Sunteți pe pagina 1din 9

Journal of Maternal and Child Health (2019), 4(5): 342-350

https://doi.org/10.26911/thejmch.2019.04.05.07

Maternal Mortality Evaluation: A Case Study


in Bantul, Yogyakarta

Arlina Dewi1), Nikma Kurnianingtyas Bekti1), Supriyatiningsih2)

1)Masters Program in Hospital Management, Universitas Muhammadiyah Yogyakarta


2)Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Faculty of Medicine and Health Science,
Universitas Muhammadiyah Yogyakarta

ABSTRACT

Background: Maternal mortality rate is one of the indicators to measure the level of a woman's
health. The maternal mortality rate in Indonesia is still high, it's about 190/100.000 live birth. The
objective of the present study is to evaluate the cause of maternal death in Bantul at 2016 which
related to the health services including human resources.
Subjects and Method: This was a mixed method with case study design on maternal mortality in
Bantul District. The qualitative data collected through Focus Group Discussion (FGD) and the
quantitative data from the questionnaire were filled by a senior midwife throughout the hospital in
Bantul. The number of hospitals in Bantul District was 11 consisting of 1 government hospital and
10 private hospitals.
Results: The number of obstetricians who could be available 24 hours in hospitals was still
limited. The skills of midwives were still considered to be limited in handling a number of obstetric
emergency conditions due to the lack of regular training. The primary health care services which
had been provided to support and handle obstetric emergencies, but the infrastructure and human
resources were still considered inadequate. Thus, there was also a condition where the utilization of
integrated ANC facilities in the primary health center (Puskesmas) was still low, soan early
detection of complications of pregnancy was less optimal.
Conclusion: There are three main topics causing the maternal mortality at Bantul, and those are
1)Maternal mortality related to hospital facilities, 2) Maternal mortality related to human resources
at the hospital, 3) Maternal mortality related to health center facility.

Keywords: maternal, obstetrician stand-by, hospital

Correspondence:
Arlina Dewi. Masters Program in Hospital Management, Universitas Muhammadiyah Yogyakarta.
Jl. Brawijaya, Bantul 55183, Yogyakarta, Indonesia. Email: dewikoen@yahoo.com. Mobile: +6281-
22972576

BACKGROUND been able to reach the MDGs target which


Maternal mortality rate (MMR) is a health is still 190/100,000 live births while the
problem that is one of WHO focuses. Every MDGs target is 102/100,000 live births
day, it is estimated that 830 women die due (WHO et al., 2015).
to the causes related to pregnancy and Based on the maternal mortality data
birth. from Yogyakarta health office in 2015, it
In 2015, approximately 303,000 was found that in the city of Yogyakarta,
women died. Ninety-nine percent of mater- there were 2 cases, and Bantul Regency had
nal deaths occur in developing countries. 11 cases. Besides, Kulonprogo Regency had
Indonesia is one of the developing count- 2 cases, Sleman Regency had 4 cases.
ries which need attention to maternal mor- Gunungkidul District had 2 cases as well.
tality. In 2015, MMR in Indonesia has not Hence, Bantul Regency occupied the top

342 e-ISSN: 2549-0257


Dewi et al./ Maternal Mortality Evaluation in Bantul, Yogyakarta

position in the Special Province of Yogya- health services in Bantul Regency. A sam-
karta (Dinkes DIY, 2015). pling of qualitative data was selected by
The results of the Maternal Perinatal purposive sampling method. The informant
Audit (MPA) concluded that the causes of had been determined by a researcher
maternal deaths in 2015 were severe pre- consisting of all senior midwives at Bantul
eclampsia (SPE), 36% (4 cases), bleeding by Regency hospital. Therefore, quantitative
36% (4 cases), pulmonary TB 18% (2 cases), data samples were chosen by representa-
and amniotic emboli 9% (1 case). The tives of a senior midwife or maternity room
spread cases of maternal deaths in Bantul coordinator in each hospital in Bantul
regency occurred in several sub-districts regency.
with the highest number of cases reported
in the Sedayu II Health Center, Bangun- RESULTS
tapan I, and Jetis I with 2 cases (Dinkes The FGD results were categorized into 3
Bantul, 2017). In addition, the maternal groups namely 1) hospital facilities related
death audit used 112 medical records to maternal deaths, 2) maternal mortality
conducted by the Indonesian Obstetrics rates related to human resources in hospi-
and Gynecology Association in November tals, 3) maternal deaths related to primary
2014 which divided the causes of maternal health care. For more detailed information,
deaths in 3 major groups namely: 1) each result is explained in the following
General condition, 2) Pre-hospital role, and paragraphs.
3) Hospital role (Saleh, 2014). 1. Maternal mortality Related to
Hospital Facilities
SUBJECTS AND METHOD Hospitals as advanced health facilities
This was a mixed method study with case should have the readiness facilities and
studies on maternal mortality in Bantul infrastructures which support the services
Regency. Qualitative data were obtained for pregnant women, especially who are
from the Focus Group Discussion (FGD), referred to special condition or emergency
and quantitative data used a questionnaire condition.
as a research instrument. The number of A representative of obstetrician stated
hospitals in Bantul Regency is 11 consisting that there were several conditions of the
of 1 government hospital and 10 private hospitals which were not in accordance
hospitals. Likewise, the study population with the hospital standards:
for qualitative data involved all midwives, “Well, if we take a look at some
obstetricians, and health department staffs. explanations of the people who have
Moreover, Bantul Regency which is contributed into maternal mortality cases,
directly related to maternal health services. evidently, there have not been sophisti-
In the quantitative population data, those cated tools in accordance to hospital faci-
included all midwives who work in Bantul lities, availability of operating rooms, and
Regency hospitals. Besides, qualitative data availability of doctors.”
samples were the participants consisting of Bantul district health office also
senior midwives or maternity room coordi- added about the conditions in Bantul where
nators who worked in hospitals as obs- all cases of death occurred at the hospital.
tetricians and gynecology specialists as well The statement mentioned was likely related
as representatives from District and Provin- to available ICU room and foundation
cial Health Offices related to maternal management at the hospital:

e-ISSN: 2549-0257 343


Journal of Maternal and Child Health (2019), 4(5): 342-350
https://doi.org/10.26911/thejmch.2019.04.05.07

"Indeed, from 12 deaths, we evalua- other Obstetricians or a suggestion or a


ted that some deaths occurred in a second- mechanism where if there was something
ary health facility or at the hospitals. that really needed to be done, it included
Regarding the possible existence of ICU quite a risky action. Also, there was a
rooms and foundation management in the symbiosis of suggestions from other
health facilities, we cannot deny that there obstetricians which might not be available
are still people who access un-PONEK at this time. "
hospitals directly. " In addition, existing human resources
In regards to the audit results submit- also needed to get updated knowledge
ted by representatives of the Yogyakarta regularly only if it was needed especially for
Health Office, it was obtained from 12 cases personal evaluation. In line with what was
of maternal deaths in 2016, three cases stated by other obstetrician representatives
occurred in government hospitals, two who argued:
cases in central hospitals, and the rest of “From the study, it was mentioned
the cases occurred in private hospitals. that 53% of patients experienced improper
Therefore, it was necessary to pay more clinical decision making which was quite
attention to private hospitals. Also, the high. From the case mentioned, it needed
statements mentioned were supported by to be evaluated and it also included 47% of
the statement below. late execution personally. "
“If we pointed out to Bantul regard- Yogyakarta provincial health office
ing the maternal deaths in 2016, the also added the conditions when there was a
maternal deaths also occurred at all referral to a hospital, not all referral cases
hospitals. For the season, it turned out that were handled by an obstetrician. Some
this private hospital also contributed to references were still handled by hospital
helping the maternal deaths. Besides, from midwives as stated below:
12 cases happened in Bantul especially in a "Evidently, this hospital also had a
regional hospital, there included only 3 lot of cases in regards to the limited human
cases of maternal deaths. Also, at central resources of doctors, especially for specia-
hospital, there were two cases of maternal lists, so if there was a reference, it turned
deaths happened. Thus, the existence of out that there was also an existing mid-
private hospitals had to be given more wife. Then, the one who helped or provided
attention as well.” the first treatment or even the midwife
2. Maternal Mortality Related to would be clear in consultation or
Human Resources at the Hospital telephoning.”
One of the conditions associated with In addition, there were also problems
human resources in a hospital was about an regarding the periodic training for mid-
obstetrician’s dilemma when facing certain wives which were rarely carried out due to
emergency cases. The dilemma was related constrained costs. Most of the people who
to decision making to take immediate attended the training were only to fulfill the
action. Thus, an obstetrician representative registration certificate extension require-
conveyed his experience: ments. Some hospitals facilitated funding
“One of taking the decisions is about for midwifery training, but many of them
the system which can be done in order to also did not facilitate medical staffs because
get results for very severe cases which do they considered the training to be a private
not stand alone. Perhaps, it could be with

344 e-ISSN: 2549-0257


Dewi et al./ Maternal Mortality Evaluation in Bantul, Yogyakarta

investment of a midwife, not related to the Representatives of obstetricians


hospital: focused on the stabilization of pre-referrals
"Midwives also have a kind of and communication between referrers and
periodic training, and they should do the health workers in the referral hospital:
training in order to courage their abilities "Not only one person who had a title
increased, sharpened, and reminded. For of Sp. OG had to work, but also from the
the problem, I ask midwives training, and beginning, if we had already known about
they say it is expensive. Well, nurses have it, we thought at first level health or in
the same assumption too. In fact, the health care provider (PPK 1), we had all
training is expensive which sometimes it the warnings. Now only we want to not
does not participate in training as well, or obey the warning. All of them are already
sometimes, the training is very tight when at high risk, so from the beginning, a
they have to extend the registration certi- consultation conducted. Also, it should
ficate. Besides, some hospitals facilitate to include well-evaluated in order not to get
allocate funds for this training. However, an emergency to the women. Well, in my
most hospitals are unwilling because they opinion, there must be good communica-
might be considered as their own needs. As tion from the leader to the staffs of health
same as the obstetrician, every 5 years, the providers.”
registration certificate must be followed up An obstetrician representative also
regarding the for permission practice added about the situation of patients who
license extension in renewing the registra- had never performed ANC to a first-rate
tion certificate. Therefore, they have to pay health facility, so they were not immedia-
for it their selves, but maybe, for some tely referred to secondary health facilities:
midwives; it might still be an obstacle.” "I have also met a number of patients
3. Maternal Mortality Related to whose actual risk factors should have been
Primary Health Care detected beforehand, but the patient was
Bantul regency has 8 PONED health never referred to at least get an ANC
centers and 16 health centers hospitalized consultation in our place so that it seemed
to facilitate first-level health services. How- suddenly. Also, the condition was not good
ever, it is still constrained by limited human even though it was actually a series of
resources and physical infrastructure. As several weeks earlier. "
stated by representatives of the Bantul Representatives from one of the
District Health Office, they said that: health center highlighted the importance of
"For the health centers related to implementing integrated ANC at the health
maternal handling readiness, we prepared center. Recently, some pregnant women
8 PONED health centers and 16 health preferred to go directly to the hospital or to
centers inpatient car. Then, all of them still an independent practice doctor even
experienced possible limitations in terms of though there were not including integrated
human resources. For the limitation ANC provision facilities except the health
related to physical infrastructure, we center.
strived to always propose at the district "All pregnant women should be
level which was expected to be able to meet contacted to the health center especially
the needs related to physical infrastructure for monitoring the local area. Secondly, it
and medical devices for maternal should get integrated ANC. Then, I have to
handling." convey the integrated ANC to the mother

e-ISSN: 2549-0257 345


Journal of Maternal and Child Health (2019), 4(5): 342-350
https://doi.org/10.26911/thejmch.2019.04.05.07

in Bantul in which the integrated ANC is dentist at the health center. This is why
required by the health center. For the first after all if you have the patients, you
handling of patients, they should be should bring them to the health center
contacted by a general practitioner for based on their needs. Also, if the patients
screening the disease. For the second step, have a nutritional problem, they should be
the patients must be contacted by the brought to nutrition experts as well.”
Table 1. Maternal Mortality in Bantul Regency
Hospital Types Year
2014 2015 2016
B (1 RS) 3 4 3
C (2 RS) 2 2 1
D (6 RS) 0 0 1
Total 5 6 5

Table 2. Questionnaire Data to Support the Facilities of Pregnant Women Health


Services in Hospital
Hospital Types
Parameter
B (n=1) C (n=2) D (n=6)
Anesthetic equipment, operating room, 24-hour 1 2 6
standby surgical equipment
Baby resuscitation equipment 1 2 4
Active management equipment 3 1 2 6
Equipment for obstetric emergencies in the emergency 1 2 6
room
Obstetric emergency equipment in the delivery room 1 2 3
Obstetric emergency medicine at emergency room 1 2 5
Obstetric emergency medicine in the delivery room 1 2 6

Table 3. Human Resource Questionnaire Data Related to the Care and Treatment
of Pregnant Women at Hospital
Hospital Types
Parameter
B (n=1) C (n=2) D (n=6)
Standing-by Obstetrician in 24 hours 1 2 3
The operating team with the operating assistant / 1 2 5
24-hour standby surgical nurse team
The operation team with a 24-hour standby 1 1 1
specialist
The emergency doctor with obstetric emergency 1 2 3
competency

DISCUSSION pregnancy, or aggravated by pregnancy or


In regards to The Tenth Revision of Inter- in the handling. Besides, maternal morta-
national Classes of Diseases (ICD-10), the lity is not caused by an accident(Say et al.,
maternal mortality occurs during preg- 2014). In addition, there are several risk
nancy or in 42 days after the end of preg- factors which can influence maternal
nancy, regardless of the length and location mortality, and one of them is related to the
of pregnancy, caused by anything related to non-medical factors and health services
(Arulita, 2007).

346 e-ISSN: 2549-0257


Dewi et al./ Maternal Mortality Evaluation in Bantul, Yogyakarta

Hospital facilities as a place of refe- uneven distribution of health workers


rence should meet minimum standards. (Sousa et al., 2006; Speybroec et al., 2012).
However, at some referral hospitals, this The previous research was also in line with
has not yet been fulfilled. Meanwhile, in Bossert et al. (1991) who said that uneven
Bantul regency, there is only a hospital distribution of health workers becomes a
which has been certified as a PONEK hos- serious problem in medical health world.
pital. For un-PONEK hospitals, many of Efendi (2012) explained that in his
which are still constrained by the absence research, it related to the provision of
of obstetricians who stand-by for 24 hours. health workers in remote areas in Indo-
Powell explained that on his study, good nesia. Government programs in the form of
hospital infrastructures can be one of the contract workers and special assignments
keys in decreasing maternal mortality. showed a significant contribution to incre-
In this national health insurance asing the availability of health workers.
(JKN) era, the facilities and infrastructure Apart from the unequal distribution
in the referral hospital are deemed unable of health personnel problems, there are
to respond to the surge in referrals. The several other things which cause problems
multilevel referral system only allows refer- in the human resource aspect. The low
ring to a higher type of hospital. Mean- salaries of existing health workers, poor
while, number A and B hospitals are still a working conditions, lack of supervision,
limited number. In addition, to the limited and lack of infrastructure also influence
number, not all referral hospitals have the human resource problems (Ferrinho et al.,
facilities for handling obstetric emergen- 1999; Kirigia et al., 2006; Lehmann et al.,
cies. From the statement mentioned, it is 2008; Ramani et al., 2013).
caused by the determination of hospitals Additionally, regular training for mid-
that were only based on the minimum wives is also a concern focus in order to
number of beds and are not based on more reduce maternal mortality. The limited
important considerations such as ICU, number of obstetricians who stand by for
NICU facilities, ventilators, or other health 24 hours at a hospital has resulted in
equipment. There are some hospitals which hospital midwives needing to improve and
have fulfilled the latest and more needed always update their skills in handling
medical equipment requirements, but they emergencies in pregnant women. In several
are still classified as class C hospitals (lower studies, it was found that the availability of
classes) because they do not meet the trained midwives showed a significant
minimum number of beds. As a result, the reduction in maternal mortality (Campbell
hospital may not serve labor complications et al., 2006; Wilson et al., 2011).
which are quite severe (Noerdin et al., The health system in Indonesia which
2015). uses a multilevel referral system makes
The existence of health workers who primary health facilities as the main gate-
are competent in the obstetrics field is one way for the community as well as in the
of the things which become highly prio- service and handling of pregnant women.
ritized in pregnant women services. In fact, However, from the FGD results, it was
in reality, there are still many shortcomings found that some conditions were not ideal.
in terms of quantity and quality. In the One of them was the lack of attention from
previous study, it was found that one of the the health center on ANC discipline of
lack of health providers quantity is an pregnant women which caused when a

e-ISSN: 2549-0257 347


Journal of Maternal and Child Health (2019), 4(5): 342-350
https://doi.org/10.26911/thejmch.2019.04.05.07

condition required a referral as if the Available facilities and infrastructure do


patient "suddenly" came in a bad condition. not meet the specified standards. The
Yego et al. (2014) mentioned that in his number of obstetricians who can stand-by
study, ANC is really needed by the pregnant 24 hours in hospitals is still limited.
women since it can be very helpful in Besides, there are conditions where many
identifying the risk factors in order to referrals to hospitals are also not directly
prevent maternal mortality. handled by obstetricians, but they are
In addition, there are also short- handled by hospital midwives. Meanwhile,
comings in the aspects of human resources the skills of midwives are still considered to
and infrastructure in the health center. be limited in handling a number of
Besides, this condition can be seen in the obstetric emergency conditions due to the
basic data of DIY health center in 2015 lack of regular training.
where there were several health centers There have already included several
which had not yet become PONED health PONED health centers to facilitate health
centers and also lack of midwife staffs services for pregnant women, but infra-
(Kemenkes, 2015). structure and human resources are still
Taking a look at the conditions at the considered inadequate. Regarding the
health center, it is necessary to have better referral system, good communication
monitor compliance with Standard Opera- between referrers and health workers in
ting Procedure (SOP) and the applicable referral hospitals is one of the important
guidelines. The use of SOP and updated things which play a role in reducing the risk
guidelines can help to improve the commu- of referral to pregnant women. Another
nity service. In addition, health workers at thing that also needs to be considered is the
the health center are also expected to lack of utilization of integrated ANC facile-
understand well and also have initiatives ties in the health center. Therefore, early
related to services provided in accordance detection of complications of pregnancy is
with the guidelines (Mashalla et al., 2016). less optimal.
Moreover, some pregnant women also
choose to come to the hospital and health REFERENCES
center. Regarding the research conducted Arulita F (2007). Faktor-Faktor Risiko yang
by Emelumadu et al. (2014), this is possible Mempengaruhi Kematian Maternal
that the services in the hospital are more (Studi Kasus di Kabupaten Cilacap)
comfortable, and there are specialist (PhD Thesis). Tesis, Program Studi
doctors. Also, the hospitals are easily Magister Epidemiologi, Program Pas-
accessible. In some previous studies, it was ca Sarjana Universitas Diponegoro,
found that pregnant women prefer to come Semarang.
to health facilities which have more Bossert T, Soebekti R, Rai NK (1991).
complete health workers although some Bottom-up’ planning in Indonesia:
pregnant women in rural areas still use decentralization in the ministry of
traditional midwives services (Hutchinson health. Health Policy Plan. 6: 55–63.
et al., 2011; Osubor et al., 2006; Uzochuk- https://doi.org/10.1093/heapol/6.1.5
wu et al., 2004). 5.
Campbell OM, Graham WJ (2006). Strate-
CONCLUSION gies for reducing maternal mortality:

348 e-ISSN: 2549-0257


Dewi et al./ Maternal Mortality Evaluation in Bantul, Yogyakarta

getting on with what works. The Lan- Mashalla YJ, Sepako E, Setlhare V, Chuma
cet. 368: 1284–1299. M, Bulang M, Massele AY (2016).
Dinkes Bantul (2017). Profil Kesehatan Availability of guidelines and policy
Kabupaten Bantul 2016. documents for enhancing perform-
Dinkes DIY (2015). Narasi Profil Daerah ance of practitioners at the Primary
Istimewa Yogyakarta. Health Care (PHC) facilities in Gabo-
Efendi F (2012). Health Worker Recruit- rone, Tlokweng and Mogoditshane,
ment and Deployment in Remote Republic of Botswana. J. Public
Areas of Indonesia (SSRN Scholarly Health Epidemiol. 8, 127–135.
Paper No. ID 2884694). Social Sci- Noerdin E, Aripurnami S, Anindhita F,
ence Research Network, Rochester, Elison NK, Pelangi B, Susanti LR,
NY. (2015). Pemenuhan Fasilitas Kesehat-
Emelumadu OF, Onyeonoro UU, Ukegbu an Ibu Melahirkan Era Jaminan Kese-
AU, Ezeama NN, Ifeadike CO, Okezie hatan Nasional.
OK (2014). Perception of quality of Osubor KM, Fatusi AO, Chiwuzie JC
maternal healthcare services among (2006). Maternal health-seeking
women utilizing antenatal services in behavior and associated factors in a
selected primary health facilities in rural Nigerian community. Matern.
Anambra State, Southeast Nigeria. Child Health J. 10, 159–169. https://-
Niger. Med. J. J. Niger. Med. Assoc. doi.org/10.1007/s10995-005-0037-z
55, 148. Powell-Jackson T, Gao Y, Ronsmans C,
Ferrinho P, Van Lerberghe W, da Cruz Zhou H, Wang Y, Fang H (2015).
Gomes A (1999). Public and private Health-system determinants of decli-
practice: a balancing act for health nes in maternal mortality in China
staff. Bull. World Health Organ. between 1996 and 2013: a provincial
Hutchinson PL, Do M, Agha S (2011). Mea- econometric analysis. The Lancet, The
suring client satisfaction and the Lancet-CAMS Health Summit Abs-
quality of family planning services: a tracts booklet 386, S15. https://doi.-
comparative analysis of public and org/10.1016/S0140-6736(15)00593-0
private health facilities in Tanzania, Ramani S, Rao KD, Ryan M, Vujicic M,
Kenya, and Ghana. BMC Health Serv. Berman P (2013). For more than love
Res. 11, 203. https://doi.org/10.1186- or money: attitudes of student and in-
/1472-6963-11-203. service health workers towards rural
Kemenkes (2015). Data Dasar Puskesmas service in India. Hum Resour Health.
DIY 2015. 11: 58. doi: 10.1186/1478-4491-11-58.
Kirigia JM, Gbary AR, Muthuri LK, Nyoni Saleh N (2014). Audit Kematian Ibu.
J, Seddoh A (2006). The cost of health Say L, Chou D, Gemmill A, Tunçalp Ö, Mol-
professionals’ brain drain in Kenya. ler AB, Daniels J, Gülmezoglu AM,
BMC Health Serv. Res. 6, 89. Temmerman M, Alkema L (2014).
Lehmann U, Dieleman M, Martineau T, Global causes of maternal death: a
(2008). Staffing remote rural areas in WHO systematic analysis. Lancet
middle-and low-income countries: A Glob. Health 2: e323–e333.
literature review of attraction and Sousa A, Tandon A, Dal Poz MR, Prasad A
retention. BMC Health Serv. Res. 8, (2006). Measuring the efficiency of
19. human resources for health for attain-

e-ISSN: 2549-0257 349


Journal of Maternal and Child Health (2019), 4(5): 342-350
https://doi.org/10.26911/thejmch.2019.04.05.07

ing health outcomes across subnatio- WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA, World Bank
nal units in Brazil. World Health Group and the United Nations Popu-
Organization. lation Division.
Speybroeck N, Paraje G, Prasad A, Goova- Wilson A, Gallos ID, Plana N, Lissauer D,
erts P, Ebener S, Evans DB (2012). Khan KS, Zamora J, MacArthur C,
Inequality in Human Resources for Coomarasamy A (2011). Effectiveness
Health: Measurement Issues. Geogr. of strategies incorporating training
Anal. 44, 151–161. https://doi.org/- and support of traditional birth
10.1111/j.1538-4632.2012.00842.x attendants on perinatal and maternal
Uzochukwu BSC, Onwujekwe OE, Akpala mortality: meta-analysis. BMJ. 343:
CO (2004). Community satisfaction d7102. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.-
with the quality of maternal and child d7102
health services in southeast Nigeria. Yego F, D’Este C, Byles J, Williams JS,
East Afr. Med. J. 81: 293–299. Nyongesa P (2014). Risk factors for
WHO, UNICEF, UNFPA, World Bank maternal mortality in a Tertiary Hos-
Group (2015). Trends in maternal pital in Kenya: a case control study.
mortality: 1990-2015: estimates from BMC Pregnancy Childbirth 14: 38.

350 e-ISSN: 2549-0257

S-ar putea să vă placă și