Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
___________________________________
An Investigatory Project of
of
___________________________________
Student-Researchers
Research Adviser
2
ABSTRACT
The Philippines is greatly affected by hunger and poverty. There are still families in need
of help and support against this crisis. Degradation of soil in the country has also become a major
problem in the country, in which soil erosion is the most widespread and studied type of soil
degradation, while very few studies have been done on other types. With the addition of other
recent calamities, there is a need to help in decreasing further problems and make needs more
affordable for families so that they no longer experience starvation and poverty.
Hydroponics is said to have helped in situations like these, where instead of using
traditional soil to grow crops, a nutrient-rich solution is used to grow crops with the same quality
of plants grown in soil. It is said that hydroponically grown plants have increased yields, with
crops grown fast in good quality, which can contribute immediate support to areas where poverty
This study focuses on the effects and differences of growing pechay (Brassica rapa) in
hydroponics and soil in terms of number of leaves, height, wet weight, dry weight, and percent of
moisture. The hydroponics set-up was built with recycled materials, while the soil set-up was
grown in seedling bags. Results had shown that pechay grown in hydroponics had better effects
than in soil, where the plants had more leaves, taller height, and heavier weight than soil-grown
pechay, because the nutrients in hydroponics was more secured and controlled than in soil.
3
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TITLE PAGE
Abstract ……………………………………………………………………………. 2
Introduction
Recommendations ………………………………………………………….. 23
INTRODUCTION
The Philippines is a country rich with many products and resources. But as of today, the
country is still being greatly affected by hunger and poverty. An estimated 3.1 million Filipino
families experienced hunger at least once during the fourth quarter of the year 2016 based on a
Social Weather Stations (SWS) survey reported (Gavilan, 2016). The SWS held again a survey,
stating that fewer Filipino families experienced hunger in the first quarter of 2017, with 2.7
million still experiencing famine (Gonzales, 2017). Although already a big decrease, there are
still families that need help and support against this crisis.
Degradation of soil has become a major ecological and agricultural problem to both urban and
provincial areas in the country. It has been confirmed that soil erosion is the most widespread
and studied type of soil degradation processes in the Philippines but estimates of the rate of soil
loss are greatly variable due to the different methodologies used and the varying environmental
factors. Very few studies have been done on other types of soil degradation such as chemical and
physical soil degradation (Asio, Jahn, Perez, Navarrete & Abit, 2009).
With the addition of calamities, such as Super Typhoon Haiyan (Yolanda), which still
after four years is a problem, and the Battle of Marawi City that had people loss homes, there
have been studies, plans, and practices that had been done by many more people and are now on
track to help decrease further problems and make needs for them more affordable until families
Hydroponics has been part of the efforts done to help these situations. It is an alternative
farming method where instead of using soil to grow plants, a nutrient water solution and a
growing medium to anchor the plants is used. Hydroponics broadly means growing plants
without soil (Santos & Ocampo, 2009). In Swaziland, a study was made to make hydroponics
more low-cost and as a solution to food shortages in areas under conditions of poverty. Through
this study, people managed to produce large quantities of crops for relatively small areas using
waste materials and without using harmful chemicals, increasing food production and thus
With the conduct of this study, the researchers must make clear that there is a necessity to
compare whether or not hydroponics will serve as a better alternative or traditional soil-growing
will remain superior. The determination of the effects hydroponics will exhibit in this study may
benefit people in areas of poverty and may finally solve starvation of families as well here in the
Philippines.
Research Problems
1. What are the effects of the hydroponically grown Pechay in terms of the
following variables?
A. Number of leaves;
D. Percent of Moisture
6
2. What are the effects of the traditionally grown (grown in soil) Pechay in terms
A. Number of leaves;
D. Percent of Moisture
3. What are the differences between the Pechay grown in hydroponics and in soil
A. Number of leaves;
D. Percent of Moisture
Research Hypothesis
The following are the hypothesis derived from the research problems of this study:
A. Number of leaves;
D. Percent of Moisture
7
A. Number of leaves;
D. Percent of Moisture
A. Number of leaves;
D. Percent of Moisture
Using hydroponics may help solve hunger and poverty crises in the Philippines by
providing immediate food supply for people to consume. Plants may be grown in urban areas
without getting damaged, with fewer pests and less diseases, and can also be placed indoors or
Hydroponics may also help lessen the expenses of growing plants because it does not
need the use of soil or fertilizers. Setting up a hydroponics system requires minimum input and
materials used can be found locally or at home. Materials can also be recycled, which may help
reduce much cost. It may also support in problems fast because rapid growth can be observed
8
and more quality harvest may be collected, in which it may be benefitted by people who were
Aside from the advantage of less pests and diseases in plants, hydroponics can be
considered as environment-friendly due to the use of less water and without any use of
pesticides, which is as applied as necessary in traditional soil planting. The Simple Nutrient
Addition Program® or SNAP® Hydroponics Nutrient Solution used in our study is not harmful
to humans, animals, and plants, were proportioned just enough for the nutritional requirements of
plants, and is not toxic unless misused. SNAP® Hydroponics is also the simplest hydroponics
system so far in the country. Moreover, crops grown hydroponically are deemed safe and
Lastly, hydroponics may help improve certain areas of business, agriculture and economy
in the Philippines, all of which are greatly focused in the country and in need of further
development. Thus, hydroponics may well serve as a more efficient, safe, and affordable
This study mainly focuses on the effects of both hydroponics and traditional soil growing
based on the number of true leaves, height, wet weight, dry weight, and moisture content of the
test organism. Pechay (Brassica rapa) shall only be used as the test organism for both methods
of plant growing for its use as a model organism in other studies. The study is limited only to the
This study shall also be observed for a maximum of forty-five (45) days, and some
equipment used are recycled, collected locally or at home, and improvised. General materials
9
include the nutrient solution for hydroponics (SNAP® Hydroponics Nutrient Solution),
styrofoam boxes and cups collected from local fruit shops, loam soil, the growing media for
hydroponics (coco peat), garbage bags, a weighing scale, and a medicine cup used for vitamins
and cough syrups (improvised). Materials should always be clean and undamaged before use to
measured with the medicine cup before being poured into the water used for the set-up.
Replenishing of the hydroponics set-up with the nutrient solutions should only be around the
amount of twelve and a half (12.5) millilitres or half-strength of the initial volumes each and
must only be done when necessary. Both solutions should only be mixed into the water
separately.
Each seedling plug and seedling bag of both the hydroponics and soil set-ups respectively
must contain only one pechay plant. Each pechay seedling must have true leaves before being
In the collection of data, the weighing scale that shall be utilized to collect the wet weight
and dry weight of each grown pechay plant must be digital. The data for both weights can be
collected from local fruit and vegetable shops where digital weighing scales are given permission
to use.
The location of the hydroponics set-up must receive sunlight but must also be covered
from rain. An umbrella was used only as temporary cover for the hydroponically-grown pechay.
10
Establishment of Seedlings
Pechay (Brassica rapa) seedlings were germinated for three (3) weeks on a sowing tray
containing one (1) inch thick growing media (Coco Peat Bricks) and water. Twenty-four (24) of
Growing boxes for the hydroponics set-up of the experiment were assembled to hold the
hydroponics-grown pechay plants. Two (2) styrofoam boxes collected from local fruit shops and
polyethylene garbage bags bought from a hardware shop were the materials used for this
assembly. The lids of the boxes were punched with an empty tin can of big evaporated milk, with
both sides of the can opened from top and bottom, to form six (6) holes on the lids which will
later hold seedling plugs (See Diagram I). The garbage bags were used as liners for the bottom
Seedling plugs were prepared to hold hydroponics-grown pechay plants, while seedling
bags were prepared to hold soil-grown pechay plants. Twelve (12) styrofoam cups bought from a
local wet market were used as the plugs, with eight (8) holes sawed off by the sides of each cup
with a hacksaw or cutter , and were filled with half (1/2) inch thick of growing media (See
Pictures 1, 2, and 3). Meanwhile, twelve (12) seedling bags that were bought from local garden
shops were filled with loam soil. A one (1) inch gap between the soil and the top of each seedling
bag served as the allowance. The germinated pechay seedlings were transplanted to each
seedling plug and seedling bag and watered lightly. The seedling bags, now designated as the
Picture 1. Sawing of styrofoam cups Picture 2. Filling of Cups With Growing Media
The hydroponics set-up was placed where sunlight and cover form rain can be received.
With the growing boxes arranged there, each box were filled ten (10) litres of water and twenty-
five (25) millilitres of SNAP® Hydroponics Nutrient Solutions A and B that were ordered
online. The solutions were mixed separately to the water, the hole-punched lids of the boxes
were placed after, and the seedling plugs were placed to each hole of the lids. Each styrofoam
cup was “plugged” evenly and the bottom of each touched the nutrient-rich water by a half (1/2)
inch deep, not any deeper or shallower. Troubleshooting for any leaks was done as much as
Both set-ups finished, with twelve (12) pechay plants for the hydroponics set-up and
twelve (12) pechay plants for the soil set-up (See Diagram III), were constantly observed every
morning and afternoon. Replenishments were given, with water for soil-grown plants every
morning and afternoon, while half strength (12.5) millilitres of fresh SNAP® Hydroponics
Nutrient Solution A and B for hydroponics-grown plants only when needed. The number of true
leaves of each pechay served as data measured and was faithfully recorded. Five (5) weeks was
Final gathering and analysis of collected data started on the last day of observation. All
pechay of both set-ups had leaves counted individually, measured with a ruler for height, were
uprooted and weighed to measure the wet weight of each plant. After, the pechay were dried for
14
one (1) week and weighed again to collect the dry weight per plant. Collected data for the wet
and dry weights were calculated to identify the percent of moisture of each plant by percentage.
All different data had been tallied and presented in tables as shown in in the results.
RESULTS
E 8 3 5
F 7 3 4
G 6 3
3
H 8 -
I 6 3 2
J 7 3 1
K 7 2
0
L 9 2 Hydroponics Soil
Total 79 27 Set-up
Average 7 3
Table 1 shows the number of leaves of each pechay. The total and average amount of
leaves grown in hydroponics was greater in quantity than of soil. The average amount of leaves
in hydroponics was around seven (7), while in soil the average was only around three (3). The
number of leaves most pechay had grown in hydroponics was greater in amount, showing better
effect than pechay grown in soil (See Pictures 4, 5, and 6). The trend of the average amount of
Height (cm)
E 11 6
F 9 6 6
G 9 4.5
H 11.5 - 4
I 9 4
J 10 5.5 2
K 14.5 7
0
L 13 1 Hydroponics Soil
Total 112.5 49.5 Set-up
Average 10 5
The height of each pechay plant was measured with a ruler in centimeters (cm). The
average height of hydroponically-grown pechay, which measured ten (10) centimeters, was
higher than soil-grown pechay, which measured around five (5) centimeters. The total and
average height of plants in hydroponics was greater than of plants grown in soil, as shown in
Table 2. Most pechay grown in hydroponics were taller than pechay grown in soil. Figure 2
After being uprooted, each pechay plant was immediately weighed for the wet weights of
the individual plants, shown in Table 3. Most pechay in hydroponics, as with the number of
leaves and height, were heavier than the pechay grown in soil, altogether weighing four (4)
kilograms against the zero (0) kilogram total weight in soil. The average wet weight of pechay
grown in hydroponics was also heavier than in soil. The tendency of the weights is shown in
C 0.25 0 0.35
D 0.25 - 0.3
Weight (kg)
E 0.5 0
0.25
F 0.25 0
0.2
G 0.25 0
H 0.5 - 0.15
I 0.25 0 0.1
J 0.5 0 0.05
K 0.5 0
0
L 0.5 0 Hydroponics Soil
Total 4 0 Set-up
Average 0.4 0
E 0.1 0
F 0.1 0 0.06
G 0.1 0
H 0.1 - 0.04
I 0.1 0
J 0.1 0 0.02
K 0.1 0
0
L 0.1 0 Hydroponics Soil
Total 1.1 0 Set-up
Average 0.1 0
17
After getting the wet weight, the individual plants were dried and weighed again to
collect the dry weight. As shown on Table 4, after being dried, the weight of each plant grown on
hydroponics went from an average of two-fifth (0.4) kilograms down to one-tenth (0.1)
kilograms. The total weight in hydroponics went down from four (4) kilograms to one and one-
tenth (1.1) kilograms. However, the total and average dry weight of plants grown in hydroponics
was still heavier thanpechay grown in soil. In Figure 4, most pechay in hydroponics still had
D 60 - 60
E 80 0 50
F 60 0
40
G 60 0
H 80 - 30
I 80 0 20
J 60 0
10
K 80 0
L 80 0 0
Total 760 0 Hydroponics Soil
Set-up
Average 69 0
Percent of moisture of each pechay was calculated after the collection of the wet and dry
weights as tallied in Table 5. The formula used to identify the percent of moisture of each plant
The percent of moisture of most pechay plants grown in hydroponics was greater than of
pechay plants grown in soil. With the average of sixty-nine percent (69%), plants that had grown
in hydroponics have greater moisture content compared to plants grown in soil. Figure 5 shows
the total and average moisture content of pechay grown in hydroponics was still in greater
All data have supported that there were significant effects both on hydroponically grown
plants and traditionally grown plants. The data have also supported that there were significant
differences between pechay grown in hydroponics and in soil in terms of the number of leaves,
wet and dry weight, height, and moisture content of each plant, whereas hydroponically grown
plants showed better effect in all variables than traditionally grown plants.
DISCUSSION
This study focuses on the effects and differences of using hydroponics and soil in
planting pechay. The results showed that there were significant effects and differences between
using hydroponics and soil, in which hydroponics had shown better effect in terms of the number
of leaves, height, wet weight, dry weight, and moisture content of pechay grown than compared
to soil.
The effects of hydroponics in pechay were observed to see if whether or not the growing
technique works on the first place. The hypothesis that there are no significant effects in
hydroponics were proven false, which should be as hydroponics was developed to produce crops
with the same quality when grown in soil. Because all nutrient elements are available to the
plants in plenty (Jain, Pandey, & Singh, 2009), stored in a secured container, and conditions in
the environment such as weather and sunlight being adequate for plants to grow on, pechay had
grown properly in the set-up. This also proves that hydroponics can be grown in areas where soil
is a scarce resource, as long as the conditions for growing plants are good.
Pechay were also grown in soil to see if there were effects and differences of using this
technique compared to hydroponics. There were significant effects in using soil and there were
great differences between the two methods. Within the forty-five (45) days allotted for observing
the set-ups, it was collected that while hydroponically grown pechay had an average of seven (7)
leaves, ten centimeters (10) height, and weight before and after being dried, traditionally grown
pechay only had an average of three (3) leaves, five centimeters (5) height, and virtually had no
weight even before being dried. It was expected that the pechay grown in soil would have lesser
values than compared to hydroponics in terms of the variables, as hydroponics have the nutrients
21
for the plants to grow on more secured than in soil. However, it was not expected that the data
would be too low, as conditions in the environment were met just enough for plants to grow on.
The pechay in hydroponics having grown better than in soil, based on the variables
tested, was because the nutrients in hydroponics is more controlled than soil. While the
hydroponics set-up had nutrients secured in growing boxes and in plenty for plants to grow on,
being able to be in optimum growing conditions at all times (Omaye & Treftz, 2015), the soil
set-up is not secured. Soil has the tendency to change due to activities caused by people and the
environment. As soil material is displaced, nutrients is loosed as well, causing constraints for
plant growth such as low organic matter and nutrient content (Asio, Jahn, Perez, Navarrete &
Abit, 2009), which is why the pechay grown in soil happened to be less developed than in
hydroponics.
roots (See Picture 7). Soil-less culture, including hydroponics, have nutrients fed directly to the
22
roots of the plants, and as a result grow faster and lead to better quality produce (Admane &
Sadare, 2013). Because of the nutrients being more controlled and easier for the plants to
consume, the growth of pechay in hydroponics was rapid and had more quality produce within
the allotted days for the experiment than compared to soil. Within the forty-five (45) days of
observation, the crops in hydroponics had grown more developed than the crops in soil,
supporting that hydroponics can be an immediate source of good quality food supply for areas
Conclusion
This study had proven that there are significant effects of using hydroponics for planting
crops. The plants, when compared to soil, were taller, heavier, and had more leaves because all
nutrient elements are available to the plants, secured for more control over the nutrients, and
conditions in the environment being adequate for plants to grow on. Hydroponics proved that the
method can be used in areas where soil is degrading or uncommon, as long as conditions for
This study also had proven that there are significant effects when planting in soil.
However, the plants grown had less leaves, were short in height, and virtually weighed nothing
when compared to hydroponically grown pechay even after forty five (45) days of observation
and conditions in the environment being enough for plants to grow on. This was because
hydroponics has nutrients for plants to grow on more secured and controlled than in soil.
In this research, it is concluded that using hydroponics for planting crops is better than
using soil. Hydroponics is proven that it can be used for immediate and quality food supply
23
especially in areas affected by hunger, poverty, and calamities since hydroponics produce quality
Recommendations
The hydroponics set-up should be covered with mosquito nets against pests from
A more proper shelter for hydroponically grown plants should be considered as well.
Other plants aside from pechay can be used for hydroponics. Lettuce, tomatoes, and herbs
REFERENCES
Ocampo, E.T.M. & Santos, P.J.A. (2009). SNAP® Hydroponics. Pasay: Agrilink
Ocampo, E.T.M. & Santos, P.J.A. (2008). HOW TO SET UP SNAP HYDROPONICS.
Admane, S.V. & Sardare, M.D. (2013). A Review on Plant without Soil – Hydroponics.
Omaye, S.T. & Treftz, C. (2015). Comparison Between Hydroponic and Soil Systems
problem-hydroponic-troubleshooting/2/1232
Padayachee, A. (2013). Nutritional quality of hydroponics vs. soil grown veggies and
https://drannelinepadayachee.com/2013/05/22/191/
Vaishnavi, H. (2017). Started by four friends, Triton Foodworks grows 700 tonnes of
25
organic food without soil. Your Story. Retrieved August 29, 2017, from
https://yourstory.com/2017/08/triton-foodworks-hydroponics
Karst, T. (2017) Fate of organic hydroponics still unsettled. The Packer. Retrieved
unsettled
Rotor, A.V. (2014). Grow Pechay without Soil (Hydroponics). Living with Nature.
without-soil-hydroponics.html
Gavilan, J. (2017). SWS: 3.1 million Filipino families suffer from hunger in Q4 2016.
https://www.rappler.com/move.ph/issues/hunger/159333-social-weather-stations-
hunger-survey-4th-quarter-2016
filipino-families-in-q1-of-2017-sws
Abit, S.M., Jr., Asio, V.B., Jahn, R., Navarette, I.A. & Perez, F.O. (2009). A review of
Poor Subsistence Farmers. Google Science Fair. Retrieved October 24, 2017,
from https://www.googlesciencefair.com/en/projects/science-fair-2012-
ahjzfnnjawvuy2vmywlyltiwmtjydwssb1byb2ply3qypagsda
Salvosa, I. (2017). Solving hunger: Why it’s important for millennials to help out.
26
https://www.rappler.com/brandrap/advocacies/184179-solving-hunger-
millennials-help
hunger-urban-agriculture
Jain, V., Pandey, R. & Singh, K.P. (2009). Hydroponics Agriculture: It’s Status, Scope,
Research Institute