Nama : Siti Hartinah

NPM : 1706978843
MATA KULIAH : Penulisan Ilmiah
DOSEN PENGAJAR : Prof. drh. Wiku Adisasmito, MSc. Ph.D

SYSTEMATIC REVIEW

METHODS

SEARCH STRATEGY

We first searched for articles in PubMed, Science Direct, and the American Journal of clinical
nutrition. This database provides broad coverage of health, especially the literature on
nutrition. There was a restriction set in the literature search between 2009 - 2019. Only articles
published in English with full texts are considered. The following search terms are identified
and used in combination to search each database: 'Fish consumption', 'Fish intake', 'Fish',
'Protein intake', 'Zinc intake', 'stunt *', 'Malnutrition', 'Linear child growth’. These terms were
searched in titles and/or abstracts.

Kami pertama kali mencari artikel PubMed, Sciencedirect, dan American Journal of clinical
nutrition. Basis data ini memberikan cakupan luas tentang kesehatan, terutama literatur tentang
nutrisi. Ada batasan tahun yang ditetapkan dalam pencarian literatur antara 2009 - 2019. Hanya
artikel yang diterbitkan dalam bahasa Inggris dengan teks lengkap yang dipertimbangkan. Istilah
pencarian berikut diidentifikasi dan digunakan dalam kombinasi untuk mencari setiap basis data:
‘Fish consumption’, ‘Fish intake’, ‘Fish’, ‘Protein intake’, ‘Zinc intake’, ‘stunt*’, ‘Malnutrition’, ‘Linear child
growth’

Download PubMed:

1. Fish consumption AND stunt*  21  12 free full text

2. Fish consumption AND malnutrition 

FIXED:
INCLUSION CRITERIA
Systematic reviews must meet the following criteria: (i) published in journals between 2011-
2019; (ii) reviewing research on stunting; (iii) published in English; (iv) the population including
pregnant women and children under five; (v) clearly illustrates fish consumption related to
stunting.

Systematic review harus memenuhi kriteria berikut: (i) dipublikasikan dalam jurnal antara 2011-
2019; (ii) meninjau penelitian yang membahas tentang stunting; (iii) dipublikasikan dalam bahasa
Inggris; (iv) populasi yang termasuk ibu hamil dan balita; (v) dengan jelas menggambarkan
konumsi ikan yang berhubungan dengan stunting.

The primary object of this study is to determine the association of fish in reducing stunting. The review
was restricted to studies of fish consumption and/or its nutrient (protein and zinc), discuss about
correlation of fish consumption and stunting, also types of fish that link into child growth. Written in
English, those studies were included if the subjects are pregnant women and under 5 children. Studies
that were conducted with cross-sectional, case control, systematic review, and cohort were also included.
The inclusion in this study also include articles that concludes there’s correlation between fish
consumption (protein & zinc) with reduction prevalence of stunting.

Tujuan utama penelitian ini adalah untuk menentukan hubungan ikan dalam mengurangi
stunting. Tinjauan ini terbatas pada studi konsumsi ikan dan / atau nutrisi (protein dan seng),
membahas tentang korelasi konsumsi ikan dan stunting, juga jenis ikan yang terkait dengan
pertumbuhan anak. Ditulis dalam bahasa Inggris, studi-studi itu dimasukkan jika subjeknya
adalah wanita hamil dan di bawah 5 anak. Studi yang dilakukan dengan cross-sectional, kontrol
kasus, tinjauan sistematis, dan kohort juga dimasukkan. Dimasukkannya dalam penelitian ini
juga termasuk artikel yang menyimpulkan ada korelasi antara konsumsi ikan (protein & seng)
dengan pengurangan prevalensi pengerdilan.
No. Kategori Referensi Jumlah

1. Not full text

2. Discuss other micronutrient 2

3. Membahas kandungan protein saja 1

4. Focused on discussing stunting regards another factor 1

5. Focused on other disease 8

6. Discuss dietary pattern only 7

7.

No. Kategori Referensi Jumlah

1. Proceeding 5

2. Focused on discussing stunting regards another factor 59

3. Duplicate 40

4. Focused on other disease 1438

5. Membahas kandungan protein saja 49

6. Membahas kandungan zinc saja 46

7. Membahas tentang ikan saja

.