Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
3-INCH (STN)
$
161. 00
EA1-S3MLW-N
10-INCH (TFT)
4-INCH (TFT)
$
899. 00
$
356. 00 EA3-T10CL
EA1-T4CL
8-INCH (TFT)
$
749. 00
6-INCH (TFT) EA3-T8CL
$
299. 00
EA3-T6CL
I NSIDE
and equipment on the wellpad are interconnected, talking to each
other, and relaying real-time information back to the control room.
Image courtesy: ABB
06 DEVELOPMENTS TO WATCH
Cyclone separators
Real-time 3D printing enhances the viability of using cyclone separators in oil and gas applications.
07 COVER STORY
Integrated HMI/SCADA systems enable smarter data acquisition 07
Open platform development tools enable more effective, affordable approaches to SCADA.
19 REGULATORY MEASURES
Electric actuator technology prospers in production fields
President Obama’s Climate Action Plan has a goal to cut methane emissions from the oil and gas industry by 40% to
45% from 2012 levels by 2025. This has led to new regulations that require widescale pump retrofitting.
26 WORKPLACE SAFETY
De-risk by design: Maintaining safety at heights
A major challenge facing oil and gas facilities is inadequate lighting and the need for workers to climb
to elevated heights to repair or replace lights.
28 NEW PRODUCTS
A selection of oil- and gas-related products engineers will find useful
ERIC R. EISSLER
PUBLICATION SERVICES
JIM LANGHENRY, Co-Founder & Publisher EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
630-571-4070 x2203, JLanghenry@CFEMedia.com
STEVE ROURKE, Co-Founder
630-571-4070 x2204, SRourke@CFEMedia.com
TRUDY KELLY, Executive Assistant
630-571-4070 x2205, TKelly@CFEMedia.com
2015 in review
AMANDA PELLICCIONE, Director of Research
978-302-3463, APelliccione@CFEMedia.com
ELENA MOELLER-YOUNGER, Marketing Manager
773-815-3795, EMYounger@CFEMedia.com
L
KRISTEN NIMMO, Marketing Manager
630-571-4070 x2215, KNimmo@CFEMedia.com ast year was Oil & Gas Texas, shared his industry insights about
PAUL BROUCH, Director of Operations Engineering’s first year as a print the challenges related to pipeline cleaning.
630-571-4070 x2208, PBrouch@CFEMedia.com
edition. Here are the top five arti-
ERIN DUNNE, Project Coordinator
630-571-4070 x2220, EDunne@CFEMedia.com cles from last year based on data 5. Predictive analytics hit the
JOY CHANG, Digital Project Manager from our partners websites, Control midstream
630-571-4070 x2225, JChang@CFEMedia.com
Engineering and Plant Engineering. Model-based, predictive analytics lends
MICHAEL ROTZ, Print Production Manager
717-766-0211, Fax: 717-506-7238 itself to crunching multiple data sources to
mike.rotz@frycomm.com 1. Hacking oil and gas control pinpoint risks for pipeline integrity manage-
MARIA BARTELL, Account Director, Infogroup Targeting Solutions systems: Understanding the cyber risk ment, while analytics for process monitor-
847-378-2275, maria.bartell@infogroup.com
RICK ELLIS, Oil & Gas Engineering Project Manager,
Cyber attacks are growing in num- ing and measurement evolve to better
Audience Management Director ber and intensity over the past decade. discover crucial variances.
303-246-1250, REllis@CFEMedia.com
Companies in the oil and gas industry are
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
Please e-mail your opinions to BVavra@CFEMedia.com high-profile targets and must take mea- Based on these top five articles from
INFORMATION sures to protect themselves from hackers. 2015, proved to be that cyber security,
For a Media Kit or Editorial Calendar,
e-mail Trudy Kelly at TKelly@CFEMedia.com career development, big data and predic-
REPRINTS 2. Black October on the horizon tive analytics, and pipeline maintenance
For custom reprints or electronic usage, contact:
Brett Petillo, Wright’s Media The price of oil may not have hit the and pigging were the highest ranked
281-419-5725, bpetillo@wrightsmedia.com bottom yet, supply is almost double that topics of the year based on our readers’
MAILING ADDRESS CHANGES of demand, and the Iran deal may slash oil clicks.
Please e-mail your changes to REllis@CFEMedia.com
prices to new lows. We’ll be interested to see what our
readers choose as hot topics for 2016. As
PUBLICATION SALES
3. Thirty years later, the industry is this was our first year, we don’t have any
losing its best and brightest, again previous data to compare to, but you as
JUDY PINSEL, National Sales JPinsel@CFEMedia.com
1111 W. 22nd St., Ste. 250, 847-624-8418 In the 1980s, the oil and gas industry the reader have the power to determine
Oak Brook, IL 60523 Fax 630-214-4504 was going through the same crew change our editorial path based on what you
as it is now. Highly educated workers were read and your feedback.
laid off and the cycle is repeating itself. Will
the industry learn its lesson this time? Wishing you all a great start to a suc-
cessful New Year and, of course saying,
4. Dirty pipelines decrease flow, thank you for reading!
production—pig your line
Allen Pennington, president of Pigs -Eric R. Eissler,
Unlimited International located in Tomball, Editor-in-Chief
With global gas prices dropping rapidly, you can’t afford ongoing monitoring can also help your operators make
to be on the defensive when it comes to downtime. better-informed decisions to improve asset utilization
To keep oil and gas applications up and running at all and boost production.
times, a proactive approach is essential.
The best path to greater productivity is a proven
Siemens automation solutions allow you to automation strategy. And the best defense against
continuously monitor your operations — on-site or downtime is Siemens. Visit usa.siemens.com/oil-gas
remotely — so you can identify potential issues and today to learn more.
correct them quickly. The data gathered through
usa.siemens.com/oil-gas
input #102 at www.controleng.com/information
Advertorial
F
alling oil prices and collapsing profit margins are driving the industry to lower costs any way
possible. While reducing labor costs and gaining supplier concessions can help, output must
continue if not increase, especially on completed wells, to meet commitments to buyers. Some
in the industry may persist in using time-tested manual methods and localized automation, but
the economics of continuing to do so just don’t add up. Nor do they scale, as new drilling and comple-
tion techniques increase service densities along with operating complexities.
The drive to retain (or regain) profitability has never been stronger or more urgent. The fact is, oil and
gas industry professionals – especially those involved in asset management, automation and controls,
and production, transmission or plant management – can accelerate the development and deployment of
technology solutions to lower the breakeven points of their operations. This paper provides ways to think
about how automation can increase operating efficiency, visibility and reliability to help lower costs and
boost profitability.
The paper also highlights four automation design principles that can help oil and gas companies acceler-
ate putting more automation to work in their operations or those of their industry customers:
• Eliminate
• Simplify
• Standardize
• Virtualize
As oil and gas industry veterans know, the current downturn may be painful, but prices will rebound. In
the meantime, highly leveraged or undercapitalized companies may close or consolidate with larger, better-
capitalized firms. But when the rebound occurs, the capital
investments made today by companies willing to carefully
consider and deploy automation solutions will still be generat- Check out usa.siemens.com/oilgas-
ing substantial returns through greater operational efficiency, resources for more Oil & Gas White
visibility and reliability. For those companies, their competitive- Papers on:
ness and profitability will never be greater.
• How to Develop Cost-Effective, Rugge-
dized Skid-Based Applications for Remote
For more details about Today’s drive for greater Deployments. Lessons from the Design and
profitability: Never stronger — or more urgent that Engineering of an Oil-Mixing System.
every oil and gas industry executive needs to know visit • Topic Paper: From Drill Bit to Boardroom:
www.usa.siemens.com/reliable-oil-gas-operations Four Ways to Accelerate Automation’s
Deployment Across Oil and Gas Enterprises.
• Topic Paper: Rethinking Automation: A
Revolution in the Oil and Gas Industry.
Cyclone separators
T
he use of cyclones as separators would the incom-
By Don Yates be very popular if unwanted particles ing physical
in oil and gas applications were consis- mix to be
tent in size and would stay away from separated.
the walls of the cyclone. Unfortunately, This can be
the particles that need to be removed used to trap
in oil and gas feeds can vary in size, and when particles in
they come in contact with the walls of cyclone suspension,
separators, abrasive wear occurs. so reducing
the wearing
Enter enhanced 3D printing exposed area
One solution to this problem is the evolution of and promot-
3D printing technologies which has seen myriad ing an order-
flexible setups become possible. There is no ly downward
need for just one print head to be in use at the flow of the
same time. Indeed, many 3D print heads can be unwanted
assembled together, side by side, to dramatically separated
increase the material placement volumes particles to Figure 2: Software controlled 3D print-
and speeds, so the outcome can resemble a removal ed particulate flow changing internal
an extrusion machine. Like a smart extrusion point at the profiles.
process, the output can have almost any 2D bottom of
profile, but with the added features of varying the the device.
physical and chemical composition of the print The centrifugal parameters that aid the removal
material, in real time, and of differing specification, of certain particles can be changed in real time to
Figure 1: An example of how depending on the task. target their extraction for a cleaner output of oil or
a cyclone separator works. In the indicative cyclone separator, the internal gas, as desired. The process exploits a world of
All images courtesy: Colum- flow control wall profiles of the cyclone can be new Internet of Things monitoring points, micro-
bus Group continuously replaced by feeding in the “just-in- electromechanical sensors and smart logic to
time” 3D printed materials, but with connect the dots.
the additional feature that the feed A benefit of 3D printers is the ability to output
in profiles can be varied to form and different materials from the same printing pack-
composition to become appropriate age. Depending on the physical characteristics
cyclone surface materials, includ- of the particles to be removed, the separating
ing hard deflecting and super soft cyclone wall also can be continuously regener-
absorbing surfaces (see Figures 1 ated in a mix of magnetic materials with varying
and 2). attractive strengths to ensure that the extracted
As part of the continuous online unwanted materials are removed from the oil or
rebuild process, the 3D surface gas flow. OG
materials are injected in the same
direction as the induced oil or gas Don Yates is the CEO of Columbus Group where
flow to replace the internal wearing he heads up the R&D
contact surfaces caused by con- activities: a pursuit of
tinuous impact of the different size more than 30 years
particles. With this system in place, and 1,700 projects in
downtime is effectively eliminated. automated safer min-
The profile can also include a ing, smarter oil and gas
surface treatment to encourage extraction and other
a “spiral down” enhancement of industrial projects.
Integrated HMI/SCADA
systems enable smarter
data acquisition
Open platform development tools enable more effective, affordable approaches to SCADA.
H
arnessing the power of data has Integration simplifies development
By Martin Rudloff driven substantial change in the HMI/SCADA systems are deployed in some of
oil and gas industry. As embed- the most dangerous, remote, and technically
ded technologies have fast-tracked sophisticated environments on the planet.
and expanded data collection and It is no small value to ensure compatibility
analysis, the impact is global, and and simplify development, as these systems
operators worldwide are able to develop fuel are integral to ensuring nonstop oil and gas
sources that were once thought inaccessible exploration and production. They must be able
at any cost. High-performance, HMI-based to meet a range of environmental extremes,
systems are at the center of this technology including resistance to shock, vibration,
expansion, handling diverse and demanding temperature, and dust. Incorporating SCADA
physical computing environments while exe- software at the manufacturing level is a new
cuting sophisticated SCADA trend that ensures customized performance
applications. It’s a successful and prevents the runaway integration
PROBLEM: Developing ad- combination of hardware and challenges that can occur when systems are
vanced SCADA applications is software capabilities that has dropped in—either for new deployment or
a challenging and time- broadened horizons for oil refreshing existing systems in the field.
and gas operations, setting
consuming process for oil and
the stage for intelligent oil- Open platforms make all the difference
gas system developers. fields where people, equip- Open platform SCADA development tools are
ment, and assets are con- the most important factors protecting cost,
SOLUTION: While pre-inte- nected for the highest qual- flexibility, and more importantly, longevity of
grated HMI/SCADA technolo- ity production and safety. integrated HMI/SCADA applications. An open,
gies are breaking new ground Conversely, SCADA appli- nonproprietary alternative to costly in-house
to solve the challenge, not all cations are complex and design supports oil technology companies
systems meet the ideal re- time-consuming to develop, facing pressure to reduce costs or quickly
quirements for rugged perfor- increasing the challenge introduce new features in connected embedded
of seamless integration designs. An open platform ensures an efficient
mance, intuitive HMI controls,
with new and existing path to meet application requirements without
interoperability and long-life HMI systems. Deployment incurring large, upfront development costs,
systems. becomes even more com- compounded by lengthy time-to-market.
plex as designers and OEMs A common mistake is to expect an expen-
ACTION TO TAKE: OEMs must reduce development sive licensing requirement as a stumbling
should follow a careful best resources to ensure compet- block. However, OEM licensing models con-
practices checklist to ensure itive value in unique oilfield trast favorably to the expense of retaining an in-
long-term performance is op- settings, but must not sac- house development team creating applications
timized from both a hardware rifice proven rugged perfor- from the ground up. Existing software modules
mance, system consistency, help developers avoid time-consuming, low-
and software perspective.
and long-term supply in the level processes, and instead, remain focused
process. on customization to distinguish their application
OIL&GAS ENGINEERING FEBRUARY 2016 • 7
INTELLIGENT OILFIELDS
and get to market faster. For increased long- consider the software’s ability to easily view data,
term value, the open platform ensures applica- remotely control operations, or communicate
tions can be maintained or used by any system with multiple sites from a central control facility.
integrator. Next-generation systems offer these features
from a thin-client application accessible on por-
Flexible deployment options based on table devices, such as tablets or smartphones.
price vs. performance
Oil rigs or mining platforms may be operated Ensuring reduced costs for long-term
by PLCs from different manufacturers. software migration
Supporting these various product families is Open platforms also can bridge the gap
a costly challenge, requiring OEM support of between customized features and faster, more
HMI development packages from each PLC fluid integration. In addition, long-term software
vendor. In contrast, an open HMI/SCADA migrations are protected with the forward and
platform is compatible with most types backward compatibility maintained in a licensed
of PLC families; with fully open platform development tool. Oil OEMs are assured a path
communications and connectivity, the system to the newest development platforms without
can communicate with PLCs and controllers extensive re-engineering costs.
from nearly any manufacturer. In an optimal licensed software development
As a result, OEMs minimize integration product, support is added routinely, enabling
issues that can add up over time in terms of OEMs to capitalize on new operating systems;
cost and overall resources. It’s important to technology standards, such as HTML5 for web
note that without this ability, an oil producer access; and other valuable communications
might be faced with choosing all products protocol development—but without assign-
related to a single PLC family. ing resources of their own to develop these
This potentially increases costs by eliminat- improvements. Planning ahead also includes
ing the ability to evaluate each piece of an embracing mobile access or cloud-ready
integrated system on its own merits of price options.
vs. performance. For example, a panel PC
running recognized HMI software could be as Pre-integration reduces on-site
much as several thousand dollars more per deployment challenges
installation, compared to a bundled hardware/ OEMs must pay attention to how simply the
software HMI and SCADA system. application can be deployed on-site. Add-ons
can present common problems because
Transforming oil and gas systems suddenly need a raft of new interfaces
with better data or features to connect to existing systems.
Integrated HMI/SCADA systems acknowledge Several oil technology partners offer the option
that reliability feeds profitability. The top priority of shipping an HMI/SCADA system as a fully
for these streamlined systems is to deliver real- tested, turnkey system. It is a best practice
time data to help produce gas more efficiently to determine the ideal level of partnership
and safely. Best practices for SCADA software between OEM and technology supplier
include database connectivity that simplifies or developer because a more synergistic
the linking of multiple data sources, both to relationship can save valuable time and
record information and to use data to develop resources in deploying the end-user application.
analytic dashboards. This allows operators to With a partnership approach, manufacturers
read information at a glance, and make quick can integrate customers’ intellectual prop-
decisions that improve safety, productivity, and erty as part of system development, creating
efficiency. compatible plug-and-play options that refresh
Notably, as systems grow less isolated and systems, streamline part numbers, reduce
begin to take advantage of Internet and cloud- development time, and ensure simple on-site
based capabilities, the ongoing need to mobilize integration. Expertise in applications, such as
oil and gas data is driving many operators to chemical analysis, fracking data collection,
seek SCADA applications that provide mobile and undersea robotic equipment, subsea systems,
remote-monitoring capabilities. OEMs should and onshore/offshore surface logging adds
8 • FEBRUARY 2016 OIL&GAS ENGINEERING
value here, helping reduce
development time and
costs and minimize inte-
gration headaches.
Longevity as a
business practice
Continued updates
to both hardware and
software are essential
for keeping oil and gas
systems fielded for
long-term deployment.
Working closely with the
forward and backward
compatibility of the
software development
platform, the hardware
side of the equation
requires consistent, high-
quality components and
flexible materials planning. Can the vendor further minimize OEM Blending rugged HMI hard-
Creative and proactive programs add value, costs by delivering not only hardware and ware with open platform
helping to protect investments in long-term software, but also the OEM’s custom appli- SCADA development tools
product lifecycles. Oil OEMs should expect cation, pre-installed, tested, and ready for reduces costs and simpli-
fies support of multiple
technology investments backed by a focus on deployment? Ask for assurances that costs
PLC families, often found in
longevity by design with extended support are firm and committed. This applies to con-
complex oil, gas and refinery
programs readily available. tract services as well as software customiza-
systems. Image courtesy:
tion, technical support, and product availabil- Corvalent
Best-practices checklist ity for the long term. Lastly, for remote oil-
Request details on oil and gas experience field deployments, it may be critical to work
as well as familiarity with other ultra-rugged with a manufacturer offering training, such as
industry segments. Increased insight here webinars or on- and off-site classes that can
will have an impact on product performance. help operators avoid unknown challenges or
Are environmental concerns addressed for unexpected delays in the field.
hardware performance, including differentiators
such as IP ratings, ruggedness validated for A new era of data-driven oil and gas
extended temperature and designs incorporating development
processors on a long-term embedded roadmap? Asking the right questions can help determine
What reliability and compatibility tests are your best options for advanced HMI/SCADA
performed and are they continually evolving with platforms that are driving the oil and gas era
industry needs? of access to data anytime, anywhere. These
Before making a technology investment, ask high-availability, open-platform systems are
for specific planning commitments that ensure capitalizing on long-term product development
the HMI software’s forward and backward roadmaps, commitment to longevity
compatibility. Does that include assurances for and reduction of costs while optimizing
hardware/software compatibility moving forward performance all the way from wellhead to
for new operating systems, drivers, and firm- corporate offices. In the field, integration is
ware? Can the system be accessed via mobile seamless, customized, and protected from
and cloud-ready platforms? These are essential runaway costs. OG
questions that establish future flexibility of the
SCADA application. It may be worthwhile to Martin Rudloff is the chief technology officer at
choose a flexible tool that offers both options. Corvalent.
Real-world impact
of simulation
Disruptive simulation technologies enabled a large oil pipeline company to maximize profits.
Twenty percent savings in capital projects were realized, amounting to $85 million. An additional
$24 million in savings was achieved in additional annual, recurring revenue.
S
By Allan Chegus imulation is a disruptive technol- A disruptive technology
ogy that changes the nature of the Simulation replicates the key elements of a
decision-making game. The oil and problem or opportunity to mimic reality in a
gas industry faces the challenge of controlled, virtual environment. In this way,
optimizing large capital assets and a reasonable representation of the problem
extracting maximum value from is created, and any number of variable
investments. But the difficulty to do this is in inputs and outputs can be manipulated.
analyzing the components acting in an inte- Decisions that would otherwise be avoided
grated system (network), rather than silos. or ignored can be tested for feasibility
A large transnational crude oil pipeline because players—from technical staff to
experienced this dilemma. The company executives—are operating in a risk-free,
managing this asset understood that tra- virtual environment.
ditional modeling methods were unable to These gamification principles make simu-
resolve the problem because of the system lation effective and fun at the same time.
constraints moved and changed across the Users are able to drag-and-drop various
network as operating conditions changed. components and events—such as economic,
In addition, the combination of variables regulatory, and taxation—and run simula-
became exponential con- tions to obtain real-world output potentials.
sidering the high system By running the simulation multiple times,
complexity. The system optimal decisions can be determined for the
PROBLEM: Ineffeciencies and
contains: short- (1-to-3 month) and long-term (10-year)
lost revenue are major problems • Five major terminals horizons.
in the oil and gas industry due • 73 storage tanks
to not maximizing potential or • 47 commodity types Innovative real-world results
optomizing the entire system. • 16 commodity pools This oil pipeline company was growing
• 20 default routes quickly. However, it continued to
SOLUTION: Modeling and • 37 business rules experience a chronic shortfall in its
simulation based on real-time • 1,200 connections throughput and revenue performance.
• 26,000 km of pipe- In addition, a structural change in the
operational data can provide
lines. regulatory environment forced the
the the best system operational
company to increase throughput while
scenarios. In addition, the system pushing for cost savings and capital
processes 14 million bar- efficiency.
ACTION TO TAKE: Talk to data rels of oil daily in 400 con- After deciding to move forward with
scientists about how to get current batches. simulation, a multi-commodity terminal
started using real-time data in In light of these con- located in the U.S. Midwest was chosen
simulations to determine the straints, management as a candidate for modeling. The terminal
best strategies for optimizing a decided to try simulation consisted of more than 40 medium- and
modeling to maximize large-diameter oil storage tanks with many
system or process.
profits and optimize interconnecting manifolds, associated
scheduling. meters, and instrumentation.
10 • FEBRUARY 2016 OIL&GAS ENGINEERING
The first step in the process was to deter-
mine the data available within the organiza-
tion. Data were collected from the analytics
team, which served as the umbrella group
for collecting operational information for
the company. In addition, batch data were
collected from the scheduling department.
Prior to this, the operations and batch
departments had worked in isolation. The
simulation exercise facilitated collabora-
tion between the two groups and created
departmental integration.
After collecting and analyzing the data, an
assessment of operating performance rela-
tive to industry benchmarks was performed.
Over the course of this assessment, operat- model existed at first, but it gained Figure 1: Typical terminal
ing gaps and areas for improvement were increasing acceptance as analysts model. All images courtesy:
identified. The objectives of the modeling obtained working experience with the Stream Systems
exercise were to: model.
• Determine whether existing tankage at Finally, the organization did not have
the upstream terminal would be ade- robust analytical capabilities or underly-
quate to store deferred batches without ing support systems for a comprehensive
shutdowns. data management strategy. Furthermore,
• Quantify the impact of customer out- operating data were scattered and incom-
ages on the overall system volume plete. This mentality changed after the
throughput. importance of comprehensive data collec-
• Determine whether planned expansion tion was realized.
would be adequate to mitigate future
outages. Significant savings
As a result of the modeling, the organization
With the data collected and objectives determined that it was possible to eliminate
identified, an initial high-level model was one large storage tank, numerous piping
created. Working with the operations and manifolds, and associated valves and
batch departments, features and functional- instrumentation.
ities were developed to gain greater fidelity A year after implementing the simulation
and alignment with real-world operations. findings, there was a 20% savings in capital Figure 2: Typical user inter-
After a working model was confirmed, simu- projects, which amounted to $85 million. An face.
lations were implemented accounting for
real-world variables.
Overcoming implementation
challenges
The simulation implementation was not
without its challenges. First, learning
statistical methods and moving away from
reliance on spreadsheets were required
to implement the models. With no prior
experience using whole-terminal models
or large complex network simulations,
analysts looked at the problem in a micro
rather than macro sense. In addition, a
distrust in the validity of the simulation
OIL&GAS ENGINEERING FEBRUARY 2016 • 11
CASE STUDY: GAMIFICATION SIMULATION
Figures 3 and 4: Typical simu- additional $24 million in annual, recurring by MIT Sloan Management Review, top
lation outputs. revenue was achieved. Besides this exam- corporate performers in more than 30
ple, companies typically realize an average major industries indicated they were
of between 10% and 20% capital savings twice as likely to use simulation and
after implementation of simulation recom- advanced technologies to guide their
mendations. decisions compared to their competitors
(see “Five simulation effectiveness
What makes simulation effective? criteria.”)
These results are not specific to this
particular case or industry. In a study Simulation is here to stay
Maximizing efficiency in the oil and gas
industry is difficult due to the scale and
Five simulation effectiveness criteria integrated nature of operations across
There are many ways that simulation can transform complex and departments; problems do not exist in
dynamic decision-making in the oil and gas industry. Here are five of silos. In addition, system considerations,
them: such as the economy, changing regulatory
1. Asset planning tool: Simulation is an asset planning tool, not a environments, and taxation framework
scheduling application tool. It optimizes large capital assets and extracts impact the effectiveness of potential
maximum return from those investments. Therefore, the outcomes are
decisions. This is why simulation is
comprehensive in scope, taking into consideration the most important ele-
innovative in its ability to create disruptive
ments of the problem.
2. Forward looking: Simulations are validated using actual real-time and material change.
data, but the data are not extrapolated into the future to make decisions. Moreover, it will continue to be adopted
With simulation, data patterns are determined from past behaviors, and by organizations that seek to decrease
the simulations are run taking into consideration the possibility of and overhead costs and increase efficiency.
complexity of future activities and events. Simulation accounts for big-picture issues
3. Time: Whereas models of this complexity typically take 4 to 6 and allows for testing in a risk-free environ-
months to configure using conventional software, simulations typically ment. It is through this creative, out-of-the-
take between 4 and 6 weeks. This is possible because of proprietary soft- box thinking, that change can occur. OG
ware, algorithms, and because the model is fit-for-purpose with the appro-
priate level of details to solve the problem. It is also possible because of
Allan Chegus is president and cofounder of
the processing power of today’s computers. Gut-based decision making is
Stream Systems, a product and multidisciplinary
eliminated because real-world answers become evident in a short period
consulting firm specializing in business simula-
of time.
4. Collaboration: Collaboration across disciplines is required to achieve tions, advanced optimization, and predictive analyt-
optimal decision making. Departments no longer operate in silos, and ics serving the oil and gas industry. Chegus has
they become interdisciplinary as data are shared. This collaboration extensive project and
results in robust outcomes as the entire system is considered. program experience in
5. Team advantage: The team behind the simulation is crucial. Data business simulations and
scientists draw patterns from past data and determine the most important advanced decision-making
variables to include and manipulate in the simulation. It is important that systems including feasi-
the team have experience, not only running traditional simulations, but bility and business case
also working on the core operating activities in the oil and gas industry. It
development for multi-
also is important to find a balance between individuals with strong techni-
million-dollar energy-
cal skills and those who are systems thinkers.
related business projects.
I
By Roberto Michel n these cost-constrained times driven by accordingly. As part of that, more companies
low oil prices, the goals behind asset reli- are examining asset performance manage-
ability initiatives shift somewhat. While ment (APM) strategies.
asset uptime will always be the central
focus when it comes to asset perfor- Toward APM
mance, in a down market, having the More companies in the oil and gas industry
insights to let noncritical parts run to failure are putting in place APM technologies, which
to save on maintenance costs and to help use analytical tools and functionality for
right-size spares inventory becomes more managing recommendations to improve asset
important. effectiveness. Reliability technologies are
A full year and a half into the oil price plunge, essential to APM in that they help companies
which began in mid-2014, few would argue establish maintenance strategies, according
with the notion that oil and gas industry man- to Ralph Rio, research director with ARC
agers need to do everything they can to curb Advisory Group.
costs, including re-examining maintenance “Reliability technologies determine which
strategies. Part of the challenge, however, assets are most critical to APM, and what
is that enterprise asset management (EAM) kind of maintenance plan you should apply
systems excel at executing maintenance pro- to a particular asset,” said Rio. “The end goal
cesses, but do not necessarily contain the type for APM is to improve return on assets and it
of analytical functions and improvement work- tends to place emphasis on maintenance plan-
flows that help a company establish and follow ning, whereas EAM is more about executing
through on maintenance strategies. maintenance processes.”
Inventories of spare parts and other main- APM software solutions, according to Rio,
tenance, repair, and operations (MRO) sup- can have different types of applications, but
plies must be further tightened in this down reliability centered maintenance (RCM) is
market. In 2013, research firm IHS high- the key type of APM application. Such soft-
lighted the problem of “toxic MRO catalogs” ware usually has an analytical component to
that plague asset-intensive industries. IHS assess factors, such as safety or downtime
reported that MRO stockpiles were growing risks. However, added Rio, APM is more than
by 9% per year, and that up to 30% of MRO business intelligence layered on top of EAM
inventory will never be used. history in that these technologies typically
To optimize MRO inventories and ensure have workflows to manage recommendations,
that the most critical assets stay produc- and their analytics can take in many types of
tive, the trick is to assess which assets are asset-related data, not just EAM history.
the most business-critical, which are less The APM vendor landscape is still emerg-
critical, and rethink maintenance strategies ing, with plenty of overlap among companies
OIL&GAS ENGINEERING FEBRUARY 2016 • 13
Case study: proaCtive maintenanCe
involved. The market includes a handful Another key concern in getting APM and
of vendors that specialize in APM or RCM EAM processes in sync is master data man-
applications, EAM vendors with RCM tech- agement. Tools within APM and EAM solu-
nologies, major enterprise system vendors tions that manage master data over assets
who have manufacturing execution system can help, but ultimately, the user organiza-
(MES) technology with plant intelligence tion must decide which technology will be
software that addresses equipment reli- the system of record for asset information.
ability, and major control system vendors “Getting to a state of consistent master
‘
who have plant intelligence software that data can take years,” said Rio, “and may be
A full year into addresses reliability and asset health. best pursued as companies perform major
Additionally, some end-user companies upgrades to a plant, rig, or other key asset.”
the oil price have custom-built technologies for functions
plunge, which such as RCM. “ARC views APM as a devel- APM in action
oping space that for the most part, has been In practice, APM initiatives typically involve
began in user-driven, with many customized technolo- applications that pinpoint failures to critical
mid-2014, few gies that have been created to maximize equipment and also set maintenance plans
return on assets,” said Rio. for different classes of equipment. These
would argue Simply deploying APM software, how- implementations typically tie into EAM
ever, is no guarantee of improved reliability, technologies to follow through on changes
with the notion
warned Rio. One major hurdle is organiza- to maintenance procedures, and to verify
that oil and tional: The people in a company analyzing improvements.
asset reliability might be disconnected with For Super Octanos, C.A., a Venezuelan
gas industry groups in charge of maintenance, those in manufacturer of gasoline additives, such
managers charge of production, and those in charge as methyl tertiary butyl ether (MTBE), an
of IT. “Organizational hurdles are real, and APM program and supporting software has
need to do they can, and often do, lead to problems,” improved equipment reliability and uptime.
Rio said. Back in 2007, the company decided to pur-
everything they
The organizations that have learned to sue an APM initiative after seeing the gap
can to curb excel at APM have created asset reliabil- between its asset availability plan and actual
ity groups with participation from leaders performance reach 27%.
costs, including across disciplines, reporting up to one chain Super Octanos wanted to increase avail-
re-examining of command. Other organizational changes ability by eliminating or reducing failures,
that can help is to have a manufacturing IT thus improving its “on-stream factor,” which
maintenance group that is separate from corporate IT. A is a percentage measure of the time that a
strategies.
’ manufacturing IT group can help users of
APM technologies collaborate with users of
EAM and control systems. In some instanc-
process unit is operating. The initiative was
successful in improving the plant’s on-stream
factor, in part, by analyzing and recommending
es, it may be possible to build links between fixes to a recurring failure in a critical motor.
APM and EAM technologies so that a The short-circuit ring electric motor (11
recommended action from APM analysis MW), part of an Italian design compression
gets passed into the EAM technologies for system for an MTBE plant, failed six times
execution. between 2008 and 2012. Images of the asset
“Some integration between asset reliabil- revealed physical failure of the circuit’s con-
ity and EAM application can be important tacts due to melted copper. The motor was
and necessary, but it may not suffice to one of five in existence worldwide, limiting
actually improve performance if the right available support. Each repair to the short-
information isn’t also provided to the main- circuit ring electric motor could result in lost
tenance organization, or it isn’t deemed production of 1,692 metric tons of MTBE, or
credible enough from their viewpoint,” said more than $1.4 million in revenue.
Rio. “So you have to layer some organi- Super Octanos needed to monitor this
zational change on top of any application asset’s performance and complete the APM
integration.” implementation to identify the root cause of
14 • FEBRUARY 2016 OIL&GAS ENGINEERING
failure and determine the best action to resolve the prob- components, updated work instructions for maintenance
lem. The project’s objectives included: personnel, a new training plan, and use of a quality voltage-
monitoring system. These steps have been successful
• Designing and implementing APM continuous in nearly eliminating downtime from the motor. Overall,
improvement processes through the implementation of Meridium’s APM and failure
• Undergoing APM best practice knowledge transfer elimination applications, Super Octanos’ gap between its
• Improving availability on-stream plan and actual data has decreased significantly,
• Reducing cost down from 27% in 2007 to 2% in 2014.
• Managing risk To overcome the cultural challenges initiated in the APM
• Training and establishing industrial systems reliability transformation, Super Octanos worked with Meridium to
specialists. assign key resources as functional leaders, communicated
new information policies to all employees, and built reliability
Super Octanos chose APM software from Meridium as into the company’s framework and
its APM foundation and to support failure elimination pro- mission. As Garcia summarizes, “We
cesses. The APM software includes asset taxonomy, which established a reliability focused culture
is a hierarchy and classification of asset structure, and an and eliminated failures with the help
event history with a standard process to capture and inte- of Meridium’s knowledge and leader-
grate performance history and condition data. The company ship expertise.” OG
integrated the APM software with data from its Oracle
EAM system, as well as other asset-related data, to support Roberto Michel is a freelance writer and
analysis and identify assets experiencing the highest failure editor with more than 20 years of experi-
rates, thus helping to develop mitigation strategies. ence with business-to-business publications.
Using APM-failure-elimination technology and work pro-
cesses, the company used standardized asset taxonomy
to understand where its asset failures were occurring and
enact recommendation management to implement repairs
and monitor success in reducing failures. The company
Electrical Solutions
also instituted event-reporting work processes, work-order
reporting processes, and lost-production opportunities
for Hazardous Locations
analysis.
Change management
According Juan Garcia, technical manager for Super
Octanos, the APM initiative boils down to a structured
“find it, fix it” process for identifying equipment and/
or procedures prone to failure, and then instituting the
fixes and follow-ups. “To say ‘find it, fix it,’ sounds simple,
but there are many work processes and cultural changes
involved in doing this successfully,” said Garcia.
Using the APM technology for failure elimination involves:
Protecting FPSOs
from arc flash
At a large floating production storage and offloading (FPSO) unit, managers have found a way
to protect workers and equipment from electrical arc flash and reduce the risk of downtime.
F
By Dr. Jay Prigmore PSO operations require electrical over time, which “track” to the nearest
power, which must be distributed electrode causing a short-circuit or arcing
safely and reliably. That’s why man- fault. Electrical tracking may occur in any
agers at a large floating production energized piece of equipment including
storage and offloading (FPSO) took a cables and switchgear.
proactive electrical safety role. This Therefore, it is a common practice in the
floating structure is located 10 miles offshore electrical system to deliberately float or
in the Atlantic Ocean. It processes more than employ high-resistance grounding. These
250,000 barrels of oil per day and is capable measures help mitigate the risk of phase-to-
of storing more than 2 million barrels of oil. ground faults, which are responsible for the
On-site power generation is required vast majority of arc flash events. Another
on FPSOs to power onboard equipment. advantage of this system design is the ben-
Many protection schemes and methods efit of allowing operations the ability to ride
are investigated to determine the most through the fault.
effective safeguards for the FPSO. These However, a chance remains for phase-to-
inspections include, but are not limited to phase or 3-phase arc flash events, which
short-circuit current, arc flash, and system research shows are more likely to occur
stability studies. The engineering firm per- in the presence of maintenance workers
forming the studies discussed the impor- due to movement in the area, and some-
tance of arc flash mitigation on the FPSO times caused by a dropped tool, according
in addition to addressing the short-circuit to the NFPA’s “Occupational Injuries from
current. An electrical accident, such as Electrical Shock and Arc Events.” The dan-
an arc flash, in the presence of explosive ger to workers has made arc flash mitiga-
gases, could be catastrophic to the opera- tion a priority.
tion and personnel.
Five types of arc flash mitigation
The perfect storm for arc flash The managers and a consulting firm reviewed
At sea, humid salty air and water from the available arc flash mitigation approaches,
extreme weather can increase the risk and categorized them into five groups:
of electrical tracking and electrical arcs.
Electrical tracking or sometimes referred 1. Fault interrupting technologies include
to as electrical treeing or dry banding current limiting fuses, expulsion fuses, and
is a breakdown phenomenon in solid circuit breakers. In the presence of fault
insulation caused by partial discharges current, these devices open the circuit by
THE HOTTEST
NAME IN TEMPERATURE SENSORS.
levels. Because this was applied at
the bus tie between numerous gen-
erators, operation of the protector
would cut overcurrent to within the
breaker ratings and approximately
lower the arc flash energy to 25%
Pyromation. For decades, we’ve been custom of its peak value. This was enough
designing and manufacturing temperature to protect the equipment and to
sensors for the oil & gas industry. And we mitigate arc flash at that location.
can tackle any challenge you send our In cases where the setpoint is rela-
way. Quickly. Cost-effectively. And with tively high, secondary arc flash pro-
the kind of no-excuses service that
tection, such as arc flash relays may
keeps our customers coming back.
be applied at downstream electrical
At Pyromation, we offer:
panels. But in this case it was not
// A comprehensive product line necessary. OG
// Industry certifications
(FM, CSA, ATEX, IECex) Jay Prigmore, P.E., is a product devel-
// Custom designs to meet your specs opment engineer
// Fast delivery (same-day
with G&W Electric,
shipments available)
// Sales & engineering expertise a supplier of elec-
trical power equip-
Call or visit our website
Oil & Gas ment. He has a
and see why, when it comes PhD, and an MS in
to temperature sensors, one 5211 Industrial Road • Fort Wayne, IN 46825 electrical engineer-
name is beyond measure. (260) 209-6341 • www.pyromation.com/oilandgas ing from Arizona
State University.
M
By Barb Boynton ethane is a major component of the valve is stroked open and closed. Pneumatic
natural gas, and is also a green- devices typically work as described below:
house gas that is 25 times more • High pressure gas is controlled by a pressure
likely to contribute to global warm- regulator valve to a constant pneumatic gas
ing than carbon monoxide. The supply pressure.
U.S. Environmental Protection • Mechanical process measuring devices
Agency (EPA) estimates that 30% of methane further regulate the supply gas pressure to
emissions come from the oil and gas industry. a weak pneumatic signal depending on the
When breaking down where these methane process measurement high to low level,
emissions come from, pneumatic devices are pressure, temperature, and flow rate.
considered one of the top contributors, especially • The weak pneumatic signal flows into a
with natural gas production. Pneumatic devices in controller, which through a precision set of
gas extraction are designed to vent methane into nozzles and orifices, directs the pneumatic
the atmosphere as a part of normal operations. supply gas to or from the valve actuator.
This vent or “bleed” of natural gas not only con- • When supply gas is routed to the actuator,
tributes to poor air quality, but also hurts the oil the diaphragm pushes the valve plug open or
Figure 1: The photo shows an and gas producers by not capturing the value of closed.
electric actuator installed on a this gas as a sellable commodity. • When supply gas is vented, an opposing
4-in. suction control valve feed- There are two basic types of pneumatic devices spring pushes the diaphragm back, closing or
ing a compressor. All images that bleed methane to the atmosphere: controllers opening the valve.
courtesy: Curtiss-Wright/Exlar and valve actuators. While controllers bleed gas • The weak control signal is often vented con-
Actuator Solutions continuously, valve actuators bleed gas only when tinuously (bled) to the atmosphere.
• The strong signal is vented intermittently—
only when the valve opens or closes.
Solar-powered thermal
mass flowmeters operate in
flare-gas monitoring system
How can new gas flowmeters operate at an oilfield without utility power service in the
remote southern Bakken formation region of North Dakota? That was the challenge facing
Legacy Reserves at remote sites at the Williston Basin, N.D.
I
By Bernie Schillo, Mike n an era of increasing environmental for commercial use, is sent to a tank with a
Smith, and Steve Cox concern and regulation, the team at this flare unit and burned off as necessary.
isolated oilfield at the Williston Basin Each of the 14 well heads would require
needed to upgrade its waste gas report- two air/gas flowmeters to support the pro-
ing capabilities for the North Dakota cess. The variable and sometimes low-flow
Industrial Commission (NDIC) and the volume at the wells meant that differen-
U.S. Bureau of Land Management (BLM). tial pressure technologies, such as orifice
The team realized that new state and federal plates could not be used. The company also
regulations would require monthly testing wanted to use existing gas lines as much as
and reporting, requiring more sophisticated possible.
flow measurement. The team completed an assessment for
“We are now required by the NDIC to the NDIC prior to starting the project to
monitor waste gas resulting from each of prove that production could continue while
Figure 1: This photo shows our 14 production wells,” said Bernie Schillo, meeting environmental standards. Previous
a solar power system at the production foreman at Legacy Reserves. regulations required only one annual 24-hour
Schillo site. All images cour- “We wanted to add new flowmeters to each test of the flare-gas monitoring system.
tesy: FCI well for this purpose in advance of the dead- Today, the more stringent monitoring
line. The state has set new lim- requirements are driving the need for con-
its for gas emissions, and we tinuous flow measurement.
must stay within those limits “We had to convince the state that it was
or cutback well production.” more cost effective to install flowmeters on
the wells than to install multiple new gas
Challenge: lines,” Schillo said. Our gas streams are on
no outlet, no power the low volume side and the other approach
Without utility power at the (new gas lines) just wasn’t practical.”
field’s location in the Golden
Valley of North Dakota, Schillo’s The final answer: solar power
team decided to explore Schillo’s team contacted Mike Smith, Jasper
powering the meters with solar Engineering, Williston, N.D., to help with
energy. The 14 wells are laid the solar-powered flowmeter system. Smith
out on one well pad connected agreed with the feasibility of the team’s
to a 3-phase heater/treater decision to use solar energy to power the
tank that separates the crude flowmeters, and asked the applications team
oil into three process streams: at Fluid Components International (FCI) for
oil, natural gas, and water. a flowmeter capable of handling the variable
Waste gas from the separation low-flow wet-gas measurement with solar
process, which is unsuitable power generation.
OIL&GAS ENGINEERING FEBRUARY 2016 • 21
WELDED METAL
BELLOWS CASE STUDY: FLOWMETERS
When your
applications demand
zero leakage & high
cycle life seals in the
most demanding
environment.
IECEx certification
makes safe safer
Is the European standard of IECEx for harsh environment computers right for design
engineers? How does this European standard impact U.S.-based operations?
W
By Mike Hadaway hile the phrase “IECEx cer- accepted and does not require ongoing qual-
tification” isn’t part of the ity or facility audits.
daily conversation for sys- Other common certifications include; the
tems engineers in the U.S., class/division ratings based on the NFPA
indications are that it may (National Fire Protection Association) 496,
be soon. While the U.S. pri- the NEC (National Electric Code), and the
marily uses Division-based systems, such as ATEX (Atmosphere Explosibles) Zone rat-
Underwriters Laboratories (UL) certification ings. As a result of the improved safety and
marks, for addressing hazardous areas and international recognition of the IECEx, more
equipment, other countries have adopted U.S.-based oil and gas processors in on- and
the Zone-based IECEx system. offshore facilities are beginning to imple-
The inconsistencies in hazardous area clas- ment this standard.
sification have made it difficult for U.S. manu- Deciding whether or not to require that
facturers to tap into globalized markets, such as the hazardous area computers purchased for
oil and gas processing. This has led to the shift an offshore location meet IECEx standards,
toward global solutions that meet not only U.S. and then navigating the certification process
standards, but international ones as well. is challenging for systems engineers.
De-risk by design:
Maintaining safety at heights
A major challenge facing oil and gas facilities is inadequate lighting and the need for workers to
climb to elevated heights to repair or replace lights.
O
By Bradford Morse il and gas facilities are among the to threats is the most effective risk reduction
most demanding and hazardous of measure.
industrial settings that require proper
lighting to maintain worker safety. Spring-assisted telescoping light poles
To address this concern and help Spring-assisted light poles are designed for
improve safety some recent innova- industrial walkways, platforms, stairways, and
tions in lighting technology have been developed. conveyors where OSHA/Health, Safety, and
Environment (HSE) regulations typically require
Identify the challenge fall prevention equipment. A worker can remain
Maintaining lighting in industrial facilities is often where an existing guardrail provides protection
complex, time consuming, and costly because and lower or raise the light with the spring-assisted
most fixtures are in dangerous and difficult to telescoping pole during installation or maintenance.
reach locations. As a result, an industry average
of one-third of all lights at an industrial facility are Safety innovation
out at any given time. The installed base of high Improving upon previous generations of
intensity discharge lights should be re-lamped rotational light poles, the simple vertical travel of
every two years. However, this is a telescoping light pole provides true controlled
typically not done. lowering, reducing the strain on the worker,
PROBLEM: Lighting is According to Occupational and eliminating consideration of surrounding
inadequte in some areas of Safety and Health Administration obstructions. Spring assistance allows the
facilities. (OSHA), fall protection is the luminaire to be lowered safely and easily,
most frequently cited violation. meaning that work can safely take place on any
SOLUTION: Instead of plac- Worse, 36% of worker deaths on platform or walkway, eliminating the need for
ing a person in a dangerous construction sites are from falls portable ladders and fall protection equipment.
according to the United States
position to do work, use
Department of Labor. Safety initiative
spring-assisted light poles.
Typically, workers climb to ele- A study conducted by Liberty Mutual Research
vated heights to repair or replace Institute for Safety reported that for every $1
ACTION TO TAKE:
lights. When climbing to an elevat- invested in safety, there is a $3 to $6 return
• Use spring-assisted ed height, beyond the protection on investment. Using this type of light pole,
lights to avoid working of a guardrail, fall protection must the investment in worker safety provides
at heights. be used. Two generally accepted a compelling return while ensuring overall
• Protect workers with methods to protect a worker are integrity of the facility. OG
a fall-arrest system or used while working at heights of
scaffolding when work- 4 ft or greater; personal fall-arrest Bradford Morse is a product manager at Eaton. He
system or scaffolding with guard- leads the launch of new products and enhancements
ing at heights.
rails. While personal protection to existing products for Eaton’s Crouse-Hinds series of
• Seek safety solutions
equipment will help protect work- industrial fittings solutions. Morse has 18 years of expe-
that help minimize risk ers from some threats, there is rience and has held a variety of engineering and product
and help staff avoid still a risk of injury from a fall. management positions. He has defined, launched and
working at heights. The bottom line: Preventing marketed more than 10 successful products for compa-
workers from being exposed nies Eaton, General Electric, and Motorola.
ADVERTISERS’ INDEX