Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Article history: This paper is aimed at finding the optimum configuration of the number of holes and their arrangement
Received 27 January 2008 for the 290 140 90 hollow clay bricks with 3-D numerical simulation by a home-made code with
Received in revised form 18 March 2008 finite volume method. Seventy-two kinds of configurations with different hole number and arrays are
Accepted 18 March 2008
chosen elaborately and their equivalent thermal conductivities are numerically predicted. In addition,
the effects of the hole surface radiation and the indoor–outdoor temperature difference on the equivalent
Keywords:
thermal conductivity are also investigated. The major findings are as follows. The radiation of the hole
Hollow clay bricks
surfaces makes heat transfer enhanced and the equivalent thermal conductivity enlarged in some extent,
Numerical simulation
Equivalent thermal conductivity
ranging from 25.8% to 4.6%. The optimum configuration has eight holes in length, four holes in width and
Natural convection one holes in height, whose equivalent thermal conductivity is the lowest and of 0.400 W/(m K),which is
Surface radiation only 59% of the highest thermal conductivity of the all cases studied. When the indoor–outdoor
temperature difference varies from 50 8C to 20 8C, the equivalent thermal conductivity of the 72 kinds of
hollow bricks does not vary too much, usually within 5%. Especially, the equivalent thermal conductivity
of the optimum configuration holds no change within this variation range of indoor–outdoor temperature
difference.
ß 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction a great role. This is probably the main reason that most related
literatures are of numerical study. In the following, a brief review
Hollow clay bricks used as building materials have obvious of literatures in recent 10 years is presented. In [1] 2-D simulation
advantages in improving thermal insulation performance of was conducted for enclosures similar to the hollow clay bricks with
building walls, separating sound as well as reducing building wall single or double holes. Surface radiation was taken into account by
loads. Thermal insulation performance of the hollow clay brick treating the radiation energy as the additional source term of the
mainly depends on the hole configuration, that is, on the number of control volume bounded with the surface. The results emphasize
holes, their arrangement and the void fraction, and investigation the effect of the thermal boundary condition on the total heat
on the hole configuration effect is of great significance to improve transfer. Lorente et al. [2] studied the heat flux and thermal
its thermal insulation performance. It is well-known that the heat resistance of a hollow brick with a single vertical hole by using
transfer and fluid flow process within a hollow clay brick is a simplified analytical model. They also studied the influence of
typical complicated combined mode problem, with conduction, environment temperatures on thermal resistance of the walls built
convection and surface radiation being all involved. Theoretically with some shapes of vertical hollow bricks [3]. When time entered
speaking, both experimental and numerical methods can be used into 21th century, study on the hollow brick related problems
to find an optimum configuration of a hollow brick under certain receives more interests of researchers because the world-wide
condition. However, because of the large number of the possible energy shortage. Castro Cadoso et al. [4] numerically studied a
variants of the hole configurations experimental study is very cost- structure with 12 rectangular holes for which the horizontal top
expensive. Meanwhile apart from surface radiation the transport and bottom surfaces were adiabatic and vertical left and right
process in the hollow brick is conduction and laminar flow in surfaces maintained at constant but different temperatures. The
nature, and this is a typical case that numerical simulation can play effect of the hole surface radiation was examined. Hinojosa et al.
[5] predicted the Nusselt number for the natural convection and
surface thermal radiation in a square tilted open cavity. They found
* Corresponding author. that the heat transfer via radiation is in the same order of natural
E-mail address: wqtao@mail.xjtu.edu.cn (W.Q. Tao). convection. In [6], indoor thermal environment of office space
0378-7788/$ – see front matter ß 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.enbuild.2008.03.010
L.P. Li et al. / Energy and Buildings 40 (2008) 1790–1798 1791
2. Mathematical formulation arrays. Here, the void fraction means the percentage of the volume
filled by air divided by the total volume of the hollow clay brick.
The 290 140 90 hollow clay bricks is one type of bricks The largest void fraction means that for given hole number and
commonly used in China to construct building walls with 300 mm array, the hull of the brick is 10 mm, the ribs parting the holes are
thickness. Their exterior sizes are 290 mm in length, 140 mm in 7.5–10 mm, which are the essential need for hollow clay bricks not
width and 90 mm in height. For simplicity, the denotation of to be split.
Lm1Wm2Hm3 is used to represent the brick with m1 holes in Based on the fundamental physical process, the following
length, m2 holes in width and m3 holes in height such as approximations can be adopted in our numerical model: (1) The
denotation L8W4H1 represents the brick having eight holes in hollow clay bricks and the air in the holes are of constant thermal
length, four holes in width and one hole in height. The denotations physical properties; (2) Air flow in the holes of the hollow clay
of some selected hollow bricks from all 72 kinds are listed in bricks is incompressible, steady state and laminar; (3) When
Table 1. radiation is considered air in the holes is a non-participating
From the building wall structure the smallest computational medium; (4) The Boussinesq assumption is adopted for the natural
domain (unit) consists of four blocks of the bricks that have convection in the holes [15]; (5) the convective boundary
identical configuration and is conglutinated by mortar according conditions are taken at the indoor and outdoor surfaces of the
to the manner of putting bricks. It is considered that its computation domain while the other four surfaces are considered
boundaries are repeated periodically in both up/down and left/ as adiabatic (Fig. 1(a)); (6) The mortar is assumed to have the same
right directions. Fig. 1 shows one of such 72 computational conductivity as the clay brick; (7) The hole surface is gray and
domains consisting of four blocks of L8W4H1. It should be noted diffusive.
that all the holes are rectangular in cross section as shown in The numerical prediction of the equivalent thermal con-
Fig. 1. It is obvious that the heat transfer phenomenon is three- ductivity will be performed under given third kind of boundary
dimension in nature, i.e., both the temperature (of the solid part conditions for both indoor and outdoor sides. That is the fluid
and fluid part) and the fluid flow velocity in the holes vary with temperatures and the total heat transfer coefficients of the inner
the three coordinates. Hence, their equivalent thermal con- and outer surfaces of the wall are prespecified. Then in order to
ductivities are numerically calculated with 3-D numerical predict the equivalent thermal conductivity of the brick
simulation of the temperature and air velocity in Cartesian structure, its two surfaces temperatures have to be known. In
coordinates by using a home-made code of finite volume order to obtain these two surface temperatures the partial
method. differential equation of the temperature in the brick structure
As indicated above the equivalent thermal conductivity of the should be solved under the given boundary conditions. Since
hollow clay bricks depends on the hole number, their arrangement within the brick holes air flows exist and the fluid velocity will
(arrays) and void fraction. The 72 kinds have two things in affect the heat transfer process, the momentum equations of the
common: there is only one hole in the height and in length and fluid in the holes should be simultaneously solved. Thus, to
width directions the holes are uniformly distributed. The hole determine the equivalent thermal conductivity, the governing
number varies from 1 to 14 in length and 1 to 6 in width. All of equations for the temperature and fluid velocity in the brick
them have the largest void fraction at given hole number and should be simultaneously solved.
Table 1
Comparison lnat with lrad for 290 140 90 bricks
Kinds Holes number Void fraction (%) lnat (W/(m K)) lrad (W/(m K)) (lrad lnat)/lrad (%)
@T
z¼0 u¼v¼w¼0 ¼0
@z (2c)
@T
z ¼ Z1 u ¼ v ¼ w ¼ 0 ¼0
@z
where X1, Y1 and Z1 express the size of the computation domain in
x, y and z direction, respectively. Eq. (2a) expresses the no-slip
boundary condition of the three velocity components and the third
kind boundary condition of the temperature at the inner and outer
surfaces. Eqs. (2b) and (2c) represent the symmetric boundary
condition, i.e., adiabatic, at the boundaries of y and z coordinates
for the temperature. It is interesting to note that the above
governing equations are valid for both solid part of the brick and
the air in the hole. Here, an idea from [17] is adopted, i.e., the solid
is regarded as a special fluid with very large viscosity. This is a very
successful numerical technique to treat the complicated fluid flow
problems where both the fluid and solid temperature should be
simultaneously predicted, and has been widely adopted in many
numerical simulation [16]. With such a technique, the surfaces of
the holes are no longer the computational boundaries, rather they
are the interfaces within the computational domain, and no any
special treatment is needed for such interfaces when the governing
equations are solved. The details of the numerical technique will be
presented below.
According to general building construction engineering prac-
tice, following thermal physical properties are used in simulation:
Tf1 = 293 K; Tf2 = 253 K; h1 = 8.72 W/(m2 K); h2 = 23.26 W/
2
(m K); Pr = 0.707; cpf = 1005 J/(kg K), lf = 0.0244 W/(m K), h =
17.2 106 kg/(m s), rf = 1.293 kg/m3, ls = 0.755 W/(m K), e = 0.85.
3. Numerical methods
!
@ðru2 Þ @ðruvÞ @ðruwÞ @p @2 u @2 u @2 u
þ þ ¼ eff þh þ þ
@x @y @z @x @x2 @y2 @z2
!
@ðruvÞ @ðrv2 Þ @ðrvwÞ @p @2 v @2 v @2 v
þ þ ¼ eff þh þ þ þ rc g bðT T cÞ
@x @y @z @y @x2 @y2 @z2
! (1)
@ðruwÞ @ðrvwÞ @ðrw2 Þ @p @2 w @2 w @2 w
þ þ ¼ eff þh þ þ
@x @y @z @z @x2 @y2 @z2
!
@ðruTÞ @ðrvTÞ @ðrwTÞ l @ T @ T @2 T
2 2
þ þ ¼ þ þ
@x @y @z cp @x2 @y2 @z2
where, peff = p rcgy. conductivity of solid and fluid regions are adopted individually
The boundary conditions of the governing equations are while the specific heat for the solid area should be replaced by the
value of fluid area in order to guarantee the heat flux continuity at
@T
x¼0 u¼v¼w¼0 h2 ðT f2 T w2 Þ ¼ ls the separating surfaces [16,19]. By adopting a very large value of
@x (2a) viscosity amounting to1030 in the momentum equation for the
@T
x ¼ X1 u ¼ v ¼ w ¼ 0 h1 ðT w1 T f1 Þ ¼ ls solid part of the hollow brick, the zero velocity of solid area can be
@x
actually gained.
@T From the simulated temperature field the equivalent thermal
y¼0 u¼v¼w¼0 ¼0
@y conductivity can be determined. The relationship of the equivalent
(2b)
@T thermal conductivity and the predicted temperature field can be
y ¼ Y1 u ¼ v ¼ w ¼ 0 ¼0
@y found as follows.
1794 L.P. Li et al. / Energy and Buildings 40 (2008) 1790–1798
3.1. Formulae for calculation of equivalent thermal conductivity transfer theory [13,14]:
8 2 9
> 2 2 31=2 >
2 < 4 1þX 1þZ
5
2 1=2 1 X
2 1=2 1 Z 1 1
=
X IJ ¼ ln 2 2
þ X 1 þ Z tan 1=2
þ Z 1 þ X tan 1=2
Xtan X Ztan Z (11)
pXZ >
: 1þX þZ 1þZ
2
1þX
2 >
;
Obviously, the solution process is iterative in nature. Both T(I) 4.1. The influence of the hole number on the equivalent thermal
and qr(I) should be updated during iteration procedure. Besides, in conductivity
order to ensure the convergence of iteration, the relaxation for
velocity components and pressure is absolutely necessary for all Simulation started on the cases in which surface radiation in the
cases. holes was neglected. The results of lnat for 72 kinds of
290 140 90 hollow clay bricks are drawn in Fig. 4 and some
3.4. Convergence criteria selected values are listed in Table 1.
From this graph we can see that when the holes in width
Convergence criteria of the iteration procedure for the resulted direction are 1–6, with the increase of the hole number in length
algebraic equations discretized from the governing equation, from one to two holes lnat decreases sharply, it further drops off
Eq. (1), are taken as follows: with the increase of lengthwise holes from 2 to 4,and reaches its
Rmax/G < 106; jQinwall Qoutwallj/min (Qinwall, Qoutwall)<102; minimum at holes of 4–6. Then it increases gradually. When the
and lengthwise hole number is greater than 4, widthwise hole
kþ300 k
number shows some effect on lnat: the more the widthwise
l l
6
10 holes, the larger the value of lnat. This variation tendency can be
kþ300
l understood as follows. If surface radiation in the holes is
neglected, the main influences on the equivalent thermal
for all cases to be simulated. conductivity are the heat conduction through the clay and
natural convection in the holes. When the hole number is not
3.5. Grid-independence examination much, the increase of the hole number leads to such a situation
that the deterioration of natural convection is larger than the
In the preliminary computations, the test of grid independence enhancement in heat conduction through the increased rib,
of the solution has been carried on for the most complicated which makes lnat smaller. Otherwise, the increase of the hole
L14W6H1 hollow clay bricks. The results are drawn in Fig. 3. number leads to an opposite results and makes lnat larger.
Compared case 1 with case 4, when the total grid number increases Therefore, whether lnat increases or decreases with hole
from 122 104 to 949 104, lrad has an increment no more than number depends on which factor is dominant.
Fig. 3. The validation of grid independence. Fig. 4. lnat for the 290 140 90 hollow clay bricks.
1796 L.P. Li et al. / Energy and Buildings 40 (2008) 1790–1798
conductivity in some extent. The L2W1H1 hollow clay brick has the
largest increment of 25.8% while the L14W6H1 hollow clay brick has
the lowest increment of 4.6%. Generally speaking, the more the hole
number, the less the surface radiation effect. The detailed
comparison between lrad and lnat can be found in Table 1.
From Fig. 5, following features may be noted. First, the brick
having only one hole in both width and length has significantly
higher equivalent thermal conductivity than all the other cases.
Second, for the case with at least two holes in width, the effect of
hole number in width becomes much weaker, as all the curves with
2–6 holes in width direction being more or less compacted. And for
the cases with 37 holes in length direction, the equivalent
thermal conductivity of 5 holes in width is the least. The character
of the hole number effect is due to the complicated heat transfer
process caused by conduction, convection and surface radiation
taking place in the hollow clay bricks simultaneously. With the
increase of the hole number convection and surface radiation in the
holes are deteriorated while conduction through the clay may be
enhanced. Therefore, the equivalent thermal conductivity depends
on the total effects of conduction, convection and surface radiation.
Fig. 5. lrad for the 290 140 90 hollow clay bricks. According to the simulation results, the optimum configuration of
the 290 140 90 hollow clay bricks is the L08W4H1 brick, which
4.2. The influence of the surface radiation on the equivalent thermal has the lowest lrad of 0.400 W/(m K). Compared with the lowest lnat
conductivity of 0.350 W/(m K), there is an increment of 12.5%. Therefore, the effect
of surface radiation in the holes cannot be neglected. It is interesting
The equivalent thermal conductivities of 72 kinds of to note that this lowest value is quite close to the one of
290 140 90 hollow clay bricks with the effects of conduction, 240 115 90 brick, which is 0.419 W/(m K), and the related void
convection and surface radiation all being considered simulta- fraction is not different too much either (from 46.9% to 50.3%)
neously are drawn in Fig. 5 and some selected values are listed in
Table 1. Compared with lnat in Fig. 4, it can be observed that both lnat 4.3. The effect of temperature difference between indoor and outdoor
and lrad have the same variation tendency: with the increase in hole on the equivalent thermal conductivity
number the equivalent thermal conductivity decreases first, reaches
the minimum and then increases gradually in some extent. By keeping the indoor temperature at 20 8C while changing
However, the surface radiation enhances the equivalent thermal outdoor temperatures from 30 8C to 0 8C, the effects of the
Table 2
The temperature influence on lrad for 290 140 90 bricks
Kinds Tf1 Tf2 = 50 8C lrad Tf1 Tf2 = 40 8C lrad Tf1 Tf2 = 30 8C lrad Tf1 Tf2 = 20 8C lrad Maximum difference
(W/(m K)) (W/(m K)) (W/(m K)) (W/(m K)) (compared with Tf1 Tf2 = 40 8C) (%)
Fig. 7. Isotherms for the L1W1H1 hollow clay brick (z = 0.21). Fig. 9. Isotherms for the L8W4H1 hollow clay brick (z = 0.21).
1798 L.P. Li et al. / Energy and Buildings 40 (2008) 1790–1798
Acknowledgments
References
[1] C.Y. Zhao, W.Q. Tao, Natural convections in conjugated single and double enclo-
sures, International Journal of Heat Mass Transfer 30 (1995) 175–182.
[2] S. Lorente, M. Petit, R. Javelas, Simplified analytical model for thermal transfer in
vertical hollow brick, Energy and Buildings 24 (1996) 95–103.
[3] S. Lorente, M. Petit, R. Javelas, The effects of temperature conditions on the
thermal resistance of walls made with different shapes vertical hollow bricks,
Energy and Buildings 28 (1998) 237–240.
[4] S. Castro Cardoso, E. Chenier, G. Lauriat, Transfertsde chaleur dans une structure
alverolaire, in: Congres Francais de Thermique SFT2003, Elsevier, Paris, 2003.
[5] J.F. Hinojosa, R.E. Cabanillas, G. Alvarez, C.E. Estrada, Nusselt number for the
natural convection and surface thermal radiation in a square tilted open cavity,
International Communication in a Heat and Mass Transfer 32 (2005) 1184–1192.
[6] T. Kim, S. Kato, S. Murakami, J-w. Rho, Study on indoor thermal environment of
office space controlled by cooling panel system using field measurement and
Fig. 11. Isotherms for the L14W6H1 hollow clay brick (z = 0.21). numerical simulation, Building and Environment 40 (2005) 301–310.
[7] A. Mezrhad, H. Bouali, H. Amaoui, M. Bouzidi, Computation of combined natural-
convection and radiation heat-transfer in a cavity having a square body at its
are so small that they can hardly be spotted with the same printed center, Applied energy 83 (2006) 1004–1023.
scale and are not shown by figures. [8] M.M. AL-Hazmy, Analysis of coupled natural convection-conduction effects on
the heat transport through hollow building blocks, Energy and Buildings 38
(2006) 515–521.
5. Conclusions
[9] J.J. del Coz Dı́az, P.J. Garcı́a Nieto, A. Martı́n, A. Lozano Martı́nez, C. Betegón, Non-
linear thermal analysis of light concrete hollow brick walls by the finite element
Through an extensively numerical study on the influence of the method and experimental validation, Applied Thermal Engineering 26 (2006)
hole number and arrays, with and without surface radiation as well 777–786.
[10] J.J. del Coz Dı́az, P.J. Garcı́a Nieto, C. Betegón, M.B. Prendes, Analysis and optimi-
as variable indoor–outdoor temperature difference on the zation of the heat-insulating light concrete hollow brick walls design by the finite
equivalent thermal conductivity of 290 140 90 hollow clay element method, Applied Thermal Engineering 27 (2007) 1445–1456.
bricks, following conclusions can be made. [11] G. Lauriat, G. Desrayaud, Effect of surface radiation on conjugate natural con-
vection in partially open enclosures, International Journal of Thermal Sciences 45
(2006) 335–346.
1. The surface radiation in the holes makes the equivalent thermal [12] L.P. Li, Z.G. Wu, Z.Y. Li, Y.L. He, W.Q. Tao, Numerical thermal optimization of the
conductivity augmented in some extent, with the maximum configuration of multi-holed clay bricks used for constructing building walls by
the finite volume method, International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer (In
increment being 25.8% for L2W1H1 brick and the minimum Press).
increment being 4.6% for L14W6H1. With the increase in hole [13] F.P. Incropera, D.P. DeWitt, Introduction to Heat Transfer, third ed., John Wiley &
number the surface radiation influence decreases. Sons, New York, 1996.
[14] Y.A. Cengel, Heat Transfer, second ed., McGraw-Hill, Boston, 2003.
2. The hole number and their arrays have crucial influence on the
[15] D.D. Gray, A. Giorgin, The validity of the Boussinesq approximation for liquids and
equivalent thermal conductivity. The brick with only one hole in gases, International journal of Heat Mass Transfer 19 (1976) 545–551.
both length direction and width direction has the largest [16] W.Q. Tao, Numerical Heat Transfer, second ed., Xi’an Jiaotong University Press,
Xi’an, China, 2001.
equivalent thermal conductivity. The L8W4H1 has the smallest
[17] S.V. Patankar, Numerical Heat Transfer and Fluid Flow, McGraw-Hill, New York,
equivalent thermal conductivity of 0.400 W/(m K), which is the 1980.
optimum configuration of the 290 140 90 hollow clay [18] Z.Y. Li, W.Q. Tao, A new stability-guaranteed second-order difference scheme,
bricks. The effect of hole number in length direction is larger Numerical Heat Transfer Part B 42 (2002) 349–365.
[19] Z.G. Qu, W.Q. Tao, Y.L. He, Three dimensional numerical simulation on laminar
than that in width direction. For the hole number of 2–6 in width heat transfer and fluid flow characteristics of strip fin surfaces with X-arrange-
direction their variation curves of the equivalent thermal ment of strips, ASME Journal of Heat Transfer 126 (4) (2004) 697–707.