Sunteți pe pagina 1din 65

c 

  

Immigration & Refugee Core


MAGNET DISADVANTAGE POLITICS DISADVANTAGE

  
 8 & " 
-9

6 
 ' (!

   
 8 & " 
-9

6 
 ' (!

   
  8 & " 
-9

6 
 ' (! 

   
! 8 & " 
-9

6 
+
& ,
' (!!

   

  " 
  #$ 8 & " 
-9

6 ' (!$

   

  " 
  #% 

   
c "
&c "' () 

   
c "
&c "' (* STATES COUNTERPLAN

   
+
& ,
' ( c
   .&

 c & "2!%

   
 ,
 c
   .&

 c & "2!)

   
 ,
 c
   .&

 c & "2!*

   
 ,
 

   
- . .&
 .
" /0   

   
-&  ",.
"  &! REFUGEE KRITIK

   
-&  ",.
" /0 $ :  (!

   
"&
 .
"  &% :  ($

   
1 & "
& .
"  &) 

   
0"
/" 2.
"  &* 
 CASE STUFF
 c & "2; & 
 $
IRAQI REFUGEES DISADVANTAGE c & "2; & 
 $
 
 c & "2- , 1
 /0 $ 

3 
 c & "2,&& /" /0 $!

3 
 c & "2; & $$

3 
4 3  5+
,  9& 2

$%

3 
5    
3 

3 
6  "' (  

3 
6  "' (! AFFIRMATIVE STUFF

3 
78' ($ 
   
 # $)

3 
78' (% 
   
 # $*

3 
4cc 
&
) 
   
 # $

3 

  
&' (* 
   
 # %

3 

  
&' ( 
   
 # %

3 
5
3c 
&  #  
3 
 # ;/' ( %

3 
&/
  
9& 2 
&' (  
3 
 #  1
"(& % 

3 
&/
  
9& 2.
"   
3 
 # 4c &%!

3 
 ,
6  "  :  ( # %$

3 
 +
,  9& 2 ! 

3 
 '
 ,. $ 

3 
 c0
"(  % 

3 

3 
9& 2.
"  & ) 

3 
 .
"  & * 

3 

& 2.
"   

3 
54c "21
! 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

 R
c 
  

RNC ± Magnet Disad


Ê 4<4//cc6-c //c6-=

CSM, 6/25,  
c" "  >, .5
 "  " " 2 9&%$" "?" ?, #?
" ?,
?",
? ,?
 ?9


The deep US recession has had one effect ,
. &&
2# &.&
   "
5Illegal immigration is falling. More
illegal immigrants are leaving. Fewer people are sneaking in. ,
.200,000 a year instead of 500,000 in recent years>
estimatesc  Camarota, an economist at the Center for Immigration Studies =
,  ,>America¶s illegal
population has fallen 
9  &&  ;9 
2) 
&  &&  ,;9 
2>,"
&"&
c #, 

 9" 
,  ."

 
 #&&> 
9&2#&&the recession,
shifted the terms  ,9
@  
#
2>2The US slump proves that immigration is sensitive to economic conditions 
& #
(  ,
  . ?
 
 " ,
 , 
 A 9 "
# B   


  ,
"&
C
9   
"D+.   
 #&2

&
9&
.&  !)&& 
# (  !%$ "".
 >

 2 ,

( .  #, ,  ,2# 9   ,4c,4c?9 
& 
2, &
"&

A  2 A 9. .&
   

9 &  
>",
, (. 
  ?
 
"# ( - &2 ."(  ,. " 
, &

&&

A  2-"  >" "A  " .    ,
 9
8 & ".&
2
, &; 0
.&5 && 
9" 4c
" E  22
9   >   ,9"   "
 ,
.9&"
,



" &9  
  ,
+ c.
( 
"28& >

 "
>,
9& "(
&
 ?" &9&& "    ,& >
2 21"(>0"  "  9 4c>
 .  
 "
 
"  
 c&
&2>c

A  2&
 +
2  

,
9 C
 &2., 
  2D &&
&
>
2
c  >
.    ,;
   "

  >
, =
,   .  &  
   "  "
&&
   

  2C
  "
" 
 . 
D, , " .    ,9
 , 
.,"
&  ,&     ,> ,4c,
 9 
?2
A. . .&
   , 2 )&& 
 ,
   # ,
 " ,%The growth rate has slowed ,"
>9  ,4c
 && 
"( 
 *&&   . That¶s the elephant in the room> 1"(
2



c 
  

RNC ± Magnet Disad


1Ê ':+/;;//c=/';/6/4c6cc7/ 4c4c1'/6-

[orjas, 20026 F>8 E, 8   89&"8 &"2
+

B: 2c", & 6   >
",
 "

 ,

&1 
 /" "
",>
/

;&& # 
 c 
 ,   
 
c >,.
"  =&
  
=&
4>   
 c >  . >
",>
, .5###" 
"&9 A
, 

," "  ,


29" .9&"",
,

&#
29 
"
&" .    ,9
  
 . &"2  ,4  c
# 
&
,
 
 " "    ,.  
&& (9 # 
 
#&
,   ,. ".   ,
 , #


.  
, 9  
#,  ".9&"

"9 # )
& , ,
&2  
.
".
  #&
. 

" "& ,

, , &,

& # . 9
9& 2  " .9&"

" ,
4c?9 , , &>
2 " "   ,
 "  ,
 , 2&E
" #
 &  " " G
, , &,
9"  &(&2  ".9&"

" ,

, , &12
%>1 A

+& % .  ,
  "&9 ,"
,
 ?"
,9  ",
"

 
.  ,    #&
>

&2. "  
 "  2. 

">
" .
  &2!. "  
, " 
 &&  
 #&

. 
.
# 

.&2 # & 
  ,

.     
H.
2 , #
2H  ,#&

, ">   >,
9" 

.
.
 
2"  ?9  "
&"&
   ," ".
"  
 There is
& concern over the possibility that ,
&
&2generous welfare programs offered by the U  S
,
become a magnet for immigrants,
  
,2. ,,

&
"  . 9&> 0
.&> ,
welfare programs attract immigrants who otherwise would not have
migrated to the U  S
I  ,
the safety net discourages immigrants#, 
&  ,4  c
from returning to
their source countriesI  ,
 ,,  
.   #&
9  
"  ,  
&& "
 ", " 
  ,4  c


.&
"
,
2"
&9    &
&2  
In short, the welfare state creates a magnet that influences the migration
decisions of persons in ,source countries>.  
&&2",
  ," .   
 
.,"& "
   ,
. .&
   ,4  
c
 #
2 ,

2 9
9&The.  
&magnetic effects of welfare raise questions about9 ,the political legitimacy
and ,economic viability of the welfare state5=,   &  ,
 2   ,
 "

0.
2 .
2 @ "
 ,4  c

  
0   ,

 2    ,    ,# &@c .  &2>
.  , .  
& "
"># 
.     ",
  "" 0 
 ,2
. "
&&2.
   J
=&
. 
  ,4  c
?? , ,   92=  / .


G
"(..  2#&&#, " .
  ,

 &  
    ,# &K&& ."   )> , 2."
&;, , &# , # ",&   
& 
" & "

0 L%>)* "
,
9  ,, , &. 9
9&23
&  
.# ,
, L > 

&&2  ,, , &
& .
".
  ,"
. 
> 
"
 
&9  
&
  L>)  ,
 >. ?"
.
 "  ,
#
L >%>  & 9
 #
L%>%>
  ,8,&..  
#
L >$ Income differences across countries influence a person's decision of whether to move to the U  S
G
regardless of whether these  "arise in the labor market or in the safety net provided by ,welfare


& >there are valid reasons to be concerned# , ,. 9& 2that generous welfare programs, attract a particular
type of immigrant.   
&&>welfare. 
#&&. 9
9&2attract persons who qualify for subsidies and repel persons who
have to pay  ,A strong magnetic effect>" 9 # ,
 " 9  " &. &"2>can literally break the
bank. Put bluntly, the immigration of potential public charges can easily fracture the political legitimacy of the social
contract that created and sustains the welfare state.  . 
" E "
9 

9&20."  ."(. ,
9
 9E    &&  H ,,&
H


 ë
c 
  

RNC ± Magnet Disad



 
c 
  

Magnet Disad ± Immigration Decreasing Now


6-=+-;68-84'-cc'-=66-c -=

Grand Rapids Press, 2009
2)

Deterred by
 &
#
the lackluster economy, the population growth of Hispanics and Asians in the U.S. has
slowed,"
  ,    .,9
"( 
 #,   #&&9"  ,
A  292
",

"
 

 &
, 
2

& , ## +.
"# 
  9 9
 #&2  


  ,c  ,
 > "&  (

> 
6 
>
2 
. >  
> 
 
&
#
2& "
 >",

& 
  2 9  ,
 K 
&&  2. .&
 "     
&2>
 
 . "  * !%&& >  !. "   ,
&. .&
 1 the slowdown
 +.
"

continues to shift
conventional notions on when the tipping point in U.S. diversity will come?? 
  ""   ,
 , "
  #1&
"(
 # ,
 
  #,
&
, 2?0
,
& # +.
" # , *" .
# , ,2
9 ,"& #  .&
"#,  ,
,  999&9  >",



 E
>#,",&  "  "  A 9 ,
   

" 
- , " 
#    #

 
   ,c  ,
 >.  &2 
    

"   A 9 & # ?"  " " .
  ,. "  ,
  "
 >"  

& 
>&& 
#F 2, #
   (

>

"   
. & 2" .
,
" ,  
# ( >&
 
 #  9  
+.
"
9& "   ,  
.
2 >

9&
.
>
,  "  &  ;
2 &&> (;
, 
     
>#,  , 
&
,
&   
&A 9 ,
..  ,
& ,2&
9, >,
8 &"  ,#  (

" 


 
( "# , ,
,&. 4c
 
 H K  , ( K &(&2 ,2K   9
"( 0"  /&c
&
  #,   ,2K  >H,
H,2K A 
"
&&   
&29    


( 
 
9  # (,2A .
"(.
 H8 & "
&  " ,. & "
&" "
9
,,        "  9 &
  9   >&
&2   "
1

"(-9

>
+.
" .
 #&0  ,  # "&  
   &"  
 ,2.,
     ,

 E 

& 
 
  & + 

   ," >.   &
 ?  
,  . .&
 H A #, 

2 . >9   

2 . 



2 . >H

(
, >
 "
".   
, .  8 .&
   "1 
>"   .

"&  " 2 ,
,
& "( ,4c. .&
 &
&2 .&
""I was surprised the
drop in Hispanic growth rates wasn't bigger given the decline in immigration,",
H6   . &"2#&&"
 &2,


A 
"    
"
 , "" .   >  
( 
"   
   H


 G
c 
  

Magnet Disad ± Immigration Decreasing Now


6-c //c61- /8-'88/+/c-c8-7/

Associated Press, 6/R6, .5### #
0" M
 M .%%$*$, &

The number of [order Patrol apprehensions nationwide dropped for a third consecutive year, falling more than R percent
to a level not seen x >
""    #   

,4c1  8
&G",
# ,"
", &&
&
 
 ,
 K
9  
G,
)!>
.. ,   *>
""    , .
  + &
c"  2K-" 
 c
 ",
K #   
&2
&&  $  2? . "   , 
.. ,  #   ,  ,# 9  # ,0" 
. "   , "
, # 0"
The
report cited the slow U.S. economy
 , 9  "  2as. 9&factors contributing to the drop., 9  
.. ,  
,  ,, && *%>#, 1  8
&
 
&2)&& 
.. ,  


+/4//--'/c 76 //c/ 6-

[ogan, /2F>c
=   
.   ; 9>, .5### 9" )&&
&?
 ?
 .& 2 ?9 ?0" ? 
", &

 &,    &  .& 2   &
, 
2>"  92    , 
*&& &&
&
  ,4c
9  ,;  , 
F&2,"  $N .& 2 # &9# # ,   ,>
26  +
 > "   ,   8
""/" 
 ,4   2 

& 
c
  >" 9 &&
&

H, "(
9 9 H "& &H,.  ""2"&"
& 2  ,.& 2  


&.  ""2"&"
& 2  ,.& 2  
# ( >H+
 
2An estimated 200,000 to 600,000 illegal immigrants have lost
their jobs in the past two years, perhaps 60%  , 0" H, 
 ,workers who are easiest to hire; , are the
workers who are easiest to fire,",
2H1"
 ,

""   
. . 
,
  , " 
 
.& 2   ,.# > .
9"
 ,2
" "
 "  "  > ,

 , 
#
( 
&& 
 
&
9   2 &   , # # H,("( @H;  , low-skilled workers#, have seen wage declines as a
result of illegal immigration> ,2
 9   >9  ,    2#&&
29H= , ,A 9
(  
#
(># . .&

"   ,c  , 9    ,4cI K
& &
,   ,9&&   &&
 ,   ,   , >0"
# ( 
9
 
L9&& , > #  L 9&&   ,
.   *>0" K"
&9
( . = 
2
2
. &# .
"&
&2&
># , ,

&  
" .. N
N> ." &2>" .
  ,
 ,&
 2
> . &2 , . 
&& " ,9
(
(. 
"(
 , 9  $ 
+   , .>
 %?2
? &" ( 0"  &; 9 ,
job losses, cutbacks in hours and fears of being
fired are reasons why0"
>   ,large immigrant groups  ,4c>are sending less money home.c.
(  9, 


#","   > , ,   , >#, 
" (
,   A 9

.   $A
 
, " >
, ,  ,
9 " 9
"(
9  N


&   "
 29   ,"&
 " #,

>
2 #, 
(
9  L)$
,  >
# 
9  (.  , .
? 
A 9,9 , >, # > ,
 ,2,
A 9>  ,
.
2 . ,   ,
 
, .
2 

2 
2 "    , . ,>,
#
>H K  "   ,
 . .&" H 0" >   #   ,

 ..  , 
&,2 
  
   
 2, 51 # !
$>0"

9
 , L%9&& 
" 0" 


9  L $. 
 , #

 %N
"&   
" * L$9&& > ,   .   ,

"
There appear to be fewer people crossing the border. The
U.S. [order Patrol reports that apprehensions
&  ,c  , 9  were down 2 % 
2" .
  ,
 ,&
 
2
-  ,   ,  ,2
>
.. ,  &&!N )> %*. .&" .
# , ,
.  
2

 ,9  .
&>#,",,

9 &   
( >
  >
  ">9& K
&     . .& "  H+ .&&2>#,  ,2
&& ,

", & 2
.  &> ,2K&& , ( K # , >H
2c   992>
=
,  > ?9
. (
  ,.
&


 ^
c 
  

Magnet Disad ± Social Services Link


c-'c/7//c/c66/;'-- -;''/6'6-

Gray, 20061"(>,8 &"2
&2 
 ,
    >+,  =
= &1
   &&
&

>c. 9 >, .5#### " " . & "* 
&, &

, ,
9 " 
9&9
 "    
  ,+ 
c
",
9 
9  
  , #

  ,
&

8 .   

#
2 ,&. ,# ( . c
&&9 " .&
 
9   ,
 
&9   # &.&
"  ,;
&
" " 
9  
,.
"  # &,
  
 B A 9/"  

9   ,.
"  
2 
2 ,
  ," 2=,
  
&( 
9  >
, # >the appeal raising the minimum wage would have on attracting more illegal immigrants  ,
&
,.
"  
,
 
 
&&&
&
" &9, "( How many more illegal workers can the state support? How much more
"
benefits can be provided? How many more x 
x x can the state provide? How many ",&   
&&
&immigrants can the school systems educate@How many jobs can be provided@
  , #
> 
   
, , 9  . 92 ,
>" & " 

 
  9  &&
&
 "   ,
&
:.  , #

 ,
"  
 L$$. ,  # B   ,
&&  &&
&
>9  # B  " 
  "   ,c
1 1&&c1)!>
 
 ?

 9&&9  ,+ +1)!>&&
#
 
 , #
 L%$. ,  >  &&
  ,
 ,
&
,# &
(
 ,
&
B #
 ,,,     
> ,,, 9 # ;& 

#F 2>
 ,! ,,,   ,"  2c0
,

 #

&
#,2&  , 
(    #,
# ( 
.
# 2? 
"  &2
  ,
,   ,
 92
,
&   GL$$. ,     
,
 #
,,  ,
 ,
&&&# &A   ,
- ,
# ,
,,, &&
&. .&
  
>   
&&2( #>  ,
 #

,,  ,
 ,
&
, ,0
>#,",
2# &



   &&
&> 
&   #
>9"
  . 0 2 0"  && &&
&
&  ,4  c
>

& , ,  
.  ,
 9 
&& ,2"  "
.0 .  2
. & "   ,2"   "
 # (>

2
  29
"(,   , 
& ,
&
B&&
&
. .&
  

!>?%>They come here because of the
generous"
benefits, a plethora of social services>", &  , ",&  >
2  B&"  3  >&
0  &
#>
  
.
&2>A 9  &&
&&& ,& # .
2 A 9 ,
( ,
   =, 9  #,  ,.
2  ,A 9
@,# ( 
 ,9  
,.
2"
&>

 

2  ,
&&
&
  &2# & ,&&
&
# ( "9  
&2>9 > " ,
&

# &9    ,,,  #
  ,  > ,L%$
 .
2
# &9

   &&
& ",  ,
&

 ,  #>
&9 
&&
&>, '
 2
 ,&&
 . .     ?
    &&
&
 # ,
&&
#
 
 , #
 A 9
,
# &  9  &&
&=,2  ,&
 ,.  ,6 
&9&2"   #
 .  
 9   . .&#, 
, 
&&
&&2G
&&.


0.
2 B0. @When low skilled illegal workers flood the workplace, the value of all low skilled workers
is diminishedG ,  "
# (  #
(.

"
&&2& #>
since there are more workers
than jobs available, unemployment goes up. When unemployment goes up, there is more demand for social services and
welfare.4 &
 &
   

9&,>
(  ,
&
 

"  &&
&# ( >92
  , #
>9

.9&"
" ". &"2


c-'c/7/c//6//;;/+/c4/ccc7/6-

Facchini and Mayda, 20096 
>8   /" "
c/
4   2>


>
8   
,c", & ;  c "
 .
  /" "
6  # 4   2># /" "
c
 ">

2

&
.    ," &92 , " ? 9  " 3 " 
 
# ( 
" " 
9   #
 &

(&&&&9"
 ,2
#
2  " 
 " .   >  "  # #
.    ,  " 
" 9    , # &   "
 2
,

"" .
& 9
&E
 !-  , , ,
>
# ( #&" 
#, " .&  ,  ,&
9 
( " 
 &
important dimension of the debate is represented by the welfare-state channel 
" >the very existence 
2 
 
"  of redistributive social insurance programs is likely to have a magnetic effect on  (&&
>
interested not only in new job opportunities, but also in the benefits that come in the form of subsidized healthcare,
unemployment compensation, or provisions concerning dependants.$=,& , 2. &
9 & #&(&2  .  
  9    ,
.9&"
"  ,,  "  >  
&
 "
,
 , ..  "   ,#&

> 0
.&>#, 

(&&
& 
#, , 
  .  
  "   9   .9&"
">
A    ,  9  "
  92 ,#&



 
9&
.
&2> ,.
. , # ,
 , 2.  . "
  92 ,#&


(2  
  ,"  
  
 9 .  ,
. .&
 
>

" 3 ">  
& .  
9  
  ,&,   ,>#& .
 ,  "
&
# (  
&
 
#

  #,", ,&
9 
( 
#&

 
" # ,
", , 
    .  


 º
c 
  

Magnet Disad ± Social Services Link


6/6c-'c/7/c-= c6c64//c/c'6=7/c-;6-

Karth, 2009
&&>; &
"F 
& >, .5###,&"  *! ?#,2?&&
&?
? ? ,??, &? ?
"?   ?9  

&&
&
"   ,"  2 
9  &- ",   A 9 ,
2 
 K #
  >#,& , 
(A 9 . .&&(2 

9"
 ,2#&&# (
A 9 & 2
2,
9
9>
&     

  , &
 9  ",&  
 , "
&0. 
,  ,  ,
, & ..Encouraging More Immigrants. Providing a safety net for immigrants makes it so that more
and more of them desire to come.  
&&>,  ,2 "money for , children> ,2 health care  ,
#&&
 
. 
"> ,2 "food stamps>
,

 

& other benefits,encouragemore illegal immigrants to
come into the country., 
# . "  &&
&
 >#,2# & ,2 #
 " @,2    
>A 9>

&  
&,   ,c
,2 K 8
2;  # (  "
#.
2    

"  ,  
0/
",.
2","(# , "

& ,9    ,   .
2 
("
    # >9 #

& .
2  
("
 . .&#, ,
" , &&
&&2,2
 K 
..  9, >9  # ,
 ,2
>#,
 .
2  =,
 .
2  ,
"  ,
 ,2 K 
(
", 2>,
 #   ,  

2
(>
   # ( "
,,2 K .
2
0 A 9 ,2# (&&
&&2  
 ,2 .
   ,
9&> "
,> # ,  .
2 &&,  ,
, 
,   "
&& ,&.& 2
&

0.  ,>#,", "   ,2 K .
2&&
&=# (,
 ., &    ,&
#  ,
 =
2  . ,>   >
 
" &
+ # >#  ,   . ,&&
&
,2
&&
&

",, & 9
 " 
 
2They should not be taken care of>by our government>  
92  , .
&  
 ,2, &9 9
"( 
, "  2 
   , &&
&
"  2#
2,
,>
 ,2
 #,
,
 & 1  ",
> , 9  
&&
&
"
 "
" # ,#  2#+ # >  , 20.  "& 
 

  2  ,, &&
&
#&&# (
  ,,  
 

2  ,.
2 "   "
,2# (,

( L$? $
,  
&& ,  
 =,  ,,  
 

    ,2,. #     ,2,
9 , ,2  # 2  ,"
 ,2. ",
  ,2 ", ,2"
&&.
 ,  
 
  
"&
&, 9
"( 0"  #& 0
&
 ,
,

 
 9  &&
&
c   ,9

(&   2  ,  
"   
.& 2
 A 99"
 ,2#&&# ( & 2
2# (  , & #,  ,2,

 
  # ( , #
"&
 
.>,
& ,"
>
 , ",&    ", & "
.
2  , 
>   , " >
 9"
=, 
#, #&&  @


c-'8-6c/c/ 6-

Malanga, 2008c  >c  ;&& #
 ,
,

    >
( c5&
, 7# /" "D> ,
/  >. *? 


 K9 & ,
,  ,
.&2 ,
 
,,?
 
&(
& 
>
?9   
.
2 .      


& "
&
0 ,

 
 " "9     > ,"   &2&(&2  #
 ,  ?9 . .&
 ??#,",,

& 
2
,  
9  . "   ,4c. .&
 #,  ,c #    ,&
 
9  . "  
2??(. # ,
,
. 
  " ,)>#, 
# &&(&2 9  , "
&. 
  ,6 
c " 2 ,
 ,
?9 . .&
 >
2
+

"  1 A
>  ,
welfare and other social programs are a magnet drawing certain types of immigrants??
nonworking women, children, and the elderly -- and keeping them here when they run into difficulty.


 Ñ
c 
  

Magnet Disad ± Health Care Link


Increases in healthcare fuels illegal immigration into the U.S. ± also turns the case
ARC 8 ± "
"  "  "&
O, .5###
"
 " &9.
. $, &P" 

,.
. "   ,
,
& ,"
9 .  &&
&
 
 
"
&
   ,2 >
#&&

9   
9  
 &0 "
 
  ,"  2,.
. . 
 " ,
, #, # ,"   .  
,
& ,"
 &&
&
9"  . ,9 ,.
. .   ,
 , &2"  &    3 .  " E ,.9 
.  ,
& ,"

 . ,9   &&
&
0".    "2 
 ># ,.
  " ,2 "  ;  ,8
. 5H""   
8
 %

   9&& "  ,4c  92  

"    &
 # &
( 
"  . ,
& ,"
 
,  "
& " &&
&

"  
"( #& ," .&0
&
 ,"
&  & . ,9  ,
& ,"
>9 "  
,
H 2  "
& "  ,  , 2 ,
    . ,
  "  ,

&&  ," 9  , ,
>
,,
& ,"
> ", & ,
&&

   ,

#. .&  ,"  2
K 2  
  E H
"  K9&&,

9 .
 &
#
 2 >9  ,  " 
 ..  =
,  

"  ,4  c
  ,&&
   ,( >  ,. 9&
&&
&
,
& ,"
"  (.  2 H




 Y
c 
  

Magnet Disad ± Turns The Case


c 4c+/c/ 6/6--7/14 /cc-'c/7/c '-:cQ'/-;8-7/Q

Espenshade et al, R99 , 
F>",
&;0>= 2R 
>, 
 9 >C
 
c "
&8 &"25#
    
-&D>4   2 ="  
      
", 8  2>; "7 &* >;
&&=  

 &7  ,
" >"
  
&.   ,

" 9 ,&
&
&&
&
> &"  ,.,&  .,"
& "   "[y denying
federally funded public benefits to #&2
&
&immigrants  ,  2
 ,2
  ,"  2
&9 # , 
&
. 

0".  >the welfare legislation makes a sharp distinction between U.S. citizens and noncitizens> ."   , &
& ,  
  ,4  c
8 &"2
( ,
, , 
#  "  9 # &
&. 
   
" E >  

# 
& 9 # &
&

&&
&
, 

&
 
 ..   ,  . &";   ,
 ,generosity of the U.S. social safety net
serves as a magnet to the disadvantaged of other nations>.
"&
&2 , "  # ,  & ." 

.9&"" In consequence, xx   
  x x 

  
&#

 " A 9" .     ,
" 
2&
9 
( >as well as increase
0burdens stemming from greater demand for services, from education to
welfare. 
& "&
 ,
 ,.   
,
9 , (  ,  . 9& 2 . 
"
&.. I
,  # &9   ,    . 

"  ,

  ,
,
   &  

?9 
& #&
 " 

  
5 ,
public assistance becomes a crutch that inhibits immigrants
from adapting more quickly to the nation¶s culture and from seeking productive work.


Social services attract illegal immigrants and lock them into an inescapable cycle of poverty that leads to
organized crime and violence
Gorak 8 ±
>0"  "   ,# 
&   "
 
Oc >, .5### , "
&"
" " 

.9&, "M*M! "M*M!M
(, &P" 

4 .& 2 


 "G9   
2
 
( B2&
E  G ,
 , &
  9   , 
 B  ,
  .  
 
. &"2,
9" 
 , 
 ,
# B   &  . & "
9  
(  &2 ,.9&"B #  # ,

 ,. .&#B
9    =
,    .       
 " " # ,( .  ,0"
   
    +.
" ,
 ,2

# ,&&&  ,  . 9&   , "    >

A  2 #, "    && , ,2,
,
 # ,&
 9     G  ,

,
&  , 0" G.     ,"  2,
>#,&&(.   #"   "
  ." >
 
" 


"
&&2  9"
 ,2,
 ,&0 2 
#&

 2   . . ,. ,2
& 
", ,    

9  &,&0 2#
 B 

&
9& 
2  ,!&& 
#, "
,    ,**!C6 
=
D
9      ,  # "    " " #  
&

#  > 0
.&> ,

&  %. "       ,"  2   ,6 

.  .
"(.
&  , >
  ,.
 
#&&   (
&&  , ..   2 9   ,&I 
2B

&" # ,

    & 9"
  , " #

&
9&  ,> "& C D"
 
,
& ,"

 "
 
  B
&" 
 ?
   
-    B#&&   .
   " &+.
">#,", "&     "  # 
 
&
#>,
 ", ,
  ,  2
3
& 2 & 
2"   > "& c&
>
&>+
 B # ,  # =,
B
( .&
" c&

   ,.
 $2
& +
 B"&9
# (>0 
+
 #   ,
 "&&
&
 9"

&   ,3 
&&2 #,",,
&>  ,
   , 2
"
  , 
  &&
 

C- 
,   ,
&7
&&2,
9 9 (   ,  =
 ,

 . 2
I # #
&&># , &
  , #
2D  
9&2> ,
 , 
2> ,
A  2  
2B


. &2"

 (&&
" 9  ,  
" 2 ,
B " 
 &2( #&  
 & > ,2 
 
 & #?.
2  "" A 9 ,



?     ,
 , " 
/ .
   ,&
 "  2>
, # >9 , # , ,.
(&&  
 # 2  "  2 ,
   ,.  
& . 
&


" ,&
"( .#
 9& 2  ,+.
""   2>
"
&#  >,&.  &" 


 " 
9 ,. 
 ,
,
 #   
E
 & && , #   
  ,
 ,
&
 . " ,
# (
 #&&  ,.
  
&&2 0  
 +.
">#, 
& 9  # , , 

  #
"
 
 ,/ &,&

,
( 
& "& 
& 
   #    >+.
"
 " 
  
  ,  # "&  
 ,
   ", &
 
",  , ,
 ,  #
"  2,
", 9
,
 =,
"
9  
&# , ,. 9&
 "
# , 
2B&
,
9&

 

 . &"2@
&

   , # ?.
 &  5;  > ,"  2,
 #.
 && # ,0
.& "  &(


> &
>


&
 ,
,
?.,
E ,  

 
&2  "
  
  
   , 
# ,(&&9 "
&  ,  ." 
" c" > ,4c 
&     ,#&

  




 R
c 
  

Magnet Disad ± Turns The Case


/c/ 6- --c+//;;/7//cc-;c-'c/7/c4c+/c/

Kolb, 2008+ & >4   2 -
9 "(>C/
"; 
5;
 
/" 8 . 
& 
 8 &"2
 D>c-/8 &"21  > 

c"
" ". 92
 
=  
 
 2."
&&2.   ,  ,
9
  ,
" &B9
" (.  2> .& 2 >

9& 2>"( > &
> ,  "

( ,2  ,92.&  ", ,
" . 
 ," 3 &   "  ,
", (   

&c",

 
..& 
&&
9 > ."   , .  
  .  " ""
.
" c

&    ,.,2"
&   2 
, 9 92  .
S"  2 
 "  B  ,  
. &" ">&
#  " 
 "> "1 
9  

 ,
 
"
&&2

&
 9   "
&.  
. "   , , .,2"
&"  2", 
2 " "& ,
 ,
 

. "    "> 
9 ,.  
&& #
"" 
9 & "
" 

?.  ",.    , "",

"  92
& #  
0"&
9& 2>
  ,
  2"& 
0.  0"&
9    ,   > "
&"  29  
.
"&
&2
". 9&  
& 25 , &
  
 "92 9 
2 & "
, 9 B ..   2 
(


  ,
 " && 

  . "  ,.   
 "Concretely speaking, immigration produces an increase in the number of
beneficiaries of state-provided services.More recipients" &mean
lessening  service quality and limited
accessibility  ,
B 
&9 This 9 ,logic behind common fears of the social welfare system¶s
µmagnetic effect¶
"   S
   , "
&2 BIn response, states cannot accept immigration
  
> ,2 
&&" . , "   ",
  2 #9 #, #&&.  
&&2 
& "
" "
& "


/c/ 6-c/c4'c-/8-7/Q

Rector, 2008 9 c  ;&& #
 ,+ 
;  
 >8  25-..  7#.  c >.%

,data indicate that ,"  influx of low-skill immigrants will raise poverty in the U.S.  &2
 ,.   >9  
 
  "   low-skill immigrants will raise both the absolute number of poor persons and the poverty rate in the
U.S.  , 
9&  , 
  , & # & #?(&&
> , 
  ,& ?   " 
 .  2#&&9


c 4c+/c/ 4c/c c/c/8-7/Q

Camarota, 2009c  >  "  
",
 ,   
 c >4 9
>! ,/  >.)

,   " 
&
9 ,
>."
&&2
 ,9    ,&
9 
( #, 

  " "
There
is a good deal of
research showing that immigration has contributed to the decline in employment and wages &?"

All
research indicates that less-educated immigrants consume much more in government services than they pay in taxes.Thus>
 &2 ",immigration harm America's poor> 
& 9  
0.
2 &&.
  , 
&

 RR
c 
  

Magnet Disad ± Turns The Case


c 4c+/c/

Rector, 2008 9 >c  
",;&& #
 ,+ 
;  
 >  
&  2>c. 9 $

 "
"  &20.  "  
 " && 
 /
",2
 ,&2$&& &
&
&&
&
  

(.  "  ,
4c  &2  ,  "
  9 -    0"
&  ,4c 
2K

. . 
&2. &2"
,
"" 9"
illegal immigration primarily attracts low skill workers
 ,&
&
 2 
 ( ,.   
(&&&& & >one third of all adult immigrants lack a high school degree>" .
  &2  . "   ?

, 
"  " ".   ,
 ,& #"
 &&  " 

.
 
. 
 , "
&.
 >
 ,
 ,4c,

&#
2

 
#, # . &2"
 &
  ,
9 . .&
 + "
&&2> ,#
  ,"
, ,     4c, 2> ,
"
 && 
#
3
& >  
  ,
> ,
  ?
The steady influx of low skill# ,  
,,", & 

?(&&# , &2
,,", & immigrants inevitably leads to increases in the number of poor persons in
the U.S.Low
?skilled immigrants
 , 
& #comprise almost one fifth of all poor persons in the U.S.
=,& , 
"  2 , ,

& &#&
>  
& 2>

,
2  #&
 " ;Q*>& #
?(&&

 " L9&&  
?  #&

,,,&& #&
 ". ."
&&2 (  "
2  , .
&&
&

"  &29
 #&
Welfare expenditures would rise even more strongly if illegal immigrants are granted

  2
eventual access to the welfare system.  
  & # .


   
& "
&
&

. &"While society seeks to reduce poverty and dependence>"  immigration increases both
 .
" ">9 ,
&
&
&&
&> .
&(
2  
?

&#&
  
",9   &&  . 
"
&&2.   
&  ,4c
 
. &"2
.
" " 9  " # ,
 # "  " .  2
#&
 2 #. &"2, &( 9  > 9  > ,
0.
2 
 "  ,4c    " " ..   
 "
&9  Hundreds of millions more people would immigrate to the
U.S. if they had the opportunity. 6  ," 0 > ,4c 9&"   
 . &"2  ,  >4c

 . &"2, & " 
,,?(&&
 
 " &2& .  2? 
 & #?(&&
  
 
&>government policy should limit immigration t  , #, #&&9  "
&" 9 >avoiding those who will
increase poverty and impose new costs on overburdened U.S. taxpayers.


 R
c 
  

Magnet Disad ± Overpopulation Impact Ext.



 Rë
c 
  

Magnet Disad ± Oil Crunch Impact Module



 R
c 
  

Magnet Disad ± Oil Crunch Impact Ext.



 RG
c 
  

Magnet Disad ± Nuclear Terrorism Impact Module



 R^
c 
  

Magnet Disad ± [iological Terrorism Impact Module


Increased Immigration Causes influx of terrorists with bioweapons
c
Francis,2001
c2 "
 &  >
  5 >?$>, .5###
" 
"9,M
  2M, 
It's been like pulling teeth, but the reality of the alien terrorist threat within the United States is finally forcing even the pro-immigration
Bush administration to recognize the suicidal folly of tolerating mass immigration from countries and cultures profoundly different from
our own. Last week the president himself uttered the first words that indicate he's starting to perceive where the real danger comes
from. [Read transcript , listen via RealAudio.] Acknowledging that "never did we realize that people would take advantage of our
generosity to the extent that they have," Mr. Bush ticked off a list of changes in how the country would receive²or not receive²
immigrants in the future. Tighter visa security and procedures, the most popular mantra of the hour, were high on the list, but so were new regulations forbidding the entry of
suspected and potential terrorists. Later in the week, Attorney General John Ashcroft unveiled a new list of 46 more groups for the list of known terrorist organizations. This is progress,
letting just about anyone who wants to come
sort of. Apparently it requires immense concentration of mind and steely girding of loins for the ruling class to see that
here enter the country and wander about at will is really not a good idea in itself, let alone the most effective way to deter foreign
terrorists. Even with the new announcements, the president had to pause every other sentence to explain that he's really not against
immigration per se. Although we need to "tighten up the visas," Mr. Bush also insisted "that's not to say we're not going to let people come into our country; of
course we are." Then again, just because some people we let into our country are evil and need to be "brought to justice," "by far the vast majority of people who have come to America
are really good, decent people²people that we're proud to have here." Maybe so, but it ought to be unnecessary for the president to have to keep saying it. No doubt most of the people
of Afghanistan are "really good, decent people" as well, but neither the president nor the military leaders planning the bombing campaign feel the necessity to tell us so. As for the late
and unlamented "amnesty for illegal Mexican immigrants," that dominated the news prior to Sept. 11, it turns out that amnesty is not quite as late as some had thought. "It's not dead,"
says White House press secretary Ari Fleischer, but due to "other duties," drawing up the amnesty plan just "has not moved at the pace the president had hoped it would move." What all
of this means is that the ruling class in general and the Bush administration in particular have not really changed their minds about immigration one iota. It's just that they have at least
enough political sense to grasp that most Americans know immigration is a major reason why we have foreign terrorism at all, why we are having to
worry about continuing anthrax attacks, why we need to keep worrying about what immigrant terrorists are planning to do to us in the future, and why the FBI and similar
agencies keep issuing warnings about imminent terrorist attacks. If
there were no Arabic or Muslim immigrants here, if those here who are clearly
sympathetic to terrorism or are clearly anti-American in their religious and political views were kicked out, there would not be much of a
terrorist threat at all.

B) Extinction
John Steinbrenner, Senoir Fellow at the Brookings Institute,
12-22-97, Foreign Policy, lexis

Although human pathogens are often lumped with nuclear explosives and lethal chemicals as potential weapons of mass destruction,
there is an obvious, fundamentally important difference: Pathogens are alive, weapons are not. Nuclear and chemical weapons do not reproduce
themselves and do not independently engage in adaptive behavior; pathogens do both of these things. That deceptively simple observation has immense implications. The use of a
manufactured weapon is a singular event. Most of the damage occurs immediately. The aftereffects, whatever they may be, decay rapidly over time and distance in a reasonably
predictable manner. Even before a nuclear warhead is detonated, for instance, it is possible to estimate the extent of the subsequent damage and the likely level of radioactive fallout.
Such predictability is an essential component for tactical military planning. The use of a pathogen, by contrast, is an extended process whose scope and
timing cannot be precisely controlled. For most potential biological agents, the predominant drawback is that they would not act swiftly or decisively enough to be an
effective weapon. But for a few pathogens - ones most likely to have a decisive effect and therefore the ones most likely to be contemplated for deliberately hostile use - the risk runs in
the other direction. A lethal pathogen that could efficiently spread from one victim to another would be capable of initiating an intensifying
cascade of disease that might ultimately threaten the entire world population. The 1918 influenza epidemic demonstrated the potential
for a global contagion of this sort but not necessarily its outer limit.


 Rº
c 
  

Magnet Disad ± Mexican Economy Impact Module



 RÑ
c 
  

RNC ± Iraqi Refugees Disad


U.S. bringing in Iraqi refugees now, but funding and organization are tight
AP 9 ±  "
8 
OF )>, .5###
#
#"   #M"  .,.@T)*)%U&
T M #P" 

&&  . .&# .&


"92 ,#
 
3,4  c
,
 " 
 , 9   9   & 
 % 
9  )> ,2
,"  
 ,4c. 
 ",
 9 , 
E
 
  9"
 . 9&
,,  92 ,& 9
&" " #  
9"
 ,,,&2"
. .&
 ,
."
& - ,    &  ,
4  c

"&
. 9&>9  ,
3,
,,&& 

> A 2

, ,

( ,  
  . "
 > , . 


H   >
&
 9    &
3

& # #>  # ,2  ",&  >#, 
,   

& >H 

H,# #> "& 
2#, ,
 .& 2 0.  ">
0."   
A 9
..  ,&
 , 
&, &2
  

&H








An influx of new refugee cases will tradeoff with more difficult, backlogged cases, ensuring they never get
addressed
CIS ±  E ,.

 c "
OF >, .5###, 0&9
2
 c-1M 
&M. M).P" 

,-9
&&2.. 4cc  3"(&2
" &2" .&  ,"
+ # > ,"     " .& &
 9  "
.  . 9& ; 0
.&>

4cc. & "   "9


 #,
  " .& 
 2."
&"
  ,-9
B  
  ,
& ",


# (&
 >"

4cc   
","

&&2
( ,   " .& >4cc#&&. 
"
&..  >,  
 ,

(&   ,

,   " .& 


. 
 
&   "  , "B9 -"# ,  ,
 ,

 9  "& "
  " ,
 2 # ( ,
"& "
 , ,&2#&& 9
3
&2 9"
 , 9  " .&  #&&9& #
#,&> " ,
., " .&  ,
2"
#&&
, 9  #- & " 92 ,-9
,

&
 9  & ?.  "
#,", 3 9

&
A"
,  + # > " 
 ,
 " "
 ,
 ,2"

 
, & >"& "
# ,   
&2
"   , . "  2 .  4cc,
3
 /-/ -)??,-9
,
 9 
,
 # "

. " 3"(&2#,&"
  ,
0 , &
 " 
 &29
"(& ,-9
.. 

,4cc  
0E"
" .&  >9 
    9 " 
"&
  & "





The backlog consists of Iraqi refugee applications ± the U.S. is processing them now, but their inherent
complexity and difficulty means they¶d be pushed to the back
Reuters
Oc. >, .5###
&    , # #( $, P" 

,4  c

..     "
& = 
2 "&
, & 
    
3> && # ,
."  " ,
 ,
 &" . .&#,  ( , 
& ,&. ,4c#
,4  c
 ,

  &2  
3 "&
 -" ??& ,
 . "    ,


> 
&& "
  ,4  c
 
 92 ,4+,    >
4c "
&
;  , #  #.  >c" 
2 c
  &EE
"

.& 
F
; &2  " 
 
3 
+ &
c"  2c" 
2",
&, 
..
 &
#0. ' c"
&
99

  
 ; &2>
  4c
9

  +
 >
(

# ,     ,
H
29 
"
"
9& "( ,
" .
9 ,
&
.. . 
&2>H
c
 .
  . 2. (
 
2+
"

 , 
H9 
"
"9 "(?9 
( H # (# , ,
3
 
&&2 .&
"8  
(; "

, 
 " "&
 , 9
"(&   ,
!>   #,
9 " .&  ,
>
 , .
  + &
c"  20."  ,
  #
.. 0
&2!>$
3 92
,   , ,>, 
 

 HQ #
&  9 &  ,"  2 (
 "
# ,
    #
? "  >."
&&2"   &
92&
 9     >H, 
 " 

"  2. " .  " ,c. 



"(    "      "&&
 &
,
& #

3 
 >
/&& c
 9 2>

" 
2 
 . .&
 > 

 


 RY
c 
  

RNC ± Iraqi Refugees Disad


Lack of asylum for Iraqi refugees ensures radicalization that leads to widespread instability in the
MidEast and Iraq
Senanayake ± c,
>
 ; / .
 '9 2

OF&>, .5###  & "  
"&))), &P" 

=,& 
3K ,9  &# , ,&   >,


 
E
 9
 ,&
"(     , 

&"   2 ,&. ,," 
  
 ?
"
&& H,




"
"H.  
&&2 .  ,  
 . 
9&,
 , &# ,  ,

. .&
  ,6
E
c .
2 "
 > ,  ,
& 
" " ,&
  
E
 +

 
 ,.   
  
 8
&  
  ,6
E
c .>  &2    ,   ,
& "".
 >9 
&  .  ",  "
& " ,
 ,8
&  
   
  " &  
" >+

K%&"  " 2
2,
,
&  # ,9
  & "
&
&  ,   ,
 ,9
" " ,2.  . .&  ,  & , ,>+

,
   ,. & "
&
  
>  &&


3 " & .&( ,
"  
    
E
 92
2=  
>
 "  &2 
. #  &# ,8
&  
 ,  28  
,99
 > , 
" "  ,
 
2K

8
&  
5
&
. .&
  .&
"
 
",. .&# , ,.  
& 9" 
"
&E ",
&



"
&E. .&
 # &  &29.  
&&2
9&E  "  ,,  "  2>9 920    ,
    




Extinction
Steinbach 2 ± F , >   
", 6& 9
&E
 
O
 >, .5###& 9
& 
","

"&c/ , &P" 

,
& "&


&,
.   .&"
   ,   .
"  , /
 >
 &  >  ,  .&
  
"&
 
&c,
,
( ,

&,
     .
"0".  ,
#,","
   #   >
,

9 & &2       
   
 , "
&  "&
. 
 "  &2
 "&
? &/
 >H
&K   "  ,
 .     "&
#
. "
9 
 ,  
  #,",
&

2  H !""   c2  + ,>H ,E
 ., "
  
&K "&


&
&& # ",
 &c,
  
  
#  ,
.  ,
&/
 
92 ,.&"  , 
  "&
 "H $6 
& c,
,
(?'.( >  
&, c
3 H   . 9& 
&( 
3
9   
 #,
I   . 9& 
&( 

9   
 #,

 &2
9  
"&
E
 = ,c2 
#"
 
&&2
&( , H %RKc,>

&&
20. #    +

 E
>H=,  9& ,

&#&&   ,4   . ,9   ,. &
   "&
#
. 
2 
 >H )

 2

 ",>  "   ,
&      , & .  =
. 2>
 !>H,
&
. & "
&
   "&
#
.  ,

#,",   " , 

"3"   ,
 7

&
&& , 
#,",&

# ,.  "  
&#
. 
& 

 9" 

&
H *
& " 29"  
 . &
E> , & "  ,
"
& , 9"   ""   c,
,
(>H,. ."  6,/ >  "&

, ?# 
&

">     ,&  
& 2 
&>E " & 
& "&
#
. "
9. "&#,&
&A#, " 2   
 
2. &
E
 > ,
&"  22  " 
 &2 &  ,
"    " ,   ,
(  ,0  , H ,
9
>& 
#
 
&K "&
. 
>9  &2   "  "  >
. " 0  "
 ,.

   , 
 .
"  ,  > 3   ,  # #
.  

 "     
  &/
  #

  " . 9& 2  ,
"    &c,
>
  " #
" 
&# ,
9& 2 "   ",   ,

"  8
&  
"&

<92
 $ >  ,

"  8
&  
"&



 
&   & 2> ,&
 ",  &  
&   2
c
9

c,
&
 *
92  ,. 9&
&  "&
#
. , & 9"  ""   c,
,
(>H



K "  
&K 
& #, ,  ,2
3..# ,0.&  .  
H!=,", 3 
H "  
&H
. >
. ,
. 30".  9  ,
3c4 

"(   ,6&=

#,&> ,0  " 


& 
 "   ",
 
9&     ,
  .&"
    
" &


   
 >


c, &#
9 
(    ,&/
 

 > , &
2
9
  &

  
&>

  , , 
  "&
#
c2  + ,#
>H


 "&
"
&

,
3> # & 9
 . 9
9& 2
> " , (
9&0". 

&
   >  # H!
/E
=
>
&K"  8  
H, "&

  
  
 , 0 #
#&& 9"  
&H!

9   ,c  4  ,
& 9 

A   ,
A 
  
& ( #&2 .  ,
 ,.  ".
&. .  F
,
8 &&
K.2  
&#
  ,
&& 


& (

 ,


 c  
 
 , .   

 &
  4c "&

  
2! c "&
 ",   # 
&&  **>
& &   4c.2"  

,
&
  &2" .&"


 

" &  
 
>
 , 2&
 > , &

&.    "&
#
. 92
&  &2
9&E >



"
&&2& #  , , , &  , 
" 
&>  
&&   "&
#
  ,#  
(6
 2>H ,
&
.
 
&    #
.  
 "  # ,
" .&" 2    ? #,
  
 ? ,  .  &/
 " &" " &  
# &" &

 H!!

 
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± Uniqueness


Obama has reversed [ush policy and is settling Iraqi refugees now
Costantini 9 ± 8  >2 
 

&# "2
OF >, .5###

  #%$!, P" 

 ,1,
 
 ,
 
 E  ,  2 >, , # # &,
   , . ? 5H=&"   ,,   ,9
>,&
3
>
."
&&2 ,  2 #,  (2  &# ( # ,1 
, 
29 , >9  2 , &0. 8&

"". 
 .
2 ,&2","(
 
&& & 

 (    
.. "
 >


&
9&&  , #2   #

8  1

"(-9

,
. 9  - ;9 
2)>,
5H .& 
"2


"
&  3  ,&. ,
    
& 
9&. . .&H

&&  .&
"
3, >#  
",&  

& " 3 "  ,#


",
&&  
9& 2  ,  >
 ,2 9" 
.
 
3K " "&
 

"  2  "
,


"   ?


& . 9& 2? 
"   ,"   ,> 2
 
 #&&.  


"

( .  " 
 

&..  "  
& 
2,    I#K&&" .
# , ,    &
3
"  
. 
& (I
##&&# (# , ,
3
         & 
.&
"
3# , 
3?9"
 , 
# . # & "
 &
  .
" ,
.&
"" E     , H








The U.S. has turned its attention to processing the huge backlog of Iraqi refugees now
CNN 8
O;9!>, .5  " " *=-' 
 !
3  0, &P" 

,c
 .
 , .   
&   & >
3 92c. 9 >. 
   &2 )$ 
 ,2
> ,.
 K " 


 
2H,

&&  9   
 


9&>H
 ,c
 .
 K  " 
 
3 >9

 F
; &2> 

 ?"

9  # , .  ; &2#
9 ,  &
 2
 "  , ,9 
"
" 
.9 #  ,.
  c



+ &
c"  2>
    ,
,&2"  "E ,& #.
"   & 
3 +.
#,
,"
&&H 
&
0"&& " .
 H # .&
"
9 #  , # .
  . "  924c "
&  ,"
2>; &2",
&&  .  &
 2
 ,
 ,4  c
,
.&
 
 )>
3  ,
"
&2
  &
 
&&>
2 
 "
&. (& , , ,c


.
 
 ,
 ")> 
& 
3 "
> &2>%*
   ,4  c
&
 2
 +"
&& ,& #. "H
"
.
" 2. 9&>H9 ,# ,  ,
 " ,
   ,
=
9& 
"
.
" 2#,",#&& &  
"
> "&  ,4+,    >
# ,  ,4  c
 &H1& . ,"
.
" 2 
  , . ">H,
H

",   9 &


   ,2
; &2.     " .
 # ,4+
0.
4c. " 
"&  F 

 , "   ,
#&&.. ,. " 
&&2>9  
&
  , , ,4  c
  ,   #&&9  #  
..&"
 
34 & # ,2,
 9. "  , "  >."
&&2 0 ? F 

c2 
>#,",,
,
 " .# , ,&
 &  . .&& 
3

+
& 
9  ,9
"(&   "
9   & c2 
>#,",9
. "    
&
 , )







USCIS backlogs are being cleared now ± F[I check processes are running efficiently
Palmer 9 ± 1 2
>6& 9
&7


OF  >, .5###& 9
&
"  #9M"&
M
M","(M9
"(& M MM
 $, &P" 

9
"(&   ,;1B. " ","(  ,
 

..&2  
4c


   , &>
&  "&
,"&

" ,
,

&   ,;1B  .?. ,


?","( "92,   
>.  
  
.
   ", & 2,;1,
&
","( 
 %?)&& 4c


..&"
 
",2
 
2 ,
 ,","(  ,
..&"
B" 
&9
"(  


&"  2 (
 
(  & ,
 
2   "
># , , 
  " .& # , 
2>
(  ,. "",3"(  . .&
..&2 # ,
4c
 ,9
"(& .
(

  $>
&&"
  9 )># ,  ,
&  ,"
& .     ,
 ,  ,>#,& # &    
2
",
&2   ,4c E ,.

 c "

4cc
2 ,;1,

S 
 B 
& # , ,9
"(& > 
&2 "  ,  
( 
..&2

 
4c
+
  ,
   ,"
 ,
  ,   
 > #,", , 
%>"  &2    ,4cc>
  "&  ,;1 + # >
,
C9 & (
I ,2 K A   
,&>H
""    ,;1B

 "  

&"  2
 "  "
  "
>6  2c ,


 R
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± AT: Refugees Returning To Iraq Now



The security situation in Iraq is not stable enough yet ± refugees still need to be taken in
P[S 9 ± 89&"1
"
  c "
OF >, .5###.9 #  #
& 
" ?0
  #
3? !*!P" 

; 
#,&>  & " 
3#
9 
 , 
&& 
3#, ,
& , "  2# &9
9& 
  ,  " &2

2> ,4  
 +,       &   . "   
 
" 
 
3
9
1  
2 ,O4P
"   

2
3,
9  "    , 9  #

>
,  , 

&
"   2 

  .. C=,& 
&&"  2"   ,
. > ,2
 2 

9& ,
,
 " 

    
3>D

 "2. (.    







The security situation in Iraq is still too dangerous ± refugees are not resettling
The Independent 9
OF  >, .5### .  " ( ## &&?
 
3? ?
"" .&,?)!!%), &P" 

c"  2",.  1


,

"
&
3" .
  # 2

 >#,  >. .&# 9 (&& 2 ,1  ,.   &2 "
   ,&
,  
 , " .
 1
,

2 #9
  ,
 
,>9   && 
  ,
:
9&>,&&  #, & F 

c2 

      &

9 , 
 "  9
"(9"
 ,2
 &&9 
9  "  2
& "   /&" " 2..&29   ,2
>9 
 && . 
 , 
"   &
"( "&
#
 
3 #,
 #  ,
*&&  9&., " .
    c

> , , , &
9& 2
3
& 2  , ",


 ..
&
 &2  ,&
 2
c  # && . .&,
A 9# , ,   

#&&.
>9  , & & , " .& 2  
3 " 2> 
 "  


" 2# ,


 92 2
 #


"  ,4c "".
 
&  9&#,
#
 2
> 
2
#
2>0
" 9

3K. 9&  , 0 #
2> , &  2#&&9 
#
 "
"   

& &" .
>    . ,
&&   .   
&>
 ,  
. "  c""& "  "  #&&9 ,(2 
3K& ? 


c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± Generic Link


Increases in the overall number of refugees logjams the process of settling Iraqis
Scialabba 8 ± ' >c     ,c" 
2 + &
c"  2 
3
O, .5###""  0"@;"  T  " 7#= U  " MT)U  2.T U  " 2.T U8
 2.T+U; T)%*)*U;-:/
T ! ) )P" 

  & 


" .&0>& ? .. "  & 
&
 9  .&
2 >
&& 
&  ,""  ,. 
=,
,
0"&& 
" .
 
  ,.
    ,
3. 
  ,.    
2+ # >  ,
 ,
" .&"
. "
  & & .&  
 
&>#"
" &
&& ,

9& ,
"

"  
 
 2 
" 
2
"  ,. 
>  "&  , 9  
3

"   #
 4+  
 > ,  
3    &  ,4  c
> , 
&&.
"  
 

. "   >
..&"

&  
..
  , . "     #>4cc  # &, .
 > ,"  " .
  ,      
&& # . "  ,  >
 , 

" ",
9
"(  "&

">"
&>
  &   ?. " # &
& &( 
( ,  .
2   ,.  9 

.&  ,  
3" >#,",#
  &
# F

2* ,*4cc# ( # ,    +c" .  > -c
 ,

&c"  2  "&    , #9  .&  , #.    , # , -c>
#,

& 
29  .&  ,8   2 .  &   # ,"& 
&29   ,4  c
929&  
. ?0  8   2 . 
39 "
 ? 
 &
.      >
3
..&"
#, 

 " ?, .& 2  ,4c6    


3 
 
E
    2"& &2
 "
# , ,4c  
3  
4c?9

 
E
     
& 
E
 
9  " 
 "
"  , -c.&  .
 
, 

&- 
E
  
 - 
"" , . 
4cc
& # (  0 " ,0.
"  
2
 ,  2  ,  &
.. . 
 "  *92"   
& .
"
  "


. 9&"

  ,0.
  ? &

9& 20.  
&& #   , #&&
 =,&# (  0 " , #
 ,  2>4cc,
.&
"
, &  
& 
..&"
   
&#, 
29"   . 9&
0.     , 
  >4cc # 
..&"
    ,   "
"    ,     
&, &9"   . 9&0 "  ,"  
20.   ?"  2. "  
3,

9 4cc
 -c,

& 
29 . " ' "
&&2/.& 2c
'/c 1
,
#, 

 ( . "  9
  , 
 "
 # , ,4c6   >
#&&
 , 

&29 ,   .  
& 
/9
21
,
 "& '/c
 , 

&29 4cc" .&  ,  " "   1
,
 ?
",.. "

 " 0. . "  , , , 
    ,  & . "/0.
   ?"  2
. "  
392  ,  
& 
&#&&  & "
" 
 
 

 2 .
 = . "# , ,   
       ,
 2
"  2 9 ,  & .  &
 ?"  2 
..&"

= , ,  > +c> -c>/9
21
,

-
( #
2  " 
"
.
" 2
" "2;
&&2>4cc  "-.
 
 -c
 "  
 , #9  0.
c."
&
7
. " >#,",
  " 

  # 

A"
 
3"
,
9 
#&&"   9
 ..   2 4cc=

. 
>.



.
  . " 

"   # ( # ,   , 


 B
& 
  >
3   ,4  c
 ;Q*
" .  
-c
 , . 
.
  

 "2  , .
  + &
c"  2>4cc 
 &
     .  

&"  2 = "   . . "   3
&  
3

 &#, 
  ,# &#,&., &  ,
 & , ,&&&  ,
&
&
29",
&&  > ,2
 
 # , 
, ," 
 &20"    ,
. " &#,

9&, . " 
3 "   ,=& ( #
 "     .  
"& ?# (  &
 ,.# ,  c
 .
 " &&

   , .
  "
2    ,,


  
  
3
  ,4  c








U.S. success in bringing in Iraqi refugees is fragile ± perception that the U.S. has put them on the
backburner leads to other nations rejecting them, which triggers the impact
[yman ±
&>c  ;&& #>;  8 &"2>c
9
   &/
 8 &"2
O $>, .5### &#9  #=1c;9c //?)1cF@-. " P" 
,
 

  9    
3   ,4  c

" 
9&>9   ,  "  " 8 & "
&&2>


?
?  & . 
 .  

  
&   ,4c  9  
9& 2 
3 ?



(   "
 " 
 
 .#&&,
&292.
, "    ,
#, &
  , 
  #, 
9 ,
9
&  9&  

". ." >

& #G 


&, ,
 &
1
,
 
& 
>F 
>9 A.

",
" & 
9 9 c
&=,
K >   , #, 
(
,&    ,4  c
#&&,
9 
"
&E 
3>
(  ,.  
&"

 &
 . ,
#,  .
 4c &=,& ," " 
3  
&> ,2 K   #, "
K
& . 9& 2
 , 
 
" ( ,

&
 & #"

&  
&
9& 2-  & "   ,-  &2 .
 8 
>#,",9 , ,    , 
 7
  &  ,4  c
G #,  
&&29"
 &4c" E  
   

&& #  


3  &, >9    
3  
&
 "
&# &
&  .  , #
& ,2"  
  ,&/
 


"".  
3 & / .  , "     ,  > ,# &9 
(. ,.  
&&2
 " "
 
& 
3K
9  > "  , ( ,
 , " &9 "        &&
 . # &
&  " ,&(&, 
,
 , . 9&# &
"
&E ,  ". & " F 
>c2 
>  ,  
&,  4 & ,4  c
#&" 

  > K &(&2 ,
=
,  #&&9
9& "  " , =  
   .  ,  c 
&&#&&,

 
&

"" " >#,&" .& 
"2"
., ,     

"c && , " &
&
 . 
"
&.. 
 , ,&.&&#,  ..  ,#

"  "E ,4c "".
 ,   ,  
. & "
&&2.
&

9& ,
    " ..   ,4c&
2 

 ë
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± Generic Link


Overloaded asylum system means that any increase in cases directly trades off with the status of other
refugees
Fischer 5 ± 1 >8  
,
   , .
  + 2
 

4   2
OF
>F 
& / , "

 c >'/VcP" 

, 
  
 A .
   E  "   , ,   ,4  c
  ,

&
&9
"(   
 
  
     &
#2  >
     &
#2   9   . 
&
#2 92

   #   ,   "
" 
2&?(  "  . 
&
#2 

2& 
&2$. "      ,
     &
#2 

6  .&
2
 &  ,
 

#&&c 2? # . "  A

&9 #  
. . 
&2
  ,  &  ,   , .    &  A
#  #,  
"&  

$. "   ,"


 ,
" 9  ,&(2,



",& # >
 ( 9& #. "  
&
  A 
c  , 
A "  ,.
"&
A  
& ,
 ,  "
  
?2
.  ?? >*!%, 0   
" A &  >$%"
   ,
.  2&
 "
" .&
  ,
 ,  
.   ,.
 

, .
  F " 0.&
  , "


 ,",
 A
(   
&


AK.  
"9
. 
 

 ,     
"( , "  A , #
2  , " 
   

,, &&&(2F> , >
2
  &2  , 9  "
 ,2,

  , 9  "&
 ,2
.. 2&
 "

& " .&
  ,
A,

 ","       , # ,2" " ,
  
 A
  "   

.
( .9&"# ,  
 , 
 >9  ,

  ,
   ,.   ,2
"
 " 
  , "
&
&(2;  ,

= &c 2 .  ,


 , #    >
2&"
.  9 4c
   4c   

,,
 " 
  A &  , 
&&  
","

  "  ,
  

   ,

 ".  c A,


&  , 9  # 
"&

"
.  c A  
&& # &., "   2 3   ,
2&?
(  "   ,0.  9   #   , & "
 F"
0"&# >
  ,
 ,2,
& &     ,"
c A&  ,
   

",# "
 
   ,
F

& 
9& &  ,
    "
2 " ,
"
9.   
2 "
F

9& 0  "        ,
 

 " >"   # , 


 
&
 
, #"&   ,
  ,
" 
&,
  , " #&&9
"". ,  "  .  
&&2 .
"   ,  "   ,,
 

 
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± TVPA Link


Current TVPA ³extreme hardship´ standards key to reducing USCIS processing work
Honeycutt 5 ± >4   2 #0" 
O, .5 .  2 + 2"  
8
$N N*.P" 

 G
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± TVPA Link


USCIS processes few trafficking victims now ± large numbers of victims in the U.S. means the plan could
cause an explosion in the number of cases
D.O.S. 4 ± Uc .
  c

O
2>, .5###
 "
  #
,&? &,!
2!$! $F *%*!), &P" 

""   4c    


>
9  *> > >#  
",&  

"(
",2

"  

&9  # &# 0

 , . . I
.. 0
&2*> >  , " 

"(  ,4  c
 &  > ,4c     
&2L)!
&&  " 9
 ,# &#
"(  ,
9 >9  ,4  c
3
&&2"   " 9
 
"(   9  9 
" , 4c'
#,(2   ,4c   K .    
2&
 2 ,
"( 
7" 8 "  " 78>
"  &
# -" 9      2 ,, 

  
"( 
 " 
.
& > ,78 3 
&
 " " 9

"(   "
&&2
 # (# , , 
  
  ,. 9&
 

&&2,8   
  ,
 
 K"     ,#, ,  ,
"( 7" 8 "  
 , E
 "   "9  ,78"&

"(  9
" 
"
&&  ,4c    
. " 
. ,
"( >. " 
 ,
9&
 ," >
.   ," 
&
"  7"  
"( 
2
..&2 
7
 ,2
.,2"
&&2.    ,4c 
""    ,
"( >,
" .&# ,
2 

9& 3  


"  ,  
  . "    ,
"  
"( >
# & 0 ,
,.  &  
&
 ,
.   
&  ,4c7" 
  & . 
"2>.,2"
&. "  >
 ,   

"#,& , "


. " -  "9 %>>8  6 =1,   ,
&  ,7892  

&c"  28  
&  " > #,",, " 
&
 " H   ,  , " &&"  >"
.
9& >
" 
  
..  ,. &"2 " 9

"(  .  H, " 
&  .     
 ,  &2,
& #   "   ,& 0  >."
&&2  & ",&  >  > ,4c  .
 ,H8 " 
&
- , 
 & /  ,/0.& 
  ,&   
28-/" H4   ,H8-/" >H  #
"  
2.      ,4  c
>  
4c" E  &
#&. 
    
&
9
> 0
&&2
9",&  ,8  K
 
 "2
(; "  4c
?
"( . &"
. 
,
(; "",
 92 ,c" 
2 c

  " 
.& 92 ,c  8 &"2-.
 6 .>#,","   ,,?
( 
&    "
& 
 
 "
.
 ,
( "
 , .
  .   ,

&&
."   ,, 

  
"( 

 92 ,
.. . 
   
 ":24c6    ", .
  F ">+
& ,
+
c ">

+ &
c"  2,
 . 9& 2 ,  
"( 

  " # ,  ,4  c
4c .
  F " -F5F " .
 
2G&92 , 
&c"    ,&,   G. " "


  

"( 
. 
   
  , #
?
"( &
#+   "      "&
9 
0
&0.& 
 ,
9 ""&&2 "I , 
"( ,
9 . " 
" "  , ,F " .
  
 F

2!> 26 
&F , ,"   9  ,
 , #

,
. " 
  ," 
&. "   ,

"(   ,4  c
  ,&
  , "
&2
c.""
&&25?? -F",

"( G
 , ? & " 
   ,
.   , 2
- ,>) "&0?
"( 
&&
 > ,,,  ?? -F" "   9
 & 2.&
 )) 
>
 " 
   ,
$. "    ,.   , 2
- ,>$ 
#   & 2 0?

"( ",
?? -F .  #  
 >  ,
 9& , 9  .   ,.   , 2
 F

2*>!> , 
&c"    ,&,   ,
 . !
"(   
 >  ,
 #" , 9 
.  F

2 , &   , .
  F "> ,-" 7"   -7>  " .. >. "   ">. " 
&
&
#  " 
>
"
    " 
"( " 
"  "
.  , .
  +
& ,
+
c "++c5++c . 9& " 2  ,

.  

"( " 
 ,  &9&  .
2,  >&
&

">"

& ..   >
&,
& ,"  & >   ",&"
>

 , 9  ,. 



.& 92

92 E   ?    
E
 6-# , ,

" ++c   
 >
.  
2,
9  92&
#  "  "
&

.  
&" 9  2 
H" H92++c ,&. ,.  
 
  , 

" . "  
"( > , .
  F ". 
 6- 0  &


" " #, 
 92&
#  " 9 
 2 " ++c,
&
 ",


?
"( .9&"
#
 "
.
 # , # 
&5 " 
"     #,"," #&&&
  2  ,&9"
 ,2( # ,2#&&9. " 
 , 
. 
  ,&. ,I
  
", , #, 
&(&2 
 "   
"( " 
 &  , ,&.    ," 
"
"(  #   ,
"( c.""
&&25??++c.  
, & ***? ) ?)***  92 , 
+  
"
&& #, ,
 "   "  ,

"( 
 
 2& "
&   "

&
9&  , "   2 ,&." ??/0    
  #,
"    ,

"( > ,.
   ," >
 ,&
&

"

&
9& 
&&"   &  
 #++c#9 5
, .5###
",, 
"( ??.9&" " & 
 " >,
92++c
 ,4  
 >#&&9
   " 
.9&"
#
  
 
"(  


&&&>
 .9&"E ,, &  .
  + &
c"  2
 +c5 +cK1 
 
 
 /  " /> . 9&  ,  "  
&
 &
#
 ,  
  ,
& >
"(  .  >
",&0.& 
   /,
 ...
"( 
  
  F

2>

 "&& >0
#, ,

0&
 2  #
  "  2
 .  '
   #F 2>/ "  
.        ,

"(0"
 &>#, # &   ,4c &2 9 " 0
&
&
 2 #Q ( 2>/  
 "  

"(   # ( ,
 "  c  ,: 
#  >.   ,A 9
,  9  "  , # (
.      > +c&
 ",-.
 8 
>
. 
 
 ",&. 

  ,  ,  ,  0  "> ,. 
,
""&&25??
(   ,    "
  ,
>",&. 

0   I??  
 ,&
 ?   
   &  
.,2I??"  ,  ? 
   "

0   
&    "  (   
 0# , I??= ( " 



9
 
& "
&>
>
&
 

&&
#  "    2 "  ",&0.& 
  +cK1 
  E ,.

 

4cc . 9&    8  "


?
 
"( " c " , ".    ,
c "

. 
 >4cc,
  8  " !" 
,

 ?

  )
"( " 







Trafficking victims are given Priority One in the USCIS ± refugee caps ensure a tradeoff with Iraqis
D.O.S. 2k ± 4c .
  c

O, .5" ",
   " &
&  M& 4cM -cM- 
M6  M6& .P" 

= ,  &&    ,# & 


2> ,4  c

9& .  


" 
&&  ,; ,  >
 &   "
&2 , &    2 ""  &2> ,8  > " &
 # , ,  > 

&"&   , 9   #, 
29
   ,4c
",2
, , ,
9&,   # &# . " .   2
2 > ,4  c
,
  &   ,  &2

 
. "   
..&"
 # ,  ,
 , E"& ,# &#

. " .   22  "  



"


  &    ,
 ,  #, 
  
 ,


" "   ,4c ,

""  ,4c

 & 8 
,. " .   
 .  "
&&2  &"     ,     & # &# 
2> ,4  c

 
,,
.   2 
  & 
9&
& 
 ," "  &"   
 
""  #    ,
4c  & . 
 
&#, 


#  ?
? (
    ,cW 
 
  #  8   2- 6 
&&2> ,#  

C
? (D924+9"
  ,
  ,2
 ,

& 
20.  "  ,"  2   &, 
*Note: the duties of the INS have since been transferred to the USCIS


 ^
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± USCIS Is Normal Means


USCIS is the agency charged with providing asylum and processing applications for trafficking victims
Kibble 9 ± :
> . 2  " >-"   
 4c
 
 /  "
O
>###"  "&9. #   (99& MM "P" 

/
 4cc
 ,.  ".
&
 "",
# ,.  
  & "  
"(  /. 
, ?  

  &( # 
C  8  ">D

 " "  
"(   
   ,4  c
 , ,"
  2.  ?

> "&  ,
4
 
",  ,"
" >#
 ,"   

4cc
A"

..&"
   ?

 &
 
 
&B" "
 

"  

8  ">#,",.
   C" ?"  
..
",D

   
"( , ?

. &  ?     & 
"( "   8  "  ,
#
 

?

&& # , .
  +
& ,
+
c " C" 2D"   ,
 ,2"

""
&9  
 "  ,
0  
  
&
 ?

"

& 
A  , 
  ,
 &
#&. 
 
 . 
  " &2. &
 &
 








USCIS normal means for sex trafficking victims and T-visas


USSC[ accessed 9 ± 4c   " 
, &"1, .
O""F  >, .5###""9  
"(  . , &P" 

 E ,.

 c " 4cc" 
# ,/ 
  8  ">
 .
2
2 .
 > " #, 

"
2

" 
 ,. "    , 
"( 4cc
& 
#
 ?

>
."
&  ?2

 "  
"( #,",#&&
&& # , 

A  &
&. 
   "
. &9& 2

 º
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± Tradeoff Internal Link


USCIS is processing backlogs that were previously held up by security concerns now ± but applicants
with Middle Eastern-sounding names are more likely to get pushed to the back of the line
[ernal 9 ± & >/  #F (8 
OF  >, .5 #A (.  " % 9?
?","(?. 
?#&&?&
?9
"(& ?
2?"P" 

4cc
 "  
2 ,
 , #  
E
 

(  &

&  ,4  c
#&& # 9   "  ,;1,4c E ,.

 c "

,
C 
&&& D . 

( ,. " ","( 


   ,;1

9
>3"( ,;1B

&

,"(8 
92 ,4cc>9 
& 92 , 
 "   9
"(  ","( . .&#, #
 # (  ,
&   >
 
=, +  "  >  9
 
6  "
 

&E
 >
""    ,;1B#9 1 

. " 
&& , 
"&  ,2 
  c. 9 >,;1
2 ,
 , #

  
","(  3 
  ,4cc" 
 
9
"(& >#,"," 
 
&&
2  ,
..&"
 . "  ,4cc
 ,2
#
   ,;1 "&
. .&B  , #   !>
  9. " 
",I  ,
>
$>
,
9 .     ,
0 ,>
""    ,4cc,&
2.
(.9&" 

   ,F " .
  ."  
&

 9
"( *

   ,
 ,;1B
,"(8 
>CO &P   
 ", & 2
. &2
 # ( c 

#
    &  
  , ,  # (   2 > "
 
&"  2
> ,2
  ,",
"  Dc 
  

,.
  F "B
 > ,=
,  8  .9&,
 
& F !>*
""  ,;1 9 C " .  D
 C. , 

#, .&
292 , &D+ 
 ..   ,8  B 
&>C,
6
D=+Bc

@; &
,
> 
29 ,
  "9 # 
3"(.
, " E ,.

 # ?2
  " 
 . 
2 
,
,
&  ,=
,  

 )
2
>
>
  , &.  >,
,&. .

 "& " . .&#, &
"("
& 
"# 2

 > 
,
>#, #
9  
>
..& 9" 
4c" E +
..&"
 #
   ,;1 #,
, &,
9 

  9
"(  ","(>
 
,

,,
 ,
  ,9 
 "






USCIS procedures ensure easier cases are taken up first ± sudden increases in the number of applications
means backlogs grow and go unaddressed
Murthy Law Firm 8 ± 
 '
#
O
2>, .5### ,2"  # M, , , &P" 

 2 
"( #&. 9& ,
 &&.   ,4cc " 

""


&& "
 ; 0
.&> " ,
 9 

9" 

&
9&>9
.  ," 
 &"   , ,&2 -c7
1&&  > ,
&& #3
&2 .  "
 9
.. 

&& #  ,
&   #"
# , ,4cc  
&&2
2 #, >#,   ,H9
"( H .  "

.. 
&> ,H  H

&  .  
"". 
2"
# ,.   2
.    ," 
   ,7
1&&  ,4cc
9& &  ,
" 
& 9  ?!*$

..&"
 &>
 
&&9
.  , -c7
1&&  >#,",#
   &" 

&
9&
 9  "
 ,

.  
 
2 
.. 
&,> "
#,  , 
 

..&"
  " ,
 , 

 9 
" 
&&2

&
9&#,",#,
,
..   ,  )> , &  

9
"(&  "

2
..&"
,
 #
  
&2
9  , 
..&"
 "
9
A"
>
 , 

.&2  ,
 9  
&& # "

.. 
&-  ,&
 
&2
 , &  
 ? # 9
"(&  "


  2 
..&"
 
,
 ,
 "2
9& . " 
  ,. 9&>H ,4cc,

 . 
. "  
2 ,
 " " .&  "
#, 



&2

&
9&
 # ( "
  ,.  A ,  
.. 
&>H#,  
 9 
2 

&
9&=,
 ,
 ,
"

 ## ,   
  ,

&
9& 2 
 9 
> 2 , 
   > ,2

 
2 
.. 
&,2
 , 
" .  " ,
 9 9" 

&
9&>#,"," &9
2 ,  2
&
 




 Ñ
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± Tradeoff Internal Link


U.S. backlogs are filled with Iraqi refugee applications
Husarska ±  >  . &"2
 
 , 

&"  
OF !>, .5### , "  # ?"

&%!, &P" 

; && # 
9

 "  "  ,

 
. &+&&> ;9 
2 ,1,
 
 
 " ,
. )>
3 # &9
&& #    ,"  2 ,2
, > "  >
9
"(&  
3

#
   9
   ,4cc  ,
 
 , ,
3"(&2 " 
 , 9   # 
 1 
, 9 
" 
&&2&&  ;9 
2 A ,  
",, .
  + &
c"  2??#,",,
 " &2 " ,& %
3#
   9. "??

 " 
2 ,
 H.  
..  ,
..&"
   
&2%
3H1   , 9 

..         ,
 +c.   0. A "
 

& $. .& .& , 
&c 
#, ,  +c

, 
%> 
..&"
 &  

#&&
" 
&&2&   ,. 
 , 9 
 &&9&
(F )
3,

 
"  ,"  2   ,.
 ,  ,  ,
,

9 #  #
 ,
  , #"
&2
 -"  +c ."(. ,.
"






Iraqi refugee applications are easily backlogged ± the government sees them as big security risks
IPS ±   8 c "
Oc. !>, .5###"   
 
",)!!)%P" 

H
& #, #
  ,#
# ,
3>#
     9& ,
  "
,

 

& 9&
  
  ,
3#, ,
" 
 &2
..    "
    
3
#, &
 . &

 & >H
: 2>#, 9&&# &" 
$>."
&

 
3#, 

  # ( # , ,4c??  %$>
3"  &2# (
  , .
    "  9?"
" 
& ??92
&& #  ,0. 
 #
  &  , , " 
2&
..&"
   ,4c     
 (  

 , , 
&924+,c
 .
  ( . #

& # , ," 92
 9

 F
1; &2
 ,  " 
 
3; &2
 
.& 
#, #&&"   , &  

&


 
 
 ,

&=
 &&
#
 " ,
9

  +
 , .
  + &
c"  2
& 
 " ,
' c"
&
99
# &&& , # &   
  
3
  

  
  ,
..   >

+ &
c"  2c" 
2",
&, 
.  0.&
  ,9
"(&   
..&"
 92   ,
H#
& 
 9 &  ,"  2 (
 "
# ,
    #
? "  >."
&&2"  
 &
92&
 9     H


 Y
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± AT: Iraqis Streamlined Now


Slightly improved security in Iraq means Iraqi refugees are no longer streamlined and must be considred
case by case
Human Rights First 9 ± ?.  > .

 

&,
 ,  
E

O
2*>, .5###,
,    9&  $ ?
?
3? ?? ? 
&&2? #, &P" 

4+,
    ,
"  2,
.  "
&2 , ,  
3>
 .
"&

,9 #  , .   ,
B. ." ,
9  ,


  ,  ,
  ,#   
 &? 9
4+ #
2  ,
  
&"  2  ,  ,

 ,

3#, & ,, &


 
"
&&29"   >9   
, &9
& # , 
"
92"
9
     ,2
"
 
&. "  ",
  ,.
" " ,
B9  .&
" ")1   ,  .
>  , . 4+" 9
 2

& 
 >#,  & 
" 
& . .
# ,.  2 , ,   ,"  2>& 
 ,

"  &2&
2 & # &&,
 ,
9& 2 . 
  
,  >
 ,    . & &" . "   &,  
&& ,> ,4 &&
  
 
" 

&. "   
&&


3& 1
,

 ,  "
&.
  ,"  2G ,    ,
 
A  2   



 ë
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± Middle East Instability Internal Link


Failure to provide asylum for Iraqi refugees will cause massive flows in the MidEast that destabilize the
region, increase radicalization and terrorism, and trigger wars
[yman ±
&>c  ;&& #>;  8 &"2>c
9
   &/
 8 &"2
O $>, .5### &#9  #=1c;9c //?)1cF@-. " P" 


&2 
& 2

2"   ,   ,&/
 G.
"&
&2  ,"
 
3Q  ,  

#,  , ,  ,  
3
&  ,9  .    "
K& ?     5
.    ,
3 "   , 
9&E  ,  c 
> ,9
  ,4  c
,
 "  ,
 
3#, ,
# (# ,4c.& 


 & >



&

  & , , , 
&
 #
."
&9 >   . 9& 2    , ,4  c
, &
"".     , 
  
 

 " 
 , 
A . #    ,
=
,  , &
&   

. 
 9   ,"
.
" 2  ,9  
 ,   
.   , 9"  
  "  
9& 2& , ,"

& 2 .  
 ,,
& > 
3


&   

  0     ,
&& 
3G 

&. .&
  )&& G,
& ,",
>
 , 9  # 2
2/  
3,
& , , 9 
,
  &  , .
 
3> , ", "
&&2
   ,&
9&H Hc 
> ,
,
"&   
 "&  
3>.
"&
&2 c2 

F 
4c  ,&. , ,

 9&  0  ,4  c


 9 ,
&&2
9,  
,
 

(  9
&2  ,
>
3 9 #&& . &29   , > 0 2
5
 "
. "
 " 
  , 
"9  &2#,  ,
9 &2& #9

"  


"
&&2&&?
 
9
  ,  
 , 9 > ,4c
&  
9&,"  2 
3  , 
&
 , , ' 
&&2&&  . .&,
&  , "" "
">
 ,4  c
9
",  , . 9& 2 "

2>  

9&2>
2 ,
 ,2"
 &  
" " 9  
9& 2 
3>9  ,

  0"  ,9
  2 ,&. , #, "    8  
  
& . 9& 2> ,4  c
  
(      "

"

(,!*
&#
  .  ". "  ,
)> &  %2
&
 > ,   &&   ,
&   & , . 9&,8
&  
 " 
" 9  #
9 # 
&
  ,9  $%>%)>
*>
#&&
 
&K" 
  . 9&;#

3 
 " .
  ,
  ,

,    ,>9  ,  . ."  ,
 ,2#&&    
3 &
 9   , 
   # & 9 .  >2
  #>&&  
3 &&&   , , "  2 

'
 & #"
  
  ," 

, # > ,. 9&#&& 
..
#  # , ,8
&  
. 9&>
3K " & 
   
&" 

 ",
 , 
.,"
(. 
&& #
(
>.  #,

& 
2
&"
. & "
&9
&
"- && 

3 
9

&
   F 
K. .&
  & ,
%&&   > , .&29   , #
# , ,5;,   &# , " 9




&
 ",

"(9
"(  , , "  >#,& , #,   ,  "   ,,   ,
K #9
   ,#

 " !> 0
.&>+ . .
&  ,9    "
".9&"   
"   &
 "," ?9  


  #

K # ?&   >#,",,

  ,,+ ,   "    "
.>  ,
9
 #,", .&
> 
E>
&
 ",

"(  .  &2> , ##

   9
 

"( ,"
.>. ".
 
"&#
   ,
&  ," &&
.  ,

 , 
 ,
, && ,9     
2 2   #

& 

"(92 ,   0.&   ,  , 9
&  ,   K9,
&    ,
?
3#
  ,*>


3

#, ,
& , 
 ,

. 02
2> ,1
  .>

  c

K
3,,  ,
    
3>

2,
A   ,
3. &"

&
2c 
3. & "
 &&
"" ,  .   &2# (  
"
."

& 9 "9
     .Q   G9 >
9  >

""  
# &  & . & "G


& "  
28
&  
 & "( A      .>.   
"
& &    ,
 &
&
.  
  , .&, .
"&&2-  > "

& 
"
&E ,. & "  , ,  
  '9
   ,
&2)> ,.  " 
, 
 
8
&  
  ,"  2 
9&29"

"   . & "
&
., ,"  2 #
"&#
 8
(
 
2>" 

 ,H
&9
E
 H  ,"  2>
   "  ,#
2 #,",8
(
K..   ,

,
 #,   ,"   ,
&9
  ,,
" 9
"( ,
 8
(
c"

 >"9 9 >
 & 
"
&
 #
  

. 
&  8
(
,
 

  9    
3   ,4  c

" 
9&>9   ,  "  " 8 & "
&&2>


?
?  & . 
 .  

  
&   ,4c  9  

9& 2 
3 ?
 .#&&,
&292.
, "    ,
#, &
  , 
  #, 
9 ,
9
&  9&  

". ." >
(   "
 " 
  & #G
 
&, ,
 &
1
,
 
& 
>F 
>9 A.

",
" & 
9 9 c
&=,
K >   , #, 
(,&    ,4  c
#&&,
9 
"
&E 
3>
(  ,.  
&"

 
&
 . ,
#,  .
 4c &=,& ," " 
3  
&> ,2 K   #, "
K
& . 9& 2
 , 
 
" ( ,
&
 & #"

&  
&
9& 2-  & "   ,-  &2 .
 
8 
>#,",9 , ,    , 
 7
  &  ,4  c
G #,  
&&29"
 &4c" E  
   
&& #  
3  &, >9    
3  
&
 "
&# &
&  .  , 
#
& ,2"  
  ,&/
  
"".  
3 & / .  , "     ,  > ,# &9 
(. ,.  
&&2
 " "
 
& 
3K9  > "  , ( ,
 , " &9 "   
    &&
 . # &
&  " ,&(&,  ,
 , . 9&# &
"
&E ,  ". & " F 
>c2 
>  ,  
&,  4 & ,4  c
#&" 
  > K &(&2 ,
=
,  #&&9
9& 
"  " , =  
   .  ,  c 
&&#&&,
  
&

"" " >#,&" .& 
"2"
., ,     

"c && , " &
&
 . 
"
&.. 
 , ,&.&&#,  ..  ,
#

"  "E ,4c "".
 ,   ,  . & "
&&2.
&

9& ,
    " ..   ,4c&
2  
2 > ,4  c
  " 
 

 ", "
&

" 
3K ,9 >.
"&
&2F 



& 
&&  ,8 
6&,"   9
9& . &" "   
9  ,
 , 
& 
2
2 "
& "
 " .& &2  #,&92 , #

&c " , . 9&&(&2  #
 ,4  c

#
 #   "># 9  ,

" #  .    2    ,9
 >.  & ,


 &
 &2  
3K ,9 >, .  ,. 9&#&& & &1 
#K&
  ,&/
 >, . 
. &"2

 "
  2   & ,. 9&9 
", 
 "  .   ,
.  > #&&9 &





Failure to provide relief to Iraqi refugees triggers instability in the region and provokes conflict
Loescher 2 ± 6&>, 

&     c
"c >'  
O ">, .5###""?" 841'-c# (%).P" 

,."    #" &" 


 # & #,

& 
2 
&2,,   
&" " 
9    
 
9& 28
 0.  "  ,
 ,  
& .   , 

&"   2#&&9    ,
  
   ,   

 
"&
 , 
&2 .

 
   ,
3 
&&1 
3B ,9 ,
& "
.
" 2

3
 
 "   
9 9  ,  

&
 9   6  , " "" 
  
&

 
" 
2  ,
"  >  
& " 0."  ,    .  # , 
& 
 "  


&
9&  ,  # " E ,>  &(&2 ,
 ,"  #&&9
9& . 
3
. "  



" &
 9    
. &  # ,  0   

&

"

 ëR
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± Middle East Instability Impact


WMDs have changed the calculations ± MidEast conflict will lead to extinction
Nassar 2 ± 1
,>
9 
   6->
 ?
8 .&Bc &
2- 
E

O $>(2 .
.    9
 
&  8
"
+
,  / .
 ,&/
 >, .5### & 9
& 1
,

, P" 

=
  ,&/
 
 
 # 2.;  &2> ,.    "&
#
. 92 ,4  c

 ,c  
4  ,
.   ,>   ,9
&
"  , "&
  > &
 ", #


  
", ,   ,&
/
 > ,.    "&
#
. 
 , #
.  
 "  &
 &
2"&
,
#
  
 
&
 #
.  
 "  > ,4  c


&
 &
2 " .   ,  
"3   ,>#,& ,2   

   ,  # #
.  . 
&2 , 
  , 
 1  ,. "  >. &
 
 , 


 #
.   
  "   "&
","
&
9 & "
&

  ,
A & 9
&. 9&#,"," &&
>&  ","(>  ,0  "   & 


,     ,& ",

"     #
> ,"  #
  ,&/
 
.&
& 9
&. 9&

"
&
 , 
   
  &  ,


 ë
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± Turns The Case (Generic)


Failure to process backlogged applications depletes the USCIS budget
CIS ±  E ,.

 c "
OF >, .5###, 0&9
2
 c-1M 
&M. M).P" 

,"   " .&  ,"  9


"(&    *>? 
. 
( 
&
&.  >4cc &2&
2  , 
9&
> " > " 
  ,"    ,
 "2 . " ,"


  ,
L$&&  
2>9
 4ccB"   
0.&
   . .  &%1"

..&"
.
  ,.   #,  ,2
.   

# 9  .  2


> , .
2   "   
2B"     4cc"   . " ,/
",
2
 ,
. " &
2 ,"   4cc#&& " 
   ,  
  ,
 
""    &
 ,> ,
"  ,
4cc
"
. "
",  ,.    " "&  #
", 92. &"2    "
&&2 #






That turns the case ± USCIS funds are tight for 20R0 ± budget problems hinder the ability to process
refugees
LOC 9 ± '9
2   
O+ . ?$)? /8/-;+-/' c/4Q88-8-c1''>>, .5### , 
 "?
9 ".3 2@U9
T".UT". % U  TU M T, $)U TU&T-M!!) UP" 

,   4  c
 E ,.

 c " 4cc . "
&&

 ?
9   .     ,4  c
I

A"


&E
  3 I.  

&"  2
  &
 
 I&

 
A"
 9
"(& I
.&  &   . 
 "   "4cc
& 

 9

& " 


 &

 , 
&#, ,

..& 
 9  /-/ -,   "  L!*>> "  
2
.. . 
  4cc>L%>>9& # , 3 &&
L!%>%>
9  ,
  .  
 3 > ,  . L$>> " .& /' ,9& . # ,  ,4cc
.. . 
 >9 # ,, & ,   9&
  &4cc> " A "  # , ,c
 c
 . 9& & .  ,2 >9 


0.   .&
, # , # , #&&9 &E"9& #> ,  . O ,  && PL>>  , 3 O # ,  

0&& PL%>> .
2 . "  
..&"
 

2&"&
   # , "  
 "
  , ,   , . > ,  
.     

"  
 
"  9"
  ,6K "   " 9  ,,  
 -" "    , .  
 . 9&  
 (
 , 
 

"   4c/;//;4 / 8-6c,
9  
 ,
4cc#&&
(L>$ > > ? 0.    "
&2
>#,",
 ,    ,  "  
2 3  . " 
2&> >
&
2

&E
   .
92.  

,  " " 


9  

..&2  


 9  "     ,
A  2 4ccK   ">
.. 
A"
  
..&"
  
 9  

.   
"  


&
."   ,? 0.    
   "
&2>4cc  ,

&& %. " 9& #. A"  
  ,  0 , "
&2
>
" "
 " & "
& "
  ,
  #&&"   9
9& #. A"  #&& "
&2
1
  ,  K

&2># ,   .

&",
>"
&2
. " "  
20"" &&"  
92
&
 L>>=,& ,     " &2" &4cc
 ,  > 9& ,
 ,
 "2, &"  "  9 9
 
".
  >


".
"  4 &(
 " #,",     
.. . 
   "&&92&&
 .""
.. . 
 >4cc..  9
&
"  .
 # ,
,   " &&"   "  
 & > ,  "
  " " ". 4cc ,
 ,  2 
0.    ?  .
  ,
# &9.. 92. A"   ,  
&  9& ,
4cc,
 .  ,.9&"
# ,

&

&2 #, ,  , # .&
 
A 
..&"
  
" 0.    
,
",  
&1 -"1-9
&  
. A" " &&"  
L>$>>>#,", ,&23
&  

,1-. A"  
 ,"  ",& 
 
..&"
 ",

  
""   

,9  
>  , ,

",
 
"  ,"   . " 
..&"
 >
2&"&
> &
2

&E
 & 
&2> ,4cc9 
 ,
 
" &&"  #&&90.  . " 
..&"
 >
2&"&
>
&
2

&E
 >
 ,
 , . " "  #&& " 
  &

2
"   # ,>.
2
>



&E
 ," &"   
  ,  & >" 9 # ,
&
"( 
& &
2

&2  ,.
 4cc>
( 0". 
&&2"&   ,  
 ,.9&"   
 ,    & (
 4cc






New refugee programs are unfunded mandates that deplete the USCIS budget, destroying agency
effectiveness
CIS ±  E ,.

 c "
OF >, .5###, 0&9
2
 c-1M 
&M. M).P" 

,4cc   "     ,.  ".


&",
&&  " 
 &2& 2 
  "
,
  #,",4cc 9
    
"  2
"  4cc .
 > "&  ,
9& 2 5
.&  #. 

. "   
I9   
  ", & 2
 , 
 
  I
 .&

  ,    

 ,
4cc9&? , "&"    ,"   . 
 #,", ,
 "2",
 >>
C  

>D",

2&
 . " 
4c
 "

&E
 & >
#&&
 .

&  ,

  
  ", & 2  E
 

 ëë
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± Turns Human Rights Credibility


[ringing in Iraqi refugees key to U.S. human rights credibility
Human Rights First ± ?.  > .

 

&,
 ,  
E

OF >, .5###,
,     , M# , = M$$, P" 

,4  c
,


       ,. " 


"  ,"  #
>
    ,
%&&   ")$
 2 #,
 
&&2   .     
3 >  &  &2
 &
3&
  ,,4  c
    
2
3 ,&. ,4c9 #&& 

",&.      ,"  #> ,. "    > ,


9& 2  ,  >
 ,
&" 9& 2  ,4  

c


&&
 ( .
    ,4  c
 &
 , 

&"   2 
  ,"  
" . , 
     ,  
"  +
, ;    
 ,&. 
3 
 

">%>$+;
..  A   "
&&  4cc
 " .  
9.

9&& "92c
/#
: 2
6  c ,,C  
3" D#&&
&& #. " 
3#, ,
"&    ,4  c
? ,  , ,# ( 
, ,
&2? 
..&2 " &2  ,4c . 
,9&&
& " 
$>."
&
 
3#, # ( " &2# , ,4  c
>

( ,
#. "  , #, 
   
  
,;
&&2> 
( ,c" 
2 c
 

,   &
 9  
3 & .& ?   &  

.
"(
 ,&. ,
 
A  2  , #, #&& 
   ,   

& .
# (# ,"    ,  

#

   , # " 


    
 B
&" 9& 2



U.S. refugee leadership key to our human rights credibility and successful global refugee settlement
Human Rights First 8 ± ?.  > .

 

&,
 ,  
E

O ">, .5###,
,    .*!?cQ?
2&?9&.  .P" 

,4  c
,
& 9  "  E

9
"  , .

 2  ,. " 
  ,# &,
   
.    "   & >. & "
&> , "
 ,   . "  "
&     2


 "     

."  ,
  2,, ""   "  " &
& 9&
  #,", ,4  c
,

9" 9

2  ,%)8 " &  ,$    &
   ,c
 > ,4  c
,
.&     . .& .&
"#,  , &   # &9 , 
 9"
  , 
"> & >


& 2> "
& . . & "
& .  , 

&&
& 9&
 #
.&  
&&2  ,"  * ) , # 
.. 0
&2!&&  # &#> ,
 
A  2.&
"  , , &
 

1"
    2
,9  "  - &2

&&. "
  ,
& 9    , 
2&   
&E"  '
 2
>$>). .&
..& 
2&  ,4  c
I$>)# 
. "  



  

 &
 ,. & "
   

& &  . "  >4c 
  
  ,& 9
&

=, 4c&
 ,.
&  > ,


 >
 
" " 
 (


 ë
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± Turns Refugee Leadership


Asylum in the U.S. for refugees fleeing wars is uniquely key to U.S. refugee leadership and an effective
international refugee protection system
Schoenholtz 5 ±   #> . 2  "   ,      ,c 2  

&
 
 
", 


 &
#
. &"2
6  # '
#
Oc.  > &9
+
, '
##>'/VcP" 

,
#   ,
& # +
 

2&(  
&. "  $%,

. "      ,4  c

  , &#,   ,  
=,& ,",
&&  & . ",,
 . 9& 2
 "
> ,8  K &  9 ,,
. .&#,  . "  

 , , 

&&
 ,. & ,
 ,4  c
  .    " 
  , 
 . " 
6  ,
   (
2& & . 
$)> ,&
 ,. &"  "
& 
" 
 

&. "  2 ,4  c
"

& , #&
 ,.92. "   & " &"     ,
2&( #, 
(. "    ,4  c
"  ","  =,& ,4  c
. "  , # ,
#&&?  
 . "  >4c&
#  . 
2,



 
 
&9
  , #, ,

#&&  
 
,
&  .. "  . 
 ,"     ,c" 
2 + &
c"  2>9   ,
,,&2. & "
&  
   . " . .&& 
   "&" &" $*=,& ,4  OW %!Pc
 
&&2  . ",


,  ,
&
", 
&# ,   , > ,4  c
, &
9&,

> ,&
#&
 ,# ,   ,  
2  ,4  c

. &&, 

 
&,



 . "  , & "&" &" $




Resettlement of Iraqi refugees key to U.S. refugee leadership


Taft ± F&
>   "   , 
 "2
(; "   ",  & 


" 
2

 . .&
 > 


OF )>, .5####
,  .  " #.?2 "  
"&)%)%)%, &P" 

  2& , (   ,,9



#&
 #(>
= &
2.
>
 & # ,
  9&"
"  ,4  c
 ,# &K    " 9  

 &>
#,

&#
2
(  ,&
   &  Q   "  2,
  ,9
  ,&. ,
3
" 
,

0&  
 "&
  ,#
2  ,   & >#,
9& "( , .
, 
 2# ,9 
"
"9
 
. & "
&, &8  
1,, && ( 
, .9&"
.  >6
&; >

0
.& 0" &
 ,. 
   "  )$8  ; 
(  " 
 
 "2
( "",
# ,  &   ",    ,4  c

1 # 
2
 ">)$>#
"

  &  ,
 >7
#, # 
 ( . "  = " ,. .&  ,
"  ". & "
& ..     
&&2> 0
.&>
& 
6 F 21 # 
 " ,
,
#
   ,
=  "
, &"
"

&& ,  9
"&9"
 ,.  ,
"      2 , . 9& 
 ,&  ,7
#, ,
 9; . 
.9&"

  "
   

.. . 
  "2 >
,  
#
    & 
; ,
  (

 "

&>", ",
2
  .   ,.  K&
 ,.# ,   .      
     ,c  ,
8
"">  
  " # (!?,  
2=,2 ,  &
    "2  ,!&& 
3.&
"
 
 @8  1,,&,
2  .
(  ," & , ,9  ,
 
 "&
 ,


3

 ..   2>
  9  &&
   2- &2 
3 
  , ,  . " 
 2  ,4  c
 
2>
 &2 
  , ,9 ,4  c
,
"    # )>"


  

> 92 ,   ,"


&2
> c. 9 ,


2
   
. " 
 &
29
"( )$=,
,
,
..    &
 ,.  ,@,
 
 

  "
#
 
2  , &
"( . & "
&#&&,
"   
2. .& , &9&&
 "&
 #(92c /#
: 2 ?

6  c ,?- > ,  
3" ># &9  ,. "92# &2.   " 

 &  .  

  , 
 (9"
  , 
 "
 # , ,4  c
,.  
& , & "  ,
>
&& "
 
  ,2
9 
3;
&&2>#  " 

 "  
  ,&/
  ,
" 9 
,   && 
3I ,# &,&.   ,
 , "

2
 ,
 ,,  "   
 #&&  (. ,   .  
  "
&
2 ,
 ,9  &    ,


3 " 

9&, &
 #,", "
     #
 ,
 &    ,
 ,  ,&>9 "    
3

 ,
   ,
 "  ,,


"   9" 
.
#  . & "
&.  " 
9   ,
     
3,#
 # , ."     " 7
 >
   #
 
 2  #  ,#
> #&"   ,. " 

 92     , ,  ,   




The U.S. started the Iraqi refugee problem ± inaction on this issue is uniquely key to refugee leadership
Limon ± '
 
>8    ,4c   

>  "   ,-" 
 & 
O###  .&
;&  
89&"
 MUM ",=cM ",)c& c .P" 

,4  c
 
"( #&  ."
& 9&
  
3  "
>#
2,
..  , 
  

3  2

   ..  ,&
2
"   "
>#
29&#, &"    &
2  &" 2 .. 

# ,
#
&,9

   " >

.

 > #&& ",
 ,
"  ,
 
&2 # && . .& ,
&  & ">  >. "  >
 "  2,


& 
"  ,

 "
,
9 
9& . "  ,. .&#,& ,2#  
3=,
9 
9& . "   .& 2  ,4c&
2> "
/9
2> "
"
" > ,


 
E
 =,
9 
9& . "  & 

#
   "& 


,
&
,  
=,
9 
9& . " 0c ?c,B

&=,
9 
9& . "   !. "  
3B. 
&"&
 ,
" .  ,9& 9& "( 

9& " 2  , >

,

 ..   2 
"".   ."
& 9&
 
0 &
 ,.  . "  , >#  >
",&  #,& ,2
 
0&=, &  ,  &29"
#9
  . 9& 2  , .&, >  &29"
  , ,  ,   >9 9"
 ,# &#
", , ## . 
#, . .&#, A     
  9&=&&#9
"    
&&
..  
&
 , @=&&#,
9,   

.
" "  .   
 " 
.  . "   , 
&
 
&

" 3 92 ,4+@=&&#
"   .. . &" ,
.    ,  ,    

&&
#
. "
. "    # &#@

 ëG
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± Turns Sex Trafficking


Failure of U.S. to take in Iraqi refugees means they inevitably must go to Syria
Arbuthnot ± ;&" 2> 3 " 9  6& 9
&
",
OF&>, .5###& 9
& 
","
 0.,.@" 0 T
U
T% *!P" 

, "
>#, " 
 ,"

 ., 
&&
3> ,. 9&# &9, #  
 #,
  " . 
  
( >H
 
H##  
(&
&
"  

   ,1  ,


# , ,
&4c
? #  ?c2 

F 
..  ,
9?
&+
 F 
+ "
& 
,", (9
"( 
 >   
>
 >" .&0#
2  ,  ?

4c?&9 9
  
3
    
  :#
 c93 &2 ,2,
,&   , ,
 


31 ,
.
2 
,
. ",4  c
?. .&
 A    && 
 F&2)?,

(  A %
3 " ,  
  1 
 >  , ,  ,

)>$
3,
"&

2& " ,  
 

That turns their sex trade advantage


New York Times
O
2> .

3  c0
 c2 
P" 

 0. 
3.    ,
,&. 
(c2 

. .&
 
  0    #
& , "  
    ,&
/
   ,"&9B.
( & > 
&2,
&  ,"
,
c
&" .&
; 

"  &2
9  0,  92"
>.
  , ,F 
>  ,c
9  c2 
>#,   &
&2
2 92
&" , &

"# ,#  >. .&


& #?"  

, , #    , 

& > "& 

 ""
> &&# (
.     

">9 >
 ?2
? &
#(  
   . c
  


3,
.,
2  ,   9 C; #,
B >). "  *. "   , &
 1
,
# ( 
 ,
"&9
+9
>0.&
  ,
 ,
 

# (  ,9  

" 
2

3>D,
C,  ,  c2 

 0.   , 
& ,2 9
"( 
3
,2B&&9&
,  >
 , , &2# (

&
9&D


 ë^
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± Iraqi Instability Impact Module


Lack of refugee resettlement destabilizes Iraq
New York Times 8
O;9$>, .5### 2 " *$#
,  $ , &P" 

C B,
 
 

9&
3#, &&  
3
&
,   ,9  "  >D
:  &Q  >
 "
&
,4  c


.& 
  ,
3 " 
#,

& (. ,
. D= ,  ,c
 .
 >  "
&>.
(   ,
 , .C2

 >

"    
2 29"
 ,2
 
 , E " ,9A" .9&"&2>
2 ,
 ,2 .&2  . 0. 
  3 ,9 & "(
" 
3#, (   

,4  c


9  
&
 . 9&
"   
3=,&
&
 9  
3,
     ,"  2  "  ,
 ,"  2 
 
,
. > ,4  
  
&
&
 2
 ,
  # && 
3,
& c2 
>F 

 ,  ,9 






Nuclear World War III


Corsi ± F >8, > "
 8 & "
&c" " +


OF
*>C=
# ,
  >D, .5#### &  
&2"  0.,.@
T86/#U.
T $ P" 


9
 #
9 
(   
3>-& #&&"
 &2
".     ,
&&
2  ,6
E

  +


 
'9

  +E9 &&
, ,
,
.. > #&& &29

   9 
&
 ,4c,
 ", "9   

c2 
,
3#
" &3"(&2.  
 
&#
># ,
&#
    ,&  
2 &
 ",

 

& ( 
 ,
" & "&
" "
& "&
#
. = ,
 
2 &  ,L9&& -? 
"? ?
 & 2  

>&
2&
 
 #&&  #
  &  

"(
 # ,


,
,
  
 A   , c,
,
 .
 8
" >#&&

,
 
92&2, & ,4c& (&(#
#  
#  
&#
  ,&/
 @#  .&2  &
 
3>,

2,
 ,     
  
#
 "
 
&&9
  
&#
" &
&2&
 
 , 
# &#
>",
= &=

9




 ëº
c 
  

Iraqi Reugees ± Terrorism Impact Module


Failure to take in Iraqi refugees ruins U.S. credibility in the region
Delahunt 8 ± 4c. 

O;9%>'/VcP" 

=,& # # 
.
,


" # ,.   " 3 "> K   &2
 , 
  ,
  ?
?
?,
&
&& 
3#, 
 
2 ,     
3> 
 ?"
&& 8> 
&&2.&
".  >. 
&2

 &   ,"

"&
  ,
,
 ""  
3   ,.
 2
# &9  ,
 ,

 
& 2. 

& . 9& 2  ,
 
 
 ,  > #"
 2 ,
 ,
.. 0
"
  ,,

2 , 
  
3
 
  
,  9&92
2 ,
 ,


 "
?
" -  . > ,  > 9 &2>"
&&2?   "?? .&29"
  , >

&"  #, #


. .&
  
&>9 9"
 #&&
& .   , ,    , ##
#  ,
 



That¶s key to solving terrorism
Pan 4 ± ",
&>  . &"2

&2  

&"  2
 

&. &"2
 ,    "
8  
O!>, .5###
 "
.   !*9%$**, &P" 

=,2" 9& 2 .


@,"  
&#  " " 9& 2 " 9& 2K
(>9  , 
&.  5 ,#
   "
9#  ,   
,# &   ,4  c
  ,
  ,#
   > ,1,
 
  
"&

  ,# &K
 5HQ K  , # ,> 

  H   , 2
> 
..
 ,

 #
# ,
=,&  "
 
&#
2
.  &>#"
  , . "     &#"     
& = ,  
 &

  

&" .
 >#"

 , ,   " &2 # + K#,25Wc"   ,# &K. ,
  c"  2  
c  .&
""  ."  . # &#    . ?"  ). "  4c?9  "
 - &2
#  ,.&


,4  c
  # (# , ,  
. # &#,
   ,. 
,"  &  c.
".
,
2 .  / .

>9 &
"(
2.   ,&/
 
 "& &2   "


 

&"   2 3"(&20.
 ,. 
  " ,,& 
9& 2  ,# &K. W && . &
 ,. c
26 . " &2
" "& ,
 , , 
 
 "&


"(", 
  ,
 ,.9&" 
&E- &2& 
 ,
"   
    ,8 &
 c"  2  
8c>

 .. ,.  #
.  
 "  # &#,
  "
&& .
".
  8c 90    ?-"  >.""
&&2

,
   " 
,.> ,4  c
 " .    ,&

  ,& 3    ,
#, "

&#
 
9 

 

 - , #>
4  
 c"  2  "&  &    4c" 9& 2(2 "  "  
 >.
"&
&2 ,   "

 ,&/
 > .
".
  ,8c  


 .. # ,  ,c"  2  "&W       ,#
     &  &2.      

"(9  ,2 "" >9 
&        
" 

  ,# &,
  . #   ,
 ,4  c
 H 
",  >&   >
# (# , , "   ,
"
,&.H=,& ,
 
 ,
 
 &
 ,.# ,8
(
>   
&  # (# , ,  #
(


 ,

,
     >",
,


c

9
W  .     
"
&  # (c
&&
    2"
 

 

"(c ">L&&     
 ,
9 
E>  &2 
9
>9  ,E 
,


"
&&2& # #& &

&  
&92 ,4  c
 ""    ,  >H& &

& E ",
 # 3 #
  .  9 9 .  " >
&
  ,&   . 
 , 
&&2    ,
& & 2
" 
&&2 E H
 & >H# &#
  E,
 9 
3
&2  "
,
9 
&2" " HW1 
( .   "  "
   "  

,4  c
  && "  , 
9 ,& #?
,,? ","  "
 " 
928
(
 
, ,  
  ,
   ,
9    4c
"
&     


    -

9 '
 K& #? ",
 "  "
  , ",
.  

  ,9
"( 
 (2 3 ( #&  , 
 Wc,
  ,9  ,4  c
"  &2,
> . 
,

>9 -K 

&c"  2; "
".   &2%>$ %> "& " 9    ,4  c
 
3> ,4c,
 "& & 

&,&.    ,L!!!9&& 9&&,&" 9& 2

,4  c
,
> ,& , 

&"   2#&&#
 # (# ,>
 , ##&&,
 .
2,.  
>H=
,  
,&O  P 
3 #  ,
 ,    ,      # " H1  2
2># ,
 ,      # " >
#&&
 ,

>c2 
> ,8,&.. >& 
>
  
="
  
& 

 .
 
 
#   " 9& 2
"  "  







Extinction
Alexander 2 ± Q
,>c  ;&& #
  "   , 

&    c 
O*I, .5####"#"  .   , &P" 
,c. 9 >

"(  ,4  c
,
 
 ,
  ,
  
&29" 
. 
 
  " .
2&,
 2
#&
  
2. .&> ,
9& 2 
2 > ,,
& ,
.
" " "

& . > ,0.


   "
"2>
  
& "&E
  &

&& , 
 92 ,.,    
2K   
9   
E> . 
&>


9  3.. ,
 , , "
&"   .
", & "
&& .    #
 ?
 , . 9& 
","
&>9 & "
&>
 "&
 & " 
",
 .   . & "
&   &
 
&. 9& 2,
  
  
 #


"29 ?  
 #
   ,.  
&",
&&   , 2 
& "&E
 


 ëÑ
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± Morality Impact


The U.S. has a moral obligation to resolve the plight of the Iraqi refugees
Delahunt 8 ± 4c. 

O;9%>'/VcP" 

# # 
.
,


" # ,.   " 3 "> K   &2
 , 
  ,
  ?
?
?,
&
=,&

&& 
3#, 
 
2 ,     
3> 
 ?"
&& 8> 
&&2.&
".  >. 
&2

 &   ,"

"&
  ,
,
 ""  
3   ,.
 2
# &9  ,

,
 
& 2. 

& . 9& 2  ,
 
 
 ,  > #"
 2 ,
 ,

.. 0
"
  ,,

2 , 
  
3
 
  
, 9&92
2 ,
 ,
 "
?
" - 
. > ,  > 9 &2>"
&&2?   "?? .&29"
  , >
 &"  #, #


. .&

  
&>9 9"
 #&&
& .   , ,    , ##
#  ,  






The U.S. displaced the Iraqi refugees ± we have a moral obligation to solve their plight
Downes ± /&
>c
=   >1-c--''/6/+ =-' '=F-4'
Oc.  >1  , = &'
#F 
&>'/VcP" 
  ,*>
"   ..  4c  &  
& "

  , 3
&
..&"
  
 2. "    
 ,
,


. &"2  
&  "& &2   . &"2    ,
 2 &&  . " 


,2 
 "   "2 " 9    & "
.,

& ,
 &&   , , # ,  

.  "   & "


"  . "  ,

 ,
9 
 
  ,4c  &  
3>. ,
.# ,  
 
 "  ,
"  ,
 ,4  c
 ,
 

 "".
3c /#
: 2 ?
0.  ,   . 9& 25H, 
#   ," & 2 ,

   

>
 ,2"
9  & (  "
9
,
2 . 9& 2  , .&, =,

"&
 9&
   .   


,&.",

 9&"   
 , "     H 



 ëY
c 
  

Iraqi Refugees Disad ± AT: U.S. Residency [ad


Joblessness among settled Iraqi refugees is on the decline and is irrelevant since the alternatives to U.S.
asylum are much worse
P[S 9 ± 89&"1
"
  c "
OF >, .5###.9 #  #
& 
" ?0
  #
3? !*!P" 

,4  c
  &
3 
&(",
>#,",,   ,
 B&
 
9
&"   1 # , , . " 
 .& 2 
  ,

>
,   &
2 
 " , 
&   ,&2>
3
9   "   , 

# ,&

"   &(/&
A   ,  (  c
  >
 " &(+  >0
?#,  , .& 2 && . &#
% . " C=
"

"(, #&  
(. .&  A 9>D


>  "  c "
  
 ,   +  C #

( 
. .&
0
 , 
#,&>9  ##B 9
"(  ,  ,>#,",#& 
9  "    ,
 ,2,

# (0.  "  ,4  c
D  
 ,    # ,
2 && "
 >9     ,  2&&# (  

"     "( #
, C=B
&#
2

  "&  ,
 ,

  
>9  
& 

  
#, 
   2&&A 9>D

C,4c8 
 
A 9. 
 

. .  . .& & 


.&
"#,  ,2,
.,2"
&. "  
 , ? "&  , ,  # (D
3 >:
&c&#
>
2 . .&&(
,
 2
2 /&
A    # , &
   
2,
 9 # 2
 ,2 &  A 9>
,
2  ,#,,,
  "  1   
 

 
3    , 


 
c 
  

Politics Disad ± Obama Good ± Immigration Link


/c6c-'c/7/c;-6c=-4'  /8'//-1Bc8-''8'

Primus, R99 = &&>;   . 2
c" 
2 +
c "8 &"2  ,4c .
  +
& ,

+
c "> &
  ,   1 
8 &"28     ,1 (      
 ,4 9
    >
C
 8    ,#=&
'
#D>4   2 ="  
      
", 8  2>; "
7 &* >;
&&=  

=,
&  ,.  @Elected officials were unable to defend immigrant use of welfare>.
"&
&2cc>against ,
calls for curtailment of government expenditures on public assistance  
&
on immigrants in particular.
Immigrants¶ continued eligibility was"  politically unsustainable  ,
" 
 ""&
  ,
   . "   ,

9 "
 cc#  " E > ,
  $. "   , &&
 & &2cc ". #    
& >
 ,

2
# 
..&2 
 9  
&2
   , , ?2
 .   
9&,desire for large budgetary savings
& drove the policy
debate.
9&  
 ,
  ,; >; c
.
"
. 
> " E ,
,, .
".
 
G9  ,


&E" E 
,
& # .
".
 
G ,
 ,
?9 ,
9& "& 
 " E  
9
" > , & &>
2> "

  "  &E
 
9 # 

 ,
9   ,; 
; c
.. 
  ,cc. 
>, # >9 , " E 



&E" E ,
,, .
".
 
 ,

?9 " E ,"
  ,  
"" " &2  ,%6  1 (5C89&"'
#!?
 O ,#&
  9&&P    "
. &"2 #&
  " E    929
    " E #, 
  ,    " 
#&
9       " E 
"",
 &2  , . 
9A"  
9 # ,
 "
c

"
&"   D1  , #
&
#, "  ,
>  ,    " ,9  . 
9
>lawmakers,
decided to exclude people from assistance solely
because of their status as&
&immigrants>  ,   9  
 "0
" &2 ,


" E B,
 "

.
   ,  . 
  C.9&"",
D.  ,
,
. 
&   "  2B  , 2 ,  
 &
#,
 0.&" &2
.  &
&
 9 &9& .9&"9  ," ".  C.9&"",
D,
9 . 
&2 0"&
  2 
,4  c
G
 > ,&
  
92 , .
  c
, # ,

.. 0
&2$>

",2

  3   2
9"
 ,2"

9&, ,
 ,2
 &(&2 9" C.9&"",
D+ # > "

,
9 
&
&  "> ,
9  ,
"  2B& ?
 . &"2  "  E ,
  "
 "" 3
&&2 " E 
&
&
>
 ,

 
&B&9& 2 9  
, & 99
 &&2 " E ,. 

; , >
( 
  
  C.9&"",
D  ,. .  .  

,

 
&&29 &      #, ,  ,
,

& &2 9
 9  ,",
 .  B . 9& 
&&
.  
   "   , . 9& #  .  , ,  "   
9&2>
"
&     "
&. &"2#
 &
#,  , &# 
..&
 ." &2   9  
 ",
  , 
9      > 

0.   &
     
&  
   ,   ,
9 

  ,"
  ,
.    ,#&
9&&> ,
..
",#
 A" 9"
 ,9
2
   ,9&&
 9

&&2 
"  "   ".   , &&


&
" .   "   ".   . 
>

..&2  , & &2  #&
&

    ,"  2# &,
2& 2
&&
 Critics of ,welfare restrictions argue that complete bans on
eligibility do not recognize , 
& 2 ,
the needs of ,immigrants
2",
 0." &2
992  ,.  B

9& 2  >
 ,
.   ,&
2&  "  
9& 2> .& 2 >  , " "
"92 
, " &     >neither the political parties nor the administration were prepared to   

 
on
this issue. ,#

0 &2"&  

&2E, 

2  "&
"
  
>
","&
"
 # ,  
.&"
   
   
",  ,
 2  . 
= ,  ,9
 
&"&
 
 , 
# (?.    &
?.  

> 

2&.. #
 
&2
9&,, #
2&
&
# 
" 
&&2 #&
 &&8 .
 "   

 

 2   .  > . ."  &2
 # ,
..&"
  "  9 "
>#
"& 
9 + #, & ," ".   ,
.9&"",
9  "@,  "& 
." #
 ,.   "
&"
   # &9
9& .  ,
  )$?2
? &.
 > 
0
.&># & 9" .9&"",
>  ,0. 
  ,
& ,
& ?  "
       ,"  2 
&"
& 
" 
,& &20. 
,
  ," .& 9
 cc
 
. ".      #,
 &
5 ,.   ,
 3 
&&>

,  ,
 &2.
>  , "   ,.   9

&
9&  ,&
&

2
 ,
 
#, .  ,
9" 
.   ,  #&&9 &9& 

"1 #  2 ( #, # ,&
##&&
" 

&E
 >
 ,  9
 &9& 2 

&E
" E , " 
&09& 2  
 " 


  &
&
92  "   
"" . 
."
&&2. 9&
""
&
"
> .
"&
>0 &20. 
 
&&
. " ,
   "

#&
&9& 2.  #&&" 


#&

   
>
#&&9 .   "     3  The immigrant provisions are
 the most
onerous in the welfare bill., #
& &     &
#
 &
    
B&9& 2 #&
>0".   ,cc
. 
  , . 
>#&
 ". 92
#
 . . 
&2   9
&
"# ,#&
 ". 92" E ,.9&"9
"(&
,

  
cc, ,
9 
 ,

. &"
& 9 " 
# ,#&
. &",.  2
 "#,","&
&2, # ,&(&2.
" 
 ,
.    ,#&
9&&#    &E .,
  
  . . 
&Given the tenor of the debate, the large
sums of money that would be needed to fix the immigrant provisions, and the  xx x
    

 
,
there is little evidence to suggest that these provisions will soon be ameliorated.,#&&9.
"&
&2  
&2)>
#,  ,     9 &(&2 99
&
"  ,
&9 


 R
c 
  

Politics Disad ± Obama Good ± Immigration Link


+/8'c/V//'Q--7/c'c84ccc7/14 6/;6+c

Espenshade et al, R99 , 
F>",
&;0>= 2R 
>, 
 9 >C
 
c "
&8 &"25#
    
-&D>4   2 ="  
      
", 8  2>; "7 &* >;
&&=  

Anti-immigrant sentiment has intersected with another trend. The federal budget deficit grew to unprecedented size  ,

&2*>engendering#,
,
9 "
&&
³balanced-budget conservatism,´ 
C  .  . & "
& " " >
.  " >

0
 
"D, >  > ,
 ,E  ," >
  ,,
& ,  ,
" " 2>,
9"  ,2
 "( 
  
"  
&9  . &"2>
" > ,
groups see themselves as being pitted against each other in competition for shrinking
government resources .&
9& ,

growing fiscal conservatism>   "92" "
 "
& "  2>has
given rise to initiatives curtailing theE
generosity of government. The welfare legislation ending entitlement to public
assistance is &2the most prominent example.  , >nativism and fiscal conservatism have brought about legislation
that seeks to reduce ,.9&""   immigration by extending to&
&immigrants ,restrictions on , ".  social
services ,
,
" 
?&2
..& &2 &&
&
= ,  , #"
&. & " 
 >&
&
& "
 9#
.
  ,

   ,,,"    "
& "+
 & &   "  ,&"
> ,29"



" 
& 
9&
 


+/8'c8:c/c/841'-88-c-

Camarota, 2004c  >  "  
",
 ,   
 c >C,+,   ,
.'
9 5&&
&

 
 ,;
&1 D>   
 c . > 

Concern over illegal immigration
 

&"  2
 , & &
#  , (# &?9&&
&
(    ,"  2
 , #&&?
9  ", 1  ,fiscal effects are a key part of the issue. In fact, much of the public¶s anger over illegal immigration
stems from the belief that illegals are a drain on taxpayers. Past policy responses to illegal aliens, such as barring them
from welfare. 
>were
& driven by the desire to minimize"
&costs,>     ,
" 
&"
&.
"  &&
&

 "  "
&&2.
  &
 
. &"2 .  &&
&
 


8-7 6c-'c/7/c-6cc/V//'Q48-84'=++/841'

LA Times, 200 C
2= &  2&&
&
"" 1
"c "
&c "D> "9 $

c "
&c "One of the issues surrounding immigration being debated is how much access, if any, illegal immigrants should
be given to public social services. The survey found concern about this?more than a third of voters nationwide said
that illegal immigrants have had a mainly negative impact on their communities>
 
&2one in five#,  , ( ,



2( ,
.
"  , "   2 
 
#
2pointed to the drain on social services as the problem>
  , "  , 
"   ,"

&2 =, 
(
#, 
  ,"  2&&
&&2, &9

"" 
2    "
& "?.9&"
", &>  "2 >  &" > 
.>  ?
"   " &&   > N    
&&
 ,
 ,2# & 2
"" 
&& 
, ", "& #    .9&"

N   "
# & K 

"" 
2  ,     
  
""#

  "2"
&"

!%N> && #92 && ",&   .9&"", &
!N6
   2. &   K&"  "N   >
 && #92 
.
*N
 ?
" &&   "  
Nc0. " #  K  


 
c 
  

Politics Disad ± Obama Good ± Immigration Link


Increasing social services to immigrants is extremely controversial politically
Ugalde 9 ±   >4   2 0

     0"
 "
c 
O+
& ,
c "
&c "  

&'
9 
>6 &1 (P" 

 ë
c 
  

Politics Disad ± Obama Good ± Immigrant Health Care Link


+/'+/;-6cc/V/'Q7-''/ --7/c'cc4/ =-4'  /7c/-1B c8'

Weilbaecher, 2008 >
& +
& ,'
#>C;   
&1
E&2c2.  "" +
& ,
D>) +
& ,
' )>c >'0

Despite convincing" "
 ?" "arguments supporting ,increase access to health care for immigrants>
&&

policy makers are reluctant to act >government funding of immigrant health care is a ÿ  

issue. %""    ,

&
  '
#  >H ,,  & 2  ,

& "
&9
>, # >&

"&
 ,
  &
#&&2.  

 , 
&29  "  "  "
& "
.
""  ,
#"  "
& " ,
 
 

&
9& 
& 
 
H ),debates are 
 

  around the
provision of health care to undocumented immigrants. *Due to political pressure, even the politicians who encourage
comprehensive health care coverage omit undocumented immigrants in their proposals.


 
c 
  

Politics Disad ± Obama Good ± Refugees Link


Congress will backlash against changes to the refugee program ± they view it as weakening security
Martin 5 ±
>;&& #
 ,
 8 &"2    
8   ?'
#
 ,4   2 7  

O
2>, .5###
   
  
 .&
2"@ T $P" 

 
 
2&

"( .

   ,

&"&  > 
A   
2&
 &
&. 
   
,9
"(& ,
 
",
#, &&2
 


 #
2&"
0."  #
 )2
9 9"  
&
&. 
   
    ,
"( " E ,.
  9&.  #, 

=, ,  #

."    (9

 2",

",,
 "
&& 
2K    

#
, ,


 #&&  "&.    , && "  9&&
"   "9 ! ,
9.
(

  ,  & 2
.(. " #

2&>#,"," &
&2.&&    , 
  , , ,  & . 
>

    ,
. 

  





Allowing refugees in the U.S. is unpopular ± they¶re seen as competitors for jobs
Fischer 5 ± 1 >8  
,
   , .
  + 2
 

4   2
OF
>F 
& / , "

 c >&0P" 
,. "  & &9

 
.   
 . & "
&
2&  ,4  c
, 9",

"  
&  > ""

&&2&
#>   
9
2
0 &20. ??# , ,",
" ""
, &  ,
9 # & "
>
,. ",
 ,.  
& 9"   &2 " .&09 
&  "& , 9   
..&"
   
&>9 ,&

.. > #  ,cc
 "
&Q
9 (
("&
>9 # *
9 , ..  9 
$>!
..&"
 # & *
*>$*# 
.. >#, 
>*$!
..&"
 # & 
%%>$!%
.. , "&
&2 
 ,
>#,&Q
&K. "   
  ," K
   K 9" " > ,

,
.. 
&
  &9


        K
   K  !$&9

   >
..&"
 *. " # 
. & "
&
2&92
2& " 4c .
  F "

2&?( #, "


"
9 
 A" 
9&2& # 
"&    ,
.. 
&
#
$$. " 
92 #
 #  !!. " 4c .
  
F "  &(&2 ,
 ,  . .&
# ,",  , "
&"
 ,
" "   "&  
?
"  
. & "
&

 " "  "


2 "
   ,
 , A 9
9 A .
92
A 9?( > ,




&9 
9  , 
 92

  "
" "
& "   ">
 ,
 , "  2" &
9 , 
 92
>.
"&
&2 &&(  &9




 G
c 
  

States Counterplan ± Immigration/Refugees Solvency


c/c/;;/7/'Q8-7 /c-'c/7/c-68-84'-c

Espenshade et al, R99 , 
F>",
&;0>= 2R 
>, 
 9 >C
 
c "
&8 &"25#
    
-&D>4   2 ="  
      
", 8  2>; "7 &* >;
&&=  

 $>",
&;0
= 2R 
>  ,4 9
    B
8 &"28 
> #0  
&

". 
 


 
 .  
&.
"  
 &&
. . 
& , .  -  ,.
  2
>
;0
R 
>the federal
government has had a  "&
 . &"2> "  &
.
 #

&2  "
 >9 ,
&
&2,

laissezfaire, hands-off
immigrant policy.89&"responsibility for incorporating newcomers and their families has fallen>  &292
& >to state
and local governments. 4c
. &"2"   
 
. &"
0"&&2 &
&2
 #"  I&&
&2 

 
&2 &9& 2 & 
  
 "
&#&

"
 . 
I
 , ,  
& 
 ,2,
9    ,"  >   
  .   "    
& "  Assistance programs have included the following: (R) programs that provide health, public
assistance, job training, and social services to refugees and asyleesIprograms directed at&
2
" 
2
school students

&  & / &,. " "2I policies and resources intended to deter discrimination 
.& 2   ,9
 &" 
& 


&  ",

"   "I!   ".  

& "
&   
   ,"
&.
"  .""
 .> ,/  "2
/"
 " 
. 
  9 

  ,"    "
"
 " 
&
& >"9& #I$efforts made by 
&>state, and local governments to
help immigrants naturalize. &   , &2
&. 
 ,
0.&" &2
  ,9


.
  

&  "
 " 2
  

2&>#, ,
9 "  
."
&"
, & 8 
>
9&,92 ,*" >.   
 " .. >,
& , ">A 9
  >
 "
& ";    ,. 
&& L)>!.   L>  &
 ?
A  &&

9 # "
&2
*!
!!;
&   
 
. 
& 
,
"& ,
&   .  ,&2L 
&& " 9   , # .  ".
&&


"3  . 
>9& 
&"
  &
2
" 
2  
/ &,

c" 
'

 
& 1 # *$
> , 9  & ?/ &,?. " ",&    ,
 B", & 92%$. " > 
9  $&& 
   ,

.  > 
& " 
 
&.   9& 
&"
  92 &2!. " 
" .
 > ;Q> ,
 
& 
. 
L*&&  

& "
 . 
I
&.  >.  ,. "
 " 
>
& &2L&&  9    ,/  "2

/"
 "      
"     ?9   #, ,
& ,
 , " .& 
"
"2
 4c", & !>
, # )>",  >
 ,


&
9&
   
.. 0
&2L$. 
",&,. 
   
"    "
"
 
" 
&
& > "
 >#&&. 
.. 0
&2L>. .    .
" 
 ;Q%







 ^
c 
  

States Counterplan ± Immigration Solvency


c/c+7/+/4+-Q-8-7 /c-'c/7/c-6c  -c-/;;/7/'Q

[orjas, 20026 F>8 E, 8   89&"8 &"2
+

B: 2c", & 6   >
",
 "

 ,

&1 
 /" "
",>
/

;&& # 
 c 
 ,   
 
c >,.
"  =&
  
=&
4>   
 c >  . >
",>
, .5###" 
"&9 A
, 

State-Provided Safety Nets 
9 >some states chose to offer their safety nets to   ,immigrants
 &2

" 928=-;  
"> ,welfare reform legislation
(  
#,    ,4  c
9 
 >%> &9& 
2 2. 

">",
;
"
,&&
 >, # >
& gives states
the option to offer TANF and Medicaid to   ,immigrants, and some states chose to do so.  
  >some states
also chose to offer various types of state-funded assistance to immigrants #, 

   >%#,
 >
,

 2."
&&2 &9&    2. 
&

"These state activities will further increase
dispersion in "welfare opportunities" available to immigrants&    
,4 9
    K 0 H#&
   2H
"&

   "
 
""    ,

&
9& 2  ,

 2  ,
#, ",
#
H  

&
9&H "&
& 


&& I ,
#,  ,
#
H #,


&
9&H "&#Q (
;& 
I ,
#,  ,
#
H&

&
9&H "& E


",
I
 ,
#  ,
#
H&
 

&
9&H "&-, 
0
 # ,   ,
  ,0
# , ,&
 

. .&
    . 
9 ?

&& 
? 

" 
 ,0".  9 0
 ,4 9
     0 "&
2

  #  2.5   
>
#, 
#
  

&
9&  #,


&
9&>
&  
>
#, 
#
&


&
9&
&
 

&
9&
9&), #, # ,H",&& " H #&
  .   ,
"  
( 92 
&
; .&" 2>"&
2
, , &
""    ,
 


&E
 
  ,, , &,
,

 "
 ,
 ,#&
.
".
 
  ?" E & 
  ,&  
 ..92
&  . "
.   *!. "  !. "    ,.   "
 > ,.
".
 
  ?
" E &   ,   
 .. &292
9  . "
.   ). "  !!. "  # ,   ,
 ,.
".
 

 
  " E , , &   
&
2",   2  ,

&
9& 2 
? 

","   ,
? . 

   #,  ,
.&  "   ,, , & ,
&  
& 
,#&
.
".
 
  ?" E , , & ..92  
. "
.    ,&  
>#,& ,.
".
 
  ?" E , , & ..92 &2 . "
.    ,   

;
&&2> ,&
  # 
9&), # ,
  ,    " 
.&G , ? , , & ,
&  
& 
G ,#&

.
".
 
  ,, , & ..92
&  . "
.   ,2&  ,&  
>9 &&92& ,
. "  ,2& 
,   
In short, the state-funded programs offered by the more generous states seem to have prevented the
chilling effect of federal welfare reform on immigrant welfare participation that would otherwise have occurred.



4+-Q;-6c-'c/7/c'/c=++/c/c+/-4/8'c-'7/c 7- c;/ /'c

Espenshade et al, R99 , 
F>",
&;0>= 2R 
>, 
 9 >C
 
c "
&8 &"25#
    
-&D>4   2 ="  
      
", 8  2>; "7 &* >;
&&=  

," & " .   
 
&    

 
&" " 
9  
  &"  
&.  
the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of R996, the federal legislation establishing a new
federal±state relationship in the design, management, and financing of public assistance for poor Americans  , 
, > ,
"  .&
" ;
&# , .  ,&  ; # ,.
2
" 2;
&;4 &(; >;

9&,  
&  &  9  
delegates a great deal of program authority to the states regarding the design
and
management of program specifics.1 the legislation"
 & "
& "   ">
.   shift control over welfare
to the states #,& & " 
 9  
", "




 º
c 
  

States Counterplan ± Immigration Solvency


6c-'c/7/c;''4 /+/847/=-;c/6-7//c?+/-4/8'c-'7/c=+-4;46
;/ /'c

[orjas, 20026 F>8 E, 8   89&"8 &"2
+

B: 2c", & 6   >
",
 "

 ,

&1 
 /" "
",>
/

;&& # 
 c 
 ,   
 
c >,.
"  =&
  
=&
4>   
 c >  . >
",>
, .5###" 
"&9 A
, 

In R996, Congress gave individual states the option to supplement the federal benefits available to immigrants with state-
provided benefits.      ,

&  
&&  ,states with large immigrant populations chose to extend ,state-
provided safety nets to immigrant households. ,. & "
&", "
92 ,
.  
2
, , &
 9     ,#&
 &&>
,&.
 
 ,.
"  #&
   
#&



c/c/;;/7/'Q8-7 /c-'c/7/c-6c

Primus, R99 = &&>;   . 2
c" 
2 +
c "8 &"2  ,4c .
  +
& ,

+
c "> &
  ,   1 
8 &"28     ,1 (      
 ,4 9
    >
C
 8    ,#=&
'
#D>4   2 ="  
      
", 8  2>; "
7 &* >;
&&=  

The welfare bill authorizes states ³to determine the eligibility´ of qualified immigrants for ,;
Social Services
 &VV9& "(

#, #  " 

"  >%> 
 " 
 &F

2>)
  
#,   
   >%>#&&99
  ,9   2
States can provide  2
; Social Services to"  C3
&Dimmigrants#, 
 0. 
   

   ,?2
9

1& "(

9
 .
   >
 ".  2
 "&   
> ,
&
, &9
"  "  "    ,. .&
 States can also provide state-funded services$to immigrants who are
ineligible for services under the federal block grant.


-//7 //c/cc-'7/ +/-4/8'=''-6/-''/ 1:

[orjas, 20026 F>8 E, 8   89&"8 &"2
+

B: 2c", & 6   >
",
 "

 ,

&1 
 /" "
",>
/

;&& # 
 c 
 ,   
 
c >,.
"  =&
  
=&
4>   
 c >  . >
",>
, .5###" 
"&9 A
, 

", the.  
&impact of PRWORA on welfare use by immigrants    
& 
was undone by the
actions of state governments. Some statesG
.
"&
&2 , 
#, 
 Gchose to offer state-
provided benefits to the immigrants adversely affected by welfare reform.


 Ñ
c 
  

RNC ± Refugee Kritik


The Affirmative¶s use of the word µrefugee¶ juxtaposes these persons with µcitizens.¶ The aff defines the
refugee by their lack of state as the chief characteristics; they create a µnormal¶ condition of having a
state as opposed to the µabnormal¶ condition of being without one. This perpetuates state-centric thinking
that reproduces obsession with territorial boundaries and an exclusionary world, and only leading to
further oppression of these displaced persons
Ron 2k ± F
>8, > "
8  > 
8
  c", &  

&
 -
#

Oc.  >C
   ,= & , , "  >D 

&c #> >. ?!P" 

,9 (K
  ,.&2 &
 .
2"  
9      ,   
 
# & #,",   
&&2

9  
 ?

..
 9 , &2

&. & "
&  ,   #&&?
 
. 92,



"  >
 .>
,
 , &
#2  . "  - 
E
 .  &
&
,


 " H >H#&&?   
" 


  &2   , 

?" "   ,# &
" 9 #&&2? &&2  ," 
  
   
&&2

0"&
2# && , , 
"  .  
&, ?  ""  .  .&
"92.  2>#
> . "  > ,2 ,
"& ?   ..  
92 . "  , # &K 9 # ,   
&9  
># ,2 9
 " E ,.>9  
.
&>
 " &>
.
. ,  H >HE
c (
>
 3
  &2  #
2 
"
 E  ,9
 .,   H,
.&
" H .&
".  "
90&>X X> A   > .
2
& >  
I ,2
9" H H &2 
# & . &E92   
&&29  
 ?
  .  &2>
 ,9  ",&; "
& K"   >c (K
 

&.  &  "+  ,
 ,  H H
(  &2#,  A0
.    ..  >
H" E H   ,

,  # H
H
 , 92#,
 ,2&
"(?

?
    > ,2   " ,
K
"
& 2"   H  H

H
9 
&H 
     >  H 
& 2H


 
  #,"," E    ,  # >   
&&29  
12.,
E H
& H
 , K
 
&",

"   "> "   H
H
 , && 
  . & "
& 
E
 

H" E H
 , &2&
&   
&0  "-  ,
&&&2K
  , #
 ,
H

(#
>
#

( ,
>H "   , 
&&2.. & (9 # 
#

( >" &&"  
0>9 
"
"& . >

9& = (   , 
& "  
. & "
&

 >c (
(
&
 2. "&
5

( >9  

"  
& 
( ,


"    "92
 9 &   ,  # .   

"
& 2-  , 
" E 

&
&9  
 "  E
  H
9 
&>H
.. &9 
 
.
  

  K # , 
  , 
"".
9& .    
2K# &>
8
&  
>: >&9

:  
>
 ,:#
 1 ,
"   
..   , . 9& .  >
.& 2" .&0>,     H
"
 H ,
 2


&E ,
?
" "# &c
"
  "  
2,
.
 >9    "       .



 c   ,9 (K   , , ?.  ( .


, "
&> "  . "
&&2 ,0  " 
& 
#
2 "  "   ,# &1  , # H >H. .&
  .&
" .&
"# , &

1  
# . >.
. # 
>
   
&  #  
0"&,;  ", &  >#,",
( ,   ,  
 ?
>9
 ,. " ",
>9  ,.&
" "
92 ,
 &  
"&#

""&
 ,. " " 
 &2& .
 "   

. .&
   >
 , & #
 ,. "    ,    > ,'
 
 K+,    ,         
&
 
 #
" 
  ,
  
,  ,
,  >

,H 

&H2 ,
# (,
  " &
9
>. >


&E "  >" 9  
&& ,#,&  ,
?



" " ;  ,.&


".   ,&> ," 3 ",
9    1  ,&
    ,
"  2>.&
".  #  2 
"
&&2 
.

" &&92,   " & , , ,2   ,&
"( 
  > ,2
# 
& 
9& 9 ,& 
&2  ,  #   > 
      ,& "
&" 2
- " , "
 29"
 .
>.  .&
"
" 
9  # 9A"   &> &
 >

  "  ,  


.&
".    , 
. "  >9  
& "  "  ,


 9A"  
" &> &
 >
9A
 >  &2" .&"
  ,.&
" . "


 Y
c 
  

RNC ± Refugee Kritik


The politics of borders and state centricity rely on the instrumental management of populations to
establish national identity. This requires outsiders, who are tortured and exterminated. This violence
collapses politics and makes life meaningless
Dillon 99 ± ",
&F>8   8 & ">4   2 '
"
 
OC,c"

&  ,>H
&c.
"5 , ( / ,"
= &8 & "8?P" 

,"
&  ,. & "
&&2  
&G&9
>&
&>
. &"2?  
G

"   
  # &. & " "
&2"
&&
 3  > ,  > , 2
&
. & "
&  
 

"" .&,   ,  
>.
"&
&2 ,   ,

 , 

&2  
 "," "
"G

  ,
 . & "
&

&"&

 9,
& 

  , 

&
2 >
#&&
  ?"
&& 

& " 2G#
 " 
 &2&  ( #  #,
29 &".
"> #,
  
   ,,
#
2 9 >#"
  #,
#

 &2"
&&  
,
 2  . & "> ,. & "    2>"   &2   >, # >  #    & >
    >  
&E 
.  " &2 ,
 2  , 9"
   ", "
&" "2  .
G ,

& 9
&. & "    2 ,0.   . & "
 ",  9"
   
&E
9&  ,. " ,  0.     2. & ">#,& ,
"&    , 
& 
9   ,  # &B .  
 
",>. 
. # & 
  ,
 , ".   ,
 ,  #
""  ,
   ,,
#
2 9 #,
 , 2   . & "
&   2 &"
&&


 " 
 3  c.""
&&2>  . & "
&9A" "
 " 
  # ."&
  . & "
&
9A"  - 
&&2
..& ;  ",+ #, & / &

   ,  "
   ,/"  
 %*$G
 ,  

 "   
&2  
9 &    
   ,
&  
9&>& 
>

 , 
. & "
&
 >
 , " 3 "G , . "&2 ,  ,
   ,. & "
&
9A"    ,  

9A" 
"
   I
9A"  

&  ,
"  0.&&  
( ,
&   ,. & "
&9A"  9
. . & "
&9A"    ,
"   2   
&E ,

&
(  ,.  2 &   ,
#,",( 9 ,&?
>  ,#
 

,
#,", ,  
,
"   &2  9  2>2 >
  9"

 ,  . "92 , > "   &2 .  
#
2 ,
  ," 2.

  92#,", , ( 9 

9A" 2" 
> . "  
( ,. 9& 2> ,
9A" 
& > #,
  . & "
&9A" "
 

&E

  
&E;  ,. & "
&.
" " 9  >",
 >
. >0.&& >
 >   >
,&
 >  E >0" 
 >   9 2 >, >..  >


   
    , 2#
  ,2

0 "  ,
. " "   &2 

 
. & ">
"
 .
 . & "
&  2

&&
9&   2=
 >
"  
> #
 # ,   #
  . "5 . " & . 
. "   ,     
 " . " . "  
 ,&8&
&9A"  G ,2 B # &?. "

&?. " .  9


 G  ,     9  , ?9 # > ,9  
2 &  ,

"  ,
  
 9A"    

&. & ">

  

&. & ">    
.  "".
 # , ,
  
    ,

&


 G
c 
  

Solvency Frontline ± Immigration


-c-'7/Q+-c'Q6// 6c //c+/;-/7//86-/ccc-'c/7/c

Weilbaecher, 2008 >
& +
& ,'
#>C;   
&1
E&2c2.  "" +
& ,
D>) +
& ,
' )>c >'0

. "  " " "
 ?" "
 ..   , " 

"" ,
& ,"
 
>&&

. &"2
( 
 &"


"  >      
,
& ,"

, &29
 %""    ,

&
  '
#  >H ,hostility in
the state and local debates>, # >fueled a climate that deters lawfully present immigrants and their family members
from securing critical services and impedes access to ,#critical services ,
 
 

&
9&regardless of immigration
status.H ),9

.
"&
&2 &
&
  ,.   ,
& ,"
   " 
 *  . & "
&.  >  ,
. & "
#,  " 
" . , ,
& ,"
" 
    " 
  , . . 
&


+/8'cc4;;/4'8'/-+/1/c --+/1'Q-;6c-/ccc-'c/7/c

Clark, 20081 
>8   '
#
' 2 &
4   2'
#c", &>C,
+
& ,



=,
 
&&49   ,4c+
& ,
c2 D>) +
& ,'>c >'0

   >the elimination of status-based criteria would not guarantee access to care; it only removes one barrier among
many affecting immigrants. Immigrants are vulnerable along a number of axes: delays in care and poor quality care are
due to the intersection of immigration status, economics, ethnicity and race, as well as gender #  

  
 
&Immigration is"
 &2an
impediment "
>but it is not the only one. In fact> ,racialization 
"
  2. 
>OW) P
 ," 
  
. 
 "&
 H
& " E H " 
 
>
reveals the entrenchment of discrimination that will not be easily eliminated by simply challenging the health policy-
immigration link.,
&&   ,

offers only limited success because of the inherent limitations and structural
defects of our existing healthcare system.12 
   "   K  ,   
   ,0  ,
& ,"
.

>. ?
""
 "

"
 #  &2   " ,H4?,H", 2 ,
. 
,
& ,. &"2" ?
( ' 
# # ,  ,.

#&&
&#
2. 



  " E >A 
 .    . " E 

  
", , - " &
 ,
#,&& 
# 9
 
 
 
 

    
2 
 >  
2."
&  
&&2" & &,  
,
& ,"
2  ,
   &2
#& 9
 &
# 

&
.  

9  #, H    >H#,&0"& &&   ,    , , 
&   ,  # 


4+/8';4/'c+-c'Q-= c6c/7/c68-/'8-c7/6c

Clark, 20081 
>8   '
#
' 2 &
4   2'
#c", &>C,
+
& ,



=,
 
&&49   ,4c+
& ,
c2 D>) +
& ,'>c >'0

 .
 0
  ,"  
    , .
"   ,
,
& ,"


 . &"2
( 

"
 & ". .&

.  

 "
&   ,
"
 , 
"&
 ,  .9&"
 "
"2 0.

"",2
& ,&." 
     ,. & "
&#&&
0  . &"2
( 1 "
. ?
""OW P
 "
 "  "  ,
,
& ,

 
#
2 ,
&
  
 ,
& ,"

"" 

@  ,0   ,
pro-access groups, .  & ". &"2
(  , , , "  " 

> ,2should
recognize #  2.
",
&&  ,2
";  > ,2, &9 & #, ,  ,

 ,2" 
..  , . &"2
&their
discourse unintentionally reinforces parts of the dominant narrative used to fuel anti-immigrant initiatives> , they are
undermining their own goals.4  
&2>  0  the pro-access narrative unintentionally encourages a view of
immigrants as potentially dangerous and as outsiders.    >  ,0   ,
 ,. ?
""

&
9&..   
9    "  

?
 
" >this can facilitate public divisiveness among groups ,
,  , #,

"          ,,
& ,"
2  #
2 ,
9  9 , .Such characterizations may have the
perverse effect of strengthening demand for anti-immigrant measures>#,", . & "
& "
&#&&..  
&
 

 &2 .. > 

& ,
& " E 


 GR
c 
  

Solvency Frontline ± Immigration


-c-'7/Q+/+''6/;;/-4=/6+c+6/c/'61'Q

[orjas, 20026 F>8 E, 8   89&"8 &"2
+

B: 2c", & 6   >
",
 "

 ,

&1 
 /" "
",>
/

;&& # 
 c 
 ,   
 
c >,.
"  =&
  
=&
4>   
 c >  . >
",>
, .5###" 
"&9 A
, 

 %>   .   ," " 92 "& (2
? &
.    ,8 
&. 9& 2
= (-..   2" "&
 
" 8=-,&&
 ."
 #   &      ,&9& 2   ?9 .    ".
" "
&&2
&& 2. .9&"


"  ,  >8=-    2. 
?  

"  ?" E #, 

   ,&&
 #
 >
&  ,
&9& 2 
2 ?" E 
& 
2&   ,4  c
# ,

& 
20
  ,.  ?%   #&
92

, , &;0
8
&
1 A

, # ,
 ,
 #&
.
".
 
 
, , &"& ,
.&2G &
  ,
"& 0.  "92
, , &G
   ,#&
  &&
 #

"  %!,"& .
"&
&2 
(
9& "    ,
.      

& 
2&   ,4  c
  ,#&
 &&#     "   > &2

&&.
  ,

. .&
 .    ,4  c
  ,&


  %>
(   &(&2 ,
 , &9& #

&" &,
",


".
" 
 ,

&  The steeper drop in the rate of welfare use experienced by immigrant households led an influential Urban
Institute study to conclude thatH9"
" .

&2#&
&
#  &9& .9&"9  
  "9 
)> 
..
 ,
 ,steeper declines in non-citizens' ,
" E Kuse of welfare...owe more to the 'chilling effect' of
welfare reform and other policy changes than they do to actual eligibility changes";0
8
&>>.*


 G
c 
  

Solvency ± Other [arriers Ext.


'-c-;1/c8/7/6c;-/cc6c-'c/7/c?+/8'1/c/c-'7/c-/-;+/

Clark, 20081 
>8   '
#
' 2 &
4   2'
#c", &>C,
+
& ,



=,
 
&&49   ,4c+
& ,
c2 D>) +
& ,'>c >'0

c" >any attempt by pro-access advocates to use the immigrant narrative to influence policy will be constrained by the
structural defects and linedrawing inherent in our existing healthcare framework. Apart from any consideration of
immigration status, our health care system is largely based on an "Us-Them" paradigm in which access is not guaranteed
for all> 3  " 


 
"
&&2## ,." >
" 
9  #,", .  " 2, &,

"" ,
& ,"

9
 


 ., 

&2 #,   H  H   >
 " 
 
& 
 9  
0> "& 
"  , " 2> " " "

>
> 
2"
>  ,>"   ,
""&&2",
 ,


  " 
.9&"" "  
9   ,  3" " 
will not "
&2garner public support for eliminating immigrant-specific barriers or ensure immigrants' access to care.
Immigrants will still be left to compete with others for access 
,
& ,"
2  ,
. . 
&&2.   .

  

, 


 Gë
c 
  

Solvency ± Chilling Effect Ext.


-c-'7/Q6c/; -/8-/ccc-'c/7/c

[orjas, 20026 F>8 E, 8   89&"8 &"2
+

B: 2c", & 6   >
",
 "

 ,

&1 
 /" "
",>
/

;&& # 
 c 
 ,   
 
c >,.
"  =&
  
=&
4>   
 c >  . >
",>
, .5###" 
"&9 A
, 

, 
  " &  
9& 
& ,
 ,&2 ,
.
    .
".
 
 .""#&
. 

, , &
0.  "
 . "&   , ".  "
,9  ",
;  cc>"
>
 
.,

&  
E 
9& 
  ,
 ,#&
  &&
 ,

.
"&
&2 .
"   ,&(&,  ,

, , & "

",trends helped
create the current consensus that PRWORA had a "chilling effect" on immigrant participation in welfare programsG
 , by
(  
, , & &9&  "   2. 

"> 92mistakenly raising concern among eligible
immigrant households that receiving welfare could have adverse repercussions on their immigration status
. ,
.
&
 .
 


 G
c 
  

Solvency Frontline ± Refugees

U.S. asylum process has deep structural flaws the plan can¶t overcome ± there¶s little chance refugees
make it all the way through, and they are often abused by U.S. officials
Fischer 5 ± 1 >8  
,
   , .
  + 2
 

4   2
OF
>F 
& / , "

 c >&0P" 

,. "  & &9



 
.   
 . & "
&
2&  ,4  c
, 9",

"  
&  >
""

&&2 &
#>   
9
2
0 &20. ??# , ,",
" ""
, &  ,
9 # & "
> ,. ",


,.  
& 9"   &2 " .&09 
&  "& , 9   
..&"
   
&>9 ,&

.. > #  ,cc
 "
&
Q
9 (
("&
>9 # *
9 , ..  9 $>!
..&"
 # & *
*>$*# 
.. >#, 
>*$!
..&"
 # & 
%%>$!%
.. , "&
&2 
 ,
>#,&Q
&K
. "   
  ," K
   K 9" " > ,        K
   K  !$&9

   >
..&"
 *. " # 
. & "
&
2&92
2& " 4c .
  F "
,
.. 
&
  &9


2&?( #, "
"
9 
 A" 
9&2& # 
"&    ,
.. 
&
#
$$. " 
92 #
 #  !!. " 4c .
  F "  &(&2
,
 ,  . .&
# ,",  , "
&"
 ,
" "   "&  
?
"  
. & "
& " "  "
2 "
   ,
 , A 9
9 A .
92
A 9?( > ,




&9 
9  , 
 92

  "
" "
& "   ">
 ,
 , "  2" &9 , 
 92
>.
"&
&2 &&(  &9

' &&(&2 ",
  , 
9&    "  ,


,. 
& 
   ,4  c
    #
&9


 , 
2&?( #

, "&
&2
# , ,  
& c
  , .
  F "
 
  
,    , .
  + &
c"  2< .&2>
2&?
( 

&&

 #. "  

"  2
 , 

A "
 
 "

 ,
   ,9
"
  9
A 
 ,  ,  &&      ,
2 ",  , 
"
&9   .
"&
. 9&0.   
&0.   
& 
   .   >
  
 
 "
  ,
 , &
&
 9 &2  " > ,. ", & "& 

"" 
9& 2

.
 "2# ,
2&?( 

    . 
 , 
&" "   ,  
&,
  ,  9 "
&2. 
#&&, 
 
2 
" 

2&?( 9  9


&&2
  .,2"
&&2
992
 

2& " #, ,
9 
"" .   
 
&   "  ,2    
,  3
&  .   .   ",


&&  ,,
  

&




Increasing access to refugee services doesn¶t ensure admission to the U.S., only a hearing before a judge
D.O.S. 2k ± 4c .
  c

O, .5" ",
   " &
&  M& 4cM -cM- 
M6  M6& .P" 

""  ,4c8 
  9" # , ,  
  #, , 
.  
   
4  c
&
#.   2
     & ,.   
   ,4c

 I
,  
&& # ,

..&"
 
..
9  ,  #  "  

A"
   ,"
,  >
   
 
& 
.
"&
. " .   2   &" 
2
"  
 3
&"
  
   ,4c

 >9  
2 &" 

   ,
.. . 
    "2  ,    & F 
 3
&2   
  

"  
 ,    &  ,4  c
>
   
.
"&
. " .   2    &
.   4c

 /
", 
& 
9&, ,
, ,  ,
 &2

     
 ,
 ,2
 , #&9& 
   ,4  c






The judicial process for refugees is overloaded ± hardly any of the refugees the aff tries to help will
actually get asylum
Fischer 5 ± 1 >8  
,
   , .
  + 2
 

4   2
OF
>F 
& / , "

 c >&0P" 

, 
  
 A .
   E  "   , ,   ,4  c
  ,

&
&9
"(   
 
  
     &
#2  >
     &
#2   9   . 
&
#2 92

   #   ,   "
" 
2&?(  "  . 
&
#2 

2& 
&2$. "      ,
     &
#2 
6  .&
2
 &  ,
 

#&&c 2? # . "  A

&9 #  
. . 
&2
  ,  &  ,   , .    &  A
#  #, 
"&  $. "   ,"
 ,
" 9  ,

&(2 ,



",& # >
 ( 9& #. "  
&
  A 
c  , A "  ,.
"&
A  
& ,
 ,  "
  
?2
.  ?? >*!%
, 0   
" A &  >$%"
   ,
.  2&
 "
" .&
  ,
 ,  
.   ,.
  , .
  F " 0.&
 
, "


 ,",
 A
(   
&

AK.  
"9
. 

 

 ,     
"( , "  A , #
2  , " 
   

,, &&&(2F> , >
2  &2  , 9  "
 ,2,

  , 9  "&
 ,2

.. 2&
 "

& " .&
  ,
A,

 ","       , # ,2" " ,
 
 A 
  "   .
( .9&"# ,  
 , 
 >9  ,

 

,
   ,.   ,2
"
 " 
  , "
&
&(2;  ,= &c 2 .  ,
 , 

#    >
2&"
.  9 4c
   4c   
,,
 " 
 A 
&  , 
&&  
","

  "  ,
  

   , ".  c A,
&  , 9  # 

"&

"
.  c A  
&& # &., "   2 3   ,
2&?(  "   ,0.  9   

#   , & "


 F"
0"&# >
  ,
 ,2,
& &     ,"
c A&  ,
    
",# "
 
   ,
F

& 
9& &  ,
   
 "
2 " ,
"
9.   
2 "
F

9& 0  "        ,
   " >"   # , 
 
&
 
, #"&   ,
  ,

" 
&,
  , " #&&9
"". ,  "  .  
&&2 .
"   ,  "   ,,
 

 GG
c 
  

AT: Human Rights Credibility Advantage


U.S. human rights cred is high now ± U.N. Council seat
Reuters 9
O
2!>, .5 # &  
"& %*)?? "&
 ? &? , ?  P" 

 E  6& 9


&c &  "&9
 ,&"    ,4  c
 

  ,4  
 +
,   "&,
4  c
# 92
#
 >
,   ,
 ,"  2 "&
   &

& 9
&",
.  ,
 , H,
4  c
#
    ,.  ".& ,
 , 
  >
#,&." 
 ,4  
     . 
 , 

  ,# &>H
 :
>/- 6& 9
&c &  H
( 

  ,

+
,   "& , 0  .  "&
    , &.&
"

9
"  
 
A "  ,# &H  "

2 ,  "&,

"". 
9    ,# &K# &,
 , 
9 >#,  , 9 ,. 9& "(
2
"  

   ,:

"( #& ,
 , 
. 9&# , ,     >9 
 ,4c"
 " &2# ( 

H,4c,
     "
&
 ,."
.
"  ,
#"
 
( ,  "&

" "  , . 9&

9   ,  "&

 "      >H


:
H
9   , 
E
 >  .   2 9    ,
 &.  ,,,

. #,", #
  H,+
,   "&
  ?  
&9 2# ,  ,
4  
      , 
.  ,
 , 
  ,# &,1, 
 "&  A   ,"  "&#,  #
" 
 %H,

" 92 ,-9



 
     ,

"  
,  . #

( 
"&
9 
(# ,"  . &"

",
 
 #"    ,4c>  ,
9
   
A " 
&&. .&
  ,# &>#, ,  ,2&  ,4c>2

 
 >H
:



 G^
c 
  

Aff ± Magnet Disad Answers


c-'c/7/c/-'Q-/-;QS 6/cB ;/c4/c6-

IHM, No Date GivenC
 
c

9& 

&c"  2D>
, .5###,   ###
A "M.
"M
M

9& 2M
  "
.
 M*?
 .

Roots of migration.=,& ,"   " 
   &&
 ,
9 .  >little attention is given to the
factors that cause people to leave their homes

&9, 
 
( ,. & A  2 
 #&
Neoliberal economic
policies and free trade agreements such as NAFTA , "
; 
  
;
& "
; 

  have had a devastating impact on people in Mexico, Central America and other parts of the world.; 0
.&>
0"
" 
 ,
9      9 92 , &0 ",
.>9E"   ,4  c
Until people are able to enjoy
basic economic security in their own countries, they are left with few options other than migrating.


-': /8'  c8-7/c+/+/cc-;+/ c 

Camarota, 2004c  >  "  
",
 ,   
 c >C,+,   ,
.'
9 5&&
&

 
 ,;
&1 D>   
 c . > 

' #'& /"
  
 " ,    , 2, # ,
 ,. 
2 
 &&
&, , &" 

"
&" 
 ,
&&& ,

, ",& # && "
  &  & # " 

0.
2  ,

 &2*. "  ,
  , , , &,>  , , ,"   ,2
. 
 
 9 &2!%. "  ,   , , , & 

> ,  
 
 "
  " =, ,  "   ,   "
& #

  . ." 1"
&&
&
  ..  9  ,"  2>
2 "


 92 ,
"  ,
 ,2 "
2 "


&&,."
&&2  
  , , &&( 
. "
,.
2   ,,&
0  Although many Americans are upset
about their use of public services, there is little evidence that illegals come to America to take advantage of public benefits.
Most illegal aliens come for jobs>
 ,
 
A  2
 
" .& 21 & #&& "
 
 ,2
 
9&2" 
&
"   

0.
2 


+/ c c'/ /Q6c-'c/7/c-6c -/c-+7/ ////;;/

Cornelius, 2004=
2 >4   2 
& 
c
  >C && S4 #
B
 5'   ,4  
c
 ?!D>    .


 c = ( 8
.  > "9 

,4c#&
  &
# %,
&
" 3 " . 92
& 
B8 .   *)> ,federal
law made  &2
 , E
immigrants9 &
&. 
   ineligible for virtually all federally-funded benefits, like food stamps and Medicaid>
 & ,2,
&  ,4c 
&
 2
Welfare reform stimulated no mass exodus of unauthorized migrants, and there
was no let-up in the massive wave of new immigration ""    ," ,
&  ,1 
.
 #, ",&  # 
&9& 9   
"" ,9"
 "  

 "&    
 
9   ,&  ,
 ,  9   , ?3
  
&&
",&  &  
?,
, , &  ,4  c

4c" E >
 , #

 "
"&  9  92",
&  ,&
 
,
&  ,c  !5 In short, restricting access to public services has proven to be a very blunt instrument of
immigration control; it creates major social problems, and it does not discourage illegal immigration.



 Gº
c 
  

Aff ± Magnet Disad Answers


/8'-Q/c+/4'/6/c-'c/7/c/ -8+/14:/

AILA, 2008 "

 '
#2  "
 >C

  ,
  9
56 c
U' "
&
8 &"2
( 
 "
D

Proponents of ,restrictive measures hope ,
92
( &  ,4c&#&"   immigrant families>
2will ³self-
deport´
B, 4.
>'These restrictions will undoubtedly frighten immigrants> , 
&>
 , 
"   #, &
 92 ,
  "
 3  &
  +
& ,  ,
   2>'Yet the idea
that these restrictions will somehow help resolve the issue of  " immigration is foolhardy. Undocumented
immigrants are here to work, not take welfare, and passing laws that further limit their access to public benefits will not
lead these workers to leave the country.  
> ,&
##&&,
&
&&2?.   
&G "& 4c" E G#, "
. "
"  "
    , # &"
5c
. ,
 E ,.3  &  / &&  "&  /&9& E 

8  
1  >6-
 6  =,
,28
; 5'  
B"" 1  + ;
&= ,  " 
+
& ,"
  >8


-': c-'c/7/c --6c-+/4c

AILA, 2008 "

 '
#2  "
 >C

  ,
  9
56 c
U' "
&
8 &"2
( 
 "
D

MYTH immigrants come to the U  S
to get welfare. FACT:4  " immigrants come to the U  S
to
work and reunite with family members.In fact, undocumented immigrants are less likely than natives to use public
services. - 

>9 ,&
&
  " 
 "
9  L>  ,
& ,"
>" .
# ,L>$!% 
?9   & , ,

" . N  ,4c. .&
  *> ,2
""    &2*N 4c,
& ,"
"  ! 

&2 #&


92 
", 

,4 9
     
& ,
& ,
N , , &,
92  " 
 ""
,

"  2
&>" .
 $N 
, , &,
92
?9 4c" E  & >#,&%%N 0"

 .  ,# ,, &  c "
&c"  2
0  , .
2","(

%N
2 ,
.& 2 # ,, & " 
0> &2N
2 ,2,
  
",& 4c.9&"", &>)N "
 ,2,
 "c..&
&
c"  2 " >
$N & .    
.>#&
>  .& 2 " . 
 $   >  " 

 &9& 
#&
> 
.>&&" ."
>
   , .9&"9  




 GÑ
c 
  

Aff ± Magnet Disad Answers


c  -/c-4+/c/

c-'c/7/c/ 4/'-6?/6 /8/ //-4c=/';/8-6c

ASA, 2009 "
c " & "
& "
 >#0+
& ,>F >.!!

"Our research suggests that ,   &  # (

&2  ,0"
"  
&
  ,.   E
  .& 2 #&&

  
 > E #&
 ". 
 " 
 .  ?#&
.& 2 >H7
+ (
H; , >immigrant public assistance may in
fact have a positive effect on integration, helping immigrants to work their way out of poverty and off welfare."

 

 6c+7//8-c7/8-V/7/4/c+/Q=''-1:4814 6/c''

Howley, 2008: 2>


 >-" 9 >. !

 "
   
& 

 ,#  3   9& ,  #, 
&
"
.  

  ,,2" 
 #
   

99 2>A
 

,
A  2  ,low-skill foreign workers ,2

" ,
 
  , ,#,", (&
&
 "
 >9  ,2require the same social services

?9  "
5.9&"", &>&
#  " >


Deporting hundreds of thousands of undocumented low-skill workers# &
 E

0.
2    "2 "
>
9 would likely raise prices and slow economic growth. "You have to look at a budget comprehensively,"
2F
 '7"(
H" && (
 ,"    ,&" " 2   29 

2>K6 ,> K   
&&20. A     >#K

&   2KH
c", &
,
& 
.  3
2 ,"  
9   ,
" # ,  " 
= ( # ,  
> 
    ", &

  "2 >.
2
&>0">
. . 2
0    " &2> , ,  ) 2924   2  E
 
",    ,

" E >   #, 
  "   , .. c
>"   E
L! && 
2
 ,
& ,"

L*&&  &
#  " ,. " 
"
  2  "&


H/ &,&

&
 >H#,", "& " E >#

, L$!&& All told, the study said
illegal immigrants are costing ,
about $R.4 billion a year. [ut the economic activity they generate provides $R.5
billion in tax revenues, yielding a net benefit to the public treasury> , 2" "&



 -c/4-'Q6-/c-/ /-

Portland Press Herald, 2008 "9 

Expressions of concern about immigrants' use of social services
& are misplaced. People with the initiative to leave , 
native lands to seek a better home&#,    are among the best-educated and most-motivated members of their
societies.,29   ,

  
 , (&&  ", ,  #, &
Giving them a temporary hand in the process
is an investment not only in them but in the future prosperity of their adopted country.


 GY
c 
  

Aff ± Magnet Disad Answers


Studies confirm the ³social services magnet´ doesn¶t exist ± people emigrate for jobs and their families
Yang ± F ,
>8, >c  
", 
 ,4'   +
& ,8 &"2
",
OF&>, .5###"
&  # .&
;&N
  M81M;'.P" 
, 
  
9   ,0.  " &
&
 ,
 , 
   " 
'
&
. 
  &  ,

"   ,
& ,9   " ,2
&9& "

 , .9&"9    


c  ,
& (
 ,.
  &
&
 & 
9  

&
9& 29  
 " "&
  ,
"  
.9&"?9  &&  ,& "
 ", " 
 
9&>, # > ,

# , #&2
  '
 
. .&
 >",
&
9

>6 

c  ,
&
>

# , ,&
   #&
.  )>*c  
,
  
 &
&2
&&9 
 "
&&2 "
 &
 ,.9 # .9&"9     2
 ,& "
 "   #&2
 
>- , ,
   
 "
 9 # .9&"9     2
 ,& "
 "  &
&

>,    
  4  " 
 5= (>;
&2 89&"1  @, 
#   , &
 ,.9 # .9&",
& ,9  
  " 
 , 

2  "   
   ,
  9   ,4  c
>9   ,
   &2" &&"   
    " 
, .  9    " 
  ,4  c

 
9
  ,  "9 #  , 9  &
&

 ,


& 9    9 .    ,4  c
!, 
.   
  (2 
.,"",

"   "   " 
>9   .   
  #,2 ,2"
  ,4  c
 -  2 ,


 " &2
  ,  "
& "

 
    " 
    ,
  " '
 

&   


  ,4c  9
  ,
& ,"
  "
& "$, 2 2  " 
  # "    0
/&8
 

+  
 # "    
& 
;  
'  & , , ?.    #    ,
  " '
 
& 
 

,4c
 &2 .& 2 

&2  "
 =,&  .   .  "
9  >& ,
N  .  
" 
&&  "   
&
&2 , &  
  "    
 ,   
&>, # > 
,
 " .&  
""
  
 
9   , "
&
" "

"     ,& "


 #,  ,2  
&&2 & c " ,2 2."
&&2 &2 
&2 "&     ,
  
 >
B  
 
9  ,
& ,"
9     
&(&2
9&
#,      ,     ,9A" 
E#,
93  
",,
"    5 ,& "
 ", " 

   &2 & "

92 ,.  "  , 


  ,
"  2>#,& ,"  .9&"9     #
(
9 !

  
&>
  " 
 .
"&
>

& ,
& ,  ,
 ,4c?9 . .&
 

# ,
& ,"
 "$,
& , "
" 


   
>## &0."  # ,
& ,"   
,, 
,
& , " ,
 9 , , , 
0  
9   , &
 ,.9 # 
 & "
 ", "

.9&"?9     2> ," "
  
  ,
"  2
&#
2

 
 "
. " >!,   3 &2  & ( " 
9  &
&
"   .9&"9  Q  "   # , ,  # ( , 2 
 >#,"," 9
 

 "    &
 ,.
9 # 
 
 
 "  2
.  
&
 
"  2   % # 9 2  
", 
 ,.
" . 
&  # ( 
 ", ")89&"1  
c
&&;
"    

 = ,  ,
4c,
  & #? " " E 9 # 
# ,  ,4c, .  " "& "
9   , &
 ,.9 # .9&"9  

 " 
",   

 
2.  . " &   , 

 ;  >

 ,
 " &2
  &&  .9&"9  . 

  

 
 
&2

&
9&c" > ," .&0 .  92
  " E ,.
>."
&&2 , , &>
&
, >
&#&
   
%. 


&0.   0
 ",
 .9&"9     2

 =&
   &  
2
    && .9&"9  .  >
&& #  
0

    

   .   , 
",

",  , &
 ,.9 #   

 
.9&"9     2"
9  , #
,
&    & & " 
C#&

  D"    

 *  ,*
>
 # 9 2 

" &2>  ., "


 ,
" "& ,

  .9&"
 "  
   " .9&"9  ?  
 >

9     "" 



2 "
&&>c  
", "    

&&.
"  #&
   2  ,  
&"   & ,  - ,  
", 
 ,,,
&& " .&0 2 ,
   ,"   9 # 
!
2  ," &"    


  &
  ", "
&
" > "&  , .    " 
 > ,

  

&2>
 ,.
"&

 "
& & 
   
"  &
 
  .9&"9       
 ,

 #
"
92.9&"9  >
 & 9
9& , # ,
  

 +
& ,8 &"2
",1 !2 
"
&&2 & # ? ,,    2
.9&"9  

 && .9&"9  . 

   ,  

  
&#,   
& ,
  
 9 

  
.  B >
#&&


 
" G "& 
.& 2 ",

"   "G 9
9& 
 
,.
"  9     2 .  &2  ,   
   

 ,  ,
,
" "&   
"" .&,  ,,
, # 
&&   "
"  .9&"9     2   

 >$# , ,
  
 & "
 ", ">
&2 

  #,& &2 
" 
"    

 #, " .
 .9&"9     2 /.& 2  ..   2
& 
(2
"    

 " >!/
&
  ,
C=&

  +2. ,D, ,  " 

2   9   , ,  "2"

 , .9&". 
. 
&2", &>
 #  ,0   
", 
 
  

 .  

  " 


 
" "& " ,
,
& ,  , .9&"9  

 "
 
  
2 "    " 
B"  "   ,4  c
   & 
.
"&



 .9&"9  > "& "


># 
 
. "
& 
& 2
 
.9&"
. & "
&" " > , # &9

  "   . .&
  #, 
"" .9&"9  

 &
&

" E  0
.&> 
&  ,
", "
&  "  
", ,#
(. "
& " 3  
&
  ,
.    &2 
,C#&

  ,2. ,DG ,"   .   ,
.9&"9  

" 
, .  
 ,

>&
&
  " >

#  
 
 "  2  .9&"9    
&&
, .  
&
" >
 ,
 , 9  


&
9&  ,  " 
,. "
& "  ,
5Y/.& 2  ..   

&2  "
 
 ,. 
2 
  9 ,&
&
  " 
 Y=&

. &"29 ,9 

  #&
   % &2  "  ,.   .9&"9     " 
, ,  "2"
& " &
&&29.  .
  
& " E ,.
>
 
.  

, 
&   " ,
,
& , .9&"9  
"
& "   " .
 > , & & " ,
.9&",
& , 
"
 "
 
 
"  
 , E
 


&
9&   " 
  #,
 "
"   &
  B, "  2
  &   ,4c



Jobs are the real magnet for immigrants, not social services ± most immigrants don¶t even use health care
King ±   ,>    "
8  
OF )>, .5###
 "
.   )%.
M,
& ,M . .P" 

F 9 ..   
"  ,"  2
 ,C
  D ,

#
  ,"  2I 
& " ",

,
& ,"
" 

 "

  &(&2 9.& 2    ,
    ,
& ,
 
"" 
>",

 "&  >"  "  > . " > 

>
, & " 

 
&2    &(&2 # (  ,

 "& 
&  2
 #   &(&2 # (  ,"  "    2 4   
  ,  
   . "  
&&# ( " .
 

. "  # ( 
" 
&&   = ( ..    , , ?# ( . 

&  
 Q  , ?# ( . 
 
.
2> (&&&
9  ,+?. 
 
 "&  # ( 
 ,+?1. 
  ?
 "&  # ( . & >
2>,
& ,"
9    , " 
  ,. 
 !

 ^
c 
  

Aff ± Magnet Disad Answers


Other aspects of American society inevitably act as a magnet for immigrants
[urkholder 2 ± 1
9

>R-+/'+;44/c
O;9>, .5###&, .9&"
  M 
",.
  M; ".P" 

& /
 # #  
( , C
  ; "D  E
 
2>,B
(

 " 
 ,0"
9   
", 
9  &>9
&

   ">& ##



  " 
"" ,
& ,"
I
  .,
  , 



&E" E 
""& .   >

C
  D,&  , 
  , 
  && #
.
".
  , "
 
8 .&&( 
>
 &0"

#
   9 

 9&   "2"& " 8,  0B  ,c,B. 
>, &&
&&2


,
   
&
#  ,
,, 9. - c
(9>
1  
 #, ##
(&&92 ,c 9= , # 9 ,  

,  >,B
 
 #&  E
># ( # A 9
 &&"
B  
&"
 ,
&2

  > ..   2>


 ,  
9
&
9& 92
 
&&   ,# &-  && 
 ,5

  ?9 . .&"  &2   ,4cI9 # !>


$>

&&2
0."  "  0" 
&   
, 0  2







Multiple alt causes make illegal immigration inevitable


Smith ± '

>4c+  . 

OF& >, .5###, 
 
",
 ,&!%"P" 

,
 
3  &
9&

 5  9"
  
 &
#
9 ( >9 9"
 ,2
   " # &9
   A    ""  &
#  , >,

 "9 ,
  &  

9&&# ,  
8  : ?Q ,
#&&"  ,9  
. "   , &
,  &    & #
2 #,",
&
"(   " ,
&  " 
&&
&
 =,24c8 &";
&


   " ,

&. 
&29"

 
  2
,
   "
"   .& 2 #, , 
&&
&
&&
&
 #&&  99 ,   " &
& 
 ,
2

&
9& 2 A 9 
 
",
 
  -   &  "
&&  ,1, 
    ".& 2 
"  2 
"
&&2> A .
"
&&2&
"( 
3
   ",
9 
, 
. 9&, 
 ,
  3  , 9     9>
   
>
1  
8
&
  ,
  "
&&   , && " 
 8   "  ! 
&&2> ,
"  "  &2
#  ,&  " "
&& 
  ,c" ; "" ,  &  "
&&  ,1, 
  (
&& ,
   "    ""
&&   , && " " 
 &&& ,.&#
  ,c" ; ""  
 ,
 92#,&



& "
& ,
 &

&&
#92
  ?
    &&
&
c",
. &"2 #

&&
&

 ,0.  4c" E #, 
 " .
2  ? ?
   
  ,
"
 ,  &  "
&&  ,1, 
    "
&&
#
 
 ,

& . " *. "   ,&&
&
 ..
 ,9  ,  &  "
&&  , 
  
 
  . "   
 " 

" 9&    &&
& 2

& &   
 ,

& .& 


0 " &2  

(.
"( 
  
2 
,

& &&2
(  & ,
  ,

 " 9
&&
&

 >",
0.   
& &&
&
,  &  "
&&  , 
     
 ,

& . "  "

0.
2 92   "  ,


  ..  ,
.   &
&
  ,  &  
( , 
    +
.  
 
  &E , &> 3  , "
2   ">
 &2  " ,&
#>## & ,

&&
&

=# & ,
&&  && &&
&
&    "  2,1, 
 "&
#,


" 

 "  
25

  2 #,
K 
  , &   ,1, 
 K # &
"(   
    " ,&
#=   
  2   ""  &
#??#    " ,&
# &
 ,  
  2


 ^R
c 
  

Aff ± Iraqi Refugees Disad Answers ± RFE Link Turn


Plan clarifies who¶s eligible for refugee status ± this reduces the ambiguity that slows the USCIS down
Siskind & Susser 4 ± 
 &
#2 
OF *>, .5###
&
#" !A $A $!, &P" 


 
 "
>  , , ,
>.
 ,
 
  ,
 , 9 
& 
..&"
 #&&&(&2 "& #,   9  
 &     


  . " ,
   " "   , . ,     " , 9  3  / ";/

   &2#, 
0
     ,


..&"
&9& " 4cc "
 ,
0
  , & #&& &2 2
"

,  ,
 
;/
#,  ,29& ,  &9& 2  ,9    
 &
#2 ,
 "
 ,

20
  
     2
."  
 &
#
 ,;/. "
&& #&
#2  0.&
  , "







 ^
c 
  

Aff ± Iraqi Refugees Disad Answers ± No [acklog


No risk of backlogging ± USCIS now has more staff and less strict security protocols
[ernal 9 ± & >/  #F (8 
OF  >, .5 #A (.  " % 9?
?","(?. 
?#&&?&
?9
"(& ?
2?"P" 

,;1B
  " =&&
+ # 
&    ,   ,8   ,

..
 F >*  ,
 "2

2  ,

   ,
C , ?
 


&E
 c " 9 )&& 
 9 ","( 
",9
 "    5#, ,  ,2,

9    " 
 

  
;1&>D+ # ,;1 
.# , ,4cc   &    ,9
"(&  . &>*>A  #  ,9  ,8  B 
& 
2B

 "  "&
&  #,
 ,;1
4cc,
   & ,9
"(& . 9& "& ,   . .&  

,
","(>   
   "  
 #, # (  ,.
 >
92    ,
","   
C- 
"& .
 ,.# , ,;1,
 &   ,
"" .&,   , "

", # ,

&"  2
   
 >D
4cc"   . 2  " ",
&2 C,"  
# (  &
 ,.#&&,&.    ,

","(. " 
"" .&,
3"(&2
. 9&# ,  
" .  "  2" " D





And these procedures solve ± Iraqis get approved more quickly than other refugee groups
DHS 8 ± .
  + &
c"  2
Oc. >, .5###, 0 # &
. M!)!**, P" 

/&9& 2  


" 
"
?92?"
9
4cc " " " 
. 
&  #  ,
..&"
  
&"   
 
9   ,
..&"
K
9& 2
"&
  
    ,  #> , " "   ,9
"9 
.,"
&

  ,
..&"
I  ,
 ,
..&"
#
. . &2
 
""  ,4c8I   #, ,  ,
..&"
,
 .
 . "   ,

#&&?  
   . "    ,9
 
"> & >

& 2>9 ,. 
.
"&
 "
& .> . & "
& .   , , , "  2I

=
"   
   #, ,  ,
..&"

9&  ,4  c

#, , , ,,
9  &2  & 
, "  2I

 ," 9& 2  ,
..&"
/   c"  2

" "   ,    "          ,


 , 9 
  , , , . 

 
(  ,
 ,4  c
- 
2>)> +c
 "
.& 
 
 ?" 
> ,
"
9
"(  
"  2","(. " 
3 
..&2    &   ,4  c
 "

&&2

..  & &  


&&"  2","(,
9  "


&2E, ,
""  2","(  . ,& #      ,4  
c
> " ,. "  " "  &2# , ,   ?. "  .- 

> ,
&. "   
3"
 "
&2& ,
 
2

,   .# &#




No risk of a tradeoff ± refugees are bracketed into sectors with their own set allocations
Margesson 9 ± , 
>c."
&   

&+


8 &"2
O;9 >, .5 .
 ." 
 '  %.P" 

/
",2
> ,8  9 
 .    >( # 
 ," &
  " >#,","
  , 
 B. . 
"& 
 
&
&& "
   ,."  "
&2
; && # "  
&" &
   ,. . 
&> ,8  
8  
&   
    ,
 9   ,
2
,;Q# &# "& *>  "&)$>
  9 
&& "

  ,    ,# &


&& "
   $> 9  ,


"
9>
#, >
  
 
& & & .,;Q
&& "
   ,
/
 c  ,
  >#,", "&
3> )>""    ,;Q
" &
  " > ,
&& "
  "&& 
9&
3>1,
>


>
,
!!  
3   ,4  c

&* ;Q$> ;Q%>>%* ;Q)>
 >*  ;Q*!$""   
F

2

c
 .
  . >   , 
 B
& 
 
&
 )>
3  ;Q!%




 ^ë
c 
  

Aff ± Iraqi Refugees Disad Answers ± UN Solves


U.N. will successfully solve Iraqi refugees with or without the U.S.
Relief Web 9
OF *>, .5### &#9  # #9 9c /64?)$+4@-. " P" 

,4"   ..  ,6    


3 " 
 , "
2
"& 
"     ,  
      

3 , , ,.   9
" "  ,  & 
9&  ,9   "  >#,  , 

.. 0
&2$&&  > ,4,
9 
# ( "& &2# ,,         ,
 ,

""  
& "
& "
,

 
, , ,
9&,     " >
( 

&
9&
3
 "&
> ,
9&
  ,&  >.   
  
     
.&
" >#
 


 . A" >
,
& ,"
>"
  "
 


"  ,   2,40.  
.. "
  
3K ,9   "    ,  
3 >
   #, 
& "
 F 

c2 

  ,.. 

""  " ,
,
9 .   , 





 ^
c 
  

Aff ± Refugee Kritik Answers


The neg¶s kritik of discourse produces a reactionary politics which provides the illusion of criticism,
leaving the socioeconomic root causes of injustice unexamined ± this trades off with truly effective
political responses
[rown R ± = 2>8  8 & "
&c" "41 (&2
O8 & "-  + 2>. $? )P" 

.", &
 >
 ,9

9   ,> .
Cc."," (&&"  3>D+ 2' 6
 
( 
 
2 ,
.",!& , ,6
#
    #,
,
.. #, ,


," .
" #,", , ,
  
9
  
 .  9 . , >,.  
& 
..& . ,9  


  3    # , &" . & "
&.
" "      1    . & "
&3   
& " G
.","  
2   G  &2

. ,9 "
 3  


"
  &"  > 
& 0. 
.   ,  & 2 #
. & "
&&
  

 ( . . 
 # ,
&&

  "  ,  , 
&E
   ,
.
 &2  "
"
 "
 &2

&#
2"  
".
2
.
   
" 
2  >  &
 , 
.
  3   
 , 2   ,

=9 
 " 

&E
 
9 
"
E
 
3 &(&2 9  "
  , 
,  "  + #  
.   . & "
&.

 05 ,
& " 

"  "
&.
" ">  
29  2>#
( #,
    2. "&2923    , .
" "
  ,(  "  "
& 3 2   #,", ,2# 9 ,6
, ,

>Cc."," >9   "
&"  3>(&&
"  3D >#, 
>" .
2  2?9
     >9   "
&"  3> 

9&29" "  

 ,2

 "  


&E ,  2


&E ,9  
 #,
 ,2 "
.

"   "  
, "
&&2."" "
&. # 1 
& " .
", "
 (  .", 
 (&&"  3  &292.&
"  
# ,
 
9  
9
"  ,    2?9   A >9 
& 92"   . & "
& A "
. & "
&
,   

. 9&  
(>
 >
.",
,  ,



  , "
&>. & "
&?" ">

"& 
& 
  . # 
,  ,
   

&2 "
&&29

""    , "  A "  A 2>
,2"   ,

   , " .
"&
 
(  , >  , "&
  9
 
&&2 
  
&&2"
  
"
 

 , >
. & "  , "
   ,
 &2. E.
   

"  ",

  "
&&
 3
  & 
&9
&
        #,
 "
&&2
(
 
&
2>, # ,2
 .  >
, #
2 
",( 
..
 "
       

..   
 "  > ,  " ,
 

">
.  2> & "

  #  >
 , &   "
& A " 
  &
&2
"&


 
=
&  
, # 
  ,   "I9 
,  ,
0
  ,&   
 >
,  ,
9
 ,,&
    .  ">#.   
##  &&
,   ,9
 ,    "&
   # 

 B   >
&E
c

 ^G