Documente Academic
Documente Profesional
Documente Cultură
IJIACS
ISSN 2347 – 8616
Volume 7, Issue 2
February 2018
Viraja Bhat*,
Assistant professor, Symbiosis Institute of International Business,
Symbiosis International (Deemed University), Pune, India
Nikhil Patil
Student – MBA-EE, Symbiosis Institute of International Business,
Symbiosis International ( Deemed University), Pune, India
ABSTRACT:
In the current Indian scenario, E-waste is generation can be majorly found in in metropolitan cities like Mumbai,
Bangalore, Kolkata, Delhi, Pune, Chennai, etc. The source of e-waste can be attributed to inventions and discoveries of
newer and helpful technologies, the increase in number of business organizations and IT companies, the rise in mobile
shops,service centers and the dependency of humans on the electronic gadgets. The e-gadgets are in short the lifeline
of the modern society and can be found in use by almost everyone irrespective of the income, age and region. The
remarkable growth in the use of ICT devices and services, innovations and frequent changes in the technology has
allowed the users to disown the existing electronic devices which in many cases are found in either partial or fully
workable conditions when disowned. In Pune (Maharashtra), figures of E-waste generation is increasing prominently
and becoming one of the cities that generates huge amount of E-waste in India. At the end of the day the electronic or
electrical equipment, at some point in time in their life cycle reach their EOL as they become obsolete and find their way
to the waste stream in part or full form and most of the E-waste get landfilled with the regular solid waste.
Authors in this paper attempt to address the issue of e-waste and the stakeholder’s participation in e-waste awareness
and disposal. The study is conducted in the City of Pune which ranks 8th in E-waste generation chart in India, a famous
educational, manufacturing and IT hub. The focus of the study is to understand the behaviour and participation of the
various stakeholders in e-waste management process. The study was carried out through a primary survey method with a
structured questionnaire and field visits.
1.1 INTRODUCTION
Post industrialization and especially liberalization Indian cities have witnessed rapid urbanization, changing
business environments, life style changes, increase in working population and migration from rural areas. The
burden on the cities has exponentially increased due to the rise in population and leads to more and more
waste generation. The available infrastructure for waste management is not adequate and hence the
Management of waste with activities like collection, segregation, transportation, processing and disposal is a
challenge. Waste can be anything -any material or object or substance other than radioactive material
proposed for disposal or is required to be disposed of by the provisions of national law (Basel, 1989).Social,
economic, environmental, cultural, political conditions affect the stakeholders engagement in managing the
waste with limited resources and hence waste management primarily becomes the livelihood of unorganized
informal sector due to the low cost involved in dealing with it. Wastes can be mainly classified as bio-
degradable and non – bio degradable which are treated in a traditional way mainly by landfilling /
incineration. Landfilling of bio-degradable waste is not harmful and is economic but landfilling of non –
biodegradable waste pose danger to the environment and health. The presence of varied materials such as
metals, glass, paper, plastic, hazardous materials, wires, batteries etc.in the non-biodegradable waste make the
treatment a challenging task to the authorities as these wastes are handled in a unscientific method due to
lack of technology and cost factor.
The demand for the affordable electronics products increased globally due to their requirement as an essential
part of everyday life which is resulted in the growth of electronics market. Laptops, desktops, tablets, mobile
phones, TVs, CD players, etc. contain printed circuit boards, ICs, liquid crystal displays (LCDs), rechargeable
batteries, etc. which are the basic necessity for the human being nowadays and play an important role during
their useful life. After that when they become e-waste, poses a great threat because of poor management and
disposal methods because of the presence of many toxic substances, therefore it affects the environment and
human health.
In Pune, municipal solid waste management is already creating lot of problems, has become more difficult due
to addition of E-waste generated due various stakeholders in the system. As per our survey in Hinjewadi area
most of the electronics and mobile shops conduct repair and replacement of damaged electronic gadgets. The
priority given to repair of damaged gadgets by installing new spare parts in the gadgets or usable parts of other
dead cell phones or electronics. In case if the electronic gadget is not at all repairable, it is either collected as
waste e-material at the shop or usually the customer disposes it along with other solid waste.
In the fast moving world a lot of e-waste been generating daily due to new technology developments, lesser
product life and obsoleteness of present technology in the near future. To make an opportunity and to make
use of the waste by recycling and reusing it. We visited formal e-recycler started in India in 2013 head
quartered in Pune. In the same year it collected a total waste of 17 tonnes. From that it gradually increases the
amount of e-waste collection gradually by 15% growth every year. They are handling small percentage of
total E-waste generated in Pune.
In present scenario, the landfills normally consist of municipal solid wastes which have non-hazardous
industrial wastes, commercial wastes, etc. and unused electronic devices in parts or in full. Ideally municipal
solid waste should not be mixed with other types of wastes. But the mixing of unused electronic and electrical
devices i.e. e-waste has made the situation worse. The E-waste rules enforcement difficulties, stakeholders
lack of awareness, absence of proper disposal channels allows the mixing of e-waste with solid waste and
needs urgent attention.
The landfills normally consist of municipal solid wastes which have commercial and non-hazardous industrial
wastes, construction and demolition (C&D) waste and unused electronic devices in parts or in full. Due to
different types of wastes dumped together it is difficult to treat the waste and some of the contents remain in
the dumpsite forever and affect the environment. In an ideal situation the municipal solid waste should not be
mixed with other types of wastes. Regulations can help in making sure that the industrial non-hazardous waste
and construction wastes are taken care by the generators. But the mixing of unused electronic and electrical
devices in part or full referred to as e-waste has made the situation worse even in presence of the regulations
at all levels of governance. The enforcement difficulties, stakeholders lack of awareness, absence of proper
disposal channels allows the mixing of e-waste with solid waste and needs urgent attention.
Traditional way of landfilling of e-waste and it’s residues result in leaching of toxic metals into the
surrounding atmosphere and affect the human health and environment causing soil and water pollution
(Huisman et. al, 2008). There are efforts across the globe for scientific management of e-waste in order to
protect the environment and also preserve the precious metals. Developed nations use sanitary landfills and try
to prevent or minimize the leaching process but in turn loose the precious and rare materials such as gold,
palladium, copper and silver. The demand for these materials rise as the demand for electronic products
increases (Dwivedyet al.,2010) and fulfilling the global demand for metals, the e-waste management focus is
shifted on 3R concept - Reuse, Refurbish / Repair and Recycle.
Developing nations like India, Pakistan, China, Africa face a new menace due to the arrival of large volume as
e-waste from highly industrialised nations like USA, EU countries, Japan, Australia for disposal at the
dumping ground for disposal or for recycling operations (Zhang, K.,et.al, 2012). Abundance in unskilled low
cost labour, e-waste turns out to be a boon as a treasure and a bane due to unmanageable trash in these
developing countries which are already a home to growing volume of domestic e-waste attributing to rising
demand for newer products with a smaller life span. The non-scientific disposal of e-waste in these countries
pose major health hazards and need a swift attention from the governments, social organisations at
international and national levels (Huisman et al., 2008).
The global e-waste generation in 2014 was expected to be 41.8 million metric tons (MT), as compared to 33.8
MT in 2010, and is projected to grow to 49.8 MT by 2018.(Balde et.al, 2014). For almost two decades waste
electrical and electronic equipment, WEEE or e-waste, has been considered a growing problem that has global
consequences. It is estimated that only 29% of global e-waste is handled via the accepted best practice
recycling channels (earth911.com, 2016). As the population grows the quantum of e-waste multiplies at an
alarming rate with an entry from domestic generation and exports. At the same time the lucrative business
opportunities in recovering materials, primarily the precious and base metals with unskilled, easily available
and cheap workforce has prompted the informal sector to flourish (Pradhan et. al, 2014)
The highly valuable and toxic non-renewable materials in e-waste are recovered and recycled by informal
sector as they offers them prospect to flourish and hence allow the developed nations to follow the convenient
and easy route for the frequent movement of WEEE to the developing countries(Bhat et al. 2012). Countries
like India, China, and Nigeria housing a large illiterate and unemployed population with absence of strong
regulatory framework or lack in implementation provides readymade ground for the imported and domestic e-
waste processing. The workforce involves women and children who use the rudimentary methods manually
have no clue on the aftereffects of these treatment methods on their lives. When the e-waste components or
materials are burnt or recycled in an uncontrolled manner leads to n many socio economic problems not only
for the current workforce but also for future generations. Deterioration of ecological and human nervous
systems is attributed to the haphazard disposal of E-waste. (Grant et al, 2013). The lack of awareness and
basic civic sense at the sources of E-waste generation by individual consumers/ users pose hurdle to manage
E-waste. Consumer awareness plays a major role to route E-waste to the authorized collection centres and
authorized recyclers for safe disposal. The stakeholders’ awareness and participation is a roadblock in
successful implementation of the existing regulatory framework which defines clearly the roles of various
stakeholders. The innocence and ignorance of the majority of the e-goods users regarding the consequences of
irrational disposal of e-wastes on the environment, ecology and health of current and future generation is a
serious problem and needs to be addressed at all levels.
India is one of the developing nations which is a safe destination for the disposal of e-waste ranked as the
fifth biggest producer of e-waste in the world, discarding 1.7 million tonnes of electronic and electrical
equipment in 2014(UNEP, 2014). Computer equipment accounts for almost 68 percent of e-waste followed by
telecommunication equipment (12%), electrical equipment (8%) and medical equipment (7%). Other
equipment, including household e-scrap, account for the remaining 5% (UNEP, 2007). There is a complete
ignorance in public about the repercussion of throwing these products unattended. 95% of e-waste is handled
by informal sector recyclers who are not serious about the guidelines issued by Central Pollution Control
Board (CPCB) and rest 5% by formal ones (Amit et.al , 2016).
Among the Indian states, Maharashtra tops in the e-waste generation chart and the City of Pune is ranked at 8th
number. Pune city is one of the largest developing cities in India which has IT and manufacturing industries,
famous educational universities and institutes. Pune is also known as a real mixture of culture and
development and has the prospect for growth as an IT city owing to the presence of a large number of Info
Tech Parks & electronic products manufacturing companies, plays a significant role in e-waste generation.
The awareness of the citizens of Pune and the role of the corporation is pivotal in achieving the zero garbage
status in terms of solid waste management. However lack of consumer awareness and the absence of proper
disposal channels for E-waste transit systems help in the informal processing by unorganised sector aided by
the e-waste collection by traditional kabadiwalas. The open burning, extraction of metals, smelting and
physical separation of the components lead to the emission of toxic gases to the atmosphere and pollute the
surroundings without the knowledge of the residents. The treatment activities are carried out by the licensed
recycling centres and informal processors, which are located among the most populated residential areas. The
awareness of various stakeholders about the ill effects will pave a pathway for the e-waste to reach formal
recyclers for safe disposal. In the present study authors have made an attempt to understand the participation
and awareness of various stakeholders in E-waste Management in Pune city.
2. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY:
The study was carried out in the Pune city, with the help of a primary survey method with a structured
questionnaire. A sample of 100 consumers, more than 20 servicing centers and a formal recycler was
considered for the study. The study focuses on understanding E-waste consciousness, disposal practicesand
awareness about the toxic and precious nature of e-waste with reference to the E-waste(Management &
Handling) Rules 2011, implemented from May 2012.
The data was collected using random sampling method with online and offline administration of the
questionnaire comprising of different income groups, age groups, diverse education streams and locations.
E-waste given to
18% Scrap Dealers
The survey results helped us in laying out the following flow chart to depict how these service shops deal with
the e-waste generated at their end.
Collection of E-waste
The E-waste is collected from its points mainly through two ways:
1) The E-recycler use their own transport to collect the waste
2) The scrap dealers will collect the waste and send it to E-recycler or the respective waste holder will
send it by the means of their own transport (or through a dealer).
Mainly following products are seen in e-waste:
CRT screens, laptops, dot matrix printers, PCB boards and Desktops and other plastic materials.
E-waste management process in Formal E-recycler
All the e-waste collected at formal E-recycler then it is segregated as different products like cables,
desktops, batteries, etc. Then segregated products are checked whether it is working or repairable. If it is
repairable or working then sold it into the second hand market.
If the product is useless then it is dismantled by workers. Mainly there are only 4-5 workers working in
the company and they dismantle the products by hands and some mechanism like soldering, smelter, etc.
The segregation work is 90% hand held.They remove Mild Steel and copper by Smelter process. During
this process many of the waste like plastic, metals are separated which are recyclable locally and they sold
it to local recycler.
It is very good to know that the electrical/electronic products which repairable or working are sold into the
second hand market to get monetary benefits. This helps to reduce the increasing generation of the e-
waste.
At the last all PCBs separated from laptops, TVs, desktops, and other electronic gadgets are collected and
stored in small warehouse which are exported to European company for recycling.
To regular
dustbin
16%
32% 32% To e-waste bin
Yes
No To second hand
84% 9% market
27%
To scrap
material
As per Survey, above (Fig. 2) shows that it is really good to know that 84.10% of people are aware about term
E-waste. Anotherone shows that 68.2% people are dispose-off their damaged electronic/electrical product into
E-waste bin, give it to second hand market and scrapers (Fig. 3). 31.8% of respondents are dispose-off their e-
waste into regular dustbin it is indicate that respondents either do not think there are any government policies
in place to handle e-waste, or do not know of any pertinent policies or governing bodies.
Display screens
1% Speakers
21% 9%
Battery
24%
20% Headphones/Earp
hones
25% Charger
Data-cable
Above figure is showing that most frequently damage electronic product is Headphone/Earphone following
battery, data cable, charger, speakers and display screens. Within this, number of battery (hazardous waste)
discarded is significant which is causing health hazards, so it is very important to dispose in proper scientific
way.
Fig 5: Awareness about the impacts of e-waste Fig 6:Awareness on impacts of improper e-waste
disposal disposal on the human health and the environment
According to survey as shown in above figure, 84% of people are aware about impact of improper disposal of
E-waste and 75% of this people had knowledge about health and environmental hazards are effects of
improper disposal. The responses on on negative impact of the waste on environment and health show that
most of the respondents are aware of the harmful effect of the products. Likewise, they know the implication
of E-waste on their personal health.
9%
5% Toxic
Non-toxic
The most of the individual i.e. 86.4% of people from total respondents are believe that nature of e-waste is
toxic where 5.5% of peoples believe that it is non-toxic and 9.1% of people do not know about the nature of
the E-waste. Here 9.1% people who do not know the nature of e-waste, so it is very needful to create
awareness about the effects of the e-waste generated and its improper management.
4. CONCLUSION:
Pune is among several cities which are proposed to be developed as Smart City and is required to implement
the Integrated Solid Waste Management System as proposed in the strategic plan 2017-15 by Pune Municipal
Corporation which has various initiatives towards e-waste management such as e awareness campaigns, tie up
with formal recyclers, formation of core committee, study on behavior of scrap dealers, E-waste collection
drives and setting up of e-waste collection center in Kothrud.
With the smart city development there will be systems with IoT in use for digitized population, Government’s
Digital India mission forcing the rural population to use the smart phones will ensure use of more and more
gadgets adding to the existing e-waste.In this scenario, the study results are very significant as they give an
overall picture of understanding of the e-waste management situation at present in Pune City. The study
results reveal that the existing system of waste collection is convenient for the households but they are also
aware that e-waste needs special treatment. The trash/ treasure nature is also known by majority of the
respondents but the lack of formal disposal channels forces them to dispose it off with regular solid waste.
The present study aimed to measure the awareness levels and practice of people regarding e-waste
management. The survey conducted revealed that significant fraction of respondents is still unaware of the
issue; however, on getting the information they were able to link the impacts of improper management of e-
waste with detrimental health outcomes. Many respondents were totally unaware about correct ways of its
recycling and its management.
The Swachh Bharat Abhiyan is the most significant cleanliness campaign started by the Government of India.
While leading the mass movement for cleanliness, the Prime Minister exhorted people to fulfil Mahatma
Gandhi’s dream of a clean and hygienic India. But we need to consider about the awareness of e-waste and its
proper management also along with other wastes as it is more harmful in nature as compared to other wastes.
According to E-waste (Management) Rules 2016, the manufacturer of the product is responsible for the
take back the obsolete products and manage the e-waste. This also means that the manufacturers will
have to use recyclable material in manufacturing of new products for economic management of e-waste
at the later stage. Although, in Indian context it would be a challenge to implement the concept of
EPR(Extended Producer Responsibility), especially with the active informal sector i.e. scrap dealers or
Kabadiwalas who collect the e-waste. In the entire e-waste management awareness of the stakeholders
be it households, individuals or service centers is the first step in achieving sustainable e-waste
management.
REFERENCES
1. Amit Kumar Jain, KumariDibya, 2016, Harmful effects of E-waste on living beings and environment.: DEW Journal,PP 82-85
2. Balde, C.P., Kuehr, R., Blumenthal, K., Gill, S.F., Kern, M., Micheli, P., Magpantay, E. and Huisman, J., 2015. E-waste
statistics: Guidelines on classifications, reporting and indicators. United Nations University, IAS-SCYCLE, Bonn,
Germany.
3. Basel Convention.” 1989.
4. Bhat, V., Rao, P. and Patil, Y., 2012. Development of an integrated model to recover precious metals from electronic
scrap-A novel strategy for e-waste management. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 37, pp.397-406.
5. Dwivedy, M. and Mittal, R.K., 2010. Estimation of future outflows of e-waste in India. Waste Management, 30(3), pp.483-491.
6. E-waste Volume 1, Inventory Assessment Manual, UNEP, DTlE,lETC, OsakaiShiga, Japan, 2007
7. Grant K, Goldizen FC, Sly PD, et al. (2013) Health consequences of exposure to e-waste: a systematic review. Lancet
Glob Health. Publishedonline Oct 30. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/S2214-109X(13)70101-3.
8. Huisman, J.; Magalini, F.; Kuehr, R.; Maurer, C.; Ogilvie, S.; Poll, J.; Delgado, C.; Artim, E.; Szlezak, J.; Stevels, A. 2008
Review of Directive 2002/96 on Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE), Final Report; United Nations
University, 2008)
9. Links, T., 2016. What India Knows ABOUT E-WASTE :Report on Awareness Levels of E-waste amongst common
citizens in India
10. Pradhan, J.K. and Kumar, S., 2014. Informal e-waste recycling: environmental risk assessment of heavy metal
contamination in Mandoli industrial area, Delhi, India. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 21(13), pp.7913-
7928.
11. Rekacewicz, P., 2014. UNEP/GRID-Arendal. Who Gets the Trash?‘Basel Action Network: Vital Waste Graphics
12. Zhang, K., Schnoor, J.L. and Zeng, E.Y., 2012. E-waste recycling: where does it go from here?
13. http://earth911.com/eco-tech/20-e-waste-facts’