Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
GEOLOGY
Abstract
Sand samples were collected along 34 beach profiles spanning the 240~km length of the Nile Delta in order to
examine the sorting patterns of heavy minerals that develop during cross-shore and alongshore sediment transport.
Factor analysis of the heavy-mineral contents shows that two mineral factors or groups result from sorting due to the
contrasting densities and sizes of the grains. One factor is dominated by augite, hornblende and epidote, while the
second factor consists of opaques, garnet, zircon, rutile and monazite. Minerals of factor 1 are of lower densities and
coarser sizes, and represent the grains that are selectively entrained by waves and currents in areas of beach erosion
and preferentially transported to zones of beach accretion where they are deposited. The higher-density minerals of
factor 2 tend to become concentrated in areas of beach erosion, accounting for the formation of black-sand placers
where the erosion has been greatest.
The spatial distributions of these two factors reflect the grain-sorting patterns of the heavy minerals which
coincide with the general trends of shoreline erosion versus accretion that exist along the length of the delta. There
is also a distinctive pattern of cross-shore sorting, with factor 2 containing the denser minerals being best developed
within the inner surf zone, generally with a maximum at the shoreline. Its development corresponds to the formation
of black-sand concentrates on the beach face where erosion has been greatest, implying that grain sorting has taken
place mainly within the swash zone. There is a general decrease in factor 2 relative to factor 1 toward the offshore,
often with oscillations that are congruent with the beach topography; factor 1 with the lower-density minerals is
greatest over offshore bars where deposition has prevailed.
line erosion the sand becomes concentrated in compared with those areas that have experienced
opaques, zircon, rutile and garnet, the higher- long-term net accretion.
density minerals within the beach sand, while the
lower-density hornblende as well as the quartz
and feldspars are transported alongshore and de- 2. Study site and sample collection
posited in areas of shoreline accretion.
The investigation by Frihy and Komar (1991) The study area extends along the 240&m length
was limited to analyses of a series of sand sam- of the Nile Delta (Fig. 0, from Alexandria in the
ples from the beach face, and therefore could west to Port Said at the north end of the Suez
only examine the patterns of alongshore grain Canal. The sandy shoreline of the delta is charac-
sorting, not those which may have occurred in the terized by two promontories associated with the
cross-shore direction along beach profiles. The Rosetta and Damietta branches of the Nile River
objective of the present study is to extend the which have delivered sediments to the Mediter-
mineral analyses into the offshore in order to ranean Sea during recent centuries. Between
more fully document the patterns of grain sorting them is the remnant pre-modern Burullus
that occur when certain stretches of coast erode promontory, which was formed by sediments dis-
Burullus
Promontory Damietta
Rosetta
Promontory
Fig. 1. The Nile Delta coast, showing the positions of the 34 beach profiles where sand samples have been collected and analyzed
for their heavy-mineral contents. The arrows depict the broad patterns of longshore sediment transport as deduced by Frihy et al.
(1991). The wave-rose diagram is derived from the study of Nafaa et al. (1991) and shows the expected dominance of waves from
the northwest due to their generation along the length of the Mediterranean Sea.
0. E. Frihy et al. /Sedimentary Geology 97 (I 995) 33-41 35
charged from the former Sebennitic branch of the the length of the delta (Frihy and Komar, 1993).
Nile which existed until about the 9th century These profiles extend offshore to about 6 m wa-
A.D. (Orlova and Zenkovitch, 1974; Arbouille ter depth or to a distance of about 1000 m from
and Stanley, 1991). the fiied baseline. Thirty-four of these profiles
A series of reports and publications have doc- have been selected for analysis in the present
umented the extensive erosion that has occurred study, spanning the length of the delta (Fig. l),
during this century along the promontories of the and spaced at 0.5 to 9 km with the closer spacings
Nile Delta (e.g., Frihy, 1988; Smith and Abdel- being in areas of maximum erosion and shoreline
Kadar, 1988; Frihy et al., 1991; Blodget et al., change.
1991; Lot@ and Frihy, 1993). The greatest ero- Using a grab sampler, bottom sediment sam-
sion has been on the modern Rosetta and Dami- ples were obtained during 1991 at every 100 m
etta promontories, with the maximum shoreline along each of the profile lines, starting at the
recession rates of 106 and 10.4 m/yr, respec- shoreline, yielding a total of 311 samples to be
tively, having occurred near the river mouths. analyzed. Grain-size distributions were based on
This erosion has been induced mainly by dam standard rho-tap sieving. The size fractions rich-
construction on the Nile River which has elimi- est in heavy minerals, the 3-44 fractions, were
nated sand delivery to the coast, although cli- then subjected to heavy-mineral separation using
matic factors may have been important, particu- sodium polytungstate which has a density of 2.8
larly before construction of the Aswan High Dam g/cm3 (Callahan, 1987). The heavy-mineral sepa-
in 1964 (Frihy and Khafagy, 1991). With the elim- rate was mounted on slides in Canada Balsam,
ination of sand delivery to the coast, the contin- and 400 minerals were identified and counted
ued action of waves generated on the Mediter- using the line method. The results of the counting
ranean has resulted in erosion of the promonto- procedure have been converted into weight per-
ries, with the eroded sand generally being trans- centages in order to emphasize potential density
ported alongshore toward the east due to the sorting and to make the results more relevant to
prevailing wave arrival from the northwest (see the formation of black-sand placers in this delta
the representative wave-rose diagram in Fig. 1, environment; mineral densities used in the con-
derived from the study of Nafaa et al., 1991). version are given in Table 1. Q-mode factor anal-
Sand eroded along the Damieta promontory close ysis of Klovan and Imbrie (1971) was performed
to the river mouth is transported to the east on the weight percentages of the 9 mineral species
where it has been deposited along the flank of identified in the analyses for all 311 samples. The
the promontory in the form of a sand spit. Sand objective of this analysis was to derive natural
eroded from the Rosetta promontory is trans- mineral groups that might reveal the cross-shore
ported both to the west into Abu Quir Bay (Fig. and alongshore patterns of grain sorting.
1) and to the east where it is deposited to pro-
duce beach accretion. A third zone of lesser Table 1
erosion (6.5 m/yr> exists along the remnant Bu- Densities of the significant minerals within Nile Delta sands,
rullus promontory, with the eroded sand being and their presence in the two dominant Q-mode factors
transported toward the east and deposited before Mineral Density Q-mode
it reaches the Damietta promontory. The overall W cm”) factor
FACTOR 1
0.6
The dominant heavy minerals in the beach-
sand samples are opaques (magnetite and il- 0.6 -
were limited to sand samples from the beach Nile River Mineralogy (ShukrLl951)
33%
face. That study found two factors which are 29% 29%
I
nearly identical to those obtained here, and the
relative abundances of those two factors matched
the patterns of shoreline accretion versus erosion
along the length of the delta. This is further 6%
illustrated in Fig. 4, which compares the his- t t t 1%
I-- L
togram of heavy-mineral abundances in sand M 0 2 R G E A H
samples from the Nile River near Cairo derived
from the analyses of Shukri (1950, with individ- Erosional Delta Sands
ual shoreline samples collected from erosional 42.6%
0 I I ! I
diagram in Fig. 5 is the beach bathymetry as Thus, the varying beach topography corresponds
determined by the profiles obtained during 1991 roughly to the alongcoast patterns of shoreline
at the time of sediment sampling. In general, recession versus accretion, and both in turn are
steeper profile slopes and greater water depths reflected in the patterns of factor 1 versus factor
exist offshore from the mouths of the Rosetta 2 in Fig. 5.
and Damietta branches of the Nile, correspond- Very broadly, the factor patterns in Fig. 5
ing to the areas of maximum shoreline erosion. reveal a tendency for heavier weightings of factor
Beaches down drift from the zones of erosion, 1 along the eastern half of the delta, with factor 2
along the flanks of the promontories where accre- dominating in the west. This likely results from
tion has occurred, tend to have lower slopes. the overall west to east transport of sediments
0 ’ r ,, , , ,,, , , , , , , ,, , ( , , , , , , ,, ,, , , , , , , , ’
1 5 10 15 20 25 30 34
profiles
B. FACTOR 1
0 50 150
loo kilometers
C. FACTOR 2
Factor Loading
Fig. 5. (A) The bathymetry of the nearshore region of the Nile Delta, based on the 34 beach profiles identified in Fig. 1. (B) The
spatial variations of factor 1 which contains the lower-density heavy minerals and shows maximum weightings in areas of beach
accretion. (C) The spatial variations of factor 2, the higher-density minerals which accumulate in areas of delta erosion. The arrows
depict the paths of longshore and cross-shore sediment transport as inferred by the mineral-sorting patterns.
0. E. Frihy et al. /Sedimentary Geology 97 (1995) 33-41 39
the offshore. Profiles 20 and 28 of Fig. 6 are from sion, selective transport and deposition of the
accretional areas. Profile 20 is from the eastern heavy minerals within the beach sand.
flank of the central Burullus bulge, but is typical The spatial patterns of the two factors (Fig. 5)
of accretional areas in being uniformly dominated show a delta-wide trend of increasing factor 1
by factor 1. Profile 28 is located on the flank of from west to east, that has been interpreted to
the Damietta promontory in the area of the ac- represent the general sorting of the delta sand as
cretional spit. In spite of being in an area of net it is transported toward the east by the prevailing
accretion, this profile shows reasonably high load- waves arriving from the northwest generated
ings of factor 2 with a maximum at the shoreline, along the length of the Mediterranean Sea. There
probably resulting from the longshore transport is also an alongcoast rhythmic cycle between fac-
of the black-sand concentrate that originally tors 1 and 2, with the maximum loadings of factor
formed at the tip of the promontory which is only 2 corresponding to the three delta promontories
7 km west of this profile. Of special interest in (Rosetta, Burullus and Damietta) where shore-
profile 28 are the pronounced undulations in the line erosion has been greater, and factor 1 having
offshore which correspond to positions of bars the maximum weightings within the embayments
(high factor 1) versus the longshore trough (high between the promontories where accretion has
factor 2). This pattern suggests a dominance of prevailed. With this general congruence to the
net erosion within the troughs and accretion of patterns of shoreline erosion, longshore transport
the bars, an observation that agrees with the and shoreline accretion, the alongcoast variation
many studies of bar formation on beaches (Komar, in the factor weightings corresponds to the sub-
1976). Furthermore, shore-parallel sand bars have cells identified by Frihy et al. (19911 based on
been investigated by Manohar (1979) and Nafaa interpretations of the blockage of the sediment
and Frihy (1993) along the Nile Delta coast. transport by jetties, the deflection of inlets, as
Microscopic examinations of sand samples from well as variations in mineralogy and beach-sand
bars show high concentrations of shell fragments grain sizes. This simple alongcoast rhythmicity is
and coarse grains of quartz, similar to shoreline clearest in the eastern half of the delta (Fig. 5),
deposits along accretional areas of the delta: fur- with a greater complexity in the western half due
ther evidence of bar formation by net sand accre- to cross-shore sorting also being important, re-
tion. sulting in a dominance of factor 2 (erosional) in
the inner surf zone and factor 1 (accretional) in
the offshore. The separation of the factors by
4. Summary and discussion cross-shore sorting is shown particularly well by
individual profiles such as those graphed in Fig.
Q-mode factor analysis of heavy-mineral per- 6. These show strong trends of offshore decreases
centages in sand samples collected along beach in factor 2 in areas of the delta where long-term
profiles from the Nile Delta have yielded two erosion has prevailed, with the proportions of the
factors or mineral groups that can be related to factors reflecting the bathyrnetry by distinguishing
patterns of selective grain sorting in the between bars (accretion) and troughs (erosion).
nearshore. Factor 1 consists of heavy minerals of The profiles of Fig. 6 suggest that the pro-
lower density and coarser sizes that tend to be cesses responsible for the sorting of the minerals
preferentially entrained and transported from ar- and their separation into the two factors operate
eas of net erosion to zones of accretion. Factor 2 most strongly within the inner surf zone and are a
contains the opaques and higher-density minerals maximum at the shoreline where erosion is great-
that are more difficult to entrain and therefore est. This observation agrees with the conclusions
tend to remain as a lag where net erosion has of Komar and Wang (1984) and Li and Komar
occurred. Accordingly, the relative weightings of (1992) that the swash of waves on the beach face
the two factors along beach profiles and in the plays an important role in grain sorting, especially
longshore direction reveal the patterns of ero- that leading to the development of black-sand
O.E. Frihy et al. /Sedimentary Geology 97 (1995) 33-41 41
placers. In the case of the Nile Delta sands, this Callahan, J., 1987. A nontoxic heavy liquid and inexpensive
filters for separation of minerals grains. J. Sediment.
would account for the high loadings of factor 2
Petrol., 57: 765-766.
near the shorelines on the Rosetta and Damietta Frihy, O.E., 1988. Nile Delta shoreline changes: aerial photo-
promontories where erosion has been greatest, graphic study of a 28-year period. J. Coastal Res., 4:
visible as high concentrations of black opaques on 597-606.
the beach face at those sites. Factor 2 reaches Frihy, O.E. and Khafagy, A.A., 1991. Climate and induced
changes in relation to shoreline migration trends ;at the
100% on the Rosetta promontory, the area of the
Nile Delta promontories, Egypt. Catena, 18: 197-211.
most extensive development of a black-sand Frihy. O.E. and Komar, P.D., 1991. Patterns of beach-sand
placer along the delta coast. The increase of sorting and shoreline erosion on the Nile Delta. J. Sedi-
factor 1 relative to factor 2 (Figs. 5 and 6) traces ment. Petrol., 61: 544-550.
the movement of the lower-density heavy miner- Frihy, O.E. and Komar, P.D., 1993. Long-term shoreline
changes and the concentration of heavy minerals in beach
als that were selectively eroded and transported
sands of the Nile Delta, Egypt. Mar. Geol., 115: 253-261.
to areas of net accretion. The inferred directions Frihy, O.E., Fanos, M.A., Khafagy, A.A. and Komar. P.D.,
of transport, shown by the arrows in Fig. X, 1991. Nearshore sediment transport patterns along the
suggest that longshore and offshore transport Nile Delta, Egypt. Coastal Eng., 15: 409-429.
have both been important. The results reaffirm Gow, A.J., 1967. Petrographic studies of iron sands and asso-
ciated sediment near Hawera south Taranaki. N.Z. J.
that in the search for marine placers, enhanced
Geol. Geophys., 10: 675-696.
levels of high-density minerals such as the Klovan, J.E. and Imbrie, J., 1971. An algorithm and FOR-
opaques, rutile, zircon and monazite will prefer- TRAN-VI program for large scale factor analysis and
entially develop in coastal areas that have experi- calculation of factor scores. J. Math. Geol., 3: 61-67.
enced long-term erosion, while zones of accretion Komar, P.D., 1976. Beach Processes and Sedimentation.
Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 429 pp.
will correspondingly be depleted in those valu-
Komar, P.D. and Wang, C., 1984. Processes of selective grain
able minerals. transport and the formation of placers on beaches. J.
Geol., 92: 637-655.
Komar, P.D., Clemens, K.E., Li, Z. and Shih, S.-M., 1989. The
Acknowledgements effects of selective sorting on factor analyses of heavy-
mineral assemblages. J. Sediment. Petrol., 59: 590~-596.
Li, M.Z. and Komar, P.D., 1992. Longshore grain sorting and
This study is part of the Egyptian Water Re- beach placer formation adjacent to the Columbia River. J.
search Center Project, sponsored by the United Sediment. Petrol., 62: 429-441.
States Agency for International Development, Lotfy, M.F. and Frihy, O.E., 1993. Sediment balance along
under grant No. 263-0132 to the Consortium of the nearshore zone of the Nile Delta coast, Egypt. J.
International Development at Colorado State Coastal Res., 9: 654-662.
Manohar, M., 1979. Undulated bottom profiles and onshore-
University. We wish to thank Dr. Khafagy, Direc- offshore transport. Proc. 16th Conf. Coastal Engineering,
tor of the Coastal Research Institute, Alexandria, American Society of Civil Engineers, New York, pp. 1454-
for his generous assistance in providing the field 1474.
and laboratory facilities for this study. Nafaa, M.E. and Frihy, O.E., 1993. Beach and nearshore
features along the dissipative coastline of the Nile Delta,
Egypt. J. Coastal Res., 9: 423-433.
Nafaa, M.G., Fanos, A.M. and Elganainy, M.A., 1991. Char-
References acteristics of waves off the Mediterranean coast of Egypt.
J. Coastal Res., 7: 665-676.
Anwar, Y.M. and El Bouseily, A.M., 1970. Subsurface studies Orlova, G. and Zenkovitch, V., 1974. Erosion of the shores of
of the black sand deposits at Rosetta Nile mouth, Egypt. the Nile Delta. Geoforum, 18: 68-72.
Faculty of Science, Univ. Alexandria, Bull. 10, 150 pp. Rao, C.B., 1957. Beach erosion and concentration of heavy
Arbouille, D. and Stanley, D.J., 1991. Late Quaternary evolu- mineral sands. J. Sediment. Petrol., 27: 143-147.
tion of the Burullus Lagoon region, north-central Nile Shukri, N.M., 1951. Mineral analysis tables of some Nile
Delta, Egypt. Mar. Geol., 99: 45-66. sediments. Bulletin de I’Institut Fouad ler du Desert l(l),
Blodget, H.W., Taylor, P.T. and Roar, J.H., 1991. Shoreline 67 PP.
changes along the Rosetta Nile promontory: monitoring Smith, E.S. and Abdel-Kadar, A., 1988. Coastal erosion along
with satellite observations. Mar. Geol., 99: 67-77. the Egyptian Delta. J. Coastal Res., 4: 245-255.