Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Prepared ByMd.Bazlur Rahman Khan ID No.: 073-116-020 BBA 13th Batch Major in
Accounting & Information Systems Department of Business Administration Metropolitan
University, Sylhet
Sincerely yours,
Md.Bazlur Rahman Khan ID No.: 073-116-020 BBA 13th Batch Major in Accounting &
Information Systems Department of Business Administration Metropolitan University,
Sylhet
iii
Date: September 13, 2011
All gratitude and thanks to almighty “ALLAH” the gracious, the most merciful and
beneficent who gave me courage to undertake and complete this task. I am very much
obliged to my ever caring and loving parents whose prayers have enabled to reach
this stage. I am grateful to almighty ALLAH who made me able to complete the work
presented in this report. It is due to HIS unending mercy that this work moved
towards success. I am highly indebted to my honorable supervisor Md. Masud Rana,
Assistant Professor, Department of Business Administration, Metropolitan
University, for his guidance and cooperation that helps me immensely to prepare
this report. I would like to express my gratitude to Md. Haroon-Ur-Rashid, Vice
President & Manager, AlArafah Islami Bank Ltd. Laldighirpar Branch, for giving me
the opportunity, appointment for the internship program that I have completed, who
help me without considering any business purpose and also sharing his practical
experience. And last but not the least, I heartily thank to all officers of AIBL,
Laldighirpar Branch for their sincere co-operation and who helped me to learn about
banking during my three months internship. It would not be possible to prepare the
internship report without their help and valuable advice and instruction. I feel
great pride and pleasure on the accomplishment of this report.
vii
EX E C U T I V E S U M M A R Y
In a changing marketing environment, any commercial organization is required to be
customer oriented. As customers in the banking industry are becoming more demanding
and increasingly mobile between competing financial providers, simply being
customer-focused is not enough. Since customers are the driving force of Islamic
financial institutions, hence customers’ satisfaction is a very important aspect in
the competitive market. Therefore, Islamic financial institutions need to take
seriously their products marketing aspect in consonance with Islamic business
ethics. Through this Internship report an attempt has been made to assess the
customer satisfaction level at Al-Arafah Islami Bank Limited (AIBL), Laldighirpar
Branch, Sylhet. Basically this report has been developed from the basis of Primary
and secondary data. The sources of information are face to face interview with
customer, the questionnaire, annual report of the bank, different websites,
newspaper etc. My experience also helps me to prepare this report. The objectives
of my study is to know about what level the customers are assured by competence,
courtesy, credibility and security by the bank and its employees, Assess
willingness of employees to help customers & to provide prompt service, Know the
ability of employees to perform promised service dependently and accurately etc..
Customer satisfaction is an ambiguous and abstract concept and the actual
manifestation of the state of satisfaction will vary from person to person and
product/service to product/service. The state of satisfaction depends on a number
of both psychological and physical variables, which correlate with satisfaction
behaviors such as return and recommend rate. The level of satisfaction can also
vary depending on other options the customer may have and other products/services
against which the customer can compare the organization's products/services.
A firm’s future profitability depends on satisfying customers in the present –
retained customers should be viewed as revenue producing assets for the firm
(Anderson and Sullivan 1993; Reichheld 1996; Anderson and Mittal 2000). According
to Drucker (1954), the principle purpose of a business is to create satisfied
customers. Increasing customer satisfaction has been found to lead to higher future
profitability (Anderson, Fornell, and Lehmann 1994), lower costs related to
defective goods and services (Anderson, Fornell, and Rust 1997), increased buyer
willingness to pay price premiums, provide referrals, and use more of the product
(Reichheld 1996; Anderson and Mittal 2000), and higher levels of customer retention
and loyalty (Fornell 1992; Anderson and Sullivan 1993; Bolton 1998). Increasing
loyalty, in turn, has been found to lead to increases in future revenue (Fornell
1992; Anderson, Fornell, and Lehmann 1994) and reductions in the cost of future
transactions (Reichheld 1996; Srivastava, Shervani, and Fahey 1998). All of this
empirical evidence suggests that customer satisfaction is valuable from both a
customer goodwill perspective and an organization’s financial perspective. During
my study, I used three techniques; i.e. face to face interview, deskwork in
different departments and servqual instrument- the structured questionnaire of
twenty different questions to assessing the customer satisfaction of AIBL
(Laldighirpar Branch). The data that obtained from the survey was than analyzed and
interpreted by using statistical tools. From the interpretation of survey result, a
number of findings and recommendations were suggested that may help the
organization to take necessary steps to improve their service and get more
satisfied customers.
ix
Table of Contents
Title of the Report Letter of Transmittal Latter of Acceptance Certificate of
Internship from AIBL Abstract Acknowledgement Executive Summary Chapter 1- An
Introduction to the
Report.............................................................................
................... 1 1.1
Introduction ......................................................................
................................................................ 2 1.2 Origin of
the
Report.............................................................................
............................................. 3 1.3 Background of the
Report ............................................................................
.................................... 3 1.4 Objective of the
Report ............................................................................
........................................ 4 1.5 Scope of the
Report ............................................................................
.............................................. 5 1.6 Methodology of the
Study .............................................................................
................................... 5 1.6.1 Primary Data
Collection ........................................................................
................................. 5 1.6.2 Secondary Data
Collection ........................................................................
............................. 6 1.7 Limitations of the
Report.............................................................................
..................................... 6
xi
2.40 Appointment of Statutory
Auditor............................................................................
.................... 51 2.41 AIBL at a
Glance.............................................................................
............................................. 52 2.42 Corporate information for the
Year
2010 ..............................................................................
....... 53 Chapter 3- Products & Services of
AIBL ..............................................................................
................. 54 3.1 Various deposit product of the bank in
2010...............................................................................
... 55 3.2 Investment modes of
AIBL. .............................................................................
.............................. 58 3.3 SME
Banking ...........................................................................
...................................................... 60 3.4
Microfinance ......................................................................
............................................................ 62 3.5 Corporate
Social
Responsibility ....................................................................
................................. 64 3.5.1 Conceptualization of
CSR................................................................................
..................... 64 3.5.2 CSR Activities of
AIBL...............................................................................
......................... 64 3.5.3 Some CSR Activities of AIBL in
details ...........................................................................
... 65 Chapter 4- Customer Satisfaction based on theoretical
aspect ............................................................ 68 4.1
Introduction ......................................................................
.............................................................. 69 4.2 Definition of
Customer...........................................................................
........................................ 69 4.3 Definition of
Satisfaction ......................................................................
......................................... 70 4.4 Definition of Customer
Satisfaction ......................................................................
......................... 71 4.5 Shari’ah Basis of Customer
Satisfaction ......................................................................
.................. 71 4.6 CSA Role vis-à-vis Service
Expectation .......................................................................
................. 72 4.7 Sales Behavior Model Based on Islamic Business
Ethics .............................................................. 74 4.8
Importance of Customer
Satisfaction ......................................................................
....................... 77 4.9 Factors affecting Customer
Satisfaction.......................................................................
.................. 79 4.10 Customer Satisfaction- A Critical component of
profitability ..................................................... 81 4.11 Effect
Customer Satisfaction on
profitability .....................................................................
.......... 81 4.12 Consequences of Customer Satisfaction and
Dissatisfaction ...................................................... 83 4.13
Moving from Customer service to Customer
satisfaction ............................................................ 84 4.14
Techniques used to measuring Customer
Satisfaction ................................................................ 85
4.15 Steps in assessing Customer
Satisfaction ......................................................................
............... 86 4.16 Customer Satisfaction in seven
steps..............................................................................
.............. 87 4.17 To improve customer satisfaction, there have 3 principles of
employee satisfaction .................. 88 4.18
Summary ...........................................................................
........................................................... 91
Chapter 5- Assessing Customer Satisfaction at AIBL, Laldighirpar Branch,
Sylhet......................... 92 5.1 Measuring Customer
Satisfaction.......................................................................
............................ 93 5.2 Methods used in Assessing Customer Satisfaction
at AIBL (Laldighirpar Branch) ...................... 94 5.3 Analysis of Customer
Satisfaction ......................................................................
........................... 97 5.3.1 Gender
Frequency..........................................................................
....................................... 97 5.3.2 Age Group
Frequency..........................................................................
................................. 98 5.3.3 Profession
Frequency..........................................................................
.................................. 99 5.3.4 Statements in the Tangible
Dimension .........................................................................
...... 100 5.3.5 Statements in the Reliability
Dimension..........................................................................
... 102 5.3.6 Statements in the Responsiveness
Dimension .................................................................... 104
5.3.7 Statements in the Assurance
Dimension .........................................................................
.... 106 5.3.8 Statements in the Empathy
Dimension .........................................................................
...... 108 5.3.9 Summary of the survey result for five
dimensions ............................................................. 110
Chapter 6- SWOT
Analysis...........................................................................
......................................... 112 6.1
Introduction ......................................................................
............................................................ 113 6.2 SWOT
Analysis...........................................................................
................................................. 113 6.2.1 SWOT Analysis of
AIBL ..............................................................................
..................... 114 Chapter 7- Findings of the
Analysis ..........................................................................
............................ 117 7.1
Findings ..........................................................................
.............................................................. 118 7.1.1
Quantitative
Findings...........................................................................
............................... 118 7.1.2 Qualitative
Findings...........................................................................
................................. 119 7.2 Problems &
Limitations .......................................................................
........................................ 120 Chapter 8- Recommendations &
Conclusion ........................................................................
............... 121 8.1
Recommendations ...................................................................
..................................................... 122 8.2
Conclusion.........................................................................
.......................................................... 124
Appendices.........................................................................
...................................................................... 126
Appendix-I:
Questionnaire .....................................................................
............................................ 127 Appendix-II: Survey
Result.............................................................................
................................... 130
Bibliography ......................................................................
...................................................................... 136
xiii
CHAPTER 1
Page | 2
Hence, the banking sector would play a vital role in the development of the country
and efficient and sound banking management would led the country to reach at the
highest peak of success.
Page | 3
customer service. That is why it is quite justified to make an in-depth study about
its operation and evaluate the service provided by this bank and scope for its
improvement. The study may help formulating policy regarding the ideas relating to
the feelings of the customers and bankers. Furthermore, Al-Arafah Islami Bank Ltd
executives who are actually executing the policies undertaken by the top management
will have a chance to communicate their feelings and will have the feedback about
their dealing from the customers.
Page | 4
1.5 Scope of the Study
The report deals with measuring the satisfaction level of the customers of Al-
Arafah Islami Bank Limited, Laldighirpar Branch, Sylhet. These customers are the
people who have account in this branch. The total population is not covered here.
It is based on sample survey. Thus, the satisfaction level of the entire customers
of Al-Arafah Islami Bank Limited or any other branch of the bank is not measured
here and these will not be a part of the report. The study was conducted from 2nd
of May, 2011 to 31st of July, 2011. Thus, the samples were selected from the
customers who came to bank in during this period. AIBL has been chosen for three
reasons. First, this Bank is a Sharia’h based bank and is drawing attention of
millions of customers to its products and services. Second, this is one of the
largest and strongly profitable among private commercial banks in Bangladesh.
Third, it offers a wide range of products and services and has customers of
different classes of the society.
Page | 5
1.6.2
b. External Sources
Page | 6
CHAPTER 2
Page | 7
2.1 Introduction
Islami Banking System is becoming more and more attractive day by day to peoples
irrespective of Nations, religious, colors and species. More than 300 Banks &
financial institutions are serving Islami banking throughout the world. At present
in our country 7 fully fledged Islamic Banks are working successfully. And other
traditional banks have Islami Banking Wings conducting Shari’ah based banking
activities. Recent Development of Bangladesh Government Islamic Investment Bond
(BGIIB) is the milestone for Shari’ah based banking practices in Bangladesh. Al-
Arafah Islami Bank Ltd. as the name implies a newly formed commercial bank in
Bangladesh. It has been incorporated in Dhaka, Bangladesh as a public limited
company and its Head Office of the Bank is located at Rahman Mansion, 161,
Motijheel C/A, Dhaka- 1000. In the world of consumerism the business organization
of the world strive for the consumers satisfaction as a number one business
strategy whatever may be the product of the organization, either service or non
service. Service is the product of bank. There is a saying that customer service
starts rights right from the stairs of the bank building. The guard at the door is
first person pep resents of the bank, receives a customer with wishes in smiling
face.
Page | 9
2.4 Mission of AIBL
Achieving the satisfaction of Almighty Allah both here &
hereafter. Proliferation of Shari’ah Based Banking Practices. Quality financial
services adopting the latest technology. Fast and efficient customer service.
Maintaining high standard of business ethics. Balanced growth. Steady & competitive
return on shareholders' equity. Innovative banking at a competitive price. Attract
and retain quality human resources. Extending competitive compensation packages to
the employees. Firm commitment to the growth of national economy.
Page | 10
2.6 Pledges & Commitments of the Sponsor Director of AIBL
Whenever a new institution comes into existence, the sponsors claim that it would
be an institution with difference. If a new institution does not have any novelty,
why it should at all be brought into existence? The sponsors of AIBL in conformity
with the tradition claim that it would be a bank with difference. The sponsors and
promoters of AIBL made a few firm pledges and commitments in the name of Allah.
These pledges and commitments have been included in the memorandum and articles of
Association (Article 159) of AIBL (pp 65-71) incorporated with Bangladesh Bank,
Registrar of Joint Stock Companies, Securities & Exchange Commission, etc. Some of
those commitments, titled “Agreements, Pledges and Commitments of the Promoters,
Sponsors & directors of AIBL” are given below: Objectives of the Sponsors AIBL has
not been set up with the objectives of economic welfare and financial benefit of
the sponsors and promoters in this world, on the contrary, they are desirous of
welfare in the next world and Nazat in Akhirat which could be achieved more by
rendering credit services by th sponsors and bankers to others than any service to
themselves. Misuse of Power and undue Advantages The sponsor directors shall not
try to avail undue advantages of any kind from the bank for themselves, or for
firms, companies, institutions in which they have financial or other interest. The
facilities which are legal, just and due to them, that they will avail of should be
transparent and known to the Board of Directors leaving little scope for
misunderstanding.
Page | 11
Inspiration for Qurbani of Nafsaniyyat or Self-interest The promoters and sponsors
of AIBL are imbued with the spirit of sacrifices and Qurbani of the family of
“Hazrat Ibrahim (A.)” (PBUH), and which was rekindled by our beloved prophet
“Muhammed (S.)” (PBUH) and “Sahaba-i-Keram” and thereafter by the “Sufi saints” who
made supreme sacrifices and Qurbani for preaching of Deen of Allah to all comers of
the world, particularly to this region. Clean Banking is “Ibadat” The sponsor
directors agree to conduct clean banking under patronization of the government, and
firmly believe that the association with this bank would be nothing but “Ibadat”
and that they will act accordingly. Environment of AIBL Al-Arafah Islami Bank shall
bear the mark of the Sunnah of our prophet “Muhammed (S.)” (PBUH), of our faith and
conviction, our values and attitudes towards life and that the entire environment
of Al- Arafah Islami Bank shall be in conformity with Sunnah, simple in style,
noble and rich in thought, but dynamic and far reaching in impact, exemplary in
efficiency and service to the customers. Sunnah of Keeping Deposit as “Amanat” The
sponsors firmly and solemnly pledge and promise to hold the deposits and other fund
as “Amanat” and sacred trust keeping in mind the Sunnah of our beloved prophet
“Muhammed (S.) (PBUH)” who would hold the money and materials deposited with him
even by the infields in great trust for which he earned the title of “Al-Ameen”.
Page | 12
2.7 Special Features of AIBL:
All activities of the bank are conducted according to Islamic Shari’ah
where profit is the legal alternative to interest. The bank's investment policy
follows different modes approved by Islamic Shari’ah based on the Qur'an & Sunnah.
The bank is committed towards establishing welfare oriented banking system,
economic upliftment of the low-income group of people, create employment
opportunities. According to the need and demand of the society and the country as a
whole the bank invests money to different 'Halal' business. The bank participates
in different activities aiming at creating jobs, implementing development projects
of the government and creating infrastructure. The bank is committed to establish
an economic system resulting in social justice and equitable distribution of
wealth. It is committed to bring about changes in the underdeveloped rural areas
for ensuring balanced socio economic development of the country through micro
credit program and financing of SME's as well. According to Mudaraba system, the
depositors are the partners of the investment income of the bank. About 70% of the
investment income is distributed among the Mudaraba depositors. To render
improved services to the clients imbued with Islamic spirit of brotherhood, peace
and fraternity and by developing an institutional cohesion. The bank is
contributing to economic and philanthropic activities. AIBL English Medium Madrasah
and AIBL library patronize by the Bank are two such examples.
Page | 13
Performance at a glance (In Million Taka)
56,000.00 48,000.00 40,000.00 32,000.00 24,000.00 16,000.00 8,000.00 0.00
Shareholder Equity deposit Investment Profit befor Tax & Provision 2006 1,690.18
16,775.30 17,423.20 969.77 2007 2,037.50 23,009.10 22,906.40 756.18 2008 2,705.74
29,690.12 27,742.58 1,528.10 2009 3,564.73 38,355.50 36,134.08 1,729.83 2010
9,647.45 52,973.97 53,582.96 3,059.98
Executive Committee
Chairman Vice-Chairman Member : Alhajj Abdus Samad : Alhajj Abdul Malek
Mollah : Alhajj Md. Harun-ar-Rashid Khan Alhajj Md. Nazmul Ahsan Khaled Alhajj
Hafez Md. Enayetullah Alhajj Ahmedul Haque Alhajj Abu Naser Mohammad Yeahea
Audit Committee
Chairman : Sarker Mohammad Shameem Iqbal
Page | 15
Member
Page | 16
2.9 Hierarchy of Position in AIBL
Managing Director Additional Managing Director Deputy Managing Director 1 Deputy
Managing Director2 Senior Executive Vice President Executive Vice President
Chairman Senior Vice President
Director
Vice Chairman
Vice President
Hierarchy Of AIBL
Principal Officer
Officer
Executive Officer
Page | 17
2.10 Shari’ah Board of AIBL
Shari’ah Board Scholars of high repute with extensive experience in law, economics
and banking systems and specializing in law and finance as prescribed by Islamic
Shari’ah make up the AIBL's Fatwa & Shari’ah Supervision Board. The Board is
appointed by the bank's Board of Directors. The Shari’ah Board supervises the
development and creation of innovative Shari’ah -compliant investment and financing
products and services. The Board is empowered to issue fatwas on any matter
proposed to it by different business units of the bank. The Shari’ah auditors
ensure that all the transactions are carried out in strict compliance to Islamic
principles of banking. This framework along with a stringent compliance to rules
has made AIBL the pioneering organization to practice Islamic finance in true
letter and spirit. The name AIBL has come to signify innovation, financial
dynamism, leadership and above all a complete assurance that all the transactions
are free from riba (interest). The Board's Role The Fatwa & Shari’ah Supervision
Board oversees the application of different aspects of Shari’ah in the Bank. It
also ensures that all transactions are in strict compliance with the right of
contradicting (fatwa) any violating procedures, if found. The Board of Directors is
obligated to obey the fatwas, irrespective of whether a unanimous or a majority
consensus secured the decision (clause ---- of the Bank’s Memorandum & Articles of
Association). Board meetings are held periodically or whenever the need arises. The
rights of the Board are enshrined in Article Seven o the Bank's Memorandum &
Articles of Association (Clauses). Important Duties of the Shari’ah Board As an
expert source on Islamic Principles (Including Fatwas), the Board through a
representative, usually the General Secretary of the Board, supervises the Shari’ah
compliance of all the transactions in the Bank.
Page | 18
Analyzing unprecedented situations that are not covered by fatwa, in the Bank's
transactional procedures or those reported by different departments, branches and
even the customers. This is to ensure Shari’ah compliance before the Bank develops
any new products or implements any new procedure.
The Fatwa & Shari’ah Supervision Board submits a complete annual report for the
Board of Director, summarizing all the issues referred to the Board, as well as its
opinion on the Bank's transactional procedures.
Page | 19
Shari’ah Supervisors The Clause ---- of the Bank's Memorandum & Articles of
Association requires the Board of Directors to appoint a Shari’ah Supervisor,
responsible for monitoring all the Bank's transactional procedures and assuring
Shari’ah compliance. Also the General Secretary of the Fatwa & Shari’ah Supervision
Board, the Shari’ah Supervisor handles queries about the Bank's administration from
staff members, shareholders, depositors and customers, liaises with the Shari’ah
auditors and provides them with guidance. He submits reports and suggestions to the
Fatwa & Shari’ah Supervision Board and to the Chairman of the Board of Directors.
The position also calls for participation in the Bank's training programmes.
Shari’ah Auditing The supervisory function forms a part of the Shari’ah Supervision
procedures, its main task being to check Shari’ah compliance under the guidance of
the Shari’ah Supervisor. The auditors continuously review the Bank's transactional
procedures to ensure adherence to the framework created by the Fatwa & Shari’ah
Supervision Board. The Shari’ah auditors submit periodic reports to the Shari’ah
Supervisor so as to monitor and maintain Shari’ah compliance.
Page | 20
members of the Shari’ah Council sat in 3 General Meetings and 2 emergency meeting
and 2 subcommittee meeting in the year 2010 to discuss the matters placed before
them by the Board and management of the Bank to give directives and suggestions in
the field of Shari’ah principles. Muraqibs of the Supervisory committee have
visited all branches (78) of the Bank during the year to observe the Shari’ah
compliance, give necessary instructions on the spot and submitted report to the
Council. They have also submitted corrective measures to rectify the laws in
implementing Shari’ah guidelines into the banking operations. The Shari’ah
Supervisory Committee audited the Financial Statement for the year 2010 from
Shari’ah point of view. After analyzing the Financial Statement the Shari’ah
Supervisory Committee identified Tk.12.83 million as doubtful income, Tk. 54.04
million as compensation realized in different branches and Tk.0.25 million and
Tk.0.82 million as interest income received from NOSTRO accounts of foreign
correspondent Banks and Bangladesh Bank F.C clearing accounts respectively. Due to
limitation in computer software of AIBL Capital Market Department the committee
could not separate brokerage commission and margin profit income earned from
Shari’ah approved securities and interest based bank and financial institution. As
a result the entire amount of Tk.313.32 million earned from brokerage was
identified for the time being as doubtful income and the Shari’ah Supervisory
Committee in its 15th Board Meeting held in 22nd March 2011 has decided to finalize
the Financial Statement for the year 2010 keeping doubtful income amounting Tk.
313.32 million apart from basic income which will be settled later on. A library
has been established in the Shari’ah Council Secretariat of Al-Arafah Islami Bank
having about 500 books on Qur'an, Hadith, Fiqh, Islamic Economics and Islami
Banking. Honorable members of the Council give Shari’ah guidelines to run the
Bank's operations taking necessary consultations and data from those books after
exhaustive research and study.
Page | 21
2.12 Capital Market Services
Al-Arafah Islami Bank Ltd. (AIBL) is a corporate member of Dhaka Stock Exchange
Ltd. & Chittagong Stock Exchange Ltd. Membership Number of Dhaka Stock Exchange is
234 and Membership Number of Chittagong Stock Exchange is 139. After obtaining
stock broker and stock dealer registration certificates from Securities and
Exchange Commission it started share trading from 15th January 2009. Its functions
includes: (a) Share trading services in DSE, (b) Margin facility through bai-
muazzal system, (c) Full services Depository participant services and (d)
Discretionary account services. From the very beginning it succeeded to achieve
clients' satisfaction. As a result, it has been included in the DSE Most Active 20
Members list from the first month of its trading activities and during the year
2010 it secured 3rd position in the list. Considering ongoing clients demand, we
have extended branches in Khulna, Sylhet, Chittagong, Barisal, Brahmanbaria,
Uttara, Dhanmondi, Gulshan during the year 2010. As per direction of Bangladesh
Bank and SEC a subsidiary company named "AIBL Capital Market Services Ltd." has
been formed to conduct our brokerage business separately from the bank. In the
meantime DSE and CSE membership has been transferred to the subsidiary company. We
have applied to SEC for issuing Stock broker and Stock dealer registration
certificate which is now under process.
Page | 22
share was traded at taka 110.00 highest in 2010. The market trend of our bank's
share in Dhaka Stock Exchange between January 2010 to December 2010 is stated in
the list: Share price List Month January February March April May June July August
September October November December Opening (Tk.) 52.23 58.50 51.88 54.73 73.00
86.70 94.10 99.20 101.90 66.40 69.00 72.30 High (Tk.) 59.30 61.40 54.50 75.40
100.00 96.00 104.90 102.90 110.00 72.60 77.90 73.50 Low (Tk.) 50.20 52.00 48.10
53.33 56.30 81.00 91.60 92.60 100.10 63.00 64.00 54.00 Closing (Tk.) 58.88 52.60
54.15 72.85 87.00 93.80 98.20 98.70 109.70 64.40 71.50 66.88
Page | 23
2.15 Capital Adequacy & Reserve Fund
According to BRPD Circular the Bank will have to maintain Tk. 4,000.00 million
Capital & Statutory Reserve by August 2011. In compliance with the new provision,
the bank has raised its Capital & Reserve from Tk. 4,065.96 million in the year
2010 to Tk. 10,512.81 million in 2010 by declaring 30% stock dividend out of the
profit of the year 2009 and issuing right share worth tk. 2,338.64. The paid up
capital of the bank has stood at Tk. 4,677.28 million at 31 st December 2010. The
total reserve fund has stood at Tk. 1,746.42 million in the current year against
Tk. 1,223.18 million at 31st December 2009. In this account, the bank experienced a
growth of 42.78%. The Bangladesh Bank has fixed the ratio of capital adequacy
against Risk-Weighted Assets at 9% or Tk. 2000 million whichever is higher. The
capital adequacy ratio of the Bank as on 31.12.2010 is appended below:
10
0 CAR
2006 10.71
2007 10.92
2008 11.21
2009 11.25
2010 14.49
Page | 24
A. Tier-1: Core Capital Particulars Paid-up Capital Statutory Reserve Retained
Earnings Minority Interest in Subsidiaries Total Core Capital B. Tier-2:
Supplementary Capital Provision for Unclassified Investment Exchange Equalization
Fund Assets Revaluation Reserve Total Supplementary Capital Total Capital (A+B) C.
Capital Adequacy Ratio
(Amount in million BDT) 2010 4,677.28 1,681.82 1,274.86 1,948.89 9,582.85 897.66
Nil 32.30 929.96 10,512.81 14.49% 2009 1,798.95 1,156.52 542.60 Nil 3,498.07 533.53
2.06 32.30 567.89 4,065.96 11.25%
Page | 25
2.16 Deposits
The total deposit of the bank was Tk. 52,973.97 million at 31st December 2010 as
against Tk. 38,355.50 million at 31st December 2009 recording a growth of 38.11% of
which Tk. 115.05 million was bank deposit and Tk. 52,858.92 million was general
deposit. The present strategy is to increase the deposit base through maintaining
competitive profit rates and having low cost of funds to ensure a better spread
with an average return on investment. The mix deposit of the bank on December 31,
2010 was as follow:
Page | 26
Deposit Mix 2010 Nature of Deposit Al-Wadeeah Current Deposit Mudaraba Savings
Deposit Other Mudaraba Deposit Mudaraba Term Deposit Bills Payable Total BDT in
Million 6,667.08 7,227.52 11,941.82 26,325.03 812.52 52,973.97 % of total Deposit
13 14 22 50 1 100
Page | 27
2.17 Investment
The investment of the bank has stood at Tk. 53,582.96 million as on 31st December
2010 as against Tk. 36,134.08 (Net off PR) million in the previous year showing an
increase by 48.29%. The investment portfolio of the bank is well diversified and
covers a broad spectrum of businesses and industries including readymade garments,
textile, edible oil, ship scraping, steel & engineering, chemicals,
pharmaceuticals, cement, telecommunication, construction, health care, real estate,
education, transport and investment under consumer schemes. We have geared up
efforts to improve the recovery rate of disbursed investment and also taken
adequate measures for converting the classified investment into performing assets.
As a result, classified investment of the bank could be kept at a low level far
below the national average. It is 1.14% in our bank as on 31 December 2010. The
bank gives top-most priority to the creation of quality assets and does appropriate
risk grading while approving commercial, trade and project investment to different
clients.
Page | 28
Sector wise Investment Sectors Agriculture,Fishing and Forestry Industry
Construction Water Works & Sanitary Services Transport & Communication Storage
Trade Finance Miscellaneous Total (Including Profit Receivable) Less Unearned
Profit on Investment Total 2010 (Tk. In Millions) 685.40 14,277.03 2,512.86 102.27
1,535.76 17.99 32,786.47 4,786.02 56,703.8 3,120.84 53,582.96 2010 (Percentage)
1.21 25.18 4.43 0.18 2.71 0.03 57.82 8.44 100
Page | 29
2.18 Small & Medium Enterprise Investment
To ensure proper manifestation and rapid advancement of Small & Medium Enterprises,
a number of SME related schemes are running in this Bank. In the light of a unique
definition by Bangladesh Bank, bank is giving priority over financing to three
categories of enterprises viz. Industry, Trade & Services. Investment up to
December 2010 of SME Sector is Tk. 14,499.30 million on which outstanding is
12,754.30 million, which is 24.62% of total investment portfolio. Besides, to speed
up SME investment flow and to include in people who are beyond the range of banking
facilities, a scheme named 'Small Enterprise Investment Scheme (SEIS)' is launched.
With this scheme, operation of collateral security free SME investment is running.
71 branches of total 78 branches are under the operation. At the end of December
2010, number of security free SME clients is One Thousand One Hundred Twenty Eight
(1,128) and investment is Tk.
Assessing Customer Satisfaction Level at AIBL (Ldp. Br.) Page | 30
341.60 million which outstanding is Tk. 274.02 million. Skilled and experienced
staff are recruited in different branches to ensure proper expansion of collateral
security free SME investment. We prior Area Approach Method when SME financing. The
statistics as on 31 December, 2010 is shown in the table: Particulars Total SME
Investment Terms & Conditions SEIS Investment (Collateral Security Free ) Minimum
Investment Maximum Investment Number of Clients Number of Branches under the scheme
Rate of Profit Supervision Fee Maximum Duration Repayment system Recovery Rate
Terms & Conditions Status Tk. 14,499.30 Million Stipulated by the Bank Tk. 341.60
Million Tk. 50,000.00 Tk. 700,000.00 1,128 Persons 71 09 % 0.50 % 3 years Monthly
Installment 99.84% Soft
Page | 31
million. Functioning on the basis of Group and Samity, this scheme helps on socio-
economic development of farmers, labours, fishermen, micro-businessmen and small
entrepreneurs. Another important objective of this scheme is to give priority to
make economically selfdependent of rural women entrepreneur. To get investment
under this scheme, no collateral security is required. Repayment system is weekly
installment basis. Basically, this scheme is one kind of supervised credit system
and skilled personnel are working in different branches to ensure proper as well as
continuous supervision. The statistics as on 31 December, 2010 is shown in the
following tableParticulars Total Investment Minimum Investment Maximum Investment
Number of Clients Savings by the Clients Number of Branches under the scheme Number
of Samity Number of Group Rate of Return Repayment system Recovery Rate Number of
Villages Covered Terms & Conditions Status Tk. 200.70 Million Tk. 5000.00 Tk.
30,000.00 11,964 Persons Tk. 11.60 Million 44 762 2497 10% Weekly Installment
99.97% 695 Soft
Page | 32
2.20 Investment on Agricultural Sectors
To face the increasing food shortage of the country, bank is paying massive
attention to invest on agricultural sectors. The main items of agricultural sectors
are- crops, fisheries, warehouse, poverty alleviation, irrigation, livestock
development etc. At the end of December 2010, total agricultural investment is Tk.
175.80 million of this fiscal year. At the end of Fiscal Year, Outstanding is
211.35 million. With collateral and without collateral both are practiced in
agricultural investment. The statistics as on 31 December, 2010 is shown in the
table: Agricultural Investment Particulars Investment Portfolio Fisheries Poverty
alleviation Development of Livestock Warehouse of corps Crops Agricultural
Machineries Irrigation Others Number of Clients Rate of Profit Recovery Rate Terms
& Conditions Status Tk. 211.35 Million Tk. 71.16 Million Tk. 63.99 Million Tk.
32.41 Million Tk. 22.62 Million Tk. 20.28 Million Tk. 0.37 Million Tk. 0.32 Million
Tk. 0.20 Million 7577 Persons 10% -13% 98.74% Stipulated by the Bank
Page | 33
2.21 Rural Agricultural Investment Scheme
On the basis of socio-economic development of marginal and lessee farmers, an
agricultural based programme named 'Rural Agricultural Investment Scheme (RAIS)' is
launched. Development in country's internal food production as well as
socioeconomic sector of farmers are the main focus of this programme. We have
already listed One Thousand Five Hundred Fifty Five (1555) farmers under this
scheme and total investment is Tk. 27.10 million on which outstanding is Tk. 17.60
million. The statistics as on 31 December, 2010 is shown in the table: Particulars
Total Investment Minimum Investment Maximum Investment Number of Clients Number of
Branches under the scheme Number of Samity Number of Group Rate of Profit Repayment
system Recovery Rate Number of Villages Covered Terms & Conditions Status Tk. 27.10
Million Tk. 5000.00 Tk. 100,000.00 1555 Persons 24 124 315 10% Monthly/Weekly
Installment 100% 128 Stipulated by the Bank
Page | 34
2.22 Investment on Women Entrepreneurs
Al-Arafah Islami Bank Ltd. is working with women entrepreneurs to make them capable
of earning by connecting with country's economic activities. We prior women
entrepreneurs to invest on various productive sectors. By the side of collateral
secured investment, collateral security free investment is also considered in the
question of women development. The statistics as on 31 December, 2010 is shown in
the table: Agricultural Investment Particulars Investment Portfolio Terms &
Conditions SEIS (Women Entrepreneur) Investment Portfolio Number of Clients Rate of
Profit Maximum Duration Repayment system Recovery Rate Terms & Conditions
Microfinance (Women Entrepreneur) Investment Portfolio Number of Clients Rate of
Return Recovery Rate Tk. 196.05 Million 9398 Persons 10% 100% Tk. 3.75 Million 09
Persons 9% 3 years Monthly Installment 100% Soft Status Tk. 685.80 Million
Stipulated by the Bank
Page | 35
2.23 Al-Arafah Solar Electricity Investment Scheme
A different type of investment scheme named 'Al- Arafah Solar Electricity
Investment Scheme' is launched in order to face the present electricity crisis and
to spread the benefits of renewable energy among the rural people. This program
treats as a innovative step on the history of Private Banking Sector in Bangladesh.
It also has unveiled the wide field of Green Banking concept, the burning issue.
'Solar Electricity Investment Scheme' is running under the control of SME
Department with the support of newly created Power & Technology Unit. Skilled
Engineers & Solar Technicians are recruited in order to ensure the perfect
technical support. We have already established Twenty Five Thousand Five Hundred
Ninety Five (25,595) Watt Power of electricity among Four Hundred Seventy Four
(474) families through Eleven (11) Rural Branches so far. Besides, we have
established One Thousand Twenty (1020) Watt Powered solar panel for our newly
inaugurated South Jatrabari Branch to produce solar electricity for the branch use.
We are running this program with own funding as well as skilled personnel. The
statistics as on 31 December, 2010 is shown in the table: Particulars Total
Investment Electricity Provided Number of privileged Family Number of Branches
under the scheme Rate of Return Repayment system Recovery Rate Terms & Conditions
Status Tk. 12.13 Million 25,595 Watt. Power 474 11 10% Down payment & Monthly
Installment Basis 100% Soft
Page | 36
2.24 Treasury Operations
AIBL Treasury included Local & Foreign Exchange money market operated under the
norms of Islami Shari’ah principles and guideline of Bangladesh Bank which is the
Core-banking and one of the best earning units of the Bank.
Page | 37
Open Position/Overnight limit, time & amount limit for reconciliation of Nostro
Accounts and ensure adherence/compliance of these limits. In order to globalize the
Treasury activities, AIBL has in the meantime signed up agreement with ICICI Bank,
Mumbai & Mashreq Bank, UAE for direct dealing through Online. Treasury is now
trying to build up capacity to cope with all possible exigencies to maximize
returns on Investment & minimizing risks hence the Treasury has emerged as the main
source of non funded income. The treasury has introduced Total Quality Management
(TQM) system to each field of its activities.
Page | 38
2.26
Income
Investment income: The investment income was Tk. 4,143.30 million during the year
2010 which registered a growth of 3.47% over the previous year. Investment income
is 55.08% of the total income of Tk. 7,522.25 million. Income from other than
investment: The bank has earned Tk. 3,378.95 million from sources other than
investment like commission income, exchange income, locker rent etc. in the current
year which is 44.92% of the total income. It indicates 159.70% growth over the year
2009.
2.27 Expenditure
Profit paid to depositors: The Bank has paid the depositors Tk. 3,133.69 million
which is 75.63% of the investment income and 70.23% of the total expenditure for
the year 2010. It indicates 17.48% growth over the year 2009.
Page | 39
Administrative and Other Expenses: The administrative and other expenses were Tk.
1,328.61 million during the year showing 46.25% growth over the year 2009. It is
29.77% of the total expenditure.
Page | 40
2.29 Dividend
The bank has been paying dividend every year since 1998 just after conversion of a
public limited company. The Board of Directors of the Bank is pleased to recommend
26% stock dividend in the year 2010. Table of Historical Dividend Payment
Percentage are as follows: Year 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Dividend (%) 7.5% Cash 20% Bonus 16% Bonus 15.50% Bonus 26% Bonus 35% Bonus 20%
Bonus 30% Bonus 30% Bonus 26% Bonus
Page | 41
2.30 Information Technology
Al-Arafah Islami Bank Ltd. with the vision of becoming the leading Bank in the
country both in service and technical aspects have taken bold steps to full fill
the requirements of the mass. Banking sector is going through massive change with
the advent of new technologies as well as new ways and norms of banking. With
information technology becoming the tool of almost every trade, IT Division at Al-
Arafah Islami Bank took the challenge of giving the best possible service to its
users and customers alike. AIBL's pledge to adhere with the principles of Islamic
Norms and ethics and combine them with today's technology threw a great challenge
to the IT division. It has been a while now that AIBL is providing True Centralized
online payment services to its customers in all its branches. With 78 online
branches AIBL is committed to provide online facilities at any new branch that is
added to the banks existing network. To keep pace with the growing customer needs
as well as
Page | 42
new technologies AIBL has taken a number of steps to facilitate clients while
improving the existing services and adding on new services. The bank is striving
hard towards the goal of changing from brick to click bank while taking banking
services to the people who are not yet under the banking umbrella. To begin with
AIBL takes pride using successfully a locally developed Core Banking System which
it feels is major step in promoting our local talent. IT Division of the bank works
day and night with its partners finding ways to reduce costs without compromising
with customer experience. By this time Bank can proudly announce that it is the
part of Bangladesh Bank's recently launched Automated Clearing House (BACH) and its
Electronic Fund Transfer Network (BEFTN). AIBL's IT division has worked in tandem
with Bangladesh Bank's personnel to make the project successful and were among the
first banks to successfully implement and comply to requirements provided by the
Central Bank. With Allah Almighty's grace AIBL's IT Division has rose to the
occasion and extended it's all out co-operation to the central Bank in implementing
the new projects under the DIGITAL Bangladesh theme. Clearing is now completely
automated along with Electronic Fund Transfer. Under the guidance of the Central
Bank AIBL has provided CIB information as data with minimum error to the Central
Bank. The project is under way and IT Division is extending full support to CIB
Cell of Bangladesh Bank. Banks hand shake with the El-dorado project has
facilitated the far flung customers with means to get access to their funds
virtually in minutes which used to take not long hours but days to reach them.
Page | 43
In line with the bank’s strategy of taking the bank to the customers AIBL will be
launching its ATM / POS services by April 2011. Internet Banking (e-Commerce),
Mobile banking (mCommerce) and other delivery channels will be available to
customers in recent future. Bangladesh Bank coming up with guidelines for Internet
and mobile fund transfer the Bank is ready to take the challenge and provide its
customers the best possible experience of technology combined with safe and secure
Banking. Al-Arafah renews its pledge to combine the latest technology available
with cream of bankers to provide customers with an experience of hassle free
banking where a customer can pay his /her utility bill even at dead of the night.
Though AIBL have attained a lot in terms of respect from the banking industry and
customers alike in terms of its ventures with technology its management is pledge
bound to mix the latest trends in technologies with banking to provide the ultimate
experience to its customers.
Page | 44
detect the deficiencies/lapses, irregularities and reducing the risk, the Bank
Branches and Head office divisions are subject to the following audit and
inspections every year: a) Risk based comprehensive Audit & inspection – all the
branches once in a year. b) Auditing of handling Foreign Exchange & Foreign Trade -
quarterly basis. c) Surprise inspection at regular intervals. d) Auditing of each
Division / Department of Head Office once in a year. During the year 2010, Bank's
Audit Team undertook the following audit and inspections: Nature of Inspection
Comprehensive & Risk Based Internal Audit & Inspection Surprise Inspection Internal
Audit & Inspection (HO) 60 (Branches) 04 (Branches} 05 (Division/Dept.) Nos. of
branches/division
To preclude incidence of errors and their recurrences, more emphasis was given on
spot rectification of irregularities while auditing/inspecting a specific branches.
In addition, Concurrent Audit and Self Audit are also introduced in the branches.
Concurrent audit is a systematic and timely examination of financial transaction on
a regular basis to ensure accuracy, authenticity and compliance with procedures and
guidelines. Such audits are conducted by the Incumbent In-charges and assigned
officers of the branches to bring down the irregularities at a minimum level
instantly. In 2010, Bangladesh Bank inspection teams inspected different Branches &
division and Department of Head office and also conducted Special Inspections on 06
Core Risk areas in Banking.
Page | 45
Muraqibs of Shari’ah Supervisory committee conducted inspection in all branches of
the bank during the year to observe the Shari’ah compliance.
Definitions of A2 & ST-2 are given below: A2 (Strong Capacity & High Quality) :
Commercial Banks rated in this category have strong capacity to meet their
financial commitments but are somewhat more susceptible to the adverse effects of
changes in circumstances and economic conditions than commercial Banks in highrated
categories. This level of rating is adjudged to be of high quality and is subject
to low credit risk. ST-2 (High Grade): Commercial Banks rated in this category are
considered to have strong capacity for timely repayment. Commercial Banks rated in
this category are characterized with commendable position in terms of liquidity,
internal fund generation and access to alternative sources of funds is outstanding.
Page | 46
of loyalty to the company and to the customers, tenacity to learn more and the
commitment to perform characterize our human resource. Our employees with
outstanding quality are rewarded in the Bank. As a result, our staff morale is very
high. They show good performance in the Bank. The management frequently
communicates with the employees and listens to their new ideas and suggestions. A
major factor behind our success in 2010 and in the preceding years is our
employees. The Human Resource Division of Head Office is responsible for fixing
principles and policies concerning personnel and certain areas of administration.
The division is responsible for employee relation, staffing succession, planning,
training, employee benefits, compensation and their social security. The salary and
compensation package for all levels of our employees was reviewed and revised last
year to be competitive with all local private sector Banks and financial
institutions in the country. It is targeted to attract and retain good performers
in the Bank. We recruited 480 fresh entrants and 15 experienced Bankers during the
year 2010 through a transparent recruitment process to fulfill the manpower
requirement in the Bank. The Bank also sent 9 employees to BIBM, 07 employees
abroad, 25 employees to Bangladesh Bank for training in different fields to upgrade
themselves with the latest techniques of modern banking. We have 1,711 staff in the
Bank of whom 73 are executives, 1339 are officers and 299 other staffs as on
December 31st 2010. SL No. 1 2 3 Designation category Executives Officers others
Total Number 73 1339 299 1711
Page | 47
The Bank Plans to rationalize per-Branch employee by equitable Manpower
distribution of human resource amongst the existing and future branches. As a part
of social commitments Bank accommodated 279 students from different renowned
universities for doing internship program in our Bank during the year 2010. The
Bank has recruited experienced new manpower to strengthen its large scale
operations. Total manpower employed in the Bank including Managing Director is
1,711 at 31 December 2010; which was 1,296 at the end of the last year.
Page | 49
2.37 Implementation of Basel-II
Basel-II a new framework for calculating minimum capital requirement is structured
around three pillars: minimum capital requirement (on credit risk, operation risk
and market risk), supervisory review process and market discipline. Implementation
of Basel-II framework in Bangladesh will integrate the risk management process of
the bank and its capital adequacy requirement. As per decision of the Basel II
committee of Bangladesh Bank, all banks will start implementing revised regulatory
capital framework "Risk Based Capital Adequacy for Banks" from January 2009.
Following methodology of Basel II would be followed in Bangladesh: a) Standardized
Approach against Credit Risk for calculating Risk Weighted Amount (RWA) supported
by External Credit Assessment Institution (ECAIs) b) Standardized Rule Based
Approach against Market Risk and c) Basic Indicator Approach for Operational Risk
To create awareness among the credit officers, the bank has arranged training
programs on Basel-II and its impact on selection of credit proposal. Moreover to
comply with the instruction of Bangladesh Bank, the Bank has taken initiatives for
quarterly reporting under Basel-II to Bangladesh Bank along with the existing
capital adequacy rules and reporting.
Page | 50
branches and 8 SME/Krishi Branches. The number of Branches as Division wise is
mentioned in the following table: Division Dhaka Division Chittagong Division
Sylhet Division Khulna Division Rajshahi Division Barisal Division Total No. of Br.
43 13 7 6 7 4 80
Page | 51
Accountants are eligible for another terms. The Board has approved M/S Masih Muhith
Haque & Co. and M/S ACNABIN Chartered Accountants for re-appointment as External
Auditors by the shareholders till the 17th Annual General Meeting.
Page | 52
2.42 Corporate Information for the Year 2010
Date of Incorporation: 18th June Date of Formal Inauguration: 27th
Sept. Authorized Capital: Tk. 500 Crore Paid up Capital: Tk. 233.86 Crore
(30.09.2010) Statutory Reserve: Tk. 148.74 Crore (30.09.2010) Total Equity: Tk.
461.88 Crore (30.09.2010) Number of Branches: 78 (2010) Number of Employees: 1700
(11.12.2010)
Page | 53
CHAPTER 3
Page | 54
3.1 Various Deposit product of the Bank in 2010 1. Mudaraba Term Deposit Deposit
starts from Tk.50000 or above is obtained under the aforesaid scheme for tenure of
3, 6, 12, 24 and 36 months and the same is withdrawal with profit at the end of the
tenure. 2. Mudaraba Savings Deposit Any person can open a Mudaraba Savings Deposit
account by his/her name with a minimum balance of Tk. 500. The account holder can
operate this type of deposit account as their wish, i.e. they can deposit and
withdraw any amount of money at any time. 3. Short Notice Deposit (SND) This
account is generally for business organization. The owner of business operates this
account. Here the owner can deposit any amount at any time, but he have to inform
or send a short notice to the bank authority before seven days of withdrawals. 4.
Monthly Hajj Deposit Hajj deposit at monthly installment from 1 (one) year to
20(twenty) years are accepted under the above scheme to enable the account holder
to perform Hajj out of the accumulated saving with profit. 5. Monthly Installment
Term Deposit (ITD) Deposit in monthly installment @ Tk.300/-, Tk.500/-, Tk.1000/-
Tk.1500/- & Tk.2000/- is obtained under the aforesaid scheme for a tenure of
5,8,10 and 12 years and the same is withdrawal with profit at the end of the
tenure.
Page | 55
6. Monthly Profit Based Term Deposit (PTD) Under the above scheme, deposit of Tk.
1.00 lac and multiple thereof are accepted for a term of 5 (five) years and the
bank gave profit thereon Tk. 885 per month per lac and proportionately on the rest
amount of deposit under the category during the year under review. The aforesaid
rate shall, however, be adjustable at the close of calendar year on finalization of
accounts. 7. Monthly Savings Investment (SID) Deposit under the scheme is accepted
by monthly installment and after expiry of the term; double amount of such savings
is given as investment in feasible sectors by the bank as per choice of the
depositors without any collateral security. Any one by saving under the scheme can
take business venture on utilization the amount saved under the scheme as well as
availing bank investment. 8. One Time Hajj Deposit Under the above scheme, fixed
amount of Hajj deposits are accepted from the clients for particular term and as
per rules profit is accumulated thereon per year in this regard. As and when the
fixed deposit is matured, Hajj expenses are defrayed by the same. Under the scheme,
the guardians may also open Hajj account to enable their successors to perform
Hajj. Highest amount of profit is paid in the above types of deposit by the bank.
9. Under this scheme the bank has introduced saving bonds for Tk. 10,000/-,
Tk.25,000/and Tk. 100,000/- for 3,5 and 8 years. After the completion of the tenure
the deposit. (a) Al-Arafah Savings Bond (3 Years) (b) Al-Arafah Savings Bond (5
Years) (c) Al-Arafah Savings Bond (8 Years)
Page | 56
10. Marriage Saving Investment Scheme (MSIS) Fixed monthly installment for a
particular period is to be deposited to defray the expenses of marriage and the
bank allows double of saving or Tk.30,000/- which is higher as investment to
procure ornaments, furniture, fixture etc., repayable in 24 monthly installment
without any collateral security. There have some other deposit products of the
bank11. Pensioners deposit scheme 12. Special Saving (Pension) Scheme 13. Cash WAQF
14. Lakhopati Deposit Scheme 15. Kotipati Deposit Scheme 16. Millionaire Deposit
Scheme 17. Double Benefit Scheme 18. Triple Benefit Deposit Scheme
Page | 57
3.2 Investment modes of AIBL
The Total investment of the bank stood at Tk.5079.21 million against Tk.3728.41
million during the corresponding period of last year. The percentage of increase is
36.23% as against 13.00% in banking sector. The bank extends investments to the
clients under the following modes of investment under Islamic Shari’ah:
Bai-Murabaha or simply Murabaha The terms “Bai-Murabaha” have derived from Arabic
words Bai and Ribhum. The word “Bai” means purchase and sale and the word ‘Ribhum’
means an agreed upon profit. So Bai-Murabaha means sale for an agreed upon profit.
It may be defined as a contract between a Buyers and a Seller under which the
seller sells certain specific goods permissible under Islamic Shari’ah and the word
Law of the land to the Buyer at a cost plus and agreed upon profit payable today or
on some date in the future in lump-sum or by installments. The profit may be either
a fixed sum or based on a percentage of the price of the goods. Musharaka The word
Musharaka is derived from the Arabic word Sharikah meaning partnership. Islamic
jurists point out that the legality and permissibility of Musharakah is based on
the injunctions of the Holy Qura’n, Sunnah and Ijma (consensus) of the scholars.
Musharaka transaction may be conducted in the following manner: One, two or more
entrepreneurs approach an Islamic Bank to request the financing required for a
project. The bank, along with other partners, provides the necessary capital for
the project. All partners including the Bank have the right to participate in the
project.
Page | 58
The profit is distributed according to an agreed ratio. However, losses are shared
in exactly the same proportion in which the different partners have provided the
finance for the project. Mudarabah The term Mudarabah refers to a contract between
two parties in which one party supplies capital to the other party for the purpose
of engaging in a business activity with the understanding that any profits will be
shared in a mutually agreed upon. Losses, on the other hand, are the sole
responsibility of the provider of the capital. The first party provides capital and
the other party provides the expertise with the purpose of earning lawful profit
(approved by Islamic law) which will be shared in a mutually agreed upon
proportion. Bai-Muajjal The term ‘Bai’ and ‘Muajjal’ are derived from the Arabic
words ‘Bai’ and ‘Ajal’ where ‘Bai’ means purchase and sale and ‘Ajal’ means a fixed
time or a fixed period. So BaiMuajjal is a sale for which payment is made at a
future fixed date or within a fixed period. In short, it is a sale on Credit. It is
basically a contract between a buyer and seller under which the seller sells
certain specific goods, permissible under Shari’ah and law of the country to the
buyer at an agreed fixed price payable at a certain fixed future date in lump-sum
or in fixed installments. Bai-Salam The term Bai-Salam is used to define a sale in
which the buyer makes advance payment, but delivery is delayed until sometime in
the future. Usually the seller is an individual or business and the buyer is the
bank.
Assessing Customer Satisfaction Level at AIBL (Ldp. Br.) Page | 59
3.3 SME Banking
Small and Medium Enterprise (SME) is playing a significant role to the growth of
overall GDP of the country. Of all industrial productions, a huge part stems from
SME. In order to boost up the small and medium enterprises of the country,
Bangladesh Bank has recently advised the commercial banks to enhance the flow of
investment and offered directives and policies to supervise and monitor this
sector. As SME has emerged as a thrust sector, Al-Arafah Islami Bank Ltd. also
considers it important to extend and enhance finance for the same. Keeping this
idea in the forefront, the bank has prepared an integrated policies, methods and
procedures for SME investment.
Purpose
To facilitate small and medium level entrepreneurs To boost up the
small business in the country To facilitate the growth of agro-industries To create
employment To broaden the base of Islamic Banking in the society To encourage women
entrepreneurs
Modes
Working Capital Investment Bai-Muajjal Murabaha / Murabaha TR MPI / MPI-
TR Mudaraba Musharaka
Page | 60
Fixed Capital Investment HPSM (Equity required) Mudaraba Musharaka
Eligibility
Permanent resident of Bangladesh The age must range between 25
years to 60 years Physically fit and capable of working hard Capable of reading &
writing Capable of managing his / her business successfully Sufficient Infra-
structure and skilled personnel At least 02 (two) years experience in the applied
business Having Transparent CIB Report Valid Licenses, such as- Trade License, VAT
registration, TIN, NOC from Environment Department (where applicable) Other terms
and conditions stipulated by the bank
Page | 61
3.4 Microfinance
The economy of Bangladesh mostly depends on rural development. Poverty stands in
the way of the growth of this economy. Although a number of NGOs and financial
organizations work in the sub-urban and villages with a view to alleviating
poverty, a very few are found working with the compliance of Islamic Sariah. It is
a national responsibility to alleviate abject poverty from the rural area. To help
change the socio-economic condition of the impoverished people of the villages, Al-
Arafah Islami Bank Limited has initiated a project entitled "Krishi O Grameen
Khudra Biniog Prokolpa (Microfinance). With this project, Bank is working for
reduction of poverty, development in agricultural sectors, creation of job
opportunities etc. We hope this will develop the socio-economic condition of a
large segment of the rural folk. It is a group based work. The main characteristics
are: This is a supervised investment programme A group consists of 5
(five) members 8 (eight) groups make a Samitee. It means that a Samitee contains 40
members Every group has a Group Leader and a Deputy Group Leader Every Samitee has
a Samitee Leader and a Deputy Samitee Leader All members must attend the weekly
meeting
Page | 62
Page | 63
3.5 Corporate Social Responsibility 3.5.1 Conceptualization of CSR The modern era
of CSR concept was evolved in 1950s when it was more commonly known as social
responsibility. CSR has been defined as "the integration of business operations and
values whereby the interests of all stakeholders, including customers, employees,
investors, and the environment are reflected in the organizations policies and
actions. By CSR practices an organization can improve communication with the
community and other stakeholders, ensure accountability and transparency in its
operation, improve internal decision making and cost saving, enhance corporate
image, improve reputation and ability to enlarge market share and Enhancement of
customer true worthiness, profitability and sustainable development. 3.5.2 CSR
activities of Al-Arafah Islami Bank Ltd. CSR is an integral part of corporate
culture and ethics. AIBL respond positively in every sphere of social activities
and delivering innovative solution to its valued customer and in the same manner
AIBL also helping different areas of social activity through its CSR activities.
During the year 2010 AIBL accomplished different humanitarian and social activities
which include allocation of fund Tk. 24.00 million for AIBL foundation to establish
kidney dialysis center, donation to liberation war Museuim Tk. 5 million,
Bangladesh Olympic Association Tk. 5 million, FBCCI Social Activity Tk. 1 million,
Nimtali tragedy Tk. 0.42 million, Pilkhana tragedy Tk. 0.48 million and different
hospitals and universities. Besides, AIBL have taken a program to develop manpower
and make them self employed as well as assisting them for employment in abroad.
Page | 64
3.5.3 Some CSR Activities of AIBL in details:
Staff Welfare Project The Bank always keep a careful eye on the economic security
and benefit of its staffs & officers. The Bank operates a contributory provident
fund, a social security & benevolent fund and a gratuity fund for its employees.
Al-Arafah Islami Bank Foundation The Bank has a foundation performing philanthropic
activities. Al-Arafah English Medium Madrasah, Al- Arafah Islami Bank Library and
Al-Arafah Islami Bank Foundation Kidney Dialysis Center are major three are of its
philanthropic activities. AI-Arafah English Medium Madrasah & School Al-Arafah
English Medium Madrasah & School, a promotional welfare project envisaged to
transform our future generation Akhirat-oriented and at the same time provide them
with faith based and modern education which would keep them in the mainstream of
socio-economic life professionally established in 1998 by Al-Arafah Islami Bank
Foundation. This is the first English Medium Madrasah & School in Bangladesh
intended to foster the cause of Islamic education providing O' and 'A1 level
education under Edexel, UK curriculum. Al-Arafah English Medium Madrasah & School
is running a Hifz section along with its English medium curriculum. 10 Hifz
students successfully completed the Hifzul Quran course from this section in 2010.
At present total 225 students are studying in this institute. Since 1999 the
institute is providing English medium education under Edexel, UK curriculum.
Edexel, UK in Bangladesh agreed to train our teachers for O' level course. Our
institute became the member of English Speaking Union launched by the British
Ambassador in 2010 which is patronised by Her Majesty the Queen of UK. Al-Arafah
English Medium Madrasah & School is a corporate member of British Council. Our
students are enrolled as members of Young Learner Center (YLC). We are allowed at a
time to
Assessing Customer Satisfaction Level at AIBL (Ldp. Br.) Page | 65
borrow 25 books and educational DVDs for 7 weeks. Our students are taking part in
all sorts of competition program in British Council. In 2007 one of our girl
students took part in art competition on "Air Pollution" arranged by commonwealth
through British Council. In 2008 our two students got 'B' & 'C' grade in essay
competition arranged by British Council. A group of our students regularly goes to
British council to join 'Young Learner Center' to read books and watch educational
movies. Our students have also been participating in many Hand Writing competitions
in National level since its inception. Our students won 3rd prize in 2008 at
Dhanmondi local area Hand Writing competitions. 45 students took part in Hand
Writing competition in 2008 arranged by Ekushey TV channel. Later it was telecast
for viewers. Every participant got consolation prize. Some of our students joined
International Scout moot on 28th December, 2002 in Thailand. Students of Al-Arafah
English Medium Madrasah established English Language Club in 2006 to promote
English Language in the Madrasah Campus. Club's main motto is to increase Language
proficiency with correct pronunciation. Language Club Members are assigned to
promote the habit of speaking English language among students. The Language Club is
publishing a Language Magazine regularly. The Magazine contains 30 pages which
encourage all level of students to write some articles for the magazine. Al-Arafah
Islami Bank Library Library is the carrier & reservoir of knowledge. Al- Arafah
Islami Bank has shown that is not only generates profit, but also contributes
significantly in the field of providing good source of knowledge by establishing a
public library at 32, Topkhana Road, Chittagong Bhaban (1st floor), Dhaka, thus
strengthening social development. It harbours 22,000 books of reference for the
researchers, students, professionals, bankers, physicians, engineers, politicians,
writers or journalists, even for the kids. It is open to all throughout the year
and well located & accessible to everybody. It has procured some exceptional
collection of books on religion, economics,
Page | 66
banking, computer science, business administration, sociology, English & Arabic
language and juvenile literature in Bangla, English, Urdu & Arabic, which are very
rare. Al-Arafah Islami Bank Foundation Kidney Dialysis Center Al-Arafah Islami Bank
Foundation established an International Standard Kidney Dialysis Center to deliver
the dialysis therapy to increasing kidney patient in Bangladesh at reduced price.
AlArafah Islami Bank Foundation Kidney Dialysis Center is situated at Chattagram
Bhaban (1st Floor), 32 Topkhana Road, Dhaka- 1000. National Professor Dr. M. R.
Khan inaugurates this philanthropic Dialysis Center on December 04, 2010. This
center is capable to deliver the dialysis therapy to eight kidney patients daily in
two shifts. Al-Arafah Islami Bank Foundation authority is committed to deliver the
health care service to the underprivileged people of Bangladesh in near future.
Page | 67
CHAPTER 4
Page | 68
4.1 Introduction
Superior service quality is widely acknowledged as a driver of perceived value,
which, in turn, will enhance customer loyalty (Parasuraman and Grewal, 2000) and
improve the provider‘s image, sales and profitability (Buzzell and Gale, 1987;
Gummesson, 1993). Because satisfaction is basically a psychological state, care
should be taken in the effort of quantitative measurement, although a large
quantity of research in this area has recently been developed. Work done by Berry,
Brodeur between 1990 and 1998 defined ten 'Quality Values' which influence
satisfaction behavior, further expanded by Berry in 2002 and known as the ten
domains of satisfaction. These ten domains of satisfaction include: Quality, Value,
Timeliness, Efficiency, Ease of Access, Environment, Interdepartmental Teamwork,
Front line Service Behaviors, Commitment to the Customer and Innovation. These
factors are emphasized for continuous improvement and organizational change
measurement and are most often utilized to develop the architecture for
satisfaction measurement as an integrated model. Work done by Parasuraman, Zeithaml
and Berry between 1985 and 1988 provides the basis for the measurement of customer
satisfaction with a service by using the gap between the customer's expectation of
performance and their perceived experience of performance. This provides the
measurer with a satisfaction "gap" which is objective and quantitative in nature.
Work done by Cronin and Taylor propose the "confirmation/disconfirmation" theory of
combining the "gap" described by Parasuraman, Zeithaml and Berry as two different
measures (perception and expectation of performance) into a single measurement of
performance according to expectation. According to Garbrand, customer satisfaction
equals perception of performance divided by expectation of performance.
Page | 69
purchaser, is usually used to refer to a current or potential buyer or user of the
products of an individual or organization, called the supplier, seller, or vendor.
This is typically through purchasing or renting goods or services. The word
“customer” has neither been defined by the Negotiable Instrument nor by any other
law. Therefore, in the field of banking it is not cleared yet. According to Paget,
the following characteristics will be present: a. There must be recognizable course
or habit of dealing between the customer and a bank. b. Dealing between him and the
bank must be in the nature of regular banking business. Zairi (2000) said,
“Customers are the purpose of what we do and rather than them depending on us, we
very much depend on them. The customer is not the source of a problem, we shouldn’t
perhaps make a wish that customers ‘should go away’ because our future and our
security will be put in jeopardy”. The Kerala high court in the case of Central
Bank of India Limited, Bombay vs. Gopinathan Nair and others (1970) said, ―Broadly
speaking, a customer is a person who has the habit of resorting to the same place
or person to do business so far as the banking transactions are concerned. He is a
person whose money has been accepted on the footing that the banker will honour his
cheques up to the amount standing to his credit irrespective of his connection
being of short or long standing‖ In th is study the ―customerǁ means those persons
who have at least one active account of any kind at Al-Arafah Islami Bank Limited
(Laldighirpar Branch).
Page | 70
According to Hansemark and Albinsson (2004), “satisfaction is an overall customer
attitude towards a service provider, or an emotional reaction to the difference
between what customers anticipate and what they receive, regarding the fulfilment
of some need, goal or desire”.
Page | 71
for Islamic banks and financial services than now. However, under the present
circumstances, when customers are becoming more demanding and increasingly mobile
between competing financial providers, being customer-oriented is not enough.
Islamic financial institution and more specifically their contact employees (CSRs)
need to be perceived by their customers as ethically Islamic. Islamic financial
institutions should offer a complete range of Shari'ahbased products and services.
Moreover, Islamic financial institutions should aim to satisfy their customers by
letting them choose what is most suitable for them in line with Shari'ah. In other
words, customers satisfaction from an Islamic financial institutions perspective is
an important issue. Therefore, this article will highlight possible Islamic ethical
sales behaviour as may be perceived by the customers of Islamic Financial
Institutions.
Page | 73
Figure 1-Ethical sales behavior on customer satisfaction
Therefore, customer expectations regarding the core service are highly dependent on
the CSAs presentation in the service encounter. If the CSA behaves according to
Islamic ethics, they are more likely to provide realistic expectations about the
core service, and are less likely to push the customer into buying a service that a
customer does not need. Consequently, these actions may result in confirmation or
even positive disconfirmation between expectations and service performance, thus
resulting in customer satisfaction with the core service.
Page | 74
1. Customer Satisfaction with the Core Service (H1) The customer satisfaction with
CSAs increased when the customer felt the advisor had been fair in the transaction
something, which is associated with Islamic ethical sales behaviour. The figure 1
shows that the perceived ethical standard of CSAs had a positive impact on customer
satisfaction. In some service settings, discriminate validity between satisfaction
with the CSA and the Islamic financial institution should not be necessarily
expected. Taking this matter into account, we some times see that in a service
context the CSA and the selling Islamic financial institution or banks products are
often indistinguishable in the mind of the customer. Hence, a positive association
exist between core service and level of customer satisfaction with an Islamic
financial institution. 2. High Level Customer Satisfaction (H2) Leads to Trust (H3)
and Loyalt y (H4) Research in services marketing has widely shown that customer
satisfaction leads to customer loyalty. For instance, in the mainstream literate on
marketing, there are many examples that whether customers had replaced their
insurance policies or allowed them to lapse depended on their prior satisfaction
with the whole life coverage. Similarly, the core-service satisfaction is
positively associated with repurchase intentions. Furthermore, customer
satisfaction with Islamic financial institutions has a significant and positive
effect on loyalty. A few literature on customers of Islamic financial service
industries provide evidence of the positive influence of customer satisfaction both
with the Islamic financial institution as service provider and the core service on
customer intention to use the facilitys services again, and recommend the service
to a friend. With respect to the relationship between satisfaction with the Islamic
bank and trust in the bank, the later may be viewed from a global perspective as an
overall impression of the Islamic financial system. There is a long-term
orientation in this variable, since trust is also conceptualised as a cumulative
process that develops over the course of repeated, successful interactions.
Satisfying encounters are hypothesised to reinforce customers trust in Islamic
Page | 75
financial institutions. A highly satisfying experience with the Islamic financial
institution may not only reassure the customer that their trust in the service
provider is well placed, but also enhance the trust and loyalty. 3. Customer Trust
(H3) to Islamic Banks Customers trust relate to a belief on the part of customers
that the obligations of Islamic financial institutions are fulfilled. In other
words, the customers believe and feel that a CSA of an Islamic financial
institution selling products can be relied upon to behave in such a manner that the
longterm interest of the customers will be served. Therefore, trust in an Islamic
financial institution may be defined as customer confidence in the quality and
reliability of the services offered by the Islamic financial institution. This
conceptualisation of trust corresponds to the concept of post-trust that derived
from the principles of muamelat based on Islamic business ethics. Service employees
(such as CSAs) with whom the customers interact, confirm and build trust in the
Islamic financial institution or detract from its reputation and ultimately destroy
trust. Figure 1 suggest that Islamic ethical sales practices, as perceived by
Islamic financial service customers have increased customers trust (H3) in CSAs.
Therefore, there is a positive association between Islamic ethical sales behaviour
and customers trust (H3) in the Islamic financial system. This can be explained by
taking into account the important role of salespeople (CSAs) in the service
setting. It means CSAs of Islamic financial institutions are always working as
their backbone. Consequently, if the behaviour of the CSAs of a financial
institution is perceived by customers as Islamic, the institution is also likely to
be perceived as Islamic, because customer perceptions of contact employees will
affect their perceptions of the Islamic financial institution. 4. Customer Loyalty
(H4) to Islamic Bank An important consideration in a service financial institutions
customer base is the degree to which its customers are loyal. Based on the
principles of Islamic marketing ethics, customers
Page | 76
loyalty to Islamic financial institutions is conceptualised as a combination of a
customers intention to maintain an ongoing relationship with Islamic financial
institutions, and their willingness to recommend Islamic financial institutions to
other consumers. Customers perceptions of face-to-face interaction with CSAs have
traditionally been considered one of the most important determinants for loyalty.
Islamic ethical sales behaviour is likely to play a major role in developing
customer loyalty. On the other hand, unethical sales behaviour is a short-run,
expedient perspective devoid of any sense of social responsibility. Islamic ethics
encourages sellers to foster long-term relationships with buyers. Building based
upon the principles of equity, justice and welfare; Islamic ethical sales behaviour
can be considered to be an investment in the equity formulation. If customers feel
they are being treated unfairly by the CSA (because of unethical behaviour),
perceptions of inequity will emerge which in turn may translate into a desire of
the customer to leave the relationship with the Islamic financial institutions as
represented by the CSA. Therefore, it may be stated that the greater the CSAs
Islamic ethical behaviour as perceived by the customer, the greater the customer
loyalty to Islamic financial institutions.
Page | 77
business (employment, prices, profits, production, economic growth etc.) are
dependent on customers consuming products (Fornell, 2007; Johnson & Gustafsson,
2000). “Satisfied customers are not only the sum total of the value of all other
company assets – virtually all costs and revenues have some relationship, however
weak or indirect, to customer acquisition and customer retention” (Fornell, 2007,
p. 66). To create long-term profit and shareholder value, companies need to think
of customers as investors and an economic asset. It is the customers that bring
financial revenue to companies. Hence, customers are companies’ greatest asset
(ibid.). Understanding the needs of the customer is critical. A business
relationship, just like any other relationship, relies on both people getting their
needs met. No matter what type of business, all customers want the same thing. They
want to feel welcomed and appreciated by the staff. They don't want to get the
impression that they are just being used by the company for money. Small
interactions like "Thank you" and a nice smile can go a long way toward customer
satisfaction. Make sure all employees operate with the same principles. A big part
of customer satisfaction is reliability. If customers come to expect a certain mode
of behavior from the business, employees should deliver it to them each and every
time. Customers want to be able to rely on the employee. They expect consistent
delivery times and support. By training the employees to treat all customers with
the same respect, than customers will all have the same experience with the
company, which will increase customer satisfaction.
Page | 78
Be honest when the business doesn’t meet expectations. Customer satisfaction is at
its most important when something goes wrong in the chain of delivery. Whether a
customer was double charged or didn't receive what she ordered, employees need to
handle the situation with the utmost care. Employee should apologize and take steps
to rectify the situation. The phrase "the customer is always right" is at the core
of a good customer satisfaction strategy. It doesn't matter whether or not the
customer misread the instructions or made the mistake; the employee should take
steps to make the customer happy. Customer satisfaction is the foundation of a good
business. Satisfied customers will make a great foundation for return business, and
they may also bring in their friends and associates. It is said that- “customers
are the heart of any business.” It is the company’s responsibility to Keep them
satisfied, and encourage them to tell their friends about their experiences with
the business.
Page | 79
Friendly Employees Helpful Employees Quick Service Overall Customer Satisfaction
Page | 80
4.10 Customer Satisfaction – a Critical Component of Profitability
Exceptional customer service results in greater customer retention, which in turn
results in higher profitability. Customer loyalty is a major contributor to
sustainable profit growth. To achieve success, there must make superior service
second nature of the organization. A seamless integration of all components in the
service-profit chain – employee satisfaction, value creation, customer
satisfaction, customer loyalty, and profit and growth – links all the critical
dynamics of top customer service. Sadly, mature companies often forget or forsake
the thing that made them successful in the first place: a customer-centric business
model. They lose focus on the customer and start focusing on the bottom line and
quarterly results. They look for ways to cut costs or increase revenues, often at
the expense of the customer. They forget that satisfying customer needs and
continuous value innovation is the only path to sustainable growth. This creates
opportunities for new, smaller companies to emulate and improve upon what made
their bigger competitors successful in the first place and steal their customers.
Organizations are increasingly interested in retaining existing customers while
targeting noncustomers; measuring customer satisfaction provides an indication of
how successful the organization is at providing products and/or services to the
marketplace.
Page | 81
Customer Satisfaction data encompassing the findings of over 20,000 customer
surveys conducted in 40 countries by Info Quest. The conclusion of the study was: A
Totally Satisfied Customer contributes 2.6 times as much revenue to a company as a
Somewhat Satisfied Customer. A Totally Satisfied Customer contributes 17 times as
much revenue as a Somewhat Dissatisfied Customer. A Totally Dissatisfied Customer
decreases revenue at a rate equal to 1.8 times what a Totally Satisfied Customer
contributes to a business”. • • •
Zairi (2000): “There are numerous studies that have looked at the impact of
customer satisfaction on repeat purchase, loyalty and retention. They all convey a
similar message in that: Satisfied customers are most likely to share their
experiences with other people to the order of perhaps five or six people. Equally
well, dissatisfied customers are more likely to tell another ten people of their
unfortunate experience. Furthermore, it is important to realize that many customers
will not complain and this will differ from one industry sector to another. Lastly,
if people believe that dealing with customer satisfaction/complaint is costly, they
need to realize that it costs as much as 25 percent more to recruit new customers”.
• • •
Aaker (1995) said that the strategic dimension for an organization includes
becoming more competitive through customer satisfaction/brand loyalty,
product/service quality, brand/firm associations, relative cost, new product
activity, and manager/employee capability and performance (Figure).
Page | 82
Customer Satisfaction / Brand Loyalty Product / Service Quality Brand / Firm
Associations Relative Cost CURRENT PERFORMANCE LONG TERM PROFITS
Page | 83
4.13 Moving from customer service to customer satisfaction
Companies often use the term customer service and customer satisfaction
interchangeably, but they are very different. Customer service is what an
organization provides to its customers and is relatively easy to measure. Typical
measures include response time, time required to provide service, ability to
address a customer's issues on the first call, procedures for handling customer
complaints or returns, etc. Customer service is important and companies should
examine all the ways in which they touch their customer, the service they provide
and their measures to continuously improve that service. Customer satisfaction, on
the other hand, is how the customer feels about the service they receive and the
company that provided it. It is the customer's perception and emotional response,
and the company has no direct control over it. It is harder to measure and even
harder to improve. Most companies assume there is a direct relationship between
customer service and customer satisfaction, which is often the case. But there is
no guarantee that good customer service will create high customer satisfaction.
Good technical service delivered with an attitude can leave a customer
dissatisfied. Timely replacement of a defective product can be listed as good
customer service, but the customer may still be unwilling to trust the company with
future business. The reverse is also true. Difficult situations can be converted
into extraordinary customer satisfaction, if the customer is handed with care and
sensitivity. Some companies train employees in how to use poor service issues as an
opportunity to turn a situation around and create a raving fan.
Page | 84
4.14 Techniques used to measuring Customer Satisfaction
The Kano model is a theory of product development and customer satisfaction
developed in the 1980s by Professor Noriaki Kano that classifies customer
preferences into five categories: Attractive, One-Dimensional, Must-Be,
Indifferent, Reverse. The Kano model offers some insight into the product
attributes which are perceived to be important to customers. SERVQUAL or RATER is a
service-quality framework that has been incorporated into customer-satisfaction
surveys (e.g., the revised Norwegian Customer Satisfaction Barometer) to indicate
the gap between customer expectations and experience. J.D. Power and Associates
provides another measure of customer satisfaction, known for its top-box approach
and automotive industry rankings. J.D. Power and Associates' marketing research
consists primarily of consumer surveys and is publicly known for the value of its
product awards. Other research and consulting firms have customer satisfaction
solutions as well. These include A.T. Kearney's Customer Satisfaction Audit
process, which incorporates the Stages of Excellence framework and which helps
define a company’s status against eight critically identified dimensions. For
Business to Business (B2B) surveys there is the InfoQuest box. This has been used
internationally since 1989 on more than 110,000 surveys (Nov '09) with an average
response rate of 72.74%. The box is targeted at "the most important" customers and
avoids the need for a blanket survey.
Page | 85
4.15 Steps in Assessing Customer Satisfaction
Develop a listing and categorize your customers. This will include: a. External
customers-those that use your services (directly and indirectly). b. Internal
customers-all organizations have components that serve other components. These are
internal customers. Suppliers-traditionally, you are a customer to them but by
thinking of them as a customer, and of the information and access they need to meet
their contracts with you, you will gain dividends in your own services.
Categorize your products or services. Determine what needs and wants your services
or products meet. Determine what sets your service apart from others? Establish a
customer orientation to include: Customers should be encouraged to tell you about
any problems, Customers should know their rights and responsibilities from the
beginning, Customers should know how to take advantage of their rights, Customers
should feel in control. Customers should know precisely who to contact Carefully
scrutinize how your customers reach you and what barriers they encounter: a. How
does your telephone system work? What are average wait times? How many times is a
caller referred before finding someone able to answer the question? b. Where are
you offices located? Are they convenient for customers to find? Is parking
available? c. What languages do your customers use? d. What does your reception
area look like? Pleasant or foreboding? How long must people wait? What printed
material do you have that describes your agency or organization? Does it
successfully inform existing and potential customers?
Page | 86
How well are you using information technology to increase customer satisfaction? a.
Do you have a web site? b. Do you know how much and what kind of traffic comes to
the site? c. Does it provide address, telephone, fax and e-mail information? d.
Does it have a search feature? e. Does the language on the site meet the language
need of your customers?
These are some of the considerations that an organization should make as it starts
to understand and improve customer satisfaction.
Page | 87
4.17
Satisfaction
If you’ve ever coveted a J.D. Power award for Customer Service Champions, or if
keeping the customer service satisfaction (CSAT) scores high at your company falls
under your job description, this post is for you. Improving CSAT scores, and
ultimately, driving business by creating products and services that keep satisfied
customers coming back for more is no easy task. Providing adequate training for
your customer service representatives is necessary, for sure, but there’s more to
the CSAT picture than simply a well-trained employee. How about a well-trained,
happy employee? Now that’s a step in the right direction. Let’s look at three
principles for improving employee satisfaction, which will positively influence
customer satisfaction. Principle #1: Understand the link between employee
satisfaction and customer satisfaction A widely researched topic in the customer
service industry connects customer loyalty and employee satisfaction. Case studies
and company profiles repeatedly show that for employees to provide not just good
customer service—but great customer service—they must first be driven by loyalty
and enthusiasm from their employer. In other words, you can’t force devotion or
commitment on your employees, but you can foster it by creating a culture that
invites pride and ownership in the job and company. To see the concept visually,
the below graph, courtesy of MetricNet’s research on call center metrics, aptly
illustrates the connection between employee satisfaction and customer satisfaction:
Page | 88
Principle #2: Create a great work environment So it makes sense that happy
employees make for happier customers. The research backs up a fairly intuitive
concept. But to create an environment filled with smiling, customer-serving
employees, simply offering your agents a great parking spot if they are chosen as
employee of the month isn’t going to cut it. Neither is offering $.25 cent sodas
out of the company soda machine. We could write a book on creating a great work
environment (actually, we did!…and we wrote a training program, too), but for
brevity’s sake, let’s take the example of one company, New Belgium Brewery in
Colorado, that has a 97% employee retention rate. Why? The employees, quite simply,
like their jobs. The happy staff at New Belgium are also productive, motivated
employees that sell a product customers like. What exactly makes New Belgium
employees so happy? Yes, they get to sample the beer they produce, but the
management at New Belgium has taken deliberate steps to foster a loyal workforce
through the following principles:
Page | 89
Reward employees for loyalty: How about a custom-made cruiser bike after a year of
service and a trip to Belgium after 5 years of service? Create policies employees
can be proud of: The Company has a strict policy of environmental stewardship and
does things such as turning waste into livestock feed and using wind-powered
electricity.
Lead by example: The founders of New Belgium are committed to sound business
practices and stewardship in their community. They believe in what their company
stands for, and they hire employees who reflect the company’s values.
Principle #3: Create an environment that encourages low turnover We’ve written
previous posts about how customer service starts with your staff, and we’ve
mentioned the importance of adequate employee screening, training, and paying fair
wages. It’s a topic worth repeating. Turnover, quite simply, is expensive, a huge
drain on time and company resources, and leads to overall low morale. There are
many contributors to high turnover, including inadequate training, poor employee
screening methods, and a rushed hiring process. If you think paying lower wages
will save your company money in the long-run, first consider the costs of employee
turnover. According to recent data, replacing an employee can cost anywhere from
30% to 150% of an employee’s annual salary and benefits. Therefore, if you have an
employee making $40,000 a year, you could be paying between $12,000 and $60,000
just to hire a replacement. Even with a focused customer service skills training
program, there are greater forces at play when improving employee satisfaction and
creating a culture that drives high customer satisfaction rates. If you, or other
powers-at-be in the company are downplaying the importance
Assessing Customer Satisfaction Level at AIBL (Ldp. Br.) Page | 90
of employee satisfaction, examine your employee culture before attempting to fix
your customer satisfaction rates.
4.18 Summary
There are a number of guidelines that an agency may want to remember when
addressing improving and quantifying customer satisfaction information. These
include: State clearly what is being measured and how the measure is derived
or calculated. Explain why the measure is relevant to the program or service being
provided. Identify the data source(s) used to calculate the measure and indicate
how often the data are updated, including basic information on how and when the
data were collected and where the data can be obtained. Include a supplemental
attachment with information and explanation of data sources, specific agency
contacts, methodology, and other information required to evaluate agency data for
legislative audit purposes. Develop systematic data retention schedules, which
will allow interested parties to verify and further analyze customer satisfaction
data. Adhere to guidelines for valid survey research including appropriate designs
for data collection, questionnaire development, sampling and analysis. For purposes
of routine management or quality improvement, any comments from customers may be
useful, but casual comments or unrepresentative samples do not constitute adequate
measures of customers' satisfaction with state agencies or their programs. State
agencies should develop standard questions that they use consistently from year to
year to assess and report customers' satisfaction. Without consistent wording of
questions, it is impossible to monitor performance over time.
Page | 91
CHAPTER 5
Page | 92
5.1 Measuring Customer Satisfaction
With the phenomenal increase in the country's population and the increased demand
for banking services; speed, service quality and customer satisfaction are going to
be key differentiators for each bank's future success. Thus it is imperative for
banks to get useful feedback on their actual response time and customer service
quality aspects of retail banking, which in turn will help them take positive steps
to maintain a competitive edge. Organizations are increasingly interested in
retaining existing customers while targeting non-customers; measuring customer
satisfaction provides an indication of how successful the organization is at
providing products and/or services to the marketplace. Lord William Thomson Kelvin
(1824-1907) said, "If you cannot measure it, you cannot improve it." So to improve
customer satisfaction level, measurement of customer satisfaction is must.
Satisfied customers are central to optimal performance and financial returns. In
many places in the world, business organizations have been elevating the role of
the customer to that of a key stakeholder over the past twenty years. Customers are
viewed as a group whose satisfaction with the enterprise must be incorporated in
strategic planning efforts. Forward-looking companies are finding value in directly
measuring and tracking customer satisfaction (CS) as an important strategic success
indicator. Evidence is mounting that placing a high priority on CS is critical to
improved organizational performance in a global marketplace. With better
understanding of customers' perceptions, companies can determine the actions
required to meet the customers' needs. They can identify their own strengths and
weaknesses, where they stand in comparison to their competitors, chart out path
future progress and improvement. Customer satisfaction measurement helps to promote
an increased focus on customer outcomes and stimulate improvements in the work
practices and processes used within the company. When buyers are powerful, the
health and strength of the company's relationship with its customers – its most
critical economic asset – is its best predictor of the future. Assets on the
balance sheet – basically assets of production – are good predictors only when
buyers are weak. So it is no wonder that the relationship between those assets and
future income is becoming more and more tenuous. As buyers become empowered,
sellers have
Page | 93
no choice but to adapt. Focusing on competition has its place, but with buyer power
on the rise, it is more important to pay attention to the customer. Requirement of
ISO 9000:2000 Measurement of Customer Satisfaction is a new significant addition to
the new ISO9000: 2000 standard. Organizations certified to this standard are now
required to identify parameters that cause customer satisfaction or dissatisfaction
and consciously measure them. Clause 8.2.1 in ISO 9000: 2000 states: "As one of the
measurements of the performance of the Quality Management System, the organizations
shall monitor information relating to customer perception as to whether the
organization has met customer requirements. The methods for obtaining and using
this information shall be determined." The requirement has been there in the QS
9000 standard clause 4.1.6 which says: "... Trends in customer satisfaction and key
indicators of customer dissatisfaction shall be documented and supported by
objective information. These trends shall be compared to those of competitors, or
appropriate benchmarks, and reviewed by senior management."
AIBL
There are various models that are used in measuring the level of customer
satisfaction. I have calculated the Customer Satisfaction Index (CSI). Because, it
looks pretty smarter as it shows the satisfaction level as one number and this
measure model considers various parameters and this is easy to calculate. The
Customer Satisfaction Index represents the overall satisfaction level of that
customer as one number, usually as a percentage. Plotting this Satisfaction Index
of the customer against a time scale shows exactly how well the supplier is
accomplishing the task of customer satisfaction over a period of time.
Page | 94
The Questionnaire/ Instrument
I have followed the process of face to face interview in measuring the customers‘
satisfaction level. Because, it was convenient for me as I have passed much time at
the bank during my internee program. The information collection was performed by
using RATER or SERVQUAL Instrument. In the mid eighties, Parasuraman, Zeithaml and
Berry (1988, 1991) conducted extensive studies in different industries and
developed the SERVQUAL instrument: a 22-item scale with a set of service quality
dimensions to quantify a customer‘s assessment of a company‘s service quality. Five
key dimensions of service quality — reliability, responsiveness, assurance, empathy
and tangibles — have been identified and form the foundation on which a lot of
other studies on service quality have been built. By the early nineties the authors
had refined the model to the useful acronym RATER. SERVQUAL is an empirically
derived method that may be used by a services organization to improve service
quality. The method involves the development of an understanding of the perceived
service needs of target customers. These measured perceptions of service quality
for the organization in question, are then compared against an organization that is
"excellent". The resulting gap analysis may then be used as a driver for service
quality improvement. SERVQUAL takes into account the perceptions of customers of
the relative importance of service attributes. This allows an organization to
prioritize. And to use its resources to improve the most critical service
attributes. The data are collected via surveys of a sample of customers. In these
surveys, these customers respond to a series of questions based around a number of
key service dimensions. The methodology was originally based around 5 key
dimensionsAssessing Customer Satisfaction Level at AIBL (Ldp. Br.) Page | 95
Tangibles- Physical evidence of the service: appearance of physical facilities,
tools and equipments used to provide the service, appearance of personnel and
communication materials. Reliability- The ability to perform the promised service
dependably and accurately: consistency of performance and dependability, service is
performed right at the first time, the company keeps its promises in accuracy in
billing and keeping records correctly, performing the services at the designated
time. Responsiveness- The willingness and/ or readiness of employees to help
customers and to provide prompt service, timeliness of service: mailing a
transaction slip immediately, setting up appointments quickly. Assurance- The
knowledge and courtesy of employees and their ability to convey trust and
confidence: competence (possession of the required skills and knowledge to perform
the service), courtesy (consideration for the customer's property, clean and neat
appearance of public contact personnel), trustworthiness, security (safety and
confidentiality). Empathy- The provision of caring, individualized attention to
customers: informing the customers in a language they can understand, Understanding
customer's specific needs, providing individualized attention. The Rating Scale
Customers‘ responses have been recorded by using 5 point Likert Scale or Technique
where the customer were asked to evaluate each statement to rate their degree of
agreements or disagreements with each of 22 statements. These degrees of agreements
or disagreements were plotted on the 5 point Likert Scale where point 1 indicates
―Strongly Disagreeǁ and point 5 indicates ―Strongly Agreeǁ with the statement.
[Strongly Disagree]
1 2 3 4
[Strongly Agree]
5
Page | 96
5.3 Analysis of Customer Satisfaction
50 customers were surveyed as sample (from the population size of almost two
thousand) under the study to measure the satisfaction level of the customers of Al-
Arafah Islami Bank Limited (Laldighirpar Branch). The demographic information of
samples is as follows: 5.3.1 Gender frequency Table 1: Sample‘s Frequency
Distribution based on Gender Gender Male Female Frequency 36 14 Total= 50
Percentage 72% 28% Cumulative Percentage 72% 100%
Page | 97
5.3.2 Age Group frequency Table 2: Sample‘s Frequency Distribution based on Age
Group Age Group 18-25 Years 26-33 Years 34-50 Years 51-Above Frequency 14 18 15 3
Total= 50 Percentage 28% 36% 30% 6% Cumulative Percentage 28% 64% 94% 100%
Page | 98
5.3.3 Profession frequency Table 2: Sample‘s Frequency Distribution based on
Profession Profession Business Service Holder Student Others Frequency 21 15 12 2
Total= 50 Percentage 42% 30% 24% 4% Cumulative Percentage 42% 72% 96% 100%
Page | 99
5.3.4 Statements in the Tangible Dimension Explanation- The statements under this
group denotes the Physical evidence of the service. Aspects relating to tangible
dimension of service quality were asked in 4 different questions. Survey Result-
The summary of survey result of this dimension is shown by the following tableTable
1: Tangible Dimension Statements 1. AIBL has modern looking equipment and
technologies that needs. 2. Your bank has convenient business hours. 3. The
employees of the bank appear neat. 4. Materials associated with the service
(pamphlets or statements) are visually 0 1 37 106 56 200 appealing at AIBL. Total 0
0 10 30 10 50 0 1 7 21 21 50 0 0 13 24 13 50 better satisfy your Strongly disagree
0 0 7 31 Disagree Average Agree Strongly agree 12 50 Total
Page | 100
Interpretation of the Result- There is four (4) statements in the Tangible
dimension and a number of Two Hundred (200) responses acquired. Among those two
hundred responses- fifty six (56) customers are strongly agree, one hundred six
(106) customers are agree, thirty seven (37) customers are average and only one (1)
customer is disagree with above four statements. Out of four statements, the third
statement “employees of the bank appears neat”, acquire the highest position as
twenty one (21) customers are strongly agree, twenty one express agree, seven (7)
customers express average opinion and only one (1) customer is disagree. Second
statement “bank has convenient business hours” appears in the 2nd position, where
thirteen (13) customers are strongly agree, twenty four (24) customers are agree
and thirteen (13) customer expressed average opinion. First statement “modern
looking equipment and technologies” of tangible dimension exists near to the second
position. And ten (10) customers express strongly agree, thirty (30) express agree,
ten express average opinion against the fourth statement “Materials associated with
the service (pamphlets or statements) are visually appealing”. No customers express
their opinion as disagree and strongly disagree to the first, second and fourth
statement.
Assessing Customer Satisfaction Level at AIBL (Ldp. Br.) Page | 101
5.3.5 Statements in the Reliability Dimension Explanation- Four attributes were
grouped in this dimension and the respondents were asked to express their opinions.
The attributes implies that” The ability to perform the promised service dependably
and accurately”. Survey Result- Summary of the survey result of this dimension is
shown by the following tableTable 2: Reliability Dimension Statements 5. When AIBL
promises to do something by a certain time, it does so. 6. When you have a problem,
employees give appropriate solution of your problems. 7. Your bank completes your
transactions rapidly. 8. AIBL insists on error free records. Total 0 1 51 96 52 200
0 0 10 23 17 50 0 0 12 20 18 50 0 1 12 26 11 50 Strongly disagree 0 0 17 27
Disagree Average Agree Strongly agree 6 50 Total
Page | 102
Interpretation of the Result- In the Reliability dimension, four (4) statements
were grouped and Two Hundred (200) responses collected. Among those two hundred
responses- fifty two (52) customers are strongly agree, ninety six (96) customers
are agree, fifty one (51) customers are average and only one (1) customer is
disagree with this dimension. Out of four statements, the third statement “bank
completes your transactions rapidly”, stands in the highest position as eighteen
(18) customers are strongly agree, twenty (20) express agree, twelve (12) customers
express average opinion and no customer express their opinion as disagree. Second
statement “appropriate solution of your problems” and fourth statement “AIBL
insists on error free records” appears near the top position where fourth statement
is in 2 nd place and second statement is in 3rd place. In strongly agree category,
seventeen (17) customers put their opinion against fourth statement and eleven (11)
customers put opinion against second statement.
Page | 103
First statement of the dimension “promises to do something by a certain time, it
does so” stands in the lowest position among the four statements. On this
statement, six (6) customers are strongly agree, twenty seven (27) are agree and
seventeen (17) customers give the average opinion. No customers put their
perception as disagree and strongly disagree to the first, third and fourth
statement.
Page | 104
Interpretation of the Result- There is four (4) statements in the Responsiveness
dimension and Two Hundred (200) responses gathered where fifty (50) customers are
strongly agree, ninety one (91) customers are agree, fifty nine (59) customers give
average opinion. Among four statements, the third statement “Employees are always
willing to help”, stands in the top as seventeen (17) customers are strongly agree,
twenty one (21) express agree, twelve (12) customers express average opinion. A
number of twelve (12) customer express their opinions as strongly agree to both the
first and second statement of this dimension. Again, second statement acquires the
opinion as agree and average from twenty four (24) customers and fourteen (14)
customers, where the first statement acquires the number twenty two (22) and
sixteen (16) in regular order. Only nine (9) customers put strongly agree opinion
to the last statement. There have no any customers who give their opinion under
disagree and strongly disagree category.
Page | 105
5.3.7 Statements in the Assurance Dimension Explanation- Aspects relating to
tangible dimension of service quality were asked in 4 different questions. The
objective of these four questions is to know about courtesy and knowledge of
employees and their ability to convey trust and confidence. Survey Result- The
summary of the survey result of this dimension is shown by the following table.
Table 4: Assurance Dimension Statements 13. The behavior of employees in AIBL
installs confidence in you. 14. You feel safe in your transactions with AIBL. 15.
Employees in AIBL area consistently courteous with you. 16. Employees in AIBL have
the knowledge to answer your questions. Total 0 0 68 89 43 200 0 0 20 23 7 50 0 0
18 25 7 50 0 0 11 19 20 50 Strongly disagree 0 0 19 22 Disagree Average Agree
Strongly agree 9 50 Total
Page | 106
Interpretation of the Result- Four (4) statements in the Assurance dimension and
two Hundred (200) responses collected. Among those responses- forty three (43)
customers are strongly agree, eighty nine (89) customers are agree, sixty eight
(68) customers expressed average perception. As twenty (20) customers give strongly
agree opinion to the second statement “Customers feel safe in transaction”, and as
it’s the highest number for strongly agree category than other statements of
assurance dimension, therefore it stands in top position. Nineteen (19) customers
put their opinion as agree and the rest eleven (11) give average opinion to the
statement. In the first statement, the number of customer who expressed their
perception as strongly agree, agree and average category is accordingly nine (9),
twenty two (22) and nineteen (19). Third and fourth statement stands near the first
one as seven (7) customers give strongly agree opinion to both the statement.
Page | 107
5.3.8 Statements in the Empathy Dimension Explanation- The Empathy dimension refers
to the degree of the provision of caring, individualized attention to customers.
Survey Result- Summary of the survey result of this dimension is shown by the
following table. Table 5: Empathy Dimension Statements 17. Service charges of AIBL
are banks. 18. AIBL has your best 0 0 0 0 29 15 16 18 5 17 50 50 interests at
heart. 19. The employees of AIBL understand needs. 20. AIBL has employees who give
attention. Total 0 0 62 85 53 200 you individual 0 0 9 29 12 50 your specific
reasonable to as other comparatively Strongly disagree 0 0 9 22 Disagree Average
Agree Strongly agree 19 50 Total
Page | 108
Interpretation of the Result- Empathy dimension is the combination of four (4)
different statements. A total number of two Hundred (200) customer responses to
those four questions. Among those respondents- fifty three (53) customers are
strongly agree, eighty five (85) customers are agree, sixty two (62) customers
expressed average perception. In this dimension, there have no any response to
disagree and strongly disagree category. Nineteen (19) customers express their
perception as strongly agree for the first statement of this dimension. And the
next three statements achieve same perception from five (5), seventeen (17) and
twelve (12) customers accordingly. Third and fourth statement more or less stands
near the first statement. But in the second statement, large number of respondents’
shows average perception which indicates that the bank should pay more attention to
this area of customer’s interest and desires.
Page | 109
5.3.9 Summary of the survey result for five dimensions is shown in the following
tableTable 6: Summary of Five Dimensions Dimension Tangible Reliability
Responsiveness Assurance Empathy Total Strongly disagree 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 2 37
51 59 68 62 277 106 96 91 89 85 467 Disagree Average Agree Strongly agree 56 52 50
43 53 254 200 200 200 200 200 1000 Total
Page | 110
The statistics shows that four hundred sixty seven (467) customers express their
perception as Agree which is the highest number than rest four categories. Just two
customer were disagree among which one is disagreed to the tangible dimension and
another one is in reliability dimension. From the above statistics it can be said
that the overall performance of the bank is satisfactory. But it should pay more
attention to their service quality which may lead to get more highly satisfied
customer and to compete with other banks.
Page | 111
CHAPTER 6
SWOT ANALYSIS
Page | 112
6.1 Introduction It has always been important for a business to know and understand
how it fits in and interacts with the surrounding environment on both an internal
(office/factory/shop environment) and external view (how business operates with the
outside world).Researching the environment will benefit the company and management
team by putting in a position to develop a strategy for both the long and short
term. The most influential way of doing this is to perform a SWOT analysis of the
company. The SWOT analysis comprises of the organization’s internal strength and
weakness and external opportunities and threats. This analysis can be performed on
a product, on a service, a company or even on an individual. It helps to identify
where the company is strong and where is vulnerable, where company should defend
and where it should attack. SWOT analysis gives an organization an insight of what
they can do in future and how they can compete with their existing competitors.
This tool is very important to indentify the current position of the organization
relative to others, which are playing in the same field and also used in the
strategic analysis of the organization. 6.2 SWOT Analysis The acronym for SWOT
analysis stands for Strengths Weaknesses Opportunities Threats
Page | 113
6.2.1 SWOT Analysis of AIBL Every organization is composed of some internal
strengths and weaknesses and also has some external opportunities and threats in
its whole life cycle. Strengths AIBL provides its customer excellent and
consistent quality is every service; Financially sound company; Utilizes state
of the art technology to ensure consistent quality and operation; AIBL provides
its works force an excellent place to work; Company name recognized on a
National/Regional/Local level; The company already achieved a good will among the
client; Charges on different services are comparatively low in AIBL than other
banks; The bank has research and training division; Fully computerized accounts
maintenance; Well decorated and air conditioned facilities; AIBL has a well-
diversified pool of human resources, which is composed of people with high academic
background. Also, there is a positive demographic characteristic- most employees
are comparatively young in age yet mature in experience; Excellent transport
links (ease of access to/from the Company). Weaknesses Lacks well trained human
resource in some area; Lack of one stop service to the customer; AIBL have no
any ATM service or booth; Taking less promotional activities than any other
banks; The procedure of credit facility is to long compare to other banks;
Employees are not motivated in some areas;
Page | 114
Initiate modern banking like Credit Card facilities, SMS banking, I-banking;
Rented premises (Adding to costs). Opportunities Emergence of online banking will
open more scope for AIBL; AIBL can introduce more innovative and modern customer
service; Bangladesh is developed by improving economic condition. The banking
sector playing a vital role for this. With the change in the economy and increase
in the population, demand for banking service is also increasing; Many branches
can be opened in local remote area as its high demand; AIBL can recruit
experienced, efficient and knowledgeable officers and staffs as it offers good
working environment. Threats The worldwide trend of mergers and acquisition in
financial institutions is causing problems; Frequency taka devaluation and
foreign exchange rate fluctuation is causing problem; Lots of new banks are
coming in the scenario with new service; Some conventional banks are now a days
starting Islamic banking service/window; Local competitors can capture huge
market share by offering similar products; Restless political condition in
Bangladesh, such as strike, boom blast, etc. threats the prosperity of bank; As
well as customer satisfaction authority must have to conscious about the employee
satisfaction otherwise excessive labor turned will be a threat to the organization;
Number of potential competitors is increasing day by day; Rising cost of Wages
(Basic wage, etc); Large and increasing competition; Existing product becoming
unfashionable or unpopular.
Page | 115
As previously stated, SWOT analysis is used primarily to evaluate the current
position of the business to determine a Management strategy for the future. It
should also help to look at how management can do this by looking closely at
company’s Weaknesses and Threats that have identified. Great care needs to be taken
when planning a strategy not to disturb the balance of Strengths as management
could find that their Strengths suddenly become a Weakness if they don’t use them.
The way that SWOT has been introduced is the simplest way that it can be found. It
can be used further to analyze the business (depending on its size) on a local,
national and global level. This analysis will also help the management to forecast
and prepare for the future accurately to give realistic objectives and tasks.
Page | 116
CHAPTER 7
Page | 117
7.1
Findings
Quantitative findings Qualitative findings
The findings from the survey can be listed under following two head-
Page | 118
satisfactory, there is a large number of customer who says that guidance at
entrance and seek pardon for making wait is average that it is neither satisfactory
nor dissatisfactory. Assurance of competency, courtesy, credibility & security-
From customers’ point of view, all dimensions listed under ―Assurance head
(employees ‘behavior instill confidence in customers, safe felling in transactions,
consistent good courtesy of employees & having decent knowledge of employees in
answering customers queries) are quite satisfactory. So, on average the customers
are assured enough by competence, courtesy, credibility and security of the
employees and the bank. Tangible appearances in satisfying customers- Customers
of the bank are well satisfied with all types of tangible appearances (equipments,
materials, physical facilities & employees) inside the bank. And these factors made
the tangible dimension to stand top among all other dimensions. Performance in
personal care, understanding customers & offered banking hour- From the survey
result it is found that “the employees of AIBL have the short interest of customers
in their heart”. Other statements of Empathy dimensions such as service charges and
individual interest is satisfactory from the customer point of view. So, from the
quantitative analysis it is found that although in some dimensions customers are
not properly satisfied, the overall result is pointing to a satisfactory level of
customers‘satisfaction at Al-Arafah Islami Bank Limited, Laldighirpar Branch. There
are some points where it needs to improve performance to increase the level of
customer satisfaction. These are- holding best interest of customer, provide
service as promised, providing information exactly when service will be provided,
providing quick service, response timely to customers, etc.
Page | 119
General Banking & SME department. Customers of the bank are increasing day by day.
It will not be possible to serve customers then as they serve today. To make
provide them prompt service without creating any queue more employees are needed
under General Banking department. This will help them to carry on every day time
consuming works like voucher sorting properly and thus there will be no pending
works. They also believe that as the bank provides online services, it should use a
better internet service or make contact with such a better internet service
provider which can help the employees to provide quick and smooth service to the
valued customers.
7.2 Problems & LimitationsDuring collecting of information and data from AIBL &
making report for this project the following problems have been followed:
Decision making process is very lengthy and sometimes it creates problems, which is
unexpected to the customers. Most of the cases Head Office control the decision
making and it is centralized. The total number of employees in comparison with
needed is short. This is hampering the daily operation of the Bank. For an example,
Laldighirpar Branch General Banking is suffering from shortage of employee.
Lack of proper explanation of records and document records keeping system. In many
cases, there have lack of communication between different levels of employees.
Page | 120
CHAPTER 8
Page | 121
8.1 Recommendations
It was an interested experience to do internship in Al-Arafah Islami Bank Limited.
The staff was highly cooperated and due to their help I learned big deal about
modern banking. I suggest that such an internship program highly integrative for
the students of business administration so that the students should be enquired
with the knowledge of practice world .I do summarize that it would be a great help
to me in selection of job or future field of work. It is very difficult for me to
recommend with a practical experience of just almost 3 months. On the basis of
interviews, study and observation I would like to put some suggestions, which will
enable the bank to compete with other banks more effectively & efficiently. The
suggestions are Maintenance of Time Slots for Each Customer to Serve: While
employees deal with customers they can maintain standard time or time slots for
each customer they handle and for each work they do. This consciousness will help
to perform works quickly and to serve more customers. Bank should give more
attention to female customers and set up separate service desk for them. As it is
an Islamic bank there should be appoint female staff for provide prompt service to
female customer. Setup Electronic Calling Machine for Cash Counter- Most of the
time there is a rush in the cash counter. To manage proper queue and to manage this
rush properly setting up of Electronic Calling Machine can be effective. Setting
up of Query Desk/ Information Booth/ Reception Booth: A conventional query desk or
reception booth or information booth can serve customers who make a phone or come
at banks for simple query and this can reduce customers‘ rush to the officers
table. The employees should response more attractively and try to provide prompt
service to customers of different age. There need to start more separate and
special service for students. Now-a day’s many banks provides student support
service who wants to go abroad for higher study.
Assessing Customer Satisfaction Level at AIBL (Ldp. Br.) Page | 122
Decision Making- Decision making power should be decentralized effectively so
that business can promptly be enhanced. Appointment of more Employees under
General Banking Department: More appointed employees can simplify the works of
general banking and can serve the customers well. This will also help to ensure no
work pending and no customer un-served. Appointment of more employees under this
department will also reduce the workload of existing employees and will help to
improve their morale. Employee Training Workshops- Employees should be trained by
arranging workshops time to time. Because this can release them from monotony,
increase their knowledge and morale. Appointing Female Employees- To understand
the female customers‘ specific needs woman employees can be effective and a
separate desk for women can improve the Islamic image of the bank and will secure
the motto committed to cordial service. The employees should be signed jobs for
specific period and than they should shifted to other department so that they gain
knowledge of other jobs. Bank should properly advertise and Communicate to public
about the services provided by it, so that more customers will be attracted.
System and operations should be more defined and organized. IT draw backs should be
improved. Lockers, ATM, all these facilities should be provided to attract more
customers. In a competitive financial market, their products & services need to
focused more on customers’ needs then simply offering what the customers are
offering They should do more marketing activities to improve their presence in
the minds of the target market and also the potential target market. As we see
that, Media coverage of DBL is not so strong. To attract new clients, they should
go for mass media coverage.
Page | 123
8.2 Conclusion
During the three months internship program in Al-Arafah Islami Bank Limited in
Laldighirpar branch at Sylhet, almost all the desk have been observed more or less.
This internship program, in first, has been arranged for gaining knowledge of
practical banking and to compare this practical knowledge with theoretical
knowledge. All departments and sections are not covered in the internship program;
so it is not possible to go to the depth of each activities of branch because of
time limitation. However, highest effort has been given to achieve the objectives
of the internship program. Al-Arafah Islami Bank ltd. is a non government
commercial Bank in Bangladesh, which started its business from 1995. It is a unique
combination of Shari’ah and Islamic banking. Among non government commercial banks,
Al-Arafah Islami Bank Ltd. is a milestone for economic development. It has been
playing an important role to eradicate the unemployment problem in Bangladesh. Over
1,700 employees and 11,000 shareholders are getting benefit from this organization.
But most of the people in our country have misconception about Islamic banking
specially Al-Arafah Islami Bank Ltd. and other Islamic banks. They cannot find any
difference in its operation between conventional commercial Banks and Islamic Banks
because they have no clear idea about the activities as well as investment
mechanism of Islamic banks. The Bank is committed to run its activities as per
Islamic Shari’ah and thus it has different investment(credit) modes, different
repayment schedules, different disbursement procedure, different mark up system.
And also has a different Investment policy. People are getting more benefit from
the dealings of Islamic banking because here quarterly interest is not charged and
there is no possibility of interest to be converted into principal. For ensuring
more benefit, more facility from Islamic banks like AIBL we have to be honest and
more sincere to repay the taken money from these banks in time.
Page | 124
Developing a customer satisfaction program is not just about carrying out a survey.
Surveys provide the reading that shows where attention is required but in many
respects, this is the easy part. Very often, major long lasting improvements need a
fundamental transformation in the organization, probably involving training of the
staff, possibly involving cultural change. The result should be financially
beneficial with less customer churn, higher market shares, premium prices, stronger
brands and reputation, and happier staff. However, there is a price to pay for
these improvements. Costs will be incurred in the research surveys are made. Time
will be spent working out an action plan and in implementation of development
process. Training may well be required to improve the customer service. The
implications of customer satisfaction surveys go far beyond the survey itself and
will only be successful if fully supported by the echelons of senior management.
Page | 125
APPENDICES
Page | 126
Appendix – I
Questionnaire for analyzing “Customer Satisfaction Level at Al-Arafah Islami Bank
Ltd., Laldighirpar Branch, Sylhet.” Age: Profession: 18-25 Above Businessman
Service holder Student 26-33 34-50 51Gender: Male Female Other
Please show the extent to which you believe AIBL has the feature described in the
statement. Write number (1, 2, 3, 4, 5) that best shows your perceptions. Point
Level of satisfaction 1 Strongly disagree 2 Disagree 3 Average 4 Agree 5 Strongly
agree
Statements in the Tangible Dimension Statements 21. AIBL has modern looking
Strongly disagree equipment and technologies that better satisfy your needs. 22.
Your bank has convenient business hours. 23. The employees of the bank appear neat.
24. Materials associated with the service statements) (pamphlets are or visually
Disagree Average Agree Strongly agree
appealing at AIBL.
Page | 127
Statements in the Reliability Dimension Statements 25. When AIBL promises to do
something by a certain time, it does so. 26. When you have a problem, employees 27.
Your 28. AIBL records. Statements in the Responsiveness Dimension Statements 29.
Guidance at the entrance of the branch is satisfactory. 30. Employees in AIBL give
you prompt service. 31. Employees in AIBL are always willing to help you. 32.
Employees in AIBL pardon for making you wait. Strongly disagree Disagree Average
Agree Strongly agree bank insists give appropriate your solution of your problems.
completes on transactions rapidly. error free Strongly disagree Disagree Average
Agree Strongly agree
Page | 128
Statements in the Assurance Dimension Statements 33. The behavior of employees in
AIBL installs confidence in you. 34. You feel safe in in AIBL your area
transactions with AIBL. 35. Employees consistently courteous with you. 36.
Employees in AIBL have the knowledge questions. Statements in the Empathy Dimension
Statements 37. Service charges of AIBL are reasonable as comparatively to other
banks. 38. AIBL has your best interests at heart. 39. The employees of AIBL
understand your specific needs. 40. AIBL has employees who give you individual
attention. Thank you very much for your time, co-operation & patience
**************************************************** Strongly disagree Disagree
Average Agree Strongly agree to answer your Strongly disagree Disagree Average
Agree Strongly agree
Page | 129
Appendix – II
Survey Result 1. AIBL has modern looking equipment and technologies that better
satisfy your needs. Level of Satisfaction Strongly Disagree (1) 0 Disagree (2) 0
Average (3) 7 Agree (4) 31 Strongly Agree (5) 12 50 Total
2. Your bank has convenient business hours. Level of Satisfaction Strongly Disagree
(1) 0 Disagree (2) 0 Average (3) 13 Agree (4) 24 Strongly Agree (5) 13 50 Total
3. The employees of the bank appear neat. Level of Satisfaction Strongly Disagree
(1) 0 Disagree (2) 1 Average (3) 7 Agree (4) 21 Strongly Agree (5) 21 50 Total
Page | 130
5. When AIBL promises to do something by a certain time, it does so. Level of
Satisfaction Strongly Disagree (1) 0 Disagree (2) 0 Average (3) 17 Agree (4) 27
Strongly Agree (5) 6 50 Total
6. When you have a problem, employees give appropriate solution of your problems.
Level of Satisfaction Strongly Disagree (1) 0 Disagree (2) 1 Average (3) 12 Agree
(4) 26 Strongly Agree (5) 11 50 Total
8. AIBL insists on error free records. Level of Satisfaction Strongly Disagree (1)
0 Disagree (2) 0 Average (3) 10 Agree (4) 23 Strongly Agree (5) 17 50 Total
Page | 131
10. Employees in AIBL give you prompt service. Level of Satisfaction Strongly
Disagree (1) 0 Disagree (2) 0 Average (3) 14 Agree (4) 24 Strongly Agree (5) 12 50
Total
11. Employees in AIBL are always willing to help you. Level of Satisfaction
Strongly Disagree (1) 0 Disagree (2) 0 Average (3) 12 Agree (4) 21 Strongly Agree
(5) 17 50 Total
12. Employees in AIBL pardon for making you wait. Level of Satisfaction Strongly
Disagree (1) 0 Disagree (2) 0 Average (3) 17 Agree (4) 24 Strongly Agree (5) 9 50
Total
Page | 132
14. You feel safe in your transactions with AIBL. Level of Satisfaction Strongly
Disagree (1) 0 Disagree (2) 0 Average (3) 11 Agree (4) 19 Strongly Agree (5) 20 50
Total
15. Employees in AIBL area consistently courteous with you. Level of Satisfaction
Strongly Disagree (1) 0 Disagree (2) 0 Average (3) 18 Agree (4) 25 Strongly Agree
(5) 7 50 Total
16. Employees in AIBL have the knowledge to answer your questions. Level of
Satisfaction Strongly Disagree (1) 0 Disagree (2) 0 Average (3) 20 Agree (4) 23
Strongly Agree (5) 7 50 Total
17. Service charges of AIBL are reasonable as comparatively to other banks. Level
of Satisfaction Strongly Disagree (1) 0 Disagree (2) 0 Average (3) 9 Agree (4) 22
Strongly Agree (5) 19 50 Total
Page | 133
18. AIBL has your best interests at heart. Level of Satisfaction Strongly Disagree
(1) 0 Disagree (2) 0 Average (3) 29 Agree (4) 16 Strongly Agree (5) 5 50 Total
19. The employees of AIBL understand your specific needs. Level of Satisfaction
Strongly Disagree (1) 0 Disagree (2) 0 Average (3) 15 Agree (4) 18 Strongly Agree
(5) 17 50 Total
20. AIBL has employees who give you individual attention. Level of Satisfaction
Strongly Disagree (1) 0 Disagree (2) 0 Average (3) 9 Agree (4) 29 Strongly Agree
(5) 12 50 Total
Page | 134
Profession Distribution: Business Service holder Student Others Total 21 15 12 2 50
Page | 135
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Page | 136
Books Warde, Ibrahim. (2000). "Islamic Finance In The Global Economy". Edinburgh:
Edinburgh University Press. Dr. Aly Khorshid (July 2009), Encyclopedia of Islamic
Finance, published by Euromoney PLC, Guidelines for Islamic Banking, Banking
Regulation & Policy Department, Bangladesh Bank, Head Office, Dhaka; November 9,
2009 issue. Bangladesh bank: Scheduled Banks Statistics, April-June, 1997 issue.
Al-Arafah Islami Bank Limited (1995): Memorandum and Articles of Association of
alArafah islamic Bank Limited. Mirakhor, A (1997), Progress and Challenges of
Islamic banking, Review of Islamic Economics, vol. 4, No.2. Aaker, D. A., (1995),
Strategic Market Management. 4th ed., John Wiley, New York. Hoyer, W. D. &
MacInnis, D. J., (2001), Consumer Behaviour. 2nd ed., Boston, Houghton Mifflin
Company. Coldwell, J., at al, (2001), Customer Relationship Management, Tata
McGraw-Hill, New Delhi. Kotler, P., (2000), Marketing Management. 10 th ed.,
Prentice-Hall, New Jersey. Johnson, M. D. & Gustafsson, A. (2000), Improving
Customer Satisfaction, Loyalty, and Profit: An Integrated Measurement and
Management System. Jossey-Bass Inc, San Francisco, California. Fornell, C.
(2007), The Satisfied Customer – Winners and Losers in the Battle for Buyer
Preference. Palgrave Macmillan, New York. Siddiqi, Mohammad Nejatullah (2001).
Lecture Series on Islamic Bank and Finance. UCLA International Institute, Available
at: <URL: http://www.international.ucla.edu/article.asp? parentid=15056>. Usmani,
Muhammad Taqi (n.d.). Musharakah & Mudarabah. <URL: http://
www.darululoomkhi.edu.pk/fiqh/islamicfinance/mudarabah.html>.
Page | 137
Journals Errico, L and Farahbaksh, M (1998). Islamic Banking : Issues in
Prudential Regulations and Supervision, IMF Working Paper No. Wp/9830,March 1998,
International Monetary fund, JEL Classification Numbers. Ahmed, E.A: Islamic
banking: distribution of Profit (Case Study), Ph.D. Thesis, December 1990,
University of Hull, UK. Naqvi, Syed Nawab Haider (2000). “Islamic Banking: An
Evaluation,” IIUM Journal of Economics and Management, 8(1). Rich, Georg and
Walter, Christian (1993). “The Future of Universal Banking”, Cato Journal,13(2).
Rohrbeck, R., Steinhoff, F. and F. Perder(2010) Sourcing Innovation from You
Customer: How Multinational Enterprises use Web Platforms for Virtual Customer
Integration, Technology Analysis & Strategic Management, Vol. 22, No. 4, pp. 117–
131 Jacksonville Business Journal - by Harold Resnick Naser, K., Jamal, A. and
Al-Khatib, K. (1999), “Islamic Banking: A study of customer satisfaction and
preferences in Jordan”, International Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol.17, No.3,
PP.135-50. Peterson, R.A. and Wilson, W.R. (1992), ``Measuring customer
satisfaction: fact and artifact'', Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science,
Vol. 20, pp. 61-71. Levesque, T. and McDougall, G. H. C. (1996), “Determinants of
customer satisfaction in Retail banking”, International Journal of Bank Marketing,
Volume 14, No.7, PP. 12-20. Taylor, S.A. and Baker, T.L. (1994), ``An assessment
of the relationship between service quality and customer satisfaction in the
formation of consumers' purchase intentions'', Journal of Marketing, Vol. 58,
Summer, pp. 163-78. Bowen, J. T. & Chen, S. L., May 2001, The Relationship
Between Customer Loyalty and Customer Satisfaction, International Journal of
Contemporary Hospitality Management, pp. 213-217.
Page | 138
Journal: Parasuraman, Berry, and Zeithaml (1988) - SERVQUAL: A multiple-item
scale for measuring customer perceptions of service quality - Journal of retailing
64 (1) Spring.
Magazine & News Hokanson, S., January 2, 1995, The Deeper You Analyze, The More
You Satisfy Customers, Marketing News, p. 16. 2000, Managing Customer
Satisfaction: A Best Practice Perspective, The TQM Magazine, 12 (6), pp. 389-394.
Zairi, M., 2000, Managing Customer Dissatisfaction Through Effective Complaint
Management Systems, The TQM Magazine, 12 (5), pp. 331-335. Dr. Hayat Khan,
“Islamic Banking: Bringing morality into finance”, published on ABC Online on
Friday 19 June 2009. Research Department, Bangladesh Bank (1997): On the Dynamism
of Islamic banking in Bangladesh, latter issued to all the Islamic banks and Banks
having Islamic banking Branches and Counters on 15th March, 1997 (Letter No.
DR/PIED/IEC) 1/97).
Page | 139
http://www.marketingprofs.com http://islamicbanking.info/
http://www.iiibf.org/journal.html http://www.1000ventures.com/business_guide
http://www.al-arafahbank.com http://www.bangladesh-bank.org http://www.ask.com
http://www.businessdictionary.com http://www.managementstudyguide.com
http://www.nbrii.com/customer-survey-white-papers
http://www.allbusiness.com/sales/customer-service/471452-1.html
http://www.deepdyve.com/lp/emerald-publishing/islamic-banking-a-study-of-
customersatisfaction-and-preferences-in-tvuw1J4l3Z
Page | 140