Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
1. Project description: In 3-4 sentences, please describe the project and its main objectives.
In 2013 SOM3, APEC endorsed a proposal of Public Private Partnership on Environmental Goods
and Services (PPPEGS). As a kick off activity of PPPEGS, the project is designed to, through holding
a Public Private Dialogue on Renewable and Clean Energy (RCE) Trade and Investment, raise
understanding and awareness of opportunities for trade and investment within APEC economies in
EGS particularly RCE; share experience, lessons and opinions on the role of trade and investment in
increasing utilization of RCE and dissemination of RCE technologies; and put forward
recommendations on facilitation and promotion of RCE trade and investment.
2. Meeting objectives: Describe how the project met each of its proposed objectives. Please
outline any challenges you may have encountered in delivering the activity.
To meet the above objectives, a dialogue was held on 11 August, 2014 on the side-lines of SOM3
2014 in Beijing, China. Speakers presented their views on current RCE developments in the region.
Among them are leaders from private sectors, government experienced negotiators and academics
sharing their first-hand experiences including both challenges and best practices. Based on the
discussion, key proposals and consensus were reached and submitted to the CTI and was endorsed.
The proposal regarding the promotion of future RCE trade and investment in the region is further
included in the ministerial meeting in November 2014 and reflected in the APEC leaders’ declaration.
3. Evaluation: Describe the process undertaken to evaluate the project upon completion. (e.g.
evaluation through participant surveys, peer reviews of outputs, assessments against
indicators, statistics demonstrating use of outputs etc.). Provide analysis of results of
evaluations conducted and where possible include information on impacts on gender.
Evaluation data needs to be included as an appendix.
The outcome of the project was discussed with other economy participants during the few days
following the conference session, and during other activities and informal meetings related to the
SOM3 session, China 2014. A summary report of the dialogue was made and a presentation was
also delivered among APEC member delegations in the next few days after the dialogue and was
passed as a CTI proposal, i.e. APEC Statement on Promoting Renewable and Clean Energy
(RCE) Trade and Investment, which outlines future actions for APEC community to promote RCE
trade and investment based on the discussion and communication with the speakers and participants
at the dialogue, adopted by CTI3 and SOM3 in August 2014 and later published as Appendix B of the
APEC Ministerial Meeting Statement and referred to in the APEC Leaders’ Declaration in November
2014. (link: http://www.apec.org/Meeting-Papers/Ministerial-
Statements/Annual/2014/2014_amm/annexb.aspx )
1
4. Output indicators: Describe the main project outputs below. This may include workshops,
tools, research papers, reports, recommendations, best practices, action plans.
.
Indicators # planned # actual Details or notes
(Edit or Insert rows as needed)
# workshops / events 1 1
# participants (M/F) The recorded participants are incomplete as
a sizeable portion of them were registered
through their own economy’s delegation
and went to the venue directly at a certain
100 67 (41/26)
point of the dialogue without informing the
project consultant’s team. Therefore, the
actual number of participants is more than
the filed names in the appendices.
# economies attending 20 14+
# speakers engaged Including both speakers from government,
15 23 private sectors, NGOs and academic
institutions.
# other organizations engaged Non-APEC participating organizations
included the European Union delegation in
2 2
Beijing, the Alliance of the Sustainable
Energy Trade Initiative
# publications distributed The proceedings and the summary report
1 1 have been submitted to the APEC
Secretariat.
# recommendations agreed on APEC Statement on Promoting RCE Trade and
1 1
Investment
Other:
Comments: Through the dialogue, the three objective we set initiatively in the project proposal has
been realized.
5. Outcomes: Describe any specific medium-term changes to policy, processes or behavior that
can be attributed to result from this activity. Please include details on:
What indicators were used to measure medium-term impact? (Example indicators:
type/number of policies/ regulations/processes changed, % of businesses conforming to new
standards, change in sector’s commercial activity, # individual action plans developed, #
agencies using resource or tools etc.)
Monitoring plans in place and proposed indicators to measure impacts, including any
impacts on gender. Please summarize relevant information.
The outcome of the discussions during this dialogue is adopted by the CTI and the Ministerial Meeting
Declaration Appendix B and published on the official website of APEC. Eight proposals are included in
the APEC Statement regarding RCE trade and investment transparency, subsidy transparency, RCE
products standard harmonization, RCE tariff reduction, IPR protection, international technology
collaboration and public-private-academic dialogue in policy optimization and etc. Based on the
ministerial meeting publication, the APEC leadership also reiterated their resolution and endorsement of
the above proposals which will eventually lead to more actions from individual members and collectively.
APEC actions in promoting RCE investment in APEC region will in turn set up model for global
community in WTO negotiations on Environmental goods which include RCE related goods.
Economy
# male # female Details
(Insert rows as needed)
Please see the appendices
Other:
2
Comments: What was the approach undertaken for participant nomination/selection and
targeting? Please provide details. What follow-up actions are expected? How will
participants/beneficiaries continue to be engaged and supported to progress this work?
Each economy was invited to nominate participants to discuss their individual situations. Agenda drafts
were distributed to aid in the understanding of the project, and email correspondence was engaged to
answer any clarifying questions. A network and mail list has been set up for the participants and
speakers and business leaders in RCE sector for future dialogue and communication.
7. Key findings: Describe 1-3 examples of key findings, challenges or success stories arising
from the project (e.g. research or case studies results, policy recommendations, roadblocks to
progress on an issue, impacts on gender).
1. RCE trade frictions are of a major concern of the participants and speakers. Public – private
dialogue, private –private dialogue via trade associations are considered essential and imperative to
prevent and resolve trade disputes in RCE. Transparency in trade and investment is considered
essential to build confidence and trust for partners and competitors.
2. Cross border investment has been a strong momentum for RCE technology innovation and
revolution as it optimizes both the capital and intellectual resources deployment across borders in
APEC and the world. Hanergy shared its successful experience in realizing technology leap fogging
from a latecomer in RCE sector from a developing economy to a leading member in RCE sector,
particularly in solar technology.
3. Harmonization of standards in RCE products becomes one of the focus in the dialogue which will
facilitate the trade and investment in APEC region and set up a model for the global RCE business
community.
4. Case study “Analysis on the Financing Efficiency of China’s New Energy” analyses data’s from 81
listed companies in RCE sector in China to evaluate their financing efficiency performance. As their
financing efficiency varies, the companies with unsatisfactory financing efficiency should adjust their
internal management and enhance their technological research and innovation in order to have a
better financing efficiency.
8. Next steps: Describe any planned follow-up steps or projects, such as workshops, post-
activity evaluations, or research to assess the impact of this activity. How will the indicators
from Question 5 be tracked? How will this activity inform any future APEC activities?
The contribution by the experts, speakers and participants before, at and after the dialogue has been
adopted by APEC CTI and the ministerial meeting and reflected in the APEC Leaders’ Declaration. As
this is the first public and private dialogue on environmental goods and Services, more follow up
dialogue will be organized by members to facilitate the building up of a fair, transparency and
environmental friendly trade and investment in RCE scheme in APEC.
The contributions by experts can be built on to continue future works in the area of APEC’s role as an
incubator for FTAAP progress and other APEC efforts. Future activities informed by the revelations and
shared information from this project possibly include the APEC RTAs/FTAs Information Sharing
Mechanism, the Collective Strategic Study on Issues related to FTAAP Realization, and further
cooperation in key areas of next generation trade and investment, and regulatory coordination.
9. Feedback for the Secretariat: Do you have suggestions for more effective support by APEC
fora or the Secretariat? Any assessment of consultants, experts or other stakeholders to share?
The Secretariat has been extremely responsive and thoughtful in supporting the project consultant,
speakers and participants to carry out the project. Their enthusiasm for APEC work has served another
momentum for the stakeholders involved in the project to work harder to achieve the designated
objectives of the project.
SECTION C: Budget
3
Planned costs: (using most recently approved budget figures)
Actual expenditures
Variance notes: An explanation of any budget line under- or over-spent by 20% or more.
Variance notes:
APEC Funding
Utilization
Analysis
All
Differenc
Figures Budgete Actual Variance Notes (± 20%)
e%
in USD d
Direct
Labour
Speaker’s
honorariu
m Some speakers are not eligible for
(governm $ 4,00 $ 3,00 -25% Honorarium as they are government
ent 0.00 0.00 officials.
officials
ineligible)
Translato
$ $ 0%
r’s fees
- -
Short-
term The rest payment is scheduled when
$ 13,00 $ 5,20 -60%
clerical the project is completed.
0.00 0.00
fees
Research
ers’ fees
(including
labour
and
domestic The rest payment is scheduled when
$ 34,00 $ 13,60 -60%
and the project is completed.
0.00 0.00
internatio
nal on-
site
investigati
on)
4
Travel (Speaker,
Experts,
Researchers)
Some speakers/ are
from local or they are
from business and
paid their travel by
Per Diem (incl.
self-funding; some
accommodation and
$ 6,000.00 -73% other
“75% additional $ 1,650.00
experts/speakers are
payment”)
paid via other APEC
meeting scheme and
therefore did not use
this project funding.
Some speakers/ are
from local or they are
from business and
paid their travel by
self-funding; some
Airfare $ 20,000.00 -64% other
$ 7,123.89
experts/speakers are
paid via other APEC
meeting scheme and
therefore did not use
this project funding.
Travel for
Participants (from
Travel-eligible
economies only.
Active participants
only)
Some eligible
participants failed to
attend the meeting
while others
Per diem (incl.
attended the meeting
accommodations and
$ 16,500.00 -65% by using other APEC
“75% additional $ 5,750.00
funding scheme as
payment”)
there are a series of
events going on
during the meeting
time.
Some eligible
participants failed to
attend the meeting
while others
attended the meeting
Airfare (restricted
$ 44,000.00 -82% by using other APEC
economy class) $ 7,839.74
funding scheme as
there are a series of
events going on
during the meeting
time.
Other items
Publication/distribution
$ - $ - 0%
of report
Specialized
equipment or
$ - $ - 0%
materials (please
describe)
5
Photocopying $ - $ - 0%
Communications
(telephone, fax, mail, $ - $ - 0%
courier)
Chinese government
pays the hosting cost
Hosting (provide as a whole scheme
breakdown, e.g., room $ 10,000.00 $ - 100% of the APEC official
rental, stationery) meetings. , the
APEC funding for
hosting is not used.
Total: -70%
$ 147,500.00 $ 44,163.63
SECTION D: Appendices
Please attach the following documentation to the report as required. Note that the participant contact
list is a mandatory requirement for all Project completion reports.
Appendices Notes
Participant contact list: contact info, gender, job titles (mandatory)
Experts / consultants list: contact info, job titles, roles, gender
Event Agenda
Reports, websites or resources created: links or soft copies
Post activity survey or other evaluation data (raw and/or aggregated)
Other information or resources
FOR APEC SECRETARIAT USE ONLY APEC comments: Were APEC project guidelines followed?
Could the project have been managed more effectively or easily by the PO?
6
Public Private Dialogue on Renewable and Clean Energy
Trade and Investment
-The First Public Private Partnership on Environment Goods and Services (PPEGS) in
APEC
August11, 2014
Beijing, People’s Republic of China
Agenda
9.20 am – 10:30 am This session will have an overview of RCE trade and
investment in APEC region, discuss the background, current
development and trends of RCE trade and investment, and the
roles of public and private sectors. The challenges and
opportunities both developed and developing economies faced
will be reviewed as well.
Moderator: Mr. John Smirnow, Vice President ,Solar Energy
Industries Association
Speakers:
Terry Collins, chair, APEC Energy Working Group
Expert Group on Energy Efficiency
Li Junfeng, President, Chinese Renewable Energy
Industries Association
Qin Haiyan, Secretary General ,Chinese Wind Energy
Association
Peter C. Brun, Managing Director, the SETI-alliance
Liu Hengwei, Professor, Harbin University of
Technology
Discussion (Questions & Answers)
10:30 am – 10:50 am Coffee Break
7
Session 2:Perspectives from Public and Private Sectors: How to Create an
Enabling Environment for RCE Trade and Investment
10:50am – 12.30 am In this session, public and private sector representatives will
discuss how government policies can promote RCE trade and
investment and the dissemination of RCE technologies, how
the use of international standards in APEC economies can
contribute to increased trade and investment in RCE, how
APEC can promote existing international standards or greater
alignment of standards in this sector, and how APEC can
strengthen cooperation on designing and implementing RCE
related policies to avoid trade frictions.
Moderator: Qin Haiyan, Secretary General, China Wind
Energy Association
Speakers:
Liang Zhipeng, Deputy Director General, China National
Energy Administration
Zhu Chenyang, Vice President, Hanergy Holding Group
Ltd.
Xuan Xiaowei, Development Research Center of the State
Council, China
Jake Colvin, Vice President,,Global Trade Issues
Wu Gang, Chairman, Xinjiang Goldwind Science &
Technology Co.,Ltd
Discussion (Questions & Answers)
12.30 am – 2.00 pm Lunch
2.00 pm – 4.00 pm Moderator: Li Junfeng, President, Chinese Renewable
Energy Industries Association
Speakers:
Lisa Salley, VP & GM of Energy & Power Technologies,
Underwriters’ Laboratories
Qu Xiaohua, President & CEO, Canadian Solar Inc.
Li Shizhong, Professor, Tsinghua University
Yang Xiaozhong, Vice President, Trina Solar
Alex Lu, Sales General Manager, GE Greater China
Chiharu Murakoshi, Executive Research Adviser,
Jyukankyo Research Institute Inc.
Discussion (Questions & Answers)
4.00 pm – 4.20 pm Coffee Break
8
Session 3: Open Floor Discussion: Way Forward - Recommendations for Future
APEC Work
9
Participant contact list
Public Private Dialogue on Renewable and Clean Energy
August11, 2014
President, Chinese
China Li Junfeng Male lijunfeng@creia.net
Renewable Energy
10
Economy Name Gender Job Title Contact
Industries
Association(CREIA)
Secretary General China
China Qin Haiyan Male qinhy@cgc.rog.cn;
Wind Power Association
Professor, Ha’rBin
China Liu Hengwei Male liu.aramco@gmail.com
University of Technology
Zhu
China Male Vice President , Hanergy delialiao@hanergy.com
Chenyang
Professor National
China Xuan Xiaowei Male Development and Reform xxw@drc.gov.cn
Research Center
Assistant Manager,
China Liao Dishan Female delialiao@hanergy.com
Hanergy
China Liu Zhigang Male Manager, Siemens Ltd., zg.liu@siemens.com
Tang
China Female Manager, CREIA 86 10 6800 2618-106
Wenqian
China Geng Dan Female Manager, CREIA geng.d@creia.net
China Sun Lei Female Manager, CREIA 86 10 6800 2618-106
China Zhang Miao Female Manager,CREIA zhangmiao@creia.net
China Li Li Female Lecturer ,UIBE 86-18610167976
China Lin Zhiqin Male Professor ,UIBE 010-64492361,13691301593
China Men Ming Male Professor , UIBE 86-13911620389
China Xiaoting Zhu Female Manager, UIBE sallyzhu2003@sina.com
Xiangfeng
China Male Manager UIBE 175207004@qq.com
Zhu
China Kexuan Chen Female Office Assistant, UIBE ckx_999@126.com
China Yu Wang Female Office Assistant, UIBE cynthia635401428@163.com
Post Doc Research Fellow,
China Ran Wang Female China Social Sciences ranran06117@126.com
Academy
PHD researcher, Nagoya
China Lin Guo Femail icecream_linlin@163.com
University
Manager China Guodian
China Chang Cheng Female changcheng@cgdc.com.cn
Corporation
Manager China Guodian
China Li Gengda Male ligd05@163.com
Corporation
China Hanzhi Xu Mr Manager , Trina Solar hanzhi.xu@trinasolar.com
EU Wang Jue Female Trade official Jue.wang@eeas.europa.eu
Satrio International Trade Policy satrio.nugroho@kemendag.go.
Indonesia Male
Nugroho Analyst id
Michael
International Trade Policy michael.fernando@kemendag.
Indonesia Fernando Male
Analyst go.id
Ginting
Nor Hayati Senior Principal
Malaysia Female nhy@doe.gov.my
Yahaya Assistant Director
Nor Azaliza
Malaysia Female Senior Assistant Director azaliza@seda.gov.my
Damiri
New
Terry Collins Male Chair, APEC EGEE&C Terry.Collins@eeca.govt.nz
Zealand
NGO
Managing Director, SETI
based in Peter C. Brun, Male PBrun@ictsd.ch
Alliance, ICTSD
Geneva
Philippine Nestor P. Male Director nparcansalin@boi.gov.ph
11
Economy Name Gender Job Title Contact
s Arcansalin
Chinese
Feng-Chi Yen Mr Section Chief fcyan@moeaidb.gov.tw
Taipei
Chinese
Shih-Fang LO Female Associate Research Fellow shihfang.lo@cier.edu.tw
Taipei
Chinese Che-Ming tom6251@mail.sinotech.com.t
Male Project Manager
Taipei CHANG w
Krittiya
Thailand Female Plan and Policy Analyst krittiya_p@dede.go.th
Petsee
Thanyalak
Thailand Female Engineer thanyalak_m@dede.go.th
Meesap
Executive Research
Chiharu
Japan Male Adviser, Jukankyo murakoshi@jyuri.co.jp
Murakoshi
Research institute Inc.
Robert Jake Vice President, National
USA Male jcolvin@gmail.com
Colvin Foreign Trade Council
Director for Environment
William and Natural Resources, William_K_McElnea@ustr.eo
USA Male
Mceleana Office of the United States p.gov
Trade Representative
Director for APEC Affairs
at Office of the United Edward_Brzytwa@ustr.eop.go
USA Ed Brzytwa Male
States Trade v
Representative
Vice President, Dow
USA Ningke Peng Male npeng@dow.com
Chemical ,China
Vice President and General
USA Lisa Salley Female Lisa.Salley@ul.com
Manager,UL LLC
Vice President ,Trade &
John P. Competitiveness at the
USA Male JSmirnow@seia.org
Smirnow Solar Energy Industries
Association (SEIA)
Manager, OGIN Wind MichelleBian@oginenergy.co
USA Bian Yanan Female
Turbine m
Official in charge of
Nguyen nguyenthanhlong.2010@gmail
Viet Nam Male renewable and clean
Thanh Long .com
energy.
Official in charge of FTAs
Nguren Minh negotiations on
Viet Nam Male nmtri1987@yahoo.com
Tri environmental goods and
services.
12
Experts / consultants list
13