PROJECT - HEAVENS NIFTY APARTMENTS, EAST FORT, THRISSUR

COMPARISON OF QUOTATIONS RECEIVED FOR ALUMINIUM FABRICATION WORKS

LABOUR CONTRACT
PARTICULARS QUANTITY COST
Contractor 1 Contractor 2 Contractor 3 Contractor 4
Mr.Vinod Mr.Bijeesh Mr.Ashraf Mr.Joshy Ph-
Ph - 8547020766 Ph - 8943839161 Ph- 9562865587 9061448337
Sl.No: Item UoM Est.Qty Rate Cost Rate Cost Rate Cost Rate Cost

Fixing aluminium work for doors, windows, ventilators and partitions with
extruded built up standard tubular sections/ appropriate sections supplied by
the owner fixing with dash fasteners of required dia and size, including
necessary filling up the gaps at intersections, i.e. at top, bottom and sides
with required material supplied by the owner. Aluminium sections shall be
jointed mechanically wherever required including cleat angle, Aluminnium
beading for glazing /paneling etc. all complete as per architectural drawings
and the directions of Engineer-in-charge, using the materials supplied by the
owner. The contractor shall arrange and bear the cost of scaffolding for
fixing the aluminium works and the same shall be included in the rate.

Including scaffolding
1 Fixed Glass Sqft 300 35 10500 55 16500 45 13500 55 16500
2 Openable Windows Sqft 1366 65 88790 55 75130 55 75130 70 95620
3 Sliding Windows Sqft 190 60 11400 55 10450 55 10450 70 13300
4 Balcony Door Sqft 339 50 16950 55 18645 55 18645 80 27120
5 Ventilator (60 x 60cm) Nos 40 350 14000 220 8800 220 8800 300 12000
6 Additional cost for scaffolding LS 1 0 0 2500 2500 0 0 5000 5000

Total Estimate 141640 132025 126525 169540

Excluding scaffolding
1 Fixed Glass Sqft 300 35 10500 55 16500 40 12000 55 16500
2 Openable Windows Sqft 1366 60 81960 55 75130 50 68300 70 95620
3 Sliding Windows Sqft 190 55 10450 55 10450 50 9500 70 13300
4 Balcony Door Sqft 339 50 16950 55 18645 50 16950 80 27120
5 Ventilator (60 x 60cm) Nos 40 350 14000 220 8800 200 8000 300 12000
Total Estimate 133860 129525 114750 164540
6 Estimate scaffolding rent to be borne by Client LS 5000 2500 2000 5000
Net Estimate 138860 132025 116750 169540
 Comparison Note
1 Mr. Bijeesh has offered to bear 50% of scaffolding expenses. Hence estimate is taken as 50% of 5000 = Rs.2500
Mr. Ashraf will bear the scaffolding rent if it crosses Rs.2000/-. Whereever possible, already fixed window grills will be taken out by Ashraf for fixing the aluminium windows and the
2 grills will be refixed by him at his own cost.He has requested to fix the balance grills only after the erection of aluminium windows.
Conclusion/ Recommendation
Mr. Ashraf has quoted his best rates for the work after negotiation and therefore the rates are final. As his rate is found to be the lowest, the work may
3 be awarded to him