69%(26)69% au considerat acest document util (26 voturi)
24K vizualizări4 pagini
1. The primary source is Santiago Alvarez's memoir written in 1927 which provides a first-hand account of the events at the Tejeros Convention as Alvarez was present.
2. The secondary source is historian Teodoro Agoncillo's 1929 book which reconstructs the events through his own research and from a nationalist perspective.
3. The accounts differ as Alvarez provides a sequential eyewitness narrative while Agoncillo analyzes the events and underlying political tensions from his perspective.
Descriere originală:
Titlu original
RPH - Module 1 Primary vs. Secondary Sources on the Tejeros Convention.docx
1. The primary source is Santiago Alvarez's memoir written in 1927 which provides a first-hand account of the events at the Tejeros Convention as Alvarez was present.
2. The secondary source is historian Teodoro Agoncillo's 1929 book which reconstructs the events through his own research and from a nationalist perspective.
3. The accounts differ as Alvarez provides a sequential eyewitness narrative while Agoncillo analyzes the events and underlying political tensions from his perspective.
1. The primary source is Santiago Alvarez's memoir written in 1927 which provides a first-hand account of the events at the Tejeros Convention as Alvarez was present.
2. The secondary source is historian Teodoro Agoncillo's 1929 book which reconstructs the events through his own research and from a nationalist perspective.
3. The accounts differ as Alvarez provides a sequential eyewitness narrative while Agoncillo analyzes the events and underlying political tensions from his perspective.
Module 1: Primary vs. Secondary Sources on the Tejeros Convention
Comparative Analysis of Primary and Secondary Sources
Background Primary source: Santiago Secondary source:
Alvarez’ Memoir of a Teodoro Agoncillo’s Revolt General of the Masses Author’s Background Santiago Virata Álvarez was Teodoro Andal Agoncillo was a revolutionary general and a a prominent 20th-century founder and honorary Filipino historian. He and his president of the first contemporary Renato directorate of the Constantino were among the Nacionalista Party. first Filipino historians renowned for promoting a distinctly nationalist point of view of Filipino history. He was also an essayist and a poet. When was the account July 24, 1927 1929 written? Mentioned date(s) in the March 25, 1897 December 1896 text January 2, 1897 April 1897 March 22, 1897 Sept 28, 1947, Mentioned Place(s) in the Tejeros, Cavite Cavite,Batangas, Talisay, text Nasugbu, Tuwi, Look, Noveleta, San Francisco de malabon, Naik, Montalban, Mariquina, San Juan,Imus, Bakood, Kawit, Tejeros, Limbon. Sequence of events 1. Ariston Villanueva of 1. The Division of Magdiwang Faction Katipunan of Cavite receiving information into two factions: at Daniel Tirona of Magdiwang and Magdalo Faction Magdalo acceded in enjoining 2. Attempt of both any among the Factions to Wear the magdiwang leaders to Same Uniform ally with him (to 3. Dispute among tirona) Magdalo and 2. The assembly at Magdiwang Tejeros was finally 4. Magdiwang men convened. invite Andres 3. Chairman Jacinto Bonifacio to visit declared the Cavite assembly open as the 5. A delegate was sent leaders were seated to look for supremo in at the presidential the Mountains of table, as previously Montalban and described and all the Mariquina others were standing 6. Bonifacio refused to in groups on both heed the request of sides of those seated. the Magdiwang 4. Mr. Severino de las leaders Alas rose to speak 7. Third invitation written about the government by Artemio Ricarte they should have. upon the instruction of 5. Chairman Lumbreras Mariano Alvarez, replied that the Bonifacio acceded to Katipunan now hold the request. authority over the 8. Bonifacio left for islands. It has a cavite about middle of government of law December 1896 and a definite 9. Bonifacio was brought program. by the rebel leaders to 6. The chair next the house of Juan recognized the Casteñada Supremo. He 10. Supremo ordered to explained that the “K” arrest Fernandez in the middle of the 11. Esteban San Juan sun in the Katipunan invited Bonifacio to flag used in the attend the Revolution stood for demonstration of the “Kalayaan”. Magidwang rebels in 7. Mr. Severino replied Noveleta. countered the 12. Mutual suspicion and Supremo’s words. jealousies resulted in 8. Supremo replied for military reverses in his defense several sectors. 9. Mr. Antonio 13. Magdiwang and Montenegro spoke in Magdalo decided to defense of Mr. call a convention or Severino assembly at Imus 10. General Apoy was 14. The assembly opened hurt by his words and with Bonifacio as the he angrily stood up Chairman 11. When the order was 15. Proposal of restored, some Revolutionary wanted the Government convention adjourned 16. Suspicions and but the Supremo jealousies continued Bonifacio prevailed to plague the ranks of upon the others to the rebels and even continue. among the members 12. Mr. Lumreras’ speech of the same faction. was well received and his proposal was 17. The Magdiwang unanimously planned to hold accepted another convention, 13. Because of that, the this time in the estate- chair proceeded to house of Tejeros prepare for an 18. Jacinto Lumbreras, election for some acting as president of positions. the Magdiwang took 14. The Supremo spoke the chair and opened again before the the convention. election began. 19. The discussion was 15. Supremo appointed going nowhere and Gen. Artemio Ricarte tempers ran high as as Secretary the men insisted on 16. Mr. Daniel Tirona and their own points of Gen. Ricarte view. distributed pieces of 20. Pandemonium paper to serve as reigned as the voice ballots of Santiago Alvarez 17. Mr. Emilio Aguinaldo boomed inside the won over Mr. Andres spacious sala. Bonifacio for 21. The Republic of the president Philippines was then 18. The election and there proclaimed continued and ended amidst enthusiastic 19. Mr. Baldomero hurrahs. Aguinaldo wanted the 22. Before the ballots elections to be were cast for the finished before it go Vice-Presidency, too dark. Severino de las Alas 20. Tirona shouted for Mr. stood up and Jose del Rosario to suggested that in as be elected for the much as Bonifacio position of Secretary had received the of Interior second largest 21. Supremo quickly number of votes, he stood up and declined should automatically 22. Supremo pulled out be allowed to occupy his revolver and took the position. aim 23. The election of 23. Mr. Tirona ignored Bonifacio gave rise to Supremo’s remarks an incident that nearly and disappeared from ended a bloody affair. the crowd 24. The Seed of 24. The convention Discontent, resulting secretary tried to from his failure to get disarm the Supremo the presidency, and 25. The people began to which was watered by disperse the unfortunate 26. The supremo attitude of Daniel adjourned the tirono, who, by meeting and left another sad quickly and was coincidence, followed by his aides belonged to the and some others opposite faction, present. found fertile ground in Bonifacio’s heart and mind. Differences between the Memoir of a Filipino General Agoncillo wrote this with his two accounts was written by Alvarez who own researches and was in the scene of the said persepctive about the topic. history. Strength and weaknesses It is a first-hand evidence Agoncillo’s lack of scientific of the accounts written by the person rigor in using the Marxist lens (Alvarez) who was in the said of class struggle, but have scene. legit researches about the past. Author’s bias None, the scenes and Agoncillo's own Ideas accounts came from the katipuneros themselves