Orsina and Gene Stone, Insurance Company Operations, 2nd ed. [Atlanta: LOMA (Life Office
Management Association, Inc.), © 2005], 262. Used with permission; all rights reserved.
Courteous. The CSR is polite, tactful, and attentive to the customer’s feelings
and situation.
Confidential. Only authorized customers and staff can access and view infor-
mation and perform transactions.
Convenient. Customers can get the services they need when, where, and how
they want the services delivered.
Technology
Insurers provide effective customer service and encourage customer loyalty
by providing a seamless customer service process through a variety of service
options. A seamless process is a smooth process designed so that a customer is
not inconvenienced by—or even aware of—the steps involved in fulfilling the
customer’s request. Many automated systems, such as workflow systems, docu-
ment management systems, and other systems which we described in Chapter 5,
are essential pieces that together allow an insurer to provide a seamless customer
service process. Technology also helps in providing personalized customer service
through a variety of service options.
Most insurers offer customers a choice of self-service, human-assisted ser-
vice, or a combination of self-service and human-assisted service. Some people
want customer service to be conveniently available anytime and anywhere. With
a self-service option, the entire customer experience for some transactions can be
fully automated and available whenever the customer requires service. To ensure
security, an insurance company typically assigns a login and password or per-
sonal identification number (PIN) to authorized policyowners so they can confirm
their identities before making routine changes and requests through an automated
system. Routine requests include changing contact information and handling pre-
mium payments. In some cases, a transaction confirmation that includes contact
information for an insurance company employee is sent to the customer so the
customer has a personal contact with the company should she have any additional
questions or problems.
In addition, many insurers offer self-service website options to producers that
allow them to obtain product information, print copies of marketing materials,
prepare sales presentations, and submit applications or changes on behalf of their
customers. Another self-service option is the interactive voice response (IVR) sys-
tem described in Chapter 5. Using this system, customers may pay premiums,
check the status of applications and claims, and order forms.
Many customers prefer more direct contact with a CSR. Traditional toll-free
telephone numbers still allow customers to connect directly with a CSR at an
insurer’s customer contact center. However, insurers are also providing ways for
customers to connect to CSRs through the Internet. E-mail allows a customer to
contact a CSR and receive a response within a designated time, such as within 24
hours. When a customer chooses to communicate via instant messaging or web
chat, the customer types a question, which then appears on the CSR’s computer
screen. When the CSR types a response, the response appears on the customer’s
computer screen below the original question. Web callback allows a customer to
click on an icon at a website and request that a CSR call the customer on the tele-
phone. Web collaboration, also called collaborative browsing or shadowing, is
a technology that enables participants to “meet” at a website, synchronize their
browsers, and explore the website together, communicating with each other in real
time. With web collaboration, a CSR can help a customer complete a form online.
Insurers typically offer a combination of self-service and human-assisted
customer service because many insurance transactions are complex and require
human assistance. Many times self-service customers access the insurer’s web-
site, but find that they need help in completing their transactions. Still, providing
self-service options for less complex transactions frees CSRs to focus more on the
complicated ones.
Insurers can provide faster and more personalized service through an auto-
matic call distributor (ACD). The ACD can be programmed to route calls based
on the skills necessary to process the request. This process is called skill-based
routing (SBR), and the call is transferred to the most appropriate CSR based on
the caller’s answers to questions. One advantage of using the SBR system is fewer
call transfers, as customers reach the CSR who can perform their request without
being transferred multiple times. Computer systems that match a caller’s telephone
number or some other type of personal identifier with information in the insurer’s
database can send the customer’s records directly to the CSR’s computer screen
so that the CSR can provide personalized service to the customer. Other systems
described in Chapter 5 allow CSRs to access and manage customer information
more efficiently.
Offers products and services to satisfy those needs. Recall that privacy
laws and regulations set limits on how specific information can be used. The
insurer’s legal and compliance departments provide guidelines for CSRs in
using customer information.
An insurance company can achieve the benefits of CRM only if it takes steps
to promote a culture in which everyone in the company makes customer service a
primary business goal. Theoretically, employees are empowered to take quick
action, within certain limits, to do whatever is necessary to meet and exceed cus-
tomer expectations. In practice, this means delegating more authority and account-
ability to CSRs and other front-line employees. The insurer must give those
employees the necessary technology, training, and education to do their work;
create customer-oriented automated systems; and frequently measure customer
satisfaction to ensure that CRM goals and objectives are being met.
Life insurance policy surrenders. The owner of a cash value life insurance
policy can surrender—terminate—his policy and receive an amount of money
known as the policy’s net cash surrender value. Most insurers require the
policyowner to submit a signed surrender request form to terminate a policy.
Some insurers require that the policyowner return the surrendered policy with
the surrender request. For life insurance policy surrenders, the CSR notifies
the producer of record about the pending surrender and reviews the benefits of
keeping the policy in force and the disadvantages of surrendering the policy
with the policyowner. To process a policy surrender, the CSR calculates the net
cash surrender value and arranges for payment of that amount to the policy-
owner. Figure 14.2 lists items that are commonly added to and subtracted from
a life insurance policy’s cash value to determine the net cash surrender value.
Additions Subtractions
Cash value of paid-up Outstanding policy loans
additions
Accumulated policy Accrued policy loan
dividends interest
Advance premium Any surrender charges
payments
Annuity surrenders. The net cash surrender value for an annuity is the amount
of a deferred annuity’s accumulated value, less any surrender charges, that the
annuity contract owner is entitled to receive if the contract is surrendered dur-
ing its accumulation period. Cash surrenders are not available for immediate
annuities or for deferred annuities that have entered the payout period. The
contract owner can choose to surrender the entire annuity or elect a partial
surrender. In a partial surrender, the contract owner withdraws only a por-
tion of the annuity’s accumulated value instead of surrendering the contract
entirely. Annuity withdrawals may be subject to mortality charges, surrender
charges, and income taxes.
Policy loans. Recall that a policy loan is a loan a life insurance company
makes to the owner of a life insurance policy that has a cash value. Although
the policy loan does not have to be repaid, most insurers offer policyowners
a choice of loan repayment plans. Many insurers accept telephone requests
for loans under a certain monetary amount and require written requests for
amounts over that limit. Some insurers require a written request for all policy
loans. The CSR examines the policy record to ensure that the policyowner
has made the request and that the request contains all applicable signatures:
assignee, irrevocable beneficiary, or spouse in a community property jurisdic-
tion. The CSR determines the cash value available under a policy and, assum-
ing that the cash value is at least equal to the loan amount requested, arranges
payment to the policyowner.
updates the records to reflect the terminated policy or annuity contract. The
policy administration system calculates the net cash surrender value of the
surrendered policy and transfers the amount to the policyowner or, in some
cases, the replacing insurer. In the United States, the rules and required paper-
work to accomplish replacement vary greatly by state.
Reinstatements. After a life insurance policy has lapsed, the policyowner
may ask to have the original policy reinstated. Recall that reinstatement is the
process by which an insurer puts back in force a policy that lapsed because of
nonpayment of renewal premiums. For a policy to be reinstated it must contain
a provision that allows policy reinstatement. If the policyowner has surren-
dered the policy, a right to reinstate the policy is generally not available. Also,
an insurer is not obligated to reinstate a policy just because an insurer has
included a reinstatement provision in that policy. Typically, the CSR submits
the reinstatement application to underwriting. Under certain circumstances,
however, the CSR may be authorized to approve the reinstatement. In such
cases, the CSR obtains from the policy administration system the amount of
(1) back premiums due and (2) outstanding premium policy loans payable.
The process of ensuring that policies do not lapse but remain in force as long
as possible is called conservation. As mentioned before, policies that have been in
force for a long time are more profitable for insurers than policies that lapse soon
after policy issue. Before processing a life insurance policy surrender request, a
CSR may attempt to conserve the policy by suggesting one or more of the follow-
ing alternatives:
The policyowner can avoid future premium payments and still continue insur-
ance coverage by using the policy’s net cash surrender value to purchase either
reduced paid-up insurance or extended term insurance.
The policyowner can obtain funds and continue the insurance coverage by
taking out a policy loan.
The owner of a universal life insurance policy can reduce the amount of future
premium payments by reducing the policy’s face amount.
The owner of a universal life insurance policy that provides a policy with-
drawal feature can withdraw part of the policy’s cash value.
The policyowner can change the premium payment method to one that is
more manageable financially, such as from an annual premium payment to a
monthly premium payment.
An orphan policyowner can be assigned to a new producer, and encouraged to
meet with the new producer before surrendering the policy.
Example: A policyowner wants to use his policy’s cash value for making a
down payment on a house. The CSR points out that the policyowner can
obtain the funds he needs for the house and still continue his insurance
coverage by taking out a policy loan. If the policy were a universal life
insurance policy, the CSR would point out that the policyowner may
withdraw part of the policy’s cash value under the policy withdrawal
feature. In either case, the CSR is attempting to conserve the existing
policy.
During a CSR’s conversation with a customer, the CSR might realize that the
customer could benefit from an insurer’s additional products or services. The CSR
could inform the customer of the availability of such products without attempt-
ing to make a sale. The CSR might ask the customer’s permission to transfer the
customer to a licensed producer to talk further, or the CSR might forward the
customer’s information to a producer after the call ends. If the CSR is licensed
appropriately, the CSR can engage in up-selling or cross-selling. Up-selling is
promoting a more powerful, more enhanced, or more profitable product than the
one a customer originally considers.
Group Administration
Once installed, a group insurance product may be administered by the insurance
company that sold the coverage, by a third-party administrator, or by the group
itself. If the insurance company administers the insurance or annuity plan, the
member services department usually maintains life insurance enrollment cards,
records of dates and amounts of premiums received, life insurance claims filed
and paid, commissions paid, and other payments that affect the group policy. The
member services unit updates the insurer’s records as group insureds are added to
or terminated from the plan. Member services also handle complaints and answer
inquiries from the group policyholder, the plan administrator, and group insureds.
Steering Controls
Policies and
procedures
Authority levels
Performance
standards
Training
Customer service activities are probably the most frequently measured activi-
ties in an insurance company. Managers regularly monitor and evaluate customer
service performance by using qualitative performance measurements and quan-
titative performance measurements. A qualitative performance measurement
focuses on behaviors, attitudes, or opinions to determine how efficiently and
effectively processes and transactions are completed. A quantitative performance
measurement uses numerical methods to track and report results to determine
how efficiently and effectively processes and transactions are completed.
Insurers also use persistency rates to gauge the quality of customer service. A
persistency rate is the percentage of an insurer’s business in force at the begin-
ning of a specified period that remains in force at the end of the period. Theoreti-
cally, a high or rising persistency rate indicates that customers are satisfied with
the company’s products and the quality of its customer service. Conversely, a low
or declining persistency rate could mean that customers are dissatisfied with the
company and its products.
Figure 14.6 describes other quantitative measures that insurers use to evalu-
ate customer service transactions regarding service level, timeliness, quality, and
departmental productivity.
Source: Adapted from Mary C. Bickley et al., Insurance Administration, 4th ed. (Atlanta: LL Global, Inc., © 2011), 78. Used
with permission; all rights reserved.
Key Terms
customer service partial surrender
work team replacement
customer contact center reinstatement
customer service representative (CSR) complaint management system
customer loyalty complaint team
seamless process conservation
web callback up-selling
web collaboration cross-selling
skill-based routing (SBR) member services
irrevocable beneficiary moment of truth
talking points qualitative performance measurement
script quantitative performance
automatic payment plan measurement
producer of record customer satisfaction survey
orphan policyowner monitoring
policy rider empathy
net cash surrender value mystery shopper
Additional Activities
If you want to relate the information in this chapter to your company, try these
activities:
Can you think of an example of a moment of truth in your job? You might
have had a direct interaction with a customer that helped create a good or bad
impression in the mind of a customer. If you work in a support function, how
have you indirectly contributed to a moment of truth?
Visit your company’s website to determine which customer service transac-
tions are fully automated. Does your company offer web chat or web call-
back?
Consider the average speed to answer the next time you make a telephone call
to a business. If it takes the company a long time to answer, how do you feel
about the company?
Endnotes
1. LOMA, Customer Experience Management, Information Center Brief [Atlanta: LOMA (Life Office
Management Association, Inc.), © 2009]. Used with permission; all rights reserved.
Glossary
call provision. A bond provision that states the conditions under which the bond
issuer has the right to require the bondholder to sell the bond back to the issuer
at a date earlier than the maturity date. [8]
Canadian Securities Association (CSA). A Canadian association whose mission
is to develop a national system of harmonized securities regulation throughout
Canada. [6]
capital. The excess of a company’s assets over its liabilities. [3]
capital and surplus ratio. A solvency ratio that describes the relationship between
an insurer’s capital and surplus and its liabilities. [6]
capital gain. The amount by which the selling price of an investment is more than
its purchase price. [8]
capital loss. The amount by which the selling price of an investment is less than
its purchase price. [8]
career agent. An agent who is under a full-time contract with one insurance com-
pany and sells primarily that company’s life insurance products. [11]
cash accounting. See treasury operations.
cash flow. Any movement of cash into or out of an organization. [6]
cash flow statement. A financial statement that provides information about a
company’s cash receipts (inflows), cash disbursements (outflows), and the net
change in cash (the difference between cash inflows and cash outflows) during
a specified accounting period. [7]
cash inflow. A movement of cash into an organization. Also known as a source of
funds. [6]
cash management. See treasury operations.
cash outflow. A movement of cash out of an organization. Also known as a use of
funds. [6]
CCO. See chief compliance officer.
ceding company. See direct writer.
centralized organization. An organization in which top management retains most
of the decision-making authority for the entire company. [1]
CEO. See chief executive officer.
certificate of authority. A document that grants an insurer the right to conduct an
insurance business and sell insurance products in the jurisdiction that grants the
certificate. Also known as a license. [3]
certificate of insurance. A document that describes (1) the coverage that the mas-
ter group insurance contract provides and (2) the group insured’s rights under
the contract. [12]
CFO. See chief financial officer.
chain of command. The organizational structure that identifies who reports to
whom in the company, and supports the delegation of authority. [1]
claim philosophy. A statement of the principles the insurer will follow when con-
ducting claim administration. [13]
claim practices. Statements that guide claim department employees in the day-to-
day handling of claims. [13]
claim processing. See claim administration.
claim servicing. See claim administration.
claim specialist. See claim analyst.
claimant. A person—usually a beneficiary or policyowner—who submits a life
insurance policy claim to the insurance company. [13]
claimant’s statement. See claim form. [13]
classroom training. An employee training method in which an instructor lectures
to a group of employees, leads the group in discussion, or directs the group
members as they do various exercises, such as role-playing. [4]
click-wrap. A technology in which an insurance applicant clicks a secure web-
based “I agree” or “I accept” button on an electronic insurance application.
[12]
cloud computing. A subscription-based or pay-per-use service that, in real time
over the Internet, provides access to networks, platforms, applications, or other
IT elements that can extend an IT department’s existing capabilities. [5]
CMO. See collateralized mortgage obligation.
CMS. See content management system.
code of business conduct. See code of conduct.
code of conduct. A formal statement of a company’s values and its expectations
for how its employees should behave in the course of business. Also known as
a code of business conduct or a code of ethics. [2]
code of ethics. See code of conduct.
cognitive abilities test. See aptitude test.
cold calling. The process of telephoning or visiting prospects with whom a pro-
ducer has had no prior contact. [11]
collaborative browsing. See web collaboration.
collaborative software. Software programs that provide a work team, that may
be geographically dispersed, with the tools to communicate, collaborate, and
problem-solve over the Internet. [5]
collateral. An asset that is pledged as security for a loan until the debt is paid. [8]
collateralized mortgage obligation (CMO). A bond secured by a pool of residen-
tial mortgage loans. [8]
commission. An amount of money, typically a percentage of the premiums paid
for the sale of an insurance policy, that an insurer pays for selling and servicing
an insurance or annuity policy. [1]
data warehouse. A central repository for data that a company collects from its ex-
isting databases, its internal administrative systems, and possibly from sources
outside the company for managers to use in decision making. [5]
database. An organized collection of data and information. [5]
database management system (DBMS). A group of computer programs that or-
ganizes the data in a database and allows users to obtain the information they
need. [5]
Day 1 functionality. The administrative and systems processes that must be in
place and functioning before an insurance product can be introduced to market.
[10]
Day 2 functionality. The administrative and systems processes that are necessary
at some future date to service and administer an insurance product, but which
can be implemented after the product has been launched. [10]
death certificate. A document that attests to the death of a person and bears the
signature—and sometimes the seal—of an official authorized to issue such a
certificate. [13]
debenture. A bond that is not backed by collateral but only by the full faith and
credit of the issuer. Also known as an unsecured bond. [8]
debit agent. See home service agent.
debits. In the numerical rating system, a proposed insured’s medical and personal
risk factors that have an unfavorable effect on mortality and are assigned “plus”
values (such as +25). [12]
debt security. A financial security that represents an obligation of indebtedness
owed by a business, government, or an agency. [8]
decentralized organization. An organization in which top management shares
decision making authority with employees at lower levels. [1]
declined class. A risk class composed of proposed insureds whose anticipated ex-
tra mortality is so great that an insurer cannot provide coverage at an affordable
cost or whose mortality risk cannot be predicted because of recent or unusual
medical conditions or other risk factors. [12]
delegation. In a company, the process of assigning authority and responsibility to
an employee for completing a specific task. [1]
demutualization. The process an insurer undertakes to convert from a mutual
form of ownership to a stock form of ownership. [3]
departmentalization. The process of grouping similar or related work activities—
jobs or processes—into units. [1]
differentiated marketing. A marketing strategy that aims to satisfy the needs of
different segments of the total market for a particular type of product by offer-
ing a number of products and marketing mixes designed to appeal to the differ-
ent segments. [9]
Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). A U.S. federal law that regulates the report-
ing and use of consumer information and seeks to ensure that consumer reports
contain only accurate, relevant, and recent information. [12]
Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). A United States federal law that sets a mini-
mum hourly wage an employer must pay. [4]
favorable variance. In budgeting, an accounting result in which actual revenues
are greater than expected revenues and/or actual expenses are less than ex-
pected expenses. [7]
fax machine. A telecommunications device that sends and receives printed pages
over telephone lines. [5]
FCRA. See Fair Credit Reporting Act.
feasibility study. In a comprehensive business analysis, research designed to de-
termine the operational and technical viability of producing and selling a prod-
uct. [10]
feedback control. An organizational control applied to a business process at the
end of the process cycle to compare actual performance or output with estab-
lished standards. [2]
feedforward control. See steering control.
field advisory council. A group of producers designated to represent and provide
feedback from the sales force on such topics as product design and customer
service. [10]
field force. The collective term for an insurer’s affiliated agents. [11]
field office. An office in which an insurer’s affiliated agents work. [11]
field underwriting. The process in which producers gather initial information
about applicants and proposed insureds to determine if they are likely to be ap-
proved for a specific type of insurance coverage. [12]
field underwriting manual. A manual that guides a producer in (1) assessing the
risks a proposed insured represents and in (2) assembling and submitting the
application and any required evidence of insurability. [12]
finance. See financial management.
financial accounting. The field of accounting that focuses primarily on reporting
a company’s financial accounting information to meet the needs of the com-
pany’s external stakeholders. [7]
financial condition examination. A formal investigation of an insurer that in-
surance regulators perform to identify and monitor any threats to an insurer’s
solvency. [6]
financial consultant. In a bank-distributed system of insurance sales, a person
whose primary function is to sell investment products to bank customers, but
who is also licensed to sell insurance. [11]
financial design. The combination of a life insurance product’s financial features.
[9]
general agency. An insurance company field office that is established and financed
by a general agent. [11]
general agent. An agent who establishes and finances an insurance field office
known as a general agency. [11]
general counsel. The person in charge of an insurance company’s legal depart-
ment. [3]
generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP). A set of financial accounting
standards, conventions, and rules that U.S. stock insurers follow when summa-
rizing transactions and preparing financial statements. [7]
goal. A desired future outcome. Also called an objective. [1]
going-concern concept. An accounting principle that requires a company’s ac-
counting records to reflect the assumption that the company will continue to
operate indefinitely. [7]
group insurance policy. See master group insurance contract.
group insured. A group member who is covered by a group insurance contract.
[12]
group member. For insurance purposes, the individuals who are part of a group
but are not covered by insurance. Contrast with group insured. [12]
group plan. See master group insurance contract.
group representative. Salaried insurance company employees specifically trained
in the techniques of marketing and servicing group products. [12]
groupthink. A phenomenon in which the members of a group stress conformity
and unanimity to the point where alternative courses of action are ignored. [4]
hardware. The equipment or mechanical devices included in a computer system.
[5]
hedging. A risk management strategy that involves balancing one risk with a com-
plementary risk that will ideally offset the original risk. [6]
holding company. A company that has a controlling interest in one or more other
companies. [1]
home country staffing. A staffing option for international operations that involves
placing employees from a multinational company’s home country into an inter-
national office. [4]
home service agent. An agent who sells specified products, typically low face
amount cash value life insurance with monthly premiums, and provides policy-
owner service in an assigned geographic territory. Also known as a debit agent.
[11]
host country staffing. A staffing option for international operations that involves
staffing an international office with employees from the host country. [4]
hosted applications. See software as a service.
human resources planning. The identification and evaluation of the human re-
source requirements needed to meet organizational goals. [4]
idea generation. The step in the product development process that involves search-
ing for new product ideas that are consistent with both the company’s overall
product development strategy and the needs of its target markets. [10]
IFRS. See International Financial Reporting Standards.
image advertising. See institutional advertising.
imaging. The process of using technology to convert printed characters or graph-
ics into digital images that can be stored electronically or, depending upon the
technology, edited. Also known as scanning. [5]
income statement. A financial document that shows a company’s revenues and
expenses over a specified period, such as a year, and shows whether the com-
pany experienced a profit or a loss during that period. [6]
independent agent. An independent contractor who works for an insurance com-
pany and who may be an affiliated or nonaffiliated agent of the insurer. [11]
independent audit. See external audit.
independent contractor. A person who contracts to do a specific task according
to his own methods and who generally is not subject to the employer’s control
except as to the end product or final result of the work. [11]
independent director. See outside director.
independent financial advisor. In the United States, an individual registered with
the Securities and Exchange Commission to give advice about investment se-
curities. Also known as a registered investment advisor (RIA). [11]
information. A collection of data that has been converted into a form that is mean-
ingful or can be used to accomplish some objective. [5]
information management. All of the people, processes, and technology compa-
nies use to create and manage corporate information. [5]
inside director. A member of the board of directors who holds a position within
the company in addition to her position on the board. [1]
inside information. A company’s nonpublic, material information that employees
and other individuals associated with the company are restricted from disclos-
ing to third parties or using for their individual benefit. [2]
insider trading. Buying or selling a company’s securities (stocks or bonds) based
upon inside information. [2]
insolvency. A situation in which a company is unable to meet its financial obliga-
tions. [6]
instant messaging. The direct transmission of text-based communication in real
time over communication networks. When used by a company’s employees, it
is faster than e-mail and doesn’t clog the company’s e-mail system. When used
by customers to connect to a company, it is often known as web chat, text chat,
or Internet chat. [5]
Life-1. A financial report that insurers operating in Canada must submit to the Of-
fice of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) and to the regulators
of every province in which the insurer does business. [6]
line function. An area within a company that creates value for the customer
through various customer-oriented activities. [1]
liquid assets. A company’s cash and other assets that are readily marketable for
their true value. [6]
liquidity. The ease and speed with which an asset can be converted to cash for an
approximation of its true value. [6]
litigation. The process or act of presenting a dispute to a court of law for a resolu-
tion. [3]
location-selling system. A method for distributing insurance products that is de-
signed to generate customer-initiated sales at an office or information kiosk in a
store, shopping mall, or other non-insurance business establishment. [11]
lockbox. A post office box that policyowners use to remit premium payments. [7]
management accounting. The field of accounting that focuses primarily on iden-
tifying, measuring, analyzing, and communicating financial information to a
company’s internal stakeholders, particularly company managers, so they can
decide how best to use the company’s resources. [7]
MAR. See attending physician’s statement (APS).
market analysis. An evaluation of all of the environmental factors that might af-
fect product sales, including target market characteristics, economic conditions,
legal or regulatory requirements, and tax considerations. [10]
market conduct examination. In the United States, a formal investigation of an
insurer by one or more state insurance departments to determine if the insurer’s
market conduct—that is, nonfinancial operations—are in compliance with ap-
plicable laws and regulations. [3]
market segment. A submarket or group of customers with similar needs and pref-
erences. [9]
market segmentation. The process of dividing large, diverse markets into smaller
submarkets that are more alike and need relatively similar products or market-
ing mixes. [9]
marketing. The activity, set of institutions, and processes for creating, commu-
nicating, delivering, and exchanging offerings that have value for customers,
clients, business partners, and society at large. [9]
marketing audit. A systematic examination and appraisal of a company’s mar-
keting goals, strategies, tactical/action programs, organizational structure, and
personnel on a very broad basis. [9]
marketing environment. All of the elements in a company’s internal and external
environments that directly or indirectly affect the company’s ability to carry out
its marketing activities. [9]
marketing information system. A set of procedures and methods for the regular,
planned collection, analysis, and presentation of information for use in making
marketing decisions. [9]
marketing mix. The four primary marketing variables—product, price, promo-
tion, and distribution—that companies manage in order to fulfill marketing
goals. [9]
marketing plan. A written document that states the marketing goals for a product
or product line, and describes the strategies and the implementation and control
efforts the company intends to use to achieve those goals. [9]
marketing projections. In a comprehensive business analysis, preliminary sales
and financial forecasts that include estimates of potential unit sales, revenues,
costs, and profits for a proposed product. [10]
marketing research. A method of collecting, analyzing, interpreting, and report-
ing information in order to identify marketing opportunities and solve market-
ing problems. [9]
mass marketing. See undifferentiated marketing.
master application. An application for group insurance that contains the specific
provisions of the requested plan of insurance and is signed by an authorized
officer of the proposed policyholder. [12]
master budget. A budget which shows the overall operating and financing plans
for a company during a specified accounting period; formed by combining all
of the individual department budgets. [7]
master group insurance contract. A legal document that certifies the relation-
ship between the insurer and the group policyholder and specifies the benefits
provided by the contract. Also known as the group insurance policy or group
plan. [12]
material information. Any company information that might influence the market
price of a company’s securities. [2]
material misrepresentation. A statement made in an application for insurance
that is not true and that caused the insurer to enter into a contract it would not
have agreed to if it had known the truth. [13]
maturity date. For a bond, the date on which the bond issuer is legally obligated
to pay the bondholder the bond’s par value. [8]
maturity value. See par value.
mediation. An alternative dispute resolution method in which an impartial third
party, known as a mediator, facilitates negotiations between the parties to a legal
dispute in an effort to create a mutually agreeable resolution of the dispute. [3]
mediator. An impartial third party who facilitates negotiations between disputing
parties in the process of mediation. [3]
medical attendant’s report (MAR). See attending physician’s statement (APS).
policy loan. A loan made by a life insurance company to the owner of a life insur-
ance policy that has a cash value. [8]
policy rider. An amendment to an insurance policy that either expands or limits
the benefits payable under the policy. [14]
policy summary. A document that provides the customer with information spe-
cific to the policy being purchased including premium and benefit data. [10]
policyowner. A person or business that owns an insurance policy. [1]
portfolio. A collection of assets assembled for the purpose of meeting a defined set
of financial goals. [6]
positioning. The process by which a company establishes and maintains in cus-
tomers’ minds a distinct place, or position, for itself and its products. [9]
PPGA. See personal-producing general agent.
pre-contract training. A trial program that permits an insurance producer can-
didate who has satisfied the initial screening process to prepare to become a
producer while continuing to work at a current job. [11]
preferred class. A risk class composed of proposed insureds whose anticipated
mortality is lower than average and who represent the lowest degree of mortal-
ity risk. [12]
premium accounting. The maintenance of accounting records and reports of in-
surance premium transactions. Also known as policy accounting. [7]
price. The monetary value of whatever a customer exchanges for a product. [9]
principal. For an investment, the amount of money originally invested. [8]
private placement. A method of issuing securities in which the issuer sells the
security directly to a limited number of investors, typically institutional inves-
tors. [8]
problem resolution team. See complaint team.
producer group. An organization of independent insurance producers that negoti-
ate compensation, product, and service agreements with insurance companies.
[11]
producer of record. The agent, broker, or other type of producer currently provid-
ing service to the policyowner. [14]
product. The goods, services, or ideas that a seller offers to customers to satisfy
a need. [9]
product advertising. Any advertising used to promote a specific product or ser-
vice. [9]
product design objective. In a comprehensive business analysis, a specification of
an insurance product’s basic characteristics, features, benefits, issue limits, age
limits, commission and premium structure, and operational and administrative
requirements. [10]
product development. The process of creating or modifying a product. [10]
request for proposal (RFP). A document that provides detailed information about
the group and the requested coverage and solicits a bid from an insurer to pro-
vide that coverage. [12]
required rate of return. For a given investment, the sum of the risk-free rate of
return and the risk premium. See risk-free rate of return and risk premium.
[8]
rescission. The legal process of voiding an insurance contract because of material
misrepresentation in the insurance application. [13]
responsibility. In a company, a duty or a task assigned to an employee. [1]
retained asset account (RAA) option. A settlement option that allows an insurer
to pay a life insurance policy’s proceeds into an interest-bearing account in the
payee’s name; the payee can then withdraw all or part of the proceeds at any
time. [13]
revenue. An amount that a company earns from its business operations. [6]
RFP. See request for proposal.
RIA. See independent financial advisor.
risk. The possibility that an investment or other venture might have an unexpected
result. [6]
risk class. A group of insureds that represent a similar level of risk to an insurance
company. [12]
risk management. The process of systematically identifying, assessing, and mini-
mizing the negative impact of risk. [6]
risk premium. The compensation that investors demand for taking on the risk as-
sociated with a specific investment. See risk-free rate of return and required
rate of return. [8]
risk-free rate of return. The return on a risk-free investment—the least risky
investment opportunity available. See required rate of return and risk pre-
mium. [8]
risk-return trade-off. The interplay between risk and return; according to this
interplay, in general, the greater the risk associated with an investment, the
greater the expected return on the investment; conversely, the lower the risk as-
sociated with an investment then, generally, the lower the expected return. [8]
SaaS. See software as a service.
salaried sales agent. See salaried sales representative.
salaried sales representative. A company employee who is paid a salary for mak-
ing insurance sales and providing sales support. Also known as a salaried sales
agent. [11]
sale-and-leaseback transaction. A method of investing in real estate under which
the owner of a building sells the building to an investor, but immediately leases
back the building from the investor. [8]
special investigative unit (SIU). A group of individuals who are responsible for
detecting, investigating, and resolving claims, particularly those involving in-
surance fraud; often composed of representatives of the claim, legal, and inter-
nal audit functions as well as independent investigators. [13]
specialized medical questionnaire. A document that requests detailed informa-
tion about a specific illness or condition from a proposed insured’s attending
physician or a physician who has examined the proposed insured at the request
of the insurance company. [12]
staff function. See support function.
stakeholder. Any party that has an interest in how a company conducts its busi-
ness. [1]
standard class. A risk class composed of proposed insureds whose anticipated
mortality is average. [12]
standing committee. A permanent committee that company executives use as a
source of continuing advice. [1]
statement of capital and surplus. See statement of owners’ equity.
statement of health (SOH). See nonmedical supplement.
statement of owners’ equity. A financial statement that provides information
about changes that occurred in owners’ equity between two sequential balance
sheets. Also known as a statement of capital and surplus. [7]
statutory accounting practices. Accounting standards that all life insurers in the
United States must follow when preparing the Annual Statement and specified
other reports that are submitted to state regulators. [7]
steering control. An organizational control that is established before a business
process is begun and describes how a company intends to implement the pro-
cess. Also known as a feedforward control. [2]
stock. A type of financial security that represents an ownership interest in a com-
pany. [1]
stockholder. A person or organization that owns shares of stock in a corporation.
Also known as a shareholder. [1]
stockholder dividend. A portion of a corporation’s earnings paid to the owners of
the company’s stock. [1]
STP. See straight through processing.
straight through processing (STP). The electronic processing of every step in the
new business process without manual intervention. [12]
strategic business unit (SBU). An organizational unit that acts like an indepen-
dent business in that it (1) generates its own identifiable profits, (2) has its own
set of customers and competitors, (3) has its own independent management, (4)
has its own budget, and (5) has its own set of strategic goals and strategies. [1]
treasury operations. The management and maintenance of records and reports for
all of an insurer’s cash transactions, specifically money deposited or withdrawn
from accounts at a bank or other financial institution. Also known as cash
management or cash accounting. [6]
twisting. An unfair sales practice that occurs when an insurance producer misrep-
resents the features of a policy to induce the customer to replace an existing
policy. [11]
underwriter. An insurance company employee who (1) evaluates the degree of
risk represented by a proposed insured or group with respect to a specific insur-
ance product, (2) accepts or declines insurance applications, and (3) determines
the appropriate premium rate to charge acceptable risks. [12]
underwriting. The process of (1) assessing and classifying the degree of risk a
proposed insured or group represents with respect to a specific insurance prod-
uct and (2) making a decision to accept or decline that risk. Also known as
selection of risk. [12]
underwriting decision. The decision an underwriter makes regarding the clas-
sification of a risk and the premium rate to charge for the insurance coverage if
the risk is accepted. [12]
underwriting guidelines. General standards that underwriters follow that specify
the limits within which proposed insureds may be assigned to one of an insurer’s
risk classes. [12]
underwriting philosophy. A set of objectives for guiding all of an insurer’s
underwriting actions, generally reflects the insurer’s strategic business goals,
and includes its pricing assumptions for products. [12]
undifferentiated marketing. A marketing strategy that involves defining the total
market for a product as as its target market and designing a single marketing
mix directed toward the entire market. Also known as mass marketing. [9]
Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act. In the United States, a National As-
sociation of Insurance Commissioners model act that specifies a number of
actions that are considered unfair claims practices if committed by an insurer
(1) in conscious disregard of the law or (2) so frequently as to indicate a general
business practice. [13]
unfavorable variance. In budgeting, an accounting result in which actual rev-
enues are less than expected revenues and/or actual expenses are greater than
expected expenses. [7]
unique visitors. A measurement of website traffic that reflects the number of indi-
viduals who have visited a website at least once during a fixed time frame. [9]
unsecured bond. See debenture.
up-selling. A sales activity in which customers are invited to purchase a more
powerful, more enhanced, or more profitable product than the one a customer
originally considers purchasing. [14]
upstream holding company. A holding company that controls the corporation
that formed it and can also own other subsidiaries. [1]
Index
G incorporation, 3.4
independent agent, 11.4, 11.7–11.8
GAAP. See generally accepted accounting independent audit, 3.10, 6.23
principles independent contractor, 11.4
general account, 8.8 independent director, 1.9
general accounting, 7.6 independent financial advisor, 11.16
general agency, 11.6 individual employer groups, 9.12
general agent, 11.6 industry associations, 2.8
general counsel, 3.3 inflows, 12.2
generally accepted accounting information, 5.5, 5.6
principles (GAAP), 7.7 information fraud, 5.18
general obligation bonds, 8.13 information management, 5.2, 5.5–5.10
General Regulation 250 (Chile), 13.18 information resources, 5.2
GLB Act. See Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act information services, 5.2
goal, 1.11 information technology, as functional area, 1.15
going-concern concept, 7.7 information technology (IT) department, 5.2–5.5
government bonds, 8.12 comprehensive business analysis
Gramm-Leach-Bliley (GLB) Act, 12.22 responsibilities for, 10.6
graphic rating scale, 4.17 financial management working with, 6.9
group insured, 12.21 relation with customer service
group life insurance, risk factors for, 12.21 department, 14.5
group member, 12.19 underwriters’ collaboration with, 12.19
group products, customer service information theft, 5.18
processes for, 14.17–14.18 inside director, 1.9
group representative, 11.15–11.16, 12.19 inside information, 2.7
groupthink, 4.9 insider trading, 2.7
group underwriting, 12.19–12.21 insolvency, 6.19
instant messaging, 5.14
H institutional advertising, 9.8
institutional investing, 8.2
hardware, 5.3 insurance, laws restricting sale of, 12.22
health information, confidentiality of, 2.8 Insurance Act (India), 11.11
hedging, 6.13 insurance aggregators, 5.16
help desk technician, 5.4 insurance brokerage, 11.17
holding company, 1.22–1.24 insurance broker-dealer, 11.17
home country, 4.5 insurance company, as distribution
home country staffing, 4.5 channel, 11.18–11.19
home service agent, 11.5, 11.6 insurance-owned broker-dealer, 11.17
host country, 4.5 insurance producer, 1.6
host country staffing, 4.5 Insurance Regulatory and Development
hosted applications, 5.13 Authority (IRDA; India), 6.22, 10.9, 11.11
HR department. See human resources insured, 1.3
department integrated data warehouse, 5.7–5.8
HTTP protocol, 5.3 interactive voice recognition (IVR) system,
human resources, 4.2 5.17, 14.7
as functional area, 1.15 interdepartmental standing committees, 1.21
legal department’s responsibilities to, 3.6 interest option, 13.13
human resources department, 4.2–4.3, 4.14 interest-rate risk, 6.12, 8.14
human resources planning, 4.3–4.8 interest spread, 8.3