Education and Linguistics Research

ISSN 2377-1356
http://elr.macrothink.org

Review Form
Article Title: Using Redeployment to Optimise Human Resource in Higher Education Institutions
Reviewer’s Name: DR. ROMMEL L. VERECIO
(The reviewers' identities remain anonymous to author/s)

 Recommendation to Editor (Please mark “x” for appropriate option)

( ) Excellent, accept the submission (5)

( ) Good, accept the submission with minor revisions required (4)

( x) Acceptable, revisions required (3)

( ) Resubmit for review, major revisions required (2)

( ) Decline the submission (1)

The editor will forward the section below to author/s

 Evaluation (Please evaluate the manuscript by grade 1-5)
5=Excellent 4=Good 3=Average 2=Below Average 1=Poor
Items Grade
Contribution to existing knowledge 3
Organization and readability 3
Soundness of methodology 3
Evidence supports conclusion 3
Adequacy of literature review 3
 Strengths

Presentations and writing meet professional norms.

 Weaknesses

The problem is very interesting specifically to academic administrators, but it does not depict
according to objectives of the study.

The presentation is more on a narrative report of redeployment

 Suggestions to Author/s

 In your “INTRODUCTION” you have just presented some literatures depicting

Redeployment…Please support discussion of the existing and prevailing problem

1
 Education and Linguistics Research
ISSN 2377-1356
http://elr.macrothink.org

situation of your locale based on your experience. Give strong justification for selecting
such research problem in your capacity as researcher and your desire or concern in
improving the systems.
 Clearly presents the problem of your locale because this is your objective of the study
which you are trying to solve or improve…The problem should be stated in such a way
that it is nor answerable by either yes, no, when and where but it is a dissection of the
main problem. Sub-problems should be arranged in logical order and extensive in
coverage and must be mutually exclusive in its dimension.
 Support your literatures with a discussion of the knowledge gaps as to how it is related
to the prevailing problem.
 Discuss the Method used specifically the research design, methods of sampling and
sample size, locale and how the data is statistically treated.
 Apply some inferential technique so as to establish difference or relationship
 Apply some technique of analysis for qualitative data (e.g. grounded theory, content
analysis, etc.
 Sample size is too small; maybe you can expand your sample size to make it more
valid.
 Convert/interpret findings into some generalizations that will address the goal or
objective of the study.
 Improved the grammar to make the presentations more meaningful
Please return the completed form to elr@macrothink.org