Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
A. Wastewater treatment
Wastewater treatment is of high importance in the present-day industrialized world due to the
fact that more than 97% of the water source in the world is from seas and oceans, saline water,
and 2% of freshwater is not obtainable for human consumption resulting in a very little amount
of water available for consumption. With the increasing world population which also increases
the daily consumption per person that gives substantial load to technology and engineering in
coping up with the demands of water treatment and supply. (Rao, et al., 2013.
(Metcalf and Eddy) If wastewater remain untreated, it will go septic and the organic matter
microorganisms are contained in wastewater that will cause a lot of health problems to the
people exposed to it. It also contains toxic, potential carcinogenic and mutagenic compounds. It
contains nutrients that is a stimulant in the growth of aquatic plants that may disturb the
There are specific ways to treat wastewater based on the pollutants or contaminants present.
1. Physical Methods
2. Biological Methods
3. Chemical Methods
secondary treatment and tertiary treatment. (“Sewage Treatment Process Explained”, n.d., para.
3)
Preliminary Treatment
Removal of wastewater components such as large debris, tree branches, sticks, floating wastes,
rags and oil/fat/grease that may cause operational, maintenance or efficiency problems to the
treatment process (EPA). This stage mainly uses physical methods for the removal of pollutants.
includes, Screening – suspended materials are intercepted with coarse and fine screens and are
mechanically removed for offsite disposal (EPA). Grit Removal – sand, gravel or small stones
are removed to prevent accumulation in the downstream that may cause problems in the process
units (EPA). Oil, Grease and Fat Removal – floatation and skimming mechanism is used for
the removal or oil, fat and grease for these will cause blockages and formation of oil film in the
treatment equipment that will cause excessive requirements for maintenance and reduced
Primary Treatment
Removal of a portion of the organic matter and suspended solids. Sedimentation process is
usually used to remove settleable and floating materials. Preliminary treatment uses physical
methods, but advanced primary treatment uses chemicals or additives to improve the removal of
suspended and dissolved solids (Metcalf and Eddy, page 11) Insert primary treatment diagram
Secondary Treatment
According to the DPWH, secondary treatment process focuses on removing the organic materials
and suspended solids of the primary treatment effluent. Generally, secondary treatment uses
biological methods in removing dissolved and colloidal biodegradable organics using biological
treatment processes. It uses microorganisms to decompose organic materials biologically and can
be aerobic or anaerobic, each procedure utilizing different specific type of bacterial community.
(Use of Reclaimed Water and Sludge in Food Crop Production (1996) Treatment of municipal
Manickam) the basic principle is that air is introduced to the waste water and allows
microorganisms to grow and as they do, they tend to stick together forming a clumped mass
referred to as the “flocs” which will be allowed to settle in the clarifier tank. A part these settled
solids will be disposed and the other will be returned to the aeration tank as the activated sludge
to start the process again. The partly treated water then goes to another treatment process.
composed of varying materials, but the most common ones used are rocks and plastic media. The
filter bed is porous allowing air flow for aerobic activities of the bacteria. Although called a
filter, this process does not actually filter out suspended contaminants in the influent wastewater.
Microorganisms will grow attached to the media, decomposing organic matter as they tickle
down through the filter bed. Partially treated water will then be collected at the bottom of the
(https://denr.sd.gov/des/sw/TricklingFilter.aspx)
Tertiary Treatment
The final cleaning process of wastewater is achieved through the tertiary treatment or the
“polishing” process in which the effluent will have an improved quality, and the quality
requirement will depend on whether it will be discharged to bodies of water or recycled. In this
stage bacteria, pathogenic microorganisms and viruses are removed as well as inorganic
compounds, harmful substances including nitrogen and phosphorus Chlorination is one of the
many ways to disinfect water and is the most common disinfectant used in the Philippines. It is a
chemical method in treating wastewater and uses chlorine or a substance that contains chlorine to
oxidize and disinfect the water. This is mostly done for potable water supply treatment.
Although, it is not limited to the tertiary treatment stage because it can also be done at any point
in the treatment system to address the contaminant of concern – offering a complete span of
treatment from the point of entry to the time treated water is ready for discharge.
B. Biofiltration
carbon and energy sources. Since heterotrophic bacteria are used, it should be provided
that there would be enough surface area in the biofilter, and a wide and extensive flow
path is also provided as these bacteria grow five times faster than the other bacteria.
Biofilters most commonly rely on the activity of mesophilic organisms. In trickling filters
that were used to treat wastewater, the water flows as a liquid film on the biofilm surface,
while sufficient distance was kept between the support media to accommodate biomass
growth and air, which provides oxygen for the biodegradation reaction, is designed
(Rakesh G. , 2009). The contaminants, present in the waste water, diffuse into the biofilm
as the water flows over the biofilms, and biodegrades. For optimum metabolism it is said
maintained between 20 and 40 °C (68 and 105 °F). Operation of the filter at higher
less than 10 °C (50 °F) performance decreases rapidly, mainly as a result of reduced rates
Biofiltration is widely used and claimed to be one of the most vital stage in an
organic removal processes removing organic pollutants from water, air, and wastewater.
Because of its consistent TOC (Total Organic Carbon) and economical factor in
Compaction should be kept to a minimum, reducing the need for maintenance and
replacement of the filter material. Use a filtration rate of two inches per hour for sand and
soil. Maintaining an optimum moisture content in the filter material is the major
weight is considered optimal. Clogging often is the cause of premature failure of storm
water (bio)filtration devices. Chemical Treatment by Media Contact time and media
Increase reactive surface and durability, reduce back pressure and extend the filter
material's useful life. Develop moisture management and process control strategies to
maintain compost and cover materials in an acceptable range. Moisture content affects
microbial activity as well as the physical structure in the composting process. The media
performance studies have advanced significantly the ability to optimize the design and
effectiveness of advanced filtration-based storm water controls, such as those that have
Biofiltration Techniques
growth, and detachment of biomass was observed together with the mathematical
modeling approach to determine the proper elements to enhance the performance of the
biofilter.
Incorporating mathematical model with the biofilter parameters set to the different
operating conditions would clarify the effectiveness of the model to be used in practice.
In the Design Considerations, the parameters that can affect the performance of a biofilter
are filter media, hydraulic and organic loading, and filter backwash techniques.
The biofilter affects the level of BDOC (Biodegradable Dissolved Organic Carbon) in the
effluent. As a result, the longer the contact period, the lower the BDOC level will be. In
the hydraulic and organic loading rate, the main reason of organics being removed from
the effluent lies in the contact time and not in the organic loading rate. However, unlike
the previous parameters, backwashing does not make any difference in terms of vertical
Contaminated air passing through soil, peat, or compost, the naturally present
microorganisms also begin to biodegrade the air contaminants. Because of this, Soil
biofilters are developed, in which soil with low clay and high organic carbon content was
packed in a bed and contaminated air was passed through the soil bed to biodegrade the
air contaminants in which at the end they were able to stop the contamination.
Another problem encountered were settling of the compost, resulting in increased gas-
maintenance, and drying of the compost material due to moisture transferring to the
flowing gas phase. But by adding wood chips, which provided mechanical support to
minimize settling, humidifying the inlet air to maintain proper water content in the
compost material, adding lime pellets for pH control, and fortifying the compost with
fertilizers containing nitrogen and phosphorus compounds. Making the settling of the
compost was preventing and thus preventing the increase of moisture transfer (Rakesh,
2009).
Another technique uses two filtering media, sand and granular activated carbon.
The influence of pre-ozonation and empty-bed contact time (EBCT, from 30 to 120 min)
was determined. Using a real Wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) effluent, the
activity had developed on the filtering media and dissolved organic removal had reached
a steady state before sampling commenced. The results show that biological activated
carbon (BAC) has a good potential for the removal of DOC (35–60%), PPCPs (>90%)
and baseline-TEQ (28–68%) even without pre-ozonation. On the contrary, the sand
shows limited improvement of effluent quality. Varying the EBCT does not influence the
Designing a Biofilter
When designing a biofilter, one should note that Heterotrophic bacteria grow 5
times faster than Chemotrophic bacteria such as Nitrosomonas sp. which is used to
remove ammonia in aquaculture. One solution to this is to remove BOD and provide
extra surface are in biofilter. This slows the growth of Heterotrophic bacteria and allows
various bacteria to grow. Providing a long flow path in the biofilter will also help reduce
the ratio of heterotrophic bacteria in the overall population of microbes. Different zones
A problem with aerobic filters, which are used to convert nitrates into N2, is that it
removes N2 too slowly. Rather than relying on the aerobic filter to do all the removal of
N2, Nitrates can be removed by discharging a small amount of water from the system.
This method is sufficient enough to remove most of the N2 and is less expensive to
Activated Sludge System (+) Removes BOD (-) Does not provide effluent
(+) Commonly used water quality necessary for
aquaculture.
Fluidized Bed Sand Filters (+) Pack more biologically (-) high energy requirement
active surface area (-) bed depth will vary as time
(+) Small footprint, good for goes on because of biofilm
small space
(+) Self-cleaning; tolerates
different nutrient loadings
Submerged Bed Filter (+) can operate without (-) difficult to remove
aeration and in any reservoir suspended solids
(+) space efficient
(+) removes BOD
(+) allows nitrification
C. Steel Slags
In America, an average of 10-15 million tons of steel slags are generated every year and
about 15-40% of it are dumped in the steel plants and slag disposal sites. That is why it is
important to utilize these slags in civil engineering in order to reduce the disposal and dumping
Having knowledge about the properties of steel slags is very important because it plays
an essential role for the application to civil engineering innovations. Also knowledge in
steelmaking and refining to produce these materials as by product is also required to utilize steel
slags. This article is all about the slag generation and properties of steel slags. Moreover, the
mineralogical and morphological characteristics of steel slag samples generated from two steel
plants in Indiana were evaluated through XRD analyses and SEM studies.
c. Ladle Slag
d.
This type of furnace is common in integrated steel mills which are associated with blast
furnace. It is consist of approximately 10-20% steel scrap and 80-90% molten iron. Steel scraps
plays an important role in cooling the furnace and maintain a steady temperature in order to
successful chemical reaction. In the figure below shows a schematic diagram in order to fully
First, steel scrap is charged to the furnace and after that 200 tons of molten iron is poured
on top of it. Next an oxygen lance is lowered in the surface which blows oxygen on the charge
then oxidation reactions remove the impurities of the charge. The scrap is thereby melted, and
the carbon content of the molten iron is lowered. In order to remove the unwanted chemical
elements of the melt, the furnace is also charged with fluxing agents, such as lime (CaO) or
dolomite (MgCa(CO3)2), during the oxygen blowing cycles. Then slags are produced because of
the steelmaking process and it floats on top of molten steel. The slag generated from a
steelmaking cycle is later processed, and the final product after processing is referred to as basic-
This type of furnace uses high power electric arcs to produce heat in order to melt steel
scraps and turn it into steel. This furnace is composed of graphite electrodes. The process starts
by charging the steel scrap to the furnace, then it is lowered into the furnace. An arc is struck
after that which causes electricity to travel through the electrodes and the metal itself. By this
process it generates heat which melts the metal. As it continues to melt, a liquid steel is produced
at the bottom of the furnace. Afterwhich the steel undergoes a refining period. Then the
impurities generated are oxidized during the oxygen injections which combines with lime to
form a slag. Then the slag and steel are tapped out to different ladles.
In this furnace, the steel created by means of Basic Oxygen and Electric Arc Furnace can
be refined more to attain the chemical composition best suited for steel. This is what we cakk a
secondary steelmaking operation. In order to make high grade steels, they undergo this process.
Final desulfurization, degassing of oxygen, nitrogen and hydrogen, removal of impurities and
final decarburization. The schematic diagram below shoes how ladle refining process occurs.
Chemical Composition of Slags
Both slags are almost the same in chemical and mineralogical composition. They are both
made up of calcium oxide and iron oxide making it its major constituents. Here is a table of the
chemical composition of the different slags. The main chemical constituents of the basic-oxygen-
furnace slag are CaO, FeO, and SiO2. EAF slag is pretty similar to that of BOF slag. The EAF
steelmaking process is essentially a steel scrap recycling process. Therefore, the chemical
composition of EAF slag depends son the properties of the recycled steel. Compared to BOF
slags, the main chemical constituents of EAF slags can differ. Typically, the FeO, CaO, SiO2,
Al2O3, and MgO contents of EAF slags are in the 10–40%, 22–60%, 6–34%, 3–14%, and 3–
13% ranges, respectively.Information regarding the ladle slags are limited but it is said that its
Crystal formation normally occurs for both slags in their chemical composition. Several
researchers studied the mineralogical composition of steel slags. X-ray diffraction analysis of
steel slag samples shows a complex structure with many overlapping peaks reflecting the
crystalline phases present in steel slag. These crystalline phases appear to be mainly due to the
chemical composition of steel slag and the slow cooling rate applied during processing. Due to
the presence of unstable phases in its mineralogy, steel slags can show volumetric instability,
caused mainly by the presence of free CaO. In the presence of water, free lime hydrates and
forms portlandite (Ca(OH)2). Portlandite has a lower density than CaO and, hence, hydration of
free CaO results in volume increase as said by Irem Zeynep Yildirim et al.
D. Removal of Phosphorus
Removal of phosphorus in wastewater most especially with an influent flowrate under the
value of 3600L/d causes a problem because we can’t apply small scale phosphorus removal
technologies to large scale facilities. This is where steel slags come into picture. Steel slags have
a high rate of phosphorus removal effieciency and it is also cost effective and efficient with low
operation and maintenance needed. The basis for this is a study which is steel slag filters were
fed with synthetic domestic wastewater, real domestic wastewater and a fish farm effluent which
results to a low concentration levels of phosphorus (0.1 mg P/L). Even with these studies,
Domestic wastewater treatment with an influent flowrate below 3600L/d cannot be commonly
applied to steel slag filters due to the need of neutralizing the alkaline effluent and the costly
The problem in using steel slags as filter media is the dramatic drop in phosphorus
removal efficiency which leads to exhaustion. Exhaustion of slags may require to replacement of
slag filters from time to time. This will need more research about its longevity and design. In
previous studies conducted, they did not consider the particulate phosphorus in steel slags filter
because they mainly put their attention on the o-PO4 removal which may alter the results of the
treatment because not all the phosphorus are treated. Therefore the aim of this article is to make
an efficient phosphorus removal system using steel slag filters which can be used in
decentralized applications.
The key in the exhaustion functions is to determine the reaction of a slag sample in
different tests by batch. For each test, the saturation pH and dissolution kinetic constant were
determined by numerical inversion. Three exhaustion functions were measured on three 300-g
slag samples with particle size of 2–3 mm, 3–5 mm and 16–23 mm. Slag was sieved in the
laboratory. Batch tests were conducted with 700 mL of synthetic wastewater composed of tap
The goal is to make a phosphorus removal system by applying steel slag filters and
maintenance needs of the filter media. Slag exhaustion are determined by using 2–3 mm, 3–
5 mm, 5–10 mm and 16–23 mm slag measurements. Furthermore three steel slag columns with
particle sizes of 2–3 mm, 3–5 mm and 5–10 mm were fed with the effluent of an
aerated lagoon during 589 days. Next a barrel reactor test was used to be fed during a year with
the effluent of an attached growth aerated biological reactor. Afterwhich, the phosphorus
concentration at the effluent of the 2–3 mm and 3–5 mm columns and barrel reactor test was
between 0.04 and 0.3 mg P/L. The P-Hydroslag model was used and calibrated by using the data
obtained in the column test and the barrel reactor test which then it is used to simulate a long
term operation of a slag barrel reactor. The longevity of the filter media was greatly affected by
the influent alkalinity. The estimated life span is 7 years on 50g of Calcium Carbonate per liter
while 2 years fir an influent with 210 milligrams of calcium carbonate per liter. Lastly the
Exhaustion Functions
4 slag particle sizes are measured in this phase, each has different starting saturation
which indicates that the mineralogical composition at the surface of slag is affected by particle
sizes. Calcium oxide of the slag’s leaching capacity is proportional to the specific surface thus, it
The iron and steel slag aggregates ability to reduce the phosphorus and heavy metals
from wastewater has been seen in small-scale studies. However the use of these materials for
wastewater treatment is irregular low due to various reasons. For this paper they will conduct a
study about the potential of Australian slags to remove heavy metals from storm water.
In the environmental impact assessment of steel and slag aggregates was retrieved from
different sources in the internet. The data gathered was examined for potential environmental
contaminants caused by these slags. They tested six different slags under laboratory conditions
for storm water treatment. In Australia, Environmental Protection Agency showed a table about
Table 1: Slag origins, type and code used in the filtration study.
Metals Symbol
Aluminium Al
Antimony Sb
Arsenic As
Boron B
Barium Ba
Beryllium Be
Cadmium Cd
Chromium (total) Cr
Copper Cu
Lead Pb
Manganese Mn
Mercury Hg
Molybdenum Mo
Nickel Ni
Selenium Se
Tin Sn
Zinc Zn
The ability of slags to remove contaminants was examined by irrigation filter media with
synthetic storm water which contains phosphorus and nitrogen and the M17 metals and
measuring the concentration in the resulting leachate. The usefulness of iron and steel slags are
In this study slag materials are chosen and supplied and it underwent X-ray fluorescence
analysis. They are also tested for their retention capacity by six applications of storm water. The
stored storm water, is not stable, with solid and dissolved fractions of contaminants changing
over time. Copper and Zinc are contaminants that are commonly present in the storm water.
Therefore we can say that this study indicates that slags should be always tested for their
performance properties. All of the slag aggregates in this study can pass as storm water filter
media and can be an alternative to for sand in filtration. It can also be potentially used for landfill
leachate, agricultural, domestic and industrial wastewater. They can make an important
contribution to the treatment of water as standalone filters. The principal limitation is pH with
some slags, care being required to ensure that biota in the receiving water body will not be
further make a study about slags in order to know its viability more.
Phosphorus is important for biomass growth in our ecosystem, but too much of it causes
an extreme growth of algae which reduces the quality of our water. Research on cost effective
techniques to remove phosphorus in water treatment is needs attention. Stabilization pond and
constructed wetlands are one of the types of treatment used to improve the quality of water.
In testing for materials to be used in making these biological treatment, steel slags has the
potential to be a filter substrate for treating water. Steel slag types are commonly BOF and EAF
which is composed of iron and calcium minerals. Many studies have stated that it is suitable
material for reducing phosphorus in our degraded waters but, huge variation in experimental
variables like lag size, inlet P concentration, filter volume, hydraulic retention time, and loading
mode brings different results to different studies that is why we need more research to refine the
different parameters. In this study six filters are filled with EAF and BOF slags with varying
sizes. This study focuses on the comparison of Phosphorus removal performance and the critical
This indicates that the slags has produces high pH and Calcium concentrations in the
effluents which leads to Calcium Oxide dissolution during water filtration. he higher CaO
content of BOF-slag (Table 4) should account for the higher outlet pH and Ca2+ concentrations
observed using BOF-slag. Also, small-size BOF-slag produced higher pH and Ca2+
concentrations than big-size BOF-slag, most likely because the smaller is the size, the greater is
the specific surface available for CaO dissolution, as already reported by Anjab (2009).
removal appears to improve if we increase the Calcium Oxide content of the slag and by
decreasing the slag size. According to the studies published in the literature, the saturated flow
seemed to be the best condition to reduce the dissolution of atmospheric CO2 in the water and,
therefore, to avoid excessive CaCO3 precipitation (Chazarenc et al., 2007). Claveau-Mallet et al.
(2012) investigated the effect of the water velocity on P removal performances of EAF-slag
filters.
However, as shown in Table 1, the high pH of the slag filter effluents may represent an
environmental problem in natural ecosystems. The use of larger slag size and/or shorter HRTv
may be a viable solution to (i) reduce the specific surface available for CaO dissolution, and (ii)
reduce the contact time water to slag surface, thus limiting the increase in pH of the effluent. In
addition, peat filters can be used to further reduce the pH of the slag filter units (Vohla et al.,
2011).
EAF and BOF slags generated in Europe are suitable to be a filter substrate which aims to
remove the Phosphorus from the effluent of small wastewater treatment plants like stabilization
ponds and artificial wetlands. Slag Type, slag size and slag composition alters the performance
which is stated by the data gathered for the six sample filters. The smaller the slag size the better
the performance for removing Phosphorus and by increasing the Calcium Oxide content in slag
Even though using small size slags are efficient than big size slags, the facility is at risk
in regards to the clogging of filter therefore it is recommended to use slags 5mm larger than the
In steel-making, after water quenching and allegro cooling a granular substance remains,
which is the grain-slag. The grain-slag occupies a large area of cultivated land and contaminates
the environment when disposed by steel mills. A filter made with grain-slag as the raw material
is used as biofilm support of Biological Aerated Filter (BAF). This filter can lower the pH of
wastewater by stripping calcium carbonate (CaCO3) and keeps an optimal nitrification rate.
Filter Particle Density Porosity Biomass of Leachability of
hydrochloric acid. The slag contains 34.77% CaO which can possibly dissolve out CaCO3.
Biofilters were backwashed periodically to remove collected steel slag and the produced
biomass.
Using grain-slag in BAF was superior than that with haydite in removing ammonia
nitrogen. The increase in removal of ammonia nitrogen acquires the buffering pH value capacity
of the grain-slag. Grain-slag has a lower rate of removing organic matter, turbidity and colourity
Biological aerated filters are reactors with fixed film media that sues a certain media with
a specific surface area for treatments of wastewater. In this process carbon removal, solid
filtration and nitrification occurs. This treatment is efficient when there is small lot area. It also
has a filter media that provides large surface area per unit volume and removes suspended solids.
The type of filter and its size are the factors that determines the operational and maintenance cost
of the filter. Finding the right media is crucial in the design process of this treatment because
there is a certain standard used for the effluent produced. In this study, grain-slag’s efficiency is
Haydite and grain slags is going to be used as a biofilm in the biological aerated filter to
treat domestic wastewater. The objective of this study is to see the difference of the ammonium
nitrogen removal performance of the BAF reactors and the comparison of the influent pH values
and ammonia nitrogen load rates. The grain-slag BAF and haydite BAF had ammonia nitrogen
In road construction, slags are used as aggregates and it is spread and compacted in the
pavement to further reinforce the road. It is also used as road base course material. It is also used
as an asphalt mixture.
In ground improvement material, slags are used to enhance the soft soil. They make the
ground compact by the sand compaction pile. They use the slags as a substitute aggregates.
In fertilizing soil, by using the slags it helps in yielding and increasing the crops. It
prevents the invasion of bacteria and insects due to the silicic acid settling on the surface of the
leaves. It also enhances photosynthesis because it sets the leaves in an upright position and
causes red/blue tieds and reduces seaweed beds in the coastal areas. By applying the BOF slag in
the affected areas we might solve this problem because of its chemical composition.
Steel slag hydrated matrix is a friendly concrete block substitute that doesn’t use natural
aggregate instead it uses a granulated blast arc furnace slag to act as a binder for the concrete. It
and effectively for various purposes and it can play a key role as an effective civil engineering
material substitute. It can also be used to prevent the eutrophication of the water sources.
Therefore, slags can also be applied to treat wastewater because steel slags has a component
which can improve the quality of water. Because of this, we must invest more time in conducting
a study regarding the different capabilities of steel slags as a filter media or as a key material for
wastewater treatment.
H. Wetland Technology
Constructed wetland technology is being used in the industry because it has few
discharge standards, it is relatively cheaper than other wastewater treatment method and the
instruments used are mainly on site. The potential of this technology is great but only few
country is adapting for this technology and its advancement is relatively slow. China, Kenya,
Mexico, Nepal, Nicaragua, Tanzania, Uganda, India, Morocco, Iran, Thailand, and Egypt as said
by Haberl and Kivaisi, started implementing the enhancement of constructed wetland for water
quality improvement.
In Turkey, for the improvement of water quality, they developed two vertical subsurface
flow wetlands in the campus of METU. This is used to treat wastewater. The design of this
wetlands is based on the resources and the needs of the country. This is the first installation and
implementation of constructed wetland study here in turkey which will help in gaining
information and additional knowledge for the functions of wetland systems by using the
In Turkey, in order to treat domestic wastewater, they use biological treatment by means
of constructed wetlands. In this research, the aim is to measure the resulting performance for
each filter media of slags and gravels in an artificial wetland. The domestic wastewater has a
hydraulic loading of 100m/d. Phragmites Australis is the cell being used in the wetland. After a
year, the data is gathered for efficiency of the filter media which is proven average in removal
efficieny and effectiveness. It garnered total suspended solids (TSS) (63% and 59%), chemical
oxygen demand (COD) (47% and 44%), NH4 +–N (88% and 53%), total nitrogen (TN) (44%
and 39%), PO4 3−-P (44% and 1%) and total phosphorus (TP) (45% and 4%). Based from the
experiment slag-based wetland has a better performance rate than the gravel based wetland in
terms of phosphorus removal and production of nitrate. It is proven that constructed wetlands is