Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Topical 2% ketoconazole cream monotherapy significantly
improves adult female acne: A double-blind, randomized
placebo-controlled trial
Natcha CHOTTAWORNSAK,1,2 Yuda CHONGPISON,3 Pravit ASAWANONDA,1,2 Chanat
KUMTORNRUT1,2
1
Division of Dermatology, Department of Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Chulalongkorn University, 2The Thai Red Cross Society of
Thailand, King Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital, 3Research Affairs, Center for Excellence in Biostatistics, Faculty of Medicine,
Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand
ABSTRACT
The emergence of bacterial resistance is a global crisis. Prolonged use of antibiotics especially in acne is one
issue of concern among dermatologists. Ketoconazole (KTZ) cream, a topical antifungal with anti-inflammatory
and antiandrogenic actions, can decrease lipase activity of Cutibacterium acnes in vitro. We evaluated the effi-
cacy and safety of KTZ cream in mild adult female acne (AFA) by conducting a randomized, double-blind, pla-
cebo-controlled trial using KTZ 2% and placebo cream twice daily for 10 weeks. We assessed the improvement
of clinical severity, measured by AFA score graded by investigators and participants, and the change of acne
count. Forty-one participants enrolled in our study. The proportion of participants with acne improvement from
baseline (42.9% vs 9.5%, P = 0.015) and the success rate (45.0% vs 14.3%, P = 0.043) in the KTZ group were sig-
nificantly higher than that of the placebo group. The most common adverse events were dryness and itching. The
percentage change of acne count decreased significantly compared with baseline but did not differ statistically
between the two groups (P = 0.268). We concluded that the KTZ monotherapy showed a plausible effect in
improving AFA with excellent safety profile. It should be considered as a viable option for mild AFA treatment.
Key words: acne vulgaris, adult female acne, ketoconazole, post-adolescent acne, topical acne treatment.
Correspondence: Chanat Kumtornrut, M.D., M.Sc., Division of Dermatology, Department of Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Chulalongkorn
University and King Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital, The Thai Red Cross Society of Thailand, 1873, Rama IV Road, Patumwan, Bangkok
10330, Thailand. Email: chanat_1@yahoo.com
Received 2 August 2019; accepted 10 September 2019.
Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital, Thailand, from August 2017 evaluates two separate areas, the face (AFAST-F) and sub-
to December 2018. This study was performed in agreement mandibular area (AFAST-S), to measure the clinical acne sever-
with the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki and approved ity. “Acne improvement” was defined as the proportion of
by the Institutional Review Board of the Faculty of Medicine, participants who had achieved at least 1 AFAST grade reduc-
Chulalongkorn University, Thailand (protocol no. 317/60). All tion from baseline and “success rate” of treatment as those
participants provided written informed consent before their who achieved 0 (clear) and 1 (almost clear) AFAST scores at
enrollment in the study. Additional informed consent was the end of the treatment period (week 8) and post-treatment
obtained from a subject whose photographs are included in period (week 10). Other secondary outcomes included the
this article. The clinical trials registration number is Patient Global Assessment (PGA) score of acne severity and
NCT03178994. The Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials quality of life, which were assessed by the validated Thai ver-
checklist was followed for this manuscript. sion of the Dermatology Life Quality Index (DLQI) question-
The sample size calculation was performed with at least naire, and the self-reported skin tolerability (burning sensation,
80% power and a significance level of 0.05 to detect the mean itching, scale, dryness and skin tightness).
difference in total acne count of 40 between the two groups, All data were examined using mean and standard deviation
adjusting for 15% loss to follow up. Eligible participants were (SD) or counts and percentages for continuous and categorical
women aged above 25 years who had mild acne with an AFA variables, respectively. The paired t-test was used to compare
score of 2 on the face based on the Global Acne Severity the percent change of acne count and DLQI score between
Scale.17 The exclusion criteria were: (i) 2-week use of topical baseline and the end of treatment (week 8). The independent-
and/or 4-week use of systemic acne medication prior to the sample t-test and v2-test were performed to compare the out-
study; (ii) other special types of acne or conditions presenting comes between the groups. All statistical analyses were per-
with acne/acneiform eruptions (e.g. SAPHO syndrome); (iii) formed with Stata version 14 software (StataCorp).
irregular menstrual cycles or clinically suspected polycystic
ovarian syndrome; (iv) other facial rashes preventing the accu-
RESULTS
rate assessment; (v) known or suspected allergy to the ingredi-
ents; and (vi) pregnancy or lactation. Demographic data and clinical characteristics
After enrollment, the participants entered a washout period Forty-one females with mild AFA were enrolled and random-
for 2 weeks to standardize the daily skincare routine and cos- ized. Thirty-nine participants (95.1%) completed the study pro-
metic products used. The baseline assessment was per- tocol (Fig. 1) and had maintained good compliance throughout
formed 14 days after the last menstrual period to decrease the study period. Those two dropouts were in the placebo
hormonal variation. Randomized with a 1:1 allocation and ran- group and occurred at weeks 4 and 6, respectively, due to the
dom block of four by Stata version 14 software (StataCorp, change of workplace to other provinces.
College Station, TX, USA), participants were given either KTZ Participants were aged between 25 and 49 years old, with a
2% (Nizoral Creamâ; Janssen Cilag, High Wycombe, UK) or mean age of 35.2 and 34.1 years in KTZ and placebo groups,
placebo from the in-house preparation which were packed in respectively. Approximately 93% of the participants had per-
identical tubes. The placebo contained cetyl alcohol, stearic sistent AFA. The total numbers of lesion counts or acne sever-
acid, glyceryl monostearate, propylene glycol, sodium lauryl ity grading assessment at baseline and other factors related to
sulfate, propyl paraben and purified water. The participants
were instructed to apply the cream on their entire face twice
daily for 8 weeks. At the end of week 8, the participants dis-
continued using the cream while maintaining other routine
skincare and entered the post-treatment period for 2 weeks
more (a 10-week study period in total) to evaluate the lasting
KTZ effect. Throughout the study period, all participants were
required to use the provided cleansing gels with non-medi-
cated ingredients (i.e. water, cetyl alcohol, propylene glycol,
sodium lauryl sulfate and stearyl alcohol; in-house preparation)
and avoid changing to other skincare or cosmetic products.
The outcome assessments were at baseline and weeks 2, 4,
6, 8 and 10. In addition, well-trained research assistants were
responsible for explaining how to apply the medications at
every visit.
The primary outcome was the percent change of acne count
compared between baseline and the end of the study (week 8)
among groups. Two certified dermatologists performed the
acne counts of both inflammatory and non-inflammatory
lesions under an appropriate room light at every visit. We Figure 1. Subject disposition. ITT, intention to treat; KTZ,
chose the Adult Female Acne Scoring Tool (AFAST),18 which ketoconazole; PP, per protocol.
Figure 2. Mean percentage change and standard error of mean (SEM) of lesion counts from baseline by visit. (a) Total lesions, (b)
comedones, (c) inflammatory lesions. KTZ, ketoconazole.
We chose AFAST as it is a novel objective tool for assess- implied the expected benefit of KTZ when being used in clini-
ment of clinical severity for AFA.18,20 Subjective evaluation by cal practise for AFA.
participants also showed significant results. The positive In our study, only a few participants reported treatment-re-
results from two different evaluators of clinical assessment lated adverse effects which were transient and spontaneously
resolved without further management. This could be a crucial
benefit of KTZ when compared with available standard topical
treatments, such as topical retinoid and benzoyl peroxide, in
which skin irritation is extremely common and often leads to
discontinuation of treatment.
Together with antifungal properties and anti-inflammatory
effects, other possible mechanisms of KTZ in acne treatment
may be through its antilipase activity and antiandrogenic
effect. Lipase is one of the pivotal enzymes and virulence
factors of C. acnes to stimulate inflammation and follicular
hyperkeratosis.21 KTZ inhibits the lipase activity in both
antibiotic-susceptible and -resistant C. acnes,15,16 resulting in
a decreased free-fatty acid component in sebum and sup-
pression of comedo formation. We speculated that this may
be the explanation for the observed effect of KTZ on come-
dones and onset of action. Also, systemic KTZ can suppress
Figure 3. Percentage of participants with acne improvement
defined by AFAST-F, AFAST-S, PGA and treatment success at androgen production through inhibition of cytochrome P450-
the end of treatment (week 8). AFAST-F, Adult Female Acne dependent enzymes in the testes, ovaries and adrenal
Scoring Tool from face; AFAST-S, Adult Female Acne Scoring glands.13 It is conceivable that topical KTZ may possess a
Tool from submandibular area; KTZ, ketoconazole; PGA, similar effect on the steroidogenesis function of the piloseba-
Patient Global Assessment. *P < 0.05 from Chi-squared-test. ceous units.22
Figure 4. Acne improvement in a representative subject treated with KTZ 2% (a) at baseline and (b) the end of the treatment. Pho-
tographs taken by Visiaâ (Canfield Scientific, Parsippany, NJ, USA). KTZ, ketoconazole.
At the same time, KTZ could also affect lipase activity of Since the increase in antibiotic resistance became a major
Malassezia spp.,16 which has a higher lipase activity than public concern, many acne treatment guidelines have encour-
C. acnes.23 Some authors believed that Malassezia spp. is aged the stewardship of antibiotic use.4–7 Topical antibiotics
related to refractory acne and other concurrent inflamma- should be used in a limited setting and for a restricted dura-
tory facial dermatoses such as seborrheic dermatosis. tion. Thus, using KTZ with an effect on AV comparable with
Because KTZ treatment markedly improved acne lesions24 topical clindamycin26 but causing no risk of antibiotic resis-
and is one of the most effective treatments in seborrheic tance should be encouraged in the current practice.
dermatosis,25 one could propose an additional benefit of There were limitations in our study. First, selecting mild
treating two commonly found skin disorders by employing AFA, with few lesions presented at baseline, could limit the
this monotherapy. power to detect the difference in acne counts. Second, our trial
had a shorter study period than other acne treatment studies. 7 Goh CL, Abad-Casintahan F, Aw DC et al. South-East Asia study
Third, we would not be able to generalize our results to moder- alliance guidelines on the management of acne vulgaris in South-
East Asian patients. J Dermatol 2015; 42(10): 945–953.
ate and severe AFA, adolescent acne or acne in male subjects.
8 Akaza N, Akamatsu H, Numata S et al. Microorganisms inhabiting
We also excluded participants with clinically definite or sus- follicular contents of facial acne are not only Propionibacterium but
pected underlying medical problems, mainly polycystic ovarian also Malassezia spp. J Dermatol 2016; 43(8): 906–911.
syndrome. Future studies of topical KTZ or other antifungals 9 Numata S, Akamatsu H, Akaza N, Yagami A, Nakata S, Matsunaga
K. Analysis of facial skin-resident microbiota in Japanese acne
are required to confirm the promising efficacy including larger
patients. Dermatology 2014; 228(1): 86–92.
sample size, longer follow-up period and more varied clinical 10 White GM. Recent findings in the epidemiologic evidence, classifi-
settings. At the same time, the mechanism of action of KTZ on cation, and subtypes of acne vulgaris. J Am Acad Dermatol 1998;
acne should particularly be explored. 39(2 Pt 3): S34–S37.
Based on our study, we recommend the use of topical KTZ 11 Bagatin E, Freitas THP, Rivitti-Machado MC et al. Adult female acne:
a guide to clinical practice. An Bras Dermatol 2019; 94(1): 62–75.
in any healthy women with mild AFA, especially those con-
12 Van Cutsem J, Van Gerven F, Cauwenbergh G, Odds F, Janssen
cerned with irritation from other topical anti-acne treatments. PA. The antiinflammatory effects of ketoconazole. A comparative
We also support topical KTZ to be an additional treatment in study with hydrocortisone acetate in a model using living and killed
clinical practice guidelines for AFA. Furthermore, the combina- Staphylococcus aureus on the skin of guinea-pigs. J Am Acad Der-
matol 1991; 25(2 Pt 1): 257–261.
tion of treatments may result in optimal acne management in
13 Shaw JC. Antiandrogen therapy in dermatology. Int J Dermatol
real-life practice. 1996; 35(11): 770–778.
In conclusion, given the significant efficacy and excellent 14 Gupta AK, Kohli Y, Li A, Faergemann J, Summerbell RC. In vitro
safety profile, our study revealed a potential role of KTZ susceptibility of the seven Malassezia species to ketoconazole,
monotherapy as a viable acne treatment without concern of voriconazole, itraconazole and terbinafine. Br J Dermatol 2000; 142
(4): 758–765.
antibiotic resistance. It should be considered as an alternative
15 Sugita T, Miyamoto M, Tsuboi R, Takatori K, Ikeda R, Nishikawa A.
therapy to the standard treatments for mild AFA patients. In vitro activities of azole antifungal agents against Propionibac-
terium acnes isolated from patients with acne vulgaris. Biol Pharm
Bull 2010; 33(1): 125–127.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS: The study was supported by the 16 Unno M, Cho O, Sugita T. Inhibition of Propionibacterium acnes
Division of Dermatology, Department of Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, lipase activity by the antifungal agent ketoconazole. Microbiol
Chulalongkorn University, and was funded by the Ratchadapisek Som- Immunol 2017; 61(1): 42–44.
poch Endowment Fund (2017), Chulalongkorn University (grant 17 Dreno B, Poli F, Pawin H et al. Development and evaluation of a
no. RA61/023) and the Dermatological Society of Thailand. The authors Global Acne Severity Scale (GEA Scale) suitable for France and Eur-
would like to thank Ms Ruangrong Glinhom, Ms Porntenpin Champa- ope. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol 2011; 25(1): 43–48.
phan and Mr Anukorn Sriaram for technical assistance, and Mrs Kan- 18 Auffret N, Claudel JP, Leccia MT, Poli F, Farhi D, Dreno B. AFAST -
jana Yuttaviboon and Ms Kittima Leklad for secretarial support. Adult Female Acne Scoring Tool: an easy-to-use tool for scoring acne
in adult females. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol 2016; 30(5): 824–828.
19 Mesquita-Guimaraes J, Ramos S, Tavares MR, Carvalho MR. A
double-blind clinical trial with a lotion containing 5% benzoyl perox-
CONFLICT OF INTEREST: None declared.
ide and 2% miconazole in patients with acne vulgaris. Clin Exp Der-
matol 1989; 14(5): 357–360.
20 Poli F, Auffret N, Claudel JP, Leccia MT, Dreno B. AFAST: an adult
REFERENCES female acne treatment algorithm for daily clinical practice. Eur J
Dermatol 2018; 28(1): 101–103.
1 Morehead MS, Scarbrough C. Emergence of global antibiotic resis- 21 Holland C, Mak TN, Zimny-Arndt U et al. Proteomic identification of
tance. Prim Care 2018; 45(3): 467–484. secreted proteins of Propionibacterium acnes. BMC Microbiol 2010;
2 Walsh TR, Efthimiou J, Dreno B. Systematic review of antibiotic 10: 230.
resistance in acne: an increasing topical and oral threat. Lancet 22 Ceruti JM, Leiros GJ, Balana ME. Androgens and androgen recep-
Infect Dis 2016; 16(3): e23–e33. tor action in skin and hair follicles. Mol Cell Endocrinol 2018; 465:
3 Kakpovbia E, Feng H, Feng PW, Cohen JM. Antibiotic prescribing 122–133.
trends among US dermatologists in Medicare from 2013 to 2016. J 23 Akaza N, Akamatsu H, Takeoka S et al. Malassezia globosa tends
Dermatolog Treat 2019; 9: 1–3. to grow actively in summer conditions more than other cutaneous
4 Hayashi N, Akamatsu H, Iwatsuki K et al. Japanese Dermatological Malassezia species. J Dermatol 2012; 39(7): 613–616.
Association guidelines: guidelines for the treatment of acne vulgaris 24 Hu G, Wei Y-P, Feng J. Malasseziainfection: is there any chance or
2017. J Dermatol 2018; 45(8): 898–935. necessity in refractory acne? Chin Med J 2010; 123(5): 628–632.
5 Le Cleach L, Lebrun-Vignes B, Bachelot A et al. Guidelines for the 25 Gupta AK, Versteeg SG. Topical treatment of facial seborrheic der-
management of acne: recommendations from a French multidisci- matitis: a systematic review. Am J Clin Dermatol 2017; 18(2): 193–
plinary group. Br J Dermatol 2017; 177(4): 908–913. 213.
6 Thiboutot DM, Dreno B, Abanmi A, et al. Practical management of 26 Wolf JE Jr, Kaplan D, Kraus SJ et al. Efficacy and tolerability of
acne for clinicians: an international consensus from the Global Alli- combined topical treatment of acne vulgaris with adapalene and
ance to Improve Outcomes in Acne. J Am Acad Dermatol 2018; 78 clindamycin: a multicenter, randomized, investigator-blinded study.
(2 Suppl 1): S1–S23.e1. J Am Acad Dermatol 2003; 49(3 Suppl): S211–S217.