Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
hospital ECG changed their management. Results. A total of hibiting signs and symptoms of acute coronary syn-
281 patients were enrolled. Thirty-five (12.5%; 95% CI: 9.1%, drome (ACS). The American College of Emergency
16.8%) prehospital ECGs showed changes that were not cap- Physicians, National Association of EMS Physicians,
tured on the initial ED ECG (11 ST depression, 5 T-wave in- and numerous other organizations have made similar
version [TWI], 2 ST depression and TWI, 12 arrhythmia, 2 recommendations.2–7
arrhythmia with ST depression, 2 ST elevation, 1 unknown). Research has demonstrated that paramedics can ob-
Fifty-two (18.5%; 95% CI: 14.4%, 23.5%) prehospital ECGs in- tain diagnostic quality prehospital ECGs without a sig-
fluenced physician management. There were 30 (10.7%) in- nificant increase in on-scene time.8–12 The benefits of
stances where physicians were willing to refer the patient to acquiring prehospital ECGs includes a shorter time to
an inpatient service based on information captured on the
diagnosis and reduced time to reperfusion in patients
prehospital ECG, regardless if the initial ED ECG was nor-
with ST elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI), lead-
mal. Conclusions. Prehospital ECGs show clinically signifi-
cant abnormalities that are not always captured on the ini- ing to decreased morbidity and mortality.8,13–15 The
tial ED ECG. Prehospital ECGs have the potential to change majority of prehospital ECG research has focused on
the management of patients in the ED. Key words: acute the role of prehospital ECGs in diagnosing STEMI.
The utility of the prehospital ECG in patients without
STEMI remains to be elucidated.
In patients who are not experiencing a STEMI, im-
portant diagnostic information can be captured by the
Received November 23, 2013, from the Division of Emergency prehospital ECG before any prehospital medical inter-
Medicine, Department of Medicine, The University of Western On- ventions occur.12–18 By the time patients are evaluated
tario (MD, ML, SM, AD), London, Ontario, Canada; and the South- by a physician, their symptoms may have resolved
west Ontario Regional Base Hospital Program (MD, ML, AD), Lon-
don, Ontario, Canada. Revision accepted May 29, 2013; accepted for
and their initial emergency department (ED) ECG may
publication June 4, 2013. have normalized. Previous retrospective research has
Study results were presented at NAEMSP January 2012 and the an-
shown that 19% of prehospital ECGs had clinically sig-
nual conference for the Canadian Association of Emergency Physi- nificant abnormalities that were not captured on the
cians in June 2012. initial ED ECG and had the potential to change emer-
The authors report no conflicts of interest. The authors alone are re- gency management.18
sponsible for the content and writing of the paper. The purpose of this study was to prospectively de-
Address correspondence to Matthew Davis, 4056 Meadowbrook termine how many prehospital ECGs had clinically
Drive Unit 145, London, ON, Canada N6L 1E5. e-mail: matthew. significant abnormalities not present on the initial
davis@lhsc.on.ca ED ECG and determine how many prehospital ECGs
doi: 10.3109/10903127.2013.825350 changed emergency physician management.
9
10 PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE JANUARY/MARCH 2014 VOLUME 18 / NUMBER 1
which has a population of approximately 363,000. Nurses attached the data collection form to the pa-
EMS in Middlesex County, of which London is a tient’s ED medical record. The emergency physician
part, is provided by Middlesex–London Emergency caring for the patient completed the data collection
Medical Services. Middlesex–London EMS is a pri- form after analysis of the prehospital ECG. Physicians
vately contracted EMS that has approximately 40,000 were asked to document if there were any clinically
patient contacts per year in this county. Paramedics in significant signs of ischemia or arrhythmias (requir-
Middlesex County complete approximately 2,400 pre- ing investigation or treatment) present on the prehos-
hospital ECGs per year. Both primary care (PCP) and pital ECG that were not present on the initial ED ECG.
advanced care paramedics (ACP) can acquire 12-lead Ischemic changes were defined according to the 2010
prehospital ECGs on a battery-powered Zoll M Series AHA Guidelines for Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation
12-lead ECG with an industry standard GE Marquette and Emergency Cardiovascular Care (ST-segment de-
12SL Interpretive ECG algorithm. All ambulances pression > 0.5 mm in leads V2 and V3 and 1 mm in
are equipped with these devices. All paramedics all other leads; T-wave inversion > 2 mm in depth).20
are required to complete a Southwest Ontario Re-
For personal use only.
95% CI: 9.1%, 16.8%) had clinically significant abnor- hospital ECGs changed or influenced the management
malities that were not present on the initial ED ECG. of the ED physician. There were 30 (10.7%) instances
Of the 35 prehospital ECGs with clinically significant where ED physicians were willing to refer the patient
abnormalities that were not present on the initial ED to an inpatient service based on information captured
ECG, 11 had ST depression, 5 with T-wave inver- on the prehospital ECG, regardless whether the initial
sion (TWI), 2 with ST depression and TWI, 2 with ST ED ECG was normal. A total of 57 (20.3%) prehospital
prehospital ECGs
completed by
paramedics during the
study period
(N = 562)
For personal use only.
Missed paents
(n = 168)
prehospital ECGs
idenfied for
enrollment
(n = 394)
prehospital ECGs that prehospital ECGs that prehospital ECGs that prehospital ECGs that
changed ED changed ED changed ED changed ED
management management management management
(n = 21) (n = 23) (n = 3) (n = 5)
TABLE 1. Abnormalities identified on the prehospital ECG TABLE 3. Characteristics of prehospital ECGs determined to
not captured on the ED ECG that changed physician be of poor quality
management
Poor-quality characteristics n
How ED management was changed n
Wandering baseline 23
Consultation to specialty service 16 Wandering baseline and missing lead 1
Immediate treatment prior to formal ECG 3 Wandering baseline and artifact 11
Consultation to outpatient service 2 Artifact 19
Laboratory investigation 2 Unknown 3
Physicians were able to select more than one option. ECG, electrocardiogram; Physicians were able to select more than one option.
ED, emergency department.
ECGs were determined to be of poor quality (Table 3). to be a valuable investigation for the non-STEMI pa-
All were still deemed to be interpretable by physicians tient. This highlights the value of the prehospital ECG
despite the poor quality. The median (IQR) time to ED in emergency medical services regardless of availabil-
ECG was 45 (13, 25 minutes). ity or timely access to a cardiac catheterization facil-
ity. In our study population, 16.8% of patients had is-
chemic changes on their prehospital ECG. The results
DISCUSSION are similar to those found by Turnipseed et al., who re-
The prehospital ECG has proven to be a valuable ported that 17% of the prehospital ECGs analyzed in
tool in the early identification, treatment, and man- their study showed an injury pattern (ST depression,
agement of patients with STEMI by reducing time TWI, or LBB).12
to reperfusion via fibrinolytic or percutaneous coro- A recent study examined whether the prehospital
nary intervention.8,13–15 A recent study showed that ECG adds supplemental information to the first ECG
prehospital activation of the cardiac catheter labora- obtained in hospital.17 Investigators compared data on
For personal use only.
tory significantly reduced door-to-balloon time when possible myocardial ischemia and arrhythmias by ex-
compared to walk-in STEMI patients and to STEMI amining both the prehospital and first ED ECG. It was
patients arriving by EMS without field activation.16 discovered that 19% of prehospital ECGs showed ST
The majority of prehospital ECG studies focus on this depression that was not captured on the first ED ECG,
patient population. The focus of our study was on while 14% of prehospital ECGs showed arrhythmias
patients who had clinically significant abnormalities that were not captured on the first ED ECG. These find-
recorded on the prehospital ECG that were not cap- ings are in keeping with the results of our study, indi-
tured on the initial ED ECG and how this influenced cating that transient abnormalities can be captured on
patient management. prehospital ECGs that are not seen on initial ED ECGs.
EMS providers often evaluate and treat patients who However, our study provided clinical relevance by de-
are experiencing ischemic symptoms. On arrival in the termining if and how these transient abnormalities in-
ED the underlying process causing their symptoms fluenced ED patient care.
may have resolved spontaneously or responded to the Of the 281 included prehospital ECGs in our study,
symptomatic treatment provided by the paramedics. 35 (12.5%; 95% CI: 9.1%, 16.8%) had clinically signif-
The results of our study highlight that paramedics are icant abnormalities that were not apparent on the ini-
in a unique position to capture ECG changes while pa- tial ED ECG. The majority (62.9%) of these patients had
tients are experiencing their symptoms. As evidenced ischemic changes that were not apparent on the ini-
by the number of clinically significant arrhythmias and tial ED ECG. This represents a vulnerable population
ischemic changes that were captured in the prehospital whose severity of underlying coronary disease can go
unrecognized if the prehospital ECG is not evaluated
in the ED. This demonstrates the important role that
TABLE 2. Prehospital ECGs that were not different from the the prehospital ECG can have as a diagnostic tool in
initial ED ECG but did change initial ED management patients not experiencing a STEMI that may otherwise
be missed if a prehospital ECG is not completed or not
How ED management was changed n
analyzed by an ED physician. The presence of these
Consultation to specialty service 14 ischemic abnormalities found on the prehospital ECG
Immediate treatment prior to formal ECG 8 changed physician management in 65% of cases, high-
Early consultation to outpatient service 1
Laboratory investigation 3 lighting the significant impact it has on providing ap-
Not specified 2 propriate and timely patient care.
Code STEMI initiated 1 The ACC/AHA guidelines recommend that an ECG
Physicians were able to select more than one option. ECG, electrocardiogram; should be performed within 10 minutes after ED
ED, emergency department; STEMI, ST elevation myocardial infarction. arrival in patients whose chief complaint is chest
M. Davis et al. PREHOSPITAL 12-LEAD ECG 13
discomfort, angina equivalent, or other symptoms sug- lighting the importance of the prehospital ECG in the
gestive of ACS.22 However, this standard is not met ED care of patients. There were 30 (10.7%) instances
in up to 67% of high-risk patients suffering from where the ED physician deemed there was a signifi-
non-ST-segment elevation acute coronary syndrome.25 cant abnormality on the prehospital ECG requiring in-
Diercks et al. suggested ED overcrowding, inadequate patient consultation, regardless if the initial ED was
operational resources, and logistic challenges may im- normal. Our findings indicate that the prehospital ECG
pact the time to initial ED ECG. In our study, the can also play a valuable role in the timely and appro-
median time to ED ECG was 45 minutes. The prehos- priate disposition of the patient, which could poten-
pital ECG has the potential to assist in triaging patients tially lead to the reduction of ED overcrowding and
who may be experiencing ACS and can be used to di- increased departmental flow.
vert ED resources appropriately and earlier, especially During the study period, 562 prehospital ECGs were
if it demonstrates ischemic changes that may have re- completed by paramedics, but only 394 were identi-
Prehosp Emerg Care Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Northern Alberta Institute of Technology on 02/08/15
solved prior to the initial ED ECG. As demonstrated in fied for enrolment. Of those, 281 had study forms com-
this study, treatment and investigations may be initi- pleted by physicians. In an attempt to maximize the
ated based on the prehospital ECG and not require a number of enrolled patients, various awareness and
formal ED ECG, such as the management of paroxys- education campaigns directed at paramedics, nurses,
mal SVT or treatment of rapid atrial fibrillation. physicians, and clerical staff were implemented. De-
The occurrence of false-negative prehospital ECG spite this, only half of all patients with a prehospital
interpretation of STEMIs in patients transported by ECG during the study period were included in the data
EMS highlights the importance of the prehospital ECG analysis. It is unknown if there were unique charac-
in early STEMI identification. Patients with STEMI teristics or clinically relevant findings of those not en-
may go undiagnosed either by computer-generated or rolled that may have altered these study results. Ad-
paramedic interpretation. A recent study showed that ditionally, it is unknown whether ED physicians may
prehospital computer interpretation is only 58% sen- have been more likely to report that prehospital ECGs
sitive in diagnosing STEMI, although the study was influenced their management because of the study.
For personal use only.
relatively small and used only one brand of moni- In our study, nearly 20% of the analyzed prehospi-
tor and associated software.23 Additionally, a recent tal ECGs were of poor quality. This may have resulted
American study reported that paramedics were able in some subtle changes that may have been missed by
to identify STEMI with a 75% specificity and a 53% physicians or resulted in overcalling certain positive
specificity.24 By having an ED physician review the findings. Despite the number of poor quality prehos-
prehospital ECG, delays to initiation of reperfusion pital ECGs, all were deemed to be interpretable by the
strategies may be reduced, which may in turn lead emergency physician analyzing the prehospital ECG.
to more favorable outcomes. In our study population, Our study was conducted within a single EMS system
two false-negative prehospital ECG interpretations of and at two academic tertiary care EDs, and the results
prehospital STEMIs (0.7%) were identified by emer- may not be generalizable.
gency physician interpretation of the prehospital ECG.
Previous false-negative rates have been reported as CONCLUSION
high as 20%.26 Considering that the AHA guidelines of
initial ED ECG completion within 10 minutes is often In summary, the 12-lead prehospital ECG can reveal
not met, reviewing the prehospital ECG prior to the ED clinically significant abnormalities that are not always
ECG can potentially decrease the morbidity associated captured on the initial ED ECG. As a result, prehospi-
with delayed identification of STEMI. tal ECGs have the potential to change the management
In our study, 12 arrhythmias were identified on the of patients in the ED. The prehospital ECG may also
prehospital ECG that resolved by the time the ED lead to a more timely diagnosis, earlier treatment, and
ECG was performed. The prehospital ECG allowed appropriate disposition, potentially leading to reduced
for appropriate diagnosis, investigation, and treat- morbidity and mortality among patients.
ment. Atrial fibrillation made up the majority of these
paroxysmal arrhythmias. Identifying these paroxys-
mal rhythms on the prehospital ECG that may other- References
wise go undiagnosed on ED ECG can reduce the need 1. O’Connor RE, Brady W, Brooks SC, Diercks D, Egan J, Ghaem-
for extended cardiac monitoring or outpatient Holter maghami C, Menon V, O’Neil BJ, Travers AH, Yannopou-
monitor investigations. Additionally, relevant inves- los D. 2010 American Heart Association guidelines for
cardiopulmonary resuscitation and emergency cardiovascu-
tigations and appropriate treatment can be initiated
lar care, part 10: Acute coronary syndromes. Circulation.
sooner, which may lead to reduced morbidity and mor- 2010;122:S787–S817.
tality in this patient population. 2. ACEP Policy Statement: Out of Hospital 12-Lead ECG. Avail-
Our study demonstrated that the prehospital ECG able from: www.acep.org/Content.aspx?id=29594. Last ac-
changed physician management in 18% of cases, high- cessed September 18, 2012.
14 PREHOSPITAL EMERGENCY CARE JANUARY/MARCH 2014 VOLUME 18 / NUMBER 1
3. Ting HH, Krumholz HM, Bradley EH, Cone DC, Curtis JP, via hand-held device for patients with acute myocardial infarc-
Drew BJ, Field JM, French WJ, Gibler WB, Goff DC, Jacobs tion. Am J Cardiol. 2006;98:1160–4.
AK, Nallamothu BK, O’Connor RE, Schuur JD. Implementation 15. Brainard AH, Raynovich W, Tandberg D, Bedrick EJ. The pre-
and integration of prehospital ECGs into systems of care for hospital 12-lead electrocardiogram’s effect on time of initiation
acute coronary syndrome: a scientific statement from the Amer- of reperfusion therapy: a systematic review and meta-analysis
ican Heart Association Interdisciplinary Council on Quality of of existing literature. Am J Emerg Med. 2005;23:351–6.
Care and Outcomes Research, Emergency Cardiovascular Care 16. Cone DC, Lee CH, Van Gelder C. EMS activation of the car-
Committee, Council on Cardiovascular Nursing, and Council diac catheterization laboratory is associated with process im-
on Clinical Cardiology. Circulation. 2008;118:1066–79. provements in the care of myocardial infarction patients. Pre-
4. Crocco TJ, Sayre MR, Aufderheide TP. Prehospital triage of hosp Emerg Care 2013; (Epub ahead of print).
chest pain patients. Prehosp Emerg Care. 2002;6:224–28. 17. Boothroyd LJ, Segal E, Bogarty P, Nasmith J, Eisenberg MJ,
5. Jacobs AK, Antman EM, Faxon DP, Gregory T, Solis P. Devel- Boivin JF, Vadeboncœur A, de Champlain C. Information on
opment of systems of care for ST-elevation myocardial infarc- myocardial ischemia and arrhythmias added by prehospital
tion patients: executive summary. Circulation. 2007;116:217–30. electrocardiograms. Prehosp Emerg Care. 2013;17:187–92.
Prehosp Emerg Care Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Northern Alberta Institute of Technology on 02/08/15
6. Dracup K, Alonzo AA, Atkins JM, Bennett NM, Braslow A, 18. Drew BJ, Sommargren CE, Schindler DM, Zegre J, Bene-
Clark LT, Eisenberg M, Ferdinand KC, Frye R, Green L, Hill dict K, Krucoff MW. Novel electrocardiogram configurations
MN, Kennedy JW, Kline-Rogers E, Moser DK, Ornato JP, Pitt and transmission procedures in the prehospital setting; effect
B, Scott JD, Selker HP, Silva SJ, Thies W, Weaver WD, Wenger on ischemia and arrhythmia determination. J Electrocardiol.
NK, White SK. The physician’s role in minimizing prehospi- 2006;39:S157–S60.
tal delay in patients at high risk for acute myocardial infarc- 19. Davis M, Dukelow A, McLeod S, Rodriguez S, Lewell
tion: recommendations from the National Heart Attack Alert M. The utility of the prehospital electrocardiogram. CJEM.
Program: Working Group on Educational Strategies to Prevent 2011;13(6):372–7.
Prehospital Delay in Patients at High Risk for Acute Myocar- 20. O’Connor RE, Brady W, Brooks SC, Diercks D, Egan J, Ghaem-
dial Infarction. Ann Intern Med. 1997;126:645–51. maghami C, Menon V, O’Neil BJ, Travers AH, Yannopoulos
7. Emergency department: rapid identification and treatment of D. 2010 American Heart Association Guidelines for Cardiopul-
patients with acute myocardial infarction: National Heart At- monary Resuscitation and Emergency Cardiovascular Care,
tack Alert Program Coordinating Committee, 60 minutes to part 10: acute coronary syndromes. Circulation. 2010;122(suppl
Treatment Working Group. Ann Emerg Med. 1994;23:311–29. 3):S787–S817.
8. Morrison LJ, Brooks S, Sawadsky B, McDonald A, Verbeek PR. 21. Naing L, Winn T, Rusli BN. Practical issues in calculating
Prehospital 12-lead electrocardiogram impact on acute myocar- the sample size for prevalence studies. Arch Orofacial Sci.
For personal use only.