Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
ABSTRACT: Flushing is vital for the preservation of long-term storage in reservoirs. However, down-
stream impacts can act as a constraint in the planning and operation of sediment flushing. In order to un-
derstand the processes and the impacts of flushing, two examples are given of the Unazuki and Dashidai-
ra reservoirs, located at the Kurobe River eastern region of Toyama prefecture, in Japan. For both
reservoirs sediment inflow is extremely high compared to the storage capacity. During minimum pool
level the incoming floods erode a flushing channel in the deltaic deposits. The channel is gradually in-
creased in width by bank-erosion processes during this period. The paper investigates the impacts of
flushing on the dynamic dimensions of flushing channel, and the varying location. Furthermore, it clarify
the development of channel formation in both reservoirs. Quantitatively and qualitatively monitoring
measurements during flushing have been conducted for sediment erosion process with 3D laser scanning,
surface velocity (LSPIV), and suspended sediment concentrations. The flushing channel within Dashidai-
ra reservoir has a stable profile and extends across the entire impoundment width of 170 m at distance of
640 m from the dam.
Keywords: Drawdown flushing, Flushing channel formation, Coordinated flushing, Kurobe River.
1165
quently eroding a channel through the deposits 1.3 Aim of the Study
and flushing the fine and coarse sediments The lack of knowledge regarding flushing channel
through the outlet. During this process a progres-
evolution and its morphological processes, in-
sive and a retrogressive erosion patterns can oc- itiated a study to channel formation, applied to
curs in the tail and delta reaches of the reservoir, flushing processes in Dashidaira and Unazuki re-
respectively (Batuca and Jordaan, 2000). Among servoirs in Japan. The study aims at investigating
reviewed literature, sediment removal from reser- the causes of these observed behaviors, and find
voirs (White, 2001) generally only affords the
measures to control and predict the channel cha-
problem of sediment flushing inside the reservoir.
racteristics. Therefore this study is focusing main-
However, there is scarce information about expe-
ly on track the patterns of reservoir erosion
riences on prototypes and especially in respect to
through field and experimental modeling. Finally,
flushing channel formation. One of the phenome-
quantitatively and qualitatively monitoring tech-
na in reservoirs that is not well investigated and
niques during flushing are discussed.
theoretically explained is the formation of flush-
ing channels in the delta of the reservoir (Sloff et
al., 2004). In many reservoirs these channels can 2 CASE STUDY OF THE KUROBE RIVER
be found, e.g. see Figure 2, as they are a common
feature of deltaic deposition in wide reservoirs. Japan has geologically young mountains, steep
and short rivers with flashy flow regimes, and
densely populated floodplains. Japan suffers from
frequent heavy storms. The combination of steep
catchments and heavy storms results in wide-
spread hill slope failures and landslides and exten-
sive flood discharges.
1166
Japan Sea
Asahi Town
Niigata
N Pref.
Kitamata Dam
Unazuki Dam
Dashidaira Dam
Koyadaira Dam
(a)
Sennindani Dam
Toyama Prefecture
Kurobe Dam
Kurobe Reservoir
Kurobe
River Nagano Dashidaira reservoir
Prefecture gross capacity
Dashidaira dam
9.01 MCM
Figure 3. Kurobe River site map and location of Dashidaira Figure 4. (a) Photo of Dashidaira dam during draw down
and Unazuki dams flushing; (b) Plan view of Dashidaira reservoir topographic
map
1167
diment flushing. Several parameters are measured in 2006. These measurements included surface ve-
during and after flushing, namely: 3D topography, locity using LSPIV (Large Scale Particle Image
2D surface velocities, cross section bathymetry, Velocimetry) performed by using CCTV camera,
turbidity, and sediment transport rate. More de- in combination with geographic feature measure-
tails about these techniques are shown and explain ment with a 3D laser scanner. A high concentrated
by (Sumi et al., 2004, 2005). Figure 6 shows field SSC is also observed downstream of the dam.
measurement of channel evolution and morpho- .
logical processes during a coordinated sediment
flushing operation at the Unazuki Dam reservoir
5
Average
sluicing is performed. 10
15 Average hourly rainfall in Dashidaira reservoir (mm)
Figure 7 shows actual sediment flushing opera- 20
tion performed in July 2006. Erosion phase with 700 Dashidaira 51 hrs
Inflow discharge
Water level (El. m)
Discharge (m3 /s)
100
from the beginning of drawdown to the end at Da- 12 hrs
-100 300
shidaira dam is 51 hrs and 60 hrs at Unazuki dam. 700 Unazuki
It is a key to the coordinated sediment flushing 60 hrs
Discharge (m3/s)
time in Dashidaira and Unazuki dams that are lo- Outflow discharge
Water level
cated longitudinally. 30,000
-300
12 hrs 215
3.1 Experimental facility installation and setup Figure 7. Coordinated Sediment flushing operation in 2006
1168
3.2 Erosion and flow patterns during flushing
The final bed morphology obtained from experi-
ment is used as the initial topography for clear
water test. Here, clear water without sediment is
introduced into the basin to investigate the further
bed evolution. Figure 11 shows the flow with vec-
Figure 8. Initial bed condition and sediment material tors and the bed topography after 11.9 hrs of
flushing. Reduction of water surface generates
Dashidaira
pipe
Baffle plate
Six layers of
dam high flow velocity near the outlet; the flow starts
Settling
Drain
Inlet of water supply concrete blocks
basin to erode a wide channel. At that stage, a signifi-
cant amount of sediment deposits was flushed
through the reservoir, and the initial channel dee-
pened as a result of the strong jet flow and ero-
Six layers concrete blocks CB
After flushing
Before flushing Within Dashidaira reservoir, the actual and la-
No.5 Silica sand
boratory test of flushing channel is schematically
Elevation [m]
Elevation (EL.m)
is crashed and deposited at CS 6-2 spillway
325m
No.6-2 320
*Width of flushing channel is 30-40 m July 2008, after flushing
July 2009, after flushing
310
May 2009, before flushing
300
August 2004, after flushing
May 2004, before flushing
*Width of flushing channel is 50-80 m
290 December 1994
Elevation(EL.m)
250
normal water level 245m
240
spillway 231m
230 Sept. 2009, after flushing
224
May 2009, before flushing
220
August 2004, after flushing
210 May 2004, before flushing
2:10
222 2h13
2:13
and deposition patterns. It is therefore highly de-
2h18
2:18
pendent on the boundary conditions, the initial
221
2h23
2:23 flow conditions and the geometry. On the other
220 2h27
2:27 hand, the sensitivity of flow patterns creates op-
219
portunities to redirect the channel direction by
2:34
2h34 means of small interventions in the flow field
218 (e.g., operation of water-levels at gates, or con-
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180
structions that redirect the flow within the reser-
Distance along the measuring line (m)
voir).
Figure 18. Time series of measured water surface elevations
Channels formed by flushing in reservoir sedi-
Time and spatial variations of reservoir surface ment deposits correlate well with flushing dis-
velocities during drawdown and flushing period charge. Figure 20 shows the relationship and the
were also measured by LSPIV. These data can be comparison of observed flushing channel widths
converted to actual velocities by the 3D laser in Dashidaira and other four reservoirs. The fitted
scanner data. Both reservoir water level and flow line is described by Wf = K Q0.5 =12.8 Q0.5 (sec-
velocity changing during the drawdown. Side tion 1.2), where the width is determined by the
bank erosion process of the sand bar formed in the flow and is independent of sediment size. The
Unazuki reservoir and water surface profiles near- flushing channel width in Dashidaira reservoir is
by banks are shown in Figure 19. The location of 170 m at distance of 640 m from the dam and
the measured cross section (section 5) is shown in flushing discharge of 250 m3/s. Therefore, Sumi
Figure 6. Based on these results, it can estimate and Iguchi (2005), suggest that K value for Japa-
the height of side bank of 1.0-1.2 m is eroded with nese reservoirs is 6.4, to be reduced by twice.
the speed of 7.5 m/hr. Slope of water surface is al-
so estimated as 1/75 and water waves generated
Sanmenxia
Observed channel width, Wf (m)
-23 15h30
Side bank slope -23.2 100
Water -23.4 15h44
surface -23.6 16h01
-23.8 16h16
-24 16h31
-24.2 10
-24.4
16h45
1 10 100 1000
45 40 35 30 25 20 (m ) 17h00 Flushing discharge, Qf (m3/s)
Cross section distance (m) Figure 20. Comparison of Dashidaira dam flushing channel
Figure 19. Time series of flushing channel side bank erosion width with Atkinson relationship of four dams
processes within Unazuki reservoir
To successfully apply the channel formation
From the viewpoint of the comprehensive se- processes for removing deposits, the location of
diment management in a sediment routing system, the channel and its width can be changed by mod-
monitoring of quantity and quality of sediment ifications of the flow pattern. Before a channel is
transport during these flushing events in rivers formed these interventions can be much smaller
and reservoirs is also very important. Based on than that after its formation, because the channel
field observation of turbidimeter, movement of the attracts the main flow, and stabilizes the flow pat-
suspended sediment load discharged from Unazu- tern. The present study has new information re-
ki dam during flood, flushing and sluicing periods garding the dimensions of channels of Dashidaira
are clarified. dam, in the laboratory and the field. The width of
the channel is in accordance with the riverine
width, flow pattern, water depth, discharge, and
the bottom outlet arrangement. A larger volume in
the reservoir generally generates a higher flushing
flow depth and velocity in the flushing channel.
1172
Reservoir sedimentation management in Japan is
entering a new era. Although there are still tech-
nical problems to be solved, it is believed that the
importance of sediment management will increa-
singly grow. Assessing issues, depending on each
case, of dam security, sustainable management of
water resources and sediment management in a
sediment routing system, an effective sediment
management plan should be studied.
REFERENCES
1173