Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
Journal homepage:http://innovativejournal.in/ajcem/index.php/ajcem
62
Mandal et.al/Automotive Seat Design Basic Aspects
however, reported that they “always or often” exceed that Because it provides the interface between a mechanical
limit [11]. Commercial trucks are unique in that they are system, the tractor, and the delicate and sensitive human
specifically designed to transport heavy loads over long biological system the operator. The seat design process
distances, where for the trucks, high priority has been should consider the relative and combined effects of
given to durability and functional efficiency. On the different causes of discomfort and consider whether
contrary, automobiles are made to comfortably customer opinion of good comfort can be achieved without
accommodate passengers over relatively shorter distances unnecessary reductions in stimuli commonly associated
[12]. The personal vehicles are emphasizing in the factors with discomfort [2]. Recently the design of the truck seat
such as ride comfort, handling, technology and appearance experienced major improvements. Improvements have
are of high importance in vehicle market. The different emphasized bolster design to increase stability, and
requirements of commercial trucks and personal adjustments for backrest angle, contouring, and seat height
automobiles have led to separate directions in design. to promote good posture. Also, the development of air
Considering the long hours of hauling, it can be argued that suspension system has made the seat better capable of
one of the most important parts of the truck driver’s absorbing vibration transferred from the road surface to
working environment is the truck seat. Similarly the tractor the driver [14]. This paper describes the research and
operator comfort is dependent on vehicle design, the way development for vehicle seats based on literature review.
the vehicle is operated and the expectations and sensations The focus groups for the vehicle seat are cars, buses, trucks,
of drivers. Seat is one of the most important components, agriculture tractors, trains, airplanes and others vehicle
which influence the comfort of a tractor operator [13]. such as motorcycles.
Fig.:1 Flow Chart shows the different types of automotive seats [1]
63
Mandal et.al/Automotive Seat Design Basic Aspects
Passenger in the front and rear seats need comfortable Seats are mostly designed as per the body weight and
supporting surfaces for a variety of postures unconstrained anthropometry of the targeted user population to fit at
by the vehicle operation. Postural stress, vibration, least 90 percent of population. The 95th percentile of
muscular effort, impact and shock are the causes for male and 5th percentile female anthropometric data is
backache and lower back pain in drivers. Safety should be generally considered for accommodation on seats.
taken into account while considering the design of seats
without compromising the comfort.
3.0 FACTORS FOR SEAT DESIGN
Human geometry both in static and dynamic are considered
for designing seats. The static geometry describes the
physical size to be accommodated in the seat and dynamic
geometry describes the functional position to be
accommodated in the seat. These are tabulated in Table1.
Body size
Position of the Body Driver’s seat position is dependent on the vision and
reach of the driver. Clear view and comfortable sitting
posture are the factors considered for designing seat.
The dimensioning is mostly depends on eye, hand and
foot positioning. For different body vertical, back angle
adjustments are provided.
Posture of the Body Seat should reduce postural stress and optimize
muscular effort. Postural stress occurs due to adopting
one posture for long period of time, so comfortable
support for many postures is essential and this can be
accommodated by manipulation of anthropometric data
and the linkage system.
Vibration and ride comfort Vibration, shock and impacts are major factors for
judgments of comfort ability according to most users.
Thus, the seat design also must consider the vehicle
suspension system and the vibration transmitted to the
seated user.
4.0 GEOMETRIC FEATURES OF SEAT DESIGN
Seat design can be divided into accommodation and from 432mm at the hip to 367 mm at the chest [17].
comfort. Accommodation refers to seat size and 480mm is recommended for seat back breadth [17].
adjustments for horizontal distance from controls, height • Horizontal adjustments accommodate differences in leg
and back angle. Comfort, however refers to stiffness, length that are associated with seat height and preferred
contour, climate and vehicle features that promote users knee angle. Grandjean [17] recommended a minimum of
comfort [16]. 150 mm horizontal adjustment. The joint angles in
The seat height, width and back angles are based on the automobile are typically between 95 and 120 degrees for
human anthropometry data collected from the research, it’s the hip, and 95 and 135 degrees for the knee [18].
important to provide sufficient space for physical and • Horizontal seat travel is a function of seat height and body
psychological comfort. These are some of size. Average seat travel was investigated 148mm approx.
recommendations as stated below [16]: [19].
• Cushion’s length from seat back to the waterfall line is • Vertical adjustments accommodate differences in sitting
440-550 mm is recommended [17]. eye height between the fifth percentile female and 95th
• The breadth of the cushion is recommended 480 mm [17] percentile male. A simple trigonometric relation can be
for clothing and leg splay. The measurement is established with link length and joint angles to compute the
based on 95th percentile of female hip breadth and amount of seat adjustment needed in the vertical direction.
additional space for comfort since female • Adjusting a flat, non-deformable surface over a range of
hips are greater than male hip breadth. 163mm maintains a constant eye height. Seat cushion
• Seat back height is recommended 509 mm [17] by compression and suspension deflection are no-linear
considering the small female, sitting shoulder height. function of applied force; as a result the vertical
• Seat back breadth may be divided into lower and upper displacement needed in a soft seat is poorly calculated from
regions. The lower must accommodate a tapered shape
64
Mandal et.al/Automotive Seat Design Basic Aspects
anthropometric data. Grandjean [17] recommended a seat regards to pressure or any other factor is that, comfort is
height between 250 and 300 mm. very subjective and not easily quantified. Seating
• Seat back angle adjustments accommodate differences in discomfort varies from subject to subject and depends on
arm length and occupant preferred hip angle. Grandjean the task at hand. Comfort, however, is a vague concept and
[17] recommended a seat cushion angle of 19 degrees with subjective in nature. It is generally defined as lack of
a range from10 to 22 degrees. d on multiple joints or discomfort [15]. For example, truck drivers require sitting
overall body posture [20]. for long periods of time approximately eight hours. The
3.0 SEATING DISCOMFORT extended period of sitting includes higher risk of back
The term “seat comfort” is typically used to define the problems, numbness and discomfort in the buttocks due to
short-term effect of a seat on a human body. Seating surface pressure under the thighs [21]. The sources of such
discomfort has been examined from a number of different discomfort are listed in Table 1.
perspectives. The problem with evaluating comfort in
65
Mandal et.al/Automotive Seat Design Basic Aspects
measuring seat pan and seatback contours and a graphical models of the seated human body have been developed and
presentation for visual evaluation. Seat designers can use standardized by the ISO.
the methods for evaluating seat comfort such as support, 8.0 MECHANICAL DESIGN
fitness and accommodation. Cho and Yoon [43] developed a Mechanical research on vehicle seats concentrated
biomechanical model of humans on a seat with a backrest on the actuators, the suspensions and dampers. Liu and
for evaluating the vehicular ride quality. Rakheja et al. [44] Wagner [58] designed the controllers and evaluated semi-
developed a model to study the seated occupant active hydraulic and active electromechanical hydraulic
interactions with seat backrest and pan, and biodynamic actuators. A series of four model-free and model based
response under vertical vibration. Wang et al. [45] studied control strategies are presented for each actuator to
the role of seat geometry and posture on the mechanical attenuate road vibrations transmitted to the occupant’s
energy absorption characteristics of seated occupants lower and upper torso. The controller designs include
under vertical vibration. The results show that the relative, proportional-integral, variable structure system,
absorbed power quantity increases approximately and optimal control. Perisse and Jezequel [64] published a
quadratically with the exposure level by the person. The paper overviewing a theoretical study on active seat
results also reveal that the absorbed power is strongly suspension. The principal objective of this study is to
dependent upon the individual anthropometry variables improve ride passenger comfort by reducing transmitted
such as body mass, fat and mass index. Coelho and seat forces. In addition, Perisse and Jezequel [64] also
Dahlman [46] conducted a pilot evaluation and investigate the experimental feasibility of the active seat
experimental study on car seat side support. The suspension to improve ride comfort. The prototype of a
introduction of side supports is annoying the problem of reversible electromechanical actuator used in an active seat
designing a seat to fit every human being in the range of suspension is presented. A reversible electromechanical
accommodation targeted in the seat's design. The side actuator was used to provide a continuous variable
support is built-in in both sides of the seat and people with damper/an active force generator to realize a control
varying body widths must be accommodated back. Some policy.
research used the seated man model [47-49] and 9.0 CONCLUSIONS
anthropometrics [50-53] to study the driver’s ergonomics. The paper surveys a large number of studies and
Besides ergonomics, low back pain research is reported in up-to-date techniques developed for vehicle seats used by
[54-55]. Much research has been performed on building up different types of transportation systems. The objective of
specific biodynamic models based on certain experimental this paper is to describe the state of the art and recent
data under prescribed testing conditions; a thorough development of vehicle seat design, which are available in
investigation of mathematical human models in seated current literature, and to give a general idea about
posture has not yet received the same level of attention. In unsolved problems that arise in practice. From this
future studies, research should be concentrated on literature review, it can be seen that the majority of vehicle
knowledge improvement of the exposure–response seats studies are concentrating on vibration, pressure and
relationship between whole-body vibration and the ergonomics. Besides, these topics, driver “fatigue” also
occurrence of low back disorders, and to advance needs to be considered in vehicle seat design. The term
understanding of the other physical and psychosocial “fatigue” is used to define the physical impairment that
factors that combine to result in the progression of low results from exposure to the seat vibrations for a long
back symptoms. period of time. Fatigue may lead to decreased attention,
7.0 SIMULATION AND MODELING perception, decision-making, vigilance, and reaction time.
A simulation is the execution of a model, Future research on seat thermal and humidity comfort can
represented by a computer program that gives information be concentrated on intelligent thermal and humidity
about the system being investigated. The simulation control system and evaluate the physiological seat comfort
approach of analyzing a model is opposed to the analytical for drivers by using on-the-road experiment testing.
approach, where the method of analyzing the system is REFERENCES
purely theoretical. A simulation approach may be more [1] Pachling Vishwanath K., Chaitanya S. V. (2013).
reliable, depending on the quality of the model. Review of design aspects of major components of
Mathematical models are used to simulate and study the Automotive Seat, Asian Journal of Engineering and
seat comfort virtually [56-57]. Bouzara and Richard [56] Technology Innovation 01(01): 33-38.
developed a mathematical model to simulate the dynamic [2] Mehta C.R., V.K. Tewari. (2000). Seating discomfort
behavior of a 3-D vehicle. With this model, various types of for tractor operators: a critical review, International
non-linear suspensions, such as active and semi-active Journal of Industrial Ergonomics 25:661-674.
suspensions, can be investigated. Fatollahzadeh [57] [3] Floyd, W.F. and Roberts, D.F. (1958). Anatomical and
constructed a mathematical model, which clarifies and Physiological Principles in Chair and Table Design.
predicts the drivers’ comfortable sitting posture and Ergonomics 2, 1-16, Kharagpur, India.
position. Computer-aided engineering (CAE) methods such [4] Viano, D.C. and Andrzejak, D. V. (1992) Research
as finite element analysis and simulation techniques have Issues on the Biomechanics of Seating Discomfort: an
also been used to study and to develop vehicle seats [58- Overview with Focus on Issues of the Elderly and
62]. Verver et al. [63] used a finite element (FE) model of Low-Back Pain. SAE Paper 920130.
the human buttocks to predict the static pressure [5] Wilder, D.G., (1993). The biomechanics of vibration
distribution between human and seating surface by its and low back pain. American Journal of Industrial
detailed and realistic geometric description. For modeling Medicine 23, 577–588.
purposes and for evaluation of driver’s seat performance in [6] Pope, M.H., Magnusson, M., Wilder, D.G., (1998). Low
the vertical direction various computer-aided design back pain and whole body vibration. Clinical
Orthopaedics and Related Search 354, 241–248.
66
Mandal et.al/Automotive Seat Design Basic Aspects
[7] Paddan, G.S., Griffin, M.J., (1998). A review of the [25] Van Niekerka, J. L., Pielemeierb, W.J., Greenberg, J.A.
transmission of translational seat vibration to the (2003). The use of Seat Effective Amplitude
head. Journal of Sound and Vibration 215, 863–882. Transmissibility (SEAT) Values to Predict Dynamic
[8] Bovenzi, M., Hulshof, C.T.J., (1999). An updated Seat comfort. Journal of Sound and Vibration,
review of epidemiologic studies on the relationship 260:867–888.
between exposure to whole-body vibration and low [26] Falou, E. W., Duchêne, J., Grabisch, M., David Hewson,
back pain. International Archives of Occupational Yves Langeron, Lino, F. (2003). Evaluation of Driver
and Environmental Health 72, 351–365. Discomfort during Long-Duration Car Driving.
[9] Griffin, M.J., (1998). Predicting the hazards of whole- Journal of Applied Ergonomics, 34(3):249-255.
body vibration consideration of a standard. [27] Van Niekerk, J. L., Pielemeier, W. J. and Greenberg, J.
Industrial Health 36, 83–91. A. (2003). The use of seat effective amplitude
[10] Johnson, D.A., Neve, M., (2001). Analysis of possible transmissibility (SEAT) values to predict dynamic
lower lumbar strains caused by the structural seat comfort. Journal of Sound and Vibration,
properties of automobile seats: a review of some 260:867-888.
recent technical literature. Journal of Manipulative [28] Frechin, M. M., Arino, S. B. and Fontaine, J. (2004).
and Physiological Therapeutics 24, 582–588. ACTISEAT: active vehicle seat for acceleration
[11] Transafety Reporter. (1998). Truck Survey compensation. Proceeding Institution of Mechanical
Highlights Causes of Drowsy Driving and Suggests Engineers, Part D: Journal of Automobile
Preventative Measures. Transafety Incorporated. Engineering, 218:925-933.
[12] Gillespie, Thomas D. (1985). Heavy Truck Ride. SAE [29] Qiu, Y. and Griffin, M. J. (2005). Transmission of roll,
Paper 850001. pitch and yaw vibration to the backrest of a seat
[13] Stikeleather, L.F. (1991). Seat vibration and ride supported on a non-rigid car floor. Journal of Sound
comfort In Human Factors, module 6 of a series of and Vibration, 288:1197-1222.
quality instructional materials. American Society of [30] Nawayseh, N. and Griffin, M. J. (2005). Effect of seat
Agricultural Engineers, St. Joseph, MI 49085. surface angle on forces at the seat surface during
[14] Ahmadian, M., Seigler, M., Clapper, D. and Sprouse, A. whole-body vertical vibration. Journal of Sound and
(2001). A comparative analysis of air-inflated and vibration, 284:613-634.
foam seat cushions for truck seats. Society of [31] Boileau, P. –E. and Rakheja, S. (1990). Vibration
Automotive Engineers Technical Paper, Document attenuation performance of suspension seats for off-
no. 2002-01-3108. road forestry vehicles. International Journal if
[15] Shen, W. and Vertiz, A. (1997). Redefining Seat Industrial Ergonomics, 5:275-291.
Comfort. SAE Paper 970597. [32] Gyi, D. E., Porter, J. M. and Robertson, K. B. (1998).
[16] Basic Ergonomics in Automotive design. Seat pressure measurement
http://www.dsource.in/course/ergonomics/auto- technologies:considerations for their evaluation.
ergo/seat/seat.html. Accessed on 15.09.2015. Applied Ergonomics, 27(2):85-91.
[17] Grandjean, E., (1980). Fitting the Task to the Man: An [33] Seigler, M. and Ahmadian, M. (2003). Evaluation of
Ergonomic Approach. Taylor and Francis. an alternative seating technology for truck seats.
[18] Rebiffe, R., Zayana, O., and Tarriere, C., (1969). Heavy Vehicle Systems, 10(3):188-208.
Determination des zones optimales pour [34] Hinz, B., Bluthner, R., Menzel, G., Schust, M. and
l’emplacement des commandes manuelles dans Seidel, H. (2006). On the significance of body mass
l’espace de travail. Ergonomics, 12, 913 - 924. and vibration magnitude for acceleration
[19] Schinder, L.W., Anderson, C.K. and Olson, P.L., (1979). transmission of vibration through Seats with
Driver Anthropometry and Vehicle Design horizontal suspensions. Journal of Sound and
Characteristics related to seat positions selected Vibration, 298:627-637.
under driving and non-driving conditions. SAE [35] Seigler, M., Ahmadian, M. and Boggs, C. (2003).
Technical Paper 790384., warrendale PA: SAE, Inc. Validation of an indentor system for evaluating truck
[20] Krist, R., (1994). Modellierung des Sitzkomforts: Eine seat cushions. Proceeding of Institution of
experimentelle Studie. Weiden: Schuch. Mechanical Engineers, Part D: Journal of Automobile
[21] Floyd, W.F. and Roberts, D.F. (1958). Anatomical and Engineering, 217:343-348.
Physiological Principles in Chair and Table Design. [36] Gyi, D.E., Porter, J.M., and Robertson, N.K.B. (1998).
Ergonomics 2, 1-16, Kharagpur, India. Seat pressure measurement technologies:
[22] Viano, D.C. and Andrzejak, D. V. (1992). Research consideration for their evaluation. Appllied
Issues on the Biomechanics of Seating Discomfort: an Ergonomic, 27(2):85–91.
Overview with Focus on Issues of the Elderly and [37] Guenaelle, P. (1995). One methodology to evaluate
Low-Back Pain. SAE Paper 920130. Automotive Seat Comfort. In: Proceedings of the
[23] Boggs, C. M. (2004). Field study to evaluate driver Third International Conference on Vehicle Comfort
fatigue on air-inflated truck curshions. Master of and Ergonomics,Bologna , Italy, 29–31 March, 231–
Science thesis, Faculty of the Virginia Polytechnic 240.
Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Virginia, [38] Porter, J.M. and Gyi, D.E. (1998). Interface pressure
USA. and the prediction of car seat discomfort.
[24] Ofori-Boetang, A. B. (2003). A study of the effect of International Journal of Vehicle Design, 19(3):255–
varying air-inflated seat cushion parameters on 266.
seating comfort. Faculty of the Virginia Polytechnic [39] Zhang, L., Helander, M. G., Drury, C. G. (1996).
Institute and State University, Blacksburg, Indentifying factors of comfort and discomfort in
Virginia,USA. sitting. Human Factors, 38(3):377–389.
67
Mandal et.al/Automotive Seat Design Basic Aspects
[40] Ebe, K. and Griffin, M. J. (2001). Factors affecting of Institution of Mechanical Engineers, PartD: Journal
static seat cushion comfort. Ergonomics, of Automobile Engineering, 219:1293-1302.
44(10):901–921. [54] Bovenzi, M., Rui, F., Negro, C., D’Agostin, F., Angotzi,
[41] Alem, N. M. and Strawn. G. D. (1996). Evaluation of an G., Bianchi, S., Bramanti, L., Festa, G., Gatti, S., Pinto, I.,
energy absorbing truck seat for increased protection Rondina, L. and Stacchini, N. (2006). An
from landmine blasts. US Army Aeromedical epidemiological study of low back pain in
Research Laboratory report no. 96-06. professional drivers. Journal of Sound and Vibration,
[42] Chang, S. R., Son, K. and Choi, Y. S. (1996). 298:514-539.
Measurement and three-dimensional graphic [55] Okunribido, O. O., Shimbles, S. J., Magnusson, M. and
representations of Korean seatpan and seatback Pope, M. (2007). City bus driving and low back pain:
contours. International Journal of Industrial a study of the exposures to posture demands, manual
Ergonomics, 18:147-152. materials handling and who-body vibration. Applied
[43] Cho, Y. and Yoon, Y. S. (2001). Biomechanical model Ergonomics, 38:29-38.
of human on seat with backrest for evaluating ride [56] Bouazara, M. and Richard, M. J. (2001). An
quality. International Journal of Industrial optimization method designed to improve 3-D
Ergonomics, 27:331-345. vehicle comfort and road holding capability through
[44] Rakheja, S., Stiharu, I., Zhang, H. and Boileau, P. E. the use of active and semi-active suspensions.
(2006). Seated occupant interactions with seat European Journal of Mechanics. A. Solids, 20:509-
backrest and pan, and biodynamic response under 520.
vertical vibration. Journal of Sound and Vibration, [57] Fatollahzadeh, K. (2006). A laboratory mock-up
298:651-671. research work on truck driver’s seat position and
[45] Wang, W., Rakheja, S. and Boileau, P. E. (2006). The posture. Doctoral thesis, Royal Institute of
role of seat geometry and posture on the mechanical Technology Division of Industrial Ergonomics and
energy absorption characteristics of seated Scania CV AB Vehicle Ergonomics, Stockholm,
occupants under vertical vibration. International Sweden.
Journal of Industrial Ergonomics, 36:171-184. [58] Verver, M. M., van Hoof, J., Oomens, C. W. J., Wismans,
[46] Coelho, D. A. and Dahlman, S. (1999). A pilot J. S. H. M. and Baaijens, F. P. T. (2004). A finite
evaluation of car seat side support: leading to a element model of the human buttocks for prediction
redefinition of the problem. International Journal of of seat pressure distributions. Computer Methods in
Industrial Ergonomics, 24:201-210. Biomechanics and Biomedical Engineering, 7(4):193-
[47] Boileau, P. E. and Rakheja, S. (1998). Whole body 203.
vertical biodynamic response characteristics of the [59] Hix, K., Ziemba, S. and Shoof, L. (2000). Truck seat
seated vehicle driver: measurement and model modeling- a methods development approach.
development. International Journal of Industrial International ADAMS User Conference.
Ergonomics, 22:449-472. [60] Verver, M. M., de Lange, R., van Hoof, J. and Wismans,
[48] Liang, C. and Chiang, C. (2006). A study on J. S. H. M. (2005). Aspects of seat modeling for seating
biodynamic models of seated humanb subjects comfort analysis. Applied Ergonomics, 36:33-42.
exposed to vertical vibration. International Journal of [61] Rebelle, J. (2000). Development of a numerical model
Industrial Ergonomics, 36:869-890. of seat suspension to optimize the end-stop buffers.
[49] Kim, T, Kim, Y. and Yoon, Y. (2005). Development of a 35th United Kingdom Group Meeting on Human
biomechanical model of the human body in a sitting Responses to Vibration, ISVR, University of
posture with vibration transmissibility in the vertical Southampton, Southampton, England, 13-15
direction. International Journal of Industrial September.
Ergonomics, 35:817-829. [62] Tewari, V. K. and Prasad, N. (1999). Three DOF
[50] Broughton, J. (2004). The actual threat posed by modeling of tractor seat-operator system. Journal of
unrestrained rear seat car passengers. Accident Terramechanics, 36:207-219.
Analysis and Prevention, 36:627-629. [63] Liu, X. and Wagner, J. (2002). Design of a vibration
[51] Hanowski, R. J., Perez, M. A. and Dingus, T. A. (2005). isolation actuator for automotive seating systems-
Driver distraction in long-haul truck drivers. Part II: controller design and actuator performance.
Transportation Research, Part F8:441-458. International Journal of Vehicle Design, 29(4):357-
[52] Chou. J. R. and Hsiao, S. W. (2005). An 375.
anthropometric measurement for developing an [64] Perisse, J. and Jezequel, L. (2000). An original
electric scooter. International Journal of Industrial feedback control with a reversible electromechanical
Ergonomics, 35:1047-1063. actuator used as an active isolation system for a seat
[53] Latchford, J., Chirwa, E. C., Chen, T. and Mao, M. suspension. Part II: experimental study. Vehicle
(2005). The relationship of seat backrest angle and Systems Dynamics, 34:381-399.
neck injury in low-velocity rear impacts. Proceeding
How to cite this article: MANDAL, Subrata Kumar. AUTOMOTIVE SEAT DESIGN: BASIC ASPECTS. Asian Journal of
Current Engineering and Maths, [S.l.], v. 4, n. 5, p. 62-68, oct. 2015. ISSN 2277-4920. Available at:
<http://innovativejournal.in/ajcem/index.php/ajcem/article/view/35>. Date accessed: 22 Nov. 2015.
doi:10.15520/ajcem.2015.vol4.iss5.35.pp62-68..
68