Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
1, JANUARY 2010
Fig. 2. Part of the damper network showing single damper bar including the
end-ring impedances ZRi . RD is the damper-bar resistance, XDσ is the bar Fig. 3. Air-gap permeance function Λ(ξ) over two pole pitches l = 2τp ,
leakage reactance, Xij are the self and mutual reactances, and Ui is the external calculated with a self-developed boundary element code. The pole pitch is
voltage source. τp = 923 mm, and the minimum air gap is δ = 18.5 mm.
currents in converter- and line-fed synchronous machines. resistances, self and mutual bar inductances, as well as leakage
Keller [11] calculates damper currents at rotor unbalance. With inductances (Fig. 2). Induced voltages from the external air-
the same approach, Keller et al. [12] take into account the in- gap field is considered as voltage sources. When assembling
fluence of damper currents on the stator-winding voltage shape. the network equations, a linear system of equations is obtained.
Nica et al. [13] analyze the damper-current effect in converter- The advantages of a damper-winding network compared with
driven machines. Rocha et al. [14] study damper currents by a more simple d- and q-axis equivalent-circuit computation
using a coupled circuit. Nitta et al. [15] analyze damper- method [2], [3] are as follows.
winding currents due to subharmonics with finite-element (FE) 1) The actual position of each damper bar is taken into
method (FEM). account. This allows the consideration of special damper-
The content of this paper is the computation of the current bar distributions on the pole shoe, like an irregular distri-
distribution and the associated power losses in the damper- bution or a damper-winding displacement.
winding bars of salient-pole synchronous machines due to 2) For fractional-slot windings, the model is simply ex-
the tooth-ripple pulsations and the stator-winding armature- tended over a repetitive section of the stator winding. The
reaction harmonics. effect of subharmonics is correctly considered.
The computation relies on an equivalent electrical network
of the damper winding where the self and mutual inductances A. Air-Gap Permeance
as well as the bar voltages are calculated using an air-gap
With an air-gap-permeance function Λ(ξ), the magnetic-flux-
permeance model [16]. Instead of applying Fourier expansions
density distribution B(ξ) is obtained from the mmf function
for the formulation of the air-gap field as proposed in [6]–[9], a
V (ξ) according to
numerical integration based on sample functions is used.
The presented algorithm is verified by comparing with a B(ξ) = V (ξ)Λ(ξ). (2)
conventional approach based on the d- and q-axis equivalent
circuits [2] and with transient FE computations [17]. This approach assumes radial field lines and infinite perme-
ability of the iron parts of both sides of the air gap. For a
machine with a constant air gap δ, the constant permeance is
II. A NALYTICAL C OMPUTATION Λ = μ0 /δ, with μ0 denoting the permeability of air. In the case
Consider an arbitrary time t and space ξ dependent air-gap of a salient-pole synchronous machine with a variable air gap
mmf field wave δ(ξ), a permeance function
1
Vν (ξ, t) = Re {Vν · exp(jkν ξ − jων t)} (1) Λ(ξ) = μ0 · (3)
δ(ξ)
where Vν is the mmf amplitude, kν is the wavenumber, and ων is obtained. Λ(ξ) can be obtained from a simplified analytical
is the angular frequency. The circumferential space coordinate estimation [14] or a numerical field calculation [18]. Fig. 3
ξ is based on a rotor-fixed coordinate system. When moving shows an example air-gap-permeance function calculated with
relative to the damper winding, the resulting air-gap magnetic a self-developed automatized boundary element code. Note that
field induces voltages in the damper bars thus, generating the algorithm works in the same way for special designs like
circulating currents. displaced pole shoes.
The calculation of these currents is based on an equivalent For machines with a fractional-slot winding, the full model
electrical network, where all damper-winding bars of a repeti- and, therefore, also the permeance function Λ(ξ) extends over
tive section of the machine are modeled. The network contains a whole repetitive section of the stator winding.
156 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS, VOL. 57, NO. 1, JANUARY 2010
B. Air-Gap Transformation
The air-gap permeance model considers that field waves with
a short wavelength λν = 2π/kν cross the air gap as radial field
Fig. 5. Damper-ring design example: Damper ring embedded (top figure) into
lines. They will create an air-gap field distribution with curved the pole end plate and (bottom figure) on the pole end.
field lines. Part of the flux lines will close through the air gap
and never reach the rotor surface. This effect is considered with
an air-gap transformation factor [1]
ByR 1
fg = S
= (4)
By cosh(kν δ)
Fig. 6. Pole geometry showing the location of the damper bars and the
which is the ratio of the normal magnetic-flux densities on the imaginary return conductor considering the actual position of each damper bar
rotor and stator surface (Fig. 4). fg is obtained from the solution on the pole shoe.
of the Laplace equation based on a simple air-gap configuration
[16]. In the same way, ByR is expressed as a function of the
stator-side linear current-density function K S
μ0 K S
ByR = . (5)
sinh(kν δ)
III. A NALYTICAL V ERSUS N UMERICAL C ALCULATIONS B(ξ, t) = Re {Bt · exp(jkt ξ − jωt t)} . (13)
The presented calculation method is validated by comparison The tooth-ripple angular frequency ωt = ωG · 6q is based on
with transient 2-D FE simulations using the Flux2D software the grid frequency ωG and the number of slots per pole and
158 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS, VOL. 57, NO. 1, JANUARY 2010
TABLE II
M ACHINE DATA OF T HREE -P HASE 120-MVA S ALIENT-P OLE
S YNCHRONOUS M ACHINE U SED TO VALIDATE DAMPER
C URRENTS AT S HORT-C IRCUIT T EST
Fig. 10. Current distribution in the damper bars (amplitudes) of two poles
at no-load condition for a damper-bar slot pitch τd = 40 mm: comparison
between FEM and the presented analytical method.
Fig. 12. Current distribution in the damper bars (amplitudes) of one pole at
short-circuit-test condition 300-Hz component (harmonics −5, +7): compari-
Fig. 11. Power losses per pole pair at no-load condition for different damper- son between FEM and the presented analytical method (example machine 2).
bar slot pitches based on a stator slot pitch τs = 60 mm: comparison between
FEM and the presented analytical method.
TABLE III
M EAN DAMPER -BAR C URRENTS C ALCULATED W ITH D IFFERENT M ETHODS
total power losses in the damper winding as a function of the for estimating losses as long as the air-gap-transformation
damper-bar pitch. coefficient is introduced.
[5] J. Matsuki, T. Katagi, and T. Okada, “Slot ripples in the damper windings Georg Traxler-Samek received the M.S. and
of a salient-pole synchronous generator,” IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., Ph.D. degrees in electrical engineering from Vienna
vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 126–134, Mar. 1994. University of Technology, Vienna, Austria, in 1996
[6] H. Karmaker and A. M. Knight, “Fields, damper currents and losses in and 2003, respectively. His Ph.D. thesis was on
large salient-pole synchronous machines with skewed stator slots,” in additional losses in large synchronous machines.
Proc. 16th ICEM, 2004, pp. 1–5. In 1996, he was with the Hydro Power Division,
[7] H. Karmaker and A. M. Knight, “Investigation and simulation of fields in ABB Austria. Since 1999, he has been with the Hy-
large salient-pole synchronous machines with skewed stator slots,” IEEE dro Generator Technology Center, ALSTOM Hydro
Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 20, no. 3, pp. 604–610, Sep. 2005. (Switzerland) Ltd., Birr, Switzerland, where he is re-
[8] A. M. Knight, H. Karmaker, and K. Weeber, “Prediction of damper sponsible for the development of special calculation
winding currents and force harmonic components in large synchronous methods and tools. He is currently a Visiting Lecturer
machines,” in Proc. 15th ICEM, 2002, p. 35. at Darmstadt University of Technology, Darmstadt, Germany.
[9] A. M. Knight, H. Karmaker, and K. Weeber, “Use of a permeance model to
predict force harmonic components and damper winding effects in salient-
pole synchronous machines,” IEEE Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 17, no. 4,
pp. 478–484, Dec. 2002.
[10] W. Vetter and K. Reichert, “Determination of damper winding and rotor
iron currents in converter- and line-fed synchronous machines,” IEEE
Trans. Energy Convers., vol. 9, no. 4, pp. 709–716, Dec. 1994.
[11] S. Keller, “Large low speed hydrogenerators—UMP and additional
damper losses in eccentricity conditions,” Ph.D. dissertation, Ecole Poly-
Thomas Lugand received the M.S. degree in
technique Federale de Lausanne (EPFL), Lausanne, Switzerland, 2007.
electrical engineering from Grenoble Institute of
[12] S. Keller, M. T. Xuan, and J. J. Simond, “Computation of the no-load volt-
Technology, Grenoble, France, in 2007. He is
age waveform of laminated salient-pole synchronous generators,” IEEE
currently working toward the Ph.D. degree in
Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 42, no. 3, pp. 681–687, May/Jun. 2006.
electrical engineering at the Grenoble Electrical
[13] C. Nica, S. Enache, and M. A. Enache, “About currents from the
Engineering Laboratory (G2Elab), Grenoble,
damper winding bars of three-phase synchronous generator connected on
and ALSTOM Hydro (Switzerland) Ltd., Birr,
rectifier,” in Proc. 17th ICEM, 2006, pp. 1–4.
Switzerland.
[14] E. J. J. Rocha, M. K. Uemori, and A. De Arruda Penteado, “The damper
His research interests include electromagnetic
winding influence upon salient pole synchronous generator electromotive
simulation of generators and further studies on
force,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Electr. Mach. Drives Conf. Rec., May 18–21,
double-fed induction machines.
1997, pp. TC1/7.1–TC1/7.3.
[15] T. Nitta, T. Okada, T. Naito, and S. Moriyasu, “Analysis of damper wind-
ing current of synchronous generator due to space subharmonic M.M.F.,”
IEEE Trans. Magn., vol. MAG-19, no. 6, pp. 2643–2646, Nov. 1983.
[16] G. Traxler-Samek, T. Lugand, and A. Schwery, “Calculation of power
losses in the damper winding of large hydrogenerators at open-circuit and
load conditions,” in Proc. 18th ICEM, Sep. 6–9, 2008, pp. 1–6.
[17] T. Lugand, “Two-dimensional transient FE analysis of currents in
the damper bars of salient pole synchronous machines,” M.S. thesis,
ENSIEG-INPG, Grenoble, France, 2007. Alexander Schwery (M’05) received the B.S. and
[18] C. A. Brebbia and J. Dominguez, Boundary Elements—An Introductory Ph.D. degrees in electrical engineering from the
Course. Southampton, U.K.: WIT Press, 1992. Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Lausanne,
[19] J. H. Walker, Large Synchronous Machines: Design, Manufacture, and Switzerland, in 1994 and 1999, respectively, and
Operation. Oxford, U.K.: Clarendon, 1981. the Ph.D. degree in science of management from
[20] C. Group, Finite element software F LUX2D3D. [Online]. Available: the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, Zurich,
www.cedrat.com Switzerland, in 1992.
[21] A. Schwery, G. Traxler-Samek, and E. Schmidt, “Application of a tran- In 1999, he was with the Hydro Power Division,
sient finite element analysis with coupled circuits to calculate the voltage ABB Power Generation. He has been a member of
shape of a synchronous generator,” in Proc. 10th Biennial IEEE CEFC, the Hydro Generator Technology Center, ALSTOM
2002, pp. 92–95. Hydro (Switzerland) Ltd., Birr, Switzerland, with the
[22] Rotating Electrical Machines—Part 2-1: Standard Methods for Determin- move of these activities to ALSTOM in 1999/2000, and where he is currently
ing Losses and Efficiency From Tests (Excluding Machines for Traction the Head of the R&D Electrical Group. His research interests include the
Vehicles), IEC Std., I. 60034-2-1, Sep. 2007. electrical simulation of generators.