Not all chargers are alike

Improve battery performance with proper charge methods

Isidor Buchmann
Cadex Electronics Inc.
isidor.buchmann@cadex.com
www.buchmann.ca
August 2003

To a large extent, the reliability and longevity of a battery hinges on the quality of the charger. In a price
competitive market, chargers are often given low priority, especially for consumer products. This article
assesses the charger as the quintessential provider and guardian of the battery. It also examines
recommended charge methods that will increase the performance of nickel-cadmium (NiCd), nickel-
metal-hydride (NiMH) and lithium-ion (Li-ion) packs. Well-performing batteries and chargers are
especially important for in radio communications in public safety and other critical applications where
battery failure is not an option.
A battery should always remain cool during charging because high temperatures shorten battery life.
However, some temperature rise cannot be avoided when charging nickel-based batteries. The
temperature peaks when the battery approaches full charge, then moderates after the battery switches to
trickle charge. The battery should eventually cool to room temperature.
If the temperature remains above room temperature after a few hours in ready mode, the charger is
performing incorrectly. Remove the battery when ready because any prolonged trickle charging will
damage the battery. The caution applies especially to NiMH because this chemistry cannot absorb
overcharge well.
A lithium-based battery should never get warm during charge. If this happens, either the battery or the
charger is faulty. Discontinue its use.
Nickel-based chargers are grouped into three categories:
Slow Charger — The slow charger, also known as ‘overnight charger’, applies a fixed charge of about
0.1C* (one tenth of the rated capacity) for as long as the battery is connected. Charge time is 14 to 16
hours. Slow chargers are found in cord-less phones, portable CD players and similar consumer goods.
Quick Charger — The quick-charger, or rapid charger, serves in the middle of the range, both in terms
of charging time and price. Charging takes 3 to 6 hours and the battery switches to trickle charge when
ready. Quick-chargers accommodate nickel-based or lithium-based batteries and service commercial
products such as cell phones, laptops and camcorders.
Fast Charger — This charger offers several advantages; the obvious one is shorter charge times. At a 1C
charge rate, an empty NiCd or NiMH typically charges in a little more than an hour. Accurate full-charge
detection is important. Once fully charged, the charger switches to topping and then trickle charge.
Communications batteries are normally charged on fast-chargers. This puts empty packs back into
mission-ready status as quickly as possible. Fast chargers are also used for industrial equipment such as
two-way radios, video cameras and power tools.

* The C-rate is a unit by which charge and discharge currents are scaled. A charge current of 1000mAh (1C) will charge a
1000mAh battery in slightly more than one hour.

1
Simple Guidelines:
• A charger for NiMH can also accommodate NiCd, but not the other way around. A charger especially
designed for NiCd would overcharge the NiMH battery.
• Nickel-based batteries prefer fast charge because it reduces crystalline formation (memory).
• Nickel and lithium based batteries require different charge algorithms. The two chemistries can
normally not be interchanged in the same charger.
• If not used regularly, remove the battery from the charger and apply a topping-charge before use.
Do not leave the battery in the charger for standby.

Charging Nickel Cadmium

Battery manufacturers recommend to slow charge a new NiCd for 24 hours before use. This process
brings the cells within a battery pack to equal charge level because each cell self-discharges at a different
rate. The initial trickle charge also redistributes the electrolyte to remedy dry spots on the separator
brought on by gravitation of the electrolyte during long storage.
Some battery manufacturers do not fully form the cells before shipment. Full performance is reached after
the battery has been primed through several charge/discharge cycles, either with a battery analyzer or
through normal use. In some cases, 50 to 100 discharge/charge cycles are needed to fully form a nickel-
based battery. Quality cells, such as those made by Sanyo and Panasonic, perform to specification after 5
to 7 cycles. The initial readings may be inconsistent but the capacity becomes steady once fully primed. A
slight capacity peak is observed between 100 and 300 cycles.
Most rechargeable cells are equipped with a safety vent to release excess pressure if over-charged. The
safety vent on a NiCd cell opens between 150 and 200 psi. (The pressure of a car tire is about 35 psi.)
With a resealable vent, no damage occurs on venting but some electrolyte is lost and the seal may leak
afterwards. A white powder accumulating at the vent opening indicates venting activities.
Commercial chargers are often not designed in the best interests of the battery. This is especially true with
chargers that measure the battery’s charge state solely through temperature sensing. Although simple and
inexpensive, charge termination by absolute temperature is not accurate.
More advanced NiCd chargers sense the rate of temperature increase. Defined as dT/dt (delta
Temperature/delta time), this charge detection system is kinder on the batteries than a fixed temperature
cut-off, but the cells still need to generate some heat to trigger detection.
More precise full charge detection can be achieved with the use of a microcontroller that monitors the
battery voltage and terminates the charge when a certain voltage signature occurs. A drop in voltage
signifies full state-of-charge. Known as Negative Delta V (NDV), this phenomenon is most pronounced
on NiCd charging at 0.5C and higher. Chargers based on NDV must also observe battery temperature
because aging cells and cell mismatch reduce the voltage delta.
Fast charging improves charge efficiency. At 1C, the efficiency is 1.1 or 91 percent and the charge time
of an empty pack is slightly longer than one hour. On a 0.1C charge, the efficiency drops to 1.4 or 71
percent and the charge time is about 14 hours. On a partially charged battery or one that cannot hold full
capacity, the charge time is shorter accordingly.
In the initial 70 percent of charge, the charge acceptance of a NiCd battery is close to 100 percent. Almost
all energy is absorbed and the battery remains cool. Currents of several times the C-rating can be applied
without causing heat build-up. Ultra-fast chargers use this phenomenon to charge a battery to the
70 percent level within minutes. The charge continues at a lower rate until fully charged.

2
Past 70 percent, the battery gradually loses the ability to accept charge. The pressure rises and the
temperature increases. In an attempt to gain a few extra capacity points, some chargers allow a short
period of overcharge. Figure 1 illustrates the relationship of cell voltage, pressure and temperature while a
NiCd is being charged.

Cell Voltage
Pressure
Temperature
75/1.50 100

65/1.46 80

55/1.42 60

45/1.38 40

35/1.34 20

25/1.30 0
0 50 100
State of Charge (%)

Figure 1: Charge characteristics of a NiCd cell. The cell voltage, pressure and temperature
characteristics are similar in a NiMH cell.

Ultra-high capacity NiCd batteries tend to heat up more than standard NiCd if charged at 1C or higher.
This is partly due to increased internal cell resistance. To moderate temperature buildup and still maintain
short charge times, advanced chargers apply a high current at the beginning and then lower the amount to
harmonize with the charge acceptance.
Interspersing discharge pulses between charge pulses improves the charge acceptance of nickel-based
batteries. Commonly referred to as burp or reverse load charging, this method promotes high surface area
on the electrodes to improve the recombination of the gases generated during charge. The results are
better performance, reduced memory and longer service life.
After the initial fast charge, some chargers apply a timed topping charged, followed by trickle charge. The
recommended trickle charge for NiCd is between 0.05C and 0.1C. Because of memory concerns and
compatibility issues with NiMH, modern chargers tend to use lower trickle charge currents.

Charging Nickel-Metal Hydride

Chargers for NiMH batteries are similar to NiCd systems but require more complex electronics. To begin
with, the NiMH produces a very small voltage drop at full charge and the NDV is almost non-existent at
charge rates below 0.5C and elevated temperatures. Aging and degenerating cell match diminish the
already minute voltage delta further.

3
A NiMH charger must respond to a voltage drop of 8 to 16mV per cell. Making the charger too sensitive
may terminate the fast charge halfway through the charge because voltage fluctuations and noise induced
by the battery and charger can fool the NDV detection circuit. Most of today’s NiMH fast chargers use a
combination of NDV, rate-of-temperature-increase (dT/dt), temperature sensing and timeout timers. The
charger utilizes whatever comes first to terminate the fast-charge.
NiMH batteries that are allowed a brief overcharge deliver higher capacities than those charged by less
aggressive methods. The gain is approximately 6 percent on a good battery. The negative is shorter cycle
life. Rather than 350 to 400 service cycles, this pack may be exhausted after 300.
NiMH batteries should be rapid rather than slow charged. Because NiMH does not absorb overcharge
well, the trickle charge must be lower than that of NiCd and so is set to around 0.05C. This explains why
the original NiCd charger cannot be used to charge NiMH batteries
It is difficult, if not impossible, to slow-charge a NiMH battery. At a C-rate of 0.1C and 0.3C, the voltage
and temperature profiles fail to exhibit defined characteristics to measure the full charge state accurately
and the charger must rely on a timer. Harmful overcharge can occur if a partially or fully charged battery
is charged with a fixed timer. The same occurs if the battery has aged and can only hold 50 instead of 100
percent charge. Overcharge could occur even though the NiMH battery feels cool to the touch.
Lower-priced chargers may not apply a fully saturated charge. The full-charge detection may occur
immediately after a given voltage peak is reached or a temperature threshold is detected. These chargers
are commonly promoted on the merit of short charge time and moderate price. Some ultra-fast chargers
also fail to deliver full charge.

Charging Lithium Ion

Whereas charges for nickel-based batteries are current limiting devices, Li-ion chargers are voltage
limiting. There is only one way to charge lithium-based batteries. The so-called ‘miracle chargers’, which
claim to restore and prolong batteries, do not exist for lithium chemistries. Neither does a super-fast
charging solution apply. Manufacturers of Li-ion cells dictate very strict guidelines in charge procedures.
The early graphite system demanded a voltage limit of 4.10V/cell. Although higher voltages deliver more
capacity, cell oxidation shortened the service life if charged above the 4.10V/cell threshold. This problem
has been solved with chemical additives. Today, most Li-ion cells are charged to 4.20V with a tolerance
of +/-0.05V/cell.
The charge time of most chargers is about 3 hours. The battery remains cool during charge. Full charge is
attained after the voltage has reached the voltage threshold and the current has dropped low and leveled
off.
Increasing the charge current does not shorten the charge time by much. Although the voltage peak is
reached quicker with higher current, the topping charge will take longer. Figure 2 shows the voltage and
current signature of a charger as the Li-ion cell passes through stage one and two.

4
 Voltage / Cell
Charge Current
Stage1 Stage2 Stage3
Max. charge current Max. cell voltage is reached. Occasional
is applied until the Charge current starts to drop topping charge,
cell voltage limit is as full charge is approached. about 1 per
reached. 500 h
1.25/5

1.00/4

0.75/3

0.50/2
Terminate
charge when
current <3%of
rated current
0.25/1

1 2 3
Time (hrs)

Figure 2: Charge stages of a Li-ion battery. Increasing the charge current on a Li-ion charger does
not shorten the charge time by much. Although the voltage peak is reached quicker with higher current,
the topping charge will take longer.

Some chargers claim to fast-charge a Li-ion battery in one hour or less. Such a charger eliminates stage 2
and goes directly to ‘ready’ once the voltage threshold is reached at the end of stage 1. The charge level at
this point is about 70 percent. The topping charge typically takes twice as long as the initial charge.
No trickle charge is applied because Li-ion is unable to absorb overcharge. Trickle charge could cause
plating of metallic lithium, a condition that renders the cell unstable. Instead, a brief topping charge is
applied to compensate for the small self-discharge the battery and its protective circuit consume.
Depending on the battery, a topping charge may be repeated once every 20 days. Typically, the charge
kicks in when the open terminal voltage drops to 4.05V/cell and turns off at 4.20V/cell.
What if a battery is inadvertently overcharged? Li-ion batteries are designed to operate safely within their
normal operating voltage but become increasingly unstable if charged to higher voltages. When charging
above 4.30V, the cell causes lithium metal plating on the anode; the cathode material becomes an
oxidizing agent, loses stability and releases oxygen. Overcharging causes the cell to heat up.
Much attention has been placed on the safety of Li-ion to prevent over-charge and over-discharge.
Commercial Li-ion battery packs contain a protection circuit that prevents the cell voltage from going too
high while charging. The upper voltage threshold is typically set to 4.30V/cell. Temperature sensing
disconnects the charge if the cell temperature approaches 90°C (194°F); and a mechanical pressure switch
on many cells permanently interrupt the current path if a safe pressure threshold is exceeded. Exceptions
are made on some spinel (manganese) packs containing one or two small cells.
The charge process of a Li-ion Polymer is similar to Li-ion. These batteries use a gelled electrolyte to
improve conductivity.

5
Charging at High and Low Temperatures
Rechargeable batteries work under a reasonably wide temperature range. This, however, does not
automatically permit charging at these extreme conditions. While hot or cold temperatures cannot always
be avoided, recharging a battery is at the control of the user. Efforts should be made to charge at room
temperatures. No commercial battery should be charged below freezing.
Nickel-based batteries should only be fast-charged between 10°C to 30°C (50°F to 86°F). Below 5°C
(41°F), the ability to recombine oxygen and hydrogen is diminished and the resulting pressure build up
may cause the cells to vent.
The charge acceptance of nickel-based batteries at higher temperatures is drastically reduced. A battery
that provides a capacity of 100 percent if charged at moderate room temperature only accepts 70 percent
if charged at 45°C (113°F). This explains the poor performance of vehicular chargers in the summer.
The Li-ion batteries offer reasonably good charge performance throughout the temperature range. Below
5°C (41°F), the charge should be with less than 1C. Charging at freezing temperatures must be avoided
because plating of lithium metal could occur.
The Cadex Universal Conditioning Chargers (UCC) feature a built-in temperature sensor that applies a
trickle charge if the battery is too cold. No charge is applied if too hot. These advanced chargers use
reverse load charge and detect the full charge by NDV, dT/dt sensing and timers. Intelligent battery
adapters configure the charger to the correct charge algorithm. The UCC chargers are available in single,
dual and six bay (Figure 3) configurations. The two-bay unit is designed for vehicle mounting.

Figure 3: The Cadex Universal Conditioning Chargers come in one, two and six bay configurations.
Intelligent battery adapters accommodate different battery types on the same charger. The vehicular
UCC2 is shock and vibration resistant.

6
Summary
Commercial fast-chargers are often not designed in the best interests of the battery. The two common
battery killers are high temperature during charge and incorrect trickle charge after charge.
Choosing a quality charger makes common sense. This is especially important for radio communications
equipment where dependable service of battery and equipment is essential. In most cases, the extra money
invested in a more advanced charger is returned in longer lasting and better performing batteries.

Isidor Buchmann is the founder and CEO of Cadex Electronics Inc. [in Richmond BC, Canada]. He can
be reached at Isidor.Buchmann@cadex.com. This article contains excerpts from the second edition of
“Batteries in a Portable World — A handbook on rechargeable batteries for non-engineers”. The 300-
page book is available from Cadex (book@cadex.com) and www.amazon.com. For additional
information on battery technology, visit http://www.buchmann.ca or http://www.BatteryUniversity.com.
Product information is on http://www.cadex.com.

040517 L:\Article03\English\ChargingMed Word count 2,651