Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Schools
You are here:
1. Home
2. Uncategorized
3. Ethical Issues in Education –…
Every child should be educated and the United Nations has made it
one of the fundamental human rights of every child, recognizing the
harm in having uneducated persons and the importance of an
educated citizenry. Unfortunately, there are some barriers to effective
learning that receivers and givers of education have dealt with since
time memorial, and some of these barriers are rooted in our ethics.
The list of unethical issues in education that sometimes act as
stumbling blocks to effective learning can be said to be endless.
However, some of the common ethical issues in education faced by
stakeholders in the education sector are as follows:
Choice of Instructor /or Teacher
One of the commonest ethical issues in education is the choice of
teacher a particular child or set of children will have in the following
year. Such issues usually ensue between the principal, school
administration and parents of the children. The choice of instructor /or
teacher usually ensue between the principal, school administration
and parent. Two predictable outcomes usually result from such an
issue – the principal either reluctantly concurs to the parents’ request
or he makes a blanket statement stating the policy against honouring
parents’ opinion as regards the choice of teachers for a particular
class.
Issues of Discipline
The notion of zero tolerance policy against the give-them-another
chance policy cannot work across the board. Some quarters,
especially parents and guardians might be against the zero tolerance
policy for reasons best known to them, others support the idea. Both
concepts can be applied simultaneously in all educational institutes.
While the zero tolerance policy is used for aggressive and anti-social
and behavioural in-disciplinary actions like carrying firearms in the
school and bullying, the second chance policy can be used for the
encouragement of better academic performance. The second chance
policy does not necessarily mean one should spare the rod and spoil
the child.
Ethnic and Social Diversity
Schools are continuously faced with the issue of diversity stemming
from students having different social and ethnic backgrounds. Public
schools in particular, have had to deal with issues relating to racial
inequality and ethnic differences. All educational institutes, particularly
the public ones, need to address the issue of diversity by modifying
the curriculum. Ethnic sports and multicultural festivals should be
organized at schools, helping to bring together students of diverse
backgrounds and helping to promote unity amongst them. The
inclusion of prominent historical issues from different ethnics would
also help students to get familiar with one another’s cultural, ethnic,
racial, and even religious differences.
Grading
It has often been argued that examinations are not a true test of
knowledge, as some students suffer from what is sometimes referred
to as “examination fever”, where even a brilliant student finds it difficult
to pass the simplest examination. On a serious note, the argument of
how students should be graded and the parameters guiding such
grades are always questionable. On the other hand, who takes the
blame for the failure of the student(s) – the rather incompetent teacher
or the lazy student. In addition to the ethical issues affecting learning
mentioned above, other issues worth noting include flexibility in the
curriculum development, teaching strategy, continuous assessments,
knowledge transfer and best practices cross the board. Each of the
issues mentioned requires deep understanding and careful scrutiny to
proffer effective solutions and enhance the educational system.
Citation
IICE (Ireland International Conference on Education) Blog, (2017),
Ethical Issues in Education – Barriers to Learning in Schools,
https://www.iicedu.org/blog/ (Accessed Date: Insert the date).
Moral and Ethical Issues in Teacher Education.
ERIC Digest.
This ERIC digest will address two components related to the moral and
ethical
preparation of teachers. First it will consider issues related to the
identification and assessment of professional education, and then it will
address foundations and specific models for the preservice training of
teachers of character.
ISSUES OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS IN EDUCATION
Consider Irma, the student teacher. Not only does she already have a contract
from the rural district in which she was born and raised, she is also bilingual.
Irma wants to live in the community and teach in the elementary school in
which she was taught. She has a natural rapport with children and a positive
personality. As the student teaching semester progresses, Irma's Master
Teacher Mrs. Baxter grows increasingly uncomfortable. Irma is enrolled in a
full set of courses during the student teaching semester and works 30-40
hours a week. Her relationship wit her boyfriend is serious and takes
additional time. Because of this busy schedule, it is difficult for Irma and
Mrs. Baxter to meet to discuss the classroom curriculum and review teaching
plans.
Mrs. Baxter offers to meet with Irma before class, at 7:00a.m., but Irma has difficulty getting to
school that early because of her late night hours at work. Meetings between the two are sporadic.
Mrs. Baxter has noticed other behaviors that bother her about Irma. For
example, she has observed that on the playground Irma watches the students,
but does not actively interact with them. In the computer room, Irma searches
the web, but does not help the children. She has asked Irma to prepare a
theme unit and has given her time at school to prepare. But it is now three
days before the unit is to begin and there are no plans and Irma has not
discussed the unit with Mrs. Baxter. Mrs. Baxter feels that perhaps Irma is
just "putting in time" because she knows she has a job waiting and the other
facets of her life--her class work, her job, her boyfriend--have taken
precedence.
Irma's performance as a professional-in-training is inadequate. She's involved in many activities
and has interests that compete with her professional preparation. Though Irma has potential, her
behavior is "unprofessional" or even "professionally unethical." That is, if ethics is concerned
with actions and practice, with what one ought to do (Pojman, pp.1-2), them Irma's actions do
not represent ethical behavior. Rather, they violate principles of professional ethics that should
be part of her professional preparation. If professional ethics concerns, "those norms, values, and
principles that should govern the professional conduct of teacher..." (Strike & Ternasky, p. 2),
Irma flunks this part of her training. her behavior violates the most basic principle of the NEA's
Code of Ethics of the Education Profession (NEA, 2003)--Irma is not foundationally committed
to her students.
Though codes of ethics may not have played a significant role in teacher
preparation programs in the past, (Strike & Ternasky, p.3), professional
ethical dispositions of teachers must now be addressed as part of the National
Council for Accreditation of Teacher Education (NCATE) accreditation
process (NCATE, 2002). A program of ethical education developed for
dental professionals at the University of Minnesota more than 25 years ago is
finding adaptations to other professional training programs, including the
training of teachers (Rest & Narvaez, 1994). Called the Four-Component
Model of Moral Maturity, the program assumes that moral behaviors are built
on a series of component processes (Bebeau, Rest, & Narvaez, 1999). Each
component is clearly defined, and educational goals, teaching strategies and
assessment methods can be derived from those definitions. The components
are:
1) Moral sensitivity, the awareness of how our actions affect other people. It
involved being aware of the different lines of action and how each line of
action affects the parties concerned. It involves knowing cause-consequent
chains of events in the real world, and empathy and role-taking abilities.
Issues related to the moral and professional ethical education of teachers are
the focus for several book-length treatments (e.g., Tom, 1984; Sockett, 1993;
Goodlad, Soder, Sirotnik, 1990; and Goodlad & McMannon, 1997). It would
seem that this is developing into an area of greater interest to the profession.
UNDERSTANDING FOUNDATIONS FOR MORAL AND
CHARACTER EDUCATION
For most of history, the concept of character formation--the duty of the older
generation to form the character of the young--has been a basic principle
structuring moral education. For example, Aristotle (trans. 1962) wrote about
the development of excellence, stating that to become excellent at any craft,
including becoming virtuous, we have to exercise (practice) those behaviors.
He stated: "We become just by the practice of just actions, self-controlled by
exercising self-control, and courageous by performing acts of courage.
Hence, it is no small matter whether one habit or another is inculcated in us
from early childhood; on the contrary, it makes...all the difference" (1962, pp.
34-35).
CONCLUSION
It appears that moral and ethical issues, including character education, are
slowly becoming part of the teacher education programs. Philosophical
writings and psychological research exist to provide guidance, and exemplary
university training programs, provide beginning models of practice.
Overwhelmingly deans and administrators of teacher education programs
agree that core values can and should be taught in our schools. It's now up to
the profession to ensure broader and deeper implementation.
REFERENCES
Bebeau, M.J.; Rest, J.R.; & Narvaez, D. (1999). Beyond the promise: A
perspective on research in moral education. Educational Researchers, 28(4),
18-26. EJ587024.
Benninga, J.S.; Berkowitz, M.W.; Kuehn, P.; & Smith, K. (2003). The
relationships of character education and academic achievement in elementary
schools. Journal of Research in Character Education, 1(1), 17-30.
Berliner, D.C., & Biddle, B.J. (1995). The manufactured crisis: Myths, fraud
and the attack on America's public schools. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
ED 393 167.
Goodlad, J.I.; Soder, R.; & Sirotnik, K.A. (Eds). (1990). The moral
dimensions of teaching. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. ED 337 443.
Goodlad, J.I., & McMannon, T.J. (Eds.) (1997). The public purpose of
educationn and schooling. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. ED 403 657.
Piaget, J. (1965). The moral judgment of the child. New York: Free Press.
Pojman, L.P. (1998). Ethical theory: Classical and contemporary readings,
3rd Ed. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
Sockett, H. (1993). The moral base for teacher professionalism. New York:
Teachers College. ED 366 576.
Strike, K.A., & Ternasky, P.L. (Eds.) (1993). Ethics for professionals in
education: Perspectives for preparation and practices. New York: Teachers
College. ED 377 589.
Literature Review
Overview
Empathy & Respect. Aristotle would promote the idea that empathy
and respect are interconnected and go hand-in-hand. That these two
components are essential elements in a school leaders character and
as such they exist mutually together and serve the best interests of all
stakeholders at heart. He would suggest that these interests are
cradled in the simplest proponents of the Golden Rule and promote a
climate of mutual worth for all persons.
Justice, Care & Courage. Shapiro and Stefkovich (2005) argued that
moral virtues associated with leadership have a particular importance
to safeguard and promote the best interests of others. When the
ethics of justice, care, and courage are joined with an ethic of inclusive
Aristotelian discourse, educational administrators have a model to
ethical decision-making founded on principle.
convictions that incorporate the respect, trust and integrity for being
authentic and true to their
Cunliffe and Eriksen (2011 p.1432) would argue that “we exist in
mutual relationships with others and our surroundings and that we
both shape, and are shaped by, our social experience in everyday
interactions and conversations.” It appears that such theories in
relational ontology lay the foundation for mutual members of an
organization to extend mutual respect and regard toward one another
when such relationships are formed.
Cultural Boundaries
Self-disclosure can also be construed as a vehicle for cultural
sharing. Most of our participants stated that their school districts
were transitioning to a higher level of diversity as students of
various ethnic backgrounds moved into their areas. Donna’s
willingness to discuss her personal background and celebration of
family holidays with her students suggests the importance of
individual openness to different cultural backgrounds in the
classroom. Helping students understand the various influences on
not only the teachers, but also on their peers, may lead to better
understanding, communication, and cooperation in the classroom as
students respect cultural differences.
Emotional Boundaries
There must be one protocol in between teacher and teacher trainee
on like; Emotional regulation, appropriate levels of emotion shared
in the classroom, and comfort levels with others’ emotions were
among the responses we encountered. What are sometimes
perceived as “unpleasant” emotions: anger, frustration, and even
hate were mentioned as emotions that should be masked or
expressed with care. Participants also talked about boundaries of
emotional intensity. There are levels of emotions you shouldn’t
share. And what’s appropriate for one child might totally be
inappropriate for another.”
http://pubs.sciepub.com/education/2/12A/1/index.html
I am lover of quietness‐
Unechoed songs within a silent heart,
A sliver pond, a statued loveliness
Where words can take no part.
Stanza 1: The persona acclaimed his love and desire for natural quietness. This “quietness”
stands for inner peace and happiness residing in his heart. It is alluring. His thoughts are
more powerful and speak louder than any uttered words.
II
I love the quiet ways of memory,
The quiet looks to give you loving praise,
The quiet secrets of my misery
Through quiet nights and days.
Stanza 2: The persona constantly refreshes some memories which bring him back to his
starting point. Discovering the divine in oneself and recognizing the divine over everything.
He wonders of his struggles and melancholy but still remains faithful to Him. It is his
relationship with God that sustained him. God is someone you can talk to in silence.
III
The quiet mountains of the earth I love,
The moving clouds, the sun, the dewy leaf.
My quiet questioning o God above,
My quite, tearless grief.
Education is simply the soul of a society as it passes from one generation to another.
G. K. Chesterton
Indeed, education is an ongoing process. We are always receiving and passing it on, adding
something in the process, sometimes even taking certain things, impertinent from time to time,
away from it while passing it on further. However, the industry of education is a serious one,
requiring well-defined ethics and values, well-bound in visible legal outlines to regulate its
exchange and distribution. Let us take a brief look at some of the most common issues of ethics
in education.
Causes of Overpopulation
Communist Economy
About Us
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
This site uses cookies to analyze performance and enhance user experience. By
clicking OK or by continuing to use this website, you are agreeing to our policy of
using cookies.
OKLearn More
Save
Ethics in Education
Post a comment
Share
Google+
One thing I’ve realized after five-plus years of teaching a course on research integrity
is that graduate students struggle with questions over ethics and integrity on a regular
basis. My course focuses on helping students to think about why essentially good
people sometimes do bad things. This approach, based on behavioural ethics, asks the
question, “what factors influence people from being able to make and follow through
on ethical decisions?” Similarly, “what factors when present in our environment, in
the ways that we think and interact with others, make us more likely to act
unethically?” Some of the factors that we focus on:
Rationalization and bias: We believe that we are more ethical than we actually are,
and create rationalizations to explain any unethical behaviours. We believe that we are
good people and this leads us to make ethical decisions rapidly.
Obedience to authority: We are more likely to make unethical decisions when we
are told to do so by someone more senior than us.
Conformity bias: We are more likely to make unethical decisions when we can
justify that “the whole group is doing it.”
Time pressure: Unethical behaviours are more likely when we act under a time
pressure.
Fatigue: Unethical behaviours are more likely when we are fatigued.
Lack of transparency: Unethical behaviours are more likely when we know that no
one is watching.
To anyone who has been in grad school or in a research laboratory, these influences
on behaviour likely resonate. By approaching ethics in this way, students feel
immediately empowered by the fact that they can identify what these influences look
like in their current environment (ex: tight deadlines, pressures to complete multiple
tasks at once, long hours in the lab, group thinking and culture among labs). Rarely do
people act badly with the intention of doing so. Explaining the reasons for unethical
behaviour doesn’t make our actions right, but being able to identify the factors that
influence people to act even against their most rational ethical judgment is an
important step in giving students the confidence to stand for integrity.
If you are looking to introduce behavioural ethics into your course you might consider
some of the following:
Develop learning objectives that focus on having graduate students identify their own
bias and identify key influences in their current or future environments.
Incorporate case studies that entail a range of complex personal and professional
ethical dilemmas.
Allow time for discussion (case studies or reflection) with senior and junior faculty, as
well as peers.
Encourage students to think about how these factors may be present in different
contexts (for instance, in business, sports, or in different work environments).
A chief benefit that I see in teaching my students about the general factors that
influence ethical behaviour is that it equips them with transferable skills for the
workplace. Inside or outside of the lab, students will encounter difficult ethical
dilemmas in carrying out their work. Recent graduates may also have to navigate new
team dynamics, unfamiliar organizational culture, and environments driven by fast-
paced returns, and large expectations of employees. Prepared with the appropriate
training, students become employees who promote an ethical culture in their
organization and act as ethics advocates. In turn, they are also able to make better
decisions faster, which in turn should also please their employer.
Besides the obvious benefits of strong moral development in the workplace, I hope
that the sheer acknowledgement of the need to examine why and how we make ethical
decisions in these trainings encourages additional personal growth.
See the paper “Behavioral Ethics and Teaching Ethical Decision Making” for more
examples and further discussion.
lfutterman@dadeschools.net
MARCH 31, 2015 06:00 AM, UPDATED MARCH 31, 2015 08:33 PM
“The first step in the evolution of ethics is a sense of solidarity with other human beings.”
Albert Schweitzer
▪ Values are rules from which we make our personal decisions about what is right and
what is wrong, good or bad. Values help direct us to what is more important and past
what is less important. This helps guide us when making decisions.
SAVE NOW
▪ Morals tend to be broad yet are more far reaching because of their strong link to good
and bad. We judge others by their morals rather than their values.
▪ Ethics, in contrast, are a set of rules that tend to be adopted and upheld by a group of
people. This could include medical ethics, journalism and advertising ethics and
educational ethics. So ethics or intent, tends to be viewed as something upheld and
adopted internally, such as professionalism, while morals are ideals we impose on others.
As Mary Ann Cutter Ph.D. explains, ethics can be applied to almost everything.
Biologists have learned an extraordinary amount about the genetic code that shapes mice
and men. The ethics of these professionals guide them in how to use these new genetic
technologies and the information that comes from it. In addition to cloning animals and
sequencing the human genome, amazing revelations have been presented. So while we
are gaining information everyday — the genetic footprints breast cancer and Alzheimer’s
disease, what we know about the genome still pales in comparison to what we do not yet
know and the implications what lies in between.
We are all too familiar with the sordid tales of the unethical choices that a few educators
have made, as well as stories of parents who have been dishonest about their residence in
order for their child to attend a school outside their boundary, or have been compelled to
do their children’s projects so they could a higher grade. We have also heard stories about
educators, parents and community partners who have and continue to step up and
selflessly give their time and/or funds to improve education.
At an upcoming conference May 1-2, 2015 at the University of Miami Storer Auditorium
and Miami Senior High School, the Miami-Dade Commission on Ethics and Public Trust,
along with the University of Miami and Miami-Dade County Public Schools will be
presenting Ethics in Education: A-Z.
The program will focus on universal topics for parents and educators from private, public
and charter schools and the issues relate to K-12 and higher, such as turning around
troubled schools, student testing, school choice and even “tiger moms.” The conference is
is intended for teachers, students, parents, educational administrators and concerned
citizens. Miami-Dade School teachers and administrators can earn up to 12 Master points.
I hope you will consider attending and spread the word through your schools,
organizations, websites, calendars, newsletters, social media outlets and personal email
lists. Here is a direct link to the website: http://ethics.miamidade.gov/ed-conf-2015.asp.
If you go
When and Where: There will be an opening reception on May 1 at the University of
Miami’s Storer Auditorium and a full day of presentations and discussions on May 2 at
Miami Senior High.
Friday Highlights: Local notables will present the Lifetime Achievement Award for
Ethics in Public Service to former Chief Justice of the Florida Supreme Court Gerald
Kogan. Principal Baruti Kafele, a former high school and middle school administrator
who gained fame for turning around troubled inner city schools in New
Saturday Highlights: Miami Hurricanes Head Football Coach Al Golden and former
Miami Dolphin and current County Court Judge Edward Newman are among the
panelists discussing how to balance education with the allure and power of school sports.
Local 10 Broadcast Journalist Glenna Milberg will moderate a discussion on the
immigration influx with Miami-Dade School Superintendent Alberto Carvalho and
Harvard Professor Andres Alonso. Other sessions will address civics education, bullying,
social media and the role of school police, among other topics. The day includes an
“ethics bowl” demonstration and a discussion among high students on race and justice,
moderated by Ethics Investigator and veteran South Florida columnist Robert Steinback.
Cost: $50 for both days, which includes three meals and all supplies.
For more information: For a complete list of participants, a detailed program and to
register, visit ethics.miamidade.gov or call 305-579-2594.
FROM OUR ADVERTISING PARTNERS