Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Accepted Manuscript
International Journal of Applied Mechanics
by UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW on 09/12/18. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
DOI: 10.1142/S1758825118500801
To be cited as: Mohamad El Asswad, Samer Alfayad, Khaled Khalil, Experimental Es-
timation of Friction and Friction Coefficient of a Lightweight Hydraulic
Cylinder Intended for Robotics Applications, International Journal of
Applied Mechanics, doi: 10.1142/S1758825118500801
This is an unedited version of the accepted manuscript scheduled for publication. It has been uploaded
in advance for the benefit of our customers. The manuscript will be copyedited, typeset and proofread
before it is released in the final form. As a result, the published copy may differ from the unedited
version. Readers should obtain the final version from the above link when it is published. The authors
are responsible for the content of this Accepted Article.
T
Accepted manuscript to appear in IJAM
September 10, 2018 14:17 Friction˙estimation
IP
CR
International Journal of Applied Mechanics
c Imperial College Press
US
Lightweight Hydraulic Cylinder Intended for Robotics Applications
Mohamad El Asswad∗
LISV, Paris Saclay university/UVSQ, 10-12 avenue de l’Europe, Velizy, France
Samer AlFayad
LISV, Paris Saclay university/UVSQ, 10-12 avenue de l’Europe, Velizy, France
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
Khaled Khalil
MGC CRSI, Lebanese University faculty of engineering, Tripoli Lebanon.
EMM LEM, UMR CNRS 6183, 58 rue M.Ange, 44606- Saint Nazaire France.
Received date
Accepted date
Recently, hydraulic actuator has been used in several engineering applications such as:
DM
aeronautics, construction and robotics. This is due to the need of high torque and power
density in such engineering applications. Despite of these advantages, hydraulic actu-
ator are fabricated from metallic materials, which provokes their heavy weight, which
necessitates the development of a lightweight hydraulic actuator, fabricated of composite
materials. Using composite materials in hydraulic cylinders, it is important to study the
friction force characteristics and to estimate the friction coefficient between composites
and O-rings, which is presented in this paper. This paper deals with the estimation of
Coulomb friction and friction coefficient in the lightweight hydraulic cylinder fabricated
mainly of composite materials. The actuator is presented by its dynamic equation of mo-
tion, where each term is discussed including the stiffness coefficient, the viscous damping
coefficient, the kinematics and the pressure parameters. Meanwhile, these coefficients and
parameters are obtained according to data recorded from conducted experiments. As a
result, the new methodology which uses the experimental measurements combined the
dynamic model has succeeded to evaluate the friction inside the hydraulic cylinder which
TE
has been estimated and found to be around 166 N , while the corresponding coefficient
of friction is computed (about 0.61 as average value). These results will be important for
further optimization of the material choice and actuator design, which will help in the
amelioration of the hydraulic cylinder.
1. Introduction
Since decades, hydraulic actuators show an efficient performance in several appli-
cations starting from aerospace van den Bossche (2006), industrial manipulation
∗ Typeset names in 8 pt roman, uppercase. Use the footnote to indicate the present or permanent
address of the author.
C
1
AC
T
Accepted manuscript to appear in IJAM
September 10, 2018 14:17 Friction˙estimation
IP
CR
2 Mohamad El Asswad, Samer AlFayad, Khaled Khalil
Shimamune and Tanifuji (1995), construction Abdalla et al. (2013) and end-
ing with robotics applications Zinn et al. (2004). This is mainly due to their high
torque and power density Habibi and Goldenberg (2000) Zinn et al. (2004).
Recently, several robotics researchers have moved to develop hydraulic actuated
robots such as Atlas Banerjee et al. (2015), CB, CB-i Cheng et al. (2006) and
by UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW on 09/12/18. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
HYDROı̈D S.AlFayad (2011) Alfayad et al. (2014) humanoid robot, the first hy-
US
draulic integrated robot. In addition, several rehabilitation devices are hydraulically
actuated such as: prosthesis Kargov et al. (2008) Koganezawa et al. (1987) G.
et al. (2009) and exoskeletons CaoJun et al. (2010) Zhang et al. (2012).
However, dealing with hydraulic actuators made up of composite materials
presents several challenging points due to its nonlinear characteristics Sulc and
Jan (2002) Sirouspour and Salcudean (2000). In other words, the system motion
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
depends on several nonlinear parameters such as the system friction, the viscosity
of the oil, the system damping and the system equivalent stiffness. Add to this, the
presence of composites, in contact with rubber O-ring in oil environment, introduces
more non-linearity and complexity to estimation of friction force characteristics. It,
consequently, becomes more important to estimate the friction force, when talking
about the new lightweight hydraulic actuator, made up of composites.
In a hydraulic cylinder, one can recognize two forms of friction forces: static
friction and dynamic friction Yanada et al. (2014). The interacting zones in these
DM
two types of frictions are the zone of contact of the piston O-rings with the cylinder
surface and the zone of contact of the caps O-rings with the moving rod. Thus,
the total friction force is the summation of the two friction forces in both zones.
In addition, investigating the different models used for finding the friction such
as Coulomb’s model, viscous model and LuGre model of friction force Alfayad
et al. (2014), the friction forces evaluation depends on the oil viscosity, oil velocity,
stiffness and stiffness coefficient and the deflection of bodies in contact.
However, Several experimental researches can be conducted in order to measure
the friction forces at the hydraulic cylinder. One can measure the friction forces
by evaluating the necessary force to move the piston at different speeds and at no
TE
pressure difference Sadashivappa et al. (2001). Another can find the needed pres-
sure difference to move the hydraulic cylinder at no load and at different velocities
Sadashivappa et al. (2001). Other can place a load cell between the piston rods of
main and loading cylinders at constant speed. These methods should be combined
to theoretical model in order to calculate the friction forces inside the cylinders.
This is carried out in this paper.
EP
This paper contains 4 sections excluding the introduction. First, the studied hy-
draulic cylinder properties are indicated at section 2. Second, the dynamic equation
parameters and coefficients are stated, explained and determined using experimen-
tal data. This is in section 3, where they have been used to estimate the friction
and the friction Coulomb coefficient in section 4. Finally, conclusions are given in
section 5.
C
AC
T
Accepted manuscript to appear in IJAM
September 10, 2018 14:17 Friction˙estimation
IP
CR
Experimental Estimation of Friction and Friction Coefficient of a Lightweight Hydraulic Cylinder Intended for Robotics Application
ElAsswad et al. (Oct 2017) metallic cylinders with this new series of optimized hy-
US
draulic cylinder. HYDROı̈D robot is an underdeveloped hydraulic integrated robot
S.AlFayad (2011), which represents a new solution toward using hydraulic actua-
tion, without the necessity of piping systems.
Talking about the hydraulic cylinder, the barrel and rod are made of woven
carbon fiber/epoxy composite material, the caps are made of aluminum and the
piston is a 3D-printed nylon filled glass fiber (Figure 1).
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
DM
The studied example of this new series of the hydraulic cylinder is the one which
will replace the knee actuator of HYDROı̈D robot. The dimensions of this hydraulic
cylinder are given in table 1.
IP
CR
4 Mohamad El Asswad, Samer AlFayad, Khaled Khalil
CylinderDiameter mm 25
by UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW on 09/12/18. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
US
P istonDiameter mm 20
RodDiameter mm 12
P istonStroke mm 110
Where m is the mass of the moving rod-piston, c is the viscous damping co-
efficient of oil, keq is the equivalent stiffness of the hydraulic cylinder, x is the
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
displacement position of the piston, ẋ is the piston velocity, ẍ is the piston acceler-
ation, P1 is the high pressure, P2 is the low pressure, A1 is the cross section area
facing the high pressure and A2 is the cross section area facing the low pressure and
Fr is the static friction force.
of the cylinder through a distance equivalent to the stroke of the piston (Fig. 2).
While the flow takes place, a shear stress τ is developed counter the internal surface
of the cylinder and can be expressed according to Newton’s viscosity law Munson
et al. (2009) as follows:
TE
EP
du
τ = −µ (2)
dr
C
AC
T
Accepted manuscript to appear in IJAM
September 10, 2018 14:17 Friction˙estimation
IP
CR
Experimental Estimation of Friction and Friction Coefficient of a Lightweight Hydraulic Cylinder Intended for Robotics Application
Where µ is the dynamic viscosity of the fluid, u is the velocity of the fluid and r is
the internal radius of the cylinder. On the other hand, the velocity profile inside a
cylinder u(r) can be expressed as follows Munson et al. (2009)
r2
by UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW on 09/12/18. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
US
R2
Where Uavg is the average velocity of flow and R is the radius of the cylinder.
Now deriving and replacing at r=R, the maximum shear stress τmax is expressed
as follows:
Uavg
τmax = 4µ (4)
R
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
The damping force Fd is the product of maximum shear stress τmax with the internal
surface contact area between the cylinder and the fluid Ai =2πRLp and can be
expressed as follows:
c = 8πµLp (6)
Where Lp is the stroke of the piston.
1
keq = 1 1 1 (7)
koil + krod + kcyl
The piston-rod stiffness is function of the Young’s modulus of the piston rod
Erod , the cross section area of the piston-rod Arod and the piston-rod length Lrod
and can be expressed as follows Feng et al. (2017):
EP
Erod Arod
krod = (8)
Lrod
The oil stiffness koil is function of the oil bulk modulus Eoil , the high pressure
chamber section area A1 , the low pressure chamber section area A2 , the volume of
the high pressure chamber V1 and the volume of the low pressure chamber V2 and
C
AC
T
Accepted manuscript to appear in IJAM
September 10, 2018 14:17 Friction˙estimation
IP
CR
6 Mohamad El Asswad, Samer AlFayad, Khaled Khalil
the fluid line volumes at the high and low pressure chambers VL1 and VL2 . It can
be expressed as follows Feng et al. (2017):
A21 A22
koil = Eoil ( + ) (9)
V1 + VL1 V2 + VL2
by UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW on 09/12/18. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
US
The cylinder expansion stiffness is due to the radial deformation of the cylinder
internal diameter due to the increase in the pressure. It is expressed as function of
the pressure difference ∆P , the cylinder cross section area A and the piston stroke
Lp as follows Feng et al. (2017):
A
kcyl = ∆P (10)
Lp
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
The cylinder cross section area A varies due to the radial deformation δr in the
cylinder diameter and it can be expressed as follows Feng et al. (2017):
(Dcyl + 2δr )2
A=π (11)
4
Where Dcyl is the initial diameter of the cylinder at zero pressure. The radial
deformation of a cylinder under internal pressure can be expressed as follow Feng
et al. (2017):
DM
Rcyl ∆P Db1 + 1
δr = ( 2 + νcyl ) (12)
Ecyl Db − 1
Where Rcyl is the outer radius of the cylinder, Ecyl is the Young’s modulus of
the cylinder, Db is the diametric ratio of the cylinder and νb is Poisson ratio of the
cylinder.
IP
CR
Experimental Estimation of Friction and Friction Coefficient of a Lightweight Hydraulic Cylinder Intended for Robotics Application
by UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW on 09/12/18. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
US
Figure 3: The hydraulic cylinder connected to the test bench
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
k0 and bending modulus Ecyl are related according to the following equation Chan
et al. (2000)
48Ecyl I
k0 = (13)
L3
Where L is the bending length of the cylinder and I is the second moment of area.
The bending modulus Ecyl is found to be 3.48 GP a according to the results in Fig.
7. Although, this value hasn’t taken into consideration the cross section variation,
EP
IP
CR
8 Mohamad El Asswad, Samer AlFayad, Khaled Khalil
by UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW on 09/12/18. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
US
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
DM
TE
IP
CR
Experimental Estimation of Friction and Friction Coefficient of a Lightweight Hydraulic Cylinder Intended for Robotics Application
by UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW on 09/12/18. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
US
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
piston stroke is 150 mm, which gives a damping coefficient of approximately 0.1
N.s/m.
The stiffness of the hydraulic cylinder is evaluated according to equation 7. The
EP
stiffness of the oil has a bulk modulus Eoil of 800 M P a ExxonMobil (2016) and
the stiffness of the oil is found to be 2480 N/mm. The stiffness of the rod krod is
calculated using the given dimensions of the rod in table 1 and the obtained results
of the rod Young’s modulus Erod . The evaluated value is found to be approxi-
mately 13430 N/mm. Moreover, the stiffness of the cylinder kcyl depends on two
experimental variables, the pressure difference ∆P and the radial deformation δr .
C
AC
T
Accepted manuscript to appear in IJAM
September 10, 2018 14:17 Friction˙estimation
IP
CR
10 Mohamad El Asswad, Samer AlFayad, Khaled Khalil
by UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW on 09/12/18. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
US
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
IP
CR
Experimental Estimation of Friction and Friction Coefficient of a Lightweight Hydraulic Cylinder Intended for Robotics Application
by UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW on 09/12/18. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
US
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
Figure 10: Equivalent stiffness keq of the composite cylinder function of time
TE
IP
CR
12 Mohamad El Asswad, Samer AlFayad, Khaled Khalil
variation of friction function of time is found (Fig. 11). The maximum friction value
is found to be 400 N while the average value is 166 N which is equivalent to 0.31
M P a as a maximum pressure losses in the cylinder and to 0.12 M P a as an average
pressure losses.
by UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW on 09/12/18. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
US
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
m
X
TE
Fr = µc Fni (15)
i=1
Where µc is the Coulomb friction coefficient and Fni is the normal contact force
which is the resultant of the squeezing of the O-ring BRIAN (2005). The normal
contact force at a specific zone of friction can be calculated as follows:
EP
Fni = ∆P Ai (16)
Where Ai is the contact area of the O-ring and the cylinder component at the
ith zone of friction. Here, two zones are defined: the cylinder contact zone with the
piston O-ring and the rod contact zone with the O-ring of the cap. The cylinder
contact area Acl is function of the cylinder internal diameter Dcyli and the line of
contact between the cylinder internal surface and the squeezed piston O-ring bcyl .
C
AC
T
Accepted manuscript to appear in IJAM
September 10, 2018 14:17 Friction˙estimation
IP
CR
Experimental Estimation of Friction and Friction Coefficient of a Lightweight Hydraulic Cylinder Intended for Robotics Application
US
∆Dcyli = 2δr (18)
Then, according to the geometric illustration in Fig 12, bcyl is calculated as follows:
p
bcyl = 4Ror 2 − h2 (19)
or
Where Ror is the O-ring cross section radius and hor is the height of the O-
ring after squeezing. hor is the difference between the cylinder internal radius Rin
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
and the gasket radius Rg (Figure 12). Thus, it depends in the deformation of the
cylinder δr .
DM
TE
The same concept is applied at the rod/O-ring contact zone and the contact
area Ar is calculated as follows:
Ar = πbrod Drod (20)
Where Drod is the rod diameter and brod is the line of contact between the rod
EP
IP
CR
14 Mohamad El Asswad, Samer AlFayad, Khaled Khalil
by UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW on 09/12/18. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
US
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
IP
CR
REFERENCES 15
4.3. Discussion
The different experimental methods mentioned in Sadashivappa et al. (2001)
haven’t recognized some theoretical parameters, such as the cylinder deformation
and the viscosity of the oil, which play an important effect in evaluating the friction
by UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW on 09/12/18. Re-use and distribution is strictly not permitted, except for Open Access articles.
forces. Moreover, the models mentioned in Liu et al. (2015) have there assump-
US
tions concerning the evaluation of the different parameters and have been tested in
the classical metallic cylinder, which is different in fabrication method and accu-
racy from the composite cylinder. This leads us to return to the original Newton
second equation and combine it with the experimental work. In other word, the
new method combines the experimental part with the theoretical part by calculat-
ing experimentally each coefficient of the Newton equation without taking many
assumptions, in a manner suitable to the new lightweight hydraulic cylinder, which
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
5. Conclusion
In summary, the friction of this new type of hydraulic cylinder was estimated suc-
cessfully. This would help further study that can be done in this actuator. In addi-
tion, the Coulomb friction coefficient between the O-ring and the composite barrel
was inherently computed. This represents a significant findings which can help in
the improvement of the actuator mechanical design. All these findings were done
depending on both theoretical and experimental studies related to both the dynam-
ics and mechanical properties of the hydraulic actuator. In details, the dynamics
TE
equation of the actuator was computed along with its main parameters including
the stiffness and the viscosity, at which the kinematics and pressure parameters
were obtained depending on experimental procedure. The resultant friction forces
and Coulomb coefficients were, then, computed according to the data obtained from
experiments and depending on Coulomb law theory.
In the future work, it is important to integrate this hydraulic cylinder in the
EP
robot joints, in order to improve its functionality and take more feedback data
related to the cylinder performance.
References
Abdalla, M. O., Nagarajan, Fakhruldin, T., and Hashim, M. (2013), Analysis of
innovative design of energy efficient hydraulic actuators, International Journal of
C
AC
T
Accepted manuscript to appear in IJAM
September 10, 2018 14:17 Friction˙estimation
IP
CR
16 REFERENCES
US
Azzam, A. and Li, W. (2014), An experimental investigation on the three-point
bending behavior of composite laminate, in 2014 Global Conference on Polymer
and Composite Materials (PCM)
Banerjee, N., Long, X., Du, R., Polido, F., Feng, S., Atkeson, C. G., et al. (2015),
Human-supervised control of the atlas humanoid robot for traversing doors, in
I. ras International, ed., Conference on Humanoid Robots,, pages 722–729
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
BRIAN, E. S. (2005), Research for dynamic seal friction modeling in linear motion
hydraulic piston applications, THE UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT ARLING-
TON
CaoJun, H., ZhouXiao, Z. X., and Wang, C. (2010), Design and control of a
hydraulic-actuated leg exoskeleton for load-carrying augmentation, in ICIRA In-
telligent Robotics and Applications, 590–599
Chan, W. S., Kazim, and Demirhan, C. (2000), A simple closed-form solution of
bending stiffness for laminated composite tubes, Journal of Reinforced Plastics
DM
Feng, H., Du, Q., Huang, Y., and Chi, Y. (2017), Modelling study on stiffness
characteristics of hydraulic cylinder under multi-factors, Journal of Mechanical
Engineering, 63, 7-8, 447–456
G., B., Lambrecht, A., and Kazerooni, H. (2009), Design of a semi-active knee
prosthesis, in 2009 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation
(Kobe International Conference Center, Kobe, Japan)
C
AC
T
Accepted manuscript to appear in IJAM
September 10, 2018 14:17 Friction˙estimation
IP
CR
REFERENCES 17
Kargov, A., Werner, T., Pylatiuk, C., and Schulz, S. (2008), Development of a minia-
US
turised hydraulic actuation system for artificial hands, Sensors and Actuators A,
141, 548–557
Koganezawa, K., Fujimoto, H., and KATO, I. (1987), Multifunctional above-knee
prosthesis for stairs’ walking, Prosthetics and Orthotics International, 11, 139–145
Liu, Y. F., Li, J., Zhang, Z. M., Hu, X. H., and Zhang, W. J. (2015), Experimental
comparison of five friction models on the same test-bed of the micro stick-slip
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
of the IEEE
Sadashivappa, K., Singaperumal, M., and Narayanasamy, K. (2001), Piston eccen-
tricity and friction force measurement in a hydraulic cylinder in dynamic condi-
tions considering the form deviations on a piston, Mechatronics, 11, 251–266
S.AlFayad (2011), Robot humanoide HYDROı̈D : Actionnement, Structure Cine-
matique et Strategie de controle (Editions universitaires europeennes (December
2 ISBN-10: 3841783457)
Shimamune, R. and Tanifuji, K. (1995), Application of oil-hydraulic actuator for
active suspension of railway vehicle: experimental study, Proceedings of the 34th
SICE Annual Conference., 95, 1335–1340, doi:10.1109/SICE.1995.526705, inter-
TE
IP
CR
18 REFERENCES
Zinn, M., Roth, B., Khatib, O., and Salisbury, J. K. (2004), A new actuation ap-
US
proach for human friendly robot design, Robotics and Automation, 1, 249–254,
doi:10.1109/ROBOT.2004.1307159, proceedings. ICRA ’04. 2004 IEEE Interna-
tional Conference
AN
Int. J. Appl. Mechanics Downloaded from www.worldscientific.com
DM
TE
C EP
AC