Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
An Undergraduate Thesis
Presented to
The Faculty of the Senior High School Department
Philippine Christian University
City of Dasmariñas, Cavite
In Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements in Research Project
Submitted by:
Brobo, Lyca Jane S.
Cifra, Joshua Ace D.
Gubalane, Ronaline C.
Lansang, Katrina Andrea C.
Lising, Julia Rebecca G.
Lomatao, Ralph B.
Lopez, Jennifer M.
Martin, Krisha B.
Padua, Cindy P.
Submitted to:
Reyes, Maurene Regine A.
June 2019
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
APPROVAL SHEET
Research Teacher
ii
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
Immeasurable appreciation and deepest gratitude for the help and support are
extended to the following persons who in one way or another have contributed in
making this study possible.
Mr. Justine Mar Mina, research coordinator, for his suggestions, provisions,
valuable comments and for the approval to conduct this study.
Ms. Maurene Regine Reyes, research teacher, for the continuous support to
our study and research, for her patience, motivation, enthusiasm, and immense
knowledge. Her guidance helps us all the time of research and writing of this thesis. We
could not have imagined having a better advisor and mentor for our research study.
Ma’am Ahvigaile Alfonso, Sir Ahjong Susana, and Sir Ronald Barredo, our
panellists, who really help us to improve our research and get the necessary information
we need to make our study more reliable and beneficial.
Mr. and Mrs. Victor Lopez Jr., parents of Jennifer Lopez, for letting their
home open for us everytime we need a place to stay overnight.
iii
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Lastly, to Jesus Christ, our Lord and Savior, for giving the wisdom, strength,
support and knowledge in exploring things, for the guidance in helping surpass all the
trials that we encountered and for giving determination to pursue our study, and to
make this study possible.
iv
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
ABSTRACT
The research is conducted to understand the reason behind the occurrence of the
said phenomenon and to provide the survey itself with accurate data. This is important
to the shuttle drivers and to other beneficiaries for them to know and to have an idea on
how the shuttle drivers manages to allocate their profit and if it is enough for their
weekly expenses.
The primary data gathered and interpreted throughout the research study came
from the shuttle drivers which are located under the premises of Philippine Christian
University - Dasmarinas Campus. And a total of 15 respondents were selected through
the convenience sampling technique.
The findings indicated that the weekly expenses, household expenses and
operating expenses, affects the sufficiency of profit of the shuttle drivers. The results
shows that their profit is enough and most of the drivers described it as "sakto lang" for
their daily lives.
v
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TITLE ………………………………………………………………………... i
ABSTRACT …………………………………………………………………….. v
CHAPTERS
I. INTRODUCTION
vi
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Synthesis ……...……………………………………………………………. 13
Research Locale…………………………………………………………… 17
Instrumentation ……………………………………………………………. 18
vii
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Conclusions ….……………………………………….…………………... 44
Recommendation …………………………………………………………. 46
BIBLIOGRAPHY ……………………………………………..……………….. 48
APPENDICES ………………………………………………………………….. 50
viii
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Gubalane, Ronaline C.
Lomatao, Ralph B.
Lopez, Jennifer M.
Martin, Krisha B.
Padua, Cindy P.
June 2019
viii
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
Students’ perspectives about commuting come along the way. Some of them
find riding a public transport a convenient way going to school, while, the other
students find private service a way more beneficial prior to the risks offered by the
public transport. More likely, universities have the responsibility to maintain the
safeness of each student. Universities are not left out in the provision of transport
services on campus for the students. Many universities are not taking the lead to
identify and develop strategies that help to sustain the quality of campus life (Toor and
Havlick, 2004) in terms of students commuting. Due to this, most of the universities
provide a shuttle service that helps the students to be more comfortable in commuting
safely. As universities continue to experience growth in student’s population,
automobile usage will continue to rise, (Juarez. 2011). Shuttle service is also a helpful
way to eliminate the risk factors that the students might encounter in commuting.
1
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
The qualifications for hiring a shuttle driver in the Philippines are a bit easy. The
driver should have at least a secondary educational attainment and especially, to have
special driving skills (CollegeGrad, 2019). Hence, the drivers also have special needs
to support other members of the family. According to Schwartz (2012), most of the
drivers have their own families to support and have different expenses in their lives. It
includes the basic needs (clothes, shelter, utilities, food, education, and health care)
and wants (expensive things or any out of the budget for household necessities) of
each member of the family.
The study will be conducted by the researchers; to know if the PCU shuttle
drivers have sufficient profit to sustain their expenses. The study also aims to know
the average profit earned by the shuttle drivers in their weekly services.
According to Patel (2011), you do not need a lot of money just to live
comfortably and know how to budget. In this way, the profit earned by the shuttle
drivers will have a capability to be sufficient for the weekly expenses. The initial study
concludes all the expenses covered by the PCU shuttle drivers and their family,
expenses for the automobile usage and other necessities to prolong the shuttle service
itself, will also include to the study.
2
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Since the study will look on different factors that may affect the budgeting of
PCU shuttle drivers’ profit earned on their weekly services. The research stated the
allocation of profit earned by the PCU shuttle drivers on their weekly services; as a
result, it will have a high possibility to recognize the sustainability of the family
members and their current status.
This study would like to answer the question on how much the drivers earn in
their weekly services. The study would also like to find out the sufficiency of profit by
the PCU shuttle drivers and how they allocate their profit.
3
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
1. How does the PCU shuttle drivers allocate their profit to their expenses in terms
of:
A. Household Expenses such as
1. food;
2. allowance;
3. leisure time.
B. Operating Expenses such as
1. fuel;
2. maintenance and repair.
2. Is their profit enough for their weekly expenses?
3. Does no. of supported family members affect the sufficiency of profit of the
PCU shuttle drivers?
4
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Shuttle Drivers – The findings of this study will help the shuttle drivers to gain
some knowledge on how the other drivers allocate their profit for their daily
expenses.
Commuters - This study will help the commuters to have knowledge and
support for the shuttle drivers since they are the one who gives income to the
shuttle drivers. Aside from that, they can also gain knowledge on where the
shuttle drivers allocate their profit in terms of their expenses.
Family of the Shuttle Drivers – This will help the family of the shuttle drivers
to acquire knowledge on how the shuttle drivers allocate their profit for their
weekly expenses. With this study, the family members may urge them to find
another source of income that will help the shuttle drivers in budgeting their
profit for their weekly expenses.
Educational Institutes – This study will contribute academic institutions that
have or provide shuttles for their students. With this study, educational institutes
will gain knowledge and will be informed on the sufficiency of the profit among
the shuttle drivers.
PCU Shuttle Operators – This study will benefit the PCU shuttle operators
since their shuttle drivers are the respondents. The PCU shuttle operators may
think of another strategy or may adjust their management for more sufficient
profit among their shuttle drivers.
Future Researchers – This study will help the future researchers to acquire the
general knowledge with relation to the topic. This study will also serve as a
reference to develop research studies related in this topic.
5
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
The principal objective of this study is to know if the profit earned by the PCU
shuttle drivers is sufficient for their weekly expenses. This study will also talk about
how they budgeted their profit in their daily circumstances.
This study includes the different expenses of the shuttle drivers in their daily
lives. This study covers their household expenses as well as their operating expenses.
Expenses for the food, allowance and leisure time are included in household expenses
while expenses for the fuels and maintenance and repair are included in operating
expenses. Moreover, although utilities expenses such as house rent, electric bill and
water bill are part of the household expenses, the researchers excluded it on this study,
knowing that utilities are usually paid monthly, therefore considering it as monthly
expenses and not weekly expenses. This study also shows the profit earned by the
PCU shuttle drivers in their weekday’s services. On the other hand, the profit earned
from the other source of their income is excluded in this study. Furthermore, this study
is only applicable for the PCU shuttle drivers and any shuttle drivers’ services from
the other schools and universities are excluded. However, this only covers the
authorized shuttle drivers of Philippine Christian University- Dasmariñas Campus.
6
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
CHAPTER 2
THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
7
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
8
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
In order to operate shuttle services, we need someone who are highly trained,
tested, and scrutinized person on the road, the drivers. Shuttle drivers are tasked with
the vital responsibility of protecting students on their way to and from school (Mclane,
2016).
“School bus drivers make an impact. We are the first ones students see in the
morning and the last ones they see in the afternoon. My job is to safely transport
students on a daily basis to and from school and I make a difference.” – Burke (2015).
9
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
$25,000 per annum in California and Alaska. Bigger salary disparities existed within
the South, as drivers attained a low of $17,000 in Mississippi and a high of $35,000
annually within the District of Columbia. In the Midwest, shuttle drivers created
$17,000 and $24,000 per annum, severally, in South Dakota and Minnesota that
described the low and high end. And average salaries ranged from $20,000 to $27,000
within the Northeast region -- with Maine representing the low end and Massachusetts
the high (Suttle, 2014). However, Philippine rates are much lower than the U.S.A. The
researchers interviewed some shuttle drivers to know about their profit, since there are
no local profit references about the shuttle drivers in the internet. They interviewed
two drivers where one of them has a fixed profit, while the other one varies on the
daily fare of his passengers. According to Henry Lunar (2019), a fixed profit shuttle
driver from Imus, Cavite; “₱800 po ang bayad ng bawat estudyante na nagpapa
service sa’kin. Meron po akong 15 na estudyanteng inihahatid sundo araw-araw.
Kumikita po ako ng higit kumulang ₱12,000 sa isang buwan”. Meanwhile, the other
one is a tricycle service driver from Dasmariñas, Cavite, Rolando Cebrero (2019). His
passengers are mostly from St. Jude of Dasmariñas and Technological University of
the Philippines-Cavite. Cebrero (2019) stated that he earns ₱600-₱800 per day.
According to him, his passengers pay him ₱10 per head, and ₱25 if special or alone.
Both might have a minimum profit job, but it involves a lot of responsibilities
(Gonzalez, 2013).
When it comes to cost of living in the Philippines, it is 52.54% lower than the
U.S.A. (Numbeo, 2013). With the shuttle drivers' minimum profit, it is not impossible
for them to have difficulties in budgeting their profit. For average Filipinos' cost of
living, Market leads the chart with 38%. followed by House Rent per month in 18%.
Next is Transportation (15%), Restaurants (10%) and Utilities with 9%.
10
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Then Sports & Leisure with 6% and the least is Clothing and Shoes with 4%.
But for the shuttle drivers, they have this ‘Vehicle Cost’ that indicates the
savings that result from the reduced ownership and use. It can be divided into two:
Fixed Cost and Variable Cost. The Fixed Cost, also called ownership or time-based,
which are unaffected by the amount a vehicle is driven. Included here are the vehicle
purchase or lease, insurance, registration and vehicle taxes. While in Variable Cost,
also called operating, marginal or incremental, which increase with vehicle mileage. In
Variable Cost is maintenance and repair, fuel and fuel taxes, and paid parking or tolls.
(Victoria Transport Policy Institute, 2017).
The portion of family shares falling below family budget thresholds but the total
number of affected individuals – parents and children. This geographic dimension of
family budget measurements offers a comparative advantage over the use of poverty
11
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
thresholds which in their measurements only use a national baseline. Furthermore, the
average household size in Philippines in 2018 is 4.4 people per household and the total
households are calculated by dividing the household population, (Bauer, 2018).
Therefore, the sufficiency of profit may depend on the number of family members to
support.
12
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
SYNTHESIS
The findings from this review reveal the sufficiency of profit among the shuttle
drivers in Philippine Christian University- Dasmariñas Campus on their weekday’s
services. Citing positive effects for their argument, these authors put a premium that
will support the profitability of the shuttle drivers for their weekly expenses. However,
according to Malasig (2018), the weekly expenses for the shuttle drivers are divided
into different categories, the wants and need of their family and for the vehicle itself,
resulting for not being sufficient for their weekly expenses.
A local study conducted by the Manila Times (2017), about 70% of the
population of the Philippines, do not own a car. However, due to widely dispersed
islands and the poor government financial investment in the countries’ infrastructure,
transport system in the Philippines is under developing.
Public transport offer convenience to people without a car and is much cheaper
than private cars. Nevertheless, public transfers give passengers no assurance when it
comes to their safety and it does not match people’ schedules because they have no
control over public transport times. Shuttle drivers are responsible for transporting the
students to and from their school. They ensure that the students are safe as they are the
students who see in the morning and in the afternoon. Campus universities take the
lead in pursuing the safety of students in terms of travel, so that they can get home
safely (Kaufman, 2017). The researchers see this as an opportunity to determine the
rising number of students who choose private transport rather than public
transportation when going to school.
With the information the researchers have gathered, a study will be conducted to
seek information if the profit of the PCU shuttle drivers is sufficient for their weekly
expenses that includes their basic needs such as food, shelter, clothing, utilities,
13
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
education, fuel, maintenance and repair and their other necessities. Furthermore, the
study will test the validity and reliability of the presentation stated by Elliot (2013)
and Allegretto (2009), which is a presupposition, in a natural setting with same
population.
14
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
Profit of PCU
-
Shuttle Drivers
The allocation of profit of the PCU Shuttle Drivers can be divided into two
expenses, the household expenses and operating expenses. Under household expenses
are food, allowance and leisure time while under operating expenses are fuel and
maintenance and repair.
15
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
DEFINITION OF VARIABLES
16
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
CHAPTER 3
METHODOLOGY
RESEARCH DESIGN
RESEARCH LOCALE
For this study, the researchers chose the current shuttle drivers from Philippine
Christian University – Dasmariñas Campus as their official respondents. The
researchers chose 15 respondents out of the 24 shuttle drivers as some do not want to
be interviewed. The researchers used a non-probability, convenience
17
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
INTSTRUMENTATION
The questionnaire is a 3-page questionnaire and is divided into two parts: the
demographic profile and the survey questionnaire. Demographic profile is consists of
their names, age, civil status, no. of the family members they support and no. of their
children. Name and age is optional as some of the respondents do not want to give
their names and age. Prior to this, the researchers attached the consent form for the
respondents as a basis that they are really agreeing into this study. The researchers
also assure the respondents that all personal information will be kept confidentially.
While the survey questionnaire part is composed of 20 questions with different
choices such as yes and no, ranges of money they either earned or expended, hours
they have to work, ranking of their priorities when it comes to spending and options
such as Always, Sometimes, Often and Never. The questions are conceptualized based
on the statement of the purpose and need of this study. To indicate their answer, they
must place a check mark on their chosen answer and must complete the demographic
profile by checking and filling up the space provided for their answers.
18
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
As the researchers conducted this study, they conceptualized questions that are
in line with their topic and on what they need to know base on their statement of
purpose. Then the researchers wrote for an approval letter as well as the permission
letter for the respondents to let them conduct a research regarding with this study.
Upon the approval of the adviser and respondents, they reproduced copies of the
questionnaire and start to interview some Philippine Christian University- Dasmariñas
Campus shuttle drivers as well as answering the questionnaire. The researchers find it
hard to interview shuttle drivers as some of them do not want to be interviewed.
Knowing that there are 24 drivers, the researchers only choose 20 as the respondents
yet some still do not want to be interviewed. That’s why from 20 respondents, the
researcher broke it down into 15 respondents. Upon having the problem, the
researchers still focus on deepening their knowledge on the understanding of this
study. Moreover, after conducting survey, the researchers get the tally of the answers
produced by the shuttle drivers and analyze it. And after interpreting data, he
researchers assure that all data gathered are all factual and unbiased.
19
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
While the questions regarding to the number of hours they have to work and to
the money they spend for the expenses, either household or operating expenses,
weekly, the researchers used a chi square statistical treatment. This is to know if the
said expenses can affect or not the sufficiency of profit of the shuttle drivers. To know
if what hypothesis should be accepted, the researchers applied the rule of chi-square;
Moreover, the researchers used bar graphs to illustrate the ranking of priorities
and the difference of lengths or frequency between the variables. Furthermore, the
researchers also used interview as their instrument to gather more information and to
deepen their knowledge about this study. Lastly, the researchers used weighted mean to
get the average no. of family members of the drivers. To get the weighted mean:
20
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
CHAPTER 4
2
4
7
4
3
3
2
2
6
5
5
2
4
1
5
55
21
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
FREQUENCY OF TALLY
QUESTIONS YES NO
YES NO
22
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
For no. 16, since the researchers wants to know the most priority and the least
priority of respondents among the variables, the researchers use bar graph to present
the tally of variables.
23
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
16. Rank your priority when it comes to spending in the following: (1 as the highest and 5 as
the lowest)
14
12
FOOD
10
ALLOWANCE
8
6 LEISURE
4 FUELS
2 MAINTENANCE AND
0 REPAIR
1 2 3 4 5
YES NO
24
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
2
4
7
4
3
3
2
2
6
5
5
2
4
1
5
55
Solution: n=15
x̅ = 55/15
x̅ = 3.67 or 4
25
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
YES NO
Solution: n=15
=87% =13%
Interpretation: 87% of respondents are a full-time driver, while the other 13% are a
non-full-time driver.
YES NO
Solution: n=15
=67% =33%
26
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Interpretation: 67% of the respondents are the owner of their vehicles while the
remaining respondents do not own the vehicle they’re driving.
Solution: n= 15
=27% =20%
=33% =20%
YES NO
Solution: n= 15
27
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Interpretation: 47% of the respondents answered yes that they build a little
discretionary spending on their budget while the remaining 53% answered no.
YES NO
Solution: n= 15
=73% =27%
Interpretation: 73% of the respondents answered yes that they put a little bit of
money for maintenance and repair and the remaining 27% respondents answered no.
28
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
YES NO
Solution: n= 15
=67% =33%
Interpretation: 67% of the drivers’ over-estimate purchase to ensure that they have
enough money, while 33% of the drivers answered no.
YES NO
Solution: n= 15
29
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
YES NO
Solution: n= 15
=53% =47%
Interpretation: 47% of the drivers responded that they do not have any work aside
from being a shuttle driver, while the 53% of the drivers responded yes, they do have
work aside from being a shuttle driver.
YES NO
Solution: n= 15
=67% =33%
Interpretation: 67% of the drivers agreed that they find it difficult to manage their
weekly expenses while only 33% disagree.
30
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Solution: n= 15
TOTAL 15 9.54
H0- The numbers of hours of work does not affect the profit of the drivers that they
could spend for their weekly expenses.
Hi- The numbers of hours of work do affect the profit of the drivers that they could
spend for their weekly expenses.
31
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Solution: n= 15
600-1000 1 3 -2 4 1.33
1000-1500 5 3 2 4 1.33
1500-2000 2 3 -1 1 0.33
2000-above 7 3 4 16 5.33
TOTAL 15 11.32
H0- The expenses on food does not affect the sufficiency of profit of the drivers.
Hi- The expenses on food does affect the sufficiency of profit of the drivers.
32
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Solution: n= 15
TOTAL 15 11.8
H0- The expenses on fuel does not affect the sufficiency of profit of the drivers.
Hi- The expenses on fuel does affect the sufficiency of profit of the drivers.
33
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Solution: n= 15
H0- The expenses in allowance does not affect the sufficiency of profit of drivers.
Hi- The expenses in allowance does affect the sufficiency of profit of drivers.
34
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Solution: n= 15
Amount for O E O- O- 𝐎 − 𝐄𝟐
leisure time E E2 𝑬
100-400 1 2.5 - 0.25 0.1
0.5
400-600 3 2.5 0.5 0.25 0.1
H0- The expenses in leisure time does not affect the sufficiency of profit of drivers.
Hi- The expenses in leisure time does affect the sufficiency of profit of drivers.
χ2= 1.4 df= 6-1 CV= 9.236
=5
Interpretation: The expenses in leisure time do not affect the sufficiency of profit of
drivers. Reject Hi
35
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
15. Where 12 2 0 1 0
does most
of your
profit go?
Solution: n= 15
Interpretation: Majority of the respondents goes their profit to food. 7% is for fuel and
the remaining 13% goes to allowance.
36
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
16. Rank your priority when it comes to spending in the following: (1 as the
highest and 5 as the lowest)
14
FOOD
12
10 ALLOWANCE
8
LEISURE
6
4 FUELS
2
MAINTENANCE AND
0 REPAIR
1 2 3 4 5
Interpretation: The most priority of the respondents is food while the least priority is
maintenance and repair.
Solution: n= 15
37
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Interpretation: 73% of the respondents tries to save money always while the
remaining respondents didn’t try to save money. According to the drivers, they never
try to save money because their profit is only exact for their expenses.
Solution: n= 15
4.5
4
3.5
3
2.5
2 4
1.5 3
1 2
0.5 1 1
0 0
100-400 400-600 600-1000 1000-1500 1500-2000 2000-above
Interpretation: Since 4 respondents says never on saving money, only 11 out of the
15 respondents answer’s no. 17 question. 4 respondents answer 1000-1500 pesos of
money they can save weekly, 3 answer 2000 and above, 2 answer 600-1000 pesos and
1 answer 100-400 pesos and 1500-2000 pesos.
38
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
YES NO
Solution: n= 15
For Yes, For No,
=60% =40%
Interpretation: 60% of the respondents say their profit is enough for their weekly
expenses while 40% says it is not enough in their weekly expenses. Some says it is
only “sapat lang” for their weekly expenses.
YES NO
Solution: n= 15
For No,
= 15/15 x 100%
=1 x 100%
= 100%
Interpretation: All of the respondents say that the university didn’t provide any
benefits for them.
39
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
ANALYSIS
67% of the PCU- D Shuttle Drivers find it difficult to manage their weekly
expenses. Most of them earn P3000-P5000 weekly, are full time drivers, the owners of
the vehicles they drive, and spend 10-15 hours driving weekly. Also more than half of
them has work aside from being a shuttle driver yet, it is just enough for their weekly
expenses. The respondents divide their weekly expense into two: Household Expense
and Operating Expenses. These expenses are budgeted by their profit according to
their weekly needs.
Most of the drivers have food as their top priority on their list. According to
the results, most of them spend P2, 000 and above for their food weekly. This does
affect the sufficiency of profit among these drivers, as all of them have family
members to support. Next on their list is the Allowance, where 13% of their profit
goes. Here includes the weekly allowance of their children. Most of them spend
P1000-P1500 and P2000 above weekly for their allowance. Yet, it do not affect the
sufficiency of their profit as some of them still have kids and one of them do not have
a child yet. The leisure time of their family comes fourth on the ranking of priority.
The researchers also found out that leisure time do not affect the sufficiency of their
profit as it is one of their least priorities.
While their Operating Expense which includes their fuel and maintenance and
repair. Fuel ranks no. 3 on their priority. 10 out of 15 of the respondents spend P1000-
1500 and P2000 above on their fuel. It does affect the sufficiency of their profit, as it
is part of their variable cost as a shuttle driver. And last on their priority, is
Maintenance and Repair. These are the expenses for a product to keep it in good
condition (Chen, 2018). Here lies their engine check-up, car wash, and other repairs
for their vehicle.
40
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
While 90% of the respondents have children on their own, all of the drivers
have family members to support, with 4 members in average. According to Bauer
(2018), the average household size in the Philippines is 4.4 in year 2018. With that, the
numbers of family members affect the sufficiency of profit among the drivers.
Some of the respondents described their weekly profit as “sakto lang” when
asked if their profit is enough for their expenses. Although most of them always try to
save money, there’s no assurance that their savings can last and can be used for
investing. Also, the university itself does not provide any benefits to the shuttle
drivers.
41
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
CHAPTER 5
The researchers used the arguments of Elliot (2013) and Allegretto (2009).
Where Elliot stated that, "Costs of living depend so much on what the residents
themselves have in terms of income". Unlike company shuttle drivers, the school
shuttle drivers can only have profit during school days thus they find another source of
income (Gonzales, 2013). Shuttle drivers earned with the minimum wage and still
42
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
have other work requirements that need payment. Sufficiency of profit weekly is
needed as a worker (Elliot, 2013). While the second argument, where “Basic family
budget measurements are adjustable by family type because expenses vary
considerably depending on the number of children in a family and whether or not a
family is headed by a single parent or a married couple”, was stated by Allegretto
(2009). Here, regardless of their civil status their budget in a family will adjust on the
children and other family members that need support from the respondents.
The study is a quantitative research, where the researchers gathered data through
non-probability convenience sampling technique. It is a descriptive research that used
four statistical treatments; the Weighted Mean, Bar Graph, Chi-Square, and
Percentage Frequency Distribution.
By this study, the researchers found out that most of them are full-time drivers
and have other source of income. Though most of them have profit that ranges from
P3, 000-P5 ,000, higher than the minimum wage of Dasmariñas, Cavite; it is just
enough for their weekly expenses. Under Household Expenses are food, allowance,
and leisure time. Base on the findings, food do affect the sufficiency of profit of the
PCU shuttle drivers while allowance and leisure time do not because some might not
have a child or they are still kids. Therefore, allowance for their children is still small
enough to affect the sufficiency of their profit. Under Operating Expenses are fuel and
maintenance and repair. The researchers also find out that expenses in fuel might
affect the sufficiency of their profit as it was one of their fixed expenses. Also the
researchers found out that they prioritize food the most as 100% of them have family
members to support and 93% have children. While Maintenance and Repair as their
least on their priority due to them spends for this almost once a week only.
43
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
This study also stated that their number of family members that they support
through their profit in shuttle driving affects the sufficiency of it. With an average of 4
members supported through the profit of shuttle drivers. Overall, their weekly
expenses cover most of their basic needs, as their leisure time does not affect the
sufficiency of their profit.
CONCLUSION
Upon conducting interviews and surveys, as well as analyzing and interpreting the
given data, the researchers concluded that the weekly profit of the PCU shuttle drivers
is enough on their weekly expenses. Although some of the drivers said it was just
enough for their basic needs and some cannot save money due to insufficiency of
profit, they still manage to purchase their basic needs. This proves the statement said
by Elliot (2013), “Cost of living depends so much on what the residents themselves
have in terms of income”. Furthermore, the researchers intended to solve these
following questions:
1. How does the PCU shuttle drivers allocate their profit to their expenses in terms
of:
A. Household Expenses such as
1. food;
2. allowance;
3. leisure time.
B. Operating expenses such as
1. fuel;
2. maintenance and repair.
44
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
As solving these questions, the researchers find out that the PCU shuttle drivers
finds it hard to allocate or manage their profit to their expenses. The researchers also
find out that expense in the leisure time and allowances on their children, do not
affect the sufficiency of their profit. However, food and fuel affects the sufficiency
of profit of the shuttle drivers. In addition, the researchers figure out that most of the
profit of the shuttle drivers goes to food expenses as well as the respondents find
food as the most priority expenses to all. Moreover, the researchers find out that the
no. of family members affects the sufficiency of profit as most of the drivers have a
family to support. Therefore the researchers concluded that the said findings proves
the statement stated by Allegretto (2009) that the “Basic family budget
measurements are adjustable by family type because expenses vary considerably
depending on the number of children in a family and whether or not a family is
headed by a single parent or a married couple”. According to the findings of this
study, the allowance on their children do not affect the sufficiency of income of the
shuttle drivers because some doesn’t have a child as well as some has but still kids
and did not have that big expenses that can affect their profit. Therefore, the
budgeting of profit varies on the number of children as well as the number of family
members the shuttle drivers’ supported.
45
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
RECOMMENDATION
This part of the study discusses the suggested recommendations of the study
based on the findings or the results of the data that was gathered, analyzed, interpreted
and presented. The findings of the study suggest how the profit of the shuttle drivers
has an effect to their weekly expenses. The recommendations of the study to the
beneficiaries that were mentioned in the significance of the study are:
To the Shuttle Drivers - the results suggested that the shuttle drivers should have a
fixed list of passengers since it is hard to have regular passengers due to the
competition between the shuttle drivers and the local drivers outside the university.
To their family members - the researchers suggests that the family should have a
proper budgeting plan and since the number of supported family members can affect
the sufficiency of profit of the shuttle drivers, the researchers also come up to the idea
that they should have a family planning.
46
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
To the Commuters - considering the fact that the shuttle drivers earns a low amount
of income on their weekdays services, the researchers suggests that commuters should
be honest on paying and support them even more.
To the Future researchers - this study will serve as a reference in making another
research related to this topic. The researchers recommend them to look at another or
different perspective to add new results or findings and to further develop or fill the
gaps of this study.
47
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Gonzales, S. (2013). Being A School Bus Driver Can Be Minimum Wage Work With Big
Responsibilities. Retrieved from https://stateimpact.npr.org/florida/2013/01/23/being-
a-school-bus-driver-can-be-minimum-wage-work-with-big-responsibilities/
48
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Schwartz, E. (2017). Super Shuttle Drivers Say They Face Tough Times Under Firm’s
Franchise System.Retrieved from
https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/supershuttle-drivers-say-they-face-tough-
times-under-firms-franchise-
system/2012/04/19/gIQAFbp9VT_story.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.40b51227e
278
Smith, K. (n.d). Hotels Driving Bottom Line Profits by Outsourcing Hotel Shuttle
Services.Retrieved from https://kevinsmithgroup.com/hotels-driving-bottom-line-
profits-outsourcing-hotel-shuttle-services/amp/?__twitter_impression=true
Suttle, R. (2014). How Much Should a Shuttle Driver Get Paid?. Retrieved from
https://work.chron.com/much-should-shuttle-driver-paid-19003.html
Toor, W. and Havlick, S. (2004). Transportation and Sustainable Campus Communities:
Issues, Examples, Solutions. Retrieved from
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/248452764_Transportation_and_Sustainabl
e_Campus_Communities_Issues_Examples_Solutions_Will_Toor_and_Spenser_W_
Havlick
Victoria Transport Policy Institute, (2017). Transportation Cost and Benefit Analysis II
– Vehicle Costs. Retrieved from https://t.co/jaCC8gOAWK
49
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
APPENDICES
50
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
APPENDIX 1
VALIDATION LETTER
51
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
A pleasant day!
We, the researchers from ABM 12 D – Ethiopia is presently proposing a study entitled,
“The Allocation of Profit Among Philippine Christian University Shuttle Drivers
on their Weekdays Services”. We would like to seek your permission to allow us to
conduct a research and interview 20 shuttle drivers of Philippine Christian University-
Dasmariñas Campus pertaining to our study that enables us to answer the main object
which is, “to know if the profit of PCU Shuttle Drivers is sufficient for their weekly
expenses on their weekdays services”. Rest assured that all the data gathered will be
strictly for research purposes only and will be kept confidential.
We are hoping for your kind consideration. Thank you and God bless!
Respectfuly yours,
The Researchers
Noted by:
Ms. Maurene Regine A. Reyes
Approved by:
Mr. Justine Mar Mina
52
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
APPENDIX 2
SURVEY QUESTIONNAIRE
53
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
Please complete the following demographic information. Note that all personal
information will be kept completely confidential and none of the responses you provide
will be connected to your name, civil status, or other identifying information.
Please indicate your answer with each of the questions regarding about our study.
Place a check mark (✓) on the choice of your answer.
QUESTIONS YES NO
54
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
5. Do you put a little bit of money aside for maintenance and repair?
10. How many hours do you have to work to pay for your weekly ___10 - 15
expenses? ___15 - 20
___20 - 25
___25hrs. and
above
11. How much money do you spend for food every week? ___P400 – P600
___P600 – P1000
___P1000 – P1500
___P1500 – P2000
___P2000 and
above
12. How much do you spend for fuel every week? ___P100 – P400
___P400 – P600
___P600 – P1000
___P1000 – P1500
___P1500 – P2000
13. If you have, how much do you spend for your children weekly ___P100 – P400
___P400 – P600
(allowances, transportation, etc.)?
P600 – P1000
___P1000 – P1500
___P1500 – P2000
55
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
14. How much money do you spend for your leisure time? ___P100 – P400
___P400 – P600
___P600 – P1000
___P1000 – P1500
___P1500 – P2000
15. Where does most of your profit go? ___Food
___Allowance
___Utilities
___Fuel
___Maintenance and
Repair
16. Rank your priority when it comes to spending in the ___Food
following: (1 as the highest and 5 as the lowest). ___Allowance
___Utilities
___Fuel
___Maintenance and
Repair
17. Do you always try to save money? ___Always
___Often
___Sometimes
___Never
18. If so, how much can you actually save weekly? ___P100 – P400
___P400 – P600
___P600 – P1000
___P1000 – P1500
___P1500 – P2000
___P2000 and above
YES NO
19. Is your profit enough for your weekly expenses?
20. Does the university provide benefits for you?
56
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
APPENDIX 3
CURRICULUM VITAE
57
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
(A.B.M.)
Section: 12 D – Ethiopia
E-mail Address:
Contact Number:
PERSONAL DETAILS
Age: 17
Sex: Female
Nationality: Filipino
Home Address: Blk 20 L9, Parklane Subdivision, Brgy. Santiago, Gen. Trias, Cavite
58
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
(A.B.M.)
Section: 12 D – Ethiopia
PERSONAL DETAILS
Age: 22
Sex: Male
Nationality: Filipino
Home Address: Blk 23 L14 Brgy. San Antonio De Padua 2, Dasmariñas City, Cavite
59
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
(A.B.M.)
Section: 12 D – Ethiopia
PERSONAL DETAILS
Age: 18
Sex: Female
Nationality: Filipino
Home Address: Blk 58 L17, Brgy. Sto. Cristo, Dasmariñas City, Cavite
60
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
(A.B.M.)
Section: 12 D – Ethiopia
PERSONAL DETAILS
Age: 19
Sex: Female
Nationality: Filipino
Home Address: Blk 139 L3, Mary Cris Complex, General Trias, Cavite
61
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
(A.B.M.)
Section: 12 D – Ethiopia
PERSONAL DETAILS
Age: 18
Sex: Female
Nationality: Filipino
Home Address: Blk 9 L23, Washington Place, Brgy. Sampaloc, Dasmariñas, Cavite
62
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
(A.B.M.)
Section: 12 D – Ethiopia
E-mail Address:
Contact Number:
PERSONAL DETAILS
Age: 18
Sex: Male
Nationality: Filipino
Home Address: Blk 17 L48, Brgy. Malagasang 1-G, Imus City, Cavite
63
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
(A.B.M.)
Section: 12 D – Ethiopia
PERSONAL DETAILS
Age: 18
Sex: Female
Nationality: Filipino
64
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
(A.B.M.)
Section: 12 D – Ethiopia
E-mail Address:
Contact Number:
PERSONAL DETAILS
Age: 18
Sex: Female
Nationality: Filipino
65
Philippine Christian University
SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL DEPARTMENT
Dasmariñas Campus
(A.B.M.)
Section: 12 D – Ethiopia
E-mail Address:
Contact Number:
PERSONAL DETAILS
Age: 19
Sex: Female
Nationality: Filipino
66