TECHNOLOGICAL INSTITUTE OF THE PHILIPPINES – QUEZON CITY

ARCHITECTURE DEPARTMENT

ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN 9 (AR 511S4) CAPSTONE DESIGN PROJECT

1st DEFENSE : DESIGN PROJECT PROPOSAL DEFENSE
(PROJECT AND SITE JUSTIFICATION)
(To be filled out by the student)
PROPONENT/S : ____________________________________________________________________________
PROJECT TITLES :  _______________________________________________ SITE: ______________________
(for the jury, please check :  _______________________________________________ SITE: ______________________
the approved Project) :  _______________________________________________ SITE: ______________________
ADVISER : ____________________________________________________________________________
(To be filled out by the panelist)
ITEM
DESCRIPTION WEIGHT P LS S VS E SCORE
NO.
THE PROBLEM AND ITS SETTING 45
THE PROJECT & PROBLEM STATEMENT
(Rationale of the Project, Background of the Project, Funnel
the topic from global to national perspective to the specific
issues that the study intends to address)
20 1-4 5-9 10 11-15 16-20
THE CLIENT
(Discussion on the issues and/or aspirations of the client as
to why the project is needed. Briefly discuss the
1 background/profile of the client)
PROJECT OBJECTIVES, SCOPE AND
LIMITATIONS
(Objectives must be SMART: Specific, Measurable, 15 1-3 4-6 7 8-12 13-15
Achievable, Realistic, and Timely. Discussion on the extent of
the study; items/issues not included in the Study)
DESIGN PROCESS
(the systematic approach using diagram or series of steps 10 1-2 3-4 5 6-8 9-10
that the student will follow in developing their project)
SITE JUSTIFICATION 45
SITE / DEVELOPMENT SELECTION CRITERIA
(General and specific criteria applicable to the 20 1-4 5-9 10 11-15 16-20
Site/Development)
MACRO-MICRO SITE ANALYSIS
2 (CLUP and Zoning, Development restriction, Constraints, and
Trends, Lot Plan, Physical Determinants that could assess 20 1-4 5-9 10 11-15 16-20
the capability and suitability of the site, SWOT analysis, Site
Zoning)
INITIAL SCHEMATIC DESIGN
(Initial Site Development Plan that will emphasize the best 5 1 2 3 4 5
possible layout in the site)
ARCHITECTURAL PRESENTATION 10
PRESENTATION REQUIREMENTS 5 1 2 3 4 5
(Completeness and Quality of Presentation Materials)
3 MASTERY AND DELIVERY
(Thorough Knowledge of the Project, Organization and
5 1 2 3 4 5
Analysis of Data, Manner of Presentation, Ability to Defend,
Oral & Written English Proficiency)
LEGEND:
P – Poor VS – Very Satisfactory TOTAL SCORE
LS – Less Satisfactory E – Excellent
S – Satisfactory

PANELIST: _____________________________________________ DATE: ___________________________________

(Signature over printed name) TIME START : _________ TIME END : _________
 ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN 9 (AR 511S4) CAPSTONE DESIGN PROJECT
1ST DEFENSE : DESIGN PROJECT PROPOSAL DEFENSE
COMMENT SHEET
(To be filled out by the student)
PROPONENT/S : ____________________________________________________________________________
PROJECT TITLES :  _______________________________________________ SITE: ______________________
(for the jury, please check :  _______________________________________________ SITE: ______________________
the approved Project) :  _______________________________________________ SITE: ______________________
ADVISER : ____________________________________________________________________________
(To be filled out by the panelist)
QUESTIONS, COMMENTS, AND OTHER CONCERNS DURING PRESENTATION
INSTRUCTIONS TO THE PANELIST:
 Please be guided by the attached guide questions corresponding to the grading sheet criteria being evaluated.
 Kindly list down all additional questions, comments and other concerns that may strike you during the presentation, also in accordance to the
criteria being evaluated, to be used as a guide during the panel discussion.
 Place a check mark on all questions successfully answered by the proponent/s.

Use the back of the paper for additional questions, comments and other concerns

FINAL COMMENTS AND OTHER CONCERNS

INSTRUCTIONS TO THE PANELIST:
 Kindly list down all comments and other concerns that may arise during deliberations as well as any other questions not answered
successfully by the proponent/s during the panel discussion.
 This shall serve as the justification / basis of the grade given to the proponent/s for this particular defense.

Use the back of the paper for additional comments and other concerns

PANELIST: ______________________________________________________ DATE: ____________________

(Signature over printed name)