Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
October, 2015
Published by:
CREESS, IJENAS
(www.ijenas.com)
CREESS (Centre for Research in Ecology Environment and Social Sciences), the
publisher of International Journal of Environment and Natural Sciences (IJENAS),
is a non government reseach organisation with thrust areas in ecology,
environment, conservation and sustainable development, and IJENAS (ISSN:
2349-3763) is a peer-reviewed, open access journal. It seeks original research
papers from all aspects of environmental studies in particular, and from natural
sciences having direct bearing on increased understanding of environment, in
general. The journal encourages research papers from interdisciplinary areas.
The Journal has got indexation from two agencies and waiting from many more.
We are lucky to have Prof. Abhik Gupta, Dean, School of Environmental Sciences,
Assam University, Silchar and Dr. Susmita Gupta, Department of Ecology and
Environmental Science, Assam University, Silchar as our chief advisors.
It is a proud moment to share with you all that a special issue ‘VASUNDHARA’ is
published this autumn. This is the festive season which again reminds us the
deep bondage between our beliefs, culture, festivals, and traditions with sense of
journey and efforts
rts to raise ourselves, to save, and to nourish ourselves - the
Human Beings.
It was always in our mind since the inception of IJENAS to publish something
which is not purely scientific and be in a language which we all can understand
and appreciate and find out our relationships with nature. VASUNDHARA is a
step towards this. We are overwhelmed and would like to thank the authors who
contributed for this first issue of VASUNDHARA. You would be glad to know that
our first issue covers variety of topics starting
arting from poetry, prose, comments,
stories etc. From now onwards we would try to bring the regular issues of
VASUNDHARA which will be in a magazine form.
Being a Climate Leader, this issue also highlights our concern on the changing
climate on earth and its effects. In 2006, Nobel Laureate and former US Vice
President Al Gore got the world talking about climate change with the Academy
Award-winning
winning film An Inconvenient Truth. It was just the beginning of a climate
revolution, and later that year, he founded
ounded The Climate Reality Project to take the
conversation forward and turn awareness into action.
The Climate Reality Project is a diverse group of passionate individuals who have
come have come together to help solve the greatest challenge of our time. We are
cultural leaders, marketers, organizers, scientists, storytellers and more, and we
are committed to building a better future together.
With regards,
Indian philosophy has always been humane and dignified view of the sacredness
of all forms of life, and that humans are only a link in the chain of life and
consciousness. Vedas, the oldest hymns composed by great spiritual seers and
thinkers which are the repository of Indian wisdom, reflect the vibrancy of an
encompassing world-view which looks upon all objects in the universe, living or
non-living, as being pervaded by the same spiritual power. There is an age old
early Morning Prayer, which indicate the level of respect, offered to the Earth, the
life yielding mother.
(Oh Mother Earth, the Goddess who is having Ocean as her Garments and
Mountains as Her Bosom, Who is the Consort of Vishnu, I Bow to you;
Please Forgive me for Touching You with my Feet)
The nine plants of Nabapatrika represent nine forms of the Goddess. Banana
plant represents Goddess Brahmani, Colocasia represents Goddess Kalika,
Mother was moved by their plights and appeared in a delightful form. Seeing the
horror, she manifested herself as Goddess Satakshi with countless eyes on her
body. First shedding tears of compassion as Shatakshi Devi and then offering
fruit, flowers and vegetables from her own body, with a peaceful smile, She came
to be called Durga, as she slayed the Demon Durgam, restoring balance to the
earth.
So, in this special season of Nature worship, we would like to declare, the
inauguration of Vasundhara, where we have blended Environment, science and
culture together. My heartiest thanks are due to our Chief Advisors, Editorial cum
Advisory Board Members, Advisors of Documentary section, CREESS-IJENAS
family.
I am thankful to all the contributing authors for being a part of this family.
With regards,
,-./012/, 34 56 e8................................................................................................................................................... 12
59n3/; я1=>?............................................................................................................................................................. 13
?/@, ............................................................................................................................................................................... 13
ECO-Comic ................................................................................................................................................................... 15
aG6 CHIJK...................................................................................................................................................................... 15
L46G
4 /; 6/Iя5C MN/=/-1 eя5? O';P-" .............................................................................................................. 23
M9/J ................................................................................................................................................................................ 24
D;-/................................................................................................................................................................................ 27
Role of global positioning system (gps) in navigation in location based services ................... 33
SOCIETY ........................................................................................................................................................................ 37
[6.................................................................................................................................................................................... 39
8/iIB? .......................................................................................................................................................................... 43
Public hearing in EIA Process – A platform for raising Environmental issues .......................... 46
Y]BI]-/..................................................................................................................................................................... 61
5C? h/2.......................................................................................................................................................................... 62
,/IAB gc................................................................................................................................................................... 71
Dialogue ........................................................................................................................................................................ 77
Durga is called as the Jagat Janani (the universal mother). It is believed that Devi
Durga bears the whole world in her womb; so she is also called the Jagatdhattri.
Durga – the name itself depicts that she is the destroyer of all the sufferings
(durgati). In some of the mythological scripts, she is described as the slayer of the
demon Durg, therefore she is Durga. According to Hindu Mythology, she is one of
the warrior goddesses who can kill the dangerous and powerful demons with
ease. But, I personally believe that she is mother in deed and warrior in need. She
fights with demons only to protect her children; she protects her children from
all evils. But in real sense, she is the mother who loves, nourishes and feeds her
children and makes their lives happy, healthy and wealthy.
In Hindu Mythology, female deities, more or less, represent the energy, fertility
and creation. Devi Durga is considered as the epitome of all energies in this
universe and beyond the universe-she is the Mahashakti. According to the
legends, Devi Durga is created from the energies of the deities to destroy the
demon of all demons- Mahisasura. She is ten armed which means that she
protects her children from all the ten directions. She rides on a lion. Here, lion
represents power, desire and ego which are controlled by her. It also means that
we can only win our sorrows and sufferings by controlling these rajasik
qualities.In Shree Shree Chandi, it is said that
She is portrayed as the Prakriti who nourishes the whole world. Prakriti means
the nature. Devi Durga is considered as the Mother Nature. She is the creator,
protector and preserver of lives. The plants, the animals, the birds, the fishes, the
human beings-all are her children and she provides us all the resources to live
here. She nurtures every single aspect in this world. She is in the shining Sun, in
the glowing moon, in the twinkling stars, in the green mountains, in the blue sky,
Special Volume 1, October 2015 10
in the dancing rivers, in the sea shore. She is everywhere- She is everything-she is
you –she is me. So, the whole world praises her as:
She gives us food, therefore she is called Annapurna. She protects the vegetation,
so, she is called as Shakamvari. Shakambari-the goddess who bears the shaka i.e.
vegetables, fruits and leaves. It is believed that the goddess Shakambari
nourishes her children along with plants and trees. She is also called Bana-Durga-
the goddess who protects the forest and the wild lives.
We are going to celebrate Durga Puja in few days. The nature is decorating
herself beautifully and telling us that the Mother is coming. The blooming
shiuliphool, the white Kashphool, the extremely blue sky-all are singing the
Agamani. In Bengal, Maa Durga is worshipped with her whole family
(Saparibaraiyee, Savahanaiyee). If we closely observe the deities and their
vahanas, we can understand that mother Durga and her entire family reflect the
ecosystem. The ecosystem, in which, carnivorous and herbivorous animals are
living together harmoniously. It also exhibits the nutrient cycle. As the peacock
eats the snake, the snake and owl eat the mouse, duck and mouse eat grains
(provided by the Maa Lakshmi) and the lion eat the buffalo. But they all live in the
same ecosystem and the Mother Nature nurtures and protects them all. So, we
worship Mother Nature through Maa Durga-the Parama Prakriti. The energy
which our scientists often talk about, the energy which supports the life cycle, the
energy which controls the whole universe, is Maa Durga. Through her, we,
worship all this energies. Durga Puja is the occasion in which we salute and thank
Maa Durga for all her kindness and blessings. But this is not enough. We should
protect our Nature properly. We should work towards the eco friendly life style.
Deforestation, destroying wild lives, pollutions-all are against the principles of
Mother Nature. We have to
understand that this world is for all and being the most intelligent children of
Mother Nature, we, the human beings, should help the Mother Nature to protect
her children. This will be the highest tribute our Maa Durga-the Parama Prakriti.
Let’s adore Maa Durga for her enumerable blessings and never ending love
towards us:
Mя e6 Yя/C
o/,/,
o/,/ D/b-/ICA
C15V,/ Mg/L4;1
D~/iJ/^o, a86,
a86 9/;3
59n3/; я1=?
a59?2 8bj/5DG1?
84] 34 56
d]ID/; 6i,
8;18eV; CI; DJ/iIN ?1-/
D4,4; M,/I?/D/ g4,3,
YDd h3 MDI]2/-1 862 Y LH8;3/; я1=? ||
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
?/@,
MJsBD gkD3K1
5A-gB,
5A-gB Y8/6 , 9/B3
5CJIn YD/Bo l4 DIN 8HhK
YBo e,@/ 5C?I,
M,IZ 5?I2 gI- h/Ic
Y6/B я1D? MXI,
YD/Bo VZIN ?/@I,B hD5?,/
YяI,B 63 a59?2 MA`,
,/- MXI, YD/B
tr GID – ?34 ? ?/@,
tr GID – YD/B a59?2
M6,YIVB pI-IV 64]I, -45,I2
YD/Bo GID –
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
A/BC Dn?/
?1V4 M8?
D/b-/ICA
8e5fIA/593 3D 8es,4I-,
94D? u56IN 8C/ M}3 64] 6nI-,
5DC10K Gi2/IN MCG, QC3.,4-,
anB1Ik D/8 ,5BIN Gi2/ Y,4- ।
p,e53B ,/IN 34 56 e, p/,e3,
8e5fB tr 34 56 8,- я1D Y5[3.
aIO/IB YBs 9H56 YBs ,/A4 - ,
8G8/ MCD164] 9/I8 Gi2/ Y,4-।
яJI3 Y58N 34 56 84BIXB G/I3,
a?49ID YN Yяo A/BC p/I3.
sBI0 YN M6/B 34 56 sB5?,/
MCD3/B aIOK 34 56 MCD1 g5n,/।
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
[ pX6 VDK ]
BtC1V/ MC MO/`
-BtC1V/
,-,/3/,
,-,/3/ 9/B3
Ashiya Ansari
Sonipat, Haryana
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
?5n3/ 9Ã/g/hK
,-,/3/,
,-,/3/ 9/B3
Bengali Association of Victoria started Durga Puja in 1989. We brought the Idol
from Kumortuli in the same year. We were all excited. Ananda Bazar Patrika
wrote Ma Durga is going to Melbourne by Plane.
26 years have passed. In the beginning we used to have gathering of about 300 to
400 devotees. To day about 1200 /1300 people from all around victoria attend
attend the cerimony. This includes our Australian friends.
Pujo is normaly performed on the nearest Friday, Saturday and Sunday of actual
Puja day. Few years back I wrote this to Bengali News paper that as we do not
have holidays during this time and we do not have any permanent place for Puja
we do puja on those days at a hired venue.
Victoria Government supports our activities an we receive grants for this
function and others .
Every 3 to 4 yrs we bring new Pratima from Kumortuli. We have our own Bengali
priests. They are scientist and engineers and fully trained prists. Some of them
are Australian Gov certified
marriage celebrant and have full
power to solemnise marriage and
give marriage certificate.
Our 3 puja days are full of fun. Many
social activities, like dance drama,
children program are performed on
these days.
Foods are completely free for three
days. Our members contributions
and donations from business
communities are enough to support
our activities. In early days we used
to cook food in the hall for all the
people. But as no increased to
thousands we have gone to Indian caterers.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
D;-/
5CV/b,; ;/2
M,/,;/W/;,
M,/,;/W/;, a86,
a86, 9/;3
History
45 years ago in 1970, millions of Americans of all ages and all walks of life
gathered together for a common cause and celebrated the “Earth Day” for the
first time. The idea was conceived by Nelson, a U.S. Senator who got worried
about the growing industrialisation and deteriorating state of the planet. It was
for the first time that there was mass concern raised for the protection of Earth
and its valuable assets. Environmental issues were placed on a global agenda and
need was felt to protect nature in all its forms. At that time Earth Day was
conceived as educational series of “teachings on environmental issues” at
campuses across the United States, with demonstrations and marches in major
cities. The effect of it was so contagious that soon the fire of environmental
awareness spread to other countries as well. The message of protecting soil,
conserving water resources and to reduce and recycle became known to all. The
Day not only marked the celebrations but also lead to the establishment of
various government initiatives in the area of environment protection during that
period.
Going down the line it appears today that the planet was very different at the
time when Earth Day was first launched in 1970. The concerns were different
and the idea was limited to having knowledge about the declining state of Mother
Earth. The initial concerns of the planet were environment pollution. It was the
time in 1962 that Raceal Carson’s book had alarmed mankind of the demerits of
using excessive pesticides. We were worried more about the provision of clean
Scene Today
Today Earth Day is celebrated throughout the world making it a world’s largest
civic function. Due to the widespread following, the environmental consciousness
among public has grown far stronger, far better led, far better informed, and far
more influential than it was 44 years ago. Since then, Earth Day is being
celebrated primarily by environment organizations and various activities
concerning environment protection are being organized. There are tree
plantations, cleanliness drives, awareness sessions and discussions on various
platforms to protect, conserve and manage the resources of the earth. However,
in spite of the growing efforts and enthusiasm, there seems to be no radical
change being observed. It is pertinent to question ourselves whether with that
increased environmental awareness has the environmental sensitivity equally
grown? Has the state of environment improved or have we been able to conserve
our vital natural resources?
A realistic analysis will only predict that we are on the verge of ecological
doomsday. The reasons may be cited as increasing population and North South
Debate or controversial climate change issue but one thing is certain that while
celebrating Earth Day we have missed out a very important factor and that it is
we ourselves.
In this entire scenario, the component of biosphere comprising human race is
mostly ignored. Earth is not simply environment but human beings too constitute
a major bulk. All the past discourse on earth day have centred around protecting
environment and its components but human rights and dignity and values have
not been nowhere mentioned. Looking at the origin of the Day it is quite
interesting to note that in 1969 at a UNESCO Conference in San Francisco, peace
activist John McConnell proposed a day to honour the Earth and the concept of
peace, to first be celebrated on March 21, 1970. Earth means the planet on which
we live that means we are an inseparable part of it. Therefore it is pertinent to
QAI-? C/8
5A-gB,
5A-gB Y8/6,
Y8/6 9/B3
Scientists decided that the only way to provide coverage for the entire world was
to place high-frequency radio transmitters in space. A transmitter high above the
Earth sending a high-frequency radio wave with a special coded signal can cover
a large area. This is one of the main principles behind the GPS system.
Navigation in Land
GPS improves efficiency on land as well. The capabilities of satellite navigation,
when coupled with communications and modern computerized management
systems can help meet many of the transportation challenges facing all modes of
surface transportation.
Currently, it is being used to add a new dimension for automatic vehicle location
and in-vehicle navigation systems. GPS helps motorists find their way by showing
their position and intended route on dashboard displays.
The NAVSTAR and GLONASS systems use the principle of trilateration. That is,
the user’s receiver determines the distance from the user to each of several
satellites. Since the positions of the satellites are known, either through previous
publication or as part of the satellite’s broadcast information, the user’s position
can be calculated.
a?4V6 C/AA6K/
,-,/3/,
,-,/3/ 9/B3
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Y6/B D/5ZI3
D/5ZI3 M@/I, MJI,/
5D}5я\ 58b
Y8/6 5D}5DC./-2,
5D}5DC./-2 5A-gB,
5A-gB Y8/6,
Y8/6 9/B3
M@/I, MJI,/ (Gekko Gecko): Ve5XD1B 5d312 DeGt6 Gecko pя/53B p/?1ICB
9/BI3B utB-VHDK abIAi MD5AB9/J MC]I3 V/o2/ h/2। MD^Ig X/,/B uIdIA.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
M3/6/; 5DC/2 V;3
C1VIя./53 58bG,
58bG,
g=/G/5@,
g=/G/5@, a86,
a86, 9/B3
h/D ]45яN/ Mh532/ Mh/=/PJ
M3/6/; a?4V85G53I2 V/XK,. Y5?D D45- ?/9/5DD/।
V/n/ V/-
5A-gB,
5A-gB, Y8/6,
Y8/6, 9/B3
14i YJf,2011
,/-I,B 5T, ,/-I,B ,X/, 5D}5DC./-2 MXI, D/I8 5B5N-/6 ।D/I8B pX6
я/2J/2 DI85N-/6 Y56 ,,/I? MGlI/? ।YV? 6I? BD1nd8bJ13 t?5N-/6,GT/\
20i M6,2013
3/BVB YB MC]/ MV-/6 ?/ M3/6/B।e, e, ,IB 8D `/n/58,gI-/ M,I@ MJ-।
M3/6/B MC]/ MV-?/। Yя MA` `/n/58I,B MA` VB1k/। 91`? uIt5я3। C6Dn
,IB D/8IsIn C/^5ZI2 Y5N, h5C ",/я5-B" MA` e,D/B MC]/ V/i। M85C?
M3/6/B aIVk/ ,BI3 ,BI3 e, e, ,IB 8D D/8gI-/ N/Z-/6 5,nt 34 56
M,/X/2। ÎD/B MA` D/8@/ h/ID, D4,9B/ YA/ 5?I2 DI8 Y5N M3/6/B MC]/ Mh?
V/i। D/8 eI8 X/6- g/5B5CI, MC]I3 -/J-46, ?/ T/,4B 64] 34 I- MgI2IN? , M8i
D/I8B 8/6I?B я/?-/B я/2J/2 34 56। M8i 5934 ,/я-6/]/ Mg/] M3/6/B, 3ID
Yя Mh? e,@4 M9я/। MCsIZ uT-/6 D/I8 M,/?6I3 M3/6/B я/2J/B V/IA
C/Z/-/6। M8i5C? M3/6/B VBI? -/- e,5@ ,43K/ YB J91B ?1- BI~B Ml5?6,
,/I? M@B/,@/ d-, uuu.! 5, -/J5N- M3/6/I, 5, D-D! GT/\ MC]-/6 34 56
я/2J/@/ MNIZ 5CI2 uIT C/^Z/I- Y6/B V/IA। e Mh? e, Q?8K/5J, 6HG3K,
eBя?. 3./J ,BI3 V/5B Y56 iIndB 58bG/8?,3./J ,BI3 V/5B
a6e3,-8।g-nD/I8B 6ed G/o2/ D/BD/B M3/6/B g4-gI-/ Y6/B 64I]B uVB
eI-I2 5C5c- 5, 6/C, Jn 3/I3, D4, CHrCHr ,BI3 -/J-। M8]/I?i 8HtV/3
18i YJf,2016
Yя aI?,5C? ,/я5-B 8/IX MC]/ M?i । я1D? VIX aI?, e5JI2 e85N, MI-
eI85N aI?, 9/-6n se53, tL4 MI- Y8I3 V/5B5? M3/6/I, ,/я5-। M8i
M85C? G-IC uZ?/ u5ZI2 Mh? A1I3B MA`ID-/B MB/ICB 63 G/5BI2 MJ- ।
3/BVB eI,-eI, D8In 6/3/- 6/C,3/; g1IäB 3e Æ/,4-3/; 8D MJ- 5,nt 3/B
MC]/ MV- M,/X/2। GT/\ ei MO/B [/DI? M3/6/I, MC]-/6 5D8яK?O/I@B 8/6I?
…. G?G5?I2 Y6/B V/A ,/5@I2 gI- MJI-। VBI? M3/6/B G/-,/ Y,/A1 BI~B
M8/?/5- V/^Z MCo2/ A/5Z…… 5T, Mh? D`K/B яI- 9B/ C1O1B яI- M8/?/5-
MB/ICB M]-/…। 5DsI2 g6I, uT-/6, ]/5?,@/ e5JI2 O4IB C/^Z/I-/ …. 3/B
M,/,Z/I?/ W/^,B/ g4-gI-/ M, MC/-/ 5CI2 h]? 3/,/I-/…. 6I? G- MA-1B
,5D3/B un/C56?/C D45W 8/k/3 C/5ZI2 YIN। ,V/I- 3/B ,/I-/ M/^@/ ..,/I?
M8i M@B/,@/। я/5??/ GT/\ 6I? G-, aD5?B CBя/B ,Z/ ]4I- G23 D?-3/
eI8IN । M8ie,i9/ID 6nt64IgB 63 3/5,I2 Bi-/6 । h]? MO/B 9/~- 3]?
3/B aI@/5Bk/ N4 @IN YV? J53I3 । ,1 ,BD 9/DI3 9/DI3i aI@/5Bk/ e5JI2
MJ- ..9/D-/6 æ/5I,B 6IL. 3/I, Y@I, 6I?B ,X/@/ DI- MCD। Yяo 3/B
,/я-6/]/ Mg/] Y6/B 6I? YI-/Z? 8e5f ,BIN, Y6/B 9/-D/8/B M6O YD/B
JяK? ,IB WBI3 g/iIN । ei M9ID MCsIZ e5JI2 MhI3 g/i-/6, MG/^g@ M]I2
M6/D/i-@/ VIZ MJ- । M8@/ u5TI2 MC]-/6 3/B aI@/5Bk/ M?i, g/5B5CI,
MC]-/6 M?i M8। 5, ,BD M9ID uTI3 V/B5N-/6 ?/ … M6/D/i-@/ G/I3B 64IT/2
Ak ,IB LIB Bi-/6, 6I? G- eD/B h]? GI-/?/ YB 3/GI- GID?/ । Mg/I]B
M,/0/2 D/^L 9/~-, dI/^@/ Mg/I]B я- , J/- MDI2 M?I6 MJ-। 9/-D/8/ G23
WB- ?/,5,nt D`K/ 5T, M?I6 e-.. WBWB ,@4 V@/V 3яK?-JяK? 8G,/IB… 5T,
19i YJf,2016
VB5C? M6O 5gIB uяj- 8HhK/I-/I, O46 9/m-। я/?-/B ,/^g 5CI2 MC]-/6 V4IB/
uT/? я4IZ N5ZI2 BI2IN De5fs/3 5Au5-4 -, Y,/IA gIB MDZ/>Ic J/59B 63
8/5B 8/5B M6IOB C-। ABI3B ei ad43 M]-/ MCI] e, 5Ds2,B VH?3
K / a?49D
,B-/6 । 94I- MJ-/6 J35CI?B h3 6/? a596/? o 5D`/C , a?49D ,B-/6 e,
adH3 Y?n।I,? я/5??/, 6I? G- tL4 5, V/o2/I3i Y?n ? 5,N4 V/D 3/B
YA/2 X/,I3 5, Y?n M?i ? spVHBI0i 5, Y?n ? sp MC]I3 M?i 5, ? 5T,
3]5? 6I?B J91B aníVHB MXI, M9I8 uIT….
“M,/? 8/JIBB V/B GI3 YI?,M,/? 84CIH BB L?।
M9I8 MhI3 g/2 6?, MI- MhI3 g/2 ei 5,?/B/2 8D g/o2/ 8D V/o2/……..”
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
M6/; MG^V/G
5CJn =/2
M,/,;/W/;,
M,/,;/W/;, a86,
a86, 9/;3
M6/; an,/; я1=?; Yn/;5]5?
34 56 Mя/?/,PG MV/G;/DP-
YgIGI; YJD/5î Y5G-/......
D4,4; 593;3 ,5-я//5-
o-/i aG/ sn?; Ab
6i 5?Iяi t5?IN/,
rd?1- B/2IgsL4B1
?/,, D/b-/ICA
]4-?/
D4I,B D/6 5C,@/2 ,/-PDA/]1 яI6IN Dh5C?,
,I3/5C? WZ MC5]5?, D.X/ D45W5?!
Yя,/- ]4D ,IB 6I? G2—
ei D45W AB1B@/ я6/ VZI-/ M,/6/2,
Mh6? ,IB 58J/IB@ eI3/5C? M]I2IN Y6/2!
rd?1- B/2IgsL4B1
?/,, D/b-/ICA
]4-?/
]4D 5, ,f V/o Yя,/- ?
Mh6? 8Hhs
K /? ?/ GI-—
,f V/2 6/2/D1 8,/-!
6I? M?i ?
6/WB/I3 G/3 LIB M@I? 5?I3 N/IC,
Y,/IAB 8D 3/B/ M3/6/B GID
D-I3 aD/IL!
rd?1- B/2IgsL4B1
?/,, D/b-/ICA
]4-?/
,g4 V/3/2 De5fB яI-B M,/? Jl M-]/ X/I, ?/,
Y^,/ X/I, ?/ 84] 5, D/ dí] !
M365? M,/? яI-B Jl—
M-]/ M?i Y6/B Mg/I]B V/3/2,
Y,/A@/I, o6I-@ D/5?I2 5?De3 ,5B k4 L/,
p535@ 6e3 Yt/ я/I? Y6/B MD^Ig X/,/B Jl ।
eI3/5C? 8m4I] eI8 C/^Z/i5?
p,/IA. D5-5? M,/? ,X/,
Yя 5?í8bI,/Ig я/?/I3 g/i
5IB MVI3 g/i 5,N4 5?5DZ 64g3/ ।
De5fB яI- -45ð3 GD/B—
8/G8 MC]/i5? eI3/,/-,
MD-1 4 I-B 6/-/ MJ^IX Mh Mp56,
D/JC/? 8mn ,IB 5JI25N- !
3/Bi ,/-g5n Yя eI8IN a5L,/B 5IB MVI3 ।
5?3. p9/I3 h/B ?/I6 C1V j/I-/,
h/B я?. ak3 MBI]N 5?IяB 5AG5B3 h64?/
Special Volume 1, October 2015 45
M8i Y56 M3/6/Bi 8m4I] C/^5ZI2—
e, D5- MVsrI`B u\,ef ?64?/ ।
89.3/B ,/IN Y56 -4p
3D4o, 5?5DKD/IC p535C? 31b 8HIhKB 8m4I] C/^Z/i !
6rB/5tB Mg/] 5?I2 MgI2 X/5,—
Mя/\s/ ]4DI- ]4DI- ]/D DI-,
34 56 Y6/2 Cg ,IB/, s5m3 ,IB C/o Y6/B 65s×;
p,/IA. a86/p g4m? e^I, 5CI2 я/5?I2 C/o Ve5XD1I,—
34 56o De5fB яI- -45ð3 GI3 5AI]N ।
]4D MN/Ã e,@/ 5T,/?/ Y6/B,
hICB яI- 8/^3/B ,/@/B NI-—
Mh 5T,/?/ 9/58I2 5JI25NI-, M8i 5T,/?/2 5g5T 5Co;
V4ZI3 X/,/ L4IVB 63 8Im/LI? 5-I] 5Co '5p2' ।।òòò
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Public hearing in EIA Process – A platform for raising
Environmental issues
Dr. MANOJ KUMAR
Manager, Environment & Forest Department,
CCL, Coal India Limited
ABSTRACT
This paper categorizes the environmental issues being raised in Public Hearing
(PH)/Public Consultation (PC)process in Indian scenario. Public hearing in
Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) Process acts as a platform for raising the
various concerns of the project affected persons in general and environmental
issues in particular. An issues tree have been framed. Countrywide analysis for
the PH issues being raised in the mechanism along with timeline of the PH has
been analysed. This paper explores why some of the projects were subject to
public hearing, and the objectives, form and outcomes of this process. It
concludes that stakeholders’ involvement in review is essential and may lead to
enormous benefits for the proponent, stakeholders and the nation. Where this is
INTRODUCTION
DEFINITION
As per Abigail Williamson and Archon Fung, Public Hearing is an open gathering
of officials and citizens, in which citizens are permitted to offer comments, but
officials are not obliged to act on them or, typically, even to respond publicly.
Public consultation refers to the process by which the concerns of the local
people regarding the adverse impacts of a project are ascertained and taken into
account in the EIA study.
As per EIA notification 2006, Public Consultation” refers to the process by which
the concerns of local affected persons and others who have plausible stake in the
environmental impacts of the project or activity are ascertained with a view to
taking into account all the material concerns in the project or activity design as
appropriate.
EIA Process in India includes Screening, Scoping and consideration of
alternatives, Baseline data collection, Impact prediction, Assessment of
alternatives, delineation of mitigation measures and environmental impact
statement, Public hearing, Environment Management Plan, Decision making,
Monitoring the clearance condition.
SCOPE
This paper attempts to explore why some projects were subjected to public
hearings, and the objectives and purposes, form and outcomes of public hearings.
30.05.14 Project already availed 25% clause can avail under 50% clause
also.
28.07.14 50% clause extended production capacity exceeding 16 MTPA
(additional production up to 5 MTPA).
22.08.14 F.No. J-11013 l4L12006-IA-II (I) (part) : The SPCBs shall ensure
that the PH is conducted within the timeline of 45 days as
prescribed in the EIA (2006) & within the validity period of the
TORs, and that no PH is held after the validity period, of TORs is
over.
ISSUES CATEGORIZATION
This concept was legally introduced in India in the form of ‘public hearing’ in
1997. Since then the public hearing process has been conducted as a mandatory
step of environmental clearance for most projects and activities. This was the
amendment made in EIA notification 1994. The term PH is defined n EIA
notification 2006 as “Public Consultation” refers to the process by which the
concerns of local affected persons and others who have plausible stake in the
environmental impacts of the project or activity are ascertained with a view to
taking into account all the material concerns in the project or activity design as
appropriate.
The issues categorization has been made only for the environmental issues raised
in various public hearing proceedings conducted in India. The issues raised are
broadly classified into Physical and Socio-economic issues. The physical issues
Special Volume 1, October 2015 57
are related to air pollution, water pollution, noise pollution, land/soil pollution.
This covers the left part of the issue tree referred in fig. 2. On the other hand the
right part refers to the socio-economic. Air pollution issues may include road
worthiness, fire, fugitive emission, fly ash etc. The water Pollution issues includes
drinking water and noise pollution issues includes vibration, noise distraction
issues also. Soil/ Land Pollution issues includes reclamation/afforestation issues
being raised stakeholders most often.
Socio-economic issues wide variety of sub-issues related to drinking water,
electricity,road, health, education, company social responsibility (CSR),and
compensation to land losers and homestead, employment. This also includes the
mode of PH information or whether the information about time and venue of PH
been received or not.
CONCLUSION
REFERENCES
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
B/я/B 5g5T
5634 - Ct
M,/-,/3/,
M,/-,/3/, V5Â6Dm,
V5Â6Dm, 9/B3
a6- 6e34.B 6I3/ M, Mh 3/B VX MgI2 YIN
/^,/, ?1- l/,D/Ik MNI2 MJIN V/Z/...
Dn я/?/-/B V/IB MB/d4Bh4IJB M5Bo-/,
e,/ ?/@I, h/B 8/6/?. 9H56,/,
?C1B oV/IB MCA, M6I2ICB -/D0.V5B]/...
a84] D/nD 3/B, G/I3 h/B dr3 uV5AB/
V/G/IZ V/G/IZ M6O...M6IO M6IO M8/?/5- Jm1B/...
Diwali or deepawali , means the festival of lights . diwali has great significance
in hindu culture like Gayatri mantra, which also means leading us from darkness
to light. Ancient history states that when milky ocean (kheer Sagar) was
churned, goddess laxmi, the goddess of wealth, appeared as a result of that
churning .Diwali is a festival of paying tribute to goddess laxmi . As per
Ramayana, After defeating Ravana, when Rama came back to Ayodhya, People
celebrated Diwali, by lighting earthen lamps . As per Mahabharata, When
Krishna killed Narakasur, the lamps were lit to celebrate victory over the evil.
For generations, Diwali was celebrated as the festival of light. However, the
practice of burning crackers came into existance much later.
Diwali is celebrated all over india with great zeal & vigor . In North India, it is
celebrated in memory of lord Ram & in South India, in memory of lord Krishna
.During diwali people wear new clothes, distribute sweets, visit temples .
In South India, for newly married couples or couples blessed with new baby
it is called “thala” (first) diwali . The couples wear new garments & exchange
sweets, share a light moment of their life by lighting sparklers.
On diwali people get up early in the morning, offer prayer to God, make a special
paste and apply it with oil on their fore head . Then they apply 7 drops of oil on
their thigh signifying the presence of Saptha Rishis within them. After that, they
chew some betel leaves, as a part of the ritual.Finally, they take bath with herbal
powder and celebrate the day by sharing of sweets & savories
In South, crackers are made in Sivakasi. No doubt crakers contribute a lot
towards environmental pollution, but if this phenomenon can be done in a
useful way by using recycled papers & by use of eco friendly substances, which
produces less or zero noise, release no harmful gases rather useful gases, then?
This is truly an area where studies like biotechnology & biochemical
technology can be put into use in such a way that , the crackers burst & release
Special Volume 1, October 2015 60
gases which are meant for the betterment of environment , thus promoting a
safe environment & greener earth. Happy Diwali in advance.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Y]BI]-/
MCD-1?/ M8?gp
g2/G/5@,
g2/G/5@, Y8/6,
Y8/6, 9/B3
Y]BI]-/2
Ab M,I@ Det D/?/i
e,-/ID-/2।
6t 6/2/2
я5@- h3 ,l 9/5~
8Gя ,X/2।
5?C/O CG?
3@9H56B яI-B MB]/2
Y,4- kB0
W5BI2 h/2
u\8 GI3 M6/G?/I3
aD/, L/B/2
3D4o h/V?
5Dя? я1D? aя/5?I3
e65? ,]?
uC/8 J/X/2
YDN/2/ g/^C ,/D. NZ/2
hC2 M,/I`
-g MAI` ।
-4pB/I3B 845p84I]B
66KICIA
MCD-1?/ M8?gp
g2/G/5@,
g2/G/5@, Y8/6,
Y8/6, 9/B3
g/5B5CI, uItя?/,
uItя?/ e3
Y6/I, MB/D@ D/?/2
p535C? я1DI?B k3
9/I-/D/8/ tI2 X/I,
я1DI?B 3/I,-
5?V/@ 5?9/^я
tL4 6/IW 6/IW,
L4I-/D/5- я/- oIZ,
r,45@5D-/V।
8D5,N4 84IB D/^L/
QDT5, 3/I?, D.X/ h3 aIJ/N/-
VIZ X/I,
QD9D1 61IZ...a8G/2
5C? h/2।
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
a?/56,/ gkD3K1
g2/G/5@,
g2/G/5@, Y8/6,
Y8/6, 9/B3
9/B3
Aamir Khan
Aamir Khan, superstar and celebrity who backs the go green campaign. He has
great regard for this environmentalist campaign and has always supported the
cause to spread the message across the public.
Priyanka Chopra
Abhishek Bachchan
John Abraham
Rahul Bose
Actor Rahul Bose is the super talented star from Bollywood as well as
Tollywood (Bengali film industry) consistently worked to raise the profile of
climate change in India and overseas. In 2009, Rahul, who represented Oxfam at
the UN Climate Conference in
Copenhagen, joined tens of thousands of
demonstrators at a mass rally and
candlelight vigil outside the Danish
Parliament in Copenhagen. In 2011, Bose
and Priyanka Chopra were involved in a
joint program of the United Nations
Environment Program and the
International Indian Film Academy. Rahul
raised the stakes by pledging to plant two trees for every activity registered in his
name.
Special Volume 1, October 2015 65
Nandita Das
Gul Panag
Buddhaditya Mohanty
84A/n ,B
,2/,, Y8/6,
53?845,2/ Y8/6, 9/B3
(p/2 DNB ]/5?, YI] ei M-]/5@ Q35B ,IB5N-/6 5tV4B/B e,5@ ,/JIяB
,X/2। ,/Jя5@ MhI,/I?/ ,/BI0i MG/, MDrI-/ ?/। a3eD 5h5? M-]/ 5?I2
MJ5NI-?, 3/^B a?4653 5?I2 p,/IA. 5?I2 e-/6। ---84A/n ,B।)
“Y6/B BIk ,/n/яI-B Y-I3/ Jn
MGI- VIZIN L/I?B g/B/..”..(o- M9I~ Y8IN,G1IB? 9Ã/g/hK)
‘6/-6/5@ –6/?4`’ ,X/@/ V5Â6 D/b-/B B/я?153I3 ]4D MA/?/ MJ5N- MJ- 5DL/?89/
5?DK/gI?B YIJ। AbgcI, eB YIJ Y6B/ e, YIDJ9B/ я?5p2 h/t/B ?/6
DI-i я/?3/6। M8i ?/6 5CI2 Mh M,u B/я?153I3 D/5я6/3 ,IB 5CI3 V/IB? e
Y6/ICB ,l?/B D/iIBo 5N-। 3/o e6? e,@/ C- eDb 8B,/IBB 5DrId h/ICB
8mI,K M-/I, DI-? Mh 3/B/ 53? CA, B/яt ,IBi5NI-? 9H56 8bs/IBB Mя/IB
eDb MJ/@/ MCIA 3/B/ M8i ,6K8Hg1I, e5JI2 5?I2 5JI2 e,@/ ‘ я?J03/5nt,
5DpD’ ,BID? DI- M-/I, MяI? Y85N-। MC]/ MJ-, A/8I?B MA` 5CI, 3/ICB
5DrIdi ,e`I,B G/3 MXI, я56 5?I2 5JI2 eD/IB YB я56C/B ?2, 5AlV53ICB
86IW MCD/B a59Ih/J uT-। YB ei a59Ih/IJB M3/IZi eB/ A/8? MXI, uIZ
MJI-?। ‘я?J03/5nt, 5DpD’64-34 5D GI2 MJ-। D/5, MCIAB YB M,/?o YA/
Bi- ?/।
853. 5, 3/i? MC]/ MJ- eB 5,N4 VIB 9/B3 8B,/IBB ]/C. 5?B/Vt/
Yi? eDb 9H56 a5LgG0 Yi? ?/I6 dI@/ Yi? 5?I2 eI-/। YIB,5@ Yi?
i536IL. p5k2/B 6IL. YIN। M85@ 9H56 8bs/B Yi?। 2013B я4-/i 6/I8
9/B3 8B,/B eB e,5@ ]8Z/ p,/A ,IB я?63 8bgIG M?I6IN। ei8D O@?/
Y6/ICB aI?,I, 59B56 ]/iI2 MCD/B 6I3/ O@?/i DI@। e5@ e6? e,@/ 5D`2
h/ Y8I-i Y6/ICB ggK/B D/iIB X/I,। B/я?153B h/B/ 85k2 ,6K1, 3/ICBi
8я2 gkD3K1
g2/G/5@,
g2/G/5@, Y8/6,
Y8/6, 9/B3
#-Y^L/B ,/^@/2 VH0K Y6/B MCA, ]4^Iя YI-/IB]/।
MN^Z/ MV/A/I,B ?1Ig Mh pD- ,f M6I]IN AB1IB।
M, 3/I, ,f MC2, DL.9H56B яя/-? oi C./I]/
g/^Co M,6? @,@I, -/-, X6I, YIN AB\ B/5tIB।
e6? YJ6?1 MgI25N-/6, MD/I-/ ? Y?n Y6/B
8,-, -4T ,IB 5?I2 MJ- l/,/3 D/3/8।
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Y5я 34 56 D.s
5D5я3/ D6K0
Dm/iJ/o,
Dm/iJ/o, a86,
a86, 9/;3
Y5я 8/IJ 34 56 D.833 V5;N/
Y5я 8/IJ 34 56 D.s3 V5;N/
D.s3 V/G'5;N/I? M6/; ?/6 ?
……
V/G'5;N/ h5C V/G'5;N/
?/i M6/; YV5t a,'6/? ।
Sudip Dey
New Delhi, India
When Kans grass starts growing on the protruding river beds of Yamuna, I can
hear the footsteps of the Mother Goddess echoing in the air. It is when I notice the
clouds resembling puffy cotton balls paint the spotless blue canvas of the sky. I
start taking a longer route to home, just to check if the night jasmine tree in my
Special Volume 1, October 2015 73
neighbour’s yard is blooming or not. The day I get to have a glimpse of these
three together, I can feel the Puja is knocking at the door. I ask Maa if she needs a
Tussar or Jamdani saree this Puja while she ends up with the same query, “Are
you coming this time?”
I still remember the childhood days when Puja was synonymous to an occasion
when Maa and Baba would take us out for shopping and my sister and I used to
end up fighting over the number of dresses we could buy out of our allotted
budget. There was excitement, fun, jealousy and a mild tune of sadness after the
idol was immersed in the river Barak.
Listening to Maa, I got nostalgic. I was sunk in the oblivion, thinking about Baba’s
best attempt to hold me up on his shoulder to see the tallest of Durga idol even in
the most jam-packed pandal of the city.
Since my childhood, I was out of home, away from my parents. So, Durga Puja
was more about meeting my family than a mere religious celebration. With the
mythological tales of Goddess Durga’s arrival at her maternal home, I could easily
relate my experience. Initially in Silchar (back in my hometown) there were
around 80-100 pandals out of which around 10-15 Puja Pandals were the most
crowd gathering.
In 2013, for the first time, I was out of home during Durga Puja. In Delhi, there
was no holiday on Ashtami so that I could go offering Pushpanjali or to have bhog
on the auspicious day of Navami. I cried like a baby. There was no excitement to
get ready in the evening to go pandal hopping. Neither, I had any urge to wear the
newly purchased clothes. Without friends, acquaintances or a single family
member, I was alone roaming from pandal to pandal. The scaffoldings, I got to see
in Delhi were way better than the ones we usually see in Silchar. These were all
about gaiety and somehow showing-off. I could see people giggling in groups,
having fun with their fellow mates or taking selfies every now and then. There
were innumerable food stalls – both vegetarian and non-vegetarian being
thronged by the foodies and the fragrance of distinctive types of grilled chicken
and biryani were tantalising my taste buds.
In Silchar, the big budget Durga Puja would not mean more than 20 lacs. Here the
roads are narrow and filled with potholes. Unfortunately, by the time Durga Puja
holds, the post-monsoon affect does not actually disappear which result into the
occurrence of pathetic roadways. But, even amidst so many disturbing things to
complain about, there is something what makes my city popular in and out. Here
the Puja committees announce a cold war a month advance against each other in
terms of budget or the theme. But nowhere this extravagant festival appears as a
way to show off the opulence.
Bengalis are always identified with art/culture. And there can’t be a better option
than the Durga Puja to get this proved. In Delhi too, the Puja organising
Ve1A V4B,/2s (V4-,)
,)
m/,, 5A-gB,
,4m/ 5A-gB, Y8/6
g/ D/J/? Ab5@B 8Im Y6/B 8m,K 53? V4rI`B। C/d, 6/ eDb Y56... ?/Z1B
D/^LI? D/^L/। M,/? e, aCeA. A5kB @/I?i G2I3/ ,e]/I? Y6/B D/BD/B 5IB
Y8/ YB M8i aCeA. @/? D45W Y6/B C/dB Yt/B YA1DK/C। MN/@ h]? 5N-/6
3]? Y6/B g/B5CI, tL4 6/6/, 6/61, C/d YB 5CC/। Mh M,/? D/Z1i Y6/B
6/6/B D/Z1। 5,- gIZB Mh6? 92 5N- ?/, M365? YDC/B ,B/B o M,/? ]/653
Special Volume 1, October 2015 75
5N- ?/। dJK/VHIя/ MC]I3 5JI2 ,/B M,/I- gIZ T/,4B MC]-/6, ,/B V/IA DI8
h/t/ MC]-/6 , h/t/ MC]I3 MC]I3 92 MVI2 ,/B M,/I- 64] -4I,/-/6 3/B M,/?
5T,/?/ 5N- ?/। V4BI?/ g/ D/J/I?B ,X/ h]? G2 3]? Mg/I]B M,/I? M9I8 oIT
h/t/ J/I?B ,X/। a8mD 8D h/t/V/-/ 5?I2 DZICB 6IL. ,3 ,X/i Mh GI3/।
MN/@ICB 9/I-/ -/JI3/, h]? 6Iv h4d GI3/। M8i 3I-/2/IBB MT/,/T45,, gZ/
84IBB Ab 6HNK?/ । D/J/? 8bse53B 6s e,@/ я/2J/ я4IZ YIN ei h/t/V/-/।
e]? M8i 8Di G/5BI2 MJIN YL45?, ph45kB 58I?6/ VCK/B ,/IN। 6IL. aI?,
DNB gn??JIB ,/5@I2, Y6/B OIB MB/ 1986B 13i я4?। ?34 ? ,IB, V4B/I?/
8D 5,N4 I, 5IB MC]/B aC6. Mgf/। YT/IB/ DNB, MCZ h4J VIB 5IB eI8
Y?InB Mh? MA` M?i। MN/@ID-/B se53gI-/ g/B5CI, N5ZI2 5N5@I2 YIN, tL4
,45ZI2 5?I2 6/-/ J/^X/B aIVk/2। Mg/I]B 8/6I? pX6 8,/-, Mh? M8i
5Au5-WB/, 8яI? 4 I-B 8/C/ g/CIB o/,/ uIT/I?B V/IAB 91`0 Mg?/ Y6/B
YV? 862gI-/। C/dB G/3 LIB ?/63/ VZI3 VZI3 Y6/B s4- h/o2/। M3^34-
J/INB 9HI3B Jl, ,/5-C/I8B D45dB M,B/653, 8Di Mh? Mg/I]B dV/A 5CI2 WIB
VZI3 tr ,BI-/ । 5T,/?/ Y6/B MVI25N Dn4, 5T,/?/B 8n/?, 8D4я 5@-/B
Y?/Ig ,/?/Ig Y6/B D/8s/?।
Y6/I, Mh M,/2/@K/B MC2/ MG/-, 3/B 5T, 5DVB1I3 e,5@ MN/Ã 6/T। o]/I? 5N-
e,@/ p,/ MD-J/N , 3/Bi 5T, 5?Ig e, 862 5N- ?/@I,B Y^34Z OB।
M8]/I? Y6/B a59?I2Bo яn GI25N-। 6I? YIN, [1 5D?2 9H`0 gkD3K1
(5B@/2/lK 5p5nV/-, 6B5- uc 6/L.56, 5DC./-2) 3]? V5Bg/-,, ?/@, tr
GI3 O/ dI2, D/5,, 8/я OIB 5JI2 MC5] 6/6/B/ ( 8DK[1 5D6/? gkD3K1, 34 `/B
gkD3K1, B/я1D C/8, V/XK C/8, MA]B ,B, p?2 MCD, 3V? gkD3K1, 6n4 LB,
56T4? LB) 8D/i V/Il h/Ic। M,u я56C/B, M,u D/ g/,B , YD/B ,/I-/
,/VIZB V/JZ1 6/X/2 M,uD/ D19\8 l/,/3। Y6/B Mg/I] яI-B L/B/ YB 64I]
MD84IB/ ,/n/ , Y6/I,o 8/яI3 GID , M8 e, 5DA/- YDC/B। 35ZO5Z ,IB
,/5- W4 5- 6/5]I2 e, 64, D5LB 59]/5B g5BItB 8e5f MG/- YB Y56 o Bm6Iv
9H56f G-/6 । Y6/I, DhD/B MD/W/I?/ GI25N-, Dg/i 6/6/ (5D6/? gkD3K1)
Y6/I, V/ 5CI2 MI-, M9/я/5- 5CI2 M6IB M-ID, -/- -/i@ VZID, Y56 tI2
g-ID ।
tL4 @/,/ YB 5DN/?/2 6IL. 81563 ?2 (g-ID
g-ID...)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Dialogue
Geeta Chhabra
Mumbai, India
Autumn.
It is the golden season of notes –
With a learned voice.
Autumn.
It returns to me –
Like an ascetic yogi,
To reveal the veil of impermanence.
O! Spring.
The bees that lambent.
The swans that glide.
The birds that sing.
Or, the kites that collide.
They do not lambent, glide, sing or collide –
Due to your ingenuity!
They simply follow an orderly, faultless pattern.
Even the late bloomer has a reason
To be late in blooming!
Your hysteria chains you to ignorance.
Ungoverned, you claim to be at par with:
The Vault of Heaven!
Banish such thoughts to learn from your sibling.
Ah! Autumn.
It is the golden season of notes –
With a learned voice.
Ah! Autumn.
It returns to me –
Like an ascetic yogi,
To reveal the veil of impermanence.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~
1. Air temperatures over land are 2. Air temperatures over oceans are
increasing increasing
Source:
• https://www.climaterealityproject.org/blog/10-indicators
indicators-that-show-
climate-change