Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
GLEASON
REPORT
Market Timing for Investors
Identify Turning Points in Asset Classes
IMPORTANT: The Gleason Report is a newsletter of general and regular circulation published by Southwest Ranch Financial,
LLC (SWR). SWR is not a registered investment advisor and does not provide personalized investment advice. Investment
ideas presented are the opinion of SWR and are for informational purposes only. You shouldn’t act on anything without
consulting with your investment advisor. Investing involves risk and the future performance of the market timing models
cannot be guaranteed. The publisher shall have no liability of whatever nature in respect of any claim, damages, loss or
expense arising from any reliance by you on the contents of our web site, published material or an alert.
© 2010 Southwest Ranch Financial, LLC
The Gleason Report December 2010
Bonds
My bond model remains out of US treasuries.
With the Fed buying bonds and holding down
rates, it’s a phony and rigged market. Because of
the dollar’s power, this can go on until an
external shock causes international capital
outflows from America. With so many
currencies pegged to the dollar or in a weak
position themselves, I can guess what will
happen but can’t say when.
~2~
The Gleason Report December 2010
Commodities grantham-fed-has-spent-last-20-years-
The price of agricultural commodities and basic manipulating-stock-market
materials remains strong. Some are saying the
prices are too high. The rising prices reflect He believes oil has broken out of its price pattern
pricing reality in a world of rigged currencies. If and fair value is perhaps $75. More
you own a mine or something needed by many, importantly, he says that the world is running out
you are sensitive to the purchasing power of of everything – all basic materials and ores.
currencies and are reluctant to sell your valuable Own commodity firms with stuff in the ground -
ore only to own currencies being printed willy- not firms that have to buy and process stuff.
nilly. It’s simple common sense. Thus, Own farmland and timber. This advice is for
commodity prices are the indicator of fiat investors with a 10-20 year timeline. Think
debasement. Producers can sell for dollars but about it. This is exactly what the Chinese are
can’t earn anything on those dollars. The wise doing.
action is to demand higher prices – sell less ore
for more dollars. In addition to commodity firms, if you must own
stocks now, buy into a franchise Coca-Cola-type
We know that America can never pay off its firm and also hold some cash for future
debts, China is said to be a currency manipulator opportunities. He sees only 1% growth plus
and Europe has severe debt problems too. inflation for stocks over the next seven years so
Nobody will blink and reduce domestic consumer stocks are
risk. They are all gaming the probably not a good idea. Own
system and it will go on until what the world needs.
something breaks.
Grantham thinks the dollar is sort
In an interesting interview, fund of cheap now based on purchasing
manager Jeremy Grantham power but QE (money printing)
expressed his concerns about could extend losses because that's
the stock market and the what the Fed wants.
potential in commodity assets.
He’s advising wealthy people to
He says the Fed has spent the last 20 years preserve their cash in real things and to own
manipulating the stock market because a strong firms with strong earning power. TGR has
stock market creates a wealth effect and causes shown the link between oil and gold and
people to spend money. Grantham’s words only confirm what you’ve
read here before. It’s another voice and a well-
He says stocks may go to 1500 over the next 1-2 reasoned one. It should be obvious that we’re at
years but will fall badly again (agrees with my the end of the dollar-anchored monetary system.
forecast). The market will fall in half after the Anyone hoping to preserve purchasing power
run-up and QE2, 3, 4 ends. Emerging markets has to place their money into things of value.
are also a bit overpriced but they have a better
future. Bonds are terrible.
Currencies
His super high net worth clients are being My model remains out of the dollar. I sold my
advised to place their money into commodity Merkx shares at the right time. I believe the
companies. dollar’s downward thrust has abated for a while.
http://www.zerohedge.com/article/jeremy-
~3~
The Gleason Report December 2010
The Argentina Experience Economic troubles rocked the region in the mid
Comparisons of America with Weimar Germany 90s with Mexico devaluing it’s currency but
are dated because of the widespread gold Argentina performed much better than others.
standard in the 1920s and various other reasons. The 1997 Asian economic crisis and 1998
We can look at the 2001 Argentina economic Russian crisis caused panic worldwide and credit
collapse for better information. Events will lines to Argentina shriveled and by 1999
certainly play out different in America but I’ll recession set in. The boom times were over.
note some similarities.
President De la Rua took office in the 1999
In the 1980s Argentina experienced rampant elections and promised he would fix the
inflation. Carlos Saul Menem was elected in economic damage. He adopted a plan forced
1989 and was handed a difficult economy. upon him by the IMF. That plan said to lower
Domingo Cavallo was appointed Minister of interest rates and produce a new boom by raising
Finance in 1991. The Argentina stock market taxes. This would reduce the government's
soared when Cavallo pegged the peso to the deficit and stabilize bond prices. The IMF’s
dollar to stop inflation. From that point, Pesos timing was dreadful. World interest rates were
had to be backed with dollars and were rising thus increasing taxes didn’t lower
convertible into dollars. This linkage to a known domestic interest rates. The economy went into
standard caused inflation to drop along with a tailspin.
fiscal discipline.
Election fraud in 2000 angered the populace and
By 1998, the economy had grown 45% over the crowds demanded all the politicians should be
previous seven years. National utilities were thrown out.
privatized and tariffs were reduced dramatically.
Free trade agreements were signed with other De La Rua resigned in 2001 and the dollar peg
South American countries. The United States was dropped. Argentina couldn’t pay its foreign
~4~
The Gleason Report December 2010
borrowings and the IMF walked away. A severe dollar. If you look at the chain of events though
depression ensued and the Peso plunged. it’s clear we’re experiencing the same symptoms
Hyperinflation arrived as people fled the of failure but not yet the dire consequences.
currency.
America had virtually no inflation while on a
Rather than cut spending, the Economy Ministry gold standard because borrowing was
tried to get even more in taxes. More disaster constrained. Since the first market collapse in
followed. Are you listening Mr. Obama? 2001, the US has borrowed heavily. Wars were
started to grab oil and forestall a deeper
By 2002, many people were in poverty. The recession.
unemployment rate rose to 22%. Argentina
pleaded for US help in 2002. President George The IMF and world opinion has no control over
Bush said they needed to adopt economic America’s military actions or debt expansion.
reforms and start firing government workers as a Two stock market crashes, massive deficits,
precondition of IMF assistance. money printing and endless war and we get only
token moves towards sensibility.
President Duhalde took office in 2002. With an
unstable peso and no dollar convertibility, he Rather than cut spending or reign in the military,
decided to freeze the bank accounts of citizens the government’s deficit commission says we
and limit withdrawals. Inflation and a 70% need higher tax rates to increase government
devaluation ravaged savers. The middle class in revenues and to keep interest rates low. This is
Argentina was wiped out. the same stupid advice the IMF gave Argentina
and it caused an economic collapse and
Nestor Kirchner was elected in 2003. Kirchner hyperinflation. Interest rates are now rising just
fired corrupt officials and cleansed the military like when Argentina raised taxes.
of war criminals from the 1970s torture era. He
initiated impeachment trials against Supreme The real US unemployment rate is approaching
Court judges. He restored credibility to 20%; the Argentina tipping point. America is
government. racked with political corruption. We’ve ignored
the rule of law for the politicians. Crimes by
Kirchner was smart with the economy. He bankers are rewarded. Just like in failed
refused to be bled dry by the IMF. When foreign Argentina, the politicians are listening to the
loans came due he stood firm. He won. Bond bankers. Behind the scenes, the authorities are
holders were required to take a 30% write-off on gearing up for a massive tax grab on savers and
their principal. [US bond buyers pay heed.] The small business. In 2012, all US business
economy improved by 2003 and Argentina transactions over $600 will be tracked. They
moved away from the ravages of globalization want a federal sales tax. The military budget is
and the demands of western bankers. off limits.
Commodity export growth has allowed steady
improvement that still continues. Nothing done under the tent of this corrupt cabal
can fix the problem. It’s time to open the tent
From bust to boom to bust and Argentina’s flaps and expose these crooks and start over.
investors got wiped out. Not many can survive America implies China is a bad international
regular market crashes. One will get you citizen. China doesn’t start wars, has no deficits,
eventually. America is not Argentina. It’s the issues no bonds, executes corrupt officials, and
world’s dominant economy and others peg to the always pays cash. Sounds good to me.
~5~
The Gleason Report December 2010
The Dance of Yin and Yang Since 2002, gold has risen in dollars and other
The Argentina experience has lessons for currencies about 400%. Gold is thus adjusting
America. We’re on a similar path but, being the slowly to current conditions and is not out of
world’s dominant economy, different rules control. It’s just acting to restore balance.
apply. The China-America relationship exposes
what’s really going on with our economy. It has
similarities to the America-Argentina experience
but reversed.
~6~
The Gleason Report December 2010
debt and no currency for the western bankers to They use the money to buy commodities and
manipulate gives China flexibility to pursue its companies across the globe to restore balance.
growth strategy. America’s impotence at forcing They’d buy our corporations too but, like their
China to change has Ben Bernanke stymied. currency, our corporations are off limits for
Talk about turning the tables! This is the purchase. Now, who’s the real manipulator in
Chinese way – the way of Tao. this scenario?
Other emerging market economies should follow They spend our money and buy world assets for
China’s lead. Nations with natural resources their future. You can call China a currency
need to carefully manage their internal growth to manipulator but is that accurate? They have
avoid the clutches of the IMF and America’s insulated their economy from the western
bankers. Once trapped, the “solution” is always bankers and IMF while using our profligacy to
the same. The strengthen their
IMF provides economy. They
loans but requires won’t be a patsy for
severe austerity on Goldman Sachs and
the people. The Bernanke.
nation’s resources
are sold to western America has massive
corporations who debt that cannot ever
then move the be paid off. The
processing jobs to Argentines who
cheaper labor survived their
countries and bleed country’s
the nation until the devaluations had
resources are moved their money
depleted. overseas beforehand. Everyone else got scalped.
Argentina devalued the Peso and then grabbed
This is exactly what the bankers have done to the retirement assets of its citizens to pay off the
American citizens for twenty years and with the IMF. Herein lies something important for every
same results. America has borrowed heavily and American. When our budgets and dollar go bust,
shipped jobs overseas. We’re burdened by debt will your savings be the solution to the
and unemployment. All that’s needed now is government’s problem?
higher taxes and wealth confiscation to crash the
dollar. Argentina listened to America’s IMF You had better hold some assets where the
bankers and we’re getting the same stupid government can’t see them. This has become
advice. much more difficult over the last year with all
the new regulations passed supposedly to prevent
The US Fed has countered China’s shrewd money laundering. These are really capital
currency strategy by adopting Quantitative control measures to close the doors on panicked
Easing (QE = massive money printing]. What money seeking shelter. It will have nowhere to
China and Europe won’t lend to America, it just go.
prints. Does China care? I think they’re angry at
the double standard but in typical Chinese After the Argentine economy collapsed, the
fashion they play the Yin to our Yang. A good country experienced a social breakdown with
chunk of our printed dollars are spent in China. murders and kidnappings. The police were
~7~
The Gleason Report December 2010
powerless against the rioters and looters. Your and agricultural prices today. Food is being sold
neighbors became predators and home invasions to Asia. America’s vast, fertile farmland will
were common. This stage didn’t last long – benefit Asia as much as us – maybe more. Have
perhaps a year. Will it happen in America? a six month supply of food on hand. Rice and
Don’t be so sure that we’re different. Here’s a beans and canned foods are cheap now but may
long first-person account of someone dealing not be available in a crisis. And, for heaven’s
with the dangerous situation in Argentina. sake, keep a low profile when trouble arrives.
http://www.survival-spot.com/survival-
files/argentinas-collapse.pdf China places social Stop worrying about the rate of return on your
stability as its highest priority. They will never money and get it to safety. The angry people on
sacrifice this to appease America. Fox News blame liberals for our troubles. They
can’t see the big wart on their own nose.
Take a look around folks. Our unemployment MSNBC is almost as bad with over-educated
rate is approaching wonks ranting
Argentina’s worst days. about hard-line
The world can’t lend us any conservatives.
more money so we’re Let them all
printing it. We have corrupt argue – it’s
politicians working for the actually good
corporations and not the news because
people. We have endless there’s no
wars we can’t afford or even national
explain This can’t possibly consensus yet.
continue much longer. Our You should be
Ying is going to be restored taking action to
to balance by a powerful protect your
Yang countermove. China knows this and has family while they bicker. Yin is going to
positioned itself. The very wealthy advised by balance Yang and restore equilibrium. This will
intuitive thinkers like Grantham know this. be the birth of a new world financial system and
ascendant China will be a big part of it.
You absolutely, positively must get out of the
dollar to some degree. Own physical gold. In
your IRA own gold in Canadian funds like CEF, Will America Survive the Collapse?
GTU and PHYS. Buy some PRPFX or Yes it will. However 80% of the middle class
MERKX. Do not own GLD or SLV where the won’t unless they protect themselves.
metals are held in American or British banks. Hyperinflation is possible but can be avoided.
More likely, the gold has been leveraged or lent It’s triggered by a widespread understanding that
out and you’ll be cheated. Invest money in the money is becoming worthless. It’s a
companies that will benefit from the powerful psychological shift. When that shift occurs a
forces about to descend on the world economy. currency can fail within weeks. I think the US
government will act preemptively but it can’t be
Argentina is a country of 40 million with fertile assured.
farmland that can feed 300 million. After the
collapse there was widespread starvation within As James Rickards has stated on
a land of plenty. The food was sold overseas to KingWorldNews, the US is the Saudi Arabia of
get foreign exchange. Look at grocery prices gold. When the dollar falls, America can switch
~8~
The Gleason Report December 2010
to a gold backed currency – if the gold is still in ―As currently constituted, the international
Fort Knox. Ron Paul says it may not be. We monetary system has a structural flaw: It lacks a
supposedly have more gold than all of Europe. mechanism, market based or otherwise, to
China and Russia have very little. To induce needed adjustments by surplus countries,
accomplish a switchover to gold, the price would which can result in persistent imbalances. This
have to rise to well above $5000 per ounce. problem is not new. For example, in the
http://www.zerohedge.com/article/jim-rickards- somewhat different context of the gold standard
tells-cnbcs-joe-kernen-gold-going-5000 in the period prior to the Great Depression, the
United States and France ran large current
You may find that statement outrageous but it account surpluses, accompanied by large inflows
makes a lot of sense. Central bankers abhor the of gold. … These policies created deflationary
gold standard but Bernanke thinks about gold a pressures in deficit countries that were losing
lot. gold, which helped bring on the Great
Depression‖.
This past month, Ben Bernanke called for a new Source:
world monetary system. He used the speech to http://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/speec
attack China’s “currency manipulation” but it h/bernanke20101119a.htm
smacked of desperation.
Imagine you’re China listening to this bullshit.
―On its current economic trajectory, the United Bernanke wants China to drop its dollar peg and
States runs the risk of seeing millions of workers play by his crazy banker rules. Yet, America
unemployed or underemployed for many years,‖ will not adjust its own policies.
Bernanke said.
We are in the early stage of the most dramatic
…. unemployment ―might rise further in the near monetary realignment in 100 years.
term,‖ he said. This could bring an end to the
tepid U.S. recovery ..‖
Pre-Collapse Negotiations
―The strategy of currency undervaluation has Let’s dissect Bernanke’s conundrum and
demonstrated important drawbacks, both for the possible actions and see how it will affect you.
world system and for the countries using that
strategy,‖ Bernanke talks about unemployment and the
need for adjustments in his speech.
―Currency undervaluation by surplus countries Unemployment is the biggest concern because it
is inhibiting needed international adjustment and presents a threat to the establishment. When
creating spillover effects that would not exist if people are out of work they have family
exchange rates better reflected market problems, lose hope, don’t pay taxes and get
fundamentals,‖ angry at the government.
―Unfortunately, so long as exchange-rate Greenspan and Bernanke didn’t worry when high
adjustment is incomplete and global growth paying jobs were shipped to China because
prospects are markedly uneven, the problem of crappy jobs took their place and people were still
excessively strong capital inflows to emerging employed. Bush spent trillions on war and
markets may persist,‖ stimulus to ensure that economic bubbles kept
everyone fat and happy. When the bubbles
popped, unemployment emerged and D.C. got
~9~
The Gleason Report December 2010
worried. Look at the huge congressional once again and further weaken our long term
turnover in the past two elections. That’s all health.
these guys care about – the next election cycle.
They didn’t care that our standard of living has China is positioning itself for the long haul
been in decline since 1974 and they don’t care whereas America is trying to slow its descent. If
about your family today. It’s about their jobs China keeps buying our debt we can keep our
and their power and the banker and corporate navy afloat and continue our wars but we must
friends who fund their campaigns. agree not to meddle in China’s sphere of
influence in Asia. We will continue to drain our
Bernanke can demand that surplus countries [aka lifeblood and China will facilitate it.
China] take actions to weaken their economies to
help America but it isn’t going to happen. China Post Collapse Reform
has blocked its currency from international trade One day you will awaken to learn of global
and is thus mostly immune to the actions of monetary reform. China and American
George Soros and the currency trading crooks at diplomats will be on CNBC toasting each other
Goldman Sachs. China won’t play America’s with big smiles. Your money will buy less at
game. It doesn’t borrow money so the IMF is Wal-Mart. Foreigners will buy US based
irrelevant. It doesn’t corporations. No doubt, the
invade other nations and so agreement will be touted as a
has no problems with victory that establishes a new
terrorist payback. It buys world monetary order.
what it needs with
America’s dollars. These Massive domestic and military
guys are shrewd and have spending cuts will be necessary.
turned the tables on the The price of imports, food and oil
western bankers. will soar. We will experience
what happened to Argentina in
A politician’s first priority 2001 but at a different pace. The
is to shore up their political base. D.C. needs to rich and the leading politicians will already have
get a diplomatic trade deal done with China that their money hedged. The Wall Street bank
they can tout as a victory. China thinks long coffers will be replenished. Corporate tax rates
term and America short term so you can see will be cut and yours will go up. The wars will
where this is going. end.
China will concede to a quicker increase in the Former assistant Treasury Secretary, Paul Craig
value of the Yuan and perhaps limited exchange Roberts, presents this summation in The Stench
trading of its currency but will demand things of US Economic Decay Grows Stronger.
now. It will drive a hard bargain. It will want
guarantees on energy supplies and the ability to Meanwhile in America, the sheeple remain
purchase American companies in exchange for content with, or blind to, their role as sheep to be
not dumping US debt. It will want military slaughtered to feed the rich. The Obama
treaties and guaranteed protection from banker administration has managed to come up with a
currency manipulation. All these long term Deficit Commission whose members want to pay
payoffs America will concede in exchange for for the multi-trillion dollar wars that are
more jobs at home. We’ll give away the store enriching the military/security complex and the
multi-trillion dollar bailouts of the financial
~ 10 ~
The Gleason Report December 2010
system by reducing annual cost-of-living now believes WTC 7 was brought down by
increases for Social Security, raising the explosives on 9/11. This was on Fox News!
retirement age to 69, ending the mortgage What?! Watch it yourself. They run the
interest deduction, ending the tax deduction for BuildingWhat.org clip stating that 9/11 was an
employer-provided health insurance, imposing a inside job.
6.5% federal sales tax, while cutting the top tax http://beforeitsnews.com/story/274/897/FOX_Co
rate for the rich. ntinues_the_WTC_7_Discussion_with_Geraldo_
and_Judge_Napolitano.html
The American government only has resources for
wars of aggression and bailouts of rich Why this story was allowed on national news is a
banksters. The American citizen has become a mystery to me. I suspect it’s part of a concession
mere subject to be bled for the ruling to public opinion and a preparation for future
oligarchies. news. Regardless, Rivera states directly that it’s
Source: a demolition job and the Judge appears to be on
http://vdare.com/roberts/101128_us_economic_decay.htm board. Rivera has a reputation something less
than ideal but the Judge is a good guy. It appears
You may not agree with his rhetoric but there that as we approach a post collapse America,
can be no doubt that services will decline and they intend to give some explanations or
taxes are going up on Americans. This excuses.
government, like Argentina, will sell out its
citizens to protect the banks, corporations and
the political class. Failure is Clearly Evident
Look at our military leaders. Generals
McChrystal and Petraeus negotiated for months
with a guy claiming to be the head of the
Taliban. They paid him money to attend
meetings. In reality he was a shopkeeper from a
province. They tried to blame the embarrassing
blunder on the
British but the
Brit press
spilled the
beans.
Peace talks
conducted with
an impostor
Governments always survive these events but who posed as
people don’t. Americans are going to be pissed a Taliban
but powerless. As part of the reform process, leader, and which led to a meeting with Hamid
America will have to discredit and bury the Bush Karzai in Kabul and thousands of dollars in
era. They’ll confess to bad deeds once the sickly "goodwill payments", were started by the Afghan
Cheney is dead and will defuse the anger with a government and approved by the former
few show trials. American commander, Stanley McChrystal, the
Guardian has learned.
Geraldo Rivera, in a piece with Fox’s Judge
Andrew Napolitano, stated this month that he
~ 11 ~
The Gleason Report December 2010
~ 12 ~
The Gleason Report December 2010
~ 13 ~
The Gleason Report December 2010
that means a tsunami of cash will be forced to Keep filling your pantry and buy what you need
move. I believe the wise investor will act before now. We’re going to get what we deserve.
the crowd. Q. 1) You said that you currency model is in
foreign currencies, but that you recently closed
your position in MERKX. Is this a contradiction,
or are you overriding your model based on the
Q&A strength of the trend.
Q. Thanks for another great issue Tom. 2) I like MERKX as well (although management
Regarding the down slope of the peak oil curve, fee is a bit high for a currency fund) but the fund
Nicole Foss at The Automatic Earth website charges a 1% fee on the sale of shares held less
(http://theautomaticearth.blogspot.com/) , who than 6 months. This would seem to be quite a
was a former editor of The Oil Drum, makes a drag on returns if we move in and out a few
key point that is rarely mentioned about the oil times a year.
curve. The curve usually shown does not take
into account the added energy required to extract 3) I love PRPFX; perhaps more than I should. I
each barrel of oil compared to what was required like the philosophy and the discipline behind the
on the up slope of the curve. fund, and I have owned it for a few years.
However, I'm questioning how things will go
As the return per unit of energy invested has moving forward. One fourth of the assets are in
gone from something like 100 barrels extracted USD cash (yielding nothing) and one fourth is in
per 1 invested in the early days, to something bonds yielding about 3.5%. So we have half the
like 5 to 1 or less nowadays, the reduction in portfolio yielding 1.75% with significant bond
extraction cost and efficiency drives the down exposure. Part of me wants to trust the method,
slope curve much steeper than is typically but the more analytical part of me is wondering
shown, because so much of the oil being if this method will continue to perform in the
extracted on the down curve must be plowed coming five years or so.
right back in to the extraction process to make up A. 1) Yes, I'm overriding the model and taking
for the lost efficiency. This becomes a negative profit. It's an intuitive judgment. My currency
feedback loop which predicts a much faster model has only a 70% probability of success.
decline rate than even the alarming ones Many are predicting the dollar to fall a lot after
typically shown on the peak oil bell curve. What QE kicks in. Maybe it will. [Note: The dollar
you end up with is, a few years after the peak, a has gone up]
cliff-like free fall on the down side, rather than 2) The merkx fund does have a 1% penalty for
the multi-decade decline many expect. shares held less than the required time but the
A. You and Ms. Foss are correct. The down maximum charge is $250 (I use Vanguard). So,
slope of the oil production curve is much steeper if the trade is greater than $25k, the fee doesn't
than the curve up. In other words, the oil change. If you know of a currency basket fund
depletion crisis will hit us harder and faster than that offers a better deal let me know because it
even pessimists expect. I should be amazed this would benefit others.
topic gets so little press considering the 3) I understand your point about prpfx. It holds
economic danger it poses but America’s 35% in dollar assets last time I looked but only
compromised, weak, corporate controlled press 15% in longer bonds. The point of the fund is to
needs the air time for Lindsey Lohan’s latest be an all-weather place to park cash. It assumes
rehab. Ignorance and passivity rules America. the future will do the unexpected. I'd rather park
cash in the fund than hold a mm account. I can't
~ 14 ~
The Gleason Report December 2010
think of any other fund that can protect a passive invest in this area believing as you that it is only
investor better. Now, if we have high inflation, a matter of time before it becomes a pressing
the short term dollar holdings will move up issue.
at mm rates which are usually close to inflation.
So, it's not that worrisome if you consider that The Canadian oil sands are faced with a
fact. different set of dynamics. Most compelling is on
the exploration and recovery side. Oil sands are
relatively shallow and are surface mined.
Q. 1) Did the Sprott physical silver ETF ever Exploration over the past 40 years has mapped
start trading? extremely well what the reserves look like. You
2) Have you considered GCC (based on the don't drill dry holes in this industry. The
CCI) as an alternative for DBC? It exploration costs are mostly done, and are cheap
geometrically rebalances the "basket" and fixed. The compelling part is on the
commodities, I think, so, for example, oil would extraction side. There are no enhanced recovery
not grow to dominate the ETF as it does in DBC. mechanisms like nitrogen injection, fracking or
I have never used it myself, but thought I would other rework. Production volume essentially
pass it along as an idea. equals bulldozer and earth mover volume.
A. No, Sprott hasn't started trading yet. They did Extraction of the last barrel equivalent is very
place an order for 500,000oz of silver! It should close to the same cost as the first. The projects
be soon. scale in a predictable way both in cost of
production and recovery. Oil sands do suffer
The problem I'm having with commodity efts is from large start up costs. You have to build the
they're trading the next month's futures contract. Bitumen processing plant before the product can
Traders know the etf must buy and then they buy come to market. Additionally, it is an energy
ahead of it pushing up the price. Then they sell intensive process. Break even for these guys is
into it. Thus the gains aren't being realized by in the $65/ barrel range. There are
the etf. I see that GCC has done much better environmental concerns such as carbon footprint
than DBC. Is it the commodity weightings or is and destruction of land due to the mining
it doing something different? Ag has soared the process. On the whole, the Canadian
past couple months whereas oil has not. Could government has worked through these issues and
that be it? [Note: It was agriculture] I think I don't think they can afford to
DBC is weighted by # contracts traded and kill the industry because of it. Multiple plants
energy dominates. are in production, so technology risk is less.
~ 15 ~
The Gleason Report December 2010
reasons, says oil could hit $200 by 2030. I'd was allocated 25% each to GLD, TLT, and SPY
guess 2015. T. Boone Pickens says oil will hit so long as each was above it's 10 month moving
$95 next year. average. If any was below its moving average at
the end of the month, I switched it to SHY. If it
The tar sands will never be a big energy producer rose back above its moving average by the end of
because of the time it takes to process the the month, it went back into the relevant ETF.
material. But, it is a profitable producer and The only unrealistic aspect of the test is that it
investments in this area are worth considering. assumes equal re-balancing at the end of each
You know we have an energy problem when month. In reality this could probably be done
we’re leeching the oil out of sand. Again, it’s once or twice a year.
astonishing oil depletion gets so little attention.
Here are the results over the nearly six years for
I recently bought Energy Transfer Partners 2005 through last month:
(ETP). This is an energy Master Limited
Partnership. It owns 17,000 miles of gas PRPFX: Annual compound rate of return =
pipelines and just completed a new segment in 9.6%, max draw down = -26%
partnership with Kinder Morgan Partners
(KMP). ETP pays a 7% dividend. I bought this Hedged ETF portfolio:
stock because I believe that as oil prices rise, Annual compound rate of return = 10.95%, max
natural gas will be in more demand. Gas is draw down = -5.5%
cheap now at around $4.50 and ETP makes a Number of trades = 25 (about one trade per
percentage on the transport. There’s a high cost quarter, on average).
to enter this business and it’s essential to our Percent months with positive returns = 66%
economy.
Since this test covers bull, bear, and flat markets,
I think it's safe to say that the hedged ETF
Q. I wondered whether the Permanent Portfolio portfolio gets equal or better returns than
approach might be improved by hedging PRPFX, with a huge reduction in draw downs.
downside risk. To represent the Permanent A. I think this easy to apply idea has validity for
Portfolio's 25% allocation to each of Gold, Long avoiding severe bear markets. It's certainly
Term Treasuries, Stocks, and Cash, I used the better than buy and hold of the S&P500.
four ETFs - GLD, TLT, SPY, SHY.
MA systems are ok. You might also want to
As we have data for these going back through look at a 10 month / 2 month combination using
2005, I began my test on 1/1/2005 through the month-end data. Buy when the 2mo goes over
end of October 2010. The baseline I wished to the 10 month. I ran a quick report and it beats
improve upon by hedging was the Permanent the straight 10mo/300day system significantly.
Portfolio fund PRPFX. The worst drawdown A higher win percent and a higher overall gain
ever experienced by that fund since its inception relative to the market. Since 1954 it beats BH by
was a loss of about 26% during the recent big 55%. 38 trades and a 68% win percentage. It
market crash. Even though it has bounced back doesn't work for other asset classes but that's to
nicely since then, that was still a really big draw be expected. I've never seen this simple system
down. discussed outside of my own research
For my test I used monthly data only. I always I rarely discuss using moving averages because
held 25% in SHY, as proxy for cash. The rest most investors aren’t like you and me. They
~ 16 ~
The Gleason Report December 2010
~ 17 ~
The Gleason Report December 2010
(www.gleasonreport.com)
Tom Gleason, Manager & Researcher
~ 18 ~
The Gleason Report December 2010
~ 19 ~