Sunteți pe pagina 1din 11

On the Safe use of Microwave and Shortwave Diathermy

Units

Dipthermy is a common treatment modality VINCENT DELPIZZO


used> to relieve pain through localized heating.
This paper briefly discusses the mechanisms Vincent Delpizzo, Ph.D., is a physicist in the non-
ionizing radiation group of the Australian Radiation
through which heat is generated in tissue and Laboratory and is involved in research on the health
the absorption characteristics of the applied hazards of electromagnetic radiation.
electromagnetic radiation. The adverse effects
of this radiation are reviewed with particular KENNETH HENRY JOYNER
emphasis on the current exposure limits for
Ken Joyner,Ph"D., is Principal Scientist at the
operators and non-patients in the vicinity of Telecom Research Laboratories where he is con-
diathermy devices. ducting research in the interaction of electromag-
The newly introduced codes of practice for netic radiation with matter.
the 'Safe Use of Shodwave (Radio frequency)
andlAicrowave Diathermy'are also discussed.
'i

Diathermy is a form of therapy Although similar data is not avail- Because of the competing demands of
which utilizes electromagnetic radia- able for Australia, reports of unwise various microwave and radiofrequency
tion to induce heat inside the patient's and potentially hazardous practices in users, specific bands have been allo-
body. This leads to increased blood the use of diathermy have caused dis- cated by the International Telecom-
circulation which is believed to induce quiet among health regulatory author- municationUnion for industrial, scien-
faster healing. Diathermy is used ina ities and have prompted the National tific and medical (ISM) applications.
variety of conditions including sprains Health and Medical Research Council In Australia diathermy' units are al-
and strains, muscle and tendon tears, to issue a uniform code ofpractice for lowed to operate in only two of the
chronic rheumatoid arthritis, tenosy- c the safe use of diathermy machines. ISM bands, namely the microwave
novitis, bursitis and synovitis. The code was produced in two slightly band of 2450 MHz (wavelength = 122
The medical efficacy of this treat- different versions, one for microwave mm) and the shortwave band of 27.12
ment ,has 'been the subject of some and one for shortwave (radiofre- MHz (wavelength = 11.1 m).
controversy, while the potential haz- quency)'units. Both codes are included The absorption properties and the
ards posed by the high power,(> 200W) in Appendices AandB of this article. methods of application associated with
electromagnetic radiation emitted by a A similar code, has been established in these two frequencies are considerably
diathermy machine are certainly not to Canada (DHW 1983). different and therefore the heating
be neglected. mechanisms and, more importantly, the
In a Canadian survey of shortwave resulting heating patterns vary.
and microwave medical devices (DHW Shortwaves and Microwaves The interactions of electromagnetic
1980) only 54.3 per cent of the short- fields with tissue can be considered on
wave diathermy operators were de- Technically, the term rediofrequency a macroscopic or microscopic level. On
scribed as trained (38.5 per cent of the radiation refers to that portion of the the microscopic level, three basicma-
respondents provided no reply while frequency spe..ctrum useful for radio- chanisms underlie the interactions.
7.3 per cent admitted being untrained). communications ie 10kHz to 300 GHz. These include:
The. same survey indicated that 8 per However, it is not uncommon to fur- (1) the orientation of electric dipoles
cent of the treatments involved irra- ther divide this frequency range into that already exist in the atoms and
diation of the pelvis (including treat- radiofrequency (10 kHz to 300 MHz) molecules in the tissue;
ment of the reproductive and urinary" and microwave (300 MHz to 300 GHz) (2) polarization of atoms and mole-
systems) and a similar percentage in- regions. This latter convention has been cules to produce electric dipoles;
volved irradiation of the head. adopted for this paper and the codes. and

152 The Australian Journal of Physiotherapy. Vol. 33, No.3, 1987


The Safe use of Microwave and Shortwave

(3) displacement or drift of conduction


('free') electrons and ions in tissue.
Heat can be generated in tissue in
each of these three interactions. In the
first .two cases the heat is generated
through .friction associated with the
movement of atoms and molecules fol-
lowin.g~the time variation of the electric
field. I'Q the case of displacement of
conduction charges, the collision of
electrons and ions with atoms and mol-
ecules of the tissue produce heat. Note
that it is only the internal electric field
that transfers energy to the tissue.
However,magnetic fields will induce
electric fields in tissues thereby gener-
atingheat. Thus both electric and mag-
netic fields produced by the diathermy
applicator are important with respect
to the generation of heat. a
All three of the above interactions
are described by the macroscopic pr,op- Figure 1: Inductive (a) and capacitive (b) applicators
erty of tissue, called. the 'complex
permittivity', which represents the
dielectric constant and loss factor of
the tissue. The complex permittivity of
tissue is a function of frequency and, sians of the patient and therefore the medium which it is penetrating. Tissues
as a result, the propagation and atten- directionaI.properties .of the radiation having a high water content absorb
uation of electromagnetic waves are are important to its operation. The more than tissues such as fat or bone.
also dependent on th~ frequency microwave radiation is emitted by a Within a given medium absorption de-
(Schwan .1954, Schwan 1970). small antenna and directed towards the pends on the electrical properties of
In shortwave diathermy the patient area of treatment by a suitably shaped the medium, on the frequency of the
is made part of the electrical circuit of reflector. The antenna and the reflector radiation and the distance travelled by
the generator by using either an in- constitute the applicator. Different the wave. In general, in the radiofre-
ductive coil (Figure la) or a capacitor types of applicators can be used with quency range, absorption increases with
type applicator (Figure Ib). A variable the same unit to obtain different heat- increasing frequency. At the frequency
capacitor in the unit is tuned· to match ingpatterns. of 2450 MHz, the amplitude of the
the generator with the patient-appli- The heating effect of microwaves is electric field falls by approximately
cator circuit, thus.achieving maximum due to energy dissipated by the water two-thirds after propagating for 20 mm
power transfer. molecules in the tissues as they vibrate into tissues of high water content. As
If a capacitive applicator is used, the to follow the oscillations of the electric the power of the radiation is .propor-
patient is subjected to an oscillating field. The heating pattern is determined tional to the square of the electric field,
electric field which causes molecules in by the penetration characteristics of the only about 10 per cent of the power is
the tissue to vibrate and produce heat. radiation and by the type ofapplicator. transmitted past that distance.
In the case of the inductive applicator, Like light, microwaves can be trans- The rate· at which energy is imparted
primary heating is due ·to eddy currents mitted t reflected, refractedandab- to a given mass of tissue is expressed
induced by the oscillating magnetic sorbed by different media. Reflection by the specific absorption rate (SAR)
field. The heating pattern is determined occurs at the interface between two which is measured in W Ikg. The SAR
by th.e type of applicator, by its size media through which the radiation is calculated by the relationship (Wit-
and by its position relative to thepa- propagates at differing velocities (eg air tersetol 1979):
tient. and skin, muscle and fat) (Schwan
For a microwave unit, the wave- 1954). 4.19 x lcrC T
length of the radiation (122mm) is Absorption is the transfer of energy SAR
much smaller than the overall dimen- from the electromagnetic wave to the t

The Australian Journal of· Physiotherapy. Vol. 33, No.3, 1987 153
The Safe use of Microwave and Shortwave

where potentially hazardous, not only to the effect depends on many factors includ-
C specific heat of tissue direct user, but also to other persons ing ·the nature of the organ exposed,
T temperature rise in tissue who may be unintentionally exposed the intensity and duration of the ex-
t time of energy deposition in the (WHO 1981). posure, on the size and the health con-
tissue. At the Warsaw International Sym- dition of the subject exposed (SAA
posium on biological effects and health 1985).
The SAR can also be expressed in hazards of microwave radiation in 1973 For the operators and members of
terms of the electrical properties of the it was ag!eed that, from the point of the public, including other patients, re-
absorbiqg tissue (Osepchuk 1979): view of the biological effects, micro- ceptionistsetc., any effect induced in
--L . . 2 wave· power densities could be divided them is unwanted and therefore the
SAR = .2p W€o € tan oEin into the followiIfgranges: exposure must be limited to the levels
-High power densities, greater than prescribed by the Australian ·Standard
Where
10 roW/cm2 at which distinct ther- AS2772(SAA 1985) and reported in
p is the mass density of the body,
mal effects predominate. Table 1. Occupationally exposed indi-
in kg/m 3
- Medium power densities,between viduals are persons exposed to radia-
fa is the permittivity of free space,
1 mW/cm2 and 10 mW/cm2,where tionas a direct consequence of their
in farads/m
weak but noticeable thermal effects employment, which in this case means
€ is the relative dielectric constant
exist. the operators of diathermy units.
tan 0 is the loss tangent
Low power densities, below Surveys of shortwave diathermy de..
w is the radian frequency given by
lroW/ cm2 , where thermal effects vices in the USA (Ruggera 1980) .and
w= 211'"f
Em is the electric field in volts/m at do not appear to exist but other Canada (Stuchlyet a/1982) and results
the point in ·the body. effects have been reported. The ex- of measurements performed by the au..
act nature of these non-thermal ef- thorshave shown that, in general, if
Experimental and clinical research fects continues to be the subject of the operator remains approximately 1m
indicates that therapeutic responses will much controversy as they are sub- from the applicator and, in particular,
occur as a result of elevating tissue jective in nature and difficult to O.5m from the cables his or her ex-
temperatures in the range 41° to 45°C quantify (see, .for example: Sym- posure will be within the recommended
requiringSARs from 50 to 235 W/kg posium on Health Aspects of Non- limits.
(U.S.A. Federal Register 1980) in the ionising Radiation 1979, Steneck However, exceptions to this rule have
treatment area (Guy etal 1974). 1984). been reported. It was shown in the
Because of the presence of different Although no formal agreement has USA survey (Ruggera 1980) that one
layers of tissue with different physical been reached, a similar classification shortwave diathermy device produced
properties and because of the resulting may be applied to the shortwave fre- unwanted power densities well in excess
combined effects of absorption and re.. "quency of 27.12 MHz. of the recommended limit at a distance
flection, it is exceedingly difficult to The thermal effect of electromag- of 1 m from the applicator. Although
accurately estimate the dose ofradia- netic. radiation which has already been the authors of that survey did not com-
tion delivered to a specific organ. In discussed may lead toa number of menton that result, other diathermy
practice the only indicator available to detrimental effects from lesions .in devices surveyed, of the same model
the therapist is the thermal sensation specific organs to gross thermal stress and used for the same· treatment mo..
experienced by the patient and even from hyperthermia. The severity of the dality, produced much lower power
this may not reflectacturately the pos..
sible presence, for example, .of 'hot
spots' in an area which does not pos..
sess an adequate number of thermal "Table 1:
receptors. The power meter incorpo- Maximum permissible exposure .Iimits
rated in the unit's console indicates
only the" power emitted by the gener- Frequency Occupationally General
ator, not that delivered to the patient. (MHz) exposed *
27.12 1.22 mW/cm 2 0.24 ·mW/cm2
Personnel Exposure
2450 0.2 mW/cm 2
Exposure Limits
Like many sources of electromag-; * ie persons exposed as a consequence of their occupation,in this case
netic radiations, diathermy devices are the operator.

154 The Australian Journatof Physiotherapy. Vol. 33, No.3, 1987


The Safe use of Microwave and Shortwave

DD
densities at a distance of 1m from the Shortwave
knee treatment
Microwave
shoulder
Shortwave
knee
Shortwave hand treatment
applicator. It would appear that the treatment treatment

shortwave diathermy device in question


may have had either faulty cables, con-
nectors, or applicator. There were other
devices in this survey that exceeded the

o
limits ata distance of 1 rn.
. .
2m
We'htlve tried to replicate this result
using a$iemens Model 808 device with
1.6 rnW/cm 2

O.8mW/cm2 0.53 mW/cm 2


.
1.6 mW/cm2
Shortwave thigh
a wing 'applicator. An ,experienced 1m treatment
physiotherapist was asked to adminis-
tershortwave treatment to the thigh of
1m
a patient using a normal therapeutic Shortwave
knee treatment
irradiation level. The environmental
radiation level was measured at several Microwave Shortwave
points at a distance of 1 m from the hand treatment, hand treatment

applicator, using a HoladayHI3002 Figure 2: Simultaneous use of more than one unit increases the chance of
monitor fitted with a E-field probe. We overexposure of the operator. The radiation levels reported in the figures were
were 'able to obtain a level in excess of obtained during normal therapeutic use of the machines.
the standard limit only if the cables
were positioned so that they were within
0.5 m of the detector.
Also in the Canadian survey (Stu~hly
The occupational exposure limit may excess of those recommended for oc-
et af 1982) high power densities were
also be exceeded if more than one cupationalexposure.
measured at, we ,assume, the console
diathermy unit is operating within 2 m It is not impossible that persons not
of a shortwave diathermy device. This
of each other (Figure 2). We have directly involved in the use of the ma-
result was attributed, in part, to the
measured the field existing in the space chine will be subjected to doses in ex-
treatment regime which consisted of
between a number of diathermy units cess of the recommended limit (Figure
treating both knees using large diam-
(both microwave and shortwave), dur- 4). It must be remembered that for
eter air spaced electrodes~ ,Again, the
ing the administration of common these persons the recommended limit
only way 'we could replicate this result,
treatment modalities. The recorn- is five times lower than that applicable
was to be within 0.5 m of the cable.
mended limit was exceeded between the to the operator. Normally however this
In order to help ensure that opera-
shortwave devices, but not between two situation is unlikely to occur because
tors are not exposed in excess of the
microwave devices, presumably due to the power density varies inversely as
recommended limit, the codes pre-
the greater directionality of the micro- the square of the distance.
scribe the minimum distances that the
wave applicators. Careful planning of the patient treat-
operator should maintain from the ap-
mentarea can minimize these risks.
plicators and leads:
Advice on the matter can be obtained
- for shortwaves: 1m from the ap- Planning of Patient Treatment Area from the relevant state authorities listed
plicators and O.5m from the 'leads; Over-exposure to persons other than in Appendix C.
short excursions closer to the elec- the patient may result from inadequate
trodes are permitted but only when planning. To illustrate ,this we have Hazards to the Patient
necessary (DHW 1983). recreated in our laboratory two ex- Obviously these 'safe' limits do not
- for microwaves: 2 m from the ap- amples of badly planned treatment apply to the patient as the induction
plicators, but remaining outside the areas and surveyed the radiation' levels of thermal effects in the patient's body
direct beam. in positions which could conceivably is the purpose of diathermy; however,
The distance of 2 m should ensure be occupied by the operator and/or the line between therapeutic and harm-
that i~ reflections occur (it can be shown members of the public. ful dose can be uncomfortably thin.
that, due to the possible formation of Figure 3 illustrates how reflections In the specific case of diathermy the
standing waves, power densities may from a filing cabinet and a wall- detrimental effects of electromagnetic
increase bya factor offour in this case) mounted,metallic instrument panel radiation may appear in a number of
the operator exposure will be within may produce, within one, metre from instances as a consequence of inappro-
the J;ecommended limits. a microwave applicator, local fields in priate practice or because ofa particu-

The Australian JQumal of Physiotherapy. Vol. 33, No.3, 1987 155


The Safe u.seofMicrowB.ve and Shortwave

~
+-
~
-
(J \)~+
+ :0 ~O :0 Eo +fE, =lEo
...::- 1 metre ~.. 1.1 mW/cm2

~ I-=-
FigureS: Alignment of polar molecul~s
in the dielectric reduces the electriC
field between the capacitor's plates.

• 1.9mW/cm 2

At the frequency ofoperation ofshort-


• 0.5 mW/cm 2 wave diathermy, the ratio between the
two coefficients is such"that the electric
Figure 3: The presence of reflecting objects may cause hazardous radiation levels
even behind a microwave applicator. field in the fat layer is considerably
larger than in the muscle. Conse-
quently as the power absorbed is pro-
portional to the square of the electric
of radiation there are some situations field, the power absorbed in~he fat is
where they can be caused even by nor- almost eight times that absorbed in
mal therapeutic doses. muscle.
The· subcutaneous fat layer is more When the fat layer is not too thick,
easily heated than the muscle tissue capacitive applicators may still be used,
during shortwave treatment using ca- with care, but .they should be' avoided
Cavity pacitor type applicators. This effect, with obese patients (ie persons 20 per
Walt· beside being a consequence of the cent or more over the normal weight
(2 x10 mm paucity of blood flow in the fat, is also range).
plaster
sheets)
due to the different intensities of the However, if the electric field .is par-
electric field in the two layers (Guyet allel to the interface between muscle
af 1974). This can be explained using and fat, as is the case for microwave
an idealized plane wave (Christensen treatment (Figure 6), the boundary
et af 1981).Whenan electric field Eo condition requires that Er=Em • In
Figure 4: Persons other than the oper- ~ is applied to a dielectric, such as fat this case muscle absorbs more power
ator can also be exposed to radiation. or muscle, it causes a realignment of
In this example, the microwave power than fat, although the efficacy of the
density at the receptionist's waist .level
the electric charges associated with its
was measured to be =0.5 mW/cm 2 , molecules (Figure 5). The charges thus
which is 2.5 times the recommended realigned create an induced field (E)
limit. The distances between therecep.. which opposes the applied field. As a
tionist and the applicator was 2.1 m. result, the field (EJ within the dielec-
The microwave output was 180 w.
tric is less than Eo.
We can write Eo/Ed = k, where k
is the relative dielectric constant of the
larsusceptibility of the patient to in-
medium.
jury.
At the boundary between fat and
In a recent Canadian survey (DHW
muscle we must have
1980) a small number (- 4070) of re-
spondents have reported the incidence
of adverse effects, including increased
pain, burns and pacemaker interfer- (boundary condition for the electric
ence, in some of their patients. field perpendicular to the fat and mus-
cle layers) Figure 6: The electric field of the mi·
Bums and Scalds crowave radiation emitted by diathermy
Beside the obvious case ofa burn or ie Ee applicator is parallel to the fat-muscle I

scald resulting from an excessive dose interface.

156 The Australian Journal of Physiotherapy. Vol. 33, No.3, 1987


The Safe use of Microwave and Shortwave

treatment is reduced, as there is no shown that elevations of core temper- If the irradiated region contains a
therapeutic value in heating the fat ature in excess of 2.5°C during the cancerous growth, temperature tends
layer. For instance, it can be shown organogenesis stage of pregnancy re- to develop in the tumor higher than
that less than half of the incident power suIt in increased resorption of fetuses that in surrounding normal tissue
reaches the muscle if the fat layer is 2 and in congenital birth defects of the (Babbs 1981). This increase in the tem-
cm thick. central nervous system. The latter, and perature leads to the destruction of
An accurate estimate of the rate of the associated clinical disorders in an- cancerous cells and therefore, diath-
temperature increase in fat and muscle imals, have been reviewed extensively ermy is sometimes used as <a therapy
tissuei~very difficult to obtain because by Edwards (1978, 1981). for cancer patients. However, if the
of the 'many variables involved. The While experimental data is lacking temperature is between 40 and 41.5°C,
ultimate decision on the use of diath- for primates, retrospective and pro- the growth rate of tumors is accelerated
ermy units with overweight patients spective studies of mothers with febrile (Burr 1974). The use of diathermy ·is
must be left to the professional judge- illnesses in the first trimester indicate therefore contraindicated in patients
ment of the therapist. Shortwave ap- that hyperthermia has similar terato- with evidence of cancer, unless it is
plicators that have predominantly a genic effects on the developing human part ofa specific cancer therapy re-
magnetic field output (egcoil, monode, fetus (Smith 1978, Clarren 1979).. gime.
diplode) are the most suitable to pro- A recent epidemiological study of Metal intensifies the electromagnetic
duce deep tissue heating without much birth outcomes among physiotherapists fields, potentially leading to hazardous
risk of burns to the fat layer (Kloth in Sweden has found a higher than temperature increases. Therefore the
1984). normal incidence of dead or mal- treatment of patients having metallic
Perspiration must be allowed to formed infants bornto those operating implants in the treatment area is con-
evaporate freely not only to help dis- shortwave diathermy units (Kallenet traindicated. For the same reason all
sipate body heat but alsobecause~ater al 1982). Rubin and Erdman (1983) metal such as rings and watches should
is heated by the electromagnetic radia- reported four cases of patients being be removed from the area oftreatment.
tion. In the case of microwaves this is treated with microwave diathermy for The presence of a·cardiac pacemaker
the major heating mechanism. Drop-chronic pelvic inflamation who became in a patient also constitutes acontrain-
lets of perspiration on the skin can pregnant during the course of the treat- dicatlon. The risk, obviously, depends
rapidly reach a very high temperature ment and therefore received-microwave on·the treatment regime, being minimal
(Kloth 1984). Only dry towelling should exposure to the pelvis just prior to and for treatment of the extremities.
be used when this is necessary to sup- during early pregnancy. In one case the Diathermy is also contraindicated
port the induction coil used with some pregnancy resulted ina miscarriage. with patients who do not possess nor-
shortwave therapy regimes, otherwise Three similar cases, this time involving mal pain and thermal sensation in the
all clothing, bandages and coverings shortwave diathermy, were reported by area to be treated.
should be removed. Nylon and other Imrie (1971). One of the pregnancies
C

synthetic fibres are particularly unsuit- terminated in a miscarriage. Ghietti Adverse Effects on the Eye
able because they retain the moisture (1955) reported the birth of a mal- Acute exposure may cause injury to
against the skin. If, in the course of a formed, -immature, convulsive infant the eye, particularly using frequencies
microwave or shortwave treatment, whose mother had been treated with ranging from 1 GHz to 10 GHz (and
perspiration appears on the patient's shortwaves during the frrsttwomonths therefore including the freqliency of
skin, the treatment should be inter- of pregnan.cy. Although no direct link operation of microwave diathermy
rupted and the skin dried. For this can be established between these ad- units). Cataract formation may be in-
reason and to make sure that the pa- verse pregnancy outcomes and the duced in animals by exposure for 1
tient remains in the proper position and diathermy treatments, these cases, to- hour to power densities in the 150 to
most importantly, does not look to- getherwith the results obtained from 200 mW /cm~range (Ruggera 1980).
wards the applicator, .it is necessary animal experimentation, suggest that it These levels are similar to those pro-
that the patient not be left alone during is wise to avoid microwave and/or duced by microwave diathermy units.
the microwave treatment. shortwave exposure during pregnancy. Retinal lesions may also occur (Cleary
1980).
Teratogenic Effects Unintentional irradiation of the eyes
Teratogenic effects following mater- Specific Precautions is a real .possibility due to the limited
nalhyperthermia have beenexperi- Apart from the normal contraindi- directionality of the applicators.Bas-
mentally demonstrated in a number of cations such as open wounds, haemor- sen etal (1978) have reported that most
animal sp.ecies,notably the guinea pig rhage or acute infections, the following non..contact applicators exhibit a high
(Edwards 1967, 1978). It has been are more specific risks. level of radiation 'leakage', that is ra"

The AustralIan Journal of PhysIotherapy. Vot 33, No.3, 1987 157


The Safe use of Microwave and Shortwave

diation delivered to the environment It is therefore concluded that these Guy AW,Lehmann JF and Stonebridge JB (1974),
units can only be operated by registered Therapeutic applications of electromagnetic
rather than to the target tissue. Levels power, Proceedings of the IEEE~(j2, 55-75.
up to 44mWIcm2 were measured at 5 health professionals as defined in the Imrie AH(197l), Pelvic shortwave diathermy given
em from the applicator. Codes (Appendices A and B). inadvertently in early pregnancy, Journal ofOb-
stetrics and Gynaecology of the British Com-
The danger that microwaves pose to monwealth, 7891-92.
the eyes, cannot be overcome easily. Acknowledgement KallenB, Malmquist G and Moritz U (1982),
Goggles do not offer adequate protec.. We wish to thank Mrs J oanMc- Delivery outcome among physiotherapists in
Sweden: Is non-ionizing radiation a fetalhaz-
tioll-\because, as the dimensions of the Meeken and Mr Alex Ward for useful ard?, Archives of Environmental Health~37,
eyepie~esare comparable to the wave- discussions and for allowing us to carry 81-84.
Kloth L,Morrison MA and Ferguson BH (1984),
length':bf the radiation, the diffraction out measurements on the diathermy Therapeutic Microwave and Shortwave Diath-
around the edges is significant. It has units at the Lincoln Institute of Health ermy~ US Dept. of Health and Human Services
also been shown (Griffin 1983) that Sciences, Victoria. "- HRS Publication FDA 85-8237.
LeachWM (1980), Genetic, growth and repro-
metal rimmed ,spectacles enhance the ductioneffects of microwave radiation. Bulletin
field near the eye. Therefore it is References of the New York Academy ofMedicine~ Second
recommended that the head never be Babbs CF, DewittDP, (l981),Physicai principles Series, '56, 249-257.
of local heat therapy for cancer, Medical In- Manikowska-CzerskaE,CzerskiP and Leach WM
irradiated with microwaves except in strumentation (USA)~ 15, 367 ~ 73. (l985), Effects of microwaves on meiotic chro-
the course of cancer therapy. Bassen 'HI, Kantor G, Ruggera PS and Witters mosomes of male CBA/CAYmice, The Journal
OM (1978), Leakage in the Proximity of Mi- of Heredity, 76, 71-73.
crowave Diathermy Applicators Used on Hu- Osepchuk JM (1979), Sources and basic charac-
Effects on the Gonads mans or Phantom Models~ HEW Publication teristics ofmicrowave/RF radiation, Bulletin of
The testes are also particularly sen.. (FDA),79-8073. the New York Academy of Medicine~ 55,976-
Burr B (1974), Heat as a Therapeutic Modality 998.
sitive to hyperthemia. Exposure of the Against Cancer, Report No. 16, US National Rubin A and Erdman WJ (1959), Case reports,
scrotal area to microwaves at 2450 MHz Cancer Institute, ,Bethesda, MD. American Journal oj PhysicalMedicine~ 38,
ChristensenDA and Durney CH (l985) Hyperth- 219-220.
and at power densities greater thah 50 ermia production for cancer therapy: Review of Ruggera PS (1980), Measurements of Emission
mW/cm2 resulted in varying degrees of fundamentals and methods, Journal of Micro- Levels During Microwave and Shortwave Diath-
testicular damage (such as oedema, wave Power, ,16, 89-105. ermy Treatments~ Bureau of Radiological Health
ClarrenSK,Smith OW, Harvey MAS, Ward RH report, HHSPublication (FDA) 80-8119.
atrophy, fibrosis and coagulation ne- and Myrianthopoulas NC (1979),Hypertherrnia SAA (1985), Australian Standard 2772, Maximum
crosis of seminiferous tubules) in lab.. - a prospective evaluation of a possible tera- Exposure Levels~ Radio-Frequency Radiation -
oratory animals (Leach 1980, WHO togenic agent inman, Journal of Pediatrics~ 95, 300kHz ,to 3000Hz, 'Standards Association of
81-83. Australia Publication, Sydney.
1982, Manikowska-Czerska 1985). The Cleary SF (1980), Microwavecataractogenesis, Schwan HP and Piersol GM (1954), The absorp-
overies are also susceptible to hyperth.. Proceedings of the lEEE~68, 49~55. tion of electromagnetic energy in body tissues,
ermia; ,however,being located deep in DHW (1980), - Canada- Wide Survey of Non- American Journal of Physical Medicine, 33,
ionising Radiation Emitting Medical Devices, 371-404.
the pelvic cavity they are not normally Canadian Department of Health and Welfare, Schwan HP (1970), Interaction of Microwave and
affected by microwave diathermy 80-EHD-52. RadiofrequencyRadiation with BiologicalSys-
DHW (1983)" Safety code 25-ShortwaveDiath- terns, ,in "Biological Effects and Health Impli-
(Elder 1984). Shortwaves, on the other ermy Guidelines for Limited Radiofrequency cations ojMicrowave Radiation, SF Cleary (Ed),
hand, can penetrate many centimetres Exposure, Canadian Department of Health and US Department of Health, Education and Wel-
of tissue and may put the ovaries at Welfare, 83~EHD-98. fare,Washington, pg 13-20.
Edwards MJ(1967), Congenital ,defects in guinea Smith OW, Clarren SKand Harvey MAS (1978),
risk. pigs following induced bypermia during gesta- Hyperthermia as a 'possible teratogenic ,agent,
tion, Archives of Pathology and Laboratory Journal of Pediatrics, 92, 878-883.
,42-48. SteneckNH (1984),The Microwave Debate~ MIT
Conclusion Medicine~84,
Edwards ,MJ (1978), Congenital defects due to Press, Cambridge, Mass., USA.
hyperthermia, Advances in Veterinary Science Stuchly MA, Repacholi MH, Lecyer DWand
We have reviewed the hazards pre- and Comparative Medicine 22, 29-52. Mann RD (1982), Exposure to the operator and
Edwards MJ (1981) Clinical disorders offetal brain patient during shortwave diathermy treatments,
sented by the high radiation level as.. development, in Fetal Brain Disorders-Recent Health Physics~ 42,341-366.
sociatedwith shortwave and micro- Approaches to ,the Problem of Mental Defi- Symposium on Health Aspects of non-ionizing
wave diathermy. ciency, BS Hetzel and RM Smith (Eds.), Elsev- radiation (1979), Bulletin of the New York
ierlNortb Holland Biomedical Press, Chapter Academy of Medicine, 55, 973-1296.
We have pointed out the possibility 14, pp. 335~364. USA Federal Register, (1980), Microwave Diath-
for the operator to be exposed to levels Elder JA and Cahill DF (Eds)(l984), Biological ermy products; Performance standard~ 45, (147).
exceeding those prescribed by the ap.. Effects ofRadiofrequency Radiation~ EPA-6001
Witters OM and Kantor G (1979), Free~Space
88-83-026F,Research Triangle Park, North Car-
propriatestandard. olina.
Electric Field Mapping of Microwave Diath-
ermy Applicators~ HEW Publication (FDA)
Patients ,may also be at ,risk if the Ghietli A (1955), Embriopatia da onde corte -
79.8074.
Contributo cUnica sperimentale, Minerva Ni-
operator is untrained and/or careless piologica (Torino)~5, 7-12.
WHO (1981), Environmental Health Criteria 16
or if the patient is unco.. operative eg - Radiofrequencyand Microwaves~ World
GriffinDW (1983), Techniquesfor Measuring Mi-
Health Organization - Geneva.
unable to understand and follow the crowave Fields Near the Eyes in Models oj
Humans~ 19th International electronicsconven- WHO (1982), WHO Regional Publication Euro-
instructions and appreciate thepoten- tion and exhibition, The Institution of Radio pean Series 'No. 10, Non-ionizing Radiation
tial risks. and' Electronics Engineers, ,Sydney. Protection~ Copenhagen, p. 111.

158 The Australian Joumalof Physiotherapy. Vol. 33, No.3, 1987


The Safe use of Microwave and Shortwave

Appendix A for therapeutic purposes. The unit includes time threshold required for cataract pro-
applicators, the microwave generator, and duction. Goggles do not offer reliable pro-
Code of Practice for the Safe all associated electronics, controls and en- tection.
closures. In Australia the only approved
Use of Microwave Diathermy frequency for microwave diathermy treat- Effects on the Gonads
Units (1985)* ments is 2450 MHz. Exposure to microwave .radiation may in·
Treatment means the use of a microwave crease the temperature of the testes to the
Introduction diathermy unit ana human being to treat point where temporary sterility is induced.
The therapeutic use of heat produced by a symptom, disease or disability. Very .high specific absorption rates may
microwtlye radiation absorbed in the body Applicator- means any device designed to cause permanent damage. The ovaries may
is called*, microwave diathermy. The heat conduct, transmit or transferelectromag- also be at risk.
increases the .flow of blood in the tissues netic energy from a microwave diathermy
through dilation of the blood vessels. This unit to a patient undergoing treatment. Teratogenic Effects
in tum increases capillary pressure, cellular Contro/means any control used during op- Abnormalities in offspring have beenre-
membrane permeabilitY,and metabolic rate, ertion of a microwave diathermy unit which ported in several animal species after ex-
causing a more rapid transfer of nutrients affects the microwave radiation· emitted by posure to intense microwave radiation. In-
from the· blood across cell membranes. These the applicator. tense fields resulting in significant
actions may reduce pain and promote Health professional means a registered per- temperature increase of the foetus could
quicker healing. son who has satisfactorily completed an ap- result in teratogenic effects in humans.
A microwave diathermy unit is a device propriate course of training approved by
the relevant registration board and the State/ Examination and ·Interview
designed to generate microwave radiation
and transfer it, via a coaxial cable and a Territory health authority. Microwave treatment shall not be admin-
radiating antenna, to the area to be treated. User means the person having administra- istered unless prescribed by a health profes-
The antennais incorporatedin an applicator tive responsibility for ·use of·a particular sional .(as previously defined). At the ex-
which· has the function of directing the ra- microwave diathermy unit. This. person.shall amination .and interview, when treatment is
diation towards the area to be treated. be the owner or hirer of the unit or his being prescribed, the health professional
These devices are capable of generating agent or, if. the unit is owned or hired by shall determine the suitability of the patient
a sufficiently high levelaf radiation that an .institution .or organization, the agent of for treatment. This.should not be prescribed
there may because for concern for the that body. if:
safety of the eyes, the gonads and, in the Operator means the health professional - The patient does not understand the
case of pregnant patients, the foetus. It is given the responsibility, by the user, to treat potential risks,
claimed that radiation from microwave the patient using .a microwave diathermy - the patient is not able to co-operate with
diathermy applicators has caused cataracts unit. the operator in maintaining the proper
in patients being treated for sinus condi- Shall indicates that the particular require- position and in reporting the presence
tions. The eyes of patients being treated for ment is considered necessary to ensure pro- ofa heating sensation which is the only
a neck or shoulder injury could also be tection from radiation. indication of an adequate or excessive
inadvertently subjected .to ·stray radiation. Should indicates a procedure or precaution dose.
Improper use of the machine may result in which is to be applied, whenever practica- - the patient does not have normal sen-
burnsand/or scalds and tissue or organ ble, in the interests·of minimizing radiation sation ·in the treatment area,
damage. Care must also be taken to avoid hazards. - the patient has metallic implants within
subjecting the operatorand/or the public the treatment area,
to radiation levels exceeding those pre- - the patient is pregnant,
Hazards of ffigh Level Exposure to Micro- - the patient wears apacem,aker,
scribed in the Australian standard AS 2772 wave Radiation
(Maximum Exposure Levels - Radio.. - the patient has undergone ionizingra-
Burns diation therapy to the treatment area in
frequency Radiation - 300kHz to 300 These may result as a consequence of
GHz). It must be noted that the level of the three months prior to the diathermy
excessive irradiances or may he due to pref.. being administered, as skin sensation and
radiation present in the vicinity ofadiath- erential absorption of microwave radiation
ermy unit may .be increased by reflections. blood circulation may be diminished,
(as in the case of a wet dressing over a ;,- there is evidence .or known history of
Care must be taken to ensure that the wound) or to red.ucedheat dissipation mech-
microwave radiation does not cause inter- vascular insufficiency,
anisms (as in the case· of the subcutaneous
ference with other equipment. - the patient has any evidence of cancer,
fat layer). .In some cases deep tissue and
This Code sets down appropriate rules unless the microwave treatment is car-
organ damage may ensue. riedout as partofa hyperthermia treat-
and procedures to avoid excessive and/or
unnecessary exposure to microwaveradia- ment regime. (The metastasis of a can-
Ocular effects cerous growth may be accelerated bya
tionbut should be read in conjunction with Lens opacities maybe induced by micro-
any State/Territory regulations covering moderate increase in temperature,such
wave radiation..Single exposure to intense as .can be caused by a microwave treat-
their use. (> 100 mW /cm~ electromagnetic radiation ment not specifically intended to treat a
at 2450 MHz for an hour or longer has malignancy.),
Definitions resulted in cataract formation inexperi- - there are open wounds,haemorrhage,
Microwave diathermy unit means a device mental animals. The power density in the ischaemic tissue, tuberculous joints, or
using electromagnetic energy in the micro- therapeutic beam is of a similar level, but acute infections within· the treatment
wave frequency range (300 MHz to 300 GHz) the treatment time is generally somewhat area.
shorter. However, repeated direct irradia- In the cases where the health professional,
• Reproduced by courtesy of The National Health and
tion of the eye at such levels and for such after due risk/benefit consideration,sees it
Medical Research Council. treatment times does approach the power- necessary to prescribe >microwave diathermy

The Australian Journal of Physiotherapy. Vol. 33, No. 3)1987 159


The Safe use of Microwave and Shortwave

treatment outside the guidelines given above, ment except' 'a mild, comfortable A shortwave diathermy unit is a device
adequate advice shall be given to the patient, warmth", designed to generate radiofrequency radia-
to the user and to the operator of the micro,,- -"-ensure that the testes are not .directly tionand transfer it, via cables andelec-
wave diathermy unit. irradiated and that care is taken to min- trodes, to theare~ to be treated. The units
The head shall not be directly irradiated imize indirect ·irradiation, can be operated in either a continuous wave
as there isa significant· risk of irradiating -ensure that the coaxial cable is correctly or pulsed mode, but both produce heat in
the eyes. Most applicators are notsuffi,. connected to both the machine .and the deep tissue. Two basic types of electrodes
ciently directional to restrict irradiation to applicator, (applicators) are in use, the capacitor type
the targeted area. Microwave irradiation of - .not rest the applicator or cable over metal and the inductor type. In the first case tissue
the head may only be carried <out as part surfaces, heating is basically due to the radiofre-
of acaAcer therapy. -align the· applicator. accurately to ensure quency electric field, while for the inductive
an appropriate pattern of heating, electrodes .(coils), .heating occurs by a com-
User Responsibilities - direct the applicator awayfromthe unit's bination of electric field effects and currents
The user shall ensure, by.administrative controls, induced in the tissue by a magnetic field,
controls or otherwise, that: - use.care in.handling the applicator (dam- the heating profile of the two mechanisms
- the microwave apparatus complies with age may result in an alteration of its is somewhat different.
all relevant Australian Standards and is directional properties), These devices are capable of generating
maintained .inaccordance with the reI,. - ensure that the chair or other patient a sufficiently .high level of radiation that
evant State requirements, support is not metallic. there maybe cause for concern for the
- the unit is operated only by health After activating the unit the operator safety of the gonads and, in the case of
professionals, shall: pregnant patients, the foetus. Improper use
- the unit operator is not exposed to a - remain outside the field of emission of of the machine may result in burns andlor
radiation level exceeding the standard microwaves and at least 2 metres from scalds and deep ·tissue or organ damage.
for ·occupational exposure specified by the patient, Care must also be taken to avoid subjecting
the appropriate .authority, - not leave the patient alone in the room the operatorand/or the public to radiation
- the general public (including waiting pa- during .the treatment, levels exceeding those prescribed in the Aus-
tients, receptionist etc.) is not exp,osed - ensure that the patient maintains the cor- tralian standard AS 2772 (maximum expo-
toa radiation level exceeding \hat rect position and remains co-operative, sure levels· - radio-frequency radiation -
recommended by the appropriate au- - interrupt the treatment if perspiration 300kHz to 300 GHz). It must be noted that
thority, appears on· the patient'sskin, the level of radiation present in the vicinity
- a range of applicators suitable for treat- - not allow the patient to touch the unit, of a diathermy unit may be increased by
ing different areas of the body is avail,,- - ensure that no other person is in the the presence of nearby metallic objects or
able (the use of modern applicators vicinity of the unit or of the applicator other units or by reflection from the wall.
which reduce scattered radiation and during the treatment, in accordance with Care must be taken to ensure that the
concentrate the energy to the treatment the administrative controls established shortwave radiation .does not cause inter-
area is encouraged), by the user. ferencewith other equipment.
-"- a visibleandl oraudibl~ signal is in- This Code sets down appropriate rules
stalled, to indicate that the unit is op- and procedures to avoidexcessiveand/or
erating, unnecessary exposure to shortwave radia·
- the unit is not. the cause of electric in- tion but should be read in conjunction with
terference with other equipment (This anyState/Territory regulations covering
may require the use of a screened.cubicle their use.
a
and .mains ruter.),
AppendixB
- non metallic chairs andlor beds are Definitions
available to patients undergoing micro- Shortwave diathermy unit means a·device
wave diathermy treatments. Code of Practice for the Safe using electromagnetic energy in the short-
Use of Shortwave* wave frequency range (3-30 MHz) for
Treatment (Radiofrequency) Diathermy therapeutic purposes. The unit includes elec-
Before administering the treatment the trodes, the shortwavegenerator,and all
operator shall: Units (1985) associated electronics, controls andenclo-
-"-ensure that the thermal sensitivity of the sures. In Australia the only approved fre-
patients is not impaired by analgesics, Introduction quency for shortwave diathermy is 27.12
- ensure that the patient has removed all The therapeutic use of heat produced in MHz.
metallic objects (rings, watches metal deep tissue ·by<electromagnetic radiation ab"- Treatment means the use ofa.shortwave
rimmed glasses, etc.) from the treatment sorbed ·in .the body is called diathermy. The diathermy unit ana human being to treat
area, heat increases the flow of blood in the tis- a symptom, disease or disability.
-ensure that the treatment area is not sues through dilation of the blood vessels. Applicator means any device designed to
covered bya wet dressing or adhesive This in tum increases capillary pressure, conduct, transmit or transfer electromag"-
tape, cellular membrane permeability, and met- netic energy from a shortwave diathermy
-"- remove bandages or clothing from the abolic rate, .causing a more rapid transfer unit to a patient undergoing treatment.
treatment area, of nutrients from the blood across cellmem- Control means any control used during ap-
-"- ensure that the skin is dry, branes. These actions may reduce pain and emon of a shortwave diathermy unit which
- ensure that if the patient is wearing a promote quicker healing~ affects the radiation emitted by theappli-
hearing aid, .it is. removed, cator.
-"-ask the patient to immediately report any • Reproduced by courtesy of the National Health and
Health professional means a registered per-
symptoms experienced during the treat- Medical· Research Council. son who has satisfactorily completed an .ap-

1'60 The Australian. Journal of Physiotherapy. Vol. 33, No. 3,1987


The Safe use of Microwave and Shortwave

propriate course of training approved by - the patient does not have normal sen- Treatment
the relevant registration board and the State/ sation in the treatment area, Before administering the treatment the
Territory health authority. ~ the patient has metallic implants within operator shall:
User means the person having administra.. the treatment area, ---ensure that the thermal sensitivity of the
tive responsibility for use of a particular - the· patient is pregnant, patient is not impaired. by analgesics,
shortwave diathermy unit. This person shall - the patient wears a pacemaker, --- ensure that the .patient has removed all
be the owner or hirer of the unit or his - the patient has undergone ionizing ra" metallic objects (rings, watches, metal
agent or, if the unit is. owned or hired by diation therapy to the treatment area in rimmed glasses, etc.) from the treatment
an instttution or .organization, the agent of the three months prior to the diathermy area.
that bod¥. being administered, as skin sensation and - remove bandages or clothing from the
blood circulation maybe diminished, treatment area,
Operator means the health professional
- there is evidence or known history of - ensure that the skin is dry,
given the responsibility, by the user,· to treat
vascular insuffiCiency in the treatment - ensure that if the patient is wearing a
the patient using a shortwave diathermy unit.
area, hearing aid, it is removed,
Shall indicates that the particular require-
- the patient has any evidence of cancer, - ask the patientto report immediately any
ment .is considered necessary to ensure pro..
unless the shortwave treatment is carried symptoms experienced during' treatment
tection from radiation.
ollt.as part of a hyperthermia treatment except "a mild, comfortable warmth",
Should indicates a procedure or precaution
regime. (The metastasis of a cancerous -ensure that the cables are correctly con-
which is to be applied, whenever practica-
growth may be accelerated by a mod- nected to both the machine and the ap-
ble, in the interests of minimizing radiation
erate increase in temperature, such as plicator,
hazards.
can be caused by a shortwave treatment - not rest the applicator or cables over
Hazards of Higb Level Exposure to Micro- not specifically intended to treat a ma- metal .surfaces,
wave Radiation lignancy.), - align the applicator accurately to ensure
Burns - there are open wounds, haemorrhage, an appropriate pattern of heating,
These may result as a consequence of ischaemic tissue, tuberculous joints, or - ensure that the testes are not directly
excessive exposures or may be due to non- acute infections within the treatment irradiated and that care is taken to min-
uniform heating of different tissue layer& or area. imize indirect irradiation,
to reduced heat dissipation mechanisms (as In the cases where the clinician, ·after due -ensure that the cables leading to the ap-
in the case of the subcutaneous fat layer). risk/benefit consideration, deems it neces- plicatorare not placed in the vicinity of
In some cases deep tissue and organ damage sary to prescribe shortwave diathermy treat- the patient's non targeted tissue,
may ensue because heating is induced at a ment outside the guidelines given above, -ensure that the chair or other patient
depth where thermal sensation is reduced. adequate advice shall be given to the patient, support is not metallic and that other
to the user and to the operator of the short- large metallic objects are kept at least
Teratogenic Effects wave diathermy unit. three metres from the electrodesandca-
Abnormalities in offspring have been re- bles.
User Responsibilities After activating the unit the operator
ported in several animal species after ex-
The user shall ensure, by administrative shall:
posure to intense shortwave radiation.
control or otherwise, that: - remain at least .1 m from the electrodes
Intense fields resulting in significant tem-
- the shortwave diathermy unit complies and 0.5 m from the cables during treat-
perature increase of the foetus could result
with all relevant Australian Standards ment,
in teratogenic effects in humans.
and is maintained in accordance with - ensurethat the patientmainta,ins the cor-"
the relevant State requirements, rectposition and remains co~operative,
Effects on the Gonads
- the unit is operated only by health - not leave the patient during the .treat-
Exposure to shortwave radiation may in-
professionals, ment,unless the patient has been sup-
crease the temperature of the testes to the
- the unit operator is not exposed toa plied with an emergency cut-off switch
point where temporary· sterility is induced.
radiation level exceeding the standard and the patient is reliable,
Very high specific absorption rates may
for occupational exposure specified by - not· allow the patient to touch the unit,
cause permanent damage. The ovaries may
the appropriate authority, - ensure .that no other person is in .the
also be at risk.
- the general public (including waitingpa- vicinity of the unit or of the applicator
Examination and Interview tients, receptionist etc.) is not exposed during the treatment, in accordance with
Shortwave treatment shall not be admin- toa radiation level exceeding that the administrative controls established
istered unless prescribed by a health profes- recommended by the appropriate au- by the user.
sional (as previously defined). At the ex- thority,
amination and interview, when treatment is _ - a range of applicators suitable for treat-
being prescribed, the health professional ing different areas of the body is avail-
shall determine the suitability of the patient able, Appendix C
for treatment. This should not be prescribed - a visibleand/or audible signal is in-
if: stalled, to indicate that the unit isop- Advisory Authorities
-Thepatient does not understand the po- erating,
tential risks, - the unit is not the cause of electric in- Australia:
- the 'patient is not able to co-operate with terferencewith other equipment ·(This Australian Capital Territory
the operator in maintaining the proper may require the use of a screened cubicle Consultant, Radiation ·Safety
position and in reporting the presence and a mains filter.), ACT Health Authority
of a heating sensation which is the only -non metallic chairs and/or beds are PO Box 825
indication of an adequate or excessive available to patients undergoing short- CANBERRA CITY ACT 2601
dose. wave diathermy treatments. Telephone: (062) 47 2899

The Australian Joumalof Physiotherapy. Vol. 33, No.3, 1987 181


The Safe use of Microwave and Shortwave

New South Wales South Australia Western Australia


Officer-in-Charge Senior Health Physicist The. Director
Radiation Health Services Occupational Health and Radiation Control Radiation Health Branch
Department of Health Branch Health Department of Western Australia
POBox 163 South Australian Health Commission Verdun Street·
LIDCOMBE NSW2141 GPO Box 1313 NEDLANDS WA 6009
Telephone: (02) 646 0327 ADELAIDE SA 5001 Telephone: (09) 389 2713
Telephone: (08) 2183473
Norlhern Territory
Tasmania Commonwealth
Director Health Physicist
Occup~tional and Environmental Health Director
Division of Public Health
NT Department of Health Australian Radiation Laboratory
Department of Health Services
PO Box 1701 Lower Plenty Road
PO Box 191B
DARWIN NT 5794 YALLAMBIE VIC 3085
HOBART TAS 7001
Telephone: (089)802601 Telephone: (03) 433 2211
Telephone: (002) 306421

Queensland Victoria
Director Chief Radiation Officer New Zealand:
Division of Health and Medical Physics Radiation Safety Section The Director
.Department of Health Health Department of Victoria National Radiation Laboratory
535 Wickham Terrace 555 Collins Street POBox 25-009
BRISBANE QLD 4000 MELBOURNE VIC 3000 CHRISTCHURCH
Telephone: (07) 224 5611 Telephone: (03) 616 7084 Telephone: Christchurch 65 059

162 The Australian Journal of PhysiQtherapy. Vol. 33, No.3, 1987

S-ar putea să vă placă și