Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS
OF VARIED ATTRIBUTES
SCORES
Technological Institute of the Philippines
method. However, the scores of the other processes were not comparable enough
to those of Process 1. In this part, lowest scores obtained by Process 2 and Process
Stirring- Neutralization
Calcination
CRITERIA Crystallization of Sulfuric Acid
Process
Technique Process
For P21, the raw
For P11, the raw For P31, the raw
materials needed
materials needed materials needed
are magnesium
are dolomite and are magnesite
hydroxide and
sulfuric acid, and sulfuric acid,
sulfuric acid,
Price of Raw which are priced which are priced
which are priced
Materials at at
at
₱ 2,706.88/ton ₱ 34,835.17/ton
₱ 25,000.00/ton
and and
and
₱ 20,341.71/ton ₱ 20,341.71/ton
₱ 20,341.71/ton
respectively. respectively.
respectively.
The total capital
43
Technological Institute of the Philippines
The number of
No. of Energy No changes were energy intensive No changes were
Intensive made, remained equipment made, remained
Equipment at 5. changed from 5 at 2.
to 3.
For P11, the For P21, , the For P11, the
operating operating operating
temperature and temperature and temperature and
pressure pressure pressure
Operating
remained which remained which remained which
Parameters
ranges from 20 to ranges from 30 to ranges from 40 to
100 oC and 0.5 to 500 oC and 0.5 to 200 oC and 0.5 to
1 bar 2 bar 1 bar
respectively. respectively. respectively.
The Level of
PPE for P31
The Level of The Level of
remained the
PPE for P11 PPE for P21
same which is
Health Hazard remained the remained the
Level C, but the
same which is same which is
rating changed
Level C. Level B.
from 2.00 to
3.00.
No changes No changes
Toxicological The rating for
made, remained made, remained
Rating P31 is 2.50
at 2.75 at 2.20
Scores for this Scores for this Scores for this
Availability of
criterion remains criterion remains criterion remains
Raw Materials
the same the same the same
No changes were No changes were No changes were
Environmental
made, remained made, remained made, remained
Hazards
at 1.55 at 1.70 at 1.85
44
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Table 6.81.1 Quantitative Summary for the three varied processes’ evaluation
ATTRIBUTES P1 P2 P3
Economics (Php, ₱)
Price of Raw Materials 23,048.59 45,341.71 55,176.88
Total Capital Investment 184,316,219.71 230,426,741.06 240,184,674.01
Total Annual Production
158,370,924.68 186,110,244.93 192,690,118.04
Cost
Manufacturability
Number of intensive
5.00 3.00 2.00
equipment
Safety
Operating parameters 25-100oC 30-500oC 40-200oC
Health Hazard Level C PPE Level B PPE Level C PPE
Toxicological Rating 2.75 2.20 2.50
Sustainability
Availability of Raw
3.00 2.00 2.00
Materials
Environmental Impact
Environmental Hazards 1.55 1.70 1.85
45
Technological Institute of the Philippines
The scoring for chosen process was done the same way calculating in
Process Selection section. Table 6.83 shows the scores of the varied attributes
46
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Table 6.83 Worst-Case and Best-Case Benchmark for each varied attributes
WORST
ECON 1
ECON 2
ECON 3
SAFE 1
SAFE 2
SAFE 3
ATTRIB
MANU
BEST
BEST
BEST
BEST
BEST
BEST
BEST
BEST
BEST
ENVI
SUST
UTES
ECON 1
0.45 0.45 0.45 0.31 0.45 0.45 0.39 0.45 0.45 0.45
ECON 2
0.30 0.30 0.30 0.28 0.30 0.30 0.29 0.30 0.30 0.30
ECON 3
0.60 0.60 0.60 0.57 0.60 0.60 0.59 0.60 0.60 0.60
MANU
0.06 0.06 0.06 0.15 0.06 0.06 0.12 0.06 0.06 0.06
SAFE 1
0.15 0.15 0.15 0.10 0.15 0.15 0.05 0.15 0.15 0.15
SAFE 2
0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.30 0.20 0.30 0.30 0.30
SAFE 3
0.24 0.24 0.24 0.26 0.24 0.24 0.30 0.24 0.24 0.24
SUST
0.45 0.45 0.45 0.30 0.45 0.45 0.30 0.45 0.45 0.45
ENVI
0.30 0.30 0.30 0.24 0.30 0.30 0.26 0.30 0.30 0.30
Just like in the table 6.31, Table 6.83 shows the worst – case and best –
case benchmark for each attribute based on the varied scores used in the process
selection.
47
Technological Institute of the Philippines
LEVEL OF
ATTRIBUTES SCORE WEIGHT
IMPORTANCE
Economics 1 7 87.40 0.16
Economics 2 6 77.77 0.15
Economics 3 9 100.00 0.19
Manufacturability 1 10.00 0.02
Safety 1 2 21.11 0.04
Safety 2 3 36.29 0.07
Safety 3 4 45.92 0.09
Sustainability 8 93.14 0.17
Environmental Impact 5 62.96 0.12
TOTAL 534.59 1.00
Same level of importance and scores were used in determining the chosen
process.
48
Technological Institute of the Philippines
SINGLE-FACTOR
METHOD
49
Technological Institute of the Philippines
The results in Table 6.86 indicate that the chosen process would still be
Process 1 even if the Best-Economics 1 score is changed from the base case score
of 87.40S. Further increasing the scores even up to 1000, the choice of process is
still Process 1. This implies that the best option in terms of price of raw materials
among the three processes is Process 1 and is the best route for the production of
magnesium sulfate.
50
Technological Institute of the Philippines
BEST ECONOMICS 2
Total Capital Investment
SCORE CHOICE
10 P11
20 P11
30 P11
40 P11
50 P11
60 P11
70 P11
80 P11
90 P11
100 P11
200 P11
300 P11
400 P11
500 P11
600 P11
700 P11
800 P11
900 P11
1000 P11
*Base score is 77.77
The results in Table 6.87 indicate that the chosen process would still be
Process 1 even if the Best-Economics 2 score is changed from the base case score
of 77.77. Further increasing the scores even up to 1000, the choice of process is
still Process 1. This implies that the best option in terms of total capital
investment among the three processes is Process 1 and is the best route to produce
magnesium sulfate.
51
Technological Institute of the Philippines
BEST ECONOMICS 3
Total Annual Production Cost
SCORE CHOICE
10 P11
20 P11
30 P11
40 P11
50 P11
60 P11
70 P11
80 P11
90 P11
100 P11
200 P11
300 P11
400 P11
500 P11
600 P11
700 P11
800 P11
900 P11
1000 P11
*Base score is 100.00
The results in Table 6.88 indicate that the chosen process would still be
Process 1 even if the Best-Economics 3 score is changed from the base case
score of 100.00. Further increasing the scores even up to 1000, the choice of
process is still Process 1. This implies that the best option in terms of annual
production cost among the three processes is Process 1 and is the best route for
52
Technological Institute of the Philippines
BEST MANUFACTURABILITY
No. of Energy Intensive Equipment
SCORE CHOICE
10 P1
20 P1
30 P1
40 P1
50 P1
60 P1
70 P1
80 P1
90 P1
100 P1
200 P1
300 P1
400 P1
500 P3
600 P3
700 P3
800 P3
900 P3
1000 P3
*Base score is 10.00
500, will cause a shift from Process 1 to Process 3. Further increasing of score
value to 1000 will come up with Process 3. It can be assumed that at an analysis
53
Technological Institute of the Philippines
54
Technological Institute of the Philippines
LEVEL OF
ATTRIBUTES SCORE WEIGHT
IMPORTANCE
Economics 1 7 87.40 0.09
Economics 2 6 77.77 0.08
Economics 3 9 100.00 0.11
Manufacturability 1 405.00 0.44
Safety 1 2 21.11 0.02
Safety 2 3 36.29 0.04
Safety 3 4 45.92 0.05
Sustainability 8 93.14 0.10
Environmental Impact 5 62.96 0.07
TOTAL 929.59 1.00
increased from 2% to 44% which makes it the highest of all attributes. This
leaves other attributes equal or less than 11%. Based on the weight calculated,
3. Compromised safety since all safety attributes are of less importance. Commented [JO1]: For edit
55
Technological Institute of the Philippines
BEST SAFETY 1
Operating Parameters
SCORE CHOICE
10 P11
20 P11
30 P11
40 P11
50 P11
60 P11
70 P11
80 P11
90 P11
100 P11
200 P11
300 P11
400 P11
500 P11
600 P11
700 P11
800 P11
900 P11
1000 P11
*Base score is 21.11
The results in Table 6.91 indicate that the chosen process would still be
Process 1 even if the Best-Safety 1 score is changed from the base case score of
21.11. Further increasing the scores even up to 1000, the choice of process is still
Process 1. This implies that the best option in terms of operating parameters
among the three processes is Process 1 and is the best route for the production of
magnesium sulfate.
56
Technological Institute of the Philippines
BEST SAFETY 2
Health Hazard
SCORE CHOICE
10 P11
20 P11
30 P11
40 P11
50 P11
60 P11
70 P11
80 P11
90 P11
100 P11
200 P11
300 P11
400 P11
500 P11
600 P11
700 P11
800 P11
900 P11
1000 P11
*Base score is 36.29
The results in Table 6.92 indicate that the chosen process would still be
Process 1 even if the Best-Safety 2 score is changed from the base case score of
36.29. Further increasing the scores even up to 1000, the choice of process is still
Process 1. This implies that the best option in terms of operating parameters
among the three processes is Process 1 and is the best route for the production of
magnesium sulfate.
57
Technological Institute of the Philippines
BEST SAFETY 3
Toxicological Rating
SCORE CHOICE
10 P11
20 P11
30 P11
40 P11
50 P11
60 P11
70 P11
80 P11
90 P11
100 P11
200 P11
300 P11
400 P11
500 P11
600 P11
700 P21
800 P21
900 P21
1000 P21
*Base score is 45.92
The results in Table 6.93 indicate with the Toxicological Rating score of
600, will cause a shift from Process 1 to Process 2. Further increasing of score
58
Technological Institute of the Philippines
BEST SAFETY 3
Toxicological Rating
SCORE CHOICE
600 P11
601 P11
602 P11
603 P11
604 P11
605 P11
606 P11
607 P11
608 P11
609 P11
610 P21
620 P21
630 P21
640 P21
650 P21
700 P21
800 P21
900 P21
1000 P21
Table 6.94 shows that at Toxicological Rating value of 610.00, the choice
59
Technological Institute of the Philippines
3 Score
LEVEL OF
ATTRIBUTES SCORE WEIGHT
IMPORTANCE
Economics 1 7 87.40 0.08
Economics 2 6 77.77 0.07
Economics 3 9 100.00 0.09
Manufacturability 1 10.00 0.01
Safety 1 2 21.11 0.02
Safety 2 3 36.29 0.03
Safety 3 4 610.00 0.56
Sustainability 8 93.14 0.08
Environmental Impact 5 62.96 0.06
TOTAL 1098.67 1.00
increased from 9% to 56% which makes it the highest of all attributes. This
leaves other attributes less than 10%. Based on the weight calculated, the
60
Technological Institute of the Philippines
BEST SUSTAINABILITY
Availability of Raw Materials
SCORE CHOICE
10 P11
20 P11
30 P11
40 P11
50 P11
60 P11
70 P11
80 P11
90 P11
100 P11
200 P11
300 P11
400 P11
500 P11
600 P11
700 P11
800 P11
900 P11
1000 P11
*Base score is 93.14
The results in Table 6.96 indicate that the chosen process would still be
Process 1 even if the Best-Sustainability score is changed from the base case
score of 93.14. Further increasing the scores even up to 1000, the choice of
process is still Process 1. This implies that the best option in terms of operating
parameters among the three processes is Process 1 and is the best route for the
61
Technological Institute of the Philippines
The results in Table 6.97 indicate that the chosen process would still be
Process 1 even if the Best-Sustainability score is changed from the base case
score of 93.14. Further increasing the scores even up to 1000, the choice of
process is still Process 1. This implies that the best option in terms of operating
parameters among the three processes is Process 1 and is the best route for the
62
Technological Institute of the Philippines
TWO-FACTOR
METHOD
63
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Economics 1 Score
Economics 2
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 1 Base Case Score is 87.40
*Economics 2 Base Case Score is 77.77
64
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Economics 1 Score
Economics 3
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 1 Base Case Score is 87.40
*Economics 3 Base Case Score is 100.00
Economics 1 Score
Manufacturability
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 1 Base Case Score is 87.40
*Manufacturability Base Case Score is 10.00
65
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Economics 1 Score
Safety 1
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 1 Base Case Score is 87.40
*Safety 1 Base Case Score is 21.11
Economics 1 Score
Safety 2
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 1 Base Case Score is 87.40
*Safety 2 Base Case Score is 36.29
66
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Economics 1 Score
Safety 3
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 1 Base Case Score is 87.40
*Safety 3 Base Case Score is 45.92
Economics 1 Score
Sustainability
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 1 Base Case Score is 87.40
*Sustainability Base Case Score is 93.14
67
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Economics 1 Score
Environmental
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Impact Score
10 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
20 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
30 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
40 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
50 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
60 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
70 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
80 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
90 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
100 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
*Economics 1 Base Case Score is 87.40
*Environmental Impact Base Case Score is 62.96
Economics 2 Score
Economics 3
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 1 Base Case Score is 77.77
*Economics 3 Base Case Score is 100.00
68
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Economics 2 Score
Manufacturability
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 2 Base Case Score is 77.77
*Manufacturability Base Case Score is 10.00
Economics 2 Score
Safety 1
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 1 Base Case Score is 77.77
*Safety 1 Base Case Score is 21.11
69
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Economics 2 Score
Safety 2
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 2 Base Case Score is 77.77
*Safety 2 Base Case Score is 36.29
Economics 2 Score
Safety 3
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
20 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
30 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
40 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
50 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
60 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
70 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
80 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
90 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
100 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1 P1
*Economics 1 Base Case Score is 77.77
*Safety 1 Base Case Score is 45.92
70
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Economics 2 Score
Sustainability
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 2 Base Case Score is 77.77
*Safety 2 Base Case Score is 93.14
Economics 2 Score
Environmental
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Impact Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 1 Base Case Score is 77.77
*Environmental Impact Base Case Score is 62.96
71
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Economics 3 Score
Manufacturability
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 3 Base Case Score is 100.00
*Manufacturability Base Case Score is 10.00
72
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Economics 3 Score
Safety 2
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 3 Base Case Score is 100.00
*Safety 2 Base Case Score is 36.29
Economics 3 Score
Safety 3
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 3 Base Case Score is 100.00
*Safety 3 Base Case Score is 45.92
73
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Economics 3 Score
Sustainability
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 3 Base Case Score is 100.00
*Sustainability Base Case Score is 93.14
Economics 3 Score
Environmental
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Impact Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Economics 3 Base Case Score is 100.00
*Environmental Impact Base Case Score is 62.96
74
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Manufacturability Score
Safety 1
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Manufacturability Base Case Score is 10.00
*Safety 1 Base Case Score is 21.11
Manufacturability Score
Safety 2
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Manufacturability Base Case Score is 10.00
*Safety 2 Base Case Score is 36.29
75
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Manufacturability Score
Safety 3
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Manufacturability Base Case Score is 10.00
*Safety 3 Base Case Score is 45.92
Manufacturability Score
Sustainability
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Manufacturability Base Case Score is 10.00
*Sustainability Base Case Score is 93.14
76
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Manufacturability Score
Environmental
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Impact Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Manufacturability Base Case Score is 10.00
*Environmental Impact Base Case Score is 62.96
Safety 1 Score
Safety 2
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Safety 1 Base Case Score is 21.11
*Safety 2 Base Case Score is 36.29
77
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Safety 1 Score
Safety 3
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Safety 1 Base Case Score is 21.11
*Safety 3 Base Case Score is 45.92
Safety 1 Score
Sustainability
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Safety 1 Base Case Score is 21.11
*Sustainability Base Case Score is 93.14
78
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Safety 1 Score
Environmental
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Impact Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Safety 1 Base Case Score is 21.11
*Environmental Impact Base Case Score is 62.96
Safety 2 Score
Safety 3
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Safety 2 Base Case Score is 36.29
*Safety 3 Base Case Score is 45.92
79
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Safety 2 Score
Sustainability
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Safety 2 Base Case Score is 36.29
*Sustainability Base Case Score is 93.14
Safety 2 Score
Environmental
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Impact Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Safety 2 Base Case Score is 36.29
*Environmental Impact Base Case Score is 62.96
80
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Safety 3 Score
Sustainability
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Safety 3 Base Case Score is 36.29
*Sustainability Base Case Score is 93.14
Safety 3 Score
Sustainability
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Safety 3 Base Case Score is 36.29
*Environmental Impact Base Case Score is 62.96
81
Technological Institute of the Philippines
Sustainability Score
Environmental
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Impact Score
10 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
20 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
30 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
40 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
50 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
60 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
70 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
80 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
90 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
100 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11 P11
*Sustainability Base Case Score is 93.14
*Environmental Impact Base Case Score is 62.96
82
Technological Institute of the Philippines
83