Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
I. INTRODUCTION
Bidirectional
With the exacerbation of global environmental pollution AC
AC/DC/AC
AC/DC
DC/AC
AC load
DC converter
.
.
.
and fossil energy crisis, the clean renewable energy and
distributed power generation technology becomes the hot DC Bus
+
-
research topic. A superior utilization mode of the distributed AC gistributed generation units
DC/DC
AC/DC
978-1-5386-3758-6/18/$31.00 2018
c IEEE 1762
microgrids can be shared among the whole microgrid sources. ω ac = ω ac* + K mz ( Pac* ← dc − Pac ← dc ) (3)
A decentralized AC/DC droop control method based on the *
DC capacitor dynamic characteristic and AC frequency droop where Pac ← dc and P are the active power flow and reference
ac ← dc
characteristic is proposed in [11]. However, it causes value from DC to AC subgrid, respectively; Kmz is the
continuous operation of the bidirectional AC/DC converter for corresponding droop coefficient and can be obtained as
any load variations, which will result in more power loss in P max − Pacmin (4)
K mz = ac ← dc ← dc
the converter. By measuring the instantaneous value of ω max − ω min
frequency and DC voltage, a coordination power control
strategy of the bidirectional AC/DC converter is proposed in where Pacmax min
← dc and Pac ← dc are the maximum and minimum power
[12]. In this strategy, the transfer power command of the flow from DC to AC subgrid, ωmax and ωmin are the maximum
bidirectional converter is closely related to the proportional and minimum frequency, respectively. In this way, (1) and (3)
gain while no determination methods are given. Therefore, it jointly describe the droop characteristic of the sources and
is necessary to further study the coordinated power sharing loads that connected to the AC bus. When the active loads in
within the whole hybrid microgrid. AC subgrid change, the output of each distributed generation
In this paper, the two kinds power droop characteristic of unit and the bidirectional AC/DC converter change
AC and DC distributed generations are described as the droop accordingly with each droop characteristic to reach a new
characteristic of AC bus and DC bus of the bidirectional power balance.
AC/DC converter. Then a novel active power control strategy The active power droop control characteristic of distributed
of the bidirectional converter based on the bidirectional droop generation units in DC subgrid is
characteristic is proposed to realize the power balance and *
U dc = U dc + K n1 ( Pdc* ,1 − Pdc ,1 )
independent sharing of the hybrid microgrid. Small signal ° (5)
modeling and analysis of the bidirectional converters are ®"
°U = U * + K ( P * − P )
conducted to evaluate the characteristics of the proposed ¯ dc dc ny dc , y dc , y
control with different parameters. Simulation results show the
where U dc and U dc* are the measured DC voltage and the
validity and efficiency of the proposed control strategies.
reference value; Pdc and Pdc* are the actual active power and
II. BIDIRECTIONAL POWER FLOW CONTROL STRATEGY
the reference value of each distributed generation unit; Kn is
the droop coefficients; the subscripts (1,…,|,are used for
A. Active power droop control of the bidirectional AC/DC
converters representing the source index in the DC subgrid. Generally,
the droop coefficients satisfy to share power proportionally
In the active power control, the droop characteristic of the among distributed generation units
active power is simultaneously related with the AC frequency
K n1 Pdc* ,1 = K n 2 Pdc* ,2 = " = K ny Pdc* , y (6)
and the DC voltage. The two different sets of droop equations
need to be merged before arriving at the final active power Similarly, if we take no account of the internal power
command for the bidirectional AC/DC converter. The active distribution of the AC subgrid tentatively, and regard it as the
power droop control characteristic of the distributed power source that can provide active power flow (inflow or
generations in AC subgrid is first introduced. According to the outflow) to the DC subgrid according to the DC bus voltage
measured AC bus frequency, the active power output can be deviation, then the droop function of the active power and the
available using the droop characteristic described as DC voltage is
*
ω ac = ω ac
*
+ K m1 ( Pac* ,1 − Pac ,1 ) U dc = U dc + K nz ( Pac* → dc − Pac → dc ) (7)
° (1) where Pac → dc and Pac* → dc are the active power flow and the
®"
°ω = ω * + K ( P * − P ) reference value from AC to DC subgrid, respectively; Knz is
¯ ac ac mx ac , x ac , x the corresponding droop coefficient and can be obtained as
where ωac and ωac
*
are the measured AC frequency and the P max − Pacmin (8)
K nz = ac → dc → dc
reference value; Pac and Pac* are the actual active power and the U dc max − U dc min
reference value of each distributed generation unit; Km is the where Pacmax min
→ dc and Pac → dc are the maximum and minimum power
corresponding droop coefficients; the subscripts flow from AC to DC subgrid, Udcmax and Udcmin are the
(1,…,{,represent the source index in the AC subgrid. To maximum and minimum DC voltage, respectively. Therefore,
make distributed generation units share the load demand in (5) and (7) jointly describe the droop characteristic of the
proportion to their capacity, the droop coefficients should sources and loads that connected to the DC bus.
satisfy In the hybrid microgrid, the two different kinds of power
Km1Pac* ,1 = Km2 Pac* ,2 = " = Kmx Pac* ,x (2) droop characteristic of the AC bus frequency and the DC bus
As for the DC subgrid connected to AC bus through the voltage should be managed for the proper power flow of the
bidirectional AC/DC converters, if we take no account of its bidirectional AC/DC converters. Thus it should be a kind of
internal power distribution tentatively, and regard it as the ‘‘bidirectional’’ droop control with the form of
power source that can provide power flow (inflow or outflow) Pac ↔ dc = P0 + K 1 (ω ac − ω ac
*
) + K 2 (U dc − U dc* ) (9)
to the AC subgrid according to the AC bus frequency
where Pac ↔ dc is the power flow among the AC and DC
deviation, then the droop function of its active power and the
frequency is subgrids and P0 is the reference value; K1 and K2 are the droop
2018 13th IEEE Conference on Industrial Electronics and Applications (ICIEA) 1763
coefficients of " Pac ↔ dc − ωac " and " Pac ↔ dc − U dc " , respectively. The parameters should satisfy
The bidirectional droop control uses the AC bus frequency and P0i K1i K 2i Pi ∗
= = = . (13)
DC bus voltage as the input to manage active power flow P0 j K1j K 2j Pj∗
between the two subgrids according to system operating state
(The positive direction is defined as AC side to DC side). where i and j represent two different bidirectional AC/DC
With the droop control in the whole hybrid microgrid, the converters with their power ratings are Pi ∗ and Pj∗ . Since all
distributed generation units can share proper power and the interlinking converters are connected in parallel to the AC and
plug-and-play feature is ensured. DC bus, all converters can share the active power proportional
Since the power flow between AC and DC subgrids satisfies with their ratings at steady state.
° Pac ↔ dc = Pac → dc = − Pac ← dc (10) B. Reactive power control of the bidirectional AC/DC
® * *
°̄ P0 = Pac → dc = − Pac ← dc converter
the two droop coefficients K1 and K2 are derived as (11) The reactive power control of the bidirectional AC/DC
together with (4) and (8) converter is relatively easy to implement as it is only relevant
1 to the AC bus voltage amplitude. The bidirectional converter
° K1 = K + K can supply reactive power for the AC subgrid to maintain AC
° mz nz
® (11) bus voltage at the rated value with the constant AC bus
°K = −1
voltage control. Nevertheless, the reference reactive power can
°¯ 2 K mz + K nz
be set as zero for unity power factor operation and less
Finally, the active power droop control of the bidirectional capacity burden of the bidirectional converter.
AC/DC converter can be available as
ωac* III. SMALL SIGNAL MODELING AND THE CHARACTERISTICS
_ ANALYSIS
ωac + 1 P0
K1 = A. Small signal modeling of the bidirectional AC/DC
Kmz + Knz + + Pref converter
+ To analyze the characteristics of the active power control
U dc + −1
K2 = strategy, it is essential to conduct the small signal analysis.
_ K mz + K nz The topological structure of the converter is shown is Fig.4.
U dc* G1 G3
idc
G5
Fig. 3. Active power control of the bidirectional AC/DC converter P, Q
1764 2018 13th IEEE Conference on Industrial Electronics and Applications (ICIEA)
U = G ( s ) i
° d1 id ( dref − id ) where Gp(s) the power PI control for tracking the reference
power command.
® (16)
¯ (
°U q1 = Giq ( s ) iqref − iq) In the AC/DC hybrid microgrid, the bidirectional converter
can help to transfer power between subgrids to realize the
where Gid(s) and Giq(s) are the PI control function. Furtherly,
reasonable power sharing. Therefore, the dynamic
it has
characteristics of the AC frequency and the DC voltage are
° id (
G ( s ) i )
dref − id = ( R + Ls ) id related not only with the supply-demand balancing of the DGs
® (17)
( )
and the loads, but also with the power flow of the converter.
°Giq ( s ) iqref − iq = ( R + Ls ) iq For the convenience of analysis, it is supposed that there is
¯
To conduct the small signal analysis, the state variables are only one source in both AC subgrid and DC subgrid. Then the
written as the sum of the steady state and small disturbance, small signal models of the source are shown in (24) with the
that is id = I d + Δid and iq = I q + Δiq By ignoring the consideration of the transmission power of the bidirectional
converter.
second order disturbance term, the small signal equations of
the inner current loop is shown in (18) °Δω ( s ) = − Km ( ΔPac ( s ) + ΔP ( s ) )
® (24)
Δid ( s )
=
Gid ( s ) °̄ΔU dc ( s ) = − Kn ( ΔPdc ( s ) − ΔP ( s ) )
°
° Δidref ( s ) R + Ls + Gid ( s ) where ΔP is the transmission power of the bidirectional
® (18)
° Δiq ( s ) = Giq ( s ) converter; ΔPac and ΔPdc are the load variation in AC subgrid
¯ qref ( s ) R + Ls + Giq ( s )
° Δi and DC subgrid, respectively; Merging (23) and (24), the
small signal closed loop transfer functions of " Δω − ΔPac "
The small signal model of the outer power loop of the
converter is then deduced. It is supposed that the d axis of the and " Δ U dc − Δ Pdc " are shown in (25).
rotating coordinate coincides with the a axis of the three- Δω ( s ) Km
phase static coordinate, and the unity power factor operation is °TFac ( s ) = − =
° Δ Pac ( )
s 1 + K m Gω ( s )
adopted, then it has Eq = 0 and iq = 0 . Thus the transmission ® (25)
°TF s = − ΔU dc ( s ) = Kn
power of the converter is ° dc ( ) ΔPdc ( s ) 1 − K nGU ( s )
¯
ωc 3
P= ⋅ Ed id To analyze the response characteristics of the AC bus
(19)
s + ωc 2 frequency and DC bus voltage of the bidirectional AC/DC
where ω c is the corner frequency of the low pass filter. converter, the pole-zero map of the small signal model (25) is
Similarly, the small signal equation of the power is shown as plotted in Fig. 8 with the varying droop gain Km.
ωc 3
ΔP = ⋅ ( Ed Δid + ΔEd id ) (20)
s + ωc 2
According to the superposition theorem, it can be deduced in
(21) with Laplace transformation
ΔP 3 ωc Ed
° Δi = 2 s + ω =G1 ( s )
° d c
® (21)
ΔP 3 ω i
° = c d
= G2 ( s )
°¯ ΔEd 2 s + ωc
With the same approach, the small signal model of the
bidirectional droop power control transmitted by the converter
is shown in (22).
ΔPref = K1Δω + K 2 ΔU dc (22)
where Δω and ΔU dc are the deviation of the AC frequency
and DC voltage. Furtherly, the small signal closed loop
transfer functions of the control are obtained as following with Fig. 5. Pole-zero map of TFac(s) with varying droop gain Km
(18), (21) and (22)
ΔP ( s ) G1 ( s ) Gid ( s ) G p ( s ) K1
° = =Gω ( s )
° Δω ( s ) Ls + R + Gid ( s ) + Gid ( s ) G1 ( s ) G p ( s )
®
° ΔP ( s ) G1 ( s ) Gid ( s ) G p ( s ) K 2
° ΔU ( s ) = Ls + R + G ( s ) + G ( s ) G ( s ) G ( s ) =GU ( s )
¯ dc id id 1 p
(23)
2018 13th IEEE Conference on Industrial Electronics and Applications (ICIEA) 1765
(a) Active power in AC microgrid
Fig. 6. Pole-zero map of TFdc(s) with varying droop gain Km (b) Active power in DC microgrid
It can be concluded that there are two poles and two zeros
both of TFac ( s ) and TFdc ( s ) . Among these poles and zeros,
two zeros and one pole are fixed during the varying of droop
gain Km and all located in the left half of the imaginary axis.
One pair of pole-zero are constituted as dipoles and they have
no much influence on system stability. Another pole is varying
with the change of parameter Km and is the closed loop
dominant pole. As for TFac ( s ) in Fig.5, the varying pole (c) Reactive power in AC microgrid
moves away from the imaginary axis with the increasing of
droop gain Km. And for TFdc ( s ) in Fig.6, the varying pole
moves towards the fixed zero z2 with the increasing of droop
gain Km but will not cross the fixed zero. The varying pole
plays a role in the system stable operation and the power
distribution of the microgrid. Thus the coordinated and
autonomous power flow between the two subgrids not only
relies on the transmission power of the bidirectional AC/DC (d) AC bus frequency
converter, but also has relationship with the proportional
power sharing among distributed generations in each AC
subgrid and DC subgrid.
1766 2018 13th IEEE Conference on Industrial Electronics and Applications (ICIEA)
the rated reactive capacity in AC subgrid, the transmission [2] J. M. Guerrero, M. Chandorkar, T. L. Lee, and P. C. Loh, “Advanced
reactive power of the bidirectional AC/DC converter from DC control architectures for intelligent microgrids—Part I: Decentralized
and hierarchical control,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 60, no. 4, pp.
subgrid to AC subgrid is 10kVar. Although the active load in 1254– 1262, Apr. 2013.
AC subgrid increases to 45kW at t = 3s, the balance of power [3] J. M. Guerrero, P. C. Loh, T. L. Lee, and M. Chandorkar, “Advanced
supply and demand can still be satisfied, which means it is still control architectures for intelligent microgrids—Part II: Power quality,
no need for the bidirectional AC/DC converter to transmit energy storage, and AC/DC microgrids,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron.,
active power. However, when the active load in AC subgrid vol. 60, no. 4, pp. 1263–1270, Apr. 2013.
increases to 85kW at t = 4s, the DGs in AC subgrid can only [4] V. Nasirian, S. Moayedi, A. Davoudi, and F. Lewis, “Distributed
cooperative control of dc microgrids,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron.,
supply rated 80kW active power and the lacking 5 kW is vol. 30, no. 4, pp. 2288–2303, Apr. 2015.
supplied by distributed generations in DC subgrid through the [5] F. Nejabatkhah, Y. W. Li, “Overview of power management strategies
bidirectional AC/DC converter. Because of rated active power of hybrid AC/DC microgrid,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 30, no.
the AC distributed generations supplied, the AC bus frequency 12, pp. 7072–7089, Dec. 2015.
can be maintained at 50Hz. At the same time, the AC bus [6] U. B. Tayab, M. A. B. Roslan, L. J. Hwai, et al., “A review of droop
voltage can also be maintained at 380V since the bidirectional control techniques for microgrid,” Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., vol. 76,
pp. 717–727, Sep. 2017.
AC/DC converter can supply required reactive power. The DC
subgrid is all along in light load condition so the DC voltage is [7] Y. Sun, X. Hou, J. Yang, et al., “New perspectives on droop control in
AC microgrid,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron., vol. 64, no. 7, pp. 5741–
a little more than 700V, which reflects the deviating 5745, Jul. 2017.
characteristic of droop control. [8] P. C. Loh, D. Li, Y. K. Chai, and F. Blaabjerg, “Hybrid AC-DC
microgrids with energy storages and progressive energy flow tuning,”
V. CONCLUSION IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 28, no. 4, pp. 1533–1543, Apr. 2013.
In this paper, the two kinds power droop characteristic of [9] P. Ch. Loh, D. Li, Y. K. Chai, and F. Blaabjerg, “Autonomous operation
AC and DC distributed generation units are described as the of hybrid microgrid with AC and DC subgrids,” IEEE Trans. Power
Electron., vol. 28, no. 5, pp. 2214–2223, May. 2013.
droop characteristic of AC bus and DC bus of the bidirectional
AC/DC converter. Then a novel active power control strategy [10] P. Ch. Loh, D. Li, Y. K. Chai, and F. Blaabjerg, “Autonomous control of
interlinking converter with energy storage in hybrid AC–DC microgrid,”
of the bidirectional AC/DC converter based on the IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 49, no. 3, pp. 1374–1383, May 2013.
bidirectional droop characteristic is proposed to realize the [11] N. Eghtedarpour and E. Farjah, “Power control and management in a
power balance and independent sharing of the hybrid hybrid AC/DC microgrid,” IEEE Trans. Smart Grid, vol. 5, no. 3, pp.
microgrid. Simulation results show the validity and efficiency 1494–1505, May 2014.
of the proposed control strategies. [12] D. R. Aryani and H. Song, “Coordination control strategy for AC/DC
hybrid microgrids in stand-alone mode,” Energies, vol. 9, no. 6, Jun.
VI. REFERENCES 2016
[1] A. M. Bouzid et al., “A survey on control of electric power distributed
generation systems for microgrid applications,” Renew. Sustain. Energy
Rev., vol. 44, pp. 751–766, Apr. 2015.
2018 13th IEEE Conference on Industrial Electronics and Applications (ICIEA) 1767